Capital Gains Tax Bill, 1974: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 199–398 of 398. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 42 of 1974 ›
That is the word I want. I want to keep this discussion on a friendly plane and I hope, despite the time we are taking that we are helping the Minister a little. The primary purpose of this legislation would be construed as taxation but legislation as a whole often has to be looked to in the courts. Here, you are entering an area—I have mentioned oil specifically—where very big interests may be involved from the point of view of the Minister's colleague in another Department and the Government as a whole in dealing with what promises to be one of the greatest preoccupations of our Government's for the foreseeable time. There is that factor on the one hand and the challenging of the legislation on the other which might well involve the State in very great legal and administrative expense not only here but in other jurisdictions. Therefore, the greatest care and attention should be given to possibilities arising from uncertainties of the kind I have mentioned.
I should like to make my point more specifically. Subsection (2) of section 4 says:
Subject to any such exceptions, a person who is neither resident nor ordinarily resident in the State shall be chargeable to capital gains tax for a year of assessment in respect of chargeable gains accruing to him in that years on the disposal of——
That deals with the person. Subsections (d) and (e) locate the very interests that are special there.
What I am really saying to the Minister is that I should like to alert him to the possible dangers of defining the location of the interest or the asset on the one hand and legislating accordingly, and defining the location of the persons chargeable in respect of this asset on the other hand.
To pursue the point more closely I would have to put myself in a hypothetical case—which I do not want to do—and then examine the Bill as if it were law from the point of view of counsel seeking to advise a client on a particular aspect which the client raises. The difficulties I fear can arise in two ways, either when a substantial client consults his lawyers and counsel approaches this Bill to advise him, or the State itself is involved in negotiations which require that the State's legal advisers look into the matter in much the same way. When that arises it is a very different situation from that in which we approach a Bill here. When somebody approaches it in a case like that he has a fixed viewpoint. Our difficulty always in regard to legislation is that we do not have a uniform point of view. That is why we were adumbrating principles on the previous section. In most legislation, especially when considerations of anti-avoidance or anything like this arises we do not keep a uniform point of view. But the lawyer who will attack this in the way I have suggested will have a uniform point of view with the result that he will take the whole Act on the point that is mentioned and finecomb it. The Minister who is a lawyer and Deputy Colley who is a lawyer and all of us who deal with the law will appreciate that when one gets something like the contradiction that is between section 4 and section 48 that I have mentioned, it is a very fruitful beginning.
I have expanded on this because I fear it may involve very big interests; even the State itself may be involved and the State would be involved in either case because of the costs of legal actions, either in our jurisdiction or elsewhere, and this is the type of thing that could arise in other jurisdictions. I have given the case of oil and the net point is the attempt to define location of the person chargeable and location of the asset and then the total exception in section 48 and section 4.
For these reasons, I would most urgently and co-operatively press the point on the Minister, and not in the spirit which we may sometimes find here. I really do urge on the Minister to consider whether, if he is in a real dilemma about this, section 48 is necessary at all. It seems to be tidy and neat, but we cannot tell what the double effect of these two sections on the whole Act is. If this thought had occurred earlier, what one should do is take a hypothetical case—I do not want to be specific, to prompt anything—and then sit down as counsel would sit down and see how I can use two things to burst something somewhere else in the Act. That is what I want to alert the Minister to.
Comment on this
I am grateful to the Deputy for doing so. He may be assured that our objective is the same as his and we feel that it is very necessary to have section 48 because without it there would be considerable dispute as to the location of some of the assets. I cannot see that it is contradictory of section 4. What it does is to give the provisions of section 4 in relation to certain assets precedence over section 48, those assets being particularly offshore oil and gas and mineral deposits which are described as being exploration or exploitation rights in the designated area. They are caught very specifically relating to persons so as to ensure that any gain arising out of the disposal of them will be caught. The exceptions to which the Deputy referred in subsections (1) and (2) of section 4 refer of course to all the exceptions and exemptions which are in the Act.
Comment on this
Including the £500 a year, the £2,000 of tangible movable assets, the exemptions given to charities and all the other several exemptions in respect of Government securities.
Comment on this
It is either chargeable or not chargeable. If we say that a thing is not chargeable, it is an exception.
Comment on this
I accept everything the Minister says and I want to be helpful. I know that that is the intention and that that is what is said but what I am trying to say is, and I am talking purely legally now—I do hope there is no contradiction that could arise but "except as otherwise used"—"except" is the word used in section 48 and you do not define exceptions and exception is not only exception in regard to money. Exception can be construed as excepting provisions of the Act, so one has to be very careful as to the legal meaning of the two words. For instance, the Minister might have a point if he had "save otherwise as provided in section 4," but the very fact that he uses the word "except" in section 4 was what alerted me.
Comment on this
I can understand that argument. If others were confused in relation to the words, we might well put it in in case anybody relates the exception in section 48 to the exceptions which are referred to in section 4, but are not granted by section 4.
Comment on this
I will certainly have a look at it, but the Deputy will accept from me that section 4 does not provide the exceptions which are referred to in the first words of subsections (1) and (2) of section 4.
Comment on this
I do not want to try to suggest more than I have suggested. I only gave the case about oil to give substance to the point I was making——
Comment on this
It was to give substance to the point I was making and if the Minister does that, it goes some way, while it may not go the whole way, to answer the point.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 44, subsection (3) (a), lines 21 to 25, to delete subparagraph (ii) and to substitute the following paragraph:
"(ii) where bargains, other than bargains done at special prices, were recorded in that list for the relevant date, the price at which the bargains were so recorded, or if more than one such price was so recorded, a price halfway between the highest and the lowest of such prices,".
Subsection (3) (a) of section 49 sets out the method used to ascertain market value of quoted shares by reference to the official quotations on the stock exchange list. There are two sets of figures shown on the list, the price at which bargains were last recorded, known as the previous price, and where bargains were recorded on the relevant date, the bargain price. The object of the subsection is to allow the lower of these two values to be taken as it appears in the Bill. Paragraph (a) (ii) of the subsection involves a further calculation outside the bargain price and will take the mean of the bargain price and the previous price. This is a somewhat complex procedure and it is better to confine the calculations in paragraph (a) (ii), to bargain prices only. Thus the amendment will simplify the calculation and there will then be two values to be looked at, the previous price and the bargain price, taking the lower value.
The amendment to paragraph (b) (ii) brings the wording into line with that of paragraph (a) (ii). The same principle of calculation in relation to bargains will therefore apply to both the Irish and the London lists.
Comment on this
Effectively, what is the difference between what is provided in the amendment and what is in the Bill at present?
Comment on this
We are deleting the intervening price as it were, the calculation that was originally required by paragraph (a) (ii) and paragraph (b) (ii). Now we only have to look at the bargain price.
Comment on this
It is only in the amendment one has to look at the two prices and get a half way figure only where more than one price is recorded on the relevant date?
Comment on this
In most cases what would be required would be to get the price at the relevant date or else the previous price and whichever is the lower is the one that will operate?
Comment on this
It is purely a drafting matter but, while essentially the same as that, the balance of the substituted paragraph is different. The phrase "other than bargains at special prices" is at the end of the original and in the amendment it states "other than bargains done at special prices". I presume the interposition of the word "done" is purely meant as an improvement to drafting and that it has no substantive significance?
Comment on this
Since it is the Minister who has the responsibility I take it that he was fully advised.
Comment on this
I was consulted in relation to the amendment and I am satisfied those words do not make any significant difference.
Comment on this
I was curious at the intervention of the new word and the transposition of the clause.
Comment on this
Obviously bargains done at special prices or for special reasons might not reflect the open market value which is that which is determined by the willing seller and any willing buyer but special arrangements could be made for a variety of reasons to transfer shares other than what would be the open market price.
Comment on this
How does the Minister know if they are recorded because we are talking about quoted securities?
Comment on this
The Minister has informed me that this paragraph applies only in relation to shares or securities listed in the Stock Exchange Official List (Irish). A bargain done at special price can be a bargain recorded but do I take it that unrecorded bargains do not come into the reckoning at all?
Comment on this
That is true but the stock exchange from time to time records and identifies special bargains if prices are fixed by special bargains. They are identified if they are significant, though obviously small transactions are not.
Comment on this
Is the Minister going to tie all special bargains to that? I take it that special bargains would generally be accepted whether in the list or not?
Comment on this
I do not think so unless they are at the ordinary quoted price. If they are at a special price for whatever reason the Revenue Commissioners would have to satisfy themselves as to the market value, is that the position?
Comment on this
That is true. A bargain price may be fixed for a variety of reasons. It is difficult to determine them all. There could be rearrangements, reorganisations and mergers and matters of that nature for some reason or other might put a special price which would not reflect what strangers bargaining in the market might themselves pay but if they are recorded there is no trouble. If they are unrecorded there is no trouble either because they are not within anybody's knowledge.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42.
In page 44, subsection (3) (b), lines 37 to 40, to delete subparagraph (ii) and to insert the following subparagraph:
"(ii) where bargains, other than bargains done at special price were recorded in that list for the relevant date, the price at which the bargains were so recorded, or if more than one such price was so recorded, a price halfway between the highest and the lowest of such prices,".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 45, lines 17 to 22, to delete subsection (6).
The taxpayer has a right under paragraph 8 of Schedule 5 to appeal against an assessment to capital gains tax. The basis of valuation of assets would form a valid ground for an appeal, which would be determined in accordance with paragraph 8 of Schedule 5. Section 49 (6) also deals with claims under the Act and where a decision on a claim—not itself an appeal—is disputed by the taxpayer the application of section 432 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, as adapted by paragraph 2 of Schedule 5 to capital gains tax confers on the taxpayer a right of appeal against the decision. The appeal would be heard and determined in the same way as an appeal against an assessment. In view of this there is no need for subsection (6) of section 49 and, accordingly, it is being deleted.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say whether the effect of relying on paragraph 8 of Schedule 5 makes any difference either to the method or grounds of appeal which might be open to the taxpayer as distinct from what would be available under subsection (6)?
Comment on this
I take it there is no doubt that the appeal provided for in paragraph 8 of Schedule 5 would apply in cases envisaged by subsection (6)?
Comment on this
Why is the machinery envisaged in subsection (3) confined to the stock exchange here or in Britain and not extended to other stock exchanges?
Comment on this
In subsection (3) we are dealing with the two stock exchanges with which we are most familiar, the rules of which are well known. With regard to the value of shares that may be registered in other stock exchanges, there may be a variety of different ways of presenting those valuations and short of putting in a section to deal with every stock exchange in the world we could not provide for it in the legislation. In looking at the facts of particular cases, the Revenue Commissioners would tend to apply the disciplines and ideas that are used in our stock exchange, subject to whatever qualifications it might be proper to consider in relation to prices on other stock exchanges. The world is becoming more integrated and probably the differences are less than they would have been at another time but it was considered we could not deal adequately in this legislation with the variety of different arrangements, actions and assessments that operate elsewhere.
Comment on this
The Minister has said there may be different methods of valuation in other stock exchanges. Is he merely covering this contingency or is he or the Revenue Commissioners specifically aware of different methods of valuing stocks or shares on other exchanges?
Comment on this
It is not so much a question of valuation as the presentation of valuations and the record of figures. My information is that all stock exchanges do not record the prices and price movements in the same way as do the Irish stock exchange and the London stock exchange.
Comment on this
A further aspect of this matter will arise on a subsequent paragraph which I shall raise later.
Comment on this
The principle of market value has been accepted and it is probably the fairest one for this legislation. Subsection (2) states:
In estimating the market value of any assets no reduction shall be made in the estimate on account of the estimate being made on the assumption that the whole of the assets is to be placed on the market at one and the same time.
I question the necessity of that provision quite apart from wondering about its equity. I am in some difficulty here as I do not want to depart from discussing this Bill. There is a certain homogeneity about this capital legislation. For instance, the market value of a property in a block and the value of that piece of property could be different—first, if it was a simple disposal in its own right and, secondly, if it was a disposal as part of a block. That type of situation arises frequently in this city. I am not saying whether this acts in favour or against the State or an individual but I am pointing out there is a real question of estimating the value of this subsection.
Before Deputy Belton came into the House I mentioned the question of a property in the middle of a block that might become available for development. The purchase of the block could make a big difference to the market value of the property. The same thing could happen with regard to a block of shares. For the moment I am not considering subsection (3) and what follows because I do not wish to be sidetracked from my main point by an extraneous consideration.
In principle, the market value of a block of shares might be very different from the actual value of the shares. For instance, if a block of shares gave virtual control of a substantial interest, a purchaser might be prepared to pay substantially more for the block than the quoted market value of the shares taken individually. Conversely, a person might have a large holding he wanted to get rid of and the fact that he had a purchaser on the spot might prompt him to sell the holding at a smaller price.
I am asking the Minister whether subsection (2) is necessary or desirable. By referring to market value, are we not giving discretion to the Revenue Commissioners who, in turn, fall back on the Valuation Office? We are tying the hands of the Revenue Commissioners with such a provision. I may appear to be too trusting in my attitude but I think I am right to ask why insert a subsection which is not necessary. Are there any loopholes it is designed to block? As an ordinary citizen I would be happy to leave it to the discretion of the Revenue Commissioners to decide in any transaction whether there had been an appreciation or depreciation of value because the asset was or was not part of a larger deal. The Revenue Commissioners would be well able to cope with such a matter without having to look at a section that can put them in difficulty because it removes elasticity.
Though sometimes so regarded, the Revenue Commissioners are not a lot of ogres. People talk about oppression but I have known cases, and so have many other taxpayers, where the inspector was anxious to find an answer in an equitable case but was tied by the provisions of the Act. Do not let us get this complex that the Revenue Commissioners are always grinding the faces of the poor, so to speak. Very often they work the other way. The important thing is the system has worked fairly and equitably and in all my time here I have never heard any really serious complaint levied against the Revenue Commissioners; any complaint there has been against the provisions under which they operate. I would urge the Minister to consider seriously whether subsection (2) is appropriate at all.
Comment on this
The subsection really means that the value to be placed on an asset is that value which would be obtained if a normal transaction, subject to normal conditions and so on, were to take place and it eliminates any abnormal fluctuations in price which might occur if the market were flooded with a vast quantity of similar assets at some particular time resulting in an unusually low price. Deputy de Valera asks is it necessary to have the subsection there at all. I think he has in mind to say that is the kind of reasonable rule reasonable people would assume. One would take a normal price in a normal transaction in normal conditions, and not any abnormal fluctuation, as an estimation of the true value of property.
Comment on this
At least we know what we are talking about, but I understood Deputy de Valera to query whether it is required at all.
Comment on this
He assumes that the particular rule here is such a reasonable one he could not visualise any valuation other than a reasonable valuation arising out of normal circumstances being taken as the only true valuation. One could have a situation in which people would argue that a price related to a flooded market price rather than to the appropriate one and that would be a wrong assessment and a wrong valuation to make.
Comment on this
I do not quite understand what the Minister means by a flooded market under subsection (2). I purposely said "Forget subsection (3) which brings in shares". There are two points. First, what does the Minister mean by abnormal? He talked about flooded markets. Are fluctuations in the property market normal? Keep to the case I mentioned—the sale of a house or small business premises in a larger block where there is a possibility of development. Quite clearly the price of that particular house will vary according to whether it is going as part of the acquisition of the block or otherwise—to perpetrate a pun, whether it is going with the block or whether it is blocking the block.
There is a case. It is abnormal. Why does the Minister have to legislate for it? Would not the true market value be the circumstances? A small business in a large block can determine the value of the rest of the block. The price that will be given for it will depend on whether the sale is such as to facilitate the acquisition of the block by a developer or whether the acquisition will be a hindrance to the acquisition of the block. Surely that is a market factor and surely it is a factor for which one cannot legislate. In the last analysis, surely the proper value is the price in the open market, if market value means anything. We are talking here about market value. Surely the true test of market value is the actual value in the open market. By the way, a great deal of what I am saying here is in favour of the Revenue and not the reverse. We only have recourse to valuations and other standards of measurement when we do not have the direct test. The property has not come, so to speak, on the open market. That is one case, normal or abnormal.
There is then another case for the Minister to consider. I would be only too happy in the case I have given to leave things to the Revenue Commissioners because they would be able to ask the appropriate question: is this a fiddle or a straightforward deal? If it is a straightforward deal and a genuine market transaction, why does the Minister want to put in something in contradiction of subsection (1), because that is what he is doing here? Subsection (2) will prevent the implementation of subsection (1).
I will give another example. The Minister talked about a flooded market. I can understand the Minister's point but markets become automatically flooded due to economic conditions. Consider what happened to house property some 12 months or so ago. Property was climbing out of all proportion in value on the open market. Property was soaring. Suddenly that stopped and there was a decline. Was the upward spiral the opposite of flooding? Remember, flooding can be positive or negative. I would like to test this. I can think of a house in the suburbs of Dublin that a few years ago went for £7,000 and was sold very recently for £13,000. That is not flooding. Supposing the Government succeed in their avowed objective of providing housing and accommodation and the market value of houses slumps, is that flooding? No.
I am making these points, as on other sections, purely by way of illustration to show that there is substance in them. I believe that the Revenue Commissioners are perfectly capable of implementing subsection (1) through their staff, their assessors, inspectors and so on. The true market value is the test. Subsection (2) can be a contradiction of subsection (1). If the Minister will not accede to my plea to delete that subsection, I would like him to give us some concrete reason as to why he feels the Revenue Commissioners need subsection (2) to implement the Bill because I fail to see that they need it. In fact, I think it will impede them.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) is not directed primarily to land or house property but is also directed to stocks and shares. This illustration might help to indicate what we have in mind: you could have a person with, say, £2 million worth of stock in a particular concern. The normal transaction in the market in relation to that company might be £5,000 to £10,000, even £50,000 a day. With such a pattern, obviously, the price would remain fairly stable but if the whole £2 million were to be put on the market in one day the price would come tumbling down. The number of persons seeking a particular stock at any given time dictates what the pattern will be. Obviously, if there was a sudden flooding of the market with a particular asset, the demand might be normal but if the market was flooded, obviously the price would come down.
What we are saying is that if an estimate has to be made of the market value the estimate must be based on what would be the normal price, not the price if the whole £2 million worth were put on the market in one day. If the owner of the shares were disposing of them for a consideration other than cash one would have to assess their value. The value would be determined, not on the assumption that £2 million was going on the market in one day but on the basis of the normal price of those shares. If it is £X, then two million times £X is the appropriate figure and not, as it might be argued if we had not got the subsection, by the owner of the shares: "If I put the £2 million on the market the value of the shares would be £X minus £Y and that is the figure that we should estimate this at and not the other."
Deputy de Valera might say that it would be unreasonable to argue in that way, and that, therefore, section 49 subsection (1) is sufficient because that says that it is the value which those assets might reasonably be expected to fetch on sale in the open market. The trouble is, what are those assets? Are these assets the £2 million worth of stock or are they the amount which assets of that type if sold in normal quantities might be expected to fetch on the open market? You would certainly have to amend section 49 subsection (1) in order to deal with the situation which I have indicated.
Let me come back to house property that the Deputy was talking of. Of course, if the place is sold on the open market that value would normally be accepted without further ado. It is not common for people to sell land or house property on the open market in a contrived situation. It can happen, I know.
Comment on this
The amounts involved are so massive that it is improbable but it is certainly possible. One would not say that because house property was obtaining a low price because of an economic recession that was not the appropriate market price, that it should be a price related to times when things were better. The person who is putting house property on the open market seldom contrives to create the economic situation which might result in either boom or depression in demand.
What we are dealing with primarily in subsection (2) is that situation in which it could be argued that a person disposing of a very substantial block of assets would by disposing of them on one day receive a smaller price for those assets than would be normal if they were sold piecemeal.
Comment on this
On this question of subsection (2), first of all, it should be noted that it provides only for there being no reduction in an estimate in the circumstances envisaged. It does not say: "nor increase in an estimate". It is only dealing with the possibility of the estimate being reduced on the assumption that the whole of the assets are placed on the market.
Secondly, in general the kind of situation in which this can arise is only where one portion of assets is sold and it is necessary to apportion as between the whole and the part sold and, therefore, one has to estimate the value of all the assets.
I had a suspicion when I read this, and that suspicion has been confirmed very strongly by what the Minister has said, that, basically, this subsection is designed to prevent avoidance in terms of stocks and shares. There is a theoretical case but in practice I cannot find it easy to envisage any other kind of assets where the market could be flooded if one put all of them on the market. It is theoretically possible but in practice stocks and shares are what this is concerned with. If that is so, a specific reference to stocks and shares and confining it to that would probably make this more acceptable and more workable. I am not sure that anything would be lost if that were done. I do not know if Deputy de Valera would agree with me in that approach, whether he might still think it necessary to have subsection (2). It strikes me that in practice stocks and shares are involved here and to confine it to that would make it far more intelligible and acceptable.
Comment on this
There might, of course, be rights in commodities, or something of that nature. Obviously, there is a lot in what Deputy Colley says and, indeed, what I say. I could not visualise many assets other than stocks and shares to which subsection (2) would apply. I have no doubt that many ingenious people would be able to contrive new situations to avoid paying tax if we did not deal with it in the way it is at the moment.
It may be of some interest to Deputies to know that a similar provision has existed in estate duty law since 1910. The legislators were probably simpler people in those days. Yet they had to get around to making some such provision. I am not aware that it has caused any difficulty.
Comment on this
The Minister will recollect that when I started on this section I specifically excluded consideration of subsection (3) onwards because I knew the point which has developed would arise on it. I am glad to have the opportunity of showing that I am willing to go with the Minister some of the way if he can convince me. As Deputy Colley says, this subsection is more appropriate in relation to subsection (3) and could be included in it or after it but that does not quite meet the point I am making here. I still believe it would be better to give discretion to the Revenue Commissioners but I am a little perturbed about what the Minister said as to what policy might be adopted in regard to it.
Before I suggest a compromise I should like to emphasise the importance of subsection (1). I should like to think that the Revenue authorities would approach any transaction in the spirit of the fair and genuine market price at the time. I agree that in relation to stocks and shares a very real problem arises. In relation to stocks and shares, I should like to have included in the appropriate place that no reduction shall be allowed other than at the discretion of the Revenue Commissioners. If you feel something positive has to be done, it should be still left discretionary.
I should like an undertaking given that the whole thing would be administered genuinely in the spirit of subsection (1) and that the genuine market value, whether it is property, shares or anything else, would be the ruling factor. If such a device as the artificial flooding of the market were attempted to be used to defeat subsection (1), I would gladly give the Revenue Commissioners the right to disallow a reduction.
Deputy Colley cannot imagine a case outside stocks and shares arising. The first line of the subsection states: "In estimating the market value of any assets . . . " Take the shop in the block that I have been talking about, which could be developed. The value of that business cannot be arrived at, short of an actual sale, without taking the value of the block, the other assets, into consideration. For valuation purposes it is a question of what are the assets. The word "assets" used in the subsection is really used to apply to two different things at the one time, the particular thing that is being valued and the assets around it which determine the valuation. A valuer will look at this and say that the shop is worth so much if sold by itself. In order to determine what the market value would be the whole block would have to be considered.
Comment on this
I believe I am right in saying that under the subsection the question of the whole block can only come into it if it is owned by the same person.
Comment on this
No. I am talking about estimating the market value. This is not the charging of an asset. This is how the valuation is done.
Comment on this
The assets of somebody else are what will determine the market value of the assets in question. The market value is determined by the value of surrounding assets. The word "assets" can be used in the double sense.
Comment on this
I agree that only the assets are involved but the circumstances are there. Subsection (2) states:
In estimating the market value of any assets no reduction shall be made in the estimate on account of the estimate being made on the assumption that the whole of the assets is to be placed on the market at one and the same time.
In order to reach the value of the assets in question you have to know the value of the surrounding assets. It is a question of how you estimate the value. It could be construed that you could not value the block or the environment except by reference to whether that block went as a whole or whether it was sold in pieces like the premises. That is the point.
It is not a question of the chargeability. It is at the base of the valuation. Although the point may be strained to some extent, the fact is that in a case like this, it would be better to have discretion. Therefore, I suggest to the Minister that he should put the subsection lower down and if possible qualify it. The qualification I would like to see in it would be a discretionary one.
Subsection (2) provides that in estimating the market value of any assets no reduction shall be made in the estimate on account of the estimate being made on the assumption that the whole of the assets is to be placed on the market at one and the same time. The value of my shop depends completely on the value of the block. The value of the block depends on whether it is put on the market in part or as a block. With a bit of ingenuity the subsection could be used unfairly to defeat subsection (1). I would ask the Minister to rephrase it in such a way that the Revenue Commissioners will have power but it will not be mandatory on them to exercise that power.
Comment on this
I cannot give the Deputy an assurance that I will seriously contemplate a change in this because if I did it might minimise the assurances I have given about giving serious consideration to other amendments which I may make. I am impressed by the fact that this has stood the test of 65 years without any significant complaint so far as I am aware.
Comment on this
I am also satisfied that there is clarity and that the taxpayers will know where they stand if the subsection remains as it is. The worst that can be said about it is that it might work to the disadvantage of the taxpayer. I do not think that is so. We are not dealing here with cases of actual sales. If actual sales take place, there is no problem.
Comment on this
There could be an actual sale of part of the assets and then one has to determine the apportionment between the part and the whole.
Comment on this
That is true but if the part sold were sold in a normal transaction it would probably be taken as the sale price without further ado. We are dealing primarily with situations in which no sale would take place. There would be no immediate ready reckoner to assist in establishing what the value would be. We simply eliminate from any calculation any disposal of an unusual quantity of assets. On that account I think it ought to stand the way it is.
Comment on this
I will not press the Minister further on the matter but it is no harm that we debated it.
Comment on this
There are some other points I should like to raise on the section. I have referred to the British stock exchange. Subsection (3) refers to " . . . in consequence of special circumstances . . . ". Is what is envisaged in that phrase the same as the reference further down to bargains at special prices?
Comment on this
Line 14 on page 44. The phrase is " . . . in consequence of special circumstances . . . ." Is what is envisaged in that phrase the same thing as is referred to further on as "bargains at special prices" or is something more than that envisaged?
Comment on this
Could I refer the Minister to paragraphs (a) (i) and (b) (i). Paragraph (a) deals with the valuation of shares or securities listed in the stock exchange official list, Irish. In effect, paragraph (b) refers to the stock exchange list in Britain. A different method of valuation is prescribed in the case of those on the Irish list and those on the British list as illustrated in subparagraph (i). In the case of the Irish ones it is the price shown in that list at which bargains in the shares or securities were last recorded and, in the case of the British stock exchange, it is the lower of the two prices shown in the quotations for the shares of securities on the relevant date plus one-quarter of the difference between those two figures. Could the Minister tell us why there is a difference in approach between the two?
Comment on this
There are differences in the manner in which prices are fixed on the Irish stock exchange, and the stock exchange in Britain. Therefore, it is necessary to provide rules for valuing shares and securities listed in the Irish official list as well as those quoted on the stock exchange daily official list which is how the list is known in Britain. For shares or securities shown on the Irish list the valuation to be taken is the price at which bargains were last recorded. Where shares or securities are listed on both lists on the same date, provision is made for taking the lower relevant valuation. Does that answer the Deputies question?
Comment on this
I do not think it does. I think I know the reason for it but it might be as well if we could get it on the record. I think what the Minister was referring to was a subsequent provision in the Bill and also the amendment which only amends subparagraph (ii) in each case. I was referring to the difference in paragraph (a) (i) and paragraph (b) (i). In the case of paragraph (a) which deals with the valuation of securities listed on the Irish stock exchange, in the circumstances envisaged what is provided is that one takes the price shown in the list at which bargains in the shares or securities were last recorded. When one is dealing with the securities quoted on the British stock exchange the corresponding provision is the lower of the two prices shown in the quotations for the shares or securities on the relevant date plus one quarter of the difference between the two figures.
Comment on this
On the Irish list only the previous price is shown. On the London list there are two quotations and that is why we have to use a different formula.
Comment on this
Yes, and it is because there are other quotations on other exchanges. We have not sought to spell out the rules to be applied if stocks are listed elsewhere.
Comment on this
Might I refer the Minister to the last part of paragraph (b) of subsection (3), line 41? It states:
taking the amount under subparagraph (i) if less than under subparagraph (ii) or if no such bargains were recorded for the relevant date, . . . .
If the Minister looks at paragraphs (i) and (ii) of subparagraph (b), he will find that both of them refer to "the relevant date". Therefore, how is it possible to take the amount under paragraph (i) of subparagraph (b) if no such bargain were recorded for the relevant date, considering that both paragraphs (i) and (ii) depend on the relevant date?
Comment on this
In subparagraph (i) it is the lower of the two prices shown. In subparagraph (ii) it is the highest and lowest prices at which oargains were recorded.
Comment on this
Whereas the portion to which I referred refers to the manner in which one values if there is no bargain recorded for the relevant date, but the manner prescribed to do that depends on a quotation on the relevant date.
Comment on this
Even if there were no bargain on a particular day there would still be quotations shown on the list.
Comment on this
As far as I can see, the previous quotation arises only in the case of the Irish list. We are dealing with subparagraph (b) which, for convenience, I shall call the British list. There is no provision there for previous quotation.
Comment on this
Nevertheless, there would be prices shown, if there were no bargains on the day in question and they would be the prices of the last transactions. Perhaps we ought to go down to the stock exchange and have a "teach-in".
Comment on this
Yes, but I think it is answered by what I am saying, that is that the prices are shown even if transactions did not take place on the relevant date.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that the procedure, say, on the London stock exchange is to show a price for all shares or securities quoted on every day whether or not there is a bargain struck, whereas that is not the practice on the Irish stock exchange?
Comment on this
Because if that is not so, I do not think what the Minister is saying stands up. Anyway, it is not something on which we need spend a great deal of time now. I want to draw the Minister's attention to what, on the face of it, appears to be a somewhat impossible provision, but it may be that it is possible.
Comment on this
The Deputy may be assured that we processed this through our stock exchange advisers but I will bring the Deputy's observations to their attention to ensure that we have the proper jargon to deal with the situation before the Bill goes through in final form.
Comment on this
Further on in subparagraph (3) there is said:
Provided that—
and then there are listed paragraphs (a), (b) and (c). In paragraph (b), line 51, there is reference to a more active market. The provision reads:
(b) this subsection shall not apply to shares or securities for which some other stock exchange affords a more active market;
What I would like to know in this regard is, first, how is it proposed to ascertain that another stock exchange provides a more active market? Secondly, having ascertained it— assuming it is a stock exchange in X somewhere in Europe or in America —how will the securities be valued on the basis of the quotations there?
Comment on this
These provisions are similar to the practice followed for estate duty purposes. If some other stock exchange affords a more active market for the shares or the securities in question, the valuation will be based on the quotations in that stock exchange. If any of the stock exchanges concerned is closed on the relevant date, the market value is to be based on the lower of either the latest previous figure or the earliest subsequent figure on which the stock exchange is open.
Comment on this
Yes, whichever is the lower. Mining shares come quickly to mind as an example of shares which might be more actively traded in stock exchanges other than the London exchange. The Revenue Commissioners, if they felt that the London price was not the most appropriate one, would raise the question of the price in another exchange. Indeed the taxpayer initially might offer the price on another exchange and there might be no dispute about it. If, of course, there is a dispute and the taxpayer feels disadvantaged by the quotation from the more active exchange, then the matter would go to appeal for decision.
Comment on this
That is really what I wanted to know. Once it is determined that the other is the more active exchange, then the valuation is arrived at on the basis outlined by the Minister?
Comment on this
The Minister will note that subsection (5) deals with the ascertainment of the market value in relation to unit trusts. At the end of subsection (5) there is a provision reading:
. . . shall mean an amount equal to the buying price (that is the lower price) so published on the relevant date, or if none were published on that date, on the latest date before.
But in paragraph (c) of the proviso to subsection (3), there is a somewhat similar provision in relation to securities on the stock exchange which continues to say:
whichever affords the lower market value.
That does not appear to be provided in subsection (5) and I am wondering if it is a deliberate omission.
Comment on this
The stock exchange price is one which is determined by the forces of the market between two parties deemed to be at arms length. But the unit trust situation is not one in which the price is determined by the inputs of two different persons, one selling and one buying. The price is that which is fixed by the managers of the trust who are inviting, as it were, people to tender at that price.
Comment on this
Yes, but what practical effect does that have? I am thinking of this from the point of view of the taxpayer who, in the case of stocks and shares, can opt, in effect, for whichever of the market values is the lower. He cannot do that in the case of the unit trust quotation. Does the reason the Minister has advanced have relevance from the point of view of the taxpayer who wants, say, to rely on the lower valuation that would have been open to him were this provision the same as in the case of the stock exchange?
Comment on this
The stock exchange gives a very active, regular and independent assessment of valuations. The same cannot be said for unit trusts which are more limited. The buying and selling prices are determined by the managers of the trusts, not by the market forces. One cannot assume that one gets the price which is as closely related to the market value as that which operates in respect of the stock exchange.
Comment on this
Yes, but there is not the same dynamism in respect of unit trusts calculations as there is on the stock exchange.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The explanatory memorandum states that managers must publish the buying price.
Comment on this
The taxpayer seems to have less choice if he has a unit trust holding than if he has a stock exchange holding. However, if the Minister is satisfied that it is necessary so to provide, I will not pursue the matter further. I merely wished to draw attention to the omission in that subsection.
The first line of subsection (7) reads: "If and so far as any such appeal . . . "
We have deleted subsection (6) which provided an appeal, therefore, at least the word "such" should be omitted. I am not sure if any other redrafting would be necessary.
Comment on this
The Chair must point out that we cannot retrace our steps. That amendment will have to be left until Report Stage.
Comment on this
On principle, could I suggest that if the House agrees, this can be done? I think that is a general principle which can be stood over.
Comment on this
I want to clear this point. This is against Standing Orders.
Comment on this
We cannot go back once we have started to deal with the section, as amended. It is clear, therefore, that this amendment can only be made on Report Stage.
Comment on this
It is now being said that no section, even though not disposed of, can be amended because we have disposed of the amendments put down. In other words, there cannot be amendments on this stage, even by agreement of the House. That is a new proposition as far as I am concerned.
Comment on this
I am advised that the question is: "That the section, as amended, stand part of the Bill." This rules out amendments at this point.
Comment on this
I will not waste the time of the House arguing this point but, while I accept the ruling of the Chair and am prepared to go ahead on the basis that it will be amended on Report Stage, I am not to be taken as accepting the proposition that this House cannot, if it wishes, amend a section in Committee across the floor. Could the Minister indicate the effect of subsection (8) and give an example of what might be involved?
Comment on this
This subsection ensures that in arriving at the market value in the case of a foreign security coming within the exchange control regulations made under the Exchange Control Act, 1954, allowance is to be given for the part of the premium over the official rate of exchange which, because of the regulations, the owner of the securities would lose on a sale. I will now give an example. If a New York stock exchange sale realises $1,000, the premium would be $150. The resaleable value would be $850. This resale-would be taken instead of $1,000, because that would be the resaleable value.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): That gives the Minister the right to adjust taxes upwards any time he wishes.
Comment on this
Would the Minister have the terms of section (1) of the Provisional Collection of Tax Act, 1927, handy?
Comment on this
Subsection (1) means that capital gains tax will be one of the taxes which, to be changed, would require a financial resolution of Dáil Éireann. Subsection (2) places on the Revenue Commissioners the same responsibilities to account for capital gains tax as already lies on them in respect of other inland revenue duties. The section is necessary because capital gains tax is a new tax being introduced for the first time. As the House is aware, similar provisions already exist in respect of value-added tax by virtue of section 28 of the Value-Added Tax Act, 1972. The Provisional Collection of Taxes Act, 1927, section 1, contains a list of definitions and states that the word "tax" includes duties of customs, duties of excise, income tax and super-tax but no other tax or duty. VAT has already been added to that list, so has turnover tax and to these will be added the capital gains tax.
Comment on this
Rightly so, I think, and for that reason inheritance tax and gift tax should not go into it. I do not know about wealth tax. The Minister said the effect of subsection (2) is to give the Revenue Commissioners power to collect the tax.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): There is a section which proposes to increase the interest rates on arrears. Does that apply in this Bill as in the Finance Act? I think the figure is 18 per cent.
Comment on this
I take it that gains which have arisen up to now in respect of which no payment could have been made until the Bill has been passed would not fall for interest?
Comment on this
The liability arises after assessment and assessment cannot be made until the Bill becomes law.
Comment on this
Speaking from memory, there is a provision in the Wealth Tax Bill that whether you are assessed or not you have to pay within three months of 5th April, 1975, as that Bill stands. I assume the Minister will be amending that.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Interest is applied when arrears have been outstanding for three months——
Comment on this
The Minister will be aware that under existing death duty legislation if a return is not made the assessment of duty cannot be made until the return is received by the commissioners in the normal way. If they were aware of it they might be able to make an assessment of their own, but normally speaking they cannot make an assessment until they get an Inland Revenue affidavit from the executors. Notwithstanding that, the interest there is charged by reference to the date of death—on the value of realty from 12 months after the date and on the net value of the personalty, from four months after the date of death, irrespective of the time of assessment. I imply from what the Minister has said that it will be otherwise here and I wonder if that is wise. If a return is not made to enable an assessment to be made, as far as future gains are concerned it would seem one can avoid the payment simply by not making a return. I do not think this should apply to gains that were made before the passing of the Act because nobody could make a return at that time. I am thinking about future gains and drawing a contrast with the existing situation in death duty legislation.
Comment on this
It is so long since I dealt with the relevant section that I am not in a position quickly to answer the questions, but I will try to answer it before the discussion ends. In relation to a capital gain, there is no question of charging interest on it until after the passing of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43a:
In subsection (1), page 45, line 42, to delete "Schedule 4 (specified securities)".
The purpose of this amendment is simply to delete the Fourth Schedule, which is the one containing a long list of exempted stocks and shares, Government securities. We have incorporated the stocks in question in the Bill itself.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) presumably is necessary in order to give the force of law to the Schedules but I am not clear as to what is the effect of subsection (2).
Comment on this
It provides that the technical provisions of Schedules 1, 2 and 3 and the provisions of the Bill fixing the amount of consideration deemed to be given on the disposal or acquisition of an asset are to be treated as having effect before 6th April, 1974, where it is necessary to compute a chargeable gain by reference to events and circumstances before that date.
The subsection, for example, would apply where under paragraph 18 of Schedule 1 a chargeable gain on the disposal of an asset acquired before April 6th, 1974, is computed by apportionment of the gain over the whole period of ownership. It would also apply where for the purpose of paragraph 16 of the same Schedule the amount of the whole gain on the disposal of a block of shares acquired before 6th April, 1974, is compared with the amount of the gain arising by taking the base cost as being equal to the market value of the shares on 6th April, 1974, in order to ascertain the lesser amount to be taken as the chargeable gain.
Comment on this
Why is that not achieved in subsection (1) which gives statutory effect to the various Schedules?
Comment on this
Without subsection (2) we cannot relate the Schedules to events before 6th April, 1974. Subsection (2) relates the Schedules to events prior to that date.
Comment on this
Do the Schedules themselves not deal with the situation arising before 6th April, 1974, and are they not given statutory force by subsection (1)?
Comment on this
This section of this Act is the one that applies the Schedules to events before 6th April, 1974, and we must have a section in the Bill itself which gives effect to the Schedules in relation to these events.
Comment on this
I did not, possibly, hear all the Minister said when he gave the meaning of subsection (2), but it seemed to me, from what I heard of it, to give rise to a problem that may perhaps have been dealt with earlier in the Bill but nonetheless would arise on this subsection in the light of what he said, that where it is necessary to go back before 6th April, 1974, to ascertain a capital gain as between the date of acquisition and the date of disposal, the amount that would be chargeable would be the proportion of the gain that would be deemed to have arisen since 6th April, 1974. Is that correct?
Comment on this
As a matter of principle, it seems to me that, in the light of the particular situation that has existed in this country since April, 1974, there may well be many assets which, over a long period since their original acquisition perhaps 20 years ago, have undoubtedly made a gain if they are being disposed of, say, at the present time, but no part of that gain would in reality be referable to the period subsequent to 6th April, 1974. Indeed, there may be many instances where the value of the asset would be much greater at or before 6th April, 1974, than it would be on the date of disposal. In those circumstances, since there is either no gain or a loss since 6th April, 1974, is it fair to charge capital gains tax on a proportion of the total gain since the date of original acquisition which might be as far back as, say, 1953 or 1954? I agree that the further back the date of acquisition the smaller the proportion of the gain that would be sought to be made referable to the period post-6th April, 1974, and therefore the amount cannot be very great proportionate to the value of the asset. Nonetheless, as a matter of equity and in recognition of the depressed state of so many markets in the past 12 months, if the taxpayer could show, as he probably could in a great many cases, that there was no capital gain on the assets between 6th April, 1974, and today, if he sold the asset today, he should not be liable for any capital gains tax, notwithstanding the fact that there may be a substantial capital gain between the date of original acquisition and the date of sale or disposal.
Comment on this
The taxpayer may, of course, elect to take the value as at 6th April, 1974, and if the taxpayer is able to establish that no gain has been made since then or can show a loss since then, then no doubt that would be the date he would take. Therefore, the option is there at the taxpayer's election as to which date he takes, that date or the original date.
Comment on this
That does not answer the question. The Schedules, to say the least of it, are complicated. Is it available in all cases where the taxpayer so opts?
Comment on this
In the case of an asset which was purchased before 6th April, 1974, say a year or two before that, at a round figure of £100 and which fell on the stock exchange to £60 at 1st April, 1974, and recovered in the last four or five months to £80 or £90, is it fair that a person who had to dispose of that asset should have to pay capital gains tax on the increase from 1st April, 1974, despite the fact that a much higher price was paid for the assets?
Comment on this
I think we are getting into details of the Schedules themselves. Might I respectfully suggest that if we get to the small print of the Schedules we shall be able to talk more precisely and relevantly?
Comment on this
While I agree with that, I would make one point before we come to the Schedules. Again we are back to an old problem. This is only one Act in a series of three at least, excluding the income tax and other provisions. The Minister is rather cleverly posing the problem for all taxpayers: the value you would like to put on it for the purpose of one Act at that date will be the opposite to the value you want to put on it for the purpose of the next Act. In other words, if you value anything for the purpose of capital gains on a base date, that value may be favourable from a point of view of this Act, but it may be most unfavourable from the point of view of another Act in the series. Am I right in that?
Comment on this
For, instance when it comes to death duties under the Acquisitions Tax Bill—as there will be death duties under that legislation— if you value upwards to minimise your gain, you are going to value to be caught on the disposal on death, and in the same way on the wealth tax. The implications of this section are really tied up with the other measures, and it is very difficult to discuss it. Am I right in that point?
Comment on this
If I have an asset and I want to sell it under this Act and I have to go back to find the proper valuation on the 6th April, 1974, or any other base date you care to take, I must have regard to the fact that I am also placing a value on that asset from the point of view of the other Acts. If I take the highest value I can get so as to minimise the capital gain, I am maximising my liability under the other two Acts. Is that the situation?
Comment on this
I like the way the Minister puts that, and he is right, but, unfortunately, in the words of the song, it is the poor that gets the blame, and it is the honest that will pay the tax anyway. It is the dishonest I am worried about.
I do not think we have really adequately considered the whole question of base valuation. This section raised the basis of valuation. On the previous section we spent a long time discussing market value but in our minds all the way through we were thinking of the value and discussing it mainly in relation to value at the date of disposal and gave very little thought to value by reference to the base date. Perhaps the Minister will say that this arises under the Schedule—possibly it will in detail as it arose elsewhere—but I should like the Minister to say what are the mechanics involved. How can one find the value of assets at a certain date? Already a year will have elapsed and two years will have elapsed before the case becomes really practicable under this Bill.
Deputy O'Malley has already mentioned the question of that date and dates anterior to it. How is it visualised that one will find the value of an asset at the base time? What evidence will be accepted of that value? These are matters vital and substantive to the Bill and I think it is on this section we should discuss them.
Comment on this
This is primarily a matter for the relevant Schedule and, with respect, it does not arise on section 51 except in so far as section 51 applies the whole Schedule but rather than have a general debate on the whole Schedule now, before we pass section 51, I suggest we leave over the detailed argument until we come to the Schedule itself. But, to reply briefly to the Deputy's question, the normal position in relation to valuations of property where valuation is on record, as it is on the stock exchange for instance, is to obtain a certificate of valuation from a reputable valuer. The Revenue Commissioners may or may not accept this. If it is not agreed there are negotiations and usually there is a settlement. If not, the matter must be determined elsewhere.
Having regard to the fact that we shall not have a flood of sudden disposals but we shall have people disposing of their property gradually over a period of years, we do not anticipate any particular difficulty in working this section. Historical valuations are not unusual especially in relation to estate duty where generations are involved sometimes and you may have to go back decades to get valuations, particularly of farm land, as it has been transferred from one generation to another. Obviously, the farther you go back usually the less relevance to current tax liability the historical valuation has.
Comment on this
Without going further into the content of the Schedule it seems that there is something unusual in this section at the end of a Bill. Surely when Schedules are referred to they have effect for the purposes of the Bill. Perhaps I am repeating something said by Deputy Colley when I was not present and if the Minister has answered this point, I do not wish to repeat it. Subsection (1) reads:
Schedule 1 (computation), Schedule 2 (companies and shareholders), Schedule 3 (leases), Schedule 4 (specified securities), Schedule 5 (administration) shall have effect for the purposes of this Act.
Of course they are in the Act for that purpose, not anything else, I presume. Therefore, why do you say "for the purposes of this Act"? If you were to say "for the purposes of this Act only" I could see the point. It would mean you wanted your definitions to be exclusive and not over-intrude into any other area. I could understand the Minister saying that Schedules, especially schedules such as those in this Bill where there is a good deal of substantive legislation, were confined to the purposes of the Bill. If they were not, such substantive enactments as are contained in them would normally be in the body of the legislation. I am fairly certain that in more than one place there is a substantive enactment here in the form of a definition or positive legislation for a contingency. I am puzzled as to why we must say "shall have effect for the purposes of this Act". That they are included at all and referred to in each section should be enough. Does the Minister intend that they shall have effect for the purposes of this Act only? Or is he merely ensuring that the substantive provisions in the Schedule are carried over into the Act? In the latter case I would make the point that both in the drafting and in the presentation of legislation that is no way to do business. We should have substantive legislation in the Bill itself and Schedules should be confined.
We have had legislation by order and by God-knows-what other means but if we are to have a new type of legislation by Schedule we are embarking on further legal confusion and becoming involved in further traps and dangers. Could the Minister tell me what is the purpose of inserting subsection (1) and could he specifically advert to what I have suggested that the purpose could be, that it was intended that the Schedules would be strictly confined to this Act and not be interpreted as general legislation such as the Act itself will be?
Comment on this
They cannot be related to any Act other than this but it is necessary to have this subsection in order to ensure that everything in the Schedules is applicable to this Bill. I agree that there are references to the Schedules from time to time and to particular parts of the Schedules but I would not like to guarantee that everything in the Schedules has already been brought in by reference in another section. This is a safety clause, as it were, to make sure that it is all applicable. It is normal and there are many other examples.
Comment on this
We will agree to the section, as amended, standing part, provided we are not precluded in any way from discussing the details of the various schedules referred to in it and applied by it. They are unusually complex, as the Chair will appreciate, running to 33 pages. Could I make the suggestion that some of them are so long, with ten or more pages, that we will get completely bogged down unless we can take them section by section? I appreciate that it is not normal to do this with a Schedule, but could we take each section of each Schedule separately? For example, Part I of Schedule I is so long and covers so many matters that we could not——