We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Capital Gains Tax Bill, 1974: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–198 of 398. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Capital Gains Tax Bill 1974
Enacted

No. 42 of 1974 ›

Richie Ryan Minister for Finance (Mr. R. Ryan) Fine Gael

I do not think I have anything to add to what I was talking about 12 hours ago.

Comment on this

Perhaps I could assist the Minister. He was dealing with a point I had raised on subsection (9) in regard to a forfeited deposit of purchase money. The subsection provides that where a deposit of purchase money on sale is forfeited, that money is to be deemed to be disposal and acquisition and subject to capital gains tax. I questioned whether this was consistent with other provisions in the Bill to which the Minister had referred from time to time, specifically the provision that a disposal of money or currency is not subject to capital gains tax.

The Minister was arguing there was more involved here than money, that there were rights under contract, rights to property normally. I suggest that when the deposit is forfeited the question of right to property has ceased because the contract has been terminated and the deposit has then been forfeited. What is involved is simply a money transaction. So far we have been dealing with the person who received the forfeited deposit but I want the Minister to say what is the position of the person who loses the deposit: is he entitled to claim the amount of the deposit so lost as an allowable loss?

Comment on this

No. The position is that the person to whom the money is forfeited has made a gain out of the property because he has sold to another person the right to acquire the property. The person who forfeits has no capital asset on which he has suffered a loss. The right is extinguished through its non-exercise. He has no capital asset and, therefore, has no loss to set off but the other person has a property on which a gain has been made and, therefore, has had a capital gain.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): In an earlier section the Minister said he would not allow cash deals as allowable losses but I do not think the Revenue Commissioners can have it both ways. In one section it is maintained that a cash transaction will not be an allowable loss and then we come to another section where there is a cash transaction. How often have we seen a deposit placed on a property at auctions and so forth and a person fails to raise the necessary money to carry through the deal? This is strictly a cash transaction but the Minister builds it into a capital gain under this section, while at the other end a man who loses his deposit —he could have other property—will not be allowed to claim it as a capital loss. I do not think the Minister is consistent. It is a cash transaction. The Minister has stated that cash transactions are not allowable losses, yet we come to this section where a man takes an option and puts a deposit on property, if he fails to raise the necessary money to go through with the deal, the Minister says the deposit is a capital gain. There is no consistency between the two previous sections and this one, but to make matters worse the Minister is not allowing a chargeable loss to a man that may already have one or two properties and who borrows from the bank to put a deposit on a new property for which he fails to raise the necessary cash. Surely there is a case there for an allowable loss.

Comment on this

While I agree that a person who makes any profit out of an option should pay tax, I felt yesterday that in this discussion there was a certain amount of bitterness or hatred against people who might be in this option market or who might be involved in a speculation. There are many people who sell shares. If they can buy them at a lower rate they can sell them at a profit and if they cannot buy them at a lower rate they must pay a higher rate and lose. It is a risk.

However, on this question of options, say there are 11 properties in a deal. If a property manager said tomorrow morning: "I am going to buy them" those involved would all look for treble the price, but if he gets an option on, say, half or one-third of them and goes along to the remainder and says: "Your property is worth £X as it is. Developed it is worth £2X, which I am willing to give you", if ten people agree and one refuses, the one person who refuses may be blackmailing the property manager and holding out for, say, six times the amount. Therefore he cannot go ahead with the development. If he has paid 10 per cent of £1 million, he has paid £100,000 on it.

All these people who get £10,000 each pay income tax on it, but the man who pays £100,000, the man who is needed to get all these people together, if he sells all his options, he pays tax on it; if he develops the property he pays capital gains on it, or if it is a company they pay normal tax plus corporation profits tax. If a person takes this risk I cannot see why he is not allowed on it, whether he is an individual or sets up a £100 company to do it. If he puts in the money and loses it it should be chargeable as a loss. If this is a company that is in a capital gains position, does the Minister intend that they should get no allowance for the losses on options on such properties as I have spoken about?

Furthermore, if you are a trading company, you pay tax in the normal way and you are not in for a capital gain, but in a straightforward business, if you buy the property with the intention of developing it and fail to develop it, are you allowed tax on your losses on the option? I agree with the section in so far as it deals with people who are just in and out, but there are people who are legitimately in the business, and areas would not be developed without them. Dublin city is crying out for development of flats rather than business properties. It would be a retrograde step if a person who was prepared to buy property in a package deal and then develop it was prevented from doing so.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) deals with the situation Deputy Belton describes. The abandonment of the type of options he is talking about could give rise to capital gains or capital losses, which of course, would be allowed.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I do not think that covers what Deputy Belton is talking about as regards taking the option and losing it, that you cannot offset it against a capital gain.

Comment on this

If a man pays £100,000 on a property worth £1 million and one person refuses to deal with him, the development cannot take place. He pays £100,000 reasonably hoping that he will get planning permission. Supposing the planning permission is refused, are the Government going to charge tax in such a situation? Is that the position?

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is depicting a scene in which a person loses £100,000 because he does not exercise the option. The reason why he does not exercise the option is irrelevant here, whether it is planning permission or because he changes his mind or anything else. He is abandoning the option here and he has a loss in the situation depicted, and this would be an allowable loss.

Comment on this

Fair enough.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): According to this section, it is not an allowable loss against future capital gains. The Minister is talking about a trading account for the year whereby it can be written off, but a future capital gain is not allowed.

Comment on this

Deputy Belton is talking about a person who engages in property development. Such a person will presumably be engaging in similar activities in the future and so will be able to use losses in one situation against another.

Comment on this

Does the Minister mean that if the person described by Deputy Belton sustained a loss of this kind for some reason or another, he could charge it against a capital gain he might make in some other area?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Where is that provided?

Comment on this

Subsection (5) (b) says that if:

an option to acquire assets exercisable by a person intending to use them, if acquired, for the purposes of a trade carried on by him,

is disposed of or abandoned, then—

(i) if the option is abandoned, the abandonment shall, notwithstanding subsection (3), constitute the disposal of an asset (namely, of the option), and

(ii) paragraph 9 of Schedule 1 (restriction of allowable expenditure for wasting asset) shall not apply . . .

Therefore, the full loss will apply.

Comment on this

He can charge his loss against another capital gain?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): What about subsection (9)?

Comment on this

Subsection (9) deals with forfeited profits.

Comment on this

Is the provision in regard to abandonment not that the person who benefits as a result of the abandonment, who makes a gain, becomes liable to capital gains tax but the person who loses cannot claim that as a loss? I understood that was the position under the section. That is why I asked the Minister where it was provided. I am not sure, on the face of it, that subsection (5) (b) does precisely what the Minister says.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) deals with assets which are acquired for the purpose of a trade. In such a case the loss could be used—it would be allowable. But if it is not for the purpose of a trade that a person forfeits a deposit, then such a person would not have a loss which would be allowable.

Comment on this

In the case described by Deputy Belton, if that is not the person's trade—the development of property—and if the loss occurs as described by Deputy Belton, is it not true that he is not allowed to claim that loss as an allowable loss against other capital gains?

Comment on this

If the person is not operating as a property developer but is simply in once only—or even for a period he might be a property developer and then abandon it—if it is only an occasional operation rather than a trade, then the loss on a forfeited deposit would not be allowable.

Comment on this

On what principle do you apply that?

Comment on this

In one case the person is engaged in the trade and acquiring an asset for the purpose of business. In the other case the person is not engaged in a business operation but in a once only or occasional enterprise.

Comment on this

But if he were engaged in an occasional enterprise would he not also be charged for a capital gain?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Why would he not get the benefit of a loss on an occasional transaction as he would otherwise?

Comment on this

If he gets it in one case why not in another?

Comment on this

It is very easy, indeed, to fabricate losses by arrangement. Persons could arrange with other persons in their confidence to have a contract under which losses would be fabricated and deposits forfeited by agreement. It would be impossible to police developments of that kind.

Comment on this

So we do injustice because we cannot police?

Comment on this

No. If a person is in this accidental or occasional situation which subsection (9) visualises, such a person is unlikely to be in a recurring capital gains situation.

Comment on this

I agree in the case of fabrication. What the Minister is talking about is where somebody who has a loss transfers it to somebody else. But if an individual has a genuine loss in an occasional transaction, since if he had made a gain he would be chargeable, he should be able to charge a loss.

Comment on this

Is that not the general principle on which the Minister has been proceeding—that if there was a chargeable gain there could be an allowable loss or, alternatively, the transaction was taken out of that category altogether?

Comment on this

I do not see how it could be fabricated where the person was going to make himself liable for a capital gain.

Comment on this

He could sell his loss.

Comment on this

One side would have to pay while the other side——

Comment on this

I understand the difficulties of collection and policing but here, again, I should like to urge on the Minister the importance of working on the principle and not trying to close every conceivable loophole because you will leave some big gap in any case. This is the sure way to do it.

First, there is a principle in this Act that capital gains are to be taxed and I think there is universal acquiescence in that but the Minister has emphasised that, as the obverse of the coin, allowable capital losses will be set off against capital gains. I leave it to my colleagues to deal with actual details, Deputy Belton, Deputy Dockrell or Deputy Fitzpatrick, and I shall try to deal with the legal principles because we are making law. If that is the principle of the legislation, it is important to apply it universally. That raises the first practical difficulty which we understand, the difficulty of the Revenue Commissioners when they are up against people indulging in planned avoidance of the provisions and the difficulty of policing. Policing difficulties restrict all of us in the community whether it is policing for the Revenue or for crime. The next principle one would rule is that there be fairness in the restriction. Every effort must be made to see that no person is penalised or no group penalised or put at a disadvantage more than another.

I see that principle being infringed here as I have mentioned on earlier sections. Here, for anti-avoidance purposes a situation will develop where some genuine people will be penalised in that they will be liable for gains but will not get the equity available to others under a provision which will be exploited by the people on whom the Minister is concentrating. The genuine people will be penalised as against others.

To encourage the friendliness and usefulness of the discussion we have had I want to tell a story that once happened in the old days. It will illustrate the futility of trying to foresee everything and block every outlet.

In the county of Dublin 50 or 100 years ago, it was the custom in a certain town for the boys and girls on Hallowe'en night to go around with a stalk of cabbage and bang the doors. There was a cranky old dame in one house who was utterly determined that no one would bang her door and she went to all the trouble of having the door taken off and brought beside her at the hob. She sat there guarding the door and said: "They won't bang my door tonight" but what happened? One of the girls, the least expected of anyone, quietly came in and said: "Goodnight, Maggie; aren't there terrible noises around?" Suddenly out came the cabbage stalk and banged the door and out she went. The door was banged all the same. The Minister and the Revenue Commissioners can never block or prevent everything and the more the Minister goes on with this, the more his door is going to be banged and this is what I have been fighting on all these sections. I know that the Minister has not got unduly irritated by my insistence but it is an awfully important point.

What is really activating the Minister here, it seems to me, is not any particular desire to penalise anybody. In answer to Deputy Belton, he has brought out the dangers, but I am going to ask him on the principle: can he not face this without going to the extent of making an exception in the general principle of the Act of allowing losses where a person is in principle chargeable for gains? I will even concede that certain very clear cases might force something like this but not, I think, where bona fide and genuine business or transactions are concerned. That is my plea to the Minister.

Secondly, on the section as a whole, the Minister will recall that I said last night, and say again, that this is a necessary section as it goes, and Deputy Colley, I think, joined with me in that, but we have to look at its provisions and try to make it a better section than it is in the Bill. I want to be assured that it is not revenue-getting that is involved here. Here is a question which we have not asked the Minister very much so far on the Bill and I refrained from asking it but the type of thing envisaged here may involve very big monetary transactions and I do not completely accept that this section is merely included to be explicit on action and prevent abuse. I have a feeling that revenue considerations may come into this. In other words, it is definitely a taxation section and the Minister hopes to get a significant contribution, and particularly what I might call an economic contribution, from this.

To explain what I mean, and I do not wish to appear to be making a Second Reading speech, certain taxes give a high return and are easy to administer—PAYE, for instance. Here the cost of collecting has been virtually handed over to the private citizen and it is not difficult to police it and it has a very high content of return. Something the same could be said about VAT. A capital gains tax can be a less remunerative tax, for tax it is, however dressed up in social conscience, and none better than the Minister to give it a very good look from that point of view. It is taxation, however dressed up, and the Revenue Commissioners are obviously concerned with enforcement because in this whole capital section in the end the assessment is placed on the taxpayer and the sanctions are there to see that he pays.

Leaving aside that aspect however, I should like to know how much in relation to this section the revenue element comes in. If it is a case, and this is the crunch, that it is anticipated that considerable sums will come in under this head and although nobody wants to say it explicitly, the allowing of losses would decrease the contribution or leave it too uncertain, that is a policy matter and should be stated positively. Note my "ifs". The Minister will understand that there are no imputations in this. I am merely trying to dissect the problems which have arisen on this section.

What I am saying is that there are three problems on the section, which we all agree should be in the Bill in one form or another. The first is— and I ask the Minister to answer this general policy question first—why can we not continue to apply the general principle of setting off allowable losses against allowable gains in this area? If there are specific cases where it is necessary to modify that principle, the Minister should say specifically what they are. The Minister would shorten our discussion and help us greatly if he could do so policy-wise and, in fact, answer the question.

Secondly—we know that there is a lot of anti-avoidance in this section, that that is nearly the purpose of the section—would he say—I am only guessing when I put the question but I am still entitled to ask it and to get an answer—is there a significant revenue element here and, if so, would the allowance for losses significantly influence the position? Let us have the answers to these questions before we get lost in further discussion.

Comment on this

The Minister gave me answers regarding trade in companies and their appeals against tax and yesterday Deputy de Valera asked me to go into the details on this. I was puzzled yesterday to hear three lawyers chatting about lessee and lessor; I could not get into my head what they were talking about.

Comment on this

I endeavoured to return to the principle of that.

Comment on this

I understand the position but I did not get involved in the discussion because I would need to be practising in a solicitor's office daily to argue the matter fully. I accept some of what the Minister has stated. A person who buys property is in it to make a capital gain and he is willing to pay 26 per cent tax but if he loses, and he can lose for many reasons other than his own bad judgment, he should be able to use that loss against a capital gain in the future. If of 11 people involved in a scheme one does not come across with the result that the scheme has to be abandoned and there is a loss of £100,000 the Minister has said if a person who suffers that loss is in for the first time, is a gambler, he does not see why he should get an allowance. I do to an extent. It is usual that such a person gets options for a sizeable amount and he must be backed by a strong company. While the options are being prepared, it must be remembered that planning permission for the development of the area has not been sought or obtained from the planning authority. The planning authority may then say they want a road to go through the property because of the provision of Government offices there.

When the planning authority place a CPO on the property the person is stuck with a loss of £100,000. He will get some of it back with the houses up the middle but he will get none of it back from the development on either side. This loss has occurred through no fault of that person; it has occurred because the planning authority interfered. That person, who was willing to pay capital gains tax, is then faced with a capital loss. If a local authority held up the passing of plans, that person could be put into an unprofitable position, a position he did not foresee and for which he is not allowed anything. I accept that the Minister is endeavouring to stop the fly-by-night individual but the person I have spoken of is not catered for. The person who sells his 10 per cent after paying the Minister his tax and then loses that 10 per cent afterwards should be allowed something on it. I can understand how this works with a trading company.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I am confused as to what the Minister said in regard to trading companies. I should like to give an example. Mr. A. has an hotel and he buys a site from Mr. B. for £8,000 to build another hotel. Mr. B. owns a public house apart from the site. Mr. A. fails to find the rest of the money and loses his deposit of £8,000. That person then sells his hotel. As I see it, he cannot write off that loss of £8,000 against the capital gain of £20,000 which he makes on the sale of the hotel. If Mr. B. sells the site that he has taken the £8,000 for and makes a capital gain of £20,000 the £8,000 will be added to the £20,000 and become a £28,000 capital gain. Is that the correct interpretation?

Comment on this

If a person has acquired an hotel for the purpose of carrying on the business of the hotel, then subsection (5) will apply.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I am thinking of the £8,000 he lost by taking an option on a site for the purpose of building another hotel.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) applies.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): After selling his first hotel and making a capital gain of £20,000, can he write off the £8,000 as a capital loss?

Comment on this

He can.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): If Mr. B. sells his pub, will the £8,000 be added to the capital gain on that sale?

Comment on this

Yes. As far as a business is concerned subsection (5) applies and losses are allowable.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): But not in the same year. The hotel I am referring to could be sold a year or two later and could the loss then be carried forward against his capital gain?

Comment on this

Yes, but not backwards. So far as the non-trade transactions are concerned it is most unlikely that there will be any hardship by reason of the operation of this section. I cannot say what the revenue element is; we do not know. We do not know the number of transactions of this kind here because there has been no obligation to bring this to the notice of the Revenue Commissioners hitherto. As ordinary men of the world, we know these transactions occur.

Comment on this

I asked if it was an anticipated revenue return but I accept the answer of the Minister.

Comment on this

In so far as it will be operated to discourage avoidance it means there will be a revenue return. There could be a situation in which a person has a capital gain of £5,000 and he could arrange with ten other people a scheme under which ten deposits of £500 each would be forfeited to ten others. Those £500 lots of themselves would not be taxable because they would be below the limit and who can say whether or not money passing in that situation on paper would not be handed back in more casual locations and would not come to the notice of the Revenue Commissioners? There could be a situation then of having ten fabricated losses being used to prevent a charge on a gain of £5,000.

Comment on this

Surely when losses are claimed to be set off against a transaction, the Revenue Commissioners would not accept a suspect case like that without some investigation.

Comment on this

That may be the position but one might generate these over a number of years in anticipation of gains in such a way as not to make the evidence readily available to the Revenue Commissioners. I will look at the points made here to see if we can tackle this matter in some other way. The genuine case where there is not a fabrication of losses and which is not designed primarily as an avoidance device might deserve different treatment if hardship were caused. I doubt very much if there would be hardship in many of the cases that have been described, but neither would I want any element of significant hardship. "Hardship" is an emotive word and it is a condition that is difficult to calculate. People seldom talk about taxes without using the word "punitive" and they seldom talk of a loss without calling it a hardship. It is not necessarily something that causes all that much pain or disturbance. However, I should like some time to think about the points that were raised and if it is possible to have a different way of treating these issues, I will be disposed to consider it for Report Stage.

Comment on this

Where a person loses money either because of bad judgment or through no fault of his own he is not allowed to offset the loss, but if he did another deal and made a profit, would he be allowed to offset the loss against that profit?

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): He might be in the trade for the first time.

Comment on this

These are matters of degree and an assessment must be made in each case.

Comment on this

I am involved in this so far as a trading company is concerned. The capital gains aspect does not worry me. I am discussing the case of a person who is caught and I cannot understand why he cannot claim in future. I can visualise where a person who might be in business on a small scale could lose and have no way of getting the money back. If that person makes a gain of £2,000, he will have to pay capital gains tax but if he loses £5,000 he does not get any allowance for that. It seems unfair.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I should like to ask the Minister some questions with regard to the option situation and how it might apply to an ailing industry. There are many such industries at the present time. Perhaps I might take the example of the textile firm of Martin Mahony, Blarney, in my constituency. This firm is in serious financial difficulties——

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy will appreciate that in tax matters we should not refer to individual concerns.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am merely taking it as an example.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I trust the Deputy is not availing of this opportunity to bring up this matter.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

That is not my intention. I am merely referring to an example where there were approximately 260 people employed. The local representatives who are concerned for the preservation of the jobs naturally are trying to interest people who may not have been involved in business prior to this. Jobs must be protected. The textile industry has not got any help from the Government——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have to refer to the section under discussion. He is introducing extraneous matter.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Perhaps the Chair will allow me to develop the point.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will not be allowed to proceed on these lines.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am anxious to develop the option situation. If we succeed in getting somebody to take an option in all or part of such an industry——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid the Deputy is availing of this opportunity to refer to a specific industrial problem in his constituency and I am specifically ruling that out of order. The Deputy must not refer to the matter again. He must refer his remarks specifically to the section under discussion or else resume his seat.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

May I refer to the broader issues——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy must refer to section 47 of the Capital Gains Tax Bill—nothing else.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Perhaps the Minister would clarify the situation where somebody succeeds in getting a person who has not already been in business to take an option in all or part of such an industry. It is probably a gambling option so far as that person is concerned because he may not be able to get adequate finance from other sources——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is seeking to circumvent the ruling of the Chair. If he persists, I shall ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Chair may be somewhat more suspicious than is necessary——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair is satisfied about what the Deputy is up to.

Comment on this

I suggest the Deputy has a valid point in relation to this section and to the inducement of people in taking options. The section provides that in such circumstances if they lose or abandon the option they cannot claim this as an allowable loss and, therefore, there is no inducement.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) would apply——

Comment on this

I am afraid it would not and this is why I am making the point.

Comment on this

They would be acquiring assets intending to use them for the purpose of a trade. I assume that is what Deputy Fitzgerald is talking about. I do not think he is assuming they would acquire the asset in order to dispose of it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

If the person for some reason cannot take up the option afterwards because of inadequate finance, what becomes of the option? Should not special cognisance be taken of such an individual who may be in a position to save the jobs of many people? We have many ailing industries and, perhaps, some person might decide he could make a success of a business. He may take an option but may not be able to get the necessary funds. In that situation does he lose or is there any attraction for him to go in and help our economy, help save jobs in an area like Blarney which has been neglected by the Government?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy knows it is not in order to make specific references.

Comment on this

It is not customary to mention specific names and the only error Deputy Fitzgerald made was to mention the name of a firm. I submit I am quite entitled to make the point being made provided I refer to the matter in general terms. If I say: "Consider the case of a firm"et cetera that is within the terms of the section and I submit I am perfectly in order. In my own time I fear I have on occasion been a little unreasonable with the Chair. I further submit that, if we pursue argument on this, the publicity will be greater than ever.

I should like to get back to the section. It was probably wrong to mention the firm. Let us all agree on that, but the Minister has made an answer to us on the proviso in subsection (5) which is the subsection I now want to talk about. Am I in order in dealing with a hypothetical general case of a company or an asset—I shall leave out the word company, though it is a company in this particular case—which is in danger of going? Forget the reasons for it. If somebody is prepared to take an option but may be discouraged, or find it not good business, or too dangerous, am I entitled to discuss that?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes.

Comment on this

That is what I wanted to know. Furthermore, if the Minister gives me reasons why he will not do something, since there are social matters involved, am I entitled to raise social considerations with regard to the maintenance of employment and things of that nature? Is that in order?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Yes, general matters.

Comment on this

We want to keep in order.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy knows that a Member can be quite at liberty to discuss the section and its subsections without going into specifics or mentioning the names of particular individuals.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

I am sorry if I introduced a specific case but I am emotionally upset about the situation. The case I mentioned was merely an example of something about which I am only too well aware as I am only too well aware of what the consequences may be for the area.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not continue to refer now to specific matters.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Let me generalise. In such industries surely adequate protection should be provided for the encouragement of John Murphy, who has never before been in business but proposes to engage in business for the first time, possibly making a success of it with obvious benefits to the area in which the industry is situated and benefits to the economy generally. If John Murphy loses the option, if he loses the money, what happens then? If the receiver gets £10,000 what is the position in regard to that £10,000? Is it charged to capital gains or is it a capital loss? Could it be claimed as a capital loss?

Comment on this

I have said that subsection (5) provides it can be claimed as a capital loss by the person who suffers it.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Not the first time in business.

Comment on this

For the purposes of a trade carried on by him.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

But he never did any trading before.

Comment on this

The subsection provides for that eventuality. The terminology used is ". . . . intending to use them, if acquired, for the purposes of a trade carried on by him".

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

If he is established intending to use them for the purposes of a trade carried on by him, there is no problem.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

There is, I think, another interpretation. The terminology " . . . intending to use them . . . for the purposes of a trade carried on by him" can be interpreted as a trade he carries on at present.

Comment on this

I shall have a look at it again and, if it is necessary, I will make clearer what the intention is; in other words, it will be seen to be a case of genuine trading intentions.

Comment on this

The Minister has referred to subsection (5) on a number of occasions and I would like some further clarification on the subsection. The subsection refers to two kinds of options:

(a) an option to subscribe for shares in a company, or

(b) an option to acquire assets exercisable by a person intending to use them, if acquired, for the purposes of a trade carried on by him.

The section then goes on to say that if an option of either kind is disposed of or abandoned certain things will happen. If it is abandoned "the abandonment shall, nothwithstanding subsection (3), constitute the disposal of an asset (namely, of the option). . . ". The Schedule provides that restriction of allowable expenditure for wasting assets shall not apply and accordingly subsection (4) shall not apply to such an option as is mentioned in paragraph (a). Perhaps that is clear to the Minister but it is certainly not clear to me because the subsection is dealing with two kinds of assets. It provides that, in the event of an option of either kind being abandoned, then so and so shall happen but it does not say what happens if it is disposed of. Furthermore, it seems to apply some parts of the subsection and previous subsections to one kind of option and not to the other. Whatever the intention is, what is purported to be achieved in this is anything but clear. I would, in particular, like the Minister to spell out precisely where the question of the loss resulting from the abandonment of an option is treated as an allowable loss. It says here if the option is abandoned the abandonment shall, notwithstanding subsection (3), constitute the disposal of an asset . . . " would the Minister pursue that a little further and spell out precisely how that produces the situation of an allowable loss because the next part says that the allowable expenditure in respect of a wasting asset does not apply while the next part seems to apply only to shares.

Comment on this

Subsection (3) provides:

The exercise or abandonment of an option by the person for the time being entitled to exercise it shall not constitute the disposal of an asset by that person . . .

That is why, in relation to assets acquired for the purposes of a trade, it is provided that, notwithstanding that subsection, it will constitute a disposal.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying, in effect, that because it is a disposal then, if a loss arises, it is an allowable loss?

Comment on this

All the consequences of a disposal then apply without having to be specifically spelled out again.

Comment on this

I am afraid I am a little bit confused now about this point. Let us take the case that we were taking. There have been strangers, without naming names or giving indications, who have come along in this country in recent years and who have promoted industrial activity because they had capital resources or who were motivated by social reasons or, perhaps, if one wants to be cynical, the reasons that motivated them were personal reasons but that motivation caused them to do good. It is not unknown that such a person has been willing to come in and take a company or a business which was failing, revive it and deal with it. This is the case that I want to focus on. On the point we are currently discussing I am not quite clear how this section applies to him if he proceeds to deal with it by way of option. He may want to deal with it by way of option to gain time or to resolve uncertainties and to keep things going.

I can think of a case in this city of many, many years ago. I will not indicate it but it cannot possibly cause any emotions now. It was a case where somebody of the nature described, a very well-known citizen, did come and revive in this kind of way at least one industry that I have in mind which today is still flourishing as a result of that intervention.

I would like to know how this affects the encouragement to people. I think that is the net point which Deputy Fitzgerald could have made in order on this section. There is a further point but, perhaps, until the Minister answers that one I will reserve it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair would point out and Deputies will appreciate that it is an old ruling of this House that a citizen's or firm's affairs would not be discussed in the House.

Comment on this

We are not discussing——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No. The Chair is just taking the opportunity of explaining the background to the ruling.

Comment on this

I hope I did not offend in what I said.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

I agree completely. It is still relevant from the point of view of encouragement. For instance, let me be more specific. I may wish to take an option on some assets—I am saying "assets" now— for time but also for social reasons and I am faced with the fact that I may be liable for a gain but I am going to take a certain risk and I will not be in a position to set off an allowable loss. I think that is the net point. I am not going outside the rules of order when I say that that is a disincentive. We have on other sections discussed social reasons. I have not even mentioned the social reasons. I am leaving it as abstract as that. I am asking the Minister does he take the point or what is his answer? He has mentioned subsection (5) as his answer. When I get that answer, I will come on to the technical point.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is just explaining, not in regard to Deputy de Valera's point at all, but in regard to the ruling as it applied in Deputy Fitzgerald's case. That is all.

Comment on this

I accept that completely and I hope I made clear our attitude in regard to that.

Comment on this

Deputy de Valera is now entering into the very field in which he says discretion should be left to the Revenue Commissioners to deal with it.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

In fact, they will have to deal with such cases——

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

——notwithstanding all the details that exist in the Bill. He says, of course, a person may acquire an option to purchase some property or to maintain some business for what he calls social reasons. There is an element of business in it——

Comment on this

There is, of course.

Comment on this

——an element of trade, even if there is not a profit. A person may acquire a trade knowing it will make losses. The fact that he did it for social and humanitarian reasons would not disqualify him from the relief in respect of a trade. Here we are going into an area of trying to analyse motivation and trying to calculate whether or not a man is sensible to be engaging in certain transactions. Quite clearly, we cannot legislate for those situations. The Revenue Commissioners would look at the facts of every case. They would not deny a man his right to claim a capital loss merely because from a business point of view they may consider his original investment to be an imprudent one even if motivated by the best possible charitable reasons.

Comment on this

Now the Minister is, so to speak, accepting some of the points I made earlier. What we want to avoid here is the tying up. This section might unduly tie the Revenue Commissioners. The powers that are given them in certain provisions are necessary, as we said at the beginning of the discussion on this section, but I would like to feel that the Revenue Commissioners were not tied. In this case the specific nature of the proposed legislation does tie the Revenue Commissioners. Of course, I agree with the Minister that we cannot legislate for motivation. What we must do is have regard to the general consequences of our legislation both social and taxwise.

The Minister is shoving an open door with me when he talks about relying on the judgment and discretion of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Then he has to provide for that.

Comment on this

He has to provide for that. I would like him to look at subsection (5) from the point of view of the Revenue Commissioners in the context in which I am talking. Paragraph (b), to which Deputy Colley referred, says:

an option to acquire assets exercisable by a person intending to use them, if acquired for the purposes of a trade carried on by him.

In the case I have visualised, again taking it in the abstract, a person, he might be one of our citizens who has done well abroad or somebody who has come here and become naturalised—I am thinking of a very famous person in the oil world who was a great benefactor of this country years ago—comes in and is not carrying on a trade or business in that sense and he certainly will not acquire the assets for the purposes of a trade carried on by him. If, for instance, Deputy Fitzpatrick is running a business making glass marbles and he gets into difficulty and I am somebody who has capital; perhaps I was fortunate in diamond mining in South Africa, although I cannot think of anything more remote from possibility than that; this man has the capital and has returned to this country. He is probably motivated by personal reasons. He is ready to save that industry and the employment in it. He has to act immediately. This is very often a consideration in options. It is a genuine device for taking quick action where the whole commitment cannot be effected in the time. This person may be engaged in business plus philantrophy. He will intervene in this in a way that cannot possibly be captured by the phrase "purpose of a trade carried on by him". This man probably never saw a glass marble since the day he played with them in an Irish schoolyard. He will not be acquiring this business for the purpose of a trade carried on by him. Therefore, I fail to see that subsection (5) will cover him.

Comment on this

The Minister said he will look at an amendment but he is getting to an amendment which brings in a double question of intention. This subsection talks about a person intending to use the options. If the Minister is to cover the kind of case highlighted by Deputy Fitzgerald and now by Deputy de Valera he will also have to provide by way of an amendment not only for his intention in regard to the use of the assets but for his intention to carry on a trade.

It is not quite legislation for motivation but it is getting very close to it, the thing the Minister said could not be done. It is legislating for intention. The more I look at subsection (5) the more unintelligible I find it. There are a number of other difficulties involved in it as well but I do not want to pursue them at the moment and perhaps take away the Minister's thoughts from what Deputy de Valera said.

Comment on this

As Deputy Colley said, I said I will have a look at it. I can accept there can be such situations but we all know how impossible it is to try to draw up a Bill to treat every known tax difficulty and every hypothetical one as well. There is no reason why we would not anticipate in the future, if some hardship case was thrown up or some case in which a philanthrophist was being unfairly dealt with, that we would not amend the law. I would much prefer to think that we were legislating now in a perfect way so that further amendment was not necessary. I have indicated my readiness to have a look at this as long as we can be assured that any provision in relation to future conduct will not be available for use in a way which would lead to abuse. Obviously, if an option is not exercised the query then arises as to why it was not exercised. This goes to the very root perhaps of the original intention, particularly if the person had not been engaging in the marble trade beforehand. I will certainly look at it. I am anxious to assist a genuine case such as that illustrated by Deputies de Valera and Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister appreciates that it is not to tie the Revenue Commissioners by law here but to give them power and discretion. That is what motivated me in raising the last point. I would be absolutely satisfied with cases like that provided they were not tied hand and foot. I would fear the section would do that.

Comment on this

I want to again refer the Minister to subsection (5). I have been trying to make some sense of it. I am trying to simplify it as it appears. It states that where an option is of the kind specified and it is disposed of or abandoned then under (1) if the option is abandoned, (2) paragraph 9 of Schedule 1 and so on shall not apply. Would the Minister tell me if it is intended that paragraph (i) will apply only in the case of abandonment and that paragraph (ii) is intended to apply in the case of disposal or abandonment? On the face of it, it does not appear to be drafted that way, but is that the intention of it?

Comment on this

The first one says an abandonment is a disposal. As it is a disposal paragraph 9 shall not apply.

Comment on this

That is what I thought at first.

Comment on this

I think the point Deputy Colley is making is why use the words "disposed of or abandoned" if it only relates to abandonment?

Comment on this

Subsection (4) treats of the disposal of a transfer. This appears to be purporting to treat disposal or abandonment although subparagraphs (i) and (ii) appear to be relating only to abandonment.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy may be raising a drafting point. I do not think it is very much more.

Comment on this

I was taking this in stages. If the Minister goes on to look at the proviso he will see the matter becomes even more complex. It goes on to say: "Provided that the provisions of this subsection do not apply in the case of such an option as is mentioned in paragraph (a)," unless it is of a particular kind. Paragraph (a) provides for an option to subscribe for shares in a company. Subsection (4) deals with a disposal by way of transfer of an option binding the grantor to sell or buy shares or securities which have a quoted market value. This proviso goes on to say that what has been said already will not apply, although you would think it was saying it would apply, to options to subscribe for shares in companies unless it is a certain kind of option.

The more I look at this the more I think this subsection is virtually inapplicable because so many convulutions come about to try to cover all sorts of things. I am certain it could be drafted more simply. It is a crucial subsection having regard to the point raised by various Deputies, including Deputy Belton. The Minister relied on it to assure him that the kind of case the Deputy was talking about would not be affected. It transpired that the kind of case the Deputy was talking about would be affected in certain circumstances. Then the Minister relied on subsection (5) in regard to a person acquiring assets for the purpose of a trade carried on by him, but we have established that that is not sufficient. The Minister has agreed that that would have to be amended to meet the kind of cases we are talking about.

The whole subsection in my view is so drafted as to make it almost unintelligible. Instead of putting things in and then taking them out, it must be possible to start from scratch and draft it in some way that would be simpler and more to the point and on which we could rely. It is quite a crucial section. Since the Minister will have to do some redrafting I take it he will have it looked at from scratch.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy that guarantee.

Comment on this

Thank you. I want to come back to subsection (9). Apart from the points raised earlier, I want to ask the Minister about another point. In the case of a deposit being forfeited under, say, an ordinary contract for sale of property, as I understand it the provision at the moment is that the would-be vendor who receives the forfeited deposit becomes liable to capital gains tax on that, whereas the would-be purchaser who loses the deposit is not allowed the deposit which is lost as an allowable loss.

In the case of the person becoming liable to capital gains tax—in other words, the would-be vendor—will he be allowed as a deduction from the amount of the forfeited deposit the expenses which he has incurred and, in particular, the interest which he has incurred? I presume he will not because I think the interest is precluded under Schedule 3. In the normal way as the Minister well knows—I think it is true to say that in law—the vendor is not entitled to the deposit as a forfeited deposit unless he can show that it represents liquidated and ascertained damages which he has suffered. In other words, he can show that is the measure of his loss. If he shows that is the measure of his loss should he, in fact, be subject to capital gains tax on this? I think the Minister will agree that legally he is not entitled to the deposit unless he can show it is a measure of his loss.

Comment on this

Clearly we have to treat forfeited deposits in a similar way to options or else all options would become forfeited deposits. I would not go all the way with Deputy Colley in relation to deposits in contracts for sale. A great deal will depend on the provisions of each particular contract. Of course they can vary. There might be an absolute forfeiture——

Comment on this

That is not enforceable, as the Minister knows.

Comment on this

——irrespective of whether the vendor suffered any loss. Compensation for damages would not involve an element of capital gains if it was no more than compensation for expenses which had been incurred. Supposing compensation included an element of the higher price which the vendor would have received if the original sale had taken place than the price which the vendor received when the subsequent sale took place, in such a case the vendor would obviously enjoy a greater gain by the enforcement of the provisions of the first contract than he would enjoy if the first contract had not existed at all. To that extent there would be a gain element over and above the compensation for expenses actually incurred.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Deputy Colley raised the point as to whether the total amount of the forfeited deposit has to be taken into account. It seems to me that a case can be argued, and no doubt it will be argued, that the only element which should be taken into account is the element of net price gain as distinct from compensation for costs actually incurred.

Comment on this

That is the right principle but I am not so sure that is what the subsection says. In fairness to the Minister he was thinking on his feet. I suggest he came up with the right conclusion but I do not think that is what the subsection provides.

Comment on this

I will look at that. It is very difficult to relate one provision to another but, having regard to the other sections, I think the compensation for costs-incurred element may be deductible and, if it is not, we will certainly have a look at it.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): It would be very unfair to charge capital gains where a man loses the sale of his property. Somebody takes an option on it and perhaps two months later he gets a lower price for it. He would still be charged on the deposit, would he not? It would be a capital gain.

Comment on this

Supposing the original price was £5,000 and the person sold the property for £4,000 ultimately. If there was a deposit of £1,250 on the first sale and that was forfeited, clearly £1,000 would be attributable to the difference between the first and the second price. He has received his £5,000 anyway because he got £4,000 plus £1,000 for the original forfeited deposit plus another £250.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): At 26 per cent he may not make up the loss.

Comment on this

Remember we are not dealing here with the total consideration. We are not taxing the total consideration. We are only taxing the element which contains a capital gain.

Comment on this

Hopefully that is what we are doing.

Comment on this

Since the Minister will be looking at the section I will just draw attention to two points. The phrase "as it applies" is a common one.

Comment on this

Where is it?

Comment on this

Subsection (9). ". . . .as it applies in relation to the consideration for an option which binds the grantor to sell and which is not exercised". Would the Minister have a look at the word "as" in that context? Subsection (1) provides that an option is a disposal. Subsection (2) deals with the case of exercise. Subsection (3) talks of exercise or abandonment. Subsection (5) talks of disposed of or abandoned, and so on. The phrase ". . . . which is not exercised" seems to be based on what I might call the residue after positive legislation. It is a question of drafting and expressing the Minister's intention in words. Perhaps the wording of that subsection should be attended to.

Comment on this

I will re-examine it.

Comment on this

I do not want to delay the House or the Minister. I do not expect an answer to that now.

Comment on this

Earlier on we discussed the principle involved here of charging a capital gain on a forfeited deposit or in the type of situation described by Deputy Belton in which there was an option on property which had to be abandoned. The person who received the benefit from that was liable for capital gains tax but, on the other hand, the losses incurred in such cases were not to be allowed, subject to what has been said, as allowable losses. I am not quite clear on what precisely was the Minister's attitude to this question. I wonder could he clarify his approach to the problem raised. It seems to me that what is involved here is not merely a question of drafting or anything else; it is a question of principle in the way one approaches it.

Comment on this

A person who has acquired a forfeited deposit has certainly made a gain. Nobody can dispute that. You may say a person who has forfeited a deposit has made a loss, but in respect of the person who has forfeited the deposit there is no asset upon which the loss has arisen. The person who makes the gain makes it in relation to an asset which he retains. The other person has put money down——

Comment on this

I wonder is the Minister quite correct in that?

Comment on this

Of which he will get the advantage if certain circumstances arose.

Comment on this

Surely the question of a loss can arise only when there has been a disposal and an ascertained loss? If one has disposed of an asset and ascertained one's loss, then one does not have the asset. Therefore, one has one's loss but it is not related to an asset which one holds. I do not see the logic of what the Minister is saying.

Comment on this

In simple terms, would not the forfeiture, in itself, be a disposal of the asset in which there is a loss from one point of view anyway?

Comment on this

He is not happy about losing anyway.

Comment on this

No, but it is a disposal of the asset because, in a sense, he had a certain ownership of that asset from the moment of the option. Let us take the example of an option to purchase land. In a sense, that very option is an interest in land; it is an interest; it is an interest in the asset. It can be argued either from the point of view of the vendor or purchaser that there is no interest. There is a very definite interest on both sides. There is a very definite disposal within the meaning of this Bill. The very fact that I contract with somebody else to purchase land, or a house, gives me an interest in that land or house. Certatinly, it would be an interest within the meaning of practically all legislation and, in certain cases, would be an interest for tax purposes. It is an interest; I have acquired an interest by taking that option. The vendor has disposed of an interest in so doing.

Let us go back to the definitions. "Asset" in this case is not confined to being the realty. Take the house— and I am speaking about a definite case now—here is a house; I am going to sell the house to say, Deputy Belton. I do it by an option—even if one calls a forfeiture an option—which is really what the deposit procedure is. But, suppose I do it formally by an option. I give Deputy Belton an option to buy the house. I have disposed of an interest in that house and Deputy Belton has acquired an interest in it.

Let us take section 7. One must not think of the house as being the asset here only. The Minister's argument, if I understand him correctly, might be all right if one did that. But we must be consistent and use the same term throughout. Section 7 says:

All forms of property shall be assets for the purposes of this Act whether situated in the State or not, including—

(a) options, debts and incorporeal property generally,

(b) any currency, other than Irish currency and sterling, and

(c) any form of property created by the person disposing of it, or otherwise becoming owned without being acquired.

Therefore, clearly the case I cited here is the passing of an interest. I would go even further, in the normal case, where there is a sale of land, where there is an ordinary selling contract, where there is a forfeiture clause, and say that that certainly passes as an interest. Again, I am speaking of principle and I should like the Minister to bear that in mind.

Comment on this

An option is a wasting asset.

Comment on this

So is a contract.

Comment on this

So is a contract. It wastes into nothing if not exercised. To take the transaction between Deputy de Valera and Deputy Belton, Deputy de Valera visualises himself as giving a right to Deputy Belton to acquire some asset or other which he, Deputy de Valera, holds. If Deputy Belton does not exercise that right it wastes away into nothing.

Comment on this

Quite.

Comment on this

Therefore, though he may have suffered a cash loss, at the moment of suffering it he has suffered it on a non-existent asset as far as he is concerned. On the other hand, Deputy de Valera has made a gain on an asset which he still retains, unaffected, undiminished, with no part of it disposed of at the very time that he makes the gain.

Comment on this

He may not have made a net gain; he may have made a loss. Suppose Deputy Belton did not take that house and forfeited his deposit to me, he might have done so for a very good and simple reason. Supposing some intervention had occurred, as Deputy Belton says, such as planning permission. Supposing Deputy Belton contracted with me to buy a house. That house had certain amenities which Deputy Belton would like to have and then, say, a circumstance such as planning permission or a drop in the market intervened in the matter. There are circumstances where losses can occur. The Minister's argument that I had made a net profit because I got the deposit does not stand up on an analysis of that nature; even the Valuation Office would not accept that.

I do not want to delay the House by pursuing this. I do not want to put the Minister to the trouble of chasing all sorts of hypothetical cases. What I am saying is this. Let us get back to simplicity, get away from worrying about anti-avoidance. Do not tie up the Revenue Commissioners by attempting to legislate for everything. Give them scope to exercise their good judgment.

Comment on this

Certainly I do not want to be put in the position of having to chase both Deputy de Valera and Deputy Belton in respect of capital gains on hypothetical cases or otherwise.

Comment on this

Unfortunately under this section it would appear as if the Minister would be chasing them for capital gains but not allowing them any capital losses. I think the Minister ought to pause and think when he finds himself, with all due respect, having to argue in such a thin way to justify on this section a breach of two principles laid down in the Bill and to which he has referred repeatedly. They are both breached in this section. One of them is that a transaction which is a transfer of cash, whether in Irish or other currency, is not subject to capital gains tax and is not to be allowed to create an allowable loss. That is one principle. The other one is that any transaction which is subject to capital gains tax can give rise to an allowable loss. They are two principles laid down in the Bill to which the Minister has referred repeatedly. Both are breached in this section. That fact alone should give the Minister food for thought.

The only way the Minister can even attempt to deny the breach of these things is to produce a totally artificial interpretation of people having losses but not related to particular property, whereas they have gains on a particular property. The Minister knows in his heart that that is a very thin argument which does not stand up to analysis.

There is something wrong with a section which obliges the Minister to breach these two principles laid down in the Bill. Having regard to the consequences of what is being done in the section, I am trying to ascertain what is the Minister's attitude in principle to it, as distinct from the actual drafting and what may emerge from amendments. Does he accept, where a transaction may produce a capital gain and thereby be subject to tax that, if it produces a capital loss it should be an allowable loss?

Comment on this

We are dealing here with capital and the losses must relate to capital disposed of and gains must relate to capital disposed of.

Comment on this

That is not right. The Minister specifically provides in some sections for the collection of capital gains tax on transactions where a gain accrues, but a person does not acquire any property or asset.

Comment on this

Options and deposits are special and obviously are distinct from non-wasting assets. The options and the circumstances which lead to forfeiture of deposits are changing all the time.

Comment on this

The Minister is really saying that options are contracts. If that is his thinking, he had better rethink subsection (7). Under this Bill we are trying to have things both ways, and, of course, that is the one sure way of ensuring that we will not have it at all. I understand the anti-avoidance problems and I will not repeat all I said on this. The Minister is putting an interpretation on "capital" which is not in the Bill. I pointed out that there was a trap here because we could think of assets in terms only of tangible assets. When we talk about "capital" we are falling into the trap of implicity defining capital in a restrictive sense. That will lead us into all kinds of legal traps before we are finished. Again I want to emphasise that we should keep this simple. If we give discretion to the Revenue Commisisoners we will avoid all these traps.

Comment on this

We have had a very full debate on this section and I will be looking at it again in the light of what has been said here.

Comment on this

I appreciate that but a number of points were raised where redrafting is necessary. I am trying to ascertain the Minister's attitude on the principle as well as the drafting problems. I am not trying to be difficult but, in my opinion, it is important that we know this. Does the Minister accept that we should endeavour to provide that a transaction, which may give rise to a chargeable gain, can also give rise to an allowable loss? Does he further accept that a transaction which does not give rise to a chargeable gain, because it is in money, should not give rise to an allowable loss?

Comment on this

We are dealing here with more than money transactions. We are dealing with the sale of rights, including wasting rights. I have discussed the principle as I see it and I will consider what has been argued here and see if we can produce a better section.

Comment on this

Does the Minister realise that he is getting himself into black knots in this section? As an anti-avoidance measure, probably all that would be achieved here is injustice to the genuine cases. From what the Minister said I take it that he intends looking at the section and introducing amendments to clarify it. I am also taking it that he will also look at the principle involved. If we agree to this section it will be on that understanding. If the Minister finds he is unable to redraft the section so as to accept the principle we were adumbrating in regard to genuine cases, we would feel it necessary to introduce an amendment on the next Stage, to achieve it.

Comment on this

The word "capital" is not defined in the Bill. "Capital gains" is defined in a way that it is not quite clear what they are, except as one goes from section to section.

Comment on this

Strangely enough nobody ever bothered to define "income".

Comment on this

They do not have to pay tax at all.

Comment on this

In mental energy we are all paying a tax on this Bill, the Minister no less than anybody else.

Comment on this

There are some points I want to raise on this section. There is a provision in the section which reads:

The situation of any such assets are as specified in this section shall, except as otherwise provided by section 4, be determined in accordance with the following provisions . . .

Why is it necessary, having regard to section 4, which is fairly complex, to lay down other apparently alternative provisions here? Subparagraph (b) reads:

subject to the following provisions of this section, the situation of rights or interests (otherwise than by way of security) in or over tangible movable property is that of the tangible movable property.

I take it that what is intended to be conveyed there is the situation of tangible movable property at the date of disposal, which is the crucial time in determining this. It does not quite say that but I presume that is what the phrase means.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It would be helpful if the Minister could give an example of the kind of thing envisaged in paragraph (b). In regard to paragraph (e), the Minister will note that it states:

subject to paragraph (d), registered shares or securities are situated where they are registered and, if registered in more than one register, where the principal register is situated.

On the face of it, that makes sense, but in the light of it may I refer the Minister to paragraph (h):

patents, trade marks and designs are situated where they are registered, and if registered in more than one register, where each register is situated and copyright, franchises, rights and licences to use any copyright material, patent, trade mark or design are situated in the State if they, or any rights derived from them, are exercisable in the State.

What is the effect of that provision if the register is situate in the State? It would appear to constitute a considerable difficulty in dealing with these items. Paragraph (f) deals with a ship or aircraft. Are they deemed to be either wasting assets or tangible movable property? Paragraph (h) provides that patents and so forth are situate where they are registered. The Minister will probably agree that rights in regard to trade marks are frequently exercisable not only in the State but outside it, at the very least in Northern Ireland and sometimes further afield.

In that situation what is the position that will arise where it is exercisable in practice both in the State and outside it, which would very often include many countries in western Europe? What is stated is that they are deemed to be located in the State but sometimes the right, while exercisable in the State, may be a minor part of what is really involved—the major part could be exercisable outside the State. Does that provide any problem in the matter of assessment of capital gains tax or losses—I do not mean in theory but in practice?

Comment on this

I hope I can deal with all the specific questions that have been asked. In regard to paragraps (b) I will take, for example, a picture. The location is, of course, the place in which the picture is located. On paragraph (h) I was asked why it is treated differently to paragraph (e) which states the position in regard to registered shares and securities, that they are situate where they are registered and if registered in more than one register, "where the principal register is situated".

The Deputy will appreciate that patents, trade marks and designs may be registered in a number of countries and have separate capital values in the different countries. Obviously, if a patent is registered here the right to use the patent or trade mark or design is limited to our jurisdiction or Northern Ireland or possibly some other area depending on the patent or trade mark laws of other countries. Whichever country, it has a sale value.

If the same patent or trade mark or design is registered elsewhere the fact of its registration elsewhere means there is a separate right to use it elsewhere. The mere fact that it is registered in Ireland does not mean that the person acquiring it in Ireland would acquire the trade mark, patent or design in some other jurisdiction. Each one has to be separately assessed. Though the patent may be a similar one, it is the right to use it that gives it the marketable value.

Comment on this

So that in theory it is one register here and in other countries for the purposes of the Act but we would be concerned only with the registration in Ireland and the value of that?

Comment on this

No. Paragraph (h) states:

patents, trade marks and designs are situated where they are registered, and if registered in more than one register, where each register is situated and copyright, franchises, rights and licences to use any copyright material, patent, trade mark or design are situated in the State if they, or any rights derived from them, are exercisable in the State, and

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): If one had a patent right in this country and opened a factory in America, or even joined with a company in America and were given a licence, is it something like that we are getting at? If one moved to America and registered there is that type of situation caught here?

Comment on this

That is a capital asset held abroad by a person resident in Ireland. He has a capital asset abroad, he is the owner of the right abroad. If I am resident in Ireland and I sell to somebody the right to use the patent——

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Under licence?

Comment on this

Yes, then I remain the owner of that in the other jurisdiction. Paragraph (f) refers to a ship or an aircraft. A ship presumably has a lifespan of less than 50 years.

Comment on this

An aircraft, I hope, would but I am not so sure about a ship.

Comment on this

Perhaps not, but ships are invariably used as plant and machinery of a business and so would be dealt with in that way. Of course one might have a luxury yacht which would not be plant or machinery used for the purpose of a trade. I am not at all certain how a yacht could be treated but you would have to look at each case to see the purpose for which the object was being used.

Comment on this

Presumably it would be a tangible movable asset, not necessarily a wasting asset.

Comment on this

The same can be said, I suppose, for a train, if I am disposed to buy one; it is a tangible movable asset, but invariably it is regarded as plant and machinery.

Comment on this

This section gives us again the type of problem I can foresee growing up on this. Here we start a section with the words: "except as otherwise provided in section 4". I go to section 4 and I read that its provisions are "subject to any exceptions in this Act". So which is which?

Comment on this

Subsections (6) and (7) which deal with gains accruing on the disposal of exploration or exploration rights are the subsections which are relevant to section 48.

Comment on this

Subsection (7) refers to "gains accruing to a person who is neither resident nor ordinarily resident in the State on the disposal of such assets . . . " I shall follow the Minister's train of thought in a moment, I want to raise the relevancy of subsection (1) of section 4 which reads:

Subject to any exceptions in this Act, a person shall be chargeable to capital gains tax in respect of chargeable gains accruing to him in a year of assessment for which he is resident or ordinarily resident in the State.

I do not want to be carping about this, but this is one of the traps, that you make two provisions mutually subject to each other; and if you do so, what is the consequence? The Minister would be quite right if there was no relevancy in this, but I want to show that there is. Do not let us get lost as to whether it is a subsection or not. That gets into another area of interpretation. We shall have to bring all the canons of interpretation down here before we finish this Bill.

In section 4 you read: "Subject to any exceptions in this Act" and then you read in this section: "except as otherwise provided by section 4". Naturally one asks oneself which is the cart and which is the horse. However, subsection (2) goes on to say: "subject to any such exceptions". Therefore, the exceptions in subsection (1) of section 4 are carried on into and qualify subsection (2). In subsection (2) there are three paragraphs (a), (b) and (c). Quite clearly paragraph (a) relating to land in the State, raises no problem; paragraph (b) in relation to minerals in the State, in so far as they are tangible assets, raise no problems, that is the minerals themselves, but paragraph (b) in toto reads:

Minerals in the State or any rights, interests or other assets in relation to mining or minerals or the searching for minerals;

Consider the wording there: "Minerals in the State or any rights, interests or other assets". I shall not delay the Minister by giving the reference to all the sections, including the section defining assets, as I have done already, section 7 and so forth. Come to section 48, the section we are discussing. It excepts as otherwise provided in section 4, and presumably excepts as provided in subsection (2) of section 4. If it excepts as provided in subsection (2) of section 4, then what difficulties can arise on paragraph (e) of section 48 and, indeed, (d), because I am thinking of the rights of oil exploration. Incidentally, even in the section itself, subsection (8) (b) says:

"designated area" has the meaning assigned to it by section 1 of the Continental Shelf Act, 1968.

Therefore, clearly, in contemplation of the drafting of this Bill the oil in the Continental Shelf and in our coastal waters comes within the purview of this legislation.

To continue my point, here you will have the tangible asset situate under the provisions of paragraph (a) or (b), that is, the actual mineral or oil, but associated with this in that very complex financial structure and all the coming and going with leases, options, contracts and so on, these interests— I am using the word for short—may come into the category of registered shares or securities. In that case what rules? In other words, I am posing to the Minister the question of taking paragraph (b) of subsection (2) of section 4, on the one hand, and paragraph (e) and possibly (d) of section 48, on the other hand. Is there a latent possibility of contradiction and complication here? I might go to refer to paragraph (g) which reads:

The situation of goodwill as a trade, business or professional asset is at the place where the trade, business or profession is carried on.

Fundamentally, what the Minister is up against is that intentionally section 4 is dealing with the person; section 48 is primarily intended to deal with the asset. That is where the dilemma arises. Section 44 is intended to determine the location or situation of the person and section 48 deals with the location of the individual. Section 48 attempts to prescribe, I use the word "prescribe" although it is not exactly a precise definition. The difficulties are portrayed by the words used in the following provision. Normally, if you meant this to be positive legislation you would say "shall be" but the difficulties are disclosed and the cat is let out of the bag by the phrase "be determined in accordance with the following provisions" instead of the definite "shall be". I appreciate the reasons for that. Yet, it is legislation and "be determined" will be given some measure of mandatory sanction. When a court comes to these paragraphs and compares them with the clearly mandatory provisions of section 4, conflict could arise. It is significant that the wording in section 4 is "shall be". Such a possible conflict could be the most fruitful cause of extensive legislation for the State. You are now in an area where very big interests are involved and I should like to warn the Minister— when I say "warn" I mean——

Comment on this

Alert.

Comment on this