ORDUITHE AN LAE. - ORDERS OF THE DAY. INTOXICATING LIQUOR BILL, 1927 —THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 157–320 of 320. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 7 of 1927 ›
This amendment and the three following amendments, Nos. 70, 71 and 72 are, in my opinion, unnecessary and inapposite in a Bill of this kind. Parties having a right of audience may be represented by counsel or solicitor. These matters are usually dealt with in the Rules of Court. The existing Rules of Court do, in fact, enable to be done what the Deputy seeks to do. As regards amendment 72, it is clear from the Bill that as the party entitled to adduce evidence he will be able to put his assessor or valuer in the witness box to give evidence as to value on his behalf. Therefore, I submit, amendments 69-72, inclusive, are not necessary and are covered by the existing provisions in the Rules of Court.
Comment on this
I think, so far as Deputy Everett is concerned, all he wanted was an expression of that kind from the Minister to make the point clear. Therefore I withdraw that amendment and will not move the other amendments standing in his name.
Comment on this
Before we pass this section I would like to draw the attention of the Minister to what is, perhaps, an unintentional omission on his part. In this section, or the subsequent section, no provision is made for notice to be served of a reference order that has been made by the district courts. I would suggest that either a new section be inserted here, or after the next section, or else that another paragraph be inserted in this section to the effect that notice of this reference order should be gazetted at least within ten days of the time for the hearing of the application for abolition. I will give my reasons shortly for this proposal. There are others interested in licences besides the actual licence holder. In many cases there are mortgages and charges, and I think it would be only fair that provision should be made whereby public notice should be given enabling all those who think that they have claims, whether as mortgages or otherwise, to be in a position to state their case and make their claims, if any, at the time of the adjudication on the abolition. It is proposed, I know, in the subsequent section that no other party shall be entitled to be heard on the question of abolition, but I submit that in all fairness these parties, say a mortgagee, for example, an immediate lessor of the premises, should know that this abolition application was about to be considered and that his interests in the matter should be safeguarded.
Comment on this
I can consider between this and the next stage the point which the Deputy raises — the matter of notice, of publicity for the making of a reference order. In that connection, I want to safeguard my own position. It is not proposed to give anyone except the licence holder audience on the question of the extinction or non-extinction of the licence. I have in contemplation certain proposals enabling other persons to be heard on the question of compensation, and it may be argued that with a view to their being fully prepared for the compensation stage it is right that they should have full notice that proceedings leading up to compensation are initiated by a reference order from the District Court to the Circuit Court to have the issue tried of whether or not that licence should be extinguished. It is a matter I should like to look into, and I think it probable that I will be in a position to bring up an amendment.
Comment on this
I am obliged to the Minister for his reply. I understand that he does not desire to have others than the licence holder represented on the question of extinction, but on the question of compensation I would ask him to consider the position of other interested parties.
Comment on this
On behalf of Deputy Johnson I desire to move amendment 73. In the section power is given to pay compensation to the owner of premises as well as the licensee. This amendment aims at giving power to enable compensation to be paid to any employees who may lose their employment as a result of the abolition of licences. People employed in licensed houses as in other businesses have a certain amount of interest in the business, and if the owner and licensee of the premises are entitled to compensation it is only reasonable that those who lose their employment, and who might find it very difficult to get other employment, should at least be entitled to some compensation also.
Comment on this
This amendment of Deputy Johnson's and the amendment in my name single out as deserving of a share of compensation not only the owners of licences but the employees. I think the majority of Deputies will agree that if a law is introduced for the good of the general public and it deprives persons of their employment, those persons should not be deprived of their means of livelihood without some consideration from those who benefit. The Bill provides that compensation is to be paid for property. The property of the employees of licensed houses is their labour. Not alone is their labour being depreciated by this Bill, but their employment is being taken away in some cases. In view of the circumstances, I hope the Minister will favourably consider the amendment, and see that no injustice is done to any persons who may lose their livelihood as a result of the Bill.
I am not quite sure that compensation is provided for the licensees of tied houses. The first portion of my amendment deals with the ordinary employees in licensed houses, but in the South of Ireland there are a certain number of tied houses and the Bill provides compensation for the lessor. I have been informed that in a few of these houses the original owners, through trade circumstances, got into the power of brewers who have mortgages on their premises, and some of these men fear that if the Bill is left as it stands the lessor, otherwise the owner of the bricks and mortar, will get the full compensation, although the Dáil has admitted and the Minister has admitted and used in debate in furtherance of various sections of the Bill that the licence was an asset created by a monopoly. If the manager of one of those tied houses was the original licensee, and the licence is as valuable as the Minister has stated, the brewer who has a claim on the house should not be put in a position, because he has a mortgage on it or is the lessor, to throw the licensee and his family and others who are employed there aside without some consideration.
Comment on this
Might I suggest to the Deputy that the next section, "Allocation of Compensation," is perhaps the section on which the matter that he is now discussing would most appropriately arise—Section 37.
Comment on this
It does not altogether clear up the position regarding tied houses. I ask that the licensee of the tied house and his employees should get some consideration.
Comment on this
That is the point I should like to get cleared up.
Comment on this
The point that I should like to get clear from the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is whether, in connection with an amendment dealing with employers, we are at liberty to discuss people other than employees.
Comment on this
It has been ruled that the two amendments are to be taken together. My amendment only differs from Deputy Johnson's amendment by one word, "licensee."
Comment on this
You, sir, have ruled that the two amendments are to be taken together. In my amendment I have the question of licensee added on to employees. If I am out of order in raising it now, it is not my fault, because my amendment says that compensation shall be paid to licensees.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment deals with persons employed in or about licensed premises in connection with the sale of intoxicating liquor. The point I am making is that the tied house licensee is not an employee and therefore it should not be open to us to discuss him under either of those amendments, both of which deal with the question of employees.
Comment on this
With your permission, a Leas-Chinn Chomhairle, on the next section I will repeat the case I have made for the licensee of a tied house. I take this opportunity, however, of supporting the amendment asking for compensation for those who may lose their employment as a result of the passage of this measure.
Comment on this
These two amendments raise the question of the position of persons employed in a licensed house, the licence of which is extinguished under this part of the Act. The first point I would like to make in discussing this question is that I regard it as being largely, if not entirely, academic. The kind of house that will disappear as a licensed house under the operations of this Act, is not the kind of house that employs paid labour. It will be the house that is run by a proprietor and his family and so on, the smaller, cheaper establishments in the country. I simply want to clear the ground by that remark.
I agree that the point is relevant, that the question raised by the amendments does arise, but I regard the matter of disemployed labour as a result of the operations of this Act as largely academic. I think that the degree of disemployment that will be occasioned under the operations of this section will be negligible, if it exists at all. Deputies may reply that they have no guarantee as to that, and I am accustomed to the reply that if it exists at all that this question is there—the question of the position of the individual who finds himself out of employment as a result of legislation passed by the Oireachtas. Well, we ought to try to clear our minds on the principle of that, and I would like to put to Deputies a few cases which may be regarded as roughly analogous.
When the duty on tea was abolished by the Minister for Finance many people in the Customs service, not established officers but people employed in the Customs service in connection with the tea tax, became redundant. There was no longer work for them to do. They had been employed for a great many years as long as that duty was imposed but when the duty was removed these people became unemployed. They made representations to the Minister for Finance stating that as a result of the abolition of the tea tax they found themselves under notice and that they considered it a grave hardship, but the Minister did not feel that he was called upon in his capacity as steward of the national finances to pay any compensation to those persons who found themselves disemployed as a result of the alterations in our fiscal arrangements. I am informed that under the betting tax many people have lost employment —book-keepers, clerks, and people who were colloquially known as "touts" and so on.
Comment on this
May I remind the Minister that betting was not legal and that those men of whom we are now speaking are engaged in honourable occupations?
Comment on this
So that we may not get into any complications in regard to honourable callings I want simply to keep to the merits of the case—whether the people who find themselves out of employment as the result of State action, legislative or administrative, are entitled to look to the State for compensation. That I think will be regarded as a simple statement of the question that arises. I am pointing out that quite frequently as a result of administrative changes, sometimes as a result of legislation, people do in fact find themselves unemployed and that is regarded as simply an almost inevitable result of any change. One does not go seeking out the question of whether people in casual employment, having no particular contract of service, lost employment as the result of the changed conditions. The Dáil should think over this matter very seriously, whether it is right to impose on the licensed trade the duty of compensating persons in casual employment in a house the licence of which is abolished under the provisions of this part of the Act. I undertook to a deputation that waited on me in this connection to look into the matter. I have looked into it; I have endeavoured to find any precedent for what is sought here and I have been unable to find it. So far as I know, countries that went the whole hog in this matter of abolishing licensed houses paid no compensation either to the licensed holders or their employees. They simply wiped them out.
Comment on this
Does that arise— does the question of cocaine arise in connection with this matter of unemployment? I am not discussing the merits of prohibition. I am discussing the facts in so far as they have any bearing on this question of compensation—that so far as I know, in the countries which simply wiped out the licensed houses altogether, there was no compensation paid either to the licensed holder or to his employees. We have not taken that line. We have regarded the licences as being, to some extent, property. We have made provision in the Bill for compensation. Should one go further and say that the maid and the yardman and any other persons in casual employment in and around licensed premises are also to be compensated if, as a result of the extinction of the licence, loss of employment ensues? Deputies ought not just jump too readily to the conclusion that the right thing to do is to take the course embodied in these two amendments.
It is a matter that requires very careful consideration. It is a matter that will unquestionably be quoted as a precedent and I am very doubtful as to the propriety of accepting—even in principle I certainly would not accept them as they stand—the suggestion put forward in these two amendments. The girl that minds the child and occasionally runs in and serves in the bar: is she to receive compensation under the Act as a result of the abolition of the licence?
Comment on this
The Deputy if he wants to interrupt should endeavour to interrupt intelligently. If, as a result of the extinction of the licence there is a loss of employment— the yard man, the maid-servant, any of those persons employed in and around the house—are they to be compensated if under the operations of the Act their employment ultimately ceases? Is it fair to ask the remaining members of the licensed trade to undertake a burden in respect to loss of casual employment of that kind? We were told from the Labour benches —Deputy Davin told us—that we were only expediting a process that was already at work, that in fact if we only let well-enough alone a large number of licensed houses in the country were going to disappear in any case and that it was very questionable whether we were justified in interfering to expedite this process of decay of the licensed trade that was already in full course. We were told that we were undertaking an unnecessary expense in interfering. Very good. Suppose then that under the normal progress of this process of decay, people went out of business, gave up the ghost and said, "There is nothing in the trade under present conditions," and their employees lost their employment, what would happen? There would be no compensation. But we are told that we would be only simply expediting the process already at work and that we were enabling people to get out with compensation who would get out, at any rate, with or without compensation in the course of time. Now I question very much whether there is an obligation in connection with casual personal employment of this kind such as one might recognise as existing in an organised service like the railway service, and which inevitably, if Deputy Davin comes in, will be quoted in this connection. I would point out, however, that in the matter of the railway employees who lost their employment as a result of the amalgamation a minimum of five years' service was laid down.
Is the question of the duration of a man's employment to figure at all in this connection? Is the question of how long he had been there and what real expectations he had of remaining there to be considered, or whether he was not subject to variations in the conditions of the trade, whether, in fact, his employment was not of a very transitory and precarious nature, at any rate? All these various considerations arise and I feel that they deserve the consideration of Deputies before they lightly decide that because we proceed to prune the number of licensed houses in the country we should take on an obligation to persons employed in and around such houses. What is the basis? The railwayman's position was that he had a specialised, kind of employment, that he could not be said to be particularly fit for other employment if he had been a long time employed in the railway. But in this country where licensed houses are, for the most part, in very great proportion, mixed houses, the bar hand is in reality a grocer's assistant as well. He is not a bar-hand simpliciter. He is really a shop-hand, an assistant who can turn his hand to any form of retailing.
There is one other matter to which I want to call attention—it arises in connection with Section 35—that is the extremely long notice which even as a minimum the employer and employee has of the change that is coming. The very minimum notice of the extinction of a licence under the provisions of sub-section 1 of Section 35 is nine months. The sub-section reads:—
"As soon as conveniently may be after the making of a reference order and in any event not later than the next following 31st day of December the compensation authority named in the reference order shall hear and determine the question whether the licence the subject of such reference order should or should not be abolished, and if on such hearing the compensation authority determines that such licence should be abolished the compensation authority shall make an order (in this Part of this Act referred to as an abolition order) abolishing such licence at midnight on the next following 30th day of September."
So that, at a minimum, there is nine months' notice of the coming extinction of the licence and one knows that the normal case will involve a notice of a year and upwards. Now, having regard to that, Deputies will, I think, agree that the case is very much weaker. The employer has a year's notice that he is going to lose his licence on the next following 30th September. The employee has a year's notice of the change that is coming about; and he, presumably, will be in a position to ascertain how his position is affected by that forthcoming change. Generally, there is an opportunity for both parties to adjust themselves to the position.
That is just about all I have to say on this amendment, except to re-assert what I said in commencing, and that is that I believe that this question does not really arise in connection with the extinction of licences that will take place under this part of the Act, because the licences that will be extinguished will be licences of small houses through the country, houses that are run by the proprietor and his family, and that are not run by paid or employed labour at all. The principle is there for discussion. I will regard the discussion that takes place on these two amendments as being for the most part academic.
I do not believe the matter will arise in any real proportion at all in connection with Part 4 of the Bill. In so far as it does arise, I believe that a year's notice of the change meets the situation, and gives people time to look around for alternative employment and to adjust themselves to altered conditions.
Comment on this
One thing has been accomplished by these amendments: the Minister has given an indication as to the class of house that is going to go out. The houses that are going to lose their licences are the small houses, the houses run by men and their families. They are going to be deprived of their means of livelihood as against the big trader who carries on an extensive business with a hardware, drapery and provision store. The Government are going to take the licence from the small man simply because they do not want to make any provision in the Bill to give compensation to employees engaged in the large shops. If the Minister will refer to the Local Government Act he will find that when putting it forward the Minister for Local Government and Public Health had amendments carried under which the employees of local authorities—the employees of county councils and the clerks of district councils—were entitled to compensation.
Comment on this
You pension a man who has worked in an office for ten years, but in this case you do not consider any compensation. Take the case of a man who may be employed as a foreman in a shop. He does office work just the same as a clerk, in addition to other work in the shop, and yet you refuse to give him superannuation, compensation or gratuity of any description. One is a clerk in an office and the other is a man behind a counter. It is not fair to make any distinction and the Minister should consider inserting something in the Bill which will entitle an employee in the trade for over ten years to some compensation.
Comment on this
An employee in a licensed premises for a period of ten years and over should be entitled to compensation. By this measure you are making it necessary for an employer to give up his means of livelihood and it is only just that that man's employees should be compensated. In other measures you specify that any person with ten years' service is entitled to two-thirds of his salary by way of superannuation. Why not have the same applying in this case?
It is all very well for the Minister to say that a shop assistant loses practically nothing by being dismissed —that as a grocer's assistant he may act for one hour in the bar and for another hour behind the provision counter, and so on through the working day. But he is still a man who had to serve three years to the trade and in a very large number of cases parents had to pay a substantial fee so that the boy could get such a position. They did not want him to go out on the street to break stones; they did not want him on the farm tilling the land; they preferred to see him in a respectable position and possibly in time he might succeed in purchasing a place of his own, becoming an independent trader.
If a person is working behind a counter for ten or twenty years, that person is not capable of performing any other duties for the purpose of earning his livelihood. Those people who lose their positions through the abolition of their employers' licences are not to receive any compensation and in that case it is up to this State to provide suitable employment for them. It is all very well to say they have nine months' notice.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding that a man may have been behind a counter for twenty-five or thirty years, after nine months' notice he has to go without any compensation. There is no further use for that man. The Government he probably helped to put in power find it necessary to cast him on the scrap heap as a piece of wornout machinery. The man behind the counter must be of some service to the State. To my mind he is as useful to the State as persons in an office or in a railway station. They are public servants and the man behind a counter is also a public servant; he is a servant of the public and it is his duty to attend to the public.
In ten out of every fifteen cases of people who lose employment they will not be capable of being employed in any other position. Later on when the 4,000 publichouses will be abolished you will find a large number of unemployed will have to be attended to and it will be necessary to vote an extra amount of money in order to enable those people to keep body and soul together. If you agreed to give them some compensation, they would probably be able to carry on some little business in the way of a huckster's shop. Otherwise the result will be that they will have nothing. If any members of the Government had served their time to the licensed trade and had spent 20 or 30 years behind a counter and if this Act were introduced by England, without compensation, they would very soon flock into a union for protection. Why not do for others what they would have done by themselves? We are told that the trader would have to bear this compensation for the employee out of the compensation received. That would be an easy matter to settle. I hope the mover of the amendment will test the feeling of the House, so that we may see how many members of the Farmer and Government Parties are really interested in labour. The Deputy who votes against this amendment has no sympathy with the worker. This is a question of the worker and the worker alone. These men should be put in the position of maintaining themselves, even if they are not able, on the compensation afforded, to maintain their families. The officers of the Boards of Guardians and the Rural District Councils, which were abolished, were compensated. A boy who walked straight from school into one of those offices and who had spent five years in the service was entitled to a gratuity. If he had spent ten years in the service, he was entitled to two-thirds of his salary and emoluments. Similar provision should be made for the assistant who loses his employment under the present circumstances.
Comment on this
There appears to me to be two great difficulties in the way of giving effect to the amendments of Deputies Byrne and Johnson. It would, first of all, be exceedingly difficult to define what unemployment exactly is. You might have different degrees of unemployment. The position of the man who stands behind a counter selling liquor, and who has never done anything else, is quite clear. But suppose he is a man who has performed half a dozen other duties, and who has been selling half a dozen other kinds of goods—as happens more often—how are you going to deal with him? We might go a little further and ask what about the brewers' draymen or the distillers' draymen who, instead of going five times to a house, have only to go four times? Suppose, then, he is an employed carter; his horse may be idle for one day a week and his oats and hay may be cut down. You can arrive at all kinds of indirect disemployment, and it would be very difficult to give effect to a provision of this character. Secondly, there is the question of precedent. You would be establishing quite a new precedent. It might be argued that State action had in the past closed down breweries and distilleries, as it has. Taxation and other State action have been frequently contributory causes to the closing down of breweries and distilleries and other establishments. Are we to admit the principle that if a premises is closed down, directly or indirectly, by any form of State action, every employee is to be compensated? It would, I think, be very difficult to give effect to any such provision. Then, would you contemplate making this sort of legislation retrospective? Would you go back for years and give a right to all sorts of people disemployed, owing to any sort of State action, to compensation? Furthermore, what is to happen if a man who has been compensated steps into another job in the morning? Would Deputy Lyons support that kind of compensation?
Comment on this
I spoke on behalf of the man who has been working, say, 20 years in a shop, and who is unfitted for any other employment. If the employee be very young, and if he walk into another job in the morning, that is a different proposition. That is why I asked the Minister to accept a ten-year term.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy know any people who got gratuities or pensions who did not seek to get other jobs—civil servants, for instance, who retired under the Treaty?
Comment on this
I do not agree with Deputy Lyons that a person who has been employed for a number of years in a publichouse is, ipso facto, unable to take up any other work. That is not my experience. They usually perform quite a number of duties. The vast majority of assistants in the trade in the country, as I know by experience, handle all sorts of goods. They are mainly employed by mixed traders. If men who have held positions for 20 years are disemployed, there are a great many employers who would be only too glad to obtain their services. I certainly should like to have a list of men of that class. I do not think that that type of man would have any difficulty in obtaining other employment. Although the principle may, prima facie, seem all right, it would be practically impossible to give effect to it.
Comment on this
I gathered from the speech of the Minister this evening that very few houses which are affording employment will be abolished at all, because one of the fundamental reasons for abolition will be lack of trade or the bad condition of the house. Respectable assistants, with 20 years experience, would not be found in such houses. If there are such men, I think they are worthy of consideration. But I think there will be very few of these houses abolished at all. It should, therefore, be very easy for the Minister to make allowance for the compensation of any of these assistants who are disemployed. It may arise in a few cases but the demand on the Minister would not be very great. I will vote for Deputy Davin's proposition.
Comment on this
I find myself in a difficulty, owing to the absence of Deputy Johnson. I should be sorry to take advantage of his absence in dealing with this amendment. But I should like to ask, if it is proposed to compensate persons who are deprived of employment through the operation of this Bill, what about the persons who are being disemployed in connection with many other measures? Reference has been made here to the betting tax. There have been more persons put out of employment in connection with the betting tax than will be disemployed in five years in connection with the Licensing Bill.
Comment on this
They were motor drivers—persons you represent. Deputy Byrne voted against the Betting Bill. I am against the amendment, on the principle that if you are going to give compensation to any persons who are disemployed under this Bill, you will have to compensate a very large number of motor drivers and innumerable persons disemployed by reason of the betting tax.
Comment on this
This evening the Minister publicly welcomed a statement from the licensed traders on another issue, concerning licences that are to be abolished. The Minister met a deputation representing the Grocers Assistants' Association that put before him the effect this Bill will have on the employment of their members. If I am correctly informed, the deputation told the Minister that if the two hours' closing was insisted on in the four cities it will involve the unemployment of 130 assistants. In the closing stages of the speech he has just finished the Minister stated that the licences likely to be abolished were those attached to houses run by employers and their families. I can understand why Deputies like Deputy Beamish have been so enthusiastically advocating and supporting this Bill, both inside and outside the House. There are other people in the same fortunate position as Deputy Beamish. If I am correctly informed, Deputy Beamish will be in the happy position, when this Bill passes, of having 30 or 40 tied houses in Cork wiped out, with the consequent elimination or dismissal of one and perhaps, in some cases, two employees, thereby reducing the overhead charges of his business at the expense of local private traders. What applies in the city of Dublin, and in the case of Deputy Beamish, clearly applies elsewhere. There will be unemployment caused as a result of the passage of this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but I do not like to have a Deputy attacked behind his back.
Comment on this
I am sorry if Deputy Lyons, or any other Deputy, looks upon the statement I made as a personal attack on any Deputy.
Comment on this
Suspicion haunts the guilty mind. The unemployment that may result from the passage of this Bill will be deliberately created as a result of State action. Even though a man may be a small trader, the Bill comes along and wipes out his employment, as well as that of his family. That is doing away with employment in the same way as the employment of 130 assistants will be done away with if the two hours' closing of licensed premises is insisted upon. I hope Deputy Shaw is not looking for a reprisal on members on these Benches, simply because of the attitude of any one Deputy with regard to the Betting Bill. I hope he will take a more impartial view of the matter we are discussing, and not try to get his own back because someone did something he did not like.
Comment on this
The majority of the Deputies on the Labour Benches voted for the Betting Bill. When they did that they voted for the unemployment of motor drivers.
Comment on this
I am prepared to admit that ordinary grocers' assistants engaged in pulling corks out of bottles in publichouses could not be regarded as being in skilled employment. What are the facts? The ordinary grocer's assistant or the young man who comes from the country is generally the son of a respectable small farmer. Where there were too many sons for the farm they had to go to America, or join the R.I.C. or become grocers' assistants in the city. The father paid a fee for the son who came to Dublin to serve his time at what he regarded as skilled employment. The idea of that young man's father and relations was that he would eventually become the owner of a shop. This Bill has closed that avenue from the country to the city, and puts out of the mind of grocers' assistants the idea of ever owning a house in Dublin or elsewhere. That avenue of remunerative employment is closed for the future. As that is the result of State action, I think the Committee should recognise that there is an injustice done to the individual concerned.
Deputy Egan amused, or rather amazed me by asking me what would be the attitude of Deputies regarding compensation paid to individuals who would find other employment a few days afterwards. Is not Deputy Egan aware that the taxpayers of this State have given very fine pensions to civil servants who served the British Government, retired under the Treaty, and since then have come back into the service of the Free State Government? They are drawing salaries in addition to their pensions.
Comment on this
Yes, but that was one of the conditions of their employment.
Comment on this
It was not a condition that they should get employment from the Free State Government which they refused to serve. No man was to get a pension unless he deliberately refused to serve the Irish Government. That was the condition to get a pension under the Treaty. Deputy Egan must know that many of these men in the Civil Service and Garda Síochána have pensions under the Treaty. There are Deputies in this House in receipt of pensions from the State. Probably Deputy Egan would not take exception to that, because he voted for the measure that made it possible.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy say that Deputies in this House are in receipt of pensions from the British Government?
Comment on this
As Deputy Cooper must know, there are Deputies in receipt of pensions under the Military Service Pensions Act for which Deputy Egan voted.
Comment on this
For which Deputy Egan voted. The House has got to make up its mind whether or not young men who had certain careers cut out for them, but who will now, as the result of the passage of this Bill, be thrown on the scrap heap, are entitled to compensation, and whether that compensation is to come from the people whose houses are closed or from State sources.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy define the word "certain" in that connection? Does he mean a particular career or an assured career?
Comment on this
When I mentioned the word "certain" what I had in mind was that a certain number of people would be thrown out of their present employment and that their future careers in a particular business would be practically destroyed. So far as the Bill affects their promotions or their getting into more remunerative positions, the House is called upon to vote on that, and it will be interesting to read the records afterwards to find out how Deputies can vote for the elimination of a certain number of tied houses at the expense of private traders, thereby reducing the overhead charges of the parties concerned, and now refuse to give compensation of any kind for unemployment that may be caused as the result of the abolition of those particular tied houses.
Comment on this
I would have no pre-occupations whatever with regard to having my vote examined on this amendment afterwards. It seems to me that the first question we have to consider is, whether the persons referred to in these amendments who, I presume, are largely bar tenders and assistants, have in their present positions any inherent right or even an expectancy to a pension by the loss of their employment. In the ordinary course, say, a trader goes out of business. He has made enough money to enable him to do so, and that means that he disemploys his assistants. The question is, are they entitled to any pension or have they any expectancy of getting one? Is it any part of their contract of employment, or is it in any way a tradition in the trade? I am not aware that it is, and I certainly think it would be imposing a grave injustice, both upon the traders who will have to pay the compensation and the State, if any attempt were to be made to create a new class of pensioners in this country.
Comment on this
The principle of the amendment is sound. I do not know that the Minister has been quite fair in stating that this is purely an academic question. I heard the spokesman for the bar assistants give figures as to the number of assistants who are likely to be dismissed if this part of the Bill is carried through. In Dublin City alone there is the possibility of 130 men being dismissed. The man who made the case seemed to me to be making a very reasonable one and he did not appear to be desirous of exaggerating it in any way. It seems to me that if in one area of the State 130 men are likely to be dismissed, the matter is not quite so simple as the Minister seemed to indicate.
Comment on this
Let us be clear on this. Is the Deputy talking now of the operation of Part 4 of the Bill? There are two different things to be considered, and I ask the Deputy to allow me to draw a distinction. I was told that under the two hours' closing down a certain number of assistants were likely to find themselves unemployed in Dublin. An estimate was given which I did not accept. Deputations say many things to me that I do not accept. I take it that Deputies will not resent that remark. I did not accept that estimate for a moment. In any case, I distinguish between persons unemployed as a result of Part 4 of the Bill and persons unemployed as a result of any pruning of hours or any modifications of the licensing laws that might take place under any portion of the Bill. What I undertook to look into was the question of unemployment directly due or alleged to be directly due to the extinction of licences, because that is a thing apart. I have looked into that very carefully in the interval, and as a result of my examination of the matter I am not satisfied that there is any obligation on the State to make compensation in that matter, and I am not satisfied that I would be doing a proper thing by accepting Deputy Johnson's amendment.
Comment on this
I do not accept the Minister's view on this question. Deputy Egan, in dealing with this case embarked on a trend of argument which, to say the least of it, was the most ridiculous I ever heard put up in this House. He asked us to visualise the case of a man with half a dozen other jobs, the man who spent part of his time helping at the grocery counter, some other part of his time at the drapery counter, and so on. It seems to me that if a man is so well employed as that there is not much possibility of his losing his job. All I can say is that, in my opinion, that was an imaginary case and one not likely to arise at all. The Deputy also spoke about the brewer's drayman and other classes of people having some indirect connection with the business. I do not know that anybody is trying to make a case for that kind of person. I think that is not the type of case that is intended to be covered at all under this amendment.
The principle involved in the amendment is to give some compensation to men at present engaged at this work, and who have no other means of earning a living, men who are dependent for their regular employment on this business, not men in the casual employment that the Minister mentioned.
There can be no question about it that a number of people are permanently engaged in this work, and therefore if they are disemployed as the result of the passing of this Bill the principle of giving them some compensation is a sound one. The Minister spoke about the girl minding the child. That, I suggest, is not treating the subject seriously. I do not know that there is any need for dealing with that type of argument. This Bill has been held up to the country as a very necessary one, and as a great measure of social reform. If it is going to be that, surely there is some responsibility on those who have framed it in regard to the people who will lose their employment as a result of its passing. We have been generous from time to time to other people who have lost their employment in other walks of life. I think that the responsibility for doing something in the same connection here is very clear. The Minister has been fair enough in dealing with the principle in that he has not turned it down definitely. I think that he might with advantage to the Bill, and in a spirit of fair play to those who will be affected if the measure goes through as it is, reconsider his attitude on the whole matter.
Comment on this
The thing that I stress most in connection with this matter is the minimum notice of nine months for the employer that his licence is to be extinguished. Nine months is the minimum, but it will be more often a year or fourteen or fifteen months. If any abolition orders are issued earlier in the year than the 30th September, there will be more than a year's notice of them.
There is ample time for the employer and employee to envisage the situation that will exist when the licence for the sale of intoxicating liquor is gone. People in that kind of employment are very lucky indeed if they never find themselves unemployed at less than a year's notice. Yet that would be the position under Section 35 sub-section (1). There is compensation in the Bill for property abolished, withdrawn, because after all, the licence is something in the nature of property and the State, in the public interest, thinks it necessary to extinguish a certain number of those licences and proposes to give compensation.
Comment on this
The State has to levy from someone and thinks it right to levy from the people who benefit. The State gives the compensation and provides it by its legislation. The principle raised by the amendment is of a different order. It raises the principle that people who, as a result of State action, legislative or administrative, find themselves unemployed are entitled to turn to the State for compensation. That is a principle that ought not to be accepted without the fullest examination. I have given the case of the Customs people who were unemployed as a result of the abolition of the duty on tea by the Minister for Finance. The tea duty was withdrawn. He found a certain number of people in the Customs service who were then redundant and because he is not entitled, in the light of his duty and responsibility to the people, to pay their money out needlessly he is not entitled to keep in the public service people who are redundant. Consequently he notified those people that their services were no longer required. There is no question that they were unemployed as a result of an administrative decision to abolish the tea duty. They said this was a great hardship and felt that they were entitled to compensation but did not get it, while many Deputies say they should have got it.
Comment on this
Not to other State employment. The position was that they were redundant in the State service because the tea duty was abolished. Take the other Bills. These are only examples chosen at random. One could go into other questions of unemployment arising from State action of one kind or another. The Betting Bill might be said to cause unemployment. There have been Bills in the past, not merely Bills but administrative decisions, which caused some variation of conditions which resulted in some measure of unemployment. I think the kind of unemployment, of a degree that will arise or could arise under this part of the Bill, is something that should be averted. I think it will be negligible, and that this discussion is about something that is not going to arise. Then I point out that there is a year's notice of the alteration, ample time for employer and employee to envisage their new position. I am not satisfied that a case is made for the acceptance of one or other of these amendments.
Deputy Lyons talked about a man twenty years in employment. I cannot conceive a licensed house being abolished under this part of the Act in which any person will have had twenty years' employment. As a matter of fact, I know that the kind of houses that will go are not run by paid labour, but by the proprietor and his family. To accept an amendment that means that the yard-man, a maid-servant or any paid hand about the house, who found himself or herself seeking new employment as a result of the change, would be entitled to be a charge on the remaining licensees, is something that I am not prepared to undertake. Deputies did not talk intelligently about the thing, did not put up reasonable proposals. They did not say that if a man can show that he was five or ten years in employment in this establishment and that, as an immediate and direct result of the extinction of the licence, he was unemployed would we meet that case. I am not prepared to talk in terms of a man about the yard or a maid-servant about the house. If the Deputy says that a man had a contract of service, had done not less than five years in that employment and could show that his unemployment was directly and inevitably due to the extinction of the licence, one could talk business at any rate on those lines.
Comment on this
I can talk to Deputies along lines of that kind. I am not accepting principles at this stage. I am rejecting principles at this stage. I am rejecting the principle embodied in Deputy Byrne's and Deputy Johnson's amendments, but I want proposals that can be examined. I want a minimum period of service. I want a contract of service. I want the employment to be in connection with the sale of intoxicating liquor and nothing else. I want the unemployment to be the direct and inevitable result of the extinction of the licences, and along those lines one could talk business.
Comment on this
That is not all that is involved. Will the Deputy use his commonsense or borrow someone else's, and apply it to the amendment?
Comment on this
People have talked in terms of employment of bartenders as almost specialised employment and we are asked to envisage the manager, a person with twenty years' service. As a matter of fact, I ridicule the suggestion that this kind of person will find himself unemployed as a result of the Bill at all.
Comment on this
I would require a minimum period of service, a direct contract of service and would require the person concerned to be in a position to show the compensation authority that he was unemployed, because I am taking the situation post factum, the situation after the extinction, as a direct, inevitable consequence of the extinction of the licence. Then after all that I want a maximum set to the compensation that might be awarded by the compensation authority to that person, the equivalent say of a month's or two months' salary. Amendments such as Deputy Johnson's or Deputy Byrne's would be wholly unacceptable, and I have no alternative but to ask the Dáil to reject them.
If the provisos, the conditions, that one might consider reasonable are attached to the general principle, that is so easy to state and so easy to talk about with a certain glibness, then one could consider it. But there must be some commonsense in dealing with the thing. It is not simply a matter of making a certain number of persons a present of a lump sum because the State has decided to embark on a desirable reform. Let us have set down the minimum period of service, the contract of employment, the unemployment directly and inevitably arising out of the extinction of the licence, and the failure to secure alternative employment, and with all that I would want a maximum to the compensation that could be awarded to such a person. But I will not accept in their baldness and comprehensiveness the amendments of Deputy Johnson and Deputy Byrne.
Comment on this
It is a pity that in his first statement the Minister did not say what he has just now said.
Comment on this
It is a pity that the Minister did not set a good example in that respect. I am quite sure that Deputy Johnson did not intend that anybody should get compensation who would not be entitled to it. I noticed, though, that the Minister did not say that even if an amendment of that type, about which he has made so many conditions, were put down he would do more than consider it. He has not indicated that he would even favourably consider it.
Comment on this
The word "consider" has come to have a particular meaning in the Dáil. It has ceased to have its real meaning, and when a Minister says that he will consider a thing it is taken as equivalent to saying that he will accept it. I am not prepared to say that I will accept an amendment I have never seen, but I could really get near Deputies along those lines.
Comment on this
Would not the reasonable thing to do, if the Minister is of that mind, be for him to put down an amendment himself on the lines he has suggested?
Comment on this
Do you want us to start it all over again? I say that an amendment might be put down along the lines which the Minister suggested, but that he could offer objection to it, and then as we would be on the Report Stage the opportunity would not arise again.
Comment on this
I will put down an amendment, but I want to tell Deputies roughly what it will be like. It will be something on these lines, putting it in my own words: If (after a period to be stated) after the abolition of a licence, a person appeared before the compensation authority, and was in a position to show that he had not less than so many years service with the proprietor of the house in question, that he had a contract of service, that as the direct result of the extinction of the licence he had lost his employment, and that he had since been unable to secure alternative employment—under conditions of that kind—a minimum period of employment prior to the extinction, a period of unemployment after extinction, directly due to the abolition of the licence, and conditions of that kind—it should be open to the compensation authority to make an award, that would be added to the total compensation sum awarded in respect of the premises, of the equivalent of not more than two months' salary. Something of that kind is what I would consider a reasonable provision. But when Deputy Murphy asks if no one ever heard of a person who had got a pension or gratuity looking for alternative employment, what he meant was this, that in fact the licence is to be extinguished, the employer is to get his compensation for the extinguished licence, the employees are to get their bonus for their prospective unemployment, and then, possibly a week after, they are to be back working with the same employer, or working with the man next door.
Comment on this
No, I did not mean any such thing, but if they did they would not be any worse than anybody else I ever met in the same position. I would not ask the Minister to deal with the case of a person who would go into another shop the next day.
Comment on this
A period of actual unemployment and failure to secure employment, with unemployment directly due to the extinction of the licence, a previous minimum period of employment with that employer, and conditions of that kind, will figure in the amendment which I will put down. But I could not and should not accept the kind of amendments that stand in the names of Deputy Johnson and Deputy Byrne. It would not be fair to the licensed traders, who will have to bear the burden of this compensation, to expect them to deal with the matter along those lines. But I will put down, for the Report Stage, the amendment that I would consider reasonable to meet such a situation, because there is no such amendment before the Dáil.
Comment on this
I am thankful to the Minister for indicating the lines which his amendment will take. It will give an opportunity to others who wish to put in alternative amendments to do so. One point that he stressed I am not clear about. He has spoken of a contract of service. What exactly does he mean by that? Is there anything technical or special in that— that the man must show he has a contract of service?
Comment on this
What I meant by it was that a man must have had some actual tenure. There must have been a definite employer-employee relationship. It must not have been simply a casual or temporary employment.
Comment on this
Would not the minimum period of employment that the Minister has referred to secure that?
Comment on this
For my part I could not regard any scheme of compensation as satisfying the necessities of the case which left unprovided for those persons who lost their employment as a result of the action taken by this House. The Minister referred so often to casual employment and to the maid about the house that he evidently did not read my amendment, because the amendment said "in or about the licensed premises in connection with the sale of intoxicating liquors." I do not think that the maid would have anything to do with that. My amendment is very clear and definitely deals with a man or woman earning his or her livelihood solely in a licensed house. I do not want compensation for people who were merely casually employed, but I think if the House, in making laws for the public good, deprives people of their means of livelihood it should give them some compensation. The Minister is perfectly well aware of the position, because I have noticed that some of the points made by him were points made during a discussion in 1904 in Westminster on the question of the scale of compensation for men—three months for so many years' service, and so on.
I am not altogether disappointed, because I think the Minister will do something. While he will not accept this amendment, he sees that there is reasonable ground for amendment of the present proposal. There is no use saying that it is only the small country house where the trade is carried on by the man and his family that will be affected. I can well imagine when this Bill comes to be considered in Dublin and the Government have made up their minds that there are certain houses in side streets that must go, it will mean one assistant at least will be thrown out of employment. I say it is not just for any member of this House to give a vote that will deprive any man of his means of living without providing some compensation. Personally I will not press my amendment but I shall reserve the right, with the permission of the Chair, to put in an amendment when I see the amendment which the Minister brings up.
Comment on this
In view of the promise made by the Minister I ask leave to withdraw the amendment I moved on behalf of Deputy Johnson.
Comment on this
On the wording of this section I should like to draw the attention of the House to the definition in sub-section (8) line 15 "the occupation interest.""The expression ‘occupation interest' means the least or lowest estate or tenancy subsisting in the licensed premises on the day before the date of the reference order." Now the importance of that definition, occurring in this section, will be seen when we come to the following section because in the following section it is proposed: "Compensation shall be paid to the person or persons who on the day before the date of the reference order was, or were, the owner, or owners, of the occupation interest." It has been suggested, in some quarters, that this term as defined here does not cover those known as managers of tied houses. The question as to tied houses came up before the Commission and while they did not propose to abolish the tied-house system they mentioned in the report that the system was practically confined to the City and County of Cork and that there two local brewers owned about 300 licensed houses.
These licensed houses are owned by the brewers, and are worked by managers who are tenants of the brewers. But in the contract of tenancy there is a certain covenant. I understand all these contracts of tenancy are the same, and the following covenant, as far as I know, universally, is included, and it reads:—"In any case, at any time, that the said licence shall be extinguished under or by virtue of any Act of Parliament and compensation shall be given in respect of such extinction, such compensation shall be payable to the company"—that is to the brewer—"and in case any money shall be payable to the publican or to any person in his behalf in respect to such compensation, the publican shall pay the same to the company."
That seems a very sweeping covenant, and would seem, upon its face, to prevent the actual man occupying the premises and working it as the licensed holder from obtaining any compensation at any time; even if he had obtained compensation he would have to repay it to the lessor—the brewer. I would like the Minister to make clear his intention in this regard. As I say, this sub-section as worded here may possibly cover the case of those who are now lessees of the brewers, and who run these tied houses really as managers for the brewers, who have in many cases been in those positions for 10, 20, 30, or 40 years, and who are virtually, though perhaps not legally, the actual proprietors. It is true that they may not be legally so, but I submit that they have an equitable interest, certainly, and that they have a greater interest in the premises and in the continuation of the licence than anyone else. Therefore, I would like to ask, first, whether it is the intention by those words to enable those existing occupiers to be paid compensation or whether the compensation is to go to the brewers, and, secondly, if that is the intention, would the Minister make it clearer than it seems to be in the Bill at present. In asking these questions I desire to point out the serious position that those people will be placed in. There are certainly at least 300 such people in Cork city and county, many of whom probably will be deprived of their means of livelihood because their means of livelihood has been in their conduct of these houses.
It is interesting to recall that in the year 1904, when the Licensing Bill was going through the British Parliament, a proposal was made that people in such a position should be compensated. Mr. Asquith, speaking on that occasion, in July of that year, said it was absolutely essential, if justice was to be done in this matter, that the occupier should have first charge on the fund; it was not the great brewers that would suffer from the suppression of licences; on the contrary, in many instances they would positively gain from their reduction; on the other hand, the individual publican, whatever be his legal status, whether tenant, manager, agent, or trader by commission, was the man actually carrying on the business and was the first to suffer if the licence was suppressed. Provision was made in that Act whereby the manager—as he is usually called in England, where many of the houses are conducted on the tied-house system—was compensated. I am, therefore, anxious to know whether it is the Minister's intention to give any compensation to this class of people in the present Bill and, if that is his intention, whether he will make it clear in any part of this or the next section—perhaps it would be better to insert it here—that the occupation interest means the interest of the managers of tied houses and, if he is satisfied that the present wording does cover it, I would like to hear how he arrived at that conclusion.
Comment on this
Whatever the occupants of tied houses are they are not managers. They occupy the premises under a definite contract of tenancy. They pay rent in the ordinary way and they are not in a position of having to account for the profits of their trade to anyone. The only limitation on them is that they are obliged to sell only certain kinds of intoxicating liquor, generally the product of the brewery which owns the premises. A man who is in that position is not a manager. He is a weekly tenant who, but for the Rent Restriction Act, would be liable to quit at short notice, but while he conducts the business there as a licence-holder he is not obliged to account for his profits to anyone. His sole obligation to the brewery is to sell their products and no other. Deputy Redmond quoted a certain provision of the agreement made between the lessee of a tied house and the brewery owner. The provision which he read has in fact been amended.
I will read the old and the new agreement. Article 8 says:—"In case at any time the said licence shall be extinguished, under or by virtue of any Act of Parliament, and compensation shall be given in respect of such extinction, such compensation shall be payable to the company or their assignees." The old agreement reads:—"And in case any money shall be paid to the publican, or any person on his or her behalf, in respect of such compensation, the publican shall forthwith pay same to the company or their assignees." That was the agreement between two parties, a private agreement that should not in any way affect a provision made in legislation for allocation of compensation. This would arise, no doubt, as a legal instrument thereafter, but the article has, in fact, been amended and, instead of the sentence, "and in case any money shall be paid to the publican or any person on his or her behalf in respect of such compensation the publican shall forthwith pay same to the company or their assignees," you have the sentence, "such compensation shall be payable to the company or their assignees, and the publican in the proportion decided on by any Government tribunal set up for such purpose." Let us take the two positions, the old and the new. Under the old wording the Oireachtas passes this Bill which provides, amongst other things, for compensation. It provides for the allocation of such compensation between parties having an interest. This comes up afterwards as a valid and binding agreement between the parties, but it is something with which we have nothing to do. In the amended version the agreement is that "such compensation shall be payable to the company and their assignees and the publican in the proportion decided on by any Government tribunal set up for such purpose."
Comment on this
I only know that it is a thing now in force, that it is an agreement now subsisting between the lessee of a tied house and the brewer.
Comment on this
I do not want to embark unduly in the Dáil on a discussion of what is primarily and essentially other people's business, but this is an agreement between the brewery and its tied-house lessee.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that that agreement was not accepted by nearly half the managers or licensees, that at least half of them did not accept it, and that the brewery to which he refers is crushing them at present in expectation of this Bill?
Comment on this
Could the Minister say whether that agreement supersedes the old agreement quoted by Deputy Redmond or whether it applies to new tenancies?
Comment on this
I only know that this article at present exists between some tied-house lessees and the brewery owner.
Comment on this
No, but, whether it does or not, that is essentially a matter as between the parties, and may I suggest that in this matter the Dáil would do well to confine itself to what is actually its business and to what is actually before it? There is no question that under the definition of "occupation interest" given on line 15, of page 18, the tied house lessee comes in. The expression "the occupation interest" means the least or lowest estate or tenancy subsisting in the licensed premises on the day before the date of the reference order. There is no doubt whatever that the tied tenant holds the occupation interest within the meaning of those words. He has a tenancy from the landlord, or immediate lessor, and that tenancy is the lowest tenancy subsisting in the licensed premises. Section 36 provides compensation for the immediate lessor or holder of occupation interest. Sub-section 6 makes it clear what the occupation interest is to get. The compensation authority must take every case on its merits. In some cases occupation interest will get everything, as under sub-section (6) of Section 36. If the compensation authority determines that any part of the compensation is payable in respect of interest to the immediate lessor the residue of the compensation shall be deemed to be payable in respect of occupation interest, and if the compensation authority determines that no part of the compensation is payable in respect of interest to the immediate lessor the whole of the compensation shall be deemed to be payable in respect to occupation interest.
It is strange that I have had representations from both sides in connection with this section. I have been told on behalf of the brewery owners that the wording of the section is considered dangerous for them, that this reference to occupation interest, and so on, might mean that the tenant would be the person to receive the major share of the compensation, and that the brewery would be lucky if it came off with any. On the other hand, you have Deputy Redmond suggesting now that under the provisions of the section the tied-house lessee is in danger of getting nothing. I do not say more in connection with this matter as between the tied-house lessee and the brewery landlord than that under this section, as I understand it, the matter of allocating compensation between these two parties is left to the compensation authority.
I recognise that this section is one that will have to be very carefully drawn and very carefully examined, and any representations that people have to make with regard to its working either way will be looked into, but I do not want to pronounce, and I do not want the Oireachtas to pronounce, on the question of the allocation of compensation between those parties. I think that is mainly a matter for the compensation authority to decide in the light of all the relevant facts and evidence. All I am aiming to ensure is that the matter goes unprejudiced to the compensation authority, that we secure by our section a hearing for both, and that we leave room by our section for compensation to both in whatever proportions the compensation authority thinks fit to decide upon. I think from that point of view the Deputy may make his mind quite easy. The words "occupation interest" certainly cover the tied-house lessee as defined on the top of page 18, and for the rest, if there is any need to prune or polish the wording of the section he may take it that I am going to consult with the Attorney-General between this and the next stage as to whether the section is sound and good from the point of view of what I am aiming at, namely, securing that there shall be hearing for both parties before the compensation authority, and that the compensation authority be free to allocate compensation between them.
Comment on this
The Minister said that so far as seeing that everything is fully covered the section in its final form would want to be very carefully drawn. I agree that we should be very definite on this question. In connection with this matter I wish to mention another type of tied-house that has not so far been dealt with. I know of a number of cases where people have gone into possession of houses of this kind, not as managers or weekly tenants, but as people who paid a fine, not perhaps anything like the value of the house, but a substantial amount. Now they are tied down with very severe restrictions. They cannot sell, as the Minister has pointed out, anything but the product of the firm to which they are bound. If they do proceedings are started in the High Court, an injunction is obtained, and the costs are so heavy that these people are put out of business. That certainly is the type of house that will be abolished under the Bill. These people are poor and have not a big stock to carry on a flourishing and independent business, and certainly they would come under the operations of the restrictive portion of the Bill. Another type of tied-house is the one-time independent house, the tenant or head of which died leaving children. That house was rather loosely managed and fell into the hands of the brewery by reason of debt, or matters of that kind. People of that sort feel they have a fairly definite interest in the business of the house. They would need very definite protection under this section. I am not talking of the person who goes into the house as a weekly tenant, but of persons whose predecessors had some direct interest in the house, and I would beg of the Minister to bear such cases in mind.
Comment on this
The history is not remote. I am dealing with comparatively recent cases. I am taking the case of a man whose father occupied the house twenty or thirty years ago, and who got into difficulty, with the result that the house is now in the position of being a tied-house.
Comment on this
I agree, but after all there is a considerable difference in regard to the type of house I am referring to.
Comment on this
Is there in fact a difference in the relationship between the type of house the Deputy is referring to and the brewery landlord, and the relationship that exists between him and the ordinary tied-house tenant, because the difference in the circumstances that led to the present legal position is really not material?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say that in the case of a person who built the house and who got into difficulties and who was, perhaps, treated as narrowly as possible—the brewer set out to get the house into his hands and he has been as hard as he could with the tenant—is there not a great difference between that and the cases referred to?
Comment on this
No, because it was open to the trader at all times prior to this relationship to sell in the open market, and he must have entered into this relationship because it suited him better than to sell.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister has quite grasped the situation in Cork or he would not say that, because as far as I am aware it has been barely possible for people such as those referred to by Deputy Murphy to make any other arrangement than with brewers. There is nobody outside the brewing interests who would have taken over the house that he has mentioned, and though it may have been a free contract legally, at the same time there was a considerable amount of duress in the matter. I would suggest, though the Minister does not seem to entertain the idea, that this would be a matter for the compensation authority to consider when they were determining this question of the amount of compensation that they would allocate as between the person who owned the occupation interest and, say, the immediate lessor. However, I am glad to hear the Minister state that this phrase "occupation interest" and the definition contained here does in his view cover the existing lessees of what are known as tied houses. I am also glad that he corrected a misapprehension that I may have conveyed to the House when I described some of these as managers. I can assure him that was not my intention. It is difficult to get a term which would describe the actual position of those people. They are strictly lessees, but they are more than lessees, because they are not merely tenants of those places from week to week or year to year, but in most cases they have had an interest in them, apart from their mere tenancy of occupation of the premises. In many cases the Deputy referred to they have had to pay a fine to go into them. It was not a fine for the mere tenancy of the house but for the licence and what it was worth. The Minister says there seems to be some ambiguity about the section because representations have been made to him from both sides.
Comment on this
I imagine that if there is nervousness neither side is thoroughly convinced as to what the section really means to convey. However, I hope that he will make himself perfectly satisfied before the Bill passes that the section at least goes as far as he intends, namely, that the matter of allocation as between those parties shall rest with the compensation authority, and certainly that the lessee of a house such as those tied ones shall be entitled to his amount of compensation, whatever that may be, as the owner of the occupation interest. I would ask for further consideration of Deputy Murphy's suggestion, that the fact that fines have to be paid in many cases, the fact that the brewers have been placed almost in a coercive position in regard to these places, that they are the only source from which these licence holders have been able to get any assistance, should be taken into consideration by the compensation authority when about to make the allocation as between these various parties.
Comment on this
I do not think we should attempt to provide in the Bill that these things should be taken into consideration, but these things will no doubt form part of the setting that a skilful counsel would present his case in. The man can be put in the box and can give the antecedents of the whole present position, and it will be for the compensation authority to give whatever weight it thinks fit to that. But in our provisions in the Bill we ought not to attempt to get away from or get behind the existing legal relationship, however that relationship came about. Deputy Murphy talked of pressure and duress and so on. I was a little bewildered as to how a man came to enter into a relationship which was disadvantageous to him; more disadvantageous than, let us say, to put up the premises for sale in the open market for what they could fetch. I must presume that he entered into this relationship with the brewery owner because it suited him better to do that than to do anything else open to him.
Comment on this
Than to sell. Is it suggested that he had nothing to sell—that the owner of licensed premises in Cork had nothing to sell?
Comment on this
Perhaps I was not quite clear about the type of case I was dealing with.
Comment on this
Let me say what I understood from the Deputy—that the owner of hitherto free licensed premises gradually contracted debts with a brewery for supplies of their particular product and presently became so deeply entangled in a net of debt that there was nothing left for him but to accept the relationship of tied tenant and brewery landlord, and that that is now the legal relationship that exists. My comment on that is that that was not the only thing open to him. He could have sold, and if he did not sell it must have been because it suited him better to contract the existing legal relationship with the brewer, or else because he had in fact no valuable interest to sell at all. In this Bill we ought not to try to get away from the present-day legal relationship. Anything else would be for counsel to bring out as the setting—the framework of the present-day position—to bring out in evidence as something having a certain relevancy, at any rate. But the Bill must deal with the position as it exists to-day between party and party through legal relationship.
Comment on this
I did not raise this point so much because I wanted special treatment for the type of case I referred to as much as to instance it as one of the cases that would furnish an argument for being very definite about this matter. Perhaps I would not have pressed the point so much were it not for the manner in which the Minister tried to dismiss the whole thing. I gathered that the Minister was making the case that people generally in tied houses had no interest whatever in them; that they were simply tenants at will; that they went in and left quite casually without any great interest in them. I mentioned this case in order to try and establish the principle that Deputy Redmond and myself are interested in. The Minister has pressed me on the point, and I should like to say that I have in mind a case of people who got into difficulties as a result of debts and family troubles, and who had stock piled on to them, perhaps more than they wanted; whose business fell into the hands of relations who managed it badly, and who found themselves in a bad way, financially, in a short time. It would be very easy, the Minister says, for them to sell, but they wanted to keep a roof over their heads. You cannot blame people for thinking that they have more than a passing interest in a business of this kind. It is obvious that they have more than a passing interest. The business originally was free and independent, built up by these people, the structure in many cases being put up by themselves. After all, they were forced to accept terms that were not fair and reasonable. While I do not want to put the Minister in a false position about the legal aspect, I mentioned the cases in order to strengthen the argument we are putting forward for this principle.
Comment on this
I support the case made by Deputy Murphy, because when I sought, in a previous amendment, to have consideration given to the licensee, it was a case similar to his I had in mind, where a man in Cork some years ago owned his own house. He bought it as a licensed house, and he was the licensee. He got into some difficulty. The brewery supplied him and allowed his account to run on, and eventually when he owed the brewer a certain sum, the brewer put the screw on and demanded full payment or else—— To get out of that difficulty this licensed trader was forced to sign an agreement with the brewer. That man personally said to me up in the gallery, "Mr. Byrne, there is a certain Deputy in the House who is after speaking, and he has an interest in houses similar to mine, and they were got by similar means." That was the position that was put up to me. If there are any more cases than the one I heard of in which licensed traders were unable to pay small sums, and in which the screw was put on, is it fair that if compensation is being paid for the licensed house that the original owner should not get special consideration because of the circumstances?
Comment on this
I am wondering where we are getting, whether we are going to write a provision in the Bill on the strength of ex-parte statements made in the gallery, in the lobbies, or round the precincts of the House, or whether we are going to leave unprejudiced to the compensation authority the problem of allocating compensation as between the brewery landlord and the tied house lessee, to decide in the light of the facts, in the light of the evidence after a hearing that would be the reverse of the hearing which Deputy Byrne gave up in the gallery, what a just and equitable allocation would be. Deputy Redmond professed himself satisfied with the statement that line 15, page 18, of the Bill does cover the tied house lessee, that he is eligible for compensation, that it will be for the compensation authority to decide on the allocation as between himself and the brewery landlord. I do not think that we really shall spend our time very profitably by going into the history of special cases, particularly cases based on ex-parte hearings by individual Deputies.
I rather deprecate the repetition in the Dáil of statements of that kind. From my personal experience statements of that kind prove on investigation to be very garbled one-sided versions indeed. I have had so many poor tales poured into my ears, in hurried interviews, in corridors and so on, and I have found the facts to be so very different that I distrust nine out of ten of the hard case stories I am told about the unfortunate man who, through no fault of his own, got into serious financial difficulties and then had his face ground by some plutocrat tyrant. Generally there is another side to the shield—that after a calm and judicial investigation the first version undergoes substantial changes. What we come back to is: Deputies are satisfied that the section leaves unprejudiced to the compensation authority this difficult question of the allocation of compensation as between the brewery landlord and tied house lessee. I think it would be unwise to prejudice the matter. I think it is eminently one for judicial decision after a calm hearing and consideration of all the relevant evidence. That is what is aimed at at any rate and I believe that is what is secured. It may be that the section might need to be overhauled and re-examined in its drafting aspect but substantially it effects that and I think that is what we should aim at effecting.
Comment on this
There is a subsequent amendment to this section in the name of Deputy Redmond which is practically the same as mine. There is only a difference of 10/- in the sums mentioned in the amendments. I think Deputy Redmond's amendment would be more acceptable to the Minister because the sum mentioned in it is 10/- more than that mentioned in mine. I shall therefore not move my amendment in order to allow Deputy Redmond to proceed with his.
Comment on this
I move amendment 78:—
In sub-section (1), line 23, to delete the words "seven pounds ten shillings" and substitute therefor the words "five pounds ten shillings."
I am obliged to Deputy Daly for permitting me to move my amendment. The principle involved in this amendment does not demand any payment by the State. What is asked for is that the remaining licence holders shall be entitled to make their contribution at a lesser rate. Of course amendment 78 should be taken in conjunction with amendment 80, which proposes to substitute the word "forty" for "twenty" years. The proposal in the two amendments is that instead of paying at the rate of £7 10s. the rate should be £5 10s., and that the period of years, instead of being twenty, should be forty.
I am not tied to these figures, but I suggest that the Minister should consider the proposal that the period of twenty years be extended. It is a short term to make the repayment. The State would not suffer in any way by the proposed alteration, because the amount that might have to be paid in the end would be actually more.
Comment on this
I do not think we are very clear about what the Deputy means. If we take up amendment 78, does it mean that he wants the £7 10s. reduced to £5 10s.? There is nothing in amendment 78 about the extension of years. The Deputy is reading that into it himself.
Comment on this
If Deputy Egan kept his ears open he would know that amendment 80 is being taken in conjunction with amendment 78.
Comment on this
Yes. It is necessary for me to point out what is proposed in amendment 80 to enable me to explain what is proposed in 78; and I propose if amendment 78 is accepted to move amendment 80.
Comment on this
Amendment 78 would not have much meaning, but unfortunately you have to proceed step by step even in construing and making Acts of Parliament.
Comment on this
Well, in some cases, but the Ministry does not think in all cases it is. It is proposed in 78 to delete the words "£7 10s." in Section 1 and to substitute therefor "£5 10s.," and in amendment 80 it is proposed that in sub-section (2) of Section 40 the word "forty" be substituted for "twenty."
Comment on this
It is a matter of keen regret to me that the Minister for Finance is not available for the discussion of the amendment. Entering into the merits of this amendment involves calculations turning on the present value of one annuity payable for twenty years as against the present value of another annuity payable over forty years. I have ascertained from the tables that the present value of an annuity of £7 10s., payable for twenty years at 5 per cent., is £93 9s.; and at 5¼ per cent. it is £91 10s. That is, the annuity mentioned in the Bill is, at 5 per cent., equal to £93 9s., and at 5¼ per cent. £91 10s. The present value of an annuity of £5, payable for forty years at 5 per cent. is £85 16s., and at 5¼ per cent. £82 19s. The Deputy's amendment is £5 10s. The present value of an annuity of £5 10s. over forty years is £94 7s., and at 5¼ per cent. £91 4s. So it occurs to me to wonder whether all those discussions we seem likely to have over this question of amounts and terms are worth while, in fact whether what we are discussing is something that amounts to a contribution of 10s. a month to a trader.
If you put into the Bill that no trader shall be asked to bear, in a given year, a compensation burden greater than his licence duty, then, in fact what you mean is that the average trader will not have to bear a burden of more than £7 in the year in respect of compensation. Whether it is worth while to travel over this whole ground of an annuity of £5 10s. spread over forty years as against an annuity of £7 10s. spread over twenty years, in view of what just the difference would mean translated into a burden on a given trader in a given year, is very questionable indeed. The Minister for Finance pointed out that the rate of interest is not. in fact, 5 per cent., that he does not expect to borrow next at 5 per cent. while he would expect to get below 5¼ per cent. Even with 5 per cent. the present amount over a period of twenty years would represent a contribution of £6 10s.; that is, a State contribution of 6½ per cent. At 5 per cent. the Deputy's term represents only a State contribution of £5 13s., so that, in fact, it works out at a lower contribution than the provision in the Bill. As against that it extends the term; and the extension of the term to some extent affects the credit and affects security really, because licensed houses are not like land, something that was there before us and will be there after us. They are subject to variations, and twenty years is as much as one cares to look ahead in a matter of that kind. There may be fluctuations of population and so on that would affect the value of licensed premises and their value in particular areas. Changes of that kind affect the security on which the State advances money to the extinguished licensees. Twenty years is a long enough term for a calculation of this kind.
It is not as if one were dealing with property like land and is it worth while to advocate the extension of the term to forty years, securing in that way a slight reduction of the State contribution? In the one case you have a State contribution of £6 10s. and, under the Deputy's suggestion, you have the State contribution reduced to £5 13s. We went into this matter very carefully and we examined the tables and considered what the different amounts would mean for different periods and, after a good deal of discussion between officials of my Department and officials of the Finance Department, and subsequently between Ministers themselves, we came to the conclusion that we really were not likely to be able to arrive at anything better either from the point of view of the State or of the trade.
Amendment put and negatived.
Comment on this
I beg to move amendment 81:—
Before sub-section (6) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—
"(6) Section 47 of the Local Registration of Title (Ireland) Act, 1891, shall have effect as if a charge created by virtue of this section were added to and included in the burdens mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (i) of that section."
Comment on this
This amendment merely means that the State need not go to the trouble of registering the annuity as a charge on licensed premises in order to make it a valid charge. The general position under the Local Registration of Title Act is that charges must be registered in order to be effective, but there are several exceptions to that rule and this particular charge seems to be one that could be properly added to the list of exceptions. The point is that every possible purchaser of a publichouse will be aware of the fact that a levy under this Bill is in existence and he will have regard to that fact when he is buying the publichouse. He will not be taken by surprise and will not be at a loss when he finds he has to pay a small annual contribution under this Bill although, in fact, there is no note of such a contribution on the Register of Titles. I think that the matter will be one of such notoriety and publicity that it is a reasonable thing to ask for exemption from the provisions of the Local Registration of Titles Act.
Comment on this
I move amendment 83:—
In sub-section (1) (a), line 50, to delete the word "ten" and substitute therefor the word "twelve" and to delete in lines 50-53 the words "or between the hours of three o'clock and five o'clock in the afternoon" and in line 52 to delete the word "ten" and substitute the word "eleven."
Comment on this
In this amendment we will take first the point involving the word "twelve;" that is, the opening hour, merely.
Comment on this
We will take the beginning of the amendment first; that is, the morning hour.
Comment on this
The idea of that amendment is that as far as clubs in general go, there are not many members arriving before 12 o'clock in the day. To my mind, 12 o'clock is quite early enough to open bars in clubs for the sale of intoxicating drink. If I have to deal specially with the deletion of the word "ten" and the substitution of the word "twelve," I think it would be rather hard to deal with that if I did not also deal with the latter portion of the amendment.
Comment on this
Very well, let the Deputy go for the whole amendment then.
Comment on this
Why I put this amendment down was in order to reduce the number of hours for the sale of intoxicating liquor in the clubs, but while cutting off two hours in the morning I propose that they should be given one hour extra in the evening. For the hours lost in the morning we want an hour extra in the evening. As a result of my amendment the clubs will have one hour less for the sale of intoxicating liquor than the publicans outside have.
A strong argument can be put up in favour of this amendment. Notwithstanding the fact that a very large number of Deputies do not agree that clubs should get any better terms than the ordinary licensed trader outside, I think this is a very proper amendment. The licensed trade itself, I believe, would be completely against this amendment allowing the clubs to sell intoxicating drink for an hour after they are closed. Notwithstanding those facts, we must take into account the type of people who visit those clubs. Traders of different kinds— even men engaged in the licensed trade —visit a club for an hour's amusement when they have their shops closed and I think it is only right that those people should be able to get a drink. Then there is the case of the engine driver who gets into town at 10.30 p.m. or 10.15 p.m. and who is a member of a club. He should have an opportunity of getting a drink if he requires it. The adoption of this amendment would not lead to any additional abuses. The clubs are now governed by the same regulations as the public-houses and are subject to inspection by the Gárda Síochána. By adopting this amendment, you would be catering for people who have spent the day behind their own counters or who have been travelling throughout the day. I hope the Minister will give the club this extra hour—that is two hours less in the morning and one hour extra in the evening. I may be criticised by the licensed traders for standing up for the clubs but the men who visit these clubs and who do not abuse privileges deserve our consideration. The greatest advocate of temperance is the man who cannot take a drink himself and the greatest supporters of the closing of clubs at the same hour as licensed houses are the men who cannot themselves take the risk of the extra hour.
Comment on this
On the question of the hours, 3 to 5, in the afternoon, I presume if a subsequent amendment is carried limiting the closing interval to one hour, that will also apply to clubs?
Comment on this
I move amendment 84:—
"In sub-section (1) (b) page 21, line 54, to delete the words ‘ten o'clock in the morning' and substitute therefor the words ‘twelve noon' and to delete in lines 55-56 the words ‘or between the hours of three o'clock and five o'clock in the afternoon' and in lines 56-57 to delete the words ‘half-past nine' and substitute therefor the word ‘eleven."
Comment on this
Will the Deputy take the decision on amendment 83 as governing 84?
Comment on this
No, sir. I said to-day that the longer the Government sat the longer I would talk. If the club is to close for one hour during the day, it should be entitled to an extra hour in the night. The Minister should consider Saturday night and the necessity of giving a club a little latitude. I only ask him to give an hour or one and a half hours.