We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

ORDUITHE AN LAE. - ELECTRICITY (SUPPLY) BILL, 1927 THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 228–460 of 460. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electricity (Supply) Bill 1927
Enacted

No. 10 of 1927 ›

But in the meantime the section stands, and I presume Deputy Byrne is within his rights in speaking against it.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It will come up later.

Comment on this

But in view of the fact that for this evening the section is before the House, am I not in order in putting my views forward? I think, in view of the fact that the Minister stated that he may later move the deletion of it, I might assume he will propose to put something else in.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

What I propose to put in will be in fact before the House to-night. It is amendment 92, on which the Deputy can speak.

Comment on this

In the meantime this section stands until we come to amendment 92.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

It stands until such time as it is either withdrawn or defeated.

Comment on this

I suggest that the Minister should withdraw the section now and reserve to himself the right to move the amendment that he wants to insert.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is what I proposed, but apparently it has not met with approval.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

When there is no amendment to delete a section the usual procedure is to have it deleted on the next Stage.

Comment on this

But are we not in order? The Minister has said that he has a later amendment which has some concern with this section. But what is really before the House, I submit, is Section 68, and if Deputy Byrne wishes to make a statement on that section as it stands he is entitled to do so.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Nobody is questioning his title. The only matter is that if a speech has to be made on this point, would it not be more properly made on an amendment which it is proposed to insert what Deputy Byrne wishes to object to, rather than on a section that I have given notice I want deleted?

Comment on this

That is a matter for Deputy Byrne himself to decide. If he claims a right to speak on the section as it is I submit that he is in order in doing so. The Minister suggests that it would be more appropriate somewhere else. Whether that is so or not. I maintain that Deputy Byrne has a right to speak on the section if he wishes.

Comment on this

I think you have ruled, and I think the Minister has agreed, that I can speak now. But when I referred on previous sections to this confiscation of the rights of Dublin citizens I was told that it would come up on Section 68. Having made half my case for the removal of the section and of the objectionable proposal to confiscate the rights of the people of Dublin, I was put off and off. Now I am told that the Minister intends to move the deletion of this section later on. But in the meantime the section stands. I hold that I am entitled to make my case now for the removal of the section. Had I caught your eye, Sir, before the Minister stood up you would have ruled me in order. The Minister stood up to prevent — I will not say myself personally — anybody making a case for the deletion of the section. I have already on two or three separate occasions made an effort to remove this confiscatory method of dealing with Dublin, and each time I was told that the matter would come up on Section 68. Am I, because of something that the Minister says he intends to do in the future, to be debarred from drawing attention to the rights and privileges that Dublin citizens have under existing legislation dealing with electricity? If the Minister objects to my going on, very well——

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

There is no privilege which the Deputy is entitled to that he will not be allowed.

Comment on this

With your permission, I will make the case on this section as it now stands. I have stated that at present an undertaker who is a local authority is entitled to apply a sum not exceeding 5 per cent. upon the aggregate capital expenditure on the undertaking (1) to the relief of the local rates, or (2) to the improvement of the district, or (3) in reduction of the capital moneys borrowed for electricity purposes.

In the case of Dublin this is set out in the Dublin Electric Lighting Order of 1892, Section 53, and I understand there is a similar provision in other Electrical Provisional Orders.

In Dublin the aggregate capital expenditure is over £1,300,000. This would justify a payment to the relief of the rates of £65,000 per annum.

Up to the present the surplus in Dublin, which amounted for the last three years to £150,000, has not been applied to the relief of the rates but has been kept in the undertaking. But, notwithstanding the amount of the surplus, I find the following statement on page 163 of Report of the Department of Local Government and Public Health, First Report, 1922-25: —

"The undertaking has proved so successful as to reliability and economy that various public bodies such as the Port and Docks Board and several railway companies found the Corporation supply sufficiently attractive to justify them in closing down their own stations. In addition the Urban District Councils of Rathmines and Pembroke instead of extending their stations have taken supplementary supplies from the Corporation."

It is quite possible, therefore, without any hardship on the electricity consumers, to make a profit and set it to the relief of the rates. The consumer has got his supply cheaper than he could make it himself and the supply is also more reliable. I mention this point on account of the Minister's reference to municipal undertakings making profits. I understand that the new City Hall in Belfast was largely, if not altogether, built out of the similar surplus of the gas undertaking in Belfast. Why should not the citizens of other places look forward to a contribution to the reduction of the rates or towards some local improvement, such as additional housing, as of right and not subject to the veto of the Board? It will be noticed that no funds can be devoted to any purpose unless with the approval of this new Electricity Board.

The Minister in the course of the debate on previous sections has thrown doubt on the right of the local authority to any such contribution, but the section of the Provisional Order makes the matter quite clear. I will read it, but before doing so I want to emphasise the fact that in depriving local authorities of the powers it contains to apply surplus earnings in relief of the rates the Minister is repealing a provision that appears in every Electric Lighting Order since 1882 and is identical with Clause 7 of the Schedule of the Electric Lighting (Clauses) Act 1899 which is incorporated with every Electric Lighting Order made since 1899. The following is Section 53 of the Dublin Electric Lighting Order of 1892: —

"The undertakers shall carry the net surplus remaining in any year and the annual proceeds of the reserve fund when amounting to the prescribed limit to the credit of the local rate as defined by the principal Act or at their option shall apply such surplus or any part there of to the improvement of the district for which they are the local authority or in reduction of the capital moneys borrowed for electricity purposes.

Provided always that if the surplus in any year exceed five pounds per centum per annum upon the aggregate capital expenditure on the undertaking the undertakers shall make such a rateable reduction in the charge for the supply of energy as in their judgment will reduce the surplus to the said maximum rate of profit but this proviso shall only apply to so much of the undertaking as shall for the time being remain in the hands of the undertakers."

In this clause, as I stated, and in many other clauses it is suggested that all these powers of the Dublin Corporation to repay to those whom they took money from in the days gone by in order to make the electricity undertaking the success that it is, so that railway companies and big undertakings think fit to scrap their own plants and take their requirements from the Dublin Electricity Supply, are to be withdrawn. I think, now that it is a paying concern, that they ought to hold the right that I have quoted under this Order of 1892, to contribute to the relief of the rates in return for what the ratepayers did for them in the days gone by. Everybody knows that for practically the first twenty years the Dublin Corporation Electricity Supply was run at a loss. The ratepayers had to guarantee its success; their credit was pledged for that purpose and, as I stated previously, instead of paying back the moneys that the ratepayers were entitled to out of the profits, you are now making an effort under this Bill to make it possible to take from them what might be a contribution of £60,000 a year to the relief of the Dublin rates. You are going to devote it to some other purpose that your Electricity Board may think fit. The Corporation and those who helped to build up the undertaking will have no say in what the profits of the undertaking shall go to. I hold that the Government's action towards Dublin City in this matter amounts to nothing but barefaced robbery. Probably I will get very few Deputies to agree with me on that point, but I want you to understand that the electricity undertaking of the Dublin Corporation is a paying concern to-day. You may ask me why were not the rates relieved in the days gone by? Why was not some portion of the £60,000 put towards the relief of rates? It was because our worthy President and Mr. Kettle and the gentleman on the right of the President, who was Secretary to the Electricity Supply Committee at the time, thought that it was a wise policy not to contribute towards the rates, but to make improvements and build up a big paying concern. They withheld from the rates what the ratepayers were entitled to get when this concern began to make a profit.

Instead of devoting it to some municipal improvement or giving grants towards the relief of the rates, they made all the improvements out of revenue, and did not borrow for the purpose. At that time the President and some of the advisers of the Minister to-day thought that was good financial policy. The result is that Dublin City will suffer. Had it been known that when we got the right to manage our own affairs an Electricity Bill would be introduced and that Dublin City would get its supply of electricity nationally, every year since the Corporation started to make a profit — from 1911 onwards — they could have given anything from £5,000 a year to £60,000 a year towards the relief of rates. But they did not do it. It is the citizens' loss, because of the financial policy adopted by the Corporation at the time.

I hope that the Dublin citizens, the people who made the undertaking the great success it is, will be treated fairly. I have no hesitation in saying that it is the best managed undertaking in Great Britain or in Ireland. That can be proved. I believe the Ministers themselves are satisfied on that point. Now we are told it is proposed to take over surplus funds and the right to manage the concern as the Board desire without any complaint being made against those who are now running it. I have here some figures which will be interesting. From 1891 to 1910 there was a deficit in the working of the Dublin Corporation electricity supply. From 1911 to 1924 they made very handsome profits, as the following figures will show: — 1911, £6,458 net surplus; 1912, £11,607; 1913, £7,767; 1914, £4,000; 1915, £1,000; 1916, £8,000; 1917, a loss of £1,500; 1918, a profit of £4,000; 1919, £7,000; 1920, £14,000; 1921, £44,000; 1922, £62,000; 1923, £45,000; and 1924, £39,000. This represents the net surplus each year, allowing for everything. Now, with a stroke of the pen, our own Government is setting out to fleece the Dublin citizens of the privileges they held under existing Acts.

I ask Deputies, regardless of their constituencies, to do justice in this matter to Dublin citizens. I ask them, whatever happens the Shannon scheme, to see that Dublin citizens shall not be deprived of rights that they hold under various Acts that they worked their concerns under. I am satisfied a good case can be made out for Dublin. There are, I am sure, others who could handle the matter better than I. I do not feel capable of doing justice to the case that could be made for the Dublin citizens. I ask the support of the House in seeing that every justice shall be given to the citizens of Dublin.

Comment on this

I repudiate absolutely and entirely two terms used by Deputy Byrne and by some newspapers in connection with this controversy. The terms are confiscation and robbery. I repudiate both terms. There is absolutely no ground whatever to justify the use of either one or other, or both, of those terms. I am rather sorry for the sake of public life in the country and intelligent criticism of measures before the Oireachtas that people lose their heads to such an extent as to use such terms when, if they really understood the meaning of them, they would realise they are absolutely out of place in connection with a matter of this kind. I happen to be a Dublin citizen; I was born and reared here and I have spent very much the larger part of my life in the city as, amongst other things, a representative on the Corporation. I should be just as anxious and just as desirous of seeing any institution owned by the citizens getting its full measure of justice as anybody else.

This Bill, when the Minister's final touches are put to it, will give the citizens of Dublin the fullest measure of justice. With regard, to the statement made by Deputy Byrne that it is mentioned in an Act of Parliament that it is open to any municipal trading concern to contribute a portion of its profits in relief of rates, that is not the last word in wisdom upon that particular matter. It does not for all time stereotype the morality of that proceeding. I do not subscribe to that and I do not agree with it. I submit every municipal undertaking should stand by itself; that it should not impose upon the people who contribute towards its success, or who partake of its advantages, or who contribute in any way towards continuance, anything in excess of the cost of the particular facilities. We are told it is in an Act of Parliament that five per cent. could be payable in relief of rates or for local improvement. I do not subscribe to it. I am not taking my morality from that Act of Parliament. I pay no tribute to its wisdom and I give no consideration to the fact that if there are profits they should be used in that direction.

The citizens of Dublin are going to lose nothing by this Bill. I believe they will benefit very much by it, and such terms as confiscation and robbery are no contribution whatever to the settlement of a matter of this kind. If I assume that Deputy Byrne is correct and that the ratepayers should be paid back what they put into this concern, I would like to submit this particular matter for the consideration of the Dáil. Up to seventeen years ago the ratepayers contributed £46,000 or £50,000 to this concern. Is it to be the task of the Minister to find out the ratepayers who made the payments and hand back to them this £46,000 or £50,000? If I am to accept what the Deputy has said as correct, that should be the Minister's concern. He should discover them and hand them back the money, because it was they who paid it out. Some of them have gone out of business.

Comment on this

What about their representatives or successors?

Comment on this

That is out of the question, and the Deputy knows the position of ratepayers quite well. The ratepayer has a year's life. He starts life on 1st April and he finishes on 31st March of the following year. It was the ratepayers from 1892 or 1893 up to 1911 who contributed towards this Dublin municipal undertaking. A great many of those ratepayers are gone.

Comment on this

Does the President mean to say that the policy of the municipal authority is altogether confined within the year from 1st April to the 31st March?

Comment on this

The basis of municipal finance is to make the ratepayer every year bear his burden for that year. If, in the case of a capital undertaking, it has a longer life than a year, he bears his proportion of that life, and that only, and that is correct municipal finance. Anything else is raimeis and the Deputy knows it quite well.

Comment on this

It is very arguable.

Comment on this

I have had a considerable experience of municipal finance, and I am at a loss to know how we are to find the ratepayers who contributed this £46,000 or £50,000.

Comment on this

I should not think there is any occasion to. That does not affect the principle of the thing at all.

Comment on this

Of course not. We will take one particular case. There is at present in Grafton Street a very big firm that was not there 17 years ago. Messrs. Woolworths were not there then, and they paid none of that £46,000 or £50,000. Another firm, Messrs. Selfridge, are there for the last ten or twelve years. They were not there 17 years ago.

Comment on this

Is the President not dealing with individual ratepayers now? Is not the individual ratepayer of to-day paying for acts of the Corporation many years ago? Is not the rate in Dublin a comprehensive rate, that does not apply to a particular year but covers up a large number of years?

Comment on this

Apparently the Deputy realises that I am getting him into a tight corner. He would like to free himself a little, but I am going to bind him down to the cases I have mentioned. These firms are ratepayers at present. If the Deputy wants other cases I might mention the Imperial Tobacco Company, which has three establishments in Dublin at present. They were not here 17 years ago.

Comment on this

On that ground they should not be paying the rate charged them to-day for operations that took place antecedent to their arrival.

Comment on this

I have been listening to the Deputy, and now I am bringing him up against the fact that, in essence, the Minister is asked to give back the £40,000 or the £50,000 paid by ratepayers 17 years ago, and by some as long as 37 years ago. He is to pay it back to the Imperial Tobacco Company, to Selfridge's, and Woolworth's, as well as to people who contributed the money. When they bought these concerns did they buy that interest?

Comment on this

I submit that is raimeis. They did not.

Comment on this

Did they buy the premises—bricks and mortar—or the goodwill as well?

Comment on this

They bought the goodwill, but none of the other things. They did not know about them. There was no item on the balance sheet in respect of them. We are asked to give these people that particular item now. Let me put another side of the question. When I first became a member of the Corporation of Dublin my recollection is that there were 35 miles of streets with electric mains, I think that in only 14 miles of these streets were there customers, so that there were 21 miles of streets, or some considerable number, in which there were no customers for electricity. Those streets were lighted by electricity, and they were well lighted. I have not looked through the Corporation accounts for a long time, but I believe that the price of public lighting, so far as electricity is concerned, was cheaper than the price to ordinary customers of electric light. Supposing that the £46,000 or the £50,000 was divided between the years 1892 and 1912, approximately 20 years, it would amount to about £2,300 a year. That was not a very large sum to pay for the better lighting of the streets. I am putting it in this way: that the ratepayers at that particular time got some advantage from this concern.

The principle of this Bill and what attracts me is that electricity is to be provided at the cheapest possible price, with all the best modern advantages, and that Dublin, which has contributed considerably by putting down mains, will have less to pay in the way of generation and transmission costs than places in which there has been no capital expenditure at all, or that will now have to provide mains or the other necessary equipment inseparable from the distribution of current.

Comment on this

Does the President say that is in the Bill?

Comment on this

I say that the Minister has made the position so plain that even I, who do not regard myself as a particularly astute person, can understand it. I looked upon this matter with very considerable concern for Dublin, because, as I said, I am first a citizen of Dublin; secondly, I have been a member of the Dublin Corporation, and, thirdly, I have some concern with the particular policy adopted. the fruits of which will be realised when this Bill is passed.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not intend to go into an argument with regard to Section 68 as to whom benefit will accrue, as that will come on when I move amendment 92, which is designed to prevent the fleecing of Dublin electricity consumers for the benefit of the general ratepayers. The amendment is rendered necessary by the talk that was put forward here and comments in the Press for a week past. When I come to move that amendment, I will deal with this question of surplus allocation. I had intended at the beginning to agree to the deletion of the clause. It is quite clear now that it should not be deleted until amendment 92 is dealt with, and until the House is in a position to see what happens. If amendment 92 is passed I will, on the Report Stage, move to agree to the deletion of Section 68. For the time being I abide by this, and I hope the Committee will agree with me.

Comment on this

Is it clear that it is the wish of the Minister to delete this clause, seeing that the whole matter will be under discussion again? I would not like to pass it without some comment on the President's observations. However, I do not want to duplicate any statement I may have to make. As far as I am concerned, it will be as convenient for me to comment on the Minister's amendment when it comes on later.

Comment on this

I move:—

In sub-section (2), line 44, to delete all words after the word "sub-section" to the end of the sub-section.

Under the provisions of the Act at present in force dealing with borrowing by local authorities, all loans rank equally and the security of the last lender is as good as that given to the first. The form of mortgage schedule in the Public Health Act of 1878 gives to each mortgagee such proportion of the rates as the sum borrowed shall bear to the whole sum borrowed on the credit of the rates.

If by any chance default was made in payment of the amounts due each creditor or mortgagee would have an equal right to payment and the last lender would not have to wait until all previous loans were paid before he could get anything. Therefore it is possible to borrow easily and at a reasonable rate of interest, but if priorities are to be established between the various loans, it would become very difficult as the security would be affected. I therefore wish to move the deletion of these words, as they are in conflict with the Public Health Act provisions. The amendment simply means that all Corporation loans are to rank equally and none is to have preference over another. The section as it stands would establish a preference for the electricity loans and would disturb the general finances of the Corporation. For that reason I would ask the Minister to accept my amendment now or give it some consideration for a future Stage.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I might point out that the Deputy is quite wrong in his last statement. These loans would have priority only "next after the charges on such rate existing at the time such sum was advanced." They would not have complete priority.

Comment on this

How would they stand in regard to the other loans?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

With regard to other loans they would have priority in preference to any loan that came later in date.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that they will not have any priority in regard to existing loans?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think that is the meaning of the two lines "shall have priority next after the charges on such rate existing at the time such sum is advanced."

Comment on this

We are passing an Act of Parliament and the Minister should explain it. We want to know what we are doing.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We are passing an Act of Parliament but we are not passing it on my interpretation.

Comment on this

The Minister is here to explain the provisions of this Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I cannot explain this statement: "These sums shall have priority next after the charges on such rate existing at the time such sum is advanced." Does that require explanation?

Comment on this

It does. I want to know from the Minister if this particular loan is to have any priority in regard to existing loans?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I answer in the words of the section that they "shall have priority next after the charges on such rate existing at the time such sum is advanced."

Comment on this

That does not answer my question.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think it is a complete answer.

Comment on this

Does not that mean the Minister is interfering to a certain extent with future loans to be raised by the Corporation? Is he not giving priority to one over the other? If ordinary Corporation Stock goes out the electricity undertaking will have preference over it and will have preference on the market. As the Bill stands now he is to have priority for his own undertaking.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is so.

Comment on this

Is that fair to Corporation Stock and stockholders?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy consider the other side? There are consumers in all parts of the country, and the consumers' interests are to be protected. If they are not protected the debt has to fall on them. The Deputy is apparently considering some place where a local authority is going to be in default. If it is going to be in default surely the Board's concern for other consumers in all parts of the country must be considered.

Comment on this

I think the President is taking a wrong view of Deputy Byrne's amendment. The question of priority does not anticipate any failure by the local authorities to pay. One must always recognise and I am sure nobody recognises it more than the President does, that the value of stock issued to the public is affected by the position in which it stands in relation to other stock of the same company. Supposing a company was issuing ordinary stock and preference stock, the preference stock would have higher value because it would have higher security. The proposal in this section is that certain stock issued by the Corporation must be earmarked. It is under different conditions from the general consolidated stock because it obviously carries a priority charge which makes it more valuable. If it makes it more valuable it ipso facto makes the other stock less valuable.

This differentiation is not quite the small matter that the President would seem to think. It has a considerable bearing on the borrowing powers of the Corporation. I think the President and the Minister might take that section into consideration and see if it is really a fair thing to a local authority to make prior stock with prior security to the perfectly secured stock which the authority issues, because, after all, there cannot be any greater security than a municipal undertaking. The borrowers have the whole community as a security, both collectively and individually, so that the security is ample. I think it would be undesirable to make a differentiation in a case where money is raised on behalf of an undertaking which, according to the Minister's forecast, is going to fall ultimately, not on the undertaking at all, but on the Board as a separate concern. If the Board goes to an undertaking and requires them to borrow money I think the ordinary security under that authority should be sufficient.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I should be prepared to consider the point Deputy Hewat has raised, but that is completely different from the issue raised in the amendment. The amendment simply proposes to delete the portion saying that priority shall be given to certain charges "next after the charges existing at the time such sum is advanced," and it does not say how the loan is to rank. Deputy Byrne refers to some Public Health Act, but there is no reference to that in his amendment. It would simply wipe out the provision contained in the last few lines and say nothing about it. The point Deputy Hewat has raised has some relation to what Deputy Byrne was trying to argue. That is a different point from the amendment. The amendment could not be accepted in its present form, but the point raised by Deputy Hewat is one which I could look into.

Comment on this

I am not quite sure whether or not this point was referred to before, but I asked the Minister on a previous occasion when the Bill was under discussion whether the local authority having to borrow in accordance with certain Acts of Parliament, those Acts would not have to be repealed in order to alter the method of borrowing. The Minister could not answer that question. There is nothing in this Bill repealing those previous Acts under which the local authority must borrow. If these Acts are not repealed we must borrow in accordance with them. If this Bill repeals those Acts then we need not necessarily borrow in accordance with them. If the Minister makes it clear that the Bill repeals those Acts and that we will not have to borrow in accordance with them, then there is no necessity for the amendment, but if there is not such repeal there is necessity for it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is my intention on the Report Stage to move an amendment of this type:

Page 35, before Section 76, to insert the following new section:—

(1) Whenever a local authority which is an authorised undertaker borrows under this Act any sum from the Board for any purpose, the purpose for which such sum is so borrowed shall be deemed to be a purpose for which such local authority may borrow under the Public Health (Ireland) Acts, 1878 to 1919, and the said Acts shall apply to such borrowing in like manner as they apply to any borrowing thereunder by a local authority with the modification that the sanction required by the said Acts for any borrowing thereunder by a local authority shall for the purposes of the borrowing under this Act of any sum from the Board by a local authority which is an authorised undertaker be the sanction of the Board.

(2) Any sum borrowed under this Act from the Board by a local authority which is an authorised undertaker shall not be reckoned as part of the total debt of such local authority for the purpose of any limitation on borrowing imposed by the Public Health (Ireland) Acts, 1878 to 1919.

Comment on this

There is no such amendment on the list of amendments. The Minister tells us now that he is going to move that amendment on Report, but it is the absence of such an amendment that makes the amendment in the form before us necessary. The President will agree with that, having some considerable knowledge of the work of local authorities.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

This amendment of Deputy Byrne is probably the most unacceptable amendment put down, because it leads us nowhere. It wipes out a certain provision of the section and leaves us nothing in its place.

Comment on this

The terms contained in the section were absolutely necessary in the absence of the Minister's proposed amendment. That clarifies the position beyond all doubt.

Comment on this

This amendment, without that further amendment would be necessary.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I cannot imagine any amendment hereafter which would render this amendment of Deputy Byrne a useful or reasonable one.

Comment on this

The point I make is that the amendment proposed by Deputy Byrne would be necessary if that other amendment, which the Minister has quoted, and which he proposes to bring forward on Report Stage, were not incorporated in the Bill.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. This amendment of Deputy Byrne, if passed under any circumstances, would be bad.

Comment on this

I am not going to take the Minister as an authority on municipal finance.

Comment on this

We will have an opportunity of considering the Minister's amendment on Report.

Comment on this

I ask leave to withdraw my amendment, in view of the undertaking given by the Minister that he will introduce an amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Let us be clear as to that. My promise was to consider a point raised by Deputy Hewat which, I think, is a different thing from what the Deputy referred to in his amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 90:—

In line 7 to delete the words "of electricity," and in line 8 to insert after the word "authority" the words "of electricity," and in line 9 to delete the word "it" and to substitute therefor the words "such supply."

This is really a drafting amendment. It makes the effect of Acts dealing with electricity more precise.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 92, which is as follows:—

Before Section 77 to insert a new section as follows:—

Whenever a local authority which is an authorised undertaker has in its hands at the end of any local financial year any surplus funds arising from the authorised undertaking after discharge of all liabilities in relation to such undertaking, such authorised undertaker shall not allocate or apply such surplus funds to any purpose save a purpose approved in that behalf by the Board."

This is an amendment previously referred to as an amendment to prevent the "fleecing" of the electricity consumer in the interests of the general ratepayer. It is an amendment which I would not have considered absolutely necessary but for the outbreak here and in the Press with regard to certain conditions that may be set up under certain provisions of this Bill. No matter what one might have thought of the protection of the electricity consumer in any area previously, founded both on the theory of municipal trading and on the practice of authorities, so far, it is quite clear that—no matter what the theory may be—the practice is going to be changed hereafter and the electricity consumer, in fact, is going to be fleeced—I am using the words of Deputy Byrne—for the benefit of the general ratepayer. It is absolutely necessary that this section should go in, so that the Board will be enabled to prevent such charges being made for electricity as will allow profits to be made, and these profits to be applied to the benefit of the general ratepayer. I do not intend to traverse all the ground I traversed before——

Comment on this

Will the Minister refer to the second portion of his amendment? The undertaker, according to that portion, is not to apply the surplus to any purpose save a purpose approved by the Board.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is what I am specially adverting to. That is the principal part of the provision which is rendered absolutely necessary by the revealed intention of the various people concerned, with electricity supply to charge electricity consumers more than the service is worth and to apply the surplus to purposes outside electricity undertakings. Even though it may be repetition, I propose to refer to evidence given before the Private Bill Committee in connection with the Liffey Bills. I want to make the point, however, in connection with these quotations, that the circumstances were these: you had three applications put forward with regard to the development of the Liffey and the supply of electricity therefrom. Two were on behalf of companies and one application was on behalf of the Dublin municipality. The Dublin municipality were making the case that the right with regard to electricity-undertaking in the development of the Liffey should go to the municipality and not to the companies. The sole case put up by them, in opposition to the two companies, was that the companies would make profit out of the electricity consumer in the area, whereas the municipality would not. When giving evidence on oath before this Private Bill Committee, Mr. Kettle, City Electrical Engineer, said:

My opinion is that all profits should be reinvested in the undertaking itself. In other words, as we are getting the profit from the electricity user, it ought to go back to the electricity user.

Later, during cross-examination by Mr. Jellett, Mr. Kettle was asked:

I understand you are not in favour of money going to the ease of the rates?

Mr. Kettle replied:

No. I am in favour of its going back to the electricity consumer.

That was Mr. Kettle on oath before the Private Bill Committee.

Comment on this

Would not that be the natural view of an electrical engineer?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

If the Deputy will allow me to go on, I will show that Mr. Kettle was backed by a person who is not an electrical engineer. On the same application, Mr. Murphy, Town Clerk, gave evidence. He was asked by Senator Barrington:

Is it not obvious that your profits must be a great deal more if you (the Corporation) generate this electricity by means of water?

Mr. Murphy replied:

No. We will reduce the price. We do not want profits. Profits are absolutely contrary to the principle of municipal trading. The object of municipal trading is to provide services for the citizen at the lowest possible cost. The Corporation would have nothing to do with the profits.

Again, in reply to a question by Senator Irwin, Mr. Murphy said:

The word "profit" is frequently used with regard to municipal undertakings. It is entirely a misnomer. The word is "surplus," and the fact that you earn more than you expend only proves that the price you charged was too much for the service rendered. It is an estimate for each year and the practice of the Corporation, in my opinion, ought to be to balance income with expenditure as regards any particular service.

Chairman: To do more than that is really immoral?—Yes, as you are drawing money from the smaller body to spread amongst the larger.

Those are very sound sentiments.

Comment on this

What about water?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Would the Deputy think it right that the Corporation should set out to make a profit on the supply of water so that they could distribute the profits to the general ratepayer?

Comment on this

Certainly not.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Then I do not know what the meaning of the Deputy's interruption is.

Comment on this

There was never a profit made on water or on markets by the Corporation during the years I was a member of it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The sentiments I have quoted are very sound sentiments with regard to municipal trading—that there should not be profits made, which profits would go to persons other than the persons from whom the profits were made. What you get from the electricity user should go back to the electricity user. The idea of profits, according to the Town Clerk, is absolutely contrary to the principle of municipal trading. That is what I read before. I think it was relevant to the argument I put up here before. I wonder whether anybody who got his information as to what was happening in connection with this Bill from the newspapers would gather that that quotation was ever used—that any argument had been founded upon quotations made from responsible people in the Dublin Municipal undertaking. Strangely enough, I discovered myself described as having used two arguments which were contrary to each other. In the first part of an editorial at the end of last week, I was described as having said that it was immoral to make profits on municipal services and to dispose of those profits to some other body. That having been my quotation from the Town Clerk directly, in the first part of the editorial, the newspaper went on to say that I advanced to another stage and said that municipal trading was immoral. I wonder did anybody here remember me using those words. I certainly have no recollection of using them. I founded myself entirely on that quotation from the Town Clerk, that it was immoral to do more than earn what you expend.

Comment on this

I think the Minister will have to nationalise the Press.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

On this point, I have got a further quotation. It is from the City Electrical Engineer, who read a Paper before the Irish Centre in December, 1926, in which he dealt with State ownership. At one point in his speech he said:

If there is any business in which nationalisation is justified it is certainly that of electricity supply. Electricity supply is not properly an industry, in the generally accepted interpretation of the word. It is far more; it is the life-blood of every industry, and cheap and abundant power will assist every national activity. Apart from the question of industrial power, light and heat are a necessary of life for every individual citizen, and electricity is the ideal medium for giving him light and heat in the cleanest, healthiest and most convenient way. Nationalisation is only an extended form of municipalisation, or, as those who do not favour it would say, an "aggravated" form. The battle of municipal versus company administration has already been fought out in the sphere of electricity supply, and no unbiased critic can say that the municipalities have not more than held their own in point of efficiency. If a State scheme be as well run as the municipal schemes, there is no reason why it should not prove a success."

Nationalisation, according to Mr. Kettle, is only an extended form of municipalisation. The municipality is a trustee. The municipal authorities are the trustees for the consumers out of whose charges they have built up certain undertakings. It is proposed now that the trustees shall be changed and, instead of them being the municipal authorities, they will be the Board. Despite Mr. Kettle's statement that nationalisation is only an extended form of municipalisation, we are being asked to pay something between £1,300,000 and £1,500,000 for the undertaking.

Comment on this

Did Mr. Kettle ask that?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. I cannot say that Mr. Kettle asked it. I do not know who asked it, but various prominent gentlemen have been going into newspaper offices recently and delivering themselves of weighty comments as to what should be done. Certain influential gentlemen in the commercial world, I understand, have almost been living in newspaper offices for the last three days writing up these articles.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister will be able to identify them. Personally, I have not been in a newspaper office, I might almost say in my life. Does the Minister say that I visited the offices?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No indeed.

Comment on this

Does the Minister refer to me?

Comment on this

Does he refer to me? I have had full opportunity here, and I think I availed of it during the past week.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Obviously when Deputies tell me that they are not the people to whom I refer, I am bound to accept their statements.

Comment on this

If I was there I would not deny it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No. But we have somebody inspiring the campaign that in the future there are going to be extra charges made, more than what the service warrants, on the consumers, and whether it be surplus or profit it is going to be disbursed in the interests of the general ratepayers. Deputy Byrne asked what can the consumer complain about—he is getting his electricity generated more cheaply than if he generated it himself. That is not the point. The point is, is he having to pay more than the service entitles him to pay? The fact is that he is. That is the policy which renders absolutely essential the insertion before Section 77 of this new section which I propose, namely, that if there is any surplus it shall not be allocated to any purpose save that approved on that behalf by the Board. We hear a lot of talk about moneys that were lent on undertakings, moneys gathered on the credit of the general ratepayers, and the obligations of electricity undertakings towards these people. The President's argument, which is accepted by a great many people, is sound, namely, that you strike your accounts in a municipality every twelve months and then close them, and there is a fluctuating mass of ratepayers, so that it is impossible to give a return to those who provided the funds at first. Leaving that out of consideration, I guarantee that whatever outstanding sums there are the Board will repay them to the particular district on the basis of interest and sinking fund, spread out over a period of years. Let me take Dublin. In Dublin, I read in the newspapers to-day, the ratepayers supplied £46,000 or so, and the statement is made that the ratepayers have been recouped that sum, and, in addition, money was carried from time to time to the credit of the general ratepayers.

That statement is false. The moneys have not been recouped. There is still £22,000 or £23,000 outstanding. I cannot conceive how money could be carried to the easing of the general ratepayer before the liability of the general ratepayer was paid off. When it is admitted that sum is outstanding it is futile to argue that money was carried to the easing of the general ratepayers. In fact there was no payment made out of profits or surplus, or whatever they are called, carried to the credit of the general ratepayers. Following on the very good theory announced by Mr. Kettle and the Town Clerk, if one thought these two were to be put in control and their point of view, as placed before the Private Bill Committee, were carried out, one would have very little use for this in reference to Dublin. But we have seen in the last few days a new attitude towards electricity, and that is that the consumer is going to pay a little more for the service given, and the profit to be carried to the benefit of the ratepayers. Owing to that campaign having been started by certain people this amendment is rendered absolutely necessary.

Comment on this

The arguments put forward by Deputy Byrne are not quite fair to the electricity users in the city. Was it not enough in the past for the electricity users to pay for electricity? The argument of Deputy Byrne and others is that not alone should the users in Dublin pay for the light, heat and power, but that they should pay £50,000 a year towards the rates. I think that is a very unfair proposal as regards the users of electricity. It is founded on a wrong principle, and it is particularly cruel to advance it here on behalf of electricity users.

Comment on this

Who advanced it?

Comment on this

It was your argument.

Comment on this

You must not have heard me.

Comment on this
Pádraic Ó Maille AN LEAS-CHEANN COMHAIRLE Cumann na nGaedheal

The Deputy must address the Chair.

Comment on this

You said that the electricity works in Dublin at present not only supply light and heat, but make a profit of £50,000 a year.

Comment on this

I said no such thing. I never mentioned the sum of £50,000.

Comment on this

You read out a list of profits made by the electrical works in Dublin for 10 or 15 years. You quoted that in one year a profit was made of £60,000, another year £50,000, and another year again £23,000, and so on. If I am inaccurate in anything to the extent of quoting these figures, I make a present of the amount of that inaccuracy to the Deputy. But he is running away from the point he was making——

Comment on this

I never run away.

Comment on this

It is something like it. I submit that the users in Dublin were doing a fair thing when they paid for the electricity. There should not be any liability on them to pay anything towards the rates. The case in opposition to this Bill is based on the assumption that they are liable. With regard to the question of compensation, it seems to me, as an outsider, that the user in Dublin will look at the matter from this point of view, "Am I to pay more or less for my electric light in future; am I to get the same advantages, the same amount of light, or more?" and he will consider the question of compensation does not arise unless something is taken from him, and that the advantages that he enjoys are not lessened in any way. In anything that has been published by authorities on electrical works for the last 20 or 30 years in England and other countries the conclusion arrived at was that electrical schemes must as far as possible be concentrated, because the more they are divided the less chance there is of profits. They all urge unity of generation as far as possible. If you go to any Dublin citizen and say to him: "It is open to you to continue to have your electricity generated as at present, or to come under the Shannon scheme, where you will have better and cheaper light," what would be his decision? Under the present scheme, if there was a coal strike, as there was last year in England, he might have to pay a double price for his electricity, and the whole concern might even have to be shut up, whereas under the Shannon scheme, the only possibility he has to dread is that some day the Shannon might cease to flow. In my opinion the average citizen of Dublin would be quite satisfied to come under the Shannon scheme, and would regard with anxiety the possibility of being excluded from it.

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

When this general question came up on Friday last I voted against the amendment which was moved. There are one or two objections I have heard regarding this question, and I think it is only right to give the Minister an opportunity of dealing with them. There is, as the Minister said, and I agree with him, an extension of municipalisation in this case, but there is this point to be considered. The citizens of Dublin have an undertaking which is held in trust for them, and if we leave out for the moment the fact that we have Commissioners instead of an elected corporation, it would be within the control of the citizens, as the trustees would be elected by themselves. Is there anything in the Bill guaranteeing that the citizens will get as good or a better or cheaper service than at present, seeing that they will not henceforth have that same measure of control they now have? There will, I grant, be new trustees, but the citizens will not have the same measure of control over them as they have had.

It has also been pointed out, no matter how fantastic the idea may appear, that it would be possible under this Bill for the Board to take over this undertaking and run it for three, or four, or five years and then sell it to a private company. I am not saying that is possible, but I am pointing out to the Minister that that suggestion has been made to me. These are objections that are being made by the man in the street, and I think the Minister should deal with them.

Comment on this

The arguments that have been running through the criticisms of the Bill seem to concentrate on how it will work as regards the Dublin station, and rightly so, I think, for Dublin as a municipal electricity undertaking is of pre-eminent value as compared with other electricity undertakings in this State. The Minister has searched all the archives for statements that would help his case. He relied on statements made by Mr. Kettle and the Town Clerk under totally different circumstances. One must admit that these statements were made on the personal authority of the individuals concerned. I do not think that they could be taken as more than an expression of opinion at that time, and it was not an unnatural position for them to take up in connection with the conflict which was waged before the Private Bill Committee, where the Corporation were up in arms against other undertakings which were making proposals for doing the same work as themselves.

Circumstances, of course, alter cases. Obviously, whereas the Town Clerk and the City Electrical Engineer may have been expressing opinions which they thought at the time were their opinions, the circumstances were altogether different from those which arise to-day and which present a different aspect to their minds. It is a grand debating point for the Minister, excellently prepared for him by his opponents, because I do not think it can be said that either Mr. Kettle or the Town Clerk is in favour of the proposal embodied in the Bill. The President, intervening in the discussion, said that the basis of municipal life was comprised in the period between the 31st March and the 1st April of the following year. In other words, that the whole of the municipal structure is of a butterfly nature, and that an act done on the 1st April has no bearing on an act done on the 31st March. That, of course, is absurd and you cannot look at the subject in that light. I suggest that the proper light to look at it is this: that the citizens of Dublin, through their elected representatives, decided they would organise and institute a system of electrical supply for themselves. There is no use in talking about the consumers paying the bill in the sense that the starting of the station was the action of the elected representatives; that some of the ratepayers took the electric light and that in the earlier stages of the undertaking the big majority of them had no interest or concern in it as consumers.

In the course of time losses were made and paid for, profits were made and dealt with, but in each year, whether they had losses or profits, the whole position was reviewed by a Committee of the Corporation, which then decided what it would do either with the surplus or the deficit. There is no use in the Minister getting up and stating that the policy of the Corporation was to make a surplus and pay off the rates. The underlying principle involved in the carrying on of the municipal undertaking was to provide electricity for the consumers at a price which, on a commercial basis, was competing with other forms of energy and light. Considering the municipal undertaking during the years that it has been in operation, the substantial profits arising from it were only made in recent years. I am sure that the Corporation, as the elected body, representing the citizens, would, in the event of the station making any substantial profits recognise that the surplus remaining over should go in the direction of reducing the rates to the consumers. One must remember, as in the case of any trading body, that you may lay down what you think are the rates which will come out of either profits or losses. In the course of the ups and downs of the year it would never be possible for an undertaking such as this to base its operations in such a way that it would come out a line ball. Therefore, any accusation against the intentions of the Corporation would have to be based on an unreasonable amount of profits being developed in the course of operations during the year. In any commercial concern starting at zero and working on to a certain point of prosperity, the whole outlook as regards the future is in the nature of creating a definite interest in the concern. What I complain about is that while the Dublin station was working and extending, growing in importance and usefulness and creating a really valuable asset, that when, as I think the Minister expressed it, the extended municipal idea of nationalisation comes into operation, due regard must be had to the value of the undertaking that is taken over from the citizens of Dublin and at the time that it is being taken over.

It is not right, in a transaction of this kind, to ignore the commercial value created any more than it would be in the amalgamation of certain companies. The Minister has laboured the idea that the municipal authorities, from statements that have been made, were prepared to go out to make a substantial profit on the undertaking. I think that is a travesty of any intentions or expressions that were given on behalf of the contention that Dublin was being treated unjustly by the Bill. There was no such intention on the part of the municipalities as far as anybody knows. That does not justify the Minister in not recognising the value of the asset that is being brought into the pool, according to his view, in the national interest. We are talking here about the return to the ratepayers— this point has really been laboured—of sums of money that were paid by sets of ratepayers who have disappeared. That, I think, is hardly the point. I would rather put it this way: Supposing a man, by the exercise of his industry and ability, creates an asset for himself, would it be just or proper that somebody else should come along and say to his son "You did not create that asset and must be deprived of it altogether"? Broadly speaking, that is what we object to. As regards comparing a national undertaking with a local undertaking Deputy O'Connell must recognise in connection with this criticism that the people of Dublin will not be satisfied or jubilant even, apart from questioning the value of what was taken over, if they have no say in the administration of their own affairs. You may as well come down to rock bottom and recognise that the policy in this Bill is to deprive citizens of Dublin of the right to manage their own property and control their own affairs. The Government may just as well say that they were going to nationalise municipalities as a whole and create a body or Board, perhaps situated in Limerick, to manage the affairs of the township or city. I think if the citizens of Dublin were asked to express an opinion on that point they would be strong in saying that they would prefer to have control of the management of their own affairs.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

What objection did they make when the Corporation was abolished?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

resumed the Chair.

Comment on this

I think there was a great deal of objection from various sources.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

Not from the people objecting to this proposal.

Comment on this

Does Deputy O'Connell maintain that the same causes that operated in the appointment of Commissioners apply to the electricity concern of the Corporation?

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

It took control out of the hands of the representatives of the people.

Comment on this

They did not hand it over to someone in Limerick.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

They were not asked to whom they were to hand it over.

Comment on this

I think that is another red herring and that Deputy O'Connell is taking a leaf out of the Minister's book.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

The Deputy is taking a leaf out of ours.

Comment on this

This is the blind leading the blind in the matter. If there were any reasons for the Commissioners being appointed it was on the score of mismanagement. Right through the Bill they recognise the obligation to submit to the control of the Board if inefficiency is disclosed in any direction. The Minister says: "I do not care whether it is inefficient or not." That is not the purpose. I say, as far as the views of the citizens of Dublin are concerned, if you ask them whether they are content, or will be content, for any length of time to continue the operation of the affairs of the city by three Commissioners or to have the control and administration of their electrical light distribution taken over by a Board, they will not agree to either one or the other.

Comment on this

What would the electricity consumers do?

Comment on this

In this matter there is no difference between the electricity consumer and the ratepayer; as far as the electricity consumer is concerned, the only thing is that at present there is no obligation on him to take the municipal supply. He has an alternative. Certainly any alternative he has of supporting any measure that would give him relief is done away with by the establishment of the Board.

Comment on this

We can narrow down the discussion to this point, if we can get this understood. Is the dispute between us that the electricity concern owned by a local authority should make profits and distribute them to the ratepayers?

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

I have a suspicion that we discussed that already.

Comment on this

The Minister said it was immoral.

Comment on this

The President does not want an answer.

Comment on this

Deputy Sears referred to the fact, and I think the President indicated something of the same kind, that the consumer in Dublin, if offered better light at a lower price per unit, would be willing to accept it. I think it is plain that he would, as an individual. On what basis do you say in this Act that a consumer in Dublin is going to get better or cheaper light? Is there any guarantee whatsover that in giving up the right to manage their own affairs they are, in fact, going to get cheaper and better light? If we have a guarantee of that it will help the citizens of Dublin to be satisfied with the position before them, that what they have built up in value in connection with the establishment of the electricity undertaking is to be handed over, without any compensation, to the Board that has been set up.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Deputy Hewat may play with the idea that it is impossible to get a line-ball situation with such an undertaking as electricity. I have never asserted it is possible. What I am against is the declared intention of having profits made and distributed to other people than those from whom the profits are got. That is the clear case, apart from the idea of always being on the right side and not having a loss, and the declared proposition of the last two or three days is that the township here has a right to make extra charges to get in more money than what the service costs, and to distribute that surplus; that is what this amendment is designed to prevent. The Deputy has spoken of red-herrings. I have not seen one yet to equal, in its diverting powers, any red-herring like the one the Deputy introduces of handing over control to a body in Limerick. That is the first time I have heard of the body in Limerick. I do not know where that emerges from except it be the Deputy's excited imagination. That is equal to the rest of the Deputy's statements, and this is an amazing thing: The ratepayers and the electricity consumers in Dublin are the same people: When you are talking of one you are talking of the other. Let us take the numbers. There are about 50,000 ratepayers and 12,500 electricity consumers; yet the 50,000 is the equivalent of the 12,500.

Comment on this

It was by the sale to the bigger number that the assets were created.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy should have made his own argument at the right time. The statement was that you were talking of two bodies, but really they were the same one. They were the same crowd. Fifty thousand is equal to 12,500. If that is the sort of calculation as to the cost of generation, bulk price, etc., there is to be more argument than I have looked forward to.

Deputy O'Connell asked me two questions that require an answer. The second, which I will put first, is as to control—as to the possibility of the Board at some time after it is established and having acquired a number of undertakings, handing over the amalgamated undertakings, or some section of them, to a company which might operate for gain. I do not think that is possible under the Bill. Certainly we will see that it is rendered absolutely impossible. Section 8 rather has a small bearing on it. Section 8 says:—

The Board may exercise any of the powers and perform any of the functions and duties (other than the making of orders) conferred and imposed on the Board by this Act through or by any of its officers or servants authorised by the Board in that behalf.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

I said selling to a company—disposing.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is the only power that the Board has got by way of divesting itself of certain duties and functions excepting this: that where it takes control of a particular undertaking it may hand back, after a five year period of control or a lesser period, that undertaking to the original owner. Those being the only two ways in which I see the Board could dives itself of any of those duties or any property which comes into its hands. I think the point raised by the Deputy really is not one we need fear. If there is a gap I certainly will stop it, because it is not part of my intention. unless there came about such a situation, such a state of things, that application were again made to the Oireachtas, and the Oireachtas decided that in some new state of things the best thing to do was to abolish the Board and let some private company take over. But until that day, and without specific approval by legislation almost of the Oireachtas, I do not think what the Deputy envisages should be allowed to occur. If there is the slightest fear of it, I will guarantee that that fear will be removed.

On the other point: Is there anything to guarantee a better or cheaper service than now?—the answer to that point must be taken in relation to what I have already said on Section 37, where I have already indicated to Deputy Thrift that I would get an amendment phrased in some way to achieve this: that that portion of the charge which relates to cost of distribution will have a relation to the liability taken over by the Board in taking over the particular district. In other words that when one comes to make up the rate at which Dublin consumers will have to pay for electricity, there will be, as I said, four items to be considered (a) generating costs, (b) costs of distribution. That cost of distribution will have to include whatever be the extra liabilities imposed on the Board in taking over the Dublin undertaking, but will not be allowed to include the liabilities incurred by the Board in taking over some area down the country. I have to include in Dublin the transformer district of Dublin. Let me put it that way. There can be no discrimination afterwards as between Dublin and Pembroke and Rathmines. They will be served from one transformer station, and it will be the addition to the cost there that will include the distribution cost.

Having said that, I put it to anybody that we have to consider four items in making up the final account that any electricity consumer has to pay. He pays (1) generation and transmission costs; (2) costs of the local network— the cost of the local distribution; (3) the wiring of his premises or house; (4) his appliances. On the appliances, undoubtedly, the Board will be able to give him cheaper material. On the matter of wiring, the Board will be able to give him facilities. I do not insist at the moment on cheaper wiring although I think that will come—I think it is bound to come. At any rate, there will be better facilities in the way of spreading out the costs. The mere fact that we have been told that over a period when the Dublin Commissioners were, on the Dublin undertaking, only able to make £60,000, a Finance Corporation could be found to offer £1,500,000—the ordinary amount to be looked for to recoup that would be on the eight per cent., as taken as the ordinary return on an electricity undertaking, £120,000 —shows there is any amount of money to be made in economies and in better management and in distribution in Dublin with an efficient system.

Comment on this

Does the Minister make the accusation that the Dublin undertaking is in an inefficient state?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The people who have been writing in the papers and talking about the £1,500,000 offer have made that charge, not I. They have, by implication, made that charge. If you take that £1,500,000 and invest it and take the ordinary return looked for on an undertaking, and take it, as Deputy Byrne said, that that one-and-a-half millions was offered in relation to all the charges, then if the Commissioners were only able to make £60,000 and somebody else says that this is able to make £100,000 or £120,000, there is a necessary implication. I have not made it—I am calling attention to it.

Comment on this

Was there ever a one-and-a-half million offer?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not think there was, but Deputy Byrne said there had been.

Comment on this

He must have made a slip of the tongue.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

There must have been a great many made in the course of the last few days. I do not want to make for Deputy Byrne the excuse that Deputy Hewat has made for Mr. Kettle and Mr. Murphy, that they put up arguments that were not facing the circumstances that are facing us to-day, and consequently their words are not to be taken as literally true. I would hesitate to have a defender like Deputy Hewat when he puts up a defence of that sort. On generating costs, I ask Deputy O'Connell and anybody else interested to consider that the experts' estimates on the sale of a particular number of units, on the costs as estimated for the building out of the scheme, run to 53 of a penny at the outskirts of Dublin, or to 8 all over the country, and that it is necessary for that scheme to advance from being a five million scheme to being a fifteen million scheme before the generating costs are going to come to what we are told, and have not yet examined, are the generating costs in Dublin at the present moment. On all four items, generating cost, cost of local distribution, wiring of houses and appliances. there is no guarantee; nobody can give a guarantee, but there is every likelihood that the consumer is going to be benefited in each of these ways. I have been asked by Deputy Myles if I could give a guarantee, and I replied in a casual way: Is a guarantee from me worth anything? It has to be dealt with in the light of all the circumstances. I will not be driven into making futile efforts about guarantees that mean nothing, but I have said to the Dáil that when the scheme looks to me to be going to cost more than £5,200,000, that is, adding in interest and loss on working, I feel I will be bound to come to the Dáil and announce that. I had not made any announcement up to date on that point. I have no evidence that the scheme is going to cost more than the original estimate. That means that the cost of generating still stands at the estimate of the experts at 53 outside Dublin and 8 all over the country and, that being so, there is an undoubted benefit going to be given immediately to the Dublin consumer. The Dublin consumer will have to pay for the local distribution liabilities he is under at the moment and there is a question: Will better management or other management get him any benefit? There is, however, a very obvious benefit he is going to get through the sale of appliances at a cheaper rate and definite facilities by way of wiring of houses or getting money advanced for various purposes. It does not amount to a guarantee, but it is the most moral certainty that ever there was.

Amendment 92 put and declared carried, the names of Deputies Good, Hewat, A. Byrne and Myles being recorded against the amendment.

SECTION 77.

Comment on this

I move amendment 89:—

In addition to the power conferred upon the Board by this Act to make advances to local authorities it shall be lawful for local authorities to borrow for the purposes of this Act subject to the provisions and restrictions contained in sections 237, 238 and 240 to 243 (both inclusive) of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878.

I leave the matter in the hands of the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not know what that means. If the Deputy likes to leave it for my consideration or rejection well and good.

Comment on this

I leave it in the Minister's hands in this way. I do not want to prolong the proceedings. The Minister understands the meaning of the amendment perfectly well, and if he says he is not going to accept it I shall withdraw it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would like to get an opportunity of examining the-particular sections of the Public Health Act referred to in order to make it clear to myself.

Comment on this

As a matter of fact, I feel some embarrassment because I do not know the sections myself.

Comment on this

I should like to be taken as dissenting.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

We shall take Deputy Byrne as objecting to Section 77.

Comment on this

I raised a question earlier in the evening in regard to standard poles, and perhaps I might get some information on the point now. I asked the Minister whether in the event of the land on which standard poles were erected being available for building, these poles would be removed, and he said "No." Then I asked him if he would not remove the standard poles from land which could not be let if they were continued there, whether compensation would be paid to the owner, and he said "No." That seems an extraordinary situation. I do not know whether the owner of the land has a right to object to the position in connection with the standard poles. But if this land should become valuable for building purposes the Minister refuses to move the poles. Might I point out to him what happens in connection with another department of the State somewhat analogous. We have telephone poles and poles carrying wires in connection with telegraphs set up in the country. They are frequently erected an positions from which they have to be removed by reason of certain developments, and that particular Department, when it is pointed out to it that these poles are causing obstruction, makes no difficulty whatever in having them moved. Here is a parallel case, but the Minister refuses to remove the poles. He thereby does injury to the owner of the land and refuses compensation. That, in my view, is a most unfair and unreasonable position. I ask the Minister if he has considered that answer in the meantime and if he cannot see his way to insert something in this Bill that will meet, what is admitted to be, unfair to particular persons.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The Deputy has brought up an analogy which is by no means perfect. He says because the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has removed poles that may interfere with a site that is going to be built upon, I should be able and ready to move poles or towers erected for the transmission system. There is no analogy between the two types of poles. If he asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to remove the Post Office, would the Deputy get a favourable answer? That would be more of an analogy with my transmission towers. It is not possible to remove the transmission towers, and if it was possible it could not be done under Section 80.

Section 80 gives me, if anything, a little more leave in that regard, because it says that these pillars, poles and stands "so erected as aforesaid shall be and remain the property of the Minister." But that has no reaction upon the particular points to which the Deputy is referring. I gave him the other day not merely an answer, but I gave him a reason for the answer, that wires for communications and wires for electricity are entirely different things. The thing to avoid in the transmission system is any diversion which would prevent the line from running in as straight a course as possible. That would entail the erection of strain poles. These in themselves are much more expensive than any of the other type of pole, and in addition there is a danger to the whole system by these strain poles and by making the line run in a crooked way, and consequently there is no analogy. On the matter of compensation, I said that I did propose to pay compensation for the erection of the poles in the ordinary way, but, following the Continental practice, that would be merely nominal and would have no relation to the damage done But here this special point of compensation for poles is on the assumption that they would prevent lands otherwise useful for building ground from being so used, but that is a special point that we cannot deal with here.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider it?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Certainly. I think it would mean an amendment of the 1925 Act. I do not know whether it is possible to bring in other amendments to the 1925 Act, in addition to what was first stated. It would mean a special amending section.

Comment on this

This admitted grievance possibly arose from an oversight. Could we not insert something in this that would meet that grievance?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I do not think it is possible to do so, but if it is a grievance it is still prospective. No case of it has yet occurred.

Comment on this

Will the Minister see that in the case of entry on private property some application will first be made to the owner of the house, garden, field, or whatever it is, for permission for the men to go in and select the places for the poles? To go in without first receiving permission would not be at all courteous to any citizen.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It has to be proved that it is being done.

Comment on this

It is no harm to mention it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would like Deputy Myles to intervene and say that Deputy Byrne does not mean what he said.

Comment on this

I do not want any Deputy to make an apology for anything I say in this House.

Comment on this

Will the Minister say that the people on whose lands these poles are to be erected have a right to object, and that their objections will be considered?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That matter is dealt with in a particular section of the 1925 Act. The procedure was laid down, and I presume that that procedure will be followed. But also the contractors, acting under authority from me, have certain powers with regard to the erection of these poles, and these will also be exercised. But, of course, every effort will be made to have regard to existing circumstances in particular localities and to see what can be done.

Comment on this

If the Minister would recognise the necessity for safeguarding the rights of the people I think he would deal more fully with the point as regards making everybody alive to the fact that it is desirable not to put poles in that position at all. In other words, in consideration of the position in which the poles will be erected, due consideration should be given to the fact that they may be injurious to certain property, and that that injury might be avoided by altering the sites of the poles.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Obviously the poles will be put in positions that will entail the least possible payment of compensation.

Comment on this

If that is recognised—

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

It is.

Comment on this

But will the owner of the land be consulted to make sure that the poles are being put in the least objectionable positions?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am afraid I have not made myself clear. Once the line is established there really can be very little diversion from the course settled upon. In a matter like the digging of the canal we could swing about to avoid disturbing this, that and the other thing, and in the matter of telegraph wires that could also be done to a great extent. But in the matter of these transmission lines it is a question of getting the straightest course possible, and once we enter upon these transmission lines it is only within very narrow limits that any changes can be made.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 93 is to exempt from Customs duty matter "which was or is apparatus for electrical cooking or heating." The section aims at exempting articles which are intended to be used solely for the purposes of or in connection with the Shannon works. I think that the extension aimed at by the amendment is not in order here. It would, of course, be quite in order on the Finance Bill, which will be coming before us shortly.

Comment on this

It is a question of the application of Customs duty.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

To electrical appliances that concern the Shannon scheme.

Comment on this

Perhaps it is a little presumptive for me to indicate to the Minister for Finance what he ought to do.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Of course, the Deputy will have opportunities after Easter to indicate that to the Minister for Finance on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I think that this section is open to serious objection, because it leaves a loophole for possible irregularities. There may be a gain under it, but I think that that gain would not justify it. I think if it could be avoided it would be better.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The point has been made to me that the section, as drafted, is far too wide, and that although there is a definite limitation in it to articles imported that are being, or are intended to be, used solely for the purposes of or in connection with the Shannon works, that it might apply not merely to the original Shannon works, but to articles required in the way of maintenance and repairs, and that it might be held to cover a very wide variety of articles. Any examination I have been able to make has not led me to believe that a great variety of articles which might be covered are now liable to Customs duties, but inasmuch as the number of articles which it was desired to exempt is very small and will have no appreciable effect on the scheme, in order to avoid any confusion or any heartburning on the matter I was prepared to withdraw the whole section. I will move that on the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Then the Minister intends to delete this section altogether?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think so.

Comment on this

I would only like to express my approval of his action. I think it is very undesirable to raise the question of preferential treatment in the event of there being any competition in the matter of electrical appliances.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

Amendment 94 is taken as decided.

Comment on this

Always subject to consideration by the Minister as to its application in any particular section. Would he agree to adopting it where it is applicable?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I have urged very strongly against the appointment of the arbitrator being taken out of my own hands and put into the hands of the Chief Justice on the clause dealing with evaluation on acquisition, and it was definitely defeated there. What I am prepared to do is to move an amendment on these lines: That wherever there is a legal question as the outstanding point to be determined, the arbitrator would be a legal man and would be then appointed by the Chief Justice. In other words, the Chief Justice, being the obvious person to appoint legal people and having the best idea as to who would be the proper legal person for a particular legal point, I would certainly bring him in in such a case. But it would be a matter of finding out where that would occur. It would not occur on the matter of value on acquisition, or on any of these value points. There it would be somebody like an engineer with a finance outlook who could estimate what the value of the plant was, how much depreciation there had been, and so on, and definitely value a certain amount of plant and prospects. Where it is a legal matter I would look into it and see that a legal person would be appointed, and that would be under the Chief Justice.

Comment on this

Not necessarily a legal matter, but where ordinarily a legal person would be appointed to the position of arbitrator the Minister would be prepared to do that?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes, I will try to bring in an amendment along those lines.

Comment on this

I move:—

To add at the end of sub-section (1) the words "an appeal from the decision of such arbitrator may be made to the Circuit Court Judge."

I want to impress on the Minister the desirability of an appeal from the decision of the arbitrator. It is the custom in all legal institutions; there is an appeal from the District Justice to the Circuit Court, and so on. I ask for the same treatment under this Bill. If the decision of the arbitrator is not satisfactory, the undertaker should have the right to appeal, that he should have some safeguard to fall back on, some rock to steady himself on. I think the Minister might give in on this point.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

The point that strikes me is this: If there is going to be any appeal at all, say on such a matter as the amount to be paid on acquisition of an undertaking, I cannot imagine any two people agreeing on the same sum down to the last penny. You will have some difference of opinion; there are bound to be some little points here and there which will not appear in the same light to any two individuals. It would be very hard to get exactly the same sum decided on. Why have two methods of procedure, going first to the arbitrator and then going to a Circuit Court Judge? If there was some legal point in dispute, and if there was a reference further wanted with regard to the legal point, I would not have any objection to it. There are so very few legal points arising in connection with this; it will be simply a matter of valuing property and prospects.

Comment on this

Take the case of a malicious burning. What special knowledge has a Circuit Judge to assess damages? This is a similar position.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Exactly, but the way the Circuit Judge arrives at an opinion is that he gets in assessors or expert witnesses. It was thought that arbitration proceedings would generally be cheaper than court proceedings. There is a scale of court fees, and all the rest, and there would be an array of counsel, solicitors and others. It was thought better to try to avoid that. The whole aim and object is to have agreements come to in the cheapest way, because eventually, whatever be the cost of proceedings, it will, in some way or other, be borne by the electricity consumers. The thing is to have one procedure, either court proceedings or arbitration proceedings, and when one comes to determine on that, I think there is no doubt about it that arbitration proceedings are much the better type for the settlement of the problems that will arise, and there is no necessity to involve it by having, first of all, arbitration, trying to get cheapness, security, ease and determination, and then having an appeal to the Circuit Court, having additions by way of costs to the whole proceedings, these costs being eventually borne, either by the Board or by the undertaker, and in any event paid for by the consumer. If a legal point was involved I could see a certain amount of reason for an appeal to a legal man from one who is not a legal man, but not under any other considerations. I ask the Deputy to think of it from the point of view of the costs that might be piled up.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should not anticipate such enormous costs in the Circuit Court. We passed rules here the object of which was to give cheaper law to the people. I would remind the Minister that in the cases I have in mind the men concerned would be fighting for their life's savings, their life's work, and they would like to have some final court of appeal. It will mean absolute ruin to the people concerned if a mistake should be made, and I think it would be only fair to give them a chance of going further. The Circuit Court would not be so expensive in cases of that kind.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Any expenses are additional to the arbitration expenses. Unless there is a big necessity for these expenses being added, I would ask that the matter be reconsidered. Certainly one could not have it that in every case that goes to the arbitrator there should be an appeal. There may be a limited number of cases, which the Deputy can pick out between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Will the Minister undertake to make provision on the Report Stage that in the case of the compensation to be awarded to a private undertaker he shall have the right of appeal to the Circuit Court?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

That is the very point on which I would not like to have an appeal; at least I would not like to have double procedure. If the Deputy does not like the arbitrator let him move to substitute the Circuit Court.

Comment on this

In this matter the Minister is thinking too much of economy. I suppose he is fortified by the Minister for Finance, who has come in and sat beside him. I think a very much more important point has been raised by Deputy Myles, that is, the feeling of security of the litigant, who will really be the defendant, in this matter. I think the Minister might really take a less serious view of the cost that will be involved in taking a case before the Circuit Court Judge, in view of the greater confidence that will be engendered in the mind of the person whose property is to be the subject of assessment.

Comment on this

May I make a suggestion to the Minister that in the case of an appeal to the Circuit Court, if the party aggrieved shall show cause to the Minister, the Minister may allow an appeal to the Circuit Court?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I would not care to have that jurisdiction thrust on me at all or on any other layman to follow me. What I can do is to consider this further with a view to allowing the undertaker in certain instances to opt for the Circuit Court Judge or for the arbitrator. I do not like this idea of appeal. I would prefer to have the case tried in a single way.

Comment on this

The Minister will remember that the cases I want particularly considered are those whose whole means of livelihood may be taken away by this measure.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

The Deputy is not pressing the amendment?

Comment on this

No. I desire to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 97:—

Before sub-section (2) to insert a new sub-section as follows:—

"(2) There shall be paid to every arbitrator appointed under this section such fee in respect of every arbitration held by him under this Act as shall be determined by the Minister with the approval of the Minister for Finance and such fee shall be paid by such party to such arbitration or by the parties to such arbitration in such proportions as the arbitrator in his award shall determine."

This is a point which I consider very necessary. It is to make allowance for the payment of fees to an arbitrator and for the division of the fees between the parties to the arbitration, leaving it to the arbitrator to decide the proportion to be borne by the parties.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move amendment 98:—

To add at the end of the section the following new sub-section:—

"(2) The Board and also any authorised undertaker with the consent of the Board may pay the reasonable expenses of the attendance at any conference or meeting of any such associations as aforesaid of (in the case of the Board) any member, officer or servant of the Board and (in the case of an authorised undertaker) of any person appointed by such undertaker to be his representative at such conference or meeting."

The section allows contribution to be made to certain associations which are described. The amendment is a necessary addition.

Comment on this

I move amendment

In sub-section (1), line 42, to delete the word "space" and substitute therefor the word "place."

I am doing this on behalf of Deputy Cole, in whose name the amendment stands. This is dealing with a matter I raised the other day. It touches upon the definition of a place. What I want to make clear is that the words "place" and "space" are used a bit loosely. It may happen that a man, in his private grounds, will be prevented from bringing electricity from, say, his house to his garage by the use of these words here.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I am not sure yet as to what the change involves. Can the matter be held over until I further consider it?

Comment on this

I am quite satisfied, and, therefore, I will withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

The following amendment stands in my name:—

In sub-section (2), line 52, after the word "lawful" to insert the words "after the Board has been established."

There is the same point in this section as I raised on a previous section. and the Minister said he would consider it. In the circumstances I will not move the amendment.

Comment on this
Michael Hayes AN CEANN COMHAIRLE

That matter has already been dealt with.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will ask that amendments 99 and 100 might disappear for ever, because wherever there is reason for the Chief Justice to be substituted for the Minister, surely it is not in this matter of deciding whether or not trees should be lopped.

Comment on this

A work of supererogation.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In amendments 101 to 107, inclusive, there are really two points and I think I might move them all together:—

101. In sub-section (1), page 42, in line 57, after the word "divest" to insert the words "the Minister or."

102. In sub-section (1), page 42, line 60, after the word "navigation" to insert the words "and of the drainage works."

103. In sub-section (1), page 42, line 62, after the word "navigation" to insert the words "and drainage."

104. In sub-section (1), page 42, in line 63, after the word "said" to insert the words "Minister or the said" and after the word "by" to insert the words "or under."

105. In sub-section (2), page 43, in line 2, after the word "divesting" to insert the words "the said Minister or."

106. In sub-section (2), page 43, line 3, after the word "aforesaid" to insert the words "the said Minister or."

107. In sub-section (2), page 43, in line 10, after the word "by" to insert the words "the said Minister or."

It is merely to put in every place where the "Commissioners of Public Works" occur the words "Minister or" in front and to add on the word "drainage" in addition to "navigation." The point about the first amendment is that there were certain functions which, at one time, were carried out by the Commissioners of Public Works and which really belonged to them. These were transferred to the Minister for Industry and Commerce and have not since been re-transferred. Some of the functions of the Commissioners of Public Works remain with the Minister and, so far as these relate to navigation or drainage, we want to have power to divest both the Minister and the Commissioners of the functions and hand them to the Board. The other point involved in the amendments is to transfer to the Board these functions at present under the authority either of the Commissioners of Public Works or the Minister for Industry and Commerce in relation, not merely to navigation, but also to drainage works around that area.

Comment on this

The new Board will take it over?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes. It is necessary that they will. The executive Council may by Order divest either the Minister or the Commissioners of such function relating to these matters and transfer them to the Board.

Comment on this

What will the position be in regard to navigation? The Board gets control of all questions in connection with the navigation of the Shannon?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

In place of the Board of Works?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this

What will the attitude of the Board be on that matter? Is it purely for the protection of the works that you prefer to do this? Why can it not remain as it is? So far as navigation is concerned, why should it not remain under its present control?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No; because the one point essential to the navigation is the question of the water levels. The Commissioners of Public Works are bound to keep the level to certain heights. This does not mean that the Board, on getting the powers, will simply neglect to keep the water at different levels. It is quite obvious that the Board, having complete control of the Shannon for power purposes, and having control of the level of Lough Derg—unless this proposal is carried out there is going to be a conflict of authority. The Board of Works are trying to navigate on certain levels. It is not proposed to interfere with the levels. Instead of having one Board dealing with navigation and another Board dealing with pretty well everything else, in which connection there will be a conflict of authority, it is proposed that the one Board should deal with all. Otherwise there would be two bodies looking after what one can do quite easily. There is simply an amalgamation of duties, and it seems these duties could be better carried out by the Board. There will be no interference with the rights or obligations existing, except those are modified by Order.

Comment on this

But the Board would have power to disregard the importance of navigation?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

No, they will be bound by what the Commissioners of Public Works do.

Comment on this

They transfer the obligations?

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Yes.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I move:—

In sub-section (1), page 43, in line 31, to delete the word "made" and to substitute therefor the word "may."

Comment on this
Tomas O'Connell Mr. T.J. O'CONNELL Labour Party

I move:—

To insert before Section 107 a new section as follows:—

The Board and any authorised or statutory undertaker may, if they think fit, adopt and any such undertaker shall if so required by the Board, adopt the provisions of Part IV. of the Local Government Act, 1925 (No. 5 of 1925), in the same manner as if the Board or such undertaker, as the case may be, were a local body within the meaning of that part of the said Act, and upon such adoption the provisions of that part of the said Act shall apply as if the Board or such undertaker were such a local body as aforesaid.

I have no hesitation in putting forward this amendment as a reasonable one, because not only the Government and public bodies but all well organised private undertakings have pension schemes for their employees. The result is that better service is given by employees. If that were not so, I do not think so many large private undertakings and companies would have established these schemes. The amendment does not impose a superannuation scheme on the Board, but authorises it, if it wishes, to establish one. It is only right that the Board should have authority to do so, if it thinks that as a result better service will be given. I do not agree with the cry that is sometimes heard about giving pensions to everyone. Pensions form a part of employees remuneration, and they are entitled to get them. After all, pensions are deferred pay. I hope the Committee will adopt the principle of the amendment and give the Board power to set up a superannuation scheme on the lines laid down in the Local Government Act.

Comment on this

I could support this amendment in a general way, but I think it is difficult to understand why a certain section of people should be pensionable and others not. I think the Labour Party would be doing a better service if it produced a scheme that would have general application rather than one dealing with particular cases. If the Minister is right this is not a State scheme but one based on commercial lines, so that the application of the clause for pensions would refer just as much to other undertakings of a similar kind. I do not think the Executive Council would be prepared to advance the proposition that all commercial undertakings should provide pensions for their staffs.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

Should they prevent them doing so?

Comment on this

My attention has been drawn to the fact that the amendment seems to be a little out of place, because it follows Section 106, which deals with the prohibition of discharge of corrosive matter into the River Shannon, and comes before a section referring to the Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

At one time I had in the section a phrase which would have allowed the Board to pay its officers and servants not merely remuneration and allowances but pensions and gratuities. I took the words out for this reason: that I thought it was better not to have them in for the first period of the Board, because the first five years is going to be somewhat of an experimental period. One cannot foresee exactly what changes may have to be made in the attitude of the Board towards the employees after the first five years are over. One would not like to have the second Board coming along and finding itself involved with a tremendous number of officers, who had obtained pensionable rights from the start of the Board's operations. I believe that a Board such as this, operating such an undertaking, should eventually establish a pension system for the officials. In fact, I have a certain idea that there might be a pensions scheme for members of the Board, because they will be taken from fairly lucrative occupations, so as to get the proper men, and they are given a very small tenure of office. They may have lost their own business and wasted the best years of their lives in the service of the Board and then be suddenly flung out. It might be desirable to have some pensions scheme arranged hereafter out of the revenue of the Board for people who served, say, two periods of five years. I think eventually the Board should be instructed to make provision by way of pensions for its employees.

I doubt if it is wise to insist upon that or even to give them that power for the first five years, which is going to be largely an experimental period. The whole thing might have to be recast after five years. I have no suspicion that that will occur, but it might occur, and one would not like to have to face up to a situation in which there were people taken on and assured of pension rights from the start. We would have a new army of approved pensioners to deal with and, possibly, we would have to find other occupations for them. I approve of the sentiment behind Deputy O'Connell's amendment, but I do not think that amendment is appropriate until the first period of office of the Board has terminated. That has reference to the Board's staff.

The Deputy's amendment says, further, that any authorised or statutory undertaker may adopt these provisions. The reaction of that on the Board is this: The Board might acquire, say three years hence, an undertaking which, in the meantime, had established a pension scheme for all its officials. The Board might find itself with two groups of employees—(1) employees taken over from a local authority, or authorised undertaking, which had adopted a pension scheme under-which all its servants were pensionable, and (2) its own servants, specially recruited for its own purposes, without pensions. That would be an invidious position in which to place the Board. I do not know whether this suggestion would meet the Deputy—that we would try to forecast that after the first period of service of the Board this amendment might begin to run. That could be done, but it is hardly the thing to do. It is really a matter that should be left over and argued later, when one sees how the Board is operating, or when the question of the setting up of the second Board arises at the end of the five-year period. That would be the appropriate time to consider an amendment of this sort.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

The Minister must realise the difficulty involved by the fact that, if no provision is made in this Bill, it will be almost impossible to get legislation passed with the special object of providing a pension scheme for these people later. I have had personal experience of that difficulty in another connection, as the Minister for Finance is aware. I appreciate the point made by the Minister, but I should like to know if some provision could be inserted in the Bill which would compel the Board to produce a pension scheme not later than, say, five years after establishment.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We could reinsert in sub-section (2) of Section 7 the words which were previously there —"There shall be paid by the Board to its officers and servants out of the funds at its disposal under this Act such remuneration and allowances as the Board shall determine"—and then make it an instruction to the first Board that they shall not establish a pension scheme to come into operation earlier than five years after the date of their appointment.

Comment on this
Mr. O'CONNELL

If something of that nature were done, it might meet the case.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I will consider that.

Comment on this

I want to ask the Minister to pay attention to one point when considering this matter. Even in the first five years, this new Board will have to make a number of appointments to its staff. If it is without any such powers as the Minister has mentioned, the selection by the Board of its officers will be made much more difficult. It will affect the class of applicant that will be got for the different posts. I do not think the Minister can satisfactorily divest the Board of some such power, even in the first five years.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think if the Board is asked more or less to take a risk for the first five years the employees should be willing to take a certain amount of risk also, having in view that if the scheme runs successfully they are bound to benefit. In fact it is rather an incentive to the whole body, the Board and employees to work harmoniously together to achieve good results.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister understands the point I made. My point is that any person applying for appointment as an employee of the Board would consider what is going to happen him if he became unfit for work. It would be much more attractive if he knew that after a service of some time he would have a pension.

Comment on this

Would the Minister bear in mind that he will have an enormous staff for five or ten years and that some of the staff will be redundant after ten years? A great many of them will be temporary. It might be ten years before he is able to get the staff down to normal proportions.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

I think whoever will be on the Board after the first five years will be in a position to determine what proportion of the staff is likely to become redundant after two or three years, and they would not obviously put these members on a pensionable basis.

Comment on this

Recollect you will have a manufacturing staff.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

We discussed that at considerable length.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

We "may" manufacture.

Comment on this

I hope that will not add a further difficulty to the question of the distribution of work. I hope the Minister will bear that point in view when considering this matter.

Comment on this
Patrick McGilligan Mr. McGILLIGAN

In regard to Section 109, I would like to make this statement. The section can by no means be regarded as conclusive of the dispute that is likely to arise as between the Department of Posts and Telegraphs and whatever Department that hereafter will have anything to do with this Board or with electricity and its development. This section sets out the rights of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs as they are at the moment, but some time during the next three or four months, there has to be a definite thrashing out of the respective priorities of communications and electricity —the powers that the Minister for Industry and Commerce now has on the one hand with regard to electricity undertakings and the powers of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs in regard to communications. The conflict there is will have to be resolved in some way or other, and undoubtedly there will be amending legislation required either to increase the power of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs under this Section 109 or to diminish it.

Comment on this