Finance Bill 2011: Committee Stage
Contributions 166–322 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 2011 ›
Perhaps some are still in that category, albeit reduced in value.
Comment on this
It would need to be a cottage orné like in the constituency of the Minister of State.
Comment on this
Did the Government want to deal with a fair taxation system, whether concerning tax exiles or the wealth I have described? The Government patently ignored it and went after the usual suspects, those on low incomes across the board. That is grossly unfair. People said that Sinn Féin is not prepared to increase taxation but of course we are. We are prepared to introduce cuts in the public sector. We have outlined that in terms of capping salaries of €100,000 and dealing with the pay of Ministers and Oireachtas Members. People ignored what we were proposing. Let us call the adjustments cuts.
It would be interesting if the Government accepts this amendment. Perhaps the Leas-Cheann Comhairle can advise on the following matter. Will this be invoked one month after the passing of the Bill? Does that mean that the Dáil will not be sitting by then? I am sure there is provision for this somewhere.
Comment on this
It is the prerogative of the Taoiseach. I look forward to hearing from the Minister of State.
Comment on this
Unless requested, I will only address what has been discussed.
I accept it is a fraught question and there are genuine concerns on this matter on all sides of the House. The difficulty about it is that, in this sense, we are not an island and the greater the wealth, the greater the mobility. One only has to read the press across the water for debates that reach into politics, where treasurers of parties are involved in non-domiciled rules. I do not propose to accept the amendments but for the following reasons. The report proposed by Deputy Burton is clearly a report on the contribution to the Exchequer made by so-called tax exiles. The Minister has stated on previous occasions that he is informed by the Revenue Commissioners that there is no one register or list of so-called tax exiles and nothing in Irish law thus far makes reference to tax exile status.
The taxation of individuals in the State is in line with that prevailing in most OECD jurisdictions. Individuals who are not resident for tax purposes pay tax here only on income arising in this State. They pay tax on income arising in the State and from income derived from working here. Many individuals — I am not saying most or all — who declare on tax returns that they are non-resident in this State do not have an Irish address. Many of these non-residents are foreign nationals or have a foreign domicile and many non-resident Irish citizens or Irish domiciliaries included in this figure may have become non-resident for reasons unrelated to taxation but may have retained Irish investments such as rental property. Individuals leaving the State are not required to give reasons for leaving. In other words, it is not true to say that 6,000 individuals, or whatever number is suggested, are tax exiles. Some non-residents have an Irish tax liability but it is not true to say that all or most of them are Irish domiciled individuals who have moved out of Ireland for tax reasons. As there is no definition of tax exile in Irish law, nor any way of determining how many non-resident taxpayers are non-resident for tax reasons, it is difficult to prepare a report on the subject.
In referring to the measures introduced in their Finance Act 2010, the Deputy is presumably referring to the domicile levy charged on an individual Irish domiciled and an Irish citizen whose worldwide income exceeds €1 million, whose Irish located property is greater than €5 million and whose liability to Irish income tax is less than €200,000.
Incidentally, in the previous year's Finance Act, the Minister abolished the Cinderella rule. This was originally introduced when the Labour Party was part of the Government. Before the abolition, an individual could be present in the State for most or practically all of the day, provided he or she left just before midnight. Hence the name Cinderella.
Comment on this
Most of these folks might have a bit more than that. The current rules state that an individual can be present in the State for 182 days or less and still be non-resident. As it is difficult to estimate the number of individuals who satisfy this criteria, it is not possible to predict the number of individuals subject to the levy or the likely yield from the measure. This is the reason for regarding the amendment as premature. The first payment date for the domicile levy, as Deputy Burton correctly pointed out, is 31 October 2011 in respect of the 2010 tax year. Once there is a yield from the levy, it would be more sensible to prepare a report on the subject. Whether I am in the House, I shall look forward to it with interest and anticipation. This point has been much discussed in the House and in the relevant committee. I look forward to how the next Government will deal with this subject.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said it all there. I wish him the best of good fortune in returning to the House but, obviously, that will come down to the voters of south Tipperary. The Labour Party has an excellent candidate there in my Seanad colleague, Senator Phil Prendergast, who I hope will also be returned to this House.
Comment on this
She is not a Cinderella, rather she comes from a background of having been a very experienced professional midwife. If she is elected to this House, it will be a first for this House to have a Member who was a professional midwife of long standing and who would have such experience of the health services.
The Minister of State said it all in one, namely, that if the first contributions from the arrangements entered into in last year's Finance Act and announced in 2009 produce a contribution, it will only come in, as it were, in October 2011. For the many people absolutely astonished by the rigour and level of the universal social charge, they basically got about three weeks' notice of it and bearing in mind that notice period included Christmas and all the bad weather at that time, it is no wonder people did not necessarily spot it in the budget coverage.
I was involved in a debate here on budget night with the former Minister, Deputy Harney, and I raised with her the issue of medical card holders having to pay the new universal social charge. If I recall correctly, she stressed that it was the policy of the Government to decouple the whole issue of taxation and medical cards. People who were setting out the policy did not have regard to the level of contribution required by people in quite poor economic circumstances and they were going to proceed with the measure, partly because of the IMF. This is one of the problems with the Irish taxation system. The former Taoiseach, Garret FitzGerald, has spoken about it on a number of occasions. The Labour Party, Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil would disagree on many tax issues and on the effectiveness and fairness of taxation.
We have a hollowed out tax system in respect of which use is made of an enormous variety of loopholes and contrivances and tax advisers are used across a wide range of taxes. There are people with significant wealth, influence and power whose view of taxation in terms of a contribution is "We will not pay a cent". We do not have, as there is in other countries, an ethos whereby one makes a contribution, even if one is very wealthy and such a person does not use his or her wealth status to avoid making a contribution. It is not enough for somebody who has become very wealthy and who is very successful in business to say that his or her success in business — which is celebrated — involves him or her providing employment for people, even though that is welcome. Many multimillionaires and billionaires are to be congratulated on their success and good fortune. In some cases some of them inherited their wealth. They just happened to be born in the right spot with the right name, but in many cases people are substantially self-made or have made fortunes built on more modest amounts of money that their parents may have left them.
Comment on this
Such people cannot simply avoid making their fair contribution. If reform in this area is to be introduced by the next Government, it will be difficult because these are very powerful people, with vested interests and they employ the best lawyers in the world. We have to get everyone in this country contributing at an effective rate. That is the only way we will keep taxes low and moderate, which is what we need. We must get everyone to contribute.
It is regrettable that for seven or eight years Fianna Fáil — going back to the time of Charlie McCreevy, moving on to the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Cowen, and now the current Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan — has ducked and dived on this issue. I think it was I who coined the term the Cinderella clause in terms of midnight, which has become part of taxation language. When the Cinderella clause came in approximately 18 years ago, based on a British clause, most very wealthy people in Ireland then did not have personal helicopters to take a little ride out over Lambay island or Howth Head out of the jurisdiction for a couple of hours and then hop back again. What we need, and I hope it may emerge in the coming election, is a consensus from all the parties that even people of great power, wealth and influence — who are widely and correctly admired by many and many of whom I know are very charitable — must contribute their fair share. I ask the House to support the Labour Party amendment.
Comment on this
The vote will be deferred until 4.30 p.m. in accordance with the order of the House.
Comment on this
We oppose this section. I am interested in hearing from the Minister of State the rationale on the question of consecutive days. This section which is an amendment to the principal Act substitutes 28 consecutive days for seven consecutive days and I want to hear from the Minister of State the purpose of that in respect of this amendment of the principal Act.
Comment on this
I do not propose to accept this amendment. Section 53 of the Bill amends section 17 of the VAT Consolidation Act 2010 to extend the notification requirements on foreign-based mobile traders, namely persons not established in the State supplying goods for consideration in the State.
Section 17 provides that where a premises provider allows a foreign-based mobile trader to supply goods for consideration on his or her land for a period of less than seven consecutive days, the premises provider must notify Revenue of the mobile trader, and this notification must be made 14 days in advance of when the trading takes place. This arrangement informs Revenue that the mobile traders are trading in the State and Revenue can then visit these premises to ensure tax possibly due by these foreign-based traders is returned and paid to the Exchequer. Currently, there is no obligation on premises providers to make such advance notification to Revenue if the mobile trader trades in goods for periods in excess of seven days.
The stipulation on seven days is now considered to be too restrictive, particularly in reference to the types of events, now more commonplace and occurring nationwide, but lasting for periods in excess of seven days, such as boat races, fairs, Christmas markets etc. Some of these events have up to 70 stalls and many traders are from mainland Europe, but not established here.
Section 53 amends section 17 to provide that the period of trading by a foreign mobile trader, which would require a premises provider to make advance notification to Revenue, is being extended from seven days to 28 days. I would just clarify that the period provided for notification by premises providers, currently 14 days, is not being amended by section 53.
This amendment is an anti-evasion measure to ensure that Revenue is aware of various different events happening countrywide, lasting up to 28 days. The information is received in the various Revenue districts and compliance officers are then sent out to visit these premises to ensure tax properly due by these foreign-based mobile traders is returned and paid to the Exchequer.
I repeat, this amendment will assist in combating tax evasion by foreign-based mobile traders. Perhaps in the light of that explanation, the Deputy opposite might consider withdrawing the amendment.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State give some examples to the House of foreign-based mobile traders? Is the notification period to be extended? That would seem sensible enough as a means of making it clear to the authorities that a certain trader is coming such that they could ensure they have the wherewithal to deal with the matter. However, in doing that, would conditions be made more restrictive for traders entering the country?
Comment on this
I gave some examples and referred to boat races, fairs and Christmas markets. We can all imagine events around the country that have many stalls. Such events occur fairly frequently in towns and parts of cities. I do not know what examples are required beyond those I have listed.
Comment on this
Section 53 is effectively an amendment of the principal Act. Where did it come from? Was it flagged to the Department by the Revenue Commissioners? Who lobbied for a change to the principal Act?
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners. As the Deputy would expect, the Revenue Commissioners have a part to play in respect of most anti-tax-evasion measures. There are also traders entering the country through Northern Ireland.
Comment on this
Is this section an amendment to the principal Act in respect of the application of VAT to immovable goods provided by public bodies? I presume the measure extends VAT to local authorities' goods and services in respect of which no VAT applied heretofore. The Minister of State may correct me if I am wrong. It is an important issue.
The section deals with the capital goods scheme. In amending the principal Act, have the Revenue Commissioners and the Department assessed the likely financial imposition of the proposal on public bodies? I am aware of a case in my local authority area in respect of which VAT is deemed to apply based on decisions of the European courts. I am not exactly certain that the legislation applies in this instance. I am interested in hearing the rationale for the change the Minister of State is proposing to make to the principal Act.
Comment on this
This section amends section 95 of the Value-Added Tax Consolidation Act, which deals with transitional arrangements relating to deductibility for housing and burial plots sold by public bodies that have been subject to VAT from 1 July 2010. The amendment provides for a deductibility adjustment, which is to be no greater than the amount of VAT due on the sale, for housing and burial plots sold by public bodies on or after 1 July 2010 which were required or developed by them before that date and where there is otherwise no entitlement to VAT input credit.
Since 1 July 2010, the deductibility adjustment has been provided administratively pending the necessary amending legislation. If I understand the section correctly, it is less an imposition and more a relief for public bodies. Sometimes, if one does not have one side, one cannot claim it on the other.
Comment on this
Is the measure only implementing a decision taken last year in respect of the change?
Comment on this
The first part of section 57 deals with the exemption from VAT of public postal services provided as part of the universal service set out in the EU postal directives. It extends this both to An Post and any other designated provider of that service. I presume this means postage stamps will remain free of VAT, in addition to postal services, be they the traditional services provided by An Post or those provided by new providers that may be competing in the deregulated market.
As we come to the end of the life of the 30th Dáil, it is appropriate to state on the record that very many postal workers, bus drivers and other drivers in various public services did a lot to help those who would otherwise have been very isolated and alone during the recent cold spell. In the rush to deregulate postal services and amend or lose the universal postal service, this assistance should be noted. In a country like Ireland, which has a large number of roads and some very isolated housing, the services of postmen and postwomen are really valued. Their services comprise an important part of the fabric of the State, particularly in rural areas.
Now that there are many changes and a collapse in banking, it may well be that instead of having large numbers of banks in Ireland, particularly in smaller towns and some villages, there will be but one large Irish bank. A bank comprises a very important part of community services, particularly for those in isolated areas and those on low incomes.
I welcome the confirmation that cultural services are to remain exempt from VAT. I am sure the Minister of State must have been influential in that regard. The exemption is to apply to charges such as those to enter museums and stately homes. It is helpful that there is confirmation in this regard. The measure helps to keep prices competitive, both for the Irish and tourists from abroad. Last year, following an EU court case, local authorities had to charge VAT on services provided. I welcome the recognition of organisations such as museums. It allows them to continue to apply the VAT exemption to their services.
Comment on this
I endorse everything Deputy Burton said, especially on the value of the postal service. As she pointed out, the service is particularly valuable in rural areas, where on weekdays one can predict within an hour the time of arrival of a postman. Despite the discussions, debates and rationalisation attempts of the past 20 years, the service to the door continues in the majority of cases. Long may it do so.
I will confirm explicitly that stamps are free from VAT. I take a certain interest in stamps, having been for many years a member of the philatelic advisory committee. I welcome that the standard internal post rate of 55 cent has been maintained for many years.
Comment on this
We were wondering why Mr. Haughey was going to be on the next range of stamps.
Comment on this
We will definitely keep the Minister of State on that body.
Comment on this
It is normal for a Taoiseach on the centenary of his birth. No exception would or should be made for Mr. Haughey.
Comment on this
The Minister of State should remain on that committee.
Comment on this
I needed to resign when I became a Minister of State.
Like Deputy Burton, I welcome the clarification regarding cultural services. As we know, all of the principal cultural institutions and many of the buildings run by the Office of Public Works are free of entry charges. Some places have an entry charge where it acts as a rationing mechanism or there is a high level of foreign visits. Even in museums and galleries, there tends to be a charge on special exhibitions to make them financially viable. Our existing policy, which has lasted for many years, is essentially a good one.
Comment on this
I ask for the Chair's indulgence while I stray slightly as others have done.
Comment on this
Will the Minister of State ask the Government to reconsider its recent decision to abolish the patent royalty relief? During the past four or five years, various Ministers have often referred to our smart economy and the importance of its continued development. One imagines we would be encouraging the people in question to be innovative and to develop their entrepreneurial endeavours. As such, the abolition of this relief is a serious retrograde step in respect of the many small people who have tried to develop indigenous industries, particularly in the current climate. I fully accept that many of the big people, as it were, abused the system to some degree.
Comment on this
I beg the Minister of State's indulgence in straying slightly from the topic.
Comment on this
No, but the situation is serious and I ask the Minister of State to redress it. Many people have been innovative because of the incentives provided up to a maximum of €5 million. Most of our small industries, particularly outside the major urban areas and industrial centres, benefited from the support provided through these incentives.
The Government repeatedly discussed the smart economy, but how can we reconcile the abolition of the relief with the considerable support that the Government is providing to research and development at third level? People who are trying to develop enterprises outside third level institutions and on their own initiative are being penalised. Will the Minister of State re-examine this issue and reduce the relief in such a way as to eliminate those who were abusing it? Instead of a complete abolition, the relief could be reduced by half or even 33%. There is no point in throwing the baby out with the bath water. It would be an iron-fisted response. I would appreciate it if the Minister of State could inform the House about the saving that will accrue from the abolition of the relief and about whether a cost benefit analysis has been carried out.
We sell ourselves as trying to encourage foreign companies to come to Ireland and the consequential research and development, particularly in University College Galway, where outstanding and innovative work has been done. Galway has become a hub for medical devices. Despite the fact that money is being pumped into research and development at third level, will such work now be de-incentivised? Reconciling the abolition of the relief with where we want to go is difficult.
This might be my last opportunity to contribute in the House. I would like to offer a sincere word of thanks to my colleagues, first and foremost those in Galway East, and to wish those who are retiring well, those being, Deputies Connaughton and Treacy. In particular, I wish Deputy Treacy, who stated yesterday that he will not be going forward for re-election, a speedy return to health. I also thank the Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh, for his outstanding work and the support he gave to the people severely affected by the recent flooding in east County Galway, be they in the Ballinasloe or Gort area. Some doubted him, but he followed through on his assertion that he would take the lead role in driving relief forward. I compliment him in this regard and hope that the work will continue to provide relief for the many people whose incomes and households suffered.
It is regrettable that we cannot get many insurance companies to respond to the needs of people. They have taken a heavy-handed approach by refusing people home insurance. Those people will live in constant fear until such time as full remedial works have been carried out to prevent further flooding.
I wish all candidates, particularly my colleagues, well in the forthcoming election. Deputy Brian Hayes is a former student of mine, one of whom I am proud. I wish him well, not only in this——
Comment on this
Now the Minister of State knows who to blame.
Comment on this
I wish him well for the future.
We must examine issues throughout the country, in particular those that arise frequently. The question of special needs is important. When legislation was introduced in the House, the only missing element related to the rights of people with special needs. Sure enough, it turned out to be an important element. It is regrettable that the rights to which they were entitled were seriously qualified by the availability of resources. Many of the people we as public representatives encountered ten or 20 years ago have grown old. Their greatest fear is the future facing themselves and their siblings. It is a difficult future. They campaigned to achieve even the basic entitlements and it was a long and difficult struggle. It is regrettable that special needs children have to go without. They are being put back into mainstream education and they will lose out substantially and their future lives will be restricted as a result.
There are many other issues I would like to have seen addressed. I greatly appreciate the Acting Chairman's flexibility with regard to time. We must accept there are so many fine people in the public service and in the Civil Service who are never recognised for their true worth and the work they do for the community and for the services provided by Departments. Their positive response on all occasions to our representations has been wonderful. I pay tribute to them all.
Comment on this
The immediate matter raised by Deputy Burke relates to income tax and corporation tax in sections of the Bill which were dealt with this morning. However, I will convey the Deputy's comments to the Minister. I thank him for his camaraderie in the Seanad and the Dáil. I deeply appreciate his recognition of the work we are doing on flood relief in Galway and which will continue under the next Government. More than 62 minor relief works were carried out in 2010 in south and east Galway, and major schemes, including those in Claregalway. We are tidying up the Ballinasloe area. Intensive discussions are being carried on with the insurance industry to ensure that they recognise where works are being done that this alters the risk factor. A very small handful of properties cannot be economically managed by works and practically all of them are in the Deputy's part of County Galway. The Minister, Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív and myself are trying to address this with the very small number of people involved.
I wish Deputy Burke the very best in the years ahead and I thank him for his long public service.
Comment on this
I wish to ask a question on section 57.
Comment on this
We have five minutes in which to finish with two sections but I will allow the Deputy.
Comment on this
I did not have an opportunity to refer to the betting tax issue when it was being discussed in an earlier section. I am dealing now with section 57 but I am aware that the House dealt with the betting tax issue earlier.
Comment on this
I ask Deputy Hayes to deal with section 57 as these sections must be finished with by 4.30 p.m. and another section awaits.
Comment on this
I just want to ask a question. The third section of this new section refers to the VAT on betting. The first section deals with the question of postal services and the second section on cultural institutions. If I can have the indulgence of the Chair, I wish to ask one question which I was unable to ask at the time because I was not in the Chamber. I refer to the 1% turnover tax and the annual renewal fee which will now be charged to all the operators who provide Internet gambling, seven out of ten of whom are outside the State, effectively offshore. Did the Minister consider the question of increasing the annual renewal fee for all operators? I understand from the previous section that this fee ranges from €5,000 up to €100,000. Has the Minister considered imposing a higher starting point which would ensure that the fly-by-night operators would be persuaded not to come into our market? It will be very difficult to collect the 1% turnover tax from operators who are not based in the State on the basis that we do not have a particularly good record in chasing down turnover in operations not based here unless we have armies of people in the Revenue who will be able to chase after these issues.
In the context of this section, has the Minister looked at an enhanced annual renewal fee which is proposed in the Bill to ensure that the revenue will be larger than just 1% and those who are not based here and who might attempt to hide the turnover tax will, at the very least, have to make some significant contribution by way of looking for a licence to operate here? I ask this in the context of section 57(1)(c). This subsection will come into operation on such day or days as the Minister for Finance might appoint by order and different days as may be appointed for different provisions for different purposes. Why is the operation of the subsection subject to ministerial order, as opposed to other sections where an operating date is clearly notified?
Comment on this
I will explain the purpose of the section. Paragraph (c) replaces paragraph 10(1) of the schedule relating to VAT exemption for certain types of gambling by inserting a new subparagraph (1A). This new provision includes within the current VAT exemption bets and commissions that have been made subject to excise duty by a separate provision of this Bill in section 46. The bets and commissions in question are bets entered into remotely by bookmakers with persons in the State and the commissions of betting exchanges earned from bets entered into on the exchange by persons in the State. The reason the amendment is subject to a ministerial commencement order is because the application of Internet betting duty is itself subject to a ministerial order.
Comment on this
Now that the House has dealt with section 58, we must take the deferred division on amendment No. 90a in the name of Deputy Burton.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Regarding the health insurance levy, it is very hard for people to understand how the Supreme Court made a landmark decision on risk equalisation in 2008 and yet the Government has stated that legislation to deal with the issue will not be ready until 2013. This levy is an imposition on people who, in many cases, are finding it difficult to manage already. It also raises fundamental issues of health policy. We have a health service with major difficulties; we have extraordinary inefficiencies and at the same time extraordinary stresses and strains on our hospital service. We have an undermanned general practice primary care service and are not investing enough in general practitioners' training. People are being charged for a visit to a GP in a way that would be unacceptable in any other European country. Why is the Government perpetuating inequalities at a time when there should have been a fundamental reappraisal of health policy and how the health service operates?
This is my last time speaking in this House. I hope one of my legacies will be in regard to producing in 2001 the Labour Party policy document "Our Good Health", which was the first policy document of any party that developed a worked-out health insurance model to provide equal access for all while also providing for an efficient health service. I regret very much that the Labour Party was not in a position to promote that in Government but it has been gratifying that even though at the time it was considered too radical — Fianna Fáil of course bashed it and Fine Gael kept silent — as time has gone on Fine Gael has accepted the merit of our position and has made its own proposals. Even on the Fianna Fáil side there has been grudging acceptance that it is the way forward. I would hope that whatever vicissitudes and difficulties the next Government will need to endure — it will undoubtedly endure many — providing and developing a universal health service with equal access for all would be its legacy.
We should consider how major progressive reforming policies were initiated in the past. I can think of two developed by Fianna Fáil Ministers, one was the access to second level education and the other was reform of general practice to provide medical cards on the basis of equal access so that it is against the law for a general practitioner to discriminate in any way between his or her private and public patients. Why were these considerations not brought into play when introducing fiscal policy that would underpin a decent health service and give us what the people are entitled to have as members of the European Union? Most of the population automatically presume that they can rely on such a health service where people are treated equally.
We will not oppose the provision on stamp duty. It was my honour to serve in the rainbow Government as Minister of State with responsibility for housing and urban renewal. Again, it would have been helpful had both this Government and the previous one given an honest statement or assessment of how things went so wrong. When we left Government I was conscious, because of information that came to me, of an increase in house prices in the private market — it was quite evident. I was satisfied, and the evidence is there on an absolutely factual basis, that we had managed to keep within the income and mortgage ratio required for a manageable market. We could stand over that record. Unfortunately, when the new Government came in the system and the market spiralled out of control. Some people made very large amounts of money while others have been very badly shackled with negative equity and very large mortgages at exactly the wrong time of their lives. Many are young people hoping to set out and have families at an expensive time of their lives or perhaps they already have young families and now have this crippling burden.
The Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh, is an intelligent and, I believe, an honest man. Why has a good, hard, concise assessment not been carried out? This Government is coming to the end of its days but we have a Civil Service which has provided information, analysis and very good advice through the years. We now have a situation from which none of us can take any heart because the hole dug for us by Fianna Fáil in particular is so deep it is very hard to see a way out of it. I believe the new government will provide the road to recovery and a fresh start which, even in itself, will be helpful. The one thing we must not do is repeat the mistakes of the past.
We already discussed tax breaks. When I was Minister of State one of the first things I did was to commission a review on urban renewal designation, what worked, what did not, what worked aesthetically, environmentally, socially and, most important, what worked economically and financially. That was a useful piece of work that at least tried to provide an honest appraisal of what had happened. We made mistakes. I would be the first to say the seaside renewal scheme was not a success and anybody who looks at the effects it had cannot take much heart from it. Ultimately, none of us is infallible. It is the lack of honesty and responsibility on the part of this Government which I find unnerving. I had to smile when I heard the Minister for Finance, Deputy Lenihan, talk about the Opposition being in denial. Wow.
Comment on this
We are only in the halfpenny place.
I do not wish to create any difficulties because this is the last time I shall speak but I must say some words of thanks — to the Ceann Comhairle, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, the Acting Chairmen and those who preceded them. I have been a chairperson and I know it can be a boring job as much as anything else but it requires diligence and fairness and I am very grateful for that.
I wish to thank my colleagues. As Members of this House we rely on a solidarity but it must be one based on principle and integrity. I am very comfortable in being able to say that has always been the case in the Labour Party since I came into this House and I am extremely grateful for that.
I wish to thank the Ministers I had to shadow; in health, the Minister, Deputy Harney, and the Minister for Energy, Communications and Natural Resources, Deputy Ryan. I mention one particular thing the Minister, Deputy Ryan, did which was very helpful. He ensured that civil servants in his Department were very open to providing members of the Opposition with briefings and ensuring we were well informed and able to access their expertise. Not all Ministers are as generous. From our point of view this has led to a more informed debate.
There is a final point I wish to make. When I came into this House in 1992 it seemed as if a new dawn had broken. Women had, in effect, been absent from this House. In the 1950s they were known as the "silent sisters" because they were the relations of Deputies — no other women were elected. In the Dáil prior to 1992 there had been women pioneers such as Nuala Fennell and others who had led the way. Coming into the House with a new cohort of women Deputies I thought something new was beginning. It is my great regret we have stalled in that progress. I have no idea whether there will be more women in the next Dáil; I hope there will but I will not be overly expectant in that regard. I hope we can achieve some kind of parity in the future. I urge the two parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, to look to their own in this regard. The Labour Party worked very hard to ensure we achieved the election of a critical mass of women but we are only one party. There is a terrible gap or lacuna in both those big traditional parties in terms of female representation. The responsibility lies with those parties to make the break through and change.
The only time I felt afraid in this Chamber was when we began the debate on the abortion referendum and I realised there were so few women in this House. There were six or seven men for every woman so there was only a handful of us who could ever know or imagine what it was like to have a crisis pregnancy. That was a lesson that made me more determined to defeat that referendum and I am very glad the Irish people chose to do that. However, it certainly brought home to me that it is not a fully functional Parliament unless we can have that kind of balance in the future.
I do not wish to speak much longer other than to thank those who assisted me. I also wish all those other Members who are retiring from this House all the very best and, more particularly, I wish those who are going forward well. It is a hard station to stand for election. Representing the people is a great honour but it is not easy and is not getting any easier. In my view it is getting harder. Some of the personalised attacks on the Taoiseach, Deputy Cowen, were unacceptable. It is neither right nor fair that anybody should have to put up with those kinds of attacks and in particular it is not right or fair that his family should have to put up with them. I do not say that people in this House have been guilty of that; I do not believe they have. However, when one looks at the public space this is unacceptable. That should be recorded. I thank the House.
Comment on this
To clarify, we have agreed section 59 and are now on section 60. Deputies Pearse Doherty and Seymour Crawford indicated they wish to contribute on this section.
Comment on this
Given the ticking clock and the limited time we have to deal with these matters I will try to keep my comments very brief.
I enjoyed the final statement from the previous speaker and I wish her well in whatever course of action she takes in the future, as I do all retiring Deputies after the dissolution of the Dáil in the coming days.
Perhaps the Minister of State can shine some light on aspects of section 60. It is obviously very technical and refers to previous sections of enacted Bills.
I welcome the section dealing with first-time buyers with regard to those who are incapacitated in terms of a dwelling house or part of such a house. That is welcome.
I have a question on the abolition of the relief for the transfer of a site from a parent to son or daughter. Will the Minister of State provide information on the cost of that relief in the first instance? We all know how the Irish people have an affinity with the land, arising from the history of landlordism and evictions of the past. We are talking about a modest transfer within a family to a son or daughter, with the State taking money as part of that land transfer. The value of the pieces of land in rural Ireland would not be excessive and I am not referring to those who are trying to abuse the system, as we have seen with bankers who transfer property to spouses in order to evade the grip of NAMA. We are talking about genuine people who have worked hard for the wee piece of land with two or three family members and where there was always an intention to pass the land on in order for sons or daughters to build properties.
Perhaps it is not the case that they will come under the revision and there will still be an exemption but will the Minister of State clarify the issue? I am not sure if it is a practical step and I do not see the value or benefit. I am open to suggestion from the Minister.
One of the big problems with the section is that when the Minister of State dealt with section 60, he spoke about the revision and simplification of the stamp duty mechanism. He spoke about the abolition of reliefs and those who wish to live alone and take advantage of the exemption relating to first-time buyers. Parents or a trust would buy the house on the behalf of these people and although they would not previously have been classed as first-time buyers, they will now be classed as such as the act is on behalf of another person. I disagree with the assertion that this will stimulate the property market and commence the necessary infrastructure for the commitment in the national recovery plan for a site value tax. I am fundamentally opposed to the intention behind this.
The details and effect of the measure with regard to taxation is separate. This is being used to bring in a property charge, which is the fundamental problem for me and my party. I outlined in my Second Stage contribution how indirect taxation is relied on heavily by the State, with 42% of taxes collected in 2008 in the form of indirect taxation. This is another form of such taxation, which as we all know is not progressive. Although a property tax may be somewhat progressive, it does not deal with ability to pay because it should be income-linked in the first instance. The best way to ask those who have the ability to pay to give their fair share is through direct taxation, so there is a fundamental opposition to the intention behind this section.
As the Minister indicated, this commences the necessary infrastructure for the commitment in the national recovery plan for a site value tax. This plan should be abandoned. As I mentioned in discussing the transfer of land from father to son or mother to daughter, the relief will be extinguished. We are missing a paragraph in this legislation which would deal with the scandal that was the transfer of assets from those who have liabilities to this State through the banks and NAMA and who are transferring assets willy-nilly to spouses.
This takes me back to the priorities of the Minister for Finance and his officials — although I do not blame the officials — in the construction of the Finance Bill. Why is there no amendment dealing with banking bonuses two months after the publication of the budget? I mentioned on Second Stage that the Finance Bill is very technical. It is very difficult for a new Deputy who is not a chartered accountant and who does not have an economics degree to deal with it. If I were Minister for Finance I would have told officials to include the amendment dealing with bank bonuses at an early stage. If we had to wait for a finance (No. 2) Bill in order to introduce a charge on those earning as little as €80 per week in the guise of the universal social charge, so be it.
The same logic would apply to stamp duty, an area in which those with liabilities are transferring assets in a fashion that appears completely legal now. That is the information I have been led to believe. There is no taxation measure to get to grips with what is in my view a morally wrong and corrupt practice. It is our responsibility as legislators to address such issues in every finance Bill. When we see people using tax avoidance measures we must close the loopholes immediately. Such loopholes may be legal because they have not been identified or were purposefully left in previous Bills. This section of the Bill could deal with the transfer of assets.
The Minister has indicated that a 90% rate of tax on bank bonuses will be applied and in a similar fashion we could consider a stamp duty or transfer rate on assets flowing from one spouse to another if we know the process is to avoid liabilities to NAMA, for example. It is pity the Bill is not being used in such fashion. I seek clarification on the first issue I raised.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to raise a few questions relating to the section and get some clarification. As somebody living in a rural area I know of cases where sites are transferred from parents to sons or daughter. It is an extremely important process which has encouraged young people to live in rural Ireland who may not have been able to afford to live there otherwise. A cost placed on this will have a major effect. The former Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy John Gormley, has introduced regulations to such an extent that it will be almost impossible for young people to get planning permission in rural Ireland and this further impediment will not help. It is important to remember that sons or daughters living adjacent to family homes in rural Ireland can be extremely helpful in looking after parents or handicapped siblings. There should be clarification on the issue as the Bill as published would be a major step backwards in this regard.
Stamp duty at high levels has done much damage in the past. The transfer of land from father to son or daughter, if it is not done before the son or daughter is 35, can bring about significant costs. For different reasons some transfers may not be done before the son or daughter reaches 35; for example, a son or daughter may have had to leave home because of insufficient income in the home for two families. We need to consider these types of issues carefully.
I am annoyed that the Bill will require first-time buyers to pay stamp duty, albeit at a rate of 1%. Young people are finding it impossible to get onto the housing ladder. Recently, I encountered a case of a young couple, both of whom are in reasonable jobs, who were refused a mortgage to buy a house which cost one third of what a similar house would have cost five years ago. We must not impede efforts to utilise the current stock of empty houses. We need to encourage young people to move into empty houses.
I listened to Deputy McManus's comments on the need for greater gender balance in the Oireachtas. I have an interest in this matter because I encouraged a young woman to accept the nomination to follow me into the Dáil. The lady in question will face all sorts of difficulties because the political system is structured in a manner that does not encourage female participation in politics. Deputy McManus and other Deputies who are about to retire have been extremely able contributors to Dáil proceedings. I hope she and other colleagues who are conscious of the difficulties experienced by politicians and their families will seek to ensure they are replaced by female colleagues and encourage greater female participation in politics. While I fully appreciate the issue is not related to the Finance Bill, I wanted to respond to the Deputy's contribution on this issue, with which I concur.
On a separate matter, we have recently been dealing with the Neary affair in Drogheda, a highly delicate matter. When the issue first arose the presence on our team of former Deputy Nora Owen and Senator Frances Fitzgerald, also a former Deputy, was invaluable.
Comment on this
Last week, I spoke at a debate organised by the Historical Society of University College Cork entitled, "The Recession Then and Now". The debate compared our current economic difficulties to the economic problems of the 1980s, focusing specifically on personal circumstances and how individuals are faring now and how they fared then. It became apparent in the course of the evening that the circumstances leading up to the current recession are similar to those leading up to the economic problems of the 1980s. In both cases, Governments pursued reckless policies, we had poor governance and the political system failed members of the public, not because of its structure and processes but because of the type of leadership shown by those who had responsibility to govern.
On the evening of the debate, as I headed across the UCC quad, two young lads of about 13 or 14 years who happened across my path on their bicycles recognised me and said "Hello". As one approaches a general election, it is always nice for a candidate to have one's face or name recognised. Given that one does not normally see 13 or 14 year old children cycling on the grounds of University College Cork, I jokingly asked the two boys which subject they were studying. They replied that they were studying economics and were currently dealing with the bond markets. I was struck by this response because it highlights the level of discourse among members of the public about the current economic crisis. Financial terminology such as "bond markets", "subordinated debt", the "International Monetary Fund" and other technical vocabulary have become everyday language, as reflected in my conversation with two 13 or 14 year old children. However, while members of the public may have a better grasp of the discourse of national and international economics, do they understand our current problems better than people understood the problems of the 1980s? The big question being asked of the Finance Bill is whether we are recreating the past or building something new. It appears the Government is essentially seeking to recreate the conditions that led to the problem.
When discussing the property market commentators frequently refer to taxation and measures that would lead to a recovery in the market. The last thing the country needs is for the property market to recover to the levels we saw in the past decade. Taxation policies and measures created the current crisis. In 1999, when Deputy Eamon Gilmore was the Labour Party spokesperson on housing, my party published the Drudy report. The report warned of a future crisis if national policy on housing was not adjusted and identified a number of key future problems. Its warning that the employment sector would become over-reliant on the building and construction industry was proved correct when 20% of the economy subsequently became tied into the construction bubble and pyramid scheme.
The Drudy report also argued that the property market would overheat. This proved to be the case when so-called affordable homes — subsidised homes to enable people to enter the housing market — were placed on the market at €250,000. The cost of affordable housing has since fallen by half as prices start to reflect the real economy. During the years from the late 1990s to 2007, house prices and house price inflation reflected a parallel universe.
These developments were the result of the Fianna Fáil Party's policy of incentivising property investment through taxation measures. Homes became commodities to be bought and sold for investment purposes, at the expense of families, communities and the model of sustainable development. Individuals bought property using loans on which they repaid the interest for two years before selling it on in the knowledge that the price would have increased. Tax relief on interest repayments, capital gains tax changes and the stamp duty regime were used to incentivise and facilitate these types of investment.
The cost of the Government's approach was that it drove the price of housing up and put it out of reach for ordinary working people. Calculating the value of a house is a simple equation. In normal times, a typical three bedroom, semi-detached house costs three to four times the average household income.
At the height of the property madness we saw house prices for first-time buyers reaching eight to 12 times a household income depending on the region. In rural areas the cost could be six, seven or eight times a household income, while in Dublin — particularly in suburban areas of high demand — the figure could be between ten and 12 times.
Another way of measuring house values is to determine the annual rent a property will accrue and then multiply that figure by ten or 12. Nonetheless, property values at that time were well in excess of the multiple based on annual rental income. All the alarm bells were ringing to tell us that a serious difficulty would arise in this respect, but Fianna Fáil — in its different manifestations over those years — continued to introduce further taxation measures to create what in essence was a pyramid scheme. People were led to believe that if they joined the scheme it would deliver in six, 12 or 18 months' time. They were encouraged to grab the money and reinvest it. The inference was that the pyramid scheme would continue forever on the simple premise that house prices would increase infinitely. That could not be logical, however, if the housing market did not reflect the real economy, and it has not done so for a long time.
The term "normalisation" must be used loosely regarding property sector taxation. The Government must choose one area of the property sector over another. The Government can either promote the concept of the principal residence and its ownership, which comprises home owners, or, as we have had to date, it can give preference to a taxation regime which incentivises investors to speculate by buying and accumulating properties, thus driving prices up.
In order to have a normalised housing market, the Labour Party believes a policy is required which reflects and promotes the concept of home ownership and principal residence, although that has not existed in this country for over ten years. For that to occur, we must have a taxation system that is neutral at least and positive at best in favour of principal residence occupation.
Over the past 12 months, we have seen suggestions emanating from the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator to the effect that such an approach would be taken. In July 2010, the Governor of the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator published new recommendations on mortgage lending. Those recommendations referred to getting back to the ratios I mentioned, as well as having more robust measures to examine people's incomes and other steps to ensure that such a crisis cannot recur.
For those of us who first entered the Dáil in May 2007, that date now seems like a century ago. In terms of perception, Ireland was an entirely different country to what it is now, although the writing was already on the wall. An examination of the books showed that the difficulties we are in currently were well and truly under way.
The 31st Dáil, to be elected shortly, will face an entirely different climate to the one that existed when I first entered this House in 2007. The next Dáil will have to realise that we are not in the business of recreating or revitalising a type of housing market through various taxation measures. Research shows that the more tax incentivisation is given to property, the more it drives prices upwards. As surely as night follows day, if one incentivises property investment through significant tax relief, the price of property rises. While those gaining tax relief may be beneficiaries to some extent, those who are trying to buy property, either as a retail or manufacturing business investment, or simply as home owners, will not benefit from that taxation model.
In moving towards a normalised taxation system and housing market, we will have to begin picking up the pieces left by the current Government's policies. Some 300,000 home owners are currently in negative equity as a direct result of the Government's taxation policy which drove up house prices to unsustainable levels. In addition, 30,000 to 40,000 householders are in mortgage arrears to the extent that it is becoming a registered problem with their lending institution. Even if they are employed and can complete robust assessment criteria to obtain loans, first-time buyers will find it difficult to get money because banks are not lending and the price of borrowing will increase significantly.
I will revert to the two young lads on bicycles whom I met in UCC on Monday night. We may have a different type of language to describe our current economic difficulties compared to the 1980s. We may now have a broader discourse involving subordinated debt, sub-prime lending and other terminology, but are we any wiser than we were 25 or 30 years ago? Are we again in between recessions and, if so, will we be having debates in UCC and other universities in ten years' time on future recessions and the periods in between? In order to have economic stability, the type of governance we have witnessed in the House for 17 of the past 20 years needs to come to an end. Political tampering and tinkering with a taxation system that benefits very few, and for which most of us must pick up the pieces, is no longer acceptable. We need not just a new Dáil in March or April with new Deputies, but also a new governance and structure for politics. Thus, when we debate taxation policies, it will be for the benefit of the economy and society as a whole, not just the select few who have benefited from this Government over the past 20 years.
Comment on this
I wish to refer to something that has arisen in practice in the context of section 60. The residential housing market is not moving at the moment, but many young couples have bought homes. They took a risk, although people said the market was still falling. In many such cases, people were advised to close and pay stamp duty at 1% prior to the budget, whereas they are now paying 4% or more. The people in this group need some relief. In some cases, they will have to pay additional stamp duty of between €10,000 and €15,000 or €16,000. The reference to "on or after 8 December 2010" is a penal provision. There is merit in the argument that it should be amended to read "on or after 30 November 2010". That would give people a week's latitude. We need to consider cases in which sales had not been closed, or were still conditional, on 8 December last. I have contacted the Department of Finance on many occasions to raise this real issue, which affects young couples buying residential homes.
I intend to introduce an amendment to deal with this matter on Report Stage and I look forward to doing so. I ask the Minister to address it during the Committee Stage debate on section 60. Perhaps he can give favourable consideration to the introduction of a transitional arrangement to assist people who bought a family home — as opposed to a property — "on or after 30 November 2010". If he moves the cut-off date back a week, he will give them some relief. We are not talking about property speculators. We are talking about those who are paying for the mistaken policies of the banks and the Government. They are buying homes, in many cases on the basis of advice, and thereby bringing stamp duty to the Exchequer. I do not think the level of stamp duty should be penal.
I would like to hear the Minister's views on the amendment I intend to introduce on Report Stage. I am aware that people have been making representations to the Department of Finance on this issue. It is fair and reasonable that we should assist young married couples and partners who are under enormous pressure at the moment. Some of them have young children. Their pay packets have been decimated in the last month. Rates of child benefit have been cut. The mortgage repayments of some young people have increased. Many young people do not have job security. Some of them are facing the prospect of unemployment. They see stamp duty as dead money because it is going to the Exchequer. I would like to hear the Minister's comments. I know he is aware of it. I hope to introduce an amendment on Report Stage to address it.
Comment on this
I would like to pick up on the issue raised by Deputy O'Donnell. I am sure the Minister agrees that difficulties will exist regardless of the deadline one sets in this regard. Deputy O'Donnell made the point that there is a fundamental difference between 1% and 4%. It could be worth many thousands of euro to young couples who are finding it difficult to get 10% from the banks to furnish their homes. It could ultimately make a huge difference. There is some merit in the idea that the Minister should consider the matter. I suspect the number of people affected by this measure is not huge. Perhaps the Revenue Commissioners have given the Minister some indication of the total number involved. It is a small group of people. A fair change, if not a substantial one, is required.
Section 60 provides for transitional arrangements whereby purchasers who entered into binding contracts before budget day, and execute the relevant instrument before 1 July 2011, will not have to pay an increased amount of stamp duty. Some degree of fairness is built into the system and will last six months. If one draws down one's contract within six months of the date of budget day, one will pay the lesser amount. I assume that is the 1% rate. I can understand that. Can the Minister explain the rationale for the six-month timeframe that has been provided for after budget day? Why was a 12-month timeframe not provided for? We are not talking in every case about people who will initiate the relevant instrument within six months. It will depend on conveyancing and agreements between purchasers and vendors, for example. What is the rationale for the six-month period that applies to the transitional arrangement? Is it based on the fact that such a period applied when stamp duty changes were made in the past?
We are discussing the general issue of Part 4, which relates to stamp duty, but I would like to refer specifically to section 60. There is considerable anger in society, particularly among those in their late 20s, 30s and early 40s who paid substantial amounts of stamp duty over the last ten years. In many cases, they had to borrow between €40,000 and €60,000 to meet their stamp duty requirements. They have been lumbered with significant debts. They may be among the 350,000 people in negative equity, to whom we often refer. Ultimately, some form of release will be needed to resolve the difficulties of those who are paying enormous mortgages and are hugely in debt. As a society, we have a responsibility to develop some means of releasing them from their debt. A societal benefit would be associated with establishing such a means. In the absence of such a mechanism, many people will be unable to spend, consume and contribute to society as we may wish. I do not under-estimate the depth of the anger that exists across society, including parts of my constituency, about the sizable amounts of stamp duty people had to pay over the last decade or so.
I remind the House that not a million years ago, the then leader of a certain party lectured us that we did not need the revenue that was being generated from stamp duty. That says a great deal about the political judgment of the former Deputy, who represented the constituency of Dublin South-East when he was proposing these radical changes in the stamp duty regime. It goes to the heart of the collapse in the Irish economy that such a large amount of the tax that was raised each year in our society depended on stamp duty. It was completely unsustainable to rely on such a transaction tax. It was out of character with European norms. This society and this economy has to rectify that. I ask the Minister to examine the transitional arrangements in section 60. Can he give some indication of the number of people involved? I suspect it is quite small. Can he deal with Deputy O'Donnell's point before he initiates his amendment for the purposes of Report Stage?
Comment on this
In the context of section 60, which provides for the termination of property reliefs, I wish to raise the transfer of a portion of land from a parent to a child. It is primarily a rural issue. It is particularly unfair and unreasonable to remove this property-based tax relief at a time when the banks are closed, the rate of stamp duty is being increased in some cases and we are trying to get some people back to work. Those who are not lumbered with the cost of purchasing a site are among the few who can currently proceed with the construction of a property. The Government is proposing to remove the tax-based relief they currently enjoy. It is particularly unfair that such people will now have to pay stamp duty. If we are serious about encouraging some movement in the property market, we need to look at this. While this problem applies mainly to rural Ireland, it can also have an effect on urban Ireland. If somebody has an urban dwelling on a large site, he or she may be fortunate enough to have enough space to build another property. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle will be familiar with such cases in Wexford town. In such circumstances, the proposed extinguishing of this tax-based relief will kick in. I ask the Minister to consider this, taking into account that we must get people back to work. I would like to hear from the Minister how much income this is likely to generate for the State.
Comment on this
I did not have an opportunity to speak after Deputy Liz McManus, who made a rather valedictory speech on the previous section. I pay tribute to her service to the House——
Comment on this
——and to Irish politics. She made a particular contribution to the development of Labour Party health policy. One of the things I will be interested to observe in the future — Fine Gael has a similar policy — is how such a system can be successfully superimposed on the present structure and what sort of vested interests will be encountered along the way.
While I am on the subject, I believe Deputy Crawford will also retire from the House, and I pay tribute to the service he has given to an electorate that lives along the Border, including during troubled times. I have had quite a bit of contact with the Deputy on different issues and I have always found him an exceptionally honourable and decent parliamentarian, speaking from the heart about his community.
The issue raised by Deputies Doherty and D'Arcy relates to tax relief on sites transferred between a parent and his or her child. The cost of this relief is €6 million in a year. Offspring are still eligible for the half-rate applicable to transfers between family members. It should be pointed out that the average price of an acre of agricultural land is now less than €10,000, and if such a site were transferred, no tax would be payable. That price is considerably less than it was a couple of years ago. On a piece of land suitable for residential development, which would cost more than average, the rate of duty would still be low, at 1% between €10,000 and €20,000, and so on.
We should recall that Ireland is one of the only OECD countries that does not have an annual tax on property. We need to broaden the tax base, and a tax on property is one way to do this. This has been recommended not only by the Commission on Taxation but by nearly every independent body. I find it surprising that all parties in the House, including Sinn Féin, are on the conservative side of the Government on this issue.
The capital gains tax relief on the transfer of sites to children for the purpose of building a principal private residence remains in place. However, as many of us know from planning decisions, we need to be aware of the potential for abuse. For example, in a family with five children, sites may be released to each of the five children and then sold on after a little while to people outside the family. This has happened in the past. The system as it is at present confers a considerable benefit. I will be interested to see whether the parties opposite, if they come to this side, will still make the same arguments in a few months' time.
Deputy O'Donnell raised the issue of stamp duty relief on certain dates. The possibility of stamp duty changes in the budget was generally recognised, and the problem — as mentioned by Deputy Hayes — is that no matter what date is fixed, some people will unfortunately be just on the wrong side. To fix a date of 30 November would perhaps increase the sense of injustice felt by those who bought on 29 November.
Comment on this
Six months should be adequate to enable any instrument to be executed. By reference to experience when stamp duty was changed in the past, the six-month period may be considered generous. Six months is an adequate period in which to formalise conveyances.
Deputy Ciarán Lynch talked about the affordable homes initiative and the rise in house prices. There were efforts in the late 1990s, including the two Bacon reports, to damp down the growth of prices in the property market, and I had some regrets at the time that the fight was abandoned. There were considerable pressures. It was always easy to make the argument that building more and more houses would create jobs in construction and give people homes. As I have said before, there were not many voices telling us in the boom years that we ought to go more slowly. One of them was the former European Commissioner Pedro Solbes, who said this in 2001 to Charlie McCreevy——
Comment on this
——and nearly all of us were highly indignant at his interference in our sovereign affairs. This may have contributed to the loss of the first Nice referendum. However, I am afraid the Commissioner was right and the Minister and most of the rest of us were wrong.
Deputy Hayes made an oblique reference to a former Deputy, and Minister, Mr. Michael McDowell, on the subject of stamp duty. It must be said that Fine Gael was very active on the stamp duty issue not long after that time.
Comment on this
To return to the practical point, the problem is that if one makes a radical change to stamp duty — in this case, reducing the rate to 1%, or 2% above a high threshold — one can always say that it creates some inequities, looking back. Is that an argument that one can never change anything? Any reduction in tax will feel inequitable to those who paid more previously. It is a difficult issue, and I am sceptical as to whether a new Government will find the financial scope, however desirable it may be, to provide some compensation for those who were unfortunately caught by the change.
Comment on this
On the practical issue, I know that many calls have been made to the Department of Finance — although not a huge number — from people who are upset because, when they were purchasing their homes, the stamping instrument went through prior to 8 December. Similarly, there are cases of people who bought their homes on the same date. Some would have effectively put through the statutory instrument prior to 8 December, and some might have done this afterwards, even though the sale might have gone through at the same time, because, I believe, they have to put it through, I believe, within 30 days.
Has the Department quantified the number of people this new provision would affect? I agree with the Minister of State's sentiments to the effect that the situation cannot be so inflexible as to preclude the Department looking at change. Has the cost to the Exchequer been quantified — because I would say the Department of Finance has received a reasonable number of calls in this regard — by amending the date from 8 December to 30 November? I am putting this purely in respect of the family home. I ask the Minister to look at it, as it is a relatively small measure. Does the Minister know how many people it would impact on if the date was to be changed from 8 December to 30 November and what effect would this have on the Exchequer? Some €3,000 or €4,000 or even €10,.000 to an ordinary hard-pressed family is an infinitely higher proportion to that family than the cost to the State. I ask the Minister of State to deal with these practicalities.
Comment on this
The imposition of taxation is always prospective. Likewise, reliefs and concessions should be prospective as special circumstances dictate. Otherwise, if a concession were to be granted, it would serve as a precedent every time stamp duty or any other event or transaction tax such as capital gains tax or capital acquisitions tax were to be changed. That is the reason why there would be considerable hesitation.
I am aware, of course, that in various parts of the tax code some transitional relief has been granted from time to time. That, in any event, is the situation at the moment. There has been a good deal of talk today about a finance Bill (No. 2) later in the year and if the Deputy's party is in office, it is very welcome to look at the matter again.
Comment on this
The Government is giving transitional arrangements where someone who enters an agreement after 8 December ends up paying a higher amount that he or she would have paid if going through before this date. In the interests of fairness the reverse should apply. The dates are arbitrary but I am focusing on the week before, from 1 December. I should like if for Report Stage the Minister could ask his officials to quantify the number of people this would affect, based on representations, and the cost to the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 91:
In page 201, before section 61, to insert the following new section:
61.—(1) The Principal Act is amended by substituting the following for section 106B:
"106B.—(1) In this section ‘housing authority' means—
(a) a housing authority, within the meaning of the Housing Acts 1966 to 2009, in connection with any of its functions under those Acts,
or
(b) the Affordable Homes Partnership established under article 4(1) of the Affordable Homes Partnership (Establishment) Order 2005 (S.I. No. 383 of 2005) in connection with the services specified in article 4(2) of that Order, as amended by the Affordable Homes Partnership (Establishment) Order 2005 (Amendment) Order 2007 (S.I. No. 293 of 2007).
(2) Stamp duty shall not be chargeable on any instrument giving effect to the conveyance, transfer or lease of a house, building or land to a housing authority.
(3) Stamp duty on any instrument giving effect to the conveyance, transfer or lease of a house, building or land by a housing authority chargeable, as specified in Schedule 1, shall not exceed €100.".
(2) This section applies to an instrument executed on or after 1 April 2011.".
This amendment inserts a new section 61 and substitutes a new section 106B in the Stamp Duties Consolidation Act. Section 106B implies a stamp duty exemption on a conveyance of property by or to a housing authority or the Affordable Homes Partnership. There is no requirement to present the instrument to the Revenue Commissioners and as such there is no record of the transaction in Revenue's e-stamping system.
This would affect the collection of data for compiling house valuations both for the purposes of publishing a valuation database, to bring greater transparency to the housing market, and for the introduction of a site value tax, as proposed in the national recovery plan. On the other hand, applying a full stamp duty charge to such transfers could reduce the take-up of the enhanced tenant purchase scheme for local authority tenants which the Minister announced in the budget.
To meet these competing concerns, this amendment removes the stamp duty exemption in so far as this relates to a conveyance of property by the local authority or the Affordable Homes Partnership. Accordingly, such transfers will have to be presented to Revenue for stamping and details of the consideration will be recorded. However, the stamp duty payable will be limited to a maximum amount of €100 and such a low level of duty is unlikely to deter take-up of the tenant purchase scheme. The amendment will take effect for conveyances executed on or after 1 April 2011, and I commend this amendment to the Committee.
Comment on this
This was flagged by the statement made by the Minister on the night of the budget, I believe. It was welcomed at the time, in respect of removing stamp duty. In general, this amendment is welcome. On the question of valuation of social housing, given that there is such a reduction in the price of property generally across the economy, what is the mechanism for doing that, and what is market value now? As regards social housing, affordable housing or shared ownership, how is market value arrived at given the difficulties involved in establishing what it is?
Comment on this
The former Minister of State, Deputy Finneran, made an announcement that the tenant purchase scheme would now be adapted and that there would be a 45% discount for people who had been social housing tenants for 15 years and over. I believe that is what is being referred to in the section there. The former Minister of State also gave the impression that this would be enacted on 1 January and that local authorities would be able to roll that out. Given that we are debating it in the House this evening, it is clear that local authorities are not in a position to do that currently. Could the Minister of State indicate as to when social housing tenants will be able to avail of the 45% discount?
With regard to something the Labour Party has been consistently calling for over a number of years, the housing price database, this is necessary because it is the only way that accurate housing information and prices can be given. It would give confidence to people buying homes to ensure that the prices they pay are reflective of true market value in their estates, and this resonates into social housing situations, as Deputy Hayes has indicated. The core principle, if we are to introduce normalisation into the housing market, is to have an accurate house register database. I welcome the fact that the Minister of State indicated this in his speech this evening. Once again, is there a timeline as to when this will be in place?
Comment on this
With regard to section 62 and the different rates of stamp duty, the reduction as regards lower valued properties is to be welcomed, since people on low incomes were being penalised. I know the Government is getting rid of the exemption from stamp duty for properties under €127,000, so people who buy a very small house worth, say, €80,000 to €100,000 or whatever will now be subject to stamp duty. However, the Minister of State referred to the fact that properties valued at more than €1 million will be subject to the 2% rate as distinct from the existing 9% rate. There are still trophy houses on the market in the region of €5 million. Based on what the Minister of State has said, the reduction we are introducing in this Finance Bill is in the region of 7%, which would mean a total saving for somebody buying such a trophy house of, say, €350,000. How can this be reconciled with charging stamp duty on modest housing worth in the region of €120,000? There is a major saving to be made for those buying at the very high end of the market. The intention here is to stimulate the property market, which is not moving currently, but we have had situations before where all types of reliefs were introduced in Finance Bills and so called "section 23 reliefs" to stimulate the market.
We know where that got us. We need to be careful and to ensure those who have the ability to pay do so. This includes anyone buying at the high end of the market. Even if the direct saving from 9% to 2% does not amount to €350,000, and I understood it was tiered, the public could not countenance that type of saving as a result of the Finance Bill given that the State is trying to make savings. I would appreciate it if the Minister of State could subsequently reply.
Comment on this
As it is now 6 p.m. I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 25 January: "That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to Part 4 of the Bill and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill and in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said part, that the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to."
Comment on this
The Dáil divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
Will the Minister of State read his briefing note on this section?
Comment on this
This section corrects unintentional drafting errors in sections 89(4), 102A(2) and 104(3) of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Consolidation Act 2003. Section 89(4) of the Act provides for a clawback of agricultural relief where agricultural property is disposed of within six years of acquiring a gift or an inheritance and is not replaced within one year of the disposal by other agricultural property.
Section 102A(2) provides for a clawback of agricultural and business relief in respect of the development value of development land where that land is disposed of after six years of acquiring a gift or an inheritance and within ten years of that date. Section 104(3) provides for a clawback of the CGT credit allowed against CAT where the property in respect of which the credit was given is disposed of within two years of acquiring a gift or an inheritance.
The section ensures that the clawback in sections 89(4) and 104(3) will apply where a disposal takes place on the date of the gift or inheritance. The section also ensures that the clawback of agricultural and business relief in respect of the development value of development land provided for in section 102A(2) will apply where such land is disposed of on the sixth anniversary of the date of the gift or the inheritance. The section applies to gifts and inheritances taken on or after 21 January 2011.
Comment on this
This area of taxation is complex. I understand the Minister of State to mean that, up to now, a farmer who sold his farm to the NRA, for example, and used all the proceeds to buy more agricultural land was exempt from capital acquisitions tax. Will the Minister of State outline the implications for a farmer who gives a site to a son or daughter? What is the position if a farmer's daughter has planning permission for a site, thus making it development land, but disposes of the site without building thereon because she is nursing, then marries a man from Dundalk and moves on? If one has built on a site, is its value taken into account if it is disposed of within the six-year period? Is that governed by different sections of the Act?
Comment on this
This is only correcting very minor points. It is crossing t's and dotting i's so a particular date will not be taken from a pedantic legal point of view as not being covered by the legislation. There are no implications except those that apply at precedent.
This section is required because the Revenue Commissioners received counsel's opinion in a case involving a clawback of the capital gains tax credit allowed against capital acquisitions tax. In that case, counsel advised that, because the clawback provision referred to a period within two years after a gift or inheritance, the clawback did not apply where the disposal arose on the date of the gift. This is the way folks seem to interpret the law. I have always had a bit of an objection to that type of pedantic interpretation. However, that is the position and, therefore, provisions must be absolutely explicit or our learned brethren will find a way around them.
Related difficulties arise with the provisions for clawing back agricultural relief or business relief on gifts and the inheritance of development land. Section 64 amends the relevant sections to ensure that a disposal of the gifted inherited property, on the date of a gift in the case of CGT credit and agricultural relief or on the sixth anniversary of a gift or inheritance in the case of agricultural or business relief on development land, triggers a clawback of the relief in question. In other words, the measure is combating a pedantic interpretation of the clause. It is not contrary to the spirit of the measure. It is only aimed at those who might exploit a legal loophole. As we know, loopholes sometimes appear in law after the enactment of legislation without their having been in any sense the intent of the legislator. Anybody who operated the relief as intended would be unaffected by this measure. It has no particular implications for roll-over relief in the case of the NRA or in any other case.
Comment on this
The Minister of State has answered my question. There is no policy change and the measure is closing a minor loophole.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 92:
In page 205, subsection (1), lines 26 to 29, to delete paragraph (c) and substitute the following:
"(c) as if, in the definition of “threshold amount” in paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 2, the consumer price index number for the year 2009 applied to gifts and inheritances taken in the year 2011.”.
This amendment corrects a drafting error in section 65(1)(c) of the Bill. The effect of that paragraph would be to disapply indexation entirely for gifts and inheritances taken in 2011. The intention is that the annual change in the CAT-free group thresholds from 1 January by reference to the consumer price index number for the previous year will not apply to gifts and inheritances taken in 2011. This amendment will achieve this result so the tax-free thresholds after indexation, which were reduced by approximately 20% in budget 2011 for gifts and inheritances taken on or after 8 December 2011, will also apply to gifts and inheritances taken in 2011.
I will outline the relevant tax-free thresholds that will apply to gifts and inheritances taken in 2011. The group A tax-free threshold, which broadly covers transfers from parent to child, is €332,084. The group B tax-free threshold, which broadly covers transfers between siblings, from children to parents, from grandparents to grandchildren, and from uncles and aunts to nephews and nieces, is €33,208. The group C tax-free threshold, which covers all cases not covered in groups A and B, is €16,604.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 94 and 95 are related to amendment No. 93 and they are to be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 93:
In page 205, subsection (1)(a), lines 35 and 36, to delete “ “30 September” for “31 October” “ and substitute ““30 June” for “31 August””.
This arose from the decision by the Minister in the draft finance Bill to bring forward the date of filing of tax returns on the part of certain taxpayers from 31 October to 30 September. I understand the Minister has agreed with Deputies Lowry and Healy-Rae——
Comment on this
In that case, will the Minister of State read his note?
Comment on this
These amendments relate to section 66, which brings forward the pay and file date in respect of gifts and inheritances from 31 October to 30 September. Section 46(2)(a) of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Consolidation Act 2003 provides that where the valuation date in respect of a gift or inheritance arises in the period from 1 January to 31 August in a year, tax must be paid and a return must be delivered on or before 31 October in that year.
Where the valuation date arises between 1 September and 31 December, tax must be paid and a return must be delivered on or before 31 October in the following year. Interest on outstanding tax runs from 1 November in the relevant year. In addition, there is a surcharge where a return is delivered after 31 October in the relevant year.
The effect of amendment No. 95, tabled by Deputy Noonan, would be to move the relevant date referred to in section 46(2)(a) of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Consolidation Act 2003 forward from 31 August to 30 June. In addition, the Deputy seeks consequential changes in regard to the provisions dealing with the date when interest on overdue tax becomes chargeable and the date when the surcharge for late returns arises.
As the amendments proposed by Deputy Noonan would reduce the yield from gift tax and inheritance tax by €30 million in 2011 because of the shortening of the relevant period referred to in section 46(2)(a) of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Consolidation Act 2003, I am not in a position to accept them, especially given the current state of the public finances.
Comment on this
We have reached the end of section 66, our consideration of which was to conclude at 7.30 p.m. As we are ahead of schedule, I propose that we move directly on to section 67 and amendment No. 95a in the name of Deputy Noonan, which is on the additional list of amendments circulated today and proposes the insertion of a new section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 95a:
In page 206, before section 67, but in Part 6, to insert the following new section:
"67.—In respect of Section 14 (Annual Returns) of the Industrial and Provident Societies Acts 1893 (the 1893 Act):
(a) to delete “March” and substitute “August”, and
(b) to delete “one month” and substitute “four months”.”.
Comment on this
This amendment substitutes dates in the 1893 Act. The Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation has no objection in principle to the amendment. However, it should be made in the context of amendments to the relevant Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation legislation after proper consideration. I am not able to accept the amendment to the Finance Bill, but it should be possible to have it enacted in the appropriate legislation.
Comment on this
Has the appropriate Department any planned legislation that could serve as a vehicle for this amendment in the near future?
Comment on this
I am afraid that is beyond my knowledge. Naturally, a new Government will order legislation. I do not doubt there will be an opportunity in the reasonably near future to make the change.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister of State's reply, I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I understand this section refers to the mandatory disclosure of information regarding people who are arranging particular tax transactions and may be involved in fairly aggressive tax planning. Will the Minister of State read out his note on this section so that we might have a sense of what is intended?
Comment on this
Section 68 amends section 817M of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, which is concerned with the provision by promoters to the Revenue Commissioners of details of clients to whom certain disclosable transactions were made available for implementation. This provision forms part of the legislation governing the mandatory disclosure of certain transactions regime, which was introduced in the Finance Act 2010 and was followed by regulations on 17 January 2011.
During a consultation process on the proposed regulations last summer, concerns were raised regarding taxpayers being identified to the Revenue Commissioners in circumstances where those taxpayers may not have undertaken the transactions concerned. This section modifies the original provision to remove the disclosure obligation on promoters where they are satisfied the client did not undertake the transaction at the time in question. If the transaction is undertaken at a later time, the client's details must be disclosed in a normal way. The regulations will be amended in due course to take account of this change.
Comment on this
Is the section designed to deal with people involved in aggressive tax planning so that the people who might be the beneficiaries of said planning can be identified to Revenue? As I might not understand the section correctly, perhaps the Minister of State will clarify the situation.
Comment on this
That is my understanding. The transaction needs to have been made. If it is merely discussed and not acted upon, the situation is different.
Comment on this
Do the Minister of State's officials have a view on how much income has been lost to Revenue through these aggressive forms of tax planning?
During the past year or more, a great deal of information has emanated about people with deposit accounts in Switzerland in particular that have been used to avoid tax. In well publicised cases, whistleblowers there have identified people from various jurisdictions who have been salting money away from the prying eyes of tax collectors. I would not be surprised if some of those people were from Ireland.
In the interests of ensuring aggressive tax planning does not occur, perhaps the Minister of State could inform the House about the situation pertaining to people with non-resident deposits in tax havens like Switzerland and Austria where banking regulations are extraordinarily secretive. For example, we know from The FitzPatrick Tapes of a strange transaction involving Anglo Irish Bank, which took the Taoiseach out golfing and so on at various intervals prior to the State’s guarantee of the bank. He was telephoned in Singapore and attended a dinner hosted by Anglo Irish Bank in Heritage House just before he became Taoiseach. In July 2008 before the bank guarantee there was the famous round of golf and dinner afterwards with various Anglo notables. It has always intrigued me that the purpose of these contacts made by Mr. FitzPatrick was, presumably, to plead with the Taoiseach that the bank needed deposits from the National Treasury Management Agency. At or around the time of the guarantee, this bank had a subsidiary in Austria where banking secrecy is extreme. Lo and behold, shortly after the guarantee, this bank which desperately needed deposits, sold the Austrian subsidiary with about €600 million in deposits. What has always intrigued me is how did a bank, which was begging for deposits, sell a subsidiary bank with deposits of €600 million. Was this connected to tax avoidance transactions?
Comment on this
I have written to the Minister for Finance on several occasions on this matter. Was this connected to tax avoidance? Were the depositors in that bank——
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister of State is in a position to answer particular questions relating to correspondence the Deputy has had with the Minister. They cannot be answered on the floor of the House now. I ask the Deputy to deal with the specific details of section 68.
Comment on this
The section describes transactions and persons and contains a reference to promoters. The transfer of large deposits of money from the Irish jurisdiction to tax havens by means of promoters or to places where there is a practice of banking secrecy, is the highest form of aggressive tax avoidance management that I am aware of. The Minister will remain a Minister for the duration of the general election and until the new Government is formed. I have written to the Minister for Finance about this on a previous occasion. I understand the Minister of State does not have an answer to hand but this is a very murky area of aggressive tax planning. Will the Minister of State arrange——
Comment on this
——for the officials to write to me?
With regard to what is described as the mandatory disclosure regime, can the officials advise the Minister of State why this amendment was introduced unless they were certain that certain promoters of schemes were able to avoid examination of the schemes by the Revenue Commissioners? I ask the Minister of State to give the background to the amendment.
Comment on this
I am unable to give the background details but it is an ongoing if not an eternal battle between Revenue and governments against tax evasion and either aggressive forms of avoidance or tax evasion. The Deputy is a member of the Joint Committee on Finance and the Public Service and will be aware that a great deal of progress has been made in extending double taxation agreements, taxation information, exchange schemes and narrowing the space in which jurisdictions which have been very happy to welcome deposits in the utmost secrecy, without inquiring too much into their legality in terms of the law of the country from which they come, can operate. More work remains to be done and disclosures were made with regard to Liechtenstein. The United States in particular, has been very strong on this. The German Social Democrat Minister for Finance, Peer Steinbrück, was exceptionally strong. He and his French counterpart organised some meetings to deal with this matter and Ireland has always been supportive. In one respect, Ireland has a law on tax evasion that is without counterpart in any other country, which allows for the quarterly publication of lists of defaulters and penalties. I have been informed by both German and British delegations that although they are quite impressed, they did not think this would work in their jurisdictions. Ireland is ahead of the posse in that respect.
This provision only applies where no scheme has been implemented. Revenue does not want to know who might have looked at a scheme so long as they did not bite.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 96:
In page 206, to delete lines 27 to 35 and substitute the following:
""(c) Where the Revenue Commissioners issue a notice of attachment in respect of any amount of money due by the relevant person to the taxpayer as emoluments under a contract of service, and where the relevant person is controlled by the taxpayer within the meaning of Section 10, the notice may provide for the payment by the relevant person of the amount of the default out of the emoluments, after taking account of statutory deductions, over a period specified in the notice.”,”.
Section 70 amends section 1002 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 which is concerned with Revenue's power of attachment in respect of outstanding debt. Revenue will now be able to issue a notice of attachment in respect of emoluments and may provide for the attachment of such emoluments to be spread over a period of time. The amendment is drafted to modify this provision and to focus it more acutely where the Revenue Commissioners issue notice of attachment in respect of any amount of money due by the relevant person to the taxpayer as emoluments under a contract of service and where the relevant person is controlled by the taxpayer within the meaning of section 10, the notice may provide for the payment by the relevant person of the amount of the default out of the emoluments after taking account of statutory deductions over a period specified in the notice.
Comment on this
Before I reply to Deputy Noonan's amendment, I need to mention some matters before the conclusion of Committee Stage.
Before continuing with today's proceedings, I would be obliged if, in accordance with Standing Order 136, the Ceann Comhairle would direct the Clerk of the Dáil to make the following minor drafting correction to the text of the Bill. The correction is as follows: in paragraph (d) at the end of page 41, the reference to section 784(3) should read, section 784C(3).
I also wish to give notice that the Minister will be moving two amendments on Report Stage. First, an amendment to a section of the Bill, as amended on Committee Stage, to deal with the taxation of excess remuneration paid to persons employed in an institution that has received financial support under either the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Act 2008 or the National Pensions Reserve Fund Act 2000. Second, an amendment deleting section 18 of the Bill, as amended in its entirety on Committee Stage. This section deals with self-assessment pay and file.
Comment on this
Notice will be taken for report of the Minister's announcements. Is the instruction to the Ceann Comhairle acceptable?
Comment on this
I will deal with amendment No. 96 regarding the attachment of debt. Attachment is an enforcement option available to the Revenue Commissioners to recover unpaid tax, unpaid interest or unpaid penalty due by taxpayers who have ignored the normal collection approaches and notification procedures taken by Revenue. Attachment is used judiciously by Revenue in accordance with strict guidelines which require that any decision to use attachment must be approved at principal officer or nominated assistant principal officer level. A number of amendments to the attachment provisions are being made in the light of the experience of the Revenue Commissioners to make them more effective in the pursuit of tax defaulters who have ignored all reasonable attempts by Revenue to collect taxes in default and to improve efficiencies in certain situations.
When attachment was introduced in 1988, attachment of emoluments was not regarded as necessary by reference to the circumstances that prevailed at the time. However, circumstances have since changed and many persons now carrying on trades and professions also derive emoluments from directorships and employments. In addition, certain persons carrying on trades and professions have ceased those activities leaving undisputed tax liabilities unpaid. Where these people have directorships or employments, it is appropriate that they should meet their tax debts of previous and current years whatever the source of their resources. Where this is not done on a voluntary basis, it is appropriate that the Revenue Commissioners have the use of the attachment procedure where necessary to recover these debts. I emphasise that attachment is used by the Revenue Commissioners only where all normal collection attempts have been ignored by the taxpayer.
If the amendment was accepted, it would seriously restrict the Revenue Commissioners' ability to recover outstanding debts in circumstances where the individual had ceased trading leaving substantial unpaid tax liabilities and was now in employment where due to the level of net income it was deemed appropriate to use the attachment procedure. In these circumstances, I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
I wish to hear the comments of the Minister of State on this section.
Comment on this
Section 73 formalises taxpayer confidentiality. The need for such provision arises because of the volume and comprehensiveness of personal and commercial information concerning taxpayers which Revenue acquires. At present, there is no specific tax-related provision other than the statutory declaration made by inspectors in respect of Schedule D tax and corporation tax governing confidentiality requirements. Reliance is placed on the absolute ban imposed by the Official Secrets Act on civil servants revealing any information acquired in an official capacity. This section provides a specific tax-related provision which will reassure taxpayers that personal and commercial information revealed for tax purposes is protected against unauthorised disclosure. In other words, this strengthens by being specific the rights of the taxpayer.
Comment on this
I wish to hear the comments of the Minister of State on this section.
Comment on this
This concerns payment of tax by relevant payment methods. This section provides that tax can be paid to Revenue by credit card, debit card or any other method or methods of payment which is or are approved by the Revenue Commissioners. The section enables the Revenue Commissioners to make regulations relating to these payment methods. This measure is a customer service initiative to provide taxpayers with additional options for the payment of taxes and duties and will give them greater flexibility for making payments while also facilitating voluntary compliance.
Comment on this
I presume the Revenue Commissioners accept payment in cash.
Comment on this
Will they accept payment in cash other than in euro?
Comment on this
Yes. Many people have sterling around, as we know.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 97:
In page 213, before section 76, to insert the following new section:
76.—(1) Schedule 24A to the Principal Act is amended—
(a) in Part 1 by inserting the following before paragraph 1:
"1A. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Republic of Albania) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 16 of 2011).",
(b) in Part 1 by substituting the following for paragraph 2:
"2. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Republic of Austria) Order 1967 (S.I. No. 250 of 1967), the Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital Gains) (Republic of Austria) Order 1988 (S.I. No. 29 of 1988) and the Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital Gains) (Republic of Austria) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 30 of 2011).",
(c) in Part 1 by substituting the following for paragraph 14:
"14. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital and Gewerbesteuer (Trade Tax)) (Federal Republic of Germany) Order 1962 (S.I. No. 212 of 1962) and the Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and on Capital) (Federal Republic of Germany) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 31 of 2011).",
(d) in Part 1 by inserting the following after paragraph 15:
"15A. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Hong Kong Special Administrative Region) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 17 of 2011).",
(e) in Part 1 by inserting the following after paragraph 22:
"22A. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (State of Kuwait) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 21 of 2011).",
(f) in Part 1 by substituting the following for paragraph 26:
"26. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Malaysia) Order 1998 (S.I. No. 495 of 1998) and the Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Malaysia) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 32 of 2011).",
(g) in Part 1 by inserting the following after paragraph 27A:
"27B. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Montenegro) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 18 of 2011).
27C. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Kingdom of Morocco) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 19 of 2011).",
(h) in Part 1 by inserting the following after paragraph 35A:
"35B. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income) (Republic of Singapore) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 34 of 2011).",
(i) in Part 1 by substituting the following for paragraph 38:
"38. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital Gains) (Republic of South Africa) Order 1997 (S.I. No. 478 of 1997) and the Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital Gains) (Republic of South Africa) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 33 of 2011).",
(j) in Part 1 by inserting the following after paragraph 41A:
"41B. The Double Taxation Relief (Taxes on Income and Capital Gains) (United Arab Emirates) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 20 of 2011).",
(k) in Part 3 by inserting the following after paragraph 1:
"1A. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Antigua and Barbuda) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 22 of 2011).
1B. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Belize) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 23 of 2011).",
(l) in Part 3 by inserting the following after paragraph 2:
"2A. The Exchange of Information Relating to Taxes (British Virgin Islands) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 24 of 2011).",
(m) in Part 3 by inserting the following after paragraph 3:
"3A. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Cook Islands) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 25 of 2011).",
and
(n) in Part 3 by inserting the following after paragraph 8:
"8A. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Republic of the Marshall Islands) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 26 of 2011).
8B. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Saint Lucia) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 27 of 2011).
8C. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 28 of 2011).
8D. The Exchange of Information Relating to Tax Matters (Samoa) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 29 of 2011).".
(2) This section applies as on and from the date of the passing of this Act.".
The purpose of this amendment is to amend Part 1 and Part 3 of Schedule 24A of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997. This schedule lists all international tax agreements entered into by Ireland. Part 1 lists all the existing double taxation agreements and Part 3 lists all the tax information exchange agreements. As I stated earlier, many Members of the House will be familiar with these from meetings of the Committee on Finance and Public Service. The amendment adds seven countries to the list of countries in Part 1 with which the State has entered into a double taxation agreement, DTA, and eight countries or territories to the list of countries or territories in Part 3 with which the State has entered into a tax information exchange agreement, TIEA. It also adds four protocols to update the provisions of four existing double taxation agreements.
Double taxation treaties are widely regarded as critical pieces of fiscal infrastructure for developing substantial bilateral trading and investment opportunities by reducing tax impediments that might otherwise deter cross-border activity. To ensure that Irish business remains competitive and that Ireland remains an attractive destination for foreign direct investment we have been rapidly expanding our double tax treaty network. The six new double taxation agreements are with Albania, Hong Kong, Kuwait, Montenegro, Morocco, Singapore and the United Arab Emirates. The addition of these six agreements — I am sorry, as I may have misled the House; I count seven rather than six. The addition of these seven agreements will bring to 62 — or possibly 63 — the number of double taxation agreements that Ireland will have ratified.
The four protocols are under the existing double taxation agreements with Austria, Germany, Malaysia and South Africa. These protocols provide for the updating of the exchange of information articles in the Malaysian, Austrian and South African agreements. The protocol to the German double taxation convention updates the convention to reflect the current taxation laws of both countries. The protocol to the South African agreement as well as updating the exchange of information article also reflects the change in the taxation laws of South Africa with regards to taxation on dividends.
Tax information exchange agreements are also important international agreements which strengthen the ability of the revenue authorities in both countries to enforce their tax laws and thereby encourage the development of closer economic relations between both countries. The eight TIEAs are with Antigua and Barbuda, Belize, the British Virgin Islands, the Cook Islands, the Marshall Islands, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines and Samoa. These will bring to 17 the number of tax information exchange agreements that Ireland will have ratified.
All of these agreements have been considered and approved by the Committee on Finance and the Public Service on 15 December 2010 as part of their ratification process. The addition of these 19 countries or territories to schedule 24A is the final step in the legislative and ratification procedure that will ensure that these agreements will have the force of law.
Comment on this
The proposed section 76(1)(d) is on the double taxation relief on taxes on income with Hong Kong. The Minister of State will recall that we had a discussion——
Comment on this
——about this at a committee meeting. I am not fully convinced that the withholding tax on transfers from Hong Kong is appropriate and may continue to be a disincentive for investment in the Irish Financial Services Centre.
Has the Minister of State or his officials had any second thoughts on the matter?
Comment on this
The Minister of State said he was doing it because he thought there might be a vehicle for evasion; one could say that about anything.
Comment on this
I will give the House the gist of it. Hong Kong has a territorial taxation system under which foreign-sourced income including interest will not be sourced in Hong Kong. Furthermore Hong Kong does not have a withholding tax on interest payments paid to non-residents. These features of its tax system could open up possibilities of aggressive tax planning involving the Ireland-Hong Kong double taxation agreement. Ireland's usual treaty policy is to seek nil withholding rates for interest payments. However, to avoid double non-taxation a 10% rate was agreed to be included in the treaty. I am afraid there has been no consideration of this, but like everything else the next Government will be free to have a look at it if it wishes.
Comment on this
The Minister of State should not be giving up too soon.
Comment on this
Fine Gael has not closed off the Fianna Fáil option and Deputy Martin has already suggested it.
Comment on this
Are there any specific investment locations with which Ireland has not had a double taxation agreement or with which we propose to have a double taxation agreement? Are there any obvious places which might have been a location for investors in this jurisdiction?
Comment on this
The principal one with which we are working at the moment is Brazil, which is a very large economy. The Deputy will have heard of the phrase, the BRIC countries, which are major countries in the developing world. He can do the arithmetic for himself; if we have approximately 70 double taxation agreements and there are more than 200 countries in the world, we have some way to go. We prioritise those with which we have either trading or commercial relations. This is an area that has been expanding very rapidly. While I do not know if it is true today, it was certainly true four or five years ago that with the exception of Singapore, Ireland is practically the most globalised economy in the world and so obviously we need these agreements because we are trading with many different countries. The negotiations with Brazil are slow, but we are continuing to negotiate. We are also negotiating with Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the Philippines.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 98:
In page 217, line 4, to delete "2011" and substitute "2010".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 99:
In page 217, line 14, to delete "2011" and substitute "2010".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 100:
In page 217, line 22, to delete "2011" and substitute "2010".