We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Defence and National Security

General Scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025 : Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Witnesses examined the Bill’s removal of the triple lock, which would end the need for UN Security Council authorisation before Irish troops can be deployed overseas. Professor Tonra and Mr. Murphy argued the change reflects a changed security environment and gives Dáil and Government greater flexibility, but both said stronger safeguards, such as legal review or wider parliamentary oversight, may be needed. Mr. Noonan strongly opposed the Bill as too open-ended and lacking clear guardrails, warning that it could erode the trust given to earlier treaty commitments on neutrality. Members divided sharply over whether the change is a practical update or a fundamental shift that should go to referendum.

Contributions 156–322 of 322. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will now go to the non-members of the committee who will have three minutes each. I will take a supplementary list for the permanent members of the committee to have another round and they will also have three minutes.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming and for their submissions. My first question is for Mr. Noonan. We spoke about the pressure that politicians and the media refer to from Europe to step up Ireland's defence. What are Mr. Noonan's thoughts on how that pressure interacts with the declarations of the Nice and Lisbon treaties that acknowledge the neutrality of member states in the context of the Common Defence and Security Policy.

Second, the committee heard from another witness a few weeks ago about concerns that this legislation could potentially undermine the Nice and Lisbon treaties themselves and the validity of them and that they could face a legal test. What are Mr. Noonan's thoughts on both these points, please?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

I will answer the second question first because I do not agree, candidly. I have been at the European Court in Luxembourg and seen how the structure works in the formal sense and I do not see that happening.

In regard to the relationship between the assurances given in the declarations and the pressure, I am also indirectly aware of the pressures. I have seen them in a semi-detached way and those pressures are unrelenting and never sleep. They are ruthless and they are 24-7. Those of us in the privileged position of seeking to preserve and maybe develop and present some constructive suggestions as to how this country might maintain its rather unusual perspective on these matters have, if we are lucky, busy lives and are doing other things. We are here on our own dime. Against that, we have the Lockheed Martins and big corporations that, speaking as a lawyer, are bound by law to chase profit. They have no empathy, no compassion and do not feel pain Those are simply statements of fact. This is the contest we are facing, and if we are talking about the interrelationship between the pressures and the assurances, the assurances are always under pressure.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Noonan. I have a quick question for Mr. Murphy. He mentioned the Chad withdrawal of forces. I was under the impression that was a unanimous decision of the UN Security Council on the basis of an expressed wish of the Chadian Government but he referenced a veto. Will he clarify which it was?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

We were coming into the rainy season-----

Comment on this

Was it a UN Security Council veto or not? I have one question for Professor Tonra after this one.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

There was a question over whether or not the mandate would be renewed. We got to a stage where we had a window to get out, and if we did not hit that window-----

Comment on this

So, it was not a veto then. I have one question for Professor Tonra. Does he now or has he ever lobbied on behalf of arms manufacturers or any associations that include arms manufacturers?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I am secretary and director of the Irish Defence and Security Association, an organisation that promotes Irish security and defence and has arms, dual-use and small and medium-sized enterprises and other international enterprises as members.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I have not personally, no.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

The other two non-members present are Senator Alice-Mary Higgins and Deputy Catherine Connolly. They have three minutes.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy has acknowledged that a force can be authorised on the basis of a resolution of the General Assembly under the 2006 Act, although he has said these would not be blue hat missions. However, the additional missions that might take place should this legislation remove the triple lock would not be blue hat missions either. Missions can be authorised through the General Assembly although they would not be blue hat missions. The language in the 2006 Act is quite wide. It says "established, mandated, authorised, endorsed, supported, approved or otherwise sanctioned" so there is quite a wide set of ways that a-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

That is only with a UN Security Council resolution. To put it in context, the question put to me was whether a General Assembly resolution would effectively be the same as a UN Security Council resolution, to which my answer was "No".

Comment on this

The definition under the 2006 Act does say "or the General Assembly of the United Nations". It is an "or" not an "and".

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

The "or" arose from a decision made in the late forties or early fifties when a particular mission was approved by the UN General Assembly but that has never happened since. It is not considered legal.

Comment on this

It is a possibility, however.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

It is hypothetically a possibility.

Comment on this

It is a possibility that has occurred in the past.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

On one occasion 60, 70 or 80 years ago.

Comment on this

Going on to the language of the Bill, we have spoken a lot about peacekeeping, peacekeepers and peace missions, but the Bill is quite wide, not just as to how missions are authorised but also as to their purposes. It also refers to the purpose of "strengthening international security". That is also a phrase that is used. What does strengthening international security not include? Can it include the security of interests, including economic interests? I have a third question so I ask Mr. Noonan to keep his answer short.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

That goes to the heart of the problem. The language in this is utterly permissive. It appears to be otherwise but that is, in fact, its legal effect. There is nothing really excluded by the language in respect of the terms the Senator has particularly highlighted.

Comment on this

Is anything excluded?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

If I may clarify, that language is lifted directly from Article 3 of the Lisbon treaty protocols.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy is referring to the term "strengthening international security".

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Yes.

Comment on this

I direct this question to Professor Tonra. Does "strengthening international security" potentially include the security of interests, including economic interests?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

It would be what the government of the day proposed.

Comment on this

For example, would the recent decision by the EU to deploy troops to protect commercial shipping from the Houthis fall under that-----

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

That was counter-piracy. It would probably be encompassed in that definition.

Comment on this

From Professor Tonra's perspective, it can, therefore, include economic interests. I have one last point. It is just a point of clarification. I did not actually plan to raise this. It relates to lobbying. For clarification, I understand that Professor Tonra is listed as a lobbyist on the register.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I volunteer to give my time to the IDSA.

Comment on this

The IDSA's members include Lockheed Martin. I had not planned to raise that but I mention it for clarity.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I have never lobbied on behalf of a particular company or group of companies.

Comment on this

However, from an organisational------

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

Yes, absolutely. That is in my biography.

Comment on this

I just wanted to clarify the issue of lobbying.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I need to move on to Deputy Catherine Connolly.

Comment on this

I want to go to the conflicts of interest. Is there a protocol here that, when witnesses come before the committee, they should declare any conflicts of interest? Has that happened with any of the witnesses so far?

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

No, it has not happened.

Comment on this

Does Professor Tonra believe he has a conflict of interest?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

No.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the witnesses have been invited here and given their presentations. For people to question whether they have conflicts of interest is irrelevant. If, in the opinion of a member of this committee, there is a conflict of interest, they should have raised that before the witnesses were brought before the committee. I will put on record that every witness who has appeared here has been approved by the members of this committee. If people coming in here want to go down the road of conflicts of interest, that diverts from the purpose of this meeting.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I think people's interests have been established anyway so let us move on from that.

Comment on this

The Deputy has just diverted my attention from the question. I am perfectly entitled to come in.

Comment on this

I am a Senator, by the way.

Comment on this

The Senator has just diverted attention.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I remind Deputy Connolly that she is using up her time.

Comment on this

I am not using the time. The Senator has used my time deliberately. It is a very legitimate-----

Comment on this

I am sorry. Excuse me but-----

Comment on this

If I may continue-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We have heard what Senator Wilson has to say.

Comment on this

Honestly, we are entitled to ask questions and witnesses are entitled to respond. We are talking about strengthening security in the world through this legislation. That is so broad that it could include anything. We are therefore entitled to tease things out and that includes conflicts of interest. Professor Tonra has clearly said that he does lobby and does represent his association. What was the title of it?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I am sorry-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

That has been established.

Comment on this

I just missed it because of the interruptions.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It has already been established.

Comment on this

The wide nature of this, which will allow anything, has already been mentioned. We have been repeatedly told that the use of the veto - according to the Government, it is mostly Russia that has used it in the past, although it has ignored America - would stop a peacekeeping force. We have seen America use the veto lately. Is that not right? I am talking about stopping the conflict in the Middle East. Is that not correct? It used its veto. As I understand it, the logic is that we should still send a peacekeeping force to that area. Is that not the logic if Russia's veto stops us sending such a force but we want to send one regardless? We want a different system and want to remove the triple lock. That will do away with the misuse of the veto so that we can still send peacekeeping or peace enforcement forces. Is that not correct? I address that to any of the witnesses. Perhaps Professor Tonra or Mr. Murphy would like to answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

I am not sure I got the question.

Comment on this

The logic of the narrative we are given all the time is that this is about the misuse of the veto, predominantly by Russia. However, we have lately seen an acute example of American misuse of the veto. We want to stop the misuse of the veto by introducing a different system and pulling out of the triple lock. Is that not right? The idea is that we will use a regional organisation to send peacekeeping forces. Is that not the logic?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

When I answered the question previously, I said that it is not just Russia that uses the veto. China and America use it. People also use the threat of the veto so that you never even see a Security Council resolution or the draft of one.

Comment on this

Let us stick to the practicalities. It has been said that the use of the veto stops peacekeeping or peace enforcement forces going abroad. Let us take the most recent example of America using the veto. Should we now just ignore that and send a peacekeeping or peace enforcement force over to the Middle East?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

The current legislation requires us to have a UN Security Council resolution to participate.

Comment on this

I know that but let us say that we have removed the triple lock. Is the logic then that we would send-----

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

With the troops Ireland has, there is no way it is going to mount a peacekeeping operation on its own. You are going to have some international body or coalition engaged in the process. All sorts of headquarters are required.

Comment on this

Who will do that? We have seen what side Europe has taken in Israel's war on Gaza. Who will determine whether a peacekeeping force is to be deployed? Will it be Germany, Europe or the UK?

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I ask Mr. Murphy just to answer that. I have allowed a bit of extra time.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach very much for that.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

In the normal course of events, it would be the European Union. It could also be the African Union or ASEAN. You need an international group to come together to say something is a problem. It is not for any one state to say "This is a problem. Everybody, come with me."

Comment on this

You do see that. It has been exposed.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Over the long period of time I was policy director, my experience has been that international organisations come together and see a particular problem. There may be countries within those organisations that do not particularly see a problem but you need that international dimension to bring a sufficient number of states together.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach for the flexibility.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We will move back to the permanent members, who will have three minutes each. I will just give the list. We will start with Deputy Stanley and then have Deputy O'Connell, Deputy O'Meara, Senator Craughwell and Senator Kyne. If anyone else wants to speak, I ask them to indicate.

Comment on this

We have to respect the witnesses who come in. They have obviously come in from different positions and that is the reason we have them here. As a member of the committee, however, I was not aware until a half an hour ago

of Professor Tonra's involvement in lobbying. He is entitled to do so but I want to hear his point of view, even though I disagree with him on probably a lot of what he said. He made some good points but I disagree with some of what he is saying.

One point he made with which I disagree is point 18. He said that Ireland's traditional neutrality will similarly be unaffected by the proposed amendment. I am picturing the scenario, to pick up a little bit on what Deputy Connolly just referred to, where we are part of an alliance with Germany, Britain, France and those countries. They have not just sat on their hands with regard to Israel and Palestine. In some cases, they are actively supplying the weapons and materiel that are being used in the slaughter of civilians and have given other logistical and intelligence help to what I would call the terrorist State of Israel. I am picturing us being part of some ill-defined regional force with a mandate to protect international security - Mr. Trump and Mr. Netanyahu use phrases like "international security"; I hear them at that regularly - but under what mandate would it operate? We know from previous conversations here that we would be subject to the command of one of those larger countries or the likes of NATO - we have clarified that it could be under NATO - on a mission to strengthen international security. Surely, that would affect our military neutrality. Can Professor Tonra not see the contradiction in that? It is left wide open.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

Again, that paragraph was referencing the fact that there is a very different understanding of what neutrality is. Mr. Noonan, for example-----

Comment on this

Professor Tonra made the statement very clearly. I read it twice last night. He said that Ireland's traditional neutrality will similarly be unaffected by the proposed amendment.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

"Traditional" as defined by consecutive Governments, which, as Mr. Noonan said, is very narrowly defined as "non-membership of"-----

Comment on this

That is defined in our-----

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

-----and that does not change.

Comment on this

However, it is as it is defined in our 1937 Constitution and copper-fastened and stated in a national declaration as part of the Nice treaty and Lisbon treaty. Would that not be correct?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I do not understand the question; I am sorry.

Comment on this

Okay, I will leave it at that.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Time is up.

Comment on this

I will ask Mr. Noonan a question very quickly. We have been operating under multilateralism as part of the UN, as imperfect as that may be. I have one question for Mr. Noonan. We are being pressured, and there is a lot of pressure. We can see that building up in terms of the sense that we must move.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy Stanley-----

Comment on this

Does Mr. Noonan agree that by being, for want of a better word, a patsy and going along with what the bigger powers want, we will lose respect internationally instead of standing as a neutral state and maintaining the level of respect we have gained? It is a "Yes" or "No" answer.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Deputy Stanley, you have gone over your time. It is a "Yes" or "No" answer.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

That would be a "Yes". We will lose respect.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Do the other witnesses wish to respond? It is just "Yes" or "No".

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

No.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. We will move on to Deputy O'Connell followed by Deputy O'Meara.

Comment on this

There has been much talk from members and the witnesses about the importance of trust. I understand from Mr. Murphy's contribution that it really is the Dáil, the Oireachtas and the Government that are ultimately the protector of our neutrality as opposed to the UN Security Council, from his outlining of the history in that regard. If that is the case, the people we are trusting ultimately, as Mr. Noonan pointed out, are the people who get to elect the parliamentarians.

From that perspective, Mr. Noonan talked about the pressures we come under, particularly as a small country. We have done very well, especially recently, in terms of those pressures. We have been taking a leading role in highlighting the plight of Gaza against all the external pressures and have potentially suffered quite significantly politically by burning that political capital, yet we are still standing firm on it. We have demonstrated even in recent times our ability to withstand those external pressures.

I would also like to highlight that in our electoral system, nobody is entitled to a seat or handed a seat. Everybody got here by fighting fairly for it. All of our parliamentarians have the ability to fight and stand up to external pressure. The electoral system ensures that everybody here achieves that. My question for the three witnesses is whether they do not have trust in our parliamentarians to make the right decisions in these types of circumstances where there is an ask to deploy?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

The Constitution is what I go back to, and that entrusts parliamentarians with certain powers on behalf of the people. Articles 29.1, 29.2 and 29.3 set out the principles that were intended to guide the exercise of those powers with regard to war. In 2003, the High Court found that they were merely aspirational, so I would like to see them be given legislative force. In terms of Senator Kyne's request for suggestions, I would go back to that. The Deputy is quite right to highlight the fact that we have stood up very well under immense pressure. I will go back to the point I made earlier that if we have this here at the moment, it is oddly a protector against susceptibility to pressure of a certain kind, and if we take it away without being very clear of what we are putting in its place, we are making a mistake. The assurances that were given very categorically in the beginning of this process on behalf of the Department-----

Comment on this

I am sorry to interrupt Mr. Noonan. I am just watching the clock and I would like to hear a response from Mr. Murphy.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

I will stop with these words. Those assurances cannot be relied on.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Murphy trust the people to elect the right parliamentarians and the parliamentarians then to withstand?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Yes, absolutely. That is the issue I have been pointing out. From the very beginning, it was seen that the Oireachtas and the Dáil were the protectors of the sovereignty, neutrality and the independent foreign policy that Ireland could assert and, in fact, that Dáil Éireann may have to decide to withdraw from the United Nations in the event that it made decisions that were not consistent with what we wanted. The UN was not seen as the harbinger and protector of our neutrality; it was actually the Dáil that was seen as the protector against the UN.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Professor Tonra might give a short answer.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

The short answer is "Yes".

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay. We have Deputy O'Meara followed by Senator Craughwell.

Comment on this

I would like to come back to Professor Tonra for my next question. He made the point that some countries in recent times have reversed decades, if not centuries, of defence policy or points of neutrality. Finland and Sweden are two prime examples of this that were very dramatic in nature. Were Ireland to remove the triple lock, would our change in policy be any way compared to a move as dramatic as that which Finland and Sweden have made?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

To my mind, no, not even close.

Comment on this

I would probably have agreed with Professor Tonra before I asked that question, but particularly today with regard to Mr. Noonan's point that it seems we would need a referendum to join NATO, that makes that dramatic change even less severe.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I will defer to Mr. Noonan's legal knowledge. I could not comment on what the Constitution does and does not provide for in that respect.

Comment on this

In his opening statement, Mr. Murphy discussed the changes and amendments that have been made to legislation over the years and the number of times the Act has been amended. We are now looking at another amendment that is getting a lot of attention and controversy from some parts. At any point during discussion of those previous amendments, was there discussion of our neutrality and the losing or abandonment of it? Does Mr. Murphy think these current proposed amendments would threaten our neutrality?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Certainly, there was a discussion in this House about whether those changes affected our neutrality, particularly in the case of the 2006 Act because it broadened the definition and also gave circumstances where the Defence Forces could be deployed without the provision of a UN Security Council resolution. The reason for that was that those situations existed and the UN Security Council would not be concerned about them because they did not represent a threat to international peace and security. Certainly, yes, there was discussion around it, including in this House, but the conclusion was that it was not affecting us, even though we expanded quite significantly the definition of an international United Nations force over that period. As for how that definition came about, we went back through 55 years of UN Security Council resolutions and looked at every single provision that authorised or established a force.

They used all sorts of terms. There was a massive expansion in the definition of what constituted an international UN force at that time but what never changed was the requirement for, or the prerequisite of, a Security Council resolution in some form or other. The problem now is that we do not have those.

Comment on this

Will we be less neutral if we remove the triple lock?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

No. There is no relationship between the two.

Comment on this

Mr. Noonan adverted to the constitutional position with respect to Ireland declaring war. I am quite agnostic on the triple lock because we do not have enough troops to send anywhere so, to my mind, it is a red herring. However, if we wanted to re-establish our sovereignty and re-establish the Oireachtas and the office of the President as the de facto authority to deploy troops, what would be wrong with a constitutional referendum on Article 28 that would give the Seanad and the President a say on the deployment of troops and get rid of the dysfunctional UN?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

There is probably a seminar in that on its own. The Senator will probably have several university departments busy for years answering that question and I say that with all due respect. We really are at the crux here on the question of where power resides. As parliamentarians, committee members understandably feel entrusted, as they are, by the people to make decisions on behalf of the people. I am, however, trying to look at this as a citizen, from a distance. I am as guilty as anybody of thinking we know best and that even if we listen, more or less, to others, we should be able to make the decision for others, but that is not what the constitutional scheme actually provides for in certain respects. That was seen dramatically in the Supreme Court judgment in Crotty, where the Government felt it was entitled to join an increasingly powerful European Union, albeit not called that at the time, in the Single European Act. Crotty went to court and the court agreed with him that the Government was giving away the power to say "Yes" or "No" and that it could not do that without the people's permission. There is always a tension. I am not going beyond saying there is a tension between the popular sovereignty as expressed in the Constitution and what parliamentarians decide to do. It is understandable that Oireachtas Members feel they are entrusted and that, therefore, they are trustworthy, but those things have their limits.

Comment on this

I have to cut Mr. Noonan off because time is against me. I do not feel I am entrusted. I was elected to my seat in Seanad Éireann and that brought trust with it, as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

Yes, I agree.

Comment on this

With respect, Mr. Noonan adverted to us getting closer to NATO. I visited CCDCOE in Tallin and am damned glad that we are close to CCDCOE because cyber recognises no borders. Does Mr. Noonan have a difficulty with us co-operating at that level?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

I have not made any comment that would suggest that I have a difficulty in co-operating at that level. We have to dance carefully and box clever. We have to do what we see as being in our own best interests. What concerns me is external people putting constraints on our ability to exercise that power.

Comment on this

I might ask our other two guests to comment on co-operating with CCDCOE and the like.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Obviously, we lack expertise in terms of the volume, and that comes together in these NATO centres of excellence. I was there when those decisions were made. Nobody brought any pressure on Ireland to join any of these things. Ireland decided of itself. In fact, NATO would be at pains to point out that it is a matter for Ireland to choose what it does and does not get involved in.

Comment on this

I want to go back to the guardrail issue. Mr. Murphy mentioned the General Assembly and the practicalities and constraints on that. How would Professor Tonra and Mr. Noonan view the General Assembly as a safeguard to the five permanent members?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I just do not see it as practicable because, as has been said, the General Assembly cannot create a legal entity of a UN force. The laundry list the Senator gave was exactly that; it was deliberately designed to be a laundry list to encompass as much as possible. What the Senator is suggesting is that 190 countries in the UN General Assembly would devote precious time and political energy to satisfy us to send our troops overseas. I just do not see it as a practicable alternative, to be honest.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

It seems to have merit, be grounded in law and be deserving of attention. I would just add that regarding the care we have to take, for very good historical reasons, in deciding to send soldiers overseas, if nobody did that, the world would probably be a safer place. We have that dilemma. We have a tradition, so it is imprinted in our approach to this, of being able to do that under the Blue Helmets. That has now run up against a roadblock so we are casting around for something else that we can express that through. Unfortunately, the indicators are that the available channels being proposed are fraught with difficulty and so we should not throw out the baby with the bath water.

Comment on this

To take up Professor Tonra's point, is it practicable?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

Yes, it is. It is practicable in the sense that clearly, as we have seen over Gaza, huge numbers of members of the General Assembly can agree on resolutions and trivial numbers disagree. When we are coming to a decision to send troops overseas, we have to have that level, practically, of global consensus before we do it. That makes sense to me and it is grounded, as I said, in the legislation.

Comment on this

Would Mr. Murphy like to comment?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

It may be grounded in legislation but operationally it is not feasible because we do not get control of the UN system by virtue of a resolution of the General Assembly. The UN system involves military headquarters, strategic headquarters, logistics, lift and so on. The General Assembly can vote for something but if the Security Council has not approved it, the General Assembly cannot invoke the institutions of the UN to support a military operation overseas. In practical, military terms, it just does not work.

Comment on this

I am conscious of time and that Deputy Callaghan is here now. If she wants to take my time, she may do so.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Clonan for that. I was chairing another meeting, which is why I missed the contributions of our guests. Professor Tonra said in his opening remarks that if we are no longer to rely on the Security Council as the gatekeeper of legitimacy and are finally to remove the veto given to the five permanent members, we must establish robust mechanisms of our own. Does he not think that the Government and the Dáil are robust enough in that context? Does he not think we have robust measures already?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I do but if we are looking for additional guardrails, I have put two ideas on the table.

Comment on this

Does he think we need additional guardrails?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

No, other countries do not have them. Once the government decides and the parliament authorises, they will send their troops overseas on a particular mission. There is nothing that requires them, but Mr. Noonan has talked about the pressures and the need for guardrails. I am just saying that if we feel we need additional guardrails, those are a couple of options to consider.

Comment on this

They would not be essential.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

No, not at all

Comment on this

There were references to an annual review mechanism that could empower the Dáil to monitor ongoing missions. It is my understanding that there is currently an annual review for UNIFIL. It might not go before the Dáil but certainly the Minister and Department of Defence currently conduct a review.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

That is the kind of mechanism that we could expand, for example, to cover all potential missions.

Comment on this

To follow on from Senator Kyne's point about the General Assembly, which was well addressed by Mr. Murphy. Can the General Assembly compel any country to act?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

No.

Comment on this

I want to go back to the point about our neutrality. I asked this question at the committee last week. If we were to remove the triple lock in its entirety, would we be any less neutral than we currently are?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

The short answer is "No". The two issues are entirely unrelated. They have been conflated but they are entirely unrelated.

Comment on this

Would our neutral status change at all?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

Absolutely not.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Noonan have a comment on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

I disagree with that. The position we took in 1960 only to send our troops overseas under the blue helmet reflected a particular world view at the time. To change that now by removing it means that we are changing our world view, changing our relationship and doing it against the backdrop of a proposed scheme which envisages taking the EU lead. We are doing that against the backdrop of assurances officially given that the EU always obeys international law. That is a change to our world view from the times past. In that sense, when we are using this difficult word "neutrality" and when the question is posed as to whether that brings about a change to our neutrality, I would say that it does.

Comment on this

The world we are looking at is changing and I do not necessarily agree that the point Mr. Noonan made does impact on our neutrality.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

We can say that we differ.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It might be said to be a contested space.

I call Senator Clonan for one minute sharp and after that Senator Higgins if everyone is satisfied.

Comment on this

Mr. Murphy cited possible concerns over the renewal of the UN Security Council mandate that would have led to a rapid withdrawal from Chad. He talked about having to leave all our bullets, weapons and things behind because of the rainy season and so on. I was on a mission where a rapid evacuation almost happened because we came under sustained attack from the Israelis. Is it not more usual to seek to withdraw our troops for operational reasons? The cancellation of a UN Security Council resolution would be so rare as to be a red herring.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

In the 15 years I was in the job, on a significant number of occasions we were on the cusp of making a decision to withdraw because of a UN Security Council resolution. I never had to consider a situation where we were under attack or as a result of kinetic activity in the area. Therefore, the Senator is not correct.

Comment on this

Is Mr. Murphy suggesting that my experience did not happen?

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

I am not saying his experience did not happen. In fact, his experience probably predated my arrival in the Department of Defence, as it was then. All I am saying is that in the time when I was policy director, the decision to exit a mission never arose from the operational situation. It always arose in terms of warning orders and whatever, from worries about-----

Comment on this

I differ with Mr. Murphy on that. I am concerned about it being mobilised or cited as a reason for dispensing with the triple lock. I also dispute his assertion that there is no link between neutrality and the triple lock and that that is a conflation. In fact, we know that if any future Government can deploy any number of troops anywhere in the world at any time in the future, that absolutely impacts on our neutral status. That is an actual fact. It is not possible assert otherwise without any evidence.

I must also say that the witnesses here today have presented some of the most interesting evidence to the committee and I thank them all. Professor Tonra said that our neutral status is not respected in Europe.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He was asked the question as to whether it was respected or not.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I said it was.

Comment on this

He said that in one sense it was but, in another sense it was not and that people kind of dislike it. I have been on the interparliamentary mission of the OSCE. I am a member of many different academic and military groups in Europe. As a journalist for the last 25 years, I have met many key decision-makers in Europe and in our community. I have never encountered any criticism or disapproval of our neutral status. From time to time I have encountered curiosity. The only thing I have encountered is that people are sometimes surprised at how poorly funded our Defence Forces are and the state they have been allowed to get into through no fault of the personnel. Where is Professor Tonra's evidence for suggesting that our partners in Europe or internationally dislike or disapprove of our neutral status?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

I did not use either of the words "dislike" or "disapprove".

Comment on this

I cannot quite recall the formula of words he used. Where is the evidence for that?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

Across the literature, looking at comparative neutrality in the European context, there are many conversations about what neutrality entails and the reasons for that kind of neutrality. The Senator is as familiar with the literature as I am. Particularly when countries look at Ireland, they see Ireland's highly beneficial geostrategic situation, allowing it not to have had to participate in many of the big and tough decisions on European security and defence. That is a privilege we have enjoyed by virtue of our geography. The attitude that one does come across occasionally is that people look at Ireland's position and say it is very easy for us to take that position when others have to make much more difficult choices. Consequently, to stand on a pedestal claiming that neutrality makes Ireland a better country than other countries gives rise to a certain degree of - let us call it - dissatisfaction.

Comment on this

I thank Professor Tonra.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will allow Senator Higgins in for one minute.

Comment on this

Determining international law is one of the core questions and Professor Tonra suggests the Attorney General, for example, or other legal opinion. How important is it to have transparency and make publicly available the international law basis or UN Charter interpretation on which an action is to be taken? While there does not seem to be any recourse in the Bill, what recourse would any of the witnesses suggest there should be where the Oireachtas, a citizen or any other party believes that an action or a deployment is not consistent with international law? The language seems very loose here.

My final point is for Mr. Noonan. Again and again we have been hearing whether the UN protects Irish neutrality. Does Irish neutrality contribute to the protection of the UN and international law and to credibility? I note that Mr. Noonan has very concrete ways in which he believes we can have a particular credible role when it comes to international law and the UN. For me, that is the core of neutrality.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will just allow that to be answered.

Comment on this
Mr. Joe Noonan

As I mentioned earlier, we sometimes underestimate the quality and potential of Ireland's role. The world as it is is looking for alternative models. I think the old ways are going. They are seen as destructive and self-destructive. We need to build on what we have. In my paper I quote Michèle Griffin from a conference in Dublin Castle a few years ago. In answer to the question as to what the real threats were, she shocked everybody by saying that to billions of people the real threats are climate change and gender-based violence. How do we shape the entirety of our society, not just our military, to counter those threats? We really need to question the in-built assumptions and silo-based thinking that we bring to bear on too many problems.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Do any of the other witnesses want to address anything else?

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

That is a genuine issue, which is why I suggest using either the Attorney General or independent counsel. I know there is an issue in terms of the Oireachtas having independent legal advice. I would encourage the committee members to investigate that. It would be a useful to their considerations in looking at a mission.

Comment on this

It would need to be publicly available.

Comment on this
Professor Ben Tonra

Absolutely.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will give the last word to Mr. Murphy.

Comment on this
Mr. Ciarán Murphy

The criteria are set down in the Bill. Obviously, anybody can challenge whether the mission meets those criteria. Governments have previously published legal advice and offered legal advice to Members of the Oireachtas. In this case that is potentially available to do again, but it would be a matter for the government of the day.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

On behalf of the committee, I again thank the Professor Tonra, Mr. Noonan and Mr. Murphy for giving their time this morning. I also thank them for the material which was circulated to the committee members in advance of today's meeting.

Comment on this