Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026: Committee and Remaining Stages
Sinn Féin proposed a report within six months on how many short-term lets use the seven-year planning provision, to assess its effects on housing and distinguish family tourism businesses from commercial operators. Several Deputies backed monitoring but warned that the provision could let established commercial operators continue using homes for short-term lets; others stressed the importance of protecting rural tourism and called for greater certainty for hosts. Minister Peter Burke said the Bill creates no grandfather clause: eligible operators can use a streamlined process to regularise their planning status, and EU registration rules do not allow operating history to determine registration. He said the amendment was technically flawed and could not accept it.
Contributions 1–102 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 101 of 2026 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 6, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"4.The Minister shall within six months of the passing of this Act lay a report before both Houses of the Oireachtas setting out the number of short-term letting properties that have registered with Failte Ireland having availed of the seven-year grandfather clause in 5.1 of the Planning Policy Statement on Short-Term Lettings."
I am sharing time with Deputy Ó Broin. The Minister and I have had several conversations about the importance of the Bill. The fact that we did not have the planning guidelines left the Oireachtas committee in the position that it could not complete pre-legislative scrutiny but I am not going to go over that.
The amendment relates to the seven-year grandfather clause. We are calling for a report within six months on the number of registered short-term letting properties availing of the clause. This would allow us to see whether the legislation is targeting the commercial investors with multiple properties or unfairly and disproportionately impacting small, family-run businesses and rural hosts. The amendment seeks to create transparency; establish how many properties benefit from the exemption; close the potential loopholes; allow for scrutiny of whether the clause weakens the planning restrictions; show the impact on housing supply, revealing the level of properties continuing in short-term letting use rather than potentially entering the residential market; provide evidence needed to determine whether the exemption is proportionate; and ensure that the legislation is operating fairly. More importantly, it will help to distinguish family-run accommodation from large commercial operators. A key provision we want in the legislation is a distinction between the small, family-run business and the large commercial operators that avail of tax incentives, loopholes and all of that. We are dealing with two very different categories here. We aim to improve Oireachtas oversight and enable early scrutiny and corrective action, where necessary, in respect of this legislation.
Comment on this
One of the challenges of doing Committee Stage in the Dáil is that there is a tendency for us to revert to Second Stage speeches. I am not going to do that in the few hours we have. There are two things I am going to try to do, and maybe the Minister and I can have a bit of an exchange as we go. The first is to raise some genuine concerns. Most of those concerns are about the planning policy statement that has been agreed by Cabinet. It does not fall under the Minister's remit and, therefore, my primary criticisms are actually of his counterpart, the Minister for housing, Deputy James Browne. This is the only opportunity we have to raise those concerns and at least bring them to the attention of Government. Second, there continues to be enormous confusion. Some of it has been caused by the slowness of publishing the policy statement and the genuine difficulty for people in getting their heads around it. Some of it has also been because Members in this Chamber have said things that I do not believe are factually accurate. It may be that they are confused themselves or that they have some ulterior agenda. I am urging the Minister to put as much clarity on the record as possible for all of those people who are trying to make sense of the legislation in front of us and the regulations, whether they are involved in the provision of tourism products or are concerned about the lack of rental supply in our housing system.
One of challenges with the grandfather clause is that, according to the report that the Housing Agency asked Indecon to produce, which I have here, a table on page 14 indicates from its analysis through Inside Airbnb of short-term letting registrations with the platform that about 70% of people currently trading on Airbnb in the State have been trading for seven years or more. The difficulty, therefore, is that if we have a grandfather clause that is just a blanket presumption to grant permission with a very small number of caveats, then the overwhelming majority of those people are going to get it unless, for example, they could contribute to very significant road traffic hazards, where there is a serious risk of flooding or where there is a small number of short-term letters inside the old rent pressure zones, RPZs, that had planning enforcement taken against them. What we are trying to do with this amendment is have some monitoring and some assessment of that so that we can have a proper debate into the future.
While I know that the Minister present is not the Minister with responsibility for planning, he is his proxy and he had that portfolio previously, so he is well acquainted. I want to understand why the Government has taken this approach. As I outlined in my Second Stage speech and as my colleague, Deputy Conway-Walsh, did much more eloquently than I did, we have always been very clear on what we want here. What we want, particularly in urban areas and where there is a shortage of rental supply and a significant homeless problem, is that there be a very tough regime whereby properties that were given planning permission for long-term residential occupation are brought back into long-term residential occupation.
In rural high-amenity areas, however, we want a more flexible approach and that approach should do two things. Where people are involved in family businesses, particularly in properties that are within the curtilage of their own homes and have never have been in the rental sector or are not suitable for it, we want them to be able to regularise and get on with their business. However, where we have commercial interests - for example, there is a company that is registered in London that has been snapping up family homes throughout the Connemara Gaeltacht for short-term lets - that should not be permitted. The local authorities should have the tools, flexibility and, crucially, staff to make that decision.
By having such a blanket grandfather clause, what the Government is essentially doing is allowing huge numbers of commercial operators that are illegally short-term letting what should be long-term residential homes to continue to do so. I just do not understand that because both the Minister, Deputy Burke, and the Minister, Deputy Browne, have repeatedly said that they want those types of property back in the housing system and that they are not the tourism product they are seeking to regularise and continue to operate. Why such a broad, wide and potentially dangerous grandfather clause? While we know that the Minister is not going to accept the amendment, I would like to hear what it is that both the Minister and his colleague, the Minister, Deputy Browne, are going to do in terms of monitoring the operation of this from 1 December to ensure that their twin aim, which as the Minister stated is to support a good-quality family tourism product in rural high-amenity areas while at the same time bringing properties that should be in long-term residential use back into residential use, is actually what happens.
Comment on this
I am glad to get the opportunity to talk on this very important Bill tonight, which I am against. It is a terrible attack on the democratic right of house owners to do what they wish with their own houses that they have bought, built, inherited or owned in one way or another. Many of these people have been doing Airbnb and short-term letting and have been involved in the tourism product we have in Killarney in County Kerry for many years and I am afraid that this is going to hurt many of those.
Tourism has been a critical part of the financial well-being of Kerry since way back in the late 1800s when Queen Victoria visited Killarney and Muckross House. Since then, tourism has developed all over the county. Short-term lets - Airbnbs - are a critical part of this product. There are many parts of Kerry that do not have hotels. We remember when the hotels in Killarney were filled with refugees and asylum seekers. We depended so much on the short-term lets to allow people to come and stay in Kerry and keep the taxis and buses going. They kept the jarvies going. They kept the fishers going. They are so important. There are parts of west Kerry that do not have enough hotels. For that reason, we rely so much on these people.
The seven-year rule has been mentioned in a negative way. It is called the grandfather rule or whatever. The seven-year rule is a fact of life in planning. When someone is at something or has something built for seven years or more, he or she has planning by default. On 10 February, I raised the seven-year rule with the Taoiseach on the Order of Business. I said:
I believe anybody who has been doing Airbnb for more than seven years is entitled to planning permission because they already have it. There are people who [I know] have been doing this for 20 years and more. Whatever the Government is bringing forward should allow the people who have been doing Airbnb to continue doing it as they were. If the Government wants to bring in laws for new people going into Airbnb [that is a different story].
The Taoiseach answered, when I put it to him about the seven-year rule:
Planning laws were there prior to this legislation. Any variation to commercial use requires planning permission. The Deputy referenced seven years plus. [The answer the Taoiseach gave me from where the Minister is sitting across from me was that I was] on the ball to a certain extent; that is the existing position, which is not changed by anything.
Now, this is going to happen to people no matter how many years they have been at it. We were told that populations of less than 20,000 would be exempted from this. To get registered with Fáilte Ireland, people have to get a letter from the planning authority saying that they are exempt and be able to prove that they have been at it. They must go to get the planning, and it is up to the planning authority. I have been involved in planning and helping people in Kerry for as long as I can remember, both with my father and as a councillor. Since I got elected as a TD, I have been involved in people getting planning through default doing whatever they were doing or having whatever they had for-----
Comment on this
Yes, that is what I am getting at. The nub of it is that all people should be asked is to prove that they have been at it for seven years or more. They should not have to get a letter from the planning authority. That is what I am saying. That is what the Government has changed. I believe that the local authority has enough to contend with with applications coming in - fresh applications and every different application - besides asking it then to vet applications for people just to get registered with Fáilte Ireland. This is where people are going to get caught. I am telling people to be very careful before they apply for retention planning because if someone applies for retention planning, I know that that means they are actually saying that they do not have planning and asking for it. I am telling the people who have Airbnbs - people who have been at it for seven years, 20 years and more - to be very careful before they go looking for a letter from the local planning authority because that is going to jeopardise the fact that they have been at it for so long. I am asking people to be very careful and to take legal advice on it.
Do they have planning if they have been at it for seven years or more or do they need to get a letter from the local authority? This is where I am asking people to be very careful. I appreciate, as much as anyone else, the great and valuable work these people and businesses have done for our communities in Kerry and, indeed, in all of the local communities around the country.
Comment on this
I am finishing up anyway, but it is very relevant. It is all relevant. I am saying to people to be very careful-----
Comment on this
I will decide if it is relevant, and it is not, so finish up if you cannot be relevant.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, minutes are going to be very important in this.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt Members-----
Comment on this
I am asking people to be so careful before they look for retention planning just to get registered at this point in time. It is not fair, to my mind, what the Government is doing, trying to bring in laws-----
Comment on this
All right. I will come back in again later if-----
Comment on this
Yes, I hear the Ceann Comhairle.
At the outset, I hope that the Minister can give a genuine and considered response to the issues that we raised previously. In terms of the amendments, I hope that he takes them on board because it will be very difficult for us to support this legislation if the amendments are not brought on board. The key concern of the Social Democrats is to ensure that there is a proper system of regulation put in place, one that balances the needs of tourism with housing needs. Our concern is that the Minister has been dragged into this. He has delayed and been dragged into it because of the requirement to meet the EU timeline but he is really not wholeheartedly behind what he said is trying to do and, in particular, what his own Government's national housing plan sets out. As I said the last day, this Bill actually breaches the Government's own housing plan. How can the Government introduce legislation that is actually contradicting its own national housing plan? That plan, as I set out in a previous contribution, makes it very clear that restrictions will apply to towns with populations greater than 10,000 but the Minister has now changed that to 20,000. I want clarity on that because it seems to me that there is a contradiction there.
The other issue and the biggest concern that I have is around enforcement. Are we actually going to see genuine enforcement of these restrictions? I am also concerned about the issue raised earlier by Deputy Ó Broin in relation to the grandfather clause, which is essentially a get-out clause. It is another example of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael making up policy that sounds great but when it comes to practice, they provide opt-outs so that they are not really applying the policy, legislation and subsequent law equally. I am concerned about this because we have had a planning requirement in place since 2019. I went back and looked at the figures for the number of owners of short-term lets who had applied for planning permission between 2019 and 2024 and it was only 426. Only 186 applications were granted planning permission, so there are tens of thousands of short-term lets operating across the country with no planning permission. They have been in breach of the law for seven years? What is going to change now? The Government is going to introduce a register. My concern is about where the actual planning legal requirement will be when people make their declarations. Will that be evidenced? I hope that the Minister has made a change to require evidence of planning permission or planning exemption achieved.
The other issue in relation to the grandfather clause is important. We should have evidence to see what impact this Bill has on properties. The Government said, and it made a commitment in its programme for Government, that short-term lets were going to be restricted to ensure that housing would be available for people. I am very concerned that this Bill is setting out overtly to achieve that but will not achieve it in practice.
Comment on this
One thing the Minister said last week that I would agree with was that we should all co-operate and work together. Is he going to accept some of our amendments here tonight? That is how co-operation works, or it is certainly the way it has ever worked in the real world.
I am standing up tonight for the protection of Airbnbs in rural communities. Once we sign into law the planning aspects of this, it is game over for many of them. It is game over for most of them unless there are new ones setting up. I listened to people talking in here last week and in fairness to Deputy George Lawlor, he was very much to the point. He was the best speaker here and Deputy Conway-Walsh was very good as well. The bottom line, though, is that when it came to pressing the button, he pressed the button the wrong way and was not able to convince the rest of the members of his party to do the same. That is very disappointing. The Social Democrats are so far removed. They have no clue how tourism works, yet their leader is from the capital of tourism. Maybe the lads from Kerry might fight with me on that but west Cork is the capital of tourism.
Comment on this
To think that Holly Cairns has not been able to explain to her party and give it an understanding of rural tourism is shocking beyond belief.
Comment on this
It will not be forgotten in west Cork.
Comment on this
I am talking about the amendment. I want to begin by acknowledging the amendment tabled by Sinn Féin. I can see the direction that party is going in and I recognise the concern behind this amendment. It asks the Minister to report on the number of short-term letting properties registered with Fáilte Ireland that have availed of the seven-year grandfather arrangement in the planning policy statement. That is useful information to have but I would make one very important point. There is a fundamental difference between reporting on how many operators have benefited from the Government's arrangement and actually giving established operators the legal certainty they need right now. That is where I have difficulty with the approach.
I have been contacted by people throughout west Cork and other parts of rural Ireland who have operated holiday accommodation for years. Some have been operating for seven or eight years while others have been doing it for 15 or 20 years. These are established businesses. They are not people who suddenly decided last week to buy up a row of houses and put them on Airbnb, as some parties in here - those that have no understanding of tourism in rural Ireland - think. They are families who have invested in their properties, paid their taxes, welcomed visitors and contributed to the local economy. Now they are facing uncertainty about whether they will need another planning permit simply to continue what they have been doing for years. That is the issue we should be addressing.
We have already had considerable confusion about the seven-year rule. The Taoiseach previously suggested to me in the Dáil that somebody who had operated an Airbnb for seven years did not need planning permission. Is that the case tonight? No, it is not. Now we see that this Bill says that they will need to apply. Were we conned? Were we misled here in the Dáil? Has the Taoiseach come in to correct the record of the Dáil? These are very serious matters because tens of thousands of people are going to be put out of business. Even the companies that are out there protecting Airbnbs were all conned. I have been told that. I have been inundated with messages from my own constituency, never mind anywhere else, from people who were misled by Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. They were promised that this would not have planning in it in relation to the seven years and over. It is written all over the document. If the Minister wants to co-operate with people tonight, he should accept our amendments. These organisations believed the Government and told their people that because that is what they were told.
Now they are in a fury because they realise they were conned. Everybody was conned in this game. The Minister was too. He was led up the garden path. It is no wonder he was giving out about Independent Ireland all weekend at the conference. There were texts coming out left, right and centre. They did not know if it was an Independent Ireland conference or a Fine Gael conference, they were so obsessed by us.
Comment on this
I am sorry; I forgot about that actually. The Government's planning policy statement proposes a presumption in favour of retention permission for certain established operators, but a presumption in favour is not a guarantee. It is not a statutory exemption and does not provide the same certainty as a clear legal entitlement to continue an established use. That distinction is fundamental. A family that has operated a holiday cottage for 15 years should not have to rely on different interpretations of Government policy to establish whether they can continue their business. They need clarity.
That brings me directly back to the Sinn Féin amendment, which asks for a report on the number of properties availing of the grandfather clause. What exactly is being called grandfathering? If an operator still has to apply for retention permission, pay the relevant fees, wait for planning decisions and face the possibility of refusal, that is not the same as a permanent statutory exemption. It may be a more favourable planning policy, but it is not the legal certainty that many established operators are looking for. That distinction matters when we are talking about how many businesses have benefited. Are we counting people who have obtained permission, people who have submitted applications, people who have been told they may qualify or people whose established use has been protected? Those are different things.
I remind the House of the type of accommodation we are dealing with. In beautiful west Cork and along the western seaboard - I have had many people ringing me from all over the country - we have holiday cottages, converted farm buildings, small family-operated properties and accommodation developed specifically for tourism. Many of these properties have been providing accommodation for years. They support local restaurants, pubs, shops, attractions and employment. They support local employment specifically for a lot of women who are trying to provide a side income to educate their children and keep the family home going. Some of them could never realistically provide permanent residential accommodation. A small tourist cabin is not necessarily a family home. A converted traditional farm building is not automatically suitable for long-term occupation. A property used by a family for part of the year and rented to visitors for the remainder is not the same as an ordinary residential house. Permanently removing these distinctions from the rental market matters. It matters when deciding if a planning restriction is necessary. It matters when considering the effect on housing. It matters when determining if established operators should receive grandfathering protection.
I acknowledge Deputy Gogarty's work on this legislation. It is clear from the amendment he has tabled that he has examined the practical circumstances of different operators in considerable detail. He has recognised the position of small family providers. He has addressed accommodation that is used privately for part of the year and by visitors seasonally. He has considered accommodation associated with the family home. Those are precisely the types of distinctions that must inform any meaningful grandfathering arrangements. I expect that we will all co-operate and work together. Are we going to see that tonight, or is the Minister going to oppose all these amendments? A simple count of properties benefiting from a policy statement will not, by itself, tell us if the Government has dealt fairly with the different types of established accommodation. I am disappointed with the approach taken by the Labour Party, when they voted against us last week, and in particular by the Social Democrats. There has been plenty of discussion about protecting housing. Nobody disputes the seriousness of the housing problem. However, we need more than a watery Opposition and political fence-sitting when it comes to the actual consequences for rural businesses. It is easy to talk about returning properties to the housing market.
Comment on this
I am speaking about the Sinn Féin amendment. You have to ask if the particular property was ever realistically part of that market in the first place. There is a world of difference between an investor buying up ordinary residential houses in a city and a family operating an established holiday cottage in rural Cork. The legislation needs to recognise that difference. Otherwise, we risk applying an urban housing solution to rural tourism accommodation without properly examining the consequences.
I turn to the recent European judgment. We have spoken at length with our MEP, Ciaran Mullooly. This is not dictated from Europe. It is a different policy completely to the one dictated from Europe. This is an Irish-driven solution. Last week I spoke about places like Durrus or Courtmacsherry feeding into the crisis in Dublin. It is outrageous what the Government has done here. Ciaran Mullooly has made that clear because he has spoken to his counterparts in Europe. While they want a register, they do not want to dictate to or close down businesses, which is what the Government is doing here. Smartflats also makes the question of proportionality particularly relevant. Planning restrictions on short-term letting may be justified but they must satisfy applicable requirements of necessity and proportionality. The European Commission's proposed affordable housing Act expressly recognised grandfathering as a possible and less restrictive alternative to prohibitions on property use. It demonstrates that grandfathering is a recognised policy option when the Government is considering how to regulate established uses. That is important in the context of this amendment. The question is not simply how many operators have benefited from a Government policy. The question is whether the policy provided adequate and proportionate protection in the first place.
Returning to the Sinn Féin amendment, I understand what Deputies Conway-Walsh and Ó Broin are trying to achieve. They want to establish how the seven-year grandfathering arrangements will work. That is a legitimate question, and I acknowledge the direction of their amendment. However, we should not have to wait six months after the legislation is passed to discover whether established businesses have been adequately protected. We can identify the uncertainty now. We know that a planning presumption is not the same as an exemption. We know the established operators are concerned about having to apply for permission. We know that some of these properties have been providing tourism accommodation for many years. We have brought forward our own proposals in 12 amendments. The Minister said he wants to co-operate, so I look forward to him agreeing to most of them dealing with the permanent grandfathering. I will address those in detail when the relevant amendments come before the committee. For now, I ask the Minister a straightforward question. Why should an established operator who has been providing tourist accommodation for seven, ten or 15 years have to go through another planning process simply to continue that established use, where the appropriate safety and environmental safeguards can be shown to exist? This is the central issue. While I acknowledge the purpose of the Sinn Féin amendment, I want the Government to go beyond reporting on this problem. I want it to provide established operators with the certainty they need.
Comment on this
I will be brief. I am disappointed that we are having this debate in the House and not in a committee where we can tease out all the issues that should be dealt with. The Minister has been talking about this for a long time. He met the organisations and the people. Commitments were given by Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and the Independents supporting them that they would not use a sledgehammer to crack a chestnut, which is what they have done here. They extended the registration period for more than a month, which is the busiest month of the year for people. Maybe it is not for the providers as they might not have many holiday makers, but Christmas is a busy time. There are end-of-year accounts if they are farming and whatever else. Some of them are calving early as well. It is a busy time, so a month is not an adequate period of time. It should definitely be extended to three months to give people more time.
The seven-year clause is there. We have been debating that for decades at council and planning meetings, at the side of the road and everything else when something has been in existence for seven years. Now the Government is trying to suck them in, like a spider drawing them into the web to pounce on them. That is what they are at and people can see that.
The Government is completely misguided in its belief that there are tens of thousands of housing units throughout the country in short-term lets. Nothing could be further from the truth. I visited Tomás O'Keeffe's lovely building early yesterday morning. It is a restored farmhouse right in the middle of a farmyard. It is suitable for people who like that and come to visit. It is a great addition to the area for rural tourism. I could also mention a house in Dundrum in the middle of farmyard. Those properties cannot become living units for a normal family. It just will not happen. It is used by the family in these cases for anniversary masses, reunions and things like that. They then rent it out as non-farm income to supplement and augment their farm income which - my God - has been decimated enough with the CAP coming down the road. The Government wants to get involved in wars and armaments and cut money from the CAP. I am totally opposed to the way the Government has gone about this.
Comment on this
I will speak to the amendment. It deserves support because what the Government is doing with the grandfather clause, which I call the great-grandfather clause, is to give commercial operators an amnesty.
It is only fair that the Oireachtas knows the scale of that. That is reasonable because this legislation will not address the Indecon report finding that 16,870 housing units or homes are being used as commercial short-term lets in areas of high housing demand. We need to see exactly where this legislation leads us to in six months because the way this has been handled has not been acceptable. The enterprise committee did pre-legislative scrutiny that it could not conclude because of some sort of a bun fight that was going on between the Department and the Department of housing in relation to agreeing the planning statement. The way the planning statement was handled was deeply cynical. At the eleventh hour, with no Oireachtas scrutiny at all, it was just presented to the Cabinet as a fait accompli. Then - wham, bam - we come in here tonight and we do this all in four hours. We know this is being rushed because the Minister has to meet an EU deadline. That is why the Government is rushing this through in the way that it is. This could have been done four years ago. It could have been done two years ago. As far as I recall, it was in the previous programme for Government.
The fact of the matter is that we need to see the exact criteria that are going to apply to the seven-year threshold and to the grandfather clause. We need to see what exactly the effect of those criteria will be. I believe they will effectively, ipso facto, allow illegal short-term lets that are not complying with planning to get the presumption of planning permission to operate outside the parameters of the law, as it already stands. It is basically giving them a free pass. That is not acceptable because the stated purpose of this legislation is to get homes in high-demand areas that are being used as short-term lets, and should be part of our long-term rental supply, back into the long-term rental market to deal with the housing crisis.
The Minister might address the fact that there are a number of significant errors in this Bill. Deputy Lawlor, my colleague, will speak on this later. There are errors in the Bill, as published, that have not yet been corrected and we are now on Committee Stage. Based on our analysis and the work we have done, we believe that unless some of these errors are corrected, they may make the Bill very difficult, if not impossible, to enforce.
This is a sensible amendment. The Minister for housing claimed that the Bill provides for the strongest system of regulation of short-term lets in Europe. I do not believe that to be true. Certainly, for those of us on this side of the House who have gone through it, because of the grandfather clause or, as I have called it, the "great-grandfather clause", and because of the two-year bedding-in period, there are a number of holes in this.
Those of us who have issues with the Bill believe it will be largely ineffective because of the system of self-certification and because of the holes we have found. There are also criticisms of the Bill from people who believe short-term lets should not be regulated at all. What we all agree on is that we should have a report laid before the House within six months to see clearly where we are at six months after its enactment.
Comment on this
There are 71 amendments to deal with here today. There are people around the country and in the Gallery who want us to get on with the work. We are over half an hour into the debate and we have not dealt with one amendment yet. If we keep going this way, we will do nothing for the people. The people that I am talking about, in particular, are the people in Kerry who are looking for us to move these amendments. I am going to be so brief, it will be sensible and brief. I support the amendments that are put forward. I want to us to move on.
I just want to clarify one matter. A previous Deputy spoke about an amnesty. There is no such thing as an amnesty in what the Minister is proposing. Everyone is to apply for planning. There is no EU deadline either. This is a Government-set deadline.
We have 71 amendments. If we all stand up here tonight and make big flowery speeches, we will do nothing for this sector. The people who are here representing the organisations are horrified at the length of time it is taking us to deal with one amendment. The people at home who are watching what is going on in here are horrified to think we are talking and doing nothing. I want to move on with getting to the important amendments, having spoken to the Minister. I want to have the votes as necessary and drive this on. I want to try to work for people and not be making big flowery speeches about nothing.
Comment on this
God, sure I am not saying a bit to you.
Comment on this
Is it me, so? Is it those of us who are standing by the people of Ireland and tourism?
Comment on this
We are well entitled to stand by our people.
Comment on this
We have 71 amendments to move.
Comment on this
We are all entitled to speak and we will.
Comment on this
We have 71 amendments to move.
Comment on this
I am standing by my people of west Cork and the Deputy can stand by his of Kerry and make up his own mind.
Comment on this
I want to move the amendments.
Comment on this
A lot of them will not be improving amendments anyway.
Comment on this
Hold on now, Michael. I will not talk about flowery speeches because I am in construction and I understand what I am talking about. We might look at the way that Deputy Michael Healy-Rae should be still over in the Government because he has been voting with it since he left, even when he sat back over here. Now, we will speak to the amendment and we will get rid of the flowery words. It is very simple. Speaking to the amendments, we will look at the grandfather agreement and at the proposal to give people an extra month to apply for this. Will the Minister come into the real world? I believe the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, probably does want to do something about it but the Minister, Deputy Browne, will not allow him.
I advise Deputies to try to get an engineer or an architect in the next six months, never mind the next month. I deal with this on a daily basis. I deal with planning permission and building. I build. We are looking at the lack of people to do applications, the cost of doing the applications and the viability of doing the applications. Then we look at the seven-year rule that people are talking about. The seven-year rule means that if you apply for planning permission after the seven-year rule, you have to be granted a permission but you have to regularise what you have done once nobody had objected to it in the seven years that the building was there or the business was going on there. That is what the seven-year rule is, and that is simplified. The problem here is that the Minister is looking to regularise every person who has been doing this in the past seven years. We are talking about the same people who rolled up their sleeves and welcomed people from Ukraine. The Government filled every hotel in Ireland with people. The people who put out for the tourism sector of this country were those with the short-term lets. The people who welcomed people into this country to help the tourism industry were those with the short-term lets. What we are talking about here is a realistic time.
I will outline what Minister should also be looking at if he wants people to regularise their units. To qualify under the current planning regulations - we are moving from SR 6 - you not only have to qualify under the building itself, and under the percolation if you have an external percolator, but you also have to qualify for road distance on an entrance coming into it. Even if there was no application made or no accidents recorded on the premises where you are, this is where the regularisation comes into it. This is why the Bill should have gone to the committee. As I said to the Minister yesterday, we are debating all the amendments in here today, but it should have been done in a committee.
I would like to see how many Members who are talking about the flowery stuff voted for it not to go to the committee. That is where we should be dealing with this to get the problems sorted out before we bring it to this House and have it guillotined. I am going to sit down on this, and we are going to look at the different amendments to make sure we try to cover as many of them as we can. When someone stands up to say they want to talk about all the amendments when they were the one person who stopped it going to committee in the first place, then I have a concern. The same person votes with Government even though he has moved to the other side of the House. This is what I am talking about; talking out of both sides of the mouth. Let us look at the record here. Who was really trying to help is the likes of people from Independent Ireland. I have to admit that Fine Gael spoke long and hard enough about it at its Ard-Fheis and we are here today talking to the Minister again. It is like déjà vu.
Comment on this
It is the first amendment and normally with the first amendment people tend to elaborate a little beyond the reasoning so we have to allow a little bit of leeway. This amendment is referring to something that is not even in the Bill because the Minister for housing is bringing in the changes. The core eligibility criteria for the seven-year rule include continuous operation for at least seven years, a clean enforcement record, safety and infrastructure standards and occupancy compliance. Then there are disqualifiers such as a local housing needs assessment and disproportionate concentration. Basically, it streamlines it, and they are hoops to jump through anyway. If all those criteria are met, a person is exempt from submitting architectural floor plans and elevations. They only have to give the approximate floor area and a brief description of the details, so it is a slightly less onerous process, but still onerous enough. For a lot of the places that have been operating for more than seven years, the concern is about the ones that are operating in tourism towns. These are the types of premises that family members own and would not dream of letting out as commercial landlords. That is what we are trying to protect. If we had just gone with the EU legislation, we could have had a very simple registration position but the Government was trying to merge the housing and tourism issues and trying to deal with the urban operators who are milking the system by having short-term lets when they should be letting properties out with proper Residential Tenancies Board, RTB, adherence and freeing up houses in the market. I fully support that because it makes a lot of sense. However, as I said previously, and as Deputy McGrath just referenced, the Government is trying to crack a nut with a sledgehammer. I do not think anyone in this Chamber should really oppose the amendment because all it is doing is looking for a report. There are valid reasons people would apply under the seven-year rule for less onerous restrictions. It is not any conspiracy theory of people trying to get out of renting under the RTB through the back door. It is not, pure and simple, so let us get on with the legislation and debate the more intricate bits that we need to protect people in rural communities.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputies for their contributions.
I will outline the technical response to amendment No. 1. While the policy objective of the amendment is clearly understood, the drafting is technically incorrect and could give rise to legal operational uncertainty. The Bill does not provide for a grandfathering clause. Section 47 introduces a new section 83A to the Planning and Development Act 2004, which grants two years' grace for operators outside built-up areas with a population of under 20,000 to regularise their planning status. The national planning statement recognises rights under the planning code, whereby if no enforcement action has been taken by the planning authority for at least seven years, an operator may apply for retention permission to regularise an established but unauthorised use. This provides a pathway for long-established short-term rental accommodation to achieve planning compliance and participate in the registration system.
The short-term letting registration scheme has been designed to comply with requirements of the EU short-term rental regulation, which establishes a harmonisation registration framework across the Single Market. Under Article 4(3)(a) of the regulation, registration procedures must operate on the basis of declarations made by hosts. Article 4(3)(b) further requires member states to provide for outlying registration procedures that allow for the automatic and immediate issuance of a registration number. Article 5(1)(b) requires hosts to declare whether the accommodation is subject to an authorisation scheme and, where applicable, whether the necessary authorisation has been obtained. In Ireland, authorisation to provide short-term rental accommodation is determined by compliance with the planning code. The regulation does not provide for different treatment based on the length of time a host has been operating. As a result, the duration of the operator's activity in the market cannot form part of the registration process nor can it be used as a basis for determining eligibility for registration. Accordingly, the registration process cannot require a host to provide information on how long they have been operating. Rather, in accordance with the regulation, hosts are required to declare whether they have the necessary authorisation to offer short-term rental accommodation services.
Regarding some of the comments that have been well-made by Deputies, I can appreciate that people are coming from very different perspectives and backgrounds here. As a rural TD and tourism Minister, I bring to the table concerns about our rural economy and areas where the availability of tourism accommodation is challenged and trying to ensure that we do not create unintended consequences for the tourism sector. I am also very aware of the acute housing needs in society. As a Government, we cannot stand by and watch housing units being rented out for one, two, or three weekends a month in areas where people cannot get secure housing accommodation or cannot get long-term rental accommodation. That is an absolute need that society has to balance. The Government cannot stand by and not take action and let 10% growth in the sector carry on year after year without any regulation. It is incumbent on Government to act. However, we have to act in a balanced way and that is where we hear both sides of the debate coming to the forefront here. We can see with this amendment Members supporting it with very different perspectives coming to the table.
There are a few comments I would like to put on the record. I understand that there is a lot of concern in relation to the different perspectives. First, let us consider someone in a population area of under 20,000 in the short-term letting market and letting out accommodation for more than seven years but who does not have planning compliance. I have been very clear that the person has to pay a registration fee of €25 to Fáilte Ireland and has two years to be compliant.
Second, the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage has drafted a planning statement whereby it states very clearly that there shall be a presumption in favour of granting planning permission. It is also very clear in relation to the retention process that we have from last September a streamlined administrative process which clearly states that the new SI 500/2026 provides for detailed plans or maps not being required where this is a wholly administrative process for applications where no additional works are proposed. There is a streamlined process with a €25 registration fee and two years to carry out regularisation. That is a fair, balanced and proportionate approach for people who are engaged in the short-term letting market in areas where tourism accommodation is needed. It is very important to drive that huge economic growth that we have in many rural areas. If they have been operating for less than seven years, they still avail of the streamlined administrative process and get planning permission. The Government has a call to make, and this is key in deciding what the metric is. I hear a lot of voices across the Chamber but I do not hear many identifying exactly what Members want.
Many of them said that they want to protect rural businesses and communities. How do we do that? No one identified the rule that will lead to us protecting rural businesses and communities.
The original threshold identified by the Government, about which I had considerable concern, was towns with a population of 10,000. That would have brought an additional 29 towns into the reckoning. Some of those towns are in areas in which accommodation is needed for our tourism sector. As the Minister for tourism, working with the Minister, Deputy Browne, I have to balance those needs. That is why the Government, through discussions, came forward with a threshold of a population of 20,000, which includes 25 towns and cities. We believe that provides a greater balance.
Deputies said that tens of thousands of units are going to come back through this process. I do not believe that for one minute. We are not going to get tens of thousands of units back. I have seen no data to suggest that will be the case. However, in some of the 25 areas where housing demand is acute, I expect we will get a significant proportion of accommodation units back into the long-term rental market. That is what we are aiming to do. That is what the design is for.
A Deputy asked why people should have to go forward into another planning process if they have been in operation for seven years. If people have been in operation for seven years, they do not have planning permission. That is the key issue. We are not asking someone to go forward into another planning process. They are not complying with the law right now. Surely we should expect people to be in compliance with the law of the land. It is critical that we, as a State, have tourism information data to allow us, as policymakers, to plan and decide on the policies that our tourism sector needs for the future. That is good for our tourism operators. Many of them welcome this legislation because it will provide valuable data to assist us in the future.
I appreciate Deputies' bona fides. I am a rural TD. I know that these balancing issues are tricky. I know that to weave a cohesive path through the Dáil is difficult. I accept that people are concerned about the timing. I understand that. However, I am limited, too. I am trying to work with my Government colleagues and another Department. I am not in control of everything. We have tried to work with the committee as best we can, but I cannot control the operation of everything within the system. We have made our best effort. We had a good communication campaign and there will be a second in September. I have met many operators. The team in the Department has had many round-table discussions with stakeholders over recent years. This has been proposed for a long time. We have achieved a fair balance.
Unfortunately, for the reasons I have given, I am unable to accept the amendment. However, I thank Deputies and appreciate the bona fides that everyone is bringing to the table.
Comment on this
I have two brief comments and two queries to help with clarification. The amendment is trying to address a challenge. If the Minister were to come to my constituency in Dublin Mid-West, which is suburban Dublin, and I took him to Cabra in the north inner city, but also if I were to bring him to part of the Cooley Peninsula or the Connemara Gaeltacht, I would show him homes. They are not at all the rural businesses we are talking about and trying to support in different ways. These are homes that were built for residential occupation and that have been acquired not by local families or communities but by commercial interests, which, in many instances, are not rooted in those communities. If they have been operating for more than seven years, they will, under the terms of the planning policy statement, have a presumption of a grant. The difficulty with that is that it runs completely contrary to the Government's stated aim of wanting those properties back in residential occupation.
I agree completely that we are not talking about tens of thousands of properties. I have always thought that people on the Government side and the Opposition side who use those types of figures are doing us all an injustice. However, having a system whereby commercial operators, which have sucked family homes out of the residential market, whether in urban or rural areas, are given this seven-year period simply makes no sense. I suspect it will be open to legal challenge by somebody who has been operating for six or five years. The seven-year rule is arbitrary and is not linked to planning enforcement. The Minister is correct that just because somebody has been operating outside the planning process for seven years does not mean that he or she is planning compliant. In fact, the opposite is the case. There may be genuine difficulties in that regard.
There is another problem with the 10,000 and 20,000 thresholds. I am not questioning the Minister's bona fides, but I have genuine concerns. The 10,000 threshold means that Maynooth is no longer captured by the stricter regime, and it should be. In residential parts of Maynooth, there is significant short-term letting in properties that were recently built for long-term residential occupation. That is a real problem.
Let us consider some of those very high tourism areas. There are Deputies present who represent those communities in counties Kerry and Cork and they have far better knowledge of them than I do. However, I should not be allowed to form a fund with some people in Dublin and go into An Daingean, Tralee, Killarney or wherever else and start buying up homes on housing estates and letting them in the short term. I should not be allowed to do that. However, if I have been doing that for seven years, I have a get out of jail free card. That causes difficulties for the genuine family-based tourism businesses in those areas. The threshold, whether it is 10,000 or 20,000, is completely arbitrary. Almost all of us are united on the fact that it is not based on anything.
The Minister has dealt with one of my questions, but I want him to be specific. Some people think the retention processes outlined in the circular he mentioned, and which I have in front of me, only applies to people availing of the grandfather clause. In his response, he made it clear that is not the case. It will apply to all of those who are applying for planning permission. If we were crystal-clear about that, it would clear up some of the confusion.
The other issue is that nobody knows what the planning fees will be. The application form for retention is very short. I have it in front of me. I have no issue with that. In fact, it is helpful. That there are no required drawings or inputs from architects or engineers should be of some comfort to people. However, the fees are still unclear and, therefore, if the Minister could provide any clarity, I would appreciate it.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for his comments. The streamlined process applies across the board. I want to provide clarity on that.
Comment on this
It is for everyone. The average retention fee is approximately €125. That will be paid through the local authorities, depending on their charging policy in that regard.
I hear what the Deputy said. There are difficult challenges for policymakers when we are trying to find a strong balance for a proposal that has significant teeth to deliver, particularly in those 25 towns I mentioned with a population of over 20,000. However, in consultation with the Attorney General, I was advised that there is an established legal principle to the effect that I cannot differentiate in respect of the seven years in towns with populations of over 20,000 and under 20,000. The advice was that I could not offer a seven-year process for towns with populations of less than 20,000 whereby they could have a streamlined process for regularising their planning and not allow it in towns with populations of over 20,000.
Comment on this
Nor would I have argued that, but that is a separate issue
Comment on this
We are trying to balance the rural economy and accessible accommodation with having to allow for a process in towns with a population of over 20,000. I am being frank and honest. Those are the challenges you meet when you are trying to deliberate on these policies. That was the established legal principle I was advised of on that point.
I know that people give out about the thresholds. I am disappointed that I have not heard anyone else come forward with an alternative. It is easy for us to say that we need to protect local businesses and the families who are bringing in a small bit of revenue through Airbnb to put their kids through college but that we do not want the commercial operator up the road partaking of that behaviour. Those are nice thoughts, but from a legal perspective I have not seen anyone put forward such an amendment. Of all the amendments before us, I see none that puts forward a mechanism to deliver on some of these issues. I have brought forward a clear pathway that protects tourism in rural Ireland.
If someone is in a town, village or settlement of under 20,000 people, they have a clear mechanism to get planning with a positive presumption on board, a streamlined process, a €25 fee and two years to do it. That is very fair, and no matter how long we debate this and look at it, it will be very difficult to get a measure as balanced as that. However, I appreciate that there are people in this House who think I am not going far enough. They almost have a zero-tolerance approach to Airbnb and short-term lets. There are also people here who think I have gone too far. That is healthy democracy. We can debate in the House but I have to make a call on it. I appreciate the sentiments from people along the way.
Comment on this
I appreciate that Members can make their contributions, but I called Deputy Ó Broin and the Minister replied, and then I got three other indications. Can we take it that, on this round, that would bring us to a conclusion on the matter? I ask Members to think of the rest of the amendments.
Deputy Collins indicated, as did Deputy Hearne.
Comment on this
I am not ruling the Deputy out. I am just trying to get some balance. We will also hear from Deputy Conway-Walsh and then ask the Minister to respond before we put the question.
Comment on this
I noted some of the comments that the Minister made. He said that he was not agreeing with all of the amendments. Is it just that he is not agreeing to this one? We know what the answer is going to be for the rest of them if he is not going to agree to this. He asked last week for co-operation. Amendments are a way forward.
The Minister also said that none of us was telling him exactly what we wanted, but it is very clear. We know what we want. We know how rural tourism works. We are not fools; we are around a long time. In fairness, the Minister said he was a rural TD. I believe that this is not what he wants, but he is going to have to sell it because the Minister, Deputy Browne, cracked the whip.
The Minister, Deputy Burke, referred to a good communication campaign. That is wrong and he cannot tell Members, the people in the Gallery or the audience - a lot of people have told me that they are watching this debate - that it means something. It was one of the worst Bills brought before the Dáil in its history, or certainly in my ten years here. It was stopping and starting and starting and stopping and nobody ever knew what it meant. Campaign groups acting on behalf of people with short-term lets were given slight guarantees along the line but then those guarantees were thrown in the bin. Deadlines were missed. It was a complete hames from start to finish. I am very concerned that the Minister is not going to agree to any of these amendments.
The Minister referred to a presumption of getting planning. What did he mean by that? Is he saying that someone who has been running an Airbnb for 15 years and been planning compliant all their lives is going to have somebody going into their property? That could happen because I can see a lot of this being one person reporting another. It happens quite a lot in ordinary planning, so why not with this. Does that mean that the planning official who is going to arrive will tell them not to worry and that even though what was compliant 15 years is not now, the official will turn a blind eye because a presumption of getting planning has come into place here? I do not think so. I was below in the committee room when the Bill was debated. This matter should have been debated there, and I called a vote in the House yesterday to ensure that we went back into the committee. Sadly, that proposal was voted against. Some people did not even stay for the vote even though they were there before the vote was called. The Minister must explain the presumption of planning. It is very important. If somebody has been successfully and safely operating something for many years, is a planning officer going to visit and say that, in the last ten years, there have been rules on disabled access, septic tanks, electrical compliance and whatever? The planners who were at the committee meetings that we were allowed to have told me that they should sign away and not to worry. That is ridiculous. I asked one if he would put it in writing but he said he could not. Obviously he could not because he knows that when you get a knock on the door and you are not planning compliant, you have to make things compliant.
That is the concern and the crux of my wanting to speak about this amendment and others. It is a general situation. The Minister is saying that he does not know what we want but I am telling him. We did not get enough time to sit around that table. No matter how many times people sat around the table, there was a slight difference, a slight twist and a slight turn to the story and it all got changed again. The Government made a complete hames out of it.
Comment on this
I will be brief. The rationale for this amendment is obviously that we would have the data to inform policy. It may be needed to differentiate between rural, small, family properties and commercial properties. We do not want large commercial entities buying up properties in rural areas and making huge profits on the backs of the small operators who are already there and off the rural areas themselves. I am going to press this amendment because if that data is not available to us, we will not be able to make proper policy on this in future.
It has been helpful to have this discussion, although it has been a bit long. However, the communication concerns me. The Minister says that we will have further communication in December, but by then it will not be long before Christmas. I ask the Minister to front-load the very accurate information. Some of the questions raised by Deputies, even ones the Minister has answered, ask for information that the small operators will need in order to be able to make proper decisions and judgments about their properties.
Comment on this
I will not delay us long but I want to talk about the presumption of planning and the Minister's statement that two years will be allowed in settlements of fewer than 20,000 people, which is fair enough. However, what if someone has two properties in one folio? One of them could be used under the rent-a-room scheme and could be rented for up to a certain amount. The second one, to make it planning compliant, may have seen a massive investment even if it is only a one-bedroom or two-bedroom apartment for Airbnb. Under the current regulations in a rural area, there was the standard septic tank, which was a six-person unit. Someone may then have to put in an eight- or ten-person unit. A person can rent a room in a household and earn up to €14,000 tax free but they might have a little apartment for holidaymakers that is earning way less than that and the Government still wants that person to spend €20,000 to €30,000 to regularise that apartment for a short-term stay. What I am trying to say is that some of these are no longer viable. This is what we are saying about a seven-year rule. I understand what the Minister is saying about how they were not planning compliant if they were running an operating like this, but people have been giving up rooms in their houses, or maybe a little flat adjacent or just slightly away from their house, for decades. They are not planning compliant but the Minister is talking about regularising it. It has to come down to viability. The Minister is so adamant about the two-year rule, but if it is not viable for property owners to do it even though they are helping their communities, will he introduce a grant system to make it sustainable for a person who has a short-term let in a rural area that needs the business it provides?
Comment on this
That concludes the contributions. If the Minister answers any of the questions that were not answered previously, I can then put the question.
Comment on this
I thank Members for their comments again. I take the point about the communications campaign. There was one in October 2025. I appreciate that a lot has changed since then, so we will have a significant campaign starting next week. I note that there is a website with all of the details of the changes. I will put on the record that I had a number of meetings with the Department and round-table discussions with what were essentially stakeholders in connection to this. Officials from the Departments of housing and enterprise attended the Irish Self-Catering Federation annual conferences on 11 November 2024 and 10 November 2025. Fáilte Ireland has done a lot of work with some of the platforms in terms of discussions.
I wish to point something out in connection with some of the concerns that have been raised. People talk about protection. Deputy Collins says that he knows what he needs.
I appreciate that. The Deputy wants to ensure that local rural operators can continue to offer accommodation and to ensure there are no unintended consequences for the tourism sector. However, as a Government, we also have to tackle the problem whereby we have significant swathes of Airbnbs that are increasing by a minimum of 10% per annum in cities that are only let out for very short periods during the month and where there is a huge problem with housing accommodation in those areas. Society cannot stand idly by and look at young couples trying to get housing and people trying to get long-term rental accommodation where there are significant housing pressures and we keep seeing the prevalence of Airbnbs increasing. Looking at the figures, in Dublin in particular we have nearly 13,000 units of hotel accommodation going through construction. Nationally, we have 38,780 currently in planning but two thirds of them are in Dublin. I need to tackle that issue too and I cannot look at one in isolation. That is why this strikes the best balance in providing a clear pathway so that I can look any rural operator in the eye, who is relying on an Airbnb, and say directly to them that for €25 they can register and they have two years. They have a presumption for positive planning. They have a streamlined process. They do not need maps. They do not need plans. They have a very straightforward process if they are not carrying out additional works for retention.
In response to what Deputy O'Donoghue brought up - it is very clear in the planning statement - that if your property is not suitable for the long-term residential market, because it is an older property or it is in the curtilage of your own house or area, that those are the types of accommodation we want to grant planning permission for. I appreciate that there are challenges. People have to go through a streamlined process but it does provide a pathway, which is what I want to do. I want to try and ensure that we are not hindering rural accommodation. This is the best effort in doing that.
In relation to the amendments before me, I am considering an amendment to the timeline, perhaps in the Seanad. I will give further consideration to that. I want to work with people. I appreciate that people are coming from different perspectives. I have more adjudication to do on that. I will listen to the debates on it. That is what I am here to do. I am not accepting the amendments before me but I may come back on some others. That is the best I can do at the moment.
Comment on this
What about the grants?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 6, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
“4. The Minister shall within six months of the passing of this Act lay a report before both Houses of the Oireachtas setting out the operation of the register in urban areas with a population above 20,000 people including details on the number of properties refused access to the Failte Ireland register due to non-compliance with the Planning Policy Statement on Short-Term Letting and the number of properties being registered with full planning compliance.”.
I am not going to labour the point because we have dealt with some of the issues this amendment deals with in the earlier discussion but I want to make two points and then I will invite the Minister to clarify.
The challenge with the figure of 20,000 is the desire that the Minister has stated about those areas under housing stress but by setting it at that threshold, there are areas that have just the same volume of housing stress that are on the other side of it. I am not surprised that in his deliberations with the tourism committee nobody has come up with an alternative because that is not its job. That is a planning matter. Deputy Gogarty is right: we are having lots of debates about the planning policy statement that was made law a week ago without any Oireachtas scrutiny. This is our only opportunity to address it. Most of us would have preferred, particularly those of us on the planning side, if we were not in here across from the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, but in the housing committee with the planning Minister dealing with these issues and tabling amendments on them. There are better ways to do that than to have a completely arbitrary population cap. I have been arguing for some time in the context of the planning regulation of short-term letting, that using a metric not unlike what was originally put in place for rent pressure zones, where we have a certain number of indicators of housing stress and homelessness, would be a much better way because it would have given the Minister an evidential base. A population figure, whatever the number, is completely arbitrary and will leave people on the wrong side of it. This amendment, like the previous one, is to try and properly understand the operation of that.
The Minister was right in his comments at the start of his response to the last amendment, and I am sure it is in his speaking notes for this one. In fact, we should not even be coming here asking him to put this into his legislation. That should not be the case, but we literally have no other opportunity to raise these fundamental issues, which is why we are doing it here. I repeat the point: the Cabinet – the Minister was there - agreed a planning policy statement a week ago without any public ,sectoral or Oireachtas scrutiny. If the Minister is not in a position to do it now, I would invite him to send a note to members of his committee.
The Minister referenced fees for retention. The difficulty is there are very different fees for retention if it is a dwelling unit versus a commercial unit. There are some variances between local authorities but, in my local authority, for example, retention for a dwelling unit is €2.50 per square metre, but it is capped at €195, but there is no cap for a commercial unit, and it is €10.80. That is quite a difference. Again, just given the volume of confusion, any information whereby the Minister can provide clarity would be very useful. Does he know, for example, if the retention application is for a dwelling unit rather than a commercial unit? If he finds out during the course of this debate or in the Seanad debate, it would be very helpful if he could put it on the public record. My colleagues from Independent Ireland are raising these issues and raising them legitimately. If greater clarity could be provided, not just to the public and people applying, but to local authorities on what the retention process will be, that would be very helpful. Again, the form is very short. It is important that every local authority understands there is no requirement for architects, engineers or drawings. What we cannot have is the Department saying that, but then a local authority deciding to operate on a different basis. Some of what the Minister is saying is not in the circular. It is generally referenced on page 21 of the planning policy statement, but we need absolute clarity so there is consistency across the board. Those people who are providing legitimate tourism products in properties that would never and should never be in the long-term residential or rental market should have a clear, simple, low-cost process. At the same time, those operators - the Minister and I are agreed on the intention, if not how he is doing it - who should not be allowed to continue short-term letting are not able to avail of that.
The last thing is kind of interesting, and I was not going to raise it, but the Minister said the advice was he could not have a seven-year grandfather clause in areas below 20,000 and not in areas above. My argument is I would not have had a grandfather clause at all; I would have just had a simplified retention. The Minister has a two-year process in the areas below 20,000, and not above in the regularisation. I have no issue with the regularisation process. My good friend to my left, Deputy Collins, misunderstood me during Second Stage. My view would have been 12 months, for example, but I would have been open to some other period. I do think a regularisation period for the small operators is very sensible. It is interesting that the legal advice did not say we could have a differential regime in the areas below and above for the transitional period, but we could for the grandfather clause. I am interested in hearing if the Minister has an explanation for that.
Comment on this
I just want to follow on from that. I need to get clarity from the Minister on amendment No. 2. I seek clarification on the interpretation of planning permission when it comes to local authorities. The interpretation of planning authorities in Limerick, Cork, Galway or anywhere else is different. At the moment, any regularisation I have seen of planning applications means that people have got to regularise their septic tanks or percolation areas. A walkover survey of the site has to be done. I have yet to see a regularisation of a planning application where you do not need an engineer or drawings. What does a person need? The Minister might as well just sign it here now so it can be regularised if we do not need somebody to come in and regularise the application in the first place, regardless of whether a person is in an urban or rural area. What I want is a breakdown of the form the Minister will be giving to all local authorities, stating that they do not have to do a walkover survey, they do not have to comply with the current regulations for the environment for percolation and storm water and they do not have to comply with the current regulations for sightlines.
The Minister is saying that the person walks in, says this is the building, here is the piece of paper and that they are looking for regularisation of what is there. How is the Government going to identify properties that are not deemed as short-term lets that the Government wants to make long-term? How is it going to do the paperwork and foresee this? Is it going to take everyone at their word? Things change. Every mapping system has changed. There is probably not one person in this Chamber who has not built something on their own properties and have questioned how many years it is there or if they have even got planning permission or need planning permission for it. The only thing that I look at planning permission at the moment is that a person qualifies and that a person is allowed to put 40 sq. m onto the rear of a house without planning permission. A person is allowed to put on 1.5 sq. m to the front, but cannot touch any other elevation of the property. Yet the Minister is able to say to me here that he has the sheet of paper that says a person does not have to get a walkover survey, an engineer's report or an architect's report. What does the Minister want? Why are we here? What exactly will the Government be giving on a format to the planning authorities? When it comes down to all guidelines, including the EPA guidelines, that are giving down to the local authorities which they look at to make an interpretation of planning, a format needs to be given, full and clear.
Comment on this
The issue of presumption of planning is something that is going to invest so much confusion into this. If there was ever a Fianna Fáil term - no disrespect to any Fianna Fáil Members here - but the presumption of planning is something that would have been used over many years. No doubt in relation to the homeless issue if we combine all the cities, we would probably hit about 15,000 out of the 17,000 who are homeless in Ireland. Whether all those properties that we are discussing are going to return to facilitate local authorities or private landlords to put into the rental market is another question.
I am really disappointed in one of the points. To get back to the presumption of planning and to allude to what Deputy O'Donoghue was talking about, these will now be deemed to be almost semi-commercial and commercial properties. Is Part M of the building regulations one of the regulations they will have to accede or adhere to to presume that they will get planning? We had discharge licences issued at various times over the years with differences in them. Is this going to change? Will this affect their ability to presume to have planning under the presumption of planning? How often has the Minister dealt with planners? One of the things that planners will certainly rebel against is a direction to say that a person has a presumption of planning. Regarding any planning in a local authority that I have ever dealt with, the planners are very serious operators who take their jobs very seriously and take adherence to planning law very seriously. The notion that there will be a presumption of planning is something that the Minister should look at again with my constituency colleague, the Minister, Deputy Browne.
There is an old saying that those who like laws and sausages should not see them being made. That is the case when we come to the Minister's refusal to allow the enterprise committee's continuous scrutiny on this. What was the Minister afraid of? We have a very fine committee and committee Chair. We have discussed this seriously over recent times. However, the scrutiny that was required on this legislation has been abandoned such was the Government's rush. Regarding the Government's rush, and my colleague, Deputy Sheehan, alluded to it earlier, the Minister said that he has a very clear pathway, but he does not have a very clear Bill.
I will give the Minister an example of a few of the drafting errors that we discussed. Section 27F(1)(b)(i) refers to refusals under section 27(3)b or section 27(3)(c)(i). They do not exist in the new section 27. Refusals are made under section 27(4) and section 27(5)(a). As drafted, refusing a new registration may not be an appealable decision. Another example is that section 27F(4)(b)(iii) also refers to a non-existent section - section 27(3)(a). On section 47H(9) and (10), Part 53, the cross references are each one subsection out. Notices are set to be served under subsection (5) or subsection (6) and they served under subsections (6) and (7). The appeal period is said to be in subsection (7), but it is in subsection (8). Section 47H(10) says a decision takes affect only if confirmed on appeal under subsection (7) or on summary application under subsection (8). Those are subsections (8) and (9). Read literally, no sanction on a platform could ever take effect.
I have numerous drafting errors here in this Bill. This is what rushing legislation gets the Minister. He is more experienced here than I am. There are 71 amendments, none of which is a ministerial amendment correcting drafting errors. If it goes through, the attached list of errors makes key provisions unintelligible or unworkable. How serious is this in terms of legislation and law? It is one of the more serious Bills to come before this House in recent times with huge implications for many people. There are huge life-changing implications for people who have been involved in self-catering. We remember the ads of self-catering Ireland back in the day. I am old enough to remember great, wonderful, flowery ads that were made by Discover Ireland where self-catering was a wonderful thing to be part of. Yet we are not able to make law that is accurate or draft law that is accurate. I have ten or a dozen drafting errors in this Bill that I would like the Minister to comment on. The notion that we have 71 amendments and none of them is a ministerial amendment to correct drafting errors is extremely serious and speaks to the lack of intent in pushing this Bill through. I ask the Minister to comment on that.
Comment on this
The Minister did not come back to me in relation to my question. I have since followed it up further. There are some pretty profound contradictions between what is set out here in the Bill, the planning statement upon which it is based and the housing plan. I will discuss a contradiction between what the Minister just said and what is set out in the national planning statement. If we look at Delivering Homes, Building Communities, which is the Government's national housing plan, it says very clearly that: "Planning permission for new short-term lets will be generally precluded in cities and large towns..." The definition of a large town under the guidelines for planning authorities on sustainable and compact settlements is towns with a population of 5,000 and greater. The Minister maybe can provide clarity if that is not the case. Otherwise, this Bill and the Government's planning statement are contradicting what the national housing plan says. Has the Government ripped up the national housing plan? Is that no longer functioning? The Minister can maybe explain what is going on in relation to that.
I want to get real clarity about this. Under the Bill and the planning statement that is underpinning it, if a person has a short-term let in a rural area or a town under 20,000 then he or she will have two years to regularise planning or apply for planning permission. The Minister said that in rural areas and towns under 20,000 there is going to be a presumption of positive planning. That means that a person will get planning permission. What the Minister is saying very clearly is that for rural areas and towns under 20,000, including our Gaeltacht areas, there will be no restrictions on short-term lets. Why this is now clear to me is because it says it in the planning statement.
The planning statement is also contradicting itself. As the Minister said earlier, the planning statement states:
The core objective of the [short-term letting] reforms is to assist with bringing a proportion of the existing houses and apartments in the 25 largest cities and towns with a population above the identified threshold of 20,000 persons ... that are currently being used for [short-term letting] purposes, back into long-term rental or the housing sales market ...
The Minister said there is "a presumption for positive planning" for areas with a population of under 25,000. Sinn Féin has nothing to worry about. There are no restrictions coming in for rural or Gaeltacht areas or places with a population of under 25,000. Will the Minister make that very clear? He just said there will be "a presumption for positive planning".
The national planning statement, as set out by the Minister for housing, goes on to refer to "areas outside of the 25 largest settlements, where it is an objective of Government policy to support local economies and the sustainable development of rural and regional areas ". It continues:
In these areas, where suitable in all other respects from a planning perspective, the use of residential properties ... may be considered to be acceptable [that is not a presumption of positive planning]. However, there may be circumstances which may justify a proposal being refused permission by a planning authority on the basis of provisions included within a statutory plan ...
Can the Minister clarify whether areas with a population of under 20,000 will be granted planning permission based, as he said, on "a presumption for positive planning"? Deputy Ó Broin named some of the towns to which I will refer. They include Maynooth, Tullamore, Killarney, Midleton, Mallow, Arklow, Enfield, Kildare, Newcastle, Kilcock, Wicklow, Ashbourne, Leixlip, Clonmel and Malahide. There will be no restrictions in all of those towns, or maybe - if they are areas of housing need - there could be planning restrictions. I would appreciate a reply from the Minister.
Comment on this
I find it regrettable that the Government decided to raise the population cap from 10,000 to 20,000. One of the reasons I thought it would have been better to leave it at 10,000 was due to the long list of relatively well populated towns that my colleague, Deputy Hearne, listed.
I support the amendment because legislation is only as strong as its enforcement. We have seen previous attempts to deal with this issue fail. The Eoghan Murphy rules failed because there was no mechanism by which they could be properly enforced. In urban areas with a population above 20,000 people, it is entirely reasonable that we would be furnished with data. That is why I am so supportive of the amendment. We need to know, for example, how many properties will be refused access to the register because they are not compliant with planning. We will then need to know, subsequent to that, how many were compliant. It is important that we, as a Legislature, are given the tools to be able to properly measure and quantify these things. I somehow doubt that this will be the last Bill the House will ever discuss in terms of regulating short-term lets.
Comment on this
We are an hour and a half into 71 amendments, and we are on amendment No. 2. I welcome that the Minister is present. Sensible people see nothing wrong with a register. People representing organisations see nothing wrong with a register. I sought a three-month period for people to register in an orderly fashion. The Minister said there would be one month. I ask the Minister to consider a compromise, such as two months. That would be welcome and a positive move.
The Minister has trivialised matters. When he speaks about planning, he must remember that when he says people have to go for planning, words such as "amnesty" were incorrectly used during this debate. There is no amnesty. People will have to apply for planning and this will cause a big problem. People will have to put up planning notices. Those who might want to object will have the right to do so. If there is a river at the back of an existing property, that could be deemed to be a potential flood plain which would mean that a presumption of planning would not be granted. Roads engineers will be involved. If a septic tank is involved, a site assessment will be required. The Taoiseach did the same thing, namely, trivialised the planning issue. Planning is a big elephant in the room for existing operators, even people who have been at this for over seven years, because a planning notice is a planning notice. It has to go in a newspaper. People can say that the process will be streamlined or simplified, but it is still open to all of the objections and problems that a planning application can cause.
If people have read the national planning statement, they will see the problem and the difficulties with what is being proposed here. The quicker we can move on to voting and getting into what I would call the meatier amendments, the better. We have dealt with the issue of the timeframe sensibly and the Minister has shown an indication, which I appreciate, that he will deal with that.
I have to correct the record of the Dáil. Last week, we had a debate on whether we are in favour of the Bill being rushed. People had concerns about that. I was one of the ten people who voted against it quite simply because I believe it is being rushed. I was accused of missing a vote here yesterday. I missed nothing here yesterday. I was officially paired with a Minister who needed to not be here and that is where my vote was yesterday. It was facilitating a working Minister. I will make no apology to the House for facilitating a person who needs to be absent.
The quicker we can deal with the amendments, the better. The organisations we are working for will thank us for doing so.
Comment on this
Regardless of what side people are speaking from, there is still a lot of confusion about the presumption of getting planning. The Minister knows as well as I do that the proper place to iron this out was during pre-legislative scrutiny through the committee. The Minister refused that. He is railroading the Bill through the House and is giving out. He has said we will communicate after everything has been signed, sealed and delivered by the Minister, Deputy Browne, or whoever wants to impose these planning guidelines on the people of rural Ireland.
I live in a scenic landscape. The Minister has no idea how difficult it is for people to get planning permission there. Every God-damn thing is put in front of them. I know the paperwork alone has cost some people €15,000 or €20,000 for a simple application for planning, not including any of the work that needs to be carried out afterwards.
I will walk away from here delighted with myself. The Minister said a presumption of planning is very clear. He put that in writing. What does that mean? If a planner comes to a house or home and has to fill out a form on 1 December, and asks whether the owner does or does not have planning and they say they do not, what is the next step? Is the Minister saying they have no more to worry about and it is game over? Is he saying that somebody will knock on the door but will be very nice to them? They might be very nice, but they might cost the person €150,000 before they leave. The Minister can laugh, but they are the facts. If the septic tank is not up to standard, it will not cost €2,000 or €3,000 to rectify that.
Deputy O'Donoghue spoke about a grant system. That is the least the Minister should have done to make sure that people who are providing short-term lets and Airbnb accommodation are not put out of business. The Minister rushed the Bill and would not allow pre-legislative scrutiny. He can say what he wants, but he did not allow it. The Bill should have been before the committee this week or a month ago and we should have been given time to iron out the difficulties.
There was a poor communication campaign. The Minister has now said he will not support any of the amendments. I do not know why we are putting all of our time into this whole process because the Minister is railroading the Bill. The date for registration will be 1 December. Am I correct in saying that, or has the Minister said the date may instead be 1 January or 1 February? Is he sticking to the old rule? We genuinely do not know. We have the right to ask. It is unfortunate that we are not getting to the other amendments, but the Minister will reject them anyway. The point is that people have a right to know what will lie ahead of them in two years' time.
That is basically the bottom line. Is the Minister saying the planners are going to be clearly instructed that they should not take the guidelines that are there at the moment into account or is he saying differently? I would like the Minister to give us absolute clarity here tonight because thousands of people are listening and they are depending on a tourism Minister to deliver for the people that provide great tourism. That is not happening here at the moment. It is only delivering confusion. The Minister is going to hobble away over this, fall at a few fences and jump a few more and get it down to a point that we will have a chat and he will communicate with them afterwards. That is not good enough. The communication should be now before this is signed into law.
Comment on this
This is the problem with not having this discussed at the committee, which allows for populist politics where people put stuff on Report Stage after having a good debate that the Minister is not supporting on Committee Stage. There is still scope on Committee Stage to put stuff through, see that it is not workable from a technical point of view and then it does not come back up on Report Stage. However, we now have a lot of discussions.
We are on amendment No. 2. Again, in principle I support it because there is no harm having reporting within a set time. However, that the first recommended amendment for grouping is amendment No. 6, which is to be taken with amendment No. 48. They relate to totally separate sections of the Bill. Amendments Nos. 1 to 5, inclusive, all propose changes between lines 25 and 26. I ask Members to excuse my ignorance on this, but if it is possible for the proposers to ask for amendments Nos. 3 to 5, inclusive to be grouped this amendment, it would help move on the discussion, given the limited timescale. In any event, I support this amendment on the principle for which it is set down.
Comment on this
If somebody who has been doing short-term letting for many years does eventually apply for planning to retain what they have been doing for more than seven years and they are refused for some reason, is that the end of them or can they continue as they were doing for the seven years and more? If they are refused planning permission, does that mean they will have to cease at that point? I need an answer to that question.
Comment on this
I thank Deputies again for their contributions. I will read the technical response to the amendment first.
While the policy objective of the amendment is understood, the drafting is technically incorrect and could give rise to legal operational uncertainty. The EU short-term rental regulation establishes a harmonised registration system across the Single Market. The regulation provides that registration procedures operate on the basis of declarations made by hosts in Article 4(3)(a). It further requires member states to ensure that registration procedures are available online and allow for automatic and immediate issuance of a registration number.
Ireland's approach reflects these requirements. Under the proposed system, hosts register by providing the information required under the regulation and declaring that they are authorised to provide short-term rental accommodation services. In Ireland, the authorisation is determined by compliance with the planning code. Upon registration, a registration number will be issued immediately by Fáilte Ireland, as required under EU law. Fáilte Ireland will not refuse access to the register, as it may only verify information after the registration number has been issued. This reflects the framework established by the EU regulation, which is designed to ensure that no interruption to the provision of accommodation services within the Single Market while providing robust verification and enforcement mechanisms. During verification, Fáilte Ireland will share the relevant registration data including the host's details, property address and eircode, with the relevant local authority.
The Bill provides for data sharing between Fáilte Ireland and local authorities to facilitate verification and compliance activities. The local authority will confirm whether the property has the necessary planning permission in place. Where it is established that the necessary planning permission is not in place, Fáilte Ireland may suspend the registration number, thereby preventing the operator from lawfully accessing the market. Fáilte Ireland may also issue the relevant order to online short-term rental platforms requiring the removal of listings associated within the property.
A number of issues have been raised. Let me reiterate the provisions in relation to those who are operating in areas under the 20,000-population threshold and are over seven years in operation. Deputy Hearne was quoting two separate mechanisms for the 20,000-population threshold. There are those over seven years, and there are those who are operating for less than seven years who have to apply for planning. They are similar criteria, but not the exact same. If someone operating for over seven years is applying for planning permission, the form is already there. The local authorities have had the fast-track administrative application form since last September to go through that process. As I have said, no detailed maps or plans are required where no significant work is needed for the retention process. It is a strict, straightforward process. Hosts must just apply through the retention process. It is €25 to register with Fáilte Ireland and there are two years to go through that process.
I am a former planning Minister and I was eight years on a local authority in a rural area. I know there are risks with everything in life. However, when the national planning policy statement is issued, if any planning authority's development plans and guidelines does not comply or contradicts it, under the new structure, it must come back and rectify it with local government within two months. It is a very strong tool to issue the presumption to grant planning permission for. The message has gone out very clearly from the Government. We have an express administrative process, and we have a presumption to grant planning permission. I cannot be clearer on that. If there is an extreme issue, an extreme risk or something badly wrong, we all have to be honest that the reality is that planning authorities have to do their work too. We cannot take that away but the hosts do have to go through the process, and they have time on their side. We are not asking anyone to spend €100,000 or anything like it. I know how difficult it is in rural Ireland for accommodation, particularly for the tourism sector, which is very badly needed. I absolutely understand that.
Deputy Ó Broin raised a number of points. In relation to RPZs, the whole country is a rental pressure zone right now, so RPZs are not giving me any mechanism whereby I can protect a small rural operator that is needed versus someone in a larger populated area. Critically, it is not providing me an agile quick mechanism. That is the key issue. When I am coming forward with a metric, though people may argue that it is very arbitrary and there are other towns, like Maynooth that the Deputy referenced that should be in it, I appreciate that, but perfection is the enemy of the good. I cannot micromanage to get the perfect answer everywhere. My number one job is to ensure that I bring in the greatest number of short-term lets into the long-term rental market as quickly as possible, particularly in those 25 towns and cities where housing pressure is most acute. I am not saying there is not housing pressure outside of them, but those are the areas where it is most acute. That is the mechanism I have employed.
From the Attorney General's advice regarding the seven years, this is a long-standing planning position in relation to retention. The reason I can differentiate with two years is because I am changing the law. I am bringing forward a register, and I am changing the law for those two years on the register. I am establishing a new law for that. I can provide the Deputy with a note on that. There are two different things; one is a judicial precedent meaning I cannot differentiate between different people, but when I am creating a law there is a separate mechanism to do that.
Regarding the points raised by Deputy Lawlor, I am fully confident there are no mistakes in the Bill. There are a number of laws that it is intertwining with, particularly with the EU regulation. We have gone through a lot of quality assurance with the Bill.
I can see where the Deputy is coming from and why he might think that is the case. I am happy to get the officials to go through the references he read out and explain exactly what is their intention. We have had long enough to go through this and I am very happy that the Bill is in a good position.
There is another point I want to make.
Comment on this
What is the position regarding the fees? Are they commercial or residential?
Comment on this
Is it a commercial retention fee that will be charged?
Comment on this
Yes, it is a commercial fee. I am trying to regain my train of thought. There was another issue I wanted to address.
Comment on this
I can look at an amendment on registrations. I am open to working with colleagues in relation to the timeframe. I will come back to that. I want to ensure the intention of the Bill is carried through.
The point I was going to make was that I want to put on record that I really value the work of the enterprise committee. I know more than most what it does. I engage with the members regularly to go through issues of the day and I appear before the committee when the members ask me to do so. I have a very good relationship with the Cathaoirleach and all the members. This Bill has been there for a significant period. I do not mean to be disingenuous in any way about this. I absolutely acknowledge that pre-legislative scrutiny began in October 2025. The Government originally came forward with a population threshold of 10,000 before increasing it to 20,000. I am limited in terms of the control I can give to the enterprise committee. I am waiting for another Department to come forward with the national planning policy. It is the right and prerogative of the enterprise committee to say it will not go forward with a pre-legislative scrutiny report until it gets sight of that document.
I have other pressures to work through. It is very clear in the handbook that, in essence, we do not want to delay legislation. That is a key point. This Bill has been around for a long time. There are housing units that I want to get back into the long-term rental market as quickly as possible in the 25 towns that are under significant pressure. I also want to ensure we achieve a balance in protecting rural areas. That is what I have endeavoured to do in this work. I absolutely appreciate and fully respect the perspectives people have brought forward.
Comment on this
I would like clarity on a particular point. The Minister's comment on presumption of positive planning was specifically in relation to properties operating for seven years or more in towns with a population under 20,000. If a property owner has been operating for less than seven years or is newly applying for planning permissions, restrictions will apply in areas of housing need. Why then does the Minister continue to say that his aim is to get housing back in the 25 towns? Why is it not also his aim to get housing back in towns with a population smaller than 20,000? Will he clarify that there will be limitations and that in terms of planning, there will not be a presumption in favour in towns under 20,000?
Comment on this
It is clearly outlined on page 19 of the planning policy statement the position regarding operators not in compliance with the law and operating for less than seven years. The parameters within which they can be considered for the granting of planning permission are set out. There are a number of conditions attached. The housing need and demand assessment is one of the key factors, depending on housing pressures in those areas. The local authorities will have to make an adjudication on that. The information is on page 19 of the planning statement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 6, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"4. The Minister shall within six months of the passing of this Act lay a report before both Houses of the Oireachtas setting out the enforcement activity of Fáilte Ireland and planning authorities with respect to non-compliance with the registration and planning requirements of the legislation and accompanying planning policy statement, including an assessment of the staffing requirements involved in the compliance related to the Short-Term Letting Regulations.".
Much of how this regime works and whether it is successful or not will depend on the operation of the enforcement, some of the detail of which the Minister just gave us, and the resourcing for both Fáilte Ireland and the local authorities. From my conversations with people concerned about the lack of long-term homes in their communities, both urban and rural, and the small, family-based tourism operators who hope to be able to continue to operate their products, this is one of the areas they least understand. I invite the Minister, in his response to my questions and comments, to clarify in more detail how the enforcement will work and how it will be resourced. The logic of this amendment is to allow us to track that.
The Minister clarified one of the queries I had when he said that everybody who applies from 1 December will get their registration number and that the process of verification and adjudication will take place after that. I will concentrate for a moment on the areas above a population threshold of 20,000 because they involve the people for whom there is meant to be a tougher regime unless they are availing of the seven-year grandfather clause. On the one hand, they cannot be on the register without demonstrating planning compliance but the Minister is telling us that, initially, they will get a registration number. I assume that they will be on the register during that period. There will then be a process of trying to verify with the local authority whether they are planning compliant. We know the overwhelming majority currently are not compliant.
What kinds of conversations have the Minister's officials had with Fáilte Ireland on the resourcing that will be required specifically for that cohort? This will be quite an onerous task in that initial period. If we imagine a scenario where all those people apply to get on the register - judging by what happened with Eoghan Murphy's regulations in 2019, that is not guaranteed, but there are many thousands of such properties - how long is that likely to take and has there been an assessment of the resourcing requirements? It will put a lot of stress on the local authorities in those areas to be asked to address that matter. These are the same local authorities whose representatives told us some years ago, when the Minister was a Minister of State at the Department of housing with responsibility for planning, that they were already chronically under-resourced in terms of their planning capacity. They now have to deal with new areas of enforcement, including free-standing residential extensions and other exempted developments. I am keen to know how that will operate.
I am also keen to understand because, again, it is relevant to the amendment in terms of resourcing, in the case of a short-term letting operator in a population area above 20,000 who is then found not to be planning compliant - whether a week, a month, six months or a year later; we are not sure how long it will be - how will the enforcement from Fáilte Ireland operate at that point in terms of its resourcing and timelines? A lot of our conversation is focused on the people who own the properties but it is really important for us to mention that in the middle of all of this, there is a very large and very profitable international corporation that, for a decade, which is as long as I have been in this House, has been facilitating and profiting from the widespread breach of our planning system. I refer, of course, to Airbnb. It is not the only agency that is knowingly facilitating and profiting from the breaking of the State's planning laws but it certainly is the most successful and aggressive in terms of its lobbying operations. How will the enforcement of requests to remove advertisements for short-term letting operate in real time? I have read the legislation but I do not know it as well as do the members of the enterprise committee.
As the Minister knows from his time both as a councillor and in the Department of housing, enforcement is often where these rules fall down because it is slow and cumbersome and it allows people to avoid and evade, in many cases for long periods. Has there been any assessment within the Department as to how long enforcement will take in the case of operators in areas with a population above 20,000? What will happen when somebody applies to go on the register who is not planning compliant but has submitted a retention application to the local authority and the latter is taking longer than the statutory time period to process that application? The Minister may not be able to answer my last question. Has there been any conversation between his Department, Fáilte Ireland, the Minister for housing, Deputy Browne, and his Department and the County and City Management Association, CCMA, as to what the resourcing requirements will be for the local authorities to process all these planning and retention applications?
That is a very legitimate question to have answered here, as is the question on making decisions on those. Likewise, will the Minister provide clarity as to the role of An Coimisiún Pleanála in all of that and whether there have been conversations with the commission about resourcing as well? Even if there are very well-crafted rules and regulations, and with respect to the planning policy statement I do not believe they are, in the absence of the staffing and resourcing of the enforcement regime those regulations are not worth the paper they are written on. I look forward to the Minister's responses and I may come back with supplementary questions depending on those.
Comment on this
Obviously, enforcement and the amendment we are talking to right now are hugely important. What does the Minister mean by enforcement? He is saying that Fáilte Ireland can block registration - I think he said that earlier. No? Did I pick that up wrong? I am sorry if I did. What happens if someone is not applying by the rules or the guidelines and does not have the planning? The Minister might answer that question.
The other thing the Minister is saying relates to planning. I have no issue with registration nor has anybody that I have met, such as groups above here in the Gallery. They have no issue with registration. That is kind of out of the way. Maybe the speed at which people are trying to do it could be an issue. The Minister is saying 1 December. I think he might have to look at that.
The Minister is saying no significant works on a property will have to be done unless it needs to be done. That is a conflicting kind of way of saying things. I will just pick one area. The planner will say if the person is not compliant. Only the planner who calls to the house can say what compliance is. A property can be running perfectly for the last 20 years doing Airbnb, which quite a lot of them are. It may be a little side apartment, some pods, some sheds, some this or some that, or whatever, it does not matter. Is the Minister saying that a planner will come out and say a septic tank is not up to standard but will not say anything to the person, that they are okay, because the planner likes the person? That is the area a lot of people are finding a problem with. They do not understand this. The pre-legislative scrutiny in committee would have been helpful because we would have tried to tease it out. We are even teasing things out here tonight, inch by inch, and it is fine. This is the only area we can do it. But what does the Minister mean by compliance. Are they just going to come out and shake your hand and say it is fine, not to worry at all? Or, are they going to come out and say that they need to look at the septic tank? Maybe the planner will say he or she needs to look at whether there is disability access. The planner may say there is a regulation and as a senior planner they will not walk away until something is done as they have to cover their own back. Is the Minister saying no, the planner will be quite happy, and will stand at the door and say okay, that the person is doing business in the right way? That is the clarity needed here. That is the issue.
We spoke to our European colleague Ciaran Mullooly MEP about this. He is very clear that many other countries in Europe that have huge tourism figures are not bringing this type of draconian law before their people. They are very careful not to damage a certain sector of tourism. As is so often said here, we seem to be using a hammer to crack a nut, which is a successful and very tasty nut too. Unfortunately, everyone knows the biggest problem here with regard to a planner coming to your door, and I can see it a mile away, is that people are going to report others. This happens quite a lot in relation to planning decisions because somebody down the road reported it. Sometimes it is people in another county reporting them. That is the concern. If the planner stands at the doorstep will he or she say to the person they have been operating perfectly for the last 20 years and the planner will not open their mouth about the septic tank that was meant to be for the family, and yes there are extra people or that disability access is not going to worry the planner, etc? I would like that clarity.
Comment on this
In 2025 Kerry County Council dealt with 1,430 planning applications. There are approximately 4,000 short-term lets, STLs, in county Kerry. A large percentage of those will be seeking planning because they will not have planning already. We may have some of them in holiday villages which would already have planning so they will not have to go for planning but it is fair to say that many of those 4,000 will need planning. There were 1,430 applications in 2025. How does the Minister expect our very hard-working local authorities to deal with the influx of planning applications that will come in over the two-year period? Even if we divided it and said that in a very orderly fashion half will apply in the first year and half will apply in the second year, we know it will not work that way. How are the planners supposed to deal with the applications?
Over the last number of minutes the Minister has trivialised the planning because he is missing the elephant in the room. The Minister will know better than any one of us inside here that a planning application involves a planning notice, a planning report, a site assessment report and a road report. All can be very onerous despite the fact that the diktat from Government is to assume a grant of planning permission. The Minister knows it will not be a rubber-stamping exercise.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. It is fundamental to the whole debate about this Bill. I cannot have confidence that the Bill is serious because the Minister has not set out clearly where the additional resources are to be given to planning. I do not agree with the some of the Deputies on a lot of things but actually they are right to say that this is a massive piece of work that is coming to our local authorities in terms of planning if this is going to be done seriously - but if it is not and it is just another nod and a wink and whatever, well clearly it will not be. If these rules, as set out, are to be applied it will require significant planning. I do not know who it was, but someone asked what if there is an extreme risk and planning consent is given. What happens if the building is not up to standard and is granted planning? Is the planner then responsible if something happens in short-term let accommodation? Planners have to ensure that if they are granting planning permission they actually know there is not a serious risk there, unless we are moving to self-certification planning, which again requires significant time.
There is a real lack of seriousness around what actually is going to be required if this is going to be enforced. It leads me to a fundamental belief that this is not a serious Bill about clamping down on short-term lets. The Minister still has not said that his aim is to also clamp down on short-term lets in areas under 20,000. The Minister has just referred back to the planning statement but there is no clarity on it. I would like a clear statement on that.
Comment on this
I will first read the official response, which is the technical one, to amendment No. 3. The proposed amendment is not considered necessary. Fáilte Ireland and the planning authorities are already subject to established governance, reporting and accountability arrangements, including oversight by the Oireachtas and relevant Ministers. The amendment would introduce a specific statutory reporting requirement in relation to enforcement activity and staffing matters, which are operational issues for the bodies concerned and are subject to ongoing review. Resource allocation and staffing requirements are best considered through existing management, budgeting and oversight processes rather than through a legislative reporting obligation.
Furthermore, the legislation already provides a robust framework for compliance enforcement. The proposed reporting requirement would not add materially to the existing transparency and accountability arrangements. Appropriate oversight of the regime can be achieved through establish governance reporting mechanisms without the need for an additional statutory obligation.
A good few issues were raised on this point. First, let us go back again in relation to the operator who is seven years in operation and is seeking to regularise their planning permission in an area with a population under 20,000. This is a change of use application. When they got planning originally one would imagine there should be some criteria they would have already adhered to. This is why we have been able to bring forward a simplified administrative process from last September, where no maps are needed and where no plans are needed. Why? Because they would have already brought it forward on the original planning application. This is a simplified process for those who are in operation, with the explicit intent of Government policy, to ensure that the tourism sector can continue to operate in rural areas.
The presumption to grant planning contained in the national planning statement is very clear. It is also very clear that the register in Fáilte Ireland will give two years to allow them to do just that. It is very clear that it is a change of use application. As a rural councillor, I saw many planning applications. If I am going to build a new property, and I am looking at sight lines, percolation and so on, it is very different from having an existing property that has planning for a different purpose and applying for a change of use under a simplified mechanism by Government that is already out since last September. Local authorities are already working through this.
On additional resources, over the last three years, the local authorities have had a recruitment plan to bring additional planning staff into the system. They are already working through this simplified process. It will be more efficient because it is a straightforward process. It is not that officials have to delve through plans, maps and so on. It is a simplified process for those over the seven years and under the 20,000 that people are concerned about. As Deputy Hearne has said, I have alluded to the planning statement in connection with those who are looking for planning, where there is a pathway for under 20,000. However, when someone is looking for planning there is a different threshold. They have to prove that it meets the criteria laid out within the planning statement. I am not an expert in planning so I do not want to give an assurance as to what exactly people have to do, but the pathway is there. If the Deputy asks me if I want to stop people from getting planning permission for an Airbnb in an area with a population of under 20,000, the answer is that I do not want to stop people from getting planning as long as they meet the criteria of their local authority and as set down by the national planning statement. There will be considerations that they can address in their adjudication on that. I absolutely want to see units coming back in those 25 towns and villages with populations over 20,000. Notwithstanding that, as contained in the statement, there will be housing pressures in areas under that threshold on which a local authority can adjudicate. They are contained in the national planning statement.
On Fáilte Ireland, 12 additional staff have been brought in to deal with the operation of the register. A huge amount of this is through data-sharing. The work is essentially automated, to examine the register and find out who is on it and not complying. Everyone can register. Fáilte Ireland will not be stopping people from registering. It will go into an enforcement regime in respect of people who have registered and are not planning-compliant. To address Deputy Michael Collins's point, if someone does not have planning and they are going on to register with Fáilte Ireland, there is a box they should tick saying they are in the process and are going to regularise their planning situation. They should tick the box on registration and then their obligation is to regularise their planning situation. For those who do not, the penalties are significant. In respect of the platforms, first of all, I refer to the Digital Services Act. We have a rate to follow on that of 2% of global turnover, which is significant. We are also working through the whole process under Article 5, where Fáilte Ireland will work with those. If it is deemed someone is not compliant with the planning code, we are very strict and clear that they will be fished out in the over-20,000 category. The penalties are significant but it is necessary to check, through the process, whether there has been a genuine mistake or issue, or whether it is essentially not in compliance with the law. We have our fines and policy attached on Article 6. I am very clear on the spirit of the legislation and what it is trying to do. We have the resources to do that. Fáilte Ireland's chief executive has assured me that they have no impediment to running this efficiently. There is a great deal of uncertainty and unpredictability, naturally, in terms of how many housing units can come back. We want to bring back as many as we can. My firm conviction is that when a huge number of people in society need long-term accommodation in areas where housing pressure is acute, we must ensure that we bring it back.
On the EU point, 22 countries already have the regime. Some have it far stricter than we have here. Every country has to manage its response and adjudicate on what is best for it. I hope I have outlined my thought process in coming to the policy position that has been considered by Government, which I think is reasonable. I fully accept that there are Deputies who do not think it goes far enough. That is a fair point. I can absolutely see the merits of that. I can also see the merits in Deputies saying it goes too far. I will go back to my core point. People can say this is a planning issue. This is the Bill we are taking it on. I have not seen an amendment that shapes and protects what some Members are suggesting here. I see a lot of reports and extensions but I do not see a robust mechanism whereby rural operators in areas of no pressure are protected and can continue to bring in a second income, put their kids through college and derive an income, while commercial operators with which people have an issue or those in areas of acute housing need are brought back into the marketplace. I have not seen such an amendment. Maybe there is something wrong with me, but in all 71 of the amendments before me, I have not seen it.
Comment on this
In the same way as I said at the start, I am really inviting the Minister to provide clarity here. Unfortunately, on some of these key issues he has actually made things a little bit more confusing. Let us just go through them one by one. The reason we have these amendments providing for reports is that we are not allowed to table amendments that would put a charge on the State, for example through a requirement to have a workforce plan or to increase resources. We are not permitted to do that. Also, there is not transparency on the interrelationship between Government sanctioning additional posts in State agencies and what those State agencies need. For example, directors of services in local authorities will come into the housing committee regularly. When we ask if they have enough resources they say, "Of course, we have all the resources and the Minister tells us just to knock on the door if we do not." However, when we meet those very same directors of services privately, they will tell us of the enormous difficulty they have getting Government to agree to that sanction.
Let us just use the case in point. When the previous housing Minister, Deputy Darragh O'Brien, was bringing forward the most controversial and detailed reform of our planning system in the modern history of the State, the County and City Management Association produced a report to say that before that legislation was even enacted, they were 550-odd planning staff short. This speaks directly to the question Deputy Michael Healy-Rae has raised. They have been given sanction for 200 of those staff and they have not yet recruited them all. That is before the Planning and Development Act has been commenced - only half of it has been commenced over the last two years – and before the new exempted development regulations have been introduced, or the new planning policy statements on rural and Gaeltacht housing. Right now, our planning authorities do not have sufficient staff to do the work that is front of them. At least the Minister is telling us that there have been no conversations of which he is aware about what additional staffing requirements they will need to address this.
Here is where that gets tricky. If somebody’s structure, whether they are in an area above or below 20,000, already has planning permission, the Minister is correct that it should be a more straightforward retention application, in theory. What if the planning permission that was granted for that building was not for any human habitation at all but for an outhouse, a farm building or a structure for some other use? All of a sudden the change of use planning application is now going in on the basis that X number of people are expected to be in that dwelling at any given time. That raises all sorts of planning questions. I absolutely acknowledge that the circular indicates there is a short process. There is no doubt about that. What it is not clear about, and what it is not providing the planning authorities or the applicants guidance on, is those complicated issues where it is not a straightforward or simple case. That is going to cause quite a level of difficulty. I do not want to be putting words into the Minister’s mouth so he should correct me if I am wrong, but what he is saying is there has been no additional sanction of staff for Fáilte Ireland, above and beyond what it has already, to address the early-stage roll-out enforcement. If that is not the case the Minister should correct me because we do need clarity. It seems to be the case that there is going to be a process whereby thousands of short-term letting property owners across the State have to register by December, and then there is a verification and approval or removal process that takes place.
If a significant number of those people are also then going to be applying in parallel for planning permission, in cases where they are refused, they will, one assumes, be appealing them to An Coimisiún Pleanála. That is a very heavy administrative workload. Even under the simplified process the Minister has outlined, that is a very onerous process.
My fear is that in the absence of a workforce plan accompanying the two elements of this register - the planning and Fáilte Ireland - there will be a real struggle. My biggest concern is on the planning side because that is where my area of responsibility is. My colleague, Deputy Conway-Walsh, obviously deals with enterprise and tourism. I am not hearing anything from the Minister on that. For example, in areas with a population above 20,000, significant numbers of operators on the register without planning permission will continue to break the law in respect of properties that the Minister says he wants brought back into residential occupation for a period of months, if not even longer, because there is a 14-week statutory process for the local authority. There might be a further information request, it could be refused or it could be appealed to the board. The Minister and I both know that when those smaller applications go to the board, it can take six, 12 and sometimes 18 months to deal with them, notwithstanding the good work of the commission in clearing the backlog. Throughout that time, and the Minister can correct me again if I am wrong, they will be able to trade because they will have a registration number and the process of addressing the planning issue will be in train. Can the Minister at least give us some clarity on how all of that is going to work?
For example, given that all of the operators in the 25 larger areas with a population above 20,000 have known since 2019, when Eoghan Murphy introduced the rules, that they are required to be planning compliant - it is a much different issue in the rural areas that were brought under the RPZs last year - they should have been going about getting their planning regularisation many years ago. Why was it not a requirement that, in fact, at the point of registration, they had to demonstrate planning compliance? I can absolutely accept the need for a lead-in period for regularisation, particularly in smaller, traditionally non-RPZ areas. It seems to me that this is a big loophole right in the middle, which means the claim the Minister is making, that he wants those long-term homes brought back into long-term residential occupation, will fall foul of a poorly designed enforcement regime and we will be coming back to him in a short period of time to say it is chronically under-resourced and not able to do what he said earlier it would be doing from December onwards.