We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Defence and National Security

General Scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025: Discussion (Resumed)

Summary

Witnesses from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance and the Transnational Institute argued that the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025 would dismantle the triple lock, weaken Irish neutrality and allow Irish troops to join EU or NATO-led missions without a UN mandate. They said the change could be unconstitutional, would expose Ireland to pressure to deploy in foreign wars, and would make the Dáil’s own approval an inadequate safeguard. Members questioned whether the triple lock really protects neutrality, whether it limits sovereignty, and what alternatives might replace it. The witnesses insisted it is a minimum check worth keeping, and urged either retaining it or enshrining neutrality more firmly in the Constitution.

Contributions 1–218 of 434. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Apologies have been received from Deputy Catherine Callaghan.

The joint committee is continuing its pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the defence (amendment) Bill 2025. I welcome on behalf of the committee Mr. Stephen Kelly from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance, and Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain from the Transnational Institute. They are very welcome. The witnesses are here to discuss the general scheme of the Bill. The format of the meeting is that I will invite each witness to make an opening statement, which is to be followed by questions from members of the committee. Each member has a seven-minute slot to ask questions and for witnesses to respond.

I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member partaking via Microsoft Teams to confirm formally prior to making a contribution to the meeting that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.

Both members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that any such direction be complied with. As the witnesses will probably be aware, the committee will publish their opening statements on its website following the meeting.

I invite Mr. Kelly to make his opening statement, which will be followed by statements by Ms Ní Bhriain.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I thank the committee very much for inviting me here. The Peace and Neutrality Alliance was established was established almost 30 years ago to advocate the right of the Irish people to their own independent foreign policy with positive neutrality as its key component. We advocate a constitutional amendment to enshrine neutrality in the Constitution and for a Danish-type protocol to exclude Ireland from further militarisation of the EU.

We have had both successes and defeats over those years. One of the key successes was both in 2002 and 2009 securing an agreement that the Lisbon and Nice referendums would only be passed if the triple lock remained in place. We strongly oppose the proposed removal of the triple lock, representing in our view a reneging on these solemn commitments. We argue that doing so without a further referendum would risk being unconstitutional.

We are gravely concerned that there is no meaningful limit on where Irish troops could be sent under the proposed new legislation. This is particularly worrying given the ever-more unpredictable and unstable nature of the world we find ourselves in. We completely reject that the Dáil or Government self-certifying its compliance with international law would be an adequate safeguard. The move to abolish the triple lock is based on a caricature of the UN Security Council.

In fact, far from being a deadlocked, veto-riven entity, between 2020 and 2024, 264 out of 284 resolutions voted on at the council were passed, with no permanent member casting a negative vote.

I will finish with a quote from Éamon De Valera when addressing the League of Nations in Geneva in 1936:

All the small States can do, if the statesmen of the greater States fail in their duty, is resolutely to determine that they will not become the tools of any great Power and that they will resist with whatever strength they may possess every attempt to force them into a war against their will.

I thank the committee very much and I am very happy to take questions.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Go raibh maith agat. I call Ms Ní Bhriain.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak. This Bill would severely erode Irish neutrality, a policy that has characterised Ireland's engagement with the world since the foundation of the State and one that has kept Ireland safe and served it well through a world war, a Cold War and a so-called "global war on terror". If Ireland abandons the triple lock and begins deploying troops on EU-led and, potentially, NATO-led missions, it may embroil Ireland in foreign wars that have nothing to do with us and may expose Ireland to attack. Considering that Irish troops already participate in EU battle group training exercises, future deployment on EU-led and, potentially, NATO-led missions is not something that is unlikely but, rather, a foregone conclusion if the triple lock is abolished. Members should seriously think and question whether such deployments could ever be compatible with Irish neutrality and reflect on the grave and inherent risks that will stem from approving legislation that would permit those deployments to take place.

The EU, like the UN, was born out of the ashes of the Second World War, but it has clearly lost its way. There is mounting evidence that the EU does not uphold international law. Its approval of Israel throughout the commission of a genocide is a case in point. There are other examples. For Ireland to retreat from UN peacekeeping missions and participate in EU battle groups is hugely problematic. The EU’s training mission in Mali is a case in point in this regard. Numerous Defence Forces personnel participated in the training of the Malian armed forces. The Malian national security forces received training and finance from the EU, and later went on to participate in two coups and horrific human rights violations that saw hundreds of civilians killed. Irish troops were involved in training those Malian soldiers. This is characteristic of the EU training missions and not an isolated case.

I will finish by reflecting on some conversations I had that took place during a neutrality roadshow, a people-led initiative that saw 22 events take place over 30 days across 19 counties and which engaged hundreds of people. People across Ireland expressed deep concern and alarm at the wholesale erosion of Irish neutrality. Many did not realise that neutrality was not protected in the Constitution. The wilful obfuscation by the Government regarding the triple lock has left many people feeling blindsided and ill-equipped to challenge the Government's narrative, although they instinctively know - in the same way we did with the Nice and Lisbon treaties - that something fundamental is taking shape. I feel a particular responsibility to mothers, family members of Defence Forces personnel, teenagers and former peacekeepers, who shared their stories with me during the neutrality roadshow and expressed genuine fear at what may lie ahead if the triple lock is abolished.

We need to be very clear that this Bill is about putting people in harm’s way. I urge all members of the committee to scrutinise and vote on this legislation as though they were sending their own sons and daughters to be deployed with EU battle groups. Those members who do vote in favour of and enact this legislation should know that if Irish personnel are deployed to future wars from which they return maimed, traumatised or perhaps in body bags – no one returns from war unscathed – their cards will have been marked and voting in favour of this legislation will be their legacy. I thank the committee.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Go raibh maith agat. I open the meeting now to questions from members. Each member will have seven minutes and it is up to individuals to use their time however they so wish. Non-members will have five minutes. I call Deputy Brian Stanley.

Comment on this

I welcome Ms Ní Bhriain and Mr. Kelly. I also see Mr. Roger Cole in the Public Gallery. I have met Mr. Cole several times down through the years on various campaigns. It is good to see him here. Starting with the declarations, I was involved in the campaigns on the Lisbon and Nice treaties, the Single European Act and various other issues over the years. I can recall these declarations. I thank Mr. Kelly for providing the copies of them, which I read again this morning. I note these are national declarations and not made by a political party or a government. They were made on behalf of the Irish people and are attached to the Nice and Lisbon treaties. I recall that the late Raymond Crotty took a case to the Supreme Court in 1986, which he won. That ensured we would have referendums on all other subsequent major changes in terms of integration into the European Union. I am in favour of being part of the European Union, by the way. I might have some disagreements about what shape it takes, but I think it is a good thing that we are in a Common Market and a Union, whatever faults the latter may have. Do the witnesses envisage a constitutional challenge to this change being taken in the courts if it is passed in legislation?

Turning to the veto, the document submitted to the committee helpfully sets out the number of occasions when the veto was not used. It was stated that "264 out of 284 resolutions voted on at the Council were passed with no power exercising a veto." The witnesses might address this aspect in terms of reform of the Security Council. I recognise that things are not the way they should be in the context of the permanent members of the Security Council. I remember lobbying in Geneva for Ireland to have a place as a non-permanent member several years ago. People there from different political persuasions were very receptive to the case we were making because Ireland was an independent state that had been colonised. One part of the country is still somewhat colonised, but, thankfully, work is in progress there. The fact we were a neutral state meant that states that had been formed out of former colonies in the southern hemisphere, in particular, were very open to our case, as indeed were others. This helped Ireland to get a place as a non-permanent member on the Security Council. I see the need for non-permanent members to have an equal say at the UN Security Council as one of the reforms that must happen.

On the question around us abdicating our responsibilities - Ms Ní Bhriain might address this point - we are piggybacking on Uncle Sam and John Bull. The RAF and the Yanks look after us. I ask the witnesses to comment on that.

Mention was also made of self-certification. The Government has a majority in the Dáil and would be self-certifying. The argument is made that this is democracy and we have sovereignty. The Irish people have elected parties to the Dáil, a government is formed from those members and that government is democratically elected. We all accept that is the case. The point being made is that this is the ultimate sovereignty. I ask the witnesses to address that argument.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I thank Deputy Stanley very much.

Regarding the declaration, I cannot predict whether there will or will not be a constitutional challenge.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

There is a good chance of it. I do not know whether it would be successful but there is every chance there could be a constitutional challenge. Advocates of neutrality have won referendums previously. There was the Crotty case and there were the McKenna and Coughlan cases. They were technically on the issue of divorce but they constituted strategic litigation. I draw the committee's attention to the case of Tomás Heneghan v. The Minister for Housing, Planning & Local Government & Ors. In that case, Mr. Justice Murray in the Supreme Court said that when a referendum is held, the commitment given by the Government to the people in that context constitutes a type of pact between the people and their elected representatives. That was in a different context so the facts were not the same. It was in the context of the Senate referendum in 1979, which a lot of people would forget about so the facts are a bit more obscure. A possible argument could be made in this case that a commitment was similarly given. It was not part of the official legislation the same way in 1979. It was not part of what was exactly on the ballot paper but a commitment was given and it was embodied in the Referendum Commission literature, which was distributed to every house in the country and paid for by the taxpayer. That could allow for a referendum to succeed if this is passed by the Dáil without another referendum.

As regards the veto, taking it from a first principles perspective, nobody would have designed the UN as it is. It does not make any sense in principle or theory why certain members have a permanent position while others do not. We all know the history, which is that those five permanent members were the victors in the Second World War and insisted on that place in order to set up the United Nations. I am very keen to listen to any alternative anyone has in terms of reforming the UN and the Security Council provided it is not something that results in the collapse of the UN because that is a very real risk. We know what happened with the League of Nations. It did not have the buy-in from the big powers. This needs to be avoided. Until such time as there is a workable alternative, we have to stick with the United Nations because it is better than the law of the jungle.

I will deal briefly with abdicating responsibility. I do not accept that we have a responsibility to defend Europe. We have a responsibility first of all to protect ourselves. There were three neutral states during the Cold War - Yugoslavia, Finland and Austria - that were in Russia's back garden and were never invaded. They adhered scrupulously to their neutrality so the idea that Russia is going to invade us when it has not even invaded those neutral states in their back garden is not really credible so I do not think we have a security obligation in that way.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses, as well as Mr. Roger Cole. My first question has been partially answered. The Peace and Neutrality Alliance submission underlines very clearly its view that the legislation as currently framed - and we are dealing with the general scheme rather than the full legislation - could conceivably be unconstitutional. Could the witnesses expand on that?

There has been some discussion about the intentions of this Government. It is not necessarily about this Government. One has to consider future Governments when one frames legislation. Removing the triple lock potentially exposes a future Irish Government to significant pressure from other major countries in the EU or NATO regarding the deployment of troops. Does removing the triple lock expose Ireland to greater pressure diplomatically and politically?

The legislation very significantly hinges on the removal of triple lock. I do not believe it is about the amendment or adjustment of the triple lock. As far as I am concerned, it is about its removal. That removes the need for a UN mandate and, therefore, without a UN mandate, we are looking at more or less three things. They are a multilateral group of countries operating together, an EU mission or a NATO mission. Regarding NATO, could the witnesses give an outline of their sense of where NATO is deployed and the nature of the type of deployment? How do they see future EU missions being deployed? The majority of people here and the majority of people in the country support membership of the EU for a variety of reasons - social, economic and so on. However, they also have concerns about the direction of the EU regarding defence, security and potential militarisation. I do not know if there is always an awareness of the type of missions the EU has deployed on. Ireland has not always participated in them because of our neutrality, to the extent that we have neutrality, but I am not sure that there is always an awareness. The witnesses spoke about Mali. Are there other examples in terms of missions led by the EU that would cause concern that if Irish troops were to participate in, we could no longer categorise Ireland as being neutral in such circumstances?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

EU missions have been rolled out since 2003. Once the Nice treaty was enacted, the EU started deploying military missions across Africa. They started in the Balkans and there have also been deployments in Somalia in the Red Sea area. These have been hugely problematic. The Mali example is not an isolated case. Niger is another example where a mission was approved. The EU started sending in financial support to buy serious contingents of lethal military equipment. That started in February 2023 and by the summer of 2023, there was a coup using the very same funding that the EU had sent and the lethal equipment that had been purchased by the EU for Niger. Mali is an example where the EU is training soldiers. Two coups took place while the EU troops were there. Mozambique is another example where EU training missions are taking place and then there are horrific human rights violations. I set some of them out in the submission. There is ample evidence that the EU missions have nothing to do with peace. They do not bring peace. One can see a track record of where the missions go in and there is more and more instability instead of less. Mali is a case in point but there are various examples.

Regarding the pressure point and deployment, an EU battle group has never been deployed. They train constantly and the most recent training exercise was in Hungary in March and April 2025 when 139 Irish troops took part in that training exercise. It says in EU documents that they will deploy within five days. That is the idea. In those five days, without a triple lock and with the pressure coming from Brussels, that is the pressure the Government is going to be under to send Irish people. It is said very clearly that these are combat conflict missions to be deployed outside the EU under an EU mandate. That is the pressure the Government is going to be under and it will have five days to decide whether to send Irish troops. This is clearly not enough. We need a safeguard. This is Ireland becoming embroiled in a foreign war on behalf of the EU in an instance that has nothing to do with us.

As regards NATO, Ireland has had a Partnership for Peace agreement with NATO since 1999. NATO is a war alliance. Partnership for Peace is a stepping stone into being part of NATO. I do not think the Government has any intention of becoming a full member but we do not need to be a full member. We are already so closely aligned with NATO and the EU. In the words of Ursula von der Leyen, the EU is "one Union, one Alliance, united in purpose". That is a quotation from Ursula von der Leyen as regards the EU and NATO and that relationship. Often it is said we are not going to become a member of NATO. We do not need to be a member. We are already so closely aligned that if this legislation is enacted, we can be sent without any safeguard at all on any NATO mission. We have seen NATO participate in invasions in Libya, in the Balkans early on, in Serbia, in Afghanistan and in Iraq. We are opening ourselves up to having Irish troops sent on those missions if we approve this legislation.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I will start off by stating once again that the triple lock is a red herring and that we should be spending our time on other things to do with the Defence Forces.

I will give the witnesses a definition of sovereignty. Sovereignty refers to the supreme authority and power of a state or governing body to rule itself without interference from outside sources. In politics, it is the backbone of national independence. A sovereign country controls its own laws, borders, economy and foreign relations. First, do the witnesses regard Ireland as a sovereign state when it is in some way subservient to the United Nations Security Council when it comes to the deployment of its own troops?

Second, I would like to see some empirical evidence of how the triple lock interacts with neutrality, given that Ray Murphy and Ben Tonra have both agreed that Ireland does not meet the criteria as set down in international law with respect to neutrality. Ms Ní Bhriain spoke about returning from missions with trauma. Our soldiers return from missions with trauma already. Jadotville is a case in point. The soldiers who came back from Jadotville are still suffering the trauma they went through.

As for the final point I would like the witnesses to address, Ms Ní Bhriain spoke about pressure from without. We are not a member of NATO, we are not a member of any military alliance, yet our Taoiseach yesterday was told by the Japanese Prime Minister that Japan is deeply concerned at the lack of defence in this country, particularly when it comes to Internet cables. Mr. Kelly said we are not under attack from Russia. Russia is just the common enemy, it seems, but we were attacked by Russia and it cost our Health Service Executive millions of euro to put that right.

It strikes me that the triple lock is a hamstring for the Government. Why is it that when the witnesses advocate for a referendum, they do not advocate for one to allow for all Houses of the Oireachtas to have a say on where our troops are deployed and, when deployed, or if a question arises to deploy them, they set the bar so high in that referendum that it makes it very difficult for a country to just send troops away wherever it wants? It is my view that the three Houses - the President, the Seanad and the Dáil - should be the people deciding where our troops are deployed.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Russia did not attack our health service. That was an attack carried out by an entity called Wizard Spider, which was an organised crime group, which I understand no longer exists. It consisted of a relatively small number of people in-----

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

They were not state-sponsored. They were a relatively small number of people in and around the St. Petersburg area. Russia is a country-----

Comment on this

Well, let us not waste time on that then. We will move on.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Well, it is a very important point. Stating that Russia attacked our country is very serious. The most serious attack we have ever had was the Dublin-Monaghan bombings in 1974, and that was not perpetrated by Russia.

As regards sovereignty, we are a sovereign country. Article 25 of the UN Charter makes clear that member states have to agree to adhere to and implement decisions of the Security Council. Therefore, if the triple lock is an infringement of our sovereignty, so is Article 25 of the United Nations Charter.

As regards neutrality and the triple lock, they are not the same thing but they are related. The triple lock is a close cousin of neutrality rather than being exactly the same thing. Because we unfortunately do not have neutrality in the Constitution, the triple lock is one of the best things we have in the absence of that. It is really in the absence of clearer legal safeguards that we think the triple lock should be maintained. We did not advocate for Yes votes in the second Nice and Lisbon referendums because they did not go far enough, notwithstanding that they had the triple lock.

Regarding a referendum, is the Senator suggesting that we would have a referendum each time there is a decision to have a deployment as an alternative to the triple lock? It is-----

Comment on this

Come on now. I specifically said, if the witnesses want a referendum, it should empower all three sections of the Oireachtas, namely, the President, the Seanad and the Dáil. Rather than looking to an outside agency, you would look inward.

Mr. Kelly quotes the United Nations. What about regional deployments? The triple lock prevents us from participating in regional deployments, which are a part of the United Nations Security Council Charter Mr. Kelly speaks of. He is happy enough to use one part of the charter and not that happy to use the other part.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Regional deployments can be permitted under the UN Charter but not always. For example, in 1999, NATO's attack on Yugoslavia was not authorised by the United Nations, so it depends on the facts. We have no problem in principle with regional deployments taking place where they are approved by the UN.

I will hand over to Ms Ní Bhriain.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

To continue on that point, the idea that the Security Council has a say over where we send our troops is disingenuous. This is where the Government pins its argument but it is a flawed argument. What the Security Council does is mandate a peacekeeping mission in general. The way the Government frames it, it is as though the members all sit down around a table and say, "Can we approve Ireland's participation in this mission?" That is not what happens. The Government frames it as though they are sitting in New York and saying Ireland can or cannot go on this mission. No. They take a list of criteria on whether, as a Security Council, they can approve a mission and then they approve it, and then it has the backing of the world's most powerful nations.

Comment on this

In fairness, I think the Irish people are not that silly. It is very clear that once United Nations Security Council clearance is given for an operation, we can deploy troops if we so wish. Without that we cannot, and it is as simple as that.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, but, like I said, I have spent over a month going around Ireland speaking to hundreds of people, and people simply do not know what is going on with the triple lock because the Government has fudged and led false and disingenuous arguments.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

People simply do not understand the functioning of the United Nations Security Council. The way the Government frames it, it is as though they are sitting around a table deciding whether Ireland should be allowed to deploy, yes or no, when they are actually approving a mandate in general and then, once it is approved, we deploy. As Micheál Martin himself said on the Dáil floor in 2013, that is at the core of our neutrality. If we deploy on a mission that does not have UN mandate support, we are necessarily taking sides in a conflict. The discussion that took place around sending potentially a coalition of the willing that Keir Starmer mentioned into Ukraine is an example. If we were to join that coalition of the willing, that would be an example of Ireland joining a mission that would not-----

Comment on this

We have already provided military aid to Ukraine.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Exactly, and that is also a violation of Irish neutrality.

Comment on this

I said it on the floor of the Seanad.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

The triple lock is the bare minimum that we need to protect. Then we need to have a much bigger conversation about what kind of Ireland we want going forward as the world becomes more unstable, as we edge closer and closer to all-out war. What kind of Ireland do we want? Do we want to be part of a military alliance that exposes us to attack or do we want to preserve our neutrality? As a small state, we have never been a military power and we should never-----

Comment on this

Does Ms Ní Bhriain honestly think that if there is all-out war, our little island will be left alone?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Well, there was all-out war before and our island was left alone.

Comment on this

No, it was not. We provided safe passage for the Allies right through the Second World War.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, but tens of millions of people were killed and Ireland was a country in Europe which managed to save-----

Comment on this

Thousands of our people died - thousands.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Time. I am sorry. I have allowed enough time for the witnesses to answer. I call Deputy Ryan O'Meara.

Comment on this

I wish to start with the example Ms Ní Bhriain gave of the Mali case and the number of troops who were sent there. Was a triple lock required for them to be sent?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

There is a carve-out within the Defence (Amendment) Act 2006 that permits us to participate in training exercises. For example, the reason we can go on the training exercises with the EU battle group in Hungary that I mentioned, and other training exercises, is because of that carve-out. In the case of Mali, I am not sure of the specifics of how the lawyers within the Defence Forces looked at it but it is a training exercise and there is a permission within the Defence (Amendment) Act 2006 to participate in training exercises.

Comment on this

It does not need the mandate of the Security Council.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

If it is a training exercise similar to the EU battle group training exercises, it would not necessarily because of the carve-out in the Act.

Comment on this

That one in particular did not receive the mandate.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Not that I know of. I do not think so.

Comment on this

I believe it was Mr. Kelly who mentioned Yugoslavia, Austria and Finland as three neutral countries, particularly with regard to the Soviet Union. How many of them had the triple lock that helped protect their neutrality at the time?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

None of them had the same legislation we have but they all had different legal protections. Austria's neutrality dates back to its state treaty when it got its independence. Its neutrality has a very clear legal and constitutional basis. Yugoslavia no longer exists. I do not know exactly what the legal basis was for its neutrality or for Finland's neutrality but while other neutral countries may not have the triple lock, they have different protections. In many cases, these are protections that go beyond the triple lock. Malta, for example, has neutrality in its constitution-----

Comment on this

In a lot of cases, are their protections the democratic systems within their own countries?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

The triple lock is a protection within the democratic system of our country.

Comment on this

It is also outside of it. We are relying on the UN Security Council.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

You could say the same thing about our membership of the UN. Would the Deputy advocate we leave the UN?

Comment on this

None of those many other neutral countries in the world is relying on the triple lock to protect their neutrality.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

None of them has the exact provisions we have in respect of the triple lock. There is disingenuousness on the part of people who want to be in the United Nations and simultaneously not comply with the UN Charter. The triple lock does no more or less than ensure we are doing what we already should be doing as members of the UN by ensuring the UN Security Council is protected. It codifies it in Irish law, and that is the way it should be.

Comment on this

I have asked a number of witnesses about my next point. It is the one I really struggle to get my head around. It is from those who believe we need to keep the triple lock in order to protect our neutrality. It is, essentially, that we would rather trust the Security Council to protect our neutrality and have given over our sovereignty, or some part of our sovereignty, to the Security Council, particularly the likes of China, Russia and the US, rather than trust the people who elected us to these Houses to protect a neutrality we all stand for. That is a point I just cannot get my head around - anyone coming in here to present that we would genuinely rather maintain the triple lock and allow the veto to continue rather than taking a second look at a mechanism within these Houses that would continue to protect our neutrality while trusting the democratically elected people of these Houses more than we trust the veto.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I will take a minute on this. With greatest respect to all present, politicians need to have a certain sense of perspective about why they are elected. People do not elect politicians because they think they are fantastic or the best people that could possibly represent them. They often elect them on the basis of a Hobson's choice. They do not elect politicians because they want them to have unlimited control over everything. They elect them as part of a constitutional framework of checks and balances. The triple lock is not in the Constitution, but it is part of a framework of checks and balances. We can take this tabloidesque view of it being "Putin's veto" or whatever. It is a framework, we would argue, of checks and balances that is necessary. One can always drill down into specifics and ask why a particular country in certain circumstances has a veto power over Irish troops. It is a framing-----

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

-----and it is a framing I do not agree with. One could say that Cabinet decisions are supposed to be made by unanimity. One could ask why the Minister for sport should have a say over what the Minister for Finance decides should be spent in agriculture or whatever.

Comment on this

That brings me to my final point-----

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

One can always pick these things apart. It is about looking at it as a whole.

Comment on this

-----because the Constitution allows for exactly that at Cabinet but does not demand the triple lock. My final point is on the argument for a referendum. I do not know of any referendum mandated in this country that does not explicitly change the Constitution. Therefore, if we are not explicitly changing the Constitution with the removal of the triple lock, why do the witnesses think their argument in regard to a referendum holds up?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I might come in on the previous point. The Deputy said he could not get his head around the narrative that was being rolled out. I cannot get my head around it either because it makes no sense. The logic, narrative and rationale being put forward by the Government that the Security Council somehow has a veto over Irish troops is simply not the case. It does not have a veto over Irish troops. I have explained that already; it is in my submission. It can veto missions, but once a mission gets the backing of the organisations tasked with and responsible for international peace and security, we can deploy on it. Why would we want to deploy on any mission that did not have the backing of the United Nations? The framing is completely disingenuous. The Deputy is right; many people cannot get their heads around it because it is absolute nonsense.

On the vetoes, I went through every single Russian veto - I have them here - since the beginning of the nineties to check if there had ever been an instance where Russia had vetoed a peacekeeping mission such that Ireland could not participate. There was not one instance ever where Russia vetoed a peacekeeping mission. This legislation is not necessary. The Government is laying out a case to do something that it does not need to do and it would be much better if the Government was honest about what its intentions actually are, which is to send troops on EU battle groups and potentially NATO-led missions, and not get lost and entangled in the inner workings of the UN Security Council.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will go to Senator Tom Clonan but are there any other permanent members who wish to indicate before I go to the non-permanent members? Now everyone puts a hand up. Senator Clonan can continue.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for attending. We are coming to the end of our pre-legislative scrutiny of this Bill. With specific reference to the triple lock and its impact on neutrality, I want to summarise and ask the witnesses questions about it.

On 1 July, we had a number of very experienced military officers, some with a combined total of over 150 years of military service. In our questioning of them, it was confirmed absolutely and categorically that any missions assigned to Irish troops outside of the UN Security Council mandate were likely to be peace enforcement or war-fighting missions. The days of peacekeeping in the old sense of having the consent of all the belligerent parties are over in this new reality of a multipolar world with accelerating threats and hybrid threats. Our troops will be engaged in peace enforcement almost exclusively, which is war fighting. We gave the example of the UN mission to Korea, which turned into a full war with a land invasion and, more recently, the UN intervention in Afghanistan, which evolved into full-spectrum combat operations.

We also learned from the Department of Defence back in May that if the triple lock was removed and the legislation was enacted as drafted, Irish troops could have been sent to invade Iraq back in 2003. The Department of Defence also confirmed that if this legislation was enacted as written, Irish troops could be sent to join any coalition of the willing of troops in a future environment. Finally, to frame my question, it was also confirmed here by my former colleagues and fellow veterans that such is the number of troops Ireland can deploy meaningfully - which is battalion-minus or, in fact, just north of a company - that Irish troops sent into these peace enforcement or war-fighting scenarios will inevitably come under direct command of foreign higher formations.

In light of those findings that have been made very clear to the committee, do the witnesses think that this - it is not an amendment of the triple lock, but its removal - will fundamentally change the nature of Ireland's military service overseas and how we are perceived in the world? Does that have an impact on our neutrality?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Yes, it will fundamentally change it because it will mean that any mission we have been invited to take part in, that we have not taken part in to date because of the triple lock, we could take part in.

That was the case with the Iraq War, as Ms Bernie Maguire confirmed on the first day. In the case of Iraq, the UK self-certified that it complied with international law. The British Attorney General was pressured to provide legal advice saying that, which I have explained in our submission in some detail.

The real concern with any possible war-fighting force we could take part in is the possibility of direct confrontation with nuclear-armed Russia. The European Commission's White Paper for European Defence – Readiness 2030 identified Russia as being the key threat. That is consistent with the rhetoric that has emanated from numerous EU figures and is the key factor behind this drive to accelerate EU militarisation. Everything in the EU's White Paper is consistent with that. Among other things, it calls for the acquisition of capabilities for high-intensity warfare. That is not a peacekeeping mission where one is simply playing a supervisory role. It is high-intensity warfare, like is seen in Ukraine. It is about having the capacity to make deep precision strikes in enemy territory, which is, again, clearly targeted at a country like Russia, with a vast landmass. That would be the biggest concern and it is a realistic concern because of, for example, EU leaders such as President Macron calling for direct deployment to Ukraine and Sir Keir Starmer's coalition of the willing.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I have a copy of the White Paper here. I do not know if everyone here has read it. I recommend that everyone do so. It is effectively a war plan. It sets out, step by step, the different stages that Europe will take between now and 2030 to engage in active war fighting. As the Senator says, this language is terrifying. As we sit in this room, we should be discussing strengthening legislation to ensure we do not become involved in a war. We are actually sitting here discussing how to remove legislation to permit that eventuality to happen. Have we lost our minds? We should be sitting here talking about how to strengthen our neutrality and keep ourselves out of war. Instead, we are thinking about how we can distort our understanding of the UN Security Council vetoes so that we can permit Ireland to participate.

Comment on this

I am sorry to cut across Ms Ní Bhriain. My time is brief. On 29 May, the Department of Defence confirmed explicitly that the upper limit of 12 troops did not apply when Ireland required to send our troops on a rescue mission, for example, to evacuate Irish citizens from a foreign airport. It does not apply when we send troops, if we wish to, to provide assistance to our neighbours or partners with man-made or natural disasters, secondary to climate change and so on. The Department of Defence set out quite clearly that the upper limit of 12 bears no relationship whatsoever to our ability to deploy troops in those situations. Does Ms Ní Bhriain agree that the triple lock has no bearing whatsoever on our agility or capacity to respond as we see fit, as crises arise, on a case-by-case basis, and that it only applies to formally mandated international missions, which is an entirely different matter?

My last question has two parts. All the evidence we have heard here from Professor Ray Murphy, the professor of law who appeared here on 12 June, and from Mr. Conway who was here last week is that any future Government can send any number of Irish troops anywhere in the world by simple Dáil majority. Do the witnesses think that safeguards should be put in place to replace the triple lock in that context? Do the witnesses think that the Irish people - the citizens of this country - are ahead of the current Government with regard to how they feel about this and its implications for our perceived neutrality?

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will allow the witnesses to answer briefly but the Senator's time is up.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

On the 12 troops and the deployment, it is clear in the Defence (Amendment) Act 2006 that troops can be sent overseas for evacuation missions. It is clearly set out in law, so I agree with this.

Comment on this

There is no upper limit.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

There is no limit, so we can participate in evacuation missions. That is allowed for in the 2006 Act. This or any future Government can send any number of troops anywhere with a simple Dáil majority vote, as the Senator said. That is why this is terrifying and why we need to be really serious about what we are talking about here.

Yes, the Irish people are ahead.

Regarding the 2030 readiness plan, when I participated in the neutrality roadshow, I spoke to hundreds of people. A mother came up to me. She had calculated the number of years as I was speaking, and she said, terrified, that she had just realised that her son would be 18 when this kicked off and the 2030 plan was ready to go. She asked would he be sent off to war. That is the reality and that is why people in Ireland are ahead. It is about sending Irish people off to war. We need to be very clear about it.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for attending. I have a number of questions for them. I commend them on having those roadshows about neutrality. It is useful to try to engage. They made a point that we should be having a discussion about what sort of future Ireland we want. That is important. My view on many of these discussions is that this is really the first stepping stone. Perhaps there could be a similar series of roadshows with a wider discussion. Neutrality is a limited focus. As an academic, I know that would result in a self-selected audience as opposed to the wider discussion of where we want Ireland to be and the explanation to people about how the world is changing. From talking to people, I find that they are terrified about how the world is changing. They are looking at what is happening in Gaza and Ukraine and at our close former allies and how their attitudes are changing, and they are wondering where the world is going. That is part of a wider discussion that we need to have. I see this debate as part of that. It is a step on the road to try to put us in a position where we are better able to engage in this changing this world.

Where UN Security Council approval may have been useful in the past, we are no longer finding it useful because of the reasons that have been articulated by many previous witnesses. The witnesses here talked about the vetoes. Many witnesses who have come before us have said that if it is thought that something will be turned down, it will not even be pressed to a vote. That is why votes are no longer being taken on these things. That has been restricting us as a country from participating. As another witness said, it has resulted in us being regarded as unreliable partners with the people who we regard as close allies and countries we want to work with on this.

The witnesses quoted Éamon de Valera, saying that he did not want us to be the tools of any great power. Is that not effectively where we are at the moment by having the triple lock? Are we not giving our power to the five permanent members of the Security Council to decide what we do as a country? It fundamentally goes against everything that Éamon de Valera would have stood for himself. In my view, it completely undermines our independence and sovereignty. Does any other neutral country require this or are we alone on this?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

This point has been made over and over again about the Security Council. It does not impose a veto on Ireland specifically. It mandates peacekeeping missions on the basis of the information that it has before it. Once the mandate is given, Ireland deploys on those missions. The Deputy said the Security Council was defunct, but at the moment, there are 11 active peacekeeping missions around the world. Ireland can participate in any and all of those missions, without any impediment, as we wish. We can continue to participate in peacekeeping with a UN mandate if we wish. This is not something that has fallen apart entirely and those mandates are regularly renewed, as was laid out clearly by Mr. Kelly.

On the idea that the world is changing, we are sitting here talking about defence readiness for 2030. Europe is heading into war. We are sitting here talking about that and the Deputy's conclusion is that that is where we would need to be, that the Security Council is not working as it should, so we should-----

Comment on this

We are not talking about that. We are talking about specific legislation here.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, but if that legislation is enacted, that is exactly where we will find ourselves. We are saying the world is changing. If the world is changing, why would we come to a conclusion that allows us to act outside of the United Nations?

There is nothing to be gained from Ireland acting outside of the United Nations. If, tomorrow, the United Nations shut down its peacekeeping and said peacekeeping was over and it would not do any more UN peacekeeping missions, I still would not advocate for Ireland to send troops on EU, NATO or any other missions. I would advocate for Ireland to do more of what we did on the cluster munitions legislation and the legacy of Frank Aiken on nuclear non-proliferation. Ireland has an incredible legacy on peace that goes beyond peacekeeping missions. They are just one part of it. If we look at the direction the world is going in, it is going in a very bad direction. If the conclusion we draw from that is to decide to deploy our troops on EU battle group missions, that just would not follow.

Comment on this

Ms Ní Bhriain is making a huge leap there. We are talking about one specific thing and there are an awful lot of shoulds, woulds and coulds being mentioned.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Ireland participates in EU battle group training exercises. In March and April, 139 troops went to Hungary. Right now, we cannot deploy on a battle group mission because of the triple lock. Why are we participating in the training exercises if we do not plan to deploy?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

It is interesting that Deputy O'Connell would suggest Ireland is perceived as being an unreliable partner by allies - I think that was the phrase she - because we are not in a military alliance and a neutral country does not have allies.

Comment on this

I used the term "friends".

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Ireland should not be seeking respectability in the eyes of countries that are arming and equipping Israel and committing a genocide in Gaza.

Comment on this

Just to be very clear, we are not. We are very clear in our position on Gaza and we are alone in Europe on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Is that not precisely the point, that Ireland is an outlier among countries that might want us to be a reliable partner?

Comment on this

Yes, but we get to decide that, not somebody else.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Yes.

Comment on this

That is what I am saying. In our position on Gaza, we have made that decision. With the triple lock, we are allowing other people to make that decision for us. It is quite a significant difference. We are trying to take back our independence here and trying to decide what we want to do as a country and where we want to position ourselves. At the moment, we are hamstrung by this triple lock.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do not agree because it is just a minimum requirement to have UN Security Council approval or approval from the UN General Assembly under the "uniting for peace" jurisdiction. There is no requirement for Ireland to deploy troops where the UN decides to authorise a deployment. A reference was made earlier to the disastrous Korean War which was UN-authorised. We do not envisage Irish troops should simply go wherever the UN wants it to go. It should be a decision of the Dáil and of the Government but the UN is a necessary safeguard.

Comment on this

Mr. Kelly agrees then that just because something is approved by the UN currently, we do not have to participate.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I agree, yes.

Comment on this

Thus, all this is really doing is ensuring we have that flexibility in every decision we make.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. What are the witnesses' attitudes to the deployment of our troops in south Lebanon as part of the UNIFIL mandate?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

It is a very important mandate. It started in the late 1970s and it began because of Israel's invasion of Lebanon. It took place at a time when western countries were much more willing to stand up to Israel, I would say. It is a very important mandate. Irish soldiers have been killed by Israel and Israeli-backed forces down through the years. It is an extremely important mandate.

Comment on this

In relation to the current conflagration in the Middle East, we can see very clearly the US and UK are behind Israel. We can see Russia and China are behind Iran. If Russia or China decided to box clever to further destabilise the situation, either of them could veto the renewal of the UNIFIL mandate that is required in a number of weeks to further destabilise the area in aid of their friends in Tehran. What does Mr. Kelly say to that?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do not agree with that framing of the situation, necessarily. The question is always "What is the alternative?" The fact there may be some missions vetoed, even if they are worthwhile, is, in my view, better than having a free-for-all where the Government can send troops wherever it wants, be that a possible war with Russia or an invasion such as Iraq. I hope the mandate is renewed. It is a very important mission and Ireland has an exemplary record of service. The reason Ireland has an exemplary record of service and is taken so seriously is our scrupulous adherence to only deploying in UN missions, I would argue. I hope the mandate is renewed.

Comment on this

We are talking about UN missions here.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Exactly, yes.

Comment on this

If the mandate is not renewed in August, for whatever reason, the committee was told by other witnesses to the committee we would have to withdraw our troops immediately. It would be an immediate withdrawal which would destabilise that part of south Lebanon, on the border with Israel.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

It is important that the mandate is renewed.

Comment on this

It is important that the mandate is renewed but what happens if Russia or China decides to play games?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

We could say the same of western countries.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

It could be vetoed by-----

Comment on this

The veto would have the same effect, whether it is vetoed by China, Russia, the UK, the US or France.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

The mandate could be vetoed by anyone but by the same logic, if it is vetoed and the UNIFIL mission is wound down, what business would Ireland have being in Lebanon if it does not have a UN mandate? The thing that gives us legitimacy in being there is having a UN mandate, blue helmets and blue berets. When Irish troops came under fire at the end of last year the thing that gave us legitimacy to be there was the UN mandate. If the mandate is vetoed, and I hope it is not and the mission continues, Ireland would have no mandate to be there.

Comment on this

The situation would potentially be destabilised further.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

The destabilising factor would be-----

Comment on this

That is grand, thanks. Mr. Kelly mentioned he would like to see a referendum to enshrine neutrality. If a wording were agreed, the people were agreeable to it and it was passed and became part of the Constitution, would Mr. Kelly be in any way worried about the triple lock legislation in that context?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

It would depend on exactly how the proposal was worded but I would be much less worried in that context because having neutrality, if it is properly worded in the Constitution, would mean necessarily that Ireland could not take sides in foreign wars, so we would not be able to deploy in a combat capacity. It would be implicit, really, whereas it is currently explicit.

Comment on this

Mr. Kelly uses the word "implicit". One of the witnesses at last week's meeting, Mr. Joe Noonan, who is a legal specialist in this area, confirmed to the committee that the courts have recognised, implicitly, our neutrality.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I am not sure they have. I think in the Horgan case it was held that neutrality, as defined in the Hague Conventions, is part of customary international law but, unfortunately, the courts were not able to enforce a ban on Shannon Airport being used by the US military, as was requested, because it has not been formally adopted. I wish that were true but, unfortunately, I do not think it is.

Comment on this

That is what Mr. Noonan says and he is the one who held himself to be an expert in this area, from a legal perspective. For argument's sake, and I know this is not the position either of the witnesses adopt, if the triple lock were to be gone in the morning, can they suggest alternative safeguards Ireland could put in place to protect our position as neutrals?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Somebody else, or maybe it was the Deputy, put the same question to Mr. Ray Murphy. I cannot see any good reason for abandoning the triple lock, so I would not waste my time trying to come up with alternatives. Ireland has a triple lock that has served us really well and we would be very foolish and reckless and it would be playing with fire to decide to get rid of it. As a base minimum, I would keep the triple lock and build on that. Deputy Brabazon referenced Mr. Joe Noonan's interventions. In reference to the court, Mr. Noonan said he would look to have the aspirations mentioned in the Horgan case actually enshrined in law. That is the direction we should go in, in terms of strengthening our neutrality and not eroding it.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for their presentations. I am sorry I was late but I listened to them on the phone. Ms Ní Bhriain stated:

I feel a particular responsibility to mothers, family members of Defence Forces personnel, teenagers and former peacekeepers, who shared their stories with me ... [conveying] genuine fear at what may lie if [the Government abolish the] triple lock.

In her submission, she wrote: "I urge the members of the Committee to scrutinise this legislation as though it were your sons and daughters being deployed on EU battlegroup or NATO-led missions". I speak as a father of a member of the Defence Forces. As I have said to a number of people who have appeared before us as witnesses, we take every item of legislation seriously in these Houses and we take it as if we are dealing with the sons and daughters - or gender-neutral members - of any family, no matter what the legislation is. I assure Ms Ní Bhriain of that. That is what I will be doing and what my colleagues from all sides will be doing.

Mr. Kelly made comments about elected representatives. Has he ever stood for election?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

No, not for public office.

Comment on this

Okay. It is important then that Mr. Kelly realise the fact the people who stand for election put themselves forward. In every election, there are hundreds of people who put themselves forward, whether at local or national level. Some are successful and most are not, but at least they try. I suggest Mr. Kelly try it some time before he makes those comments about public representatives.

I will put my questions. Do the witnesses believe we as a country can be militarily neutral if we cannot defend ourselves? Do they believe the United Nations is a fully functioning organisation? In relation to what Deputy Brabazon asked them, if the triple lock is dispensed with, do they believe there is a function for the Seanad and, indeed, the President as a substitute?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do not particularly appreciate the Senator's comment. The implication that-----

Comment on this

I am sure you do not.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do not appreciate it at all. I am a citizen. I have come here. I was invited to come here. I did not have to. I was invited. I took the day off work. I do not like the implication you need to run for election to have an opinion on something. The TDs are there to serve the public.

Comment on this

I am sorry but you do not degrade Members of the Houses-----

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

How did I degrade them?

Comment on this

-----or question them if you have not put yourself before the public.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

What did I say that degraded a Member of the Houses?

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I think it would be best to move to answering the questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

On the UN being fully functioning, I do not think it is a fully functional organisation but it is better than the alternative. We saw what happened when the League of Nations fell apart. I cannot remember the one about the President and the Seanad.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

On the question of whether we can defend ourselves if we are militarily neutral, one has to ask oneself what it means to defend oneself. For example, let us say the Government is planning on buying fighter jets and having them stationed in Shannon. I am from County Clare and the idea we would have fighter jets on the runway in Shannon terrifies me, especially when we have no functioning hospital in Ennis and people from there have to go to Limerick to get the hospital treatments they need. When we are looking at what we need to defend ourselves, we need to ask what we need to make us feel secure. If we were to ask people in County Clare whether they would feel more secure having fighter jets on the runway in Shannon or having a functioning hospital, I think we would find they would all choose the functioning hospital. Going beyond that, what are we going to do with the fighter jets? If we send them out over the Atlantic and they see a suspicious ship, take aim and fire, what happens next? Imagine that is a Russian ship, for example, because we hear about Russian ships all the time. That means Ireland is in direct conflict with a nuclear power.

The concept of defence really needs to be interrogated. As a small island nation with very limited defence resources, our best and only defence is our neutrality because we could never go up against a nuclear power or any other military and we should never try because the results would be catastrophic. We should make sure we do not get attacked in the first place and that is about maintaining an active neutrality policy. With neutrality, military neutrality and all these concepts, we have to look at what we actually mean when we come to a situation where we are sending a fighter jet over the Atlantic and it ends up taking aim, potentially, at a Russian ship and then Ireland is in conflict with a nuclear power.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

So I would not be buying the fighter jets. The Senator asked about being "militarily neutral if we cannot defend ourselves", but our only defence is our neutrality. We would get wiped off the map if we were to try to defend ourselves militarily.

Comment on this

If tomorrow morning this island was invaded, who would defend us?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

We have to make sure that eventuality does not happen.

Comment on this

But that is nonsense.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

And that is-----

Comment on this

It is actually nonsense

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

It is really not nonsense, though.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

We have not been invaded. We have been-----

Comment on this

It is utopian. I am sorry; we have been invaded. For 800 years, we were invaded.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, but I am talking about since we have had a 26-county Republic.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

That invasion came to an end for the majority of the island due to an asymmetric war that was fought with around 3,000 people, namely, the War of Independence. One way or another, we are never going to be able to compete with a major power on that power's own terms. Only making it hard enough for them to occupy us that they would not bother is the only, I suppose, defence policy that makes sense.

Comment on this

We have to deal with reality here. In an ideal world, everybody would get on with everybody and there would be no war. We spend trillions of dollars as a world looking up into the sky to see if there is anybody else out there but we cannot get on with ourselves. I really appreciate the witnesses' presentations but in other words, they are saying we should not have a front door or a back door on our house because nobody is going to come near us.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

PANA has never opposed the existence of the Defence Forces. We acknowledge there is a necessity to have a relatively small army as a kind of first line of defence, but we have to maintain a sense of proportion. It is never going to be capable of inflicting an outright defeat on a major power. North Korea is the only small country in the world that could do that.

Comment on this

I thank Ms NÍ Bhriain and Mr. Kelly for taking the time out to be here. Since we started this process, we have listened to a number of witnesses from both sides of the argument and I have found it very enlightening. We have got to a point where we need to have a conversation about neutrality and what exactly it means because having listened to the witnesses who have appeared to date, everybody has his or her own idea about what it means. In the world we live in today, that is a conversation we need to have.

Flowing from that, let us take what is going on in Gaza and Ukraine. Do the witnesses agree with this country's stance to date on both conflicts?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

"No" would be the short answer. We have been very strong in our rhetoric on Gaza and very weak in our actions. Francesca Albanese, the UN expert on the occupied Palestinian territories, has said as much. It is a disgrace we have allowed aeroplanes to transit Irish airspace, as has been extensively documented by The Ditch, carrying munitions of war, in many cases to Israel. We were correct to condemn Russia's invasion of Ukraine but I do not agree we were correct to provide training to Ukrainian troops. We should have confined any assistance to humanitarian assistance with organisations such as the Red Cross.

I do not agree with providing lethal training, which is what we have provided because we have provided rifle training to troops.

Comment on this

If I may cut across Mr. Kelly for a second, is this not a simple argument of right and wrong and what side of the fence you are on? Is what the Russians have done to the Ukrainians right? Is it right what is going on in-----

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

No.

Comment on this

Why then does Mr. Kelly have a problem, as I see it from listening to him, taking sides in that argument?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Sorry, is the Senator asking why I have a problem taking sides?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

What we are advocating is that we do not take sides in a military sense.

Comment on this

Is what is going on there right or wrong? That is my question. Does Mr. Kelly agree with it or does he not agree with it?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do not understand.

Comment on this

I do not understand what he is saying to me. Is what the Russians are doing to the people of Ukraine right?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

It is not, no.

Comment on this

Mr. Kelly disagrees with that, so he agrees with the Irish Government's stance that what is going on there is wrong.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I do.

Comment on this

Right, so how does that affect our neutrality? Mr. Kelly is now taking a side in a conflict. I am only asking the question. Is that not contrary to our neutrality?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

In my view, no, because we in PANA advocate positive neutrality, that is, remaining outside of other countries' wars but being robust in standing up for the United Nations and international law. The Russian invasion breached the UN Charter so there was no problem condemning it. We have to be clear that there is a contrived distinction made between so-called political and so-called military neutrality. We advocate neutrality under international law, and under international law there is just neutrality. That is how it is set out in the Hague Conventions and in customary international law. When people say you cannot be neutral because you condemn this, that or the other, it is a misunderstanding of what neutrality means. Neutrality has never meant that you have to maintain strict impartiality in every single view you take. Even in 1939, when the legislation providing for our neutrality was going through the Dáil, de Valera expressed the view that Irish people would naturally sympathise with Poles as they were fighting off the German invaders. That misunderstanding has never been what neutrality has meant.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

To add to that, the way Senator Gallagher has set it out, it would seem that neutrality and international law are almost incompatible, but they are not. I agree with what Mr. Kelly said. The Government has been extremely weak on Palestine. If you look at what the neutrality convention, the Hague Convention, says, it is very clear that we should not be allowing US military troops to use Shannon Airport as they are arming and backing a genocide. That is very clear under the neutrality convention. We have done absolutely nothing, with all the knowledge we have of what is going on in Shannon, about the Israeli overflights transporting weapons. We could rely on neutrality as a legal construct in that convention and enforce that and we would still be in line with our obligations under the Genocide Convention, under which we have an obligation to take steps to prevent as well as punish. We have done nothing to try to prevent the genocide. We continue to trade with Israel. There are a number of steps we could have taken that we have not taken. If we were to take an active neutrality stance and not allow Shannon Airport to be used, that would go a long way towards trying to stop the genocide, which is our obligation under international law.

On Ukraine, I also agree. Of course it was an illegal invasion, and what is happening in Ukraine is absolutely horrific. I do not agree that the Irish Government should be sending Irish troops to train Ukrainian soldiers because that is a violation. That could not possibly be compatible with our neutrality. We should be using-----

Comment on this

Ms Ní Bhriain is happy enough with her stance on neutrality and to let the people of Ukraine be pounded by the Russians. She is happy enough-----

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

They have been pounded regardless. We have been-----

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Senator, please keep your contribution to the legislation we are trying to scrutinise. I know the argument you are developing.

Comment on this

Yes, but both are connected, whether we like it or not.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

They have been pounded regardless of the training we have given them and they will continue to be pounded until some state actually steps up - and it is a real shame that Ireland has not done this - and says we need to negotiate peace. Why is Ireland not using its position within the European Union to say we need peace and we need to bring together the parties and have a negotiation? Ireland is a small-----

Comment on this

With respect to Ms Ní Bhriain, it is Russia that started this. Surely the first thing the Russians have to do is to stop their illegal invasion.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I disagree with that analysis of the conflict.

Comment on this

Fair enough. We are not going to agree on that one.

Does Ms Ní Bhriain agree that we should increase our defence spending in this country to protect ourselves?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I think we need to guarantee that our soldiers have their employment and their accommodation and, if they are sent on foreign missions, that they are paid well. All those things need to be taken care of. Do I think we should be buying anti-tank missiles and fighter jets? No, absolutely not. As I said, I am from Clare. We have a hospital in Ennis that is not functional. People are going to Limerick and spending days on trolleys.

Comment on this

With respect, that is a health issue. That is a health committee job, not-----

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

The money needs to come from somewhere. If you are going to be buying fighter jets, you are not going to be spending-----

Comment on this

There are those who would say we are happy to freeload on the backs of others. What would Ms Ní Bhriain say to that?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I would say that Ireland has had an unwavering commitment to peace throughout our membership of the United Nations. We are the only state that has an unbroken record of peacekeeping missions. I mentioned cluster munitions. There is the nuclear non-proliferation treaty. That is not freeloading; that is building peace. The idea that we are freeloading because we have decided to invest our time, energy and resources in building peace instead of joining a war just does not make sense. We are not freeloading on anyone. We are about building peace.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I call Senator Seán Kyne.

Comment on this

I welcome the witnesses. I seek one bit of clarity first from Ms Ní Bhriain. She said in her contribution of any politician who votes for this Bill, "their cards will have been marked". What does she mean by that?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I mean that it is a public vote and we will see who votes on this, so if a Member votes in favour of this and Irish troops are sent off to war, we will know exactly who has voted on this and who is responsible for this legislation.

Comment on this

Like any legislation.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes.

Comment on this

Okay, so it was not a threat.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Was it a threat from me? No.

Comment on this

It seemed like a threat. It is not a threat.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

No, but I think Members really need to take seriously the responsibility they have been given here.

Comment on this

We do. We are all here. Look at the attendance.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I really hope so, but when I was-----

Comment on this

We are all here.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, but I think when people see the-----

Comment on this

We take our responsibilities very seriously.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I hope so.

Comment on this

It is agreed - I think everyone here agrees - that Russia carried out an illegal invasion of Ukraine. Under the triple lock, the country that carried out that illegal invasion should decide where this country participates in peacekeeping. How do the witnesses rationalise that?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

Russia should not have carried out the illegal invasion. It is true that it has a veto. The UK and the US carried out the illegal invasion of Iraq. They have vetos. France carried out the illegal invasion of Egypt. It has a veto. China carried out the illegal invasion of Vietnam. It has a veto. That is the problem with big countries. They choose to ignore international law where it suits them, particularly when they have nuclear weapons. There is not a choice of having an organisation like the UN where the big countries adhere all the time to international law. It is a choice between having an organisation like that or not having it at all. The situation with permanent members defying international law is disgraceful. It is outrageous that they can simply disregard international law when they have a responsibility to uphold the UN Charter as permanent members. Unfortunately, however, I think that without the UN it would be even worse.

Comment on this

Yes, absolutely, without the UN but the UN is not functioning in its make-up and, ultimately, any peacekeeping mission that Ireland was to participate in would have to be with the consent or the abstention of the P5 members. That is the whole point of the issue here.

Colonel Doyle last Tuesday stated that the UN veto system reflects the realities of global power dynamics but also leads to deadlocking situations where the P5 interests conflict. Touching on and following on from Deputy Brabazon's comments on the UNIFIL mission, that is a case in point. The witnesses both agree that that peacekeeping mission is worthy. I think the Irish people do. There is a proud record. Soldiers have lost their lives on those peacekeeping missions, and the military experts who were here last week indicated that soldiers, in many cases young recruits, join the Irish Defence Forces because of peacekeeping missions and to be part of them. Were geopolitics to interfere with that, and were Israel to encourage the United States to block that mandate, would the witnesses accept that as being fine or right or proper?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

We have both set out that we support the mission in Lebanon and we hope that it is extended. However, if it is not extended and it is wound down, we have no business being there. What are the chances of us being able to keep the peace if we are there without the backing of the United Nations? Under what mandate would we be there? If we do not have the backing of the United Nations, imagine we are there as an EU-backed mission-----

Comment on this

But what if it was decided at the whim of, for example, Israel putting pressure on the United States?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, and that is the reality of the Security Council. I do not favour the veto system and, as we have already discussed, there needs to be reform within the United Nations. If they vote against the Lebanon mission tomorrow, it would be a real shame but that is the reality. In that case, Ireland would have no business being there, if we did not have a United Nations mandate.

Comment on this

Even though it is the right place to be?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Is it the right place to be if we do not have the backing of the United Nations? What mandate would we have?

Comment on this

In that case, all it would take is not having the backing of Israel encouraging the United States, for example.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

What mandate would we be there on, if we are not there on a United Nations mandate?

Comment on this

A moral mandate, a historical mandate.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Where is the moral mandate in international law? The mandate is on a piece of paper.

Comment on this

Ms Ní Bhriain is happy with the mission as it is and most people agree that there is a proud record of peacekeeping in Lebanon. What if the mission were not to be renewed because of political interference?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, it would be a real shame and it would be horrific but a mandate is not this kind of moral fiction that exists in the air. It is printed on a piece of paper and it is handed to the UN staff in Lebanon for them to implement. Who will print that mandate and give it to the personnel if the mandate is wound down?

Comment on this

What if other countries decided to stay, so that there was a presence?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I would not support Ireland's participating in any mission that does not have a UN mandate because we would then be operating outside the UN system and that essentially means that we are taking sides.

Comment on this

Is this Ms Ní Bhriain's position, even though one of the P5 members, as Ms Ní Bhriain agrees, has carried out an illegal invasion of another country or a number of them as Mr. Kelly stated? That is the whole point here. If it is deemed to be a proper mission today, and if one country decides it does not like it for whatever geopolitical reasons and decides not to continue on that, does Ms Ní Bhriain see the contradiction?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

The Senator has not said what the mandate would be. If we have a UN mandate, we can be in Lebanon. If there is no UN mandate and we talk about a moral mandate or a coalition of states that send another mission, I would not support that because it would mean Ireland was acting outside of the UN system. As a small, neutral country-----

Comment on this

But would it be consistent with the UN Charter?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

We are talking about a fictitious mandate. I have no idea if it would or not. If we act outside of a Security Council vote, then it would not be consistent with the UN Charter.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

As there are no other permanent members indicating I will give five minutes to each of the non-permanent members, starting with Senator Alice- Mary Higgins. I will take indications for a second round of one short question each.

Comment on this

To pick up on the issue of the mandate, we focused a lot on Russia and Ukraine. I was very struck by the number of missions in Africa, including Mali, Niger, Mozambique and the Sahel region. This is a large number of military actions taken by Europe. We were told that the language in the proposed legislation is directly taken from the Lisbon treaty, which talks about conflict prevention and strengthening international security. This is not just peacekeeping but also strengthening international security. These are clearly some of the interpretations that have been made by the EU. When we talked about the solemn promise and commitment that was made, it was not simply about who gets to decide where we deploy, it was about a guarantee of how the UN Charter would be interpreted. Clearly, with these missions, the EU is interpreting that it is allowed to strengthen international security under the UN Charter. On the other hand, the Irish public looked for the guarantee that it would be a UN body, including the General Assembly that might interpret the UN Charter. That is where the interpretation of the international law comes back to the core point of who interprets international law.

Regarding the examples Ms Ní Bhriain gave, is it the case that EU interpretation of international law or how it has interpreted its actions in strengthening international security, could potentially include actions in terms of interests? I am looking, for example, at the protection of commercial shipping in the Red Sea. Does the EU interpretation seem to include action for the protection of interests, including economic or commercial ones?

Regarding the General Assembly, will Mr. Kelly clarify whether, with 190 countries and if UNIFIL is cancelled perhaps a motion could be achieved at the General Assembly? We know that there have been very striking majorities in relation to the 190 countries' interpretation of international law and the UN Charter. Under the 2006 Act this does not compel us to act but allows Ireland to act.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I will come in briefly on the interpretation of international security and conflict prevention and then the question of interests that the European Union sets out for its military missions. It has four pillars, including peace and security, which are very laudable aims, but the fourth aim is to protect European interests. It is stated directly and you do not have to read it between the lines. The EU sets out very clearly that these missions are very much driven by protecting European interests. On this, they do not align with international law. We have already mentioned the various ways in which the EU has been violating international law and these missions are hugely problematic. I have brought along one of the reports that we did on 20 years of EU military missions. Horrific human rights violations have been perpetrated by military personnel trained by the European Union - predominantly in Africa, because that is where most of the missions are - including military coups and horrific human rights violations. We are also financing their lethal equipment. In my opening remarks I gave the example of Mali. Tens of millions of euro was sent to Niger in the run-up to the coup.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I agree about international law. The European Court of Justice, ECJ, has held in the Kadi case, for example, that the Union does not have to follow legally binding decisions of the UN Security Council. I do not accept that the EU can be relied on to uphold international law. As regards the "uniting for peace" facility, people who do not think that this is something that can be relied upon need to clarify why this is in the legislation in the first place. Recently on Irish radio, the UN special rapporteur for food called for Ireland to use the "uniting for peace" facility to push for an international force in Gaza to distribute aid. I am convinced that this could command the requisite two-thirds majority in the General Assembly. It has not been activated for a long time but it still a possibility, not a remote-----

Comment on this

Would Ireland be better positioned to do that if we maintained our UN position? Do "interests" potentially include commercial and economic interests?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I think so, that we would be better positioned.

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

Yes, we would be much better positioned to put forward the "uniting for peace" resolution. On the commercial and economic resource question, the members can look at the maps in this report.

Comment on this

I know that much of this discussion is bound up in the changing context and the changing world we have today. The witnesses touched on the illegal invasion of Ukraine by Russia and also mentioned France, China and the US in Iraq.

It sounds like what the witnesses are describing with the Security Council has been a long-existing issue and the global context has not really changed. Will they speak to that and whether there is a different context or has it remained the same? Are we couching this discussion in a new context which is not true because we have always had these challenges?

The veto has been cited as something that stopped us engaging in peacekeeping missions previously. Will the witnesses touch on the Golan Heights, the UN mission there and why that was prevented?

Given the emergency situations around things such as civil evacuation and drugs missions are not subject to the cap or Dáil approval under this Bill, what scenarios do they envisage for the 50 troops being sent without Dáil approval?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

I will take the question on the changing world. Over the course of the research I have been doing on the European Union, it is changing in that it started out as a political and economic union and then legally it has evolved, with Nice and Lisbon, so that the European Union is now very much a fully fledged military union. This is a change that has come about during the duration of Ireland’s membership of the European Union. That militarisation has gone hand in hand with the European Union inviting in arms companies. As I wrote in my submission, it has been very much influenced by arms companies and arms lobbyists, which have set up shop in Brussels and are actively influencing the shape of policy in the European Union. We have seen that with the group of personalities that was rolled out in 2015. For the first time ever, we have funding going directly from the European Union to the research and development of military equipment and weaponry, which is highly contested under the European Union’s own law. Therefore there is a change in that sense because until the last two decades, the European Union was not so much a militarised union in the way it has become and that is where the pressure points are for Ireland as a member of the European Union.

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

I would absolutely agree that this has long been an issue. The attack on Egypt in 1956 took place just when Ireland had joined the United Nations. This has been an issue for a very long time but again, it is a question of what is the alternative. It is better to have the United Nations even though it is often ignored, unfortunately, than not to have it at all. It is a challenge that has long existed. I do not think the Russian invasion fundamentally changed it because it is not the first time that a permanent member has breached the UN Charter, unfortunately. Therefore I completely agree.

Comment on this

On the Golan Heights and also the scenarios for the 50 troops?

Comment on this
Mr. Stephen Kelly

We did have a mission in the Golan Heights. I am not across the details of the latest developments. I know it was terminated but I understand the new regime in Syria is seeking to negotiate with Israel the possible surrender of the Golan Heights. I need to look at the details of that so someone else would be better placed to comment.

On evacuation, the Defence (Amendment) Act 2006 allows for evacuations under the law as it stands so I think the law already caters for situations where there is an urgent need. The key distinction is that it is not a combat-type mission. For us the key issue is -----

Comment on this

Where would Mr. Kelly see those 50 troops being deployed under this legislation given that there are already those mechanisms for evacuation under the 2006 Act?

Comment on this
Ms Niamh Ní Bhriain

That is what is so terrifying about it. It opens up the possibility to deploy Irish troops anywhere. We could really be sent anywhere. The legislation opens up the possibility we could be sending our Irish troops to any war or conflict coming down the line. The language used by Senator Clonan of “war fighting” is what we are opening ourselves up to. The Government needs to clarify where it plans to send these troops and we have not heard that.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Four permanent members have indicated. I will give two minutes to each person and ask them to try to stick within the time. I will start with Senator Craughwell, then Deputies Brabazon and Stanley and then Senator Clonan, so far.

Comment on this

Two minutes is a very short time. I must draw attention to the comments Mr. Kelly made about elected representatives. We live in a democracy and that democracy means every one of us sitting around this table was elected. We put ourselves forward for election and we take all the insults and social media that goes with that. To come in here and sit before us and undermine and diminish the role we play is frankly quite insulting. I do not believe you need to stand for election to understand what is involved in being an elected representative but it is the attitude he has betrayed in here that sets the public against politicians. The distrust of politicians is driven by people like him who make statements like those which he made today.

Comment on this
Rose Conway-Walsh An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Does Senator Craughwell have a question?

Comment on this

Yes. The witnesses came in and made a statement about 264 of 284 resolutions passed by the United Nations Security Council. When was the last time the United Nations Security Council authorised a peacekeeping mission?

They speak about the United Nations General Assembly. It has been established here by the academics and military that have been here prior to the witnesses that first, it has not made a recommendation since, I think, 1956 and second, even if it made a recommendation it does not cover and United Nations Security Council authorisation is required.

Finally, the witnesses spoke about our airspace -----

Comment on this