We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill 2011: Second Stage

Contributions 1–114 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 2011
Enacted

No. 8 of 2011 ›

Brian Lenihan Minister for Finance Fianna Fáil

I move: "That the Bill be read a Second Time."

In the first place——

Comment on this

I understood from his office that the Ceann Comhairle was to facilitate each party in the opening slots on Second Stage of the Finance Bill but that is not what he has just indicated.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As I indicated, speaking time will be given first to the Minister, Fine Gael and the Labour Party will have 30 minutes and the Green Party and the Deputy's party, Sinn Féin, will have 20 minutes on the first round.

Comment on this

That was not the understanding we had from our contacts with the Ceann Comhairle's office prior to the commencement of business today, which we accepted in good faith. There is a change to what was indicated to us, namely, what the Ceann Comhairle was prepared to facilitate. I do not understand why——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy, I have done much to facilitate you. You will realise that the Technical Group no longer exists. That is the position.

Comment on this

I understand that situation.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Green Party has six Members in Opposition, Sinn Féin has five and that is the proposed sequence.

Comment on this

If I recall correctly from my earlier engagement with the Ceann Comhairle's staff, under Standing Order 121(3) we made the point that the House can order time. The Ceann Comhairle indicated this to us and, as it was not laid down in terms of time formation within the Order Paper, we had every reason to understand that what was communicated to us from his office was what he would honour on the floor of the House. That is not what was just communicated. I do not seek to be vexatious in any way but I ask the Ceann Comhairle to appreciate it was indicated to us that we would have a 30 minute slot, the same as each of the other opening speakers.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I must advise you that in all the circumstances it is a concession on my part and on the part of my office to allow the Deputy to speak in the debate.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the position because the Technical Group no longer exists as a result of the changed dynamics in the Chamber. As a result of the exceptional circumstances in which we find ourselves, we have decided to allow the Deputy speak on behalf of Sinn Féin.

Comment on this

What about the Independents?

Comment on this

Will the Ceann Comhairle clarify if the opening contributor will be allowed to share time?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would have to be agreed by the House.

Comment on this

We ask that the House would agree that.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is it a sharing of time?

Comment on this

In the interests of democracy and fair play, every Member of the Oireachtas should get the opportunity to speak on this important piece of legislation. It is very simple.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The proposal is for a truncated debate. The sharing of time is agreed.

Comment on this

Is it 20 minutes for the Green Party and 20 minutes for Sinn Féin?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

That seems reasonable. If the Independents could be facilitated as well, everything would be fine.

Comment on this

In order to be helpful I would seek to facilitate those who were members of the Technical Group, although there is no longer such a group. If 20 minutes are to be shared, I presume it could be shared with the people forming the Technical Group. I am sure Deputy Finian McGrath could get five of the 20 minutes, having supported Sinn Féin in setting up the group. The party would hardly forget him at this late stage.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach enjoyed his support for much longer than we did.

Comment on this

The Deputy has reminded me again of the well-known generosity of Sinn Féin. When it suits the party, it forgets about those who helped it.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We should have some co-operation in the House.

Comment on this

First, I thank the main Opposition parties for their co-operation yesterday in agreeing a timetable which will allow the passage of the Bill before us today. The Finance Bill is an integral and important part of our commitment under the external assistance programme. Any uncertainty, or worse, failure to have it enacted would have been damaging to Ireland internationally and could have jeopardised the arrangements we have reached with the European Union and the IMF which has given us access to the funding we and every Government will need to pay for the public services this State will provide to our citizens over the next three years.

This Finance Bill is being brought forward in an unprecedented set of political circumstances. The Government would have liked more time to bring forward significant amendments, for example, to allow for the necessary changes to the tax system arising out of the civil partnerships legislation. There are also other matters we would have wished to address on an annual housekeeping basis in this finance legislation. The requirement to accelerate the Bill in order to facilitate an earlier general election has made it impossible to deal with these matters now but they can and should be dealt with speedily by the new Government.

The necessarily truncated process has restricted us but notwithstanding the time pressure under which it is working, the Government agreed this morning to bring forward a number of important amendments. Among them is an amendment which deals with the position of medical card holders under the new universal social charge. We now propose that the maximum rate applying to medical card holders should be 4% rather than 7%, the same rate as applies to persons over 70.

The universal social charge represents a very substantial change to our tax system. It is based on the principle that everybody must pay according to their means. As I have said many times, it is simply not sustainable that 45% of income earners should pay no tax, and I stand by that statement. However, it is apparent that those who have medical cards have been adversely affected by the new charge and the Government wants to ameliorate their position while at the same time maintaining the principle that everyone must make a contribution. The cost of this change, which is about €80 million, will be made up by increasing the universal social charge rate paid by self-employed taxpayers from 7% to 10% on income in excess of €100,000. It is important to realise that any changes to the tax provisions of this Bill must be paid for by increases elsewhere. This is not just a fundamental issue in this debate as it is a fundamental issue in the national debate lying before us. Any changes in expenditure or taxation plans must be fully justified and costed.

The passing of the Finance Bill 2011 will give permanent legal effect to the revenue measures which were provided for in the resolutions passed on budget night on 7 December last. The Bill will continue the process of stabilising our public finances, providing appropriate support to business and assisting the Revenue Commissioners to maintain a climate of compliance. This country has been through the most severe downturn in the history of the State, with crises in both the public finances and banking system. Over the past two and a half years, we have taken swift action to address the deep imbalances in our public finances and to ensure that the banking system is returned to a stable and sustainable footing.

As the House will be aware, the Government has decided that in order to achieve the deficit target of 3% of GDP by 2014, an adjustment of €15 billion is necessary over the period 2011-2014. The Government understands that the scale of the adjustments will have an impact on the living standards of us all. However, sustainable public finances are a prerequisite for a return to growth. To show our resolve, the budget contained considerable frontloading, with an adjustment of €6 billion, and this Finance Bill will enact many of the measures necessary to bring about this adjustment.

There were considerable imbalances built up in the Irish economy through the middle part of the previous decade, with growth dominated by an unsustainable construction boom. The last number of years have seen the Irish economy rebalance itself towards a more sustainable growth path for a small open economy, that is, one led by exports. Figures from the most recent national accounts show that exports rose 13.2% in the third quarter of last year, while data from the purchasing managers' index suggest this trend is set to continue in the coming months. This strong export performance reflects the significant price and wage adjustments taking place, which is testament to the flexibility and adaptability of the Irish economy and workforce.

During the building boom of the middle part of this decade, Ireland had its competitive edge eroded relative to our main trading partners. We took our eye off the ball so to speak. However, as a country we are regaining this competitiveness and while the falls in domestic prices, easing wage pressures and improvements in productivity are helpful, we must not be complacent as further improvements in our competitiveness are essential to take advantage of the global recovery. To this end, the national recovery plan sets out in considerable detail a series of microeconomic reforms, including labour activation measures which will improve our competitiveness and underpin our growth into the future.

In the labour market, there was a significant fall in the claimant count number of unemployed in the last quarter of 2010, so there are signs of stabilisation. Another encouraging development is the movement of the current account of the balance of payments into positive territory in the third quarter of 2010, which means that the nation as a whole is no longer increasing its external liabilities. I am pleased to say that, following the sharp contractions during 2008 and 2009, available data points towards a stabilisation of economic activity last year. Recently published figures show both GDP and GNP expanding in the third quarter of 2010, which is very encouraging, and most commentators expect this upward momentum to be maintained this year, with a full year of positive growth in prospect.

The recovery is being driven by the exporting sectors, underpinned by the significant improvements in competitiveness. As wages and other costs are adjusting, we are pricing ourselves back into global markets. This is most evident from the 13% annual rate of export growth recorded in the third quarter of last year, one of the best performances in the EU. Moreover, this export growth is broad-based, with the pharmaceutical, software, financial and food sectors all performing well. With this export-led growth, Ireland will have a balance of payments surplus this year, so the country as a whole will be paying its way in the wider world, notwithstanding our public financial difficulties.

Given the impact of the fiscal consolidation and the necessary unwinding of private sector imbalances, domestic demand will remain relatively muted this year, although in the coming years export-led growth will gradually filter through to the domestic economy. I acknowledge the high levels of foreign direct investment that Ireland continues to attract; almost 1,000 companies, including household names such as Google, eBay and Facebook have chosen Ireland as the hub of their European networks. Eight of the top ten global medical technology companies have a manufacturing base in Ireland and eight of the top ten pharmaceutical firms have operations in Ireland. The message must be clear that Ireland remains open for business and is still the destination of choice for many of the world's leading firms. That is the real hope existing in our economy and it is that to which we must attend as public representatives.

The public finances stabilised over the course of 2010. The underlying Government deficit for 2010 is expected to come in at the 11.6% of GDP forecast in budget 2010. The budget figures were on target last year but a gap remains between Exchequer expenditure and revenues in 2010 of just under €19 billion. It is clear that the State must reduce its level of borrowing over the coming years by aligning more closely its revenues and expenditure.

In the past two and half years, the Government has engaged in a process of reprioritisation and consolidation across all areas of expenditure to close this gap. The measures have reduced all aspects of Government discretionary spending, including public sector pay and running costs across Departments and State bodies. Significant revenue raising measures have also been implemented over this period, including the introduction of an income levy, a carbon tax and increases in capital tax rates. Based on a budgetary consolidation package of €6 billion in 2011, the general government deficit is expected to decline further this year to 9.4%. The measures outlined in the national recovery plan will assist in reducing this deficit to below 3% of GDP by 2014 in line with the commitments given.

Before I go through the Bill in detail, I draw Deputies' attention to some of the key measures contained in it. The Bill sets out the details of the universal social charge, which replaced and combined the income and health levies. It is a more sustainable charge and applies on a wider base. It removes the steps and poverty traps associated with the income and health levies and goes some way to providing a smoother progression and dealing with irregularities in the previous two charges.

I am aware that the introduction of the universal social charge has been the subject of much comment in recent days. The charge was introduced for a specific reason. We must move away from a position in which people do not make any tax contribution to society and, as a result, the burden falls too heavily on others. As I have often stated in this House, a position in which 45% of tax units do not pay tax is unsustainable for any Government.

However, both the Government and I are aware of concerns expressed by some about the universal social charge. While some concerns are overstated, others are more legitimate. As regards the latter, I propose to bring forward two amendments on behalf of the Government on Committee Stage which will make the measure fairer without conceding the key principle that everyone must make some contribution. Under these proposed amendments, those in receipt of a medical card will see the top rate of charge reduced from 7% to 4%; the same as applies for persons aged over 70 years. The new rate will apply as follows: 2% on income up to and including €10,036 and 4% on income above that amount.

The rate for the self-employed earning more than €100,000 per annum will increase from 7% to 10% over that level. I undertook to look into this matter when it was raised by Deputy Noonan on budget night. This change ensures the contribution made by the self-employed will be of the same order of magnitude as the contribution made by employees and will leave their top marginal tax rate unchanged on last year. These measures, if adopted, will be transitional in nature and will have effect until the end of the period of the national recovery plan.

A number of reliefs and exemptions are being either restricted or abolished in accordance with the announcement in my budget speech. These tax expenditures include rent relief, which is being phased out over eight years, patent royalty exemption, tax relief for trade union subscriptions, relief from benefit-in-kind for employer provided child care facilities, capital expenditure on new machinery and plant for use in mining and a number of share related measures, namely, relief on loans to acquire an interest in certain companies, approved share options schemes and relief for new shares purchased by employees.

The provisions on the property related tax expenditures, as announced in the budget, are fully contained in the Bill. However, the Government has decided that they will now be subject to a commencement provision which may only take effect in the next tax year following the preparation and publication of an economic impact assessment on the proposed changes. A Committee Stage amendment may be introduced to further clarify the precise commencement of this provision.

The business expansion scheme is being reformed and renamed the employment and investment incentive. This new incentive will be more targeted at job retention and creation. Once the necessary approval is received from the European Commission, the new incentive will be commenced by ministerial order. This will encourage job creation in both new and existing companies.

Income tax relief will be provided for expenditure incurred by individuals, not the landlord of the property, on a range of works undertaken to improve the energy efficiency of residential premises situated in the State. A maximum of €30 million in relief per annum will be allowed under this scheme.

The Bill gives effect to the fundamental reforms to stamp duty on residential property announced in the budget. Stamp duty is now payable at 1% on residential property transactions valued up to €1 million and 2% on the excess over €1 million. This applies to all such transfers on or after 8 December 2010.

The scheme introduced in budget 2009 which provides a three year exemption from corporation tax on the trading income and certain gains of new start-up companies is being extended to include start-up companies which commence a new trade in 2011.

I will now take Deputies through the Bill and describe the main provisions contained therein. Part 1 deals with the income levy, universal social charge, income tax, corporation tax and capital gains tax. Section 1 is the usual interpretation section. Section 2 provides for the cessation of the income levy. The health levy was abolished in the Social Welfare and Pensions Act 2010 which was passed by the Oireachtas before Christmas.

Section 3 makes provision for the introduction of the new universal social charge as announced in the budget. The charge replaces the income and health levies and applies at a low rate on a broad base. It is charged on an individualised basis on gross income at 2% on income up to and including €10,036, 4% for income in excess of €10,036 but not greater than €16,016 and 7% above that level. Those aged more than 70 years do not pay this higher rate and there is a lower exemption threshold of €4,004.

The universal social charge does not apply to social welfare payments, including contributory and non-contributory social welfare State pensions. While there are no exemptions for pension contributions or medical cards, Deputies will be aware of the proposed Committee Stage amendment to introduce a low rate for persons with medical cards for a transitional four year period. The social charge is a more sustainable charge than the income and health levies. It removes the anomalies associated with these charges and ensures a smoother tax progression across income levels.

Sections 4 to 6, inclusive, provide for the budget announcement to reduce the standard rate bands, age exemption limits and tax credits in line with overall reduction in income. The single standard band is being reduced by €3,600 per annum from €36,400 to €32,800. The married one earner band is being reduced by €3,600 from €45,400 to €41,800. The married two earner band is being reduced from €72,800 to €65,600, with transferability limited to €41,800. The one parent-widowed parent band is being reduced by €3,600 from €40,400 to €36,800. The age exemption limits are being reduced by €2,000 in the case of a single person and €4,000 in the case of a married couple to €18,000 and €36,000, respectively.

The personal credit is being reduced by approximately 10% per annum from €1,830 to €1,650 in the case of a single person and by €360 per annum from €3,660 to €3,300 in the case of a married couple. The employee PAYE tax credit is also being reduced by 10% from €1,830 to €1,650. All other credits are being reduced by 10%. The age credit is being reduced by €80 per annum from €325 to €245 in the case of a single person and by €160 per annum from €650 to €490. These changes are in line with the commitments in the national recovery plan.

Section 7 provides for the changes to certain exemptions from benefits-in-kind taxation already announced in the budget. First, it abolishes the benefit-in-kind exemption that previously applied to payment of professional fees and subscriptions by employers. It also abolishes the exemption from benefit-in-kind where employees are in receipt of child care facilities which are subsidised by their employers' capital contributions towards the costs of such facilities.

Section 8 restricts the amount of tax relief of ex gratia payments to a lifetime limit of €200,000 with effect from 1 January 2011. This €200,000 limit is reduced by any previous exempt payments which an employee may have previously received.

Section 9 amends section 470B of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, which provides for an age related tax credit in respect of health insurance premiums. The section abolishes the age related tax credit for individuals aged 50 to 59 years and increases the amount of age related tax credit in the case of insured persons aged 60 years and over for relevant contracts renewed or entered into on or after 1 January 2011.

A number of previously announced budget changes are being introduced in relation to shares. Section 10 provides for the abolition of relief for new shares purchased by employees, the abolition of approved profit sharing schemes and also brings the tax treatment of the value of share awards into the PAYE system.

Section 11 abolishes interest relief on loans that are used to acquire an interest in certain companies. This relief will be phased out over four years with an annual reduction of 25% in the amount of interest that can be relieved. No relief is allowed for new loans taken out from budget day. Section 12 provides for the abolition of tax relief for trade union subscriptions for the 2011 and subsequent tax years.

As I announced in my budget speech, I am introducing a new tax incentive scheme to encourage taxpayers to invest in works that will improve the energy efficiency of their homes. Section 13 provides the legislative basis for this scheme. The tax relief will be provided by way of repayment in the tax year following the year in which the work has been completed and in which the expenditure was incurred. The maximum amount of expenditure that will qualify for relief in any one tax year will be €150 million. This equates to tax relief of €30 million. This section is subject to a commencement order to allow for processes and procedures to be put in place.

Section 14 provides for the abolition of rent relief for new claimants from 8 December 2010. It makes the legislative changes required to withdraw the relief from existing claimants on a reducing rate basis until no further relief will be provided in the 2018 year of assessment. The withdrawal period is in line with that previously announced for mortgage interest relief.

Changes are made in section 15 to tax relief for third-level fees and charges to take account of the Government decision to replace the existing student services charge of €1,500 with a flat-rate student contribution of €2,000. Section 16 provides for the introduction of a €40,000 limit on earnings for the artists' exemption that was announced in the National Recovery Plan 2011-2014 and in the budget.

Section 17 is a routine update of the schedule of accountable persons for the purposes of professional services withholding tax. As a means of improving the assessment of tax performance in advance of the usual December budget, the pay and file dates for self-employed income tax and capital gains tax, CGT, are being brought forward by one month from end-October to end-September and this is addressed in section 18. There will continue to be an additional 14 days for payment on-line via the Revenue on-line service, ROS. These changes are aimed at reducing the over-concentration of tax receipts in late October and mid-November, which will enhance the accuracy of next-year budget forecasting. Therefore these changes are introduced not to raise additional revenue, but to ensure that the accuracy of forecasts in my Department can be enhanced by an earlier receipt of this particularly volatile section of the income tax receipts base.

Section 19 deals with the various changes in the tax treatment of private pension provision announced in the budget. These changes involve the extension of the flexible options on retirement — that is, access to an approved retirement fund and so on — to all defined contribution pension arrangements, subject to certain changes to the general conditions attaching to those options and to certain transitional provisions. There will also be an increase, from 3% to 5%, in the annual imputed distribution which applies to the value of assets in an approved retirement fund in respect of asset values at 31 December 2010 and future years. The section provides for a reduction in the maximum allowable pension fund on retirement for tax purposes, known as the standard fund threshold, to €2.3 million with transitional arrangements for individuals with pension rights valued above the reduced threshold on budget day.

In addition, there will be a reduction in the annual earnings limit which, along with age-related percentage limits, determine maximum tax-relievable contributions for pension purposes from €150,000 to €115,000 and, finally, a reduction to €200,000 in the overall life-time limit on the amount of tax-free retirement lump sums that an individual can draw down from pension arrangements. The excess of retirement lump sum payments over €200,000 will be taxed at the standard income tax rate of 20% up to an amount equal to 25% of the new standard fund threshold, which is €575,000. The excess of retirement lump sum payments over that amount will be taxed at the taxpayer's marginal rate of income tax.

Before turning to the next issue, I would like to review the pension changes. It is a matter of regret that we were not given a greater opportunity to reflect on these changes by virtue of the insistence of the Opposition on an accelerated timetable for the Finance Bill. These are matters which did require further reflection but I accept that, as a minority Government, we are not masters of our own destiny. However, they are matters about which I would have preferred more extensive reflection before the enactment of the relevant measures.

As I announced in the budget, there are major changes to the relevant contracts tax regime. These are covered in section 20 and involve the replacement of the current residential contracts tax rates with a three-rate withholding system on a revenue-neutral basis. The current 35% rate will be retained as the default rate only where the other rates are not appropriate. In addition, the monthly repayment system will be abolished and replaced with an offset system while the reporting system for RCT principals will be strengthened in order to enhance compliance and reduce the opportunities for fraud.

An area of particular concern is the loss of tax revenue caused by false claims for tax credits or refunds. Section 21 introduces a penalty for any person who makes a false claim or assists in making a false claim. This measure also seeks recovery from the beneficiary of any tax refunded on the basis of a false claim. Finally, it provides for the charging of interest on such proceeds from the date the person first benefited from the false claim until the proceeds were paid back to Revenue. I have seen some public criticism of this provision. It is important to understand that this relates to a false claim. The sum being recouped to the Revenue is one that is lost to the Revenue by way of interest bearing which would otherwise have accrued.

Section 22 provides for restrictions to schemes of accelerated capital allowances under the various area-based and property-based tax incentive schemes. Section 23 deals with restrictions to relief for lessors of rented residential accommodation, that is, section 23 relief. Both of these sections provide for changes to property-based reliefs as set out in the budget night financial resolutions. However, the commencement of these provisions is now dependent on the carrying-out and publication of an economic impact assessment into the effects of the proposed changes. In essence, the provisions restrict the use and carry-forward of capital allowances and section 23 relief. The aim of the changes is to reduce ongoing legacy costs to the Exchequer and ensure that tax will be paid on some income previously sheltered by the various reliefs.

The restrictions only apply to passive investors and not to those actively engaged in the businesses, nor do they affect residential owner-occupier relief. If commenced the provisions provide that first, all reliefs must be used within seven years in the case of seven-year schemes, such as hotels; and ten years in the case of ten-year schemes, such as section 23. Any carry forward of unused reliefs after that period will no longer be allowed and the unused reliefs will be lost. Second, tax reliefs can only be used to set against income arising from the trade or rental property that gave rise to the relief. This applies to both capital allowances and section 23-type reliefs. It ensures that tax will now be paid on some income previously sheltered by the various reliefs.

It was always intended to carry out an impact assessment of the proposed changes and that is why I announced it on budget day. However, because of the widespread level of concern that has been expressed by individuals and groups, in particular regarding the downstream effects of the changes on the real economy and on employment, I have proposed in the Finance Bill that an economic impact assessment of the changes should be undertaken in advance of the commencement of the provisions.

Legislating for the restrictions in the Finance Bill, as originally intended, combined with undertaking an ex ante impact assessment of their effect in advance of the commencement of the provisions, strikes the right balance between seeking to restrict unnecessary tax reliefs on the one hand and, on the other hand, taking notice of real concerns that have been expressed about the proposed changes. Those concerns relate to the solvency of individuals on relatively modest incomes, to the consequential exposure of the banks concerning the same, and to the prospect of legal challenges to the arrangements proposed in the legislation. Real and substantial concerns were expressed about the impact of the measures as proposed in the budget. It appeared that the intention of the budget, which was essentially to cut off the tail of these reliefs over a period, was effectuated by provisions which in effect provided for an instantaneous cutting off of the entire tail in this particular legacy. That would have had serious implications for the solvency of many individuals, some of whom have modest means. In those circumstances, the Government took the view based on the correspondence we received, that the best course of action was to carry out a comprehensive impact assessment before the commencement of the relevant measures.

Comment on this

Would it still be invoked in 2011?

Comment on this

That matter is still being examined with a view to an amendment on Committee State. In general, the commencement of such provisions takes place on an annualised basis. However, we are examining the issue of post-commencement receipts in this year with a view to an amendment on Committee Stage. However, there will not be a retrospective commencement of these provisions in relation to the period during which the impact assessment is being carried out.

Section 24 provides for the continuance of the relief to farmers for the increase in stock values for a further two years to 31 December 2012 from the current closing date of 31 December 2010, subject to the usual state aid clearance from the European Commission. Section 25 abolishes the tax exemption for income received by an individual or company from a qualifying patent. The tax exemption for distributions made by companies from exempt patent income is likewise abolished. This measure was announced on budget day and was also included in the list of tax expenditures set out in the national recovery plan for abolition or curtailment. The abolition of the exemption applies to income from a qualifying patent which is paid on or after 24 November 2010, which was the date of publication of the plan.

Capital expenditure on new machinery and plant for use in mining has qualified for a 20% investment allowance in addition to normal wear and tear allowances. An allowance of 20% of expenditure incurred on mining exploration has also been available in addition to the 100% exploration allowance for such expenditure. Section 26 abolishes these additional 20% allowances in respect of expenditure incurred from 1 January 2011 in line with the recommendation in the 2009 report of the Commission on Taxation.

Section 27 is an anti-avoidance provision. It introduces changes to legislation to counter attempts to extract funds from close companies on a tax-free basis using trusts and other such arrangements. The changes will apply to transfers of assets or liabilities made on or after the publication of the Bill.

Section 28 amends sections 256 and 267B of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 to provide for an increase of two percentage points in the rate of deposit interest retention tax with effect from 1 January 2011. The rate is now 27% where the interest is paid annually or more frequently and 30% where the interest is paid less frequently than annually. To match the increase in deposit interest retention tax, section 29 increases the rates of tax applying to life assurance policies and investment funds by two percentage points with effect from 1 January 2011. The changes in sections 28 and 29 are expected to yield a total of €22.5 million in 2011 and €30 million in a full year.

As previously announced, the existing business expansion scheme is being reformed and renamed the employment and investment incentive. This is being done in section 30 of the Bill. The new incentive will ensure the tax relief is more targeted at job retention and creation. It is subject to the approval of the European Commission. The existing scheme will continue until this has been secured.

In my 2009 Budget Statement, which I made in October 2008, I introduced a scheme providing a three-year exemption from corporation tax on the trading income and certain gains of new start-up companies. I have extended the scheme each year since. The scheme is being extended again in section 31 of the Bill to include start-up companies which commence a new trade in 2011. However, it is being modified to link the relief to the amount of employers' PRSI paid by a company in an accounting period, subject to a maximum of €5,000 per employee. The purpose of the change is to better target the relief at companies generating employment.

Section 32 amends Schedule 24 to the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 to make it clear that a company is not permitted to allocate relevant trading charges on income as it sees fit in the computation of the credit due to it in respect of foreign tax paid on its income.

Sections 33 and 34 of the Bill deal with provisions relating to tax relief on interest on borrowings. As a result of this legislation, relief will not generally be allowed in respect of interest on intra-group borrowings to finance the purchase of assets from another group company, nor will such interest be allowed as a deduction in computing the profits or gains of a trade. Other changes are being made in this area to ensure the interest relief provisions operate as intended. The scheme of accelerated capital allowances for expenditure——

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I am afraid the Minister has already exhausted the time available to him.

Comment on this

I am pleased that I have exhausted my time. I have to work through a number of sections.

Comment on this

I can give the Minister five minutes of my time.

Comment on this

I take it that the speech has been circulated. I will simply——

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Ryan has suggested that the Minister could take five minutes of his time, if that is of assistance.

Comment on this

It is not really. I am working through the provisions of the sections. I will conclude briefly.

Comment on this

The Minister has other duties to which he needs to attend.

Comment on this

I have no other duties to perform at this stage, other than to listen to Deputy Noonan's contribution. That is my next duty.

Comment on this

It is in the bag.

Comment on this

The scheme of accelerated capital allowances for expenditure by companies on certain energy-efficient equipment that was bought for the purpose of a trade was introduced in a previous budget. The Finance Act 2008 provided that the scheme should last for a three-year trial period and end in 2011. Section 35 extends the scheme for a further three years to 31 December 2014.

The remaining sections of the Bill continue to implement various matters that have been decided on by the Government and were contained in the budget. I hope the structured amendment schedule that has been agreed for Committee Stage will give us a good opportunity to tease out the implications of these provisions in detail.

The eyes of the world will be looking at us when we vote on this measure at the conclusion of Second Stage. It is of no particular political advantage for this Government to take responsibility for the enactment of legislation that results in an increase in the imposition of taxation on citizens. However, it is important that Ireland, as a country, is seen to be able to do its business in the wider world. The resolutions associated with this Finance Bill, which were approved in December 2010, should be carried into effect before the end of this month so that we can demonstrate this country's capacity to deliver what it undertook to deliver. That will be a fundamental prerequisite for any future Government of this country. Regardless of the side of the House on which I find myself following the general election, I will undertake to provide such support in the future.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

To delete all words after "That" and substitute the following:

Dáil Éireann declines to give a Second Reading to the Finance Bill, having regard to the fact that the Bill contains virtually no proposals to encourage economic growth and job creation and the fact that certain provisions of the Bill have a very severe impact on the most vulnerable in society.

Yesterday, representatives of Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, the Labour Party and the Green Party reached agreement on a schedule to debate the Finance Bill. If its measures receive the support of the Houses of the Oireachtas, it will pass through the Dáil and the Seanad by Saturday evening and may then be signed by the President. The Finance Bill is even more important this year than in previous years, following the Government's agreement with the International Monetary Fund and the European Union that its passage is a primary condition for drawing down the bailout funds. There was majority support for the budget on 7 December last. Fine Gael opposed the budget and voted against it. We believe there continues to be a majority in the House that supports the measures in this Bill.

We are debating the Finance Bill 2011 in difficult political circumstances. The Green Party has left the Government. The Government is in a minority. A general election is imminent. Fine Gael believes that only an election and a new Government will restore certainty to our country. We accept that control of the Finance Bill has passed from the Government to the Dáil. As the Government is in a minority in the Dáil, it would not win a vote of confidence if such a motion were moved next week. The position is more complex this week, however, because the Green Party wants the Finance Bill to be enacted. There is still a majority in favour of passing the Finance Bill, even though the Government no longer has a majority. Every political party must accept the consequences of the new situation. Fine Gael is prepared to hold back on its motion of no confidence so the way may be cleared for a general election after the passing of this Bill. Fine Gael and the other parties have agreed a debating schedule for the Bill, on the basis of an undertaking that a general election will be called early next week. If this occurs, I presume the election will take place on Friday, 25 February 2011.

While Fine Gael supports the new arrangements for the Finance Bill 2011, we do not support the Bill itself. We opposed the measures it contains on budget night. We will continue to oppose the measures in the Bill before the House. I suggest that approximately 95% of this legislation is a repeat of the measures that were voted into law by this House, by way of Financial Resolution, on budget night. The Finance Bill, in the normal way, will provide the ongoing legal framework for those decisions. There is very little new material in the Finance Bill, as published. The Minister had signalled that he intended to introduce some new material by means of Committee Stage amendments. He has now restricted his intentions to those Committee Stage proposals that he outlined in his speech.

The Deputies who supported the budget have a responsibility to ensure the safe passage of this Bill through the Dáil. Fine Gael, of course, will be constructive in its approach. There are some good proposals to which we have no objection. Other measures could be improved by amendments. We will table such amendments to improve the Bill. This Finance Bill is the last act of a crippled Government, which has brought this country to its knees over a three-year period. The Government may claim some credit for the fiscal adjustments made in previous budgets, but I believe they were rough, ready, rash and ill-conceived. The social or economic consequences of individual measures were not assessed. Some gain was made on the bottom line of the national finances as a result of measures that had appalling economic and social consequences. They reduced growth in the economy, cost thousands of jobs and inflicted pain and hardship on the most vulnerable people in our society.

In December 2010, Fine Gael proposed an alternative budget and four-year plan. Our plan was based on four principles, the first of which was that we accepted the budgetary targets set out by the European Commission to correct Ireland's fiscal imbalances. We are all familiar with these: that the debt to GDP ratio should be less than 3%, first by 2014 and now by 2015, and that the correction should be front-loaded by way of an adjustment of €6 billion in 2011. Fine Gael is committed to those targets. The work remaining over the three subsequent budgets, then, is an adjustment of €9 billion in fairly even tranches.

The second principle on which we based our alternative budgetary strategy was that the correction should be made by a combination of expenditure savings and tax increases. Fine Gael believes that the correction should be achieved principally through expenditure cuts rather than tax increases — I will return to this — and we suggested a proportion of three to one. The Minister in his budget introduced 65% — about two thirds — of the tax increases envisaged in the memorandum of understanding with the IMF and the EU in the first year, so the balance has changed slightly. However, we are still committed to making the adjustment, by and large, through cuts in expenditure so that we do not have to increase taxes unduly.

Our third principle is that each budgetary measure should be examined and politically, socially and economically proofed so that the social consequences of each proposal are known and we do not enter blindly into proposals that would hurt many vulnerable people, as has happened in several budgets in the past, sometimes because Ministers were callous and on other occasions because they were careless and did not realise the impact of the measures they were taking on the most vulnerable in society. Those who talk about list systems for elections to this House and ways of bringing in an elite of super-qualified people should always remember that Deputies learn the nuts and bolts of Irish society while they are doing their normal advice work in the clinic, and they would not make the silly mistake of bringing in measures that had not been thought out and that hurt the most vulnerable people in society if they were in contact with their constituents.

Comment on this

Hear, hear to that.

Comment on this

The fourth principle is that the economic consequences of each proposal should be measured to ensure it does not have an adverse effect on growth and job creation and, preferably, that it has a positive impact in these areas. These are the principles to which we applied our thoughts when we were introducing the alternative budget. I suggest that it was a more carefully thought out document than the Minister's budget, which fails on many of these headings, especially in its lack of measures to promote growth and job creation and its callousness about measures that affect the most vulnerable in society.

Fine Gael is committed to meeting the targets set out in the bailout package agreed by the IMF, the EU and the Government. If the Finance Bill goes through, the initial adjustment of €6 billion out of a total of €15 billion will be under way, and with proper fiscal controls over expenditure and proper financial management of Votes in the Department of Finance, the targets should be achieved.

I accept that arising from the passing of the Financial Resolutions on 7 December last, the Government made concrete commitments internationally and domestically and any resiling on these policies now could have serious financial consequences. However, there are different roads to the same destination, and the Minister for Finance should be open to accepting amendments which would have the same yield or impact on the deficit but a better social or economic impact.

There are many measures in the Finance Bill which are difficult to accept. The universal social charge and the extension of the tax net to capture persons on quite low incomes will impose severe hardship. I agree with the Minister that 45% of the workforce not paying tax is a large proportion which is not to be found anywhere else in the EU, and some widening of the tax net was necessary, but he went down to a threshold that was too low. The floor for the universal social charge — about €4,000 — represents a very low income, and the Minister should accept an amendment to raise this threshold, perhaps by €1,000. He should also indicate in his reply to Second Stage whether he will amend his proposal to exclude persons with severe disabilities or illnesses from the charge. Widows should also be exempted if we are to restore the status quo ante. I am aware of the intention of the Minister to move an amendment to exclude persons on medical cards. This is a move in the right direction, which is welcome.

The Minister indicated in his Budget Statement of December 2009 that he would be introducing a universal social charge, so it was well signalled, although it excited very little discussion at the time. He has now introduced the charge, but the provisions are rough and ready. The incorporation of levies and other payments into one charge has a regressive impact, with high-income persons paying less and low-income persons paying more. I had written my speech before I heard of the Minister's second amendment. He is now taking into account the advantage bestowed on high-earning self-employed people and introducing an additional 3% levy for persons who are self-employed and have an income of more than €100,000. However, he is catching and penalising a new section of society. I remember from the debate here that a person had to be receiving almost €200,000 before he or she was a beneficiary of the new provisions, and the real benefits were bestowed on people with incomes of half a million or three quarters of a million euro — members of the Law Library or those who had been working in tribunals for 13 or 14 years.

Fine Gael believes that the fiscal adjustment should be achieved preferably through expenditure savings rather than tax increases. We feel strongly about this because Fianna Fáil and other parties in the House have been cautious in cutting public expenditure. The Minister has been particularly light in his proposals on public service reform, although he tried to disguise the impact of what he was doing. He made a commitment to reduce the numbers in the public service, which stand at about 310,000 at present, by 26,750 — almost 27,000. However, he took 2008 as his base year, and when we examined it we found he had achieved more than half the target already through natural wastage. Thus, the commitment was really to reduce the complement of public servants by 12,000 over a four-year period. Three thousand a year is a very light commitment to public service reform and to the reduction of the public service payroll by concentrating on the numbers. As the Minister knows from his experience, anyone in private industry will tell one that if one wants to control the payroll bill, one has two choices: one can cut pay, or one can cut numbers. The Minister cut pay in his initial budgets, and I do not think he should cut public service pay again, but he should concentrate on the numbers.

The connection is this: if one does not cut expenditure, one must implement higher taxes. The parties that advocate the fewest cuts in public expenditure are the high-tax parties. We are not a high-tax party, and we oppose this. We are not saying on a whim that adjustments should be made principally through cuts in public expenditure. It is because the alternative is to implement higher taxes, taxing people out of employment and creating more unemployment. Everybody in the House understands the point I am making. This is the principal reason the budget, the Finance Bill and Social Welfare Bill had such severe consequences for the low-paid and those on welfare. If the Government had done more to cut expenditure it would not have been obliged to cut the pensions of the blind, the widows and the disabled. It gained about €90 million from those provisions. We are not discussing the Social Welfare Bill today but I am making the point that more cuts and savings in public expenditure give us the headroom to go more easily on the most vulnerable. The end result of a high-tax policy and cuts in social welfare is that the most vulnerable in society get hammered. Sinn Féin Members preach about going to stand up for the poor and those on low incomes, but when their economic policies are applied to that category of people, the result will be the exact opposite because they will be forced into implementing high taxes, which affect the poor more severely than any other category of society.

Our other principal objection to the budget and the Finance Bill is that there are no real measures to encourage jobs and growth. The business expansion scheme has disappeared and there is now a commitment to introduce it by ministerial order. If the Government has this order ready — it seems to have gone to Brussels — will it publish the text of it so we can know what we are discussing, even though the Minister is not introducing an amendment to this effect?

I have also argued that each sector of the economy should be stimulated by low cost supply side measures, many of which are tax based. Again, there is nothing in the Bill of a supply side nature based on taxes. We have to play to our strengths, and the Minister has been over this ground several times. Manufacturing industry is going well, tourism has great potential and the food industry will have massive potential when quotas are abolished in 2017. Progressive farmers are investing already to produce more food and there is enormous capacity now because of the removal of quotas in that industry. The financial services industry has held its place, despite Ireland's adverse reputation. It has lost very few jobs and is at a point of growing again. The IT industry as well as the pharmaceutical industry have the potential, too, for additional growth in job creation. I believe these sectors should be stimulated by low cost inexpensive supply side initiatives.

The Minister referred to Ireland's lack of competitiveness, and even though some ground has been gained we are still not back to where we should be in terms of job creation. However, I have not read a Minister's speech in the past 20 years that did not deal with the lack of competitiveness in Irish society. Why is something not being done about it? There seems to be no will to drive the agenda to make the country competitive — to restore competitiveness and to create jobs. There seems to be very little interest in doing small things. I gave the Minister an example on budget night, and I shall give it again. There is an argument to the effect that research and development would be stimulated and inward investment encouraged if the write-off of tax that is allowed for research and development investment was not only available against corporation tax but also against employer PRSI payments. If it were done through tax and if the investment were made in only one year, it would not be possible to get the benefit. The cost involved would be very little, but it is an issue for companies involved in research and development. Minor measures such as that would give an advantage to the IDA package when seeking to attract foreign investment here.

Of all the Government failures, the banking fiasco is undoubtedly the greatest. It is difficult to see how the country can prosper without a thriving banking sector, and yet every policy initiative taken by the Government has made the situation worse. The resolution of the banking crisis is now embedded in the IMF-EU bailout, and Fine Gael in government is committed to renegotiation of the terms of the package. In the general election we are seeking a mandate from the Irish people to conduct this renegotiation. There are three elements to it.

Fine Gael wants to replace specific conditions in the memorandum of understanding with measures more acceptable to us which we believe will have better social and economic impact. We also realise that any replacement measures, however, will have to have the same impact on reducing the deficit as the ones contained at present in the memorandum of understanding. We have been assured by the IMF and the EU that they are open to this approach, despite the protestations of the Minister over many weeks when he attempted to throw cold water on any attempt by an incoming government to renegotiate the bailout package.

Fine Gael wants a lower interest rate on the Luxembourg base fund which is providing much of the money for the bailout package. At 5.8%, the interest rate is too high and is almost unaffordable. We need, in the interests of the country and to restore the economy to growth, to have it at a lower level. The interest rate is 300 basis points, 3%, above the cost of the funds. The first tranche of funds into Ireland was raised on the markets at 2.9%, almost 3%. Recent discussions in Europe have indicated that policy is changing rapidly and the new arrangements for the fund envisage a lower interest rate. This is a welcome development and I hope an incoming Irish Government will succeed in negotiating an interest rate reduction. When we suggested this a couple of months ago, the Minister shouted "mission impossible" and did not pursue it. Only last Wednesday week in the House, in reply to a priority question, the Minister treated me with scorn and dismissed out of hand any possibility of negotiating with the 26 other member states to get a reduction in the interest rate. On the following Monday night I saw the Minister on television in Brussels, where he was talking up the possibility of a reduced interest rate. He was now the great negotiator and was going to achieve this.

I cannot understand that the Opposition can be aware of what is going on in Brussels by reading the quality financial newspapers and the Minister and his officials are not and have to reverse engines over a weekend when such matters are pointed out to them.

Comment on this

The Deputy should leave the Minister's officials out of it. Leave that out.

Comment on this

We should blame the Minister on his own then.

Comment on this

Make foolish political charges, but please do not bring officials into this.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Allow the Deputy to make his contribution, please.

Comment on this

I will not bring the officials into this if the Minister gives me a commitment that he will publish in advance of the election the report on the Department for Finance and whether it is fit for purpose. I am not going after officials. It was a passing remark, and facts are facts. If the Minister went to Brussels and did not know what he was doing, either he was to blame or he was not briefed. If the Minister wants to blame himself, I accept that fully and if he was fully briefed but had not the time or inclination to listen to his officials, that is grand.

Comment on this

They were foolish political charges; that is all they were.

Comment on this

They were not foolish political charges, and I can take him through it if he likes. Is he aware that an IMF team was in Spain a fortnight ago and that they are negotiating a low line of credit, which is in the IMF's remit? Is he aware that they are making special arrangements for the cajas in Spain, which somebody described to me as being the equivalent of 90 Irish Nationwides, with colossal insolvency problems, and yet they are getting money at a lower rate? Is he aware of proposals coming from Europe that moneys should be provided to the Irish and other authorities so they can buy their own debt? Is he aware that the senior bank debt we are pledged to redeem, at the moment, at 100% is being sold and discounted on the markets at 80%? Is he aware that what he has pledged to redeem, at100% is being held by hedge funds in New York, London and Luxembourg which stand to make a 25% capital gain on the basis of the commitment the Minister has given and stood back from, to redeem them all at par.

I accept we cannot act unilaterally on these issues, but at least the Minister should be aware of what is going on around him and should be in on the negotiations, because deals will be done. The policy is moving very rapidly and it seems the Irish Government is not even at the table. That was the final point I wanted to make. I do not have to read the piece on the script, but I believe the third piece of renegotiation we have to be involved in is with the holders of unguaranteed senior bank debt. They have to become involved in sharing the burden. It is a principle of capitalism that the rules of moral hazard apply to both borrowers and lenders. Those who lent recklessly and those who borrowed recklessly should share the burden. At present, the only person sharing the burden is the Irish taxpayer. If I may misquote "Hamlet", the Irish taxpayer was neither a borrower nor a lender in this context. Yet, the Irish taxpayer is picking up 100% of the Bill. That is unfair and it puts an unacceptable burden on the Irish Exchequer and the Irish taxpayer. Due to the arrangements entered into and because of commitments given, we cannot move unilaterally on this issue. However, we will seek to negotiate a better outcome and a more acceptable solution with our European partners, the EU institutions and, particularly, the European Central Bank. It is quite clear people are concerned across Europe about these matters. Representatives of eurozone countries, such as Prime Ministers and Ministers for Finance, are particularly concerned and there are several proposals of different status coming forward. There seems to be a consensus emerging that better solutions must be found. An incoming Government will make sure we are in there, within the context of our European colleagues, under the umbrella of Europe and the umbrella of the European Central Bank — the monetary authority — seeking to negotiate on behalf of the Irish taxpayer to get a better deal. We are pleased there is such a movement of policy in Europe.

We know it will not be easy. We are not trying to say a magic wand can be waved to sort things out. There is a negotiating position we should not miss. There is a negotiating opportunity we should not miss and Fine Gael, as part of the incoming Government, has no intention of missing it.

I refer to some of the amendments being introduced. The Minister referred to the universal social charge in his interview on the "News At One". The Minister was very lucid and explained his amendments very well. I welcome the amendment on the universal social charge. We would find the universal fully charge acceptable if the Minister increased the threshold so that it does not have an impact on persons with an income of only €4,000. The second charge on higher paid people is also acceptable to us. The second series of amendments are a package of exemptions that are being restricted or abolished. One concerns a patent royalty exemption. It was a little generous but I think the Minister should apply it at 50% rather than abolishing it completely. Those that develop new inventions and patent them are a small group of people with an intelligence I do not doubt. They have a creativity and intelligence we should treasure and abolishing the measure completely is the wrong way to go. It was too generous but perhaps the Minister can consider an amendment to reduce it to 50% rather than eliminating it completely.

We have all been lobbied on the property related tax expenditures. The Minister went too far on budget night and should have suspended the benefits of these during the period of readjustment, allowing people to enjoy them again five, six or seven years hence. There was always going to be a legal challenge because there was a legitimate expectation the contacts would be fulfilled.

I referred to the business expansion scheme. I cannot see why the Minister is importing material into the Bill that will cause him grief. Taking one month off the payment of taxes by self-employed people and bringing the effective date from October to September will cause much grief. It will leave many young accountants redundant from October to Christmas because they will have nothing to do. They will be twiddling their thumbs and they will be let go. The farming community is particularly irate about this. The measure gains nothing. It might make it easier for the tax flow to be predicted by the Minister's officials but there are plenty of sources of data that do this. The Minister is looking for grief for no return and I think he should drop it.

The tax on student fees is a similar imposition. It was not announced on budget night. I do not know where the recommendations, which have the effect of keeping the children of the less well-off out of college, are coming from. They are being repeated so often that it sounds as if they are ideologically based. I disagree with them. This was a good scheme and abolishing it cannot yield very much to the Department. Perhaps the Minister brought it in as a paper tiger so that he can drop it under pressure from Deputy Lowry and Deputy Healy Rae. If that is the case, I can understand it. If he really intends enshrining this in law I recommend that he takes it out because it will become a lightning conductor and cause political grief.

I thank the Minister for Finance. I wish him well in the contest tomorrow. I always found the Minister a most affable, reasonable person.

Comment on this

What about me?

Comment on this

And the Minister's curate.

Comment on this

The curate is in another parish.

Comment on this

He is no longer Deputy Willie O'Dea's curate; he is looking for a new parish.

Comment on this

I thank Deputy Noonan.

Comment on this

I also wish the Minister for Finance well. He is a constituency colleague of mine and, while I have disagreed vigorously with the Minister on policy and particularly on the handling of the crisis and the building boom, I have never doubted his personal integrity. Nor have I ever doubted the personal integrity of the Taoiseach. I disagreed with the Taoiseach's handling of the economy but he wanted to do the right thing. Unfortunately, it did not work out that way and it was a disaster for us.

My party's support for the timetable for this debate can in no way be interpreted as support for the content of the Bill. We opposed the budget proposed by Fianna Fáil and the Green Party and we put forward a detailed, costed alternative. This would have provided a desperately needed economic stimulus, jobs, growth and tax and public service reform. The Irish public finances face a double crisis. We have a budgetary crisis brought on by the disastrous economic policy followed for the entire past decade and the distortions created in the tax code to promote the construction boom and we have a bank resolution crisis that has proved incredibly costly by the inept way it has been handled by the Government right from the start.

A proper budget strategy would have faced both crises head on with a twin-track approach. Instead, Ministers persist in the delusion that one crisis can be decoupled from the other while the truth is that the continuing shadow of the bank guarantee haunts every move and frustrates every effort to secure a transition to a manageable budget deficit and a path to recovery that allows the domestic economy to expand and create jobs. All other parties in this House voted for the bank guarantee scheme, not just Fianna Fáil and the Green Party in government but also, unfortunately, Fine Gael and Sinn Féin. They voted for the bank guarantee scheme and they unleashed a tragic sequence of events. It will take years of hard, dedicated work to undo the damage to this country and generations of our people to come caused by that unthinking vote on the night of the guarantee.

Today, Allied Irish Bank had to bow to the inevitable and delist from the Stock Exchange, yet another monument to the failure of the Minister's banking strategy. AIB will need another €5 billion handout from taxpayers next month. The Finance Bill's weakness is the inherent imbalance and unfairness that lies at its heart. Ordinary citizens recognize that the public finances have to be brought into a more manageable state and that sacrifices have to be made to achieve that.

I have seen proposals from Independents and political parties that appear to offer only tax breaks and tax reductions and not contributions, which unfortunately are required from every citizen in this country, but when we recreate economic growth all our citizens, particularly those on lower incomes, can be the first to be the beneficiaries of the improved fortunes. Certainly, if the Labour Party has the honour to lead and serve in Government, that will be our absolute priority.

Ordinary citizens recognise the state of the public finances. They know that we must have money to pay our teachers, firemen, gardaí and nurses. What they cannot and will not accept is the overwhelming concentration of pain on families on low and modest incomes, whether they receive an income from work or welfare. This month, people are reeling from the impact of the universal social charge on their pay packets. I cannot understand why the Minister acted in such an underhand way in implementing this charge. While he mentioned it in the 2010 budget in December 2009, there was no White Paper, no consultation document, that would have allowed this new tax to be subject to preliminary discussion and scrutiny because it is no more than a tax by another name. Many of the detailed provisions of the charge are blatantly unfair, not least the perverse outcome that those on the very highest incomes come out of it with a net benefit.

I accept that the Minister has today relented in agreeing to a small concession for those with medical cards, although I wonder whether this has more to do with swaying members of the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Party than with easing the burden on taxpayers. Realising that a serious problem would arise in the levying of this new tax on medical card holders, I highlighted this on budget night but it is not the only one. I must also mention widows. I advise the Minister in the constituency that he and I share there are many not only older widows in receipt of social welfare incomes but, unfortunately because of the murder rate, road accidents and other tragedies, many younger widows. I ask the Minister to reflect on that when he brings in amendments tomorrow.

In regard to the universal social charge, I read the ESRI report, which was the only one that was done in a way that was cost neutral, which is very different from what the Minister did in the budget. When one calls a measure a universal social charge, there exists a principle whereby such a measure was originally called a universal social contribution. The idea of it dating back to the 1930s is that it was fundamentally linked to the concept of social insurance to provide that a working man or a working woman, having contributed during his or her working life through PRSI, or a stamp, as people use to call it a long time ago, or through a universal contribution, would get some benefit when they became ill and or unemployed, or retired. When the Minister decoupled the universal social charge from social insurance and made it a tax, he made a profound mistake and that is the reason he should have introduced a White Paper and carried out a cost-benefit analysis of how this charge would impact on people.

The Minister, Fianna Fáil and many parties in this House must recognise the change that has happened in Ireland, namely, that many younger people both want to be and must be self-employed because work patterns have changed enormously. If they are self-employed, either by choice or because that is the only structure that is available to them, and if they pay, as many have done, their social welfare contribution and PRSI, unfortunately if they become unemployed, they will have no fallback position and no entitlement. Many people who are self-employed are on very modest incomes of €25,000 or €35,000. The construction industry collapse has laid many of them low. There are people living in fairly large houses, particularly in the Leinster region and in other rural areas outside cities and towns, who sometimes have hardly the money to put a loaf of bread on the table because they have to pay off the mortgage and they have no entitlements to income support because of the fact that they are self-employed. Such provision would be costly, but it is one of the major reforms that will face a new Government in taking into account that 20%, 30% or 40% of our population will most likely be self-employed in future years.

Comment on this

We cannot envisage in this situation a country where a person who is self-employed not having a social insurance mechanism through the State, to provide a contribution for when that person becomes unemployed or ill. That is a fundamental mark of a social democratic society and it goes back to the Beveridge principles at the time of mass unemployment in the 1930s. Unfortunately, Fianna Fáil and the Green Party as they exit office have left this country with a mass unemployment problem of the kind that we never thought we would see again.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party presided over unemployment when in Government in 1987.

Comment on this

Parents are grieving——

Comment on this

It was up to 20% at that time.

Comment on this

——over the fact that their children have to go abroad — not to train, learn or gain work experience — and that many of them may end up making their homes, have families and live their lives abroad. When the Minister of State canvasses at the doorsteps, I am sure he will meet that grief of parents who only see their children come home at Christmas or for a family celebration. These are issues that every party in this House must face. If we are a society, a meitheal and a community, we must think about how we protect everyone who lives in this society.

We must create jobs and employment. If the Independents and those who are members of smaller parties, which consider themselves on the left in this House, want to feel angry with the Labour Party because we have been proposing job creation and reform that would take account of the changes in Irish society, I invite them to seriously think that these are challenges that we have to face, that there is not an easy answer and that there is a cost and a burden which must be shared in a fair way. That is a fundamental principle for the Labour Party. I would point that out to those people who consider themselves to be left wing and who believe the whole business can be torn down and somehow or other the money will be found to pay teachers, nurses and social welfare income without thinking it through.

The Minister has provided for an economic impact study on the curtailment of property-based tax reliefs and has kicked the can down the road in regard to the abolition of these reliefs. It seems that some of the lobbyists who are selling property-based tax schemes are accountants, some of them tax lawyers and some of them brokers. I have received, as I am sure every Member of this House has, letters from people organising these schemes, some in respect of charities for private hospitals and so on, and all I can say is that it was with remarkable ease that they could bend the ear of Fianna Fáil within a space of seven or eight weeks and have the change postponed. Measures for tax exiles were announced in December 2009 for the 2010 budget. They will not raise a single cent until this October and there is no target for what these fortunately wealthy people should contribute to the tax basis in Ireland's hour of need. If we are all in this together, we should all make a contribution. If we all make a contribution, we can keep the contributions and tax rates moderate and modest.

This thinking contrasts with that informing the universal social charge, which was announced on budget day. By contrast with the changes to the tax code in respect of tax exiles and the phasing out of the property-based tax reliefs, the universal social charge hit payslips from 1 January. People opening their payslips this month, including those retired on private and public service pensions, were shocked. A husband and wife on a public service or private pension of €40,000 per year must pay an extra €2,000 per month in taxes and through the universal social charge. If such people, who are probably between their late 50s and mid-60s, are in the VHI, as is quite likely, they will be paying an extra €800 or €900 per month out of their after-tax income to retain the health insurance coverage to which they subscribed faithfully for most of their working lives. What we need is a full social and economic impact assessment for the introduction of the universal social charge, particularly taking into account the impact on the low paid. I will be tabling a Committee Stage amendment to that effect.

Taxes require a basic sense of fairness to be accepted. Higher taxes are never popular and the swathe of new taxes and extra burdens on families that run through this Finance Bill leaves a very sour taste in the mouth. This is because the people rightly feel in their bones that all the revenue they raise will add nothing of value to the State but disappear into the black hole created by the banking bailout and the payments of the Fitzpatrick-Fingleton and NAMA debts.

For years, I have promoted one taxation principle in this House, that is, that tax rates should be as low and moderate as possible, and that everyone should pay his fair share. This Bill does nothing more than bowdlerise and distort that principle in a totally outrageous way. It brings many lower paid people into the tax net but fails completely to provide balance by requiring exactly the same principle to apply to those on much higher incomes.

When it dawned on the Minister that the universal social charge was desperately difficult for many on medical cards, which realisation I welcome, he responded by halving the rate applying to medical card holders, at a cost of approximately €80 million. He was able to achieve this by increasing, by an extra three percentage points, the universal social charge on those with an income of over €100,000.

As Fianna Fáil and the Green Party leave office, the higher rate of income tax of 41% and the standard universal social charge of 7% combine to give a standard rate of tax of 48%. When combined with the additional 3% applying to those earning over €100,000, the percentage amounts to 51%. The PRSI rate of 4% brings the figure to 55%. That is a very high marginal rate of tax.

Comment on this

The Labour Party is proposing over 60%.

Comment on this

I want to conclude. The Minister of State is wrong in saying that.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should be allowed to make her contribution.

Comment on this

That is the marginal rate in the Labour Party's policy.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister of State should allow every Member to make her contribution without interruption.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil cannot distort the disastrous circumstances in which it has left this country.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not misrepresent her own policy either.

Comment on this

The Minister of State can whinge however he likes but he should note that he and his party have left this country in an appallingly difficult position and ruined the employment and business prospects of many families and individuals through their disastrous bank bailout.

The income tax increases and the universal social charge introduced in this budget bring to 55% the top marginal rate for somebody earning over €100,000. The standard rate for those incurring a universal social charge of 4% to 5% has risen to 24% or 25%.

Comment on this

The Labour Party is proposing a higher rate.

Comment on this

No, we did not.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister of State should not shout down the Deputy.

Comment on this

We proposed no increase of any such scale. Except for people at the very high end of the scale, in respect of whom the Minister has introduced a change today, there is no scope for further tax increases, including for those on low and middle incomes. Perhaps there will be some agreement in the House in this regard. Fianna Fáil has hiked taxes to an extraordinary level through its changes.

What Fianna Fáil has done——

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should speak through the Chair.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil has left a range of loopholes——

Comment on this

That is extraordinary coming from the Labour Party.

Comment on this

——that allow people who are very wealthy to pay advisers to mitigate or reduce their effective rate of taxation.

The measures to dismantle the vast range of tax shelters are timid at best and some have shamefully been deferred until another day. As a barrister, the Minister must know the principle——

Comment on this

The Deputy is incorrect again.

Comment on this

——of fairness in regard to tax, yet he has left it to one side in preparing this Bill. Tax justice is absent from the Bill. On foot of the Bill, the little people will carry the burden, as always, and will be squeezed under every possible heading. They are being squeezed by the universal social charge and the reductions in tax credits and the minimum wage. Vast guaranteed sums are being paid every month to bank creditors while the people on the very highest incomes are protected and mollycoddled in every possible way.

Some €805 million is to be paid to bondholders of Anglo Irish Bank next week as their bonds mature. To put this in perspective, Irish taxpayers are, in a single month, forking out to professional investors in a bust bank almost the same amount as the total amount secured by welfare cuts introduced by Fianna Fáil for all of 2011. Therefore, there is no balance in the Bill, nor is there a genuine sense that we are all in it together.

We were promised measures to cut bank bonuses and place a confiscatory tax of 90% on them. However, this promise is absent in the Bill. It is silent on the pernicious practice of giving bonuses and the Department of Finance has been woefully ineffective in supervising bank bonus payment practices to the point where the Bank of Ireland has been able to withhold information on payments it has made since the State guarantee of September 2008. The Minister told me there is a very detailed and urgent investigation ongoing. In his reply, will he update us on the status of this investigation?

When it comes to choosing between the bankers with their bonuses and their inflated salaries and the young unemployed, and between universal charges for the many and tax havens for the few, I know which side I and the Labour Party are on. The Minister said in his speech that everyone must pay according to his means, yet this Finance Bill maintains all the distortions that diminish progressive taxation and even exacerbate some of them further.

The news from the United Kingdom this morning must give us all pause for thought.

The general consensus is that economic growth will slow, but that there will still be a general small increase. Britain's economy suffered a shock 0.5% contraction in the last three months of 2010 before the full impact of new taxes and spending cuts become apparent.

The central charge against this style of austerity politics is that it hinders the essential need to foster growth. Austerity as the sole component of policy is the naked triumph of ideology over economic pragmatism. The public who must endure falling living standards, higher taxes and rising unemployment rates may well be sceptical that there is any prospect of future growth if the policy is as unsuccessful as shown in today's UK results. This is the reason for the extraordinary level of saving and paying down of debt in Ireland. People are afraid to spend due to austerity measures and cuts. The economy is desperately vulnerable and fragile. The need for a plan B must dominate the election debate. We have had enough of the tired old mantras, namely, that there is no alternative and that Fianna Fáil's plan is the only game in town.

Regarding the EU-IMF deal and our banking crisis, the latter of which is well over three years old, the Government has rubbished thoughtful contributions from a host of commentators, such as William Hutton, Joe Stiglitz and Simon Johnson, who have concluded that the terms of the EU-IMF deal are impossibly onerous for Ireland. Renegotiating a better deal for Ireland must be the immediate priority of the next Government.

To address those who did not want a Finance Bill to pass, Ireland shipped an incredible amount of negative comment in the international press during the past week or two. Some of it bordered on the racist and some of it reminded me of 19th century Punch and Judy cartoons. The Labour Party took the view that, if the Dáil so voted, the Finance Bill should be passed by Saturday night and the people should then be given their vote in a general election. Foremost in my mind as I went to meet the Minister for Finance and delegations from other parties yesterday afternoon was my desire to not have to see yet another Sunday of negative commentary, as that is the big day for economic and political commentary on American television and radio. After last Sunday, I received numerous calls from friends and business people who I know in the US asking me whether we were okay.

There is a reason to proceed with this debate. Labour opposes the Bill, but it must be debated on the floor of the House to show our friends in the US and elsewhere, particularly friends who may be interested in investing in Ireland and employing some of our well educated young people, that we have a functioning democracy, albeit one that needs a great deal of reform, and are capable of ordering our affairs.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I remind the Deputy that she has two minutes remaining.

Comment on this

A new Government can renegotiate the terms of the EU-IMF bailout. We are paying a penalty interest rate on the EU elements of the package. Where in the EU treaties is provision made for countries to pay penalty interest rates? This morning, the IMF issued a welcome statement in its updated Global Financial Stability Report. The IMF highlighted the "adverse sovereign-financial loop" where the effect of sovereign governments using taxpayers' money as a backstop for bank losses is to undermine the ability of the sovereign to fund itself. The IMF and others have already begun to outline a series of actions and measures, such as buying back debt, lowering interest rates and lengthening the timeframes of packages, to allow EU countries to deal with this grave crisis in a collective and cohesive manner.

The bond markets are reviewing the debt exposure of all countries. The Fianna Fáil-Green Party Government and the Fine Gael and Sinn Féin parties, which unfortunately voted for the bank guarantee——

Comment on this

——made a fatal decision to join the debts of Irish banks to the hip of the sovereign State on the night of the guarantee. This has damaged our credit rating. If people do us the honour of voting for a Labour-led Government, we will spend morning, noon and night renegotiating the terms in conjunction with allies throughout the EU to make the social democratic model of good public services and strong private sectors possible. This would provide work and business so that people could prosper. This is what the next election will be about and it is the basis of the mandate the Labour Party will be seeking when the people vote in the next three to four weeks.

Comment on this

I am glad that we were able to order our business to debate and, I hope, pass this Bill into legislation by the weekend. It is significant that four parties in the House were able to come together to agree in this respect. After the budget, I told the House that it was time we started acting as a parliament with a certain respect for all parties. In my ten years as a Deputy, it has been my experience that there are good people and people with failings in each party, including my own. We do not do our work or the role of politics a service by tearing lumps out of one another. There are benefits to showing that we can work together in the common national interest. Yesterday was the best example of this. It was a critical moment, given the risk that we would fluff it and bring the Parliament down in a way that would have added to people's dismay about recent political developments. That the Fianna Fáil Party was able to compromise backs up the Taoiseach's statement this morning that his motivation is to conclude this task, which arises because of the economic crisis and the mistakes of recent years.

I thank the Fine Gael Party for its swift response to the approaches we made to it this afternoon. We were seeking a way to step back from the party political point-scoring game in which parties were becoming embroiled. We sought a mechanism that would allow a debate in which we could air our differences, but through which we could also reach a common understanding that the Finance Bill must pass.

I listened to Deputy Burton with interest. It is possible that the electorate will return a result that will see the Labour Party take part in government. We should not be categoric in this regard because nothing is certain. The people are uncertain about politics. As my party leader, Deputy Gormley, stated, we should have an honest election in which different alternatives are set out.

In that regard the Labour Party also realised yesterday that the time for the politics of anger is coming to an end. It is time for plan B and the politics of outrage and anger is not that plan. Despite the difficult circumstances, any Member who has the good fortune to be appointed a Minister in Government — I recommend that anyone offered a place should take it — will be forced to operate in a very different financial situation. The actions of the Opposition parties yesterday and today show they are beginning to realise this.

It is important that this Finance Bill is passed as it will help to create an economic environment which may help a new Government as work remains to be done and real risks and challenges still exist. If that job is to be done well, it will not be easy as a new budgetary process will have to begin. Time is short. The country must enter into international negotiations and continue to complete the work of restoring our banking system which is a priority. Reform of the public service is also a priority so that public money is used well. However, it will not be easy to do this while at the same time reconfiguring the budget, particularly when there is a clear divergence of view between the Labour Party position — which is to increase taxes more than to cut spending and the Fine Gael position which is to cut spending more than increase taxes. I do not know how this divergence can be overcome. If those parties form the next Government — because nothing is ever certain — I wonder how they will try to resolve that contradictory position which would be damaging to the country. It could delay the other important work that needs to be done. I presume this reality is what caused yesterday's coming together with a compromise from all parties which has enabled the House to deal with the Finance Bill and, hopefully, given the numbers, to pass it this weekend.

Before dealing with the details of the Bill, I will outline the broad economic context. Last year was an extraordinary and very difficult time, in particular for our people who have lost jobs, had their incomes cut and seen their children emigrate which is what hurts the Irish psyche most. We have seen emigration too often and for too long. We must stop emigration by means of good and clever politics.

One year ago the country was in a much better position. The economic prognosis was reasonably positive compared to what it had been the previous year when we had faced an immediate banking and liquidity crisis. A year ago it seemed that this had abated somewhat as a result of budgetary decisions taken the previous year and the decisions about the banks which were taking effect. Our bond spreads had come down, market confidence was restored and favourable international comment was increasing. However, this situation was reversed in the past eight or nine months. I refer to the Greek debt crisis which showed the scale of the European banking crisis. Ireland is an integral part of the European banking system and its part in the broader European banking crisis was much more significant than people may have realised. The wider economic and banking problem as a result of excess debt and leveraging affected Ireland very negatively. The delay, along with the increasing scale of difficulty associated with the likes of Anglo Irish Bank, further damaged confidence during last summer and early autumn.

Deputy Burton may have different views but I am not sure what her solutions are. In the past two and a half years I have never understood what the Labour Party would have done differently. Deputy Burton may have disagreed with the bank guarantee but it was a question of what to do when faced with the prospect of the banks being unable to open the next morning. It is all very well to say that they would not have decided on a guarantee for the banks but every other party supported it, including Sinn Féin and Fine Gael. What would have happened if those banks could not open? I have listened intently to hear what the alternative is but it has never been clear to me.

It is interesting that those coming from outside the country, the IMF, the European Central Bank or others, are broadly saying that the approach to the banking system was correct, that it took a standard formula of guarantee ——

Comment on this

They are not saying that.

Comment on this

——asset sale or asset management and capitalisation. Their criticism is that it was not done quickly enough and they could be right. It took a long time for the legislation to be passed and it took a long time to deal with the European Commission and to agree on what should be done with the likes of Anglo Irish Bank. The Green Party view, which was expressed last summer, is that it would be better to shut it down and I am pleased this is what has happened. However, there could be valid criticism that the delay, that timeline of six or nine months, in the process of the policy approach, further eroded confidence, given the increasing scale of the Anglo Irish Bank losses, which were horrific.

I watched a television programme last night and a person in the audience said that the country is in debt to the tune of €180 billion. I understand why people quote the debt figures which we will be paying off. In my view, we need to be careful because one of the processes that will need to be concluded soon is the further testing of the banks' balance sheets, the loan portfolios. From what I am told by those who have come here from the EU, the IMF and the ECB, the testing done last year by the Financial Regulator and the Central Bank is holding up and is regarded as very accurate. When such large figures of losses are mentioned I can understand that, given what has happened in Anglo Irish Bank, AIB and other banks, people fear the worst. However, it may not be as bad as feared when the detailed assessment of loans is completed. This may give a certain reassurance and provide more clarity as regards our level of debt to be repaid.

The uncertainty caused by the Greek debt crisis, and the delay with regard to the Anglo Irish Bank crisis, created uncertainty regarding the position of how bonds should be treated. Last autumn, the German Chancellor made some valid points in her comments that Ireland would have to look at the status of sovereign debt. These comments had a profound and immediate effect on confidence in our own debt position. The combination of those three events led to our difficulties in the autumn and the arrival of the EU and IMF, which I deeply regret and which shocked me at the time. As someone described it to me, it was like breaking up with a girlfriend, that feeling of sadness and shock. This was the foundation for the Green Party's decision that it was better to have an election, to try to overcome that shock and to reconfigure the path. We said that we had a critical duty, in the middle of a banking crisis that had to be resolved, not to call for an immediate general election because it would have been impossible to resolve the immediate banking crisis — which has now stabilised — and to complete the budget process.

That budget process and the four year plan had been carried out by ourselves alone without any outside advice. I was engaged in the process which was methodical and drawn out over several months in order to steer the country out of the economic difficulties. Over the past four years I have gained some experience in a variety of budgets beginning in 2007 when it was business as usual and similar to previous years. It was possible then to increase social welfare spending and that of other big Departments. Most parties in the House supported those measures. I saw the difficulties and the mistakes made in 2008 because of rushed legislation but I also saw the ability of a Cabinet of 15 people to work through a budget in 2009. This was very difficult but it benefited from the redrafting and redrawing and the questioning that the budget process allows. This process was repeated in 2010. The budget and the four year plan are products of this. While there will be disagreements and people will have different views, I challenge any group of 15 Members of the House to put together a budget which requires a €6 billion cut without making difficult decisions. I was proud the budgets in 2008 and 2009 were described by outside parties as being progressive in taxation terms. They very much pushed the tax burden on the wealthy rather than on those on the lower income spectrum. I find it very difficult to support provisions in the Bill bringing those on lower incomes into our tax system and cutting social welfare. It goes against the grain of the Green Party because we believe a society that is more equal in its pay is more stable and successful. Therefore, it is not easy to do this. However, I challenge anyone to show honestly how it is possible for us to start balancing our budget without having to take some of these measures.

Recently, the Governor of the Central Bank, Professor Patrick Honohan, spoke at an Institute of International and European Affairs event. He showed very clearly that the crisis and our economic difficulties are not purely to do with the banking crisis. There is an element of debt payment and difficulties with regard to it about which we will have to be clever as we manage it, but ultimately there was a fundamental mismatch in our tax and revenues because of tax and spending decisions over the past ten years that were not long term in their thinking and unsustainable. The Governor of the Central Bank stated that even if we did not have the banking crisis, a very difficult adjustment would still have to be made. The Finance Bill is a further step in meeting this challenge and it is one I support because I do not see an easier alternative.

Yesterday morning, I participated in a programme with Deputy Pearse Doherty and I told the Sinn Féin representative that he is complaining about cuts here but Sinn Féin is implementing cuts in the North. Deputy Doherty understandably replied that there they do not have the ability to raise taxes, as is the case. I will hold up this lack of experience for analysis. I hear an argument that this adjustment can be made by taxing higher income but I am afraid it is not credible. The amount of money that must be raised is not there. When we look at how much we need, we see it cannot all be raised through the very nice concept of a wealth tax.

Comment on this

Not on its own.

Comment on this

It is not there. Perhaps it is only through experience in government and having to look at and make such decisions and seeing where the money is and how one can get it that it starts to become apparent. Perhaps this lack of experience in the North of having to raise revenue means it is very easy not to——

Comment on this

Many economists agree with us.

Comment on this

They may but I am afraid that, with respect, I do not. I would also say, with respect, that it may come from——

Comment on this

That might be a good thing given your experience.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should refer their remarks through the Chair.

Comment on this

——an analysis that our entire capitalist global market system is wrong and we should break from it. This is a valid analysis. There could well be left-wing analysis on the modern capitalist market system showing that it is unfair and needs to be challenged. The difficulty we have with being able to impose a very high rate of tax while expecting to continue to bring in income and maintain employment in an absolutely mobile world where people can travel is, particularly for this country with its small open economy that depends on trade for employment, that we live and depend on the globalised market economy. Internet and financial services businesses are mobile to an extent that was not possible even five or ten years ago. I respect Sinn Féin's logical position that it does not agree with the world capitalist model system and I understand that. However, the reality of challenging it and stating Ireland is stepping off and taking a completely different approach bears a huge risk of even greater unemployment.

Comment on this

Pardon, Deputy Morgan?

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Through the Chair.

Comment on this

I am enjoying the lecture.

Comment on this

I am just giving my view and participating in a debate, with respect.

Comment on this
Brendan Howlin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Through the Chair.

Comment on this

Today, I listened to the Minister for Finance. We had a view on the progressive measures included in the legislation on decreasing inheritance tax and decreasing the favourable terms for the wealthy to avoid tax through pension schemes and on section 23 reliefs. Many reliefs will be removed through this legislation, which is important. To be honest, we were concerned that the economic assessment of section 23 should not preclude the introduction of such taxes this year and I was pleased to hear the Minister of Finance in response to an earlier question indicate, from my understanding of his comments, that he intends to introduce an amendment to make this possible. This is important to the Green Party. It is a recognition that we must be progressive and look to the wealthy people in society to pay their fair contribution. This is an important development.

I listened to what was stated earlier about the international negotiations and we must negotiate. From my experience and previous position in government, there was no lack of willingness to consider some of the measures mentioned earlier in terms of sharing the costs of bank debt. The difficulty was that we ran up against those international constraints and the fact is that we operate with huge ECB support. That support is very beneficial and kept us going through a real crisis, but it would have been threatened had we taken a unilateral course of action that could have been very risky and difficult. We sought that support and negotiated for it. If Deputy Burton is in such a position and can do it, I will wish her well and will support it, as other Deputies stated. However, she should be careful about promising in advance what may not be easily achieved. Let us go to international negotiations and examine what is happening in Spain and other countries and work in the European Union for a favourable outcome and renegotiate any debt position. I would fully support this. We would do this in a far better stead and in a much better negotiating position if we pass the Finance Bill because it would show that we are serious, can get our budget together and are capable of getting out of the economic difficulties we are in at present. This would put us into the best negotiating position possible and this is why I ask Members to support the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Ba mhaith liom mo chuid ama a roinnt leis na Teachtaí Finian McGrath agus Maureen O'Sullivan.

The introduction of the Bill is seen by the entire public as a farce given what has happened in recent days. The politics that created the current economic mess cannot bring us out of it. Those politics are the politics of both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael — the politics of cronyism and inequality and the politics that believe in dismantling public services, cutting incomes, socialising debt, privatising profit and deflating the economy.

These politics and economics will not deliver jobs for the unemployed, which should be our primary focus. They will not see the current crisis being used as an opportunity to build something better and fairer. They will see the gap between poverty and privilege widen. This is not a Finance Bill. It is a depressing end-product of a Government whose political career spans some of the most disastrous economic policies ever witnessed not only in this State, but throughout the world.

Comment on this

Every decision the Government has made over the past three years has compounded the economic crisis. The introduction and extension of the banking guarantee, the nationalising of the corrupt Anglo Irish Bank, the NAMA decision, the recapitalisation of the main banks without nationalising them, entering into the EU-IMF package to bail out the banks of Europe and the decision to pursue a deflationary cutting approach to public finances as opposed to a stimulus are all wrong and have compounded the economic crisis we are in now.

The Government has failed to protect the vulnerable and, most importantly in terms of ensuring economic growth, it is penalising rather than rewarding working families. Even worse is that hundreds of thousands of working families whose effort drives the economy have all but been abandoned in this Bill. They have been condemned to enduring higher taxes and more stealth charges, all to fund the policies of failure.

The Finance Bill is complicated legislation which affects every person in the State by levying tax on our citizens. It introduces charges and levies not mentioned in the budget, including new powers for Revenue, earlier tax payment dates for taxpayers and curtailment of existing tax reliefs such as the relief on fees paid for third level education.

It may seem astonishing that we face such economic and social deficits after 15 years of boom but these are the consequences of pursuing a failed low tax, low spend model which sought short-term gains from the speculative activity of a small but powerful golden circle. Choices were made in the late 1990s and in the early 2000s by Fianna Fáil that diverted the economy away from industrial upgrading and new investment priorities onto a path of speculative booms, a weakening tax base and public finances that were dependent on boom-time growth rates. Now, before the last curtain falls, Fianna Fáil is rushing through a stale Finance Bill which enshrines the vested interests of the well-off, developers and speculators.

We in Sinn Féin, unlike Fianna Fáil, the Green Party, Fine Gael and Labour, realise that it is not possible to reduce the deficit by adding to the dole queues, it is not possible to stimulate the domestic economy by cutting incomes and it is not possible to claim to represent the best interests of people by facilitating the passage of this disastrous Finance Bill. The charade this week by Fine Gael and Labour highlights their contempt for the people of this State. The Government is in minority and a motion of no confidence would have been the straw to break the camel's back. We would have got the general election the people are desperately demanding. Why the sense of urgency to push through the Finance Bill when the so-called Opposition parties are so opposed to it? It would be funny if the consequences were not so devastating for ordinary people.

Since 2007, Fine Gael and Labour have been scorning the Green Party for its acquiescence with Fianna Fáil in some of the most economically and socially crippling decisions ever seen in this State. They singled out Green Party backbenchers for their unfettered support, but at least they were upfront. Fine Gael and Labour have cheated the people by agreeing to facilitate the passage of this Bill. It is clear from Labour Party comments today that the negotiations for the programme for government have already started with the Labour Party already abandoning its pre-budget proposal to introduce a higher rate of tax on higher income earners. That makes Fine Gael and Labour equally culpable for the savage measures in this budget.

No party disputed yesterday the need for the introduction of a finance Bill after the general election to address the outstanding issues on civil partnership. Why not wait until after the general election to introduce a new finance Bill, one based on an electoral mandate which would be a single Bill addressing all the pertinent issues? When the whole country is screaming for political reform and when the Government has no mandate and the people want to see it put out, it is absolutely disgusting that the larger Opposition parties are rowing in behind Fianna Fáil to kick the people one last time. The people of this State want change. They do not want Tweedledee substituted for Tweedledum. There is no longer room for this type of politics in Ireland because we simply cannot afford it. The Opposition parties are trying to play both sides, but yesterday they were outed for the political frauds they really are. The Oxford English Dictionary defines to oppose as “To contend, fight, or argue against; to be antagonistic or hostile to; to resist or obstruct (a thing, person, action, etc.)”. Fine Gael and Labour neither resisted nor obstructed.

We have also heard the usual scaremongering from the Opposition benches. If this Bill does not go through as soon as possible, it will upset the EU-IMF apple cart. Heaven forbid that we do not draw down the rest of that funding for the banks so that generations of people, born and unborn, will be subject to levels of debt unseen here for many years. Heaven forbid that all those bondholders who gambled on our banks do not get paid. Heaven forbid that we get to re-evaluate the funding requirements of the State and re-evaluate our priorities. Do we live in a market or do we live in a democracy? The Government that negotiated this deal has collapsed and the lead party has imploded. We should scrap the business of the House, scrap this Bill and call an immediate general election. Let the people have their say. We are their representatives, not the representatives of the markets.

The purpose of the tax system is to collect finances to run the State, including providing services such health, education, justice and social welfare. A good tax system is fair — it taxes those who can afford it most and asks for less from those who cannot afford it. Our tax system has been undermined as a result of changes introduced by successive governments leaving us in a position where the tax take is insufficient to fund basic public services. Fianna Fáil has steadily reduced direct taxation on the better off, while increasing flat taxes, which is regressive and impacts most on ordinary people. At a time when economic activity has hit the floor and when the domestic economy is reliant on consumption and spending, why is the Minister stymieing the spending power of the very households that can ease the recession? Cutting the incomes of those who spend everything takes money out of the real economy and creates a negative spiral which in turn leads to decreased consumer spending, lowered income and profits, leading to falling PAYE and VAT receipts, leading to more tax hikes and more job losses.

While the Government has been transfixed with reducing incomes at the bottom, what will not move down is the value of the debts incurred by households. With lower incomes but the same mortgages and consumer debts, many families will be forced to default and face home repossession. Sinn Féin believes in providing high quality, free at the point of delivery public services and these must be paid for.

This State does not have a spending problem in its structural finances; it has a tax-raising and retention problem. Many people made vast fortunes during the Celtic tiger era, much of which was under-taxed owing to the extent of tax breaks introduced by successive governments. One of the biggest spins being pedalled by the Government is that we must extend the tax system to those who do not pay any tax, which compounds the ignorance of the Irish tax structure. Let us set one record straight: Ireland relies disproportionately on indirect taxation and always has. In 2000, indirect taxes made up 43% of all tax revenue; in 2008 it made up 42%. Given that indirect taxation is more regressive, it is clear that the Irish taxation system is regressive. This indirect and unreliable taxation system created the bubble and when it burst, it had no capacity to lift us out of the crisis.

The introduction of a universal social charge in the budget and the lowering of the tax bands to bring more people into the tax net and more lower earners into the marginal higher tax rate of 41% has unfairly targeted the least well off for tax increases. The decision to abolish the income levy and health levy and create a universal charge is a step backwards, which will drag those earning as little as €80 into the tax net.

The tax changes in this Bill are across the board and fail to target those who have the ability to pay, which is a big mistake and one that will be damaging for the economy and for consumer spending. We have outlined many changes that could have been introduced, but unfortunately I do not have the time to go through them here. It is clear that the axe has fallen where it poses least risk to the electoral fortunes of Fianna Fáil. A callous decision has been made to protect those who vote for and finance Fianna Fáil. The Bill stipulates that the key property restrictions can only be applied after an impact assessment is undertaken. Not only that, but it also provides for an interval after this assessment, presumably to allow for any adjustments to be made which may arise from it. It is an outrage.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tá an t-am caite.

Comment on this

I shall finish on this point. It is an outrage that the curtailment of property tax announced in this budget has been deferred while the measures that will have the biggest impact on the least well-off have not been given any consideration as to their economic impact and will have immediate effect. This Finance Bill is a disaster and a political fraud has been enacted by Fine Gael and the Labour Party to pretend they are opposed to the Bill. At the meeting they told me and the Minister very clearly they want to see the Finance Bill passed.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Finian McGrath has three minutes.

Comment on this

I thought there were four minutes for each speaker.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, the Deputy has three minutes and there are three for Deputy O'Sullivan.

Comment on this

We had 12 minutes which, with eight, makes 20 minutes.

Comment on this
Mary O'Rourke Deputy Mary O’Rourke Fianna Fáil

Five and five.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We will clarify it and move along.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the minute is available then Deputy McGrath may avail of it.

Comment on this