General Scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025: Discussion (Resumed)
Witnesses from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance and the Transnational Institute argued that the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025 would dismantle the triple lock, weaken Irish neutrality and allow Irish troops to join EU or NATO-led missions without a UN mandate. They said the change could be unconstitutional, would expose Ireland to pressure to deploy in foreign wars, and would make the Dáil’s own approval an inadequate safeguard. Members questioned whether the triple lock really protects neutrality, whether it limits sovereignty, and what alternatives might replace it. The witnesses insisted it is a minimum check worth keeping, and urged either retaining it or enshrining neutrality more firmly in the Constitution.
Contributions 219–434 of 434. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
----- and the transportation of weapons across our airspace. How do we know they are there? We cannot see them. It is a nonsense argument.
Comment on this
The Ditch website has done extensive work documenting this. It has looked at flight manifests, international records from the airline companies -----
Comment on this
The Senator’s question was how did we know it was happening.
Comment on this
Mr. Kelly knows what is published.
Comment on this
The Senator is out of time. Can Mr. Kelly just address the questions the Senator has raised as quickly as he can, please?
Comment on this
I do not really have anything else to add.
Comment on this
On the missions, there are 11 active UN missions. Their mandates are renewed every year by the Security Council. That is in response to there being no new missions. Maybe there are no new missions but there are ongoing missions and their mandates are regularly renewed on a yearly basis.
Comment on this
My question has already been put and I am not going to put it a second time.
Comment on this
Before I ask the question may I say that as an elected representative I do not feel the witnesses' statements in any way undermine my role as an elected representative.
Comment on this
I think what Mr. Kelly and Ms Ní Bhriain are asking us to do is take our positions seriously in relation to this and he is expressing a view. People have come in here with a very different view. I was not offended by their view even though I disagree with them.
Ms Ní Bhriain mentioned that Russia has never vetoed a peacekeeping mission, if I heard that correctly. My hearing is not 100%. Will she just clarify that?
I am concerned about cables and cybersecurity. I feel we do have to protect the cables and having a functioning navy is very important and being equipped. On cybersecurity, the attack on the HSE was instanced. As someone who believes in neutrality, I do not have any problem with our increasing our capacity to deal with cyberattacks. The State is already in the process of doing that and I do not see anything in relation to neutrality that would stop us from doing that or even co-operating with other countries on that. Do the witnesses see a problem with protecting our cables or the risks of cyberattacks from hostile interests or criminal gangs?
Comment on this
I think it is incredibly important. It is fundamentally a law enforcement matter because it is a criminal matter. We need to co-operate with Interpol on issues like cybersecurity but I do not think there is any breach in neutrality-----
Comment on this
Can I clarify, in co-operating with Interpol, it would not be a breach of neutrality.
Comment on this
I would say that exactly, yes.
Regarding the cables, one has to remember that there is not a single cable that is exclusively based in Irish waters. All of these cables run either across the Atlantic or elsewhere. Any solution has to take that into account. There is nothing that any hostile power can do in Irish waters that they cannot do in other waters. It has to be an international solution and not just limited to NATO or EU members.
Comment on this
There is quite a large body of maritime law that deals with this issue. We come to it as if it has never been discussed before but maritime law has a lot to say on how to protect undersea infrastructure. It is something to take into account-----
Comment on this
Russia has never vetoed a peacekeeping mission.
Comment on this
I did up a document on vetoes which I am happy to share with members in my submission. It looks at every Russian veto that has taken place since the beginning of the 1990s. There were 39 vetoes. None of them vetoed a peacekeeping mission. There is one veto that is on a United Nations observation mission in Georgia. That was not a peacekeeping mission; it was an observation mission. It was vetoed after 16 years. There are three others, including one in relation to Bosnia and Herzegovina and one in relation to Cyprus, but they are in relation to financing. They never ended the missions. The missions continued and they resolved the financing afterwards. I have laid that out in the document. There has never been a mission vetoed by Russia.
Comment on this
I thank Ms Ní Bhriain. If she could let us have the document, we will do our best to include in the report.
Comment on this
This is a hypothetical question. What would happen if the UN Security Council Resolution 1701 was not renewed on Lebanon? That resolution allows the Israelis and Hezbollah to give consent for UN peacekeeping forces to be there. I was there when that consent was given. I do not want to say this; I was in command of Irish troops under fire. I had that privilege. We repeatedly and consistently came under direct fire over months. In that period of time, as the Israeli fire bracketed onto us, the ground and our vehicles were shaking, the 0.5 rounds were slapping off the armour. In thinking of the civilians in the houses in the villages around us, we provided the security when the Irish engineers dug into those houses with consaws and pulled out the bodies of small children and the elderly with their insides pulled-out of them; their little blue and pink intestines hanging out. That is what the Israelis did with the consent of the UN. I can tell you that if that mandate is not renewed, the Israelis will manoeuvre north and slaughter everybody in their path. In that context, if we did not abide by the triple lock and let our young men and women into that situation, do you think it would be worth it? Do you think we could prevent that when the world powers and leaders need to step up to the plate and do what they are mandated to do? I am sorry to use that sort of language here but what we are discussing is so important. For those of you who have never heard a shot fired in anger, who have never experienced it or seen it first at hand; what we are committing our young men and women to, our children and grandchildren, is something that I think is thankfully outside the experience of most people here.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Clonan for his service to this country by commanding Irish troops under fire. There are very few people who have done it. I thank him for what he did and the bravery he showed. Regarding what would happen if it is not renewed, I am sure Israel would move north and I would rather not think of the consequences. It is often not the case of what the solution is but what the solution is not. Ireland holding off nuclear armed Israel on its own would be impossible. There has to be some sort of UN force. We need to ensured it is renewed but I do not know how exactly that can be done.
Comment on this
The good we can do is done with the consent of the belligerents. Hezbollah has murdered our troops. They murdered Private Sean Rooney. The Israelis have murdered our troops. Approximately half of our casualties have been inflicted by the Israelis and their proxies and the other 50% is by Hezbollah and other Islamic resistance groups. We have to be realistic. If we abandon the triple lock and deploy troops, as was confirmed by my veteran colleagues, it will be in a war fighting capacity. That is the scenario we are committing our troops to. There may be a case where we would make that decision, but my fear is we cannot make that decision lightly. There must be a safeguard because we make mistakes.
Comment on this
I have a question for both witnesses. Do they have confidence in and do they trust the Members elected to both Houses of the Oireachtas to make the right decision on this legislation?
Comment on this
I do not place unlimited trust in Members of either House. I respect their democratic mandate, but we have a Constitution and laws that are there because no one is entitled to be trusted without limits. It is a question of trusting people but also having safeguards in place.
Comment on this
I want Ms Ní Bhriain to answer the same question.
Comment on this
Whether we trust the Government came up a lot on the neutrality roadshow. When you look at the state of the country in terms of housing, healthcare, education; people do not trust the Government.
Comment on this
I am asking Ms Ní Bhriain if she trusts the Government? It is a yes-no answer.
Comment on this
Do you trust the Irish people? Perhaps we should go to a referendum. It is subjective.
Comment on this
Hearing some of the comments in here today does not instil trust.
Comment on this
In the 1950s when there was a deployment under the "uniting for peace" resolution, it did not require the Security Council to agree to it. The General Assembly can authorise an international force. Can we have that confirmed? For example, it has been mentioned in relation to a potential force for the delivery of humanitarian aid. It has a higher bar - but is a potential one because it would not require consent - is the question of UNIFIL, perhaps, in terms of the General Assembly. Can the witnesses confirm that the General Assembly can authorise a force without the consent of the Security Council?
Comment on this
It can, in accordance with Resolution 377 (V) of 1950, "uniting for peace".
Comment on this
I am going to finish it at that. On behalf of the committee, I thank the witnesses for their time and also for the material they circulated in advance of the meeting. We will now suspend for a short break.
Comment on this
The joint committee is continuing its pre-legislative scrutiny of the defence (amendment) Bill 2025. I welcome on behalf of the committee Mr. Barry Andrews, MEP, and Ms Lynn Boylan, MEP. The witnesses are here to discuss the general scheme of the Bill and I thank them for joining us in person. Their contribution to our scrutiny is very much appreciated.
The format of the meeting is that I will invite each witness to make an opening statement This will be followed by questions from members of the committee. Each member has a seven-minute slot to ask questions and for witnesses to respond.
I advise members of the constitutional requirement that they must be physically present within the confines of the Leinster House complex to participate in public meetings. I will not permit a member to participate where they are not adhering to this constitutional requirement. Therefore, a member who attempts to participate from outside the precincts will be asked to leave the meeting. In this regard, I ask any member partaking via Microsoft Teams to confirm formally prior to making a contribution to the meeting that he or she is on the grounds of the Leinster House campus.
Both members and witnesses are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if statements are potentially defamatory regarding an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks. It is imperative that any such direction be complied with.
The committee will publish the opening statements on its website following the meeting. I invite Mr. Andrews to make his opening statement.
Comment on this
I really appreciate the opportunity to give a European perspective on this very valuable discussion. I congratulate the Cathaoirleach on her election as Chair. It is always a pleasure to be back among former colleagues and friends from the political world.
In April 2022, I published a paper entitled "Irish Neutrality in a Changing Europe". It was two months after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine by Russia. I was trying to take stock of developments that were taking place prior to the invasion of Ukraine and where Ireland was in these circumstances. Of course, the events of February 2022 hastened considerations along these lines. We could see very quickly that not only the EU but its individual member states took dramatically new security positions, including Denmark joining the Common Security and Defence Policy, CSDP, for the first time and the famous Zeitenwende speech by former German Chancellor Olaf Scholz where for the first time, Germany would take a more proactive approach in defence globally. We all know that Finland and Sweden have joined NATO and this is repeated in neutral countries such as Austria and Switzerland, a non-EU country. We saw very dramatic changes in the way people were addressing the dramatic impact of Russia's new approach to European security. Russia now prefers ideas of spheres of influence. It caused many of the neighbouring countries, particularly the Baltic states, to introduce extraordinary increases in their defence spending as a percentage of their GNP.
We in Ireland have been moving forward a bit more slowly. We saw the report of the Commission on the Defence Forces and the consultative forum on international security. In my paper, I wrote that the triple lock system was no longer fit for purpose. I simply questioned as did many of the other witnesses today why control over where we deploy our peacekeepers was placed in the hands of autocratic leaders in Russia and China. We must bear in mind that one of those leaders is the subject of an arrest warrant from the International Criminal Court, ICC. It seemed absurd that we would outsource decisions about our foreign policy and more specifically the deployment of our troops overseas to people of that calibre. We also know that the other three members are members of NATO so whichever way one looked at these issues, it seemed that it was time for reform of this issue.
There have been reviews in Ireland and progress has been made towards level of ambition 2, which is welcome and not before time. The consultative forum provided the opportunity for stakeholders to have a much closer look at these issues and gather as much information as possible from people. The forum was not decisive about this issue, which is why it is important that we have these discussions at a parliamentary level.
Let me absolutely clear that I am a staunch supporter of international law and international courts such as the ICC and the ICJ. I have spent much of my time in the European Parliament dealing with issues like that, including last night, where we had an event defending the International Criminal Court against sanctions imposed by the US. I think it is correct to be sceptical of the UN system. For some time, the Security Council has not been effective, which, as members are aware, has had an impact on peacekeeping missions. There have been none since 2014. While there are 11 ongoing peacekeeping missions, it seems that there is a chilling effect. Even António Guterres has said that the Security Council is dysfunctional and paralysed. We know that the future of UNIFIL in Lebanon is under threat from the US potentially vetoing its renewal in August. I visited Camp Shamrock as part of my preparation for the paper I published in 2022. I saw the hardship of that posting. We have seen in more recent times the literal threats to the lives of the men and women in uniform representing Ireland in southern Lebanon. When one looks at the conflicts around the world today, it is clear that there are many areas where a UN Security Council resolution on a peacekeeping force is extremely unlikely to be adopted.
Finally, to address those concerns of those who do not have faith in the Government to make the correct decisions around deployment, I agree with Dr. Cathal Berry’s approach that this committee should be tasked with scrutiny powers ahead of any proposed new mission, especially regarding Ireland’s obligations under international law, as well as the publication of the Attorney General’s formal advice. I further agree with the idea that any Dáil approval could also be subject to a review mechanism, be that an annual one or in the case of the withdrawal of a deployment.
In conclusion, no other country in the world uses our triple lock mechanism. Instead of allowing Dáil Éireann and our democratically elected Government to take decisions, we have abdicated our foreign policy to two members of NATO, two authoritarian governments and a Donald Trump led-US. I look forward to members' questions and reiterate my appreciation of the invitation.
Comment on this
I thank the Cathaoirleach for the invitation to participate today. I will focus on the wider EU policy context and what the proposed abolition of the triple lock means in such a context.
Ireland is a small neutral state with a long proud record of peacekeeping. In fact, we are the only nation to have a continuous presence on UN and UN-mandated peace support operations since 1958. Within the EU, there is no doubt that there has been an increasing push for militarisation. Recently, we had the ReArm Europe-Readiness 2030 agenda, a White Paper on the future of European defence outlining the EU policy and legislative agenda for European defence.
However, predating this latest posturing by EU leaders, we had the European Defence Fund, EDF. This was established in 2017 with a budget of €7.3 billion for the period from 2021 to 2027. This fund is for the purpose of funding defence industry research, capability development and contributing to EU defence interests in line with the Common Security and Defence Policy, CSDP. It also is worth noting that a recent investigative journalism report found that a subsidiary of Israeli Aerospace Industries, which is an Israeli state-owned drone manufacturer, benefited from at least €15 million in public funding from the EDF. The adoption of the Act in Support of Ammunition Production, ASAP, in 2023 saw €500 million of public money going to arms companies to increase their production capability.
There has been much discussion about sovereignty in this debate but it has all focused on the UN. I agree that the UN needs reform but as the UN is also under incredible political pressure and is being undermined by various actors, now is not the time to weighing in and pulling away support for the UN. We must be very clear that while we are focused on the issue of sovereignty when it comes to the UN, the European Commission and its militarisation agenda are actively eroding the sovereignty of member states. The mechanisms used under the treaties for the adoption of ASAP and more recently the SAFE regulation, namely, Articles 122 and 173 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, TFEU, are not compliant with the provisions of Article 41.2 of the Treaty on European Union, TEU.
Article 41.2 requires that expenditure from the European Union budget for the purposes of operations with a military or defence implication are prohibited without unanimity at the Council. The legal inconsistency has been highlighted in the case of ASAP by the previous Oireachtas Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform, and Taoiseach, and more recently in the Bundestag. Moreover, even the President of the European Parliament has highlighted similar concerns in relation to the SAFE regulation and bypassing the scrutiny of the Parliament and Council.
I highlight this because in the context where we are giving any future government a huge amount of scope to deploy Irish soldiers in EU missions, we also have a European Commission that is not abiding by the treaties, is not abiding by international law in terms of Israel and is increasingly violating the principle of subsidiarity and sovereignty when it comes to the defence policy of member states. Recently, we have seen Spain publicly admonished for daring to say that it would not cut social welfare spending to reach a threshold of 5% of GDP military expenditure. While this was in the context of NATO, it is also important to note that the European Commission President, Ursula von der Leyen, makes no distinction between NATO and the EU.
The triple lock, I believe, affords Ireland a firewall that protects from this ever-increasing EU shift to militarisation. Ireland will be taking up the European Presidency next year and will come under enormous pressure to play ball and, like the Spanish Government, to not resist this push for militarisation. The triple lock gives the Government a firewall to point to, that it has a mandate to represent Ireland as a neutral state.
There has been a growth in the deployment of EU military missions under the CSDP since they began over 20 years ago. These missions are in stark contrast to UN peacekeeping missions. They often take place in the former colonies of European countries, such as in the Sahel region, and are not subject to the scrutiny of the European Parliament, national parliaments, the Court of Justice of the European Union, the European Court of Auditors or to the European Convention on Human Rights.
UN missions, on the other hand, will have had a huge amount of preparatory work through a technical field assessment of the overall security, political, military, humanitarian and human rights situation on the ground. The General Assembly then plays a key role in monitoring the ongoing missions and making sure they are fulfilling their objectives. There has been no explanation of how this work will be replaced by either the EU or the Irish Government. This is particularly relevant to head 6 of the Bill, which uses the phrase “strengthening international security ... consistent with the principles of the United Nations Charter” and “maintenance of international peace and security in conformity with the principles of justice and international law”. This language comes directly from Article 42.1 of the Treaty on European Union but has not been applied in a manner consistent with the UN Charter. Instead, it has sought to protect the interests of EU countries in the global south in a highly extractive and neocolonial manner.
I wish to highlight further examples that illustrate the shifting EU policy towards militarisation and direct public funding, by Irish citizens, of arms companies that are enjoying record profits. The Commission has recently proposed to allow cohesion funds to be used for military expenditure. That is funding that in the past was used to build our road networks and that should be used for other countries to develop their infrastructure. Ireland is a net contributor to that fund. That fund now can be used for military expenditure. The European Commission has also confirmed that defence spending will be categorised as sustainable finance, thereby allowing weapons companies to compete for finance with companies and small and medium enterprises that are actively trying to combat climate change, and we know climate change is a security threat. The Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, accepted that fact at the UN.
I thank the committee for allowing me to present today and have included a supplementary paper with more details and references on the issues I have provided in the opening statement.
Comment on this
It is very important to have the EU perspective during the scrutiny of this Bill and recognising the large mandate both witnesses have. The committee invited an EU representative from each of the parties and groupings, so we appreciate the attendance of the witnesses. Each member will have seven minutes and we should use our time within the seven minutes for both questions and answers. Non-members will come in after all members have spoken and I will allow either three minutes or five minutes.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses back to the Oireachtas and thank them for their contributions. On the last point Ms Boylan spoke about the urge of the EU to increase spending on militarisation. Does she support additional investment in our armed forces here in terms of personnel, equipment and capabilities? On Tuesday, the military expert Mr. Colm Doyle, who is a retired colonel, was at the committee and he spoke about the UN veto system reflecting the realities of global power dynamics and how it also leads to deadlock in situations where the five permanent members' interests conflict. As a result, the Security Council is often unable to act decisively in conflicts in which one or more permanent members have geopolitical interests at stake. Considering one of the five members was involved in an illegal invasion of Ukraine, is there not a conflict in requiring support or at least consent or even abstention from that member in terms of peacekeeping forces Ireland would be part of?
Comment on this
In response to Senator Kyne's first question, the political party I represent, Sinn Féin, supports the level of ambition 2 investment in our Defence Forces. There is a very big difference between investing in the Defence Forces as a neutral force and then throwing our lot in with a European Union that has different interests, backgrounds and cultural context. It is also very different to using critical EU funding. For example Ireland is a net contributor to cohesion funding and that will be used for military expenditure. That is denying developing countries the development and peace programmes Ireland benefited from. That will now be used for military expenditure. It is also deeply problematic that there is no oversight of the expenditure. There is a clear distinction. Yes, invest in our Defence Forces but we do not need to lose our neutrality to do that.
In regard to the Security Council veto, I note the veto has never been used by Russia, Britain or the US against a peacekeeping mission. We are talking about something that could hypothetically happen but has never happened. There is also the fact a General Assembly resolution can allow for a peacekeeping mission to go ahead. As I said in my opening statement, I support UN reform. Ireland can play a major role in reforming the UN but now is not the time to be dismissing the UN or flagging concerns around it when it has been undermined daily by the US, Israel and some members within the European Union. We need to defend the UN because there is no plan B.
Comment on this
And by Russia of course. I note Ms Boylan did not mention Russia or Ukraine in her opening statement and strikingly, the only threat she identified was climate change. Unfortunately, however, that is not the way the vast majority of European countries see this situation at the moment. Ireland is at a level of 0.24% of GDP investment in our Defence Forces, which is the lowest of the 38 countries surveyed. Countries such as Latvia and Estonia are at approximately 5% to 7% and they are not doing that lightly. This involves massive trade-offs whether it is about borrowing, increased taxation or cutting back social services. These are really painful decisions that are having to be taken by other EU member states. In fact, the neutral countries - Malta, Austria and Cyprus - all spend a lot more on their defence forces than we do. What has happened during the past couple of years is surely a wake-up call that we need to take a much more progressive view.
On the veto, as I said in my opening statement I very much feel the UN Security Council has changed. Its main purpose is the preservation of peace in the world and we do not have to go too far into our newspapers to see that it is not really working very well at the moment and there is a good opportunity for Ireland to reflect on whether or not we want to be tethered and harnessed to that forum for decisions around our foreign policy.
Comment on this
Ms Lynn Boylan, MEP mentioned the General Assembly and the possible use of that.
The last time it was used was in 1956. Without reform of the UN Security Council, as it stands, it would require clearance on an new mandate. That is part of the issue.
Can either of the MEPs see any other safeguards? We acknowledge that the P5 is somewhat dysfunctional but are there other safeguards that could be put in place? Mr. Andrews mentioned this committee and the advice of the Attorney General.
Comment on this
I will only be repeating myself. I have recommended that there is an alternative. I spoke to some colleagues in Finland about what they do. Their flowchart is that in order to trigger the deployment of troops, a proposal is issued by the Government, which then goes to the relevant committee; the committee considers it and then it goes to a vote in the parliament, after which the president passes it. Elements of that are practically possible in Ireland to provide guardrails, given that some members are concerned that they would be added on.
Comment on this
The only point I would add is that there are legal experts who can put forward proposals. What I am trying to say to committee members is that the triple lock is a security to guard against the pressure that is coming to bear on countries in the European Union. We were singled out by Commissioner Kaja Kallas only recently. She dismissed our neutrality and effectively said that we did not know oppression or discrimination on ethnic or language rights in this country. That is the culture we are dealing with. That is the High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, who dismissed Ireland's neutrality on the floor of the Parliament. What I say to all members is that, regardless of who is in government, we can point to the triple lock as a firewall against this pressure.
To use the example of Spain, Mark Rutte has clearly said - as has Mr. Andrews here today - that we should cut social welfare in order to provide funding to reach 5% of GDP. The Spanish Prime Minister has said he is not prepared to do that, but he is coming under enormous pressure. He is being publicly excoriated for saying that. We must be honest with the public. Are we saying that we want to cut our social welfare in order to pay for European defence?
Comment on this
Of course I did not say that. I merely made the point that Latvia has had to choose between a range of options, including potentially cutting its social welfare. I do not know how Ms Boylan managed to extract from that, that I am proposing cutting social welfare in Ireland when we have a very healthy surplus and there are many other options for reaching level of ambition 2.
Comment on this
I thank this morning's witnesses. I have a few comments to make. Mr. Andrews states that the future of UNIFIL in Lebanon is under threat from the US, which will potentially veto its renewal in August. That would mean the end of an Irish presence in Lebanon. Other countries might be able to continue with a reconfigured source. This would be a terrible end for a mission we have been committed to for more than 45 years. Is it likely or could it happen that the US could object? If it does, what will it mean for our people who are currently overseas on the peacekeeping mission in Lebanon?
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Scanlon. Trying to predict what the United States will do in the next week is difficult, and trying to predict what it will do in August is impossible. Unfortunately, in recent months, since Trump came into power, there has been a significant undermining of international bodies, for example, the World Health Organization where funding was withdrawn from the Gavi vaccination programme. We can also look at the implications of the collapse of USAID. The US failed to appoint new members to the Appellate Body of the World Trade Organization. That also happened under Biden. Unfortunately, there is a massive pattern of US disengagement from international obligations.
It is not reckless to bring up the danger and the threat that the US would exercise a veto on the extension of the UNIFIL mandate. It is something that must be on our minds and feature on the committee's deliberations. What would happen to the troops? They would have to be withdrawn and come back to Dublin.
Comment on this
We can deal with what might potentially happen in the future, but we must also look at what is happening right now. One of the biggest threats to our peacekeeping force is Israel. It is the most destabilising force at the moment within the Middle East and the EU has allowed Israel to act with impunity. I reiterate the European Union is not upholding international law and therefore it is vital for us to have the triple lock as a firewall. Israel is the biggest threat to our peacekeeping force in Lebanon right now.
Comment on this
It is sad to see the hands of the UN Security Council and the UN General Assembly tied behind their backs in regard to what is happening in the world today. What are the witnesses' thoughts on that? We read in the newspapers today that 78,000 Palestinian people were killed in the past two years, yet the UN is unfortunately unable to do anything. I know the reason is that the major powers are vetoing everything that is happening there. That is very wrong.
Is there a better way to deal with these types of situations where people are suffering? We saw what happened in Bosnia 30 years ago. Everybody hoped and prayed it would never happen again, yet here we are in a worse situation.
Comment on this
The European Union has a crucial role to play here. If the EU can at least agree on one thing, which is humanitarian access into Gaza, that would be a really good start. Unfortunately, the European Union has demonstrated complete double standards when it comes to its approach to Ukraine, in respect of ICC arrest warrants in that regard, and in making sure that there is full support for Ukraine in the face of aggression. In contrast, the EU has been silent on the ICJ's decision on the illegality of the West Bank settlements and has said nothing about the ICC. Sanctions have been imposed by the US and there are options available to the EU but they are not being exercised. Unfortunately, the perception of the EU internationally is very negative. The European Union's credibility has been really undermined by this last episode, and it has had implications for international humanitarian law. The United Nations would have looked to the European Union as a reliable partner for making sure that it would back up the institutions and all the elements that make up international law but, unfortunately, that has been lost. Currently, the United Nations is undergoing reform, some of it enforced by the massive reduction in funding, not just from the United States but also from EU member states. It has embarked on the UN80 initiative. It will probably merge some of its agencies, but ultimately the UN Security Council requires drastic reform. There should be African member states. It is a 1945 answer to a question nobody is asking any more. The P5 has full responsibility and that must change.
Comment on this
I echo what Mr. Andrews is saying in one sense, in that if we want to stop innocent Palestinians being slaughtered in their thousands, we must stop arming Israel and we must sanction it. Unfortunately, that is not happening at a European level. We saw only last week that the European Council again failed to reach a decision to take any action against Israel. That is why we must reinforce the fact that Ireland is a neutral state and that we can separate and draw a distinction between ourselves and countries such as Germany and Austria, which are wholeheartedly arming and supplying the weapons that are slaughtering innocent Palestinian children.
We also have a Commissioner, Kaja Kallas, who initially when the humanitarian blockade began, said that she would work with Israel to find an alternative source of humanitarian aid. She backtracked on that but, again, she was willing to endorse the Gaza humanitarian fund, where again we are seeing innocent civilians being slaughtered.
It is therefore important for Ireland to be able to distinguish ourselves from the EU when necessary such as, for example, when we cannot stand over the inaction of the European Union and its arming, supplying and enabling Israel to act with impunity, while, as Mr. Andrews said correctly, we were very swift to apply sanctions to Russia.
Comment on this
There was a discussion about our situation with the Defence Forces and it is welcome to have that discussion. It is not strictly precluded by that. However, I welcome the interest of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael representatives, given the neglect of the Defence Forces under Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Governments in recent years that have let us get to the situation, where there are fewer members of the Permanent Defence Force than the establishment strength. It is obviously the case, as I am sure the witnesses will agree, that there is nothing in the triple lock that prevents us from investing in our Defence Forces and ensuring they are up to scratch.
My first question is for Mr. Andrews. If I understand his position correctly, it is that he agrees with the removal of the triple lock but he is in favour of neutrality.
Comment on this
One of the types of missions that it is most likely Irish troops would be sent on in the event of the removal of the triple lock would be an EU-led mission. Would that be fair to say?
Comment on this
It is possible. We have had EU-led missions before and as the Deputy------
Comment on this
Yes, but under a UN mandate. I understand. Would Mr. Andrews be confident that the institutions of the EU, including the treaties, are robust enough to ensure that EU missions without a UN mandate would be human rights compliant and would not be involved in acts of aggression or anything like that?
Comment on this
Yes, there are safeguards, not only in the EU treaties, but also in the Irish Constitution, whereby we are obliged in the exercise of foreign policy to comply with international law. The European Union is bound by customary international law and international humanitarian law and is a signatory to many of the conventions that govern the conduct of and the decision to deploy troops. For example, the UN mandated the 2003 invasion of Iraq, but many European countries decided not to deploy any troops to Iraq, quite rightly. Although there was a UN mandate, Ireland also took the sensible decision to have nothing to do with that. It is dangerous to demonise the European Union.
Comment on this
I make my own criticisms of it and am happy to do so, but we have to remember it is a Union of treaties and whatever powers it has, it has on the basis of the sovereign decisions of its members.
Comment on this
Yes, perfect.
My next question is for Ms Boylan. The EU could deploy without a UN mandate but it is bound by its treaties and so on. In her experience, is the EU and its Commission currently abiding by the rules of the treaties?
Comment on this
It is clearly not abiding by international law when it comes to the ICJ and ICC. That is first and foremost. We have seen that six of the 11 missions in the past, before 2017, were led by the former colonial powers.
A huge amount of work goes into a UN mandate, as I said in my opening statement. It assesses the situation on the ground and has set, clear objectives. That does not happen at an EU level. There is no oversight by the European Parliament, the Court of Justice of the European Union or the European Convention on Human Rights. The European Court of Auditors has also stated it has no way of assessing the expenditure of these missions. We do not have any transparency around the number of casualties. There is no analysis of the objectives of the mission in the first place.
Another example is that in 2020, the Malian national security forces received training and finance from the EU and then went on to be responsible for the killing of hundreds of civilians. An EU mission does not have the same level of preparation, transparency and objectives as would a UN mission. That is the clear distinction and we have not heard anything from the Government in its proposal to remove the triple lock about what would replace that scrutiny and level of analysis and research before we put troops on the ground.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say, however, that at times the European Commission has not abided by its own treaties? At times, it has disregarded the rules.
Comment on this
Absolutely. That was the point of ASAP and the SAFE regulation. President Metsola has already complained that the SAFE regulation did not go through European Parliament scrutiny and the Bundestag has criticised it. Equally, the finance and public expenditure committee under the last Government also criticised that ASAP was designed to bypass and not comply with the treaties. Effectively, expenditure for defence and military purposes required unanimity at Council and that rule was bypassed. Therefore, it is not complying with its own treaties.
Comment on this
Perfect.
My next question is for both witnesses. I was unimpressed with Commissioner Kallas's comments. I recognise and am happy to say that her country suffered oppression during the 20th century under the Soviet Union. I have no problem saying that whatsoever, but it was wrong of her to denigrate what was experienced in Ireland. She used that to strike out against Ireland's policy of neutrality. She did not reference the triple lock. She only spoke about neutrality. Do the witnesses believe that attitude is widely held at a leadership level in the EU, namely, that Ireland's neutrality is a questionable policy and one that has limited validity or application?
Comment on this
I will go next. On the SAFE regulation, there is a dispute. It is worth sharing this mainly because Roberta Metsola, on behalf of the Parliament, is irritated. A case has been taken against the Commission arguing that the way it passed the SAFE regulation was unconstitutional under the EU treaties. It is possible for the Parliament to do that. I make that point because it is a Union of laws and that is happening.
On the general attitude to Ireland, it is a mixed bag. There are four neutral countries, which take different positions. There were six neutral countries until recently and each time we discuss it, we make sure there is a reference to the unique constitutional provisions of individual EU member states and so, for example, to Ireland's policy of military neutrality. However, some people consider Ireland to be a laggard. They have reference, not so much to our neutrality, but to the low level of investment in our Defence Forces in proportion to the GNI.
Comment on this
In this instance, it was specific to neutrality, rather than defence spending.
Comment on this
Yes, I know and it was an unacceptable slur. I agree.
Comment on this
As the Deputy already said, there is nothing in the triple lock that prevents us from investing in our Defence Forces and I think everyone agrees that we need to invest in them. It is unacceptable that we cannot provide crews to crew our naval ships and that there are issues in the aviation sector. That is not acceptable but it is completely separate to abandoning the triple lock.
From my experience of sitting in on any of the debates in the European Parliament, it was quite distinctive that Commissioner Kallas called Ireland out specifically on its neutrality. However, what will be heard from Members of the European Parliament, even within the Green group - you feel quite isolated when you are on the left - is the need for a European army and for qualified majority voting on foreign and security decisions to be abandoned. There is huge pressure and huge dissatisfaction among other member states about the fact that some countries want to be neutral and do not share the same context or world view as other European member states.
Comment on this
In that context, there is certainly an attitude that it is a questionable policy. Given that EU battle groups can be deployed within five days, do the witnesses think Ireland could come under considerable pressure to deploy as a battle group in the absence of the triple lock?
Comment on this
I believe it will and I believe when Ireland has the Presidency that pressure will only increase.
Comment on this
Why does Mr. Andrews not believe it will?
Comment on this
I will not be around for the second round.
Comment on this
It is because there is absolutely no evidence to suggest that could happen. In other words, the battle groups have been in existence for some time. There is now a proposal to replace them with a rapid deployment group of 5,000 troops that might be EU-led. That is a proposal but there is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that Ireland came under pressure in the past or will come under pressure in the future.
Comment on this
I have been putting one question to a number of witnesses on the triple lock issue.
If we came up with an acceptable wording that was put to the people about enshrining neutrality in our Constitution and that was passed, would the same concerns around the triple lock manifest?
Comment on this
What is neutrality? While I know the committee has been through this and I know it is not the main purpose of this discussion but the consultative forum chaired by Dame Louise Richardson heard lots of different views on what neutrality is. Reference was made to the Hague Convention of 1907 but that includes political neutrality. We do not comply with that convention with regard to our position on Ukraine, so we are not neutral in that way. Austria is neutral but adheres to Article 42 of the Treaty on European Union on common European defence so it is a very strange position. We are quite a strong neutral in comparison with anybody else in the EU. Therefore, to try to capture that idea in a referendum with our history of referendums would be a really difficult thing to do and would create constraints on our capacity to carry out our foreign policy and in particular to deploy troops for lots of the purposes contained in the general scheme of the Bill that is before this committee. I would be very worried about that not only defining neutrality but that in the case of a referendum, we could end up with an answer to a question we did not ask. It can be difficult sometimes. We know that with the Lisbon treaty, part of the answer was the need for safeguards and this was where the triple lock came in. There were, however, also questions about tax autonomy in Ireland and subsequently we changed our position on tax, there were questions about abortion and subsequently we changed our position on abortion and there were questions about the triple lock and we are in the process of considering whether the triple lock is an appropriate constraint on our foreign policy.
Comment on this
I would point to the fact that even though we have changed positions on issues that came up in the Lisbon and Nice treaties, the difference here is that polling consistently shows that the Irish people support neutrality and a majority continues to support the triple lock. There is a conception that our neutrality is already enshrined in the Constitution and as it is something of which Irish people are incredibly proud, I would support having a referendum on neutrality. Regarding the wording of that, we have seen citizens' assemblies being very effective in bringing together advice in a calm and reasoned manner to come up with language. I do not think language is an excuse to not put the question to the people. I would say to the Government, which is proposing to abandon the triple lock, that if it is so certain of its position, it should ask the people because this is a matter of huge significance in terms of our neutrality. People were given assurances after Lisbon and Nice and we had the Seville Declaration that our neutrality was enshrined and the triple lock was fundamental to that. Micheál Martin, the then leader of the Opposition who is now Taoiseach, said on the floor of the Dáil that the triple lock was a crucial part of our neutrality. If the Government wants to abandon the triple lock, it should put it to the people. We can work around finding the language but that should not be a reason to not have a referendum.
Comment on this
The conflagration in the Middle East has become wider than Israel and Gaza. It now involves Israel, Iran, Russia and potentially China and others behind Iran and the US and UK coming in behind Israel. Both sides are on the Security Council and either of them could decide to use Ireland as a pawn in the bigger game and say it will veto the renewal of the UNIFIL mandate, which is required next month. In such a scenario, as other witnesses have informed us, we would have to withdraw our troops immediately because we no longer have any legal standing to have our troops there. This would be catastrophic for that region and further destabilise south Lebanon in particular. What do the witnesses have to say about that?
Comment on this
Israel put pressure on the Irish troops to withdraw about a year ago. Irish troops were under extraordinary pressure and withheld and stood up to that pressure. Their independence there is underlined by the fact that they have also come under fire from Hezbollah forces prior to that. We all know about the tragic death of Seán Rooney in those circumstances. It is an extraordinary legacy; the longest running peacekeeping presence anywhere. It was a huge honour for me to be in Camp Shamrock and to see that. The way the Deputy characterises is correct. We have the two sides of the Security Council - P5 - facing each other in the Middle East through proxies at war. It is absurd that we consider that those parties should have a veto over the question of deployment of troops. It is extraordinary and to me is a question of sovereignty. We are taking control of this decision back into our democratic institutions. I published that paper calling for the end of the triple lock in 2022. I then put my name forward for election and got re-elected. Those of us who feel we need to evolve as everyone else has have put that before the people in our democratic mandates and are entitled to push these issues in our parliamentary forums.
Comment on this
It is good to see Mr. Andrews and Ms Boylan back in these Houses while acknowledging the fact that I never served during their time here. I recognise that both opening statements contain differing points of view but I also recognise the work both Mr. Andrews and Ms Boylan do following their own viewpoints with such determination. This debate is so heavily politicised with Government versus Opposition that one would swear that it is a debate that is happening in every country or that we are not in a unique situation in this country with the triple lock. I do not think people are aware of that when it comes to other neutral countries.
The triple lock is not essential to ensure we are a neutral country by virtue of the fact that there are and have been other neutral countries across the world that have been neutral without a triple lock. What do some of those countries look like? How do they maintain their neutrality? Dr. Cathal Berry went into it. Mr. Andrews mentioned his contribution. I know some others have put forward other ideas around the role of this committee, the Houses or the President. I find it very hard to accept that the triple lock is the one thing protecting our neutrality or that we would instantly no longer be neutral if we did not have the triple lock when there are clearly other options out there that other countries have followed and are following successfully.
Comment on this
As Deputy O'Meara notes, he was not around back in the day. We remember that the armed forces were occupied with paramilitaries for a long time in the 1980s and 1990s before the ceasefires and we benefited from our geographic position for a long time but that is no longer as relevant as it was. Other neutral countries evolved their neutrality based on their geography. I know Finland quite well. Everybody has to serve time in the reserves. The country has a very high level of civil preparedness for attack. Some people mocked the idea that we are all supposed to have 72 hours of provisions in our homes but for Finland, it is a week. It has enough fuel, food and water and is prepared. It has invested heavily in its armed forces in terms of capability.
Even within the context of its neutrality prior to joining NATO, it partnered with NATO to make sure it had interoperability and that whatever it was using could be used with NATO members. It also became involved in joint procurement with NATO. It was of a very different character to the way we see it. Obviously, it has a 1,000 km-long border with Russia. We have a huge maritime area and have already very clearly seen not only vulnerability but examples of where we need to step up. Frankly, it depends on the geography. That has changed for us in recent times.
Comment on this
I go back to the point that the wider EU context needs to be taken into account. I keep using the term "triple lock". It is a firewall for any Government at the EU Council table to be able to point to and try to resist the pressure that it will come under. The pressure is enormous. We have a European Commission led by woman who is actively arming a genocide and ignoring the International Court of Justice and her own treaties in terms of defence and military expenditure.
If we are joining EU missions, they are very often EU missions led by a former colony of a region. That does not guarantee neutrality in terms of our peacekeepers. There are vested agendas in EU missions compared with UN missions. In respect of the broader context, my view is that we are looking at a European Union that has set its mind in one direction and one direction only, namely, abolishing unanimity at the Council level and where militarisation is the only show in town. Every EU fund is being made available to facilitate the arms industry and prop it up. Irish taxpayers' money is being used for that. The only defence we have against coming under pressure is the triple lock, unless we enshrine neutrality in the Constitution.
It is a unique position but I am telling the committee the direction of travel in the EU. I want to know whether the Irish public are happy that our money, which we pay in - we are a net contributor to the European Union - is being used to fund the arms industry, an arms industry that, is in effect, is making record-breaking profits.
Comment on this
My issue with Ms Boylan's point on protecting against what she says is the EU expansion into militarisation is that we are relying on a veto and a system that does not work to protect us against that. I do not see why that is the only option. Why would we go back to relying on the P5 when it is incapable of allowing new peacekeeping forces to go abroad from any country, but this one in particular, when there could be another option?
The role of the committee could be strengthened. We could trust our politicians, including our party, as well as Ms Boylan's, in terms of scrutinising any decision being made. Rather than trusting the people in the House, strengthening the work of the committee, considering the potential role of the President or other ideas that have been put forward, those against the triple lock for the reasons Ms Boylan has mentioned look back to the P5. That group is incapable of running the United Nations in any way that is acceptable at the moment and prevents us from getting into any new peacekeeping forces abroad.
Comment on this
I would say that we need to put that to the people in a referendum in order to provide some legislative protection to our position of neutrality in order that we can stand on our own two feet in the EU and defend our position of neutrality.
Comment on this
But the people elected us last November.
Comment on this
We are coming under sustained pressure on a daily basis to abandon that neutrality and throw our lot in with an EU that has an agenda of militarisation.
Comment on this
The people voted last November for a Parliament to pass laws exactly like this. There is no mandate or obligation to have a referendum.
Comment on this
The polling would argue otherwise. Polling has consistently shown that we are in favour of our position of neutrality. If the Deputy is so assured that he was elected on a mandate to not enshrine our neutrality, I would tell him to put it to the people in a referendum.
Comment on this
When I was canvassing, nobody ever brought up the issue of neutrality. Nobody asked whether we were neutral. There is a broad acceptance in this country that nearly every political party believes in our neutrality. The question is whether the triple lock will remove our neutrality. I think the answer is clearly "No".
Comment on this
With all due respect to the Deputy, as someone who ran in the European elections, it came up on numerous occasions. I gave an assurance to the electorate that we would defend our neutrality. As we know, the European elections are very different, as are European referendums. Neutrality comes very much into focus because the Irish people are not stupid. They can see the direction of travel of the EU and want to make sure that we defend our neutral status. They like certain elements of the EU, but they do not like the militarisation of it.
Comment on this
It is historically accurate to say that in 1973 a lot of those on the left opposed Ireland joining the European Economic Community, EEC, because of the EU army, militarisation and conscription. There is an idea that we will be unable to resist pressure. There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that we will be under pressure to deploy troops. One example is the 2003 UN-mandated invasion of Iraq. EU countries decided they did not want to have anything to do with that. Ireland, being in the triple lock, had an opportunity to become involved but nobody put us any under pressure. We were very close to the United States and made a sovereign decision that we did not have anything to do with the invasion, and quite rightly so.
I ask whether somebody can show me some evidence that this is happening. It is absolutely right that the European Union has decided security and defence are an absolute priority for the next couple of years but to extrapolate from that that there will be a knock on our door from Ursula von der Leyen saying that the EU wants Ireland to deploy troops against our will is just not credible.
Comment on this
As we are waiting for the Senators to come back, I will use this opportunity to ask a couple of questions.
During previous sessions, safeguarding has been mentioned in regard to the Oireachtas. This committee being a safeguard has been discussed. In terms of scrutiny, that is absolutely the case but there are constraints and it is important to point out that we are time-limited, even in terms of pre-legislative scrutiny where we have been confined to eight weeks. We were not allowed to seek an extension on that. All Oireachtas committees, to the best of my knowledge, have a Government majority, as does the Seanad and obviously the Dáil. That may not be the safeguard that some may think it is. Do the witnesses see any protections in the heads of the Bill which would prevent the growing EU militarisation encroaching on our neutrality?
Comment on this
On the safeguarding issue, and the role the committee, Parliament and Seanad plays, the argument the Cathaoirleach has put is an argument against having a Seanad, Parliament or committees. If the committee cannot, or feels it is not able to, carry out a scrutiny function, I am confused as to what the purpose of the committee is.
I was in the Oireachtas and the committees play an important role. As I mentioned, that is exactly how Finland operates. It deals with these issues through a Finnish parliamentary committee and it is considered by the people of Finland, who are a democracy and peace loving and socially progressive people, that is a sufficient safeguard. It is a dangerous argument to suggest that somehow or other, parliamentary scrutiny is insufficient and does not do what it is meant to.
Comment on this
I as Chair would stand over the fact that there are constraints around the scrutiny we can carry out. All members here, whatever their opinion, would agree that there are constraints, notwithstanding that we make the work of the committee as good as we possibly can, as in this case. We are trying to carry out the very best, fair scrutiny and most transparent scrutiny that the constraints on the committee enable us to do. It is important to point out the constraints.
Comment on this
I was in the Seanad and missed some of the debate. On Tuesday, retired Major General Maureen O'Brien spoke about the fact that while there are occasions where peacekeeping missions have ended up becoming engaged in armed conflict, it is much harder to move from a situation of military conflict or armed deployment to peacekeeping than the other way around.
This comes to a key point. When talking about peacekeeping, the vision is not to have soldiers everywhere forever. The vision of peacekeeping in its UN understanding of the term - and this is why this is kind of crucial - relates to the idea of creating space for peacebuilding. Within the UN, we see that understanding because there are structures in peacekeeping that have clear channels and connections to the structures of peacebuilding. Peacekeeping, with the application of the UN, international law and all of that, should then be linked to peacebuilding structures. For some of these other missions, however, such as some of the ones in the Sahel and in Mozambique in which EU troops have been involved, it seems to be harder to make that leap to peacebuilding from them. The focus and the place where Ireland can add value is in peacebuilding. That piece is crucial. Will the witnesses talk about peacebuilding and its construction, including the differences between the EU and the UN? Both witnesses may answer that question, but it was more directed at Ms Boylan.
I know Mr. Andrews is very passionate about the SDGs, as am I. Ireland played a key role in negotiating them. What we have heard from a number of experts is that the "uniting for peace" resolution has been used, can be used and does not require Security Council unanimity for it to be used. We have also heard that Ireland is the kind of country that could help make it happen. As Mr. Andrews has said, while Europe is losing trust internationally, Ireland is actually the kind of country that has trust, partly because of our rigorous UN history and because we do not have a complicated or muddied history from other EU missions or missions that put interests before principles. Will he comment on that? Do we risk losing some of our impact in that space and our capacity to get something like a "uniting for peace" resolution across the line? That question is for either of them as well.
Comment on this
I will come in on the peacebuilding first. There are two important points to be made. The first is Ireland's historical knowledge and experience of peacebuilding that we bring to the table. I will go back to the issue of cohesion policy funds, which we on this island have benefited from for peacebuilding and peace funding. This fund is now being used by EU countries for military purposes and is moving away from the peacebuilding. The EU was set up as a peace project initially.
As Senator Higgins said, it is also important to note that peacebuilding should follow peacekeeping. The UN is a leading instrument in doing that through working with civil society organisations, regional organisations and multilateral banks. The UN fund responds to and addresses critical peacekeeping opportunities. The structures the UN has in terms of peacebuilding pillars and the framework have to be in place. Additionally, money has to be put behind it because peacebuilding also requires money.
The UN's peacebuilding fund, PBF, strategy for 2020 to 2024 has a target of investing €1.5 billion over five years to broaden and deepen actions that would prevent violent conflict. Comparing that with the EU, not only are the cohesion policy funds now moving away from where they were, but the EU peacebuilding initiative is being funded to the tune of €5 million. That is also in the context we have at a time when the EU is proposing to spend €800 million on weapons. Annually, €5 million will be spent on peacebuilding, while €800 million will be spent on weapons. I compare that with the UN and its peacebuilding model of €1.5 billion over five years.
Comment on this
They have a very different focus.
Comment on this
To be clear, the €800 million is not being spent by the EU. The private sector and different member states are included. The EU's own spending is a much smaller figure. Ms Boylan referred to €7 billion for the EDF over seven years, whereas France spends approximately €50 billion a year on defence. The European Union is quite different-----
Comment on this
My time is limited. I sit on the finance committee. We are currently looking at extraordinarily large requests and proposals in terms of EU spending on the SAFE regulation and military spending.
Comment on this
Will Mr. Andrews answer my question on peacebuilding?
Comment on this
As far as the Middle East is concerned, the high point of hope was the Oslo Accords. Norway is a country that has been seen as a peacebuilder. It is the home of the Nobel Prize and the Oslo Accords, yet it is a member of NATO. Norway is very proactive when it comes to peacebuilding. Ireland obviously has that role. Ms Boylan is right, by the way. The investment in peacebuilding at a European level is extremely low. It is a real worry that just 3% of the NDICI-----
Comment on this
I raise the "uniting for peace" resolution and the support Ireland has got in the past across the UN. Will Mr. Andrews discuss the "uniting for peace" mechanism?
Comment on this
I do not think it is all down to the triple lock, for example. It is a combination of things, including our non-colonial history, our very principled approach to international development and sustainable development and multilateralism. All of those things contribute. Is the Senator asking-----
Comment on this
In its current iteration, is Ireland a country that would have good credibility in terms of something like the "uniting for peace" mechanism? For example, the World Food Programme has asked for the "uniting for peace" resolution to be used.
Comment on this
Ireland would be a credible country now in the current situation.
Comment on this
Yes, but that is not based on the triple lock. I have spoken to a lot of people in the EU about the triple lock. They have no idea what I am talking about. People in developing countries have no idea. We are the only people who do it.
We are here to do pre-legislative scrutiny. If the Senator is talking about the Uniting for Peace motion, there is no connection, publicly or internationally-----
Comment on this
In fairness, they know what we are not doing-----
Comment on this
The Senator is very fortunate that she is the first Senator back in. We will go back to the members of the committee now. I call Senator Craughwell.
Comment on this
I welcome the witnesses and thank them for their submissions.
They are both elected through a democratic process to the office they now hold. I therefore assume that they believe in sovereignty. Do they believe Ireland is a sovereign nation capable of making up its own mind with respect to the deployment of its troops? If we were to apply the triple lock to MEPs and had to get permission from Whitehall to allow them to go to Brussels every week, how do they think MEPs would react to that?
Comment on this
Senator Craughwell was not here when I gave my opening statement but I pointed out that a lot of the focus on sovereignty has been on the UN and the Security Council and less so on what the EU is doing at the moment to undermine to undermine the sovereignty of EU member states and in trying to push for qualified majority voting at Council level to do away with unanimity on foreign and security positions-----
Comment on this
With all due respect, are we a sovereign nation?
Comment on this
Does Ms Boylan respect our sovereignty?
Comment on this
Of course I respect our sovereignty. I respect it-----
Comment on this
But she is happy for somebody else to oversee it.
Comment on this
The Senator is clearly happy for Ursula von der Leyen to dictate Ireland's foreign and security policy. I am very concerned by the European Commission. Yes, the UN needs reform. The Senator will not hear any different from me. Is the Senator honestly, hand-on-heart saying that he thinks the EU will respect our sovereignty when it comes to neutrality when all of the evidence shows otherwise? They are trying to remove the unanimity for foreign and security decisions. As I pointed out, Ursula von der Leyen has bypassed the treaties on the functioning of the European Union as it exists and has bypassed them because she-----
Comment on this
Sorry now. Ms Boylan sits in the European Parliament-----
Comment on this
Why does she not bring them to heel?
Comment on this
The Parliament is actually taking a case against Ursula von der Leyen for not-----
Comment on this
-----complying with the treaties. The EU missions, which the Senator would like the Irish Defence Forces to join, would not have the scrutiny of national parliaments.
They would not have the scrutiny of the Parliament to which Mr. Andrews and I were elected, nor of this Parliament, nor the European Charter of Fundamental Rights, nor the European Court of Auditors nor the European Court of Justice. It would have none of that scrutiny.
Comment on this
The Irish troops will not be deployed without the Irish Government.
Comment on this
I remind witnesses it is not up to the Chair on how the members use their time. They direct the question to whomsoever they want the answer from.
Comment on this
One cannot compare the European Union to the constraints from Russia on the Security Council. I am critical of von der Leyen but we have had a net gain in our sovereignty from our membership of the European Union. There are times when we are upset with what it does but the P5 in the United Nations Security Council gives a veto over Irish foreign policy to Russia. We have to remember this discussion is happening in that context. When discussing defence, you have to have a threat analysis. The threat right now for the whole of Europe comes from Russia because Russia has decided it wants to go down the road of spheres of influence in Ukraine, Belarus, Georgia, Moldova and all of its neighbouring countries. Europe is reacting to that. To compare Ursula von der Leyen and say that somehow or another the European Commission is the same as Russia and the influence it has is absurd.
Comment on this
Sorry to cut in again. The point was made. I am as concerned as any citizen in this country at a rogue Government deploying troops somewhere in the world for some war or other. I have a difficulty using the United Nations Security Council but we are a democratically-elected Parliament. There has been suggestion that there should be a referendum. I put to Mr. Andrews that we hold a referendum to change the Constitution to allow all three elements of Government - the President, the Seanad and the Dáil, including this committee - to have a say over the deployment of troops and replace the triple lock with that. That would set the bar high enough that it makes it difficult for a rogue Government. How would Mr. Andrews feel about that?
Comment on this
I am nervous about referendums in general. It is hard to speculate. One would have to be careful about the wording. Sometimes other issues that are live at the time infect the decision-making process. We have seen that in our neighbouring country where they decided to leave the European Union on the basis of a referendum, 52% to 48%. It is a very imperfect way of making laws. I have confidence in the democratic powers of scrutiny of this committee, the Dáil and Seanad. I do not believe in a referendum being the solution all the time whereas sometimes it is, of course, necessary. We have had a good history of referendums in Ireland in recent times. The triple lock is no longer fit for purpose. I said that in my submission earlier. We cannot ignore the new geopolitical situation. We have changed a lot of things since the Lisbon treaty. For the European Union, I have to report that we are seeing an extraordinary change in approach. It is not out of a desire for militarisation; it is a desire to ensure the security and peace of Europe at a time when there is a war on the European continent we cannot ignore.
Comment on this
I do not accept the notion of a firewall. I have never accepted we are a neutral state. We do not fulfil the requirements for neutrality. As Professor Tonra and Ray Murphy said, we do not meet the international law requirement. What is Irish neutrality - it is Irish neutrality. That is it.
Comment on this
We have been involved in Partnership for Peace, PESCO and the Common Security and Defence Policy for years. The Government said it will get involved in the SAFE regulation - it is not about spending more but about spending better and procurement. When we did vaccine procurement, we did it at a European level and got vaccines at a price we could never have got on our own. As we move to level of ambition 2, that is militarisation in Ireland. We are trying to increase our military capacity in Ireland just as the European Union is. It has decided it is not fit for purpose right now. The European Union wants to work together for interoperability, to do procurement together, for civil preparedness and partnerships outside of the European Union including Japan, South Korea, Norway and the UK. We are doing the same. Characterising what the European Union is doing as militarisation is to misread the mood at the moment.
Comment on this
In the interests of transparency, I am here as someone with a mandate to defend neutrality. I was elected on that. In terms of other witnesses, I have nothing to benefit financially from my opening statement, unlike some who may have been quoted. In relation to the SAFE regulation-----
Comment on this
Ms Boylan will have to clarify that. That is a very serious comment. Chair, people's reputations have been brought into question. On witnesses who came before this committee, Ms Boylan said unlike others, who have to benefit.
Comment on this
It does not matter, you cannot let it go.
Comment on this
That has to be challenged.
Comment on this
The SAFE regulation on common public procurement includes not just EU member states but also acceding countries, candidate countries, potential candidate countries and other third countries with which the Union has entered a security and defence partnership. That is an incredibly broad provision and could have serious implications in respect of the use of Irish taxpayers' money for arming any number of countries which would fall into such a broad category.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming here today. I can only imagine how demanding their schedules are flying over and back. To give up an afternoon to come here is very much appreciated. As Mr. Andrews said, nobody else has a triple lock; it is unique to Ireland. Nobody else has an Arc de Triomphe except Paris and nobody else has an Empire State Building. The Arc de Triomphe is probably kind of useless but I like it. I like our triple lock. Maybe its usefulness is under question. I accept the reasons around interrogating its usefulness or otherwise at the moment. My concern is the Bill does not amend it, it removes it completely. In that context, would Mr. Andrews support, like other neutral states like Switzerland or Austria, if we dispense with the triple lock, that we should have an explicit statement of military neutrality put into the Constitution as a backstop? Military experts who came to the committee on Tuesday, namely, my former colleagues, General O'Brien, General Brennan and Colonel Doyle, agreed that in the absence of a Security Council mandate, any likely future mission Irish troops would be involved in, by whatever mechanism, will be peace enforcement or war fighting. They agreed with that definition, that it is war fighting. Given the size of the contingent the Irish could deploy, which the military experts said would be around 300 troops, we will always be under the command of somebody else.
Section 17A(2) of the Defence Act 1954 as amended by the Defence (Amendment) Act 2021, states "In accordance with this Act, the Minister may delegate to a Force Commander the operational control [which is military command] of a contingent, or member, of the Defence Forces." Section 17A(4)(c) states a delegation will:
in so far as is necessary for the efficient operation of a mission, provide that each member of the Defence Forces assigned to an international force led by a Force Commander shall comply with every lawful order issued to him or her by a member of the international force in his or her military chain of command, subject to any exclusion as may be [under the mission parameters].
It also states they will come under military discipline, subject to military law, of whatever force commander is there. How does Mr. Andrews feel about that? Does he agree or disagree that this will fundamentally change the nature, profile and scope of Irish involvement overseas? Does he agree or disagree that is at variance with the Irish public's understanding of our peacekeeping tradition?
In 2022, Russia's criminal invasion of Ukraine happened. It was an obscenity - murdering, raping, theft and looting. It is an obscenity, there is no other word for it. Putin is a war criminal and the Russian forces are engaged in Russian acts. I have attended security briefings at the CIA in Langley, the Pentagon and many other places.
They tell me that half of Russia's armoured fleet has been destroyed. Half of their armoured fighting vehicles, tanks, have been destroyed in Ukraine. The Russian forces are bogged down. They have not managed to achieve any of its war aims. They did not collapse the regime. The only thing they have managed to do is establish a narrow land corridor from Luhansk and Donetsk, down to the Crimean Peninsula. In Europe, I am hearing statements to the effect that Russia will be ready to mount a successful ground invasion against a NATO member state by 2029. We had a German chief of staff say Russia is now producing 1,500 main battle tanks per annum. The fact of the matter is Russia can produce about 200 tanks per annum and it struggles to do that. What it is doing is trying to refurbish old T-60 variant battle tanks that are 60 years old. Does Mr. Andrews believe the Russians are capable of successfully mounting a ground invasion against any NATO member state in Europe in the next four years?
Finally, Mr Andrews is at the beating heart of Brussels. From the distance I am out from it, what I hear is moral panic and groupthink. We had a threat posed by the Soviets. We had nuclear missiles pointed at every capital city in Europe. We had Russian and Warsaw Pact troops throughout central and eastern Europe. What weapons system brought that down? It was our social and economic success. How does Mr. Andrews feel about that sense of moral panic or groupthink? Is it something we ought to consider?
Comment on this
First, on the referendum, I have answered that question earlier. I would be very concerned about putting language into the Constitution. The lawyers would be the biggest winners. We would have a lot of problems. Once again, I would say I have confidence in the powers of scrutiny of this committee and of the Seanad and the Dáil.
Second, on the question of the troop numbers, in Camp Shamrock, where I visited about two or three years ago, it was a Polish-Irish battalion and there is currently a Spanish camp commander there. The Senator is asking about the public perception if we end up having someone who is not from Ireland commanding Irish troops. Irish troops have commanded non-Irish troops and vice versa. It is very good that we have interoperability and that we also learn from the best. We want our troops to be trained by the best, to have the best equipment and the best experience so that they are there and prepared. That is the whole idea as far as I understand it.
Third, on Russia, the Senator is right about the conventional capacity. It is probably very limited but hybrid warfare is where we are at, especially for Ireland where we have threats to critical infrastructure. We have heard so much about cables but there are also threats to pipelines such as our gas pipelines. We rely so much on two gas pipelines that come across from the UK for our electricity and everything that flows from electricity, and we have seen Russian ships having to be escorted away from them. Hybrid warfare is cheap. Drone warfare is cheap and it is evolving every few months.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Andrews think there is a link between that and the triple lock?
Comment on this
The Senator is asking the questions here. Frankly, I do not think most of this has anything to do with the triple lock but I will answer if he is going to ask these questions. As to groupthink, there is a tendency to groupthink in the European Union, yes. It used to be said about the Brits that they did not necessarily do the right thing but they all did the same thing. There might be something like that because I am seeing a massive reduction in development spending. We are all going for hard power right now and soft power being left go of is a dramatic mistake. There is groupthink around that.
Comment on this
I share the Senator's concerns because of the amendment in the Defence (Amendment) Act 2021 because it does mean, if we participate in an international force, under the provisions of the heads of Bill we could have Irish troops technically under the command of EU or NATO commanders. That is very different then just as I talked about the difference between the EU and UN missions. The objectives of those missions are very different. I share the Senator's concerns as I think the Irish population would. Regarding the groupthink in the European Parliament, there absolutely is a moral panic that is there. The Senator is right. We condemn the illegal invasion of Ukraine but what we would like to see, if we are really serious about a peace process and about a dialogue, then tooling up and allowing all EU funds to be used for military expenditure is not sending out a signal to anybody that we are actually serious about a peace process. Therefore, we are sending out mixed messages from the EU as well. I would much rather see the focus and the investment put into a peace process. Ukraine has to be at the heart of that peace process - nothing about them without them - but we are not serious about trying to have a peace process in that conflict.
Comment on this
Does either Ms Boylan or Mr. Andrews believe that Russia will be able to successfully mount a ground invasion against a NATO country by 2029?
Comment on this
I will also just say on the gas pipelines and the hybrid warfare, going back to the point again, the triple lock does not prevent us from investing in our Defence Forces and we currently do not have the personnel to crew the navy ships that could be patrolling our waters. That is nothing to do with the triple lock. We can do that and defend our cables, and the corporations that own those cables should also support that but there is nothing in the triple lock preventing us from doing that.
Comment on this
I thank both witnesses for coming in. Mr. Andrews made a really interesting point there regarding soft power and soft power being let go of being a massive mistake. We are seeing a decrease in development spending and, indeed, peace spending as a consequence of the increases in defence spending. I know Mr. Andrews is chair of the European Parliament Committee on Development as well. How does he align that then? I believe development spending is critical to our soft power. How does that align to the increased defence spending?
Comment on this
Yes. Foreign policy is balanced and should have development, diplomacy and defence.
Comment on this
Yes, I understand that.
Comment on this
Development, unfortunately, is under extreme pressure-----
Comment on this
And it is being cut by the EU in favour of defence spending.
Comment on this
Yes, but it is not an either-or decision. Senator Clonan is asking if we think there could be a Russian ground invasion. I am not sure but Finland and Latvia think there could be-----
Comment on this
My question is more just about-----
Comment on this
Baltic countries think there could be and that is-----
Comment on this
That is Senator Clonan's question. My question-----
Comment on this
-----why they are spending so much money on aid.
Comment on this
This is my time and my question is regarding the soft power. Does Mr. Andrews not think we are letting go of soft power by decreasing our development spending?
Comment on this
I would question then the increase in defence spending in lieu of the increase in development spending as a risk. Given the mandate-----
Comment on this
I will address that, if I can. The UK is saying it has to reduce its overseas aid in order to pay for military expenses. That is not the case. That is wrong. It is not an either-or choice. I would say-----
Comment on this
I feel that is how it is being treated at the EU level at the moment.
Comment on this
No, it is not. The European Union is now funding 42% of overseas development assistance across the world. That is before the Americans pulled out.
Comment on this
However, across EU member states there has been a decrease.
Comment on this
There has been a decrease across the member states. I am not defending that but I would not connect it. I do not think it is acceptable to connect it with increases in defence.
Comment on this
Okay. I would disagree with that.
We have the SAFE regulation that has not gone through the EU Parliament or the Dáil. That means EU battle groups are not accountable to the EU Parliament or the courts, I think. How does that align to sustainable development goal 16, which, for those who might not know, is providing access to justice for all and building effective, accountable and inclusive institutions on all levels? I worry that the fact that those regulations have not gone through those two institutions decreases our accountability. That is a question for both witnesses.
Comment on this
Yes. I know the Senator's time is limited but just to be clear, the EU Parliament has decided to sue the Commission because of its use of Article 122 in the way the SAFE regulation has come onto the Statute Book. Therefore, it is being taken very seriously by the Parliament. We will see how that plays out.
Comment on this
The question was around the sustainable finance and that on 17 June, the Commission adopted the fifth of its omnibus packages, which dealt with defence. One of the measures included was a notice on how the EU sustainable finance and due diligence rules will apply to the defence sector. It has confirmed to us that you cannot discriminate against the defence sector and it will be eligible for sustainable finance. For anyone who does not know, sustainable finance is supposed to be helping us to achieve the objectives of the European Green Deal and the objectives of reducing our carbon emissions and taking climate action. We now have a situation where sustainable finance will be eligible for defence companies that not only are using critical raw materials which are contributing to our carbon emissions - if you look at the carbon emissions of what is happening in Palestine right now it is enormous - but are also diverting funds away from actually addressing climate action. Climate change does lead to increase conflict.
We know that. That was accepted by the UN in 2007. The UN Secretary General at the time, Ban Ki-moon, clearly said that the war in Darfur was the first climate change conflict. Of the 25 countries most vulnerable to climate change, 14 of them are currently suffering from conflict. We do not need funding going to defence and certainly not the sustainable finance fund, which is supposed to address climate change.
Comment on this
I wish to touch on the question of safeguarding in the context of EU battle group missions. We know a lot about the different safeguards that come with a UN deployment. UN missions are a whole holistic thing that include safeguardings, the monitoring of human rights violations and ensuring missions are compliant. Mr. Andrews mentioned in his earlier interventions that the EU’s international law would be a safeguard. I am concerned because the EU is currently not meeting its international obligations vis-à-vis trade with the occupied territories, for example, and the ICJ ruling. Therefore, can we trust that as a legitimate safeguard? I would love to be able to trust that concept as a safeguard, of course. Can we trust it as a safeguard for EU battle groups when the EU is already demonstrating a failure to commit to meeting those obligations?
Comment on this
It is a legitimate question to ask. I am afraid I do not have a great answer, frankly. I am astonished at the way the European Union is approaching the Middle East and the complete fragmentation. In all other contexts and geographies, I am proud of the European Union and the role it plays internationally.
Comment on this
Were there violations in any of the Mali or Niger missions?
Comment on this
Obviously, things do not work from time to time. Push backs on migrants at EU borders is one such example. There are a lot of examples where the EU has fallen below its own standards. It is a treaty and a union of laws and I respect that. I do not accept the idea that the European Union is a negative influence. It has been an incredibly positive influence for Ireland.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I fundamentally agree with that. To come back to the battle groups-----
Comment on this
I accept the point the Senator is making in respect of the credibility of the European Union on the ICJ and ICC rulings and more generally. I do not believe the European Union has supported the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation by the way.
Comment on this
Absolutely. That piece of credibility is what I am getting at. That is my concern when it comes to battle groups. Please let me know whether there are mechanisms at Parliament or the European Court of Human Rights levels to monitor battle groups. I have that sense of safety around the UN missions because of the mechanisms that exist when they are deployed. I do not believe - correct me if I am wrong - similar mechanisms exist for EU battle groups. That is my concern.
Comment on this
That is the case at the moment. The triple lock has nothing whatsoever to do with that. We have the capacity-----
Comment on this
It would lead us to engage in EU battle groups without the UN mandate. It is linked.
Comment on this
We can have participation in EU battle groups anyway. It is not relevant to this discussion. This is an issue that-----
Comment on this
Only up to 12 personnel, surely. The triple lock fundamentally changes our relationship with the EU battle groups and deployments.
Comment on this
No, I do not think so. I do not think that is accurate.
Comment on this
I disagree with that point. I thank Mr. Andrews.
Comment on this
I share the Senator's concerns. We are giving up the triple lock, which is a protection we have. We are asking Deputies, Senators and members of the public to trust our political leaders while political leaders at the European level are ignoring international law. We are asking the Irish people to trust us when we have the President of the European Commission refusing to condemn Israel's illegal attacks on Iran. She actually came out and said that Israel had the right to proactively attack a sovereign country. She did not condemn what happened to the UNIFIL troops. We did not hear proper condemnation when EU diplomats, including Irish diplomats, had weapons pointed at them by Israel. We have a President, who is at the very top of the European Commission, not complying with international law. We are asking people to trust the EU.
Comment on this
We currently only provide training in EU battle groups-----
Comment on this
We will not be obliged to participate in battle groups.
Comment on this
While we will not be obliged, there are no safeguards to say we will not do it. We may not be obliged but-----
Comment on this
While the Senator was out, we had a fairly good discussion about the pressure that might be applied to Ireland. There is no evidence whatsoever, in my opinion, that Ireland would come under pressure, historically or otherwise.
Comment on this
At every opportunity we have had to deploy our 12 troops to any place, Ireland has done it.
Comment on this
We have deployed troops to Afghanistan. Any opportunity that has been given to us to deploy our 12 or below troops on a rolling basis, Ireland has participated in that, including missions. While I am not saying our troops were ever involved in anything that was human rights non-compliant, they have been deployed to such missions in an overall sense, including Afghanistan. That has happened historically.
Comment on this
I am going to cut it at that. I have been more than generous with time. I hope everyone is satisfied that they had a fair hearing. On behalf of the committee, I thank our two MEPs, Ms Boylan agus Mr. Andrews, for being here today and for the material they circulated to the committee in advance of today's meeting. The meeting now stands adjourned until Thursday, 10 July at 9.30 a.m., when the joint committee will meet in public session to continue our pre-legislative scrutiny of the general scheme of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2025. Go raibh maith agaibh go léir.