Finance Bill 2011: Second Stage
Contributions 115–222 of 222. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 2011 ›
I thank the Ceann Comhairle for the opportunity to speak in this important debate on the Finance Bill. Before I go into the details of the income levy, the universal social charge, income tax, corporation and capital gains tax it is important to state I am completely disillusioned, disgusted and appalled by recent events in Irish politics. I do not blame any one person for our economic crisis. There is a collective guilt among the Cabinet, some bankers, some developers and greedy sections of Irish society who have left politicians to fix up the mess. People tell me they are appalled by what has happened to the economy and the future development of the country. They demand reform and leadership from politicians. Our people are crying out for sensible solutions not petty political point scoring or insulting jibes thrown at other politicians.
I say to Deputy Shortall or any other politician it is a total insult to describe other Deputies as a "rag-bag".
Comment on this
It is offensive and degrading and insults the vast majority of Independent Deputies, councillors and candidates who are trying to serve our people and our country. Deputy Shortall should withdraw those remarks and with a bit of luck she might have a good, credible, Independent candidate running against her in the coming election.
Section 3 of the Finance Bill provides for the introduction of the universal social charge effective from 1 January 2011. It is proposed to impose on an individualised basis a charge of 2% on income up to and including €10,036, a charge of 4% for income in excess of €10,036 but not greater than €16,000, and a charge of 7% thereafter. The charge will apply to all income in a similar manner to the Tax Acts but including certain income which is statutory exempt from income tax. The charge will be applied before granted relief for pension contributions. Payments from the Department of Social Protection and a number of other similar payments made by other Departments as well as similar payments from other State estates will be excluded. I welcome that.
In regard to the broader issue of the economy there is some hypocrisy on the part of some political parties in this House. When we talk about trying to get out of this economic mess, jobs must be an important priority. Let us look at those people who recently began to spend a great deal of money on posters and leaflets. I challenge those who import such materials at a cheap cost to support small local Irish businesses. Let us have some practical economic patriotism at this time.
Comment on this
As part of the resolution regarding jobs, I would love to see a quality public service and supports for our small businesses. That is a crucial and essential point in this debate. One can see the impact of the new universal social charge and the reduction in tax credits. I am very worried that deposits are moving out of Irish banks and we also need to deal with this. People are fearful and when that is the case they lose consumer confidence. It is important to say this in the debate.
I hear a great deal about talks and renegotiation. I ask those who present such arguments where is the beef and where are the details.
I welcome the anti-tax-evasion powers of Revenue and the extension of such powers, which are positive points in the Bill. However, I have major concerns about the Bill. I have listened to many views on it but cannot support the legislation. I urge every Member to think again.
Comment on this
I, too, was supposed to have four but we will see. I thank Sinn Féin for sharing time with Deputy McGrath and me. It is an acknowledgment of how the seven of us have worked together and co-operated in the Technical Group in which now——
Comment on this
——due to a technical point we are precluded from speaking as that group. Speaking as a member of the so-called rag-bag collection of Independents, I wish to refer to my predecessor, the late Tony Gregory, who was one of the finest Deputies this House has seen. He was a man of principle and integrity and was guided by principles of fairness and justice. He was consistently returned in local and national elections for some 30 years. I find it very insulting to hear that word used in his regard.
Comment on this
It also insults the electorate which chose to vote for an Independent candidate.
I voted against the budget before Christmas and, being consistent, will vote against the Finance Bill. I accept we need money because the consequences of not having it are too appalling to imagine but there are too many harsh conditions attached to the Bill by the IMF and the European Central Bank. It is the IMF whose actions contributed to the destruction of economies in Africa, Asia and South America and seriously damaged the lives of people by its policy conditions. Its role has been to oversee the transfer of wealth from ordinary people to corporate interests.
This Finance Bill will lock us into a specific economic model, removing aspects of economic decision making. I do not see in this Bill a commitment to holding on to our natural resources — the Corrib gas field and our forests. I do not see the wealthy being unduly affected but I see severe cuts for the poor. I do not see a complete elimination of bonuses, excessive salaries and expenses and am not convinced that all tax loopholes have been closed. Those with disabilities are still living in fear, suffering the effects of current cuts and still fearing further cuts. The universal social charge has been causing major difficulty. I acknowledge the change made for those on medical cards.
Where is the insurance for those struggling with mortgages when those with several properties, bought to avail of tax relief, are being looked after? Where are the provisions for tax exiles to pay their just contribution? More people are being drawn into poverty yet €68.8 billion went to senior bondholders and €1.4 billion to subordinated bondholders. Why are these gamblers and speculators being cushioned from losses? Did they share the good times when they were making massive profits?
There has been no mention by anybody as to whether our corporation tax is fair. Where are the commitments and aspects of heritage towards ensuring, for example, proper and fitting preservation of the battlefield site of the Easter Rising for its 100th anniversary, a defining moment in our history?
I have sat here for a year and a half and listened to objections to Bills being guillotined. This most significant Bill is being facilitated by the main political parties through a type of guillotine.
Comment on this
The people should have been given their say on this and not only in the forthcoming election when the Bill will have been passed. It is the harshest budget in the history of our State and severe austerity faces us in the coming three years, perhaps for longer. The Celtic tiger is well and truly dead, replaced now by unemployment, poverty and emigration. More than €20 billion of the pension fund — working people's money — is gone.
Comment on this
It is reckoned that the Corrib gas field alone is worth considerably more than €420 billion, and there is possibly more gas and oil off our coast. What did our Government do? It gave it away to Royal Dutch Shell. Taxpayers' money went into the banks and it would now appear there is more concern for the bankers, developers and bondholders than for the ordinary people of this country.
Comment on this
I do not know whether I want them all. Deputy O'Sullivan might have had five minutes of my time.
It is not a bad idea that the Bill is being truncated. On many occasions in which I and others spoke on such Bills we went on and on, waffled and woofed and did everything we could to delay matters. This has concentrated minds wonderfully.
It has also brought forward a measure for which I am particularly glad, namely, the change to the universal social contract. When the Minister announced in his Budget Speech the universal social contract it had a benign ring to it. "Universal" meant all over. "Social" was a nice word and "contract" another nice word. I read it but knew there was more to it than met the eye. I certainly found this out when the first week in January came around or whenever the first wage packets hit people. The charge hit people on low incomes in particular. Soon enough the thread came through to everybody in the shape of the medical card. If one had a medical card one had been exempted from the health levy but suddenly the universal social charge with all its benign — not benign implications hit everybody.
I am sure there was not one Deputy in the House, wherever we sit, who did not make strong representations for an amelioration of the universal social charge. I am glad the measure has been thus ameliorated, as has been laid out in the Minister's speech. He states that the charge was introduced for a specific reason and there are two amendments, with those in receipt of a medical card seeing the top rate of the contribution reduced from 7% to 4%, the same as for persons over 70. The new rate will apply at 2% on income up to and including €10,000 and 4% on income above that amount. This move is welcome and I am very glad to see it. I am quite sure everybody in this House will contact the people who have been lobbying in regard to the issue, telling them of the change in the measure.
This may be the last full debate in this Dáil as this stage of the Finance Bill will be followed by Committee and Remaining Stages before hearing recommendations from the Seanad. After that we will be gone as if we had never been here. This Dáil would have lasted four years by next May, so we are now a year and three months short of the maximum tenure allowed. That is not too bad a distance to have run.
On an occasion such as this, when speaking about a finance Bill and the end of a time within the Dáil, we hear of so many Deputies retiring or deciding not to go forward for election. Many such people have medical reasons for this and I sympathise with them; if doctors have outlined the implications of undertaking a rigorous election campaign followed by a further stint in Leinster House, they should follow that advice. Many such people have children and families and are quite right to take the steps they did.
We do not know why the majority of the other Members are retiring. I do not believe it is because they are afraid of the fray as people in public life should not be afraid like that. I love the fray and I have done a certain amount of canvassing.
Comment on this
The Deputy frightened Senator Cassidy anyway.
Comment on this
That was an aberration which should not have happened. It was my fault entirely and that of the Fianna Fáil headquarters, which did not allow me outside the bridge in Athlone. That was an amazing direction but I have come a long and hard road since. There is much debate on the radio and elsewhere concerning new ideas from some wonderful people, like Ms Elaine Byrne, for whom I have great admiration. She is a young woman in Trinity College and is among the people who give of their opinions about democracy.
Somehow these people envisage a democracy that is not about knocking on doors and asking for votes; it is airy-fairy and nebulous, hypothesising that there should be some other way of getting elected. There is no other way than looking for votes, which is the most basic and proper way of electioneering. I am not referring to Ms Byrne in particular as she is just an example. She wrote a very interesting article recently in The Irish Times in which I believe her tongue was in her cheek. She argued in the article that political creativity, like sex, is best left to the young. It was hilarious. As somebody much older than her I hope her sex urge lasts until she is older; it would be too bad if there came an age when she would be told that she had to stop. My goodness, we would be living in Gestapo country in that case. That is why I believe her tongue was in her cheek.
The point of the article was that we need political creativity, which may have to be left to a bunch of young people. I do not know about the fuss concerning young people. There was great twittering from Ógra Fianna Fáil but I did not see anything happening or any members putting their names forward. I did not notice them enamoured of the political scene or vice versa. Ms Byrne described William Butler Yeats in the article, who in his sixties had a sex operation. She did not state that but mentioned that when he had the operation he got a great rush of new poetic creativity; she forgot to say he was in his sixties when he had the operation.
This is not an out-of-kilter debate but is quite relevant in light of all the talk and trite debate which has gone on about a new type of democracy. It seems people will not be elected but will be plucked from the wonderful world of business and commerce and be plonked into ministries. If that had been the way five years ago, Seán FitzPatrick could well have been Minister for Finance or head of some other body. That would be if he was not deemed by some to be past it and to have lost political creativity.
There is much talk about how one cannot be a legislator and attend to local issues. That is not true, although much hard work is required. I know Deputy Arthur Morgan very well and he has fulfilled his obligations as finance spokesperson for Sinn Féin to his great credit. From people I know, it is clear he has also attended to his constituency duties. I have no truck with those who decry clientelism, as it is mentioned in a denigrating fashion. People ask why Deputies should look after people's rights or take up a cause when they should be thumping a table, putting forward amendments and speaking to legislation. We should do this but there must be balance that takes in constituency work, dealing with people before coming to this Chamber to do the national business. In modesty, it is what I have tried to do for the past four years. It can and should be done in this fashion.
Why should politicians suddenly lose touch with local people when they come to Dáil Éireann? I saw a big headline in the Irish Independent where the reporter indicated that she did not want to see a politician at her funeral. She would not see it anyway but her nearest and dearest might. I go to a funeral if I know the person who has passed away very well and count myself among his or her friends. I do not go fumbling at a coffin outside but I go to mass five minutes before it commences and hear it in its entirety because I wish to do so. I may speak to whomever I wish to before going home. The idea of the declamatory article was that there should be no politician at a funeral; this means a Deputy would not be allowed to do local duties in tandem with national duties, as that is for awful plebs.
The argument is that we should be in the Oireachtas the whole time and not be any way older if involved in politics. One seems to have to be young to be creative. It seems that even when a person passes away who is a very dear friend, a politician should not attend the funeral. We have allowed ourselves to be trampled upon by these people with so-called ideas. Ideas my eye, I have plenty of ideas. That has nothing to do with my age as I will always have ideas. I am always curious and inquisitive. I want to find out what is happening, although not through tittle-tattle but rather through what is good and proper in public life.
Those of us who have survived a considerable period in public life should stand up for ourselves because we did not get here idly.
One always hears about dynastic politics. The same lady who does not want any Deputies to attend her funeral has written an article about dynastic politics. It is anti-democratic to propose that anyone who has or had a relative in the Dáil should be precluded from standing for election. It is also an insult to voters. We come through a convention, stand for election and are either accepted or rejected by voters. It does not matter what one's surname is, one may as well stay at home if voters do not like the cut of one's jib.
I read a completely inaccurate article which stated that I inherited my father's seat when he passed away. My father had been dead for 12 years when I stood for the Dáil. Where does that fact leave that story? Those who write these types of stories need to do their research. When I first knocked on doors in Athlone I was better known as one of the local secondary school teachers. Students would answer the door and run to their mammy to tell her the teacher was calling. The Minister, Deputy Pat Carey, will have had the same experience. I wish him well in performing the multitude of duties for which he has assumed responsibility. I do not know how he will manage.
Comment on this
I will have to try to remember which ministerial hat he is wearing when I approach him. He did good work in the community sector in Athlone. It is a pity he is not running in the town because its people have great time for him.
Comment on this
I hope their appreciation of the Minister's work transfers to me.
My advice to those Deputies who propose to stand in the forthcoming general election is to be stout of heart. I am quite sure I will not be back to the House. If I do not make it, I will not join the group of past Members of the Oireachtas but stay at home, write a book, mind my grandchildren, go for walks, have tea with friends, play bridge, read books and generally have a nice time. I still intend to retain my seat as I have no intention of joining any group of past Members, however well intentioned it is. Nothing could be worse than going over the things we said and did or did not say and do. Do I have time to kill a few more cows?
Comment on this
We were told that new political movements would start up. I note Senator Shane Ross will stand in the general election as an Independent. I wish him luck because he would be a breath of fresh air in the House. Deputy Brian Hayes and I are familiar with the Senator from our time in the Seanad.
I understand a second economics guru will stand for the Fine Gael Party in the general election. If he is elected, the party will be massively challenged in all sorts of ways. Apart from that, we have not seen a mass movement. I do not see Fintan O'Toole or David McWilliams on the hustings.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Rourke should not encourage them.
Comment on this
Perhaps they will emerge as candidates. If they do so, they will get a dose of reality. Why are these wonderful gurus standing in what one could describe as "posh" areas? None of them is standing north of the River Liffey or in a rural constituency. They should be given a taste of reality.
We were promised much. The Dáil should be reformed during the next Government. The House should work normal hours, perhaps from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. Such a change would be more a technical adjustment than a reform. It would also be useful if Deputies were able to obtain from Ministers in the House the up-to-date position regarding developments in their constituencies, for example, announcements of company closures. The Executive must not continue to be the top cat in every respect and leave Deputies to toil away. Much greater interaction is required between the Executive and Legislature.
As leader of the House, the former Taoiseach, Mr. John Bruton, introduced the committee system on my first day in the House. On that occasion, I decided that if I did not speak on my first day, it would be a long time before I addressed the House because one is told to keep quiet for a while and be demure and modest. I chose to speak and, in doing so, welcomed the idea of establishing a committee system. Since that time, the committee system has gone haywire. Committees which want to be noticed invite Mr. A and Ms B before them and everyone involved — Mr. A, Ms B and certain members — then engages in grandstanding before the whole thing ends up in a bottle of smoke. Only seven or eight committees are needed, each of which must have a definite remit and a timeframe within which it should complete its work programme.
I am pleased the referendum on children did not take place. The Minister of State, Deputy Barry Andrews, will have the relevant legislation ready when he leaves office. The Joint Committee on the Constitutional Amendment on Children, of which I was the Chairman, was a committee that worked well. All our meetings were held in private and we received approximately 185 submissions. We met various groups, discussed the relevant issues and arrived at a consensus. I pay tribute to the clerk to the committee who is present in the Chamber. She kept us focused on the relevant issues. It is a pity this Dáil will not continue for another month or thereabouts to enable the Government to have the legislation ready and hold the referendum on the day of the general election.
I thank the Ceann Comhairle for indulging me by allowing me to engage in a few rants. I hope they were appropriate to the occasion.
Comment on this
I propose to share time with Deputy Brian Hayes.
I like to listen to Deputy O'Rourke speak on radio programmes when I am driving late at night. She is honest and open and speaks her mind. I also enjoyed her contribution and would like to respond to some of her comments. I concur with the Deputy on the issue of democracy and the need to have public representatives of all ages. When I entered the Dáil at the age of 24 years I should not have been on my own. One needs people of all ages here. Journalists who argue that Deputies should be either all young or all elderly are wrong. One needs a proper balance, as one does with a football team. When one has a team of all ages one gets results.
As to the argument that national politicians should not do local work, people must realise that Deputies fulfil their role at national level. Members probably work for 40 or 50 hours each week on national issues, as is the case with members of other parliaments. In our system, however, many Deputies decide to do ten, 20 or 30 additional hours of local work. That is their choice under the system we operate, which I expect will change eventually, and Deputies will at some point focus solely on national issues. As matters stand, however, they perform a national and local role. As I have repeatedly stated, until local services improve and constituents do not need Deputies to intervene on local matters, Deputies will continue to provide a local service through their constituency offices.
It is important that Members do their job. While certain Deputies do not do any work on national issues — that is their business and the business of those who vote for them — the majority across all parties try to work on national issues.
On the issue of politicians attending funerals, people who are in business will attend the funerals of their customers. A pub owner will do his or her best to go to the funeral of a customer because he will have known and become friendly with all his customers. If a family member or friend dies, one attends their funeral. While I accept that some Deputies make a point of attending all funerals in their locality, the majority attend only those they should attend because they knew, were friendly with or worked with the deceased. When they write articles, journalists need to allow for the fact that, while some TDs are different, the majority act in a principled manner. While there will always be a few that may abuse funeral services, religious or otherwise, the vast majority do not. Journalists should make that distinction when they write articles otherwise it gives politics a bad name.
We will oppose this measure and I wish to tackle Sinn Féin on a few issues. That party knows quite well what is going on here this week. We want to get this Government out of office as quickly as possible. What went on here last week was embarrassing for the country and for me personally as a TD. Everybody in politics has good and bad days. Some days one may not be proud of one's party but it is a serious matter to be embarrassed about the national Parliament, which is what occurred last week. What happened was embarrassing and it was reported internationally. Friends in various parts of the world reported back to us saying that we were a laughing stock and looked silly. That had to come to an end. If we had not agreed to deal with the Finance Bill this week it would have dragged on for two or three more weeks. It was quite clear that the Greens were going to support it from the Opposition benches. They would have dragged it on for two or three weeks, while people would have been shouting and roaring, as well as motions of no confidence being tabled. It would have been a shambles with Fianna Fáil TDs who could not vote for Deputy Brian Cowen as their party leader voting for him as Taoiseach. Meanwhile, the Greens who left Government would still vote for him as Taoiseach. The Oireachtas would look even worse in those circumstances, so it had to come to an end. We do not like the idea of facilitating a Finance Bill, but that does not mean that we will support every aspect of it.
The same amount of time will probably be spent on the Bill, however. That is because over two weeks with all the argy-bargy that would have gone on, the Bill would have been debated for less time than will be devoted to it under this system. It is in the national interest to get the Government to hell out of here because the recovery cannot start until we get a change of Government. We are doing right to get the Bill through the House as quickly as possible.
When Sinn Féin Members try to lecture us about politics, they might take some time out to lecture their own leader on the economy. I heard Mr. Gerry Adams on the radio this morning but he does not have a clue when it comes to this country's finances. He showed it in 2007, when I thought it was a once-off mistake, but when I heard him this morning it was clear that he does not have a clue. He does not understand what he is talking about and he is misleading people. He is trying to do anger better than everybody else so that he will get votes, but anger in itself is not good enough. One must have proper policies and an understanding of the situation. I heard him say all we had to do with the €18 billion deficit was to take €4.5 billion out every year until the problem was solved, but that is not how it works. I am sure that Mr. Adams's colleagues know that. The €4.5 billion that comes out this year must also come out next year and every other year, but more money is required on top of that to reach the figure of €18 billion or €19 billion. It is not a question of repeating the €4.5 billion figure four times, and Deputy Morgan knows that. I listened to Mr. Adams this morning and could not believe what he said.
It is wrong for Deputy Doherty to suggest that my party is the same as Fianna Fáil because we are very different. Fine Gael has voted similarly with Sinn Féin on most of the banking issues, so we are very alike in our preference for burning bond holders, or certainly for negotiation. Sinn Féin should therefore not try to link us with Fianna Fail and say we are the same because we are not. Deputy Doherty knows that, so he would be better off lecturing his own leader. Deputy Doherty also mentioned equality. My party is all for equality of opportunity, which is one of our core values. We have fought very hard on that and always will. That is one of the main reasons we opposed the budget and this Finance Bill because they do nothing to advance the cause of equality. While one may never achieve full equality, one should always strive to reach that goal as best one can in the circumstances. This Bill could have gone further towards assisting equality and alleviate the pain felt by the most vulnerable, but it did not. It heaped more trouble on them, which is why we are opposing it. As with the budget, the Bill before us totally lacks a job creation strategy. I am sure that Sinn Féin and Labour will oppose it for the same reasons. One may go through the entire Bill but one cannot find anything that will assist in creating jobs.
In his speech, the Minister said the Bill will continue the process of stabilising our public finances, providing appropriate support to businesses and assisting the Revenue Commissioners. I do not know what the Minister means by "appropriate support to businesses". What does he consider to be appropriate? There is very little support for business in this legislation and certainly nothing in addition to what was already there. Small and medium indigenous enterprises have not received any help in this country. There have been small changes in PRSI to create some employment which is not even being taken up because it is too complicated. In addition, the idea was not sold properly to the business sector. I question what the Government is trying to do with this budget and that is why we will not support it.
On the radio earlier today, the Minister said there was no other option than his national recovery plan. He is wrong in that respect, however, because there are plenty of options. Fine Gael has proposed a different vision, which is based on a strategy of growth and job creation, not on cutbacks. Mr. Gerry Adams and others say that the bailout money is only for banks and that there is no real problem with public expenditure. That is also incorrect. Some €50 billion of the IMF fund is to run the country for the next three years. I am not happy with that but that is what it is for. To run the country for the next three or four years, while we try to reduce the deficit, we will be short €50 billion to €60 billion. That is due to bad Government and the mismanagement of public expenditure which has gone out of control without results or real reform. Thanks to Deputy Bertie Ahern, expenditure in most Departments went up by well over 150% from 2001 to 2008. Public expenditure rose in 2001 before the general election and again in 2006 before another general election, but there were no real long-term, lasting benefits to the country. In fact, it gave false hope to many people facing wage cuts, tax rises and increased borrowings. They were led up the garden path with false promises and unsustainable public expenditure commitments.
Sadly, the IMF funding is required. We in Fine Gael hope to get into government as quickly as we can to renegotiate that and make changes to it. We will target a couple of areas, including the interest rate which we cannot afford. No matter who is in government, in two or three years' time, this country will be faced with an interest bill of €11 billion. We will have to renegotiate that because the country cannot afford it, not to mind repaying the principal. In addition, many of the constraints in the document to provide savings are negotiable. The Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, should stop claiming that they are not negotiable because they are. The approach to making savings will be renegotiated.
In his budget speech and again today, the Minister purposely avoided clarifying the savings in the Croke Park agreement. When I visited the Department of Finance, together with my colleagues Deputies Brian Hayes and Michael Noonan, we asked the Minister what savings had been made as a result of that agreement. There have been none so far, yet we are told there will have to be massive savings this year under the IMF deal. I have seen no such plan. I asked the Minister if he had appointed new accountants and managers to drive these changes, but he has not. Nothing has changed, yet we are told that savings will be made as a result of the Croke Park agreement to deliver on the IMF deal. I cannot see it and it will be left to the new Government to try to put plans in place to drive such savings.
Fine Gael does not think the Croke Park agreement is a great deal, but we will try to use it to determine whether it can drive the reforms we want to achieve. Some speakers said that Fine Gael wants to slash public service numbers, but we do not. We want to take out 30,000 people over the next couple of years and believe that can be done voluntarily through negotiations. We do not approach things by sacking left, right and centre. We will do it logically, going through every little detail to see where savings can be made, as well as switching or moving staff, and doing a deal with staff members to leave the service. There are ways of doing that without taking a "bull in a china shop" approach or through forced redundancies.
I am disgusted with the Minister, who has renegued on his promise to tackle bankers' bonuses. When we proposed a 99% tax on such bonus payments, the Minister bowed to pressure and promised to introduce a 90% tax rate, but he has not done so. He had hidden away and yet again protected his own buddies. He is wrong and he has failed. He has repeatedly misled the House and has had to correct matters subsequently. Alternatively, he has changed his mind, done a U-turn and gone off in a different direction. I am fed up with it and so is the country.
Another contentious issue is the taxation status on student fees. It is wrong that people who will be faced with annual registration fees of €2,000 cannot claim tax relief on that sum. Other people may be paying €5,000 or €6,000 to attend a private college, because they cannot get a grant or a place in a public college, yet their tax relief will also be affected. That is wrong at a time of mass unemployment. People need to be encouraged to go back to education. We will introduce amendments to tackle it because it is wrong.
The last point I would like the Minister to consider overnight relates to personal retirement savings accounts. According to my reading of the Bill and the information I have been given, if one's employer contributes to one's personal retirement savings account, that contribution will now be subject to the universal charge and PRSI. That will mean an employee has to pay an additional 11% through various charges on the employers' contribution. At a time when we are trying to encourage people to invest in proper pensions, through the personal retirement savings account system, that is wrong. We need to ensure one is in a position to increase one's pension provision to provide for one's future and that of one's family. Perhaps the Minister has done this by mistake. The Minister has often reminded me to refer to him rather than to his officials. It is his responsibility. He has managed to do this. It needs to be corrected. We will tackle it by tabling amendments tomorrow.
Comment on this
It is sensible that the House has agreed to conclude the debate on the Finance Bill 2011 in both Houses of the Oireachtas by Saturday. Regardless of one's views on the Bill, it is a sign of the new reality in the House that a measure of agreement was reached between the biggest parties on both sides of the House yesterday evening. Prior to that, we had been told incessantly by the Minister that this could not be done by Friday and that it would lead to all kinds of difficulties. The House will be aware that when the Minister for Finance made his Budget Statement on 7 December last, the Government decided not to accept a proposal made by the leader of my party, Deputy Kenny, which would have allowed a finance Bill to be passed before Christmas. If there was a clear will for this legislation to be passed, that should have happened. In general, it is right that each year's finance Bill is implemented by both Houses before the end of the first quarter of the year. The deal agreed with the EU and the IMF explicitly states that the conclusion of the budgetary process should happen by the end of the first quarter of the year. The various parties may disagree on the budget, but we have a sovereign obligation to meet that commitment.
I listened to the president of Sinn Féin on the radio this morning. He was greatly confused when speaking about the negotiations with the EU and the IMF. At the start of the interview, he clearly said he would take a unilateral position on the question of debt. By the end of the interview, he was greatly muddled and said he would negotiate with the IMF and the EU. Given that their party colleagues in Northern Ireland have accepted a clear programme of austerity as a major part of the partnership government there, I find it hypocritical that the Sinn Féin Deputies in this House seem unable to consider the potential for adjustments in public expenditure in order to do what is required in this State over the next few years. The austerity programme in Northern Ireland, which will be pursued over the next four years, involves substantial cuts in public expenditure across a range of departments there. With the greatest degree of respect for Deputy Morgan, I do not think the public will buy that kind of hypocrisy over the course of the next month. It is not credible. One can have one position in Northern Ireland and another position here.
Comment on this
They are totally different positions. Deputy Hayes knows that.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin is arguing that it is hamstrung in Northern Ireland——
Comment on this
——because of the fact that the British treasury gives Northern Ireland an envelope of money for a 12-month period
Comment on this
If Sinn Féin is so opposed to the position being taken by the British treasury, why does it not depart from government in Northern Ireland? If it is so opposed on a point of principle to being caged into a financial equation in Northern Ireland, why does it not withdraw from the government there? Why does it not take up a position on the opposition benches and leave the ministries and the mercs behind?
Comment on this
With respect, I listened to the Deputy in silence. The logical outworking of the Sinn Féin position is that if it opposes the cuts in Northern Ireland, it should take up a position on the opposition benches and hand over to the other parties there, rather than play-acting in the way its leader did this morning. As I understand it, the MP for Belfast West has had no difficulty with taking £200,000 a year from the British taxpayer over many years.
This country is facing enormous reputational damage as a result of the actions of the Minister of State, Deputy Roche, and everyone else who supported the Government over the past decade. The Minister of State will be aware that our reputation as a country is on the floor across Europe, as a result of the manner in which we have handled our economy. I suspect that when he goes to bilateral meetings with his EU colleagues, he does his best with the difficult cards he has been dealt. The President of the European Commission, Mr. Barroso, was absolutely right when he referred to the domestic reasons for the problem we face. Is it not the case that the Watson and Regling report on the banking sector and the financial collapse pointed to clear international evidence that 75% of the problem we face can be attributed to domestic factors and do not relate to the difficult international conditions that are obvious in our economy? We have to correct that.
The first step towards national recovery is the election of a new Dáil. The right of the people to express their views has not been upheld. We have a new banking regulator and a new Governor of the Central Bank, but we do not have a new Government. The Irish people are the last group of people to be consulted on this issue. They will have their say soon. It is crucial for us to have an honest debate on the future of this country before that happens. My party will not make extravagant promises that cannot be stood up. We have accepted the parameters for the obvious adjustments that will have to occur over the next four years. We have agreed that an adjustment of €15 billion is absolutely essential. We have said the new Government will have to meet the requirement that a 3% deficit target be reached by 2015. The ways and means of achieving the national growth for which we are ambitious will have to be teased out during the election campaign. Our approach is different from that of the party opposite and other parties.
The various parties in this House will pursue different policies during the campaign. The Labour Party differs from Fine Gael in its views on the right balance between tax and expenditure. I respect that. The people will have their say during the course of the debate over the next month or so and will elect a new Dáil on the basis of their choices. Nobody should be under the illusion that we can choose a soft option or use a magic wand to immediately get us out of the difficulty in which we have been placed by the party opposite over the past decade or so. The Irish people are economically literate. They understand clearly the difficult choices that lie ahead. They know this country, including the Houses of the Oireachtas, has to be transformed from top to bottom. They appreciate that radical transformation of public administration and the public sector is inevitable. The party opposite failed drastically to deliver such change over the past 14 years.
Comment on this
This is undoubtedly one of the most critical Finance Bills we have ever seen, or that has ever been introduced in this House. This legislation will give effect to budget 2011, which is the first instalment and the legal base for the four-year national recovery plan. It is a critical element of the implementation of the financial package that has been agreed by our EU partners and the IMF. It is critical that this Finance Bill, more than any other such Bill that has been discussed in this House since I was first elected in 1987, be fully teased out and examined. It should not be subject to some kind of truncated consideration. Over the next five days we will engage in a shameful charade in this House. The Finance Bill, more than any other Bill, requires detailed examination and should not be rushed. If we want to make Dáil and Seanad Éireann relevant to the lives of the people of this nation, we should not do what we are doing. We should give the Bill a complete and thorough examination. Ironically, last week in this very Chamber we discussed the issue of Dáil reform, and one of the points made by people on all sides in politics and in Irish life who had served in this Chamber over the years was that we had dealt with important legislation shamefully. They said that legislation had been dealt with on the nod and without detailed scrutiny or examination. Members should mark my words: in the years ahead, the charade of this Finance Bill will become known as a low point in political debate. I support this Bill and I want to see it passed, but I would like to see it passed after a full and thorough examination.
On the Government side, we want the Bill passed because it is necessary to launch the rebuilding of our nation. It is necessary to give effect to the four-year national plan, to give hope to the hundreds of thousands of people who are unemployed, to balance the public finances and to put Ireland back on the road to recovery. I accept that some Members of the House take a different view of the Bill and of the focus of Government policy, and I respect that. However, there can be no respect for the manner in which we are dealing with the most important Bill in the history of the State. Why are we dealing with it in this way? We all know there is to be an election by 11 March. It is not important whether we have it on 11 March, 11 February or 25 February; what is important is that we fully tease out where we all stand on these political issues. This Bill is being handled in a way which can only cause us to question the approach to politics being adopted by two of the major political parties in the State. I put it to the House that the real motivation for this way of dealing with the Bill is that these two parties do not want a full, frank and clear analysis of their policies. We will end up sleepwalking into a general election, and the two parties most likely to form a Government will not have to put before the House their alternative views of the Finance Bill.
I give a certain degree of credit to Fine Gael. I have read its documents with great care, and their key analyses are not all that different from those of Fianna Fáil. However, the stance of the Labour Party is cynical in the extreme. I agree with Deputy Kenny's comment in the House this morning that one of the most important constitutional burdens placed on the Members of Dáil Éireann is the agreement of the Finance Bill. I also agree with Deputy Brian Hayes, who said only four minutes ago that the Finance Bill should, in the normal order of things, be agreed before the end of the first quarter of the year. That is not a bad position to adopt.
There can be no surprise about the anxiety of the Labour Party to get through this charade as quickly as it possibly can. It does not want a full exposition of the fundamental differences between its analysis and our analysis but also, more importantly, its analysis and that of the Fine Gael Party. The Labour Party, above all, wishes to make absolutely certain that the Irish people never have the opportunity to engage in a mature debate on the fundamental differences between the two parties most likely to form the next Government.
What do they disagree on? Deputy Hayes touched on some of the points of disagreement, including the size of the adjustment that needs to be made, the level of taxation that should be imposed, the spending cuts required, the eventual size of the public sector and the Croke Park agreement. They also fundamentally disagree on the IMF-EU bailout. I will outline some of the issues on which those two parties are at odds and on which I, as a taxpayer as well as a public representative, would like to see a response. Our friends in the media have totally ignored this. They have focused, rightly, on a detailed and incisive analysis of Government but they have given a blind pass to our friends in the Labour Party.
Fine Gael says — as mentioned by the Deputies opposite — that a cut of €6 billion in public expenditure is required. In fact, Deputy Noonan said this when speaking to The Irish Times on 10 November 2010. I agree with his analysis; that is the order of the adjustment we need in our public finances. Let us call it a cut. What did the Labour Party say a few days later? It said we need an adjustment of €4.5 billion. Two parties going into Government cannot diverge by 25% on this issue. That is a fundamental point. Every taxpayer and citizen has a right to know this. In fact, Deputy Gilmore said on 3 December that a €6 billion adjustment was unacceptable. How will he square that with Fine Gael?
Another issue of some importance is the amount of tax we must raise. Fine Gael has made it clear — again, I commend it on its clarity, although I do not agree with its analysis — that the adjustment must be made up of one part tax increases to three parts cuts in expenditure. Deputy Michael Noonan said on 28 October that every euro imposed in tax rises must be matched by €3 worth of spending cuts. He could not have been clearer. I do not agree with him on the extent of the cuts but he must be given credit for his clarity. What does Deputy Gilmore say? He says that the balance between taxation and spending cuts should be roughly 50-50. How will these two parties bridge the gap? Oddly, I agree with Sinn Féin: the reason the parties do not want to discuss this at length is that they do not want the issue to be aired between now and the general election.
On the issue of income tax rates, again, Fine Gael could not be more clear. In its pre-budget submission it stated that it would not raise either the 20% standard rate or the 41% top rate of income tax. I may not agree with this, but at least it has the benefit of clarity. What does the Labour Party say? It wants to impose a third rate of 48% on joint incomes of more than €200,000 or single incomes over €100,000. It also wants a reduction in the personal tax credit of €250, which will hit people on the minimum wage — the very people its members agonise about here. How will the Labour Party adjust its position to match that of Fine Gael?
What about the question of bringing those on the minimum wage into the tax net? Fine Gael was at least clear from the outset that it supported such things as the Croke Park agreement. In its budget perspective, the party stated: "Fine Gael in Government will support a recovery in employment levels by keeping minimum wage earners out of the tax net in 2011", and goes on to talk about what will happen beyond that. However, let us consider the proposals published by the Labour Party. It wants to reduce the personal tax credit by €250, which will affect people on the minimum wage. This will not be discussed on the airwaves or in the media. Fine Gael shares the view of the Government and of Fianna Fáil that we need a four-year timeframe to balance the public finances. It has made that clear, and I commend it because multi-annual budgeting is common sense. It is a view I take. However, the Labour Party has introduced a plan only for 2011, God forbid it goes any further.
There are other differences between the two parties, including their stances on the Croke Park agreement. Where do they stand on the number of positions to be cut from the public service? Again, Fine Gael has been clear, specifying a figure of 30,000, but the Labour Party's figure is half of that. It goes on and on. The parties are at odds over third level fees, banking, the EU and IMF, and the bank guarantee. It is critical when we deal with the Finance Act each year that we debate all the fundamental issues that will make this country recover. We are not doing it on this occasion because the political exigencies of the time so dictate, and that is a disservice to the country.
We could have waited a week or ten days further. I should not have minded working 24 hours a day for the next ten days, but we need to do a much more incisive job than we are doing, and this marks a new low in the manner in which we have handled debate in this House. There is a fundamental problem. We believe there is a right way forward. We disagree with other political parties and that will be put before the people. Above all else the people have the right to know the truth and they will not know it because of the manner in which this debate has been truncated.
We will be delighted that the Finance Bill is passed because we are in favour of it. However, this is not the correct way for Dáil Éireann to do its business. We should tease the issues out and we are not doing this.
Comment on this
I welcome an opportunity to make a brief contribution to this important debate, and I thank my friend and colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Dick Roche, for giving me some of his time. He still has friends in Tallaght, so if he is in contact with them over the next few weeks, perhaps he might give me a mention.
My son, Niall, who follows these matters, tells me Google is saying Charlie O'Connor has contributed to 110 debates in the past year, which is supposed to be above average. I get the sense that this is a very important debate, and I am anxious to make my small contribution. The news on RTE and TV3 tonight indicates that this might be the second last day we are all here. Whether that is true I do not know, but in the event, I am glad I have been given the opportunity to support this legislation. Whatever happens after that, que serra, serra. The news has also been dominated in recent days by references to departing colleagues. I have been privileged to know many of them from different parties over the years, and I wish them well.
Deputy Noel Ahern made an interesting statement today about Fianna Fáil Deputies in difficult circumstances who might blink as regards their running mates. I make it clear that Charlie O'Connor has no intention of blinking. I have been a public representative at local level since 1991. I was privileged to become a Dáil Deputy, succeeding my friend and colleague, Deputy Chris Flood, in 2002. Whatever the people of Dublin South-West think of me is all right. I have worked hard on their behalf, and have tried to represent their interests and concerns. Their judgment is all right with me, and I shall face the next 31 days with confidence, a good spirit and enthusiasm and will accept the judgment when it comes.
On what the Minister of State, Deputy Roche said, and other colleagues — I know Sinn Féin has a different view — it is important that the Finance Bill go through. I am not afraid to say from the Fianna Fáil benches that I am not entirely happy with every aspect of this legislation. In fact, there are things in this Bill that would undermine values that I have upheld in my public life and certainly during my Dáil career. However, one takes responsibility in politics and I have no intention of seeking publicity by suggesting, "Perhaps I will, perhaps I won't". It is very important to enact this Bill. There is a responsibility now for the Opposition to listen to what is being said, and it is important for the Bill to go through the Oireachtas in a proper manner this week, after a good debate. The date of election is no longer a mystery. There might be a variation of a couple of days, but we now effectively have an agreement on when it will take place. Even the Opposition made the point, very clearly, that the Finance Bill is important. I shall not be any happier than those Deputies who have indicated they will vote against the Bill. I appeal to them to have sense, and do what is right for the country, since senior Opposition Deputies have made it clear, both in private and public, that the Finance Bill should be adopted.
The Government, in fairness, has stressed that the Finance Bill is the right way to go. We all know that the country faces not only a banking crisis, but a fiscal one as well. I have mentioned my constituency several times in the time I have been here. I represent Dublin South-West. Deputy Doherty should know that I was talking to my Donegal-born parish priest this morning and he was very anxious that I should say that. I represent the people of Bohernabreena, Brittas, Greenhills, Templeogue, Firhouse and Tallaght, and I have gone out of my way to listen to what people say to me. I was not elected to hide, and neither have I hid. I certainly did not hide in the last difficult days, although I crossed the Liffey last night to chair a convention in Dublin Central, the first in 40 years not to choose Bertie Ahern. Perhaps that is something I can put on my CV.
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy not put down his name for the leadership?
Comment on this
I felt I was too young and that we needed a more mature person. I have no difficulty in that regard. I should acknowledge, incidentally, the many calls I have received throughout my constituency from people who have a view about who the leader should be.
Comment on this
It is important, but I said last week I will not get distracted by these issues. I went on record last week on the confidence motion on the Taoiseach, Deputy Brian Cowen, to the effect that it was a distraction. My colleagues on the Fine Gael benches have had experience of this, but I also hoped there would not be a divisive leadership contest. I believe that Fianna Fáil today, 30 days from the general election, will unite behind one leader.
Comment on this
Surely he will vote for the Dublin man.
Comment on this
I will not give an exclusive because I said the other day I wanted to assess the situation, consider all the candidates and listen to my supporters and community.
Comment on this
This is all about the Finance Bill, a Cheann Comhairle. I am less experienced than some of my colleagues, and I have always tried to follow what they do. I am following their example, so if I am out of line, I apologise.
The Finance Bill is important legislation. If it is the last initiative of this Dáil, it should be dealt with properly. I hope this will happen and people will make important points. The Minister for Finance has conceded today with regard to what was said to him at the Fianna Fáil parliamentary party last week in relation to universal charges, medical card holders and so on, and I know colleagues right throughout the House had issues in that regard. I am glad he listened to us and that the Government made a decision. It is not just colleagues on the Independent benches who have issues they want articulated. However, if one is a member of a party, the place to do this is in the parliamentary party room. I have always been happy to do that, without fear, and I shall continue to do so.
In case I do not have another opportunity to speak in the Thirtieth Dáil, I wish the Ceann Comhairle well and thank him for the opportunity to have chaired a number of Dáil sessions, which I have been very proud to do. I wish him well and know that at the moment he is probably the only Deputy to be guaranteed a seat in the next Dáil.
Comment on this
I refer to a number of points in the context of the self-employed, small business person. This, particularly in the indigenous sector, will be the element in bringing back the economy. There is nothing in the Finance Bill about job creation and job retention. Section 18 deals with bringing forward the filing of tax returns for the self-employed, payment of preliminary tax for 2011 and the balance of tax for 2010. This moves from 31 October to 30 September when it is filed manually and from 14 November to 14 October when filed online, which a majority of people do. This will put enormous strain on the small business person. I was a self-employed chartered accountant for many years. I dealt with these people. This measure is directly affecting cash flow. I assume it is being taken because of the third quarter and the IMF plan. One cannot squeeze the life out of the small business sector, which provides jobs up and down the country. There are 800,000 people employed in the small and medium-sized enterprise sector. The businesses cannot get credit from the banks and they are under pressure in terms of getting paid. Credit has dried up and people are withholding payment as a form of credit. In terms of practicality and work being done, by bringing returns and payment back to 30 September, it clashes with company returns, which must be submitted within nine months of the accounting year end. For most companies, the year end is 31 December. Accountants will have to file company returns and then file personal returns and returns for the self-employed at the same time. There will be chaos.
From my perspective, the issue is credit flow for the SME sector. It will put many of them out of business. The measure is shortsighted and shows a lack of understanding of how business works. The old saying is that cash is king. Squeezing the SME sector to get money into the public coffers means the SME sector will find it difficult to pay wages and will find it difficult to repay banks. It is shortsighted in the extreme and I feel strongly about this point. If we do not look after the small business sector we will not come out of the recession. The small man has been caught by this Government in recent years. I came out of the SME sector. The same applies to the person in the PAYE sector, the pensioner, the carer, the disabled and the widow. Why does the small man always end up paying? People in the SME sector will end up taking less home than staff are being paid because they are working in local communities. I see this in County Limerick and in the city. Such businesses are crippled at every level. In some cases rates are higher than rent. This should be reversed. It is penal and draconian and will not work.
There is a major amount of discussion on job creation. All Members find the same situation. When I knock on doors, I meet mothers, fathers, sons and daughters. In many cases, the sons and daughters are out of work and are sitting at home. They cannot get on to courses and cannot get a job. Many of them have emigrated. One man I met had been to Australia for a year. He could not go back because it would cost €8,000 to get a visa. He is going to Canada for a year. He asked me what there was for him here. He asked me whether there was a European globalisation fund for construction workers. He had worked as a bricklayer. I checked out the point. Last June, the Tánaiste announced she would make an application under the European globalisation fund for construction workers. Lo and behold, the application has not been sent in yet. The fund amounts to €63 million, of which €40 million comes from Europe. It would affect 9,300 people involved in the construction sector, the very people who have lost their jobs. Most of them have probably emigrated by now. The Government does not have a clue and does not understand the basic rules of commerce. If staff in the Department of Education and Skills are overworked, there should be flexibility so that the work is transferred elsewhere.
The final point concerns the European stability fund and the rate of interest we are being charged. We are paying 3% above the cost of borrowing the money, which should not be happening. People have raised the question of moral hazard and whether, if a deal is given to Ireland, other countries will avail of that rather than going to the bond markets. That theory does not stand up. Ireland is a small country. There is now some realisation in Europe that interest rates will come down despite the protestations to the contrary of the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan. There must be a Europe-wide agreement on sharing with bondholders. This must happen. The Germans and the French must realise that the banks invested in risky products with Irish banks and they must share the burden. If there is a Europe-wide mechanism for sharing the burden with bondholders, international markets will consider that the Irish State is not taking on the penal burden of the banks. The interest rate will drop. If the cost of borrowing drops on the international markets, it will drop over a quicker period and we can go back to the IMF and the European Commission and seek money for three years rather than seven and a half years. That will automatically bring down the cost of borrowing because the term is shorter. One of the reasons for the lower rate of interest for Greece is that the term was shorter.
There is a fundamental problem with the banks. The amount of money we have put into banks is equal to our national debt, approximately €90 billion. It is like approaching someone with a 100% mortgage in an estate and suggesting paying the neighbour's mortgage as well, even if the person will never own the neighbour's house. It cannot be done. There must be a write-down and there must be sharing between the banks and institutions provided funding. There is need for a negotiation. I hope people will decide to put Fine Gael into government and that will happen.
The small business person must be looked after. The Government must revisit the decision to bring forward payment of tax. This will put many small firms out of business and many jobs will be lost. That cannot be allowed to happen.
Comment on this
This is almost certainly my last opportunity to speak in the national Parliament. It has been a great privilege and experience to represent the people of Cavan-Monaghan. I thank the Ceann Comhairle, his colleagues and the staff who have been so helpful over the years, particularly when I first came here, in guiding us through the workings of the House.
When this Government came into office in the summer of 1997, it found that the former Fine Gael-led Government, under the then Taoiseach, the former Deputy John Bruton, had left a budget in surplus and an economy with employment increasing at the rate of 1,000 per week. The Minister of State, Deputy Dick Roche, was extremely worried about the differences that exist between the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party and how they will be reconciled if we get the votes to form a government. I would remind him that prior to the last election one of Fianna Fáil's strongest stances was that a vote for Fine Gael was a vote for the Green Party and that we would be forced to implement Green Party structures. We saw how Fianna Fáil rolled over on that stance.
This year's budget and the Finance Bill do nothing to improve or encourage employment. Rather they recognise the fact that we are now being run by the IMF, which has given us access to the funding we need to pay for the public services the State provides to our citizens for the next three years. The budget, like last year's budget, has hit the low paid, the blind, the widowed and the disabled particularly hard. However, I welcome the U-turn by the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, on applying the universal social charge to those with medical cards and I thank my Fine Gael colleagues for their work towards this end.
There is nothing in the Bill for small and medium-sized businesses, which, if they were to employ one extra person, would result in reducing the number of unemployed by 80,000. I support what the previous speaker, Deputy O'Donnell, said about the damage being done to that sector.
The Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, further admitted today that his Government had allowed us to lose our competitive edge relative to that of our main trading partners. As he admitted, his Government took its eye off the ball. Unfortunately, our people now have to pay for that lack of leadership.
I met a young man while canvassing in Carrickmacross last Saturday and when I asked him to consider voting for the Fine Gael Party, he said he could not because he had to go to Australia the following day. Many of our brightest and best have had no option but to leave this country to find a means to live but, hopefully, in the next few years under a different Government we can improve the situation and provide an incentive for such people to return to rebuild our State and our future.
Clearly, the universal social charge and other taxes are necessary to meet the demands of our country and our new masters, the IMF and those in Europe. I believe that a Fine Gael-led Government can go forward with confidence to rebuild our country with the help of our partners in the European People's Party where many of the senior European leaders would be on our side.
Another measure I want to refer to is the section 23 relief, which was part of the Government's building boom solution during the past number of years. It was interesting that on budget day the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, proposed serious restrictions to this scheme but he has now decided to change his decision until there is a full evaluation of it. Clearly, the Minister got it wrong again and he is now kicking to touch. It is impossible to understand how one could advise somebody to sign up for a long-term contract with a clear understanding that tax relief would be paid for the mortgage or whatever was involved and suddenly without warning the whole scheme would be pulled apart. We have talked for years about this scheme and questioned how it could be justified. Serious legal and unjust issues need to be addressed in that respect.
On a final note, I welcome the decision of the former Minister, Deputy Harney, to resign. I just wish she had done it many years ago.
Comment on this
Like Deputy Crawford, this will possibly be my last time to speak in the Dáil. Having been in these Houses for 33 years as a Member of the Seanad and the Dáil, I have seen it all. I want to thank everybody. We got huge co-operation from the staff of the Houses, the ushers and everybody concerned. It was a pleasure to work here and it was a fine working environment. I recall my maiden speech was about trying to save the sugar factory in Tuam, but that did not work either.
While this may not be directly related to the Bill, I have a few hard words to say about what has happened in this country. Irrespective of what side of the fence one is on, I believe most people would agree that we are now in a place in which we should not be. I only hope that whatever Government is in office in the future will turn matters around in such a way that people will regain at least a small bit of confidence and that they will believe there is a place for them in this country, which they do not believe now. That is the awful impact of what has happened.
I am not directing this criticism at the Minister, Deputy Pat Carey, whom I have always found to be a decent man and one who was easy to deal with. Whoever was responsible at whatever level for the IMF intervening, the minute the IMF official stood on Irish soil, it put a cloud over Ireland, irrespective of where we were ranked in the world, for years to come. This brings me on to another serious matter. We got money from the IMF and the EU at a rate of interest that we simply cannot repay. Bearing in mind that €5 billion in interest payments alone will be paid this year and such interest payments are likely to increase to €8 billion in three years' time, no small country like ours could meet that level of repayments. The Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, and the Taoiseach gave the impression when the negotiations with the IMF were ongoing that this was by far the best deal we could get. Having regard to the 5.8% interest rate that was set, we got an interest rate of 1% for repaying money we got from the ECB previously. It is against that background that there is a touch of the illegal moneylender to the high interest rate that has been set. Irrespective of what money one borrows at what interest rate, if one does not have the repayment capacity, the burden of repayment will be too much and people will bend under the pressure.
My fervent hope is that the new Government, in conjunction with the governments of other member states of the EU, economists and politicians across Europe, would come to a realisation that a small country like ours, in the throes of the misery this burden of interest payments has brought down on us, simply cannot repay the money borrowed at the interest rate set and that it will have to be substantially reduced. If it was, I could foresee a reasonable future for us.
I was extremely disappointed that the budget did not provide for any real job creation measures, irrespective of from where the money would come. If we got people back to work, it would give them a degree of self-confidence. Even if they were not to get that much more than they would receive in social welfare benefit, it would greatly enhance their self-esteem. The Government did not provide for that in the budget for whatever reason. The new Government will have to do something in that respect.
There are many other matters on which I would like to speak, including the universal social charge. It looked good on paper but its implementation has hit the people at the bottom of the ladder extremely hard.
A measure that was mentioned on budget night is not a quirky one even though it is an odd one. The budget provides, for some strange reason, that a third child is overly penalised in terms of child benefit.
Comment on this
Deputy Crawford is the third child in his family.
Comment on this
And a fine big child the Deputy was. A double whammy is suffered when the third children in a family happen to be twins. A mother asked me the other day what had we against a third child and against twins who are third children. They are losing out hand over fist. It is a small matter but I ask that it be examined because this represents the implementation of a silly proposal that should not have been put in place.
Comment on this
When listening to Deputy Connaughton, who stated how many years he was a Member of the House, I noted I have not been a Member for anything like 33 years. Having looked around before Deputies Wall and O'Connor entered, I noted what a motley crew was present. Perhaps everyone else is too busy doing other things and the dead sheep are being press-ganged just to keep the House going. I should refer to the baby of the House, Deputy Doherty, whose presence provides a contrast. Be that as it may.
The Finance Bill is very important every year, and it is more important than ever this year. We have international commitments as part of our borrowing programme and, consequently, we need to pass the Bill quickly. It could be passed now or when the new Government takes office. In the latter case, however, it would have to be passed very quickly because we could run out of time.
I hope the parties that will constitute the new Government are not spending all their time getting ready for the election, that they realise what is likely to happen and are engaging in preliminary talks on how they might create a programme for Government. If we do not pass this Bill in the next couple of days, the parties forming a Government after the election would not want to spend too long talking; otherwise we might get into difficulties.
In addition to playing politics in the House, we should think of our international commitments and those we made in respect of our funding programmes. The IMF-EU deal is important, but I disagree with Deputy Connaughton's view that a cloud came over us on the day it was made. The deal secured our funding. The National Treasury Management Agency was borrowing on the markets every month until late last year. With regard to current expenditure, we are overspending by nearly €20 billion per year. While I hope there will be an improvement this year on foot of the budget and the Finance Bill, the funding is essential. The deal is only a facility and we will not pay interest until such time as we draw down the funding. It means the National Treasury Management Agency will not have to borrow on a monthly basis. If rates improve on the markets, we will not have to use the facility. We can always go to the markets if a cheaper rate is available therefrom.
It is well and good referring to a rate of 5.8%, as Deputy Connaughton did. Perhaps we have been getting money at a rate of 1%. The commercial banks, through the Central Bank, have already received approximately €130 billion at a rate of 1%. If a money lender or whoever Deputy Connaughton spoke about gave one €130 billion, it would be reasonable for it to charge a little more if one did not pull up one's socks enough, on the grounds that a message would need to be delivered.
There has been much talk of renegotiation and statements that we are paying too much. The Taoiseach referred to these in the past week or two and said what we are paying under the deal is the best price. It is good to see that preliminary talks have begun since the ECOFIN meeting last week, as a consequence of which all 27 member states may set up new rules under which countries can get help through the fund. Greece did not get money from the fund and had a separate arrangement whereby it received loans from all the member states. There was approval in principle for the facility used by Ireland. Ireland is the first country to borrow from it. One must borrow according to the rules, regulations and measures that are in place. If we can renegotiate the deal and obtain a lower rate, not only for Ireland but for all other member states in need of funding in the future, so be it.
I envisage that, in three or four months, the new Government will be saying it is great on the basis that it is delivering the bacon and getting a cheaper rate after its predecessor having signed up to a rate of 5.8%. If a cheaper rate is obtained — let us all hope this happens — it will be because the programme to revise the borrowing structures will provide for a better system in the coming months. We must all take responsibility and stop playing politics. If we want the Bill to be passed, we need to pass it correctly. It is a little amusing for Members to state their parties are in favour of the €6 billion correction but against this, that and the other on the basis that one should proceed in another manner. While this is great Opposition stuff, one must adopt a new way of thinking sooner or later.
Comment on this
We showed the Government our way but it did not want to look at it.
Comment on this
The Department costed our proposal, yet the Deputy is calling it "funny money".
Comment on this
The Deputy wants a bit of a row, a bit of action.
Comment on this
My point is that we need to be responsible and pass the Bill.
I listened to other speakers, particularly Deputy Burton. Her leader said some weeks ago, "We are ready for an election." The Taoiseach said that was great but asked him if he was ready for government. There is a slight difference between the two. It is often said that Members on this side of the House are great in government and that Members on the other side are great in opposition. Since we are about to change sides, Members will need to prepare and put themselves into the frame of mind of those on the other side of the House. One's remarks today may be thrown back at one in a couple of weeks and may not look too pretty.
I worry about the capacity of the next Government to change role and to take on a different part on the stage, as if one were in the Abbey or some such theatre. There are difficulties. There is no point in complaining about the Government at this stage because, very shortly, others will be in government. My party has been in power for most of the past 23 years. This is a long time. We were in power with the Labour Party after one election and there was a period, after our having a row with that party, in which it, Fine Gael and Democratic Left were in power.
Certain statements that are made from time to time are a bit rich. Some days ago Deputy Rabbitte stated on the radio that Fianna Fáil has brought the country from boom to bust. This is nonsense, of course, although the Deputy often speaks a fair bit of sense. His comment was scandalously wrong and unfair. He was trying to refer to the period 1994 to 1997 during which Fine Gael, the Labour Party and Democratic Left were in power. This period was not long enough in which to do much good and, thankfully, not long enough in which to do any harm. The last time Fine Gael and the Labour Party were really in power after an election was in the period 1982 to 1987. At the end of that period, when Fianna Fáil came back into power, the country was really banjaxed, ruined and paralysed. Many of the economic statistics pertaining to that period were far worse than those that obtain now. It is a bit rich trying to come out with——
Comment on this
They were not worse then than they are now.
Comment on this
I will read them out to Deputy Durkan in a few minutes. It is a bit rich trying to claim credit for a situation that had greatly improved by the mid-1990s when Fine Gael was not in government for long enough to make any significant——
Comment on this
What about the Deputy's brother and his €40,000 speeches?
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil kept going for another six months. The public would not have been——
Comment on this
It is all right, a Leas-Chathaoirligh. Let them.
Comment on this
I will say sorry to the Chair, but not to the Deputy.
Comment on this
I reject the notion often thrown across the floor of the House that we brought the country from boom to bust. It is nonsense. In the past 20 years, the country has come from a low base and there have been great developments.
Comment on this
Tell that to those who got their pay cheques in the past few weeks.
Comment on this
We will come around to that. There have been outstanding improvements in terms of infrastructural development, services, quality and standards of living and the number of people at work. That last used to be 1.1 million before it increased to 2 million. We have rolled back, but only a little. The main core of the past 20 years' progress remains. As soon as we get out of our current difficulties, we will be able to take a higher step on the ladder.
Reverting to the Finance Bill and some of the issues on which the Minister spoke, many experts have stated in the past year or two that too many people are outside the tax net. Some 45% of income earners are paying no tax. While this is a fact, I am concerned that we not move too quickly to correct the situation. We must remember how it came about. The Government, through social partnership with unions and employers, brought about arrangements and deals. Instead of employers needing to give pay increases, the Government did its bit and reduced taxes so that products and services would be delivered or produced at reasonable prices. The idea was to be competitive.
The universal social charge has been introduced. I welcome the amendments that are to be made to it, although someone telephoned me to ask why the €80 million reduction in respect of people with medical cards, while welcome, was to be made up by increasing the charge on self-employed persons earning more than €100,000. I received a text asking why only the self-employed were seeing an increase and why the extra 3% was not being applied on the employed and company directors. Perhaps it is. We should seek clarification when Second Stage is being concluded tomorrow. Everyone speaks for himself or herself and people seek to project their points of view, but the self-employed seem to believe they are being unjustly targeted.
The economy has stabilised after one or two bad years and the export figures for the later months of last year are looking good. I hope they will lead to a better situation. There has been some good news on the industrial side. For example, Intel made a key decision to increase investment and refurbish some of its older facilities in Leixlip. In recent days, the US Chamber of Commerce issued a statement to the effect that Ireland was ripe for a strong economic recovery. After all of the bad international press, positive press is welcome. People agree that we have a flexible workforce, we are getting our cost structures in place and we are becoming more competitive. Two years ago or so, we were losing many multinational companies because of the downturn. If they are now recognising that we have got our act in order and that Ireland is a good place in which to do business, it is welcome. We must continue in this vein and encourage further foreign direct investment, an area in which we have been doing well in recent years. I welcome the changes in the universal social charge, as they sound more equitable.
I am pleased to see the changes to stamp duty. A fortnight ago, a constituent attending my clinic complained to me. As he was a first-time buyer who had not signed his contract by budget day, he was being caught for stamp duty when he would not have been previously. However, the measure is undoubtedly welcome. In many respects, life has moved on. For years, all of the sympathy of the House was for first-time buyers. That person is no longer the most disadvantaged. The current problem is getting a loan to buy a house. If one can do that, one is on the pig's back. The person who needs encouragement and has received it through this measure, which will combine the rates down to 1%, is the person who bought an apartment or house when property cost more. However, many apartment owners who have since married are looking for family homes and would once have got new mortgages and then done well on the sale of their apartments. They are now in negative equity, leaving a big step up. They need encouragement and help. This stamp duty measure is targeted at those who need assistance, not at our traditional focus, namely, first-time buyers.
Regarding section 23 reliefs in the budget, we have all verbally bashed property owners and developers in recent years and believed that certain people were managing to write off all of their incomes against these measures. I initiatlly welcomed the section 23 provisions in the budget but later, relatively normal people attended my clinic or sent me e-mails to tell me that they were landlords of two or three properties. It used to be the notion that these tax measures were being milked by large developers, which may very well have been the case, but many normal people in normal jobs like ourselves who had accumulated a couple of properties also believed the measures in the budget were unfair. It is strange to see how a measure one believes is directed at the well-to-do affects someone else entirely when it is rolled out in the real world. While I will not call it a second look, I welcome the study of the proposed changes and the attempt to analyse their real effects to ensure that, where jobs are concerned, no negative side effects emerge further down the line. One could go through many other measures. Since my time is almost up, I will leave it at that.
Did I hear that another measure was excluded, namely, the Government's introduction of a maximum salary for public servants? It was mentioned in the Minister's Budget Statement. I had a bit of paper on this measure somewhere, as I believed it was going to be included in the legislation. However, I do not see it in the Bill. When the Minister is debating Committee Stage tomorrow, perhaps he might reassure the House that, while the measure has not been included, it has not been forgotten. I hope the new Government will implement it.
Comment on this
As other speakers have done, I thank those who have sat in the Chair at different stages, for their courtesy and kindness to me over a very long period. I have been here in this Chamber for 25 years, with nine years in the Seanad and since I first stood for election 42 years ago. I am indebted not just for the courtesy of Members of this House, the staff and ushers and others, but also on occasion, for their kindness as well. Gabhaim buíochas ó chroí leo agus le mo chomhghleacaithe thar na blianta.
I want to take advantage of the wide range of speeches that have preceded me, including those on Dáil reform. Nevertheless, I wish to concentrate on what makes up some of the contextual background to what we are discussing. I wish the next Government well. It is a Government I hope to look at from a distance. I have already said I am very grateful for the kindness and courtesy of my colleagues in this House over the years and I hope not to be saying goodbye to them. If I succeed in getting the Labour Party nomination for the presidency, I look forward to meeting them all in their constituencies in a less formal setting.
When I first stood for election in 1969 I was very conscious of something that is important to me. I was leaving an academic world in which I had spent a great deal of time and on which I had expended a great deal of anxiety in order to secure entry. People from backgrounds such as mine did not go to university, did not qualify in other universities and certainly did not teach in universities. I left that world to participate in public life which was part of the tradition of my family. I wish people from all walks of life took part in politics and in public life. It is very important to act in the public space with whatever, as Connolly would put it, gifts of hand or brain one has, and to deliver it for one's fellow citizens. I was conscious in 1969, however, of the great failure of a country that then called itself a republic. I believe no real republic has been created in Ireland. The failure has been of three kinds. There has been a failure in making political power republican, a failure in making republican any kind of administrative power and a failure with regard to communicative power. Without being technical about each of these, I think those who wanted Ireland to be independent would have envisaged a country in which there would be far greater distribution of power, that it would not be confined solely to the exercise of parliamentary democracy.
Parliamentary democracy is incredibly important. For many years, people in Ireland struggled to have their own parliament and struggled to participate in it. But there is more to political power than voting once every four or five years; there is the exercise of power in every dimension of life. If a real republic had been founded, we should have been spending decades extending and deepening political power. To the credit of the Labour Party, that has been its intention and aspiration, however achieved, since it was founded in 1912. With regard to administrative power, it is quite appalling there was no real change from the time the Treasury dominated in the olden days in the hand-over to the Department of Finance. As a political scientist I find it quite extraordinary that so much attention has focused on changing the electoral system and so little on the structure of Cabinet power. There is no constitutional basis for the hegemony of the Department of Finance; it was a practice that flowed seamlessly from the British Treasury and adopted without question. If one wanted to effect radical change, one would break the connection between the monopoly enjoyed by the Government of the day and Parliament. One would allow, for example, the establishment of a committee system with the right to initiate and change legislation. If one wanted to go further as in the Scandinavian model, it would be to allow committees to have limited budgetary powers, thus ensuring people who came into politics would have a career in politics separate from being on the Front Bench if in opposition or being in Cabinet if in government. These are real reforms but they are empty and missing from the discourse. I have the impression that even though the Labour Party has produced 140 proposals which I strongly support, including in particular its proposals on citizenship, I find, generally, there is an element of fright in what those elected are suggesting as if they are offering themselves for reform, as if that was the major problem. That is not the problem.
I will give my opinion on where I think this is going, having spent my lifetime, not just in elected politics but also in academic politics and the social sciences, another area of great failure. I say this as a founding member of the Irish Sociological Association and the Irish Political Science Association. One need only watch television and listen to radio to know what is happening internationally. A significant price is already being paid for the broken connection between the aspirations of the people of this planet and those who take decisions on their behalf. The distinguished political scientist, Jürgen Habermas, has suggested that people can be invited to be bound by rules and by decisions in which they have had a chance consciously to participate. In one part of the world after another, we have the assumption that rational parliaments will be able to solve global problems such as the food crisis, the environmental crisis, the energy crisis or whatever. At the same time, very serious people are suggesting that parliament is what is irrational and that markets are rational when in fact all of the evidence shows it is the flow of international market capital which is completely unaccountable and is irrational. There is not one jot of evidence since the crash in the 1920s in the United States, as both Professor Samuels senior and junior have stated, that the markets are rational. There is strong evidence for the speculative consequences of markets.
On the other hand, people have put all their trust in parliaments and all over the world, parliament is losing. In the European Union, for instance, we are in the gravest danger of sinking back to a common market rather than a Europe beyond wars which might have been a Europe of all the citizens. The citizen deficit in Europe is its most serious failure. That is why those who want to defend their banks, be they French Presidents or German Chancellors, are defending their francs rather than the possibilities of Europe. They have put us in such danger as regards the European project.
There was a great opportunity missed to build a real inclusive republic in Ireland which would have reformed the relationship of Cabinet to the Dáil structures, that would have had a democratic, local government, that would have allowed opportunities for participation. There has been a political failure to establish a republic. There has been an administrative failure whereby administrative structures are hierarchical and patriarchal. I listen to those speaking about the clash between being a legislator and a representative and the consequences of clientelism about which I wrote in the 1970s. This is because of an authoritarian administrative system that never saw the citizen in the French republican sense of being an equal. It was because the relationship of the citizen with the State system was devalued. There is a communicative power where there is no connection between the vulnerability, the struggle and the agony of ordinary people at this time and the description of what is news, of what is happening in the world which they inhabit. They do not have equal access to the story, rather it is for those who work in the sector. I was Minister with responsibility for broadcast communications. This is not an Irish phenomenon. Across Europe and the western world, people will say that they must be cynical about presenting what the viewing or listening public will accept as the news of the day. This kind of artificial connection between what is moral and what is ethical is incredibly dangerous. It is widening an excluded underclass in Ireland. It is creating people who will move quickly to conflict because there are no mediating institutions in Europe. In one country after another across Africa and Asia, as people overthrow dictatorships they place their trust first in representative institutions and then, if they are let down, they are into a straight conflict with what are regarded as the forces of law and order. The result is war and the waste of human and other resources in the terrible tasks of war.
I say this not to depress anybody but simply to state that since I was a child in County Clare I have had a belief in the power of education and in the power of ideas. However, I believe an enormously high price has been paid for a kind of anti-intellectualism and authoritarianism in Irish culture. Therefore, I believe we need to draw one conclusion. We need not suggest that that which has failed us should or can be repaired. This is why the Labour Party is incredibly important in leading a government. We need to go back and recover the promise of a real republic that would be built on citizenship and that would reject as outrageous in a republic the kind of radical individualism epitomised in that ugly statement of Michael McDowell's that inequality is needed for the stability of society. It ranks with the mad Margaret Thatcher view that there is no such thing as society. It stands there as such a notion. People should have seen immediately how incongruous it was to speak like this with the language of radical individualism.
Instead of speaking about the republic that might be created people spoke about getting a bit of the action. Suddenly it was no longer important to have just one house for shelter or to have another for pension purposes, in case a family split up or somebody retired. One needed a string of houses and thus our property bubble was created within a bubble of speculative capitalism that had flowed from an attack on the Glass-Steagall Act in the United States which had introduced regulations following the great crash. President Clinton gave in after several years of lobbying by those who stated it was necessary to get rid of all of the regulations so that the instruments needed by the market could be pushed out to absorb what was regarded as an endless flow of credit. What was this? It was an irrational form of capitalism and thus one of the projects now is the idea of whether capitalism can save itself again.
I believe that as Ireland moves into a time when we can celebrate the founding of my party, the great lockout and 1916 we need to think about an entirely different kind of society. I am immensely practical about this. I can suggest, I have spoken and I have written elsewhere and will continue to do so that what one would do — if one wanted to deliver what I am describing in terms of political participation, administrative fairness and the equality of the right to communicate — would be to speak about a floor of citizenship below which people would not be allowed to fall. One would make secure children from the time of birth to very old people who wonder whether they will have to leave their homes to die, as they frequently do within 18 months of being sent to a nursing home. One would make it possible that children share the same class and for that period of their lives at least would be able to be equal with regard to education. In addition to this, people would have decent housing.
This was the agenda when Sean O'Casey wrote about disparity. James Connolly took the Irish Citizen Army with its egalitarian agenda and placed it side by side with nationalism. The lesson we learned from this was when the egalitarian socialist agenda was placed side by side with the nationalist agenda it would be the socialist agenda which would lose. This was in the dialogue immediately before the meeting of the first Dáil when Michael Collins told the IRB it need not bother with this because they were just going through with it.
Those of us in favour of a version of Ireland where no one will fall below the floor must say it not only to ourselves but also to Europe. In addition, a highly participative inclusive republic was the one in the vision of those who made the case for Irish independence at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century. It was this which was stolen from the people after the foundation of the State when the conservatives marched into all the principal professorships including education and philosophy. UCD became a stable for conservatism and suddenly one had the continuation of an administrative nightmare and the robbing of the people of the delivery of the republic with regard to their ordinary lives.
Frequently, people such as Slavoj Zizek have said to me that if things are as I describe them then what is needed is a form of terror that would sweep everything away and to start all over again. A terrible price would be paid for this so therefore one must put one's faith in representative democracy and having done so one wants it to work. If one wants it to work one must be open to making the type of institutional changes that I mean. How could this be carried? There is need for a discourse in which we are able to speak about the vulnerabilities that matter and where there is not a huge gulf between what we say in here and what is happening on the street.
People wonder why poverty has to reproduce itself in the same family from one generation to another or from one area to another and wonder why there is a difference between the quality of schools in one place and the quality of those in another. God did not make it like that. Nature did not make it like that. The people in the so-called Irish Republic made it like that and they maintained it like that. I remember in County Clare when one could point to the two or three people in the Labour Party because they lived in a galvanised house. People would explain that they were Labour in the same way as they would say they were on the margins of society, and they were. Therefore, with regard to thinking the Finance Bill is necessary for this that or the other, I hope the new Government realises that the model which is broken should not be repaired and that there is a discourse now which is wider and which is not only in Ireland but in Europe, where citizens are wondering what institutions might best express that which we wish to share with each other, where the concept of interdependency is accepted and where it would be regarded as obscene to state that radical individualism is what is important and what must drive us. All that radical individualism with its privileged view of professions and its side of the mouth politics with regard to benefit and privilege is what must be rejected.
This has a practical expression in Europe. If we create here a radical inclusive republic we will place it in a social Europe which accepts the interdependency of peoples rather than the aspirations of the elite property owning classes and individual countries. We would then be able to be a region in the global sense that offered guarantees about labour, security and peace. It would be a powerful moral voice in the world with regard to having alternatives to war and allowing people their own paths to development which would be very attractive.
With regard to the Bill the question the people ask, which the new Government must address, is why. The new Government must speak endlessly about jobs. This is the point for people who lose their jobs or are told they must be made unemployed. Everyone here is very reasonable and I ask people to be at least accurate about one thing I remember in this House, which is the night in September 2008 when Labour Party was left alone. The vote was 124 votes to 18 votes. We were the 18. We voted and sustained debate through two nights with regard to an unlimited guarantee that joined the debts of our speculative banks to the deficit issues of the economy. This is what we are facing tonight. I am sorry that as young a Deputy as Deputy Doherty would take it upon himself to suggest that the Labour Party was participating in any cabal. After all it was he who said on 1 October 2008 in the Seanad:
This legislation is about more than the banks. It is about offering security to ordinary citizens and to investors in Irish businesses which in turn means jobs. As the media speculated, other states may well follow this move by our State...my party welcomes this decisive move . . . I support this Bill.
With respect, it was a disaster.
I also say this now looking forward: I hope the discourse we will have now will speak about inclusion. This Bill contains some good measures, but there are also ridiculous ones. I will give one example of what I meant by the phrases, political power, administrative power and whatever. In my long time in here people agitated, for example, for the equality legislation that was introduced by my colleague, Mervyn Taylor. People imagined that when we had got the equality legislation we had arrived at a particular point, but the political science would have indicated that political power was useless without administrative power. It was only when the equality legislation was followed through with the Equality Authority and Combat Poverty Agency that it was possible to administer the benefit that had been won politically. That is the meaning of administrative power and is why we lost the Combat Poverty Agency and the Equality Agency to the right and had all the cuts. That is what citizens in a republic want; they want more political power and want administrative power. They want to communicate their vulnerability and want to be able to respond to each other's independency. The very last thing they want is more of that terrible saying that has brought us to this point now. That is why I am proud to be president of the Labour Party. If we have failed from time to time, what is never in doubt is that we were speaking about a real republic that has yet to be built in this State.
Comment on this
It is difficult to follow that. There is no one as genuine in his or her contribution as Deputy Higgins, on which I congratulate him. I also congratulate him on a lifetime of contribution to Dáil Éireann.
In welcoming the Bill——
Comment on this
I am sharing time with Deputy Dooley from Clare.
Comment on this
At no previous time was there ever so much talk in the public domain about when, how and why the Finance Bill would be carried.
Before I get into the Finance Bill, all commentators have been suggesting that politics in Ireland needs to be utterly changed and that the system for electing Members of Dáil Éireann is somewhat flawed. It is claimed that we operate a clientelist system that is totally at variance with proper governance. Ryan Tubridy's book, JFK in Ireland: Four Days that Changed a President, referred to John F. Kennedy arriving in Galway and after the American Legion provided a guard of honour, the last man in the line handed the president an envelope with a query about his American Legion pension, with which the president went on to deal. If it is good enough for the president of the United States to have people making representations to him, it is all about democracy.
An article was written on the last election for Pope in which Pope Benedict XVI was really the only nominee to succeed Pope John Paul II. He stood at the door and shook the hands and clapped the backs of each of the cardinals going into the conclave, which shows the importance of personal contact in that regard. If it is good enough to elect the Pope, we should be proud of the system we have here. With our electoral system we are very close to the people. While some might argue that other democracies are different, a former speaker of the US House of Representatives once said that all politics is local. We must ensure we represent the people who sent us to the Dáil, Seanad, local authorities or other bodies. Our system certainly keeps people firmly in tune and as we have seen if they have not been firmly in tune with it they do not regain the confidence of the people.
As we debate this Finance Bill — certainly the last Bill that will be discussed in the Thirtieth Dáil — we are at a very serious juncture in Irish political life and in the economy. We have seen the crash that has happened and the last time there was such an international crash was in 1929, which was followed by the Great Depression and people standing in the breadline. Some economic books would argue that only the build up to war in 1937 and 1938 with the demand for steel lifted the American economy after seven, eight or nine years of great poverty. We could argue that we are not experiencing the same level of poverty, but we need to support the people who are squeezed — those who have lost their jobs and those with enormous indebtedness regarding their homes and perhaps other speculative borrowing. Irrespective of what is happening with banking and so forth, the people who are really hurting are those who are losing their jobs and those whose incomes have been cut to try to maintain jobs.
We can argue the points of where we are and who was responsible, but the bottom line is that we need to face the realities of the economy and the realities of the difficulties people are experiencing. We need to ensure the measures in this Finance Bill and in the future are implemented in a measured way and are in the best of interests of everybody in society. In the period from 1926 to 1928 and right up to the crash there was an idea that the amount of wealth being generated would continue forever and the same applied in this country. When the property market was slowing down from the early part of 2006 and into the early part of the summer of that year, there were moves afoot suggesting that what we needed to keep the housing market going was to reform stamp duty. Throughout 2006 a plethora of media outlets — which are now claiming we got the policy wrong — claimed the Government was stalling the construction industry through a draconian stamp duty regime. We now know it was much more serious than it was in regard to stamp duty.
As a society, we need to be sound on a number of issues in future. As we move closer to Europe and see the benefits Europe can bring us as a peripheral island and we can see the limits of it, we also must ensure we do our own business correctly and not feed continually from Europe. We have seen the benefits in indigenous industries such as agriculture which are proving very strong in exports at this time. There are fundamental lessons we need to learn. A new financial regulatory system has been put in place in the past one and a half years. Everybody told us we had too much regulation involving too much red tape, which needs to be reviewed but regardless of what happens down the line there is a fundamental point regarding regulation in financial services.
People who have gone through this crash will experience these issues as will those who will be here in 25 or 30 years. They will be able to relate back to this period because it will be very fresh in people's minds, along with the difficulties experienced.
In the late 1970s after our entry to the Common Market in 1973, an enormous sum of money was available, in particular to the agricultural industry. People involved in agriculture bought neighbouring agricultural lands at exorbitant prices and it took a generation of farmers to work off the debt that was created. The Government of Garret FitzGerald that followed brought in a debt relief system to try to help those people out in regard to the money they had borrowed. That happened less than 30 years ago.
The fundamental point we must learn in regard to this Finance Bill and the future is to ensure that arising from the desperate lessons learned by Irish society from the crash of 2008, the huge difficulties experienced by families across the country, especially those with high mortgages and young children, or those who have lost their jobs, we should never allow any lapse in the draconian regulations which are now being put in place. We must ensure this is documented in every Department of State. Whatever benefits may be seen in the short term, in 25 or 30 years' time we must reflect back on this period and never again allow the madness that went on in financial institutions.
I am delighted to contribute these few words to the debate on the Finance Bill which is one of the most important and fundamental of its kind to come before the Houses of the Oireachtas. I thank the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for the opportunity to contribute to the debate.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute on the final piece of legislation in this Dáil term. I hope some of us will be back with an opportunity to discuss other legislation in this House. I wish all colleagues on all sides of the House who are contesting the next election the very best of luck.
It was a rare privilege for me to be in the Chamber when my good friend and countyman, Deputy Michael D. Higgins, gave his final oration to the House. I have listened to him on many occasions, from when I was a young individual interested in politics, albeit of a different colour. Nonetheless I always recognised and respected the Deputy's clarity of thought and mind, his deeply held convictions and the way in which he has championed so many good causes around the world, not only in Ireland or in his native County Clare, Galway or the west of Ireland.
It is often said that all politics is local, and that it is necessary to focus on the potholes and streetlights and street corners. That is surely very much part of political life but it is interesting that Deputy Higgins has spoken of the necessity to change the dynamic within politics. That needs to be addressed. He is and has been a great champion of equality and is someone who has reached out to those who are less well off not alone in this society, but throughout the world. This country owes him an enormous debt of gratitude for his work in that regard. I wish him well in his retirement from this House. I do not wish to suggest it will be the end of his career in public life because I know he has interests elsewhere. I have no doubt he has the capacity to take on any role he sees appropriate or fit. I extend my sincere best wishes to him and his family for what lies ahead.
Comment on this
With regard to this legislation it is clear we are facing a very difficult time as we have done from the start since we were elected in 2008. Those of us who came into the House at that time found ourselves dealing with issues that had begun to emerge in late 2006 and very quickly we were into a discussion about economic issues. There was a time when the economy was discussed only in the business pages of The Irish Times, perhaps in some journals or in the Financial Times or other media. However, from mid or end 2007 onwards, economic matters were on the front of every publication regardless of its readership or its import in general economic terms. Clearly, that has had a major impact on the lives of so many people in this country.
The most important point those of us on this side of the House must recognise is that mistakes were made. From 2002 to 2005 or 2006, it is clear that the economic policy that was developed and became the general ethos across Europe, namely, increased public spending and reduced taxation, was a model that was not sustainable. In this country the fact that we were going through our own property bubble and had become overly dependent on the transactional taxes within the property sector made the situation significantly worse.
I accept that responsibility as a parliamentarian and do not wish to be party political in regard to the last piece of legislation going through the House. However, it is worth recognising that in any budget speech one cares to research, comments by the Opposition, our opponents on the other side, clearly identified the weaknesses in the policy we put forward. However, it was not a weakness to suggest what we were doing was wrong in the way we now believe it was. The weakness was that we were not spending enough and were taxing too much. On many occasions there were speeches, Adjournment debates and parliamentary questions relating to the level of regulation and unnecessary red tape and bureaucracy that existed. In accepting responsibility or that mistakes were made, it would be welcome if all sides of the House accepted their involvement in the general lexicon, discussion and debate that existed.
Comment on this
——for sure on specifics but it is important that we look at the broader framework——
Comment on this
——and at the area which we all accept in this last period.
Clearly, the necessity to resolve our banking crisis must continue apace. The ongoing suggestion that somehow we can burn the bondholders will disappear, I hope, when we get beyond the election. I understand there are people who are trying to seek to gain political advantage by taking the debate to the lowest common denominator but we must get beyond that and will do so on the other side of the election. It will be incumbent on whoever is in charge of the next Administration to continue with a set of policies and measures that ensures we have an effective banking sector. This is not to protect or somehow enhance the privileged who sat within the banking environment or within that ethos. It is to assist the person on the street, the small business holder or the farmer, the people I and every Member of this House meet on a daily basis. It is the small and medium-sized enterprises and the farming sector that will get the 460,000 unemployed people back to work in this country. It is true multinationals play a very significant part and the increase in exports is extremely important in order to bring about a renewed sense of identity for this country and a renewed sense of employment. Ultimately, however, the bulk of employment will come from small businesses doing what they always did — providing services to the people of this country. We cannot lose sight of that.
I also wish to recognise the four year plan of which this budget is very much an integral part. A most significant amount of funding has been set aside for the educational building programme, some €1.85 billion over four years. There is no harm in introducing a little bit of a local dimension. Yesterday's announcements set in train three very important school projects in my constituency, with a new school on a greenfield site for St. Joseph's secondary school in Tulla, something that has been sought after for many years. I was happy that the school management, including the current principal, Ms Margaret O'Brien, together with the former principal, Mr. Jimmy Cooney, and the respective boards of management entered a partnership with me and others such as Councillors Pat Hayes and Joe Cooney to bring about a situation in which the Department of Education and Skills was in a position to work through a new school programme. That is an important point.
In addition, the national school in Sixmilebridge will see a very significant redevelopment, with a major extension and refurbishment works that will resolve a long overdue problem. The new Ennis national school had made major headlines in national newspapers for seven or eight years but has been given permission to go to tender, which is a significant investment in educational infrastructure. That is a right for our children and, as importantly, the teachers who have a difficult job teaching in that environment.
There are many other elements which this Government, with participation from the Opposition, has been successful in bringing to fruition over the better years when money was available. Such elements included child care, the very impressive road network and investment in agriculture and tourism. These are the important areas which will assist us in the redevelopment of our economy. The building blocks and foundations exist upon which to build a renewed economic model that will, importantly, provide employment for our people.
Two important changes have been signalled by the Minister in the Finance Bill, which I welcome. I had been in contact in with the Minister about them, although I do not take sole responsibility for the changes as I am sure many other Deputies spoke to the Minister about them too. One relates to the universal social charge and its application to those individuals who currently hold a medical card. It was identified at an early stage that it was important for people on the medical card to be given a special dispensation and the Bill will now only apply the 2% and 4% threshold rates, which is important. The 7% rate as originally identified will not be applied.
It is important that this is not about relinquishing the saving, which is to be found elsewhere. I understand that the amendment recognises that the self-employed people earning over €100,000 will make up the difference. It is right and progressive that those who can afford it will pay while those on lower incomes are protected.
I am also pleased that the Minister has accepted many of the submissions on section 23 relief, with the measure proposed in the budget being postponed for a year and subject to an impact review. I indicated to the Minister that this would have a significant impact on tourism facilities and I am aware of a number of small hotels, guest accommodations on golf courses and some time share facilities which require this relief in order to maintain facilities and attract tourism. We are all aware that the urban renewal scheme was exceptionally good and we encouraged people to invest in areas of towns and villages which had fallen to rack and ruin. Some of these house are unoccupied currently but it is a pleasure to drive through some of these places and see the level of investment which has gone into them. It is right that a significant impact review be carried out to ensure that those who have invested are not bankrupted by the decision to invest in what was a Government programme.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy Jimmy Deenihan. I am sure he is somewhere in the building and will come to rescue me at some stage. It would be remiss of me not to comment on the speech from our colleague of many years standing, Deputy Michael D. Higgins. As always, he excelled in the area and it was a joy to be along with him during his travels through parliamentary life in this House, which some of us had the pleasure of sharing with him for most if not all that time. He is a fitting example of the true parliamentarian who can use the parliamentary system and the power of speech to achieve a great deal more than many others can achieve by other methods. He also does it with much less cost. We must all wish Deputy Higgins well in his further endeavours, which I hope will continue in the public life. I hope he will remember us as we travel around and that we will, after this joust, meet and greet with him again.
On the other matter before the House, I must take issue with my colleague, the Vice Chairman of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on European Affairs, Deputy Timmy Dooley. I do not accept any responsibility and neither do all of us in the House accept responsibility for the financial position in which the people of the country find themselves. The Deputy cites instances where people on Adjournment debates and at various times in years before the 2007 election called for expenditure on schools, hospitals and other places. What else would they do having been given the impression that the money was there? The phrase was used regularly that the country was awash with money.
A perception was created that there was money to burn, which was what the Government was doing. That is where the Opposition got the impression there was money to burn and it could be seen all the time. What has happened over a long period is outlandish and outrageous. Experts have come to an agreed conclusion that what was going on from 2002 to 2007 was wrong and I cannot understand why people did not call a halt to it. There was a handful of people who tried to but were despised as being uncharitable, unpatriotic and unfit to be Members of these Houses of Parliament. It is extraordinary that people were afraid to ask questions. We had to couch parliamentary questions in such a way as not to offend those who claimed that any mention of the war, for want of a better description, would cause immediate implosion. It was coming anyway and the longer the process went on, the more serious it became.
I take no pleasure in saying this to colleagues across the floor at this stage. I have no doubt that some of them did not see this coming but I cannot understand why on a regular basis we were fed a diet of hope, support and encouragement to carry on as we were, as everything was all right and the fundamentals were correct. The fundamentals had not been correct for at least ten years and I cannot understand why the experts, support staff and advisers in the Government did not shout "Stop".
I have a theory about this. There were many advisers paid for by the taxpayer in elevated positions, reassuring the Administration that it could proceed as its course of action was right. In the old days in royal courts throughout Europe there were always people in support of the monarchy, such as jesters, advisers and soothsayers. An unfortunate jester might be brought out when the monarch was in bad form and be harshly treated if a jest was in bad taste.
Comment on this
Yes, and that is exactly what is happening. Unfortunately, it is the people who were treated like jesters in this case. They have got the back of the hand to the head and been told to get down below. We have heard the tales of people who have received a cut in wages and child benefit. The cuts take in several areas but there was no cut in mortgages; such payments are likely to increase because of raised interest rates. Sadly, every household in the country is affected in various ways, which is shocking.
The one lesson to be learned is that this should never happen again. Such events have not happened since the 1920s but it should never happen again. We hear much about reform of the institutions, with calls for changing the old ways. A retired but prominent French politician, reacting to similar calls, retorted by arguing that established old ways worked for several generations in banking and finance. What are referred to as old-fashioned economics worked nonetheless, and the people did not get bitten or squeezed. People survived because of lessons from the 1920s. Unfortunately, new ways were found and the old ways were forgotten. New methods did not work, so this politician's comments were true. What we had was a newfangled game of economics which gave people the impression that they could continue to enjoy the same lifestyle without responsibility. The Government created this perception. I feel sorry for those who led that Administration and the manner in which they influenced people. We must now pay back everything.
Ireland was fortunate to have received a loan accommodation from our colleagues in the International Monetary Fund and European Union. I hate to think of what would have happened if the IMF and EU had scoffed at us. For some years, these bodies believed the Irish economy was running wild and they could not understand what was happening here. We should not be surprised, therefore, that people look askance at this country and ask what happened to our economy. We were running it on borrowed time.
Unfortunately, the impact of the recession will be much more serious than anticipated. We do not know how various Deputies will act tomorrow but it is possible the Finance Bill will not pass. Such an eventuality would send an unfortunate, unwanted and unwarranted signal to people outside the jurisdiction. If we, as Members of Parliament, do not immediately accept our responsibilities, the pain will be extended further than the four years of the current plan. Devices will explode in the faces of our people — I speak metaphorically — over the next four years, placing further burdens on their backs.
I am sorry I do not have sufficient time to develop this subject. I hope we have learned a salutary lesson. Let us ensure that such a lesson will not be visited on a hapless people again.
Comment on this
I am pleased to have an opportunity, however brief, to speak to the Finance Bill. This is the final debate of this Dáil. I have been a Member of the House for the past 28 years and have always tried to participate in the annual debate on the finance Bill. As other speakers noted, this is the most important legislation that comes before the House. It should be debated energetically and Deputies should participate in it. Our parliamentary system could be reformed to some extent to enable more Deputies to participate in the debate.
Anyone who has been on the hustings in recent weeks will have realised that people are very angry with the Government and politicians in general. There is a perception abroad that we are all paid too much. People are maddened and riled by the severance pay available to politicians. Ministers who have served for a long time in the House are leaving politics with large gratuities of more than €300,000. From the point of view of the body politic, this Chamber, irrespective of which party or parties are in power, will have a major job to do just to restore the credibility of the political system.
I have never received as many observations and e-mails from abroad asking what is happening in Ireland. They have come from New York and Sydney and from people in the Irish technology network in the Silicon Valley who are doing their best to bring industry to Ireland. They have brought CEOs such as Craig Barrett to Dublin, Belfast and Limerick in the past three years and must now watch as the people they are trying to help destroy what they are trying to promote. This is a serious contradiction and the next Government will face a major challenge in trying to restore our domestic finances and credibility, which has been severely damaged all over the world. This country is being lampooned and caricatured in the world's media. We have seen examples of colleagues in this House being unfairly caricatured abroad. We face a major challenge in restoring the economy and the country's pride and image. If we continue inflicting the damage being inflicted at present, it is only a matter of time before those who are trying to help us become weary.
I ask the officials present to bring to the Minister's attention a specific provision of the Bill, namely, section 25 which provides for the abolition of the tax exemption provided for in section 234 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 for royalty and other income arising to an Irish resident, individual or company in respect of a qualifying patent. The provision in the 1997 Act is encouraging creativity at a time when we are trying to foster innovation and invention. As the United Kingdom takes steps to introduce a similar tax exemption, the Government proposes to eliminate the Irish tax exemption for patent income.
We are trying to create a smart economy and encourage people to enter research and invent new products. The proposed abolition of the tax exemption on incomes from patents will have a serious detrimental effect on efforts to encourage young people to be inventive. It will result in Ireland losing some of its youngest and brightest inventors to the United Kingdom and other countries. Malta, for example, introduced highly attractive provisions in its tax legislation last May, while Belgium provides an 80% allowance on patent royalties.
All over Europe, Governments are examining the issue of invention and research. We had the age of invention during the industrial revolution in England in the mid-19th century. We also had a technological revolution. We need a different type of industrial revolution, one that encourages people to think for themselves and invent. I am encouraged by the large number of young people who are producing new ideas. If they are discouraged by this measure, the legislation will have been counter-productive.
In 2007, Goodbody Economic Consultants produced a report on the Irish tax exemption for income from patents. It pointed out that the Irish research and development tax credit scheme is less generous than that of some of our European competitors and suggested the scheme be improved. I appeal to the Minister to modify the proposal. It could, for instance, scale back the level of relief to 50%. It should not be eliminated but left on the Statute Book in an amended form. If this country is to be rescued it will have to be done by people's ingenuity and intelligence. It is not just the company that gains in this respect but also the inventor. Because of corporation tax, the company would not have a lot to gain from the tax exemption, but individuals within the company are the ones who will drive exports in order to gain more from this provision. I will rest my case there.