We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Health

HSE National Service Plan 2026: Discussion

Summary

Committee scrutiny of the HSE’s 2026 service plan focused on funding, staffing, access to care and whether promised capacity will actually be delivered. Bernard Gloster said the plan is built around €29 billion and 3,300 new posts, with extra beds, surgical hubs, expanded screening, mental health and GP services, and he stressed the need for reform, regional performance management and a multi-annual funding approach. Deputies pressed him on long waiting lists, uneven emergency care, GP card take-up, primary care centres, cancer and respite services, and whether some new beds were simply delayed projects from 2025 being repackaged. Gloster defended the plan but accepted the need for better delivery, simpler access for patients, and faster opening of capital projects.

Contributions 180–353 of 353. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Mr. Bernard Gloster

The short answer is I cannot do so. How would the State incentivise gardaí to come to Dublin? How would I incentivise public health nurses to work where Deputy Sherlock is? It would fracture the entire public service model to try to incentivise. I would hope the beauty of Dingle alone would attract some people. That is the best I can do.

Comment on this

Respite for children and adults with profound disabilities is something I have raised many times as a TD here and as a councillor at home in Kerry for many years. There is a chronic shortage of respite beds. Parents tell me they are waiting six and seven months. We have a fabulous centre, St. Mary of the Angels, in Whitefield in Beaufort, where St. Francis Special School is also located. I keep saying this is an ideal location. It was donated for children by the Doyle family many years ago and there is plenty of development land there. We really need to do something on respite. People are on their knees and begging for help. It is not fair. They are not getting a wink of sleep 24-7. Is there any light at the end of the tunnel for these families?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The Minister, Deputy Foley, and Minister of State, Deputy Emer Higgins, are certainly very focused on this issue, as is the Cabinet committee on disability which I attend. There has been substantial investment this year.

As regards respite across the different categories, this year, day-only respite will increase from 66,000 to 91,000 instances, the number of people in receipt of disability and respite services will increase from 6,300 to 7,300 and the number of overnights will increase from 164,000 to 175,000. We are investing an additional €25 million in respite, targeting children in particular. What we have said to all our regions, supported by the disability capital plan and revenue plan, is we want to see the HSE itself directly take on more provision, rather than relying on the traditional models, by buying houses, staffing them with social care staff and providing constant respite. There is progress being made on that.

Comment on this

My office has been contacted by families with regard to the cut in respite from four weeks back to two weeks, which is causing a lot of hardship. Can this be reversed any time soon?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Where is that?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I will certainly look at that. I did not authorise anyone to cut anything. I will have to go behind-----

Comment on this

If he could, Mr. Gloster might look at that and come back to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I am a bit surprised to hear that, being honest.

Comment on this

We have a number of cases.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I will certainly look at that.

Comment on this

At University Hospital Kerry, oncology numbers are sadly increasing all the time and patients are travelling to Cork and Limerick, etc. Can the new oncology unit at the hospital be pushed forward? There is a great organisation locally which has done a lot of fundraising, etc.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

With the estates team, both in the south west and nationally, we are genuinely trying to see how we can expedite the development and utilisation of all the capacity of Kerry general hospital. We are in trouble there as regards capacity, and we know that.

Comment on this

I have raised the CAMHS scandal in north and south Kerry many times. When will the long-awaited look-back review be published? How are we faring as regards compensation and services for the children in question, many of whom are young adults now? We need to get this right and ensure it never happens again.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

There are two parts to that. First, when there is a problem, if you spend too much time looking back at it and not enough time correcting it, you are in trouble. A lot of time has gone into correcting and improving CAMHS service provision. This is being led nationally by Dr. Amanda Burke, one of our outstanding clinical directors. That work is ongoing and I have a lot of confidence in the service today compared to what it was several years ago. There is more to do.

As the Deputy will know, the south Kerry piece and the compensatory aspect have been dealt with. The north Kerry audit is finished. It is going through some final engagement between my team in the south west and the Department to process the implications of it. I expect we will hear more on that shortly. There are a lot of complications behind it, including legal complications which I am not in a position to go into, but the matter is receiving much attention.

Comment on this

Will the ambulance base to serve the Killorglin and mid-Kerry area be in place any time soon? I have been calling for it for many years. What is the status of the relocation of the ambulance base in Cahersiveen?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

We are looking at both of those this year. With our estates, we have a good capital allocation. There are a number of local issues, which the Deputy will be aware of, and there is a question of what exactly we would put into Cahersiveen and Killorglin. We are looking at it this year. I will come back to the Deputy specifically on this issue, which is on our agenda for 2026.

Comment on this

When will the pause on recruitment of physician associates be lifted? When will the physician associate review be published? How does the HSE intend to utilise physician associates within the national service plan 2026, particularly in understaffed and underserved services?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

We have finalised the report and are in discussions with our colleagues in the Department as to the next steps. What we want to do is ensure that there is a clear definition of the role of the healthcare context and that this role is safe, supportive and works within a multidisciplinary team. Primary among our concerns when we are looking at any discipline, whether it is doctors, nurses, health and social care professionals or, indeed, physician associates, is the provision of safe, appropriate care within a multidisciplinary team. That report is finalised, and it is the subject of a discussion with the Department.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I submitted it to the Department two weeks ago.

Comment on this

I suggest we take a quick break. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I wish Mr. Gloster well in whatever his future may hold. I also thank him for the service he has given to the public over many a long year. I wish him the very best of luck. I hope there is a warm and sunny climate on his horizon for a while. He has definitely earned it.

I will start with mental health, specifically CAMHS. I read the document that was provided to members. A total of 2,205 additional children and young people will be seen, which is a 19% increase. I am struggling with these figures because I also read that there are now 4,375 children on the waiting list compared to 2,115 in 2020. There has been a massive increase in the number of children waiting over a year. How does the HSE plan to achieve that increase of 19%? When I ask about it, I am told there is pressure on services, staff cannot be recruited and the teams are not full. Will Mr. Gloster talk me through how the HSE intends to reach that 19% increase?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

There are two things that I believe will help. I want to be honest and, in fairness to the Deputy, every time I have come before the committee, she has articulated that concern well. It is one I share. I am not going to fool anyone by saying that I think we are going to have it all cracked and sorted. However, there are the additional mental health development posts this year and also the improvements that have been made in services, which have been led by Dr. Amanda Burke and the team across the country.

I will put two things together that I think will fundamentally help. On 9 February, the new autism protocol goes live for use in the health service. I believe that will respond to a cohort of people who previously, in the absence of other pathways, were finding themselves referred and then waiting in the CAMHS space for quite a while. That is one point. The second is that of the 4,000 children who are waiting, I believe a number can be well supported and responded to by either primary care or disability services. With the single point of access model I introduced in October, we have gone from a multitude of referral forms - I think there were 47 different forms - to one referral form for children. That model will go live very shortly and under it, CAMHS, disability services and primary care services will work together to see who is best placed to respond to the child.

Those two things will help. They will not resolve everything.

Comment on this

In the context of CAMHS, no doubt the witnesses have been following some of the issues the committee has been looking at in recent times, one of which is eating disorders. A very real concern was put to the committee by Cared Ireland and Bodywhys about the lack of a national transition pathway between CAMHS and YAMHS for young adults who are transitioning out. There is a cliff edge in this regard. In terms of the 19% increase in CAMHS provision, is a transition pathway being examined as part of the service plan pathway for 2026 and will it be implemented?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The team will be before the committee in the next two or three weeks for a detailed session on CAMHS. I have asked that it specifically address that and go into the detail of it for the committee. The team will explain it better than I could. There are a lot of clinical dimensions to it. The focus now is not just on looking at CAMHS but looking at the subset of conditions like eating disorders. Not every child who requires an eating disorder response from CAMHS is the same as those children who require other responses.

Comment on this

No two children are the same.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We need to stream the response to make sure those types of different transitions can happen. No more than 20 years ago, I and others struggled to try to bring clarity to children leaving CAMHS and going into adult mental health services. All of those transitions are better, but we are not there yet by any means.

Comment on this

What measures does the service plan for 2026 contain to address the fact that there are no specialist eating disorder teams at all in 14 counties?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We have more eating disorder teams now than we had before.

Comment on this

Are they staffed?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

To varying degrees.

Comment on this

I am glad Mr. Gloster admits that because it was one of the issues that came up at the committee engagement, and nobody could say whether this model of care had ever been fully resourced and staffed. There is a real concern in this regard. It is a mental health condition that involves the highest level of mortality.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The Deputy has landed on an important square. Apart from eating disorder teams, I have the same with children's disability network teams, with CAMHS teams in general and with multidisciplinary teams across services, whether they relate to stroke or other forms of care. Every service wants the highest bar when it comes to multidisciplinary teams. To be fair to successive Ministers, there is a notion that if they resource them or approve the resources for them - the Minister of State, Deputy Butler has not been short in that regard - we can fill every multidisciplinary team with the professionals we want despite the fact that we only have a limited supply of professionals. We have to find better ways and different models. That is why you end up with the binary thing whereby not every team is fully staffed.

Comment on this

They are not functioning as a result.

The issue of dental care, particularly for children, gave rise to one of the most frustrating committee engagements I have been involved. There is a really excellent example of how it is working very well in Galway. However, the latter seems to be despite the system that is in place as opposed to because of it. There is no mention of dental hygienists at all in the service plan or of expanding the scope of work they do. This is despite the fact that a diminishing number of children are being seen through the screening programme, and there are growing delays. Where did this go wrong and how do we fix it? It went wrong somewhere, and it needs to be fixed.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

The probable reason it is not mentioned in the service plan is that we are working with the Department to shortly bring forward an implementation plan for the strategy we talked about when we came before the committee previously. The Minister has been talking with the Department specifically about hygienists, and that will be part of that plan. The Department and the HSE recognised from the meeting we had with the joint committee that there was a necessity to do something about that urgently. We hope we will bring forward proposals in the implementation plan that will be creative and innovative as to how we manage the immediate situation relating to children. There was a sense that the dental treatment services scheme has stabilised, but there is a clear recognition that there are significant waiting lists for children-----

Comment on this

I hope that will not involve removing the entitlement to this service.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

No, not at all.

Comment on this

Because that would be deeply concerning. There is reference in the document to mobile dental clinics. What are mobile dental clinics? How does the HSE intend to use them?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

There is an innovation whereby we are looking at how we would use them. We used mobile dental clinics in the past. We are looking at how we could roll out the demonstration site to try to do that. That is one of the initiatives. It is not the complete situation, but it would contribute to people being able to go to particular areas with their children and gain access to examination and treatment.

Comment on this

Why would such clinics be preferable to primary care centres?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

It is not that they is preferable. It is just an additional and innovative solution that may be beneficial in contributing to meeting the overall requirement.

Comment on this

I thank the CEO and his team for coming in today. I listened with interest to the comprehensive statement he made. There was a lot of good news and a lot of what one might call aspirational news. That is mixed with the bit of sadness or celebration in the final paragraph, I do know what you would call it. Mr. Gloster mentioned that this will be his final appearance before an Oireachtas committee. During my short term here and in the years during which I watched "Oireachtas Report", he has been an exemplary civil servant in many ways. He did his job with care, compassion, honesty and efficiency. Indeed, he did it with frankness. I like that in anyone because we sometimes hear what we do not want to hear. It is that honesty that makes him a huge loss. I wish him very well in the future.

I have a particular passion for assessments of need, CAMHS and CDNTs. I say that in the context where, while I know this plan is a vision for 2026, one thing that concerns me is that we know the target for CAMHS is to have 78% seen within 12 weeks and that in CDNTs, there is a reduction of 25%. My question on CAMHS concerns the 22% who will not be lucky. I am always reminded, and let us not forget, that these are the formidable years in anyone's life. I hope and expect that if we were to review this document in a year's time, we could look back and say that we achieved those targets. In the context of addressing the need that exists, 78% is absolutely fine. Is Mr. Gloster confident that what he outlined in his statement can be achieved?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

When discussing something as complex as children's disability services, I am always reticent to frame it as being purely binary in terms of numbers. I understand that numbers matter. I have listened with interest to and participated in the discourse over a number of years whereby we are talking about the number of people waiting. It is important that we talk about this and recognise it. In disability services, if you listened to some of the commentary, you would think it is the one area where there has been no improvement at all. The number of children's disability network teams that are now functioning well is light years away from what was the case even three years ago. The number of children being seen by children's disability network teams is light years away from where it was as well. There are people waiting, and that is the worry.

On assessments of need - and the Government is looking at the legislative aspect - the truth is that the way it is currently structured and used means it is impossible for us to comply with the law.

It will remain impossible because we are performing against an outdated construct in assessments of need. Of the children being referred for assessments of need, about one third go through that process and come out the far end with no indication of a disability. That is not good for the children, not good for their families and, quite frankly, not good in the context of the resources we are trying to apply. There are people who think they need an assessment of need in order to access services. Maybe that is our fault. People think they do, but they do not. The truth is that we are tying up an enormous amount of effort in just trying to do the assessments. If even a proportion of that resource was available to provide actual services after the assessments, children would be far better off. That part is changing. It is changing rapidly this year. I had a conversation with the Minister of State, Deputy Emer Higgins, in the past few days. I met young Cara Darmody again this week. I have met her three times now. We will make substantial improvements in both assessments and the provision of therapy services to children. Unless we reform the process relating to assessments of need, however, it will just become the type of very negative story that does not help anybody.

Comment on this

In recent times, Portiuncula hospital has referred high-risk cases to other centres.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

That is correct.

Comment on this

That was done for very good reason and was based on solid clinical advice. In terms of where we are now and when the HSE anticipates normal services will resume, is it fair to say that we are well on the road to getting to where we want to be?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We took part in a lengthy committee hearing on Portiuncula hospital recently. Perhaps Dr. Henry can assist me with this. Can I simply say this: my concentration on Portiuncula hospital is in the context of making it the best possible service it can be for the 80% of people who continue to be booked there and who receive services there. My focus on Portiuncula hospital is to make sure that it is considered in the same way as the other 19 units across the country in the new maternity strategy, the approach to which the Minister for Health, Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, is contemplating because the current one is going to run out this year . If the clinical advice given to me tomorrow is X,Y or Z, that is what I rely on. I do not hide behind clinical advice. The accusation is that we are trying to close Portiuncula hospital by stealth. The Minister has no desire whatsoever to close any part of the health service, but we are obliged to make it safe. Right now, we are continuing to book higher risk women into Galway or into other centres of their choice. We will continue to improve the service for the other women. That is where I see it being for them.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Understandably, there is focus on the diversion of high-risk women. However, there is much more to this. Twelve reviews have been completed and five remain to be completed. There are 52 recommendations pertaining to clinical care, communication between teams or within teams, communication with patients, training and follow-up to adverse events. The external team is working on those, but they do not grab as much attention. It is not just about the diversion of those who are deemed to have high-risk pregnancies. It is about improving care on the foot of the recommendations coming out of the 12 reviews that have been completed. As stated, there are five reviews yet to come.

Comment on this

Go raibh maith agaibh. Once again I wish the CEO the very best of good luck.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I thank the Deputy.

Comment on this

The committee will come back to the provision of maternity services and the national maternity strategy. There is a strong interest among members in respect of that area of women's health. We will be looking at it in more detail next time.

Comment on this

I will start the by thanking Mr. Gloster for his hard work, honesty and straight talking, and for his straight answers when he has been here. I appreciate that.

The first matter I want to raise is symptomatic breast screening and diagnostic breast screening. I have raised this previously. When a girl visits her GP and is referred urgently, or even non-urgently, with signs of breast cancer to a symptomatic breast clinic, I do not understand how she is not scanned on the day she attends the clinic. I was diagnosed 13 years ago. I had a triple assessment. Had I been sent away to wait six months, I probably would not be sitting here. My cancer was extremely aggressive. In younger women, it is particularly aggressive. I have huge concerns about women being effectively triaged on two occasions, because they are triaged when they get there as well. Even if they are part of the worried well, I do not think anybody should be walking around with a tumour in their body not knowing whether it is cancerous or non-cancerous. Will there be a focus on improving matters in this regard?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

To distinguish, there are two issues. There is screening, and I know the Senator understands this distinction. There is the mammogram, as people will know. Our aim is to return to a two-year screening programme. We have had a shortage of radiographers over the past few years. Then there are what the Senator referred to as the urgent breast clinics where we need to see people within ten working days. The Senator is quite correct. It is not just a question of being seen, it is about having access to the proper diagnostics. Of course, we face difficulties with diagnoses right across all cancer services because we are becoming more highly reliant on diagnostics and more refined imaging is required. It is an essential part of us delivering on the commitment to see people within ten working days in an urgent breast clinic so that from the moment they attend they have access to appropriate and timely diagnostics to enable a rapid diagnosis, bearing in mind that over half of breast cancers are diagnosed through these urgent breast clinics, and so they can enter treatment pathways as soon as possible. We are concerned with the whole end-to-end pathway, which is good screening, the timeliness of urgent breast clinic attendance, the diagnostics to follow, the surgery to follow and the chemotherapy or radiotherapy to follow for those who receive an unfortunate diagnosis. It should be one seamless pathway. There are problems with diagnostics and they reflect the increased referrals we are seeing to these clinics. It also refers to the way that the treatments change and expectations change, and the need for more refined diagnostics. It is something we are focusing on not just through our cancer strategy but also through our national imaging strategy.

Comment on this

I just feel something changed over the years. At the time I was diagnosed, I would have known a lot of girls under the age of 40 who were also diagnosed. They all got triple assessments at their first appointments. I cannot say enough about how aggressive cancer is in younger women. Six months is too long for a girl to wait.

Reference was also made to waiting times in accident and emergency departments for people over the age of 75. I would like to see people who are 70 years of age and older being tagged, and maybe people who have dementia and those who have autism and are in accident and emergency departments. My father, who passed away in October, was 74 and had dementia. We were waiting in an accident and emergency department, which was very traumatic, but he did not fall under the age range to be tagged. I was waiting with him for over 30 hours. I had just been elected to the Seanad. I will acknowledge, however, that a few months later, the waiting time was between four to six hours. The new chief executive in Tallaght hospital obviously acknowledged the issue, she made changes and used her expertise. I did notice a positive change there, and I want to acknowledge that. However, I would like to see people-----

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We have made a change, and that change is welcome. While we have had a couple of days where that has slipped, just because of the sheer volume, I think we have made a consistent change. We started with people who were admitted and were waiting on trolleys because they are the people who can decondition most quickly. We are now focused on the experience of older people coming into our accident and emergency departments. I met a family recently who have given me feedback and have given me a particular suggestion as to how we can particularly tag, and I mean that in a caring way, those people who present with questionable levels of dementia or cognitive impairment in order that they are not lost in our system and, at the same time, are not stereotyped. I know my successor will be focused on that.

The Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, never fails to remind me how struck she is every time she goes into an emergency department if there is an older person waiting even for a moment without the apparent signs of their being fully attended to. We have to keep that micro focus if we are really going to improve as a health service. We can do that with those extra resources. That is the truth.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

The focus on older people comes not just from the self-evident poor experience that might happen with a long wait but also from the immeasurable harm associated with that. There is evidence accumulating on this in the context of older people.

It is quite arbitrary to have a cut-off for what is considered to be older but there has to be a cut-off somewhere and it is 75. There is accumulating evidence that measurable harm is associated with protracted stays in emergency departments for older people compared with younger people.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I hope we do not go back to those days because there were stories and experiences. There is nothing more shameful than seeing an older person on their own, disorientated, on a trolley or in a chair, with difficulties with toileting and eating, and the entire trauma this brings, apart from the reason they are there. We have been intent on improving this but we can never ever relax on this focus.

Comment on this

I totally agree. To see somebody vulnerable in a very humiliating state is difficult, especially if they do not have family with them.

With regard to dental services, will there be a return to observing children in school? Things took a dip when nurses stopped going into schools to check children's teeth. That is probably where a lot of things went wrong. Mobile clinics were mentioned. Would they be a way of getting back into schools?

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

During the pandemic we stopped but now we continue to do examinations. One of the challenges for us is that we are not seeing all of the children. We do second, fourth and sixth classes and the predominant focus is on sixth class at the moment. Last year, across second, fourth and sixth classes and special classes, we did 147,000 examinations. We should have done 216,000 examinations in the school academic year. We continue to follow up on those. The plan we are bringing forward will hopefully address how we might target some of these waiting lists.

Comment on this

I echo the sentiments of all of my colleagues and wish Mr. Gloster the best of luck in his retirement and wish him many happy years ahead. I have a few questions. The plan states that 100% of maternity units will implement the Irish maternity early warning system in 2026. What consequences will apply to units that fail to meet the targets? How will the implementation be audited?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

They will implement it. It is ingrained in maternity safety in the units. It follows some high-profile events where the findings following investigations showed failures to track and identify deterioration in women, particularly sepsis. It is a critical part of our safety work in maternity units.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

To answer the fundamental question, and I do not want to be disparaging, this is a case of joining the army and wearing the boots. They do not have a choice and they do not get to opt out. This is mandatory, they have to implement it and that is it.

Comment on this

How will it be audited?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Each unit is led through a clinical governance structure that goes right up to the clinical directors and REOs, such as Ms Long who is here. We consider this to be core not only for individual practitioners but for the management of any maternity unit. It is a core safety requirement.

Comment on this

If there are issues with the implementation of it, will the public be aware of it? Will the public see the data or see which hospitals are not as good as others at implementing this?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

In recent months we published the latest round of our maternity safety data and other metrics. For the first time we deanonymised the list and named by site, and that will be a feature of it. To be fair to maternity units, most of them want to do the right thing and to do it well. The national women and infants health programme under Dr. Henry supports them to achieve it. This is not something I am worried about. I am worried about other things but I am not worried about this.

Comment on this

How has the HSE embedded the lived experience of women into the strategy, as opposed to just referencing it in policy?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

The original maternity strategy, which is coming to a close, was commissioned by the then Minister for Health, Leo Varadkar. My recollection is that patient representatives were involved. I cannot remember the detail exactly but there was broad representation in the strategy. Now that it is coming to an end, there may be a new strategy and that will be completely up to the Minister and the Department. I would expect, as with any such strategy, that there would be public and patient participation, inclusion and input into it.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We now have, for the first time ever, full-time paid patient participation managers' representatives in each region. Part of their job is to ensure we get the engagement of the public to influence how we plan and design services. I will give the example of endometriosis. The Minister held a patient forum last September, which I attended with her, and we had a subsequent meeting with the forum in October at which we launched the framework. She will bring them all back together on 5 March to review our progress and test us to see how we have done on the inclusion of the patient voice. That type of approach is the modern way of designing healthcare.

Comment on this

That is brilliant. The Minister has directed a move beyond hospital waiting lists to primary care access. What accountability mechanism exists if a region fails to meet the therapy wait time targets?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

In the service plan for this year we have a new iteration of what we call the performance and accountability framework. Each region gets a resource and an outcome it is expected to achieve, which includes adopting the primary care waiting list initiative that Mr. Healy is supporting. The regions will no longer report through a complex system but directly to me. The data of the performance is used in this engagement. It is published. There is an accountability framework through which a region can be escalated if it is underperforming. This can go right up to and include interventions by me.

Comment on this

The plan emphasises greater autonomy of health regions alongside stronger accountability. What specific consequences will follow a region if it consistently underperforms?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

This is the performance accountability framework. Again, I do not want to start from the negative construct that they underperform. A lot of people we have working are very good people who aspire to and do achieve great results. There are a couple of levels of intervention. We can support and we can put in place specific corrective action plans. We can progress right up to removing executive control of the region and replacing it with direct executive control by me or somebody I would appoint. Quite significant steps can be taken.

Comment on this

I thank everybody for coming before the committee. I want to be associated with the kind wishes to Mr. Gloster. Since I first came here a number of months ago, he has been nothing but kind and courteous. The first question he always asks me is how my wife is, and that is the sign of a good man. I thank him very much.

We spoke earlier about surgical hubs. It is Letterkenny on schedule?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

In my opening statement I said that five would open this year. Mount Carmel opened last year and Tallaght is pre-existing, and these will bring us to seven. I said two more would go to the next stage of the development and these are Letterkenny and Sligo, which we only announced a short few months ago. The design work is starting on these now.

Comment on this

As we are speaking about Letterkenny, Mr. Gloster said that he would visit the dialysis unit there. Has there been any movement on this? The building is there and it is just a matter of kitting it out. Is there any movement on getting this pushed forward?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Everybody is pushing to get to the right place with it and to do the right thing with it. I am just not 100% up to date with where it is at today. To be fair to Senator Boyle, because he has asked me twice, I will come back to him with a formal position on it in writing. It is a fair question.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gloster. Every day we receive phone calls about community hospitals and beds not opening. What is the update specifically on Killybegs and Ballyshannon? Will they be open soon? These are the beds that older people want to have near their homes.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

These beds face a number of challenges. I have made it clear to the region that it already has the resources available to it, historically and in the resources received this year. There are recruitment challenges in particular counties with staffing units such as these and agreeing staffing levels but I do not think this is a showstopper. Another element is that I am just not happy generally with the rate of opening or reopening community beds, particularly on the western seaboard.

We are particularly slow when we either close a bed to rebuild it or when we build a new one. That is why the target this year is that any new bed, any bed available and commissioned, has to be staffed and opened this year.

Comment on this

We were getting word back that HIQA was in the hospitals making changes.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes, and there can be a HIQA intervention where it believes the refurbished building has a particular deficit. There was one in Senator Maria Byrne's area in St. Camillus's Hospital when we rebuilt it. It had a particular issue. The point is that if HIQA has an issue, our job is to fix it quickly. Usually it is something to do with a door or a staircase. It is Bob the Builder stuff; it is not rocket science. We should be able to do these things faster. I am not that happy about that attitude of "Ah well, it's HIQA and sure that's grand then, we'll leave it closed for another six months". That is just not good enough.

Comment on this

In my area, in Killybegs, there have been serious delays. I cannot fathom how long it has taken, to be honest.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

In the modern era, whatever about old beds and HIQA having concerns about them, when we take steps to either close, rebuild or provide new beds, we should be well out the gate with HIQA before we finish the building of those beds. Those are the basics of good, effective management of a project. It is on us. They are too slow. For as long as I am in the chair for the next few weeks, we will still go after it.

Comment on this

One issue I keep taking up is the ambulance service in Donegal. Mr. Healy is probably tired of listening to me. One of the most important things in a rural county is to have a good ambulance service. A couple of weeks ago, there was a flu epidemic. Everybody knows about that but ambulances were waiting at the hospitals. On local radio it was said there were nine or 12 queuing up at a time. Can we have a patient handover service that would free things up? I keep coming back to Killybegs and I apologise for that, but it would be a real game-changer for Killybegs to get the second ambulance back. There are cruise ships coming in now. This year alone, 20,000 extra people are coming in through the port. Next year, they are looking to have 35,000 and we have one ambulance. Twenty years ago, we had two and it was working well. Given where Killybegs is, it really needs the second one. It covers a large area from Glencolmcille up to Inver Bridge and down to Fintown. I do not know why it was taken away. I suppose it was all cost saving. It really needs to be reinstated.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Before Mr. Healy comes in on the resourcing of Donegal, I might say two things briefly. The ambulance service particularly, if not exclusively, in rural Ireland, like on the Inishowen Peninsula and other places, is one of the most important services and one of the highest risk jobs. I send my good wishes to two paramedics who were injured in a serious road traffic accident up there just before the winter. I hope we will see them back to full health. On the issue of ambulances standing on ramp in Letterkenny Hospital, I was on every day over Christmas that the hospital where I am most concerned about ambulance delays is Letterkenny. We have a hospital-ambulance liaison person at the back door of the hospital. I appreciate demand can mean ambulances have to wait a bit longer but the delays in wait times there are wholly unacceptable. They are no fault of the National Ambulance Service. It is an unacceptable position. I have made that clear. I have seen some improvements there but daily, seven days a week, we are following it to improve it because it is not acceptable. Mr. Healy might comment on the resources.

Comment on this
Mr. Pat Healy

Castlebar and Letterkenny are getting a full hospital-ambulance liaison service. We have worked closely with the REO and the teams there. We are putting additional resources in. There will be two in Castlebar and two in Letterkenny. That will provide a full service. In addition, the REO is working with us and looking at Galway and Portiuncula. In relation to the overall ambulance service, the Senator raised it specifically when we were here in October to discuss the National Ambulance Service and has done so since on a few other occasions. I am glad to be able to say that in 2026, there are additional ambulances going into the north west and one going into Killybegs. The Senator will be glad to hear that. That is approved for the year. The other important thing for the north west, which we spoke about previously, is the HEM service. The HEM service will come into play and eight additional staff are approved for it. It will go ahead. It will be an important service for that whole north-west area and rural areas. I am glad to be able to report that both of those will be of benefit to the Senator's area.

Comment on this

I am really thankful. It was an issue even before I got into politics about ten or 15 years ago. My father and I saw my mother get sick and we had to wait so long, an hour and a half, for the ambulance to come from Letterkenny. One of the reasons I got into politics was to try to get the ambulance reinstated in Killybegs. I am eternally grateful and I thank the HSE very much.

Does Mr. Gloster see cancer care improving in Letterkenny in the short term?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes, both in performance and when we build the surgical hub. We will put an extra 15 chairs in for treatment to bring up the number of people who can be treated, and particularly people receiving chemotherapy locally. The short answer is that we are absolutely intent on improving the service there.

Comment on this

I wish Mr. Gloster all the best in his retirement. I am sure I will see a lot more of him around Limerick but you never know where he might disappear to or hibernate for a while. I am well aware of his working commitment through the years, from when he started off in the HSE and worked his way up. I wish him, Mary and the family all the best. I hope he enjoys his retirement.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

I thank him for everything and for his service through the years. I want to ask about the service plan for rehab beds. We have a very fine facility in Limerick. We have St. Camillus's, there is St. Ita's in Newcastle West and there is the National Rehabilitation Hospital but a large number of people are on the waiting list to get in. Is there any hope of expanding the service? People have benefited so much from it. I know somebody who had an operation in Cork a couple of months ago and they spent, I think, an extra three weeks in Cork - bed blocking is what I would call it - because they were waiting to get into the rehab service. They were advised they could not go home because if they did, they would lose their place.

On rehab care in community health settings and in-house, once someone is over 68, they are not as important a patient - that might be the best way of putting it. They do not receive the same level of care. I know someone who was discharged from rehab. They were told they would receive physio and different things in the community setting but then they were told that because they were over 68, they did not qualify, whereas in some areas they would actually qualify. There seems to be a difference depending on what area someone is in.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The National Rehabilitation Hospital is an outstanding facility and service. There will never be enough of it and that is the truth with the prevalence of major trauma and other things in people's lives. There are plans to expand it. We also have to increase the level of rehabilitation available locally. It is never going to be the same as that but Dr. Henry has done a lot of work with colleagues on the trauma strategy and the rehabilitation strategy. I still think that while we are doing the more complex rehab, we have to continue to develop the multidisciplinary rehab levels in St. Camillus's, St. Ita's, Thurles, Ennis, St. Finbarr's in Cork and so on. We have to keep doing that because it gets people back to some level or standard. I assure the Senator that I do not know who anywhere in the Irish health service thinks they have the right to determine eligibility. I have never heard a reference to 68 years of age but I have no doubt someone somewhere said it. I must stress there is no requirement or legislative provision for any person to be refused access to a community healthcare service and there is no requirement for them to pay for it. I would imagine that perhaps an area has decided that because it has such a limited number of therapists, it has to target the people they feel they can exploit more potential in.

We will certainly check it out, but that is not an issue of which I am aware. I do not know if Mr. Lynch wants to add anything.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick Lynch

No, it does not apply.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

And rehab?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

No.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

It is a very important service. It is going to be the defining feature into the future as to how many people will experience a continued quality of life at home versus just automatically becoming dependent on care.

Comment on this

That is perfect. In terms of children with disabilities and long-stay beds, I have worked with one or two families where maybe the parents are getting older or there is a single parent left and one is deceased, and the family are concerned. I know of one particular lady who had a stroke. The daughter had to go into residential care but was moved a couple of counties away. Is there any way of regionalising or trying to put people into residential settings as close as possible to their family home? Are there any plans or is anything being looked at in terms of extra delivery around different areas?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

This is something the Taoiseach, the Tánaiste, the Minister, Deputy Foley, and the Minister of State, Deputy Higgins, are extremely focused on in the service plan this year. The number of residential places in Ireland for people with a disability will go from 8,600-odd - nearly 8,700 - to over 9,000 this year, so there is a development in that. What we call priority 1 residential places are for people who may have a parent caring for them and the parent dies or becomes unwell. We had planned to do 70 of those last year. We ended up doing 205. We will end up doing at least that again this year. Therefore, the answer is "Yes", and all of those are locally developed places either by providers or by us. We are doing a framework in the next few weeks with the private sector because, first, we need to improve the quality and measure the quality of private provision, like nursing homes. Private provision in disability care is now a common feature. That does not make it a bad thing, but we have to put safeguards around it. We also have to control the price. Residential care now for an individual adult, depending on the level of complexity, could be anywhere between €300,000 and €500,000 per year for the rest of his or her life. We have to make sure that care is appropriate and right, so that is what the focus is. However, the provision is there for extra places this year.

Comment on this

Okay. I thank Mr. Gloster. The service plan talks about elderly people maybe being admitted or discharged within 24 hours. At one stage, there was a two-way system running in some of the hospitals where maybe older people were being sent one direction and younger people the other direction or maybe people who were more acute, but that has been stopped. Was it working or was there a reason it has been stopped? I did understand it was working in terms of older people in particular.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

We have pathways and specific metrics for older people because as I mentioned earlier to previous Deputies' questions, we know there is more harm associated with protracted waits in emergency departments. They are focused on minimising the stay, not just on trolleys but people's whole experience through the emergency department. Looking at the experience of older people in hospitals and at their triage, 82% of them fall within the top three triage categories, which suggests that the great majority of older people who come to emergency departments need the attention of emergency departments. While we have other services put in place in the community and we have established 30 integrated care programme for older persons, ICPOP, centres throughout the country, our focus is not just on older people on trolleys but on their time waiting in emergency departments to complete through to either discharge or admission. On that point, half of older people aged over 75 who are admitted come to emergency departments, so just over 50%.

Comment on this

That is okay. I have one last question. There are plans for 20 inpatient beds around child and adolescent mental health services, CAMHS, and younger people. Will they be delivered this year in this service plan?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The 20 in the new children's hospital?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes.

Comment on this

That is great. I thank Mr. Gloster.

Comment on this

Next on our list is Deputy O'Sullivan. We will take some shorter slots after that, perhaps three minutes each, starting with Deputy Ó Murchú and then Deputy Sherlock.

Comment on this

I will start with a question on disability services because I jumped into a disability committee just before I came in here. If I could just follow up-----

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I apologise; I do not want to mislead Senator Byrne. The total beds for the new children's hospital is 20. It starts with staffing seven of those. We have to build it up because it is a new building. I apologise; I did not intend to mislead.

Comment on this

That is fine. I thank Mr. Gloster.

Comment on this

It was a question relating to disability services. I do not want to misquote anybody but next door at the Joint Committee on Disability Matters, we had different providers in from across the country and the long and short of it is that we are providing residential care in name in emergency cases but in terms of long-term forward planning, it is a hodge-podge. It is all over the place. It depends on the region. I can only speak for Cork. I am dealing with Horizons Cork at the moment, and we are trying to liaise with two local authorities in terms of social housing provision for people into the future and to make sure it is adequate. What mechanisms does Mr. Gloster have at his level to ensure there is co-ordination and that it is not just a postcode lottery, as we often hear that stuff is?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The first thing, to be totally honest, is that all of the resource provision has been hoovered up in the last few years by emergencies. We could say that is because of the absence of planning. The traditional residential care placement for people was in what were called congregated settings. The policy since 2010 is to reduce congregated settings. That has seen an increase in smaller community houses, but a lot of them are provided by providers. In County Donegal, for example, we provide them directly. They are superb new houses. I have been to visit one. However, where we provide them by traditional providers or the private sector, they are so cost-intensive, and they are required in emergencies. We are all the time running to stand still.

Comment on this

Does the HSE provide them directly in Donegal and then not in Cork?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The North Western Health Board had a history of no section 38 agencies and Cork is entirely dependent on them. It is history; that is all it is. We are changing that and that is the truth. The co-ordination at my level, where there is now a better approach to that, is at the Cabinet committee on disability, which the Taoiseach chairs, and the Department of housing comes in and talks about the piece. Apart from people with a very high level of dependency, the best model we can have for people who need supported living would be for local authorities to provide us with the houses and for us to provide the in-house care.

Comment on this

That is what Mr. Gloster is hoping to do in Cork and get heads together.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes.

Comment on this

However, the Cabinet sub-committee has been meeting now for how many years?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Since the start of the current Dáil.

Comment on this

So, it is over 12 months. Has anything changed in that period? Are there green shoots? Is there progress?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I would say enormously so. First, the disability budget for services for this year is-----

Comment on this

Specific to the capital stuff in relation to residential places.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The capital plan has doubled from €20-something million for disability to almost €50 million for this year, so there is a real push. The first push is on respite. I want to be honest about that. My preference is that my colleagues in the south west would go and buy houses themselves and staff them rather than have them run by independent organisations. That is the truth.

Comment on this

Okay. I will move on to something totally different now. The last time I was here with Mr. Gloster, I spoke to him about the final year placements for students going into different therapies, such as occupational therapy, OT, or whatever. He said that by the time he leaves, which is going to be fairly soon, he hoped that would have changed. Is there any progress in relation to those work placements?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes, the clinical placement pipeline has changed consistent with the generation of new places by further and higher education. I am not aware of any particular issues. Does Ms Hoey have anything to add?

Comment on this
Ms Anne Marie Hoey

We have seen an increase year-on-year. In 2025, we saw an increase of an extra 310 alone in health and social care professions and there is a substantial increase in nursing as well. We are facilitating the clinical placements associated with those while they are in their undergraduate placements.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

The agreement I had with Government was that if it increased the placements in college to supply the workforce, I would increase the clinical placements. So far, I have not come up against any major issue. There may be some local individual issues, but I have not come up against any major ones.

Comment on this

There are no difficulties in more niche areas or anything like that, be it OT or-----

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

There will always be difficulties in niche areas because we are required-----

Comment on this

Which ones are problematic, just for our own interest?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I suppose-----

Comment on this

Where is the shortage most acute?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We have the largest number of therapies, we will say, for example, in physiotherapy. Therefore, we could take the largest body of students in occupational therapy and then speech and language therapy. It depends on the amount of experienced people we have to provide the placement at any one time. I am not aware of any significant challenge on it at the moment, however.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Marie Hoey

No, we can see year-on-year the increase in the supply but, as I said, equally, the increase in the clinical placements being facilitated.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses. I am going to move on to something totally different again. I asked a topical question in here a few weeks ago in relation to the flu vaccine. I also brought in issues in relation to the respiratory syncytial virus, RSV, vaccine.

We have fewer beds than the OECD average and I believe we spend less than the OECD average on vaccination programmes in general. The UK recently expanded the RSV programme to include people of 80 years and over. Where are we on expanding both flu and RSV vaccines?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I am going to let Dr. Henry talk about that. Before I do so, can I make one point in response? I listened carefully and I was questioned in the media several times regarding the so-called super-flu vaccine. Very little evidence yet suggests it is as super as people think it is. The rate of uptake, particularly among older people, in our vaccine programme this year showed enormous benefits, because the flu’s impact on our health system fundamentally altered after week 51 and we thought it would be worse. Second, RSV immunisation of children has been a game-changer in terms of the number of seriously ill children presenting at hospital. It is all done according to the best international advice. Maybe Dr. Henry will add to that.

Comment on this

Maybe Dr. Henry will comment on older ages as well.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

HIQA has done a health technology assessment, HTA, on the RSV vaccine. It is currently out for consultation. We fed back into it and are very firmly of the view that this is prudent, or that there is such a benefit for younger people that we need to continue with the infant and neonatal programme. Of course, there is evidence that there are also benefits for older people. As with any HTA, we have to consider the overall expense. I am referring to the cost and the benefit that goes along with that. There are other vaccines, such as for shingles, for which there have been HTAs. If the price is enormous, expenditure is not considered appropriate or worthwhile for the healthcare service. At this point in time, we are focusing on consolidating in the neonatal and infant context and translating what has been a pathfinder year-to-year programme into a multi-annual programme, ultimately to be delivered by GPs as part of-----

Comment on this

So, it does not sound like there is any prospect of expansion to older age cohorts.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Not immediately.

Comment on this

I have one more question, on the early-access programme. The last time Dr. Henry was here, I mentioned rare diseases. According to the Minister, the Department is considering an early-access programme. Is there any progress on that? I am hearing rumours that it might be specifically linked to cancer diagnoses only. Could Dr. Henry expand on that?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

There has been an agreement concluded. I might ask Mr. Healy to refer to it. As part of that agreement, we are focusing on more rapid assessment through our established processes for drugs reimbursement applications. If we get down to the 180 days stipulated in the report, the need for an early-access scheme will not exist.

Comment on this

To be fair, the 180-day period has existed for a long time.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

But it is part of the new agreement.

Comment on this

We are over time on this. We intend to have a session on vaccines, hopefully before the summer. We will go into more detail then. We have time for three shorter slots of three minutes each. We shall begin with Deputy Ó Murchú, who shall be followed by Deputies Sherlock and Quaide.

Comment on this

Ádh mór ar Mr. Gloster. I assume he will have more free time in retirement than he does at the minute.

As Deputy O’Sullivan said, the disability committee heard from Horizons, Muiríosa Foundation and Stewarts Care regarding disability housing. The witnesses have already stated they would like to see local authorities providing the housing. We can all understand that but, from what I have heard from Horizons, Muiríosa Foundation and Stewarts Care and from everything I have heard anecdotally, we are not allowing for anything other than reactive emergency care. I am referring to where a person or a family is at the end of their tether and to where someone ends up in the emergency room to be dealt with. The only people set to step in are probably not the organisations in the other room; they are more often for-profit operators, which have greater resources and which will cost the State more. We all want a far better scenario in which we have the resources that allow people to live in the family home and do whatever suits them in the circumstances. Could Mr. Gloster just deal with what is happening at the minute and the sorts of resources needed so we are not just reacting in emergency settings?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I thank the Deputy for that. As I said, last year there was a plan for 70 new priority-one places and we ended up with 205. This year, we are planning for probably the same number again, but we are also planning to increase residential care capacity from 8,600 places to just over 9,000.

Comment on this

Will that allow for the approximately 90 cases that literally end up in emergency care?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Yes. Basically, two things have happened. As I am sure the organisations would tell the Deputy, we are running to stand still, and that is the truth because of the ageing of people and the families who have looked after them. That is one factor. The second factor is that traditional residential care placements were no longer an option because of the congregated settings policy. I do not disagree with that but I am not sure the way we went about it was necessarily the best.

The last thing is that, because we were under such pressure, we became dependent on private provision, which is exceptionally costly. We had no framework for it. We are putting a framework in place this year to control the price, but more importantly to manage the quality. I do not have any difficulty with providers that we fund and commission to provide placements. I believe we will start to see them come more into place. The fundamental issue for them will be the capital cost of provision, because we cannot continue to build big centres. That is where the emphasis on the Department of housing becomes much greater.

Comment on this

I have a few questions. I wish to pick up on the topic of vaccines. The uptake among those between two and 17 is extremely low, at just over 15% this year. The HSE highlighted prior to Christmas that 40% of those hospitalised were under the age of 15. What is going to be done in the next winter period to improve that figure? Is the vaccination going to be rolled out as part of the school programme or will the HSE do something else? I am not sure I am seeing anything in the service plan to increase vaccine uptake in the age category in question.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

This pertains to the flu vaccine.

Comment on this

Sorry, the flu vaccine.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

The vaccine uptake was higher. It was up to 25% of the cohort.

Comment on this

Maybe I am reading the figures incorrectly but Dr. Henry should go on.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

That amounts to 50,000 more children. We would like to see a higher uptake, of course, and we aspire to that, but there is a significant improvement on last year.

Comment on this

Will it be done through the school system? How will we improve the uptake further?

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

We do it through a combination of GPs, pharmacists and the school system. There is a geographical imbalance in the schools teams. There is a stronger school team presence in the eastern half of the country than in the western half. We have different ways of approaching this but we are going to build on that 25%. It is a significant part of protection because children not only are vulnerable to serious influenza but also act as a reservoir for disease.

Comment on this
Dr. Colm Henry

Therefore, it is a big focus for us in the vaccination programme.

Comment on this

On physician associates, the HSE is funding the training but recruitment has been paused. Are we going to see any progress on that soon?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We have completed a very detailed analysis, which Dr. Henry commissioned for me at the request of the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. I submitted it back to the Department two weeks ago for discussion and engagement with it on how we can best structure the physician associate role going forward. I think there will be a good resolution. Not unlike the approach mentioned in the discussion earlier this morning on physiologists, we have to make sure it is right and appropriate. We also have to ensure we have a way of regulating, either internally or externally. In essence, the matter will be dealt with. The Minister is positively disposed towards this.

Comment on this

Great. I am very disappointed that Baggot Street hospital was ultimately sold. There is a lot of interest in the price tag. Does Mr. Gloster want to tell us how much the HSE got for it?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I am not in a position to state that at the moment.

Comment on this

Okay.

Ms Lucy Nugent of Children’s Health Ireland said this morning she is very happy that the staffing allocation has been agreed. What are the HSE’s concerns now, given that the buck will ultimately stop with the HSE regarding the management of CHI and the new hospital into the future? What are its chief concerns at this stage with regard to the transition process and getting the hospital up and running? That is not a trick question. I am genuinely interested.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I am well used to trick questions and know that was not one.

In very simple terms, there is a scale of priorities. First and foremost, wherever CHI is located, it is about making sure the best level of care is provided to the children served there. To be straightforward, that is the focus of CHI, the HSE and the Minister. Next is getting BAM to tell us when we will get the keys to take over. We have access and have started to put a footprint in through cleaning, putting in equipment and so on. It is a matter of getting the hospital commissioned as soon as possible and getting the children in and looked after.

In the background what you will see happen is the legislative and policy position, as well as the resource position planning, to migrate CHI into the HSE in 2027 and it will become a seamless part of the Dublin midlands region providing a specialist service.

Comment on this

I spoke to Mr. Gloster in June of last year about parliamentary questions on primary care services being sent back to me with what seemed like vague responses. Long waiters were only categorised within a category of plus 52 weeks, even though I know discipline managers routinely record much more meaningful waits. It took a lot of persistence to establish the fact that many young people throughout the country were routinely waiting 200, 300 and 400 weeks across disciplines in all health regions, and even longer in some cases. It is hard not to see that as an attempt to conceal the scale of the crisis. I asked the Minister of State, Deputy Butler, a priority question seeking a breakdown of approved psychology posts in older adult mental health services two weeks ago . The HSE told her in its response that it could not provide these figures. It is just farcical the HSE cannot tell a Minister of State how many approved posts it has in services it manages. The Minister of State asked the HSE to follow up with me in writing after that. A week later there was no sign of that so I followed up on it myself. I got another response giving me an overall workforce figure with no breakdown of older adult psychology posts per health region or integrated healthcare area. I got a similar, overly general response on adult primary care services that also used the plus 52 weeks category.

Paul Reid gave a commitment in 2020 to hold managers to account if they were delaying parliamentary question responses or obfuscating in their answers. I want the officials to comment on the pattern I am describing. Is it credible that HSE managers cannot tell public representatives how many approved posts they have in services they manage? Would it not just take an email to psychology managers and an email back to collate that data?

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

Ms Hoey may have the exact figure, but what I can say is that whatever about before the pay and numbers strategy there is unequivocally no reason any head of psychology should not be asked to say what the number of their approved funded posts is and what the care group breakdown of them is. That should not take half an hour to answer, so I do not know what the issue is.

Comment on this
Ms Anne Marie Hoey

I agree with Mr. Gloster on the ability to be able to reach out and ask. At an organisation level, psychology, similar to other professions, is captured at a national level, by region, by IHA and so on, but the level of detail the Deputy describes would not necessarily be collected centrally. As he says though, reaching out to psychology managers would assist in gathering that.

Comment on this

Is it not the case with pretty much any parliamentary question that it is just sent on to the managers who have responsibility for those statistics and then collated by a more national manager? It is very tiresome to have to keep following these questions up.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

I do not dispute that and I am not going to try to defend it. To be fair to psychology managers and local managers I have just been reminded, and should have said, that when we changed to the six regions there was a part of the country in the north east where CHO 1 was split and CHO 8 was split so there may be a bit of a row going on about who owns what. For the rest of the country though it should be a very straightforward process. I will say to the Deputy that I promise him I will come back to him with an answer on the number of psychology posts approved for later life psychiatry. I will come back to him before I go, which is a very short time. He can hold me to that.

Comment on this

I thank Mr. Gloster.

Comment on this

I would like to follow up on one of my questions from earlier on beds and what we have described as the repackaging of them. In the time since I had a quick look at the list. I had a parliamentary question submitted on the Mallow beds back in November. It was said the 24 beds would be provided under the 2025 service plan in quarter 2 of 2026. However, in this document on page 87 those 24 beds are listed here again as additional new beds. The same ones I asked a question about in November are being listed in the service plan as additional and new. Do the officials wish to clarify their answer on that one?

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick Lynch

I have put out a question so I will be coming back to the Cathaoirleach with more detail. One of the confusions in the service plan is the beds that appear in that appendix are also the ones for which revenue funding is being applied as part of the service plan, but that is not clear so we need to come back with a reconciliation of all the beds. It should be net additional and where there is a carryover from previous years that can be indicated.

Comment on this
Mr. Bernard Gloster

We will clarify for the Cathaoirleach whether the bed infrastructure is an additional 177 plus the 25. Mr. Healy is correct that what was intended in the service plan is Mallow is now staff-resourced to open in quarter 1 with that resource. That is the only explanation I can give. I will certainly do my best to bring clarity to it.

Comment on this
Mr. Patrick Lynch

We will put out a call to get that.

Comment on this

I thank the officials for their engagement. It is really important the allocation the HSE receives results in improved care and services, reduced waiting times and overall improved health of the population. I have no doubt today's session will help us with our ongoing scrutiny of this work. Mr. Gloster, it is kind of remarkable that across the board, both Government and Opposition members were complimentary of your work, your approach and your engagement. That is testament to how you have engaged with the committee and your work as a senior public servant. On behalf of everyone I again thank him for that, his service, his openness and his helpfulness. It has been very much appreciated by all of us.

Our public meeting next week is of the select committee, when we will meet the Minister for Health to consider the Revised Estimates for Vote 38.

Comment on this