We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927—COMMITTEE STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 121–227 of 227. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 7 of 1927 ›

Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

For the remainder of these amendments we come down to the question, outside the county boroughs, of the hours for bona fide travellers on St. Patrick's Day and on Sundays, and I confess that it seems to me to be a matter of extreme difficulty to discuss amendments with regard to St. Patrick's Day before we deal with Sundays, particularly in view of the fact that there are official amendments dealing with the hours on Sundays. If I might for a moment be allowed to assume that these official amendments would be carried, they would have a certain effect on the whole of the discussion subsequently. So that if it meets with the approval of those Deputies who have amendments down I think that we ought to dispose of the Sunday hours in this section first and let St. Patrick's Day stand over to the next stage. It is impossible to have a discussion on St. Patrick's Day as separate from Sundays, particularly when the Sunday hours actually in the Bill, it appears, are not the hours that will be in the Bill after this particular stage. If that meets with approval I propose to take amendments dealing with Sunday hours. Deputy Byrne is agreeable to that course, I am aware. Then there is Deputy Redmond.

Comment on this

Very well. These amendments will come up on the further stage?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes, the amendments dealing with St. Patrick's Day will come up on the next stage when the Bill is reprinted. Any amendments which may be made in regard to Sundays can be put into the new form of the Bill.

Comment on this

I will move amendment 43 now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I want to get agreement on that. If we take amendments 43 and 46 we shall get to a decision about Sunday hours.

Comment on this

On these two amendments can we discuss the question of hours on Sunday?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes.

Comment on this

Will it be possible to discuss the question of distance in connection with these two?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

No: the question of distance arises on an amendment by the Deputy himself later on.

Comment on this

I know it does. It would not be possible to avoid discussing them together, because I think the Minister has rather an open mind in regard to the question of time and distance. I think a certain amount of latitude might be allowed in regard to these amendments.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

If we are taking amendments 43 and 46 together, I will allow a certain amount of latitude with regard to the question of hours.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

In sub-section (1) (b) (ii), line 45, to delete the word "three" and substitute therefor the word "seven" and to delete lines 46 and 47.

Comment on this

On this question of hours the proposal set out in amendments 43 and 46 represents what I am prepared to stand on, if no solution emerges from the discussion that would represent perhaps a more radical change in the position with regard to Sundays than is provided for in the Bill. There are Deputies who favour the idea of a limited opening throughout the State on the basis of a complete abolition of the bona fide traffic.

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt the Minister on a point of order, but I am somewhat confused about this. According to the amendment paper, amendment 43 deals with sub-section (1) (b) (ii), line 45. That deals with St. Patrick's Day.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That is right. We should have taken the Sunday hours, and amendment 44 is the first amendment which deals with them. Amendment 44 comes on now, unless Deputy Heffernan will give way to amendment 46 and see will the actual Ministerial amendment be carried. He can have his amendment on another stage.

Comment on this

I am prepared to do that.

Comment on this

I move amendment 46:—

In sub-section (1) (b) (iii) to delete all words after the word "Sunday," lines 48-49, to the end of the sub-paragraph and substitute therefor the words "during a period of summer time between the hours of one o'clock and eight o'clock in the afternoon or on any other Sunday between the hours of one o'clock and seven o'clock in the afternoon."

Comment on this

If the bona fide traffic is to be retained, this is my idea of the hours: one to seven in the non-summer time, one to eight in the summer time period, with a discretion to the District Justice in particular cases where the circumstances might differ somewhat to alter that to 2 p.m. to 9 p.m.—the same number of hours, but moving them one hour later. I did not like from the start the idea of any break in the bona fide traffic. If it is to exist at all it is a difficult matter for the police—it has always been a difficult matter for the police, but to try to administer a break of two hours in that would simply be a task beyond the capacity of the members of any police force. Therefore, whatever the hours be on Sunday they should be simply a straight run. I am prepared to recognise that there may be a case for a somewhat different set of hours in the summer time from that which prevails for the rest of the time. The proposal I am, however, standing on, if we are to have bona fide traffic, is one to seven p.m. in the non-summer time, one to eight p.m. in the summer time, with a discretion to alter from two to nine. Perhaps Deputies might be permitted some latitude on this amendment to talk generally on the question of the bona fide traffic. I would like, for one thing, to ascertain just how much support there is within the Dáil for the idea of the abolition of the bona fide traffic on the basis of a limited opening throughout the State, on the basis, say, of a two to five opening, such as exists in the four county boroughs at the moment.

If you are prepared, sir, to allow such a discussion I would like to indicate some considerations that are present in my mind in that connection. There has always been a prejudice against the idea of Sunday opening. When it was first instituted there was considerable opposition. I submit conditions have altered very radically since it was first instituted, that for one thing the bona fide traffic has grown by reason of the increased mobility of the individual to proportions that were undreamt of in those times. The increase in the use of the ordinary push bicycle, for instance, is one factor, and the advent of the motor cycle and motor car is another. You have now a new factor of the buses, which will be spreading more and more throughout the country, so that the bona fide traffic has, in its proportions, altered very radically within the last twenty, thirty or forty years. It is a question to-day whether from the point of view of those interested in the elimination of abuse and excess, the elimination or diminution of the profanation of the Sunday, it would not be worth while, a good exchange, to accept a limited uniform opening throughout the State in exchange for the complete abolition of the bona fide traffic.

If public opinion in general, and perhaps clerical opinion in particular, is ripe to accept that challenge, then I certainly am ripe to accept it, because my own conviction is that it would be a good exchange, that it would mean less excess, less abuse, less profanation of the Sunday to abolish the bona fide traffic root and branch and allow a limited opening through the State.

Comment on this

What would be the period of opening that the Minister would suggest?

Comment on this

The period would be the period that exists in the county boroughs at the moment—a three-hours' spell in the afternoon. I should like to develop somewhat my idea on that point. I believe that a great deal of the excess and abuse attendant on the bona fide traffic comes from the fact that the individual moves out of his home area in which the ordinary checks of human restraint, of human respect, operate; that he, to a greater or lesser degree, according to the distance he travels, and perhaps according to his own significance in the scheme of things, loses his identity; that a kind of holiday spirit takes hold of him, and the idea that having travelled so far with a definite purpose in mind he should fulfil that purpose abundantly. I do believe that the bona fide traveller, who is, in fact, not a bona fide traveller but a mala fide traveller, takes very much more drink than he would take if he could get it nearby in his home area, that the man who sets out on the definite mission of getting drink —and we know that, in fact, it is impossible for any police force, however intelligent, to distinguish between that man and the man who does not, because, the devil himself, as the judge said, "knoweth not the mind of a man"—the man who goes out on the definite mission of getting drink, who travels the statutory distance in order to get that drink, will, in fact, take much more drink, having travelled that distance with that object, than he would if he could get it more conveniently.

I may be told in reply that more people will drink if you had a uniform limited opening throughout the State than drink under the existing system of the bona fide traffic. On that point, I would be glad that people would clear their minds on this question of Sunday drinking—whether it is the drink that is bad in itself, whether there is some essential difference between the Sunday drink and the Thursday drink, and whether on either day or both days it is not the drink, but the excess and the abuse in drink, that is the evil. I want Deputies to put to themselves the question, whether having a drink on Sunday is, in fact, an indifferent act, like having one's lunch on Sunday, or having a boiled egg on Sunday, and that it is the excess and the abuse of drink that makes the difference. If we agree that it is, in fact, the excess, the abuse that we should aim at eliminating, then I do believe that for those primarily interested in eliminating anything that tends to profane the Sunday, it would be a good exchange to abolish the bona fide traffic and have a limited uniform opening throughout the State. At any rate, I do wish that people generally would think more and harder on the question than they have done up to the present. The bona fide traffic has grown and is growing. The bus is a new factor.

The number of motor cars in the country is increasing; the mobility of the individual is increasing year by year; and the more that takes place the more it will become a question of whether the other idea would not now —whatever the situation might have been 40 or 50 years ago—be the better idea, and more in the interest of decency and restraint.

The trouble is largely that people think so much in terms of their own parish, their own area. The clergy say: "Well, we have no bona fide travellers here, thank God, and we do not want the publichouses open." I would prefer that people would take the State as a unit and consider whether the greater excess, the greater amount of abuse, the greater amount of profanation arises from the present regulations than would or could arise from the change which I have outlined.

I may be challenged—I have no doubt whatever I will be challenged— and asked why, holding those views, did I write into the Bill a provision along other lines. That is fair enough, and I want to give an explanation. I am not fortified in this view by any recommendations from the Commission, and if I am told that public opinion in general, and clerical public opinion in particular, does not want this change I will accept that. I am talking largely now for the sake of putting a particular point of view. I do not want to write into this Bill something that is wholly against the trend of public thought on this matter, that is wholly against the view that most generally prevails throughout the country. I am suggesting that that may not necessarily be the sound view and the correct view and that there is very definitely another side to the matter. I wish that Deputies would talk quite freely their own opinions on this point.

Coming back to the amendment with regard to hours, if the bona fide traffic is to remain, then I stand for a substantial pruning of the hours—I stand for an 8 o'clock close down in the summer-time and a 7 o'clock close down in the non-summer-time period. As the law stands, if a man travels the statutory distance he may drink all night up to 12 o'clock. I do not think that is right. I think that there should be a closing hour on Sundays at which the bona fide traffic should cease and that that closing hour should be reasonably early. If we are to retain the bona fide traffic I stand for those hours.

Comment on this

What about the distance?

Comment on this

I will talk about the distance later. I am standing firmly, at any rate, on those hours if we are to retain the bona fide traffic, and I would not be open to accept amendments varying them. We can discuss the distance as a thing apart— and I think it is a thing apart from the question of time—but I hope that any Deputy who has thought out the question as to whether the bona fide traffic as such ought to remain, whether he agrees with the recommendation of the Commission that it must remain a necessary evil and anomaly in our social legislation, will express those views, so that we may get some picture as to what is the view of the House on this question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We have reached Section 13 dealing with the bona fide traffic, to which there are a number of amendments on the Paper. The question of the county boroughs has been disposed of. The question now is the bona fide traffic outside the county boroughs, the question of hours on St. Patrick's Day, and the hours on Sundays. We have decided, as a matter of convenience, to leave out of consideration St. Patrick's Day, and to proceed with the discussion of the hours on Sundays. We are considering amendment 46, moved by Deputy Dolan, which must be taken in conjunction with amendment 50.

Comment on this

Amendment 45 stands in my name.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendments 46 and 50 hang together, because they contain a certain provision. We have, also, decided to allow latitude of discussion on the general question which the Minister has discussed, namely, whether it would be advisable to abolish the bona fide traffic in consideration of limited hours of opening all over the country. Therefore, more latitude will be allowed to Deputies than they would be entitled to under the terms of amendment 46 now before the Committee.

Comment on this

In view of what the Minister said as to his intention in regard to the hours that he proposes for bona fide traffic, if I may venture to do so, for the purpose of facilitating discussion upon this matter, I suggest that the Minister's amendment should be inserted at the next stage of this Bill. Then the discussion should take place and amendments could be tabled to those hours. I think that would simplify matters. It would mean, it is true, postponing the discussion at the moment. But I suggest that the Minister should table his amendment for the next stage, put in his new proposal with regard to hours, and let that be the substantive proposal at the next stage, and let Deputies move amendments and, upon them, discussion would take place.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Would not the same purpose be achieved if the Minister's amendment was accepted at this stage, and appeared in the reprint of the Bill? Deputies could then move their amendments to the new hours, which are more in favour of the movers of the amendment than the hours actually standing in the Bill as read a second time.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned, speaking only for myself, I am prepared to adopt that course—to accept for the moment the Minister's proposals in regard to hours for the bona fide traffic, subject to the subsequent right to move amendments similar to the ones I have upon the paper. I desire to say, at once, that I was very much struck by the speech we have just listened to from the Minister. I think he deserves great credit for making this suggestion and throwing open to the Dáil the opportunity of discussing a suggestion which was not one of those actually put forward by the signatories to the report of the Liquor Commission. I think his attitude in this respect has been a courageous one. There is a great deal to be said from his already expressed points of view, and many others, for his mooted alternative, namely, that of substituting a period of general opening throughout the country on Sundays in the future instead of continuing the present bona fide system. The question was raised at the Commission, but it did not meet with very great support—in fact, I think, the contrary was the fact —from the avowed advocates of temperance reform, and the Minister, very candidly, has said so himself.

Of course, to make this change would be a very radical step. It would alter the whole licensing system, and, I think, Deputies would require more time and opportunity to consider this than they will have at their disposal during the discussion of this Bill before making any attempt to give effect to this suggestion. But I, for one certainly, would not put it out of my mind. However, the conclusion I come to in dealing with this Bill as it is now at the time we are considering it, and in the circumstances, is that it would be almost too drastic a step for us to depart without further grave and serious consideration from the existing system. No one denies the abuses of the existing system, and nobody upholds the system in its abuses. But, though there may be abuses, at the same time, for many years it has been, and at the moment it is, the only workable system whereby justice can be done to those who are placed in certain positions on certain occasions throughout the country.

The exempted cities are now disposed of, except in regard to weekdays.

The hours that have been suggested by the Minister do not altogether commend themselves to me. If this system is to be continued I see no reason for departing from the existing hours, that except between 7 in the morning and 1 in the afternoon—these hours were put in principally because they were stated to be the hours of divine service—everyone should be entitled to the facilities afforded bona fide travellers provided they are qualified. The Minister has proposed now the hours 1 to 7 in the winter time and 1 to 8 in the summer time. He gives a discretion for the alternative of 2 to 9 in the summer, if it is so desired.

I have already mentioned the case of a place like Tramore, Co. Waterford. I could mention numerous others. I am sure others will be mentioned during the course of the debate, such as Howth and other places in County Dublin, to which, especially in the summer time, people travel. They spend a considerable time in recreation of one sort or another there. I still say that from 1 to 8 o'clock is not sufficient to meet these cases, or from 2 to 9, because people might, as they do, start out in the late afternoon of the summer to go to a bathing or seaside resort, and might desire refreshment of the nature we are discussing at a fairly late hour without having either the time or the means, or even if they had both, the desire to go into a hotel or restaurant and partake of a substantial meal. I think that the arguments I used on the Second Reading debate apply equally to these hours.

I do not know if the Minister has perused all the amendments, but I have one down suggesting first that the bona fide hours should be allowed to remain as they are, and a subsequent amendment, in the event of that one not succeeding, suggesting that the hours should be from 1 until 10 o'clock. I would appeal to the Minister to consider the later hours. Ten o'clock is not very late in the summer, especially with summer time. At that hour it is really only 8.30 sun time. I suggest that 10 o'clock in the summer time would not be an unreasonable hour to ask to have the facilities afforded bona fide travellers. However, we will have an opportunity on the next stage of further discussing this matter.

I would like to say, on the question of general opening throughout the country, that that would not quite meet the case that the bona fide system meets at present and on the other hand, it might create a new situation. What I mean by that, is that it would afford local people an opportunity, which they have not now, of partaking of liquor, and it might not necessarily afford travellers, especially those at seaside or pleasure resorts, the facilities which they enjoy under the present law, or even under the Minister's own proposal in regard to the bona fide traffic. Certainly I cannot say that I am convinced that general opening throughout the country would be a greater service in the cause of temperance, but I will also say that I am by no means unconvinced in the matter.

Still, I believe it would be foolish to depart from the present system. That does not mean that I think the present system is anything in the nature of an ideal one, but, before departing from it, we should give the whole question the most careful consideration. At this stage of this Bill it is not opportune for us to depart from a system which has obtained for several years. The thing for us to do is to try to improve that system for the benefit of the public at large.

Comment on this

I want to understand the position in regard to those amendments. I take it that we are discussing amendment No. 44, the effect of which, if passed, will be to extend the bona fide hours to a greater extent than is provided by any of the other amendments on the paper.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We are taking a decision on amendment 46 at this particular stage in order to see in the Bill an hour which, from the point of view of the people who have amendments down, is a better hour, and which is the Ministerial view of the matter. I thought the Deputy was clear about that. We are taking amendment 46, but we are taking a discussion on the general question now, and on the next stage the Deputy will, if these words are inserted in the Bill, be quite in order in endeavouring to extend the hours.

Comment on this

I am willing to withdraw my amendment and to accept the Ministerial amendment, provided that I have the right to introduce my amendment at a later stage and to have it discussed in Committee. It is rather difficult to give a decided opinion on the very large topic opened up by the Minister in his rather candid statement. I may say that I thoroughly approve of the spirit in which that statement was made. It is somewhat in contrast with the statement made yesterday. Any opinions I may express at this stage will be tentative. The public have not yet had an opportunity of discussing this aspect of the question—that is, the complete opening on certain hours on Sundays. Public opinion has not in any way crystallised on that aspect. We are speaking at short notice, and the opinion I put forward, as I said tentatively, is that the rural community would not care to accept the alternative the Minister has offered. The clerical element in the rural community would, I think, be more strongly opposed to it than the lay element. The Minister's ideas in this regard seem to be coloured by the opinions which he holds in respect of the present bona fide traffic. The Minister's ideas on this matter are not in any sense mine. The Minister seems to regard the present bona fide traffic as a tolerated evil, whereas I regard it as a form of necessary licence. The Minister seems to think that the bona fide provisions are largely availed of illicitly, that the people who take advantage of them are not bona fide in the proper sense of the term. I am not in a position to make any definite statement on that, but I think the bona fide legislation is not abused to the extent which the Minister seems to think.

One of the first questions we have to decide is whether bona fide provision is necessary or whether it is not. It is difficult to arrive at a considered opinion, because all our ideas are formed from habit and practice. We are all somewhat conservative. We are all inclined to stick to what we have become accustomed to, and we resent quick changes. I am inclined to think that the present system of bona fide traffic is necessary and that the suggested proposals of the Minister would not, in any sense, meet the requirements of the people. The whole question hangs on whether a man who needs a drink when travelling is entitled to a drink. That right has been recognised. For that reason, I maintain that we should make available for any bona fide traveller the opportunity of getting a drink at any time during prohibited hours. My amendment aims at maintaining the existing conditions. My contention is that if a man requires a drink from 1 to 7, or from 1 to 8, the same man may require a drink between 7 and 10 or 11 o'clock. I cannot see why a man should be entitled to a drink between 1 o'clock and 7 o'clock and why he should not be entitled to a drink between 7 o'clock and 10 o'clock. A man may be genuinely bona fide at 8 o'clock. He may be more genuinely entitled than the man who is travelling at 4 o'clock or 5 o'clock. In modern times, with the use of motor-cars, it is quite common for people to be out much later than 7 o'clock.

Comment on this

He becomes more and more genuine as the night goes on.

Comment on this

No, but he remains just as genuine. I believe that the effect of the Minister's suggestion would be a definite increase in drinking. It would cause a rush of people into the publichouses in the towns during restricted hours. The result of that would be that the people would consume the drink in a hurry. Sunday being a day on which the working man has money to spend, he would consume his drink in a hurry and you would have scenes. You would have drunken men in the villages and you would have a certain amount of profanation, which would be objectionable to the ordinary citizen and particularly objectionable to the clerical citizen.

I believe that public opinion is opposed to the opening of publichouses in accordance with the suggestion made by the Minister. Personally, I am strongly in favour of the retention of the present bona fide hours, because I believe that if we recognise that the bona fide traffic is necessary, we will also have to recognise that it is as necessary at one hour as at another. If a man is genuinely bona fide, he is as much entitled to a drink at 10 o'clock at night as he is at 2 o'clock in the day.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I desire to say a few words in response to the invitation which the Minister for Justice has addressed to Deputies. It seems to me that the Minister, in the course of his speech, overstressed the inter-dependence of the two questions which he mentioned—a general opening on Sundays as against the bona fide traffic. The Minister spoke repeatedly of the general opening as being a good exchange for the abolition of the bona fide traffic. I do not think the two questions are, in fact, inter-dependent at all. If there are abuses, and I admit there are in connection with the bona fide traffic, the way to get rid of them is not by creating what, in my opinion, would be a greater abuse, that is, a general opening of publichouses on Sundays. I have no doubt in my mind that if you had that general opening you would have far more drinking on Sundays than at present.

I believe that people who never bother about drinking on a Sunday now would, if the opportunity were there, avail of it. In speaking now, I have the rural areas almost entirely in my mind. Let us picture what would happen in a country village. Under present conditions the number of bona fide or mala fide travellers in a village on a Sunday for the purpose of getting drink is small compared with the number of people who live there and never travel on a Sunday for the purpose of getting drink, but if the publichouses are thrown open on a Sunday for three hours then, undoubtedly, a very large proportion of the people in that village will avail of the opportunity presented for taking drink—many of them people at present who never bother about taking a drink on Sunday.

I am inclined to say that a man does not want so much a drink as he wants another drink. With many men the desire for the second, third or fourth drink is much greater than the desire for the first one. Men going into publichouses on Sunday to get a drink will certainly be very anxious to remain on and get more drink, and even when the closing hour comes they will be a serious temptation to the publican in the village to break the law. That is an abuse that I believe will arise from Sunday opening. The Minister asks us to look at the matter from the point of view of the State as a whole. I think Deputies who look at the question from the manner in which it will affect their own particular districts are not to be blamed. It is not unreasonable for those who are aware of the abuses that take place in the neighbourhoods of the large cities, where at present you have Sunday opening in the afternoons, to ask why should the publichouses in their little districts or villages be also opened on Sundays in order to get rid of these abuses. These abuses should, I think, be tackled on their own merits. Bad as the abuses are at present. I think they would become far bigger if there was a general opening on Sundays. This would certainly be putting a temptation in the way of people who now do not drink on Sundays or even on weekdays.

In the case, say, of a man who does not take a drink from one end of the week to the other, he may wander into a village on a Sunday evening, and if the publichouses are open he may be tempted to enter them. In that way this general opening might have the effect of making a drinker of a man who otherwise would not have become one. I think that is a consideration that the Minister should take into account when discussing this question. I am certainly against the idea of a general opening on Sundays. I do not see why it should be put forward as an exchange for doing away with the bona fide traffic. If there are people in the community who think that the bona fide traffic abuse has reached such proportions that there ought to be a complete closing on Sundays, well, then, let that question be faced. For my part I do not think the abuse has reached that stage yet.

I may say that I am speaking now entirely of the rural districts. I am not referring to the county boroughs at all. There are, undoubtedly, some bona fide travellers. If they want a drink and if they feel they are entitled to it, it is no use, as Deputy Heffernan said, to say to them: "I will allow the publichouses to open in other districts between 2 and 5 where nobody was particularly anxious that they should be opened." I agree, of course, that this is a question on which various views are held. I have expressed mine in response to the invitation of the Minister.

Comment on this

I think the Minister for Justice has done a great service by inviting the Dáil to give its opinion on this question of the bona fide traffic. I take a great interest in temperance reform, though I do not consider that I am by any means a Pussyfoot. I endeavour to take a reasonable view of the matter on both sides, and from the point of view of the law to try to get what is best for the country. I agree with everything the Minister has said, and I hold that the bona fide traffic, carried on as I saw it, was nothing but a complete farce. I was a magistrate for about 30 years, and during that period I had considerable experience in dealing with these cases. I happened to own a place—I lived in it myself for many years—that was one of the beauty spots in the county. There was a right of way through it, and I can say that on Sundays, when the publichouses in the district were supposed to be closed, I have seen more drunken people going through my place, up to a late hour at night, than I could count. I am talking now of some years ago, but I believe things are better now. This was an intolerable nuisance, and you had that kind of thing going on in the district when the publichouses were supposed to be closed. I said before that most of the cases of drunkenness that came before me as a magistrate were cases that occurred on a Sunday. We must look at things from a sensible point of view. I know that, to a great many enthusiastic temperance reformers, the idea of opening on a Sunday is anathema, that the idea of such a thing is not to be considered and that they have a great prejudice against it. Everyone desires, of course, that sobriety should be observed on the Sabbath Day, but we have to look at human nature as it is.

I, long ago, came to the conclusion that it was not to be got by having the house closed but nominally open. The front doors were shut and the back doors were open. There was more drunkenness in that part of the country, on that day, that I know of. Frequently, in lonely mountainous districts, I have seen people borne out of some of those houses when they were supposed to be shut. I do not suppose there is any chance of reform in this direction, but I see nothing to alter my conviction that it would be far better to be honest and have the houses open for a limited number of hours than to have illicit drinking going on. With the reduction of the houses that will take place under this Bill there ought to be much more efficient supervision by the Gárda Síochána. It is far better to be open and working in the light of day than to have drunkenness going on all day, all through the country in a certain number of houses, badly conducted, and in shebeens. An expression of opinion has been asked for. I am as keen about reform in the licensing laws as anyone can be, but I am afraid the time is not ripe for it yet. There is a very strong feeling against it. It would be far better for the country to look the matter straight in the face and deal with it on that line. If the houses opened, under proper supervision, for three hours it would be better than to have what is going on. If that is not to be, I say the hours in the Bill are the best, and it is necessary that the bona fide hours should be less. They are ridiculously and unnecessarily long, and I say now the hours the Minister has suggested, which, possibly, may be altered in two particulars, are the best to regulate this drinking, which must be kept under proper supervision.

Comment on this

As I understand the bona fide traffic on Sundays, it practically amounts to this:—Unrestricted drinking between certain hours in certain localities. The ten mile limit, under the altered circumstances as we find them to-day, is very little prohibition. The Minister recognises that, because he said that the abuse of the bona fide system has grown enormously. We all admit that. New conditions have grown up that have led to it. He has put before you the alternative of a fixed opening for three hours on Sunday. When we look at it, on the one hand, from the point of view of seven hours' unrestricted drinking, as against three hours' unrestricted drinking, of course we all go for the three hours unrestricted drinking. The evil is one which will have to be countered in the very near future. I agree with very much of what Deputy Wolfe has said about the evils that have grown under this bona fide system

Any of us who visit our beauty spots on Sundays during the summer months are appalled at the conditions found there. Visit Glendalough and I think the conclusion you will come to, notwithstanding the attractions of the place, is that it is not a place to visit on a Sunday. The amount of drinking that goes on in this beauty spot, particularly Glendalough, on Sunday, is appalling. Not alone does it affect that particular area, but those charabancs and motors going to that area do not stop as frequently going there as when they are returning. It seems to be the duty of everyone on the charabanc to stand a drink to the driver at one of the many publichouses which the charabanc passes coming in. The charabanc pulls up and a number of people get out, including the driver. You can just imagine the conditions under which those cars are driven back to the city. I do not know whether any of you have to drive on a Sunday night. I have had to do it frequently along those roads and the driving is such that it is not safe to go on them after certain hours. That is a condition of things that must be met.

Therefore, if the Minister only puts up the alternative of unrestricted drinking for three hours as against seven hours I shall plump for the three hours. I do not know, however, that it meets the whole situation. It will certainly do a great deal to prevent the drinking that goes on which I have mentioned. Having visited a number of beauty spots in Northern Ireland on Sunday and having visited our own beauty spots in the Free State, I say there is no comparison at all as to the conditions in them. As we know Northern Ireland to-day, you have total closing there on Sundays, and I must say the conditions one finds, as a result, in their beauty spots are very different from the conditions one finds in our own. One does not find those scenes which are so very objectionable. I must say that to make a suggestion whereby those difficulties one has in mind can be remedied, from what I have seen I would go for the adoption of the system at present in vogue in Northern Ireland. The view, of course, that is held is that that would possibly be too drastic for the gallant Captain on my left and those for whom he very often speaks. I am satisfied from what I have seen that that is the only remedy that will make safe the roads and surroundings of these particular places. Drastic as it may seem, I must at all events, from my experience, advocate it as a method for dealing with this difficulty.

Comment on this

I congratulate the Minister for Justice on the very broad-minded speech he has delivered here this evening. He has thrown, more or less, the responsibility on the whole Dáil for this Bill, and that is just about what we wanted. In all his remarks I did not hear him mention nor do I understand yet how many miles he has in mind as sufficient to make a man a bona fide traveller. Hitherto we had three miles. The real traveller, the man who had to walk three miles, is the man I have in mind. The Minister is speaking of the man who has to drive three miles. It does not take that man three minutes sometimes to drive these three miles, whereas it took an hour on the part of the poor man with nails in his boots to walk three miles through the mud of necessity, and not only the poor man in the country, but perhaps the man inside the counter all the week who is taking a walk for his health on Sunday. I mention those three miles simply because I would like to know what I would be swopping for those three hours. It is suggested that the publichouses be open for three hours in the country. That goes to show that I was not very far from the harbour yesterday, when I said four hours.

There is one little exception in the country to the general run and that is seaside resorts. We have a few of them South also, and they must be separated, to my mind, as far as the law is concerned, from the inland towns. I would ask the Minister for Justice how many miles he has in his mind in order that a man might be deemed a bona fide traveller? I have not been informed of it yet. Now we come back to the three or four hours' opening. I hold that the young men who are drinking in their own village and who are under the supervision of their own Gárda, and under the supervision of their own people very often, are not in the same danger as the collection of young men who go away fifteen or twenty miles in a motor car and have a jolly fine day for themselves Deputy Good pointed out, and every time they are having one themselves the chauffeur will have one. We can well imagine their condition in the evening. I understood from the Minister this evening that he left the matter to us to decide on, and to express our views openly on it—it will be decided by the free vote of the Dáil, and that is the proper way to decide it. We will leave it to the discretion of the Minister for Justice after that to vest in his police officer in any seaside town a certain discretion whereby he could ask for a few hours' opening for visitors to a particular seaside resort. Until I find out how many miles a man will have to travel before he is to be deemed a bona fide traveller, I will keep my mind open as to whether the opening is to be for three or four hours, or whether the system of bona fide traveller is to be continued.

Comment on this

I think if Deputy Wolfe were now present he would admit that the scenes which he described, and which he stated that he witnessed on Sundays as arising from excessive drinking, were confined to a particular locality. I think he will admit that. He mentioned a certain beauty spot. I think it is not very hard to put a name to it, because the Deputy undoubtedly meant Poulaphouca, in Kildare. That place is the resort of large numbers of people from distant places, and particularly from the city of Dublin. The description which Deputy Wolfe gave to it may be warranted or not from the point from which it is looked at. I have been there, now and again, and I did not think it was altogether as bad as Deputy Wolfe stated. At all events, admitting it was bad enough. I would like the Dáil to realise that that state of things is confined to this particular locality, and that the abuse of Sunday drinking is not at all general in the Country Kildare. As to the suggestion made by the Minister that the question of general opening on Sunday should be considered, I must say, that so far as my knowledge goes, there is no demand whatever for that in the country— neither by the public at large nor by the licensed traders themselves. I am satisfied that there is not a demand amongst the licensed traders for general opening on Sundays. Deputy O'Connell has drawn a dark picture of what the condition of things would be if you had general opening on Sundays. He has warned you that people living adjacent to publichouses in the small towns and villages, and who never in the past left their homes to look for drink on Sundays, might be induced by reason of the fact that the publichouses would then be open, to seek drink on Sundays, and perhaps to take drink to excess. I can remember the time when there was no total Sunday closing, when the houses were open all day on Sunday, and at that time in some of the towns, especially the towns bordering on the Curragh, scenes were witnessed amounting to a regular pandemonium. I think the Dáil should pause before giving any support whatever to the proposal to open publichouses on Sunday.

Comment on this

Might I ask the Deputy whether I am to take him as saying that he has a personal recollection of the time when publichouses were open for the sale of drink on Sundays throughout the country?

Comment on this

Yes, I have.

Comment on this

That was in 1878.

Comment on this

Certainly, I remember it.

Comment on this

I would like to say just a few words on this question of the bona fide traffic. I want to say that so far as I am concerned, I have no difficulty whatever in making up my mind as to the merits of the Minister's suggestion that the publichouses be open for three hours on Sundays. I am absolutely against it. I believe the country will be against it.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Before I sit down I will tell the Deputy, I hope, my reasons. One of the reasons would be that it would be presenting opportunities for drinking to people who at the moment have neither the opportunity nor the desire to take drink on Sundays. The Minister asked us to look at this matter from the point of view of our own particular district or constituency. He then proceeded to discuss the matter from the point of view of the city of Dublin and its surroundings.

Comment on this

Deputy Good followed in the same direction. We were told about the tremendous abuse of the bona fide traffic. Now, so far as I know, there is no general abuse throughout the country. There is abuse undoubtedly to a certain extent, but there is no general abuse in the way that has been suggested. Deputy Good went so far as to say that it was a question of three hours unrestricted drinking or seven hours unrestricted drinking. I submit that is an exaggeration. There is no unrestricted drinking on Sundays at the present time. We know very well a traveller has to satisfy a publican that he is a traveller, and the numbers of people who go outside the three-mile limit in the country for the purpose of drinking are very few, comparatively speaking.

I am trying to visualise what would happen if we had the publichouses in every town and village in the country open for three hours on Sundays. I am trying to picture what a temptation it would be to men who at present do not think of going outside the three-mile limit, or who, if they do think of it, are not in a position to go. We must remember that men who go to drink either on a Sunday or a weekday do not go altogether for the sake of the drink alone; it is as often as not for the sake of the company. If the publichouse is open on a Sunday, men who usually sit in their own homes on Sunday afternoons and who would not dream of taking a car or walking three or four miles in the country to the nearest publichouse, would certainly think of going round the corner to the adjacent publichouse.

I have no doubt that the Minister's suggestion would be a very good one from the point of view of the publican, but a very bad one from the point of view of the public. If publichouses are allowed to be open on Sundays the Minister will not achieve what he is aiming at in the Bill—lessening the consumption of drink. From the point of view of temperance the proposal is certainly very bad.

Deputy Wolfe talked about people going out through back-doors on a Sunday. We all know that obtains to a certain extent in every place, notwithstanding the careful supervision of members of the Gárda Síochána. We know quite well that even if the publichouses in the country should be allowed to open from 2 to 5, drinkers would still be going out through the back-doors from 5 till midnight. That is no cure for the disease at all. This is really a question of providing even greater facilities than there are at present for drinking on Sundays.

I am not at all satisfied that a case has been made out for the three hours opening in the country boroughs. I would like to hear a case made out for such opening. I do not see why publichouses should be open on Sundays. I submit a case can be made for bona fide traffic. The man who is travelling, and who is out for a day's enjoyment, is certainly entitled if he wants one, two, three or four drinks, to get them.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy consider it would be practicable to administer the bona fide system in Dublin? Suppose there were no 2 to 5 opening, and suppose you put Dublin purely in the same position as any provincial town, does the Deputy think it would be feasible to administer the bona fide system in Dublin?

Comment on this

I said that I did not hear any case made out for the proposal. I take it what the Minister has suggested is one of the points in favour of it. I would want to hear a very strong case made before I would be satisfied that there should be free drinking, even in the cities, for three hours on Sundays. What does it mean? Immediately the publichouses are open they are filled. We find queues lining up outside publichouses just as they would line up outside a cinema, waiting for the clock to strike 2. Then those people rush into the publichouses and so long as they have money they will remain there drinking until finally the places are closed down at 5.

Comment on this

Have you had any experience of that?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Have you?

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this

It is really a question of consuming the greatest possible quantity in the space of time at their disposal. The proposal now is that you are to substitute that system for the present system of bona fide traffic with all its drawbacks, and it has its drawbacks and abuses. I submit that the abuses through the country do not exist to the extent suggested here. I suggest the Minister should allow the hours to be from 1 to at least 10 o'clock.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Morrissey believe that the three mile limit is sufficient to constitute a bona fide traveller? Does he believe there are abuses of the system?

Comment on this

I will talk on the mileage question when we come to it; we are not discussing it at the moment. We ought to get out of our minds that right through the country there is this terrible abuse of drink on Sundays. We are told that in the country we have dozens and scores of young men going out from towns to the first publichouse outside the limit and they stay there all day, get drunk to the extent that Deputy Good speaks about, and go home a danger to themselves and the general community. It is not fair to the country, it is not fair to the standard of sobriety we have attained in this country, to suggest that. That may obtain around the city. I do not know. I am not in a position to speak for the city. But speaking for my own country and some of the neighbouring counties that I go through from one Sunday to another. I have certainly seen nothing of that nature.

I believe that the gentlemen who use charabancs on Sunday are not always as drunk as they seem to be. They are often in good spirits. Their sense of dignity is not as great as that of Deputy Good, and they believe in giving vent to their feelings. We know that there is another type of drinker who is often, perhaps, a greater danger to himself than to the country. There is the gentleman who goes to the club or hotel and stays there until he is brought out by the waiters, but he has a sober driver outside to drive him home, and he is perhaps either too drunk or too stupid to let people outside know whether he is drunk. I strongly resent the suggestion that every party of workers who, after their week's hard work, hire a charabanc on Sunday morning to spend a day in Wicklow or Kildare in summer, go merely with the object of getting drink, and on the return journey become a nuisance to themselves and everybody else. That may happen, and, I suggest to Deputy Good, it happens just as often with people who have more sense and who have more opportunities of enjoying themselves than people who use charabancs, but they are better able to hide it. We ought to make up our minds that we are not going to improve the country or make for temperance by giving greater facilities for drinking on Sundays.

Comment on this

A fairly wide field has been left open to us in relation to this suggestion by the Minister of a limited opening of three hours for bona fide traffic on Sundays. I do not believe that it would make for temperance or help the community. I think it would involve such a redistribution of trade as would possibly, in view of the principle which we are adopting in regard to licences, necessitate compensation. By compelling a man to drink at home during these three hours I do not think that you are going to help the cause of temperance. At present there are not many abuses in regard to bona fide traffic, but I fear that if this proposal were adopted the abuses that would take place would far outweigh any advantages which we could hope to derive from a limited opening of three hours all over the country. Moreover, most of the establishments in which intoxicating liquor is sold have changed hands within a number of years back, and they have been bought and sold in relation to the position they occupy and the opportunities for trading which they enjoy under the existing system. If you are going radically to change that system and take away from these people, or any of them, their means of livelihood, which they had reason to believe was going to continue, I do not see how, in equity, you can refuse to give them some compensation for the injury which you will do to them in that respect.

I do not intend to pursue the matter further on that particular aspect of the question beyond expressing an opinion on it. That opinion, like most of the opinions that have been expressed here, has not had time to mature, but is given on the spur of the moment, from a cursory glance at the matter. I am of opinion that the suggestion would not help the cause of temperance nor be beneficial to the community generally as a substitute for the existing system. This amendment which has been accepted by the Minister stipulates that a bona fide traveller cannot be served after 8 p.m. on Sundays in summer time. I submit that that is going some distance, in any case, to improve the position in the Bill providing that the hours shall be from 1 to 3 and from 5 to 7. The arrangement of 1 o'clock to 7 in winter and 1 to 8 o'clock in summer is, at least, a straight run and one that we will be able to support, in the hope that we will succeed in persuading the Minister on the next stage to extend the time a little further in relation to seaside resorts. Deputies from my county are much concerned with the question of seaside resorts, as we have a bigger proportion of them than many of the counties represented here, and I feel that there is a certain responsibility upon us as to what ought to be equitably done in the interests of such places. The interests of such traders ought to be considered as carefully as those of the temperance or other interests which are supposed to weigh with legislators. I think confusion is caused, in the first place, by the introduction of summer time into legislation. It tends to confuse things, and we have already quite enough confusion. People hardly understand the hours for opening or closing, or their exact position in regard to the clock.

Comment on this

I will agree to an amendment to a uniform period of 1 to 7 o'clock.

Comment on this

Make it 1 to 8 o'clock. I do not like summer time in whatever direction it is used. It is to the confusion that I object and not so much in regard to the extra hours. It means great confusion to the people generally. Some go by one time and some by another, and I suggest that summer time should not be introduced. Make the period an hour less or an hour more, but do not bring in the question of summer time.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy understands that this is not so much a question of summer time but the period of summer time, the period in which the time is officially changed. As to the time in both periods, it is the official time prevailing in the State.

Comment on this

It has been so in regard to legislation and has caused infinite confusion.

Comment on this

I am afraid that I could not clear up the Deputy's confusion on this or some other matters.

Comment on this

I do not suppose I am more confused than others, but I am talking for those who are confused. I know from actual experience what I am talking about as to the difficulties that are created by the introduction of summer time into legislation. I think seaside places should get special consideration, but I feel it is impossible in a measure that proposes to deal with matters generally to make special provision in favour of particular places. The suggestion was made by some Deputies that seaside places should be put in a separate category or schedule. I do not beleive that it would be possible to do that, and difficulty and trouble would be created in the matter of definition of seaside places. In my opinion, whatever is being done should be general in relation to the question of the hours in which bona fides are entitled to be served. I do not feel that I would be justified in going into the question of distance here. I have heard the subject referred to in debate, but I do not want to overstep the rules as regards what I am entitled to deal with. It is an important question, and on another amendment I will say what I have to say on the subject. Meanwhile I leave the question of hours alone. It is a grievance and requires modification, as it is distasteful and very hurtful to a very important and valuable section of the community.

Comment on this

I have been engaged in examinations for the last couple of afternoons and, unfortunately, I have missed the discussions that have taken place here, as well as the statements made by the Minister. I understand the Minister has asked the House to consider whether there should be Sunday opening generally throughout the country for three hours during the afternoon, or bona fide traffic allowed between 1 and 7 or 1 and 8. I am absolutely opposed to the general opening of publichouses on Sunday throughout the country. This matter was discussed very fully before us in the Commission. To one after the other of the witnesses I put the question: "Do you think there is any general desire for Sunday opening throughout the country?" and the answer invariably was: "Certainly not." This answer did not come only from those who were advocates of temperance, but others. It came also from a judge who had great experience of the people. I admit that, on the whole, the police were in favour of it. I concluded they were in favour of the general opening on Sunday because it would be much easier to exercise supervision in the three hours during which the licensed houses would be open than to keep control of bona fide traffic. With regard to that traffic, I do not think anything was argued with more force, and an attempt was made to get the bona fide traffic removed in its entirety. I have personal experience of its abuse, much more in the earlier days than of late years, but there is no question that abuses still exist. That may be so to a small extent in country places, as Deputy Morrissey has said, but there is no question of the evil effects in districts around Dublin.

The question of such places as Glendalough, Killarney, and seaside resorts occupied a good deal of our attention, and we found it would be an extremely difficult matter to do away with the bona fide traffic, particularly as regards tourist traffic, in those places. It was suggested by some members of the Commission that it would be possible for tourists to be served in the hotels in these places under the hotel licences. On the other hand, it was pointed out that would mean class legislation, and no member of the Commission was prepared to sign a document regarding which it could be said it was sought to divide one class from another as far as legislation was concerned. When the trade appeared before us one gentleman from Bundoran wished to have the bona fide hours extended from, I think, 12 noon until 11 at night. He wanted apparently to catch the people who were coming from the Six Counties, who made Bundoran a calling place. As I say, there was no great desire on the part of the licensed trade to settle this difficult question of bona fide traffic. We came to the conclusion, by which I am firmly abiding, that it would be a very retrograde movement to have Sunday opening throughout the country, and that we should have the bona fide traffic confined to about four hours in the afternoon. I am sorry I have not heard the Minister's statement, as I should wish to say something further upon it. But, unlike Deputy McGoldrick, I have not come to a sudden determination in regard to this, for we made up our minds very definitely in the Commission upon the matter.

Comment on this

In my opinion the opening of publichouses on Sunday would be very undesirable. I believe it would be a retrograde step, and I do not think the licensed traders of the country are in favour of it. I was very much struck with the remarks made by Deputy Wolfe. He appears to be in favour of temperance, and at the same time he wants the publichouse open on Sunday.

Comment on this

On the point of explanation, I cannot prevent the state of things that exist. I only want to try to make them bearable for both sides.

Comment on this

The Minister called for an expression of opinion from the Deputies, and I think he has got two very favourable opinions from the Benches opposite. Deputy O'Connell put the case for rural Ireland in a straight and honest way, and in my opinion he expressed the views of every person who knows the state of affairs in the country.

Comment on this

I wish to express my opinion as to the Minister's counter-suggestion regarding the bona fide traffic. I believe it would be a very wrong thing to have a general opening of publichouses throughout the country on Sunday. Neither the people nor the trade, in my opinion, want this, and I believe many of the publicans in the towns and villages would not take advantage of these opening hours if they were granted. I believe, however, that the real bona fide traveller is entitled to refreshment if he wants it during certain hours. I do not altogether agree with the length of hours suggested by some. As to the hours put forward by the Minister, I think if he extended them by one other hour it would be sufficient for all purposes. The counter-suggestion would deal very harshly with the seaside resorts. If these resorts were allowed to open only for three hours you would probably have during these hours a state of congestion and disorder with which I do not think the Gárda could deal. At present the bona fide hours are spread over a longer period so that the traffic can be better dealt with. My county, at least, would not be in favour of Sunday opening generally, and the people would be very pleased to let the bona fide traffic remain as it is. There are several seaside resorts in my county, and if the bona fide traffic was removed a number of houses would be wiped out altogether.

Comment on this

I did not at all appreciate the speeches made by Deputy Wolfe, Deputy Morrissey and Deputy Conlan with regard to Sunday opening. To my mind, Deputy Morrissey did not consult his constituents to find out whether they would wish to have a three hours' opening on Sunday or not. I put it to Deputy Morrissey that he has not acquainted the publicans of Cahir, Clonmel and Carrick-on-Suir ——

Comment on this

I do not represent the publicans.

Comment on this

But you represent the people.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Order. We are not discussing Deputy Morrissey.

Comment on this

I presume I am in order in discussing the Deputy's speech. I hold it is the wish of the people that there should be a general opening on Sundays of from two to three hours, and I hold, further, that the Deputies I have mentioned have not voiced the opinions of the people, either of the members of the licensed trade, or of the ordinary workers and ratepayers in their districts. It is the wish of the people that all publichouses should be opened on Sundays for two or three hours. I, or any other man or woman, can come to the City, go into a publichouse on a Sunday from two to five and get a drink, but I cannot do that in the country, where I am supposed to go as a bona fide traveller. Why is it that there cannot be a general opening on Sundays? It is the wish of the majority of the people. We do not want this bona fide trade at all. We simply want the same facilities in the country as in the four county boroughs. We heard Deputy Conlan say that in olden times it was an absolute abuse, that every man who saw a publichouse open had to rush into it and get drunk, whether he liked to or not. I say that is ridiculous and absurd. That is not the Irish character. The worker, for whom Deputy Morrissey maintains he speaks, is not wrapped up in alcohol. He is more wrapped up in the question of maintaining, clothing and educating his family. That is his hobby, not the publichouse, and it is all the same to him whether it is open on Sunday or Monday. On account of the wage he receives for the sweat of his labour he cannot afford to go into a publichouse and get drunk on Sundays. I wonder if Deputy Morrissey ever had any experience of standing in those queues he mentioned, the same as a queue outside a picture house, waiting on a Sunday for the publichouses to open so that they can refresh themselves. I am sure that he has not.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept the Deputy's impression.

Comment on this

I want to show you that you are not representing the people you are supposed to represent.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy must address the Chair.

Comment on this

If a Deputy stands up here and maintains that the people whom he is supposed to represent are saturated in liquor and are perpetual drunkards it is my duty, as a representative of Labour, to contradict that.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I did not understand the Deputy to make any such statement.

Comment on this

Well, he made the statement that there are a great many queues outside the publichouses on Sundays. If there was a general opening I hold that you would have far less abuses than you have at present. What do you find with the bona fide trade? You find that publicans in the country towns and country districts must remain in all Sunday waiting from one until seven for somebody to come. But if you had general opening they would be free until three and they would be free from five, and they could go where they liked. It would mean doing a good turn to the publican as well as to the ordinary citizen. I sincerely hope that the Minister will agree to have a general opening in the whole Free State and do away completely with the bona fide traffic.

Comment on this

I have not very much to say, except that, coming from a rural district where there are a good many publichouses but not many villages, I think the people there would not be in favour of general opening. If the bona fide traffic regulations were left as they are, or the hours proposed in the Bill modified a little, I think that they would be quite content. I do not think there is any village or town in my district that wants general opening. In fact, I know that there are a good many publichouses, even at the present time, which do not admit bona fide travellers on Sunday; at all events all the publichouses do not, and therefore I do not think they would be at all in favour of general opening on Sundays. In my opinion a great many of the clergy of all denominations would certainly object to it, and I think there is no necessity for pressing the matter any further. I would appeal to the Minister to extend the hours of bona fide trading a little, to let it go to ten o'clock at least, and I think that would answer the case very well.

Comment on this

There is not much left to say on the question of a general opening after all the discussion we have listened to, but as I spoke in favour of a general opening on the Second Reading, I cannot let this debate pass without again recording my conviction that a general opening for a limited number of hours would be an improvement on the present system. Since the debate on the Second Reading I saw in one of the papers that some temperance organisation had protested against Sunday opening. There is no doubt that people who are interested in temperance do not seem to recognise or to consider that there would be any advantage to be gained for temperance by the substitution of a general opening for a few hours for the present bona fide system. That possibly is due to the fact that a number of these people come from places where the bona fide traffic has not become an abuse. The abuse, I am prepared to admit, is confined to very few areas, principally areas which are the bona fide resorts of large centres of population.

My colleague for County Tipperary has said that there is no abuse in the country districts. That, at first sight, would seem to be true. Of course, if I were to take Deputy Morrissey on a fine point, all the abuse is in the country districts, because the places where the abuses arise from the city visitors are rural areas, otherwise they could not have a bona fide traffic on Sundays; but, not to take him on that rather unfair point, there is a form of abuse in the country other than the abuse that exists in the city, that is, the number of offences against the licensing laws that occur purely as a result of the bona fide regulations. Anybody reading reports of licensing cases in the local papers will see that 99 per cent. of these cases are in some way connected with the bona fide traffic. They arise out of that, and while these cases in themselves may seem a very small proportion and are few and far between, we can take it, I think, for pretty certain, having regard to the difficulties in administering the bona fide laws, that these few cases represent the few occasions on which people happen to be "copped" and that there are a far greater number of cases in reality which are never discovered. That in itself is a serious abuse, because it leads to contempt of the law. You have the same thing in America to-day, the Prohibition law universally evaded, and it is admitted that when any law, supposedly in operation, is broken day in, day out, and broken more or less with impunity, it is a bad state of affairs in any State.

The fact is that at present there are abuses, grave abuses under the existing administration of the bona fide law, and the question before the House at present is whether we will throw up our hands and say: "This thing must go, but we see no remedy," or whether, on the lines suggested throughout this discussion, we will find an alternative. Much has been made of the argument that if you have general opening for a few hours on Sundays people who never think of drinking will be inveigled into the paths of riotous intemperance. I wonder if that is so? I do not think that when the Minister talks about a general opening on Sundays he altogether precludes the possibility of limiting the chances of improper drinking by the adoption of some such system as the split-hour system, that publichouses in the rural areas might be opened, let us say, from the hours of one to two, then closed for two or three hours, and opened for a further few hours later on. That would meet the convenience of people who come to the town in the mornings, who want to get a drink, and it would also meet the convenience of people who are entitled in the ordinary way to a drink in the course of the day, and would prevent, to my mind, any considerable abuse.

The main principle underlying this Bill, as far as it is capable of fulfilment, without undue interference with the right of a man who is going to take a drink or two and leave it at that, is to allow him to obtain his drink and at the same time to curtail the opportunities of people who indulge in excessive drinking. The Bill, as it stands at present with regard to Sunday traffic, is altogether out of harmony with the remaining sections of the Bill, and it requires some such provision as a general opening for limited hours to bring it into complete harmony, to do away with the opportunity for unrestricted drinking on Sundays, and to substitute therefor some means by which a man who is entitled to get an ordinary amount of liquid refreshment on Sunday may get it, and at the same time to curtail opportunities for excessive drinking.

Another difficulty that might arise in the administration of the general opening principle would be that in certain districts, seaside resorts and places of that kind, the hour that would be most suitable would not apply in the ordinary rural districts. The Minister might see his way to leave that to the discretion of the District Justice, so that in one district the hours might be from one to four or from one to five, and in another district from four to seven. That, I imagine, would not offer any considerable difficulty, and in that way you could make some accommodation for the needs of particular places.

There is one more point in favour of the general opening that I would like to bring to the attention of the House. that is that any system grounded on the bona fide traffic system must involve discrimination as against particular traders. Certain traders are bound to get almost the total benefit under the bona fide system. That has the evil effect of throwing the consumer into the hands of one or two traders and of leaving them—and I think it happens in some cases, at least—to supply a commodity that would not be taken if there was universal competition. Pleas have been made during the discussion in the interests of a particular class. For what it is worth, I now make a plea on behalf of a particular class. There are all over the country aged poor people who could not possibly walk three miles and who could not afford to pay for a conveyance to take them that distance, and if any man is entitled to a drink on Sunday I think the man coming on towards 70 years of age, who perhaps needs it to sustain his vigour, is better entitled to it than the man who goes out for a holiday. Such a man cannot get a drink near his home at present, but he could if there was a general opening. That is a plea for a number of people who under existing legislation have not a reasonable opportunity for obtaining a drink.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I am glad we had this discussion, and I am prepared to accept as a result of the discussion that Deputy MacCurtain and myself are in a minority in the view which we hold. It is well, however, that Deputies should be clear about the position. Under the Act of 1924, we carved a rather big hole in the bona fide day on Sunday. We provided that as between 7 a.m. and 1 p.m. bona fide traffic should not run. That was a six-hour slice out of the day. Prior to that a man who travelled the statutory distance could drink as long as he was able to stand it. There was scarcely any limitation of time. When a man travelled the statutory distance I do not know that his privilege even ceased at midnight on Sunday—I doubt if it did. The present position is that in the four cities the residents may drink in the local publichouses for three hours from 2 to 5, and that elsewhere the people who travel the statutory distance have 11 hours, if we take the halt at midnight—they have from 1 p.m. until midnight to drink. That is the position as it stands. Under the Bill, if my proposal is carried in the matter of hours, the position will be that for three hours the residents of those four cities may drink freely and locally from 2 to 5, and that elsewhere persons who travel the statutory distance may drink for six hours in the non-summer time period and for seven hours in the summer. In face of that it is, of course, not just sound to speak of Sunday opening as an evil. That really means a pretty general consumption of drink on Sunday. The question simply arises whether it would be a better thing to have a limited uniform opening throughout the State in exchange for a complete abolition of the bona fide traffic; whether, in fact, the position of three hours in four cities and six or seven hours elsewhere, conditional on travelling a given distance, is better than three hours throughout; whether it would mean less excess, less abuse, less profanation of the Sunday.

There are really three positions: There is the position of three hours in the county boroughs and six or seven elsewhere, conditional on travelling a given distance; there is the dry Sunday, which Deputy Good advocates; or there is this idea of a limited uniform opening throughout the State. That is a matter on which clearly Deputies have different views, each Deputy holding his own view with a certain amount of conviction. I have mine, but I did not feel justified, in the absence of a recommendation from the Commission, in embodying it in the Bill, and I think I am wise. I am quite prepared to agree that public opinion —certainly public opinion as voiced here—is not ripe to accept anything of the kind. In the circumstances there is only one course, and that is, to keep pruning at the bona fide hours to bring them within measurable distance of the number of hours that one would be prepared to envisage and stand over for a uniform opening. But I believe myself—and this is, of course, purely a personal view—that the bona fide traffic, as such, is doomed. I would not advise any man to invest money henceforth on the basis that it is going to survive. I do not believe it is. I think that with the increase in motor traffic, with the increased mobility of the individual, to which I have referred, the day will come, which has not apparently come yet, when people will be prepared to say that it is a better and sounder thing to agree to a limited opening throughout the State on Sunday than perpetuate this statutory farce of the bona fide traffic.

I think I made it clear to the Dáil that if they turned away from the idea of a complete abolition of the bona fide traffic in exchange for a limited opening throughout the State, then I was standing over those hours in amendment 46, which stands in the name of Deputy Dolan. I think those hours are reasonable—that is, six hours in the non-summer time period and seven hours in the summer time period. Special areas may choose whether they would take those seven hours from 1 to 8, or from 2 to 9, and the District Justice is given a discretion in that matter. The Commission recommended a break in the bona fide traffic, but it would be practically impossible to administer it. It would be a heartbreak to the Gárda Síochána sergeants throughout the country, and it would really be imposing too severe a task upon the police. I am, therefore, favouring a straight run of six hours in the autumn and winter, and seven hours in the summer-time period.

Comment on this

The Minister would not think of starting earlier and finishing earlier?

Comment on this

I would not think of starting earlier for a very good reason, and that is, that I do not want to see happening just what Deputy Daly does want to see happening—I do not want to see the whole last-Mass crowd caught by the open door of the publichouse, and that is why we have chosen 1 p.m. as the opening hour. Deputy Good was not drawing a caricature when he described the conditions arising out of the bona fide traffic around Dublin. It is a fact that these buses and charabancs and motorcars pour out of the city in the early part of the day on Sunday and that it is a genuinely dangerous thing to be facing out from Dublin at night along the Bray-Stillorgan Road or practically any of the roads leading into the city. These charabancs come lurching along the roads—you would think the vehicle itself was drunk as well as its cargo—literally taking both sides of the road. There is a halt at every village on the way back, at which the occupants dismount, which is piling Pelion on Ossa, so to speak, and always treating the driver to make assurance doubly sure. I am not shaken in my view by the general discussion that has taken place here, that it would be a good exchange for people who are primarily interested in checking the abuse and excess to accept a limited opening throughout the State in exchange for complete abolition of the bona fide traffic.

Deputy O'Connell says I stressed and overstressed the inter-dependence of the two things. "Why talk of exchange?" he said. "If a bona fide traffic is an abuse why not abolish it?" Deputy Morrissey suggested that I should also abolish the 2 to 5 opening in the four county boroughs. Talking in terms of practical politics, I do not envisage a dry Sunday as a possibility. I think people will have to make their choice; they will either have to suffer under the bona fide system, and its attendant evils, or face up to the other thing that is giving limited facilities throughout the State on Sunday evenings. I think people will not be prepared to stand for a completely dry Sunday, for the abolition of the bona fide traffic without some little compensating facility generally throughout the State. I do not believe that any Government could table such a proposal and survive. After all, we have to think in terms of what is attainable. I can quite understand temperance societies that write on their banners "Complete Sunday Closing" and lots of other ideals which they scarcely think themselves are attainable. I do not think they are attainable. I think it is a choice between one course and the other.

I am quite prepared to accept now that public opinion is not ripe for a uniform opening throughout the State, and, in the circumstances, I see nothing for it but to take another chunk, so to speak, out of the bona fide day at the end of it, limiting it to the hours between 1 and 7 in the non-summer time period and 1 and 8 in the summer time period. I hope that process will continue, that hours will be pruned from time to time and brought within measurable distance of what one might be prepared to accept as a uniform opening. I believe great evils arise from making people travel on Sunday for drink, driving them out of their home area where they are known and where the checks of human respect operate. With the increase in motor traffic and the increase of those buses and so on I believe that evil will become more and more impressed upon people's minds until in the end the view I hold and the view Deputy MacCurtain holds will cease to be a minority view, as it is fairly obviously just now.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I shall now put amendment 46.

Comment on this

There will be an opportunity at a later stage of moving an amendment to it?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes. No other proposal has been defeated at this stage.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 50 would require to be moved now as consequent to amendment 46.

Comment on this

I beg to move amendment 50:—

Before sub-section (2), on page 9, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) The Justice of the District Court may in his discretion, on the application of the holder of an on-licence in respect of premises situate in the licensing area and after hearing the principal officer of the Gárda Síochána in the licensing area, substitute the hours of two o'clock and nine o'clock in the afternoon for the hours of one o'clock and eight o'clock mentioned in the foregoing sub-section in relation to Sundays during a period of summer time, and whenever such order is so made the foregoing sub-section shall, during the residue of the period of summer time current at the date of the order or, where such order is not made during a period of summer time during the period of summer time commencing next after the date of the order, have effect as if the hours mentioned therein in relation to Sundays during a period of summer time were two o'clock and nine o'clock in the afternoon."

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We shall now take amendment 51, opening up the question of distance.

Comment on this

In the absence of Deputy Heffernan I move amendment 51:—

In sub-section (4), line 6, to delete the words "ten miles" and substitute therefor the words "five miles."

As was mentioned on the Second Reading, there does not seem much to say on behalf of the proposal as it stands in the Bill, because the existing limit of five miles from the exempted cities was arrived at as late as the year 1906, and traffic and mobility have not increased to such an extent since then as to justify the doubling of the distance. Some strange anomalies would arise if this proposal were carried. A person living within a mile of one of those county boroughs might be within bona fide distance of, say, a seaside resort, and when he arrived there would be entitled to get a drink, whereas a person actually living in the city, the difference being only a mile between them, when he travelled to the seaside would not be able to procure a drink. Perhaps I might make myself clearer if I gave an illustration. I will again fall back upon Tramore. A person living in the city of Waterford would not be entitled to get a drink in Tramore as a bona fide traveller, because Tramore is only seven miles from Waterford, whereas a person living within one mile beyond Waterford, which is practically in the suburbs, if he went to Tramore would be entitled to get a drink. That certainly seems to be an anomaly. It is penalising unnecessarily a large number of people.

But apart from that, which might seem a trifling instance, you have the whole question as to whether there is now any real reason for doubling the statutory distance. Ten miles is as easy to cover in a motor car as five miles and possibly might only take very little longer, but ten miles to a pedestrian is very different from five miles even to a cyclist. A pedestrian might be quite prepared and able to walk a distance of five miles, but he would not be able to cover the ten miles. Therefore, this proposed legislation is undoubtedly, if not in the interests of a particular class, against the interests of a particular class. The proposal, I submit, has not, so far, been justified, and I hope the Minister will re-consider it. Perhaps it might be possible for him to arrive at some compromise as regards the city area and the country area. At present the distance in the rural areas is three miles. I would suggest that six miles would be far enough from the city and four miles in any country district. He might even consider the possibility of making a universal distance throughout the whole country, say five miles from the city as it is at present, and five miles within country districts. I do not think he is warranted in doubling the distance, both from the city to outside places, and also between country areas. I hope he will listen to the discussion on this question and take the view of the House, as he has done on the question we have just been debating.

Comment on this

Are we dealing exclusively with amendment No. 51 now?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes.

Comment on this

On this question of distances, the recommendation of the Commission is that distances be doubled, and that is the provision in the Bill. One can see considerations for and against that. On the one hand, it is not in question that there is greatly increased mobility since these distances were fixed. Deputy Redmond reminds us that the city distances were revised not very long ago; certainly not nearly so long ago as the other distances were originally fixed. On the other hand, there is the question that this proposal simply wipes out one set of vested interests and creates new ones. To the cyclist, the motor cyclist or the owner of a motor car, the change is inconsiderable. I do not feel sufficient conviction on the matter to put these proposed changes in distance to the Dáil as a matter of confidence. If there is a division, I will vote for the provisions of the Bill, as recommended by the Commission, but I certainly do not feel justified in stating that this change is one on which the Government should resign if defeated.

Question—"That the words ‘ten miles' stand part of the section"— put and negatived.

Question—"That the words ‘five miles' be there inserted"—put and agreed to.

Amendment 52—"In sub-section (4), line 10, to delete the words ‘six miles' and substitute therefor the words ‘three miles'" (Deputy Heffernan)—agreed to.

Section 13, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 53 (Deputy C. Byrne) hangs on previous amendments, which have been already postponed. Amendment 53, I think, might be postponed also.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Several points are dealt with in the amendment by Deputy Redmond to this section. Two of them are dealt with by other amendments. Amendment 55, in the name of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Executive Council, deals with the question of discretion with the District Justice. Amendment 57 deals with the relief of bona fide purchasers. If Deputy Redmond were agreeable, we could get a decision on the question of discretion for the District Justice on amendment 55, to which, if he thought fit, he could propose an amendment. The question of the relief of bona fide purchasers could be dealt with on amendment 57. The other question, as to the life of an endorsement on a licence, could be dealt with now separately or on the next stage. Perhaps it would be more convenient to deal with it on the next stage.

Comment on this

I am agreeable to the procedure you propose, and I shall, therefore, move an amendment to the new section proposed before Section 22. With regard to the question of the life of the endorsement, I shall postpone that, with the leave of the Committee. I can deal with the remaining points on amendment 57.

Comment on this

I move amendment 55:

Before Section 22 to insert a new section as follows:—

"22.—(1) Whenever the holder of a licence for the sale of intoxicating liquor is convicted by a Justice of the District Court of an offence a conviction for which is required by this Act to be recorded on such licence such Justice may, if satisfied that by reason of extenuating circumstances (which shall relate only to the technical character or the trivial nature of the offence) such conviction ought not to be recorded on such licence, make an order stating such extenuating circumstances and declaring that such conviction shall not be recorded, and whenever such order is so made such conviction shall not be so recorded.

(2) Whenever an order is made by a Justice of the District Court under the foregoing sub-section on a prosecution at the instance of a member of the Gárda Síochána, an appeal shall lie at the instance of such prosecutor to the Judge of the Circuit Court within whose Circuit the District or part of the District of such Justice is situate against such order, but not against the conviction in respect of which such order was made, and if such appeal is dismissed such Judge may order the costs of the appeal to be paid by such prosecutor."

Comment on this

I have not been able to table my amendment to this proposed new section.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I will take the Deputy's amendment now.

Comment on this

My amendment is:—

To delete in line 5 of the proposed new section the words in brackets ("which shall relate only to the technical character or the trivial nature of the offence").

Comment on this

After this official amendment was put in, I heard suggestions that it did not represent a fulfilment of what I promised on Second Stage in this connection. What I said on Second Stage, in fact, was:

This Bill provides an appeal on that issue (endorsement issue) to the Circuit Judge. We say to the trader who has been convicted of any of the offences which have an endorsement as a consequence that if he could convince the Circuit Judge of his area that, having regard to the attendant circumstances, the offence which occasioned that particular endorsement was trivial, or purely technical in character, it shall be competent for the Circuit Judge to order that that endorsement shall be, for all practical purposes, inoperative and of no effect. I have been pressed on this matter and I am prepared on the Committee Stage to make even an advance on that position. I want to be very clear on this. I do not propose on the Committee Stage or on any other Stage of this Bill to revert to the position that a fine rather than an endorsement will be the normal consequence of a definite full-blooded breach of these laws, but I am prepared to give favourable consideration to some form of wording such as this: "That the District Justice shall, unless, having regard to the attendant circumstances, the offence is of a trivial or purely technical character endorse the licence." That wording conveys my idea. No doubt in the hands of the Parliamentary draftsman it would be altered somewhat, but that is the idea. I will give that, provided that there will lie with the Superintendent of the Civic Guard of the area an appeal to the Circuit Judge if he considers that an over-indulgent view has been taken of a particular case. I am anxious to meet the trivial case, the purely technical case. I am anxious to meet the case of a man whose clock is five or seven minutes wrong and who has been detected no doubt in a breach of the licensing laws, but not in a deliberate, premeditated breach. I am anxious to meet the man who is caught out under a technicality and whose offence is trivial, but I do not propose to revert to the position that a fine rather than an endorsement would be the normal consequence of a definite full-blooded breach of these laws. I may seem unduly insistent on this matter, but I am anxious not to be misunderstood, and if we leave to the District Justice a certain discretion to meet the purely trivial or technical case, I ask in exchange for that that there shall lie with the police officer, the superintendent of the district, an appeal to the Circuit Judge if, in his considered view, an over-indulgent view has been taken of a particular case and of the circumstances of a particular case, that he may go a step higher and go to the Circuit Judge and ask him whether he considers that that offence in its setting was of a trivial or technical character.

I claim, and I think all Deputies or nearly all Deputies will agree with me, that the official amendment that is on the Paper represents fully and completely a fulfilment of anything that I promised in this connection on Second Stage. (Amendment 55 quoted.)

I am told there is objection to the words in brackets "which shall relate only to the technical character or the trivial nature of the offence." That is to make sure, for instance, that the poverty of the trader would not be pleaded as an extenuating circumstance. The extenuating circumstances must relate only to the trivial nature or the purely technical character of the offence, and I think that is a necessary provision. One person, with a liberal outlook on these matters, might be prepared to regard many things as extenuating circumstances. The heat of the day might make it necessary for the client to get refreshments while the poverty of the trader might make it necessary for him to glean illegitimate profits by trading after hours and so on. The extenuating circumstances that must be relied on in this matter, if there is not to be endorsement, must be circumstances relating to the trivial nature or the purely technical character of the offence. Again may I say that the concessions that were indicated on the Second Stage have been magnified in a manner that certainly amazes me and my officials who knew just what they were. It was simply hyperbole to speak of the Bill as a distorted remnant of its former self after this particular provision had been inserted. This thing is a small matter, but it is just. It meets the only kind of case that I am prepared to consider, that is the purely trivial case, the case which I myself or any other Deputy in the Dáil might agree to be so trivial or so technical that endorsement ought not really to follow as a penal consequence. It meets that case. On the other hand, it meets no more than that, and I do not wish to meet more than that.

I think you will only get observance of those laws by taking the line that the normal consequence of a definite breach shall be endorsement rather than a fine, and that is the position that I want to preserve. That is the position I believe that I have preserved while making provision for the purely trivial and technical case. Now I was told all along by the licensed trade and their advocates that it was the trivial case, the purely technical case, they wanted to meet: the case of the man whose clock was slightly defective and went a few minutes wrong. They said it would be a great hardship if such a man had his licence endorsed. Very well, that case is met by the proposed amendment, but now it begins to emerge that that is not the case that should be met at all, that it is something else—a much more serious thing, a definite breach of the law and not a trivial or a technical offence. We must stand somewhere and draw the line somewhere and say there is finality. At this point confidence comes in, and I stand definitely and fully over this official amendment. I am not prepared to make any concession whatsoever, and if a modification of that amendment is carried, well. I shall regard that as an issue of confidence on which the Government appropriately should leave office.

Comment on this

The Minister has sought to prove that he has fulfilled his pledge given on the Second Reading.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy suggest that I have not?

Comment on this

Will the Minister please allow me to conclude my sentence? The Minister has sought to prove that he has endeavoured to fulfil his pledge given on the Second Reading in regard to this question of endorsement. The pledge that he gave on that occasion, as recited by him again to-day, was that he was prepared to give a discretion to the District Justice in regard to the attendant circumstances if the offence was of a trivial or technical nature. The Minister may honestly believe that in the section he is now proposing he is giving effect to that pledge. I do not deny that he may honestly believe he is doing so, but I will endeavour to show the House that, in my opinion, he is not. What his section proposes is, that if the District Justice is satisfied that by reason of extenuating circumstances which relate only to the technical character or trivial nature of the offence such conviction ought not to be recorded on such licence and so on. I submit that that section refers only to offences which in themselves were technical or trivial, and that it does not refer to attendant circumstances on other offences which might render those other offences thereby technical or trivial. I intend very shortly to explain the position in this regard.

In discussing this amendment, one cannot lose sight of the fact that it is proposed in a subsequent section to repeal the Probation of Offenders Act. I shall deal with that in a moment, but I would like now to recall to the mind of the House the position of a licensed holder at present in regard to endorsement. By the Licensing Act of 1872 certain convictions were made endorseable and the endorsement was to be recorded unless the magistrate, as he then was, should otherwise direct. That provision was actually repealed in the year 1874 by the Licensing Act, Section 38, but it was re-enacted by Section 16 of the Act of 1924 with the further condition that the conviction should be recorded with no provision for a discretion for the District Justice. In the year 1907 the Probation of Offenders Act was passed by the British Parliament with the object of providing some means to enable judges in criminal cases to have some discretion whereby they could mitigate sentences which might seem to them in certain circumstances connected with a case unduly harsh. It was stated by the Minister, and I am not going to score a petty point off him on this question. I think rather inadvertently at the end of the Second Reading debate, that a decision had been come to in our Courts that the Probation of Offenders Act did not apply to these licensing cases.

I did not like, at that stage, to take up much of his time—he had not much to spare before the House rose—and I simply said: "I can assure him that is not so." I find it necessary to inform the House as to the legal position to-day of licensed holders in regard to the Probation of Offenders Act. A case came before the Courts recently, and it was a test case where a licensed publican was charged with opening his premises for the sale of intoxicating liquor at a time, prohibited by law, 2.15 p.m. on the 17th of March, 1926, St. Patrick's Day. He pleaded guilty. It was admitted that his house was well conducted and that this was his first offence. The District Justice gave defendant the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1907, and ordered that he be discharged conditionally on his entering into his own recognizances. There was an appeal from that case, and it was held, on appeal, by the Appeal Tribunal, consisting of the President of the High Court, Mr. Justice Sullivan and Mr. Justice Hanna

"That on the facts in this case stated, that the justice was not entitled to give defendant the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1907. The District Justice, before giving the defendant the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1907, should be satisfied that the case falls under one of the heads of this Act, and should state explicitly on which of the grounds provided in this Act he relies before applying the Act."

These words are taken from the Official Legal Report. The result of that is obvious, namely, that in this particular case, the title of which is Gilroy v. Brennan, the Court of Appeal held that the District Justice was not justified in applying the Probation of Offenders Act, but that was a very different thing from saying that in no licensing cases was this Act applicable. In fact, that is borne out by the second portion of the headnote which I have read, where it is stated that the District Justice, before giving a defendant the benefit of this Act, should be satisfied that the case falls under one of those heads. Therefore, I contend that the Probation of Offenders Act instead of not applying to licensing cases to-day has, by this case, been shown to be applicable to them.

"The Probation of Offenders Act, 1907, provides by Section 1 that ‘Where any person is charged before a court of summary jurisdiction with an offence punishable by such court, and the court thinks that the charge is proved, but is of opinion that, having regard to the (1) character, antecedents, age, health, or mental condition of the person charged, or to (2) the trivial nature of the offence, or to (3) the extenuating circumstances under which the offence was committed, it is inexpedient to inflict any punishment or any other than a nominal punishment, or that it is expedient to release the offender on probation, the court may, without proceeding to conviction, make an order either (1) dismissing the information or charge; or (2) discharging the offender conditionally on his entering into a recognizance.'"

I want to draw Deputies' attention to what this means. All those heads are distinct and exclusive and the word "or" is used between each of those various categories, meaning thereby that where, under any of those heads, the Court was satisfied that the case could be met that they were entitled to apply the Act. The President of the High Court, Mr. Justice Sullivan, said at the conclusion of his judgement:

"I am therefore of opinion that none of the three grounds specified in the first section of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1907, was established on the evidence before the magistrate and that he was not, in the words of the question we are asked, ‘right in law in applying the Probation of Offenders Act, 1907, to the offence in question.'"

I submit that there is a record of a judgement in the Court of Appeal where the President of the High Court laid it down first that there were three grounds and then says "none of those three grounds was sustained," but Mr. Justice Hanna, went further in his judgement, and said:

"It is a matter of common knowledge that the legislature having by the Intoxicating Liquor (General) Act, 1924, made a breach of the Licensing Laws so very serious an offence, possibly leading to a disqualification, appeals are made to the justice to deal with cases under the Probation of Offenders Act."

The reason I have read that judgment is this, that it shows first, that the Probation of Offenders Act can be applied. It should not have been applied to that particular case, it is true. It shows, secondly, that in the terms of the Probation of Offenders Act there were three separate and mutually exclusive clauses under which this Act could have been applied. What the Minister proposes here is that extenuating circumstances may be taken into consideration—yes, but extenuating circumstances in regard only to one of the heads mentioned in the Probation of Offenders Act—extenuating circumstances in regard to trifling and technical offences which probably are not mutually exclusive but properly would fall under one head—extenuating circumstances, only in regard to that head of the Probation of Offenders Act and not in regard to either one or other of them, namely, to the age, character, or antecedents, or to what are called extenuating circumstances in the nature of the offence.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

Will Private Members' time be taken to-morrow?

Comment on this

Yes. We will keep on this Bill until we finish it.

The Dáil adjourned at 8.30 p.m. until Friday, 12 o'clock.

Comment on this