ORDUITHE AN LAE. - LAND BILL, 1927.—THIRD STAGE.
Contributions 1–159 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 4 of 1927 ›
When the debate was adjourned we were discussing an amendment which provides for the reinstatement of genuine evicted tenants in their holdings. I had gone into a case and explained the facts of it with a view to showing that the Land Commission are not sympathetic to the grievances of the evicted tenants, and are not making any real attempt to reinstate them, even where it is open to them to do so. I dealt with a particular case, the facts of which, I think, are known to the Minister, in order to try to emphasise the argument which Deputy Cosgrave and I are making. The holding in question is one of 80 statute acres in my constituency, outside one of the principal towns, and the original tenant was evicted during the Plan of Campaign. His only representative is a brother, who lives in Dublin. That estate came into the hands of the Land Commission a short time ago for the purpose of division. The representative of the evicted tenant made application, and his application was supported by some of the most prominent men in the town and the neighbourhood, but despite the fact that the Land Commission had all the particulars of the case, despite the fact that they must have been aware that this was the representative of a genuine evicted tenant, they have not done anything for him.
As to the genuineness of the application, the facts are that at the time of the Plan of Campaign this man's brother, being a tenant on the Smith Barry Estate, was forced to withhold his rent, in conjunction with the other tenants. As everybody knows, that estate was the centre of turmoil in the land fight, and it was practically imperative on every tenant to withhold his rent in accordance with the instructions of the leaders of the time. This tenant was evicted for non-payment of a year's or one and a-half year's rent. The lands have since been in the hands of a caretaker, or an emergency man, and now we have them divided. This evicted tenant is undoubtedly genuine, if any evicted tenant can be regarded as genuine, but he has not been reinstated. To aggravate the case and to emphasise the point that the Land Commission have really no intention of dealing sympathetically with evicted tenants, the actual emergency man who went into that place at the time of the eviction got a grant of land on the estate. That is a most extraordinary case, and it seems to me to clinch the argument that the Government and the Land Commission have no intention of reinstating evicted tenants, and have no sympathy with them.
I have not tried to make the point that evicted tenants must be in open competition as regards ability, farming qualities and other matters with the other people who make applications for grants of land. I do not maintain that this man is particularly suitable as a farmer, but I do maintain that he is the representative of the original evicted tenant, and that as a matter of justice, a matter of righting a grievous wrong, of keeping in line with the ideals of the old land agitation, and of showing our appreciation of the loyalty of these tenants to the State, that it is absolutely imperative that the Land Commission and the Government should insist that genuine evicted tenants of this kind should be reinstated.
I have another case, one with which I am more or less personally conversant, in mind also, that of an emergency man who was driven out of his place four or five years ago during the troubled times. This man is now willing to hand his place over to the Land Commission. A representative of the evicted tenant is willing to take it over, but there is no indication that the Land Commission intend to take over the place and hand it to this woman.
I think a very good case has been made, not to prove the justice of this amendment, but to prove that the Government are not seriously dealing with this question at all, and are not really taking advantage of the powers in the Land Act of 1923 for the reinstatement of evicted tenants. I support the amendment largely as a protest against the Government's inaction. I do not say that the amendment in its present form is quite workable. I think that the wording of the last line, which states that the tenant is to be reinstated in his original holding, would not be workable and practicable in a great many cases, although it would be in other cases. If the Minister would accept the principle that every genuine evicted tenant must be reinstated in his original holding, where that is available, or, if that is not possible, that he should get an alternative holding, I am willing to withdraw my support of the amendment. But if the Minister does not give a clear indication that the point of view of the Land Commission in this regard is to be changed, and that we are to have a different outlook, I have no option but to support the amendment, and to ask other Deputies to do so, as a protest against the present policy of the Land Commission. I put it to them in this way, that any Deputy who does not vote for it may be regarded as not being in sympathy with those who took part in the fight which resulted in the tenants becoming the owners of their land, and which finally resulted in the establishment of our freedom, and in the fact that we are sitting here in a Parliament of our own.
Comment on this
The effect of the amendment is that the Land Commission shall take every genuine evicted tenant and shall deal with him by reinstating him in the holding from which he was evicted. As the law stands, the Land Commission may deal with an evicted tenant. They are not under the necessity of reinstating him in the holding from which he was evicted. Moreover, they can pick and choose between evicted tenants. They can take the present circumstances of the applicant into account, and even though a man may have been a genuine evicted tenant, or the representative of one, nevertheless, they can exercise an option and refuse to give him a holding of land. But if this amendment is passed it will mean that the Land Commission shall deal with every evicted tenant, no matter what his present circumstances may be; equally important, no matter what the circumstances of the other applicants for land on the estate may be. They cannot take the equities of the case into account at all. They must deal with the evicted tenant, and somebody else must be omitted from the scheme, and they must deal with him by giving him his original holding, no matter who occupies it now, no matter what the circumstances may be. That last condition would be quite out of the question.
Nobody wants to start a series of evictions again. Lands have changed hands, perhaps, three or four times since 1880. Circumstances have changed, and evicted tenants have gone away into the cities and built up businesses, or have gone to America. Their representatives may be fairly wealthy people, and the holding from which their grandfather or their father had been evicted twenty or thirty years ago may have changed hands three or four times, and it may have been bought quite recently, or within the last ten or fifteen years, for the full market value, and with the goodwill and consent of everybody, not with the specific consent, of course, of the evicted tenant, but they may have been bought by auction in the ordinary way, without any intimation from anybody that there was any objection to their being bought. That is the strongest case of all from my point of view. It would be out of the question to eject such a man. Even if there was opposition twenty or thirty years ago to a man going into an evicted farm, we cannot re-open these matters now; if we attempted to do so, we would have to re-open a great many cases, and we would find ourselves under the necessity of putting through a series of evictions all over the country, and in a big percentage of cases, doing extreme hardship. In that state of affairs it is out of the question to say that an evicted tenant must be reinstated on the holding from which he was evicted himself or from which his grandfather, father or predecessor in title was evicted. That is the first point.
The second point is that the Land Commission shall at least give him a holding. Let us examine that for a moment. You will find plenty of cases of genuine evicted tenants from any point of view, genuine in the sense that their predecessors in title were evicted in the ordinary way from the lands which they held, just as a number of other tenants were evicted during the years from 1870 to 1890, and from the point of view of the legal definition inserted in any Act of Parliament, perfectly genuine cases. But even admitting that, there are still plenty of cases in which it is inadvisable to deal with genuine evicted tenants. Circumstances have changed a lot in thirty, forty or fifty years and you cannot base legislation on a set of circumstances that existed on the equities of the case as it stood, say, twenty years ago. It cannot be done and if you attempt to do it the moment you are brought up against a specific case you realise you are wrong. The best way to argue this whole question is to argue it around the exact case that Deputy Heffernan gave us.
Deputy Heffernan mentioned a man named Cahill who is the genuine representative of an evicted tenant, evicted because he refused to pay his rent during the days of the Plan of Campaign. He was evicted by Lord Barrymore on the Smith-Barry estate. From every point of view it was just an ordinary case of eviction. There are no peculiar circumstances in it. If there was ever a genuine case of an evicted tenant it was one. He went away to the Argentine and died there a very wealthy man and his brother and sister remained at home. The sister is a lady in very prosperous circumstances I am informed, living in the suburbs of Dublin, with a certain amount of means of her own. She applied in 1905 or thereabouts. She was offered a holding and refused it. Then one of the brothers came home from the Argentine, not the original evicted tenant but another brother, and he applied specifically when this particular farm was going and he was refused. He is a middle-aged man now I think, and is, as far as I know, unmarried. He is a wealthy man and lives here in Dublin. The farm in question is about 130 acres of untenanted land.
The Land Commission were in the position that they had an application from a man called Cahill, a genuine evicted tenant, a person probably who could buy this 130 acres three or four times over, a man who if he wanted to expend his money on a farm would buy a farm of 300 or 400 acres. They had an application from him to be reinstated. He spent his life in the Argentine. He is a middle-aged man now and he has plenty of means. His sister is also reasonably well-off. On the other side you have five or six congests with holdings varying from £3 to £4 to £10 or £12 in valuation, living near. Perhaps the shortest way would be to read out the names and the circumstances of the five or six people who got the land and let the Dáil put them on the one side and the case of the evicted tenant on the other.
Comment on this
Might I point out that exception was taken on the last occasion to mentioning names. I carefully avoided mentioning names. I thought the Minister would follow my example and leave out the names. I would suggest that the Minister should not go any further to deal with the class of tenant because that means dealing with a great many names and bringing in other names. I do not want to be forced into the position of saying whether such and such a man is a good man for a holding. There are some very good men who did get holdings, and there are certain objectionable individuals who got them. I am not basing the case on the type of men who did get holdings, but I am basing it on the claim of the particular man who is a genuine representative of an evicted tenant. I want to say that my information is that this man is not a very rich man. I understand he is a man of moderate means.
Comment on this
On the question of the names, I think it would be better, if the Minister is going to continue the illustration, that he should allude to the congests as A, B, C, giving the circumstances without the names.
Comment on this
Deputy Heffernan is quite right. I thought he had mentioned the name.
Comment on this
It is a well-known case, and he might as well have given the name. Take the circumstances of that man—we have already mentioned his name, Mr. Cahill—and put them on one side, and put on the other side the circumstances of the people who got the land and take into account also that there was only about 130 or 140 acres to be divided. The Land Commission was in a dilemma. Here we have an application from an evicted tenant for a holding. How much is he to get? Is 25 acres any good to a man like that, a man in his circumstances? If he went in for farming himself he could afford to get a farm of 300 or 400 acres, and are we to give this man who is living in town here 25 acres, and if we are which of the others are we to leave out?
I will now give the circumstances of the congests among whom the land was divided. One man got 13 acres 3 rds. and 30 perches. He was a workman living in a labourer's cottage, and he has consistently got a prize for the best labourer's cottage under the Scheme of the County Committee of Agriculture in the district. He and another are the only landless men that got land. The herd got 15 acres: he obviously had to be dealt with. Another man, who has a valuation of £2 16s., and who had 5 acres, got 14 acres in addition. Another man, whose valuation was £12 5s. and who was a most industrious man, got 12 acres in addition. The £12 5s. includes the valuation of his house and his holding, and it is barely economic. Another man had a valuation of £10 10s., including house and land, and he got 11 acres. A holding of £10 10s. valuation is not an economic holding, and the eleven would make it barely economic. Another man, who had a valuation of £15, got 9 acres. Another who had a valuation of £2 10s. got 17 acres, and another man, a married man with 11 children, with a valuation of £2 15s., got 17 acres. Finally, a married man, who had the grazing of about 10 head of stock there always, and who lived almost exclusively on that, got a holding of 21 acres.
There is a specific case. On the one side you have got a genuine evicted tenant who at the time of the eviction had all the equities of the case. He went out. He was incidentally a big farmer, well able to pay his rent. He left his holding behind and from that day to this never got a penny out of it. He happens to be a well-off man, at least for this country, and he lives here in Dublin; I do not think he has anyone depending on him. His sister who was also an applicant is quite a well-off woman living here in Dublin, and it would be simply foolish to allot, say, twenty-five acres of land to this man. Of course, what he would do, if he had any sense, would be to sell it straight away to someone who was well able to buy it. That twenty-five acres would mean that three, certainly two, of these congests would be left out. I use that case as an illustration of the fact that you should not compel the Land Commission to deal with every case. You must take into account not only the circumstances that existed at the time of the evictions, but the circumstances as they now are. That makes all the difference. The policy of the Land Commission is to deal with every genuine case so far as they have the land to do it. They have dealt with a couple of thousand cases since the Land Act of 1903, and with 53 since the Act of 1923. Every application of an evicted tenant gets the fullest consideration. All the circumstances are taken into account. You cannot give any evicted tenant, except in rare cases, more than another an economic holding. The Land Commission uses public money to buy land and the basis on which the whole transaction is carried out is that its use will be limited to re-selling to applicants economic holdings. There are men in Leix and Galway who were evicted from 200 or 300 acres in the year 1880. Suppose they were never evicted, the Land Commission might be acquiring part of their land to-day.
You could not give men 200 or 300 acres now. In some cases they acquired judicial tenancies. You could only give a man an economic holding. That is the first limitation. The second limitation is that you must take the circumstances of the time into account. It is obviously bad business and uneconomic to give 25 or 30 acres to a man who, owing to his station in life, is not the sort of man to whom 25 or 30 acres are likely to be of much use. In this particular case the man was well off. Take another case. Take just the same circumstances with this change. Suppose the evicted tenant had been a shopkeeper in Tipperary near that farm. He has a small shop with a turnover of from £300 to £400 a year. Would the Land Commission be right even in that case—a case of a genuine evicted tenant with a shop, and who is twenty-five or thirty years out of touch with land since his father's eviction and who has lost any little knowledge of farming which he had—would they be right, I ask, even in that case, in giving the land to such a man? That case is somewhat different from the case I quoted. Would they be right, I repeat, in giving land to such a man especially if there were congests about?
If 130 acres were to be divided, and suppose there were ten or twelve congests and one genuine evicted tenant, who was a small shopkeeper in the nearest town, living away from the land, are we to bring him in and leave out two or three congests? I do not think we should. The moral of the story is that, no matter how anxious you are to deal with evicted tenants, you should not put the Land Commission in a straight-jacket and pass a rigid section in an Act, saying that the Land Commission shall deal with all cases regardless of the circumstances, merely limiting it to the phrase, "genuine evicted tenants." It would be quite impossible, and for that reason I cannot accept the amendment. There seems to be an idea in the Dáil that the Land Commission are not particularly keen on dealing with evicted tenants. No meritorious case of an evicted tenant is left undealt with. Deputies should be careful, when cases of evicted tenants are put up, to look into all the circumstances.
I would not ask better than to have every case thrashed out in the Dáil. The Dáil would probably not like it, but it would settle the thing once and for all. It is the only way to do it. You cannot deal with these on general principles. Take any specific case, go into the circumstances, and I have no doubt that if the Dáil were to be the judges they would act similarly in each as the Land Commission acted. You would not get five Deputies to say, in this particular case quoted by Deputy Heffernan, that the evicted tenant should be dealt with, and the congests left out. The Land Commission will continue to deal with cases of evicted tenants. The fact that a man made application, and that it was turned down, is no reason why he should not make another. It will be considered in the light of new circumstances, the land available, and of everything connected with it. It would be out of the question to insert a rigid proposal of this sort in a Land Act, and it would be a very grave injustice.
Comment on this
Viewing this from the State aspect, and apart from class and individual interest, one is forced to accept the Minister's view-point. The word "shall" and the words "original holding" ought not, in my opinion, find expression in any Act. The Bill does not say even "portion of the original holding." It says "original holding," let it be 200 or 300 acres. We know with the present hunger for land that the phrase "original holding" is not a practical proposal. I am of opinion that the word "shall" ought not find its place in the Act.
Comment on this
The Minister has dealt to some extent, I think, in a rather unprincipled way with the evicted tenants. I hold that the original genuine evicted tenant has a right to the property which was lost by his people, or himself, and he has much more right to it than the congests whom the Minister seems to have very much at heart. I think that the Minister has congests on the brain. He seems always to put them in front of the evicted tenants, whereas they have not one-eighth of the right to the land which the evicted tenants have. I think he has dealt in a most unfair way in the case he put before the House. He tells us of seven, eight, or ten congests taking this one farm. This man had a perfect right to that farm from the point of view of tradition and justice. He was justified in making application for the tenancy of that farm. It was lying derelict, and if the man happened to be well off, as the Minister states, I do not see how his position in life, or his affairs in this world have anything to do with the injustice of taking that farm from him. It was his perfect right to own it and remain there. The Minister told us that he could not possibly give such a man more than 25 acres. He has not carried out that practice all over the country. I know tenants who have been put in possession of much more than 100 acres. If that is the argument that the Minister is trying to cram down our throats it is an unjust argument. I can specify cases where land has been given to the extent of even more than double 25 acres.
The idea of 25 acres does not stand for anything. In my opinion a tenant who had been evicted from a holding of, say, 100 acres is perfectly entitled to receive back his 100 acres. I cannot see what law would urge the Minister to give that tenant's property to other people. The Minister, since the 1923 Act came into operation, has been preaching about congests. A few days ago he told us that he had not enough land to go around. In my own county there are 3,000 acres of land that could be taken and distributed amongst evicted tenants. The Minister spoke about not reinstating evicted tenants in their own holdings. I admit that is impracticable in a great many cases, but at the time the Land Act of 1923 was under consideration here I suggested that where farms were lying on the landlord's hands and evicted tenants had no holdings it was up to the Land Commission or the Minister to try and reinstate these men. There are a great many holdings in the hands of the landlords on which evicted tenants could be reinstated. The Minister stated that 50 or 60 evicted tenants have been reinstated since the passing of the 1923 Act. I would like to know if that is correct.
Comment on this
I made several inquiries in the Land Commission offices and I could not find that the number given by the Minister had been dealt with. I find it most difficult to get the Land Commission to do anything for evicted tenants. No matter what the Minister says about every individual case receiving consideration it is my experience that the Land Commission are not a bit anxious to look after the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
I was very glad to hear the Minister say he had an aversion to starting evictions all over again, and for the reason that I have sent in a letter to the resident inspector for North Kildare asking him to do something for a man who is living in a gate-house there, and whose parcel of land has been given to another man. I do not know whether he is a congest, landless man, or herd. I understand the Land Commission is about to evict this man and throw him out on the roadside. I hope the Minister will see that that eviction does not take place.
Comment on this
When we are making a case for evicted tenants the Minister will draw a red herring across and make a case for congests, and when we are making a case for congests he will draw across the red herring of landless men. I tried to avoid dealing with the qualifications of the particular congests who got grants of land, but the Minister has seen his way to open an argument on the question of their qualifications. I think the question of wealth or otherwise does not arise at all. I am not basing my argument on that point. The Minister acknowledges that the man I have mentioned is a genuine evicted tenant, evicted because of non-payment of rent which he could have paid if he were allowed to do so. The lands are in the possession of the Land Commission, and they have power to do what they like in the matter, and to give 25 acres or 100 acres.
Comment on this
The question of an economic holding does not arise in this case, where the farm in its entirety is available. To make matters worse, one would think that the Land Commission took no cognisance whatever of the happenings during the land war, for they actually put on that estate an emergency man.
Comment on this
He was the caretaker of the place—the steward if you like. He had no land of his own. Surely the Land Commission or the Minister would not stand over putting an emergency man on the land that the evicted tenant was entitled to.
Comment on this
If Deputy Heffernan wants to make a case for some particular man I would like him to identify the man for me without naming him. Was this man a herd, or an emergency man, or what was he?
Comment on this
This man, call him A if you like, was an emergency man on a holding of Lord Barrymore's.
Comment on this
I may be wrong as to his being an emergency man, but I think he was. That can be found out. I will deal with other grantees. We hear of a valuation of £2 15s. 0d. Here is the case of a man, B, a baker in constant employment, and a shopkeeper. I can go on to the cases of other men.
Comment on this
You will have to name them. I asked for a definition of an emergency man. I found the emergency man was a herd. If we are going into the circumstances of each case you must have the particular men identified.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to go back on the question of the definition of an emergency man. This man was not actually an evicted tenant. He was the manager of that place and was in possession. The Minister may call him a herd if he likes, but everybody in the district knows that he is an emergency man. I have dealt with B. and I can deal with several other cases.
Comment on this
I dealt with the baker who has a shop and is in constant employment, and who keeps a few cows. A. is one of the uneconomic holders with no valuation. We heard nothing about his shop.
Comment on this
I suppose that is the man Patrick Nagle, who grazes cows there?
Comment on this
We need not go beyond the emergency man and the baker. These are sufficient to prove my case. I have not attempted to compare the farming qualities of the evicted tenants and the congests. I do not think it is fair that the Minister should base his argument on a comparison of that kind. We base our arguments on a matter of justice. No matter whether the evicted tenant is wealthy or not, provided he is an absolutely genuine evicted tenant—and I think there are comparatively few of them—he is entitled to his land. The Minister spoke of 100,000 evicted tenants. We have heard of only, roughly, about 50 cases being reinstated.
Comment on this
Since 1923. Previous to that there were over 3,000 dealt with.
Comment on this
If the old Land Commission reinstated three thousand evicted tenants, surely the Minister cannot claim credit for that? In fact, it ought to be the other way about. He ought to be ashamed if he could only succeed in reinstating 52 evicted tenants while the Land Commission, under the old regime, was able to reinstate 3,000. The Minister for Agriculture is a young man. I am, perhaps, somewhat older than he, and I have some recollection of the land war and of the unfortunate people who were evicted. The Minister has forgotten and a great many Deputies seem to have forgotten the sacrifices made by the people who took part in the land war. These people were regarded as real genuine patriots, just as Sinn Feiners were in a later time. Some people, however, seem to forget the past very quickly, and my object is to remind the Minister of the sacrifices made by these people so that the Government and his Department may do something for them. I maintain that the case put forward on their behalf has not been answered by the Minister. In fact the Minister has proved that the Land Commission does not intend to deal with these evicted tenants as they ought to be dealt with. I am afraid he does not intend to right the wrong which exists in regard to the evicted tenants. I think the Dáil ought to express its opinion on this matter, and I hope that Deputies will vote for Deputy Cosgrave's amendment as a protest against the form of administration which is being carried out in connection with the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Heffernan has been rather unfortunate in selecting the particular case he has spoken of in order to use it as a whip with which to beat the Land Commission. The Deputy appears to have ignored the statement made by the Minister, that the representatives of the people evicted from this particular farm were offered a holding and refused it. The Deputy did not deal with that point.
Comment on this
I listened to the Minister making that statement. I would like to know from Deputy Heffernan, supposing that he was in the position of the Minister and that the representatives of this evicted tenant had been offered a holding and refused it what would he do with the Commissioners if they dealt with the case in this particular way?
Comment on this
I would like to know what kind of a holding was offered to them. I never heard that any holding was offered.
Comment on this
I heard the Minister make that statement. On one point Deputy Heffernan was rather unfair. He admitted that the wording of Deputy Cosgrave's amendment was unfortunate, and said he objected to the words in the latter part of it. Although he differed with the wording of the amendment, he said that any Deputy who voted against it would be voting against the principle of reinstating genuine evicted tenants either in their original or in alternative holdings. I was born and reared on the border line of Tipperary, and I know a fair share about the conditions in mid-Tipperary. I could quote better cases for the Deputy than the one he referred to—cases that should be considered far and away before that particular one. If the Deputy is aware of what is going on in mid-Tipperary he must know that an agitation is being carried on there for the reinstatement of certain evicted tenants who have better rights and clearer claims for reinstatement than the one he referred to.
Comment on this
I am doing no such thing. I referred to this before, and I can say that I know of a considerable number of cases that have been passed on to the Land Commission by myself and the other representatives for the constituency that I represent. I know that some of the cases at least have been given sympathetic consideration. I am not quite sure what is the actual position with regard to all those cases, but I know that the Commissioners have decided in some of them at least, that holdings should be found for the claimants that I am now referring to. I believe that there is an agitation in the country which is influenced by the consideration that genuine sympathetic treatment is not being given by the Commissioners to the claims of evicted tenants or their representatives. I would like to hear from the Minister what exactly is the procedure adopted in dealing with claims put in by evicted tenants or their representatives. I would like to hear him say, for instance, that there is a Department or that there will be one in the Land Commission specially set apart to deal with all these claims that have been sent in, and that certain guiding principles are laid down by the Minister and the Land Commission for the guidance of those appointed to decide whether the claims submitted are genuine or not.
Suppose, for instance, that you have 5,000 claims from people who regard themselves as genuine evicted tenants or their representatives, then I think the Minister and the Land Commissioners should lay down certain guiding principles for those appointed to decide whether these claims are genuine or not. Let us take it that 2,000 out of the 5,000 are found to be genuine cases. The Commissioners should, in my opinion, find land for these people. I do not know whether that is the procedure adopted or not, but I rather think it is not. I believe that what is going on is this, that when an estate is acquired for division under the Land Act of 1923 the people or their representatives who, in years gone by, had been evicted from that estate, make application for reinstatement on it. I do not think that is the way to deal with these cases at all. I think all the cases should be taken in bulk, and that decisions should be come to after certain guiding principles had been laid down for the guidance of those appointed to deal with the claims. That work might be done by four or five responsible officials who know something about the conditions in the country. If the cases were dealt with in that way, and if the Minister was prepared to adopt this suggestion which I put forward, it would be the means, I believe, of getting rid once and for all of the idea that prevails in the country that nothing is being done in these cases.
I know that there are many cases of evictions recorded in the history of the land agitation in the constituency I represent. I know that in a good many of these cases the people who had been evicted have been provided with holdings on the estates from which they were evicted when the estates were acquired or else they have been provided with other holdings. I know also of cases where evicted tenants or their representatives were provided with alternative holdings twice the value of the ones from which either themselves or their people had been evicted. If what Deputy Cosgrave has in mind is to be carried out it will mean an injury, rather than a service, to some people that he claims to serve by this amendment. I certainly agree with Deputy Heffernan that, if the emergency man, or the gentleman to whom he refers as an emergency man, has been found a holding in this particular case, he is quite right to protest against that. I would like to hear the Minister state what is the procedure for dealing with claims from evicted tenants, and say that these claims will be dealt with as a whole, and that there should not be a question of waiting until the estates from which these people or their representatives had been evicted are acquired for distribution. The cases should be dealt with as a whole, whether the number be 1,000, 5,000, or 100,000 which was the figure given by the Minister himself, and which I believe is slightly on the exaggerated side. Whatever the number be, they should be dealt with in a businesslike way, and by people appointed by the Land Commission who know something about the conditions in the country and who will give sympathetic consideration to the claims of those evicted in the days of the Land War.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister can say that there are 100,000 evicted tenants in the country at present. It could not be possible. Like Deputy Davin, I have put forward claims on behalf of evicted tenants. Those claims are for reinstatement in their original holdings or elsewhere. I am sure they got consideration, but I do not think they got any land. It has been stated that the congests are the particular pets of the Minister. I think if it were stated that the western congests are the particular pets of the Minister it would be more correct; he does not seem to give so much consideration to congests in what I may call the home counties. At the same time, the Land Commission are making grants of very large tracts of land in my county, especially large tracts of land, I am informed in some cases, of anything between 100 and 200 acres. If there is as much land as that available it ought not to be as hard to provide for the few remaining genuine evicted tenants in the country.
Comment on this
Like the last speaker, I do not know if the Minister still adheres to his statement that there are 100,000 genuine evicted tenants in the Saorstát, but I would like to ask him again a question which I asked him on the occasion on which he made that statement, whether he is prepared to make a return of the number of genuine evicted tenants now. On that occasion he stated that he was not prepared to make such a return. I ask him now has he reconsidered his decision in the meantime, and, if not, why he could not make this return. I know I have been in receipt of numerous communications from people who regard themselves as genuine evicted tenants and who were evicted from the year 1880 or 1881 to the present time. There is no doubt that there is a certain number of those unfortunate people in existence, and what we want and what I think we are entitled to get is an official statement as to what is the definite number of genuine evicted tenants to-day. Some people say there are none. Some people go to the other extreme adopted by the Minister and say there are 100,000. Some people say because there are none nothing should be done. Some say that because there is an extraordinary number nothing can be done.
I submit there is a certain definite number, and that that number could and should be dealt with. Over and over again during the many stages of the Land War, of which though the Minister or myself may not have been engaged in, yet we must know, there were promises made and hopes held out, to say the least, to men who sacrificed themselves genuinely. I am sure the Minister is the last man in this House to deny that; if any other members of this House would deny it. I would be very surprised if they did. There were genuine cases where men who could have paid their rents declined to do so because they fell in with the general spirit of the time, the general movement that was on foot, and they purposely refrained from doing what they could in paying their rents in order to bring the landlords to their senses. Now, I think it is imperative upon us here at this stage in our national history, in our own national Parliament, to do something for those people. In doing that something we should have proper inquiries made as to the definite numbers of those who are in such a position, and the Minister for Agriculture should come here and make a definite proposal for something to restore these people or their representatives to their holdings.
I have received innumerable communications, not 100,000, but a considerable number, and among others I have had one case where the writer complained that before the passing of the Evicted Tenants Act of 1907 there were 2,000 such evicted tenants scheduled for reinstatement, and that he was one amongst that 2,000. Then he goes on to say that the farm is at present untenanted, and is actually in charge of a herd, and of course that he has not been reinstated. He says that the holding was gazetted in 1908, again in 1910, and again in 1925. I will, if the Minister desires, give him the name. Perhaps it is not advisable at the moment to make it public, but I am only quoting this as an instance which was brought under my notice, and which I am not, as a private individual member of the Dáil, in a position to reply to. I cannot tell the writer of that letter why he has not been reinstated, except to say that this Government and this Ministry of Agriculture, after four years or more, have done nothing to remedy his case. That is the only reply I can give, but I say to the Minister, in all seriousness, in the interests of the Ministry of which he is at present the head, surely, that it would be advisable that something should be done for such people, surely it would be advisable that there should be some form of reply given to writers such as this, except a mere blank negative, and surely it would have been possible before this, and even if it is not too late now, for him to come forward and say not that he is prepared to do this and do that immediately, but that he will, as soon as possible, instruct his Department through one or other of its branches to inquire into the position of evicted tenants at present in the Saorstát as to their genuineness and as to the circumstances in which they were placed, and are placed, and that he will then come forward with a definite proposal to deal properly with those people. I think that that is a suggestion which is in no way extravagant, or meant in any partisan spirit. These men or their representatives are the wounded soldiers of the Land War.
They deserve and they must get proper and equitable treatment. I am not saying that they should get everything in all instances that they ask for, but that they should get as just and proper treatment as is possible at the moment from the representatives of the people. These men have suffered in a cause for which the tenant farmers of Ireland, and consequently the people of Ireland, have distinctly and definitely benefited. I say that it would be a lasting and dying disgrace to any Dáil that something should not be done as soon as possible to restore those people to the property from which they had been evicted. I make this proposal in no partisan spirit. I suggest that there would not be a dissentient voice raised, either in the Dáil or in the country, if the Minister were to make the inquiries I have asked for, and if on the strength of those inquiries he came to this Dáil or the next Dáil and asked that justice should be done to these men.
Comment on this
I want to stress one point that has emerged from the debate. I cannot say from my own knowledge that emergency men have got tracts of land in my county, but I accept the case put up by Deputies that they have in other counties. I am aware that in my own county workmen have got very little land. Some of them only got four acres, and very many none at all. I do make the plea that the emergency man should get no consideration from the State. He was more responsible even than the landlord for what existed in the past. He was the bulwark of the landlord—the most objectionable man in the district —and his continuance there must be always regarded as a slur and an insult. I base my plea on the fact that workmen on many estates which have been divided up got very little land— in many cases no land at all. I say that the emergency man should not be considered or, at least, that he is the last to deserve consideration.
Comment on this
While supporting the principle of the amendment, I recognise the difficulty of carrying it out. I should, however, like to direct attention to a particular aspect of this question. About one and a half years ago inquiry was held in Arklow as to the evicted tenants in County Wicklow. I think about forty attended and made claims before the Inspector and I understand that about twelve were recommended for land. If that is so I think that some effort should be made to give land to those people, because if they were recommended I presume that the Land Commission are satisfied that they are genuine evicted tenants. They should, therefore, get the preference when any estates are being divided. Certainly there is plenty of untenanted land in the County of Wicklow available on which to place those people. I put the proposition to the Minister that cases of this kind, no matter where they are, if the Land Commission are satisfied that they are genuine cases of wounded soldiers of the Land War, who made most of the Land Acts possible, should get a preference over congests or anyone else when estates are being divided up.
Comment on this
I was somewhat amazed to hear the poor case made by the Minister in opposing this amendment. He stated that there was a certain number of evicted tenants reinstated since the passing of the Act of 1923. When moving the amendment I asked the Minister if he could give the number of evicted tenants reinstated and the names. He has now stated that there were fifty. I now ask him, how many have been reinstated in the County Galway since the passing of the Act of 1923? I can answer it myself if he does not—I can tell the House that there has not been one. I presume the Minister is aware that when Mr. Birrell, who was Chief Secretary for Ireland, brought in the Bill of 1909 he inserted compulsory clauses therein for the reinstatement of the evicted tenants. The Bill was passed in the House of Commons but was mutilated by the House of Lords and the compulsory clauses taken out. The following day the Tory newspapers came out with large headings of "Victory for Clanricarde." If the Minister refuses to accept the new clause I have proposed I suppose the heading in the Tory papers in this country to-morrow will be, "Victory for Clanricarde's Planters." The Minister stated that he could not re-open the question of the reinstatement of evicted tenants. If that is so, I wonder why letters were sent out from his Department to evicted tenants in different parts of the twenty-six counties?
Comment on this
What I said was that we could not begin evictions again— that is a different thing.
Comment on this
As far as I understood him, the Minister stated he could not re-open the cases.
Comment on this
At all events, letters have been sent by his Department to evicted tenants. I have got communications from evicted tenants in every county, and I have them here if the Minister wishes to see them. I have a letter here written to an evicted tenant in the County Roscommon, in which amongst other things it is stated: "It is the intention of the Irish Government to deal completely with the question of the evicted tenants, and the Bill as it stands gives them sufficient powers to do this. Those who are concerned on their behalf may rest assured that no genuine evicted tenant will in the end be unprovided for."
Comment on this
It is written from the Department of Agriculture.
Comment on this
I do not want to give the writer's name, but the Minister can have the letter.
Comment on this
When letters are quoted they should be identified.
Comment on this
Can the Deputy say that this is an official letter from the Department of Agriculture?
Comment on this
It is. It commences: "I am directed by the Minister for Agriculture to acknowledge the receipt of your letter." I will pass the letter on to the Minister if he wants it. In moving my amendment I quoted a genuine case for reinstatement in the County Galway, but the Minister in his reply never referred to the case, although he has personal knowledge of it, and, I believe, knows the man I refer to thoroughly. He did not refer to that case, but went off across to Tipperary, and referred to cases there. I ask, why did he not refer to that particular case? He talks of men being out of their holdings for a certain number of years, and said they would not be able to work them now in a satisfactory manner. This particular man and his two brothers have been working as agricultural labourers and supporting their mother and sisters from the time they were evicted. Does the Minister mean to say that that is not a genuine case in which land should be given? There is one particular case that I have received information about from the County Tipperary. I handed this letter and a letter from the P.P. to Deputy Heffernan. He mentioned it, but he did not refer to the particulars. This man was evicted from 50 acres of land in 1892. The land was in the hands of a planter until 1916 or 1917, when he was routed out of it by the people of the district, since when it has been derelict. The planter has intimated to the evicted tenant that he is willing to surrender the farm if the Land Commission will take it up and reinstate the tenant. Is that a genuine case for reinstatement?
I want to refer to the remarks of Deputy Nolan on the day I introduced this amendment. Deputy Nolan, in a mumbled statement—I cannot call it a speech—tried to lead the House to believe that when I stated there were genuine evicted tenants in County Galway, it was tantamount to an incorrect statement. I repeat that statement, and I say that there are genuine evicted tenants, not only in Co. Galway, but in every county in the Free State, including Limerick. I have letters here from the County Limerick asking me to bring cases forward, as they seemingly have no one to look after them in that county. I owe no apology to Deputy Nolan for any action I have taken on behalf of the evicted tenants, and I can assure him I shall continue to advocate their cause until the last one of them is reinstated.
Comment on this
It seems to me that there is considerable misunderstanding over this question. We are, apparently, agreed as to how the evicted tenant should be treated, and the real question is, are they getting that treatment? That is the whole question. It is admitted that you cannot ask the Land Commission to deal with every genuine evicted tenant. That is admitted by everybody.
Comment on this
That is admitted by everybody with the possible exception of Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
I said it was admitted by everybody except Deputy Cosgrave.
Comment on this
I only want to try to clear up the situation. Then the Land Commission must deal with every genuine evicted tenant. If that is so, this sort of case is going to occur. There are evicted tenants or representatives of them who were evicted for non-payment of rent between the years 1870 and 1890, and who are now doctors, solicitors or other professional men——
Comment on this
What about the men earning their bread by the sweat of their brow?
Comment on this
Surely, the Deputy is able to discriminate every man such as I have mentioned to be dealt with as a genuine evicted tenant—are they all evicted tenants?
Comment on this
I never used the words "all evicted tenants." I said "genuine evicted tenants."
Comment on this
It does not make the case any less genuine because the representative of the evicted tenant is a professional man now. There is a lot of tall talk in the endeavour to get away from the facts of the case and an analysis of them.
Comment on this
Such men as the Minister describes are not looking for reinstatement.
Comment on this
The Deputy will have an opportunity of speaking again, and he should allow the Minister to proceed.
Comment on this
I am not making debating points. The proposal is that the Land Commission shall deal with all genuine evicted tenants.
Comment on this
It is time to put "shall" in instead of "may." They have no intention of doing it and I know it.
Comment on this
There will be plenty of time for all this enthusiasm. Am I to take this proposal seriously? I suppose the best compliment to pay to Deputy Cosgrave is to take his proposal seriously. If this amendment is passed the Land Commission will have to deal with every genuine evicted tenant. My definition of a genuine evicted tenant is a tenant evicted for non-payment of rent in a certain period, or his representative, be he lawyer, solicitor, or any other sort of professional man, or whether he was a labourer, small farmer or a big farmer, or anything else. Is the Land Commission to deal with all of them? Remember that is the specific case Deputy Doyle made, but Deputy Doyle is logical in the matter. He says: "Yes, certainly." I quoted a case and made a point that the representative of the evicted tenant is a well-off man, and he said it did not matter; he should get his land back. That is at least logical and there is a case to be met. But let us know where we are. Does the Dáil agree with that and does Deputy Redmond agree with that?
Comment on this
Deputy Redmond is also logical. He is willing to agree to that, but look at what it means. It is all very fine to agree when you have not the responsibility of carrying it out. Look at what it means in hundreds of cases. It is these cases that do crop up where an Act of Parliament is being passed and five or six very bad cases of that sort would take all the virtue out of an Act of Parliament. If that clause is inserted and passed and the Land Commission acquires three or four hundred acres of land from which somebody had been evicted twenty-five years ago and whose son may be a stockbroker in Dublin or a local dispensary doctor—if he is to get back this two hundred acres of land against the interest of the congests it is simply absurd and I do not mind joining issue at all on that point. But let us be clear as to the issue that we disagree about. The Land Commission will not be asked to take up all cases, including every man, no matter what the circumstances may be. They will not be asked to give back an amount of land equal to that from which a man or his father was evicted years ago. If the Land Commission did give out such directions and they were carried out then a shocking state of affairs would arise because in many cases the immediate effect would be that men so reinstated would sell out.
Comment on this
I beg the Deputy's pardon. That statement should not be made, for people will get the impression that lands are being divided, and that the owners are selling out. That is not so. There has been more land divided in Galway than in any other county in Ireland. I know Galway inside out, and to my knowledge, in Galway, out of about 200,000 acres that has been divided, there is only one farm that has gone back to the hands of other people than the people put on it.
Comment on this
There is no use confusing it. The ordinary congest, the landless man, who gets a holding and has not sufficient capital—as a sensible man he starts by setting half and then stocking the rest and working it. That is much better than if they were to borrow and stock the whole of the land. There was one class of cases where there was wholesale selling of land, and that was the case of evicted tenants.
I think Deputies are aware that, so far as the evicted tenants are concerned, they are one of the classes that, to a large extent, failed on the land. That is not to be surprised at. It is their misfortune rather than their fault.
Comment on this
Over 200 evicted tenants were reinstated in Galway. How many of them have sold?
Comment on this
I must ask Deputies to restrain their enthusiasm.
Comment on this
I take it that in this country, and in this Parliament, when a discussion on land arises considerable latitude must be allowed. I have always allowed considerable latitude, and I have been assisted in allowing considerable latitude by my own considerable ignorance of the subject. We are discussing an amendment to-day, but in discussing it, we are really wandering into a debate on the administration of the Land Commission. We are also discussing an amendment so framed that apparently nobody is in favour of it. I am not sure that Deputy Cosgrave himself is in favour of it. Up to the present nobody else has said that this amendment meets what he wants in its present form. There is a certain amount of heat about the question of evicted tenants, but we cannot proceed to discuss the question by way of interruption. Deputies who have made speeches will have to listen to other Deputies making speeches. We must listen to speeches with which we do not agree. There is no other way of doing business. Considerable latitude is being allowed, but we cannot wander at will. If the Minister wants to make a statement he must be allowed to do so.
Comment on this
It is the conventional thing to introduce heat into a discussion on land purchase and I suppose we must be conventional. I could not possibly accept from Deputy Redmond or Deputy Cosgrave an amendment the meaning of which is that the Land Commission shall deal with all genuine evicted tenants. It would be quite impossible for the Land Commission. I am asked what is the difficulty. Anyone who knows anything about the administration of land purchase realises that if I attempted to bring a shopkeeper, a professional man or a fairly wealthy man, because his father had been evicted, into a district in which there are a large number of congests it would be a very dangerous thing to do, and the whole law would be brought into disrepute. After going to the trouble of putting in these people a lot of the holdings would have to be sold. Up to the present no one has suggested, except Deputy Cosgrave, that the evicted tenants should be reinstated in their original holdings. I could not agree to that. There seems to be an impression that the evicted tenants are not getting fair play. Subject to what I have stated on those two points, I can assure Deputies that the claims of evicted tenants, where they make claims to the Land Commission, are considered sympathetically. Perhaps I had better give the information Deputy Redmond asked for.
Comment on this
There were 13,620 applications from evicted tenants recorded in the Land Commission; 6,965 were rejected, 3,347 have been reinstated; 312 are noted for consideration in the allotment of untenanted land; 2,996 have not yet been considered. That is the whole position. Deputy Davin asked what is the procedure? There is a small section in the Land Commission which acts as a sort of clearing house for these applications and does the clerical work. What happens? An estate is bought. Everybody in the district knows about it. One thing is certain, that every evicted tenant or the representative of every evicted tenant will apply. Deputies need not be afraid that the applications will not reach the Land Commission. They always do. They reach first of all the section I have mentioned and are then divided into sub-sections. There are four Chief Inspectors in the Land Commission, each being responsible for a certain district. The applications go through each Chief Inspector down to the Inspector who is dealing with the estate, so that in the final result there are four men in the Land Commission who, under the Commissioners, have the ruling of the matter— the four Chief Inspectors. Every application goes down actually to the Inspector who is on the land, whose duty it is to make all the inquiries into the circumstances in which the tenant was evicted, into his present position, and the circumstances of the other tenants in the district who are also applicants for land. There is no other way to do it. No three or four men in the Land Commission could sit down and pick out the good applications from the bad ones.
Deputies are aware of the sort of applications that come in. They state "I was evicted" or "My father was evicted 50 years ago from a particular place. I heard the estate is sold and I want a holding there." The application is generally as vague as that. No one in the Land Commission could examine these applications. The information must be got down the country through the Inspector. The information is brought back to the Chief Inspectors. They have the full facts before them, all the circumstances of the eviction, the merits of the application as it stands to-day and, in addition, they have before them considerations such as the amount of land available, the circumstances of other applicants— who must be considered—as well as the representatives of the evicted tenants. On that they have to make up their minds. Personally I have got a good many cases of evicted tenants from Deputies, but I have never got a case yet where I consider the equities were on the side of the evicted tenant or the alleged evicted tenant. I can give Deputies an undertaking that within these limitations the Land Commission will try to deal with every genuine case. I must have these limitations. We cannot go beyond that. We cannot deal with them all on account of present day circumstances. We cannot deal with them on the line of reinstating them in their own holdings. It would do injustice. I agree with Deputy Redmond that the evicted tenants are entitled, other things being equal, to a little more than fair play. I agree with him as to the sacrifices they made at the time, but a very big number of these people were dealt with pre-1923.
The men who are left are either of two classes—people who are in extremely poor circumstances in another walk of life, and people who are very well off, having made good in other walks of life and who have cut off all connection with the land. It would be an extraordinary attitude, at this stage, to take up, that every one of these 7,000 applicants who have been rejected should be put back in their holdings. It would take an immense amount of land, and a number of them —a very large number probably— would sell out. That is almost certain when you remember that even in approved cases a very large number sold out.
With regard to the case quoted by Deputy Cosgrave, that evicted tenant was offered a holding in 1908 and refused it. He may have had good reasons. The fact that he refused does not prevent his making an application again. I do not know the circumstances. Deputy Cosgrave gives me credit for knowing the circumstances of the case. I do not know the full circumstances, but it is open to the evicted tenant to apply again. His application will be considered again, but remember that he was offered a holding before. The name, I think, is Madden. He was offered a holding and refused it in 1908. It is open to him, in applying again, to show that his circumstances have changed—to show that he had good reason for refusing in the first instances, and that his circumstances are now such that, in equity, he is entitled to a holding. The Land Commission will consider the case. The Land Commission give every consideration to evicted tenants, and will continue to do so, but I cannot accept amendments which would force them to deal with all evicted tenants and, above all, I cannot accept an amendment which would force them to reinstate evicted tenants in their original holdings, because that would impose considerable hardships on a fairly large number of innocent people.
Comment on this
The tenant, Madden, in the case referred to by the Minister, was evicted from 34 acres of the best land in my part of Galway, which he held at a rent of £33. The original rent was £24, but his father voted against the landlord's nominee at the Parliamentary Nolan and Trench election and his rent was increased by £9. It was £33 when he was evicted. He was offered a holding on the Daly estate of 22 acres of inferior land, the rent being £23 per year. That was the first holding he was offered. I know the farm well. Half of it is moor land, and there are only 22 acres in it, as against the 34 acres which he had held. The second holding he was offered was on the Butson estate. It contained 16 acres and the rent was a little over £16 a year. I think that man was quite justified in refusing to accept such a small holding as that after he had been on the roadside for 25 years. The Minister stated that a number of evicted tenants were selling or had sold their holdings. There have been over 200 tenants reinstated in Co. Galway. I should like to know how many of them have sold their holdings.
Comment on this
I assert that not five of them have sold their holdings. The Minister also stated that it would be an injustice to remove people from their present holdings. I suppose it would be an injustice to remove the planter and reinstate the evicted tenant. Is that what the Minister regards as "injustice"? The Minister also stated that he did not think it would be advisable to reinstate poor people—"people who are in poor circumstances," I think, was the phrase used. Is it any wonder that they are in poor circumstances when they have been on the roadside for 25 or 30 years? Are not the poor people the people who should be reinstated? The Minister referred on several occasions to the last paragraph in the amendment referring to the reinstatement of evicted tenants in their original holdings. But he did not suggest to the mover that the wording of the section should be changed. Would it not be possible for the Land Commission to reinstate the evicted tenants in their original holdings and give alternative holdings to the planters? That could be done in many cases. It could be done particularly in the case of Horsemann—a man who has 199 acres, 131 acres being grabbed land. I do not see why the Land Commission should not do that. This man is not living on this particular holding. The buildings were levelled by him and the emergency men, and he is living in another holding about three miles away. Why not give him a holding elsewhere if you are in favour of giving him land? I say these people are not entitled to anything, because they paid no fine for the land when they grabbed it. But if the Minister and the Land Commission think they are entitled to get land in lieu of that which they are deprived of, it can be given them. It is a matter of indifference to me so long as the evicted tenants are reinstated. I hope the majority of the Deputies here— especially the farmers, who have benefited by the sacrifices of the evicted tenants in the past—will support this amendment to get rid of the planters, and reinstate the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
Is it the policy of the Land Commission and of the Minister that a man ought not to be reinstated because he is rich, and that a man ought not to be reinstated because he is poor?
Comment on this
I am very glad that the Minister has thought fit to give us the figures. I should like to know since what date the 13,000 applications were made. It appears there were almost 7,000 applications rejected, that 3,300 evicted tenants were reinstated, and that there remain almost 3,000 applications to be dealt with. Of the 6,000 odd applications which were not rejected, 3,000 odd have been reinstated, and there are almost 3,000 yet to be considered. My complaint—I want to put it as fairly as I can—is of the delay in the consideration of these 3,000 cases. The Minister may say with perfect justice that the Land Commission, as at present constituted, was not able to cope with this work, but that does not meet my case. My case is that he, as Minister for Lands, should make some provision whereby the Land Commission, or some other body, would speed matters up and deal with these 3,000 applications.
I do not stand for a moment on the wording of my friend's amendment. I take it that the real object of the amendment was to draw the attention of the House to the delay which at present obtains in the consideration of the claims and the reinstatement of the remaining evicted tenants. Whether or not the Land Commission, as at present constituted, can cope with these 3,000 applications is beside the question. I want the Minister to provide some means by which the work will be done. As regards the point as to the present circumstances of the evicted tenant, I agree that it would be illogical to suggest that because a man is in better circumstances than his neighbour he should not have equal rights in respect to action that they both took, or that their representatives took, in the interest of the Irish farmers during the period from the year 1880.
It would be illogical: I think it would be worse than illogical. I admit that all legislation, or, indeed, sometimes very little legislation, can go entirely upon the lines of logic. But I put it further, and I say that this question of reinstatement, to my mind, is not a question of present circumstances at all. It is a question of right. These men or their predecessors were evicted. Why? Because they did certain things and took certain lines. Is it to be said that because in the meantime by their thrift or by their energy or by the exercise of their talents, whether at the learned professions or at the plough, they are to be deprived of the rights which in all equity should be theirs? I do not think that that is tenable. I do not think either that it will mean such a wonderful excess of numbers as the Minister seems to suggest. I doubt very much if so many of these evicted tenants as it would appear from the remark that has fallen from the Minister to-day, have succeeded in advancing themselves whether in the professions or in the trades or otherwise. If they have done so, and if in the meantime they have got on, why should that be a reason for denying them what I consider to be their right? I think that his case, from that point of view, falls to the ground.
Deputy Cosgrave proceeded to read from a letter which, he said, came from the Department of Lands and Agriculture, and he was asked to give the name of the writer of that letter. He read the letter, as far as I know, for what it was worth, and as coming on behalf of the Ministry of Lands and Agriculture. The Deputy did not give the name of the writer. I would ask the House whether the Deputy in that case did not act perfectly fair? Because the name of the writer is probably the name of one of the Minister's own staff, and I think it was from that point of view that Deputy Cosgrave did not give the name—I am sure my friend did not want to injure the writer of that letter.
Comment on this
I am very glad the Minister says that. Before I sit down I would like once more to impress upon the Minister the view that I take on this question, and it is a personal one—that this amendment in itself as it is now drafted, is not the only way whereby these cases of the evicted tenants can be met, nor do I suggest that it is the best way. What I do suggest is that it is up to the Minister, here and now, if he will not accept this amendment, to give the Dáil some assurance that he will get to work and do something. Even if the staff at his disposal now are not sufficiently adequate to do the work and to deal with these remaining 3,000 cases, it is his duty, and I say the House would assist him in that duty, to provide a sufficient staff, so as to put a stop to the delay that has taken place.
On the question of the wording of the amendment, I have not really consulted my colleague, but I do not think he would refuse if he were asked to alter the terms, certainly as regards the last words of the amendment—namely, if it was suggested that the evicted tenants should be restored and if the words "original holding" were omitted, I should say that the amendment might meet with general approval. But I admit the difficulty in the restoration of all the evicted tenants to their original holdings. There is no use in blinding oneself to that difficulty. The object, as far as I understand it, is that where possible, and acting in the circumstances in a reasonable and fair way, the tenant should, everything else being equal, be restored to his original holding. I am not bound to that, and personally I would not press that point. I would be perfectly prepared to have the amendment altered so that the tenant should be restored or that he should be placed in a position as regards a holding as good as he or his predecessor held at the time of the eviction. I hope, therefore, that the Minister understands that the reason why I am supporting this amendment is that I want these 3,000 cases dealt with at once. If the machinery at the Minister's disposal is not sufficient, I will give him every support in my power, and I think the rest of the Dáil will too, to provide that the machinery will be sufficient.
Comment on this
Perhaps it would be better if the amendment read: "In all cases where the applicant is a genuine evicted tenant and in actual need of land, the Land Commission shall reinstate him in his original holding where that is feasible, but if that be not feasible the Land Commission shall provide him with a similar holding on the nearest estate that is being broken up tor distribution." Perhaps the Minister and Deputy Cosgrave will agree on those lines.
Comment on this
The real issue is there between us still: "The Land Commission shall provide all genuine evicted tenants with land." I could not possibly undertake to accept that. That is the whole issue.
Comment on this
In all cases where the applicant is a genuine evicted tenant and in actual need of land, he should be provided with it. I only mean people who want land and who are entitled to it because they are genuine evicted tenants.
Comment on this
Either the Land Commission is to have discretion or on the contrary it is not. If the Deputy is to give the Land Commission discretion, then that is the existing law, and it does not require an amendment at all. The Land Commission may deal with all genuine evicted tenants taking all the circumstances into account. That is the law. If the Deputy wants to give the Land Commission discretion there is no occasion for the amendment at all. On the other hand, I cannot agree with Deputies that the Land Commission must deal with all cases of evicted tenants. They could not do it.
Comment on this
My case is that the Land Commission should deal with all genuine evicted tenants who require land. I feel that these men are entitled to some compensation——
Comment on this
I suggest, on behalf of the people whom this amendment is proposed to serve, that the amendment be withdrawn. Though we sympathise a good deal with the class of people mentioned, some of us may find ourselves in the position of having to vote against them, if the amendment is put in its present form.
Comment on this
As regards the 13,620 applications received by the Land Commission from the tenants who were evicted, or whose predecessors were evicted, in the event of the estates from which they were evicted not being likely to be acquired under the 1923 Act, how does the Land Commission propose to deal with the applicants?
Comment on this
Place them on other estates. This is really not a question of staff at all. We cannot deal with the applications made by evicted tenants except when the estate from which the tenant was evicted comes up for consideration. In other words, an inspector must be sent down to the estate. He must get all the circumstances connected with that estate, and that only happens when the estate comes up for consideration. That is not a question of want of staff. If there were more staff there, no doubt the purchase and distribution would go faster and the cases would be reached sooner. But you cannot take cases out and proceed to go around the country to estates from which there were some evictions. It is not a question of staff. The only assurance I can give is that the Land Commission will, so far as possible, sympathetically consider the cases of any evicted tenants who put in applications. The fact that an application was turned down in the past will not prevent the Land Commission from considering it again.
Comment on this
Will the Land Commission settle in their holdings the remaining 2,900 tenants? That is the whole thing.
Comment on this
The Land Commission cannot answer that question until they get the circumstances connected with each estate.
Comment on this
They have sifted out 13,000 cases and have rejected half; now, there are 2,900 remaining to be dealt with.
Comment on this
They have rejected 7,000; they have left 7,000; they have dealt with about 3,000, and there are about 3,000 left. There is no decision to deal with these 3,000. The fact that they have rejected 7,000 does not mean that every one of the other 7,000 cases is a genuine case. On closer examination it may be found that some of these cases could not be dealt with for one hundred and one reasons. You can only deal with each case in conjunction with the estate from which the person concerned was evicted. If it is a genuine case, one that should be dealt with, and there is no land, it is quite easy to deal with the tenant on another estate. Numbers of evicted tenants have been dealt with on estates other than the estates they or their predecessors were evicted from.
Comment on this
Then the position is that evicted tenants cannot be dealt with until the estates from which they were evicted come up for consideration as to purchase?
Comment on this
If there is no land available on the particular estate from which the tenant was evicted, the tenant could be accommodated on other estates, perhaps in the same county. I suggest that tenants may get land on some other estate actually under consideration. That has already occurred and in that way a certain number of them were dealt with long before their own estates came up for consideration. It is only in conjunction with some estate actually under consideration in their own or another county that they can be effectively dealt with.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give an assurance that responsible officials of the Land Commission will be set aside for the purpose of dealing with these cases and of endeavouring to see whether they can be settled on suitable estates if the estates from which they were evicted are not likely to be acquired?
Comment on this
There is already a subsection that deals with these claims. Such cases are dealt with by four chief inspectors. All the applications from evicted tenants go back to four points in the Land Commission. There are four chief inspectors, very responsible officials, dealing with these cases. It is on the recommendation of any one of these four inspectors that the cases are dealt with. The point of view of the chief inspectors is sympathetic to the evicted tenants.
Comment on this
I do not mind what the form of words may be if the Minister is prepared to accept the suggestion put forward by Deputy Byrne —that is, in all cases where the applicant is a genuine evicted tenant and in actual need of land the Land Commission shall reinstate him to the original holding, where feasible.
Comment on this
I cannot accept that for the reasons I have mentioned.
Comment on this
The existing law is quite good enough to meet the situation.
Comment on this
This is the beginning of a fourth debate on this amendment. Deputy Hennessy is beginning the fourth debate on an amendment which other Deputies are endeavouring to amend so as to make their meaning clear.
Comment on this
I believe the Land Commission are trying to do their best in the circumstances. I come from a part of the country—I was born very near Tipperary—where there were very great sacrifices made by evicted tenants. It is true that most of those have been restored to their original holdings, but there are still a few tenants who have not been restored, and we cannot get over the fact that they have been victimised.
The trouble with regard to the settlement of evicted tenants is this: they have to pay too much rent. When tenants are restored to their original holdings or get new holdings, the rent of those holdings, when you compare it with the adjoining land, is often thirty and forty per cent. more than what they would have paid if they were never evicted. I think the price paid for what I may term evicted land——
Comment on this
Surely that is another question—the price of evicted land? We have had a great deal of irrelevancy, but that is the greatest irrelevancy yet.
Comment on this
I am only discussing the obstacles to the restoration of evicted tenants, and why, when they are restored, in many instances, there are so many failures.
Comment on this
I would like to hear from Deputy Redmond whether he approves of the Minister's suggestion that doctors and other professional men, where they are genuine evicted tenants, should not be reinstated.
Comment on this
I am not an evicted tenant. I say that the price paid for evicted land should not be higher than that paid for untenanted land. The price paid for evicted land should be the same as if the tenant had run through the whole gamut of the Land Commission and got the reductions that the average judicial tenant would get if he were never evicted. Undoubtedly there were landlords who did not facilitate the reinstatement of tenants. It is useless to say it is the fault of the Land Commission. The Land Commission is sympathetic, but there have been many obstacles put in their way by local people. When a tenant is about to be restored to his original holding, there is actually an agitation amongst the local people to get some of that evicted tenant's land. I do not think that is very creditable. Those are some of the obstacles to the restoration of evicted tenants and they make it very difficult for the Land Commission to restore holdings.
Comment on this
I think the Land Commission are dealing, as far as practicable, with the position of the evicted tenants. We have heard a lot of speeches from different parts of the House, but there have been no practical suggestions put forward which would assist the Land Commission in dealing in a more expeditious manner with the cases that need attention.
If we had heard some suggestions which would assist the Land Commission in dealing with these cases in a quicker manner it would be something to listen to and something to advance the position of the evicted tenants, but we have heard nothing of the kind. I suggest, with Deputy Gorey, that the amendment should be withdrawn and the matter left as already suggested by the Minister, and I think if that were done it would be much better.
Comment on this
On a point of procedure. I am not satisfied with the amendment as it stands. I believe if it were put into the Bill it could not be carried out, and if I vote for it I will do so simply as a protest, because the Minister has not met our arguments fully and because the Land Commission has not dealt with these cases. I would ask Deputy Cosgrave to amend the amendment to meet the views of a great many Deputies. That could be done. If he does not do so the responsibility for putting forward an impracticable amendment is on his own shoulders.
Comment on this
If the amendment is accepted now is it not a fact that it can be amended afterwards on Report?
Comment on this
I offered to agree to Deputy Heffernan's suggestion, but as the Minister would not accept that I cannot do anything more.
Comment on this
The proper procedure would be for Deputy Cosgrave to withdraw the amendment now and bring it up on the Report Stage in an amended form.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy have an opportunity of moving it on the Report Stage if he withdraws it now?
Comment on this
With great respect, all that really means is that we will have this debate over again on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
If I withdraw it is it quite clear that I can bring it up again on the Report Stage?
Comment on this
I object to the withdrawal of the amendment. Two hours have been lost on this discussion.
Comment on this
A glorious victory for the Clanricarde and Smith-Barry planters.
Comment on this
I do not propose to move No. 19, but will substitute another for it on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move:—
In line 46 to delete the words "16th day of June, 1926," and substitute therefor the words "date of the passing of the Land Act, 1923."
The section provides for the reinstatement of evicted tenants in certain contingencies where they have been ejected on or after the gale day next preceding the 16th day of June, 1926. I understand that date is fixed by the Minister, having in view the fact that this Bill was introduced at that time, and I think the intention is that this opportunity should not be given to landlords over tenants when the landlords held under the Land Act. My amendment proposes that the date be put back to the date of the introduction of the Land Act, 1923. That date is fixed in a more or less arbitrary manner, but I do not stand on it if the Minister could suggest any other date that would meet my point. But the fact of the matter remains that there are certain tenants of holdings, the landlords of which hold them from the Land Commission. These tenants have been evicted since the introduction of the 1923 Act, and the argument I put forward is this, that these landlords in all probability anticipated that legislation would have to be introduced eventually to deal with such cases, and in anticipation of that they evicted their tenants. I suggest that if it is equitable and just to reinstate those who were evicted since the introduction of the Bill, it is equally just and equitable to go back to those who have been evicted since the time of the Land Act of 1923. There will be cases of hardship if this Bill is passed in its present form. I know a man in my own county who was evicted about two months prior to the date fixed in this Bill, and he would, therefore, not come within the provisions of the Bill, and I believe there are other cases of that kind. This case to which I refer has attracted a good deal of attention in the neighbourhood. The man is very decent and honest and the case has created a good deal of sympathy locally. If the Bill is passed as it is now he will not come under it. The Minister ought to reconsider the position existing at present and ought to put the date back to what I suggest, or at least a couple of years previous to the introduction of this Bill.
Comment on this
I could not agree to this amendment. In the Special Committee there was general agreement that this was the right date.