Leaders' Questions
Contributions 168–332 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
- Wind energy guidelines and turbine setbacks 185 speeches
Deputy Robert Troy presses for long-delayed national wind energy guidelines, including rules on noise, shadow flicker, turbine setbacks and statutory status, citing community concerns and conflicting ministerial positions. Minister Alex White confirms onshore wind will remain central to energy policy, says interdepartmental work continues and a White Paper is forthcoming, but warns that very large setbacks could eliminate onshore wind development.
Robert Troy, Noel Harrington, Finian McGrath, Mattie McGrath, Bernard Durkan
- Family homelessness and emergency accommodation 73 speeches
Deputy Mary Lou McDonald highlights families and children forced into emergency accommodation, attributing the crisis to repossessions, rising rents and inadequate social-housing construction. Minister Alex White accepts the situation is unacceptable and points to housebuilding, modular housing, rent legislation and local-authority supports, while acknowledging there is no immediate solution for every family.
Mary Lou McDonald, Alex White, Peter Mathews, Mattie McGrath, Barry Cowen
- Mortgage arrears and borrower protections 74 speeches
Deputy Stephen Donnelly asks the Government to adopt Social Democrats proposals for one-year bankruptcy, free financial and legal assistance, mandated borrower solutions and an expanded mortgage-to-rent scheme for people in arrears. Minister Alex White agrees to examine the proposals and confirms bankruptcy legislation, while defending the Government’s broader response, including insolvency measures, MABS and economic stabilisation, against accusations of inaction.
Stephen Donnelly, Mattie McGrath, Paul Kehoe, Peter Mathews, Alex White
When will the Minister produce the guidelines?
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil gave the Government a paper two years ago.
Comment on this
They also have a responsibility to match what we must do as a country to have a renewable energy policy that will meet the challenges of the future.
Comment on this
We gave the paper to the Government two years ago.
Comment on this
Members have been talking for too long about the issue.
Comment on this
They have a responsibility to face the future, not to constantly face the past-----
Comment on this
Compare Fianna Fáil's climate change Bill with that of the Government.
Comment on this
-----or constantly regard the job in terms of it being a representative role, as it undoubtedly is, but also to give leadership.
Comment on this
Will the Minister take over leadership of the Labour Party by blaming Kelly?
Comment on this
Members opposite ask questions but will not allow anyone to finish.
Comment on this
The Minister has not answered the question. What about the guidelines?
Comment on this
They are afraid they will be exposed for their lack of leadership on this issue. The Government will proceed. It will have a renewable energy policy that will be supported by the people because they will see the great potential inherent within it.
Comment on this
Every day families are being made homeless. Thousands of children will sleep in unsuitable emergency accommodation tonight. Home repossessions, rising rents and a shortage of council housing are the causes of family homelessness. Councils not only have housing waiting lists, they now also have waiting lists for emergency accommodation. Families are being forced to sleep rough, overhold on their leases or move in with family and friends. A huge number of those who find themselves in this awful position are at work.
Let me give an example. Máire is a single mother with two children. She works full-time in a low-paid job in retail. Unable to afford child care, her mother minds the children while she is in work. She is not eligible for rent supplement and cannot find a landlord who will take the housing assistance payment. Máire's rent has increased by 20% in the past two years. The crunch came for her when her landlord served her with a €100 rent increase this year. She told him she simply did not have the money and he replied with a notice to quit.
She looked frantically for alternative accommodation but could not find anything affordable. She presented to her local council homeless section but was turned away because all of the hostels and hotels were full. This case is not an isolated one; it happens day after day. A new survey from Co-operative Housing Ireland indicates that 32% of tenants across the State live in fear of losing their homes. In Dublin, 50% of tenants are fearful of becoming homeless.
The only meaningful solution that will allay this fear is to link market rents to the consumer price index - in other words, to provide rent certainty. These families are being made homeless because of the Government's failure to introduce rent certainty. The Minister has urged others to demonstrate leadership. I urge him to demonstrate leadership and tell us when the Government will provide the rent certainty that families like Máire's desperately need.
Comment on this
It is not acceptable that in Ireland in 2015, we have families, including children, living in emergency accommodation. The case the Deputy raises, or any other such case, is simply unacceptable. The Deputy talks about the only meaningful solution. As she well knows, the only meaningful solution to this undoubted problem that exists - nobody denies that it exists - is that we actually resume as quickly as possible, as we are doing, a home building programme in the State, one that was abandoned disgracefully seven or eight years ago, where local authorities withdrew, and in fact were encouraged to withdraw, from the building of social housing. That will allow us to provide the homes that individuals and families need and in that way ensure we address the issue of homelessness. That is the only meaningful solution in my view. That is the leadership the Government is showing and needs to show in respect of this issue of the housing problem and the associated homeless factor that we have at the moment.
We have increased funding, as the Deputy will be aware. We have allocated approximately €2.2 billion for social housing in the coming period. We have increased Exchequer support to address homelessness, in particular for emergency accommodation, by €17 million. Exchequer funding in that regard is now of the order of €70 million, an increase of 56% since 2014.
We have a cold weather action plan for the winter months in the Dublin area to assist people who are at risk of sleeping rough. Additional beds are being brought on line. We are addressing the emergency element of the problem and the Minister, Deputy Kelly, is doing that effectively. That is what leadership is about and that is what we are doing and what we intend to continue to do.
Demonstrating leadership means having a range of policy approaches to address, first, the immediate emergency edge of the problem relating to homelessness, particularly in our cities, which is what we are doing. In the medium term, we need to get going as quickly as possible, as we are doing, with a social housing building programme. That is what we are addressing.
On rent certainty, colleagues will be aware that the Minister, Deputy Kelly, is bringing legislation through the Houses in respect of the rental sector. Additional certainty is being afforded by that legislation so that we can do as much as we can with the legislative measures we put in place to ensure that people who are in rental accommodation are not in fear of rent increases on a regular basis and that can only happen over the new period of two years.
Comment on this
We are also addressing deposit protection and other changes are taking place in respect of rent certainty to protect people in rental accommodation. It may be a subject of mirth for Deputy Cowen but is a serious issue for the people affected and is a serious issue for the Government, which is why we are addressing it now.
Comment on this
The Government has not shown that for the past four years.
Comment on this
It is not acceptable for the Minister to say to families, such as Máire's, that their predicament is not acceptable when the Government has a hand in creating their misery. That is the truth. The coalition has been in government for almost five years and its record on social housing build is pathetic. I am shocked that the Minister and his colleagues repeatedly give out that message as though they had revolutionised social housing provision - far from it.
What it has allowed is a situation where families, including children, sleep in bed and breakfasts, hostels and hotels, if they are lucky. What it has allowed is a situation where children try to make it to school every day for weeks on end from those hotels, if they are lucky. What it has allowed is a situation where people sleep on sofas or in their mothers' box rooms for months or years. What it has allowed is fear in a whole generation not alone that they will not own their own home but that they will be priced out of the rented accommodation on which they rely, the place they call home.
I ask the Minister to clarify this because I am curious to know. Last night the Government Members voted down Sinn Féin legislation on the issue of rent certainty and the prevention of homelessness. Revealingly enough, most of the Minister's colleagues did not consider it worth their while to show up for the debate. How does the Minister answer Máire who needs rent certainty and all those tenants - the figures do not lie - 50% of whom are in Dublin and more than 30% are across the State who currently fear they will be priced out of their homes? When will they get rent certainty or has the Government given up the ghost on that? This is on its watch and it is its responsibility. The Minister should not talk to others about leadership when he so clearly fails in that regard.
Comment on this
We can have a debate about how the problem happened.
Comment on this
If that is the question the Deputy wants to ask, when she talks about the misery and how this was caused, we can do that-----
Comment on this
-----but I do not believe that would be productive.
Comment on this
We know the housing crisis came about.
Comment on this
The Government should fix it so.
Comment on this
We know what happened and we know where we are now.
Comment on this
The Minister knows everything, bar the solution.
Comment on this
That is what this Government is about.
Comment on this
What we are about is actually delivering solutions and delivering action.
Comment on this
What about the Tesco advertisement?
Comment on this
I do not know the exact individual circumstances of the person the Deputy mentioned. I have no doubt the case she raised is a genuine one and she has authenticated what she has said today. What I would say to that lady and others in terms of what we are dealing with-----
Comment on this
The Minister is in the Dáil not in court.
Comment on this
There is no need for personal abuse. Let us just keep to the debate. What we are dealing with here is a Government that is actually addressing the situation somebody like Máire is facing.
Comment on this
I will give an example of what I would say to her if she were here. I would say the Government-----
Comment on this
You are a Minister and not a senior counsel for the moment.
Comment on this
-----will ensure that new houses are built and there will be an opportunity for her and her family to avail of one of those houses.
Comment on this
The Government is ensuring that local authorities have systems in place whereby-----
Comment on this
He is a Minister, not a senior counsel.
Comment on this
-----if she wishes to apply or approach her local authority, her individual situation will be addressed in a sensitive way.
Comment on this
If she were concerned about rent certainty-----
Comment on this
-----I would tell her what was in the legislation we are bringing through the House to bring about rent certainty to ensure she has protection in her house.
Comment on this
There is no rent certainty in the plan.
Comment on this
The Government is running out of time.
Comment on this
It is true we do not have the complete solution for every individual faced with this situation-----
Comment on this
The Government has no solution.
Comment on this
The Government does not even have a-----
Comment on this
-----today, because as the Members opposite must accept, one cannot produce houses in a day or a week.
Comment on this
What one can do, however, is ensure the funding is put in place to deliver those houses, ensure the money is there and bring it forward.
Comment on this
One can have measures, such as modular housing, which the lady in question could well avail of.
Comment on this
People cannot avail of modular housing.
Comment on this
One could have measures in the rent legislation, which we are producing in this House.
Comment on this
Every time I mention another measure, I get heckled-----
Comment on this
The Minister should go back to the Bar.
Comment on this
-----because the Deputies opposite know that these are practical, serious solutions to a problem that they just want to talk about.
Comment on this
There are no solutions in anything the Minister said.
Comment on this
That is a disgraceful position from the Labour Party. It is pathetic. I am not interested in Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Yesterday we learned that three people in five renting in Ireland have given up on ever owning their own home. We learned that half of Dublin tenants are in fear of losing their home. Somehow the Government has managed to preside over a housing crisis, a rental crisis, a homelessness crisis and a mortgage crisis all at the same time.
Comment on this
A total of 330,000 men, women and children today are living in homes, on which repayments are in arrears.
Comment on this
The number in arrears for more than two years continues to rise and represents those most at risk of being in court and losing their homes.
Comment on this
After years of inaction and just a few weeks before the election, the Cabinet this week agreed to a bankruptcy change that could only be described as a quarter of what is needed, four years too late. Last week, the Social Democrats published a comprehensive policy response to the mortgage crisis. It introduces one year bankruptcy with a maximum of an additional two years income attachment period. It includes a one-stop-shop for borrowers providing free financial and legal expertise and representation.
Comment on this
It includes a set of mandated solutions for borrowers should they qualify. It would allow courts refuse possession orders if it can be demonstrated that there is a sustainable solution to the mortgage difficulty.
Comment on this
It also includes a realistic way of scaling up the mortgage to rent scheme. David Hall of the Irish Mortgage Holders Organisation stated that in his opinion, working with borrowers and lenders every day, if the Social Democrats proposals, which are all perfectly sensible and achievable, were implemented, the mortgage crisis would be over for those 330,000 people in 12 to 18 months.
Comment on this
That number would fill four Croke Parks.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Alex White, just stated that demonstrating leadership means a suite of policy proposals. I agree. Will he bring the Social Democrats' proposals to Cabinet and help end the mortgage crisis once and for all for 330,000 men, women and children living in fear and stress in this country?
Comment on this
I cannot promise to bring the proposals of any party to Cabinet.
Comment on this
What I will promise to do, and in the spirit of all of us working together as a Dáil, is that I will certainly look at the proposals. We should all look at each other's proposals in particular in the context of the coming months-----
Comment on this
The Government does not have any.
Comment on this
-----in terms of how we address these issues.
Comment on this
There are only eight working days to fulfil the undertaking.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware that the Government has agreed to bring forward legislation on the bankruptcy period.
Comment on this
Will it be enacted and operational before Christmas?
Comment on this
It is on the Dáil record, three times. The Taoiseach and the Tánaiste said it.
Comment on this
I congratulate my colleague, Deputy Penrose, on having brought forward the Bill. It is a genuine piece of legislation that will address the position faced by too many people, as a consequence of the economic crash we had to deal with in this country in recent years. I admit that I have not seen the proposals that are contained in the Deputy's document. I am sorry about that but I will read them, as I am sure he will read the proposals of other parties in the coming months.
Comment on this
There are only eight working days to fulfil the undertaking made on the Dáil record.
Comment on this
As we face into the closing weeks and months of this Dáil, it is necessary to recognise the achievement of the Government-----
Comment on this
The people of Ireland have the Government's undertaking.
Comment on this
-----and the achievement of what has happened in this country. We had the greatest economic crash we had ever seen, and a banking collapse on a scale that has never been seen anywhere in the world. The resulting consequences of that in terms of the living standards of so many people, in particular their opportunity to buy and own a home, have been enormous. The Government's efforts since it came to office have been to address the adverse consequences for so many people of the worst economic crash we have ever seen in this country. That is what we have been facing. If we have not been quick enough to do it, we can deal with that and address it.
Comment on this
The Government resisted any expediency.
Comment on this
If there are measures we could have taken a year before we took them-----
Comment on this
-----or six months before we took them, we can have that debate but nobody can gainsay the fact that this Government-----
Comment on this
-----with Deputy Mathews's support for a little while until he went in another direction, brought together-----
Comment on this
The Government went in a different direction and look where we are.
Comment on this
-----but the public finances to ensure that we now have an economy that can look to the future and a society that can benefit from a stable economic environment. That is what we now have for the first time in seven or eight years after the worst economic crash we have ever seen in this country. In so far as the Deputy is advancing his own party proposals on Leaders' Questions-----
Comment on this
The Minister did not understand the Deputy's question.
Comment on this
-----people will have to recognise that the two Government parties, Fine Gael and the Labour Party, have done an enormous amount to turn this country around.
Comment on this
I welcome the fact the Cabinet has agreed to reduce the bankruptcy period. I tabled such a proposal in 2012 and the Government voted against it. I tabled it subsequent to that also and the Government again voted against it. I recognise and welcome the fact the Government has changed its position and is now reducing the period to one year. However, when we talk about recognising Government achievements, when it comes to the mortgage crisis, the Government's achievement is abject failure. It gives me no pleasure to say that to the Minister. Ireland's level of mortgage arrears is several times higher than other European countries which faced similar economic and housing challenges. Why? The reason is the Government took a hands-off approach and said the banks would pretty much have to solve this themselves on a case-by-case basis. Every Member of this House is helping constituents with mortgage arrears.
Comment on this
Every Member of this House knows that the first question one asks a borrower when they come in is whether they have had financial advice. Most of them say they cannot afford financial advice. Then we ask whether they have had legal advice and if they can afford legal representation. They say they cannot afford legal representation and that if they could, they would not be in mortgage arrears. Then we ask them who is their lender, because the Minister and everyone of us knows the answer to that question will largely determine whether the family is going to recover or be buried by a vindictive lender. The Minister and I know that from our time together on the finance committee.
The Social Democrats has a set of policy proposals. A one-stop-shop for borrowers would provide financial and legal advice for free and it could be set up now. MABS is in place. Other social sector organisations are in place. We do not need to wait for legislation. We do not need to wait for a new Government next year to find its feet and figure out what it wants to do and negotiate a programme for Government. This could be done now.
Comment on this
Mandating a set of solutions which would provide consistency and fairness could be done now. Fixing the mortgage to rent scheme could be done now. I know from my time working with the Minister on the finance committee that he cares about the mortgage crisis but the sad reality is that the Government continues to take a hands off approach and does not act.
Before the next election the Government could introduce a one-stop-shop, mandate a set of solutions and scale up the mortgage to rent scheme. All of those things are possible. While I thank the Minister for saying he will look at the proposal, before this Dáil falls, why not take a genuine position of leadership and implement measures we know will immediately help 330,000 men, women and children in this country?
Comment on this
It is completely untrue to say the Government has taken a hands-off approach to this problem. That is manifestly not true.
Comment on this
The Deputy can disagree with some of the measures-----
Comment on this
-----and he can say the Government should perhaps have gone further or that he disagrees with some of the approaches that were taken but it is ludicrous to suggest that we have taken a hands-off approach.
Comment on this
The Government is asleep at the wheel.
Comment on this
The entire effort of this Government in the past five years has been to stabilise the economy after the shocking economic collapse that occurred, including, in cases where people have had to cope with the impact of mortgage arrears, including insolvency legislation which we introduced and brought through the House, and also the provision of services such as the Money Advice and Budgeting Service, MABS. My understanding is that since September this year MABS has been more involved and it has accelerated its efforts in regard to court mentoring-----
Comment on this
The finance committee was afraid to have the Governor of the Central Bank in. Does the Minister remember that?
Comment on this
-----and in giving advice to individuals who are faced with these issues. It is completely untrue to say that this is a hands off approach. The fact is that the number of people in arrears, the number of families in financial difficulties and household debt have reduced and are reducing, of that there is no question. When Deputy Donnelly compares Ireland to other countries he is not always comparing like with like because he knows that the crash in this country was far more severe than it was in any of the countries he could find with which to compare us.
Comment on this
The reality is that we have achieved an enormous amount, we have stabilised the economy and the public finances and now there is hope for the people that the Deputy and I represent------
Comment on this
You are not giving them much hope.
Comment on this
-----who have faced mortgage difficulties. They have hope, they can sense there is hope and this Government is giving them hope. That is what happening. Those are the specifics in terms of the approach that this Government has taken-----
Comment on this
Is the Government afraid of the work involved?
Comment on this
-----and that is what will continue to work for the Irish people, namely, that the Government and politicians, and I include many politicians on both sides of the House, will work genuinely in the interests of their constituents and also in the interests of the country and in the interests of ensuring we have proper measures in place that are robust, that we have an economy that works and that the people of Ireland can profit from that.