Finance Bill 2011: Committee Stage
Contributions 1–165 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 2011 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 7, before section 1, to insert the following new section:
"PART 1
Cost Benefit Analysis of Tax Expenditures
1.—The Minister shall within one month from the passing of this Act prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on a cost-benefit analysis of tax expenditures provided for by this Act, setting out the costs of tax foregone, and the benefits in terms of job creation or otherwise.".
The purpose of this amendment is to ask the Minister to do what he committed to do in the debate on the Finance Bill last year and what he indicated to us would become a standard part of the Finance Bill — that is, the presentation of a cost-benefit analysis of tax expenditures provided for by the Act.
Despite the suggestion, which has been strongly made by Fianna Fáil in recent times, that tax expenditures and tax breaks for very wealthy people are in some ways being curtailed and phased out, the reality is that while there is a promise of curtailment of some tax breaks in this budget, the only tax expenditure which has been entirely removed is the tax relief on trade union subscriptions. We do not have a particular difficulty with that but people who pay subscriptions to professional associations, if their firms pay them, will continue to get full tax relief.
I am concerned that we have a number of new schemes in this budget, yet have no idea what their cost-benefit analysis is. I am disturbed that Fianna Fáil has decided to reject evidence-based policy-making in extending a major new programme of tax breaks to different private firms. We have already welcomed some of these breaks, such as those that amend investment in research and development. However, we now have a major change to what was the business expansion or BES scheme, which is now to be transformed into a new scheme. We were told that in the 2006 survey of the BES scheme there was no cost-benefit analysis but a survey of the beneficiaries of the survivors. We also got the names of the various companies. At that point, however, the Government's own advisers, Indecon, recommended that extensions to tax-incentive schemes should only be considered after evaluation of the results in a formal cost-benefit appraisal.
The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that that analysis takes place and is published within one month of the enactment of the Finance Bill. The new BITES scheme, which succeeds the former BES scheme, is designed to support innovation and employment. Those are two tax-support concepts which the Labour Party would support provided they are targeted and costed. In addition, their timespan must be clearly planned and set out.
We know that previous and current property-based tax breaks were a key part of the downfall of the Celtic tiger. The landmark Regling-Watson report on the cause of the Irish financial crisis and banking collapse, clearly stated that the crash was home made. It also said that a significant contributor to the crash was the extraordinary availability of tax breaks linked to property development and construction. Despite all the rhetoric we still have tax breaks focused on building private hospitals, even though the HSE has announced that the private hospital initiative is at an end. We have all received a significant number of representations, both from individuals who are using section 23 tax breaks, but more significantly from professional lobbyists for these breaks, including accounting and legal firms. In addition, charities have been established for the purpose of availing of private hospital tax breaks. Essentially, however, we have no costings. What we got from these organisations was a case as to why their commercial activity of selling schemes, on which they charge very high fees to those investing in them, should be continued.
There is almost no solid information explaining who are the people who currently have and would be affected by changes in section 23. The Minister gave us no such information. Individuals who have invested in one property for a pension could be very easily dealt with, as opposed to some of the schemes involved. Investors in these schemes got ripped off big time by some of the firms selling such schemes because a large amount of their putative tax saving was taken in fees they paid to professional advisers to set up and structure the financial deals. That is one of the reasons this country's economy, banks and construction boom crashed. If we want to prevent that from recurring in future there is a role for targeted tax incentives which are subject to a cost-benefit analysis. As well as having a specific timeframe, they should have a clear consideration for employment and innovation content. The Labour Party would be happy to support something like that, but this country simply cannot afford to extend tax breaks willy-nilly without any idea of the cost-benefits involved.
Last year, the Dáil voted to accept this amendment and the Minister produced an evaluation of schemes a month afterwards. There were very few hard figures in it concerning the cost-benefit analysis. There was just a summary of the lobbyists' views of what the schemes would do, together with some notes from the Revenue Commissioners and the Department of Finance. This country's tax breaks industry expects to write the Finance Bill and to make amendments to it which are favourable to the industry. Given my own background as a chartered accountant, I understand that it is a legitimate part of the roles of accountants and lawyers to provide taxation services but these schemes have brought the economy down. At this late stage, we ask that they be subjected to a cost benefit analysis to be published within a month.
I wish to speak about the transfer of the business expansion scheme to the BITE scheme. The Department of Finance and the Revenue Commissioners know that because it constitutes a state aid, it must go to the EU for examination and evaluation. This big new scheme seems extraordinary. It is very wide in its potential reach. While I agree with the objective of transforming the business expansion scheme to concentrate on innovation and employment, I suggest we should ensure it is ring-fenced to avoid a build-up of the abuses of the past, with which we are all so familiar.
I would say the Minister has known since early last autumn that he needed to change the business expansion scheme. Although the scheme was responsible for a great deal of important investment at certain stages, in its later days many clever accountants and tax lawyers were able to convert it, like everything else, into a largely property-based scheme. Many hotels availed of it. Such use of the scheme is among the reasons we ended up with a tragic over-supply of hotels. Many owners of traditional family hotels, who had made a long-term business commitment to the hotel and hospitality trade, became disadvantaged as a result and were jumped into availing of tax breaks at the end of the property boom. Their firms have been left with serious financial and structural difficulties.
I wish to comment on the system of tax breaks for business that we would like to see develop. We do not want tax breaks like those of recent years, which existed to boost the construction industry and caused the bubble to rise to an extraordinary extent before it collapsed. Equally, we do not want a system that serves as a corporate welfare scheme. We want a rigorous debate on the various schemes. We want the employment, innovation and research benefits of schemes to be clearly laid out for all to see. We want investment criteria to be in place. We want them to be targeted at investment, employment, research and innovation. That has to happen. We will need to do our business in such a way, which is implied in the memorandum of understanding with the IMF and the EU, in the future. I recommend the Labour Party amendment to the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order, am I correct in my understanding that sections of this Bill have been grouped?
Comment on this
In accordance with an order of yesterday, if a division is demanded on an amendment in this group, that will be put at 1.30 p.m. There will be opportunities to vote on the other sections.
Comment on this
No. What sections are we debating in this group?
Comment on this
It is a disgrace that some important sections in this group will not be debated. We will be lucky to get through two or three amendments. There will be no debate on the proposed changes to pension arrangements, for example. I am keen to draw the attention of the House to this unsatisfactory situation.
Comment on this
The Deputy will understand that the Chair is obliged to implement the order of the day, as agreed yesterday. I remind the House that the composite questions on each group will be put at 1.30 p.m., 3 p.m., 4.30 p.m., 6 p.m. and 7.30 p.m. today.
Comment on this
On a point of order, we are debating sections 1 to 38, inclusive. Deputy Barrett has a particular interest in the sections that relate to the reform of the private pensions regime. Is it in order for him to speak at this stage on one of the sections in this group, rather than confining his remarks to the amendment before the House?
Comment on this
Would it be better for me to reply to the points made by Deputy Burton before we move on to another subject?
Comment on this
I would like to comment on the same matter.
Comment on this
I am happy to facilitate the Deputies. It is important that we have a brief debate on another one of my amendments, which relates to bank bonuses. I would also like us to discuss this section as a whole because I have a number of questions on the Minister's amendment dealing with the universal social charge.
Comment on this
I understand Deputies Noonan and Costello are offering to speak on Deputy Burton's amendment No. 1. I propose to take those contributions before asking the Minister of State to respond to all three Deputies. Is that agreed? Agreed. The Chair is seeking to facilitate Members as much as possible.
Comment on this
I want to make a few remarks on Deputy Burton's amendment. The introduction of a tax break as a lever should be available to the makers of public policy. When people get a tax break if they behave in a certain way, they are likely to behave in that way. When that course of action is more expensive, they are likely not to pursue it. The first time I heard about the use of tax breaks was in the context of efforts to encourage the redevelopment of port areas of certain American cities. Derelict parts of the port area of New York, for example, were revitalised. A beautiful urban development was facilitated principally through tax breaks. The redevelopment of old areas of infrastructure, such as railway yards, which had become obsolete was driven in that way. I have seen the huge tax-driven developments that revitalised the city of St. Louis. That was imitated here.
When I was in government in the 1980s, the late John Boland introduced a raft of tax incentives. He was the first Minister to legislate for urban development in Ireland to be driven by tax breaks. He designated 39 acres of dereliction in my home city of Limerick. It was revitalised and rebuilt over a period of seven or eight years. Such an approach works well.
A social response is sometimes required. I recall a time when there was a huge shortage of nursing homes and nursing home beds in this country. After discussing the issue with us, the then Minister for Finance, Charlie McCreevy, introduced a tax break to encourage the supply of nursing homes. The investors came in very quickly and, for a short period, we probably reached a point at which there was a surplus of availability in nursing homes. That was driven by tax breaks. We should not dump on the concept of tax breaks as a lever of public policy because they can encourage investors to meet economic and social needs. People respond to the profit incentive.
I agree with Deputy Burton that tax breaks were carried too far in Ireland. The stimulation of building and development through tax breaks, regardless of the end product, became one of the objectives of the tax break industry. Problems arose when it was decided to allow people to write off the rent of whatever they built against their rental income elsewhere in the State. That was fatal. There was no real analysis of whether the existence of 25 houses on the banks of the River Shannon in County Leitrim was of economic benefit to the local area. How could it have had any viability in itself, if its purpose was to ensure one did not pay tax on property one rented in Dublin? That kind of cross-matching destroyed the situation.
I always thought it extraordinary that tax breaks were treated as farmers used to treat milk quota, in that it could be bought and sold separately from the farm. It was a tradeable asset. I could never understand how tax credits became a tradeable asset. In one case I know of, a building was built with capital allowances and sold to an investor who took in the rent, while the tax credits arising from its building were sold as a tradeable commodity——
Comment on this
——to somebody who had never had anything to do with building or development. It was a deal purely to reduce the person's income tax liability. It was the extension of the tax break industry that destroyed it. This has resulted in a situation in which the man and woman on the street are saying that tax breaks are a bad idea and they should all be abolished. It was in view of this that the Minister, when introducing the budget, said that all section 23 allowances and other capital allowances would be abolished immediately. I always thought that had a doubtful legal basis, because people who had entered into arrangements when investing in property were under contract, and the concept of legitimate expectation applied. There was a legitimate expectation that the arrangement would run until the end of the period for which the contract was signed.
I always thought — and I suggested at the time — that it would be a better arrangement if the Government had, because of the financial crisis and in the national interest, suspended the benefits for four years, so that in 2015, when times were better and the Exchequer could afford it, investors could again receive the benefit of the tax break. I think this would pass legal muster, and many investors would not have objected to it because rents are currently so low that they are not availing of the full tax credit anyway. Another major issue is that people have made arrangements with their banks for schedules of repayment, and the removal of the tax break would take the floor out from under these schedules. A deferral would not have done that, and it would have allowed investors to renegotiate deals with the banks.
Deputies Costello and Barrett are anxious to speak, so I will not continue. However, I ask the Minister to consider this again, as he has said he will do, and take these views into account.
Comment on this
I am pleased to have an opportunity of speaking on this series of amendments. It is quite a large group, covering amendments Nos. 1 to 38, but I will focus only on one or two points.
Deputy Burton referred to the tax break industry, and that is effectively what it is. At the IBEC annual forum in Tralee last year, it was stated that approximately €11 billion worth of tax reliefs are given to the private sector annually. That is an incredible amount. If we take out of this mortgage relief and so on, we are left with the three major areas of property, landlord and pension tax relief. All three of these are effectively out of control. Some people have collected enormous pension pots. We have heard that Mr. Fingleton, for example, has a pension pot of €28 million and that he may have organised tax relief on all of it. It is incredible that the man was getting all his millions virtually scot free. It is unacceptable that this has not been regulated until now.
It boggles the imagination to read, in the Minister's introductory speech on Second Stage, his comments on property-related tax expenditure. What was announced in the budget was that tax relief on such expenditure was to be abolished or substantially cut. Guess what the Government has decided now, in the intervening six weeks? The Minister stated that the provisions "will now be subject to a commencement provision which may only take effect in the next tax year following the preparation and publication of an economic impact assessment on the proposed changes". Imagine that. One would have thought that before putting it into the budget the Minister would have carried out an assessment of the proposal, which would be properly researched and published.
Having introduced the provision in the budget, the Minister now says he must do all the ground work. Where are we going? What he said was code for saying that the property tax relief industry got to him, and he has taken the provision out of the Finance Bill. What we thought was a substantial measure in December has now disappeared. What will happen now? The Minister, God help us, will not even be here another month, but he will do some research and produce a paper which will appear some time in the future. What is being proposed is outrageous.
This is the kind of thing that gives the Finance Bill a bad name — when vested interests get to the Minister in the period between the Budget Statement and the introduction of the Bill. We should be considering all property-related tax exemptions. I am not saying they should be abandoned, although by and large it is time to move away from them. Section 22 and section 23 property tax reliefs were part and parcel of the collapse of our economy and one of the reasons for the state the country is in. We should seriously consider phasing out such reliefs. A total of €11 billion is handed over by the taxpayer to various interests, largely in the form of pension-, landlord- and property-related incentives. It is not good enough. Until this is dealt with transparently, we are going nowhere. The proposed change by the Minister is a bad one, and I welcome the proposal by Deputy Burton to ensure we assess all such measures in the future so that if they do not provide decent value we can get rid of them.
There is a valuable proposal in the Finance Bill to introduce tax reliefs for improving energy efficiency in residential premises. That is very welcome. However, the total amount of relief available in a year for this is €30 million, which compares badly with the €11 billion in existing tax reliefs of various types. For a tax relief that will achieve something desirable and get some economic activity going in the building industry we are providing a measly €30 million, while we refrain from abolishing the reliefs that are going into the pockets of developers to make obscene profits. I find the Finance Bill to be obscene in this regard.
One issue that should be dealt with by the Bill is that of self-employed people who receive nothing if they lose their jobs. They are not entitled to normal social welfare payments and they have no pensions. For example, as spokesperson on transport, I am dealing with this problem as it pertains to taxi drivers. There are 27,000 taxi drivers in the State and, in the old days, they had the nest egg of the value of the taxi plate. That has disappeared. When they cease to drive their taxis, they will not have a penny for their retirement. There is no lump sum, there is nothing for them except what they might get from social welfare, which is difficult enough at present.
Taxi drivers are not the only ones facing this situation, even in the transport area. Self-employed hauliers also have no pensions. Is this not something that should be considered seriously by the Minister? Surely we should be bringing self-employed people into some kind of pension bond which would provide an incentive for them to contribute. We could use the National Pensions Reserve Fund as a mechanism to encourage something of this nature, rather than leaving such people high and dry.
Finally, I will say a word about bonuses. I was speaking, I believe, on the last day of the Dáil in December and the Minister for Finance was on the other side. The Minister for Finance said that he was going to introduce a 90% tax on all bonuses being received by the financial institutions that were subject to the banking guarantee. Those are the institutions, effectively, the State has bailed out and some of them are now nationalised. He further said, because we were discussing the Credit Institutions (Stabilisation) Bill, that he could not introduce it in that legislation, although that seemed the most relevant Bill to provide for it, as the notice was too short, but by God he was going to have his 90% tax on those bonuses in the coming year in the Finance Bill. Lo and behold, it has disappeared entirely, just like the snow we had in December. It no longer exists.
Deputies will recall we were discussing the €40 million in bonuses for AIB managers in December, that had just been announced. I understand that is due to be paid out next month. The Minister had his opportunity to act on that but he has not. Neither has he acted as regards any future bonuses. Unless the Minister comes clean and says these areas, which have the country driven mad, are rooted out then this Government and this legislation have no credibility.
Serious issues arise in sections 1 to 38, inclusive, that need to be addressed and which should be amended in the opposite direction to that being proposed by the Minister. The Labour Party believes strongly that the areas of property tax breaks and bonuses, which have corrupted the banking sector, should be addressed in this Bill because they are live, demanding issues and have brought the country to its knees.
Comment on this
I remind the House that section amendments, by order of yesterday, must be submitted to the House before 1.30 p.m. I am calling on Deputy Seán Barrett, to be followed by Deputies Noel Ahern and Pearse Doherty.
Comment on this
Following on from what Deputy Costello had to say as regards people having some type of pension, I believe a system should be introduced whereby everybody contributes towards an old age pension. It is the easy to arrange. Again, we have been fiddling around with private pension funds to satisfy the failure to deal with this issue. I shall expand on that in a moment.
Everybody should have to make a PRSI payment, including the self-employed. An unemployed person should get credits, in the event, until he or she can get employment to retain his or her benefit. It is crazy that in the case of those who do not contribute the only thing they can apply for is a non-contributary old age pension. As a result of this stupid changes are being introduced here to the present approved retirement fund, ARF, system — where people cannot avail of an ARF unless they have an income of €18,000. They then have to put a lump sum into an approved minimum retirement fund, ARMF, and leave it there until they are 75. This is a crazy way of interfering with people's personal rights. None of it was mentioned in the Budget Statement. It came out of the blue and was leaked to some people in the industry.
I received this Bill on Monday, today is Wednesday and we are being asked to make major changes in respect of an ARF scheme within two days. There is no reason why this section should not be taken out and re-introduced in the finance Bill (No. 2), which I understand is under preparation within the Department of Finance. There is no loss of revenue involved, other than what was announced on budget day, so it is simple to do. I appeal to the Minister to stop messing around with these.
The then Minister for Finance, Deputy Charlie McCreevy, introduced this in 1999, because the only option somebody had on retirement — given the amount of money in the fund — was either to take the benefit, if he or she was in a scheme or, if self-employed, to purchase an annuity. Annuities, by and large, die with the person, however, which means that the State gets less income tax as a result of somebody dying after the guaranteed period of five years. The funds then go back to the insurance company and no tax is paid on them. It was discovered in 1999 when this was introduced that the annuity rates were based on a male living until 81, which was totally out of order. It was a rip-off. For the first time we loosened this up and people did not like it, particularly those in the annuity market, because they were losing a great deal of revenue.
The introduction of the ARF scheme meant that the State got tax on every penny in the fund, irrespective of when a person died, because the fund would pass into his or her estate and tax would be collected. From the State's viewpoint it is far better to have people in an ARF, therefore, than in an annuity, yet the Government is now introducing changes that push people out of ARFs, and making them less attractive. Who wants to leave money in a fund until he or she is 75? Either one has a State pension or one does not.
For those who are not drawing down, the amount that they must take is increased from 3% to 5%. What is the reason for that? Very little extra tax will be collected but for those on small pensions the funds will run out quicker than normal. The whole idea of the ARF system was to make it flexible for people because, for example, people who retire sometimes might have children in full-time education or children getting married and therefore need more money in the early years of retirement as against what is required in the latter years. This gave flexibility, so that somebody could take more in the first couple of years than in the last couple of years of retirement. That flexibility is not available in annuities. I do not understand why these changes are being rushed in when there is no need for them, with the effect of upsetting this whole market.
On the question of pension funds, it is far more important to encourage people to save. We should be trying to make certain, as far as possible, within the restrictions being imposed by Ireland's membership of the European Union, to make it attractive for those funds to be invested in this country, and not outside. To do this a small levy should be imposed on such funds on an annual basis. Fine Gael, in its budget submission, recommended that 0.5% of a fund should be taken by the State. These are changes that could be made, while at the same time protecting the whole pensions industry.
In case anybody believes I have a vested interest, I was an insurance broker, but am no longer involved in that area although I happen to have a knowledge of it. What is being displayed here shows that those who are imposing these changes do not have a clue what they are doing. I ask that members of the pensions industry be invited into a committee of the Oireachtas where we can debate all these issues. It is for these reasons I am upset this will not get proper attention during our consideration of this Bill. I appeal to the Minister to remove this measure from the Bill and leave it until the finance (No. 2) Bill.
A large volume of money could be used for investment to create jobs. The Minister can tax it but he should not start fiddling with what people can put into their pension fund. In any case, they will pay tax when money is coming out. The idea of pensions is that one receives tax relief when putting money in and one pays tax when it is taken out. The only thing the State must worry about is the amount of money that can be taken in a lump sum. This section contains that point. I do not have great difficulty with it. I have a slight difficulty with the amounts chosen because there can be a conflict between a pension fund that is part of a pension scheme where the employee can take 1.5 times the final salary and how this compares with the lump sum under an approved retirement fund.
The Department of Social Protection was charging PRSI on payments from approved retirement funds and insists these are investment funds. That is incorrect; they are the same as an annuity and one should not pay PRSI on them. Those who are retired should not pay PRSI. The Department has now come round to the idea that one should not pay PRSI beyond the age of 66. There is no reason why they were charging PRSI because no benefit is given to the person paying PRSI.
As a result of changes in the budget, those receiving the approved retirement funds are being taxed at the January 2011 rates and are also being charged the universal social charge when the payment is from the 2010 fund. I ask the Minister of State to contact his officials to find out why one can tax someone from payments in 2010 at rates included in the Finance Bill 2011. Insurance companies tell me they are obliged to do so by the Revenue Commissioners. I fail to understand why we should have to pay tax at the new rate when the tax did not apply to the moneys earned in the previous year. This should be checked out. I appeal to the Minister of State to leave this section until the finance (No. 2) Bill.
Comment on this
I was going to comment on amendment No. 1 but there is nothing wrong with it and perhaps I should not interfere when there is an obvious disagreement between the Labour Party and Fine Gael. I am on the side of Deputy Noonan. The report of Regling and Watson is being misquoted by Deputy Burton. It was made clear by Mr. Regling that every country in the world, and certainly in the EU, has tax breaks and arrangements such as this. The point concerns the extent and the level——
Comment on this
I am being brief and Deputy Burton spoke at some length. The report by Mr. Regling and Mr. Watson concerns the extent, duration and level of some of the property tax breaks. I agree with Deputy Noonan that they are an important stimulus tool for a Government. Deputy Costello made the same point. The Minister of State has more or less agreed with the amendment by deferring the changes to section 23 until after the assessment. It was always the intention to carry out an assessment during the year. He has deferred the implementation until the assessment is done.
The Minister announced changes to the universal social charge. After the budget, an issue was highlighted concerning the theoretical self-employed person on €300,000. This person might have benefited from the budget. The change recommended by the Minister puts an extra charge on people over €100,000 whereas the original anomaly concerned those earning over €300,000. Self-employed people earning between €100,000 and €150,000 feel the change has over-compensated. In his closing contribution on Second Stage, the Minister for Finance referred to a document showing the different levels. I would appreciate a copy of such a document. The suggestion is that in regard to company directors or employees, the self-employed person on a salary of over €100,000 has been jumped on. A correction was needed for those earning €300,000 but the compensation has been overdone.
Comment on this
On a point of order, an amendment of mine has been accepted by the Ceann Comhairle in respect of the publication of bankers' bonuses. My other amendments were not accepted and I ask Deputy Doherty to allow me a moment to point out that amendment No. 4 reads:
In page 7, before section 1, to insert the following new section:
"PART 1
PUBLICATION OF CERTAIN BONUSES
1.—Each credit institution that is participating in the eligible liabilities guarantee scheme shall be required, within 30 days of the passing of this Act, to submit to Dáil Éireann details of the names of all of its officers, employees or contractors to whom bonuses have been paid between 30 September 2008 and the date of passing of this Act, and the amount of the bonuses in each case.".
Comment on this
I refer to the amendments in my name that have not been ruled out of order. This is an act of political codology. A number of speakers referred to the truncation of this Bill and the inadequate time allocated to it. In reality, the party finance spokespersons have facilitated this Bill in truncated form. None of the arguments I have heard was raised at the meeting with the Minister for Finance.
We must be honest. It is extremely unlikely any of the amendments tabled will be accepted. We are trying to make our position again and again to the Minister and pointing out that when this blows up in the Government's face, the record will show that we believed this to be a damaging Finance Bill for the people of the country. It will not get us out of the economic difficulties we are in.
Amendment No. 4 deals with the bankers' bonuses and it is important that we deal with it. When the budget resolutions were passed in December 2010, what priority did the Minister for Finance give to his officials? Did he tell them that bankers' bonuses were an issue? I have already pledged to introduce a scheme to tax bankers' bonuses at 90%. Did the Minister tell his officials to prioritise bankers' bonuses in view of the fact that a couple of months remained to get the Bill through? Did he tell them to prioritise the universal social charge, which takes people earning as little as €80 into the tax net?
I listened to members of Fine Gael say yesterday that they would accept the universal social charge if the threshold was increased by €1,000, which would mean people earning less than €100 would come under the application of the universal social charge.
The first amendment deals with the economic impact assessment——
Comment on this
I will conclude on this point. The first amendment deals with the economic impact of provisions of this Bill and how they will impact on the job creation. We have read in the newspapers of massive job losses in the retail sector. We know that they are happening already because the Minister has reduced the spending power of every citizen. I refer to the people who spend all the money they have day in, day out. The Minister has taken primarily €2 billion out of their pockets through a range of measures, brought them deeper into the tax net through the tax bands, made changes to tax reliefs, introduced the universal social charge and abolished reliefs such as the reliefs on university charges. These measures will blow up in the Government's face when the time comes.
Comment on this
It is a disgrace and I am sure the Minister of State will acknowledge that. These are such important issues——
Comment on this
——and an opportunity is not even being given to discuss them. We will have a finance (No. 2) Bill——
Comment on this
——and more than likely we will have to have a finance (No. 3) Bill to deal with this mess.
Comment on this
I just want to formally move the amendments in Deputy Noonan's name.
Comment on this
As it is now 1.30 p.m. I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dail of 25 January: "That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to sections 1 to 38 and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill and in respect of each of the said sections undisposed of, that that section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to." Is that agreed?
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
On a point of order, we have just voted on 88 amendments out of 101 in the Finance Bill. We were given one hour and 20 minutes in which to debate them. My point concerns the ordering of business in the House. It is clear that the rush in dealing with the amendments was to facilitate the Fianna Fáil leadership debate and election at 2 p.m. Fianna Fáil has put its interests and the election of its leader above democratic debate in this House. It is appalling. There are only 13 amendments remaining and six hours in which to deal with them.
Comment on this
For the information of the House, section 18, which has been agreed to, will be amended on Report Stage.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Minister of State undertook to explain to us what the amendments would be. Will he at least outline, for the information of the House, the heading of the section to which he is referring? Does it pertain to bankers' bonuses being taxed at 90%, which we were promised? Will the Minister of State clarify what the amendment will be about?
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State clarify the heading?
Comment on this
What has happened to the promise——
Comment on this
——that we understand the Independents extracted to have a tax of 90% on bankers' bonuses?
Comment on this
That is coming later. The Minister signalled this morning that was coming in, and the amendment will be introduced at a later Stage.
Comment on this
As a new Deputy, I seek clarification on whether the Minister of State needs to announce to the House on Committee Stage that he intends to table an amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has just told the House he will be tabling the amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Let me finish, with the indulgence of the Ceann Comhairle. The section to which the Minister of State is referring has been agreed to and voted upon. It is now concluded. The Opposition cannot refer to any amendments that it wants to table on a section that has already been dealt with in the House.
Comment on this
Did he advise the House at the proper time, namely, when we were discussing the relevant sections, that he is to table the amendment?
Comment on this
I wish to be of assistance to the House. I am not the Minister for Finance. Rather, I am the Minister of State at the Department of Finance and the message came to me too late to handle the matter before the vote.
Comment on this
I am entitled to a clarification on the rules of the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I always understood the position to be that a Report Stage amendment was not in order unless the material to be contained therein had been mentioned in the course of the Committee Stage debate, but not necessarily during the debate on the section in question.
Comment on this
By the end of Committee Stage. It is a general rule.
Comment on this
As a long time Member of the House, Deputy Noonan is aware that there is provision for a recommittal.
Comment on this
We can facilitate the debate via a recommittal arrangement on Report Stage when the amendment is introduced. We need to move on, as we are on a tight timeframe.
Comment on this
If I might assist the House on this matter, is this the pay and file issue, a stand-alone section?
Comment on this
We have moved past the pay and file issue.
Comment on this
It is being mentioned after the fact.
Comment on this
I do not mean to hold us up, since our debate time is limited. For future reference, is it the case that, when one wants to propose an amendment on Report Stage, one does not need to announce it during the Committee Stage debate on the sections in question? Instead, one can announce it after the sections have been voted on by the Dáil. Is it in order with the rules of the House that an amendment can be announced at any time even though the section to which it refers has been debated and voted upon?
Comment on this
I need a clarification as to how the Ceann Comhairle is implementing the rules.
Comment on this
There is a provision for a recommittal by which we can effectively have a Committee Stage debate on Report Stage, with the agreement of the House.
SECTION 39
Comment on this
I understand these sections address excise rates and a number of other matters. I am particularly interested in the provisions on excise rates in respect of hydrocarbon products. The Green Party's position was to seek to impose carbon taxes on various items, but differentiating between carbon taxes, excises and VAT impositions is difficult, given that all three apply to hydrocarbons. What are the proportions of excise, VAT and carbon tax levied on, for example, a litre of petrol or diesel?
I drive a diesel car and I find diesel to be more expensive now than it was last year. A barrel of oil costs approximately $90 whereas it cost $140 just prior to this time last year, yet what we pay at the pumps now is significantly more than what it was then. This despite the fact that the price of the raw material has almost dropped by 50%. In Ireland, the higher prices must be attributable to new taxes. Since the Government went easy on its excise increases, which would kick on into VAT, the new carbon tax introduced on the proposal of the Green Party must be causing the difficulty. The middle of a recession when jobs are being lost hourly is not a great time to increase the costs to industry and to employment. Does the Minister of State possess a breakdown, schedule or other information that shows which elements of the price are excise, VAT and carbon tax?
Comment on this
I am opposed to these sections, which will impose a significant additional cost on businesses across the State. The consequence will be a significant drop in competitiveness, which will cost us jobs. The increase in the excise on diesel is punitive.
The Government constantly preached to us that it needed to cut the minimum wage to make the economy more competitive and to help business, yet here it is doing the exact opposite, namely, increasing the cost of doing business. Jobs will fall asunder as a result. We are constantly told by the Government that it is doing something about jobs, but we never see anything concrete being done to create or save jobs. This significant gap is one of the reasons the Bill will be a disaster for the people of this island, never mind this State.
The Government also expects people who live in rural areas to pay an additional cost for fuel when they have no alternative. Large swathes of this land have no public transport, so people have no option but to have motorised transport of their own. The Bill will apply a considerable additional punishment on people in rural areas. It is unacceptable, but I will listen to the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I agree with my colleague, Deputy Noonan, concerning this tax. The price of diesel and petrol is having a terrible effect on rural Ireland. I have often put on the record of the Dáil my belief that the Green Party's carbon tax is simply a tax on rural Ireland. It is not right. This winter, people needed to buy fuel to cope with the cold weather. Deputy Noonan made a valid point. If oil is $90 per barrel, the Government and the country have not dealt with the problem of the price we pay at the pumps. We are being ripped off again. It is the old thing of rip-off Ireland at every opportunity. In the week prior to the heavy snow and before we were promised bad weather, I bought two bags of salt for €7. The following week, I went to the same place on behalf of a neighbour and found that the price had increased to €7 per bag. This is the reason our country is the way it is. At every opportunity, we rip one another off.
We all want to be environmentally friendly, but a carbon tax affects people's pockets and we in rural Ireland need our cars or other vehicles. We do not have Dublin Bus, the Luas or other forms of public transport.
Comment on this
The Deputy should be sure to give me metro north when he is in government.
Comment on this
Last Sunday, I canvassed at a house where a child was sick. The woman needed to bring her child to Westdoc. She travelled approximately 50 miles from Carratigue to Ballina to meet a doctor, not a consultant in a hospital. Her family is in receipt of social welfare payments and cannot afford this type of cost. It is fine for the Green Party and for the Fianna Fáil Ministers. For the past 13 years, the latter have not bought a gallon of petrol or diesel, have not had a meal they needed to pay for and have not known what has been occurring in the real world.
Comment on this
This tax is wrong. I am glad Green Party Members walked out of Government. It is just a pity they ever went in.
Comment on this
The first point to make about the rate of mineral oil taxes is that the expected yield from the increases in 2011, inclusive of VAT, is approximately €106 million. Were we not to proceed with these changes, we would need to find €106 million elsewhere. While it is correct that people in rural areas are more dependent on car and motorised transport generally, in principle the carbon tax affects everyone who drives regardless of the parts of the country in which they live.
I was asked for the details concerning the current percentage component of carbon tax.
Anyone who crosses the Border will be aware that petrol and diesel prices are still significantly higher in the North than in the South with an approximate difference of 10% to 15% in price. The carbon tax element on a litre of petrol costing €1.19 is 4.2 cent, inclusive of VAT. In the case of diesel, it is 4.9 cent on a litre of diesel costing €1.10. Despite what Deputy Ring assumes, I buy diesel and if I knew anywhere it was being sold for €1.10 a litre, I would be around there pretty smartly. In my experience of recent pricing, it is more likely to cost €1.36 or €1.38. I think the tabular information with which I have been supplied is somewhat out of date.
The total excise on petrol is 57.6 cent per litre, of which the carbon tax is 3 cent. The point being made in the information is that carbon tax is a small additional element. I suspect that the next international crisis could be an oil-related one. We have to try to be more efficient and more economical in the use of petrol. A small level of carbon tax is a financial incentive to be economical. Irrespective of this one element, it is also a case that the State needs the revenue.
Comment on this
I wish to raise a point relating to section 46 of the Bill which makes a number of amendments to Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Finance Act 2002, in connection with the taxation of betting and related activities. Subsection (2) provides for the repeal of sections 17(2) and (3) of the Finance Act 2009, relating to the rate of betting duty. This provision was made in 2009 which allowed the Minister to increase the betting tax from 1% to 2%. I am aware of the changes being proposed here and to which I have no objection. However, I find it extraordinary that the Minister sees it necessary to repeal this subsection. It is included as a precaution. In the event of the new system not working, it would be easy for the Minister to increase the rate from 1% to 2%.
With regard to betting tax in general, one of the most important industries outside of the cities and towns in this country is rural-based horse breeding and horse training. It supplies a great number of jobs in areas where it is extremely difficult to get employment. Regardless of whether we like it, the number of jobs is reducing. A total of 85% of foals born in this country are exported so this is a valuable export industry in itself. People will not breed horses unless there is a reasonable chance of a reasonable return in prize money when the horse is put to race. Horse Racing Ireland does not have the money to give to prize money or to provide any other grants for improving conditions at race tracks or at dog tracks in the case of the greyhound industry. Both industries are vitally important.
When Fine Gael went into Government in 1982, betting tax was 20%. In his first budget, Alan Dukes reduced the tax to 10%. Over the past number of months and years, we have heard whingeing from bookmakers about a 1% or a 2% levy. We cannot expect the taxpayer to fund racing and those involved in the industry do not want the taxpayer to have to fund it. I enjoy a bet from time to time and I have no problem paying 2% tax on my bet. For every €100 bet, I will pay €2 and 20 cent for every €10 bet. Kids will not pick up a 20 cent coin off the street nowadays and yet we are allowing an industry to collapse. We are fussing around with bookmakers who are complaining, the Paddy Powers and the Ladbrokes of this world. They go on about the jobs they are creating but they forget about the jobs being lost.
I appeal to the Minister not to include this provision as there is no reason to repeal that subsection. It should be left in the Bill in the event that a future Minister may think it necessary to increase the rate from 1% to 2%. I ask the Minister, not from a party political stand point but in the event of helping the industry as a whole, to leave the tax alone. If the new provisions do not work then there is a fall back to increase the rate from 1% to 2%. I ask the Minister of State to ask the senior Minister to agree to delete this provision on Report Stage if not now and to allow the rate stand. I welcome the efforts being made by all concerned, including those in the Department of Finance, to deal with offshore betting and the attempt to deal with the exchange betting. Great efforts have been made and I congratulate those involved.
We must ensure that an important national industry does not fall by the wayside like it has in other countries. It should be borne in mind that Ireland and Britain are among the few countries with off-course bookmakers. All other countries depend on funding racing and the greyhound industry through Tote betting. I have no vested interest other than to see an industry thriving as it is a great flagship industry for the country. Ireland is renowned for its horses and nothing should be done to damage that industry. This provision is completely unnecessary, in my view.
Comment on this
I concur with much of what Deputy Barrett has said. Almost 30,000 people are employed on a full-time or part-time basis in various sectors of the horse and greyhound industry. I regret the complete shambles made of the arrangements over the past 13 years by Fianna Fáil and its various Government partners. We saw a parade of different vested interests all looking for an angle, all promising to deliver a high-quality product. One of the reasons many people from other countries come to Ireland is because of their interest in racing and horses. I refer to a regrettable result of the collapse of the boom which attracts media coverage. At the edges of my constituency, in Dunsink, horses, mostly palominos, are running wild. Many of them were starving during the cold spell. People may have bought a couple of horses and had them in training or in a field or paddock and now that the construction industry has collapsed some of these horses have been left almost to fend for themselves. It is not good in a country with a long reputation in the horse industry. People who emigrated from Ireland over the past century and a half and their descendants have been heavily involved in horse racing and breeding in countries to which Irish people traditionally emigrated such as the United States and Australia. The mess we have the moment is a reflection on the fact that Fianna Fáil in government caved in to vested interests with no clear insight as to what was best for the long-term future of the industry.
My perspective is that the earlier model was more attractive, with a number of tracks for horses and greyhounds throughout the country where people can go, as opposed to being bent over a computer screen consumed by the type of gambling which has a very high risk of addiction. There is potential for much money to be contributed to the national purse and ploughed back into the industry if we can get this right.
I have seen some of the Independent Deputies lobbying heavily for slot machine casinos in Ireland. The last proposal for a slot machine casino was in my constituency on the edge of the Phoenix Park, at the old Phoenix Park racecourse which had many deficiencies, as I am sure Deputy Barrett would have known. However, it was a wonderful tourism amenity for the Dublin area. The proposal collapsed and it never happened because it was for a casino with 1,600 slot machines. I want to say to people who are being persuaded that the best thing for Ireland when we are on our knees is that we have Las Vegas style slot machine casinos, that they would wipe out most of our horse racing industry and do the same to our greyhound industry.
I am probably one of the few Deputies in the House who worked in Atlantic City when I was a student. Unfortunately, people who go to slot machines are not James Bond in a dickie bow going to play blackjack or cards at a table in a casino. I have no problem with this type of operation where most of the people have quite a lot of money. However, I certainly do not want to see pensioners and people on social welfare incomes being shipped by bus to slot machine venues where they are relieved of much of their meagre income. In the United States a huge body of work is being done on the slot machine casino industry in areas of land and reserves owned by Native Americans. In South Africa at the time of apartheid, bantustans and areas such as Swaziland and Lesotho were used as venues for slot machine casinos. This is a personal view of mine and I know other views are held in the House.
In the Fingal County Council area in north County Dublin, where I was a local authority member, and in Dublin city long campaigns were fought, certainly by Labour Party politicians, to get rid of slot machines and slot machine arcades where much gambling was occurring, which was very damaging, particularly to young people and those with an addiction to gambling. People are holding up slot machine casinos as a way to save Ireland. This is a trap and we would live to regret the social impact on society. A day out at the races or a night at the dogs is a great and enjoyable experience and very attractive to visitors. We should think about how best to encourage and promote this as part of an overall development of leisure amenities and tourism in this country and leave the mega slot machine casinos. Anyone who has ever worked in a casino environment will realise that a casino with 1,500 slot machines is the size of three very large supermarkets. It is a gigantic undertaking and one would need very large bus loads of people who are very often on very low incomes to feed the machines. That is how it works.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom labhairt ar an cháin bhreise atá á ghearradh ar pheitril agus díosail. Tá sé go huile agus go hiomlán dírithe ar ghnáthdhaoine na tíre, ina measc an lucht gnó atá ag brath ar iompar a gcuid stuif timpeall na tíre. Tá sé go huile agus go hiomlán i gcoinne aon rud a bheimid ag iarraidh a dhéanamh amach anseo chun an geilleagar a athógáil.
The Minister of State accepted that he somewhat underestimated the cost of diesel and petrol when he read out the figures. When he corrected the figure it showed the scale of the change in the price of diesel and petrol in the past year alone. This has a specific consequence for small businesses in particular and those living in rural Ireland. Those living in larger cities have a public transport network and I will come back to this. However, in huge tracts of Ireland people are totally dependent on motorised vehicles. Small businesses trying to export our goods are also dependent on trucks and vans to shuttle their goods around the country to ports. The biggest problem is that the public transport network and the train network have been reduced and undermined in recent years by a lack of proper investment. An alternative is not there for many small businesses dependent on motorised transport.
This is a very penal tax increase and it should be resisted in every way. I am not one to encourage more and more cars in the street. However, in this city the Government has reduced the subvention to the public transport networks in recent times. So much for the Green Party and its endorsement of public transport. Years of underfunding have meant that even in this city where one would expect public transport to be the most effective and efficient for everyone to use, it has not delivered and it has not been delivered upon by the Government.
Small businesses have already been screwed by the Government because additional taxes have made it more difficult for them, as have the lack of credit from the banks and the rates increases from local authorities. I do not blame local authorities. The problem with local authorities is that over the years the Government has underfunded local authorities so their only recourse in many ways is to further tax local businesses and shops.
I urge that this Bill be totally rejected. The only part of it which I support — but which should not be there — is the reduction in the travel tax. If we are to build Ireland the travel tax should be removed altogether. There should have been an opportunity to remove that tax altogether.
On a point of order, I ask that a quorum be called.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
The seats feel okay over on this side.
Comment on this
I would be happy to get any seat at all, myself.
I wish to speak to section 46 and in particular the betting duties. Section 46(2) provides for the repeal of sections 17(2) and 17(3) of the Finance Act 2009 relating to the rate of betting duty. I do not understand why the Minister is seeking to repeal these sections. The Labour Party through its former spokesperson, Deputy Upton, published a very comprehensive paper entitled Raising the Stakes, in which she established a formula that would allow for a greater degree of online capture. Mr. Kavanagh from Horse Racing Ireland gave a comprehensive overview on the state of play at today's meeting of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. His overview referred to a fourth consecutive cut to the horse and greyhound racing fund which has fallen from €76 million in 2008 to €57.2 million in 2011 and that this was not a sustainable position from which to develop a key industry.
Across the political divide we have as a common cause the interests of the horseracing and greyhound racing industries. However, we must ensure the provisions at paragraphs (f), (e), (d) and (a) stand up to scrutiny. I do not understand why the Government is not going after the online capture. I would like further clarification as to how these provisions will translate in real terms. I do not understand why the taxpayer through the Exchequer should continue to fund the industry directly through the provision of prize money. We all understand it is an extensive industry and support the aims of Horse Racing Ireland, but we must ensure tax is captured from the punter and anybody who makes a bet whether it is online or through bookies offices on-street.
I speak for people like Mrs. Bambury in Mallow, who is a second-generation bookmaker but who does not have an online presence. The levy is being collected and yet there are bookmakers in Mallow — which has its own racecourse — which have an on-street and online presence also. There is a disparity between the collection from the on-street presence and the lack of a collection from the online presence. We should go after the online betting and we need to go after the exchanges. It is disingenuous for certain celebrities to push the exchanges as being somehow very egalitarian in their outlook. Our interpretation is that, by their very nature, the exchanges will pay out the prize money, which is fair enough. However, it will be the Exchequer — the taxpayer — which pays the prize money at the racing stadia and so on. We need to introduce a level playing pitch here. I am not clear as to the various paragraphs. We need a proper analysis. Perhaps we should look at the French model in terms of collection. The submission by Mr. Kavanagh to the Joint Committee on Agriculture, Fisheries and Food was an in-depth one and there was an actual willingness on the part of Horse Racing Ireland to engage on the issue of capturing more revenue through more imaginative means. I ask for a response to that point from the Minister of State.
I am conscious of time. HRI made a presentation to the committee today. There are 9,530 registered breeders in Ireland, some 15% are overseas investors and 92% own fewer than five mares. There were 416 stallions at stud in 2008, of which 362 stood for a fee of €7,000 or less. We must support the industry but we must also ensure that such support does not militate against the taxpayer. The industry must find more imaginative ways to fund the prize money henceforth.
Comment on this
I agree with the sentiments of Deputy Sherlock regarding Horse Racing Ireland. I understand it has been proposed to set the licence for online betting at €5,000. There is a danger this licence may facilitate cowboy online bookmakers from abroad who would come to and register in this country and signal on their websites they were registered and approved by the Irish system. There is a danger of fraud being committed by Internet cowboy bookmakers who would do damage to Ireland's reputation. Perhaps we should consider increasing that fee to €30,000 or €40,000, which would deter such bookmakers. Those in the country who work under the licence in good faith would not have any difficulty in paying that, as I understand it. We should consider increasing the €5,000 licence fee which would discourage the online cowboy bookmakers.
Comment on this
As one who does not engage in betting online or offline, I found this debate fascinating.
Comment on this
Is the leadership contest not a form of betting?
Comment on this
No, it is not, at least not in our party. I was not present at the time but Deputy Barrett asked about the 2% duty provision. As I understand it, this is regarded as not required which is why it is being repealed. However, according to the answer provided to me, the opportunity of reintroducing it remains.
Comment on this
Nonsense. I have a point of order. I appreciate the Minister of State was not present but my point was that this measure was introduced in 2009, giving the Minister power, by order, to increase the duty if he or she wishes. It should be left there and left alone. There is no reason to take it away or say it is not necessary. Who knows whether it may not be necessary in a year's time?
Comment on this
That is a valid comment but my understanding——
Comment on this
——is that it can be reintroduced. I shall make the Deputy's point to the Minister when I speak to him — in whatever capacity he may return to the Chamber.
Comment on this
The predominant part of the discussion since I came into the Chamber has concerned how to capture the online sector. As all of us know there is no doubt this sector has grown very dramatically in recent times. It is a very difficult area to capture. Obviously, provisions and arrangements will be made by regulation. We all accept that a regulatory framework must be put in place which will deal with betting exchanges and remote or online betting. I did not entirely understand the point made by Deputy Burton. As her colleague, Deputy Sherlock, pointed out, racing is a very important part of the economy, a point often lost sight of in the debate. Even a non-punter like me can see it is a critically important industry.
The proposal in the Bill aimed to create a balance by extending a modest rate of 1% to online and telephone betting, thereby creating a levelling of the playing field notwithstanding the point made by Deputy Barrett. That is the logic behind this section of the Bill.
In reply to Deputy Andrews' concerns, obviously any form of change is open to exploitation by those who are willing to operate outside the law. Again that is a matter for regulation.
Deputy Ó Snodaigh touched on remoter or wider parts of the Bill when he spoke of the differences in the excise duties on petrol and diesel. It is an interesting point and I will reply to the Deputy through his colleagues. Petrol is generally 7 cent cheaper per litre in the Republic than it is in Northern Ireland while the differential for diesel is 20 cent. That is why there is such purchase of fuels in the South by people registered in the North. The differential is so handsome that it pays certain people to operate outside the law and become involved in illegal activities, but I am sure no Member of the House has any such connection.
Comment on this
No, the sections are all taken together.
Comment on this
We will take each section as I put it. Deputies may challenge a section but the vote is——
Comment on this
No, we accept the Leas-Cheann Comhairle will bring it——
Comment on this
We raised this at the previous sitting where all sections were taken in one vote. We understood that all sections were to be taken together. On that basis, in regard to section 39, if the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is not following what was done in the previous——
Comment on this
I will tell the Deputy what the order of the House is. Each section is put separately. If a section is challenged the vote is postponed in accordance with the order of the House. In this case the group will be taken together at 3 p.m. but I must put each section separately.
Comment on this
That did not happen at the earlier stages. Must we revisit the earlier sections?
Comment on this
That is a matter the Deputy can take up with somebody else. I am putting the section now.
Comment on this
There is confusion. I oppose section 39.
Comment on this
Very good. I shall put the question formally and if there is a vote it will be deferred.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 89:
In page 186, line 11, to delete "€3" and substitute "€2".
This relates to the travel tax which my party proposed to scrap in its entirety in our alternative budget.
The Minister has reduced the charge from €10 to €7 and we propose to reduce it further to €2 or zero, if the Minister would accept that. The issue sends out the wrong message. We know tourism figures are well down, with numbers down by a couple of hundred thousand in the past year. That has a direct impact on many tourism providers, including those involved in accommodation, retail and amenities. People are under serious pressure, having built up businesses on established tourist numbers. They are falling away and nothing is being done to help these people; the opposite is occurring, which brings a direct cost on jobs and will put more people on dole queues.
In our alternative budget we put it up to the airline industries, indicating that Michael O'Leary, Aer Lingus bosses and anybody else involved should put their money into a marketing campaign and match the resources of the State in this area in order to bring in clients. If they can prove that the reduction of the tax will bring more people into this country, we will leave the tax at zero. If they fail to do so the tax can be reinstated but they should be given the chance to prove that the Government is wrong on the issue. These parties have been campaigning with an argument that the tax should not be in place, and we agree, but we challenge them to prove it.
By keeping the tax, the wrong message will go out. A person booking a flight online will see increased taxes, which will put him or her off and that person will go elsewhere. The Minister seems to believe people do not choose where to fly based on price increases of €3 or €4 but they do. When people pick a country to visit they can see the prices for flights so when taxes start building up they soon become disinterested and go elsewhere. Tourists are voting with their feet and not coming to this country for many reasons, one of which we know is the travel tax.
At this stage I ask the Government to consider reducing the figure. We would prefer to see it gone altogether but we had to put down an amendment for the €2 figure. The issue should be given some real thought as the message is wrong. We are suffering in this country because of a lack of tourists and we can really grow the sector and create jobs.
Comment on this
Deputy English made a very coherent address outlining reasons for not having an airport travel tax. I concur with everything he says because it sends out the wrong signal. The amendment his party has put down relating to the tax sends out an equally wrong signal as the party does not propose to scrap it; the amendment proposes to keep the travel tax with a reduced rate of €2. In my opening contribution to Committee Stage I argued that this is an act of political codology. The Deputy said the party would prefer to see the tax scrapped.
Comment on this
Yes but this is where we introduce aspects into law. The budget proposals will not mean anything for Ryanair or Aer Lingus, and it will not change the signals to those who want to come to this country. That will be affected by what we decide to introduce into legislation. The amendment looks to put into legislation an airport travel tax of €2, which Fine Gael would secure if the Government accepted the amendment.
The Deputy is correct in that it would send out the wrong signals to the tourist. This is a sector with the potential to reach significant numbers of people and create jobs. God above has provided assets for this country that we have not exploited properly, including our scenery, cultural tourism, language and the hospitality and good nature of Irish people. We must tap into the goodwill within the Irish diaspora to help the country regain its position in the eyes of the world. There is much potential in the tourism sector. I will not focus any more on Fine Gael bar to say that if we are to have an election debate, we must be honest with people. There is no point saying that the airport tax will be scrapped while at the same time introducing an amendment fixing a €2 rate.
The Minister's reduction of the rate to €3 does not go far enough. We should be clear that the airport travel tax should be scrapped, as this would not just be revenue neutral but would benefit the Exchequer because of an increased tourist flow to the State. It must be acknowledged that the amendment presented by the Government is an acknowledgement that introducing a travel tax of €10 was wrong. This is acknowledged through the amendment put before the House.
The Government may not be in a position next year to introduce a budget to correct the wrongs of this budget. Just as it was wrong to introduce a €10 charge, which is being acknowledged in the amendment, it is equally wrong to introduce the €3 charge. I know, coming from the north west, the impact of the downturn of the numbers of tourists coming to the region. Other measures in the Finance Bill relate to increases in petrol and diesel, which were dealt with in section 39, but we must look at the Finance Bill as a unified piece of legislation. All these measures have an impact on tourists.
Comment on this
I will conclude very shortly. I understand there is no time limit on Committee Stage as long as I speak to the amendment.
Comment on this
I am indicating that I would like to facilitate others. The Deputy can monopolise the time, as is his right.
Comment on this
I would not wish to do that. One could reasonably ask what difference €3 will make. People travelling from Boston, New York, Australia, Shanghai or New York would pay an extra €3 but their holiday will cost hundreds of euro at the very least. The cost may be in the thousands of euro if families come along. One can add the costs of increased excise and taxes. A person coming to Donegal cannot jump on the train so a car must be hired and filled at the petrol station. That person must pay the excise duties, with the rates being increased by the Government in this budget. The person will also pay the additional airport tax. The signal is that this place is closed for tourism purposes.
The reduction of the rate does not go far enough as we must put a stop to the signal that this place penalises tourists. This may have more to do with supporting the 100,000 people who will leave our shores in the next two years; they will have to pay €7 less. It is the wrong decision and the tax should be repealed. The section should be replaced with a section deleting the airport tax in its totality.
Comment on this
I am surprised at the outburst from Deputy Doherty. I appreciate he is a new Deputy but he is probably not aware that sometimes with a finance Bill an amendment is tabled in order to facilitate debate. At least Fine Gael tabled an amendment, as I do not see any amendment on the list from Sinn Féin.
Comment on this
Fine Gael has facilitated the issue.
Comment on this
He is probably used to shouting down people but I like to do business in an orderly fashion. I listened to him and am now replying. Sinn Féin has no amendment dealing with the imposition of a travel tax and Fine Gael has tabled an amendment reducing the tax. We would prefer if the tax was at zero but we are also realists in so far as the State must collect revenue. We have produced a budget based on the fact that the Government is retaining a €3 travel tax. To show our disdain for the idea of a travel tax in the first place we put down an amendment in order to debate the issue, which is more than Sinn Féin has done.
Sinn Féin should stop at every possible opportunity looking to introduce party politics into every amendment. It is criticising either the Labour Party or Fine Gael on every occasion. It has made the point that it does not believe in increasing taxes but it wants to increase expenditure. It has not indicated how everything will balance so we accept that the party lives in a fairyland. It should not spend its time criticising a party putting down an amendment to reduce the proposed tax when it has nothing to contribute.
As my colleague, Deputy English, has said, as an island nation it is crazy to impose any travel tax. We must encourage people into and out of this country. If they are travelling here on holiday, they must return home. It is beyond belief that we would impose a tax on travel when we want to create jobs and the tourism industry is crumbling. Any hotelier, publican or guesthouse owner will tell one what is happening in the tourism sector. We should do everything possible to boost tourism and create jobs. We should not have taxes which discourage people from visiting this country.
I ask Deputies to support the Fine Gael Party amendment and ensure the air travel tax is progressively abolished. While the composition of any new Government is a matter for the electorate, I hope the new Administration will abolish the tax at the first opportunity. In the meantime, the amendment reinforces the argument that Ireland does not need a travel tax when tourism numbers are in decline, the tourism sector is on its knees and hotels are closing. It makes sense to avail of every opportunity to use tourism to ensure there are better days ahead.
Comment on this
On a point of order, while I take on board the problems outlined by the previous speaker——
Comment on this
My point of order relates to the rules of the House, on which I seek clarification. Having discussed the air travel tax with my party team, I was of the view that if one tabled an amendment, for example, to delete the figure of "€3" and replace it with €0, it would be ruled out of order, as has been the case with many of my amendments.
Comment on this
That is the reason the Fine Gael Party amendment refers to a figure of €2.
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy not table an amendment? He should not criticise my party for doing so.
Comment on this
I do not propose to explain the procedure governing amendments as it is a matter for the officers of the House to explain.
Comment on this
The Deputy is making excuses and engaging in another attempt to attack Fine Gael and the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I did not have a chance to complete my point of order.
Comment on this
The procedure of the House is that when the Chair stands other Deputies must take their seats.
In the few minutes remaining, I am anxious to allow the Labour Party speaker to contribute and the Minister of State to reply. I advise the Deputy to raise the procedure for tabling of amendments with the Office of the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
On the air travel tax, I welcome the Government's decision to reduce the air travel tax to €3. At a time of great economic crisis and high unemployment Governments must be careful about the taxes they introduce. Unfortunately, the air travel tax was exactly the type of tax we did not need at an extraordinarily sensitive time for the tourism industry. While the reduction is welcome, the Government could have gone a little further. The challenge for the various operators in the tourism industry is to show that the reduction will produce a flow of visitors.
One factor which would help Ireland to recover would be a return to traditional and basic industries such as tourism, rather than construction and property development. Despite the many reductions in wages and salaries, Ireland remains an expensive country in which to live. Its high cost of living was the cause of upward pressure on wages. Hotels and other elements of the tourism industry are trying to give good value for money. This is a welcome development because we must bear in mind that other countries are competing strongly. For instance, for a considerable part of last year's off-season, Spain offered extremely attractive packages to tourists aged 55 years and over. Reports indicate that the attractive hotel rates that were made available in regional and tourist resort hotels in Spain last year were very popular with retired Irish people.
A new Government will have to focus on developing a policy to show that Ireland as a tourist destination is not only attractive but very good value for money. We do not want visitors from continental Europe, the United Kingdom or the United States being shocked at the costs they encounter when they arrive. We need to develop package programmes which ensure tourists, particularly those of average means, are well advised of what will be the likely cost of a good holiday, whether long or short. An all-in package approach would, I hope, help reinvigorate our traditional markets, namely, the United Kingdom and United States.
Comment on this
States must generate revenue and Ireland is not alone in imposing a tax on air travel. It is noteworthy that the United Kingdom applies a rate of £12 or €14.20, while Germany, France, the United States and Austria apply rates of €8, €4, $14 and €8, respectively.
Comment on this
Unlike Ireland, those countries are not broke.
Comment on this
We do not know the extent of their solvency. In any case, Ireland is not unique as air travel taxes are common across Europe. A number of countries in the European Union, including the United Kingdom and France, apply similar taxes, as do Australia and New Zealand. The United States has also introduced a tax on tourists travelling to the country by air.
Comment on this
The countries the Minister of State cites are not islands in the Atlantic.
Comment on this
The rates of tax applied by the countries to which I refer are higher than the Irish rate, in some cases substantially so. The trend in Europe is towards applying a tax on air travel. Calls have been made to abolish the tax on the basis that it adversely affects the number of people travelling to Ireland. The Minister has difficulty accepting this proposition and considers that the impact of the air travel tax has been overstated. The numbers travelling appear to be more closely related to other factors, including the level of economic activity. Notwithstanding these reservations, the Minister decided that a single, revised rate of air travel tax of €3 will come into effect on 1 March. He indicated that the reduction announced in the budget should only apply on a temporary basis and that the rate would be increased unless there is clear and decisive evidence of an appropriate response from the airlines to increasing capacity and numbers travelling to Ireland by air. He was pleased his budget announcement was supplemented by an incentive scheme introduced by the Dublin Airport Authority for a full rebate of airport charges for additional traffic delivered above a certain threshold based on 2010 passenger numbers.
A modest air tax of €3 will yield close to €35 million in a full year. The case for reducing the tax further does not stand up, particularly as we are undergoing fiscal pressures and there is a requirement that the tax system be viewed as fair. The reduction in the air travel tax was a significant concession. The correct approach is to wait to see whether passenger numbers increase on foot of the change. In that regard, the cost of enhancing the concession further would be more than €10 million. In that context, the amendment is not accepted.
Comment on this
As it is now 3 p.m., I must deal with the deferred divisions. On section 39, a division has been challenged. The division will now proceed.
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
As we have passed 3 p.m., I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 25 January 2010: "That the amendment set down by the Minister for Finance to Part 2 of the Bill and not disposed of is hereby made to the Bill and in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said Part, that the section or, as appropriate, the section as amended, is hereby agreed to."
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 90a:
In page 196, before section 52, to insert the following new section:
"PART 3
Information on Tax Exiles
52.—The Minister shall within one month from the passing of this Act prepare and lay before Dáil Éireann a report on the contribution made to the Exchequer and in particular the contribution in that regard as a result of the measures introduced by the Finance Act 2010.".
The purpose of this amendment is to restate the position of the Labour Party on this issue. Significant numbers of people — the Revenue Commissioners suggest the figure is between 2,000 and 3,000 — are tax exiles from this country but, although technically not resident for tax purposes, they have the ability to come in and out of the country at frequent intervals, have homes here and, to all intents and purposes, live large parts of their lives here. Such people should make a contribution in this time of national economic emergency.
When the Minister presented the 2010 budget in December 2009, he announced that he would ensure a contribution was made to the country's coffers by non-resident tax exiles. However, while people in the PAYE sector and in business ended up paying their increased taxes almost immediately, nothing has happened yet in this regard. The Minister introduced the universal social charge in his budget speech early in December of last year, and those with private and public pensions were shocked when they opened their pension cheques this year and found that even those with medical cards, who had previously been exempt from such charges, and those with pensions of less than €26,000 — that is, most public service and private pensioners — were paying the new universal social charge at the top rate of 7% on their relatively small pensions.
On big days in this 30th Dáil, as more and more emergency measures were introduced and as the coffers of the State were being plundered for money to hand over to the banks, there was a phrase that Fianna Fáil Deputies were particularly fond of using, namely, "We are all in this together". Surprise, surprise: we are not all in it together. The people who have the use of clever tax advisers and accountants and who have offshore and onshore residences have been able, during the boom years, to be resident in the country but not resident for tax purposes. Following a campaign by the Labour Party, which I spoke about many times on the floor of the House, it was agreed that tax exiles should contribute to the Exchequer. The Minister said in his Budget Statement in December 2009 that he would make provision for this in 2010. When I asked questions about it, I was told that no information would be available until October 2010, and when October 2010 came, I was told "Sorry — we actually meant October 2011". This is in contrast to the people who opened cheques this month to find they were paying the new tax, the universal social charge, at fairly hefty levels from 1 January, having heard about it only in December of last year.
I ask the Minister for Finance and Fianna Fáil to agree to this modest amendment, which is phrased the way it is in order to be acceptable under the rules of a money Bill, under which it is impossible for the Opposition to table amendments that result in changes upwards or downwards in the taxation system. It is impossible for the Opposition to table motions that result in changes upwards or downwards in the taxation system. We want to have the report one month after this Act, because it is important, particularly for people in the PAYE sector, to know what the Fianna Fáil mantra, "we're all in this together", actually means.
One thing that has been most striking for Deputies on all sides of the House was the position of the self-employed in the construction industry, whether contractors, sub-contractors or ordinary workers, when the boom collapsed. Although they had been paying PRSI contributions and relevant contracts tax, RCT, where tax was being deducted at source in the case of contractors, once they lost their jobs and money, they could not claim unemployment benefit. Think of all the sub-contractors on the Pierse contract for the building of schools who found they could not be paid except by the liquidator, who had no money, even though this was a State-initiated PPP. They might have had a claim to job seeker's allowance but not to job seeker's benefit. However, if a spouse was working and earning a relatively modest amount, because the job seeker's allowance is means tested, this meant in many cases that the unemployed partner had no claim to that either. Very hard working self-employed people around the country, who, despite their businesses failing, made contributions, but have no entitlement to any type of State support. This is a major social issue all over Ireland. Remember that many tax exiles who have made fortunes in development and construction moved themselves and their wives offshore to facilitate tax planning and then came back to Ireland. Now look at the small people who are self-employed and how badly many of them have fared.
I recommend the Minister accepts that this report should be put before the House. The cost would be minimal, but it would give us the numbers of non-resident tax exiles and the parameters regarding the contributions the Minister for Finance believes it is reasonable they should make. I commend the amendment to the House on behalf of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I welcome this amendment tabled by Deputy Burton and the Labour Party. As she rightly says, a Finance Bill, while it deals with income and expenditure and sets out a tax code for the full administrative year, is probably the only vehicle through which Members of the House can seek from the Minister and the Department of Finance a report on issues of concern that arise from time to time within the tax code.
No doubt the Minister of State, Deputy Martin Mansergh, is aware from his constituents in Tipperary South that the matter Deputy Burton raised is an issue of genuine concern. Despite the minimal changes that have occurred in recent years, there is a necessity for a comprehensive report, as Deputy Burton has said, to be able to reassure compliant taxpayers, the PAYE sector in particular, that there is fairness in terms of how these individuals are treated, what their status is, the length of time they stay in this country and the parameters around that. It is inherently right to insert this amendment in the context of this Bill to allow for that report. Even if the Minister was to assure the House that while it might not be possible in the context of this Bill but at some time in the near future a report would be issued by his Department along the lines suggested by Deputy Burton, some good could come from that.
The changes announced by the Minister for Finance on 7 December, the changes on budget night and those being enacted in this legislation have a dramatic effect on ordinary people, particularly those on low means. We know the consequences of the new social charge in respect of taxpayers on incomes of €4,000 or more now in the net, despite the amendments announced yesterday. The most obvious unfairness, irrespective of the failure to index tax credits, is that there is now a marginal rate for taxpayers on an income of €32,000. Once an income reaches €32,000, a person is paying the top rate of tax, along with the 7% and 4% social charge, effectively bringing the top marginal rate to 52%. Having had a period over many years when tax was relatively low, we are rapidly moving to a very high marginal rate. It is a difficult situation, where incomes are being slashed and in many instances where people are on part-time or no longer able to access overtime. They are also being affected by a very high new marginal rate of tax of the order of 52%. It is within that context that this debate is being framed.
People know the scale of the adjustment that has to occur in this country over the next few years to bring Ireland back to some form of economic stability. People are prepared, albeit in difficult circumstances, to make the adjustments in terms of their household income and in terms of the income that exists within this society. However, what they want to see throughout is a fundamental principle of fairness. People will do the heavy lifting in respect of the adjustments that have to occur if they believe that those at the top, in particular, are shouldering the burden and are prepared to make a contribution over and above ordinary and lower income taxpayers. We have an unusual situation, a type of "flight of the earls" in which people enter and leave this country, being treated as some type of high-bred class in terms of their tax status. That we allow such a situation to exist within the tax code adds to sense of unfairness that has to be tackled, so I very much support the amendment.
I am all ears to hear from the Minister of State, in the event that it cannot be done in the context of the Bill, why this might be the case. However, we have to be aware of this issue if we are asking people on relatively small means to do much of the heavy lifting in this economy over the course of the next few years. The tax code has got to be and must be seen to be fair to all.
Comment on this
I support the sentiment behind the amendment. It is interesting that an amendment must be tabled in this way, asking for a report to be laid before the House, in order to deal with the issue of tax exiles. A practical amendment could be lifted and accepted by the Government. In saying that, I magnify two aspects that are wrong with this House. One must invoke ingenuity in order to get around the rules of the House. If one manages to do so, the Government will not accept the amendment because of a convention in the House. In the time I have been here, the Government has accepted two or three amendments from the Opposition. This is telling. It says it all about how this place operates. It is crazy.
Millionaires and billionaires are avoiding paying tax while those on the new minimum wage are caught to some degree by the universal social charge. People are swanning around, not paying their fair share. The Government ignored suggestions in the Sinn Féin pre-budget submission, which sought a fair taxation system and a new tax band of 48% on those earning in excess of €100,000. This only covered that portion of individuals' income but was ignored by the Government. The other important element of the submission was to introduce a wealth tax. This amounts only to 1% and concerns wealth in excess of €1 million. There was an income-related context so that a pensioner living in a little cottage in Ballsbridge, which could be worth substantially in excess of €1 million——