We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

ORDUITHE AN LAE. - ORDERS OF THE DAY. INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927 —THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–156 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Intoxicating Liquor Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 7 of 1927 ›

I would like to impress upon the Minister the reasons why he should not accept this amendment. If a licence were forfeited in one end of a county, the traders at the other end of the county would have to pay the compensation allowed to the trader who had been put out of business. That would be a greater hardship than any hardship imposed by the Bill. If a house is value for twice as much with the licence as it would be without the licence, then the trader whose licence is abolished would be entitled to the difference. Traders in another end of the county may be called upon to pay a portion of the cost of compensating that licensee although they derive no benefit whatever from the abolition of the licence. That is not fair. In a town where there are 14 or 16 publichouses and where there is a population of about 1,000, some of the licences should be abolished. It is not the first time I have expressed that opinion. A large number of publicans in the country are more than anxious, if they get decent compensation, to part with their licences. I do not at all agree with the Minister in his statement that there are many licensed houses throughout the country which at the moment would be bought dear at £50— houses which open for one or two days in the year in order to prevent the licence being lost. Take the case of a trader in a country town who has had a licence for 30 or 40 years. He may have reared a family with the profits arising from that publichouse. Would it be fair for the Minister for Justice or for the Compensation Commission to offer that man a sum of £50 and abolish his licence? At the present time he may not sell more than half a barrel of stout in the week. There are houses in the country which are not selling more than half a barrel in a week, but that is not due to bad business methods but to unemployment. If the times were better and if industries were started which would provide workers with a living wage, those publichouses would do well. Fifty pounds would not be proper compensation to offer any person for his loss of trade.

In the small towns of the constituency I represent, a number of publichouses have recently been purchased. In the town of Moate, three publichouses have been purchased within the last four years. One of these houses cost, between purchase and fittings, £1,400. If that licence is abolished, the house will be no use to the owner, and his means of livelihood will be gone. On the other hand, if these publichouses were abolished in Moate, the people in Castlepollard would have to bear portion of the compensation, according to this amendment. I think the publican who lives in the town should pay that compensation. The Minister for Finance proposes to give £100,000 towards the Compensation Fund. I think that is very fair, and it will certainly relieve the poorer publican who is allowed to remain on. I do not think the question of compensation should be left entirely to the Compensation Commission. If there are twenty publichouses in a town of 1,600 or 1,800 population, five of these publichouses will probably go.

I was put a few questions when I was in my constituency during the week-end. I visited a large number of publichouses for the purpose of making inquiries as to the intentions of the publicans towards the Government at the coming election, after the introduction of this Bill. I was requested to find out from the Minister how long the publican would have to wait before he would receive compensation, and would he be allowed to dispose of his stock after the order for abolition of the licence. A publican may have in sufficient stock to last four or five months and, if an order is made for the abolition of the licence, I should like to know what is to become of the stock. I hope the Minister will use every means in his power to defeat this amendment. If it goes to a vote, I shall certainly vote against it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I should like to point out that the amendment which is under discussion merely deals with the area of charge. The question at issue is whether the area shall be the area as in the Bill or the county. Amendment 65, I think, aims at making the area larger still. The only question for decision now is what the area of compensation shall be.

Comment on this

I hope I am not out of order in congratulating the Minister for Justice on obtaining the support of Deputy Lyons in resistance to this amendment. The Deputy was with me, as the Minister observed, last week for a brief period. He has now, owing to the force of the Minister's argument, returned to his natural camp.

Comment on this

It is good to repent.

Comment on this

As regards the discussion we had last Friday on this amendment, two points emerged rather clearly. The first was that this is not a matter of principle in any sense. It is mainly a matter of what is most convenient—convenient administratively. The other point is that the Minister, who justifies his argument mainly on the ground of fairness, is not absolutely tied to the scheme laid down in the Bill. He invited us to meet him in argument with regard to various counties, and he suggested the case of the County Mayo. I suppose the case for reducing the number of publichouses on the ground of redundancy will be based more or less on the Second Schedule of the report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission. I think that schedule was supplied to the Commission by the Minister. Looking at the County Mayo I find that there is redundancy alleged in Ballyhaunis, Claremorris, Ballinrobe, Belmullet, Louisburgh, Newport, Swinford, and Charlestown. That covers practically the whole of the County Mayo with three exceptions, and those three exceptions are the three urban districts—Ballina, Castlebar and Westport. As a matter of fact, Castlebar appears in part (b) of the Second Schedule, so that there appears to be redundancy there too. I assume that the reduction of this redundancy will not take place in one area of the county only—that it will not take place in Swinford and Charlestown and the extreme east of the county, but will extend over the whole area. Officers of the Gárda will, I presume, be instructed to apply for reduction of licences where there is redundancy in their districts. If that be so, practically the whole of Mayo, with the exception of the three urban districts, will have a simultaneous reduction going on. I do not think it is too much to say that the licensed traders in the urban district will reap some benefit from the reduction of licensed houses elsewhere. There is not only the local trade but there is the trade of the carter and the man coming along with a Ford car.

In many cases where the cross-road publichouses are done away with, on the ground of redundancy—and a great many need to be done away with—if a party cannot get refreshments there, instead of turning off and leaving the main road, they will go on into one of these towns, so that the licensed traders there are bound to reap some benefit. I would like to put it to the Minister that the burden becomes less when it is levied over a large area. Probably the men in the best position to bear the burden are the traders in the larger towns, who have a more constant custom and all the benefit of the travelling trade. The county as a whole can bear the burden with less injustice and unfairness than the smaller area of the District Court. I do not know if it is Deputy Baxter's intention to press the amendment to a division. It seems to me to be a matter eminently for further consideration and discussion, possibly with Deputies, possibly with those who speak for the licensed trade. I have not been asked to speak on this by anyone, but, looking into the matter and reasoning it from my own knowledge, I feel convinced that Deputy Baxter's amendment is a sound one, and that the county area is the fairest area of charge on the whole.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister is not tied too tightly to the section as it stands in the Bill, and will not regard it as a matter of confidence. The principle of the Bill, adopted by the majority, was that those remaining in the trade should pay for those who go out. We had a statement from the Minister for Finance, that it was estimated the number of houses likely to be abolished would be in or about 4,000. Seeing that redundancy is not clearly defined in the Bill, I was wondering, after hearing the Minister's statement, on what basis he arrived at 4,000. Was a survey made in each licensing area, or was a general figure taken of the State as a whole, and the number of publichouses to be reduced fixed at 4,000? On the last day the debate on this amendment seems to have ranged round the question whether the area should be extended to the county as proposed in the amendment, to the Circuit Court area, or the whole Free State. The Minister explained, when introducing the Bill, that there would be 340 compensation units under his scheme. The Minister admits that, from the administrative point of view, that could not be looked upon in a favourable light. If Deputy Baxter's amendment were accepted by the House, the number of compensation units would be reduced to 26.

If the Circuit Court area were accepted as the area the compensation units would be reduced to 8. As is proposed in a later amendment standing in my name, if the area is extended to the whole Free State, there will be only one compensation unit which, from the point of view of administration, should be more acceptable to the Ministry. The sponsors and supporters of this Bill claim that if it is passed it will reduce the amount of liquor consumed. If less liquor is consumed all over the Free State, as a result of the passage of a measure which limits and reduces the number of publichouses, I do not think it is fair that people in the licensing area, as defined in the Bill, should find the whole of the compensation for those who are wiped out.

In a matter of this kind we have to look back for precedents. When the Government brought in a measure for the amalgamation of railways, which, in their opinion, was to provide a more efficient system of transport, they compelled shareholders in a prosperous concern to accept a reduced revenue in order to establish that system. It is a question of policy. Is the Government policy one of amalgamation, centralisation, or decentralisation? The compensation unit from the point of view of decentralisation would lead to chaotic administration. Take the railways as a case in point. We are arguing on the principle and are not dealing either with railways or publichouses. A shareholder in the Dublin and South-Eastern Railway who had a nominal £100's holding was given in exchange in the reorganised capital of the Great Southern Railways, following the passage of the Railways Act, £47 10s. 0d. In effect, the revenue of the shareholder was reduced by more than 50 per cent. for the purpose, from the State point of view, of creating a more efficient transport system. The principle of this Bill is claimed to be similar to that which forced the amalgamation of the railways. I say that no publican should be allowed to remain outside the scope of the Bill, so far as it affects him in finding the payment for those who go out of business.

The term redundancy is not defined in the Bill. The Minister for Justice, as long as he remains in office, may administer the Bill on the lines laid down in the Report of the Liquor Commission, but his successor in five or ten years' time may take the view that there should be no licences abolished. On the other hand, he may take the view that, instead of wiping out 4,000 licences, double the number should be abolished. Therefore, no Deputy voting on this Bill can truthfully say what redundancy means, because the term is not defined in the Bill. If we are to go by statements made by Ministers inside and outside this House, the principle of imposing taxation is that those who are best able should be compelled to pay. In other words, it should depend on the capacity of the taxpayer to pay a particular amount. But if this Bill is to be administered on the lines laid down in the Report of the Liquor Commission, it will mean that in the licensing area of the City of Dublin no publichouses will be abolished. I stated that I was informed, since the Bill had been introduced, that some houses of low valuation and others that were not properly conducted were likely to be abolished. The Minister has not contradicted that statement so far. At any rate, assuming that the Bill is administered on the lines of the Report of the Liquor Commission, there will be no publichouses abolished in the licensing area of the City of Dublin. Where is the money to come from to pay the people who go out? The Minister for Finance stated that the sum of £1,200,000 would be required to pay compensation to the holders whose licences were abolished, and of that sum £100,000 would come out of the taxpayers' pockets. But I want to point out to the House that if the Bill is administered on the lines of the Report of the Liquor Commission not one penny will come out of the pockets of traders in the City of Dublin. The people who will have to pay, and it is only a matter of opinion as to the proportion which they should pay, will be those who remain in in the licensing area. Every Deputy who voted for the Second Reading of the Bill voted for that principle. Therefore, if you are going to administer the Bill on the lines of that particular vote, but not on the lines laid down in the Report of the Liquor Commission, then you are going to leave out of consideration the people who have houses with a high valuation and the people who have made the greatest profits in the trade during the last three or four years.

For that reason I support the extension of the licensing area as defined in the Bill. I wish there could be some general agreement on the area to be ultimately decided upon, which I hope will not be the area laid down in the Bill. Every Deputy who spoke on the Second Reading of the Bill, and whether they voted for or against the Second Reading, admitted, I think, that there were too many licensed houses in the Free State. I qualified my opposition and my vote against the Bill to the extent that I realised that, and that I was prepared to admit, so far as I was concerned, that it was only a matter of paying fair compensation to those whose licences were to be wiped out under this measure. I desire to put a proposal of my own before the Minister. Whatever be the licensing area eventually decided upon, I suggest that the people who will remain in, and who will benefit by the wiping out of licences in their area, should be called upon to pay two-thirds of the cost of compensation to those whose licences are extinguished in that area, whatever it may be, and that the licensed traders in the remainder of the State as a whole should bear the remaining one-third.

I put forward that suggestion without very careful consideration or consultation with anyone and I hope the Minister will give some consideration to it. The people who remain within an area, whatever that area be—county, circuit court or any smaller area—will undoubtedly receive some benefit in the wiping out of the licences of their colleagues in that particular area, and should in the natural course of events bear a greater proportion of the cost of compensation than people outside that particular area. Whether the figure be one-fourth or one-third for the remaining traders over the whole of the State, I think those who remain within the defined limit should bear the remaining three-fourths or two-thirds, as the case may be, in the matter of the compensation to be paid to those whose licences are extinguished.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy state that he put that up without consideration?

Comment on this

I dare say that in the Minister's view I would not be the type of person who would consider anything that I was going to say.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not have time mostly.

Comment on this

I do not know how the Minister arrives at that conclusion, and perhaps he would explain that silly remark. Deputy Egan undoubtedly knows more about this particular Bill than I do, and I am quite well aware from a remark that he passed that he does not agree with this particular suggestion for extending the licensing area defined in the Bill.

Comment on this

No, I do not.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy privately for his opinion on a point that I am now going to mention, but he did not give it to me. Perhaps he would give the information to the House. The question I put to him is this: How many licensed houses in the constituency of Leix and Offaly are likely to be abolished as a result of this measure? In other words, to what extent does redundancy exist in the Parliamentary constituency of Leix and Offaly.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

That is a matter for pure speculation.

Comment on this

I agree, and that is what I wanted to get out. I hope, therefore, that the Deputy will not say what he said on the Second Reading: that this would do harm rather than good to the traders of Leix and Offaly.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

That will depend on the interpretation given by the local District Justice.

Comment on this

It will depend on the interpretation of the Minister in office, advised by the Chief Commissioner of the Gárda Síochána as to the reasons which can be put forward for wiping out licences. I candidly admit that different District Justices might take different views of cases put before them as to whether or not licences should be wiped out. I am supporting Deputy Baxter's amendment because I believe in extending the area defined in the Bill. For the reasons put forward by Deputy Baxter I am prepared to leave to a later stage of the discussion the question as to whether or not agreement can be found on the fixing of that particular area. The House, at any rate, will be faced with a proposal, as was mentioned during the debate on the last day, of agreeing to the area laid down in the Bill. The county is the area proposed by Deputy Baxter. The Circuit Court district and the State as a whole were also referred to as possible areas. I support Deputy Baxter's amendment for the reason that if the area is extended the charge to be imposed on those who will remain in will be lighter than it would be under the proposal in the Bill.

Comment on this

It seems necessary for the benefit of Deputy Davin to cover a certain amount of ground that was covered in the discussion on Friday last.

Comment on this

As a matter of personal explanation, may I say that I was absent in the country on Friday on private and family business. If I could have been here I would have been in my place as usual, but I was obliged to be away on family business.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Minister's statement was not by way of criticism of Deputy Davin's absence. The reason for the Deputy's absence was generally understood.

Comment on this

I do not intend to talk about the Railways Bill. I think that the Railways Bill was very thoroughly discussed when it was before the Dáil.

Comment on this

And amended twice afterwards to prove it was not.

Comment on this

I want to take the Deputy's point that those best able to pay should be compelled to pay. He laid that down as a cast-iron, general principle. No doubt, he would be prepared to die at the stake for it, but the question arises whether this matter of the extinction of a licence is one which permits of the application of that principle at all. Those best able should be compelled to pay. What is the basis of putting a charge at all on the surviving members of the licensed trade? That is a thing we have got to examine. The basis, as we agreed on the last evening's discussion, is that the beneficiaries pay. Those who benefit by the extinction of licences should pay. It becomes a question how best to preserve and maintain that principle. I put it to the Dáil that principle is best maintained by taking, as your area for the purposes in this section, the smallest administrative unit we know, the area that is, in fact, the licensing area at present, the area tapped for summary jurisdiction purposes by a particular District Court. There are 340 such areas in the State.

I make a present, to Deputy Davin and others, of the argument that that is administratively more difficult than the larger area, that it would be administratively simple to take the county area, and a fortiori, administratively simpler to take the area of the State, to make simply a unit of the State for this purpose. It seems to me that, inherent in that idea, there is the fallacy of regarding the trade as an entity. It is not. It is simply a conglomeration of individuals engaged in the same calling. It is not a unit and should not be treated as a unit for the purposes of this section unless, indeed, I was told, in some authentic way, that the trade itself was prepared to be treated as a unit for the purpose of this compensation—that now, before any process of extinction starts to work, with very little idea as to where the extinction will lean heaviest and where lightest, they would be prepared to undertake and share equally, amongst all their members, the burden of compensation. So far as I have been able to learn, that is not the position, and the fairest thing, therefore, seems to me to adhere to the principle that the area of benefit shall be the area of charge. It is not merely a question of saying that those best able should be compelled to pay. To pay for what? What do people get, under the operation of this section of the Bill, who reside in a county or area where no extinction whatever takes place? The principle that one applies to taxation is on quite a different footing; one gets, in return for taxation, the services the State is in a position to give to all the citizens. Here you are dealing with the putting out of a particular kind of business of a certain number of individuals engaged in that business, and the principle underlying the Bill is that those who benefit by the extinction should pay.

Comment on this

To what extent does the ordinary taxpayers, including the teetotaller, benefit by the £100,000 taken from them? There is £100,000 to be paid as a State contribution.

Comment on this

That is an approximation. There is 6½ per cent. State contribution embodied in the financial provision of this section, and the Minister for Finance, speaking on that, pointed out that some diminution in consumption is envisaged—that the survivors will not get all the business of the extinguished. They will get the greater part of it, no doubt, but not all the business of the extinguished licensees. Then there are certain administrative charges, court expenses, and so on, and there is a case for a small State contribution of that kind.

Deputy Cooper says the burden becomes less if distributed. No doubt; in one case you have a number of pools; in the other case, taking the State as a unit, you have a lake, and the lake would be less deep than the deepest of the pools. But where is the basis for the imposition of the burden? In his scheme for a large unit, the county or the State, what is the ratio, what is the basis? If you are going to impose a burden on particular traders or on all the traders of the State, then you should be in a position to name the logical basis for the imposition of any such burden. That seems to me the weakness of this suggestion that one should, simply on the plea of administrative conveniency, or even on the plea that the burden would be lighter, take the traders all over the State and say: "You have got to pay the compensation of those who have been extinguished."

Comment on this

I made no plea for taking the State as an area. I do not approve of it. My argument was that in those counties where redundancy exists, it exists all over the county except in one or two urban areas which, in fact, cannot derive a benefit from the extinction of licences.

Comment on this

That is an unsound argument. The Deputy bases it on the schedule to the Report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission, which does not purport to be a scientific examination of the question. It is based on a number of outstanding examples supplied, at random, by my Department after very hurried consultation with superintendents throughout the country.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Totally misleading in many ways.

Comment on this

I agree it is misleading if only for this reason. On this question of publichouses it is not the number of houses in the area or the total population you ought to consider. It will be the catchment area, the economic hinterland of that town, the radius from which people come pouring into the town for their ordinary business. I am faced with the difficulty that there is pressure for a larger area than that in the Bill. If I had any reason to believe that the larger area would be acceptable to the people most intimately concerned, members of the licensed trade, then, no doubt, a case could be made, because, administratively, a larger area would be simpler, but I have no such assurance. The evidence, I think, is to the contrary, and I must try to do what I myself believe is the fair and reasonable thing, and I believe the fairest thing is to take the small area, this area of the District Court, and say that for licences extinguished here the survivors shall pay, and the basis is that the survivors of that area do, in fact, benefit by the extinction of licences in that area. If you take the county at large, is that the position? Might not there be gross redundancy on one side of the county and none at all in other parts of the county? Then you would be up against having those people paying compensation over a long period of twelve or fifteen years without being able to be shown any clear basis for such payment, without being able to be shown that they benefit in any way from the extinction for which they are paying compensation. One must not do the arbitrary thing. If the trade, speaking with one voice through their organisation, asked for a larger area, my view would be that there would be no more to be said.

Comment on this

On that point, which I think is a very important point, has the trade expressed any view of its own? My information is that the trade is divided about that—the City of Dublin against the country.

Comment on this

I have no doubt whatever that the trade is divided. Therefore, there is an absence of a single voice on this matter, and in the absence of a single voice on this matter we are thrown back on our own resources to do the reasonable thing, the fairest thing. What is the fairest thing? Is it to impose our compensation burden in such a way that people may be paying for nothing If we cannot regard the trade as a unit, if in this matter it will not or cannot talk as a unit, then we must simply regard it as a collection of individuals. Is it reasonable to put a burden upon individuals without being in a position to say that there will be any set-off to that burden, that there will be any benefit to show in return for their share in that burden?

Comment on this

Why put any on the taxpayer on that ground?

Comment on this

The tax, as the Deputy knows, comes to a matter of about £5,000 for twenty years.

Comment on this

One-twelfth of the compensation?

Comment on this

It comes to a matter of 6½ per cent. on the total. The Minister for Finance estimated the entire sum at £100,000. I do not want to split hairs about it, but there is a case for some contribution, on the basis that there will be some reduction in consumption, on the basis that there will be some administrative expenses, and so on. I am not prepared to depart from the provisions of the Bill unless either I am asked to do so by authentic representatives of the licensed traders themselves or that I hear better arguments for such a departure than any that have been advanced during to-day's discussion or the discussion on the last evening. I have not heard them. One can talk at large about the county unit. We know there are some very large counties. What are you to say to the individual who can tell you, after five or six years' experience of the operation of this section, that he has been paying steadily year after year in compensation and that there has not been a licensed house extinguished within twenty-five miles of him? What is paying for? He is asked to pay because he has the misfortune to belong to a trade that got overcrowded. He is asked to bear a share of the cost of wiping out redundancy thirty, forty, or fifty miles from him, perhaps eighty or a hundred miles, as could happen in some counties.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

In how many counties could that apply?

Comment on this

It could happen in some, as the Deputy knows.

Comment on this

Where will you get the 4,000?

Comment on this

The 4,000 applies all over. Four thousand is simply a rough estimate of the total number of licences that will be extinguished. Deputy Davin talked about what was redundancy, and said "Why not define redundancy?" That is the kind of question that rushes to the Deputy's head like air to a vaccum. It would be difficult to define redundancy, but I did say the last evening that we are prepared to prevent an over-enthusiastic administration from rushing the pace, that we are prepared to put a maximum in this Bill, a proviso that no trader in any area in a given year will be asked to pay by way of compensation more than his licence duty. That provides a check on over-enthusiasm, and if at any time—five, seven or ten years hence—the Dáil forms the opinion that the pruning in the number of licensed houses in the country has gone far enough, then clearly the thing to do is to repeal the Bill or to pass a resolution calling a halt on the operations of this section. That is a thing that would be very much easier to do than to define redundancy, as Deputy Davin invites me to do.

I am not sure that I can usefully add anything more. I am standing for the provisions in the Bill because they are fairer, more reasonable than any rival suggestion that has been put forward. The Bill keeps as closely as it is possible to keep to the principle that those who will benefit will pay. If you take a larger area at all, there is really no standing ground between this area and taking the State as a whole. There is very little case that can be made for taking the county as against the entire State, because in taking any wider area than I take in the Bill you, in fact, depart from the principle of the beneficiaries paying, and if you depart from it at all you might as well take the most definite unit, the unit of the State.

Comment on this

I have listened to the arguments put forward by Deputies Davin and Baxter and the Minister. Deputy Baxter has made an honest attempt to try to help the licensed trade when it is paying compensation to those who will be eliminated. Deputy Davin made a bigger attempt, but the Minister is sticking to his guns and he asks for somebody who is an authority. Well, I am an authority to speak for Cork and Munster, and I will say to Deputy Baxter that it is nearly as hard to please the publicans as to please the farmers. I have made an attempt to help the licensed trade; it is approved by the trade in my county, and that is my amendment to Section 40. That would immediately relieve those who would be paying the compensation, and without going to the licensed trade in the country at large or in the county or the smaller area. It would be as broad as it is long in the end, in the case of the country at large or the county, and if you honestly try to please the publicans in that direction they would say: "We are just as badly off. We in Ballyporeen are paying for the publicans in Ballinasloe, and we do not know that we are not paying too much for them. Perhaps it would be better for us to be left as we were." I hope the Minister will listen to what I am saying. If you reduce the £7 10s. and made it for forty years, the publicans would get a reduction and relief in the payment of compensation. I am a little out of order, but my case is so good that the Ceann Comhairle has not stopped me. For fear I would spoil it now, I will say nothing further, except to ask the Minister to say to himself: "I was looking for assistance from some representative of the licensed trade; I have found him, and I will accept his advice."

Comment on this

I rise to offer a word of advice to the Minister. He is very much in love with the District Court area. The facts are that District Court areas are the combining of a number of Parliamentary electoral divisions. These several divisions are not rounded areas; they run into one another here and there. I have a few cases in point in mind, and one in particular at my own door. That is where a publichouse exists on the main road from Callan to Kilkenny. The district area, in this instance, would be Callan. Any compensation derived from the extinction of this licence would be by the City of Kilkenny. It never can, in any circumstances, be of any benefit to the District Court area.

Comment on this

We will have some anomalies like that in any area.

Comment on this

There is much more to be said from my knowledge, and I speak only of the county of which I have knowledge. The Minister will find that, in equity and in justice, the county area would work out very much better and would be very much preferable in the scheme than the area he has in mind. He believes his scheme is right, but I know from my experience and knowledge that the local area is the wrong unit.

Comment on this

I take it we are discussing the amendments of both Deputy Baxter and Deputy Davin?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Yes, anything relating to the area of charge.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin and, I think, everybody else admits that the principle that the survivors are to pay is, in the end, the fairest. If we take Deputy Davin's suggestion that the whole State should be the area we are going to arrive at exactly the opposite result, and, certainly, not at what Deputy Davin wishes to arrive at, namely, that the survivors are to pay. Deputy Davin's suggestion, and Deputy Baxter's suggestion, in a lesser degree, would be all right if you are going to have an even rate of blotting out licences, in every part of the Saorstát, but a little consideration will show that if one wishes to support the idea that the survivors must pay, then, the smaller the area, the more evenly the incidence to the survivor benefiting will be achieved.

Comment on this

Does not that depend to a great extent on the valuation of licensed premises?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

The question of valuation does not arise now. I am referring to the number of houses that are to be blotted out. The question of valuation and the incidence of compensation on high valuation as against low valuation is a distinctly different matter. Deputy Cooper appeared to be under the impression that the problem of redundancy was, more or less, evenly distributed over the county area. I assure him it is not. Undoubtedly in any very large county what would happen, if you gave effect to Deputy Baxter's amendment, would be you would have a group of licences blotted out at one end of the county and the compensation would be paid by men living a great number of miles away deriving no benefit from it whatever. Deputy Davin is allowing his imagination to roam very considerably when he states it as his conviction that there are not going to be any licences blotted out in Dublin. I am quite sure the trade in Dublin would be very glad to think that that was so.

Comment on this

Can the Deputy give us any information upon that point? The Minister refused to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

No one can give information upon the point until the Act begins to function, because it will rest with the local Gárda Síochána and the Circuit Court and the District Court to decide what redundancy there is. The only test of redundancy that seems to trouble Deputy Davin so much is as to whether there are too many licensed houses in a district or not, and that will depend upon the view of the various authorities dealing with the matter.

Deputy Davin, for some reason or other, wants to get a rap at what he calls the wealthy Dublin publican. Assuming that that is a very desirable thing to do—and I do not subscribe at all to it, I do not think that they are any more venal than any other class of publicans—but supposing it is the object to have a whack at the wealthy Dublin publicans, how his suggestion is going to effect that I entirely fail to see. I credit Deputy Davin with having a perfectly honest and impartial opinion on the subject, and I credit him also with having the interests of Leix and Offaly at heart. In fact, he very often tells us he is the only Deputy that is thinking of the political salvation of his constituency, but I assure him that if effect were given to the suggestion he is supporting, to make the whole of the Free State the compensation area, his constituents would not only get no benefit, but would lose considerably from it.

Comment on this

How many are to be wiped out?

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

The Deputy credits me with wonderful vision. I may have some vision, but, I can assure the Deputy, I do not pose as a prophet, whatever else I may claim to be. Obviously, the number of houses to be wiped out is altogether a question of the opinion of the local magistrate in the district as to whether there are too many licensed houses or not, and when the Minister for Finance or anybody else, lays down as ultimate that 4,000 houses are to be blotted out he has no control, whatever, over them, because succeeding people will have the administration of the Act, and it is quite possible that the local District Justices, in the exercise of their discretion, may decide, having heard all the facts, that it will not be necessary to blot out 4,000 houses. All these things are matters of pure speculation and depend upon what I may call the uncertainty of the human factor and the opinions which different people hold upon this matter.

There is just one matter that neither the Minister nor any of the other speakers mentioned in connection with this whole subject of area, and that is that one great advantage of having the area small is that the surviving licences, in that area, will have the right to appear and say why the compensation should not be extravagant. They have the right to be heard and I think that is a very good corrective.

As the Minister has pointed out, even amongst the trade, there is no absolute unanimity of view. Taking everything into consideration, I think a little study of the subject will prove that the fairest way you can give effect to this whole question of compensation is by having the area as small as it conveniently can be. Deputy Gorey mentioned a particular anomaly which would occur in a district he knew. One could repeat that kind of anomaly very frequently. I put it to Deputy Gorey that, if effect were given to this suggestion, that the county at large should be the compensating area, you would not get away from anomalies. You may have a publichouse on the edge of a county, but the bulk of its trade would be over the border, so that his argument falls to the ground. It is really beyond the wit of anybody to create an absolutely fair and water-tight scheme in which you could not find some fault. It is impossible to please everybody, but I believe that the smaller the area the fairer you will distribute the incidence of the surviving trade and the compensation which the State provides.

Comment on this

I certainly agree with the last speaker that it is almost impossible to devise a fair scheme whereby you could deal justice all round upon the basis we have been discussing. The Minister said that the area of benefit should be the area of charge. That is the principle which he has invoked throughout the whole proposals contained in this Bill for the reduction of licences. I think that the course of the debate this afternoon and during our last sitting has gone to show the fallacy of the basis that has been adopted. I have suggested, by way of an amendment, which I will not be entitled to move, that surviving traders should not be called upon to pay at least the whole amount of compensation, and the course of the discussion to-day has gone to show the difficulty of arriving at any fair apportionment, even as between the licensed traders themselves. But if you must take that principle, namely, that the survivors, who the Minister says will benefit, should be those who should pay, then I, for one, could not subscribe to the proposal that the surviving licence-holders in the whole State should be required to pay for the abolition of a certain number of licensed houses.

To suggest that anyone in Dublin, or even in Waterford, is going to benefit by the abolition of houses in Ballaghadereen or Sligo, is rather far fetched. We come to the question as to what area would be the fairest, apart from the State, having regard to the principle upon which the proposal of payment by the remaining licence holders is put forward. There is a great deal to be said for the proposal that the licence area should be the area presided over by the District Justice. There was one point mentioned by Deputy Gorey which struck me very forcibly, and that was that these areas in themselves are not really homogeneous or, as he termed it, rounded-off areas. They certainly have not been formed on any particular basis. On the other hand, you will have anomalies.

I agree with what Deputy Egan has stated, that even if you had county areas you would have anomalies, because, like every boundary, it always gives trouble and it is certain that there would be injustice on both sides of the boundary whatever that boundary was to be. I am, therefore, placed in the position that I am not in favour of any area at all. This is a proposal which is supposed to be for the benefit of the State and is supposed to bring about temperance reform, but in the same breath we are told that the survivors will benefit. I do not see why the survivors should be called upon to pay, and, personally, I am not concerned as to what actual area of payment there shall be, provided it is not payment by the survivors of the whole State at large—a proposal which, upon the basis adopted by the Minister, would be utterly fantastic.

Comment on this

I am opposed to the amendment, mainly because I think it would be grossly unfair to ask isolated traders, and traders in small villages, to pay for traders in larger towns. There is also another matter in connection with that, namely, that the consumption of drink in the various areas differs very much. During the past few days I endeavoured to find accurate figures and I ascertained, comparing the last three years, that in some towns the consumption of drink is 33 per cent. less, and in other towns it is 50 per cent. less. The amendment, therefore, in my opinion, would deal very unfairly with these people. There is a delicate matter I intend to touch. There has been cross fire between many parties regarding the extinction of licences. I take the rather peculiar view, from the information I have, that there would be more competition to get out rather than to stay in.

Comment on this

Why not put them out at once?

Comment on this

Why not allow them to go voluntarily?

Comment on this

They would get nothing for that, but now they are going to get compensation. I am against the amendment, and I believe I am speaking for the persons I represent almost unanimously when I say that.

Comment on this

I believe that the entire State should be the area of compensation. As the Bill stands, it would tax too heavily those who would remain in business. In rural areas, undoubtedly, there is very little intoxicating liquor consumed at present. I think if they were asked to pay the total amount of compensation it would finally mean more licences being abolished in the towns and rural districts. I suggest that if the Minister for Finance, in introducing his next Budget, reduced the prices of beer and spirits, these people might be able to bear the burden of compensation for those whose licences would be extinguished. I would also suggest to the Minister for Justice that the period of repayment should be extended to fifty years and the rate reduced from 7½ to 5½ per cent. That, I think, would be in the interests of the State and the country generally.

Comment on this

I am inclined to support the recommendation made by the Commission. I have not heard anything since I have been listening here to alter the opinion I formed during the sittings of the Commission. Anomalies will, I think, arise no matter what area is suggested. I was rather amazed to find Deputy Cooper speaking in a way that, I thought, was not quite as sensible as he generally speaks. The Deputy said that down in Co. Sligo there were four licensed houses in one village and four in another not far away, and that if these four in one village were wiped out, then the four that remained in the other village would not benefit. I think that is the merest rubbish. There is no authority going to wipe out four licensed houses in one village and leave four in an area perhaps a mile away. What the Commission had before their minds was in such a case that if four were shown to be redundant in one village two would be extinguished, and similarly two would be extinguished in the other. There would be no doubt the two that remained in village A would benefit, and also that the two that remained in village B would benefit.

A Deputy also mentioned the case of a publichouse on a border. It is quite obvious that a publichouse when extinguished on the border of a county will benefit people on the other side. So far as I am concerned, I have heard nothing to convince me that the recommendations of the Commission were not the right thing. The smaller area will be the more difficult, as the Minister has said, to administer, probably, but it certainly will cause very much less heart-burning. We had before us quite definitely and clearly that in certainly counties there was no redundancy, and no redundancy in certain towns, and we felt that it would not be equity to have the north of a county pay for the extinction of licences in the south, because the north would not benefit by their extinction. I have heard nothing to convince me that the recommendation of the Commission was wrong.

Comment on this

Deputy Davin, with his customary clear-sightedness, has gone to the core of this question in raising this point with regard to redundancy. All these proposals with regard to the abolition of licences are based upon the recognised fact that there is redundancy. The Report of the Liquor Commission gave figures which point to the proportion of one licensed house for every 235 inhabitants, and the recommendations were to reduce the number so as to have one licence for consumption on the premises to every 400 of the inhabitants. The reason why what Deputy Davin desires to find in the Bill is not to be found in the Bill—a strict definition of redundancy—is because such a thing is not possible to provide; but the closer study of the Bill would show Deputy Davin, and give him the opportunity of exercising his customary clear-sightedness, that there is in effect a practical definition, though not a formal definition, of redundancy. That is in Section 33. It is upon the wording of that section that I based the case I made on Friday, and base the case I intend to make to-day:

"A licence may be abolished under this part of this Act on the following and on no other ground, that is to say, that there are in the licensing area too many licensed premises and that the said licence should be abolished in preference to any other licence attached to premises in the licensing area."

Then—

"Considering whether there are or are not too many licensed premises in a licensing area the District Court or the compensation authority (as the case may be) shall have regard to the character (whether residential, agricultural, manufacturing or otherwise) of the licensing area, the number of licensed premises in the area in proportion to the population of the area, the volume of business done by licensed premises in the area, the amount of drunkenness in the area and any other matter which appears to the District Court or the compensation authority (as the case may be) to be relevant."

Therefore these guides are set out for determination of redundancy.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy point out where there is a definition of too many licensed premises?

Comment on this

Too many, as even Deputy Davin will see on a moment's reflection, is a translation of redundancy.

Comment on this

But in figures?

Comment on this

The clues by which the local officers shall be guided on the determination of the licensing areas in which there are too many are set out in the clause I have just read as determining which in that licensing area shall be extinguished and which survive. There are very clear indications given in (a), (b), (c) and (d) of sub-section (3). I rely upon that as assisting us in the solution of what is a practical problem—what shall be the area of compensation? Because licences are to be abolished compensation is to be given. That is the principle. Licences are to be abolished in a particular area because the District Justice has been satisfied, on the initiation of the Gárda Síochána in the district, that there are too many publichouses. Therefore the great, broad, fundamental principle in this Bill, I submit, is that in the interests of society, for social reformation in these districts where there are too many publichouses, because of too much drunkenness, or because there are too many facilities provided for the consumption of intoxicating liquor proportionate to the population, and so on, the numbers are to be reduced. Therefore the reduction of the number of licences is in the interests of the State and all its citizens. That is the first, and the prime, consideration. The remaining question is—inasmuch as compensation is to be given— equity demands it—from what pocket, out of what purse, shall the compensation proceed? It might well be answered that the compensation should be paid by the citizens at large, because it is the State as a whole that is to benefit by this reformative step.

On the other hand, using Deputy Davin's own illustration from the railways, is it not obvious that when the railways were amalgamated and the shareholders in one company became shareholders in the amalgamated company, that through that arrangement their interests as investors were protected? But here we take away the licence from the licence holder and convert the premises into ordinary unlicensed premises. The survivor gains in business from that. He gains, therefore, in a double capacity: first as a citizen, as a man and a brother, and he gains in regard to his business. It seems to me that on that ground the Minister's case is incontestable—on that ground.

But the next practical problem in this connection is: Can it be confidently stated that in a limited area, in view of all the developments in transport to-day, and the coming developments that time may provide, the trade lost by the suppressed houses must go to those in their own locality? I have hopes, and I believe the Minister has hopes, that the suppression of a large number of licensed houses will have the effect of promoting temperance and that the total consumption of liquor will be reduced through the absence of the facility. In any case, it is obvious that if there is a very narrow area, a very limited area of charge, we are not doing this strict justice that it is within our power to mete out by putting the compensation as a charge upon it in view of all the facts. I made the case on Friday, and the Minister and others made it again, that this is not a situation in which ideal or poetic justice is attainable. But circumstantial justice ought to be our aim, and if we clearly foresee that, it would not be fair to the surviving licence holders in a limited area to put the whole burden of compensation upon them; we must look for a wider area.

Comment on this

The State.

Comment on this

The State is too wide, unless the principle of making those who benefit in business bear a share be abandoned. I quite agree with the Minister that we are going over an irrelevant consideration when we talk about those who are best able to bear the burden being called upon to bear it. It is not a question of the rich aiding the poor, or the successful coming to the relief of the unsuccessful here, so much as the suppression of licences in an area which redounds by the very fact of suppression to the business value by an increase for those surviving. Let it not be forgotten, however, that the value of the licence attaching to the surviving house is enhanced, irrespective of the exact volume of increased trade. It, at any rate, is a licensed house in that area, and it is so much the better if it be one of a few.

It seems to me, therefore, that when we are trying to do substantial justice we should look for an area not so limited as to be productive of inequity and, at the same time, not so large as to desert the Minister's principle. I find that area in the Circuit Court area, and I would ask the Minister's attention to the provision of other sections of his own Bill. In Section 31, the very section that follows this, it is provided that there shall be a compensation authority for every licensing area, and such compensation authority shall be the Judge of the Circuit Court; and the Registrar for the purposes of this compensation adjustment is to be the Registrar of the Circuit Judge. In the passage which I read before, in Section 33, a consideration of whether there are or are not too many licensed premises in a licensing area was to have regard to a whole lot of conditions, better regard to which can be paid by the Circuit Court. There are eight Circuit Court areas. I am arguing for the county rather than the limited District Justices' area, if I cannot get the larger area of the Circuit Court.

It seems to me that if Deputy Davin's amendment were carried it would have the effect of providing in Section 32 this enactment: "That there shall be established a fund to be known as the Compensation Fund," and that will leave us simply with a national or State single fund out of which to draw compensation. It would leave untouched altogether the question of area of charge. It is merely productive of an alteration in the administration of the fund. Therefore, I submit that there is an argument from Deputy Davin's amendment so interpreted in support of the proposal that I take the liberty of making, that administration can be simplified, cheapened, made more effective, by having only eight areas to deal with instead of twenty-six, and even to have twenty-six is better than to have the District Justice arrangement. It is really productive of unification, because the Bill itself, as I have just pointed out, contemplates making the Circuit Court Judge the compensation authority for every licensing area. So I would, with all respect, submit that to the Minister.

Deputy Davin and others speak about the licensed trade and they say "the trade" as if they thought of it as a religious order. Is it necessary to point out that it is not a religious order? It is not bound by vows. The members, while interested in the wellbeing of their colleagues in the trade, are primarily concerned in their own interests. The Minister himself, while chiding Deputy Davin for his fallacy in speaking of the trade as if it were a homogeneous entity, himself asks for a demand——

Comment on this

Through their organisation.

Comment on this

The Minister is alive to the point I was about to make. The organisation, of course, functions for all the members, but it cannot put up a united demand if the members are conscious of disunion in their interests. Therefore, it is nothing to us, I submit, that the members of the licensed trade do not agree because they have rival discordant interests amongst themselves. The real consideration for us is this: We are promoting legislation in the interests of temperance, in the interests of better citizenship, and with a view to that we are calling for a reduction of the number of licensed houses, and not to be inequitable in our reforms we are providing for compensation consequent thereon. Then the next duty which falls upon us is to discover from whom we shall exact the compensation price. While I agree with the Minister that the first exchequer from which to try to draw the requisite amount is that of the people who benefit most by the reduction of the licences, I do submit that we must be careful not to act unfairly or harshly upon the survivors. It is all really a question of practice. It is not possible in the circumstances to have algebraic or geometrical formulae set out or put into operation with mathematical exactitude. That is entirely out of the question.

Deputy Egan did us a service in one portion of his speech, and I cannot sit down without paying him my tribute on that account. We were led to believe— a large body of the leading public at any rate allowed itself to form a wrong impression—that the Minister for Finance was going to abolish 4,000 publichouses. That was proclaimed in huge captions in most of the newspapers, but the fact is that the Bill proposes to empower any officer of the Gárdaí to apply to the District Court at the annual Licensing District Court to have the matter determined whether or not the licences of houses are to be abolished. So the public are mistaken in thinking that it is "off with his head," that instant execution is to be the lot of certain publicans, and that at the instance or at the initiation of the Ministry. The facts are quite other. The process is gradual—I regret it is to be so gradual—and it is at the instance of the officer in the licensing area.

What the Minister and I joined in saying about local pressure on District Justices applies mutatis mutandis here, because if the initiation of the proceedings before the court to have a licence abolished is to lie with any officer of the Gárdaí in that district need I dwell upon how easy it is to have the whole process of reformation suspended?

Comment on this

May I say that in practice it will not. In practice the superintendent will merely be the medium through which administrative policy is effected. The matter will lie in my Department, and it is in fact my Department, through the police and in consultation with the police, which will regulate the rate of extinction in the areas.

Comment on this

That was not disclosed before.

Comment on this

It is the same thing.

Comment on this

I do not agree with Deputy Baxter that it is the same thing. It is very much a different thing. I would rather see the initiative come from the area, provided the area was large enough. If the initiative is to come from above we get back to that bureaucracy which it has been our duty to declaim against so frequently in this House. We can have too much of a good thing. Central control—most admirable! Central initiation of the local steps to be taken with regard to the development or the betterment of a particular area —that is not quite so good. I think in the Minister's reply we have a very excellent argument provided, a new argument, for not leaving the area so small. In a large area, such as the Circuit Court Judge's area, the influences, I fear, would not be operative upon the officer of the Gárdaí, and the officer of the Gárdaí would be in touch with the best citizens of the district. He would be in touch with those who were nothing facts and nothing also what irregularities—the increase of drunkenness and the rest—were disfiguring the life of that community, so that, as a fair and a reasonable operation for reducing licences, I suggest it would come much better if it were worked by the public spirit and the observant character of the public spirited in a wide area.

Comment on this

Deputies have talked in favour of various areas—the State, the Circuit Judge's area, and the county. I have explained that my anxiety is to keep the burden of compensation in this matter on those who can really be fairly said to benefit.

If I get from any quarter, from the organisation of the licensed trade itself or through any Deputy who professes to have authentic information that he is expressing the trade's view, an assurance that another area is preferable—whatever that area be—County, Circuit Court, or State—then I am quite open to alter the provisions of the Bill in that respect, because any such alteration would not involve any very drastic redrafting of the Bill. But, in the absence of any intimation of that kind, I am not clear that I should depart from the present area, which is in fact the area for licensing purposes, the area of the District Court. If Deputies generally through the House had a strong preference, a strong view, in favour of the county, let us say, then that is a matter I would be prepared to meet and be prepared to yield to, if that view is supported by a majority in the Division Lobby, and I suppose the best way of ascertaining whether a majority favours anything is by a division.

In short, this is not an issue of principle or confidence or anything of that kind. It is a question of trying to do the reasonable thing, the fair thing, in the absence of any expressed intimation from the licensed trade itself as to the area it would favour. I suppose Deputy Redmond will not take the remark as having any offensive implication if I say that perhaps the nearest thing we have got to an intimation of the official licensed trade view is the view that he expressed, that there should be no area—in other words, that the surviving licensed traders should not be called upon to bear the burden of extinction at all. In that matter, of course, I am reinforced by the report of the Commission, but I am also reinforced by the report of another Commission, a Commission of the British Parliament which sat during the war to consider the question of State purchase and control of the liquor trade. It was apparently a very important Committee, a Departmental Committee. I have its report here, in which it discusses the question. It was appointed to inquire upon what terms the interest in Scotland concerned in the manufacture and supply of intoxicating liquor should be acquired by the State. There was another Departmental Committee for England and Wales. Then, at the end of the report, there are suggestions for the reduction of the number of licensed publichouses in Ireland, should the scheme of State purchase of the whole of the liquor trade not be proceeded with. They go on to say: "There are in Ireland 16,396 publichouses," and so on—that was for the whole of Ireland—"13,396 houses licensed for the sale of spirits to be consumed on the premises; 283 for the sale of beer to be consumed on the premises—that is one publichouse for every 263 inhabitants of the country. In England and Wales the number is 86,722, or one for every 415 inhabitants, and in Scotland one for every 695 inhabitants. To reduce the number in Ireland would be a great social advantage and would greatly lessen the labour of supervision by the police. Almost all the witnesses engaged in the trade were strongly in favour of such a reduction, and stated that in their opinion the owners of the remaining publichouses would willingly contribute to the cost."

Comment on this

Contribute!

Comment on this

Then they go on to make their suggestions:—"The Committee think that an amount equivalent to the whole, or at all events, to the greater part of the amount required for the purpose, could be raised by a charge on the amount of drink sold by each of the remaining publicans, one shilling per barrel on beer, and one shilling per gallon on spirits," and so on.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves that point, might I remind him of the attitude adopted by the trade at the Liquor Commission which was set up here. As one who was present during most of the hearing by that Commission, the attitude adopted by the trade in my recollection was that while they would be prepared to contribute, and while they thought that they should contribute something towards the compensátion of those whose licences were extinguished, they did not think that it was fair to ask them to contribute the whole, in view of the great public benefit in the direction of temperance that this reduction of publichouses sought to bring about.

Comment on this

This report is signed by, amongst others, Mr. Thomas O'Donnell, M.P., and there is a reservation of some length by Mr. O'Donnell, in the course of which he says:—"The alternative scheme of purchase which we have unanimously adopted seems to offer a splendid opportunity of at least making a beginning in dealing with the drink evil in Ireland. This scheme proposes to buy up at least half of the Irish publichouses—compensation in the main to be paid by those who remain, and the amount of compensation payable in each case is to be determined by the tribunal which it is proposed to set up. It may cost four or five millions, but it will be practically self-supporting, involving the State in little or no financial liability, while doing the community incalculable service. The publicans themselves, as shown in the evidence they gave, are whole-heartedly in favour of it. To carry out such a scheme, would be, to my mind, a national blessing, and in order to achieve it we should not deal in a paltry spirit with those whose licences are being taken from them. The drink traffic as it exists in Ireland to-day is one of the most serious hindrances to national progress. To lesson its ravages, to confine and limit this evil in the manner suggested in the alternative scheme, would be such a great national blessing that nothing should be done which would even remotely assist the fears of injustice or unfair treatment in the minds of the publicans. Human wrecks, physical and moral, which one sees in our cities and towns, the ruined homes, the squalor, poverty and decay, neglected, underfed and diseased children, all present a spectacle calling for immediate and radical treatment by a drastic extinction of small, badly-kept, isolated and remote publichouses and by the proper supervision and management of those that remain."

The thing I particularly want to call attention to is that in that report, as in the report of our own Commission, the principle is laid down as a desirable one to follow, that the compensation should be borne in the main by the surviving licensees. "It may cost four or five millions, but it will be practically self-supporting, involving the State in little or no financial liability while doing the community incalculable service." The principle of the survivor paying the beneficiary, the person who is available to take the business that hitherto went to the extinguished licensee is, I think, a fair principle, and in my selection of the area I am trying to adhere to that. Whether that would be very seriously disturbed by taking the county as a unit is a matter on which Deputies could, no doubt, talk at greater length than we have talked. I have a preference for the quite small area, the area of the District Court. But if Deputies prefer to take the county as a unit and to show that preference in the division lobby, I will accept that and embody it in the Bill. I doubt if we can add very much to what has been said on one side and the other. The point that Deputy Davin makes, that there is division in the licensed trade, shows that there is a recognition of a conflict of interest, but that conflict of interest is not in fact as real as some Deputies may think. Deputies may say it would be a fine thing to be fleecing the Dublin publicans for Mayo extinctions, or for extinctions in Cork and Kerry. But there is just this other side—that in the larger towns, in the more populous areas, the wealthier areas, if extinctions take place, the compensation will be heavier. If you extinguish half a dozen licensed houses in the City of Dublin the compensation for that half dozen might be as great as the compensation for a score of houses elsewhere. One might talk then of the iniquity of having the impoverished licensed traders of Mayo shouldering the burden for the extinction of substantial publichouses in other areas from which extinctions they derive no particular benefit. That is simply another side to it.

However, my position is that I do not feel there is any important principle at stake in this question of area except that I deprecate any wider departure from the provision in the Bill than would be embodied in taking the county as a unit. In the absence of an expressed intimation that that would be acceptable to the members of the licensed trade as a whole, I would simply say the administrative argument should then prevail. But, if Deputies wish to vote for a county unit as against the District Court area, I will put that into the Bill.

Comment on this

No argument on the part of those who agree with me in this matter seems to have convinced the Minister, and I confess that no argument used by the Minister or anyone who has spoken on his side has convinced me that justice will be done if we leave the section in the Bill as it stands. I contemplate the position where, as Deputy Gorey points out, we will have the man on the border; his licence is abolished and his trade goes, not into the District Court area from which his compensation is to come, but into the adjoining District Court area where the remaining publicans will not be asked to pay any contributions towards his compensation.

I agree with the point of view expressed, that it is not just to ask those who will not benefit from the abolition of a certain publichouse to pay their share of the compensation; but, on the other hand, if we are going to have, as eventually we must when this measure comes into operation, hundreds of publicans paying compensation for the abolition of other licences although they have got none of the trade, I think this House will have reached a stage when it will have to reconsider its whole attitude in this matter. I recognise that at the moment it is difficult to decide what is equitable, and it is particularly difficult for a Deputy like myself who has no idea whatever of the mind of the trade.

Contemplating how the Act will operate in the Saorstát, I feel that the opinion of the Dáil should be tested on this matter. At the moment all this talk about areas is very much in the air. No one seems to have any idea as to the number of licences which will be abolished in any particular area. The Minister has not given us any indication of the number of licences which he thinks may be abolished in a particular area. He probably has in mind a district in which he contemplates a certain number of licences will be extinguished, and, knowing the district, he feels that the District Court area would be the fairest from which to expect compensation for the abolition.

When the Act comes into operation in a county like mine, where there are, speaking from memory, thirteen licensing areas at the moment, I submit that not alone will we have the houses on the border of the county, which are doing trade with an adjoining county, but in each of the thirteen licensing districts we will have men paying compensation for the abolition of a licensed house the trade of which has gone entirely to another licensing area. That will be unjust, and it is only when application is made for the abolition of a licence that the storm will arise.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy realise that the very same thing will happen if this amendment is given effect to?

Comment on this

Yes, I recognise it will happen to some extent, but not alone will we have, in a county, houses on the border coming under the regulations we are setting up in this Bill, but we will also have involved a number of areas outside the county itself. That is where the difficulty arises. At the moment I am not able to satisfy myself what would be equitable in the matter. I feel that other Deputies, looking at the thing impartially, as I am inclined to, find the same difficulty.

Each man in the trade is, no doubt, hoping that he will be passed over by the officer and that there will be no application to have his licence abolished. He will not consider the particular aspect I have touched upon very closely until it comes to be a hard fact for him. When the application comes to be made for the abolition of a licence, and when the other traders are up against the proposition of paying compensation, then we will see the equities of this whole question. I do not know that even in this House we can get a considered view on a division that will be satisfactory when the Act begins to operate. I would prefer to have a position in which the trade would know exactly where it stood, and what the State was going to do. If the trade fully recognised the position then they could advise what would be fair and just in their opinion. If we pass this section as it is I have no doubt that we will have, later on, to make other provisions, because we will not be, in my opinion, regulating the compensation in accordance with the trade concerned in the licensed house that is abolished.

Comment on this

The Deputy will find that under any unit he takes he will have some anomaly.

Comment on this

I know that.

Comment on this

Whether you take a county area, a district area or a summary jurisdiction area, you will have some anomalies. The county, in fact, examined administratively, is a very artificial unit indeed. I am looking casually, for instance, at Co. Cavan, and I find there it is broken up into a certain number of summary jurisdiction areas which overlap into other counties. Take Arva, for instance. The court which sits at Arva includes the district electoral divisions of Arva, Bruce Hall, Scrabby and, in Co. Longford, Moyne. The court that sits at Bailieborough taps three district electoral divisions from Co. Meath. The court that sits at Cootehill taps two district electoral divisions from Co. Monaghan. The court that sits at Dowra taps the business of two district electoral divisions from Leitrim. There, taking the summary jurisdiction areas of Co. Cavan, you find some districts of Longford, Meath, Monaghan and Leitrim covered. You have these summary jurisdiction areas overlapping into four other counties to a greater or lesser extent.

That, in fact, shows that the county as a unit is not perfection any more than any other administrative unit. It will not give you perfection any more than any other unit that you can possibly arrive at. In this matter of closing licensed premises, as long as you have any unit at all, you will have some publichouses being closed the business of which will tend to go over the border of the unit, rather than to remain inside it. You are thrown back on that substantial-justice ideal, as against perfection, that Deputy Magennis talked to us about. I believe the provisions in the Bill give you substantial justice. They do not give you perfection, but no other unit will. Neither the State nor the circuit nor the county, as an area, will give you that. I think the attitude I have taken of standing for the provisions of the Bill in the absence of some expressed preference from the licensed trade itself, is a reasonable one. On the other hand, if Deputies had thought out the matter and had, in majority, a definite preference for some other area, I should be prepared to yield to them. This is not a matter that one could reasonably make a question of confidence. I think that Deputies have not, in fact, examined the matter in detail, and I make this suggestion in order to give them time— that they pass the provision in the Bill as it stands, that they look into the matter between this and Report Stage, which will not, I think, be taken sooner than the 22nd of the present month, and that they discuss the question again on Report Stage.

I might as well state now my programme in connection with this Bill. The Committee Stage, I hope, will finish this evening. I have the Report Stage down for the 22nd instant, and I have undertaken that there will be a re-committal of the Bill Then the actual report motion—as distinct from the detailed discussion that will take place on the 22nd—I have put down for the 29th instant. On that date, having regard to the pretty liberal intervals we are giving between stages, I would expect to get the Fifth Stage through also, because I want this Bill with the Seanad in the first week of next month.

Comment on this

On 1st April?

Comment on this

In the first week of April. Between this and the 22nd instant, Deputies could go into the question of area and I would not object to the matter being re-opened on the 22nd. I do not think there is a case made out for a departure from the provisions of the Bill, just now at any rate. Possibly the licensed trade might consider the question of area in the interval, and we might get one voice from their organisation as to where their preference would lie in the matter of the unit to be taken for compensation for extinction of licences.

Comment on this

I am quite prepared to accept the Minister's offer and to withdraw the amendment, if I have the leave of the House. I think it would be well that time should be given to the people vitally interested in this matter to discuss the problem.

Comment on this

I presume that the Minister's proposition as to a fixed maximum for compensation holds whatever decision is come to on this question?

Comment on this

Yes. No trader will be called upon in any one year to pay, by way of compensation, a sum greater than his licence duty.

Comment on this

The Minister has asked Deputies between now and 22nd instant to consider the issues involved with care. Deputy Johnson had a question on the Order Paper last week, addressed to the Minister for Finance, asking him to supply to the House the number of licensed houses of a certain valuation in the State. I believe that that is very important. It is absolutely essential to enable members to consider the matter properly. Would the Minister provide us with those figures? Could the Minister also give us the information which enabled the Minister for Finance to tell the Dáil that the intention of the present Ministry was to abolish 4,000 licensed houses? Would he give us the numbers for the counties? The extinction of 4,000 licences would mean that the average per county would be from 150 to 160. That is information which is necessary to a proper consideration of the question. That is the reason I deliberately stated, in speaking earlier to-day, that the proposal I put to the Minister had not been carefully considered. The Minister is probably better aware than any other Deputy that he will not get from the trade organisation a proposal as to what should be the compensation area. We all know perfectly well that the licensed trade is divided on this issue and that the traders of the city of Dublin take a different view from the traders of the remainder of the country so far as the licensed trade is concerned. Two members of my Party and I, with a number of representatives of other Parties, met representatives of the licensed trade, and it was quite clear from our interview that on this issue there is no hope of agreement. The Minister met a very big deputation of the licensed trade and he must know that it is impossible to get a united view on this question. It is for the House, rather than for the organisation representing the licensed trade, to make up its mind on this issue. If the Minister is to wait until a considered view comes from the licensed trade, then he will have to wait until after the General Election. I agree that it would be far better if the licensed trade could come to a considered decision and put up a unanimous proposal. I was glad to hear from the Minister—it is the first time we heard it from any Minister—that in matters of this kind he will, in the future, be prepared to take the view of the organisations or the persons representing the people concerned. That is a step in the right direction. If the licensed trade were prepared to put up a proposal then the House, I think, would automatically accept it.

Comment on this

I think that neither the House nor the Minister will gain anything by postponing the issue. There is not the remotest possibility of the licensed trade coming to a definite decision on this problem. Each area has its own problem, and it would be practically impossible to arrive at a common conclusion. I think the House should take a decision on the question, here and now, and finish it.

Comment on this

I would like to associate myself with Deputy Egan's remarks, because I am fully convinced that agreement on the part of the licensed trade is impossible. Deputy Davin suggested that the traders of Dublin and the traders of the other portions of the Saorstát were not agreed on this question, but Limerick, Cork and Waterford are in agreement with the licensed traders of Dublin. They are all members of the same organisation. I am not a member of that organisation. I never had the privilege of owning any licence except a dog licence. I think this question should be settled here and now. If it is not settled now, there will be the same argument on Report Stage. The same speeches will be made over and over again. Deputies who have not spoken will speak then and the Bill will, accordingly, be delayed. I should like if the Minister would reply to the question I put him to-day as to whether a licensed trader whose licence is being abolished will be allowed time in which to dispose of the stock he has in hands.

Comment on this

While the Deputy is talking a great deal about this Bill, he has not read it.

Comment on this

I have.

Comment on this

If the Deputy has read it, he has forgotten what he has read.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy need not worry about the stock on hands.

Comment on this

Section 35 reads:

(1) As soon as conveniently may be after the making of a reference order and in any event not later than the next following 31st day of December the compensation authority named in the reference order shall hear and determine the question whether the licence the subject of such reference order should or should not be abolished, and if on such hearing the compensation authority determines that such licence should be abolished the compensation authority shall make an order (in this Part of this Act referred to as an abolition order) abolishing such licence at midnight on the next following 30th day of September.

There shall be a minimum notice of nine months. The latest date on which an abolition Order would be made would be the 31st December, and that shall take effect only from the following 30th September, so that the minimum notice given a trader as to the termination of his licence will be nine months. I think most of them should be able to sell their stock within nine months.

Comment on this

I suppose when the time comes we can refer to this question again, but while we are on the question of the licensing area, I think the Minister's suggestion and view of the debate is a very commendable one. I would ask the Committee to adopt the course he has suggested, because that would leave the door open to any possible alteration on the line suggested in the debate. What I understood the Minister to say was to let the section stand as it is now. Deputy Baxter has expressed his willingness to withdraw the amendment and, at a subsequent stage, he will be prepared to consider suggestions from every quarter as to the advisability of keeping the area, as passed to-day, or substituting another one. I think the Minister's suggestion very commendable and one that should be adopted.

Comment on this

The Minister, in addressing himself to the point the other evening, stated there were districts in which there was no such thing as redundancy. Deputy Davin has asked for certain information. It would help everyone if that information were forthcoming, or even if we could get information as to districts in which there would be no reductions. If we had that information it would help us in determining how the situation could be best met. If we knew the exact areas in which there were to be reductions we would know how they should be treated. I submit that it is going to be very difficult to treat the areas without that knowledge.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

It would depend on the Circuit Judge.

Comment on this

Will the Minister agree to give, as soon as possible, certain information asked by Deputy Johnson last week?

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister's suggestion, to postpone the matter until the 22nd of the month, when he intimates he will accept suggestions from the licensed trade organisation. I think that is a very fair suggestion, to which no one can object.

Comment on this

I move amendments 63 and 64:—

In sub-section (1), page 14, line 52, after the word "judge" to insert the words "or the deputy or assistant judge."

Before sub-section (5), page 15, to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(5) Every assessor to a compensation authority may be removed from office at any time by the Minister with the concurrence of the compensation authority for misconduct or incapacity."

Comment on this

Amendments 63 and 64 are simply official drafting amendments. The view is that the assessor should be removable for misconduct or incapacity. It will be observed, however, that the consent of the compensation authority, the Circuit Judge, is necessary. The assessor will be in close contact with the Circuit Judge to advise him on questions of value and to assist him in interpreting evidence of value. It is thought proper that the consent of the Circuit Judge should be obtained before removing the assessor.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (3) (a) at the end of line 49 to add the words "the business being judged on the average of a five year period, such five year period to be taken either from 1909 to include 1914 or for the five years immediately preceding the application for the abolition of the licence, whichever the licence holder shall decide.

The principle underlying this amendment is that, when the volume of business transacted on the premises to which the licence is attached is taken into account in assessing compensation, it should not be for one year, but on an average of five years. If the abolition of the licence is consequent on the belief that the business has only been of a certain volume it would not be equitable to base the compensation on one or two years' trading, because it would not represent the value of the business that might have been done several years previously, or, perhaps, that would be done in succeeding years.

It is generally accepted that, in a matter of this kind, it would be unfair to judge of any business on the trade done for one year. For reasons that we can all understand, there are always fluctuations in business. It may be argued, of course, that it would be cheaper to abolish licences at the present time than it would have been in 1918, but if we recognise at all the right of the owner of the premises to compensation we must ask ourselves whether the basis for discovering the compensation is fair or not. I do not think myself that the trade of one year would be a fair basis on which to assess compensation.

Comment on this

This section does not deal with compensation at all. It deals with the grounds for abolition.

Comment on this

The point is that if the volume of business transacted in the premises to which a licence is attached is small, that will be a reason for the abolition of the licence. If you are to take the volume of business done in one year, that, I submit, would not be a just basis on which to assess compensation. In that particular year the amount of business done might be very small indeed. There might be special reasons for that. For instance, there might have been sickness in the family or there might have been some contagious disease in the house. If anything like that occurred the volume of business done in that house during the year might be very small and might be out of all proportion to the amount of business done in previous years. Therefore, I do not think it would be a fair basis on which to arrive at the compensation. I think that instead of taking one year the justice, when deciding the question of the abolition of a licence, should be at liberty to take into consideration the amount of business done in the premises during, say, a period of five years.

Comment on this

I should like, if possible, to have a change such as that suggested by Deputy Baxter made in this Bill at a later stage. I have actual figures obtained in connection with the sales in a particular town in the constituency that I come from. I find that the sales for 1926 are 50 per cent. down compared with the previous years. Therefore, if the compensation in this particular case were to be based on the figures for 1926 apparently it would be much less than what I would consider to be fair or equitable.

Comment on this

The conditions set out in sub-section (3) (a) with regard to the volume of business is merely one of five factors stated as being relevant to the abolition or the non-abolition of a particular licensed house; simply a number of factors are stated as being things that may be put forward by the superintendent of the Gárda in support of his contention that, positing a redundancy, this is the most appropriate licence to extinguish. What Deputy Baxter mentioned — the smallness of the business — assuming it to be admitted that it is a mere transient feature, is something that could be put forward by the licensed holder that would be relevant if he could point to a different state of things two years back or to any reasonable prospect of a recovery of business. That would be a matter that both the District Justice and the Circuit Court Judge would, no doubt, feel called upon to consider. I do not see that there is a case for the acceptance of the Deputy's amendment. The smallness of the volume of business done in a particular establishment is regarded as a good reason, amongst others, for the abolition of a particular licence, and the point of time relevant to the issue is the time when abolition is proposed. It is very difficult to see what the conditions of a business of a particular establishment in 1909 have to do with the question of the abolition or the non-abolition of its licence in 1927.

Comment on this

It was an ordinary normal period.

Comment on this

In what sense is the Deputy using the word "normal"? If we are to say that the abolition or the non-abolition hic et nunc of licences throughout the country is to turn on the amount of trade they were doing in 1909, it seems to me that that is an extraordinary illogical basis to take, because we are not proposing to abolish them in 1909, but we are proposing to abolish them in 1927 or 1928, and so on over a period of ten or twelve years in the future. We cannot have retrospective abolition based wholly on the conditions prevailing as between 1909 and 1914. The licence holder will be permitted to plead that there is some particular cause, some special transient cause, for the smallness of the volume of business which he is doing in the present year. He is not ruled out by the wording of the section from pleading anything of the kind, but it is putting too much of a task on the administration and on the police to expect them to base a case on the volume of business done between 1909 and 1914 as a factor for or against the abolition of a licence in 1927 or 1930, or even 1937.

I think most Deputies will agree with me that there is not a case for the amendment. The Deputy talked a good deal about compensation, but this Section 33 has no bearing on compensation at all. It simply purports to set out the matters that shall be factors in determining the question of abolition or non-abolition of a particular licence holder as against some other licence holder. The first thing to ascertain is whether the number of licences in the area is out of proportion to the reasonable requirements of the public in that area. If you find affirmatively on that, that such excess does exist, then you move on to inquire, that being so, what is the most appropriate licence to extinguish. Surely one of the factors in assisting you to arrive at a just conclusion on that matter is the amount of business done by that particular house, the amount of business now being done, not the amount of business they did between 1909 and 1914, which is rather like "the flowers that bloom in the spring" in the matter of having nothing to do with the case.

Comment on this

I have another alternative covering the period of five years immediately preceding the date of the application for the abolition of a licence.

Comment on this

I have not much more use for that than for the other. It is the present that matters. If a licence holder strenuously objects to extinction of his licence and pleads that it is some other licence that should be extinguished, he will have every opportunity of satisfying the District Justice or the Circuit Court that the present position of his business must be regarded as transient, due to some special cause, as the Deputy indicated, contagious disease in his family or something like that, and that if he is allowed to survive he has reasonable expectation of being in a flourishing condition, compared with his competitors, in a year's time. All that would be relevant. There is not any fear that this matter of the extinction of a particular licence holder rather than some other will be arbitrarily decided. The District Justice must do a kind of prima facie hearing of the matter. He refers to the Circuit Court; the Circuit Court must satisfy itself (a) that there is a redundancy, and (b) that, positing redundancy, that licence is the most appropriate one to extingush and the licence holder will be allowed to plead his case there.

Comment on this

Would the circumstance of a married man with a large family, as against a man with no family, be considered?

Comment on this

No doubt a man would not be turned out for mentioning it, but it is not amongst the factors set out in the section. I do not see any case for amending the section along the lines of Deputy Baxter's amendment.

Comment on this

Would there be any consideration given to licensed traders who are prepared to surrender their licences? A great many traders through circumstances that occurred during the last five or six years——

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That question does not arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

According to sub-section (1) of the section, licences may be abolished only on the one ground, namely, that there are too many licensed premises; and sub-section (3) provides that in considering whether a licence should or should not be abolished the court shall regard the matters mentioned as reasons in favour of the abolition of the licence in preference to other licences. I would like to have it clear that these would not be the only reasons that the District Court would consider. As I understand the section, it appears to me that these are merely illustrations of what the District Court might consider; they are not binding exclusively in the sense that the District Court can hear no other reasons.

Comment on this

There is no conflict between sub-section (3) and sub-section (1). Sub-section (1) lays it down that the purpose of this Part of the Act is to abolish licences on grounds of redundancy and no other ground. If the court finds there is not an excess of licences in the area, out of proportion with the requirements of the public, it will go no further, but if it finds there is such excess it moves on to consider what are the appropriate licences to extinguish. Sub-section (3) lays down —

"In considering whether a licence should or should not be abolished in preference to other licences the District Court or the compensation authority (as the case may be) shall regard the following matters as reasons in favour of the abolition of the licence in preference to other licences."

Then follow five pointers, five indications of the kind of matters that enter in as factors favouring the abolition of one licence as against another:—

"(a) that the volume of business transacted in the premises to which the licence is attached is small;

(b) that the structural condition and state of repair of the said premises is bad;

(c) that the accommodation in the said premises for customers is unsatisfactory in character or extent;

(d) that the business carried on in the said premises is not properly conducted;

(e) that the situation of the said premises is such as to render supervision thereof by the police difficult."

Comment on this

A certain amount of consternation has been caused in the country, since the introduction of this Bill, by two speeches, one by the Minister for Finance when he mentioned that the average compensation would be in or about £300, and another, which is worse still, when the Minister for Justice said that there are a great many licensed houses throughout the country which, at the moment, would be bought dear at £50. Here we are setting up a compensation authority. A District Justice or Circuit Court Judge is getting a quiet hint from the Minister as to what is a fair amount of compensation.

Comment on this

That is stretching it.

Comment on this
Mr. EGAN

There is the assessor.

Comment on this

We are going through the farce of having a judge, whether a District Justice or a Circuit Court Judge, who has got the tip beforehand through the public Press that many of the houses would be compensated for in or about £50. It would not pay the expenses for the removal of the furniture if they have to go elsewhere to some other business. There may be a figure lower than that in the mind of the Minister. I think some such amendment as Deputy Baxter has moved is necessary if the quiet hint people have got is not to be acted on.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

I can imagine a village where there are three houses and the officer of the Garda says to Paddy McCarthy that he will be up before the next District Court and the case will be put forward for the abolition of his licence on the grounds that the premises to which the licence is attached are small, and for the four other reasons given in vague language that could be interpreted in five different ways by five different judges, all conscientious men who are allowed to take different views.

The Minister talked about the ridiculous feature of Deputy Baxter's amendment in taking the business done for the period from the year 1909 to 1914. The Minister always laughs. I should like to point out the ridiculoús position the Minister finds himself in. When the Minister for Industry and Commerce was fixing the standard revenue in his Railways Amalgamation Bill he took the three pre-war years. Here again I can point to a difference in policy as between one Minister and another, both of whom belong to the Executive Council.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

And in the same circumstances.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

It would be out of order for the Minister for Industry and Commerce to make a speech on the Railways Act. Deputy Davin can say what he likes on that condition.

Comment on this

While the period covered is a very long one and dates back, I think that the Minister might agree that there should be some definite period for fixing the compensation. Undoubtedly the compensation will have something to do with the valuation of the premises as well as the amount of business done. But the business that was done during a period of years, or in one year previous to the introduction of the Bill, would be, I think, a fairly reasonable demand to put forward. I would like to see the Government make up its mind to abolish all these 4,000 houses at once. There would be much more security in the State if that could be done, and seeing that the Minister must have, on the publicans' map that he has marked for his private information, the houses in different parts of the country already fixed for abolition, I think the quickest thing for him to do would be to put his pen through them and fix compensation on his own basis, or on the average mentioned by the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that that is the way the Deputy would do it.

Comment on this

The section states: "that the volume of business transacted in the premises to which the licence is attached is small." If the case was made that the business was small at a particular moment I think the alternative would be that the man would try to prove that it was not small. That is the interpretation that would be put upon that by the ordinary man. I recognise that the Minister has given expression to a different interpretation, and of course the view he expressed covered what I have in mind. I am quite satisfied that the point on which the District Justice will decide is as to whether or not the business is small. Will the licence-holder be entitled to argue that although the business is small at the moment it might not be small generally? I am not satisfied that the right of the publican to make that case is sufficiently safeguarded, and I think it would be unjust if the position was that he could not make that case. I do not know if, with the Minister's interpretation, it will be possible to do that, but I would like to have it more clearly defined that the justice would permit that.

Comment on this

I do not really think that this amendment is necessary. There is nothing to prevent the publican whose house is threatened to be taken from urging any reasons he likes against it, and I would like to point out to the Deputy that this amendment might have an exactly opposite effect from that for which he is striving. I take it that the Deputy's idea is that fair play should be given, and I would point out that the clause only refers to the case of taking one licence in preference to another. But Deputy Baxter's amendment makes it compulsory. Does it occur to the Deputy that the publican might not want what he proposes, that he might not like to be compelled to refer to the five years' trade? I think if the Deputy reflects he will find it quite possible that the amendment might be so interpreted in practice as to bring about the exact opposite of what he is thinking. I really do not see that a person whose licence it is proposed to abolish is prevented from urging any reasons he wishes before the District Court as to why his licence should not be taken.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

On behalf of Deputy Johnson, I move:—

In sub-section (3), before paragraph (d), to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(d) that satisfactory arrangements are not made for the supply on the said premises of food and non-alcoholic drink at reasonable prices to any person demanding the same."

This amendment seeks to add to the pointers, as the Minister calls them, an additional one, to enforce the making of satisfactory arrangements for the supply of food and non-alcoholic drink in licensed premises. I have been looking over the paragraph in the Commission's Report which deals with the provision of food, and I find that they strongly advocate that arrangements should be made to compel the licensee to provide food and non-alcoholic drink at reasonable times and at reasonable prices. They go so far as to say that a refusal to do so should be regarded as ill-conduct on the part of the publican. For that reason it might be argued that this amendment is already included in that paragraph which refers to premises as not being well conducted, but I think it would be much better to state plainly and definitely for the guidance of all concerned that they are expected to provide food and non-alcoholic drink at reasonable times and at reasonable prices.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept this amendment in this Bill. A publichouse might be very large and might be doing very big business and yet might not have facilities for supplying food, and because of its value and size it might not be well to seek to abolish it. Therefore the grounds put forward are, in my opinion, scarcely grounds that should be taken into account in this connection. The idea underlying the amendment extends beyond the sphere of the abolition of existing licences. As the Deputy pointed out, in page 17, paragraph 13, of the Report of the Intoxicating Liquor Commission, reference is made to this matter, and it is unquestionably a matter that will have to be considered when the final consolidating measure including new conditions for the various kinds of licences, is being prepared. But I do not want to write it into the Bill as one of the factors determining the question of the abolition of one licence rather than another. I would prefer to deal with that matter in the consolidating Bill, which must determine what different kinds of licences for the sale of intoxicating liquor we are going to allow to survive and what conditions will attach to each of such licences.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

On behalf of Deputy Johnson, I beg to move amendment No. 68:—

In sub-section 3, before paragraph (d) to insert a new paragraph as follows:—

"(d) that the sanitary accommodation in the said premises is unsatisfactory or inadequate."

This amendment provides that there should be proper sanitary accommodation in all licensed premises. I think the argument for that is obvious, and that there is no need to stress it. Whether the same point that the Minister made a while ago in regard to the other amendment would be applicable here, I am not in a position to say. It may be argued that the object of this amendment is included in paragraph (c), but if not, I would suggest that the Minister should accept it.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will accept this amendment, because I do not think that it is quite clear in paragraph (c) that sanitary accommodation is included. In my reading of the draft report of the Commission I overlooked the fact that sufficient importance had not been given to the sanitary accommodation of licensed houses. Many of the witnesses stated in their evidence that the sanitary accommodation was of an extraordinarily bad kind, and in many cases was lacking almost entirely. In one case — I think I alluded to this on a previous occasion — we had evidence from one witness than in an establishment in Cork, a mixed trading house, there was an open urinal; that should not have been allowed. I hope the Minister will add some words to paragraph (c) that will make it clear that sanitary accommodation should be included, or else that he will accept this amendment in its entirety.

Comment on this

I consider the point raised in the amendment is amply covered by paragraph (c) as it stands, and that there is no need for anything more than simply giving instructions to the police that that be one of the matters that ought to be adverted to. It seems to me that when we speak as we do in sub-section (3), paragraph (c), that one of the conditions is "that the accommodation in the said premises for customers is unsatisfactory in character or extent," the question of sanitary accommodation is abundantly covered by those words.

Comment on this

I am not quite satisfied on that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy thinks that that wording, plus the intimation to the Superintendents of the Gárda that the sanitary accommodation is one of the matters that they should turn their attention to, is inadequate, then I do not object to writing into (c) the words "sanitary or otherwise," but I think it is superfluous. I really think that Deputies ought to apply their commonsense to the wording of paragraph (c) and ask themselves whether that wording, plus a Departmental instruction to the Superintendents, is not adequate to meet all the purposes aimed at.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

I do not think the Minister should rely too much upon Departmental instruction.

Comment on this

I rely upon the wording about the accommodation.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

I think if the Minister does what he suggests and inserts such words as "including sanitary accommodation" that would satisfy the position, and on that understanding I would be prepared to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We will not take any amendment of paragraph (c) at the moment. We will have it properly drafted and take it next time.

Comment on this

I am not promising any amendment of paragraph (c), as I do not think any amendment is needed.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

The Minister is relying on his Departmental instructions; that may be all right while he is in charge of the Department.

Comment on this

There is such a thing as continuity of policy even in matters of hygiene.

Comment on this

I would like that the Minister would consider the words in sub-section (3), line 50, in reference to "The structural condition and state of repair of the said premises is bad." That seems to me to be taking us back to the question of structural alterations. If, in the opinion of the justice, the owners of ten or twelve houses may be men that are not in a position to make structural alteration or improvements so that the premises might not be in good repair owing to the want of finance on the part of the owners or to the high taxation imposed upon them for the past four or five years, can the licences be taken from these people? I should like to know if I would be in order at a later stage to move an amendment on this matter.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy can put down an amendment to sub-section 3, line 50, for the next stage if he wishes.

Comment on this

I would like to ask the Minister in reference to (e), sub-section (3) —"That the situation of the said premises is such as to render supervision thereof by the police difficult." A great many people are exercising their minds as to what these words precisely mean. Is it contemplated that isolated cross-roads houses are to be taken amongst those to be abolished? Does it mean that a house in a situation, say three or four miles from the local Civic Guard barracks would be construed as difficult of supervision? Would that be singled out as against a house in the town?

Comment on this

The Deputy will note it is the last of the pointers, and, in fact, its position represents the order of importance we attach to it. The difficulty of supervision should be a factor. If it was pointed out that it was more difficult to keep proper supervision over a house in a back street than other premises more centrally situated, that would be one of the factors that the Court would be entitled to advert to. On the question of isolated houses — the cross-roads and the wayside publichouse — there, of course, you have to consider just what the need for such establishments is, and all the time you have to be on your guard against creating the evil of shebeening while dealing with the evil of redundancy in publichouses. Because the house is a wayside house or a cross-roads house is not necessarily a cause for its extinction. It may be that in fact it serves a very wide area, at a long distance from any other town or village, and that there is a substantial population round about; there may be a definite need for such a place. If you wiped it out it might mean somebody there beginning by getting spirits, in large quantities, or dozens of stout, and running a kind of a shebeen, which is about the last thing we want to have going on in the country. So the wayside publichouse will always have to be approached from that angle. Is it necessary? Does it fill a definite local requirement? If it does, it must remain. If it does not, it ought to go, and a factor in the case is the difficulty of supervising it. But there will be many things to be considered besides the mere question of the difficulty of supervising it by the police. That factor is put in as one of many. A place in a back street, the difficulty of approach by the police, and so on, would be stronger causes for extinction than a centrally situated place in a main street.

Comment on this

A question has been asked as to whether these words were taken from the English Act. Practically twenty-three years ago protection was given to British citizens by means of a provision in liquor legislation lessening the number of ale houses. A provision was inserted in the English Act to the effect that in determining the matter of preference the difficulty of proper supervision by the police should be taken into account. Thus Great Britain has more than twenty-two years' experience as to how it works and can therefore tell us what it means.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister when he points out that there are a great many wayside publichouses necessary. I have in mind a publichouse which is four miles away from any village and is on the high road from Cork to Tipperary. It provides the only accommodation in the place, and it has saved many a life along the road. I refer to the road between Kilworth and Ballyporeen. That house is essential in that particular area. I agree that there are a great many other publichouses which are also of use. There are, of course, a few that could be dispensed with.

Comment on this

The Commission had clearly before them the difference between publichouses situated in country districts many miles from a town. What they specially found was that the evidence was strongly to the effect that there are many small houses, particularly in the immediate vicinity of towns, which serve no useful purpose and which are often a menace to public order and a temptation to men returning from market. It was to such houses that reference was made rather than to houses situate in country districts. On the other hand, the Commission had before them the necessity of having country houses under police supervision. We had evidence about the laxity of supervision that existed and about the way in which watchmen were sent out to tell when the police were coming. We felt that a greater evil arose from publichouses situate in the immediate vicinity of market towns than from those in the really rural areas.

Comment on this

Under this proposal, a District Justice would have power to refuse the granting of a licence to any person carrying on mixed trading, and that would succeed in accomplishing under this Bill what was defeated in the Act of 1924. I think a provision should be introduced to the effect that this section would only apply in cases where there was a difficulty of police supervision. As the matter stands, you are applying it to every mixed trader in the Saorstát.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

in the Chair.

SECTION 34.

(5) On the hearing of an application under this section the officer of the Gárda Síochána making the application and the holder of the licence to which the application relates and no other party shall be entitled to be heard and adduce evidence.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

On behalf of Deputy Everett I move:—

"In sub-section (5), page 16, line 21, after the word ‘relates' to insert the words ‘or the counsel or solicitor representing the said officer or holder.'"

Speaking for myself, I do not know whether this amendment is really necessary, but it would be well, perhaps, to have the position made clear in the Bill itself. Deputy Everett is of opinion that the sub-section as it stands means that the phrase, "no other party," excluded the solicitor from being entitled to be heard during the hearing of the application.

Comment on this