We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

ORDUITHE AN LAE. - LAND BILL, 1927.—THIRD STAGE.

Contributions 160–317 of 317. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Land Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 4 of 1927 ›

Mr. HOGAN

There was general agreement, with the exception of Deputy Heffernan, that this was the right date, for this reason: There will be, of course, some hardship if we draw the line here, and equally there will be hardship if we draw the line in 1923. There will always be someone a month or two on one side or the other. If you go back to 1923 it would be retrospective legislation, and what you have to remember here is that, while there may be hardships in any event, the balance is in favour of the position as set out in the Bill, and not as set out in the amendment. Remember, you are dealing with future tenancies, to a very great extent, not with present tenancies.

It is only in the case of a future tenancy that there has been an eviction. It is only in the case of a tenancy held subject to a year's notice to quit, where there is no real tenure, that there has been an eviction. In a great many cases you are dealing with small tenancies where the landlord and the tenant are practically the same class of people, and where there are really no equities between them. The landlord in these cases that are covered by that section, exercised an undoubted right, which he had in 1922, 1923 and 1924, to serve notice to quit on a future tenant and take up the holding, and he exercised the perfectly proper right to give it to somebody else. That was regarded as a matter of form. Anyone who sets a holding on these terms, even though it is a tenancy terminable on a year's notice to quit, presumably has a right to do this at the end of the term of agreement. It is not right to call it an eviction in the sense of an eviction as we knew it, say, in the year 1881, in its application to a present tenancy where the tenant had a certain tenure. We are dealing here, remember, with tenants who have no tenure whatever, who are subject to a year's notice to quit.

We are dealing, to a great extent, with holdings near towns owned by shopkeepers, who set them to other shopkeepers, or people like that, and vice versa—owned by people who, in many cases, are not farmers at all, who hold this land as accommodation land and set it from year to year. We are going very far, indeed, in fact too far, if we allow the present occupier to purchase the fee simple in such a case. If we make that retrospective we are going to inflict considerable hardship on people who would have exercised their right in this way. The old tenant would have gone out and they would have put in another tenant. We would have to put out the tenant in existence now and put in the first tenant. That would be arbitrary and wrong. Leave it as it is. No matter where you draw the line, there will be hardship. There will be injustice on one side of the line or on the other, but you will do less hardship this way. If you go back to 1923 you will be indulging in the luxury of retrospective legislation.

Comment on this

Are there cases of legislation in connection with potential building ground?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I think so.

Comment on this

I have heard something about that, but I am not sure. If there are such cases, I think they ought to go back over the whole period.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is potential building ground, and potential building ground. If you hold ground as a future tenancy that is one case, and if you hold it as a present tenancy with the judicial rent fixed, that is another case. In the latter case the landowner might have served notice on the tenant to resume the holding, notwithstanding that it was a present tenancy, and have actually resumed it. I think there is no answer, even in a case of present tenancy, and there is no obligation on the landlord to resume it for the purpose of building. In the sort of cases that this covers, namely, future tenancies terminable at twelve month's notice to quit, it does not matter whether the ground is suitable for building or not. The real owner was the landlord, and he was exercising a perfectly legitimate right in giving that notice.

Comment on this

The Minister objects to retrospective legislation. Does he deny that the Act of 1923 was largely retrospective, especially in regard to arrears?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Arrears were always treated in that way. They are a special case.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

Before Section 14 is passed, I would like to ask the Minister whether he would consider having a longer period of years than five years to determine the annual average maintenance rate. It might happen that, owing to neglect during the last five years, it might have been overladen with congestion work.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The average of five years was arrived at in consultation with the Land Commission, and as no suggestion was made on either side I did not give the matter much thought. I will, however, undertake to see whether there is any equity in increasing the number of years.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (3), page 9, line 6, to delete the words "an error" and in lieu thereof insert the words "a clerical mistake or error arising from any accidental omission."

The object of this amendment is to make the sub-section a little clearer. It is largely a drafting amendment, but there might be an error in description that was not of a trivial character and it might carry very serious consequences. For instance, I take the case of a small holding, a cottage with one or two acres attached. That might be held to be an agricultural holding, but, equally, it might be held to be a cottage with a curtilage, and, thereby, a residential holding. Unless the position is made a little clearer it would be open to the Commissioners, when all proceedings were over, to alter the final list and say that this is not an agricultural holding but a residential holding, or vice versa. It would be inconvenient both to the landlord and the tenant. I am not absolutely tied to the description in my amendment, and if the Minister will consider the possibility of making it clear that the error is a trival error of description, or an accidental omission rather than an error of substance, I would be prepared to meet him.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The word "error" is used because it is the word used in Section 34 of the Local Registration of Title Act. I am told by lawyers that it has a rather well-defined meaning and that it would be undesirable to change it. The Land Commission has a right to make changes in flats and so forth. I am prepared to discuss the matter with the Deputy, but I am advised that it has a legal meaning and would be unwise to change it as it is so well-fixed in other Acts. Up to the present it has been the subject of decided cases, and I think it would be rather a pity to attempt a definition in that state of affairs, because there is no better definition than decided cases.

Comment on this

The Minister is aware that where you get counsel to give one opinion, you can get another counsel to give another. I am fortified with counsel's opinion in my favour. Perhaps the Minister will consider it before the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will.

Comment on this

Then I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (4), page 9, line 21, after the word "Registry" to add the words "Provided that nothing in this sub-section contained shall prejudice or affect any assignment, mortgage or charge or of any other dealing with any such holding which has been made or completed before the time at which the memorial of the registration of the holding shall have been registered in the Registry of Deeds pursuant to the provisions of Section 19, sub-section (4) of the Local Registration of Title (Ireland) Act, 1891."

This amendment is for the purpose of making some provision for those persons interested in the sale of land from the point of view of having a charge or mortgage upon it. Under the Bill as it stands, the vesting, which was previously a separate function, now becomes automatic, and the land is automatically vested on the appointed day. It is possible that people interested, mortgagors and persons holding charges, might not have adequate notice of the appointed day. This amendment seeks to preserve their rights until registration in the Registry of Deeds is carried through. It is possible that people interested would be able to find out, at an expenditure of a considerable amount of time and trouble, but when it is registered in the Registry of Deeds—that is a formality well known in the legal profession— anyone can go there and look it up. I suggest that it might be desirable to take a precaution of this kind. It simply provides that the rights of a mortgagor or a person who holds a charge on the land shall not be abolished by reason of vesting, but shall continue until the necessary registration is made in the Registry of Deeds.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I shall have to ask the Deputy to allow that to be deferred until the Report Stage. It is complicated.

Comment on this

I am prepared to withdraw the amendment. Perhaps the Minister would discuss the matter with persons interested before the Report Stage.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I move:

To add in page 9 the following sub-section at the end of the section:—

"(7) Where a holding or part of a holding of tenanted land not exceeding two statute acres to which the provisions of this section apply has been acquired by the Commissioners of Public Works for the purposes of the Public Services and the Commissioners certify to the Land Commission before the appointed day that the holding or part of the holding has been purchased by them for a sum not exceeding one hundred pounds from the tenant in occupation thereof, then the holding or part of the holding shall vest in the Commissioners under this section free from all rights and equities arising from the previous interest of the tenant therein referred to in Section 8 of the Purchase of Land (Ireland) Act, 1885, and the person to whom the Commissioners shall have paid the purchase money shall be a trustee thereof for the persons beneficially entitled thereto."

This amendment is asked for by the Board of Works. It is not of great importance. It makes it easier for them to make title. I am advised that it is not likely to lead to any abuse. They have analogous powers with regard to making title for other lands, and they merely wish to extend that to a holding which is not worth more than £100.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Amendment 23 is out of order.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1) line 30, to insert after the word "rates" the words "and other rates," and after the words "liable for," line 35, to delete the words "any other rates or."

I do not know whether I understand this section. I have tabled an amendment to include the apportionment of other rates as well as the poor rates. Sub-section (1) seems to limit the rates to be apportioned before and after the appointed day to the poor rates. In sub-section (2) the rates seem to me to be taken in a more general sense. If there is to be an apportionment it should be for all rates for the current year. Another point that occurs to me is that the word "becomes" seems to be ambiguous.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will see whether it is necessary to improve the wording of that.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I move:—

In sub-section (1), line 32, after the word "Commission" to insert the words "or any person in occupation of the lands as allottees or purchasers from them."

That is a drafting amendment.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Amendments 25 and 26 are consequential.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I move:—

In sub-section (4), page 9, line 53, and in sub-section (6), page 10, line 4, to delete in each case the words "arrears of rates."

I pointed out during the Second Reading that in my opinion there are quite a number of cases in which the acceptance of this proposal in the Bill would have been inequitable, because persons for reasons over which they have no control have not been in occupation of certain lands for a number of years, in some cases for as long as seven or eight years. As the Minister doubtless is aware, when lands were forcibly entered a couple of years ago there was no such thing as giving any compensation, and, in fact, by a decision of the Supreme Court compensation claims in respect of land in the occupation of unauthorised persons were not allowed, and have been definitely defeated. I took the point of view, on the Second Reading Stage, that we ought not to penalise the persons who own these lands and who have been deprived of their use for a number of years by mob violence. We ought not to hold them liable for rates on lands which they did not occupy, or whose use they did not enjoy. While I admit that the case can be put to me that the county council or the ratepayers must bear the burden——

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands) Cumann na nGaedheal

The only rates that can be recovered are for two years. Who is the man who has not been able to occupy his land during the last two years?

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I know the case of a man who has been out of the country for two years and who failed to occupy his land.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands) Cumann na nGaedheal

During the last two years and has taken no action.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I admit the Minister has torpedoed my amendment by saying two years. I will not press my amendment.

Comment on this

I suggest to the Minister to remove "or has been." Is it necessary to have these words there? They might lead to all sorts of hypothetical questions arising.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Hogan Mr. HOGAN (Minister for Lands) Cumann na nGaedheal

These words are required surely?

Comment on this

It seems to me they might give rise to hypothetical questions. The main question is as to whether the landlord or the owner is non-liable.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The landlord might not be liable just at the time the land was acquired by the Land Commission but was liable the previous year. I agree that with "has been" you can go back 20, 30 or 40 years. I will see whether that can be altered.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I move:—

In sub-section (1), line 59, after the figures "1923" to insert the words "or in respect of which a capital sum retained and administered by the Land Commission shall hereafter be transferred to the Public Trustee to be held and applied in accordance with a scheme framed under this section."

That is to meet the case where there is no other trustee.

Comment on this

Deputy Heffernan had amendment 29 on the Order Paper, but I did not move it, as I did not like the provision in it. I believe, however, that a central authority is required to deal with a body of tenants because I do not think the majority of them would be able to enforce their viewpoint.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

My opposition to the amendment would be that it proposed to go back to the old trustee system under which the tenant was made liable. That system has broken down undoubtedly. The trustees did not do their work. They had a most thankless job, and found it very difficult to collect the necessary moneys from the rest of the tenants. The result was that all this work in connection with the keeping of embankments was neglected by the trustees. That is one of the reasons why work of this kind has passed under the Drainage Maintenance Acts from the hands of trustees to the county councils. Deputy Heffernan's amendment proposed to go back to the trustee system again; in other words, to give notice to the tenants, six months, say, asking whether they would like to have the work done by trustees or in a different way. Tenants are not going to undertake a liability if they can avoid it or put it on somebody else. There is no more unpopular work in the country than that which falls to the lot of trustees in connection with the keeping of these embankments.

Comment on this

I do not agree with the Minister's proposal in the Bill because I am afraid it is not going to improve the present position. It is going to lead to divided responsibility in connection with this very important work. That will not be a good thing either from the point of view of the Land Commission or the county council. There is a very close connection, as I pointed out before, between the work of maintenance and the work of reconstruction. If the reconstruction work is badly carried out, there will be need for additional maintenance work; if the maintenance work is badly carried out, it will give rise to the necessity for reconstruction work. To my mind, if for any reason there is to be a transfer of any portion of this work, then I think all of it should go together. I believe that both the reconstruction and the maintenance work should be carried out by the one authority. If, for any reason, it should be transferred from the Land Commission, then I think it should go to the Board of Works where it would be all handled by the one body and where there would be no question of divided responsibility.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

This is a very big question. What happens in practice is that the Land Commission does the work in the first instance. It puts the embankments right and then hands them over to the county councils for maintenance. The Land Commission, to start with, is not a permanent body, and its functions are not to go on for ever. Deputy Wall urges that if there is to be any transfer of the work it should be to the Board of Works. What we are doing here in connection with these embankments is exactly what is being done under the Drainage Maintenance Acts in respect of drainage maintenance. A good deal of the initial work is done by the Board of Works and then the river, or in this case the embankment, is handed over to the county council. Their function is simply to do a certain amount of work in keeping the embankment in repair. Once the original embankment is put right it is simple enough to maintain it. Of course what happens in practice, in the case of some embankments which are neglected—especially embankments along the seashore—is that heavy seas break through because of neglect in attending to their repair and knock down the whole embankment. It then becomes no longer a question of maintenance but a question of construction. That was the position when tenants were responsible for the maintenance of the embankments. They neglected the work, a breach came in the embankment and suddenly the problem changed from being one of maintenance to one of construction.

Now the embankments are going to be put right for them, and it will be only a question of maintenance. Very little maintenance will be necessary every year. The county councils have the means for doing that work. They have county surveyors, men with engineering experience, and the power to stike a rate. They can strike a rate on the people who benefit by the maintenance. It will be a simple matter for the county councils to do this work. They are responsible for doing the roads, and also the drainage work on the rivers in connection with the Drainage Maintenance Acts. It will be a simple matter for them to arrange to do this maintenance work in connection with the embankments. If it is wrong that they should do that, then the whole principle underlying the Drainage Maintenance Acts is wrong. Of course I realise the difficulties that are peculiar to places like Waterford and other counties that touch the sea, where very heavy embankment work has to be done. A very big question is involved as regards places of that kind. It may be that ultimately these embankments will have to be taken over by a central authority. As regards the other cases, the county councils are quite competent to maintain any schemes that are handed over to them. I am willing to admit that the question of embankments on the seashore may have to be considered.

Comment on this

As a national question?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I do not know, but we will see how the county councils will handle them. They have a number of schemes now to look after. This may be a bigger problem than I am aware of. I do not know much about the problem personally, but we are doing here what has been done under the Drainage Maintenance Acts, and we certainly should not take up the line that the underlying principle of these Acts is all wrong until at least it has been tried out a bit.

Comment on this

I quite see the Minister's point of view in connection with this. He has been reasonable enough to discuss the matter very fully with me, but even yet, I am not in agreement with him. I think he is right when he says that he does not appreciate the seriousness of the problem. I think, as a matter of fact, that very few people do, except those who have had actual experience of the work. There is really no parallel between maintenance in connection with drainage work and the maintenance and construction of embankments, and for this reason: that if there is a necessity for doing maintenance work on drains it does not make any material difference if it is not done for a period of six months. In the other case, the effect of a delay of 24 hours in doing some necessary maintenance work may possibly involve an expenditure of £1,000. That is the serious side of the question as I see it.

Furthermore, I think it will involve additional professional men in the county council, because I understand that the surveyors and engineers in the county councils throughout Ireland have their time fully occupied already, and it will mean that you will have two sets of officials for the work, one in Dublin and another in the country. This is work in connection with embankment. Take Kerry, for example, which is a rather poor county. For the ten years from March, 1916, to March, 1926, the cost of embankments in Kerry was £22,648, rather a big sum, and that sum might be increased, even doubled, under certain circumstances in particularly bad weather. I appeal to the Minister to reconsider his attitude and to hold this matter over until the Report Stage. In the meantime, he may be able to make further inquiries into the matter and to see eye to eye with us.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

As the Deputy well knows, I discussed this matter with him often and at length, and I see no better way of doing this. If the county councils do the drainage work of the country surely they ought to be able to do this.

Comment on this

There has been a long discussion between the Deputies and the Minister arising out of the amendment, and the amendment has nothing to do with the question discussed. The amendment is no cure for the whole problem.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is not on the amendment; it is on the section.

Comment on this

I move:—

29b.—In line 63, after the word "resumption" to insert the words "on paying to the owner or tenant, as the case may be, such sum as the Judicial Commissioner shall fix as, and for compensation as and for any loss in respect of the income ordinarily derived from, or any depreciation in the capital value of such lands or holding which he may have suffered or sustained in consequence of such declaration by the Land Commission and."

Section 22 is very drastic, and it gives power to the Land Commission, which proposes to acquire land, to inspect and then if, after the final hearing by the Judicial Commissioner, the Land Commission considers the price for the land too high the land is thrown back on the owner's hands. That is a procedure that must inevitably entail considerable loss on the land owner. It is a procedure to begin with undoubtedly which limits his power of sale. No man can sell land if a preliminary notice or an inspection is made. It limits his power of using the land to the best of its value. I know after notice of acquisition by the Land Commission he can go on using his land in a normal manner, but in practice no man dares take the risk. A man with his land in dread of acquisition by the Land Commission would not dare to put his land to any good. No man in such a case would dare to put a lot of in-calf heifers in, or till or stock land to the full capacity. The purpose of this amendment is that the owner of such land, on which the Land Commission, after serving notice and giving a hearing as to prices, should receive not only some consideration as to his costs but should also receive some compensation for the fact that he has not been able to use his land to its utmost value. I think it is reasonable. After all, what is the court which decides the value of the land? It is the Judicial Commissioner of the Land Commission, an official of the Land Commission who is acting in a judicial capacity.

I have no doubt that he decides fairly, but the Land Commission brings a case to their own court and then they propose, by this section, if dissatisfied with the verdict of the Court, to annul it. There is no possibility for the owner to say, "I am dissatisfied with the price." There is compulsion on the owner, but the Land Commission has taken the power to discontinue proceedings if the price is too high. I think there should be compensation assessed by the Judicial Commissioner himself, who is not liable to assess an unreasonable or excessive compensation for the man whose enjoyment and use of the land have been unquestionably interfered with and who has suffered some material damage from the action of the Land Commission. I do not think this is an excessive amendment. I think it touches a big point of principle and I commend it to the Dáil.

Comment on this

I would like to support this amendment. Undoubtedly it seems improper that one party should have the power to discontinue proceedings, if not to start it, and put the other party into a different position from what it was at the time of the commencement of those proceedings. Undoubtedly when proceedings are started to acquire land, as Deputy Cooper has said, the owner of the land will not treat that land in the way he would if there had been no proceedings. There have been cases drawn to my notice where proceedings have been started and the owner has then been notified that they are to be discontinued. In the meantime he has suffered considerable loss. The proposal, as far as I understand it, is not that leave should not be given to discontinue proceedings, but rather that if proceedings are discontinued something in the nature of compensation should be given and that that compensation should be assessed by the Judicial Commissioner. I think it is most reasonable, and I hope that the principle, at any rate, will be accepted by the Minister.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Of course, all land purchase limits a man's right to deal with his land as he likes, and the present position is that the Land Commission may acquire compulsorily all lands for the relief of congestion. The right to sell and to get a good price are all limited. This does not carry it much further. When the Land Commission inspects, immediately after inspection it offers a price. After six months the Judicial Commissioner intervenes unless the owner blocks it and uses the legal right he has to do so. You picture the owner being unable to sell?

I say first of all before ever the Land Commission intervened there were always Acts of Parliament which said that the Land Commission might acquire any land for the relief of congestion compulsorily, and in so far as you affect the owner's right to deal with his land you are not doing it any more than you affected it by the Land Act itself. Further, this is not a new section. It was not invented by me. I would like Deputy Redmond to know that. This is not the first time it appears. It is consecrated in every Land Act passed since 1907 and it has done no harm. We find in practice that there was a really good reason for inserting it in the Evicted Tenants Act of 1907, the Irish Land Settlement (Soldiers and Sailors) Act, 1919, and other Acts. We find in practice that it was right. All we are doing is to make the Land Act, 1923, conform to other Acts put through in another parliament. They did not do any hardship. Why should this do any? So far as compensation is concerned the owner has the use of land; he is not interfered with as user in the sale. Interference is always there to some extent by the mere passage of the Land Acts, and in so far as it is accentuated the particular state of affairs only lasts for a few months, but he has the full use of the land for the whole time and I do not think compensation is called for. As Deputies know, the question of costs is for the Judicial Commissioner, who will undoubtedly do the fair thing, and the fairest way to deal with the question is to leave it to the discretion of the High Court Judge.

Comment on this

Might I make a suggestion to the Minister? As has been pointed out, this section does seem a little one-sided. Perhaps as a concession we might give the owner the right to object to the withdrawal and give grounds for his objection. If he can prove to the Judicial Commissioner that such grounds were reasonable such notice of withdrawal should be held to be void.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The answer to that is: What is wrong with the provision inserted in the previous Land Acts of 1909 and 1919? They did not work any hardship? In fact in one of these, I think it was the 1919 Act, there is no provision at all for costs. They withdraw simpliciter and the landlord gets no costs. We go one better from the landlord's point of view and we insert a provision for costs and leave it to the Judicial Commissioner to say whether costs should be given.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister has achieved complete virtue.

Comment on this

I am certain that the Minister has not achieved complete virtue. I always know when Ministers have a bad case. When they have a bad case they take refuge in precedents. Instead of wrapping themselves in their own virtue, they cast over their shoulders the worn-out rags of Westminster. What are the Minister's precedents? The Evicted Tenants Act of 1907. That was an Act covering a comparatively small area. I am not familiar with its working, but I am sure it was not successful, or we should not have the lengthy discussion we had this afternoon. The other was the Soldiers and Sailors Land Trust Settlement Act of 1919. If there has ever been an Act that worked worse than that Act and caused more general dissatisfaction and discontent, I have yet to know of it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In this respect?

Comment on this

In every respect.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is irrelevant.

Comment on this

The Minister is not in the Chair and he cannot rule me out for irrelevancy.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The effect of this amendment will be to increase the cost to the taxpayer, and as a private Deputy cannot move anything which will increase the cost to the taxpayer, I think it is out of order. Will you rule on that, sir?

Comment on this

To save any trouble, might I say that I am of opinion that Deputy Wilson is right, but this amendment would have been in order had it been moved by a member of the Executive Council. I put it down in the hope of touching the kind heart of the President or the Minister for Finance, and I can make my argument equally well on the question that the section stands part of the Bill.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

Then the amendment is withdrawn?

Comment on this

I am not withdrawing the amendment, but you can rule me out of order.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I must rule the amendment out of order.

Comment on this

I move amendment 29 (c):—

In line 64, after the word "determine" to insert the words "and such untenanted lands or holding shall not thereafter be acquired or resumed by the Land Commission without the consent of the owner or tenant thereof."

This is an amendment which, I think, is in order.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Would the Deputy mind adjourning this amendment to the Report Stage and I will discuss it with him between now and then?

Comment on this

Yes, I am quite willing to do that.

Comment on this

I am opposing the motion that this section, as amended— even though one of my amendments was accepted—should stand part of the Bill, on the grounds that I have already stated. It is an utterly one-sided provision. The precedents given by the Minister do not impress me. I think this is calculated to inflict great hardship and inconvenience on owners of land. The precedents quoted by the Minister dealt with comparatively small areas. The areas of land acquired under the Soldiers and Sailors Land Trust Settlement Act were very limited—areas for housing, not for farming. In any town you will hardly find more than four or five acres taken. In the same way the Evicted Tenants Act of 1907 would only apply to certain limited specified areas, and such precedents are of no value in bringing in an Act dealing with the whole State. The Minister said that the Land Commission had power to take all land. That is quite true. That is the provision in the Act of 1923. The working of that provision has been very disastrous to the farmer, because it has curtailed his credit, as the banks will not advance money on a restricted credit because of the existence of that provision.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

What provision?

Comment on this

The provision empowering the Land Commission to take all land—the power that exists in the Land Commission to acquire compulsorily any land other than building land that they need. That has caused a restriction of credit.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I disagree.

Comment on this

We will agree to disagree. I am quite certain that at least 200 people have spoken to me on that subject within the last two months. It is a widely held opinion, particularly in those circles where they deal with money and credit, that that is the reason the farmer is having his credit curtailed, and that the bank overdrafts are being very stringently regulated.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Will the Deputy explain how this affects the farmers' credit. The farmer holds tenanted land or land held under a purchase annuity. How is his credit restricted by the Act?

Comment on this

Because, as far as I know, the large farmer is not excluded from the compulsory acquisition of some portion of his land, or even the whole of it.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

As far as the farmer is concerned, he must get the resumption price for his land, so that he is in the position he was in since 1881. If the Land Commission acquire tenanted land we must give the resumption price for it. With regard to purchased land, if the Land Commission acquire purchased land, held in fee simple subject to a land purchase annuity, they must give an equally suitable and not less valuable holding elsewhere to the owner. The effect of the two provisions, so far from interfering with the farmer's credit, is to improve it.

Comment on this

The Minister has not made that clear until this moment. I wish he would address the Dublin Chamber of Commerce or some of the other bodies interested in the provision of credit to farmers in order to make that point clear, because there are apprehensions which exist. Unfortunately, there are people who very often read a section of an Act that concerns them without reading the qualifying section. The provision of Section 24 of the Act of 1923 has given rise to such apprehensions, and this provision in Section 22 of this Bill will intensify those apprehensions. It is a good thing we have been able to get this question threshed out and have been able to get the Minister to make that statement. I am convinced that this is a one-sided proposition. It enables the Land Commission to put the owner of the land to great trouble and inconvenience and considerable expense, and then enables them to throw the land back on his hands if the verdict of their own judge goes against him. I do not see how we could stand over a provision of that kind, and I ask the Dáil to reject it.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

in the Chair.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I move amendment 30:—

Before Section 23 to add a new section as follows:

Where the landlord and tenant of a holding to which Part II. of the First Schedule to the Land Act, 1923, applies, have agreed on a Standard Purchase Annuity for it of such an amount that the Land Commission are not satisfied that the holding is security therefor the Land Commission on serving notice on the parties in the prescribed manner may make an order refusing to advance the purchase money for the holding and may thereupon fix the Standard Purchase Annuity of the holding in manner provided under the Land Act, 1923, in cases where there had been no agreement between the landlord and tenant.

There are some cases in which there have been annuities fixed by agreement that the land is unable to bear. There has been a certain amount of collusion, and the Land Commission wants to be in a position to review cases of that sort.

Comment on this

I move amendment 31:—

Before Section 23 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Where a holding subject to a judicial rent has since the date of the fixation of that rent deteriorated in value to any considerable extent as a result of causes outside the control of the tenant and where the tenant applies to the Land Commission and the Land Commission is satisfied that the completion of purchase of the holding in accordance with the provisions of Part I. of the First Schedule to the Act of 1923 would result in an annuity the capital value of which in the opinion of the Land Commission exceeds the security value of the land the Land Commission may make an order refusing to advance the purchase money for the holding and may thereupon fix the Standard Purchase Annuity in manner provided under the Land Act, 1923, for non-judicial holdings in accordance with Part II. of the First Schedule of the Land Act, 1923.

This is founded on the same principle as the last amendment. The idea of this amendment is that in a case where a tenant comes under the Land Purchase Act as a judicial tenant, and where his annuity has been fixed in accordance with the provisions of the Act at 30 or 35 per cent. reduction as the case may be, and where, owing to exceptional circumstances which are outside the control of the tenant, the land has deteriorated to such an extent as not to be security value for the capital sum advanced, that the tenant shall have the power to apply to the Land Commission and that the Land Commission shall have the power to fix the standard purchase annuity at a level which would be commensurate with the security value of the land. I must confess that this amendment is put down, having in view one or two particular cases where the rent fixed a considerable time ago by the Land Courts is now found to be an uneconomic rent and the tenants at present are quite unable to pay it.

There is a particular estate in the County Kerry—the Stoddard Estate— about which the Minister has some information, where it is generally acknowledged that owing to tidal flooding which must be regarded as entirely outside the control of the tenants the land has deteriorated very much in value and the tenants are quite unable to pay the interest in lieu of rent pending the fixing of the annuities. I recognise there would be a considerable amount of difficulty in administering the Act if this amendment was incorporated in it but personally I cannot see any other way of dealing with similar cases. I am open to correction if the Minister can persuade me that there is some other method of dealing with cases of that sort, but if there is not it seems to me that there is justification for this amendment. If I understand the Act of 1923 the question of the security value of land, which has a judicial rent, does not enter into the case at all, the tenant automatically purchasing and the landlord automatically selling and it is taken that the land in all cases is security value. If I am wrong in that and if the security value counts it seems to me if the present situation is to continue, tenants could not buy and the landlords cannot sell if the land was not security value. If that were so it would be a most unfortunate condition of things to exist and I think there is some strong need for reform.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

As the Deputy suggested, there would be considerable difficulty in accepting this amendment. There is considerable difference between this amendment and the amendment accepted previously. This deals with judicial rents fixed any time since 1881. These are standard rents and were fixed having regard to the value of the land, prices, and all relevant circumstances and they were, therefore, fixed upon a definite basis and taking quality for quality of land, they approximate fairly closely. Taking the circumstances into account, the quality of the land, the proximity to towns and all those other things that affect the value of land, all those judicial rents approximate fairly closely. Moreover, there are three classes of judicial rents. You may have a rent fixed over the first fifteen years after 1881, then you may have rents fixed during the second fifteen year period and then you may have third term rents fixed. And in that way the idea underlying the Land Act of 1923 was that the judicial rents were standard rents that can be taken as a firm basis for reduction.

If this amendment were accepted it would mean that the Land Commission would have to reopen a very considerable number of judicial rents; they would have to set up a fair rent court. When dealing with non-judicial rents it is a different matter. Everyone recognises that they varied, that they were, to some extent, not fixed upon any definite principle, that they were arbitrary. The tenant never went into court—it was an arrangement between himself and the landlord and a hundred and one irrelevant circumstances might have to be taken into account. Some of those rents might be just as fair as the judicial rents, others not so fair; they were arbitrary. You could not apply the same rule to them all. We faced that and made an arrangement by which that rent is fixed by agreement between landlord and tenant, or the Land Commission comes in and fixes a new rent. In the case of the judicial rent you have a standard rent there, and you can apply a general reduction to the whole lot with safety. The case Deputy Heffernan is thinking of is a case where the land was security for the rent at one period, but owing to deterioration is not security now. That gives rise to another and a different question. I daresay there would be some cases, and the correct way to deal with them would be to deal with them through the Agricultural Credit Corporation, to provide sufficient facilities for the necessary improvement of the land. The land has deteriorated, and consequently it is not a case of naturally bad land that cannot be improved. It is a case of land that was once security for the rent, and which has deteriorated, and the expenditure of a certain amount of money on drainage or on the treatment of the particular disease, whatever that disease might be, would bring back the land to its original state. It is from that point of view it should be approached. It would be fatal and it would be altering the whole basis of the Act of 1923, and doubling and re-doubling the work of the Land Commission. It might be very unwise from the point of view of the tenants, in many cases, because some judicial rents are extremely low. If the Land Commission had power to increase annuities they would also have by implication the right to increase them. If they considered that the reduction of 25 per cent. on the judicial rent was too low, in some cases, if they were able to vary rents at all, they would presumably be entitled to increase it.

In equity that would have to be done. If you once admit that judicial rents have to be changed and varied on their merits, then the Land Commission must be fairly free to say what the merits of each case are. It would be a great pity to depart from rents that have become fixed and standardised over long periods. If there are cases, as I presume there are a few, where a holding has deteriorated, so that it is not security for the judicial rent. I suggest that the right way to deal with them would be by way of a loan of some kind or by making credits available to improve the land.

Comment on this

I agree that the Minister has made a reasonable statement on this point, but what about the case of a farm, portion of which has been washed away by the action of the sea? What good would a loan be in that case?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That was not the case Deputy Heffernan had in mind.

Comment on this

It is a class of case that might be covered by this amendment. I agree that generally the administrative difficulties would be almost insuperable.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

My answer to that would be if there are such cases they are a limited number and should be scheduled. It would be very dangerous to raise the question of changing annuities. If there are cases of that kind, and I presume there are a few, then they should be scheduled and examined by themselves. If the problem requires solution that solution would want to be very carefully thought out, so as not to establish any wrong precedent.

Comment on this

I am not quite satisfied with the Minister's reply. While recognising clearly the difficulties there would be in administering the Act, I think there is a genuine grievance, and that it has not been met by the Minister's suggestion. If the Minister will meet me by saying that he will do something definite to remedy the present state of affairs, I might consider the question of withdrawing the amendment. I understood him to say that he would consider the question of scheduling particular lands.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is not to be taken as a firm offer. I qualify that by saying "in the event of there being such cases."

Comment on this

I understood that the Minister would consider lands affected by coast erosion?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There would be another way of dealing with it. The holding might be retained by the Land Commission and one given in exchange. There are a hundred ways of dealing with that without raising all these questions.

Comment on this

The point made by the Minister with regard to this amendment, that if you deal with cases where land has depreciated you can deal with cases where the value of land has appreciated hardly applies, because everybody knows that in the past the same argument applied in the Land Courts, but in practice the rents were hardly ever raised by the Land Courts.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There have been plenty of cases.

Comment on this

I want to call the Minister's attention to the fact that the Land Courts have hardly been working since pre-war days. Practically no applications have been made for reduction of rents, the fixation of which took place during war time. There is no means of meeting the unusual deterioration that took place since then. The suggestion that it should be met by credits is unsound, as, while the land might be improved, the owner would have to pay back by annual instalments the advance with interest, as well as paying the fair rent. I suggest that that is unsound from the economic point of view. I am keen on having something done for that particular class of tenant. I am not satisfied with the Minister's statement. I am sorry that the Deputy from Kerry concerned in the particular case I mentioned is not here. I would like to hear his views on the matter. I think an interesting point has been raised, and I would like to hear any other Deputy who has had experience of similar cases. I am not satisfied that the Minister has offered any definite solution of the problem that exists.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I move:—

In lines 11-12 to delete the words "or where a parcel or a group of parcels of untenanted land or the whole or part of a retained holding."

Deputies will see by the section that the Land Commission has power and I believe had in the past such power, when fixing the selling price of untenanted land in a congested area to bear a loss. The new section goes a further step and says that in the case of a parcel or a group of parcels of untenanted land, which means, I submit, land outside congested areas, the Land Commission is to have authority to bear a loss, which has not been definitely ascertained, and which must necessarily be met from the public purse. I am not agreeable to the proposal that the State should bear a loss on untenanted land outside congested areas. I agree that land in congested areas has no relation whatever to land in non-congested areas. Remember it is not alone an amalgamation of a parcel or a group of parcels of untenanted land with a retained holding, or part of one. The words are "a parcel or a group of parcels of untenanted land or ..." The word used is "or." The loss is to be sustained by the State. I submit the Minister has put forward no justification for that proposal and, while maintaining an open mind. I submit we ought not to admit the principle the Minister is seeking to incorporate.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The Land Commission found, in the course of their administration of the Act, that for one reason or another they were able to buy some estates particularly cheaply, and that, on the other hand, they had to give what they regarded as more than a fair price for some other estates. The reason for that is that, in a great many cases, it is easy enough to buy encumbered land. But it is very difficult to do equity when you are dealing with an estate with a lot of encumbrances on it. There may be institutions or individuals getting rents out of the land, or they may have charges on the land. When a judge is faced with an estate on which there are encumbrances— charges of one kind or another—and when he has to fix a price and take into account, at the same time, that that price must cover something for the owner and something for the encumbrancers, the people and institutions who lent money, the people entitled to something under a family settlement, and so on, he finds that to do the fair thing he must give a bit more for the land than he would like to give if he were to take into account solely the tenants who are getting it. It is easy to be logical in respect of all that and to say "The Land Commission should deal with this matter in a cold, impersonal way and give a price for the land at which they can resell it, and no more." But I am surprised that Deputy Hogan should take that view. If it were another Deputy who raised the question, I would not be surprised. The Land Judge has to take into account not only the interests of the tenants but the interests of the occupying owner and the interests of the encumbrancers, and in some cases he sees, with the best will in the world, that he has to give somewhat more than he would give if there were no encumbrancers. There are other cases where the same results ensue for different reasons. I have quoted only one case. There are many cases like that. To make a long story short, if you are buying something like £300,000 or £400,000 worth of land per annum, the ultimate amount running into millions, you will find that at times you can get land very cheaply and at other times that you have to pay a little more than you would like to pay if you were to take into account only the interests of the tenants.

There is another consideration which affects that problem, which I should like to bring to the notice of Deputies. Lands are bought that are very valuable as accommodation lands or very valuable because of location, being near a town, or for one reason or another. There has been a considerable income out of them for a long time and the Land Judge has to purchase those lands, and to purchase them within the limits of a section in the Land Act of 1923, which says that the price is to be a fair price for the owner and for the Land Commission. In that state of affairs he finds it very difficult indeed to fix a price which resolves the dilemma—which is, in fact, a fair price for the owner and for the Land Commission, the Land Commissioners in that case being really the tenants. There is one obvious way out of the difficulty. The fair thing to do is, so to speak, to bulk estates—to combine the cheap with the dear estate and to spread the price over them. I see nothing whatever inequitable in that. Land purchase should be made, as far as possible, fair all round and on no principle of administration can I see any special reason for giving specially good terms, obtained by accident, to a certain number of tenants. It is better to give fair annuities to all than to do some extremely well and to do others anything but extremely well. When the Land Commission buys an estate which is cheap they can always amalgamate it with an estate which is dear, spread the price evenly over them, and then they get something like a fair annuity. But that does not meet the case at times. At times it is not convenient to do it, and we have found, within the last two or three years, that in odd cases we had to sell land on an annuity which we would like to see a little lower. That section is put in to place us in a position to remedy that. I do not know any better way out of it. You are up against a dilemma, and if this be not done you have got to do injustice to one party or the other. Recognise, at all events, that you are in a dilemma; there is no use in being dogmatic or chopping logic about it. We buy land from comparatively poor people as well as from rich people. They must get fair play. We are in a dilemma; if we do justice to the tenants we are doing injustice to the owner. That section is put in to meet the case.

I said nothing about the case where you want to buy land which is subject to a land purchase annuity, or tenanted land. In those cases, we are constantly in a dilemma. Where you buy tenanted land you have to give resumption price. You have to give the tenant at least the price secured to him by the Act of 1881. "Resumption price" is practically the market value. In addition you have to buy the landlord's interest. When you add the two and take the total sum you have an amount at which you cannot sell the lands without joining them up with other lands that you bought cheaply and selling the whole at a flat rate. The same thing applies in cases where we are anxious to buy purchased land—land subject to a land purchase annuity. As a rule you endeavour to buy that on the lines of exchanging the holding and giving a no less valuable holding to the owner elsewhere. At times, that is not convenient.

The man would prefer to get the price. The Land Commission finds sometimes that they cannot give him the money—at least anything that would pay him. There is an annuity on a holding, say, of 200 acres. The Land Commission pay £2,500, and it might take £2,000 to redeem the annuity. In that case, the owner has £500 for himself. He would rather take the money. It would suit the Land Commission better to give him the money instead of giving him a holding elsewhere, because land is short. Yet, they cannot do that because of the necessity for redeeming the annuity. Those are the reasons which impelled us, after two or three years' administration, to ask the Dáil for the powers sought in this section. If the Deputy's amendment were agreed to, it would take all the good out of it.

Comment on this

The Minister's statement has disarmed my hostility to a great extent. I should like to point out, however, that, on the Second Reading of this Bill, I drew attention to the fact that the Land Commission had bought land at prices far above those at which it could be set at economic rents to the tenants. I took exception to what I considered was speculation on the part of the Land Commission— buying land on a falling market when agricultural prices were tumbling down——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

There is only one way to meet that, and that is to stop buying. What would you say then?

Comment on this

We have to take account of the interests of the taxpayer. While I am with the Minister in his view that the land should not be sold at an excessive price to the incoming tenant—we do not want to keep these men in a state of pauperism all their days—this provision is not alone retrospective, but it is to continue for a definite period. I am with the Minister in his statement that you have often to "bulk" land, but I do say that this opens up possibilities which are very grave and which should be avoided. Land might be bought, not necessarily under the present Minister, but under some Minister in the future, regardless of the public purse. Although the Minister for Finance may have a say in it you are, nevertheless, putting a burden on the public. Since the land question in this country has not been made a social question, as it ought to be, apart and remote from politics, but is a political question, I do think these words, "or a group of parcels," give rise to a dangerous possibility. I am not disposed to press the amendment if I get an assurance from the Minister that the powers being given to the Land Commission will be used sparingly and with great circumspection.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That is the idea. Of course, the Dáil will have control over the matter every year on the Vote.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Amendment 33 is a purely verbal amendment:—

In sub-section (1) to delete all words from the word "all," line 24, to the word "rent," line 26, where it secondly occurs, both inclusive, and substitute therefor the words "all moneys."

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Amendment 34 is as follows:—

Before sub-section (3) to insert the following new sub-section:—

"Compounded arrears of rent and payment in lieu of rent shall be and shall be deemed to have been a charge on the holding in respect of which they are payable, having priority over all existing interests and incumbrances affecting the tenancy created either before or after the passing of this Act."

That puts compounded arrears of rent and payment in lieu of rent in the position in which they should be. The money is collected by the State and it should be regarded in the same way as an annuity.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Amendment 35 is as follows:—

In sub-section (4), line 48, to add after the word "therefor" the words "and the Land Commission shall not be restrained in the recovery of moneys due to them by reason of any proceedings had, or pending, in any court in relation to the said lands."

With the consent of the Committee, I would like to leave that amendment over until the Report Stage. I am not quite clear as to whether I ought to move that amendment.

Comment on this

The amendment which I propose is a drafting amendment:—

In line 49, after the word "where" to insert the words "after the passing of this Act."

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I will accept that amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I move the following amendment:—

To delete sub-section (1).

I take it the Committee will not have any objection to deleting that.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That disposes of the following amendment:—

In sub-section (1), line 8, after the word "Commission" to insert the words "which shall have been delivered to the Under-Sheriff within ten days from the date of the making of the same."—(Deputy Bryan Cooper).

Comment on this

Yes. That is my amendment.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I beg to move:—

To delete sub-section (3).

Deputies who read this section must realise the very severe and penal legislation which is contained in sub-section (3) as affecting many persons in the Saorstát. I direct the attention of Deputies to that particular sub-section. It is true that in the Act passed last year, the Enforcement of Law (Occasional Powers) Act, a section more or less similar to this was introduced. At that time very strong exception was taken here and in the Seanad to the provision. The principle behind it is that the sheriff can go upon any land in respect of which a land purchase annuity is owing and can take anything off that land no matter who owns the property found there. The sheriff can take it away even though he knows that it is not the property of the debtor, and he can sell it.

As some sort of recompense, the party detrimentally affected has the right to sue the Land Commission's debtor. That is more an apparent right than a real right. The old privilege by which a man, if any of his stock or implements were found on another man's premises and the sheriff seized them because the man on whose premises they were seized was a debtor, could by affidavit before a magistrate recover his goods, ought not lightly be abandoned. The present procedure is going to inflict great hardship and it is going to create an element of distrust in the country. How can anyone lend even a farm implement to another man if, without his knowledge, the under-sheriff can come along and seize it in respect of a land purchase annuity?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Or rates.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Yes, or rates. You will find this is not going to help towards the principle of co-operation. Is this the Minister's construction of co-operation—to give this power to the sheriff and to deny, except by fiction, the injured party adequate redress and subject him to considerable inconvenience and trouble? Apart from that objection, one has to think of the existing conditions in regard to agriculture. We have here a number of sections all dealing with the same principle, the more expeditious recovery of Land Purchase Annuities, and these are put forward entirely ignoring and forgetful of the extreme distress prevailing. I am with the Land Commission in recovering the Land Purchase Annuities. I would, however, prefer that they be recovered by a system which would be quite as effective but not so harsh and not so injurious on third parties.

The Minister has not on any occasion proved that the previous existing law had broken down, that it was ineffective and failed to achieve its primary object as between the State and the debtor. The Minister has not made that case and I should like him to. The Land Commission are requesting the Oireachtas to give them extraordinary powers to collect Land Purchase Annuities. And what follows? Merely that they may be handed over to Great Britain in respect of some agreement, some secret arrangement which has never come before the House and has never been ratified. They want to put our people under the harrow for the purposes of the collection.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

That's the stuff!

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We cannot get into that question at this stage.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

I am putting it forward as one reason why the House should not agree to the proposals enshrined in the Bill. We ought to take cognizance of the poverty of our people and we ought to refuse anything in the nature of extraordinary powers to the Land Commission to collect annuities. They have the normal procedure of law, which remains in effect even if these penal sections are defeated.

Having regard to the primary interests of our people, having regard to the acute distress amongst the agricultural community, which I fear will not be relieved for a considerable time, and in view also of the fact, in many cases, of the great mortality in their livestock suffered by the people, I am opposing this. As yet, no adequate system of relief has been put up by the Government to meet the loss caused by this mortality in livestock.

I hold that we ought not to give way to the panic legislation the Minister calls for. To do so is not in the best interests of the community, and it is certainly striking a very severe blow at these farmers who are down and out. We might as well say that we are voting for the wholesale eviction of the farmers. They are to be crushed out under the penal sections of this Bill. I challenge a division on this Bill, and I ask the Committee not to give the extraordinary powers that the Minister is seeking. In the normal circumstances of the people they are not needed, but we are asked to establish them now in perpetuity.

Comment on this

I am going to support Deputy Connor Hogan in this amendment. On the occasion of the passing of the Occasional Powers Act, I took advantage of the opportunity on the first occasion to oppose a similar section in the Bill that was then going through. This is a sub-section of the same kind. I would oppose it altogether, apart from the question of the land annuities. I think the tendency to safeguard the sheriff in every way is rather a dangerous one and is a growing one. Despite the fact that the Minister has shown recently a desire to support the sheriff in every way——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Why put in the word "recently"?

Comment on this

The Minister's speech in Clare was the most recent, for example.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

In that sense you can have it.

Comment on this

I say this, that there is really a growing danger in the country that the sheriff and his officers are going to act, and in many cases are acting, in a tyrannical manner to the people, backed up as the sheriff is by the legislation of this Chamber. I think the first principle of legislation should be to protect the innocent citizen so that he could not, by action of the State, in any way suffer loss in his person or purse. It is quite possible that an innocent person may suffer very considerable loss to his purse by this particular section. I have in mind very definite and tangible evidence of the work done by a sheriff. It is a case where a local small farmer in my neighbourhood was writted for £40 or £50. The sheriff's man came out there very coolly and, having walked into the land, seized stock. He did not go to the trouble of finding out the boundaries of the farm, and so he quietly walked into my brother's farm and walked off with 40 sheep. I happened to catch him before he got to the pound, and made him sorry. The fact is that if these sheep had strayed into the farm of that debtor, and they had been taken by the sheriff and sold, we would have no redress except to sue the defendant in that particular case. That is an instance of the hardship that this sub-section may do to the citizen. It is up to the sheriff and his officials to find out if the stock on the farm belongs to the defendant in a particular case; he should take responsibility for the stock seized, and so assure himself of the facts. Sheriffs are well paid, in salaries and in fees; they are, in fact, paid too much, and it is not unreasonable to expect that the sheriff should take responsibility for any stock or property that he may seize and which may not be the property of the owner of the land. There is a principle involved in this, apart altogether from the obligations of the Land Act, and I suggest to the Committee to support Deputy Connor Hogan on this amendment, that is, if it is not accepted by the Minister.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I am glad to see that the Farmers' Party are in a good way towards reaching salvation, on this question in any case. It might be no harm to remind Deputy Heffernan and other members of the Farmers' Party of an Act that was passed here, popularly called the "Sheriffs Act." The Farmers' Party supported that when it was passing through the Dáil, and now the chickens are coming home to roost. This sub-section is only an extension of that particular Act.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Will the Deputy name the date of the passing of that Act?

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Deputy Connor Hogan is better acquainted with the records of the Dáil than I am, and he will be able to search up these. I think he will find it an interesting half hour.

Comment on this

It was not passed in the lifetime of the present Dáil?

Comment on this

Oh, yes.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice knows about it.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Yes, and so do the Farmers' Party. It was, and it is no harm that they should now be reminded of it. I am supporting Deputy Connor Hogan in his amendment to have this sub-section deleted from the Bill. To my mind, it is undoubtedly a rank injustice to have such a provision as this in the Bill, whereby another man's property, a man who is in no way concerned with the debt, may be seized, and that he may be put to extraordinary trouble and cost in trying to recover from somebody from whom he may not be able to recover. Surely that is not in accordance with fair play or justice. I have in my mind instances of cases where this sub-section will work out very harshly. Take the case where a man takes grazing of a farm. He pays in advance, as is the case sometimes. He then puts his stock on the land. He knows nothing about the particular circumstances of the man on whose land he has placed his stock, and that man fails to pay his annuity. What happens? The sheriff comes along and seizes the cattle, the cattle of a man who has no connection with the debtor. The only remedy the man has in that case is to proceed against the debtor, who may have no means and who may be no mark. I hold that that is fundamentally wrong, and that there is no justification for it. It is the sheriff's duty to recover the debt from the man who owes the debt, and not from somebody else whose cattle either accidentally or otherwise may happen to be on the man's premises or farm at a given time. There may be cases of evasion, where a debtor may be able to evade payment of a debt, but it ought to be up to the sheriff to exercise his judgment in such cases, and where it is clear and definite that the stock seized does not belong to the debtor, then an action should lie against the sheriff, as has been always the case in the past. This sub-section should be deleted from the Bill. It is unfair and unjust and fundamentally wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan Mr. P. HOGAN (Clare) Labour Party

I think I can say on this amendment what I intended to say when the section was to be put. I had down an amendment to delete the entire section.

I desire to protest emphatically against this attempt to create a reign of terror amongst the farming population, because that is what it amounts to. It is an attempt to create a reign of terror amongst people who are unable to recover their economic stability and who suffered a series of disasters from many causes. This attempt to make the sheriff the high priest of our administration is a thing we should not tolerate. He should be amenable for his actions in the ordinary way, and the Minister has made no case to prove that there is any need for this drastic legislation. I know one particular case where an unfortunate widow cannot keep her children at home owing to the fear of the sheriff coming, because he came once. They clear away every night through the country. Does the Minister not see that that state of terror is going to be created through the country?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I did not get that case.

Comment on this
Mr. P. HOGAN

It is a wonder you did not hear of it when you were in Ennis.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

I did not. Perhaps the Deputy would repeat it.

Comment on this
Mr. P. HOGAN

It is the case of a woman's young family who will not stay at home with her at night because of a visit of the sheriff and the police on a previous occasion, and such was the terror created in their minds——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Of course, the thing to do in that case is to take away from the sheriff all powers to seize.

Comment on this
Mr. P. HOGAN

There is no question of taking away all powers, and the Minister should not beg the question in that fashion. This is an attempt to prevent all people who have suffered losses from recovering economically, and the Minister knows it. Rather than seek drastic powers he should use the ordinary law. The ordinary law has not broken down. It is very well able to meet the position at the moment, and instead of seeking drastic powers the Minister ought to make a survey of the agricultural conditions in some districts.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Of course I make all allowance to Deputy Connor Hogan, who is a relentless enemy of the British, who always has been, and always will remain so, but he ought to cut out that talk about paying the Land Commission annuities to England, or, if he does not, he ought to have the decency to put down a motion here stating that they shall not be collected, or, if they shall be collected, that they shall be retained here.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

Would the Minister vote for it?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

With all respect to the Deputy, that is the cheapest of cheap talk. He talks about these annuities going to England. Let him state specifically where he stands on that. Are we to pay interest on the money that was advanced? It is easy to throw out that suggestion, but it is a most dangerous suggestion.

Comment on this

Is the Minister in order?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

We cannot have a discussion on that now.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Was the Deputy in order?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

I ruled the Deputy out of order.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

May I put it this way: It is alleged that this will shake security and stability. It will not. But what is going to cause insecurity and instability are the suggestions that have been made in connection with this section. Let us see what is in all this talk about insecurity and instability. One would imagine that there was no similar provision in respect of any other debt. There is. I do not want Deputies to be deceived about this, because there are Deputies who do not know the country very well, do not know how the various processes of the law go on, and just what reactions they have through the countryside. At the present moment this section is the law of the land in respect of rates, and has been for generations, and did it ever cause insecurity and instability? Were Deputy Heffernan's sheep ever seized for the neighbours' rates? Why have not all these evils that Deputies foresee, when we extend these powers to the sheriff in respect of Land Commission annuities, shown themselves for the last twenty or thirty years, considering that the rate collector is seizing for rates, and, I may say, that seizures for income tax are made under exactly similar legislation? Now, this is the acid test. After all, do Deputies want Land Commission annuities to be collected? If they do, there is no use in saying that the people are not able to pay. That is another way of saying that they do not want them collected. The case that the people are not able to pay should be put up in another way; Deputies should state expressly that Land Commission annuities should not be collected. We would know where we stood then. But when you say in one breath: "Of course I am anxious to collect Land Commission annuities," and in another: "People are not able to pay," what do you mean? Do you mean that the Collection Department should stop operating and that annuities should not be collected? No one will frankly take that attitude.

If they are to collect Land Commission annuities why should not the sheriff have the same powers in respect to them as in respect to rates? You might ask: "Why should he not have the same powers in regard to every other debt?" We are in an absolutely illogical position about this, because arrears of Land Commission annuities are, in fact, arrears of rates. I hear it alleged that the rates are very high in certain counties, such as Clare, Galway and Limerick.

Is not this partly the reason? Could you be doing a better service to the small farmer who is endeavouring to pay his rates in these counties than by relieving him of the painful and costly luxury of paying his neighbours' as well? Why is it that this has not caused any hardship with regard to rates? For the simple reason that no one ever dreams of taking land until he gets the rate receipt. If I am going to take land the first thing I ask is: "Are the rates cleared?"—and if they are not cleared I make sure that I will not pay the rent without paying the rates first. There is no difficulty about it, and it works out perfectly—never any hardship and never any trouble. The first thing a solicitor, who has ever acted for anybody wanting to take land, asks for is the rate receipts. If he does not get them he advises his client to hold a certain amount of the money and pay the rates, and the ordinary man who is taking land knows the law well enough. How many cases have occurred in County Clare, in the past or under present circumstances, where other people's property has been seized for rates? Very few, and in these few cases the men knew that they were deliberately taking a risk.

Comment on this
Conor Hogan Mr. CONNOR HOGAN Farmers Party

You could tell the rate collectors to take other means?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The rate collector is the first person to seize stock on the land, no matter who owns it, and there is never any trouble. Do Deputies allege that exactly the same thing will not occur in regard to land purchase annuities? I say, from my experience of the collection branch, and from my knowledge of certain counties, that this provision is vital, and I know that in certain counties during the last three months arrears of annuities have come in sufficient to reduce the figure in these places by, say, ten or fifteen per cent. as a result of this section. Remember that this Bill has been before the Dáil for a long time. This section is known throughout the country, and I know, of my own knowledge, of counties in the West and elsewhere, that annuities have come in because of the threat of this section.

Comment on this

With what result?

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Very well. Go back to the question: Do you want to collect annuities?

Comment on this

The land is depleted.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

It is said that this is going to lead to instability, that no one will know where he is. On the contrary. At the moment a mortgagee is in a most unsatisfactory position. No matter how old his mortgage is the Land Commission annuities may be accumulating, and they have a prior charge. What we need is to go back, as far as possible, to the cash basis, and the best service you can do to mortgagees, and the best service you can do to shopkeepers and everybody else—it may mean a wrench at the moment, but it will be a very slight one—is to bring about the state of affairs where this particular mortgage, which has a priority over all other mortgages, will not be accumulating and increasing every year. No shopkeeper knows where he is now. If this were in operation, if you had the collection up-to-date, you would do more to reestablish the credit of the small farmer than you could by any other means. To my mind this section is vital. It will do no injury whatever. It will re-establish the security of the small farmer's holding to a great extent. It will put him in a better position to borrow, and it will lower the rates.

I cannot understand the point of view of people who complain of high rates, who have a good deal of pity for the farmer who has to pay direct taxation in the way of high rates, but who, at the same time, will not take this obviously right step for the purpose of saving the rates from the large number of people who, whatever their circumstances may be, do not want to pay until they are forced to pay, and there are a considerable number of people like that.

There are a considerable number of people who will not pay their rates if they think they can get away with it. The same applies to Land Purchase Annuities. The mere threat of this has already had a most salutary effect. It has made the wheels go round. You will not have a healthy state of affairs in this country until people realise that they must pay their debts. If the small farmer realises that he must pay his debts he, in turn, will make his debtors pay him; he, in turn, will look after the shopkeeper's pass-book. You will have complete co-operation through the country to get us back to the cash basis that is needed so badly. At present the country is run on credit to the extent of 20 per cent. Until we get to a cash basis and get rid of this slovenly system the country will not be what it should be. I am in a position to keep my hand on the pulse, so to speak, of the country; I am in a position to know the conditions in my own county, and I know from the Collection Branch and from auctioneers and solicitors the conditions under which land has been set, and the mere threat of this section has been more than salutary. I regard it as absolutely vital.

Comment on this

I fear I am in disagreement with Deputies on these Benches on this question. To me the whole question is personal, because I happen to be the trustee of a certain fund, and because I have a considerable amount of money in that fund. For six years people got the benefit of that fund and never paid a copper. I recognise that there are a certain class of men in this country who are probably as near an approach to rogues as there are anywhere, and that law is needed for them, and if it is only needed for one man I will stand for its enforcement.

Comment on this

One would have to assume from what the Minister said that he accepted it that every man who owed arrears had cash to pay.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

On a point of explanation. This is not the first or the second or the third time that Deputy Baxter has said that. I have never said that everybody has cash to pay. But the Deputy's contention, if it means anything, means that nobody has cash to pay annuities. I go this far and say that there are a large number of annuitants who, regardless of whether they can or cannot pay, do not want to pay.

Comment on this

If the Minister was able to give us a section which would make it possible to discriminate between the man who could pay and would not, and at the same time put him in the position of being able to make up what the Land Commission was entitled to get from a third party, who is actually co-operating to enable the defaulting annuitant to retain his money, one could agree that there might be some case for this section. But we know the condition of the country. It may be true that there are a number of annuitants who refuse to pay for some reason, perhaps because some of them are not honest. But there are great numbers of annuitants who are not able to pay and who are honest; the Minister knows that, and so does everybody on the Government Benches.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Does the Deputy suggest that we should give up attempting to collect the annuities from them? Let him say it straight out.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not say anything of the kind.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Give us the means, then.

Comment on this

But if the means you are going to employ to get money where it cannot be got are such as will make it possible for the sheriff to commit an offence against a third party, which is a very great offence, because no greater offence can be committed against a citizen of the State than that the servant of the State can go along in the name of the State with powers given by this House to take property which the State has no right——

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Why does it not happen in regard to rates?

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister's experience is in regard to collection of rates. My experience up to the present is that the rate collector in practically all cases takes the defaulting ratepayers to the court, and even the threat of the court, if the money is there, will make it forthcoming. If the value is not there the rate collector knows enough of the conditions to know it is no use taking the defaulter to the court. I have a great number of cases before my mind during the last couple of months where rate collectors had to stump up for men who had not paid their rates. No compensation is paid if a man is not able to pay, because his lands are unstocked.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

While the land is actually stocked by a third party.

Comment on this

These lands are not stocked by anybody.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

The whole case of the Deputy is that the sheriff will seize a third party's stock. I ask why does not that happen in the case of rates?

Comment on this

Because in this particular case there is no stock.

Comment on this
Mr. HOGAN

Then he will not seize it.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It would be better if the Deputy were allowed to proceed.

Comment on this

He will not seize it. But if there were men in the district prepared to help an annuitant to live by giving him some contribution for the service of the land, owing to the very desperate conditions that exist in many districts—because the State did nothing for these people who wanted help so badly—the sheriff takes away the man's stock without trying to discover who owns it. He does not try to discover whether the annuitant is an honest man, who is not paying his rates simply because misfortune has come upon him, or is the type of man that some people are always prepared to cast up in this House—a rogue. If the Minister tells us that there are as many dishonest people in the country as he tries to make us believe, there is very little future for the country, and I think that legislation based on the assumption that there are so many dishonest people is very unsound. No matter what the Minister says, there is nobody who wants to make a plea for the dishonest man, but at the same time, in order that there may be a chance to get at the dishonest man we are not prepared to confer powers which will be used mercilessly against the honest man.

Comment on this

I think I understand this point. It is one in connection with Bills that were before the House two or three years ago which I had to consider and discuss at some length. Deputy Baxter puts the dilemma to the Minister and to the Government: Turn out a section which will discriminate between the person he chooses to call an honest man, the person who cannot pay, as he puts it, and the dishonest man who can pay but will not. The Deputy knew he was quite safe in making that offer, because he knew that the Parliamentary draughtsman never drew breath in any State who could turn out a section of that kind. "The devil himself," as some judge remarked from the Bench, "knoweth not the mind of man," and this question of the honest and dishonest man is not practical politics, it is not practical legislation. What it comes to is this: The Deputy's plea is that the man who cares to set his land need never pay his land annuity, and he can have his neighbour salted in rates because of his default. He is to be free to have the user of his land by setting it.

He can set, year in, year out, and make money from it, but he need never pay, because there is nothing seizable. The stock on the land is not his, and so the default mounts up in the county and the ratepayers are salted in rates for the default of the land annuitant. The provision exists, as the Minister said with regard to rates, that stock on the land is assumed to be the stock of the owner of that land. The rate collector may take the stock that is on the land in quittance of rates, and the net result of that is that people are cautious, that people do not put grazing stock on land without ascertaining whether the rates are paid or not. What does that effect? That effects this: that the man who wants to set his land pays his rates and if he cannot pay out of his own pocket he sees the rates are paid out of the rent, because otherwise the stock that goes to graze those lands is in jeopardy.

Deputy Heffernan talked about innocent citizens. There may be some innocent citizens, but I doubt if there are any citizens so innocent as not to see the dilemma that it is sought to put the under-sheriff in in this matter. A man owes land annuities and will not pay. He has, perhaps, read Deputy Connor Hogan's speech in the Official Report, and he will not pay his land annuities to England, as the Deputy said. The under-sheriff in due course comes along; he goes out to that farm to seize. He makes for the speckled heifer. He is told: "Do not touch that, that is not mine; it belongs to my brother-in-law." He is paying 5/- or 10/-, or whatever the grazing rate is, and the under-sheriff is up against the problem of rebutting that statement of the man that that heifer or that the bullock is not his. The thing is absurd.

If one cannot take stock present on the land as being the property of the owner of the land, if stock cannot be treated as the property of the owner of the land, then in fact there can be no seizure of stock—and that is what some Deputies are aiming for—because it would not be within the wit of any under-sheriff in any county in the State to rebut a statement that a particular bullock or heifer, or a half-dozen particular sheep, was not the property of the owner, that they belonged to his uncle, his cousin, or his brother-in-law. Do not tell me that even in Clare a farmer would not strain things to the extent of saying that half a dozen sheep were his uncle's rather than his own if he were going to have his property by making that statement.

Deputies who are not farmers and who have not a knowledge of rural Ireland and agricultural conditions must try to put themselves into the position of an under-sheriff with a decree for land annuities in hand. They must fancy that man driving out fifteen or twenty miles from his base to a particular farm, going into a field, seeing stock there, being met by the owner—the word has passed round— and the owner has simply to say, "That is my cousin John's," and the under-sheriff must drive away. Might we not as decently write into our Bill that livestock shall not be seizable in quittance of land annuity decrees as to allow a situation of that kind to exist? Surely, we must say in respect of land annuities, as we have said long since in respect of rates, that where there is default in respect of land annuities as in respect of rates, the stock on that land shall be liable to seizure in respect of deficiency. Then you will create the same position that exists in respect of rates; people will not take lands on letting or on grazing until they are well satisfied that the land annuities, as well as the rates, have been cleared in respect of that land. That is what we want.

Comment on this

I object to this section from the point of view of the third party. We have heard about the defaulter who is a wilful defaulter and who sets his land, or who allows stock to go up on his land and receives payment for such. I desire to draw the attention of the Dáil to the drastic nature of this sub-section, as at present drafted. Under the sub-section, the Sheriff may seize goods, including stock upon the land, and even if that stock does not belong to the owner of the land, the remedy proposed for the actual owner of the stock is that he shall have a right of action against the owner of the land. Let me give a case in point. This is a case that occurred some time ago in County Wicklow, and the facts are shortly these. There were two farms adjoining one another, and the occupier of one of them was in default as regards his payments. The sheriff came along and discovered stock upon the farm. He seized the stock, assuming, as I submit, it was proper for him to assume, that the stock belonged to the owner of the farm, but when the real owner of the stock, who lived in the adjoining farm, heard of the seizure of these cattle he went down to the nearest village where the stock was impounded and had to pay £5 per head poundage to recover his stock.

There were eight animals and it cost him £40 to recover them. There was no letting contract between these farmers. The grazing rights were not set. What actually occurred was that owing, perhaps, to the faulty construction of the fence, the stock belonging to the adjoining farmer wandered on the land of the defaulter and, because the sheriff had the right to seize any stock which he found on the farm, an innocent third party had to pay £40 to have his own stock recovered and restored to him. He was told, when he asked for the return of the money he paid by way of poundage, that an action lay against the defaulting tenant, who in this case happened to be a man who had not a brass farthing, a man who was not actually a wilful defaulter but one who was not able to pay his annuities, and there are such people in the country. Is that, I ask, not too drastic a procedure? Would it not be possible to have a recoupment made in some way to an innocent third party, such as I have mentioned? Why should he have to redeem stock which belonged to him, for which he was not under any grazing contract to have placed upon the adjoining farm, by which the actual defaulting tenant was not benefiting by way of payment, and which rightly belonged to the man himself?

I think it is unfair. I do not suggest that there should not be an assumption that stock found on a farm belongs to the owner of the farm. I am not suggesting that. That is an assumption which, I think, must lie in order to carry on the affairs of the country, but, if it is subsequently discovered that this stock did not belong to the owner of the farm, and, furthermore, that there was no contract by way of letting or grazing, and that it was not even with the acquiescence of the defaulter that these cattle were there, and that he was benefiting in no way by it, I suggest that there should be some remedy for a third party other than the remedy suggested here, namely, that he should have the right of action at law against a person who in this case—and there may be others of a similar kind throughout the country—was no mark.

The position in the case which I have instanced was that this third party was at a loss of £40 and had actually to pay poundage for stock belonging to himself which was on another man's farm and for which he had no contract whatever. Viewing the matter from the point of view of a third party, I submit that in such a set of circumstances as I have stated—it is not a hypothetical case but is known to some Ministers, because I was the means of bringing it under their notice—this sub-section is too wide. I suggest in a case like this, where it is subsequently discovered that the stock has been wrongfully seized, some other remedy should certainly be provided than that which is suggested here and which, in the case I mentioned, is no remedy at all.

Progress ordered to be reported.

Comment on this