We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

ORDUITHE AN LAE. - ELECTRICITY (SUPPLY) BILL, 1927 THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–227 of 460. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electricity (Supply) Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 10 of 1927 ›

I would like to say further that I thought the Minister's justification of this section was most unsatisfactory. I think he ought to pay a good deal more attention to the difficulties under which existing contractors suffer, or may suffer, if the section goes through in its present form. It seems to me there is nothing in the section to prevent the Board carrying on the business of supplying material and wiring quite at a loss, thus preventing any fair competition between the Board and existing firms — that even quite apart from the fact that the Board will be, to begin with, in a much superior position to any existing firms, being free from rates and taxes, and they will be in immediate contact with all those who wish to consume electric current. Desiring consumers will come to them first, and they will get into immediate touch with them. In fact, everything will be in favour of the Board.

As the Bill stands at present, there is nothing to prevent the Board, as far as I can see, handing over this business to some other firm. In addition, there will be nothing to prevent them running this part of the work at a loss. It is not proposed that the accounts of this part of the work should be kept separate from the generation and transmission accounts. I think it would be a considerable improvement to the section, if it provided that the accounts dealing with this part of the Board's work should be kept entirely separate, as if it were a separate concern for the provision of electric supplies, wiring of houses and places of business that wish to get the current.

It seems to me that the section will undoubtedly be likely to do a great deal of harm to bodies with which it would be a great deal more to the advantage of the Minister to work in co-operation rather than to try to put them out of business. The Minister thinks that it will be extremely difficult for the Board, along with contractors, to do all the wiring that will be required by those who desire to get electricity. It is to be hoped that that will be the case. If it is the case, it is all the more necessary that the Minister should enable those contractors to continue doing work in which they have been engaged. Their work undoubtedly has been responsible for a great deal of the pioneer work required to make the Shannon scheme possible.

Comment on this

I was hoping that the Minister would have recognised the suitability of this amendment. I think the section is unfair to contractors generally and is a form of trading which it was recognised in the past should not be undertaken by a Government. I think it was fairly well recognised in the past, and I think the Minister must recognise it, that contractors' work was not a suitable activity for a Government Department to undertake. I think contractors outside will have a very considerable grievance if they are to compete with a State Department for work that, I think, might be left to private enterprise, as far as possible. It is difficult to recognise what a change the Bill will effect in the industrial outlook. It will remove from the sphere of private enterprise an area of operations which, in the past, industrialists looked upon as being within what might be called their province. Does the Minister forecast all the operations of the Board being done by direct trading, and that, when it is in full swing, the Board will go so far as to standardise fittings, so that it may control fittings, wiring, and all the incidental work following the full control of supplies of electricity? I find a difficulty in realising the revolutionary changes that are proposed in the Bill.

If this Bill is to be taken as a model of the development of industry under the Minister for Industry and Commerce, all the help that the Minister can give us to make us realise where we stand would be very welcome. If the programme he has outlined for the electrical industry, in so far as it recognises no intermediary interest of any sort, be adhered to by sweeping away what might be termed middlemen, whether municipal or private undertakings, coming down even to the minutiæ of the manufacture, the hire and the sale of utensils, one cannot very well see how far that will affect our every-day lives. When one sees sections of this sort inserted in a Bill, one must recognise that the revolutionary changes that took place some time ago were only the commencement of revolutionary changes in our business life. The principles which the Minister sets out to establish may have an extraordinarily far-reaching effect. I should have thought that the business of the Department of Industry and Commerce and of the Minister himself, would be to foster and assist private enterprise in every direction possible, and one must look with some surprise and with some apprehension along the road to which this Bill is apparently leading. Private contractors entered on undertakings of this kind in the belief that they were secure in carrying on their business — not secure against competition amongst themselves and amongst similar concerns but certainly secure against State interference.

The only thing that surprises me is how the Government can consistently claim to take powers, such as those given under Section 47 of the Bill, having themselves at the initiation of the Shannon scheme dealt with a firm of contractors on what I might call the broadest possible basis of contract. In regard to that particular aspect, after two years, during which the Shannon scheme has been in the course of construction, we are singularly ignorant as to the terms of the contract entered into between the Government and the Shannon contractors, but at all events we must recognise that the Government entered into that contract for the carrying out of a very big scheme with a firm founded on private enterprise. Now when we come to the distribution scheme, we find Section 47, indicating apparently the growth of State enterprise, in the same way as the Minister indicates that the operations of the Board will involve the elimination of all middlemen in connection with the generation of electricity. We must read clause 47 in the spirit that if this Board is to operate on the lines indicated, they shall have a complete monopoly of all work connected with electricity within the area of their jurisdiction. That may be reading too much into the clause, but one has to read a lot into this Bill in the light of the explanations we receive as to its outlook on the future of the industry. I, at all events, wish to enter my protest against the form which has been adopted, which will enable the Board to become not only monopolists as regards the supply of current, but monopolists as regards the supplying of fittings and everything concerned with the main operation.

Comment on this
William Norton Mr. NORTON

Deputy Hewat appears to me to have an objection to this section more on the ground that he dislikes anything that savours of nationalisation or socialisation rather than from the point of view that it is not good for the consumer. I am inclined to take the view that this section is good for the consumer. The section will enable the Board to manufacture electrical apparatus and to sell that apparatus. A Board with wide powers to do that and with considerable capital at its back will, in my opinion, be enabled to manufacture apparatus along standardised lines. By reason of its large output, perhaps in the way of a monopoly, it is reasonable to forecast that the consumer will get the benefit of cheap electrical apparatus. If that is the position — and I think that is the position aimed at in the section — I cannot, looking at the matter from the consumer's point of view, see any objection to the section, and I venture to say that Deputy Hewat cannot make a case against this section from the consumer's point of view. It seems to me, from the point of view of assisting in the elimination of a lot of unnecessary competition and unnecessary overhead expenses, this section is useful, inasmuch as it enables the Board to manufacture on a large scale, to develop standardisation, and in that way to cheapen the supply of electrical apparatus for consumers. If that be the intention of the section, I personally do not see, and I do not think my party will see, any objection to a provision which enables the Board to develop on these lines.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The last speaker has indicated the point from which I approach this whole matter. We want to give the electricity consumer, current and everything to do with current, as cheaply as possible. If you take the ordinary account that a man pays for electricity, you can reasonably divide it into four parts. One part of his payment would be for generating cost, or in the case of the Shannon scheme, it would be generating cost, plus transmission cost; the second part of the payment would be local distribution cost; the third, the cost of wiring his house; and the fourth would be the cost of supplying appliances or apparatus for the use of electricity. In every one of these four things, the Board will be in a position to give a better and a cheaper service than anybody in the country, and that is the aim.

Comment on this

I think there is a misconception there. The consumer at present wires his own house; the local authority does not wire it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

He wires his own house, and he pays for it. In future, if he can wire at a cheaper rate than at the moment it will be because the Board will give him facilities he is not now getting. In every one of these four divisions — generating cost, plus transmission cost, local distribution cost, the wiring of the house and the cost of the apparatus — the Board is going to be in a position to give a cheaper service than anybody can at the moment. That is what we are aiming at. I am attacked on this section from two different angles. Deputy Hewat and Deputy Thrift assert that it is going to wipe out of existence all the electrical contracting firms. I do not think that is going to be the case. Deputy Cooper, on the other hand, said that he knew of no Government department which had ever intervened successfully in a trading matter. The deduction from that generalisation is that the Board is going to lose money on it itself, and presumably the electricity contractor is going to be relieved of the competition which Deputy Hewat and Deputy Thrift think will be not merely formidable, but bound to overwhelm him.

I cannot answer both these arguments. I think Deputy Cooper's argument, that no Government department has shown itself successful in managing a trading concern, is simply a generalisation with too little material for its consideration. Incidentally, this is not going to be a Government department, so that whatever Deputy Cooper has in his mind with regard to the impediments in the way of a Government department operating a concern on business principles does not apply to this Board. But there is, more or less, a Government department, of which I have knowledge, engaging in this particular type of business, and engaging in it with the result that if you compare prices paid by the electricity consumer in Holland with prices paid here, in hardly any case will you find the consumer in Holland paying more than half what is paid for similar articles here — and that, after making allowance for the cost of living here, wage conditions, and everything else. Quite recently I had the advantage of meeting one of the three Electricity Commissioners for South Africa, who had been over here on a tour of inspection, and to see the latest development with regard to electricity. He informed me that he was going back to his own government to seek the powers which the Holland Government have given to their main electrical works — the powers given in this section — and his advice to me was — not knowing that I had the section already in my Bill — that I should reserve to myself the right to give the Board, hereafter, these particular powers. There was nothing, he said, which had led so much to the rapid expansion of electricity in Holland as the use of these powers by the authorities there.

At one time, before these powers were availed of, it was found, despite cheapness in the way of generation and distribution of electricity and apparatus for wiring, that the demand for current was, nevertheless, being stopped. On inquiry it was found to be stopped simply because appliances were not being sold cheaply. That department has made good. It could have made profits, but it has adopted the other line. Instead of making profits on the sale of appliances, and devoting the profits to the cheapening of current, it went in for the other policy — the lowering of the cost of appliances, selling them as low as seemed reasonable, and giving the consumer the benefit — through his appliances. Both Deputy Thrift and Deputy Cooper spoke with regard to the fitness of a Government department for this work. Having dealt with that, I now come back to the other point. This Board is not going to be a Government department, and whatever arguments may be used as to the rigidity of Government departments, and the minuting of opinions, and everything else that is said to prevent proper business dealings by a Government department, will not apply here.

As regards Deputy Good's argument, that this is going to result in the disappearance of all electrical contractors, I say that no reasonable forecast for five or seven years ahead can lead to that conclusion. The Board will necessarily have to engage, right at the start, in the sale of the cheaper type and more easily standardised type of appliances. The electrical contractor, in so far as he is engaging in the sale of appliances, will have plenty of scope for work in the sale of the better class of appliances — the article wanted by the person who desires to purchase, not merely an electrical appliance, but an electrical appliance which is. at the same time, an ornament. The electrical contractor will have the dearer and more exclusive end of the trade thrust upon him, because obviously there is going to be—at least, we hope there will be — a tremendous increase in the number of electricity consumers. We are going to have electricity brought into districts not served at present. We are going to have an upper section of those consumers who will want a particular type of appliance or apparatus, and the electrical contractor is going to have a very much enlarged field for his operations as a result of the Shannon scheme.

In so far as the electrical contractor is making money out of the wiring of houses let it be considered that there will have to be wired, in the next few years, one hundred and thirty-five towns, and that there will have to be one hundred and thirty-five local networks established. There will be from 100,000 to 150,000 premises to be wired and the difficulty is not going to be one party cutting out another but rather whether or not there will be enough men in the country to wire all these places.

Deputy Thrift has raised certain points of detail which are rather apart from his amendment, but on which I think I could meet him. He said it would be possible that the Board might even run this electrical-appliance side at a loss, making good the loss from some other side of its operations. I think we can meet that. I have already spoken of the separate account. I would undertake to make it quite clear that a separate account must be kept for these appliances. I do not think it would be necessary to go any further than to say that that end must meet its own outgoings—that, in the division of the work, the Board must see that there will be no loss on the appliances. Again, I would ask anybody to consider whether the Board is likely to have recourse to sales at a loss in order to make one side go.

Comment on this

Publicity would be the principal thing.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The main result of all this upon the aim at the back of the Bill would be this — that by removing a handicap in the way of dear appliances one will increase the sale of current. Certain people who might otherwise take current are prevented from doing so at the moment, simply because, when they add the whole thing together, the cost of appliances bulks rather largely in their view. The removal of that will lead to increased demand. I can definitely undertake that a separate account will be kept for this appliance side. I might even go so far as to say that I could consider it in relation to Clause 20 — that, even on this matter of sales or appliances, revenue should meet outgoings. I can consider that; I am not definitely promising it. On the further matter Deputy Thrift referred to — that the Board might delegate all this matter of sales and appliances to somebody authorised for the purpose — I could get that blocked definitely so long as it would not block the Board acting through its own agents. The Board will have to appoint a sales department to look after this. As long as the Board's sales department is not blocked, I do not mind its blocking anything else.

On the other general matter that was raised, namely, that we should aim at making the Board co-operate with electrical manufacturers rather than putting the latter out of court, I hold that within the first five or seven years as regards wiring there has to be the closest co-operation. I would draw attention to one fallacy that seems to be behind that argument. Deputies may have seen a statement in the manifesto of the electrical contractors on this very point, which is put up, presumably, for the green people who are to be met here. It is stated: "The Board is to have at its disposal an army of unpaid employees." As regards that I want to get back to Deputy Norton's point. I cannot imagine in this country any unpaid employee. The employee has to be paid by somebody, and, no matter who employs him, he has to be paid in the long run by the consumers. To say that the Board will have an army of unpaid employees means that it will have an army of employees whom it does not pay, but whom other people will pay and recoup themselves from the consumers. That has been dealt with in the newspapers, and I would just like to make that remark on it.

Deputy Hewat says that one must read a lot into the Bill, but I do not mind how much he reads into it as long as he does not say that this is to be a model of industrial development for the future. It is not to be put in such a way. It is dealing with electricity, with a particular commodity which is almost regarded as essential. There should be no deduction from it as to what is likely to happen to industrial matters generally. We had better leave industrial matters over until we meet them. No principle is established in this Bill, because it is dealing with a particular commodity, and the whole Bill must be regarded as one piece. All its circumstances must be adverted to. I do not mind, as I say, what Deputy Hewat reads into the Bill as long as he does not read into it that it is to be a sort of model for future legislation dealing with all future industrial matters.

As to the question whether the Board is going to lose on selling, I do not think that any Deputy, possibly with the exception of Deputy Hewat, believes that it will. Then again, as to the question whether the Board's operation will wipe out all existing electrical contractors, I would answer in the negative. The effect of this Bill is going to open a much bigger field for the operations of electrical contractors, but, on the other hand, there will be a big amount of work which the Board can do for the benefit of the consumer in cheapening the cost of appliances. You must keep the chain intact. The Board must be allowed to reduce the cost to consumers in four divisions — First, the generating cost; secondly, the distribution cost; thirdly, better facilities for wiring will ease the cost to the consumer; and, fourthly, the Board must have power to cheapen the cost of appliances to the bigger number of consumers who want cheap standardised appliances.

Comment on this

I gather from the Minister that in this Section 47 the word "may" has become "will." The section opens by saying "the Board may manufacture." From all we have heard from the Minister this afternoon "may" becomes "will." That makes the problem a much more serious one When I read the clause in the first instance I was rather inclined to read into it that the Board took these very wide powers and would only use them in the event of certain emergencies arising. But, from what the Minister told us this afternoon, it is obvious that the State is going to enter into immediate competition with ordinary traders. I think that that is a step that ought to be very carefully considered. If the State is going to do that in this particular department there is no reason why it should not follow the same precedent in other departments of trade.

What position is that going to put us into? Where is the ordinary business of the State? Where is that going to be carried out except by the State? If that is going to be the object of members of the Dáil in connection with carrying on the business of the State I am afraid that it will have a short life and a merry one. The Minister pointed out that the interference of the State in this matter will not in any way interfere with the work of the ordinary trader. Last Friday when we were discussing this matter I pointed out to the Minister that I was quite satisfied, from my limited knowledge of this particular department of trade, that there would be found to be a shortage of tradesmen in the very near future. It has been pointed out to the Minister that his Department should have foreseen the developments that were likely to arise in connection with the Shannon scheme and make preparations for them.

So far as I am aware, and I think I have as much information on this point as most Deputies, no such steps have been taken by the Minister or his Department to make any special preparations in advance for the large amount of work which we all expect will accrue from this Bill. What will be the effect of that on the industry of the ordinary trader? As I tried to point out on Friday, we have a large amount of work to be carried out, we have a limited amount of tradesmen, and we have competition between the trade on one side and the State on the other for the limited supply of workmen. Naturally the workmen will go to the State, which offers attractive and in many cases constant employment, so that the result will be that the ordinary trader will have to recruit his ranks from the workers of other countries or will have to go without them, and therefore go without work. That is a most unfortunate state of affairs. It will not help to push on the work, because where you have a limited number of workmen employed, either by the State or by the ordinary trading contractors, it means that you will only have the same volume of output. Therefore, any advantage that may accrue from State interference will carry with it considerable disadvantages.

Of course, the advantages which are claimed by Deputy O'Connell, who is smiling at the plums which he sees before him, will be in the way of pensions. We will swell the enormous pension list which we have had under consideration in this Dáil almost at every session. Deputy Norton will be glad, no doubt, to see a number of his supporters added to that list. That holds out attractions to those who sit on the Labour Benches, and it gets over any difficulty which they may have in their minds about State interference in trade. The Minister told us quite distinctly that it is his intention to start manufacturing certain specialities. I want to know from him whether these specialities will be of the ordinary type which we are accustomed to purchase, or will they be of a special type manufactured only by his department, and available only through it.

This is an important consideration, because I have been told that in the work carried out at Limerick there are special lamp and other fittings which can only be refitted by the present contractors, Messrs. Siemens-Schuckert. If we are going to have the same policy adopted by the Minister in this instance, it is going to eliminate all other competition and keep this work practically in the hands of his own department. These are considerations that should be looked into before we pass this section. I want to get an undertaking from the Minister that these fittings, which are to be manufactured by his department, will be standardised fittings as far as possible, and that everyone will be able to purchase, if he likes, similar fittings of some other manufacturer, and, in that way, keep these particular specialities of our own Government within a reasonable figure.

Comment on this

I only rise to ask the Minister one question, and to amplify slightly an argument which I made, or rather which I did not make but which the Minister very successfully answered. I never said this was going to be an ordinary Government department. What I did say was that it is the creation of the State financed and subsidised by the State. While it is plain from the Bill that the relations between the Board and the Dáil will be very distant and aloof it is equally plain that the relations between the Board and the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be very intimate. That was what I intended to say. I did not talk of this being an ordinary Government department. The question I wish to ask the Minister, and it cuts at the root of the matter, is, are there enough men in the country to do the wiring of these houses? As Deputy Good has said, if there are not it is the Government's fault. We have heard nothing about special courses of instruction in the technical schools for the training of electricians and nothing about an extension of the apprenticeship system. The need for them has not been foreseen. Where does the Board propose to get these electricians? Where will it get men to do the work? Is it going to take them from the staffs of the private contractors, or is it going to import them? That is a question to which the Dáil is entitled to get an answer, and it is specially a question on which the Labour Party has a right to know the answer, because if the first big experiment in State trading we are going to make is to be accompanied by a big importation of labour from outside, I am afraid that the average workman will not smile as happily as Deputy Norton and Deputy O'Connell do regarding this project and would be disposed to make them answer for it. I hope the Minister will be able to answer that question as to where he hopes the Board will get its employees.

Comment on this

I do not differ very much from the Minister or from other Deputies who have spoken. The main thing is to provide cheap electricity all along the line for the consumer. Deputy Norton seemed to me to be making a mistake in thinking that the outcome of this section will be in all probability to establish factories for electrical apparatus in the immediate future, I do not think the Minister indicated that at all. It seems to me what is far more likely to happen is a larger importation of standardised apparatus. That would not meet with Deputy Norton's point of view. I think the Minister is making a mistake when he says it is a question of electrical fittings and wiring and their cost that is of most importance in the main to the consumer in deciding whether he will take electricity or not. That is not the result of experience. As far as I know the deciding factor almost always is: "What is going to be the running cost; what am I going to pay for current when I have made myself ready to make use of it?" The most important feature, I am sure, will be the cost of the electrical unit to the consumer. The only hope for the Minister in making that cost small is to widen the area of supply, and to widen it as rapidly as possible.

I can tell the Minister that intending purchasers of electrical energy, seeing by this Bill that the Minister hopes to be able to get the wiring installation done more cheaply than by existing firms, have said: "We will not go on with our plans for installing electricity. We will wait until this Board is carrying out that function in the hope that the Board will carry it out much cheaper." It cuts at the Minister's idea of getting the supply of electrical energy taken up as quickly as possible. If he can supply current cheaply from the beginning he can increase the area of supply quickly, but if he cannot he will have to charge more for his current. If he charges more for current at the beginning he will cut down the demand. The whole importance of the scheme is that he should be able to provide current at the outset as cheaply as possible, and be able to fit up consumers for taking that current with as much rapidity as possible. I think the Minister has indicated the three important points on which he is prepared to improve the section. He has said he will prevent this Board delegating its powers. He is prepared to do that, and that is an improvement. He has said that he is undoubtedly prepared to insist on this part of the Board's accounts being kept separate from other accounts, and that is an improvement. Thirdly, he has said he will at least consider the making of this part of the Board's work as self-maintained. I think that would be also most important, because if he does not do that it would possibly lead to what I think we would want to prevent, namely, this becoming a real monopoly to the detriment of the interests of the consumers. If others were cut out of the field, then the Board will be able to charge what price it likes, and that, I think, would not be anything else but detrimental to the consumer's interests.

However, the Minister said on the last day that he is not attracted by the amendment in the form in which it is put. I do not like the whole section. The Minister said the amendment is objectionable to him, but the section is as objectionable to me, and I say that with no more offence than the Minister when he made his remark about my amendment. I would not myself press this matter to a division, but I think it is of fundamental importance the Minister should consider taking every possible step with the help, and that is what I mean by co-operation, of the existing firms to secure that the demand for this electrical energy starts as early as possible, and with as big a demand at the outset as possible. The Minister on the last day raised the question of the possibility of firms putting up prices. If he thinks about it he will see that is impossible. Our firms are not alone in competition with themselves, but in immediate competition with firms outside the State. If the consumer could get articles cheaper from abroad he would, and it would be to the Minister's advantage that he should. The essential fact is that the consumer ought to be able to get this electric energy as cheaply as possible all along the line.

Comment on this

With regard to Deputy Thrift's point about the co-operation of the Board with existing contractors, the Minister told us that the Board would only deal with the cheaper form of standardised articles in the wiring of houses, but the bulk of these fittings are of the cheaper standardised kind.

In passages, servants' rooms, etc., nobody puts in very expensive fittings. Would it be possible for a consumer to have his house partly equipped by the Board with the cheapest standardised fittings and partly by a private contractor in the case, say, of three or four rooms where the consumer might desire to have some ornamental fittings put up? Would it be possible to provide that the Board might undertake a contract for the partial work, leaving the remaining part to a private contractor. I would be glad if, when considering Deputy Thrift's suggestion, the Minister would also consider this point.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am amazed at some of Deputy Good's remarks. He talked of the additions to the army of pensioners. I do not see anything mentioned in this Bill giving power to the Board to allocated pensions to any of its officers, and therefore I cannot understand the reference to "an addition to the ranks of pensioners in the country" through the operation of this section.

Comment on this

Every man employed by the State for a number of years expects a pension.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Employed by the State? I am speaking of people employed by the Board and employed under the authority given to the Board and on which it acts. If the Deputy looks at the section dealing with employees he will see nothing in it as to the giving of pensions or gratuities to officers of the Board. Deputy Good also spoke of the manufacture of specialties. He said that the Government, meaning of course the Board, was going to engage in the manufacture of specialties. I have not said a word about manufacture so far. I know that there is a section giving power to manufacture. We discussed that on two or three other amendments, but we have been dealing the whole time with the sale of appliances.

I certainly do not remember having said anything about the power to manufacture certain special things. My idea is that at the beginning most of these items will have to be imported. I hope, however, that after the three-year period mentioned in the Patents Bill has expired that there will be a real chance for getting manufacture done in the country, because one can then insist on certain patented goods being manufactured here on a commercial scale, or else a licence taken and handed over, and obviously the recipient of the licence under the new conditions would mainly be the Board. Deputy Good, and also Deputy Cooper, referred to the negligence of my Department with regard to the preparations for the tremendous outbreak of work that there is going to be in connection with the wiring of houses. There will be a division of the work that is ahead. There is going to be a very big period in which an effort will have to be made to get many houses wired for the first time, and to get the first big load of appliances supplied. It will be mainly as regards wiring that men will be required. I do not know that it would be considered a sound thing to set about the training in the ordinary way, say, of five thousand men for a period of very intensive work that would only last about two and a half years. What has got to be done is to see that the bigger normal requirements in the way of skilled workmen arising out of the Shannon scheme will be provided for. That will be done and can be done quite easily. When I speak that way I desire to make it plain that I cut out the number of people who will be engaged on the preliminary wiring of, say, these 100,000 premises that have to be tackled right away, but once wired there will be the bigger field of operations year by year in the matter of normal repairs, refittings and so on. All that has to be met, and we have the intention of meeting it.

Comment on this

No steps have been taken so far to train men.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is the Deputy's statement.

Comment on this

I would like to have it from the Minister himself.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Are all the available skilled men now employed?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Good has made statements about pensions and the manufacture of specialities both of which were quite wrong. He now comes along with the statement that no steps have been taken to train men. Deputy O'Connell made the apt retort that there are certain skilled men without employment at the moment. I do not want to be taken as accepting Deputy O'Connell's statement as a complete retort to Deputy Good, but at least it answers him in part, and even if I were to admit that not a single thing has been done up to date, does that mean that men will not be trained to meet the normal additional requirements that will arise as from 1929? Deputy Cooper referred, more definitely, to the number of men required almost immediately for these 100,000 premises. I should say that the Board will have to train a lot of them. In fact, I think it is the only way in which it can be done. My Department, obviously, could not do it. Neither could one start specialised courses in technical schools for men who have to be trained in a quick way. We have models in Sweden where, following a particular extension, a big number of consumers were added, and a big number of premises were wired in a very quick way. That was done by giving training to a number of people by means of a course that extended to about 200 hours. We are not yet within the 200 hours of the outbreak of this intensive period of work, and between now and when the wiring has to take place there will be plenty of time to have the men trained. I should say that ordinarily the training will have to be done by the Board where it is not being done by the electrical contractor at the moment. Remember that there is another side to this. If a Government department is to be criticised for negligence in dealing with a business almost entirely outside its scope, what about the electrical contractor who must have been looking forward to this particular big increase in his business? We hear nothing as to whether he is taking any steps to get extra men trained or even whether he is taking steps to secure the trained men in the country at present and see if they could help in the training of the men required for the immediate rush of work that we will have in about a year's time. Deputy Cooper said that the Board would simply be a Government department. He said that he knew of no example of success achieved by a Government department in dealing with a business proposition like this.

Comment on this

I went on to say that the Board was not a Government department, but that it was rather the creation of the State.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Surely when the Deputy used that argument in relation to this section the indication was that he was thinking of the Board as a Government Department. My answer to him is this, that so far as there are any disabilities supposed to be about a Government Department engaging in business, that is the very thing we have tried to prevent here. We are putting the Board at arm's length. We are giving it tremendous freedom to make its charges and rates. We are giving it as complete independence as anybody could desire, and the only person who tried to put any hindrance on that was Deputy Cooper by the introduction of his amendment dealing with the Comptroller and Auditor-General. By the introduction of that amendment, the Deputy was imposing on the Board the very obstacle to which he now objects.

Deputy Thrift has asked me to state what I am prepared to consider by way of amendment in connection with this section. In addition to what I have already stated, I want to make one further distinction. In connection with the delegation of powers, it must be remembered that at the moment under the 1911 Electricity Supply Act any local authority authorised to supply electricity may provide or let for hire and may connect, repair, maintain and remove electric lines and fittings. I do not say it proposes to take away that power from any authority which has it at the moment. Dealing with delegated powers, I am only speaking of the special powers which the Board is here being given. I would consider the idea of not having that delegated to anyone else.

Comment on this

That is what I want.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Certainly. Deputy Thrift's other remark reminds me of a letter that I read to-day. He dissented when I said that the costs of fittings and appliances might prevent one anxious to have electricity from getting it. I did not say that by any means that that is the deciding factor in the majority of cases. I did say that you would find an individual who, looking at his prospective bills for wiring and appliances, would say "that is the last straw."

I read to-day a letter in one of the daily newspapers, where a correspondent writes to say that he had attempted to get his house wired, and taking it per point it cost him fifty shillings where he could get it in England for fifteen. That is a thing I want stopped and that is why we want the Board to have extra powers.

Comment on this

If he had read the electrical contractors' paper of the same date he would have seen, by a curious coincidence, a statement that in England labour costs in connection with electrical fittings amounted per point to between 10/- and 15/-. That does not seem to corroborate the letter.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not want to go into that point but I could give examples in another country of wage costs being pretty much the same as they are here. The comparative figures of wiring per point would be in the region of 25/- here and about 12/6 in the country I am talking of. There is no doubt that there is a certain amount of leeway to be made up in the matter of wiring. I noticed Deputy Thrift said it would be an undesirable thing to allow the Board to get into the position of having driven everybody else out of the electrical appliances trade because it could charge them whatever prices it liked. That drew a murmur of applause from Deputy Good. Deputy Good was in support of this amendment and of the appointment of an electrical contractor who would stereotype prices in this country. The Board would have to follow and Deputy Good also said he adhered to that.

Comment on this

I understood we were discussing the clause.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

My memory is not so short that I cannot remember what the Deputy said on the amendment; it was to be the first example of statutory price-fixing and if the electricity contractor wanted to raise his prices the morning after the amendment was passed by 100 per cent., all the Board could do was to follow behind.

Comment on this

I pointed out the fallacy of that argument. It is entirely controlled, in my mind, by access to other countries of supply. No consumer would purchase here if he got the same articles at a cheaper rate across the water.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There is a reaction to Deputy Thrift's argument in that prices are fixed not in Ireland but in England. The stuff comes in from England, and this clause was to put us on the same footing as the English wholesaler. If he rises his prices the Board will have to follow. As far as these fittings are concerned, things come in from England, and if the English wholesaler wanted to raise his price 100 per cent. all our Board could do was to follow behind.

Comment on this

You take Germany, which is not England.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

However, that is the situation put up to me. That seems to meet Deputy Good's approval, and now he "hear-hears," and there is hinted a danger that the Board will wipe out everyone else. The Board has no such incentive. It would be cutting its own throat if it were to cheapen electricity to the consumer, to cheapen electrical distribution costs and then to proceed to charge exorbitant prices for appliances. It would not be carrying out its own functions. I do not say I have understood Deputy Cooper's point, but I do not see anything in the clause here to prevent the Board allowing a contractor to engage in business or to supply portion of the appliances, if the contractor likes to come in and deal in articles that the Board is not going to deal in. Obviously a situation such as this will not arise. On the question of contracting, I do not know if the Deputy would desire to have anything in here as that the Board should contract out with regard to articles to the electrical contractor. If he desires that, I can give it consideration. What I can do is to discuss that with him further.

Comment on this

I intended to convey that to the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy asked would it be possible for the Board to allow a contractor to do portion of the wiring.

Comment on this

And portion of the supply of appliances?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not see anything to prevent it doing so, but it is at the Board's discretion as the Bill stands. I do not know if the Deputy wants that changed.

Comment on this
Alfred Byrne Mr. ALFRED BYRNE Independent

The Minister did not reply to the point made by Deputy Good about creating a monopoly for the products of any one firm in the way of supplying fittings or goods to be used in the country. For instance, will those fittings be of such a nature that they will take the lamps manufactured by three or four companies so that whoever gets his house fitted will not be limited to any one contractor for the supply of lamps? What the man who is not in the trade calls the "two-plug lamp" is made by several firms in America, Germany and Great Britain. We have them on the market here, and can buy them at various prices. I want to know whether the cables, fittings and wiring generally will leave it open to consumers of electricity to be able to buy lamps from any of those different firms; in other words whether the fittings would be of such a nature that they will take lamps in use generally? We have a single screw-in lamp with one plug in it, and if our wiring or cable put in will only take that single screw-in lamp, you are confining the manufacture of such lamps to one or two companies instead of giving the public an opportunity of buying in the best market they can. This is a point worthy of consideration. I think the Minister ought to tell us something on it, so that we shall be assured that the kind of cable or wires going in to-day, or which will go in, will not be the product of any special company, and will not leave the people in the position that they will have always to buy one type of fitting.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is for every individual to arrange for. In the case of the fitting the owner of the house has to see what the cable is, what the terminal is like, and so on. I have tried in sub-section (2) to put an impediment on the Board imposing any conditions by way of preference being given to certain things. If the Deputy is not satisfied with the existing provision he can put down an amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

I want further to know if the cable or wire will take any lamp in use to-day.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

What cable?

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

The general wiring coming in from the street to people's houses.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That will have to be arranged with the individual hereafter.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

The general street cable or wiring is what I am trying to get at.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There will be some other side to the contract.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

I hope I am making my point clear. What I want to secure is that the lamps in existence, which can be purchased at various prices, made in Great Britain, America, and Germany, will fit into those fittings that the Board may put up, and that the Board will not put up fittings giving preference to one or two companies. It is a point that ought to get further consideration, and a definite declaration should be made on it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Definite declarations are no good to anybody. If the Deputy is not satisfied and wants to get something into the Bill, let him propose it.

Comment on this

The Minister is not going to answer the point.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is very hard to answer a point that I have not understood.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Is it not the case that it is for the person who is getting his house wired to say what kind of fittings are to be put in?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is one side of the Deputy's case, and I think that is the answer to that.

Comment on this

Did the Minister say that I pretty fairly stated the points?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes, the three points.

Comment on this
Division

Question put—"That Section 47, as amended, stand part of the Bill."

Tá 40
·
Níl 10
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I should like to ask the Minister whether, so far as goods that are to be sold in these shops are concerned, Section 83 will apply to them? Will the Board be in a position to sell articles free of customs duty on which other dealers will have to pay customs duty? If so that would manifestly be an unfair and inequitable provision, and I hope it is not the case.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have the intention of deleting Section 83 if I am allowed.

Comment on this

I raised a question with the Minister with regard to the standards which are being erected for carrying the mains. Would that come under this section?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is not to be done by the Board, and will never be done by the Board.

Comment on this

What particular section will it come under?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

A particular section of the 1925 Act.

Comment on this

There is no section in this Bill under which we could discuss that?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. That has reference to the transmission system which is not dealt with in this Bill, so far as its construction is concerned.

Comment on this

Wayleaves here would not count?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. That has nothing to do with the Board. The Board will have nothing to do with the erection of the transmission system of the Shannon works. I am entirely responsible for that, and may hand it over to the Board, but that will be after the wayleaves have been acquired.

Comment on this

One will have to consider some means of discussing that particular question.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

A way can be found.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 69: —

In sub-section (1), page 29, line 56, after the word "charge" to insert the words "(including provision for any expenses necessarily incurred by such undertaker in taking such supply in bulk)."

This is a concession to the undertaker and as such, I presume, will be accepted.

Comment on this

I should think the undertaker in that case is thankful for small mercies—they are very small.

Comment on this

In fact they are doubtful mercies.

Comment on this

I move amendment 70: —

In sub-section (1), page 29, line 56, to delete the words "equal to or."

This amendment provides that the Board, in order to compel undertakers to take power from the Shannon, shall provide it at a rate cheaper than the cost of generation involved in the undertakers' own works. I have a prophetic feeling that when I have moved the amendment Deputy Hewat will get up and reproach me by saying that all these safeguards are no good, because the undertakings are doomed. If that is so, if the mute with the bow-string— perhaps I ought to apologise for calling the Minister a mute—is standing over the Rathmines undertaking, the Minister might at least grant its dying wish, and one of its dying wishes is that it should not be compelled to take power unless that power is provided more cheaply than it could provide it itself. It is not an unreasonable proposition. If you are asking such an undertaking to scrap its generating sections, to discharge its employees, and generally to go out of business, you ought to be able to offer it some advantages, and a provision that the cost should be less than the cost of their own electricity, seems to be the fairest and most reasonable way of doing it. If the Minister is in the mood for meeting some of the wishes of the authorised undertakings, I hope this may be one of them.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The dying wish seems to be, in a lot of cases, the wish that the Shannon scheme should die at the same time. I think the wish that is at the back of the minds of some people is that if an undertaking is to perish in a particular locality it is going to die happily if it can, at the same time, drag down the whole Shannon scheme. Let us come to the merits of this matter: The Deputy says an undertaking is to be asked to scrap its generating plant and to pay off the employees who are in the generating station. Here is the proposition: Imagine a case in which Shannon current is going to be supplied at the same rate as an undertaking generates it; that that undertaking ought to be allowed to go on generating current notwithstanding the fact that the State has sunk over five millions of money in the Shannon undertaking; that despite that, and despite the fact that it offers to supply current on equal terms to the undertaking, still the undertaking should be allowed to carry on at its own station. I think that is an unreasonable proposition.

Comment on this

I do not think so in the case of authorised undertakings which are themselves public bodies. There is not the same amount of money sunk in these undertakings, but, at the same time, there is money of the ratepayers sunk in those undertakings, and it is only reasonable that they should have a fair and equal deal. The Board will have enormous advantages as a bulk proposition. But what are the advantages of the Shannon scheme if it is not going to supply electric current more cheaply than the existing undertakings?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It will.

Comment on this

Why object, then, to the amendment?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Because it is absurd on the merits.

Comment on this

The Minister's ideas of absurdity and mine are different, but we will agree to differ on that point. It is of no great importance, because the undertakings are to be swallowed up, but it might have some temporary importance, and I urge it as a temporary provision.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The cost of generation comes in, in this way, and in any of these things it is going to be got back off the consumer. You are going to have a consumer in a particular locality, and the question is, what is that portion of his cost going to be which is represented by the generating charges? The Board is in the position of being able to say "We offer at so much," and the undertaking can say "We generate at exactly that price." Its costs are arranged after a whole lot of things have been added on, and the question is, what item is it to be allowed to be charged to the consumer as generating cost? Whatever it is, the Board can supply it at the same cost. The cost to the consumer will not be increased by one iota, and the ratepayers' money is not being put out of commission to one single penny. Everything is carried on as before, and the Board offers at exactly the same cost as the undertaking proves it can generate at. But in the background there is this fact always to be weighed, that is, if the Shannon scheme does not get a sufficient load taken from it in bulk, that is if a sufficient amount of units are not taken from it, then there is to be a loss on the Shannon undertaking. You are balancing any possible loss in the case of a local undertaking taking its supply from the Shannon against a considerable loss if the Shannon cannot sell to the undertaking. I think the merits are entirely in favour of leaving the words as they are in the clause.

Comment on this

This amendment cuts at the root of the whole proposition and emphasises the compulsory nature of the Bill as regards the Shannon scheme's capability of supplying current on advantageous terms. Deputy Cooper obviously was speaking for Rathmines electricity works. Assuming for a moment the local body had some inclination to support a national undertaking, but over and above the inclination that they would like to have a say in their own affairs, if the Shannon supply were offered to them on equal terms it might not appeal to them as a good and proper reason to execute their own concern. I do not think that the Minister has made much of a case on the lines that he has indicated and on the lines of development that have already been started of going to districts where there is no electricity at present. I think he has indicated that there is not very much difficulty, or, possibly, none at all that he can foresee, of not only getting the output of 110,000,000 units that has been laid down, but considerably in excess of that.

Surely it is not too much to expect that a big national scheme such as this should be in a position to offer a supply to Rathmines at a rate lower than that at which Rathmines is at present able to generate. I should imagine that the Minister might very well accept that position, because if the power cannot be delivered in bulk to Rathmines under their present generating price then the whole scheme, as a commercial proposition, will be a failure. There is not very much use in labouring the position as regards any one particular station when we have in the Bill the principle that nobody is to be allowed to generate electricity within the Free-State and that the supply must all come from the one source. But I do say that the Minister ought to show his faith in his own statements regarding the outlook by giving people liberty, if they do not get advantage from the bulk supply of the Shannon, to generate electricity themselves.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am asked to agree to a thing I describe as being absurd on the merits in order to show faith in something. I am really showing very little faith in people and in their ability to manipulate figures by putting in the proposition that at any time it would appear that the cost of generating from the Shannon and from a local undertaking would be the same the supply shall be taken from the Shannon. When you are getting down to the region of .5305 of a penny it will not be very hard to show that the last figure of that can be reduced by a point and thereby be brought down below the cost of the station. That is hardly worth arguing about, it is so unlikely to occur that the price will be exactly the same. And, of course, in connection with Rathmines, the whole cost of the Shannon works would have to be three times what it has been estimated at before the figure would approach anything like the Rathmines generating cost. It does not come into the calculation. You might have some place like Killarney coming into the calculation, and that is the one place I had in mind. But on that basis I am supposed to give in to something in order to give Deputy Hewat proof of my belief in the Shannon, which proof he would not accept and which would have no effect on any of his arguments hereafter, and in order to do it I am to accept an amendment for which no case has been made. The consumer will be charged a price, one portion of which will be made up of generating costs; the undertaker will say that that portion is such and such, and the Shannon Board will say: "We can supply at the same price." There is no handicap on the consumer, there is no handicap on anybody. But if there does happen to be that extraordinary state of things that the cost is the same as in the case of the Shannon, then the Shannon may suffer, and if the Shannon suffers the community suffers. On the other hand, the undertaking will not be penalised to any degree if we say: "If the Shannon costs are equal to your generating costs, then you shall take your supply from the Shannon."

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (1), line 60, to delete the words "the Board" and substitute therefor the words "an arbitrator appointed by the Chief Justice of Saorstát Eireann."

This point occurred last week, and I protested against the appointment of an arbitrator by the Minister. I protest much more strongly against the Board acting as their own arbitrator, as this section provides. The section says: "in default of agreement by the Board." The Minister has informed us, not later than to-day, that the Board will not be a Government Department.

If the Board were a Government Department I would be more inclined to accept this sub-section, but the Minister definitely says that it will not be a Government Department. It will be a business department, and the Minister seeks to place the Board in a position to arbitrate between itself and an undertaker. I contend that this is much more unfair than previous sections which empower the Minister to appoint the arbitrator.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I wonder if Deputy Myles realises what his arbitrator would have to decide. It is not a question as to whether the bulk supply is being offered at the same as or less than the generating cost, but, after that fact is determined, such terms and conditions taken on such terms and conditions as may be agreed, or in default of agreement, the terms and conditions offered by the Board. In other words, Deputy Myles wants to set up an arbitrator to say that the Board must sell at this, that or the other figure, a determination having previously been come to on the question: Is the Board offering at the same as or on less terms than those at which the undertaking can itself generate? I do not know if any department having to do with sales would permit the price at which it sells anything to be determined by some authority other than itself. This is the ordinary basis: You agree about the price, or if you do not the Board says: "There is my price," and as long as it is under or equal to that at which the undertaking itself generates the undertaking is forced to take it. There is no harm in that, and it is not being penalised. If the undertaking gets the slightest remission it is benefited by the Shannon scheme.

Comment on this

Why talk about agreement at all? Why not say the whole thing shall be determined by the Board beyond yea or nay?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy has put a rhetorical question.

Comment on this

You say it shall be determined by agreement.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Who else is it to be determined by except the Board and the undertaking to whom it is going to sell? I am afraid the Deputy does not understand the question.

Comment on this

I am afraid not.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is not the question of an arbitrator. It is not whether or not the price is equal to or less than what the undertaking can generate at, but it is, that fact having been determined, and the implication of that having been decided, that the undertaking must take from the Board. It goes on to say what it shall take it at, either the price to be fixed by agreement or, in default, the price settled by the Board. In other words, the Board says: "Here is my price. It is either equal to or less than what you generate at yourself. That being determined you have to take it from the Board at such and such a rate."

Comment on this

Does not that end the matter?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It does not end the matter. That is where the Deputy has not yet understood the thing. It does not end the matter. The first point is, is the Shannon bulk supply offered at a greater cost than the undertaking generates at? That having been determined, the Board cannot sell to that undertaking. If it is less the Board can sell. As between the cost at which the undertaking is generating itself there may be any number of prices, any number of lowerings below its own cost, and every one of these lowerings represents an improvement in the position of the undertaking in getting its supply from the Shannon scheme. Obviously this agreement is a matter of offer and acceptance. It is an ordinary sale. If they can agree to a price then that will be the price. If they cannot agree the Board says "There is my price; that price represents an advantage except in the peculiar case of its being equal to the generating cost of the undertaking." Where it is less it represents an advantage to the undertaking.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

This is the same point as we had last week and I have nothing to add to what I then said. I think it is only right when an Act of this Dáil provides for a certain arbitrator that that arbitrator should be appointed——

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That was settled in amendment 51.

Comment on this

I move amendment 74:—

To delete sub-section (4) and substitute therefor the following sub-section:—

In this section the expression "costs of generation" shall mean the cost of the current at the generation station of the undertaker and shall include all sums paid for fuel, stores, salaries, wages, repairs to and maintenance of generating machinery, but shall not include any sum for capital charges, and the expression "rate of charges" shall include the cost of bringing the bulk supply from the Board's line to the distribution centre of the undertaking, and the cost of transforming the supply to the type and pressure of the supply of the undertaker.

The Minister has already two amendments to this section which to my mind are not as clear as an Act of the Dáil should be. I have put my amendment in as clear language as possible. Taking the cost of generation first I think that the amendment very fully explains itself. It must be recognised that the capital charges in this case should not enter into the account when putting the price of the bulk supply against the price of the supply generated in the undertaker's station. Therefore, I will go on to the rate of charge and what it means. The transmission lines from the Shannon will come close to some towns. In the case of others they may pass within two, three, five, or even ten miles. That will be a very serious item. I would like the Minister to tell us definitely that the cost that he will put up against the local supply people will include the cost of bringing the supply from the nearest point of the main transmission line. It is not only a question of bringing it to the bus bars or the distributing points of the existing station, but the question of transformers comes in. Who is to pay for the transformers? Who is to pay for the cost due to the loss of efficiency in the transformers? These are matters that perhaps the Minister will, in his usual style, tell us are very small items. But people with electrical knowledge are well aware of the fact that these losses do exist and that they are very serious items in the year's working.

There is another very important question that enters into this amendment. It is a question that we will meet later, but it is no harm to deal with it now; in fact, it is necessary to deal with it now, in estimating the different costs; that is, the type of pressure in the local generation station. I am perfectly sure that a great many members of this Dáil are not well up in what might be called the technical points of the Bill. The Bill has been talked of, many a time, as a technical Bill. I do not agree that it is any such thing. I think the Bill is one with a few technical points in it, and only a few. I will try to explain the point that I wish to bring out in regard to this pressure business. Deputies may not be aware of the difference between alternating current and direct current. The Shannon scheme will generate alternating current, and it is a well known fact that alternating current can be transformed much more efficiently to a lower pressure, still alternating current, than it can by converting it to a direct current. On the one hand the transformer consists of a very simple apparatus. It is stationary—no moving parts. You have a series of coils of wire which change the energy from high pressure to low pressure.

The losses due to inefficiency in these transformers is very small compared with the losses that would be incurred in changing to direct current. In the case of a change to direct current a different type of machine would be necessary, a machine that would have revolving parts, that would require constant attention, oiling, cleaning, and general tuning up, with its attendant expenses, and it would add very considerably to the cost of what the supply would be as delivered to the distributing points of the undertaker. But worse even than the expenses incurred in this case would be the loss of efficiency in this particular machine. The loss of efficiency, I venture to say, would be in or about 20 per cent. That would be an enormous difference when estimating the cost of the bulk supply and the local supply. I think it is up to the Minister to put all these facts before us. Who is going to pay all these things? Who is going to be at the expense of these sub-transmission lines, rotary converters, and ordinary transformers? Those are matters upon which we would like some information.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have already amended the section, inserting after the word "charge" the following words "(including provision for any expenses necessarily incurred by such undertaker in taking such supply in bulk)." The question as to whether or not the rates included in that item are equal to or less than the cost of generating by the undertaker will be determined by the arbitrator. I hold that that meets the second portion of Deputy Myles's amendment — the portion that deals with the rate of charge.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

took the Chair.

Comment on this

I take it, then, you are accepting the principle that the Board should pay for all?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am accepting my own amendment. It will leave all these things as to whether there are any expenses necessarily incurred by an undertaker to be determined by the arbitrator. I do not think it is necessary to go into all these technical matters here. If people are satisfied that it is a question that ought to be threshed out, I suggest that should be done at another time. Personally I do not think it will ever come to be threshed out. It is the most academic discussion the Dáil has had for quite a long time. It is really dealing with a situation that may never arise. I can see three or four undertakings where even an approach to a case can be made and, even throwing all the things Deputy Myles has spoken of into the balance against the Board, there will be no doubt as to the cost of generation and the supply in bulk from the Board having to be taken by undertakers in the Free State.

Comment on this

It is only when we put these things up to the Minister that we get this information. Even his own amendments are very vague, and they do not convey information to the same extent as the amendments we put up.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The phrase, "including provision for any expenses necessarily incurred by such undertaker in taking such supply in bulk," covers everything the Deputy has put up and for which a case can be made. I do not say the phrase covers everything that the Deputy will put up. It is really a waste of time and a waste of effort to touch now on this question of generating costs. I wonder does Deputy Myles believe that there is going to be a very large number of instances in which there can be any approach to arguing on this matter as to the costs between the Shannon supply scheme and the local undertaker?

Comment on this

We have no means of knowing. We have not the faintest idea of what the costs will be.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This is something like the amendment put down by Deputy Hewat. Deputy Hewat casually put down an amendment to increase the period from 1932 to 1942, simply because he had no idea when the scheme would be remunerative and he was anxious to find out. Now Deputy Myles, who has nothing at the moment to go on with regard to an increase in the Shannon costs, puts forward this amendment. The Deputy has, in fact, my definite statement that I would think it my duty to come before the House and let Deputies know when the estimated costs were going to be increased. Despite my statement to that effect, and the fact that I had not come before the House to indicate any increase, we nevertheless, get this amendment and a long statement. Why, one would have to get to the region of fifteen millions before one would get a bulk supply cost about which there could be any argument on a comparison with the local undertaker and his generating costs.

As regards the second part of the amendment, I believe that what I have put down meets everything that should be properly met. There is the proviso that any expenses necessarily incurred by an undertaker in taking supply in bulk are to be decided by an arbitrator. The first part of the amendment sets out that the costs of generation shall mean the cost of the current at the generation station of the undertaker, and shall include all sums paid for fuel, stores, salaries, wages, repairs to and maintenance of generating machinery, but shall not include any sum for capital charges. In so far as there is a positive side of that, I think it is already met; in so far as it has a negative side, in that it shall not include any sum for capital charges, there is reason in saying that such capital charges as remain to be borne by the undertaker after taking a bulk supply should not enter into the count. Those should not be added to the cost of generating in the local undertaking. Again, I think that would be one of the matters to be considered, and would necessarily be considered in a whole calculation, and would be brought into the count by the arbitrator if a dispute arose.

On the single matter that there shall be definite advertence to the fact that certain capital costs remain to be borne and that those, if they are outstanding, should not be totted up in the count of the costs of generation at any station, I would agree. On the other hand, there is an item which may have to be brought in. People forget, in talking about the Shannon and its bulk supply, the very big item of the elasticity of the Shannon supply. It prevents any moneys having to be expended for an increase of plant in a local undertaking. That would have to be set against capital charges that remain to be borne by a local undertaker. The particular item I have spoken of is very hard to get into a section. The main points of Deputy Myles's amendment, leaving out the single item of capital charges which may have to be attended to in a more precise phrase, are met by amendments 69 and 72, which have been accepted. They meet everything the Deputy seeks to cover and which should reasonably be met. The determination as to whether it is equal to or less as between the Shannon costs and local costs is to be determined, if any dispute arises, by an arbitrator. That leaves the position fairly clear.

Comment on this

The position being "fairly clear" still, a little elaboration is required, and I think the amendment endeavours to get it. The Minister does not dissent from the terms of the amendment; therefore, I cannot see why he objects to taking it to his bosom.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The words "necessarily incurred" are the ones I went on.

Comment on this

The amendment deals with rather a contentious matter, the cost of generation. It is a very indefinite term, but the amendment endeavours to explain what is meant by it. In various undertakings they deal with what is called "cost of generation" in different ways and bring in very different results. The amendment would be a guidance to the arbitrator who is brought in to deal with the matter. Of course, the Minister has stated that, even if the cost of generation or of the load was considerably lower than it is at present in some undertakings, still, that would be overshadowed by the Shannon supply. I wonder if the Minister is right in that statement. I wonder has he taken everything into account.

As an example, I would like to make some reference to a concern in which, as most Deputies are aware, I am interested — the Tramways Company. I do not think the Minister will dispute the fact that the margin at the generating station at Ringsend, and the price at which power from the Shannon scheme is likely to be offered to them, will show such a difference as to make it obvious that the bulk supply from the Shannon will be the cheaper. If the Shannon supply was offered in bulk to a concern like the Tramways Company, at a price lower than that at which they could generate it, obviously that is a commercial proposition that would appeal to the Company, or to anybody of business men.

But that raises a query. What is the comparison going to be based on? What are the inclusive costs of generation at the Tramways station in comparison with the cost of the current they are going to get? The main transmission wires will come to Dublin and distribute from a certain point. Considerable cost will be involved in the transfer of the current to the Tramways Co.'s cables. Then there would be the question of the change of periodicity which will involve a considerable amount of expense. I presume these things will be taken into account between the Board and the Tramways Co. when the question arises. They are material factors as to what the calculations will be based on. The amendment appears to clear up one point. The Minister in his amendment has cleared up another point, that the total cost of giving a supply in bulk at certain points will be borne by the Board. That calculation is fairly easy and does not leave room for very much cause of dispute that a capable arbitrator could not settle.

Then comes the question of the Board's position as regards any guarantee for continuity of supply. The question of the Tramways Co. has nothing to do with this matter. I only mention it for the purposes of argument, and in order to make the situation as simple as possible for Deputies. Failing agreement between the Board and the company the arbitrator's decision fixes a certain price at which the bulk supply is to be delivered. Is there any proposal so that that arrangement shall have a guarantee of continuance? I am not thinking of a breach of faith or anything of that kind. We will assume that the Board controlling the Shannon scheme will first take the larger areas for development. They are, of course, the most profitable areas and, in that respect, the Shannon scheme is taking the most profitable end. Arising out of that the Board must and, I think, are compelled under the scheme to go further afield so as to make the current available to all and sundry. The further afield they go the more costly the supply of current must be in thinly populated areas. Are thinly populated areas to bear their own cost or will it be the policy of the Board—in so far as one can indicate any policy — to raise the price to consumers in more thickly populated districts in order to bring the price of extension and development within the means of people in scattered areas? When the Minister says that a large proportion of the authorised or non-authorised undertakings throughout the country are working on a generating cost which would be far in excess of the rate indicated in bulk for the Shannon power, is he taking into consideration the cost of development of such districts, or is he working on the basis of the cost of transmission to the areas in which this scheme will be first introduced?

It is an important question as regards relative costs when you come to a small undertaking in a distant part of the country that is at present generating at what appears in Dublin a high cost. Is it clear that with all the expenses involved in bringing current to that particular district the difference on that section as against the undertaking that is at present working is going to be as considerable as the Minister indicates? I think it will not, but that is merely a matter of opinion, largely expert opinion, which, of course, the Minister is better able to deal with than I am. But the Minister so far, has not given us any indication as to the lines on which this calculation will be made. A short time ago the Minister referred to my "absurd amendment," which, "in a haphazard way," was going to change the date from 1932 to 1942. All I can say is that if any of these absurd amendments will extract from the Minister as much information as that extracted by the despised amendment which has been rejected by the Dáil, they will have amply justified themselves.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy has made two statements, to each of which I must reply. In the first he said the Board will be compelled to go far afield. The Board will not, of course, be so compelled. The Board is not compelled to do anything in the way of supplying electricity in this sense: it will definitely not be bound to go to an area where there is no demand, so that what the Deputy has spoken of — the Board having to extend different transmission systems of various voltages or to establish local networks and then finding that they had not sales to pay for the expense of bringing and distributing current to that particular locality — will not arise.

Comment on this

In that case the area will be No Man's Land, because if the Board does not develop it no one else can.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If it is an area that can be remuneratively developed the Board will go into it. I think, of course, it will eventually go into all areas, but in the early years of the Board's activities it will not have time to make extensions into areas which would not be remunerative. It will eventually, go into such areas, but that will be after it has built up a reserve fund for that particular purpose. Deputy Hewat, speaking on another section, tried to get me to add to my bulk supply cost the interest and everything else belonging to the three and a half million now being given to the Board for working expenses. Similarly here on a question which is entirely a question of a bulk price — supply for sale in bulk as against generating cost at the station — the Deputy has talked of distribution, but there can be no question of distribution arising at this point. It simply amounts to this: is the price at which the Board offers in bulk equal to or less than a particular undertaking can generate at? The Deputy has talked of piling up costs, the cost of bringing to a particular place and of bringing to consumers in that particular place. He said that included distribution. I may have taken him up wrongly.

Comment on this

The proposal is to supply in bulk to an undertaking at a certain price. It is the cost of bringing it to that undertaker I was referring to.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is simply going back on my last two amendments. 69 and 72, bringing in two points, I think, that ought to be brought in in this calculation of the Board's price for supply in bulk and the local undertaking's home generating cost. There is no necessity to make any additional provision, with the single exception of adding to sub-section (4) something dealing with capital charges remaining to be borne by the undertaker after taking a supply in bulk offered under the section. The Deputy went on to discuss his own amendment, No. 75, with regard to tramways, but I would prefer to leave that matter until we are dealing with that particular amendment.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this

I move: —

At the end of the section to add the following sub-section: —

(5) This section shall not apply to any tramways or light-railways company in so far as such company generates current for the operation of their own system.

The Minister is quite right in saying that I anticipated this amendment in my remarks on the previous amendment. On this point, however, I would like to say that the Tramways Company is, of course, a statutory body, and under legislation already obtained they have got certain privileges and rights for generating electricity which this Bill seeks to withdraw. The offer of a bulk supply from the Shannon is a commercial question altogether, but if the Minister says that the Company will be in the same position as an authorised undertaking within the meaning of this Bill, and that the Bill extends to people who are not authorised in the ordinary way for the sale of current, then, of course, the statutory powers the company has received go by the board. What I said on the previous amendment about the cost of generation stands, and the Minister might, at this stage, indicate whether it is his intention to bring within the compulsory sections of this Bill railways worked under Acts which give them statutory authority under certain conditions. Of course, the cost of generation looms very largely for consideration in connection with this matter, but I do not think the attitude of the Minister is clear, not only in regard to the undertakings which are not in the ordinary sense authorised undertakings and which do not sell electricity but in regard to private undertakings or private plant. What is his attitude towards those undertakings and those private plants which are not operating for sale? Under a recent Tramways Bill, which is still before the House, there is provision in connection with a new line, for the Company to become authorised undertakers for the supply of current and light to the district concerned.

It is well within the knowledge of the Minister, and it will be well within the knowledge of members of the Dáil interested in Private Bill legislation, that amendments were submitted to the Committee providing that in the lighting of that district the periodicity should be brought into line with the standard in connection with the Shannon scheme. The periodicity in the case of the Shannon scheme is 50 and in the case of the Tramways Co. it is 25. That being so, it would be of interest to learn from the Minister what his attitude is towards the companies and individuals who are not working as authorised undertakers but under statutory provisions.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The section is quite clear as to that. The section refers to an offer to an authorised undertaker or a statutory undertaker and the definition of "statutory undertaker" clearly includes the Tramways Co. I was anxious to hear from the Deputy — instead of his wanting to hear so much from me — his reason for putting the tramways in a completely different position from everything else. Every authorised undertaking has definite powers given to it by Act or Provisional Order, or in some other way. These powers have been broken in upon. I was anxious to hear some argument as to why this section should not apply to tramways or light railways in so far as such companies generate current. All the Deputy did was to put a series of questions to me which, I think, I can answer simply by saying that the section refers to a "statutory undertaker," and the Tramways Co. is a "statutory undertaker" within the definition.

Comment on this

I move amendment 76: —

In sub-section (1), line 29, to delete all words after the word "Board" to the end of the sub-section, and substitute therefore the words "authorised and permitted undertakers may with the approval of the Board make similar scales for electricity supplied by such undertakers, and the Board, or any such undertaker with the approval of the Board may from time to time revise or revoke any such scale made by them respectively or any particular item therein."

The aim of this amendment is to simplify matters. Instead of having the Board go round fixing prices, I think the matter should be dealt with more or less on the lines of Local Government administration. The undertakers should be permitted to fix the charges and submit them for sanction to the Board, at the same time supplying all the necessary facts. That would seem to me to simplify the process.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not see very much difference in the methods proposed. Instead of the method proposed in the section, the Deputy suggests that the undertaker propose a scale and that the Board sanction the scale.

Comment on this

There is no catch in the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Except this: Suppose the authorised undertaker does not make a scale, there would be nothing to revise. We could alter the amendment by substituting the word "shall" for "may"—"authorised and permitted undertakers shall with the approval of the Board..." If the Deputy is agreeable, I will discuss this matter with him and see if there is any great difference between us. I think we are both aiming at the same thing.

Comment on this

Then with the leave of the Committee, I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 78:—

In sub-section (3), line 44, after the word "undertaker" to insert the words "or any permitted undertaker," and in line 47, after the word "undertaker" to insert the words "or permitted undertaker."

This point was referred to on Second Reading by Deputy Thrift. Permitted undertakers should have been brought into the section. This is an omission I should have adverted to on first draft.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 79: —

In line 64, page 30, to delete the words "as it thinks proper" and after the word "things" to insert the words "as such undertaker may require or in the absence of such requisition as the Board thinks proper."

This amendment is brought in as a result of a meeting I had with certain people who thought their interests were going to be affected by this section. They pointed out the fear they had that the control might be used really to run the plant to destruction and thereafter hand it back for the purpose of having the price fixed on the depreciated value instead of on the original value. I argued then, and I argue still, that there is a certain value, though not a great deal of value, in retaining the control section, and I think if the choice of the Board as between control or acquisition be taken out, there is really nothing to be said against the control section. This section, as amended, would mean that the scale of charges being fixed, the undertaker may serve on the Board a notice of his objection to work his undertaking under such scale, and thereupon the Board shall do one or other of two things as such undertaker may require or, in the absence of such requisition as the Board thinks proper — that is to say, either acquire the undertaking of such undertaker or take control for a period of not less than two years. The original provision was that on such objection being received the Board would do either of two things, control or acquire. Now, under this provision they will do whichever of these two things the undertaker will require them to do, and only in the absence of a requisition being received will they decide. An undertaker, on getting the scale of charges to which he objects, may come along and say: "I want to be acquired straight away and I do not want to be controlled." I think this amendment meets the point completely.

Comment on this

I move: —

In sub-section (4), line 41, after the word "ceases" to insert the words "wholly or in part."

This amendment is intended as a drafting improvement in connection with the phrase "wholly or in part" as apparently it is not safe to assume that that phrase will apply throughout the section as it stands.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

What danger does the Deputy apprehend through having the section left as it is?

Comment on this

This section applies to the question of compensating persons who would be unemployed as a result of closing down. My point is that it requires the generating station in its entirety to be closed before compensation could be given, whereas it would not be given, according to the section as it stands, if only part of the station were closed.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That I admit, but there is a further effect, which I am not prepared to accept, that if portion of a generating station be closed down the employees in the portion which remains open should not have the option of choosing between a pension and remaining at work.

Comment on this

That was not intended.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am in agreement with the amendment to this extent, that if, by reason of a generating station being closed down in whole or in part, and employees are thrown out of occupation, the first schedule should apply. I do not want the section to be put in such a form that this interpretation could be put on it, namely, that where you close a generating station in part, the employees who remain and who can get occupation in the other portion should be able to elect between getting compensation and remaining at work.

Comment on this

We have not that in mind.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Very well, the amendment could be held over, and I will get the draft altered before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Very well, I withdraw the amendment but will raise the question on Report.

Comment on this

The following amendment stands in my name:

In sub-section (4), lines 44 and 45, to delete the words "in such generating station."

As the section stands, it means that compensation would be limited to persons employed in a generating station, whereas the intention of the amendment is to give compensation to persons employed on the premises generally. There may, for instance, be persons employed by a firm who are not actually employed in a generating station.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Does the Deputy agree that disemployment would have to be due directly to closing of portion of the generating station?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then again it would be a matter of getting a draft to meet that point.

Comment on this

Very well. I will withdraw the amendment and will bring the matter up on Report.

Comment on this

I have a similar amendment, No. 83, but as the Minister has undertaken to consider the matter before the Report Stage I am prepared to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This goes much further than the previous amendment. Deputy Nagle simply wants to wipe out the words which would limit the whole section to employment in the generating station, whereas Deputy Doyle goes further and wants to enlarge it so as to include everybody in the employment of the undertaker. I agree that if somebody not actually employed in the station, but whose disemployment is directly due to the closing of the station, such a person might fall under the section. I would not like to go so far as to accept this amendment as it stands, but if the Deputy is willing to hold it over I will consider the matter before the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I hope that as a result of this section we are not going to have further additions to the pension list, which is sufficiently lengthy at present. In considering this section, the Minister should bear in mind the provision of alternative employment for these men.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think that would be agreed and that the Labour Deputies would admit that if alternative occupation could be found it would be preferable to giving compensation. The only people for whom the field of employment would be narrowed are those employed on a generating station which would be put out of commission. The employees in the generating station, of whom Deputy Nagle spoke, are provided for in the First Schedule. Where the Board does not take over control the Bill has no re-action on such employees. If the Board takes over control, it steps into the shoes of the previous employer, and whatever rights the employees had will still remain with them.

Comment on this

Where a number of skilled hands are unemployed, as a result of the closing of a generating station, why should they not be trained in some other department under the sphere of operations of the Board and be made useful citizens instead of giving them pensions? I hope the Minister will keep that point before his mind.

Comment on this

As the Minister is prepared to consider the matter mentioned in my amendment I withdraw.

Comment on this

I move: —

In line 49, after the word "lawful" to insert the words "after the Board has been established."

This amendment is merely intended to cover a possible interval that might occur between the date of the passing of this Bill and the establishment of the Board. It is quite likely that extensions might be going on when the Bill becomes law. According to the section as it stands, such extensions would have to cease until the Board was set up. I think that the amendment is necessary.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not think there is likely to be any gap. The Deputy's point is that the Board might not come into being until, say, a month or two, after the passing of the Act, and that that period should be looked to. I will examine as to the likelihood of what the Deputy fears occurring, and will see if I can meet his point.

Comment on this

I am satisfied. I think it is likely that extensions will be going on after the Act is passed. Under the section they would have to get the consent of the Board before they could proceed.

Comment on this

I move: —

In line 52, after the word "Board," to add the words "provided that such consent shall not be withheld unless there shall be a bulk supply available at a price not greater than the cost of generation by the existing or extended station in the area served or to be served by the same. Any dispute arising out of this section shall be determined by an arbitrator appointed by the Chief Justice of Saorstát Eireann."

This amendment is on similar lines to that of Deputy Professor Thrift, but it goes a little further. I put this amendment forward so that there should be no restrictions by the Board as to natural development. I am sure the Minister will say that such a thing is impossible, but this amendment would leave the undertakers in a stronger position to carry on.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Another section, 66, makes provision for the rendering of mutual assistance. That was intended as one way of meeting a case that might arise in the interval. Section 66 was put in to enable plans to be laid for mutual assistance so as to prevent money being wasted on a generating plant which would hereafter be useless. I think it is necessary the Board should have a deciding voice with regard to extensions so as to ensure that nothing would be done which would injuriously affect the Shannon transmission, either immediately or sometime in the future. I cannot imagine the Board refusing consent if it had not the supply at its disposal to offer in order to make up for the new demand. I am not sure that there is any necessity, for the words in the last two lines of the amendment are in accordance with what we have just discussed, but, again, as a matter of trying to discover what is the likelihood of the point the Deputy fears arising, I will go into the matter and see if any amendment is required.

Comment on this

I move: —

In sub-section (2), line 58, before the words "The Board," to insert the words "at the request of the authorised undertaker."

Would the Minister state what would happen in the event of a breakdown requiring immediate attention? Surely it should not be necessary for whoever was in charge of that undertaking to have to wait for plans and specifications to be passed by the Board? I think it would be in the interests of the citizens generally that whoever would be on the spot should have the power to carry on and put the machinery in proper working order, without waiting for sanction which, as we all know, is generally delayed by authorities.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy is moving to meet the question of a breakdown?

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

The section is not altogether clear as it stands. Perhaps the Minister would consider the point.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will consider the point about an emergency, and the action that would have to be taken. Obviously there could be no intention of applying Section 61 to such emergency. This is a small point, but it may require a lengthy amendment to meet it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say why the Board should make these provisions for the undertaker?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will give one reason. It is all in the interest of trying to get everything done so that the consumer may get the cheapest possible supply. Say there is a town where a network has to be designed and carried out. It may be that a contract might be made which was not really in accordance with the needs of the little locality. I think it is necessary the Board should have some control and say "That network as designed is too expensive. You can get exactly the same service at less expense." It is necessary to have an over-riding authority to say "that design does not seem to fit the needs of the locality. It is more a contractor's design than in the interests of the consumer." The point Deputy Byrne has mentioned is one I can look into, but I am doubtful if the section can be made to apply to the point. It was never intended to do so.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

Will the Minister give it consideration between this and Report?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

I take it there will be nothing in the way of maintenance or repairs in this section. Would these have to get the sanction of the Board?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

That is dealt with in a further amendment.

Comment on this

It is a question of expense. We are considering what expense will be involved. Would the Minister say, for instance, if a necessary repair had to be immediately made would that involve getting the sanction of the Board before undertaking that repair?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think the point the Deputy is dealing with might be taken when we reach amendment 86.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

I move amendment 85: —

In sub-section (2), line 58, before the words "the Board" to insert the words "at the request of the authorised undertaker."

I think that my amendment has been put in the wrong place. I meant it to be to Section 1. I really think that the next amendment in my name should be where this one is. May I say I am quite satisfied with the Minister's statement on the point I raised about emergencies. With regard to the power given to the Board to make contracts for the sale of electricity from an authorised undertaker, I do not think that the Board ought to have the power to do that without the consent of the authorised undertaker. I think it should be at his special request that the Board should step in to make contracts. As a former member of the Electricity Supply Committee of the Dublin Corporation and of the Waterworks Committee, I am aware that Government departments stepped in and tried to make special contracts which really would not have paid the concerns at the time. The Board, or the Government, as it has been referred to, would, I imagine, be more or less disposed towards Government departments, and, therefore, I do not think they should be allowed to make contracts for the sale of electricity from an authorised undertaker at a price that would not pay. I am afraid that these amendments of mine have got a bit mixed up.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy has an amendment down to sub-section (2), and I gather that that is correctly placed. He made the argument to this effect, that he thought this clause should not have relation to a sudden emergency or a break-down. I said that the clause could not refer to that, but that at any rate I would take into consideration the drafting of an amendment to ensure that the section would not have application in the case of a contract simply made to execute repairs or deal with a break-down emergency. The Deputy wants to make some special argument in relation to sub-section (2) more than that relating to the break-down. I would like to hear that argument.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

I hold that the Board is given the power to make contracts for the sale of electricity by an authorised undertaker. I do not think the Board should be allowed to do that without the invitation of the authorised undertaker. I think that the latter should be permitted to make his own contracts and that the Government should not interfere.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I presume, then, that what the Deputy wants is to have something like this inserted: "The Board may after consultation with the authorised undertaker." We are dealing with sub-section (2) now, and I would agree to consider an amendment somewhat on the following lines: "The Board may after consultation with the authorised undertaker make these contracts." That is lessening the matter a little, but is not going the full way with the Deputy.

Comment on this
Mr. BYRNE

I move amendment 86: —

To add at the end of sub-section (4) the words "Provided that this sub-section shall not apply to expenditure for purposes of ordinary repair and maintenance."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If what the Deputy means by this amendment are repairs and break-downs, then I am prepared to look into that. His amendment, however, also speaks of maintenance. I do think that there is a necessity for allowing power to supervise the execution of works which may be described as maintenance works.

Comment on this

I take it that the amendment means the maintenance of ordinary everyday work. I think that maintenance work of that kind ought not to come under the supervision of the Board.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Deputy will read the sub-section he will see that it only refers to expenditure in respect of the construction, the re-construction, extension, equipment or re-equipment of any works used by such authorised undertaker. Would re-equipment bring in what the Deputy means? I do not think so.

Comment on this

I think the amendment is only intended to give the authorised undertaker authority to carry out repairs from day to day on ordinary maintenance. Surely that is essential.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not think that is interfered with by Section 61.

Comment on this

There is some ambiguity about this and I think it would be as well if it were cleared up.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not see that it is so ambiguous as to cover the point raised by Deputy Byrne, or the point raised by Deputy Good when he speaks of ordinary day-to-day maintenance. I do not think that the sub-section touches these things at all.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Suppose the Minister brings us his considered opinion whether the words "repair and maintenance" are excluded from that sub-section.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (2), line 29, to delete the words "defrayal of" and to delete from and including the word "a," line 31, to the end of the sub-section and substitute therefore the words "paid by the Board, including the expense of altering and replacing plant belonging to the consumers."

Most of the plants in the Free State are direct burning plants, and where motors are used and certain other apparatus it will be necessary to change these when the main scheme comes along. I do not see how any of the Minister's previous arguments can come in, because he will have, in this case, to deal with hundreds, and in some cases thousands, of different individuals all working with different apparatus, and all requiring to be changed to the standardised working and system. My suggestion is that where the ordinary consumer is put to the expense of scraping electrical apparatus due to the change that that expense shall be borne by the Board.

There is another point; where an authorised undertaker is left to carry on, his stand-by plant would be useless, and perhaps it would pay the Board better to transform the current for him, to change it into a direct current. What I wish to bring out most strongly is, that the consumer is going to pay in every case where we change the system. The motors will be scrapped and the cost of that will fall on the consumer.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Again we get this peculiar view of the Board having money which it draws, apparently, from nowhere, and gets it without the cost falling on anyone. I do not care where this money comes from, the cost will eventually have to be paid by the consumer. It is only a question of the intermediate stage. Are these costs which the undertaking, as long as it remains an authorised undertaking apart from the Board, costs for which it may borrow from the Board, recouping itself by charges from the consumer, and the Board recouping itself by increased charges in the bulk supply, or whether the Board should pay and recoup itself at once by charges on the consumer? It is not a very material point. If there is going to be any increase by reason of the change over, incidentally the benefits that might not be felt at the time, but which would follow, are very much greater than the disadvantages of the change over. Who is to meet the intermediate stage of that charge? The intermediate stage does not seem to be worth much argument.

Comment on this

I am trying to assist the Minister, and I suggest this would only crop up in isolated cases among the general area of consumers. Take an average area. You will only find that this is cropping up here and there. You cannot put a charge on the area. You have to deal with the man particularly. Hundreds may be charged for the one man with the motor.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The section as it stands says:

"The defrayal of expenses necessarily and properly incurred by an authorised undertaking in complying with a requisition by the Board under this section shall be a purpose for which such authorised undertaker may borrow under this Act."

That is to say, "borrow from the Board" from the moneys that it is now having placed at its disposal. That will not be a charge to the consumers in the area. It will mean, if you get an individual or a number of individuals with motors that have to be changed, that will fall as an extra charge on them for a period until the cost of replacement has been paid off but the Deputy does not change that in any respect. That still remains and the individual has to pay the cost. Where is the money to be provided from? The Deputy says it should be paid by the Board. If he says that the Board must recoup itself somewhere, either by insisting that the authorised undertaking should charge the individual a certain extra sum and repay the Board, or else the Board will have to spread it over the whole community and say: "Replacement costs have amounted to so much, we are increasing the unit charge by some fraction." The section is dealing with this set of circumstances where there is an authorised undertaker still being allowed to operate under the supervision of the Board, and certain expenses are necessarily incurred by reason of requisition under Section 62. What it says is that it will be seen to in the area by the local undertaker, who will charge that against the individual whose replacement expenses are considerable, or where there is no occasion to advert to that at all, and for the purposes of this expense the undertaker may borrow from the Board. Of course it may be that the Deputy and myself are in agreement that the consumer is going to pay.

It will be easier for the local undertaker to operate under this section as drafted and to make the individual pay rather than make the Board pay and possibly have the direct connection with the individual whose replacement costs are under consideration. The Board may not be able to get at the individual, and may have to charge an increase in the rate at which they are supplying in bulk. It is easier to get after the individual who is going to be put to some expense and to leave it as it is.

Comment on this

Would not the individual have a reasonable claim under all the circumstances not to be put to this expense, even though it is ultimately recoverable by the undertaking in the increased charge? I do not know what the amount involved is, but the whole thing seems to be very complicated unless it is of a considerable amount. If it is a comparatively small amount the Board, who ultimately would be dealing with the consumer, would be dealing direct with the transaction through the authorised undertaker. As to the amount of money involved in this, if it is small, it seems to me that the process laid down in the Bill is very complicated.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Apart from the amount involved, I very much welcome the last speech of the Deputy. It seems to me that Deputy Hewat is at last beginning to realise that the clean-cut is the best—to get rid of the authorised undertaking and do away with all this intermediary system.

Comment on this

The Minister is now raising a rather contentious point.

Comment on this

Perhaps we might adjourn before discussing this further.

Comment on this

It is quite true that owing to the wearying process we are going through in connection with this Bill we must realise that we are up against the inevitable. If that is what the Minister means, the discussions have brought me to a frame of mind not to agree with the Minister. Certainly I agree that with the phalanxes of the Dáil behind him he is in an impregnable position against any argument that I can bring forward. Having arrived at that condition of things, I say that the method by which he is going to deal with this is complicated.

Comment on this

This question of the alteration of the current is a very much more serious one, I am afraid, than the Minister contemplates. In the particular local area that I come from, I understand, in connection with the changing of the mains alone, that to change from the direct to the alternating current will mean an expenditure of £100,000. That is only what might be called the expenditure of the local authority. In addition to that you have the motors used in industries driven by direct current that will have to be changed to the alternating current. In addition to the outlay by the local authority, it means that there will be a large expenditure on the part of the industrial users. I had an example of that from an area on the other side where they changed quite recently from the direct to the alternating current. In that case it meant an expenditure of £15,000 on the part of one firm. Where it means the scrapping of all those motors there must be some compensation for the users. By whom is that compensation to be paid? Are they to be compelled to change over from the direct to the alternating current without any compensation of any kind? In Dublin alone two areas will be seriously affected by this — Rathmines and Pembroke. In both cases it will mean for the local authority a very large expenditure in the first place, and then for all the industries in those areas a further large expenditure. I should like to know from the Minister by whom those particular bodies are to be compensated.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The amendment does not state, if the section does not state, by whom the expenses are to be borne.

Comment on this

I am not fathering either the amendment or the section.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

But we happen to be discussing the amendment.

Comment on this

It arises out of the amendment. If the amendment does not go far enough, we want to know who is going to foot the bill. Is the Board going to do it?

Comment on this

Does the Minister say that the amendment does not deal with it? It says "paid by the Board."

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes, the amendment deals with it as far as it says that it is to be paid by the Board in the first instance, but how is the Board going to recoup itself?

Comment on this

There is a charge to be put on the consumer or put on somebody. If the Minister does not put it on somebody, who is going to pay it? If the Bill provides for compensation it is going to come from somewhere, and you must recognise your obligation to the individuals and the authorities concerned. If the Minister's statement really means that because he does not know who to charge it to, an injustice must be done, that is a very broad issue affecting the whole basis of the Bill. If the Minister does not recognise any obligation on the State to pay compensation because he does not know whose pocket it is going to come out of, I would ask whose pocket does any compensation come out of? Whose pocket did all the compensation for the damage done in the recent disturbances come out of? Are not the two things very much on a par? If by State intervention a man is prevented from carrying on his ordinary avocation in the ordinary way, and the State says that he must do this and that, the amendment says that the Board shall pay. The Minister asked how the Board was going to get the money. Surely that is the foundation of the Bill. Does the Minister mean to say that because the Board has not the money, or cannot get the money, therefore the compensation is not to be paid where it properly accrues? That is a very dangerous principle.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is not our principle.

Comment on this

That was your argument.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I asked a question. Where is the Board to get the money? Has the Deputy any answer to that?

Comment on this

Is there anybody that should be qualified to answer that question better than the Minister? Has the Minister had the Bill before him for the past two years, and is not able to answer that question? If so, we must go back to the very A.B.C. of the matter again.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I was asked a question. It is obvious what the answer is, but it is dangerous to ask a rhetorical question in this House, because you get a burst of rhetoric from Deputy Hewat. But I can answer this question if he cannot. The Board will get the money from the consumer.

Comment on this

Very well, I agree with the Minister. If he has got to get the money from some place, it is to be presumed that he gets it from the consumer. But what is this £2,500,000 for? I again ask the question I asked on the Money Resolution: Can you segregate in any way this £2,500,000, or say what it is for? If the operation of this Bill in connection with compensation required more than £2,500,000 to compensate all the interests interfered with, then the Money Resolution is wrong.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy is very wrong in that. He is apparently under the impression that the Board is given £2,500,000 and has not to repay it. The Board has to repay every penny of it, and from the consumer, too.

Comment on this

The Board has also to repay £5,200,000.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Exactly.

Comment on this

The Minister wants to differentiate between the £5,200,000 and the £2,500,000, and his ground is that the £2,500,000 has to be repaid. It is on no different lines as regards repayment than the original £5,000,000 provided which is to be placed with the Board and has to be recouped by the Board to the Minister, according to the Act.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

If the Minister underestimated the amount required, surely he is not going to do it on the basis of doing an injustice to people who are compelled to undergo the charges. If the £2,500,000 was not enough, it is for him to say he wants more money and not to get up and say that because the Board has not been given sufficient money justice cannot be done.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have not said anything of the sort; I made no distinction between the £5,000,000 and the £2,500,000. They are all sums to be raised by the State in a particular way. There are works, plans and operations the carrying out of which necessitates an expenditure of certain portions of £5,200,000, and work and operations to be carried out by the Board, bringing about an expenditure of £2,500,000; and some items of £600,000 as between the two parties, and every penny of both sums has to be repaid by the Board hereafter, with interests and everything else on them.

Comment on this

Why does the Minister say there is any difference between the two estimates?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I never made that statement. The Deputy suddenly brought out that and as if it were a statement of mine, but I never made it.

Comment on this

Most distinctly the Minister questioned my statement that the money going on the Shannon scheme was £5,000,000 plus £2,500,000, and said it was absurd to say that the £2,500,000 was the same as the £5,000,000.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. I should like to get back for a moment to this point, to clarify Deputy Hewat, or at any rate make a last effort to do so. The Deputy talked about the price for bulk supply, and he talked about that price having to be based upon the expenditure not merely of £5,200,000, but of the sums here, and I said that was wrong. I said there were two items that will enter into the consumer's charge: the generating price, some item that is equivalent to the generating cost; and another item which is equivalent to the distribution cost; and that on the first will be charged a proportion of the £5,200,000, and that on the second will be charged the sums in this Bill. That was the distinction I made. But as to repayment by the Board eventually of the debt to the State, the whole of the sums advanced under the Shannon Act or under this Bill which must be repaid eventually.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

How many Deputies are asking for a division?

Mr. Good, Mr. Hewat, Mr. A. Byrne and Major Myles rose in their places.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The names of the four Deputies will be recorded as in favour of the amendment.

Comment on this

An amendment of this character ought to have had a wider discussion.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I did not do anything to restrict the discussion.

Comment on this

I wanted to reply further on it.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy should have made that point before the question was put.

Comment on this

That is the reason why I suggested we might adjourn, because the amendment has a very wide meaning and is of very great importance both to consumers and to local authorities.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The matter may be raised in another way. The amendment is now lost. Deputy Good could raise his point on the section which has still to be put. As a matter of explanation, from my own point of view I should like to say that when Deputy Hewat raised this big question and Deputy Good suggested an adjournment I thought it was a jocose suggestion. I did not anticipate that we were going to discuss one of the main principles of the Bill again.

Comment on this

I think Section 62 was held over because Deputy Good wanted to express more fully and more forcibly the objections to it. However, our viewpoint has been put fully before the House on the amendments, and I do not propose to take up more time in discussing the matter, beyond saying that we must object to the section as it stands, and while it is, of course, within our province to divide the House on it, it would be useless to do so, and if you, sir, would take our dissent we will let it go.

Comment on this

I think the names of four of us are already recorded as dissenting from this section.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is so.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The fact that Deputies voted for the amendments would show that they are against the section.

Comment on this

I dissent from that.

Comment on this

I wish to join in that dissent.

Comment on this

I do also.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

On Second Reading attention was called to this section by, I think, Deputy O'Connell, and on examination it was found that it had not been properly placed. It was intended to have relation only to local authorities and to carry out the position that more or less exists at the moment. An amendment has been put down in my name — amendment 92 —"to insert before Section 77 a new section as follows"— and then follows this Section 68, limited in its application to a local authority which is an authorised undertaker. I would accordingly move to have Section 68 deleted now.

Comment on this

The section which the Minister suggests is equally bad from my point of view.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

But we are not dealing with it.

Comment on this

In my view this section is the worst in the Bill, so far as it applies to Dublin. This is the section that robs the citizens of Dublin of their rights under an existing Act, the Corporation's Electric Lighting Order (No. 4) Act of 1892. At present an undertaking which is a local authority is entitled to apply a sum not exceeding five per cent. upon the aggregate capital expenditure on the undertaking, first to the relief of the rates or, second, to the improvement of the district, or, third, in the reduction of the capital moneys borrowed for electricity purposes. In the case of Dublin, this is set out in the Dublin Electric Lighting Order of 1892.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Might I intervene? I have made a suggestion — I believe it cannot be carried out at this moment — that Section 68 should, at some stage or other of the Bill, be deleted. Deputy Byrne is now speaking on that. Is he opposing my motion to delete Section 68?

Comment on this

But the Minister does not suggest what he is going to put in.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There is an amendment in my name — 92 — on which this speech which Deputy Byrne proposes to deliver would be appropriate.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

Can the Minister not vote against the section, and get it out in that way?

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

If the section is allowed to stand it can be deleted on Report.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I merely intended to indicate my intention to move its deletion on Report.

Comment on this