We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Vote 3—Department of the Taoiseach (Resumed).

Contributions 1–103 of 209. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

In the light of the question answered by the Minister for Finance about net external reserves in the banking system today, might I refer the Taoiseach to the page on the stencilled document marked "K.2"—they are not numbered in the ordinary way—in which he said:

The impact of the higher trade deficit in this year has, therefore, fallen on the external reserves of the banking system and on Government funds and by mid-May these external reserves of ours had shown a fall of £33.5 million as compared with an increase at the same time last year.

I should be glad if the Taoiseach would confirm that that is the figure he intended and that it is not a clerical slip because it seems to me it is not compatible with the figures. The external reserves of the banking system and of Departmental funds at mid-May this year were £208.6 million, as given to me in a reply in Volume 216, column 722. The external reserves in mid-May of last year were £230 million, a reduction therefore of £21.4 million and not £33.5 million, as the Taoiseach stated.

I thought, first of all, when the figures did not tally that the Taoiseach might, perhaps, have meant from the figures as they were at 31st December, or the beginning of the year, when there was a reduction all right of about the sum involved, but the Taoiseach said "as compared with an increase at the same time last year" and, last year, the May figures fell from the December figures and that explanation, therefore, does not fit the bill. Let us be quite sure in any event that we have our facts right and, not merely right, but right in such a way that they can be easily understood by all of us. I do not understand these figures and I should be glad if the Taoiseach would, when he is replying, let us know exactly to what figures he was referring, month by month, and where they came from.

The ninth point the Taoiseach made in relation to the ninth remedy was that he was going to lead a trade delegation to Britain to endeavour to negotiate there a better trade agreement for us. It would be wrong in the national interest that anyone should say anything that might in any way jeopardise or harm any negotiations that the Government might engage in. Bad and all as they are, they are the Government of our country and they must not be hindered or harmed in any way, particularly when, as I am glad to note, they have now repented of their folly in earlier years in saying that the British market was gone forever, thank God.

The Taoiseach also indicated as one of his points that the Government were going to consider external borrowing. I should like to be told what he had in mind; how temporary the borrowing is to be and the purpose for which it will be used. External borrowing, unless we use it for genuine productive efforts, could make the situation worse instead of better. I should also like to know where the Taoiseach had in mind for this borrowing. The position vis-à-vis sterling is, we hope, going to become better because much of our reserves are in the sterling area, and unless the position of sterling remains strong, we shall not have as good reserves as we would wish, but we must face the possibility that it could happen that sterling would be devalued and if that did happen, borrowing outside the sterling area could be a very expensive thing indeed for us. Therefore, it is a remedy that, particularly in present circumstances, requires to be considered most carefully.

In any case I am rather inclined to the view that any suggestion that we can solve our problems by external borrowing is going to cloud from our own people that it is on their own resources that emergence from our difficulties will depend. Only by bringing it home to our people that it is only by depending on their own resources, and ridding themselves of the blather that has been produced by every member of the Government from the Taoiseach down for the past year and a half in relation to our economic progress, can we ever hope to surmount the difficulties with which we are faced.

The final remedy to which the Taoiseach referred was the Buy Irish campaign. I understood that campaign had been progressing as hard and as vigorously as was possible and therefore I should like to know how it is hoped to step up or accentuate that campaign so that it will have good results, bearing in mind that, as was said on an earlier occasion, the Buy Irish campaign was excellent from the point of view of a reduction in our imports but in so far as it makes a soft market for our production, instead of being excellent, actually does harm to the economy and prevents exports.

The increase necessary in our industrial exports is not something that will come very easily. When discussing the Budget, one of the things for which we criticised it vigorously was that it made no effort to stimulate exports; indeed, it made no effort to stimulate production either, but it did not visualise the necessity for any increase in our exports to solve our economic problems. The Minister for Finance and the Government in that Budget were quite content that it should be utilised, not as a weapon of economic progress but merely as a weapon of transfer payments for social services. Desirable as those transfers were, nothing would enable us to keep them except a very much more vigorous and alert policy in relation to our economic activities.

The indications that the Taoiseach gave yesterday were not indications that the Government were prepared frankly to face the situation. The Taoiseach seemed to be more concerned with trying to cover himself with a protective cloak than with telling the people exactly where our difficulties were and where we were likely to go if we were to surmount them. There is no good in Ministers of the Government going on hiding their heads in the sand trying to pretend to the people at one stage that there might be a credit squeeze in some other aspect of national life but not in their particular aspect of it as the Minister for Local Government has been doing.

It is no good for the Taoiseach to try to tell the people that there has been no recession in economic progress. The circumstances he announced yesterday and the measures that will have to be taken to remedy those circumstances will show a recession, a retarding of economic growth and they will show it far less if we meet them frankly with the co-operation of everyone, instead of, as unfortunately we have had over the past month, the Government on every possible occasion throwing fuel on the flames by encouraging spending rather than saving, by their accentuating of progress and by encouraging people to look for a larger section of the national cake by all the talk of progress and wealth, by failing to meet responsibilities in relation to capital expenditure and the methods of paying for it and generally by trying to cod the people, a codding which was fraudulently done at the last general election and which was continued right up to the present time. The Taoiseach stripped that somewhat from his colleagues yesterday but there must be more frankness if we are to be able to surmount the difficulties with which we shall be faced.

Comment on this

I do not propose to deal with this matter at any great length and certainly not to deal with it in as comprehensive a way as Deputy Sweetman did in his very lengthy speech. We, as a Party and group here would certainly be hurt by the information that we had emerged curiously into a serious economic position about which there was very little prior notice. It is true that all of us had been told for a long time and up to very recently, up to the recent general election in fact, that the country was on the crest of the wave. We had been told continually by Government speakers that we were one of the greatest nations in Europe from the point of view of progress. Why an abrupt change should have come about and why there should be this deterioration in our status as a nation which was not foreseen further ahead, I cannot say.

When the Taoiseach came before the House yesterday, looking back on it, I suppose he had to lay the blame on somebody, but I should have resented from this side of the House any attempt that might be made by the Taoiseach or anybody else to pin the blame for an economic crisis on the workers or on the result of anything that those who represent them had done, in order to clear himself or somebody else who might be more responsible. We have to look at it in a straight and honest way. Were it not for our workers we would have no economy at all.

Reference was made by the Taoiseach—and probably rightly so at this stage—that any further requests for wage increases would have a detrimental effect on an already bad situation. While we do not accept that anything that might have been done in violation of the existing wage agreement had any serious effect upon the present state of the economy, we do not deny that it could be a factor. But this contravention of the long-term wages agreement, to which Labour leaders lent their hand, was not brought about because of the wage earners covetousness but because the Taoiseach and the Government proved themselves to be bigger fools than the trade unions had taken them to be.

Anybody in this country who had come to the use of reason knew that, if we were to have a long-term wages understanding here, it could only be successful if, side by side with it from 1st January, 1964, price control had been introduced. It was utterly impossible for any agreement to run its course if prices were allowed to get out of hand. That is exactly what happened. Any breach that has taken place was caused by lack of foresight on the part of the Government in not introducing the price control which the Taoiseach now says is vital. I would remind him that it was as vital on 1st January, 1964, as it is now. I do not at all agree that this breach was a serious factor in bringing about this present very undesirable situation.

Deputy Sweetman, I was glad to hear, said he did not want to avail of this bad situation to make political capital. Certainly, I would agree with him there. I would not like to hear anybody from this side of the House trying to make political capital out of this situation. What we want to do is to be helpful and constructive and to say clearly what we believe is the position without making any political capital.

We have been looking for price control from this side of the House for a long time. We are glad that, even at this late stage, the Taoiseach is coming before the House for authority to put it into effect. He can rest assured that that authority will be forthcoming from these benches. But we resent the finger of blame being pointed at the workers because we believe that, in justice and fair play, they are in no way responsible for the present situation.

Nobody could envisage the Government not introducing price control. Nevertheless, that is exactly what happened. Take, for example, the price of beer. This is something being seriously discussed the length and breadth of the country. The justification for it is something that will be examined. We feel it shows a complete disregard for Parliament and authority if the licensed vintners in provincial towns and cities can assemble together and put on any price they like. They had no more respect for this House and the Government than a bulldog would have for the rules of Shelbourne Park. Not alone should they be stopped but they should be severely chastised. Somebody may ask why men want to drink. But drink with the Irish worker, and the Dublin worker in particular, is a luxury that has become a necessity. It is traditional with our people. Because it has become a necessity, nobody should be allowed to rifle the pockets of the Irish worker in that regard. I would nearly go so far as to say that the price of beer has been more a factor in workers looking for increased wages than the price of any other commodity we might suggest.

We deplore that anything that might come from our side, particularly from the industrial arm of the Labour Party, would cause industrial unrest to an unlimited and damaging extent. We are going to contribute in every way we can to finding a cure for this situation. We are going to do all we can about it here as a Party. In this situation in all its aspects, we will be helpful, but we want to make it clear that the cause for it rests with the Government and with the Government alone.

Comment on this

The last speaker suggested that there had been very little prior notice and the Opposition seem to be making a point that this was a sudden development. I should like to remind the House that there has been nothing sudden about this at all. Right from the beginning of the year, one might say, certain factors in this situation have been well known and have been duly emphasised. There are two things we should remember about this situation. First, it is not by any means of emergency or crisis proportions. We are faced with one of the normal problems of national housekeeping. There are good times and bad times. There are easy times and there are times with problems. This happens to be a time with problems. It would be a terrible mistake to start off on the assumption that we are suddenly faced with an emergency crisis. As the Minister for Industry and Commerce said earlier, one of the mistakes the Coalition Government made in handling their problems in 1956 was to take just that approach to them.

The second feature in regard to the present situation is that there is nothing in the Taoiseach's speech, which we all have now before us, even if only in typed form, which is essentially new as far as information is concerned. But it is a very valuable and accurate summary of the situation we have to face and, as responsible people, we should face it. It is inevitable that the Opposition will find a continuing temptation in this debate to indulge in self-justification.

Comment on this

On a point of information, was the Taoiseach's speech made available to the House?

Comment on this

I certainly got a copy of it when I asked for it earlier.

Comment on this

But the Deputy would be in a privileged position.

Comment on this

I was not. You will get it at the office if you go to the trouble of asking for it.

Comment on this

You will not. I got the last copy.

Comment on this

Some Deputies must have been slow about getting their copies.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should have made a copy available to every Deputy. Steps should have been taken to see that copies were available. I had the foresight to book a copy yesterday; otherwise, I would not have got it.

Comment on this

That is a matter for the Dáil. Every Deputy, even the Taoiseach, is entitled to make a speech and have it taken down by the House. That is the responsibility of the House, not of the Government, for once.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy told us they were available.

Comment on this

I got one.

Comment on this

You said every Deputy got it.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You are codding yourself.

Comment on this

Let us get back to serious business, because it is serious business.

Comment on this

A minute ago the Deputy told us it was not serious at all.

Comment on this

I said the business was serious.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order; the Deputy should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

There is a difference between an emergency and a serious position.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy going back to the dictionary now?

Comment on this

Now, if the Deputies have had their fun——

Comment on this

The Deputies are not having as much fun as you had when you were over here.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order; Deputy T. Lynch has already spoken at length.

Comment on this

If Deputies are going to allow me to talk as seriously, and, I hope, in the same way as responsible Deputies have spoken on this——

Comment on this

We never denied anybody free speech.

Comment on this

That is very fair. The situation, as I said, is a situation which we have to face because of a succession of events.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman dealt with some of the financial aspects of the matter and I should like to mention two or three of what I might call the physical or human factors behind the present situation. The first is that in leading up to the present situation there was development and there was a rise in the standard of living of the people from 1957 onwards. There has been a very real increase in living standards and a real increase in remuneration and in the economic development of the country. Naturally that led to a certain tendency, to an increase in consumption and in the purchase of consumer goods. That is a fact which has to be taken into account in the present situation.

The next thing that has to be taken into account is that in that developing situation, incomes were increasing. These two factors were all right as long as balances were maintained, and in fact they were desirable in so far as an increase in consumption meant improved standards of living and was matched also by increased incomes, which in turn also meant increased standards of living. Those things in themselves were good if they were in balance but then something happened to put them out of balance.

Let us see how this disbalance has come about. The disbalance has come —in so far as one can summarise causes like this, and one can do so only very approximately—from two things. You had the position of the neighbouring economy: there was a change of Government after a deteriorating economic position in Britain and the repercussions of that situation were immediately effective here as a result of the levies that were imposed. We cannot overlook the fact that that was a factor and a very real factor in the position. It had an important bearing on our imports and consequently on the balances about which I was speaking. Then you had the natural time-lag that is to be found in such cases, a time-lag in appreciating the effect. Lastly, let us face it, there were demands for remuneration in excess of what our production would support, with a consequent increase in prices. These, very briefly and very incompletely, were some of the causes that brought about the present situation.

Before I deal with one aspect of the problem with which I want to deal —I see no point in covering ground which has already been covered—I should like to point out that these factors were there and the present situation is the outcome of a disbalance, introduced as I have indicated, operating on the natural tendencies that there were from a very good origin, namely the rapid development that had taken place since 1957 under the present Government.

As a specific matter in this debate, we have the question of price control. Prices have increased and it is right that these measures should be introduced, but it is also right that it should be recognised that this is only one aspect of a programme to cope with problems that have to be coped with. It should also be realised in regard to prices that, as the Taoiseach said, they are more a symptom than a cause. In this regard, especially having regard to some of the things said about price control vis-à-vis income increases, it is no harm to look at a few basic facts in regard to prices. People talk about warnings and I should like to go back to April, 1964, when the Taoiseach addressed himself to these problems in this House. I want to quote one paragraph because it is relevant to this debate. The remainder is as relevant but it can be read by Deputies in the Official Report. This is what the Taoiseach said, reported at column 1787 of Volume 208:

Once again it appears necessary to re-state some elementary principles in this matter. When national production is rising at an average annual rate of four per cent this is the maximum rate at which incomes can increase in real terms. If nominal incomes rise faster than that, prices will certainly move up to confine the real gain in incomes to what higher national production can support.

It is as necessary, I think, today to re-state some elementary principles as it was then.

Comment on this

Still, he supported the 12 per cent pay rise to win two by-elections.

Comment on this

I had better read the continuance.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What happened after the turnover tax?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Collins will have an opportunity of making his speech.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I hope so.

Comment on this

The reason that 12 per cent was given was clearly stated by the Taoiseach. In the following column of Volume 208, he is reported:

There was an agreement for 12 per cent and I said here at the time that it would be worth while paying some premium, over and above the average increase which the expansion of national production could support without adverse consequences, in order to initiate a new and better system of wage adjustment which we hoped would be retained in the future.

That was the reason for the 12 per cent as the Taoiseach mentioned, and some Labour Deputies implied it, that 12 per cent was not unjustified. There was a great measure of agreement and a great deal of good stemmed from it. Productivity per worker went up. It was in the first part of this year that we began to notice room for correction.

Though the remark made by Deputy L'Estrange a few moments ago may seem a smart political point, it does not get us any further with the argument. Let me return to an objective analysis of the present situation and in doing that, it is necessary to re-state some elementary principles. The point I was dealing with was that prices of themselves are largely a symptom. They cannot be controlled of themselves. If there are excess profits, by all means control them, and in so far as control is necessary, it will be done, but let us realise that price control is not the panacea for everything. Prices are in the main determined by costs. There may be sectors where prices are excessively high but a general analysis today will show that by and large there has not been an excessive increase in prices and that the increases which have occurred in recent times, during the past eight to ten years, have been the normal consequence of increasing costs. If I am right in that—

Comment on this

Then this Bill will not cure the crisis.

Comment on this

I am not saying price control will cure everything, and there is no crisis.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Why are we wasting time, then?

Comment on this

Deputy Collins can make his speech later.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

The Deputy says the Bill will have no effect on prices.

Comment on this

I did not say any such thing. I said that by and large prices have been conditioned by costs and it is important therefore to analyse where costs tend to increase. In any domestic industry here, costs are largely determined by three factors— costs of production of any article are determined mainly by labour costs, costs of materials and services required for production and lastly by taxation. Now, unfortunately, as has been pointed out before these three elements in industrial costs are to some extent cumulative and whether we like it or not-many of us do not—the costs of remuneration, of personal wages and salaries, are the key, the triggering element in most industries.

If incomes go up in an industry, that element spreads also to services and materials used in the industry. If there is a general wage rise, not only will the cost of wages in any particular industry go up but the cost of the materials it uses will go up because the materials are made and distributed from somewhere else where the general wage increase round pushes up costs in turn. Therefore, the industry must bear the increased cost of the materials and the services it uses. Lastly, a general round of wage increases will affect the entire services of the country. It will affect the public services and, as we can easily see from the figures available, there is a bigger bill for the Minister for Finance to meet and he can meet it only by increased taxation which, in turn, comes back to the industry, both directly and indirectly.

To cut a long story short, we cannot escape the fact that a prime element, a triggering element in the upward trend of costs, the vital element in the costs structure today—it need not necessarily be so but it seems to be that way at the moment—is the question of salaries and wages in an industry. That in turn affects the other essential factors in industry. We cannot get away from it.

Deputy Byrne talked about incomes and prices. There is a very interesting diagram on page 19 of Economic Statistics in relation to the Budget for 1965 published by the Central Statistics Office. Diagram 3 on page 19 shows the upward index of weekly earnings. That index is deflated by the consumer price index. In other words, earnings have been going up and so have prices, but the significant thing is that when you take the difference and call that net earnings or any suitable word you like, the graph is still going up, which means that earnings have been going up faster than prices on the whole.

Therefore, it is vital to understand that price control is only one facet of the whole problem which has to be dealt with, that it is related to costs in the way that I have mentioned and that one has to face the hard economic facts of life in that regard.

Furthermore, again to put things into perspective here, although, as I understand it, production is still going up and industrial productivity has gone up the rate of increase has been falling off in this year. That fact has to be taken as a signal for correction. It might be that in certain circumstances there was a tendency to saturation but our economy is not developed sufficiently for us to be talking in terms of saturation. We should be able to develop further.

There is a more significant factor in the situation and that is that our labour costs tend to be rising more rapidly or at least as rapidly and at an accelerating pace compared to the rest of our environment. These are all matters which call for correction but correction is the word. We can achieve that correction with the co-operation that the Deputies on the other side have so stressed—and we welcome that—and that the Taoiseach has asked for.

Deputy Sweetman was quite right when he said that we must do these things out of our own resources. That is one of the really fundamental things for us to grasp here. As I said at the outset, our development had been almost spectacularly rapid in the recent past and we may have been somewhat deluded by that into thinking that it was a relatively easy task to develop the economy of a country like this. Set-backs such as those one had to face as a result of the British levy, and so forth, are a reminder of the grim fact that we as a country live in a highly competitive economic environment and that we have to compete to live and that if we do not succeed in that competition we will not be able to live.

Some of our problems are not ours alone. As I have said, we know the difficulties of the British economy and we cannot blind ourselves to the fact that these will have repercussions here, indirect as well as direct repercussions.

I noticed in yesterday's papers, for instance, that the Labour Economic Minister in England, Mr. George Brown, said as follows, approximately —I paraphrase him—referring to the balancing of incomes and prices and to a number of problems that have certain similarities to our problems here:

If agreement is not reached voluntarily over prices and incomes it will have to come in some other way. This could be through deflation and unemployment with resources underused and investment discouraged or by abandoning the voluntary principle and its replacement by something else.

He was not making a threat. He was making a statement of the simple economic facts of life, he said.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy quoting from?

Comment on this

He was reported in an English paper yesterday.

Comment on this

It is rather unusual that quotations from a newspaper can be used without reference to the paper so that we can all see it.

Comment on this

I am not quite sure. I think it was the Daily Express.

Comment on this

We could see what it was if we had the whole quotation.

Comment on this

I will certainly get it for the Deputy but I think the quotation is substantially accurate as reported in that paper. These are the simple economic facts of life and we cannot get away from the simple economic facts of life. Deputy Sweetman has done a service in emphasising that it is by our own efforts that we must put things right.

There are sometimes psychological factors. There are the difficulties in a democracy of getting all people to pull together, and so forth, but some people might wonder why it is that we cannot seize the opportunities we have at the moment and make something out of them. We know that there are difficulties in Britain where we have a large market, that there is an environment to which the Taoiseach referred which may be difficult but, on the other hand, we have had an extraordinary resurgence here and all it needs, in the last analysis, is for us to have enough faith as a community to invest in the future.

I wish all of us here in this House could make our people realise that by a little extra effort and investment in the future, which may take the form of a little forebearance, we could capture the foreign markets that would enable us to continue the development which we have had. We have had plenty of experience to show that the hope is more than justified. We know that the economy can be developed. It has already been developed to a remarkable extent having regard to the situation as it was before the first economic programme was initiated. We have every reason to believe that we could do it. We could sell abroad. Let us face that. We have the know-how and we have been able to get to the standard of production. We could sell abroad if we could sell competitively. What is stopping us from selling abroad is that there is a tendency for our prices to be too high and, as is commonly said, for us to price ourselves out of the market. What could we not do if we could sell at the fractionally lower price in the foreign market and get the trade? That is a thought that perhaps everybody should fix his attention on.

It is all right to talk about efficiency. Yes, let us have maximum efficiency. The product that we are selling must be of the very best or we will not maintain the market. The key to the whole thing is, having got maximum efficiency and having got the product, to do what the Japanese, the Germans and many other countries have done, that is, to be determined that you are going to sell the product and to adjust your price accordingly.

Comment on this

Irrespective of labour costs.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Deputy de Valera is not comparing Japanese labour costs with our labour costs, surely?

Comment on this

Our tendency has been the other way. It is with that thought that I would like to approach this whole question of re-introducing a balance into our economy.

Again I quote Deputy Sweetman, the essential thing is to do it with our own resources but it must be done by getting foreign markets. In this modern world of ours, one cannot live in a vacuum. One cannot have the same standard of living as the rest of the world if one lives in a vacuum. We must get out and sell our products and the way to do that is to sell them at competitive prices. Mere price control as such is only one aspect of the problem. I want to emphasise that equally important with price control is the question of remuneration and above all, there must be an ordered organisation, particularly of export industry. Anyone can develop the logical consequence of that thought but, if we preserve the essential that is in the thought, we will have gone a long way towards doing it.

In conclusion, I would like to say that I was tempted to follow Deputy Dillon in some of the things he said, but, in view of the situation as it is, it is well to forebear. If we can take seriously the declaration of the Opposition of their intention to co-operate in dealing with this problem for the good of the country, I, for one, will be glad to forebear many of the other things. With that co-operation, we should also try to look objectively at the causes of this problem and not run the risk of escapism focussing all our attention on one or other particular aspect of it. We should look for the co-operation of all the sectors of the community to whom the Taoiseach looked and, if we do so, the difficulties we have to face will be successfully surmounted.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I have listened with interest to some of the amazing economic views that Deputy de Valera has so suddenly annexed to himself and also to his rather cynical scepticism about the co-operation they will get from the Opposition. He seems to forget the times when economic difficulties were abroad before and when he and some of his colleagues were not only prepared to sabotage the national effort but were prepared to use every possible base effort at political advantage to do so. They will not get that kind of treatment from this Party but that does not say that we do not have the right to copperfasten on top of this Government its own sins.

I remember Fianna Fáil Deputies laughing two years ago when I was challenging the then Minister for Industry and Commerce on the prices that had already started to soar in anticipation of the turnover tax. I had already shown him the danger that was arising from this willy-nilly increase in costs without any justification or without any effort at investigation.

Nobody welcomed more than I did at that time the fact that there was alleged goodwill growing up between employer and employee. I am not a member of the Labour Party but I can sympathise with them in their efforts to solve the problem which was created under this agreement when the value of the wage packet to the employee was dissipated by increased prices before he got the increased wages. We must be realists when we are facing economic difficulties and it is the purchasing value of the wage packet which is the ultimate analysis on which the worker can assess whether he is doing well or otherwise. If an increase of wages is to be consumed immediately by inflated prices for essentials, then that increase has no real value and no Government can criticise the worker because he wishes to extricate himself from a position in which he finds prices chasing wages.

When I heard Deputy de Valera talking about forebearance, I felt like telling him that he should address those remarks to the limited sector of the community that can adopt that attitude because the working man, whether he is rearing a young family or a large family, is the one who feels the pressure of continually rising prices from week to week and who does not know how he is to continue to exist. I have always said that this is an inept and incompetent Government. Their emphasis on development has never been right. We are all getting away from the basic reality that the widest scope for production and for the invasion of foreign markets lies in agricultural products and not in artifically-boosted industry.

One of the ills of our whole industrial policy is that we are trying to compete by means of imported raw materials processed in this country with the home producers of these materials. The great weight of our exports lies in the once despised bullock, sheep and pig. We know the burden that our agriculture is carrying. We know that it is in agriculture that there is the scope for expansion of exports that will save our economy.

It is amusing to hear a Fianna Fáil Government pleading the exigencies and difficulties of the British situation as an excuse for some of our economic difficulties. I have repeated year after year in this House that we must always face the fact that unless we build our production on something that is part of our way of life, which is agriculture, that we will always find ourselves affected by the law of diminishing returns when we try to compete against the home producers of the raw materials which we use in our industries. This is so simple and basic an economic theory that I cannot understand why we have not wakened up to the fact that much of the difficulty and much of the recession that has come in parts of our industry is due to the fact that there has not been the type of planning one would expect and there certainly has not been the development in efficiency or in methods of marketing that justifies the continuance of many of these industries at all.

It is time this country woke up to the fact that we must start planning, not in theoretical blue books, First and Second Programmes, but in the light of the capacity of our people to produce. If we are to rescue ourselves from the economic slough we are now in, we must embark on an expansionist programme that is real in relation to the lives and activity of our people and to their capacity to work and increase their production and their efficiency. We are not going to do that by trying to heap the blame on anybody or by trying to hide behind spurious agreements that are outmoded. No matter how the Government try to disguise it, the Irish people know perfectly well that a very large part of the motive that activated this agreement and this 12 per cent rise was the imminence of by-elections in Cork and Kildare and the preservation of the then tottering Government in office.

Our present difficulty stems from that. It was then that the Government should have been talking about price stabilisation and price control. It was then, when they were making this effort in regard to a period of expansion and development, that they should have seen to it that the 12 per cent was not going to be gobbled up and dissipated in what I describe as the meteoric rise in the cost of essentials. Remember that at that stage the Government were hiding behind the fact that many items that we regard as essential in the maintenance and development of a family are excluded from the items that actually affect the computation of the cost of living.

No matter what warning were given to the Government, we were told with the flamboyant abandon of which the Taoiseach is capable that we were never going better and now as Deputy Byrne of the Labour Party said, we suddenly find there is a complete reversal in the trend. The Government had been warned week after week, year after year, that this was coming. It started long before the beginning of this year. It had started long before there was any change of Government in Britain, but the Government refused to face up to the reality of the situation.

We have seen how inept and ineffective the Government can be. Price control per se may not be a complete answer to the problem but to attempt price control now, when the matter has been allowed to get out of hand and when the range of commodities and the range of investigation has become universal, will be extremely difficult, particularly in view of the fact that in the past couple of months, without reference to anybody, the costs of a wide range of goods have increased by 1d., 2d., 4d. and 6d. This is because, with demands in every direction, people are trying to take the easiest way out by foisting, without reference to anybody, extra costs on the consumer.

If we are to get over this problem and we will get over it—if we could get the Government out, we would get over it quicker but they are fairly entrenched in their seats; they have the brass neck of Old Nick and always had—the Government must give a lead. If there is to be, as Deputy de Valera is suggesting, forbearance, why do we not start where forbearance can be very effectively exercised? Let us have a look in a cold analytical way at some of the big impacts on our economy in recent times. One will find that status rises that have been a long time outstanding to the public service have had a tremendous impact on the economy. The delay resulted in the accumulation of a vast debt which I am quite sure is more than due to the overworked civil servants, but we want to ensure that that type of debt will not be allowed to accrue again.

We want to ensure that we meet our housekeeping difficulties as they come along. If we are to ask the workers, the industrial overseer, the person working on the land of Ireland, the producers, to restrain their demands in certain directions, then the load will have to be borne by everybody, not by one section. One of the things that has bedevilled this economy and one of the things that is causing unease and unrest among the people is that many of them think the Government have no policy and no desire towards the control of this ever-rising monster of administrative costs. We must get all the community properly and intelligently aware of the difficulties and, having done so, we must spread the responsibility for the recovery over the shoulders that can bear it.

This does not alter for one moment the fact that the Government never made a conscious effort to control the rising spiral of costs, the inflationary tendencies that developed, so that the real worth of the worker's pay packet would not be devalued. It was because they did not do that that we find ourselves in the jam we are in today. Every man, no matter what section of the community he is in, has the right to use all the methods at his disposal to ensure that he gets a reasonable share of the national cake.

I fault the Government, as I always have, for a lack of planning concepts and a lack of a balanced approach to what this country really can do. I have always been astounded that we should make so little of our potential in both agriculture and fishing. There is a tremendous variety of industry germane to agriculture and agricultural production but we have failed utterly to plan and develop such industry. As I have said here on numerous occasions, our lack of initiative has always astounded me. In my constituency I see the trawlers of every nation in Europe— aye, and from further afield than Europe—travelling thousands of miles to catch fish. Fishing at that distance must be an important and a valuable factor in their economy. Yet, after all our years of self-government, and all the years in which government has been under the aegis of this dynamic Fianna Fáil Party, we have never seen any real effort to develop the potential that is there in the fishery waters around our coasts.

We have not seen the development we should have seen in our agricultural industry. We have not seen the market that should be developed properly developed. We have, indeed, some queer capacity for sending people all over the world looking for exotic markets while we leave the one nextdoor without the attention it should get.

I do not want to make political capital out of this economic difficulty in which we find ourselves, but the effort to remedy the situation must be a realistic one. If the worker is to be asked to do a little more, then, equally, the employer should be asked to do with a little less in the way of profits. Let all sections of the community carry their reasonable share. The person who can least carry any additional burden is, in my opinion, the worker. He is bound to feel the pinch more severely than anybody else. In my opinion, the Government are sitting quiet and calm, hoping, to use a favourite expression of the Taoiseach's they will get over the hump. But one must get down to realities. One must do something about the situation.

If this price control is aimed at stemming the tide, then effective steps will have to be taken immediately. The Minister should have the courage to backdate his standstill order to the beginning of the year when, as alleged by the Taoiseach, the trouble started. It is no good saying now that a whole series of prices will be investigated. I would prefer the opposite approach. I should infinitely prefer to see prices sealed off as of a certain date. Then anyone who wants to increase prices should come in and justify that increase to the Department rather than have the Department initiating investigations.

We all know that since this iniquitous turnover tax entered our economy, people have been trying to exploit the situation to the utmost in an effort to recoup themselves for their added difficulties as a result of this iniquitous impost. I do not intend to enter into an economic survey of the difficulties the Government have created, but, if the Government cannot offer something better than the Taoiseach's lamentations and his milk-and-water type of price control now suggested, would the Government get out and make way for a Government who can and will do the job?

Comment on this

We welcome this Bill even at this late stage. We welcome the introduction of some form of price control. As Deputy Corish said last week, however, this appears to us to be an effort now to close the stable door after the horse has bolted.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We, in the Labour Party, have grown quite used now to the situation in which we advocate certain things and implore the Government to pursue a certain line of policy over a period of time, to be abused, sneered at and jeered at. Then, overnight, we find the Government at last converted to our way of thinking, implementing something at a belated date, something we have been assuring them for some considerable time was both necessary and desirable.

We welcome, as I say, some form of price control. We would welcome it still more if we could be assured that the Minister will use the powers he seeks and that we will not have a repeat of the situation that existed under the 1958 Act. Under the Act certain powers were conferred on the Minister. He neglected to use those powers in the interests of the nation. Under that Act he could have curtailed some of the activities which have led us into the situation in which we find ourselves today.

There are one or two things in this Bill the Minister has not made clear. He said this morning that, if these inquiries are held at his instigation, they can be held in public. When questioned by Fine Gael and Labour Deputies, he was, however, very reluctant to say whether or not it is his intention to hold these inquiries in public. I urge the Minister to give very serious consideration to the manner in which these inquiries are held. If this form of price control is to be effective it is essential that the people, and particularly the workers, should have confidence in the strength of this measure. If the form of inquiry is to be one held by a couple of civil servants from the Minister's Department, behind closed doors, with the Minister issuing his findings and saying that the proposed increase is justified, I am greatly afraid that the confidence of the workers in this form of price control will be very seriously undermined.

Workers feel that there is a tendency on the part of Fianna Fáil to discrimate between them and certain other sections of the community. If a worker seeks to increase the cost of his labour, he is required to go before the Labour Court and make a case in public justifying the proposed increase. Surely, if a manufacturer seeks to increase the price of his commodity or a utility the price of its service, then the justification for that increase should be made publicly? No matter what form of price control is introduced, there will be occasions when increases will be justified but it is of the utmost importance that those who are going to bear the increases can see the justification for them and that the manufacturer or shopkeeper who wishes to make the increases should of necessity justify these increases in public. I urge the Minister to ensure that any investigations he intends to make are made in public.

There has been great talk from Fianna Fáil benches to the effect that our present difficulties can be attributed—solely, according to some Deputies and very largely, according to some Front Bench members—to the increase secured by the workers under the National Wage Agreement. This is totally untrue and the worst feature of it is that people who have made the statement know it to be untrue. Surely members of the Government are in a position to have proper and accurate statistics; I have no doubt they have them and that they know that the increases that have occurred since the National Wage Agreement do not in any way account for the very substantial increase in prices that has taken place. The actual statistics show that while wages increased by 12 per cent, prices have increased by 11 per cent and if the agreement is to run its normal course, there are still 12 months left before another increase becomes due. Unless the Fianna Fáil Government have been completely and very recently converted to price control and unless the Minister means to use ruthlessly the powers he will have under this Bill, we can foresee without any stretch of imagination a very substantial increase in that 11 per cent.

The 12 per cent has been virtually wiped out—11 per cent of it has gone —and unless the Government are sincere in implementing price control we shall find in the very near future, in my opinion, a much more serious situation than we have today. The Taoiseach yesterday appealed to the patriotism of all sections of the community but while he did that, some speakers on the Government Benches who have since spoken have harped continually on one section. The workers are apparently responsible for all our ills, according to Fianna Fáil spokesmen; they have done it all. We know that is not true, that while workers have not only given lip service to the interests of the community as a whole, they are the one section that have proved by practical demonstrations over a number of years in their wage restraint that they have the interests of the nation at heart and are willing to play their part in recovering from any difficulties in which we might find ourselves and in contributing to the national welfare. It is only fair to say they are becoming a little fed-up with being the only section that is appealed to, the only section that in a difficult situation that has been brought about by Government policy, are being asked to contribute while no effective measures are being introduced by the Government to ensure that other sections, far better able to contribute, do so.

I assure the Minister that if there is a clear indication that the powers conferred on him under this Bill are used, the organised workers, as in the past, will be only too pleased to play their part, but it is essential that the conversion should be complete, and now that the Government have realised the absolute necessity for some sort of check on prices, it is essential that they use what they have sought, the powers given in this Bill.

Comment on this

Our people are faced with a challenge which will tax their ingenuity, ability and energy to the limit. Contrary to what some speakers have already said, I believe in and have confidence in the people's ability to stand up to this challenge and solve the difficulties facing us. I think there is nothing wrong with the nation at present; we have run into troubled waters but, by and large, I think we have solved our problems.

The previous speaker said that the workers were, I should probably say, cringing, under the strain. The majority of people in this country are workers, farm workers, organised industrial workers, local authority workers and so on. Therefore, whatever problems or difficulties have been imposed on us are the responsibility of the entire working people. Unfortunately for all of us, credit facilities were too easily obtained in the past. That brought about a wave of spending on consumer goods which stretched the limit of our finances to the utmost in purchasing from outside as, unfortunately, the bulk of these purchases were imported goods. If my figures are correct, I remember reading recently that we purchase £37 millions worth from Germany, 85 per cent of which was consumer goods, many of which we could quite easily do without. Our people were really purchasing against the wages they would earn in five or ten years time. This was a new pattern in Irish life because in the past our people never committed themselves to more than they could handle tomorrow or even today. I think that is the cause of our trouble. The measures being taken here should prove useful in reducing the import excess which in many cases was entirely unnecessary.

I was particularly interested in the contribution of Deputy Collins and the advice he attempted to give— extraordinary advice coming from a member of a Party who made no attempt to cope with the difficulties they ran into in 1956, who ran headlong into the troubles they created at that time and who indeed threw in the towel and stepped out of the arena. They were not forced out: they just disintegrated, walked out and left the position after them. I would like to know what sound advice we could get from that attitude of mind today.

This Government have always stood up and done what was necessary to get this nation out of any difficulty. This Party will get the people back on the right track and have them at work again in a realistic way. Those of us in business and closely associated with the purchasing public realise that our people have been up in the clouds and have not been facing their responsibilities. I believe this nation still has a great future and that we are on the right road towards attaining the aims we hope to reach in future years.

I had a particular instance of this in my own constituency last week where extra personnel were required for a German factory in the town of Cahirciveen which is engaged in the production of hosiery for export to the German market. These people are producing a first-class article entirely for export to Germany. They have to bear the cost of getting the article to the German shopkeeper and, in addition, have to pay a 20 per cent entry duty. Despite this, they have to compete with the locally-made product, and they are successfully doing so. When we have people able to do that, it shows there is nothing wrong with our workers and that we will solve our problems by showing the type of spirit the workers in that factory are showing. They are doing their job conscientiously and well and giving a good return for their wages. That is the type of outlook we want to get from our people. Co-operation from all sides is needed. It is up to everybody to advise our people to develop that outlook and have a united effort to produce goods which can be sold abroad competitively. I believe from the figures I have seen in Cahirciveen that we can do that.

I agree with Deputy Collins that there is scope for big improvement in our agricultural sales and marketing. Under the present system, we have to have subsidies to the extent of £53 million to sell £130 million worth of our agricultural produce on outside markets. Half of that produce would sell itself without any subsidy, which means there must be almost a pound for pound subsidy in order to sell the remainder. Those figures would indicate, as Deputy Collins tried to point out, that our market development is not correct. We know it costs a large sum to sell butter. If we have more cattle, we must have more butter; and more butter costs us more millions again. We will have to find alternative methods of developing that arm of our agriculture and enabling ourselves to face the future with confidence.

Coming from a rural area, I am always in favour of maximum agricultural production. The whole economy of my own constituency depends on high-priced agricultural produce. If we have to compete with low-priced produce in foreign markets, our chances of success are limited. Certainly, we can sell all the cattle we can produce without any subsidy. Unfortunately, more cattle mean more by-products, and the by-products cost us money.

At this stage the nation is facing one of its greatest challenges. I will not say it is a question of survival, because personally I do not think we are in that kind of difficulty. But corrective measures are necessary. Our people have energy, initiative and pride. If we can channel those attributes into the right lines of production to give us command of outside markets, we will have our people on the right road towards getting out of our present difficulties. If we can curb unnecessary imports and bring them down to the ordinary needs of our people, I believe we can resolve this position in a short time.

I would impress on the people opposite that their help and co-operation is needed. It is the urgent duty of every Irishman to see that our people are not divided in any way but that they all co-operate to develop their energies in order to overcome this temporary crisis and bring our nation back to the position it was in four or five years ago, with the hope that in our time we will see full employment for our people. In doing that, we will be doing a good day's work for the benefit of the country we all love and which we are all so anxious to see reach the place amongst the nations to which it is entitled.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On the introduction of this Estimate yesterday, in conjunction with the Prices (Amendment) Bill, 1965, we were told that the present rate of economic growth is not sufficient to maintain our present standard of living. That means that we must either increase the rate of economic growth or reduce our standard of living. There is nothing in the proposals put before the House by the Government, nor was there in the Budget introduced by the Government, to increase the economic growth. Therefore it would appear to me that the only solution the Government have, or the only alternative, is a reduction in the standard of living.

We were also told that our imports have increased substantially while our exports have been seriously reduced. Our imports have gone up for the first few months of this year, I understand, by £16 million, while our exports have been reduced by £9 million. Our exports are less than half of the amount of our imports. There are no proposals before the House, nor were there any in the Budget, to correct this state of affairs. There is no incentive to export in the Budget and therefore we must assume that the only way the Government have to correct this is to try to reduce our imports and again hit our standard of living.

In the same speech we were told that the adverse trend in our external payments this year would amount to at least £50 million, if we were lucky. That came as a startling piece of news to this House because if anybody had suggested during the last general election that that was the state of affairs, he would have been accused of sabotaging the country. As recently as the Budget, introduced only a month or six weeks ago, we were informed that the adverse external balance of payments for the year ended had been £31 million and that it would remain about the same for the next 12 months. In less than six weeks, the Government have got to know, or at least they have decided to tell the House, that the external balance of payments position has deteriorated to the tune of £20 million. I want to know did the Government not know at Budget time that the external balance of payments this year would be £50 million, if we were lucky, instead of £31 million?

In the same speech we were told that there is an undesirable rise in the Consumer Price Index; in other words, that there is an undesirable rise in the cost of living. That is one thing we had not to be told because it is something that everybody knew, that everybody felt and that every housewife fully appreciated for some time past. We were told in the same speech that in the past 12 months the deficit in visible trading amounted to £125 million. We were told that the capital inflow for this year is estimated at £25 million instead of £36 million for the previous year. We were also told that production costs still soar and that the nation is consuming more and producing less, and that bank lending has increased by £35 million, but principally into Government sources.

That roughly is the picture that was painted. It is not a success story. It is a story of gloom and, in my opinion, a story of abject failure. It is a picture that was not painted by the Leader of the Opposition Party in this House; it is a picture that was not painted or a story that was not told by a Taoiseach who had come into office and found things not as he had hoped or expected. It is a story that was not told by the Leader of a minority Government because the man who told it enjoyed an overall majority from 1957 to 1961 and from 1961 to this year, he enjoyed a safe majority. He enjoyed a majority of his own Party coupled with support from people whom he respected and in whom he had confidence, in the persons of two Deputies.

In 1962 in glowing terms, in a long speech, he said that the former Deputy Sherwin, who was then in this House and was supporting him, spoke more sense in ten minutes than all the other speakers had spoken in four hours. Several times during that speech he referred to the same Deputy in glowing terms. He also had the confidence and support of Deputy Leneghan of North Mayo during that term and he has since endorsed that confidence in and respect for that Deputy by restoring him to Oireachtas Éireann. The story I have summarised here was told yesterday by the Taoiseach, by the Leader of the Government, and can be regarded as nothing more or less than a confession of abject failure on the part of the Taoiseach and the Government. This did not happen all of its own accord; it did not happen accidentally. The present challenge, as Deputy O'Connor calls it, the present mess created by the Government as I would prefer to call it, was brought about by direct Government action over the past four or five years. I have been a member of the Oireachtas only since 1961 but I remember early in 1962, the bright young dynamos of the Government Party coming into the Seanad and saying that the national cake had grown to enormous proportions and that everybody was entitled to a fair share of it. They were putting through measures to increase salaries, by as much as £600 per year in some cases, on the basis that those increases were not required to catch up with the cost of living but that the people concerned were entitled to them as status increases.

That was the picture being painted in the early part of 1962 and on the Adjournment Debate in this House in the middle of December, 1962, the Taoiseach, speaking to criticism on that debate, in a speech in which he paid glowing tributes to his friend Deputy Sherwin, stated that the economy was sound. It is in black and white and cannot be denied. He deprecated criticism from Deputy Dillon and others in the House.

No sooner were the Christmas festivities over than the Taoiseach and the Government introduced a White Paper Closing the Gap, from which it appeared the economy was far from sound, from which it appeared that production was not keeping up with wages and salaries. That was the same man in the same Government who had the previous December stated from that bench over there that the economy was sound and that anybody who said it was not was being unfair to him and to the country. That was the situation that began to develop.

We were told in the White Paper that there was a serious gap which would have to be corrected, that unless it was corrected, the country would head for trouble. The workers were asked not to request any increases in wages and the people employed by State subsidised or controlled concerns were told they would not get any further increases in wages or salaries. One would have thought that that being the situation then, the Government would not do anything which might be calculated to increase the cost of living further, to drive the wage earners of this country to seek higher wages.

Imagine the indignation and the surprise of the country when the Budget, which came only a short time afterwards, increased the prices of food, clothing and fuel. All the necessaries of life, for the first time in this country, were taxed. That tax came immediately on top of a request for a standstill in wages, for a standstill in salaries. It came on top of a request to all to pull their weight to see that the gap was closed. Did the Government seriously expect that wages would remain at a standstill on top of an increase in the cost of living brought about deliberately and directly by their actions?

They were warned in this House by the leaders and other members of this Party that what they were doing would lead them and the country into trouble. The Government did not take heed. There was a by-election in this city that summer, in North-East Dublin, and the Government suffered an overwhelming defeat in what was regarded as the best-organised Government constituency in the country. The White Paper was still in force. The gap had not been closed.

At the end of that year, the Government were faced with a by-election in Cork city which they refused to hold. That by-election, in the ordinary course of events, would have been held at the end of 1963 but the Government refused to take the initiative to hold the by-election and resisted a motion tabled from this side of the House to move the Writ for the by-election. Then the occasion for another by-election occurred in Kildare and the Government had no alternative but to go to the electorate in Cork and Kildare. That was less than two years after the introduction of the turnover tax, less than 12 months after the White Paper Closing the Gap had been introduced warning the people the economy was not sound and that no further increases in wages could be allowed.

Then in the early days of 1964, the Government were guilty of a dishonest political trick which is causing the country its present trouble. The Government then, within 12 months of the issuing of the White Paper, gave the green light for a 12 per cent increase in wages which the workers had been forced to seek because of the increase in the cost of living brought about by the turnover tax and by nothing else. In those early days of 1964, the Government were concerned only to hold on to office, to win those two by-elections. For that purpose they sought to take credit for the 12 per cent wage increase. They were determined to avoid negotiations for wages going on at the same time as the election campaign.

We know that as a result of that they won the two by-elections in Cork and Kildare. We know that as a result of the turnover tax, followed by the 12 per cent increase in wages, things were driven out of hand. That is the cause of the trouble we have today. It is only now for the first time that the Government admit the litany of troubles I have recited. It is not my litany; it is the Taoiseach's litany. Now for the first time that litany has been acknowledged.

What would the position have been if, before the last general election, held on 7th April of this year, the Taoiseach had come clean with the people of the country and had told them our trade balance was wrong, our balance of payments was wrong, that our cost of living was going sky high, that our present rate of economic growth was not sufficient to maintain our present standard of living? He would have been swept out of office. Some people did not understand why the general election was held on 7th April. The country knew that the by-elections in Cork did not change the Government's representation in the House. The Government had the same majority in the House after the by-election as they had before it. It is now obvious to the people why the general election was held on 7th April of this year. It was because the Government decided that if they did not go to the country then, they would be driven to the country later in this year and swept out of office. It was a shabby confidence trick on the electorate.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said that we did not want to form a Government at all.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Crowley had to have a couple of “goes”, first at the by-election and then at the general election. He is grateful, of course, for the general election because he could not make the Dáil through the by-election. It was a confidence trick that was played on the people by that general election. If the Government had been straight with the people and had told them the position before the general election, I know what the result would have been.

The general election safely over, the Government introduced the Budget and did not come clean with the people even then. They come in here now. I can sit here and see smiles on the face of the Minister. Does he think the situation which has been brought about by Government action is anything to laugh at? Does he think it is a joke? Does he think that now that the general election is over, he can smile, safe in his majority in the House for the time being?

Comment on this

That is enough. Behave yourself now.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have been here and I have behaved myself in accordance with the rules of order of this House but I can observe what is going on over there. What responsible intervention has there been in this debate from the Government side of the House? We have had the Taoiseach, we have had Deputy Lemass and we have had Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this

And Deputy Crowley.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And Deputy Crowley, briefly and to the point. The Government are not taking this matter seriously nor are they taking the people seriously.

Comment on this

They are afraid.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): A number of proposals have been made by the Taoiseach to correct the state of affairs which he now admits exists. He says that he will encourage saving. Is there anything in the recent Budget to encourage saving? Will the new death duty proposals encourage saving? Will the fact that the personal allowances under the income tax code stand at the figures which they have stood at for many years encourage saving? The Taoiseach says that he will curtail bank lending. That will be a very simple operation because bank lending has stopped. It will not take any Government action to curtail bank lending at the present time. Anybody who through business or otherwise has had occasion to investigate bank lending at the moment will know that that is the easiest job to date that the Taoiseach has taken on.

The Taoiseach said that the external payments deficit must be reduced. He has not told us how he proposes to do that or what measures he proposes to introduce to close the gap.

Again, I go back to the Budget. The Budget is the instrument which once a year discloses Government policy. There is nothing in the Budget which will encourage exports either agricultural or otherwise. There is not, substantially speaking, one penny in the Budget for agriculture. I should like some of the Ministers in this House to tell the House how the Government propose to increase exports.

There are to be no further increases in wages and salaries and personal incomes. Does that mean that that will apply all round and to everybody? Does it mean that there will be no secret increases given either to heads of the Civil Service or otherwise? Does it mean that this wage freeze will apply to everybody? Can we have that assurance and can we have an explanation as to why large increases in salaries were not disclosed in estimates introduced into the House this year?

The Taoiseach said that he will borrow abroad. Is that not a dangerous proposal? Deputy Dillon has said to-day that we have sold a lot of our land for foreign capital and now if we are going to borrow vast sums of money abroad, if it is lent to us, the state of affairs may be reached where we will lose control of our own affairs.

The Taoiseach said that another plank in his platform for economic revival would be the encouragement of the Buy Irish campaign. When the British levies were introduced last year and when we had this terrific Buy Irish campaign initiated, the first thing that struck me was that the Government for years back had forgotten about a Buy Irish campaign, had forgotten about giving any encouragement to the people to buy Irish. It took the British levies to bring them to their senses. If what I am saying is wrong, why was it necessary to start such a widespread publicity campaign immediately the British levies were introduced to get the people to buy Irish? If the Government had been doing their work, that campaign would not have been necessary.

The next proposal outlined by the Taoiseach was the Prices Control Bill. None of us likes price control. The Taoiseach does not like it. He denounced it in this House on several occasions. He said that an attempt at price control usually ended in increasing prices. If price control is necessary, although we deplore it, we will put up with it, but I should like the Government to tell us something more about how they propose to operate this price control. The Taoiseach was Minister for Supplies in a Fianna Fáil Government during the war. He operated the Department of Supplies, a Department which rigidly controlled prices and supplies. That Department was necessary then.

A state of affairs then existed here which was completely beyond our control, either in its extent or otherwise. The state of affairs which then had to be dealt with was that of a world war, the greatest war in the world either then or since. Do the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Taoiseach tell this House that the situation here today, brought about by them, is something akin to the situation which existed here in the 1940's? Many traders in this country were harassed by the Department of Supplies under the present Taoiseach and I think the Taoiseach in his references to this Prices (Amendment) Bill should have told the House a little more about how he proposes to operate the measure.

Will prices be controlled from town to town; will they be controlled on a national level; will they be fixed as a result of an investigation carried out by an impartial tribunal; or will they be fixed by the Minister behind closed doors after consultation with some of his own officials? Those are the things which the people are entitled to know. The Taoiseach said that there would be control first and investigation afterwards. That sounds very like shooting first and asking questions afterwards. It is a very drastic suggestion and one that could be justified only by the most severe national crisis.

The Taoiseach introduced his Estimate with a brazen face. He did so as the head of a Government who did not think they had anything to be ashamed of, did not think they had anything to account for, did not think they had anything to explain. He introduced it in a tone and with an air of complete justification, as if he deserved to be complimented on his activities and on his record. I do not think he deserves to be complimented. I think he and his Government deserve the greatest censure from Deputies and the people of the country for allowing this situation to develop for cheap political reasons, for the purpose of winning by-elections and remaining in power throughout a general election. I am confident that when the people get an opportunity of expressing their views on the Taoiseach and the Government, they will do so in no uncertain manner.

Comment on this
Erskine Hamilton Childers Minister for Transport and Power (Mr. Childers) Fianna Fáil

Listening to Deputy Fitzpatrick, one wonders whether he really does approve of any of the proposals of the Taoiseach to deal with this particular economic crisis. There appears to be some division of opinion as between him and Deputy Cosgrave who made a most statesmanlike speech and indicated his consent, with reservations, to the proposals being made in order that we could meet the balance of payments situation. Deputy Fitzpatrick has introduced an element of purely political propaganda into the whole discussion which will not get us anywhere and will not enable us to overcome our difficulties.

He reiterated all the nonsense about the by-elections in Cork city and Kildare. Everybody knows that the negotiations for the ninth round of wage increases were undertaken by the Federated Union of Employers and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. Everybody knows that under our system the Taoiseach and the Government could have no influence on the final outcome of these negotiations and that in the period which led up to these discussions, warning after warning was given not only by the Taoiseach but by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, other Ministers and myself in public speeches of the effect of increases in wages on labour costs.

The Taoiseach is on record as saying, well before the Cork and Kildare by-elections, that an increase of anything from six to eight per cent would be much more effective than a larger increase, that it would result in the workers being able to keep more of the increases for themselves. He is on record as saying that many industries would be able to increase productivity to match a reasonable wage increase to hold for a year. To say that the Taoiseach deliberately boosted the 12 per cent increase is completely untrue, as is shown by his own speeches. Deputy Fitzpatrick knows that perfectly well.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is true, and the Minister knows it.

Comment on this

Behave yourself.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to mon-opolise the right of the Chair and to tell a Deputy who is leaving the House to behave himself?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He is just helping the Chair.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I do not feel that the Chair requires any help.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair always welcomes help.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick was also talking as if this were a unique form of national crisis, as if no other country were affected by such a crisis, as if we were the only country whose balance of payments situation was not in order and if there were no such similar situation in democratically well-run countries such as New Zealand, the great United States and from time to time in the very well organised and well-run democracies. Deputy Fitzpatrick is trying to fool the people into believing that this is something unique caused by the alleged failure of the Government to warn the country that certain eventualities might take place.

The problems that have faced other countries are in many cases similar to those which we face ourselves, the problem arising when everyone looks for a higher standard of living as rapidly as possible as the economy expands. People in most countries are not prepared to conserve something for the lean period, to restrain their demands for increased salaries or to allow for a possible change in international trade. That is the fact, and all over the world in countries run by left of centre Governments where there is a tremendous desire to improve living standards, these Governments are faced with continual demands by the ordinary people to live up to the limit of what income is available to them, due to the growth of exports and productivity.

This country is facing some of the same problems as those which are faced by other countries all over the world. People do not like to put aside reserves to meet an unknown eventuality, and the people of this country have not desired in the past five or six years to put aside reserves to meet an eventuality. In the case of our own country, the reason is more natural, that we had only a one per cent increase in national income during the whole period from the end of the war up to 1958. Other countries were advancing more rapidly than we were. When the Fianna Fáil Government took office in 1957, for the first time after a period of inevitable delay, the real incomes of our people started to mount at a faster rate than had been recorded at any previous period of our history when conditions were normal and when free competitive influences were at play.

For the first three years, our growth of production and our living costs related to each other in the most satisfactory way, and from 1958 until 1961, there was a very small increase in the cost of living. Wage level increases kept pace with growing productivity and there was every evidence that our growth of income compared with some, the very few, countries in Europe which have maintained the principle of a national incomes policy and where everybody has come to realise that wages and salaries should grow with national income, and that if they grow with national income, then the workers keep the increased earnings they are able to secure through a growth in the nation's productivity.

From 1961 onwards, the pace mounted. Let no one in this House say that the people were not warned of the possibilities that might arise if for any reason there were circumstances in which the balance of payments position might be accentuated by changes in world economic conditions. Every Minister of this Government, the Taoiseach, the former Minister for Finance, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and myself, everybody who is acquainted with or interested in economics and in the national economy and who specialise in that subject, all have warned the nation on every possible occasion, right from the coming of the events associated with the Closing the Gap White Paper, right through the whole period, about the effects of inflation. They have made it perfectly clear that we have a free enterprise economy in which no attempt is made by the Government to control the earnings of the people by any decree, that all the Government can do is to control increases by taxation and credit restriction.

We have all been telling this story continuously, suggesting that the time had come for the acceptance of a national incomes policy, asking for its consideration by the trade unions and by the Federation of Employers. There has never at any time been a lack of propaganda in regard to this whole matter. I was looking back on the speeches I made on this subject which were in consonance with speeches made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce and by the Taoiseach right through the period from 1961 to 1965. Warnings were given that this practice of taking every little bit of the cake that could be taken had its dangers. That is the position and I do not intend to bore the House by reading extracts from endless speeches I made on this subject. We made it absolutely clear that inflation was of no benefit to the workers, that they themselves would be able to have exactly the same increase in real earnings if they were to follow the example set for them by a small number of countries, mostly in Northern Europe, where this concept of a national incomes policy had been accepted and where it can be seen that there was less inflation than in other countries.

We have gone as far as we can to suggest that there is no reason for us to copy the bad practices of English industrial relations, that we should imitate the English only if they have good traditions and good practices, and that we should try to get away from the attitude of mind that has beset the whole arrangements for negotiating wages and salaries, that has beset this country particularly in recent years.

We have given all the facts about the situation. What we are facing here today can be described in the very simplest terms, and I hope that from now on everybody will begin to appreciate the facts that have been told to them over and over again, that for every £100 spent in this country, £40 is imported, and that although a Buy Irish campaign can mitigate that to some extent, because of our fundamental lack of raw materials, we are a country where imports inevitably succeed the spending of money. No worker, no salaried person, no one in the community will have a higher standard of living unless he comes to appreciate the fact that if we spend the £100, we must be certain that the £40 of exports are there, that they are sold, that they are available and will continue to be available. That is the simplest way of putting it. That has been stated many times in different ways by Ministers of this Government. Although, as I have said, the Buy Irish campaign can mitigate that and although it is better to buy Irish shirts than foreign-made shirts because there is the Irish labour in making the shirt, the materials in the shirt are mostly foreign because we cannot grow cotton here.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Is this the hairshirt the Government intends to put on the people?

Comment on this

The same thing applies to many industries, particularly industries using all kinds of metal such as the motor car industry. It is better to buy an Irish-assembled car than to buy a foreign car; nevertheless, the import content of the Irish-assembled car would be relatively high. We are an import-intensive country and we must forever remember this rule about the £100. Until people start to realise those facts in our national life, we are bound to have successive balance of payments crises at different periods.

I heard one statement by a Deputy of the Labour Party which suggested that they, or at least some of them, were under the illusion that if wages went up by 12 per cent, prices need not rise. There is no country in the world where, if wages go up 12 per cent at once, prices will not rise. One only has to go through the ordinary labour costs of any industry, which are available in various publications, to see that is inevitable. What we want to ensure is that if there is a wages increase, the industries can absorb the increase in wages through greater productivity. Some of the industries have been able to do that; some have not been able to do it. When the question of people receiving increased incomes as a result of greater prosperity is considered, it has to be remembered that there are a considerable number of industries and trades where it is almost impossible to make any saving whatever and where any increase in labour costs is directly passed back in increases in living costs and so cancels out the benefit to the worker.

In relation to these trades and industries, we have to live with this problem perpetually. A typical example is that of CIE. No matter what CIE does to increase productivity the labour content is something between 60 and 64 per cent and, if fares are increased, it is quite impossible at any time for CIE to absorb the increase in fares by greater productivity. The company simply cannot operate on that basis. I think everybody must know the reason, but it is partly because, if a train has to run every day at a given time, it just cannot stop running on a particular day because there are no passengers for it. On the other hand, a firm can cut down temporarily the production of a particular article if there is no demand for it. In a transport service, however, and this applies equally to every transport service throughout the world, where there are regular services scheduled, there is just nothing drastic that can be done to increase productivity at a particular period and, when there is a considerable increase in labour costs, it is inevitable that these must be passed on to the community either by way of increased subsidy paid by the taxpayer or by way of increased fares.

Comment on this

The Minister must not be aware of the position of the Lough Swilly Railway in Donegal. They can pay a dividend of ten per cent and they do not have to be subsidised or paid £1½ million every year.

Comment on this

We are not discussing small transport companies. We are discussing transport costs.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister was discussing CIE.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The general facts were accepted on the Transport Bill by both sides of the House and the accounts, as presented, were accepted by the House, so it is no good introducing the Lough Swilly Railway into the debate.

Comment on this

I am merely telling the Minister what happens. I am citing the position of the Lough Swilly Railway as an example. They can pay a dividend of 10 per cent and they do not have to be subsidised or paid £1½ million every year.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

All this was dealt with. The Deputy is talking old hat and there is no point in doing that on a debate in relation to prices.

Comment on this

I am only trying to enlighten the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister does not need to be enlightened.

Comment on this

That is purely a matter of opinion.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Harte should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

I did not mean to interrupt. I beg your pardon.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has been interrupting.

Comment on this

I apologise. I was only bringing the fact to the notice of the Minister.

Comment on this

A number of other considerations have been mentioned in this debate. As the House knows, the total level of taxation levied last year bore a relationship to national income that was about the same as in 1956-57. Taxes were increased because under the prevailing system of taxation there could be a very big rise in national income without receiving the same percentage in tax for Government services, which are becoming more expensive because of the national development that has taken place and will continue in the future.

There are a great many things we have to face in relation to taxation. If a turnover tax is applied on the whole community and one-third of it is remitted in increased social welfare there seems to be some sort of theory that everybody must recoup himself and herself by having an increase in wages of 2½ per cent. I wonder whether in the next ten years that will prove to be possible in connection with the turnover tax or any other tax. The Government asked the people to transfer a given amount of their incomes for the sake of national Government services. I wonder whether the workers and the salaried people generally will succeed ultimately if, over the next ten years, they try to undo the effect of a tax, which is needed by the Government and which is all spent among the people, by having increases in wages to cover the particular tax. I think, if one looks back over the history of other countries, it will be found that such ventures are not generally very successful.

What was the basis of the tax? The facts are that in 1964 the people spent £88 million in consumer expenditure and the Government asked them to give £13 million of that £88 million for Government services. The implication was that, if they recouped themselves by increased wages, then the effect of that would be to increase costs still further and you would have a leap-frogging effect which would ultimately result in no one gaining anything.

There is another question we have to consider then very honestly. These are matters about which we can speculate. Part of the increase in the cost of living has resulted from the increase in certain agricultural products. Everybody knows that. Some people say the non-agricultural community must compensate themselves for the increase in the cost of agricultural goods produced by our own people. I wonder whether they will be able to do that over the next ten years. I wonder whether it is not right sometimes for the agricultural community income to increase at the expense of the nonagricultural sections' income because the actual facts are that the agricultural income per head in this country is still lower than that of the nonagricultural community. Efforts are now being made in all parts of the world, in the EEC and elsewhere, to try to level up incomes. I wonder whether there is much use in the nonagricultural community trying to compensate itself with increases to offset the costs which provide more profits and more help for the farmer when inevitably Government policy is to transfer payments made by the nonagricultural community back to the farmers in the form of additional subsidies. I wonder whether there will be much success in that exercise in the future.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is mixing things up. The farming community is subsidising the rest of the community.

Comment on this

All these things have to be considered. There is yet another hard fact we have to remember. We have about one half of the national income per head of the British. Many other countries have similarly lower incomes than the British for one reason or another. In our case we have had a very short period in which to develop our economy. We also lack the essential raw materials which the British have or which they derive from their long imperial associations. These are disappearing. We have now had a warning that in the future we should all consider together how to provide some element of reserve resources to meet certain eventualities, international repercussions and the absense of international liquidity in payments, the effect of the British levy on our export trade, and other circumstances which arise and which all help to contribute to the crisis which we hope and believe will be overcome by the measures proposed by the Government.

One of the matters that arise in connection with this discussion—the discussion has been fairly continuous over the last three years—is the possibility of getting agreement on a national incomes policy. That is, of course, associated with many practical problems. One of them is the fact that there are different industries with different degress of productivity. Some industries can engineer a big increase in productivity, and have done so, while others lag behind. I heard some Deputies suggest that not enough was being done to increase productivity. As far as I know the National Productivity Authority have been operating with the aid of Government funds and adaptation councils have been set up for all industries. Adaptation councils have been set up for all the industries and there has been nothing to prevent any particular trade union group or any employers' group from making proposals to increase productivity. Productivity is growing; it has to grow still faster if we are to overcome some of the difficulties we now face.

In regard to the controversy over national incomes policy, it is true that a great deal of the price structure of the country is determined on a competitive basis. The Bill before the House will ensure that there are no exceptions to that and that it shall be impossible for firms to increase their prices excessively, even though they may face competition, through some kind of tacit agreement between them that prices should go up by a certain amount. Having agreement to a stricter form of price control would seem to me to answer many of the objections that have been put forward by the workers' side to a national incomes policy, that if there is price control and if the National Industrial Economic Council put forward proposals to the country as to what they believe the growth of real incomes has been and what can be safely gained at a given period in increased salaries and wages which will not be lost through inflation, the attitude towards the national incomes policy with a price control system installed may be more favourable. I hope it will be, because I have found, by making an examination in other countries where this system is operating, that on the whole it is very successful.

The interesting thing about the system abroad is that in the few countries where it operates the workers always have the opportunity, if they wish to take it, of getting a bigger increase at certain points if they feel the system is lagging. That is one of the things that is never spoken about; everybody thinks that if we have a national incomes policy it must be absolutely rigid and that at no point can there be any departure from it. People are human and in every country where there has been a national incomes policy there can be seen at certain times a departure from it because the workers perhaps felt that the rules had been too strict or perhaps that the country could afford a little bit more than was recommended. It is also true to say that there have been periods where the system has broken down and in some cases the Government have had to take corrective action because the body that corresponds to our NIEC were right in the particular year when they made their declaration and corrective action had to be taken of a disinflationary kind. In other years it would appear that when there was a departure after a number of years of following the strict rules, eventually no harm came to the community because the value of money had declined in other countries and the industries in the particular country concerned did not suffer as the costs in the other countries had gone up.

All these things need considering at present on a constructive basis. Obviously, it will take time for people to come to any kind of agreement on this proposal and I am mentioning it merely as a background to the discussions that must eventually take place arising from the present crisis.

Lastly, I want to say a few words about status increases in incomes. Nobody in the House, so far as I know, opposed any of these increases. I wonder why there was no objection to the majority of the increases by anyone. The reason of course was, as everybody knows, that the great majority of these status increases represented the inevitable levelling up that takes place in every country when the incomes of certain classes in the community relative to other classes in the community were depressed. In fact no national incomes policy in any country is so rigid that it precludes income adjustments for workers who, for one reason or another, have not been able to secure the same growth in income as has been secured by the other sections of the community. In those countries where this kind of thing takes place nobody suggests that because there have been status increases everybody should get a corresponding increase in wages. These are matters that must be looked at dispassionately and calmly. There have been criticisms in this House over the past five years in respect of sections of the community whose incomes were low in comparison with the incomes of others and now we have a whole series of statements made here suggesting that all these increases were unjustified and that they are one of the causes of the present inflation.

The Government could not face the position in which increases had occurred in commercial and industrial employment which meant that the position of others, particularly in the Civil Service, had become relatively worse and salaries by comparison with outside salaries appeared abnormally low. There were bound to be adjustments of this kind and it does not mean that anybody is going to benefit by simply washing their hands of all the issues that have to be faced and simply saying: "We must have an enormous increase in wages because these other people have been given status increases." That will not serve the best interests of the country and will not bring the workers any real increase.

It has been made perfectly clear, as long ago as December, that until productivity rises sufficiently any demand by workers for wage increases will not give them the advantages of those wage increases. What we should all long for is a system in which when workers get increases in wages they are able to keep them. That can be done; it has been achieved in a considerable number of countries where workers' real earnings have steadily increased with due regard being paid to the national economy. Anybody who wants to read the facts can find them in Switzerland or the Netherlands or in Belgium or in a number of other countries. They can see the system operating, not perfectly — it never operates absolutely perfectly—but with the real earnings of the workers advancing as a result of concerted discussions between the employers and the workers and some sort of independent council as to what optimum increase could be given which would enable the workers to retain the full benefit of what they have secured.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Would the Minister clear up one point? Does the Minister not want the worker to spend his wages and if he does not, what is his wife to live on?

Comment on this

The Deputy has obviously completely misunderstood what I have been saying. If the Deputy wants to be so irresponsible as to fail to understand what I mean by the worker keeping——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Minister should not speak in riddles.

Comment on this

——keeping his wages and not having them lost by increases in the cost of living, I do not think I could explain it more simply than that. I should prefer Deputy Flanagan to do some homework by reading the reports of the Foundation of Labour in the Netherlands.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

If the Minister would fix the printing dispute, perhaps we could read them.

Comment on this

I think I have dealt with a number of points raised in the debate. The main point I wished to make was this: we have had a great growth of national income; we have made tremendous progress but from the beginning of the period where the growth in our national production, in terms of greater costs, started to mount very rapidly as compared with the growth in the national production, taking the value of money in constant terms, every Minister of the Government has warned the people of the result of asking for too much too soon. Those warnings have been given steadily by the Ministers concerned with State companies, with Industry and Commerce, and by the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance ever since 1962. Nobody can say the underlying causes, which are only part of the reason for the action now being taken, have not been fully published and if people did not see fit to take our advice there is nothing we can do about it.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

Like many other Deputies, I am grateful to the Minister for Transport and Power for giving us this rather extended left-of-centre dissertation here late this afternoon. I am so grateful that I stayed until now, late in the evening to hear these thoughts of the Minister because I think he was courageous enough to grasp some nettles that others in his Cabinet, perhaps with more foresight, have not grasped in this debate. He mentioned this ugly word "status" which is causing quite a lot of trouble and possibly is one of the reasons why this House has rather a closed club atmosphere rather late this afternoon.

The Taoiseach asked us yesterday afternoon to preserve a sense of responsibility and calm in the discussions on the economic situation at present facing us. As responsible people we should strive to do that. We should avoid what I do not think the Minister for Transport and Power avoids, that is, chasing culprits in the trade union movement and saying that the cause of our inflation is exclusively the wage claims from that part of our society. We can all look for culprits and seek alibis at this time, but I do not think there should be a one-sided recitation of the events that have brought us to a point where we are almost back to where we were in 1956. Probably the one element that distinguishes this period from 1956 is that production is still showing a slight rise. In all other respects, we are slipping back quickly to 1956.

The Minister in his tour of the progressive countries mentioned the problem of balance of payments faced by other well-regulated democracies. That is true. Our problem is that we must be unique as being the only economy that has a permanent balance of payments problem, coupled to a considerable extent at the moment with an inflationary situation, together with unemployment and emigration. I would say a comparison with the well-regulated democracies and the common problems they face is not valid in the circumstances.

One thing I was disappointed about in the Taoiseach's speech yesterday was that there was no real honest attempt to break down the inflationary trends which have gripped the economy since the National Wage Agreement. If he erred at all, it was in having a political interpretation of the period since the National Wage Agreement. In the serious situation before us, this had a little bit of dishonesty in it. At this time there is need to state the problem before us honestly. I thought the Taoiseach could have done so more wholeheartedly. We could have had a clearer description of what elements had occurred in the price increase since the National Wage Agreement. Above all, we could have had the reduction to a proportion of what part the actual 12 per cent had in the rise in prices over this period.

We have pointed out how belated has been this action of the Government in bringing in price control machinery. We have called for it often in the recent past. But it is not my purpose to fire any parliamentary salvos about the past but to talk about the immediate problems facing us. The great tragedy I see in this situation is that in seeking to bring before the House at this moment, and in seeking to alert the country to what is supposed to be, and is, a potentially extremely serious situation, the Government lay themselves open to the charge of being cynical in their approach to price control at this time. They are bringing in price control machinery at a time when we can now see that the increase people received under the National Wage Agreement has been cancelled out by an increase in prices.

In his statement yesterday, the Taoiseach said that all the measures proposed involved no sacrifice on the part of the workers. Certainly, anybody with a trade union background, or anybody who has close contact with his constituents at this time, can tell you there is grave sacrifice on the part of all workers in the situation that the increase they received has been cancelled out. The Taoiseach, in saying there was a further year to run for the National Wage Agreement, must know he is speaking against all the current of opinion in the country and all the feeling of the working classes. The tragedy we have at present is that the workers are poised for another round and the Taoiseach tells us yesterday there is an economic crisis in the country. He introduces a Prices Bill as an element of our concern for the economic crisis. I will be a delegate to the forthcoming conference of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. They will be meeting to consider reports of movements already beginning for another wage round. This is at a time when the Government are telling us that the economic situation is so bad that we must introduce price control.

It is obvious there is an extremely difficult and grave situation before us where, because of lack of control, prices have slipped up since the National Wage Agreement. They have now registered their effect on the living standards of the people, and the people have reacted normally to them. At this time we introduce this Prices Bill and expect to have the support of the people. We expect it to be a sort of guarantee to the people that they need not seek any further increases in their living standards because there is now a Prices Bill in operation that will preserve their standard of living.

It is obvious that however much the Minister for Transport and Power may lecture us about progressive movements all around the world, and how socialism in countries on the other side of the world may appear to him, looking at it from Dáil Éireann, the situation to which we must face up at the moment means that trade unions, under pressure from their members, are on the march to increase their standard of living and we are told that the economic situation of the country is not such as to warrant that advance.

When the National Wage Agreement was signed, most of us welcomed it. Any of us looking at the economic situation over the past few months could see there was an extremely severe build-up which could have an adverse effect on our economy. Over this period nothing was done to stop the tremendous increase that had occurred on the prices front. Whatever other failures the National Wage Agreement may have had, this is surely the one part of it that will doom any repeat of a national agreement in the future. A national agreement is not something that can be agreed to at one period. It is not something if you have an unfortunate experience with it, that can be replaced in a year or two by another agreement when the first has proved a failure. Industrial relations are extremely complex. Initiatives, once taken, must be maintained and preserved. We cannot, with the wave of a magic wand, reintroduce the situation as it was before.

Over this period of the National Wage Agreement, there has been this large swing in prices and we have not taken action to counteract this increase. Presumably, the casualty of the present situation will be this—that it will make the possibility of the signing of another national agreement extremely unlikely in the future. This is to be regretted because we can see that wages going up according to a plan, and the trade union movement sitting down peaceably with the employers and bargaining amicably for increases for their members, is a better form and a better system of industrial relations than a free-for-all system with strikes and what they mean to the ordinary workers. The fact is that by our refusal or our failure to take prompt action in the period up to now, in the life of the National Wage Agreement, we have probably jeopardised any future hope of a national agreement or industrial relations based on this system.

The same can be said of the other matter to which the Minister for Transport and Power referred, an incomes policy. At one time or another, we have all spoken about an incomes policy being a just and a desirable objective that we should have before us, but can we say that an incomes policy can be achieved when we see a Prices Bill like this, which is a softener up, being introduced at such a time in the economic situation? I do not think that we can say there is a possibility in the near future of an incomes policy in the sense that we are trying to bring in a Prices Bill when the economic situation has already become too bad for such a trend and when the ordinary trade unionists have suffered for too long the erosion of their increase and are moving ahead automatically.

The Minister for Transport and Power and other Government spokesmen have made it clear that their version of an incomes policy is solely to try to control wages. This was the form of incomes policy mentioned in Closing the Gap to which the Minister referred. That kind of policy has no hope of being accepted by the trade union movement and the sooner the Minister for Transport and Power and other Government speakers get this idea into their heads, the better. An incomes policy is one that seeks a policy for all types of income, however difficult this may be to achieve in our economy, but this is the only form of policy that has any hope of success, of acceptance, or agreement as far as the trade unionists are concerned.

This Prices Bill is belated. It seeks to remedy a situation that has already moved out of control on the prices front; yet the Labour Party have been calling for such a long time for some form of action on prices that we support it and we will constructively suggest changes where we think there should be changes. But as I said before, the opportunity which a proper Prices Bill offered any Government, either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael, as an opening or as an avenue towards an incomes policy, has been postponed by the unfortunate timing of this Bill and the refusal to face up to these facts before now, to the erosion in prices which has been obvious over a certain period.

The Government now seek to hand to the trade union leaders the unpleasant task of bringing trade unions into line in facing up to an unpleasant situation. The National Wage Agreement expires next December and the possibility of another one being signed in the year after, in 1966, is rendered very slim indeed and the way forward if we were to take it towards an incomes policy has been postponed indefinitely by the timing and policy of the Government in producing this Bill at this time, and in not taking action before. I do not make these statements with any view to scoring political capital but merely to point to what I and other members of the Labour Party feel has been a dereliction of duty on the part of the Government. However, we will support this Bill constructively even though time will tell whether I am right, whether our opinion is right about this uncertain outlook for the future.

We have tinkered around with this problem for too long and I for one am rather gloomy about the prospect of improving this situation in the future. It is going to require far more consultation with the trade unions than the Government have shown themselves to be capable of. These consultations should not be held at the time of an economic crisis, such as now, but at a time when things are going well. That is the time to hear the complaints of the trade unionists in regard to the national economy. The complaints have been loud enough about prices in the period since the National Wage Agreement was signed.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The fact that the Government have at this late stage given consideration to the question of price control brings again to the notice of the public the wise action taken by the inter-Party Government between 1954 and 1957 when the Prices Advisory Body was functioning. That Government showed their concern in a very practical and positive way in regard to the cost of living and the control of prices. I should like to hear from the Minister for Industry and Commerce what machinery it is proposed to use to control prices. The speech made by the Taoiseach yesterday, the speech made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce today, as well as the few feeble speeches flavoured with hypocrisy which have come from the Government benches, have given no indication to manufacturing or business concerns, or to the public at large, how the Government propose to work this Prices Bill.

I am sure the voters of this country would like to ask the Taoiseach what extraordinary change has taken place in the country since 6th April, 1965. Everything was right on 6th April, 1965, the day before the general election, when we were told that we were living in the greatest period of prosperity, that there was no such thing as a poor person, and the voters were asked to return Fianna Fáil so that the rate of progress could be accelerated. Those were the very words used outside the General Post Office not only by the Taoiseach but by every other Fianna Fáil candidate. They said that people were wallowing in wealth, living in the greatest period of national prosperity since the State was founded.

Did the Taoiseach tell the voters that there was a crisis or did he tell them about the balance of payments problem? There have been plenty of speeches and statements from Fianna Fáil, all of which were made in an atmosphere of gaiety, of gluttony and of banqueting and dining, but what is the use of delivering an address to certain privileged classes when the speeches are given a particular flavour so that they will be relished and be more palatable to those participating in these dinners and banquets?

It is the height of hypocrisy on the part of Fianna Fáil to have conducted a general election campaign by painting a picture through the columns of the Irish Press—one advantage we have in this debate is that we have no Irish Press—for the people of the country that anything any Deputy opposed to Fianna Fáil said was wrong. The Irish Press gave the speeches of Ministers and Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, all painting pictures of the period of prosperity in which we lived.

I want to place on record very clearly that the general election speeches and promises and undertakings of Fianna Fáil were only a ruse to catch votes. Now that the Government see themselves firmly settled in office for the next 4½ years, they tell us, immediately after the general election, that there is a period of scarcity and of depression, that there must be a wages standstill and a Prices Bill to remedy a grave national crisis. They have the courage to stand up and say: "We appeal to the patriotism of Deputies, of trade unions, of all the people in the country, to stand behind us to surmount this grave national crisis".

I should like to refresh the memories of Deputies on speeches made in 1956 and 1957 when the inter-Party Government were faced with a balance of payments problem. Every speech made in those days by Fianna Fáil Deputies was a direct attack on the Government. They said the crisis had been brought about by the Government by deliberate action. There was no question of their co-operation. In the columns of the Irish Press, on every platform at every church gate, they not alone took advantage of the national crisis but deliberately misrepresented and tried to undermine the Government. What is the position today? Is it not true that the Government have brought the country to the verge of bankruptcy? They are lucky as they were always lucky. They have extraordinary good luck. They were lucky at the polls and now they are lucky that this crisis cannot be conveyed to the people of the country because of the newspaper strike.

Comment on this

In all probability designed by them.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The crisis comes at a time when the views of the elected representatives in this House cannot be conveyed to the homes of our people.

Comment on this

Hurray for "The Hurler."

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Of course there is the radio and there is the television, but neither will give a true picture of the situation. Radio and television are biased. They are always inclined to favour Fianna Fáil. Naturally enough, they are the child of Fianna Fáil and surely a child, subject to good parents, cannot go wrong. In order that the radio becomes a good son of a good founder father, naturally enough it will give favourable publicity to that father. There is nothing we can do about it. It is only right that we should direct the attention of the public to this grave crisis in every way we possibly can. We all have our views and opinions on this crisis and undoubtedly Deputies are expected on occasions like this to express their views. It is not unbecoming to a Deputy to make known his views on all subjects.

Since I am expected to express my views on this crisis, I should like to say that personally I should not give co-operation, good, bad or indifferent, to the Government. If they got into a mess, let them stew in their mess. If there was anything I could do to make the position known to the general public, at church gates or at fairs throughout the country, I should like to tell the people of the country that this extraordinary mess was made by Fianna Fáil, that they are in it, that they have dragged the people of the country in with them and let them get out of it themselves. I cannot understand how any Minister has the nerve, the audacity or the neck to stand up and ask for the support of Labour and Fine Gael Deputies to help them in their difficulties when we all know that any difficulty that exists is a direct result of the policy of Fianna Fáil.

They have made a bad job of running the country to such an extent that they have never been concerned with the welfare of the country or its people. The only concern of Fianna Fáil is to get more jobs for their friends, to remain in office as long as they can, to drive the country into debt, to allow the cost of living to soar higher and higher. The more people leaving the country, the better for them, the less they will have to contend with.

It is not our job as an Opposition to try to find ways and means to help the Government out of the mess they are in. The Taoiseach said when on this side of the House that it was not his job to tell the Government what to do. I tell him now it is not our job to find the remedy for the mess caused by Fianna Fáil. If we are in Opposition, we are in Opposition, and as far as my opposition is concerned, I say they are in this mess and they have the people in with them. In my radio broadcast the night before the general election, I said: "If the people sow nettles, they cannot expect roses to grow." The nettles were sown; they grew; and they are stinging now. If the people had sown roses this extraordinary state of affairs would not have arisen.

Is it not true to say that every effort is now being made to hamper the activities of trade unions who seek wage increases for their workers? We seem to have extraordinary ideas about trade unions. We use every publicity means to throw blame on the trade unions for all the economic ills the country suffers from. We never seem to think that the trade union movement caters for a vast section of our people, that even the Civil Service can be described as being part of the trade union movement. Not only is the person who works with shovel or spade part of the trade union movement but so are the vast majority of our people, whether they work for their livelihood in offices or shops.

The demands of the trade union movement have been right and justified. I would stand over that statement on any platform in my constituency or outside it. The reason why I say the trade union movement have been acting wisely in the interests of their members is that the increases received on the occasion of the last round of wage increases has now been wiped out, in most cases completely, and workers are worse off today than they were before they received the last round of wage increases.

The reason for this extraordinary state of affairs is that Fianna Fáil refused to take any action whatever in regard to the cost of living. Fianna Fáil never had a policy in regard to the cost of living. They were never concerned with the cost of living. Their main concern to-day is not with the cost of living but to freeze wages and to try to handcuff and blindfold the leaders of the trade union movement.

I hope that Deputies, both inside the House and outside it, will not allow Fianna Fáil to throw any blame whatever for any economic crisis that may be facing the country on the trade union movement or, indeed, on any group of organised workers who are only seeking a decent wage which will enable them to have a decent standard of living. They cannot have a decent standard of living if Fianna Fáil allow prices to soar and the rich to grow richer, while, as we have seen in the past the poor become poorer and poorer.

The Minister for Transport and Power has rambled over countries from New Zealand to the Netherlands, the Benelux countries, Australia and so on. I venture to say that in this country and in this city, there is a vast amount of poverty in the homes of persons on fixed incomes who have no trade union to seek increases for them or to fight for them, pensioners and others who have not received any increase whatever since the last wage increase was granted. It must be known to every Deputy who has a serious interest in his constituency and the problems of his constituents that that vast amount of poverty exists. One indication of the poverty that exists, as a result of almost a quarter of a century of Fianna Fáil administration, is the demand on charitable organisations for help for families and aged persons, invalids, the disabled and the blind. These persons, suffering in conditions of poverty, are expected to subsist and to meet the highest prices for essential commodities in the world.

I venture to say without fear of contradiction that the Government are now reviewing their past conduct. The slashing of the food subsidies must have some bearing on their efforts now to control prices. The slashing of the food subsidies was one of the first factors in increasing the cost of living. By that action, the cost of bread, flour, butter and the necessaries of life was increased. The Government cannot blame any section of the community for the slashing of the food subsidies. That was their own deliberate act, their own deliberate decision and policy, despite the fact that in a general election two months before that they pledged their word of honour that they were not going to interfere with food subsidies. At Belmullet, the then Leader of the Party had asked why they should interfere with the price of bread and flour, such an important item in the diet of the poor. He was not six weeks in office when up went the price of flour.

Fianna Fáil have not changed since those days. The method by which they were elected to office was intrigue, false promises and propaganda. If they had carried out the promises which they made at election times, this would be one of the most prosperous countries in the world. One thing is certain. Fianna Fáil have never been short of promises and of plans for the future. Like the Programme for Economic Expansion, their promises are eyewash and balderdash. There are numerous plans contained in that Programme. Fianna Fáil have always had plans but these plans seem to be shelved in Government Departments, covered with dust and surrounded by cobwebs. They do not seem to be put into effect.

There is a balance of payments problem, a crisis in relation to wages, prices and the cost of living. As Deputy O'Leary said, it is bad enough to have the prices problem and the balance of payments problem, but it is worse when that is coupled with a serious unemployment problem. A serious unemployment problem exists and there is also the problem of emigration. In a general election broadcast, we were told that the tide of emigration was decreasing and that fewer persons were emigrating than ever before. Even since last April, there has been a vast increase in the numbers emigrating as a result of the lack of employment opportunities. The blame for that must rest at the door of the Government.

The Government say that as a result of the control of prices, nobody can look for an increase in wages. Is this the old Wages Standstill Order in disguise? Everybody knows that the draft of the Wages Standstill Order was discovered by the late Deputy Norton some years ago in the Department of Industry and Commerce. There is nothing to stop the Government from dressing up that old Order in new clothes and presenting it to the House. Is this effort to control prices the thin end of the wedge?

The Government have not indicated the means by which prices will be controlled or what prices will be controlled. If we are to have control of prices, is it to be done behind closed doors by a group of influential manufacturers and a civil servant or two who will make a recommendation to the Minister? Or is there to be a public inquiry as in the days of the Prices Advisory Body? Under that system a public sitting was held. The manufacturers gave evidence; the consumers gave evidence; and the Irish Housewives' Association and other interested bodies gave evidence. If there are to be inquiries in relation to the fixing of prices, they should be conducted in public so that anybody who so desires may give evidence. In this way the case made by the manufacturer or whoever is seeking the increase will be made public.

I hope this matter will not be dealt with by the closed door method and, if it is, it should be exposed by every Opposition Deputy. There are usually strange and sinister movements behind those closed door inquiries which have been conducted by Fianna Fáil people ever since 1932. I always feel that there is something shady going on when such inquiries are conducted in private. If the Bill is to work, these inquiries will have to be conducted in public, with due notice given to everybody to enable them to come and present their case, and the findings must be published.

Fianna Fáil tell us that everybody is to make sacrifices. How is it that when sacrifices are required in this country, the first people called on to make them are the workers? Would it not be nice for a change to hear that the Taoiseach would address his ministerial colleagues and say to them that if sacrifices are to be made, they would give the lead and contribute their share.

Comment on this