We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026: Committee and Remaining Stages

Summary

Sinn Féin proposed a report within six months on how many short-term lets use the seven-year planning provision, to assess its effects on housing and distinguish family tourism businesses from commercial operators. Several Deputies backed monitoring but warned that the provision could let established commercial operators continue using homes for short-term lets; others stressed the importance of protecting rural tourism and called for greater certainty for hosts. Minister Peter Burke said the Bill creates no grandfather clause: eligible operators can use a streamlined process to regularise their planning status, and EU registration rules do not allow operating history to determine registration. He said the amendment was technically flawed and could not accept it.

Contributions 103–225 of 225. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026
Current

No. 101 of 2026 ›

The Minister said that Europe had accepted this and that 22 countries in Europe had accepted this regime, with some having a stricter one. Why did he not look at those countries that do not have as strict an approach? He seems to want to look at the stricter aspects of this. Our information from Europe is that it was leaving each state to make up its own mind on it and that Ireland has decided to dictate and be the hardest on ordinary people in rural communities who are providing a fantastic Airbnb service.

The Minister also confirmed that it is a change of use to commercial planning. What are the implications of this for property owners? Do they realise the costs involved in running a commercial property, with rates, insurance, etc.? What about a granny flat in someone's garden, for which the same meter point reference number, MPRN, is used for electricity? How will that work? Is there a simplified process? The Minister might be able to clarify all of this because we cannot find out these things in committee. Is there a simplified process to declassify a property as commercial and return it to residential if people want to sell it, pass it on or return it to family use? If so, is there a cost to that? What happens to a pre-1963 building for which there is no original planning? That is a very serious issue because a lot of people are operating Airbnbs in beautiful old houses and they are successful. What happens the bookings that have already been taken for next year? Can they go ahead? They were taken before the registration came in and people have planned holidays already. Do they have to cancel them? These are very serious questions.

I still have not got clarity from the Minister on the presumption of planning. He said maps will not be needed and people should not worry about plans. What if the planner is at someone's door asking questions? The Minister said regulation will be enforced. Is he saying people will not be asked what their septic tank is like? Is he saying the planners will not call out to the houses at all? If they will not, that is the best news. Deputy Hearne will not like it but I certainly will because it means we have no more to worry about. I have a serious concern because I know the way the planners operate. They have a book and if things are not by the book, people are doomed. I need to know, in this situation, whether planners are going to call to people's house and are they going to go by regulation or non-regulation? That is the simple question I am asking. I would appreciate if the Minister could also answer the other questions I asked him.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies again for their questions in connection with the Bill. First, just to clarify, Fáilte Ireland asked for additional resources and they were sanctioned. I remember-----

Comment on this

Can the Minister give us the figures?

Comment on this

It requested 12 additional people. I remember-----

Comment on this

I apologise for cutting across the Minister. For clarity, will they be in post and in situ from 1 September-----

Comment on this

-----or are they currently under recruitment?

Comment on this

As far as I understand it, Fáilte Ireland has them already, so they are in situ.

Comment on this

It has them already

Comment on this

I remember meeting the then chief executive of Fáilte Ireland within the first few days of getting this post. One of the things that surprised me at that stage, because I was taking over as the new Minister with responsibility for tourism, is that the chief executive of Fáilte Ireland said Fáilte Ireland was ready to go and do this. Obviously, we had discussions with the new chief executive and we are 100% confident that Fáilte Ireland is ready for this, can manage it - the organisation has a lot of automation - and will be able, without doubt, to robustly hold to account those on the register. Critically, when I point out that those who seek to get planning and regularise their position in the areas with a population of under 20,000 will have two years if they tick the box, while those in areas with a population of over 20,000 will not. They will not have the luxury of going to An Coimisiún Pleanála for six or eight months. That is not possible. They have one month, essentially. At the end of December, they will have to have planning permission. It is a very stringent process in that regard. That is key to trying to deliver units. That is where we have to have teeth to get the properties back into the system. If there is any misleading or things are done deliberately, there are summary offences and fines within the legislation. Some Deputies are asking me to extend that period. I am mindful, as are the Deputies present, of how long the statutory process is and that if some people commence this process now, they may not get through the system by the end of December. However, we also have to be aware that those are people in high pressurised areas who are not planning compliant. That is why there is some debate over the amendment seeking additional time. There is a cliff edge there and that is very clear.

Deputy Collins raised a number of issues. Bookings can go ahead. There is no issue with that. Those are booked now.

In relation to the planning application, the planning statement is very clear. The simplified process that local authorities already have and are utilising is there for all to see. They are going through this right now. They are going through that retention mechanism right now. People can avail of this and use it. Critically, we are giving people two years to go and do that. I cannot make it any clearer for people or spell it out any clearer when the Government is saying that there is a presumption to grant planning permission for people who are carrying this on as a livelihood in areas where tourism needs them. We know that tourism provides one in ten jobs in local rural economies. I know areas in Leitrim and parts of Mayo and Longford where there is no hotel accommodation. It is very difficult to deliver hotel accommodation. That is why I am also bringing forward an accommodation strategy. It is to try to answer some of those difficult questions about how we can get a commercial operator to deliver a hotel, working with the State, in areas that are crying out for that accommodation. We are not in the space I want to be in in that regard and we need short-term lets to fill that void.

Obviously, local authorities have decisions to make. I cannot prescribe everything and nor can the Minister for planning but I think we have a fair balance in that regard. We have a strong pathway and a simplified process. The forms are already out, there is a €25 fee and people have two years to bring their property into regularisation. That cannot be any more clear. Equally, I have to be tough on those in areas of population over 20,000 because the Bill will be meaningless if we are not robust on the other side of the coin. That is why we have to ensure that where there are housing pressures, we are bringing units back into the system.

Comment on this

I asked about the pre-1963 units. Has the Minister any clarity on that?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy, if you wish to stand and speak-----

Comment on this

I asked a question about pre-1963 properties. There are lots of people in Airbnb with pre-1963 houses. There was no planning regulation at that time. Is the Minister saying now that they will or will not have to have permission? It is one or the other. The other question I asked was about the change of use to commercial. What are the implications of this for the property owner? Do they realise the costs involved in running a commercial property, including rates, insurance and so on? What about a granny flat in the garden on the same MPRN or electricity meter? How does that work? Is there a simplified process there? All of these things should have been ironed out in pre-legislative scrutiny at the Oireachtas committee but unfortunately we did not get that chance, so now we have to do a little bit of internal digging in here. Is there a simplified process to declassify a property as commercial and go back to residential if owners want to sell it, pass it on or use it for their own family? Is there a cost to this? The Minister, in fairness, gave clarity in relation to the bookings and I appreciate that.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy rent out a bed and breakfast or part of his house without having insurance? We all have to be realistic here.

Comment on this

I was talking about rates.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Let the Minister answer. The Deputy can come back in again.

Comment on this

They do not have to pay rates.

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned insurance. Obviously, rates will depend on the registration but there are exemptions from rates for some operators. It will depend on the exemption that they have, be it that they are a registered bed and breakfast or are registered with Fáilte Ireland. I will clarify that for the Deputy. I will get an exact clarification on that. My job here is not to absolve everyone of all of the expenses in life. If people have a good business model and are letting out Airbnbs in a rural area, I am sure they have insurance. I have no doubt they have insurance. I also have no doubt that they have to pay for light and heat. These are basic things that people are doing already. My job is to ensure that we can keep capacity going in areas that need it and bring units back in areas that do not.

Comment on this

What about the pre-1963 properties?

Comment on this

I will keep asking. I am sorry.

Comment on this

That is okay. On the pre-1963 issue, that is a fair question. My understanding is that it is a change of use and if it is a change of use, people have to go through the planning process. That is it.

Comment on this

The Minister's clarification on the areas above the population threshold of 20,000 is very helpful. Essentially, they have a month. If they do not have planning permission, even with the benefit of the grandfather clause, they are not getting through planning within that month. That is self-evident. We know that from the statutory timelines and appeal decisions from An Coimisiún Pleanála. A very significant number of operators in those 25 large urban areas may not apply to go on the register because they know they will not be able to meet that one-month deadline. Some may decide to apply for planning permission and then try to get on the register at a later stage, even though I know that is not the intention. Will the Minister to talk us through, in practical terms, what the enforcement regime is going to be? These are people who will not necessarily be visible to Fáilte Ireland in that they will not have registered and demonstrated planning compliance within that month. Will there be a requirement on Fáilte Ireland, for example, to track the continued illegal operation of those short-term lets through online platforms or estate agents and to proactively go for enforcement for non-registration and non-planning compliance at that early stage?

I ask this in the context of the experience of former Minister Eoghan Murphy's regulations. We worked very closely on a cross-party basis, across both Government and Opposition in the Oireachtas housing committee at the time, in 2018 and 2019, on a report that informed those regulations. One of the big problems was that even though those regulations were, broadly speaking, in line with our committee's recommendations, we warned the Minister at the time that planning enforcement would not work and that people would simply wait and see. That is exactly what happened. Only a tiny number, as Deputy Hearne mentioned, applied for planning permission and change of use. The overwhelming majority just continued to operate outside the law and once they saw that planning enforcement was not effective, they were able to do so. Have there been specific discussions between the Minister, his officials and Fáilte Ireland about the eventuality of large numbers of operators not applying to go on the register and, whether they apply for planning subsequently or not, trying to operate outside of the regime in those early stages? That first six to 12 months is going to be absolutely key.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware, in relation to the window of opportunity to apply which runs from 1 December to 31 December, that it has been traditional over the years for county council offices to close down around 21 December or not later than 22 December. They do not open again until the day before New Year's Day. A kind of shadow attempt would be there. Not everyone goes back. It is their entitlement to take their annual leave in that space of time. People do not come back until 2 or 3 January, as we know, because 1 January is a bank holiday. It is the start of the new year. Could the Minister give an extension for the month of January, let us say? What is the panic? Get it right and give people a chance. He should at least give people a chance to apply. Why can the Minister not look at that in a favourable light and give people a chance? People are outraged over this, that they are being rushed like this, more or less at gunpoint. They will be late if they do not apply in December. Does the Minister understand the long-standing tradition of the local authorities to let people go off from 21 December until 1 or 2 January?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

That was a slightly extreme reference there, Deputy-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

It was a slightly extreme reference, that anyone would be forced "at gunpoint" by a Minister.

Comment on this

Well, it is more or less that.

Comment on this

It was a metaphor, a Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I get it. To be fair, I get it.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Is the Minister coming back in?

Comment on this

I just wanted to drive home the seriousness-----

Comment on this

Although I am not sure about Kerry people-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Please.

Comment on this

I do not have any gun here, in case you think I have.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thanks for letting us know. Minister, will you come back in?

Comment on this

At the same time, people are very worried and concerned about this rush.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Of course. The Minister is coming back in, Deputy.

Comment on this

A number of points were made by Deputy Healy-Rae. I want to understand his thought process in relation to the extension of the register. In theory, the majority of the people that he represents, who are living in areas with less than 20,000, will have two years to regularise their planning. I am confused because a lot of Deputies in those cohorts want to extend the date for the register. By extending the register, we are also allowing additional time for those who I really want to target - those in the areas of population over 20,000. That is a big call. What I am saying in relation to a number of amendments that were brought forward is that I would like to know a bit more about what the thought process is. What is the concern? Why do people want to extend it for people with short-term lets in areas of under 20,000 when they are being given two years to regularise? They can register on 1 December, tick a box and they have two years to regularise their planning position. What difference does it make if that is 1 December or 1 January? I do not understand that, which is the key point. Critically, for the robustness and the teeth of the process for those in areas over 20,000, which Deputy Ó Broin referenced, I need to have a strong cliff edge. I need to have the teeth to go after them and get those units back into long-term accommodation.

One issue that does concern me slightly is the length of the statutory process but the point that I come back to is that they are not planning compliant. Sympathy only goes so far. I am talking here about people in areas of over 20,000. It is about trying to get a balance. A lot of those people have already applied for permission. They are going through the process as we speak. To be fair, if operators think they have a pathway to compliance, they should be pursuing that.

You should not be waiting for a register to open on 1 December to try to be compliant. Fáilte Ireland will be robustly going after the register, working with online platforms and ensuring that people are not on platforms unless they are planning compliant. If people in areas of over 20,000 are not planning compliant, they will be suspended. Critically, there will be summary offences for breaches of the law. We are clear on that. I have been clear with Fáilte Ireland that we are going after that hard. This has to be robust. We have to bring back accommodation in those areas of over 20,000. There will be resources to do that, and we have a strong system. Despite Members talking about rushed legislation, we have had quite a lot of time. The system has been preparing for this for a while.

Comment on this

A lot of people have worked all the year with long hours. There is no such thing as 40 hours, or anything like that for those people. A lot of people go away totally and close down for the month of December. Maybe as we are speaking now, they have gone. I do not ever finish up, and a lot of people do not. We keep going. There are other people who have health complications and take this time to go to the North of Ireland to get their hips, knees and different things done. That is why December is not as clear a month as January, when more or less everyone is back. There is another thing. When we are talking about sending Fáilte Ireland after people to close them down, that is a new departure. Fáilte Ireland was put in place to support tourism, help people get business and sell our product abroad. Now we will have them closing people down.

Comment on this

I fully agree with Deputy Danny Healy-Rae about Fáilte Ireland. It is incredible to think an organisation that is supposed to promote tourism will be the organisation that could end the tourism sector. Those are facts. The Minister said pre-1963 houses will have to get planning. That will cost hundreds of thousands, so they are gone. The Minister is saying the system has been in place for so long. The problem is there has been nothing but confusion about this Bill and there is no point saying any different. People around the country are sending me messages left, right and centre. They do not know what is going to happen. The Minister gave some clarity, which I accept, about people who have taken bookings. That is a serious question that came up because I had a number of public meetings about it. That was the will of the people. They came up here in high numbers to protest and to let the Government know that their businesses meant something to them. They are watching this debate tonight.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Yes, but will you speak to the amendment?

Comment on this

It is to the amendment we are talking. They are genuinely watching tonight to see if they can get some kind of clarity. I keep asking the question and the Minister does not answer me. Is a planner going to come to a person's door?

Comment on this

Nobody is going to come to their door, so they are safe out. Is that right?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Minister can respond.

Comment on this

This is what it comes down to-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Is that a question?

Comment on this

Yes. There is no point telling me here that there will be no maps and no need for plans and that there is a simplified process. That is all rosy in the garden, but the bottom line is whether there is a planner if you are not compliant. You have to mark the boxing saying you do not have planning. Is a planner going to stand at your doorstep at some stage in the next two years to tell you how to become compliant? I cannot get that straight answer. Tonight the Minister says absolutely not. Sure, Lord God, we will all go back and celebrate. It is a great victory for the ordinary people.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I do not know how you can say that "absolutely not" is not a straight answer but we will give the Minister a chance to answer the question again.

Comment on this

Sorry, the Ceann Comhairle was not here, but I have asked six or seven times for that answer, and the Minister tells me that it is a simplified process, that you need no maps or plans. He is not telling me, however, whether a planning official is going to stand at your doorstep in relation to this. Are they going to get call-outs? Is the Minister saying not to worry and that that is absolutely not going to happen?

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Are you putting that question to the Minister?

Comment on this

I have put it about ten times.

Comment on this

What about the objectors?

Comment on this

Sure, the objectors will be firing in letters left, right and centre from the minute this gets going.

Comment on this

I again thank Members for the contributions. First, for extreme clarity, is there any town or area in Cork South-West with a population that is over 20,000?

Comment on this

No. Well, maybe there is Bandon.

Comment on this

Let us tease this through. No, there is not. Every Airbnb and family unit in Cork South-West can register with Fáilte Ireland on their phone in five minutes. That is all it takes, €25 and five minutes. They can tick a box. They have two years to become planning compliant. They can continue for two years and regularise their planning situation.

For those who have been more than seven years in operation, I have been clear that this is a retention application. It is not a whole new planning application. Not only that, but the Government has brought forward a streamlined process whereby no maps and plans are required. They can go and get planning, and the presumption is to grant. That is the policy of the Government, issued through a national planning statement. That cannot be any clearer.

We also have a process for those who have been operating for less than seven years to apply for planning permission, as detailed on page 19 of the national planning statement, and the considerations are clear. The pathway is clear. You have time on your side. You have certainty in terms of how you can register, and you have a planning policy statement to go forward. The Deputy has asked me if someone will be out checking the road. If a house got planning, it should have sight lines. Surely with our planning system we can expect that. If a house got planning, it should have the basic criteria for a planning application. That is why we can go through a process that is simplified. You do not need maps or plans that planners are going to peruse and check. It is a simplified process. I think that gives us a reasonable balance. I know many on the other side of the House are not happy with that. I understand why they are not happy with it, but I think it is giving a balance.

I have to say, the most enjoyable part of my portfolio has been the job of tourism Minister. I have put so much energy into it over the past year. I have been up and down the country. I have met with so many operators. We have a huge number of grants coming forward over the coming month that are going to help people with digitalisation, recognising the huge change in how people book their holidays and use generative AI to plan their itineraries. The capacity we want to build in businesses is going to be significant. We have 228,000 employed in tourism. I know that. We have 46,000 businesses that rely on tourism for their revenue. I understand that. There are 300,000 people on our island employed in tourism.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Do I have to talk to you, too, about the relevance to the amendment?

Comment on this

The point I am trying to show in the round is that we are trying to facilitate a bit of common sense here. Deputy Collins always talks about common sense. In the 25 key areas where I am trying to bring in housing, there are families who cannot get accommodation. Right around their estates and communities, they can see housing being used for only two or three weekends a month and they cannot get accommodation. Surely there is an obligation on the Government to do something about that and not let it unfold in front of society. Equally, as a tourism Minister, I have to ensure I am not jeopardising capacity in rural areas. That is why I am bringing forward my accommodation strategy to tackle that policy position in tandem and ensure we have a planned, evidence-based approach. What tourism operators really welcome is that we are going to bring in a host of evidence. Best policy is made with evidence. We are going to bring a host of evidence through registrations with Fáilte Ireland about people's patterns and stays and where people are coming from to give us the best opportunity to respond with the best policy. I absolutely hear people's concerns, but I think we are getting the right balance.

Comment on this

The Minister has answered my question, in fairness to him. It took a while to get it out of him, but he answered it. He said everybody who is going to apply for retention of planning over seven years should have had their planning correct anyway. In most cases, however, the sight lines were slightly different 15 years ago. In most cases, you did not need disability access. You used septic tanks. All of that was there, so the retention of planning means they will have to go through that type of process to make sure they are fully compliant, which most homes are not.

That does not mean that they are bad homes or dangerous homes; it means that the people involved have continuously delivered Airbnb all over parts of west Cork I could name - I would be all night doing it - and now planning compliance is going to be thrown at them in the context of retentions of planning. By God, I know what a retention of planning means for people. I know what planning permission is for them. The bottom line is that this is the biggest fear here. There is a presumption to grant. I do not look at that type of writing on paperwork at all. I want a guarantee here that the people in question will not get a visit and that they will only have to register and fully comply. I fully agree with the latter.

I have a serious concern about the rates aspect, and they could be falling into difficulties with that too. However, that might come up in other questions. As has been stated, the bottom line is that they should have been planning compliant in any event, that the rules and regulations have changed for a lot of homes and that they are now going to be caught under this system.

Comment on this

I acknowledge the clarity that the Minister has brought here. That clarity would have been brought forward had Committee Stage been taken by the select committee. The key point relates to resources for local authorities and the fact that there will be additional, ring-fenced personnel. For that reason, I will be pressing this amendment.

Comment on this

I accept that point from Deputy Conway-Walsh. I have been advised by the Minister, Deputy Browne, that over the last three years he has increased those in planning. The simplified process is meant to provide for decisions being made quickly and efficiently; it is not meant to be a cumbersome process. I will discuss with the Minister the concerns that the Deputies have raised. I am happy to do that and have no issue with doing it. I want to assure people that this is a simplified process that I want to get through in order to ensure that we get a good balance in the legislation.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 67
·
Níl 82
·
Staon 1
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 6, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“4.The Minister shall within six months of the passing of this Act lay a report before both Houses of the Oireachtas setting out the operation of the short-term letting register in Gaeltacht communities, including the number of properties registered and the number of properties where enforcement action has been taken for non-compliance with the requirements of the register including planning compliance.”.

Much of the conversation we have been having about rural areas has not considered the specific challenges for our Gaeltacht communities. As the Minister will know from his time in planning and from his time as Minister, there is an acute housing shortage in those communities. People whose children are growing up there are not able to access accommodation. Irish-language speakers and people who are learning the language and want to live in those communities are excluded from doing so because of a lack of adequate accommodation. Nobody is saying there should not be appropriate tourism products in these areas. I often think of the Connemara Gaeltacht, where there is little mainstream tourist accommodation in an area of enormous tourism potential. In fact, the tourist economy is one of the main employers there and, therefore, the balance has to be struck. However, it is simply unacceptable that a commercial entity with an office in London can buy up scores of family homes in the Connemara Gaeltacht and be able to let them in the short term. The planning policy statement and how it sets out the rules, in particular for the seven-year grandfather clause but also for the more general planning rules, does not take sufficient account of those particular challenges. It is the case that in both instances there is a reference to the language planning conditions in that local authority area. The difficulty is that in many cases they are not adhered to in the first place. Some of the properties we are talking about may not be covered by those language planning conditions. This is probably the clearest example of risk. In rural high amenity and high tourism areas with severe housing and affordable housing challenges, there is a real risk that this regime will be too lenient, not on the family operators using properties within the curtilage of their own family home or the home itself but on commercial operators, which are having a detrimental impact on the ability of people to live and thrive in our Gaeltacht communities. Those operators may be allowed to continue to operate.

In the design and drafting of the register and in the Minister's conversations with the Minister, Deputy Browne, and the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, were there specific conversations about how this would operate in those Gaeltacht communities? Was there an understanding of the challenges, particularly those arising from commercial operators not rooted in the community snapping up family homes? Does the Minister share the concern on this side of the House that if we do not get the planning aspect right, particularly with respect to the language planning conditions as set out in the planning policy statement, we could have a real problem in that properties which should not be in short-term letting and should revert to long-term residential occupation, as they were intended, will not do so, despite the Minister's claims to the contrary?

Comment on this

As the Minister is aware, there is a particular housing crisis in our Gaeltacht areas. They are the repositories of our national language. They are the beating heart of what still remains of our language and are essential to the continuation and survival of our language. A number of organisations that work in Gaeltacht areas, including Conradh na Gaeilge, BÁNÚ, the Tinteán Housing Association and Threshold, have set out and requested a number of amendments, which we have put forward, in consideration of this point and to make an exception for Gaeltacht areas. It would apply in particular in the context of the two-year extension. There would also be a specific Gaeltacht area requirement around change-of-use planning that would completely restrict the use of short-term lets in housing in Gaeltacht areas.

Tá an ghéarchéim tithíochta uafásach sna ceantair Ghaeltachta. Níl aon tithe ar fáil do na daoine óga agus tá ár dteanga i mbaol. That is the reality. The issue of short-term lets is one of the topics about which we have seen people from across the country, but especially those from our Gaeltacht areas, protest. Big demonstrations have been organised in recent years. There has been a significant amount of activism on the ground in Gaeltacht areas, specifically in relation to the way in which there are so many properties, which are used as primary properties, on Airbnb. Young people in our Gaeltacht areas cannot get a home or start a family. There is, therefore, a specific requirement to intervene on this basis. I ask the Minister to support this amendment and others. I ask him to take them on board and show that the Government is willing to restrict the inappropriate use of short-term lets in Gaeltacht areas. I ask him to apply the change-of-use planning restriction from 1 December, as is required for areas with a population of over 20,000, and to remove the grandfather clause for Gaeltacht areas. These areas need specific support. If the Government is genuine in its commitment to, and support for, the Irish language and Gaeltacht areas, it would accept and put in place these amendments. Otherwise, it will be making a mistake and letting down our Gaeltacht areas, our language and its future. I plead with the Minister to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Tá a fhios ag an Aire go bhfuil géarchéim tithíochta inár gceantair Ghaeltachta,. Mar atá luaite ag mo chomhghleacaí, an Teachta Ó Broin, atá anseo in aice liom, tá na ceantair seo an-tábhachtach, ní hamháin do na ceantair iad féin ach dár dtír ina iomláine i dtaobh chúrsaí teanga agus cultúir de agus i dtaobh chur chun cinn na Gaelainne agus an Ghaelainn, ár dteanga náisiúnta, a choimeád mar theanga bheo inár dtír. Tá an cheist seo an-tábhachtach chomh maith i gcomhair daoine óga agus clanna óga atá ag iarraidh a gclanna a thógáil trí mheán na Gaelainne ina gceantair dhúchais sna ceantair Ghaeltachta seo. Tá na tithe teaghlaigh atá ar fáil ar cíos gearrthéarmach ag cur isteach ar an margadh, ar an líon tithe agus ar na féidearthachtaí atá ar fáil do na daoine seo filleadh – filleadh atá ann in an-chuid cásanna – ar na ceantair Ghaeltachta chun a gclanna a thógáil ann nó, nuair atá siad ag iarraidh, teaghlach nua a bhunú.

Mar sin, tá an leasú seo curtha isteach ag mo chomhghleacaithe atá anseo in aice liom ionas go mbeadh ar a laghad monatóireacht ag dul ar aghaidh ionas go mbeadh baill an Rialtais airdeallach mar gheall air seo agus iad ag féachaint ar an ngéarchéim sin agus an reachtaíocht seo á cur i gcrích. Tá sé an-tábhachtach go mbeadh súil ar an gceist áirithe seo agus muid ag caint air seo, go mbeadh tionchar agus drochthionchar na tithe seo a bheith ar fáil ar chíos ghearrthéarmach aitheanta agus go dtarraingeofaí aird air.

The Minister does not need me to tell him that there is an existential crisis facing Gaeltacht areas because of the housing crisis. There are many causes of that, including the lack of affordable housing delivery, the lack of social housing delivery, price pressures, particularly in Gaeltacht and coastal Gaeltacht areas where there is considerable demand for houses, and the preponderance of holiday homes. A part of it is that family homes are used in some cases for short-term letting. I do not mean in any way to negate the fact that there is a need for tourist accommodation and tourism in our Gaeltacht areas and that many people engage with short-term lettings for that purpose, and do so quite legitimately. However, we must be conscious of the fact that in some cases there are commercial operators that are taking the proverbial and utilising a significant number of what would otherwise be family homes. In doing so, they are driving up prices and reducing supply, making it incredible difficult for young families, in particular, to return in many cases to their native communities to raise families and the next generation of Irish speakers in the Gaeltacht. I ask the Minister to consider this amendment, which is reasonable, and asks the Government to monitor the situation and lay a report on the impact on Gaeltacht areas within six months of the legislation becoming law.

Comment on this

I will explain the intention of this amendment. I live in a Gaeltacht area. The key is appropriate use. We must get the balance right. There are challenges in housing in Gaeltacht areas. There are also challenges in respect of the language. We also have language tourism. People need to come to Gaeltacht areas to learn the language. We have mná tí there but we need other accommodation options for people who want to come on a short-term basis and who are interested in and want to learn the Irish language.

I also point out that it is important to protect smaller family homes and the income they need. Many people who live in Gaeltacht areas live on very low incomes as it is. This is also a source of income for them. This is where we get to the crux of the difference between the huge commercial operators and the small, family-run businesses. Within the Gaeltacht are designated areas of special areas of conservation, SACs, and all of the other designations.

We need to be able to facilitate planning permissions where all the environmental standards are upheld but where there are family members, who are most often Gaeilgeoirs themselves, who want to return to the area to raise their children through Irish as well. We need here to preserve the promotion of the language, but this speaks as well to why we need the autonomy for local authorities to be able to make the decisions here, to look at a Gaeltacht area, such as Béal an Mhuirthead, and be able to say that this is how many houses it needs here, this is how many homes we need built here, and this is how much accommodation we need for people to be able to come and learn the language and to have a thriving tourist - I will not call it "industry" because it is so much smaller than that - sector within those areas to be able to have a local, thriving economy.

Obviously, the key to all of this is to build more social and affordable homes within the Gaeltacht areas, to build them quicker so that people can live within their own areas and that we can have the proper services and supports in that. These two things are not exclusionary, but it is important. The reason this amendment is tabled is for us to be able to properly monitor what is happening in the areas and what is needed in terms of accommodation and in terms of the local tourist economy. We can achieve this within the Bill, but I would like the Minister to accept the amendment so that we have the proper evidence and data to be able to do that.

Comment on this

I have deep concerns about this Bill. I have deep concerns about people in Gaeltacht areas and in rural areas in particular. So many families sustain themselves through income generated from tourism. That is a reality. Mayo, in particular, is a rural economy and tourism is one of the most important sectors in terms of employment and the economy. Thousands of businesses are sustained by the fact we have tourists coming to Mayo.

The question we must ask ourselves is where these people will stay. Where will the people stay who want to come to the Gaeltacht areas in Mayo, for example? The reality is we do not have enough hotels and the ones we have were commandeered by the Government. They took over the hotel beds for international protection accommodation services, IPAS, centres because of an utter mismanagement of the migration system, the vast majority of which, we know now, were unnecessary. That is important to say. The reason it is important to say-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

It is not relevant.

Comment on this

-----is because we have a shortage of hotel beds.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

It is not relevant. I explained earlier we stick to the relevance within the amendment. Read the amendment. That is not relevant.

Comment on this

It is relevant.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

It is not relevant.

Comment on this

The reason it is relevant is because I come from a rural county. I come from an area where we have a strong Gaeltacht and I know. I am speaking for these families - the families who rely on tourism. If we allow a situation where we restrict and contract the number of tourist beds, we will equally have a massive impact-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

That is not what the amendment is about.

Comment on this

-----in terms of the Gaeltacht area. I am asking the Minister to allow the amendments that are practical here today in relation to supporting the small indigenous businesses which rely on tourist beds. I strongly advise the Minister to consider that.

Comment on this

I am concerned by what some of the speakers to this amendment, especially the ones at the start, said. The answer to the housing problem is not anything we are going to do here tonight. The answer is to build more houses and to go after the vacant houses that there is no one inside of, tourist or else, that are everywhere. There has been no one inside them and the answer is to encourage and entice people to use those houses that are vacant.

To suggest that Gaeltacht areas should be treated the same as the areas of over 20,000 population is unfair and an unfortunate statement to make. In west Kerry, the Gaeltacht - Dunquin, Ceann Trá, Ballyferriter, Ballydavid and all those places - is very far away from hotels, and when people go down there, they need some place to stay. If you are going to say that you will rule out short-term lets there, you will do a pile of harm to the local economy down there.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Relevant to this amendment.

Comment on this

Yes, but they spoke this way about it. They wanted the Gaeltacht areas - they said it here, loud and clear - to be included with the lot over the 20,000 population. That is wrong, that is hurtful and I will not listen to that without talking up for those people. Those people down there depend on that tourism income. For a lot of them, that is all they have. That is what is keeping the few schools that are there going.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

The Deputy can shout for the next hour but I want it to be relevant to the amendment.

Comment on this

It is relevant.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am afraid it is not.

Comment on this

I am saying again to the Minister-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am going to move to the next speaker.

Comment on this

The amount of houses that the Government will get back out of this short-term let trying to put people out of this business will be very little, if any.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you.

Comment on this

The Government must continue building houses-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Thank you.

Comment on this

-----and do something to entice people with vacant houses to give them back-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I call Deputy Michael Collins.

Comment on this

-----and leave the people with the short-term lets alone.

Comment on this

In relation to the Gaeltachts, parts of west Cork are Gaeltacht - down in Ballingeary and Cape Clear Island. I was talking earlier on today about a crisis that is going on there with nurses. They have one but every time she is off, they have no cover there. The funny thing is, I cannot understand. Meaning no disrespect - I had better not mention names because people get annoyed here - you would have someone, maybe from Dublin, telling me, basically, how Cape Clear works. That is not the way. I would not go up and tell them how Dublin works. It does not work that way.

These people in the Gaeltacht are totally dependent on tourism for their survival, whether in Ballingeary or Cape Clear. There is not a huge amount of homeless in those areas, but they are certainly depending on valuable tourism. The mothers out there - it is mainly women that roll out that service, in the Gaeltacht and throughout west Cork and other places - are trying to get a little side income. They are not being made millionaires by this, as the Minister will be aware. They are not making a lot of money and the hassle and the stress about this Bill going through because of the confusion or whatever is unreal. Deputy Butler, the Chief Whip, said they are the only thing. People stood. We had approximately 50 or 60 supporting it, but when it came time to press the button, they forgot about which way to go. They did a totally different type of vote.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy-----

Comment on this

Sorry, yes. We are talking about the Gaeltacht. The bottom line is-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

We are actually not talking about them. People have, but the amendment is-----

Comment on this

The amendment is to provide evidence about effects on Gaeltacht operators without-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Amendment No. 4.

Comment on this

-----itself adding new restrictions. Amendment No. 4 is what I have.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Go ahead.

Comment on this

That is why I am talking about the Gaeltachts, Cape Clear and Ballingeary. There is not a major lack of accommodation there but there certainly is a thriving tourism sector that now will be ended if these planning laws are going to strike in in two years.

I accept they will get two years. The Minister said on numerous occasions that they are all right and they will be sorted out in two years and should not be worrying too much at all. That is not what these people want. These people want to continue their business, and the pubs are thriving because of it, especially in the summer. People come from all over the country into Cape Clear. They come from all over the country and the world into Ballingeary and places like that because they can go down, have a little bit of music, have a little bit of food, and go around and meet people. It has such a knock-on effect in these Gaeltacht areas. It is their very survival. I am asking the Minister, I am asking Fine Gael and I am asking Fianna Fáil - I am here three and a half hours and four hours last week asking them - to withdraw the planning aspect in rural communities and, by God, we will support that Bill.

Now there is a serious concern, given that they are going to be registered in Gaeltacht areas and others. The Ceann Comhairle is watching me tight.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Always.

Comment on this

I am delighted the Ceann Comhairle is.

Will they end up being rated as well? That question has not been answered and I am very concerned if that is the road the Minister is travelling.

The bottom line is that we are talking about the Gaeltacht areas and I will take a strong stance that those areas in west Cork will not support any type of legislative provision that would affect tourism in some way. I am a believer that when people are talking about a crisis in Dublin, Galway and other cities, they should not be looking to the Gaeltacht areas to sort out those problems. That will not resolve the crisis. Not all rural areas can be Gaeltacht areas but there are issues in rural areas. The Minister should not be doing that but it is what this Bill is all about. Rural communities are being attacked to try to deal with major problems that need to be resolved in the cities. The Gaeltacht areas are thriving thanks to tourism.

I have serious reservations about what is being proposed. I would have loved to have heard from people from the Gaeltacht at the committee. That should have happened. They should have been brought up here and allowed to tell us the value of tourism and of short-term letting. That is what has been lost in this debate.

Comment on this

I will be brief. Tá suim mhór agam sa Ghaeilge. Bhí Caisléan Nua, an áit inar rugadh mé, ina bhreac-Ghaeltacht go dtí 1965. Tá an-suim ag daoine sa cheantar i nGaeltacht, nó breac-Ghaeltacht, a thosú arís. Tá súil agam go mbeimis ábalta sin a thosú arís. Is mór an trua é go bhfuil an Bille seo ag dul sa treo seo. I am very disappointed with these proposals. I said that at the outset and I have kept my counsel all evening because I thought we would get to discuss some of the amendments put down by Deputy Michael Healy-Rae and me. Obviously, that will not happen now. There is a filibuster going on here, which is quite clear to see. I am disappointed by what is being proposed even for the Gaeltacht areas. I think it was Pádraig Pearse who said a nation is not a nation without its language. We are not nurturing our language. I know this Bill is not specifically about the language but we cannot compare a Gaeltacht area with an area with a population of over 20,000. Tá brón orm.

Comment on this

Táim thar a bheith sásta tacaíocht a thabhairt don leasú seo agus thar a bheith buíoch do mo chomhghleacaithe as ucht an leasú seo a chur síos. Tá a fhios ag chuile dhuine gur bagairt ollmhór í don Ghaeltacht an ghéarchéim tithíochta go háirithe maidir le ligeanacha gearrthéarmacha atá faoi úinéireacht infheisteoirí institiúideacha atá thall i Londain. This amendment is really important because the single biggest Airbnb operator in the Gaeltacht is Sykes Cottages, which is majority owned by Vitruvian Partners in London. As Deputy Hearne alluded to earlier, change of use should be mandated in Gaeltacht areas. We need stricter planning rules because of the way these large, almost institutional, Airbnb operators based in London are, in essence, taking homes out of the long-term market that could otherwise be used by families. That is why it is really important that we have the evidence, by way of a report, in order that we can monitor the situation and come back in six months to look at it again specifically in relation to Gaeltacht areas. I strongly urge the Government to support the amendment.

Comment on this

I thank all the Members for their contributions. I will begin with the technical response, after which I will give my views on issues raised.

This amendment, as drafted, cannot be supported as it relies on the term "Gaeltacht communities", which has no established legal definition. The absence of a clear definition would create uncertainty regarding the areas covered by the proposed reporting requirement and could lead to inconsistencies in its application.

Based on what some speakers said, there seems to be confusion about what is in the Bill. The first point to clarify is that we are not treating Gaeltacht areas the same as towns or cities with a population of more than 20,000. I want to make it very clear that the Bill is not doing that. The amendment proposes that a report be brought forward in connection with the Gaeltacht areas. In fact, under the Bill, the status quo remains as I outlined earlier in terms of the seven-year requirement, etc.

I listened to what Deputies said regarding Gaeltacht areas. This is an issue I was very familiar with when I was Minister of State with responsibility for planning. I remember a meeting I had near Ballydavid with Mr. Breanndán Ó Beaglaoich, who featured in a documentary called "The Man with the Moving House" and who later won his case to secure planning permission. I recall him outlining the challenges for people in Gaeltacht areas, which are very acute. We were doing work on that in the Department of housing at that time. The Minister, Deputy Browne, and the Minister of State, Deputy Cummins, have brought forward a new planning policy statement on rural and Gaeltacht housing to introduce additional protections for people in respect of rural housing.

We have liaised with the Department of Rural and Community Development and the Gaeltacht on these provisions. The one concern that came back from Gaeltacht areas in relation to the Bill, from our consultation and our observations, was in regard to student accommodation and the requirement to register as short-term lets. That is the one issue that was raised in the feedback we received. The Deputies will see from the planning statement that in regard to the development management process, there is reference to planning conditions relating to Irish-language protections. That is a pretty significant protection in terms of approvals through the planning process. Although it is not part of this Bill, there are other mechanisms by means of which we need to do more to protect our Gaeltacht communities, protect the language and ensure we grow the opportunity there.

In terms of this Bill, we need to achieve a balance in terms of providing accommodation in Gaeltacht areas. Tourist accommodation is needed because tourism is the lifeblood of those areas and people there really depend on tourists. Obviously, we do not want to see unintended consequences, with communities feeling under pressure because houses are being taken out for tourism. That is a wider planning issue with which Custom House must grapple.

Comment on this

I mentioned to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle earlier that it would have made a lot more sense for amendments Nos. 1 to 5, inclusive, to be taken together because they all propose a similar insertion after the same line in the Bill, whereas some of the other amendments, including amendments Nos. 6 and 48 - the latter will not be reached - refer to different parts of the legislation. In effect, what we have had is a debate for the past three and a half hours calling for the Minister to issue a report. He is not going to support this particular amendment regarding Gaeltacht areas. We have had more interactions involving party housing spokespersons during this debate than from Deputies dealing with tourism.

That is the flaw in not having a proper Committee Stage debate and also tying in the planning regulations and the absolutely worthwhile need to free up housing, even in Gaeltacht areas. Unfortunately, we have not reached most of the amendments. I would have supported this amendment in general terms just as I would have supported in principle the previous three amendments. Colleagues may have noticed that I abstained in the decision on amendment No. 3, which was for the simple reason that we will not reach the other amendments, including some I would like to see included in the Bill. As such, this will be my final contribution. If we cannot debate those amendments, I cannot support the Bill and, unfortunately, I cannot support this amendment. I cannot support a proposal and then vote against it later on in the context of the vote on the Bill itself. It is unfortunate that we have not had a proper debate in the House.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

On that point, there is no timeframe in that this is a four-hour open debate and Members can speak for as long as they wish as long as it is relevant. I do not like to interrupt Members but they have to respect what Deputy Gogarty has said about reaching everybody's amendments, given the opportunity. Speakers' contributions must be relevant to the amendment being discussed, and that applies to everybody.

Comment on this

For the people who really wanted us to do work here tonight, it is so disappointing that we are where we are.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

That is not relevant to the amendment. I accept the perspective that has been put forward.

Comment on this

I am speaking in respect of amendment No. 4 and the fact we will not get very much further out of a total of 71 amendments. With no disrespect to the colleagues who tabled the amendments we have dealt with, there were meatier amendments we wanted to get to but, unfortunately, the clock has been talked down here tonight.

As far as I am concerned, the sector has been let down because we have not been able to debate important amendments. At this stage, all we can do is plead with the Minister to take on board the consensus of what we are trying to achieve. We are where we are. We did not get to knuckle down and get through the job of work we wanted to do. It is very disappointing.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 6, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:

“4.The Minister shall within six months of the passing of this Act lay a report before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report assessing:

(a) the impact of the implementation of this Act on the supply of short-term letting accommodation operated as family-run enterprises in rural and high-amenity tourism areas, including any reduction in the availability of such accommodation, and

(b) whether the implementation of this Act has resulted in an increase in the number of properties previously used for short-term letting by commercial investors being returned to the long-term residential rental or housing market.”.

This requires an early assessment of the impact of family-run accommodation in rural and high amenity areas and whether commercial short lets return to residential use. Regulations should address the commercialisation of housing without unnecessarily damaging family-run tourism businesses. It must deliver measurable housing benefits. Regarding farm enterprises, it is vital that we protect small operators from disproportionate impacts. In the rural economy, we must also protect tourism accommodation where hotels are limited in rural areas. Family-run accommodation must be treated differently to commercial investors and their large portfolios. We must avoid unintended consequences and accurately measure any loss of tourism accommodation and associated economic effects.

The amendment also examines whether commercial short-term lets are returning to the housing market. It addresses proportionate regulation and supports adjustments where evidence justifies them. A community balance protecting local employment and permanent housing is required. I remind Members that those of us who have put forward these amendments probably spoke less on them than other Members. That is the nature of how we do business. We have tried our best to make the Bill as palatable as possible.

Comment on this

I was here for a number of hours debating this Bill last week and have been here again tonight. The Minister made things very clear from the beginning. There is no point in me talking about all of our amendments - I tabled 12 amendments. The Minister made it very clear from the beginning that he would not take any of the amendments. In fairness, that is what he said. That is what I picked up on. On that basis, it would be fantastic if we had an opportunity to debate the amendments but if he will not accept them we will be back to square one.

From the word go, including the vote in the Dáil yesterday, the Bill should have had pre-legislative scrutiny. All of our amendments would have been debated. We are talking about family-run rural accommodation. The Bill could ruin that. The mistake was made when the Bill did not go through that process. We were promised that, but unfortunately it was not delivered.

We want to talk about family-run rural accommodation and people's concerns. This is probably my final time debating this. I have a funny feeling that I will be back here in the next two years telling the Minister where things went wrong and about families who have lost income. That is a serious concern for me in respect of the people of west Cork and nationally. My phone was on fire from all over the country. People in Galway, Wexford, Waterford were on the phone to me requesting that I ask questions, and told me there is no clarity. Families need that. That is all they ask for.

People are running simple and basic, but extremely successful, businesses in rural communities and it appears that the Minister has used a hammer to crack a nut. It appears as if rural tourism will have to be sidelined to make sure that homes in cities will be accommodated. That is not how the system works. The Minister does not seem to understand that. Last week, I said that Durrus will not sort out Dublin city's crisis. Dublin city does need to have its housing crisis sorted.

If the Bill goes in the direction I think it will, the loss of finances for families providing accommodation will last for many. As the Minister keeps saying, they got a reprieve for two years, but that is only kicking the can down the road. People cannot afford that. It was a side income for many families; they are not making a fortune. Last week I told the House that in 1975 my mother provided bed and breakfast accommodation. We were all hurled into one room when she let four rooms upstairs to different couples because it put bread and butter on our table. I have nothing to do with Airbnb, and neither does any of my family. I have no skin in the game. I understood the business. We have to understand it to be able to talk about it.

I knew someone who was giving out about farming, but they never wore a pair of wellingtons. They should not talk about farming; they do not wear farm wellingtons. People do not know about this type of rural tourism. People who stayed in my mother's home in 1975 went to the town, bought food, went out to the islands off the coast of west Cork and had a great time. They went back with a great feeling about west Cork, Kerry or wherever. It now appears that such businesses are in jeopardy because we are worried about a housing crisis in cities. Rural accommodation provided a small income, but that system is in serious jeopardy if the Bill is passed as far as I am concerned because the Minister is not able to clarify the planning aspect to me.

I accept that the Minister did try to clarify quite a lot of things, and people thanked me on the phone for that, but there are other issues. I know for a fact that if the Bill is passed as it is I will be back here in the next two years explaining to the Minister that planners came to people's doors and he told them what to do. The Minister has told me people had to have planning anyway. Things change, and they can change dramatically. There will be a huge loss to the local rural economy of this country and families who wanted some side income. I ask the Minister to step back and consider the rural aspect and the damage that will be caused to people.

Comment on this

I have enormous sympathy for the comments from Deputies Healy-Rae and Gogarty on the nature of the debate. It is not adequate that a short-term letting register Bill, predicated on fundamental changes to planning law, is progressed without any scrutiny or debate of that planning law. I accept it is not the fault of the Minister, but collective Cabinet responsibility still holds and he is the only one in front of us.

This is the only time since this entire episode began in 2022 that there has been a debate on the planning proposals agreed by Cabinet a week ago. That is the real frustration. I respectfully disagree with Deputy Healy-Rae in that there is a logic to some of these amendments, namely that the Government is making claims that the planning policy statement and register will have a number of impacts. We are trying to force the Government to report on those impacts so that if our concerns are correct and the Government claims do not come to pass, there would be evidence that we can then use to make the case that the Government should change tack.

Amendment No. 5 is probably the most important of the amendments tabled by me and Deputy Conway-Walsh because it gets to the nub of the two core elements. On the one hand, there is the Government's claim that this will assist small family businesses in regularising their planning arrangements in terms of getting on the register and being properly regulated in rural high-amenity tourism areas. At the same time, in those larger population centres a significant number of long-term residential units will be brought back into use. That is what is at the core of this amendment.

My strong and considered view, as somebody who has been in favour of the proposed register since the Minister, Darragh O'Brien, and then Minister, Catherine Martin, introduced it four years ago, is that the Government got the planning policy statement badly wrong and is not willing to engage in any constructive way with the kind of reporting mechanisms we are calling for, including this amendment. The only disagreement I have with some of the other spokespeople on the Opposition benches is that the regulations are exceptionally weak. Where they are weakest is in larger urban areas. I believe the Minister was making a genuine claim when he said that a number of properties which were designed and built for long-term residential occupation in large urban areas would be brought back into use. They will not be and the amendment would provide evidence to show that the Minister was correct or we were wrong and vice versa.

We will spend enormous amounts of time, and time will be spent tying up the Minister's officials with parliamentary questions and freedom of information requests in six or 12 months' time, trying to get the information that an orderly reporting process would provide.

I have probably been here as long as the Minister, and I know these types of amendments are not accepted. However, I would urge him to do something his colleague in the Department of housing has started to do, which is voluntarily produce periodic reports on significant changes. In respect of this, because this is very important, there is a requirement, whether on an annual basis or whatever, for the Minister to lay before the Houses and publish on the respective websites of the two Departments the core outcomes that will demonstrate whether this Bill is doing what it should do. For example, the Department of housing has started publishing monthly figures on defective concrete blocks. Deputies Conway-Walsh, Mac Lochlainn, Doherty and I used to have to drag that information kicking and screaming out of the Minister and his overworked officials in the Department of housing, but they now publish it monthly. It is very good data. I am not suggesting we need something monthly, but we need something on a more regular basis.

I would have really liked to be here supporting this Bill. The idea of a registry is an eminently sensible one. It is important to remember the reason the register was proposed in the first place. It was because planning enforcement did not work under the old regulatory regime as Eoghan Murphy said it would. In the absence, however, of proper planning rules, proper planning enforcement and sufficient staff, this is not a Bill that my colleagues or I can support. That is regrettable because the regulation of the industry is needed and the register is needed. However, if the fundamental foundation upon which all of this is based, the planning policy statement, is so badly drafted and designed and chronically under-resourced, then the register, which fundamentally is about bringing properties that should be in long-term residential occupation back into use while regulating good-quality family tourism product in rural areas, will not be able to fulfil those functions adequately. On that basis, the Bill is not worthy of support.

Comment on this

I have no issue with a register. It is a sensible thing to introduce. You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar. My problem is with the difference between the Minister's interpretation of the planning laws and that of the planners in each area. The Minister said he used to have responsibility for planning. I have been involved in planning nearly all my life, as long as I have been in construction. It will be up to each individual area in the planning sector to interpret this in its own way, whereas if a person went in for a short-term let at the moment, they would not get it. Ask the planning authorities. They have told people that no short-term lets will get planning. This is what they are being told.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

What is the relevance?

Comment on this

The relevance is that this examines the impact of family rural accommodation and whatever investor-owned properties return to housing. Even if you go for a new planning application at the moment, you cannot get a short-term let. The Minister is saying it is about getting what we have at the moment regularised. All he had to do was introduce a register. Anyone who was not there within seven years, for example, would have to go back to regularise their planning, and then all the Government had to do was bring in a simple rule. It would have its register and would know what was there, and then it can validate the good ones and the ones that are poor. That would be done by people who actually live in this accommodation in these short-term lets. They would evaluate it themselves online with a star rating. That is what they would regulate. If the Minister had put an incentive in place, however, a lot more of them would bring long-term lets back into it.

How many people have left these shores because they could not stay here and short-term let out their house? What is the Government going to do now if the properties have been let long term and people cannot get back into them? Why not come up with common-sense policies and simplify something? The Government did not simplify it. It actually complicated it. What it has done is put it down the road for all the local authorities to have different interpretations. This is despite the current housing policies and the new planning guidelines, which have not been introduced and have been sent from the door here, and this is to do with planning. They have not been introduced yet even for housing that currently exists. The new planning guidelines for people who want to build on their own land have not been introduced. I asked the Minister for housing last week and he has not replied to me. Where are the new guidelines? The Minister has said that it is about the guidelines and what he has put down in planning regulation. The Government cannot deal with the planning regulation as it is and now it wants to allow local authorities to interpret how they implement the Government's policy. I do not believe it will work. I deal with the local authorities every day. They are people who like to do things right. They will say they are not going to follow whatever interpretation the Minister has because their interpretation will be different.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Deputy Murphy has just ten seconds, I am afraid.

Comment on this

I cannot say a lot in ten seconds.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

That is fine.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to keep this under review. My concern relates to the inconsistency across local authorities-----

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

I am afraid that is it, Deputy.

Comment on this

I thank the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Verona Murphy An Ceann Comhairle Independent

Unfortunately, the time permitted for the debate has expired. I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 10 November: "That in respect of each of the sections undisposed of, the section is hereby agreed to in Committee, the Schedule and Title are hereby agreed to in Committee, the Bill is accordingly reported to the House without amendment, Fourth Stage is hereby completed and the Bill is hereby passed."

Comment on this
Division

Question put

Tá 83
·
Níl 71
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?