We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Justice, Home Affairs and Migration

Garda Pursuits: Discussion

Summary

GRA and AGSI representatives said Gardaí lack dedicated pursuit training, clear operational guidance, adequate roads-policing resources and legal protection, leaving individual members and control-room supervisors exposed when deciding whether to pursue. They said consultation on the current policy ignored requests for indemnities, emergency-service driving licences and protection for members’ private insurance, while management had failed to deliver promised training or support against social-media harassment. The associations called for urgent, properly resourced training, stronger legislation and sentencing for contraflow and non-compliant driving, and greater organisational acceptance of risk. They warned that substantial pursuit training is unlikely before 2028 or 2029, with no significant numbers expected to be trained in 2026 or 2027.

Contributions 165–340 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Will Assistant Commissioner Ferry answer the question-----

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I think it is inevitable-----

Comment on this

How long will it take to get to the quantum the Garda has calculated it needs?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We hope to have around 40 instructors trained by the end of the year and then commence the first course. The Commissioner is also on record saying we are in the middle of the EU Presidency. That is-----

Comment on this

I understand that. This is the third time I will ask the same question. Is there a timeframe for the quantum of training the Garda feels is necessary to protect people in 2027 and 2028? I do not mind if he is going to say a year, two years or whatever, but just to give the public a flavour of how long this is going to take. In fairness to those in Templemore and those doing the training, I understand they are left in this scenario. How long does the Garda expect it will take?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not have a defined timeline for that quantum but we will prioritise the units that need to be trained first, which will have the greatest impact on our roads from a policing perspective. That will probably be the people in the roads policing area and also in certain divisions that will benefit from this training at the earliest point in time.

Comment on this

There was a unit called India Victor, which did great work in relation to robberies across the country. I recall a few years ago I had to bring in legislation and do stuff in relation to CCTV. Why was that unit stopped? It had a fantastic record.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

As quickly as you can, please.

Comment on this

Were its members trained in what they did?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

This is where I say over 200 members are trained to stop vehicles. There is a difference between the stop-a-vehicle piece and in-pursuit training, which needs to be-----

Comment on this

Were they trained? That is all I want to know.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

They would have been trained. I assume they were trained as CBD trainers, but not in pursuit because that is a different concept - to monitor and manage pursuits.

Comment on this

They did a good job.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thank you, Deputy Kelly. I call Deputy Butterly, followed by Senator Rabbitte.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for coming in. The last time the Garda Commissioner was here, I asked him directly how many extra gardaí would be required in order to deal effectively with roads policing and Garda visibility. He said he did not believe he needed any extra staff and, if needed, it would be to bolster Garda management rather than front-line gardaí.

In light of what has gone on since the Commissioner was here I would like to ask if that is still the case? Do we need more boots on the ground? When we were here last, we highlighted how communities in Louth, Meath, Monaghan and Cavan have consistently called for greater Garda visibility. Gardaí are being asked to deal with increasingly dangerous road policing incidents. It would follow that we absolutely do need extra boots on the ground. That is my first question.

Second, we heard from the GRA in particular about the actual training and how, particularly since the last crash, in-person training has more or less disappeared. Can the witnesses confirm that? In any profession, whether one is a doctor, barrister or whatever, one is required to do CPD every year. You are required to upskill and make sure that you at least know about all the latest technologies, skill sets, etc. Why is that not the case in An Garda Síochána?

It is very clear there is frustration. The Commissioner has consistently told members here that resources are not the issue: if he asks, he gets. However, the GRA has also stated that when it looks for additional resources and a change in policies, it consistently gets the answer that it is actually an issue. How are we to square that circle?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I will take the second part of the question, about training. One can clearly see that continuing professional development training happens on a regular basis and is conducted through the college. It is predominantly in-person and in most cases is a minimum of two days per member per year. It addresses a lot of the changes in legislation and procedures that have been introduced. That would be complemented by specific training for new projects which have come in where people get specialist training for, say, the investigation management system or body-worn cameras. That happens on top of the continuous professional development which would be additional days. We have also made greater use of the online tools available to do online training so members can do refresher training on a regular basis. There is a significant amount of training arranged, including CPD, which was the Deputy’s main question.

On resources, the Commissioner has said, and as the opening statement reflected, roads policing is the largest specialist unit in the organisation. There are currently 660 members attached to roads policing. The Commissioner has also said that as numbers increase we will continue to look at the numbers in the roads policing function. As assistant commissioner for that area, that is something I am keeping a very close eye on.

Comment on this

Is it enough?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We think it is enough. What the Commissioner touched on, which the Deputy mentioned, was maximising the capacity of that unit and what it can do and to ensure it has the equipment, including the cars, and the training to do their job. As well as that, as I mentioned in the opening statement, we also have dedicated inspectors to support each unit. We meet them every two weeks so we co-ordinate and task exactly what is going on. We look at trends and changes and make sure those things are at least advised across the board. As I said, there are dedicated superintendents at community engagement level who have responsibility for roads policing. They were introduced as part of the recommendations from the Crowe report.

Comment on this

We heard there are no off-road vehicles available. Will the Garda be purchasing off-road vehicles? Will it be increasing the fleet to deal with the increasing demand of having to police our roads safely?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The fleet is probably at its highest number of vehicles in the organisation. We will continue to look at different types of fleet to perform that duty. There will be a very limited number for off-road. We are looking at what other forces are doing, particularly in the UK, to see how that might be considered for An Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

However, there is no request in to the Minister for justice at the moment for an increased budget in order to increase the fleet.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No. We have said on record that we are happy with the budget at the moment.

In fairness, if we do need to apply it to a different area they will do that. We have bought a number of high powered vehicles that are unmarked for roads policing units and I think we have more of them coming in the next couple of months to be allocated.

Comment on this

Are those drivers actually licensed for pursuit training?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No.

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

All of the road policing units have to do the CBD 2, which is the standard. It is a very significant course and not every member will succeed in passing that. In-pursuit training is another type of course to help manage and to make decisions around pursuit, and that is what we will be introducing.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank the assistant commissioner. Senator Rabbitte is next, followed by Deputy Ward.

Comment on this

I thank the assistant commissioner for his opening remarks. I speak as somebody who does not have a legal background but a great interest in fairness and justice. I am thinking of the incidents that brought us here today. As I said to the GRA and AGSI, people looking at this committee today want to know they feel protected when they go out on the road and if they are going on a journey at night they hope not to encounter what happened the last time. We need to peel it all back. I said to my colleague sitting beside me that I would have liked to have had the GRA, AGSI and our current witnesses here together. Deputy Brabazon, who is very diplomatic would say it is normal industrial relations, but there is no doubt from the three different opening statements that not everybody is on the same page. It is disappointing because we need reassurance, as does the general public, that everyone is on the one page and I did not get that today. It is all good people – absolutely – but what I picked up on was that at the end of the day there is a serious lack of communication. The gentlemen who were before us earlier said they hear stuff through the media about what is happening about training and in-pursuit training. That is unfortunate for the general public to hear. It is not reassuring.

The second thing they spoke of was indemnity. They felt management has pushed the risk back onto the ordinary garda to carry and they are not comfortable with that. That risk is also on the control centres as well. If something goes wrong and a decision is made there is a risk attached to it; if a decision is not made there is a risk attached to it but it is the garda or the controller in the centre who is carrying it. Those are my observations. I do not think it is healthy for the general public to hear we are not on the one page on the back of such tragedy. We know there is no quick-fix solution to this because, ultimately, criminal activity is taking place on our roads. That is what it is. We all want to feel protected. We want to know the witnesses and the different groups are on the one page. That is not a criticism, it is an observation, and I would not like to see it again.

A question that kept coming up earlier was about resourcing. As a female, I would love to know what the policy is about women in the force going on maternity leave. How do we backfill them? Is there backfilling in An Garda Síochána? If we are down on gardaí – it could be in roads policing on in local stations but I will focus on roads policing because that is what this is all about – do we backfill leave or how do we cover the deficit? If our numbers are so slight and every number counts, what happens when people go out on maternity leave? I would think that is a frustration on the part of the members who feel they do not have protection of their units. Not being a garda, I assume it all works on unit, numbers and stacking and stuff like that – I am just trying to work it out.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

There is a minute left for the witnesses to answer those questions.

Comment on this

Okay. I brought in indemnity and risk. Sorry.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I thank the Senator. First, I reassure the committee, but also reassure the public, that safety is at the heart of everything we are doing.

There are a significant number of members out there. It is the highest number we have ever had within the organisation and there is a clear focus on reducing collisions on roads and on reducing our roads being used for criminality. As I said, 75% of arrests are made by front-line members. That is what the Commissioner is saying. All of our members are very focused.

I think we are on the one page. I recognise the challenges the associations have, and they rightly represent their members in saying they want more of what they can do. I met them a number of weeks ago with regard to the protections and indemnity the Senator talked about. The Commissioner asked me to meet them ahead of that submission Deputy Kelly asked about. We were pretty much aligned with what they were saying about what the protections were and what they needed. The Commissioner has made that submission to the Department of justice. Hopefully, it will be fully incorporated.

From a welfare perspective, when there is any incident, we try to make sure the supports are there at local level as peer support. From a welfare perspective, we have dedicated officers, and they put in a lot of effort. I am familiar with the effort they put in when these incidents happen to support the members who have to attend these difficult situations and, unfortunately, when members are referred to Fiosrú, which we are obliged to do if somebody is injured, etc.

It is important to assure everybody that alignment is there, and we need to continue. There is a regular consultation with the associations and there are a significant number of meetings. That is something that will continue. As assistant commissioner in this area, I would be positive about that engagement.

Comment on this

Did the assistant commissioner watch the previous engagement between this committee and the AGSI and the GRA?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I saw some of it.

Comment on this

All I have is five minutes. I would not be able to go through all the contradictions between what they said and what the current witnesses are saying. There seems to be a systemic disconnection between the front-line gardaí and management. What that issue is, and whatever caused it, I do not know, but it is clear to me. We heard from the Garda representative bodies that they believe management is failing in its duty to gardaí. We also heard that, when it comes to pursuits and something goes wrong, as it can, they feel abandoned. They feel they are on their own and all the risk is on the individual and not the organisation itself. Does the assistant commissioner accept that?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I would point to the new policy that deals with pursuits. It gives a lot of good governance and accountability to our pursuits. Most times, pursuits are spontaneous. The member may not be aware of what happened. The new policy gives clear guidance to the control rooms that members make contact to say there is an incident that may lead to a pursuit. Along with the members, the control centres are managing those pursuits using the information available to them with the clear aim of trying to end them as quickly as possible. As to control room authorisations, 80% of incidents have pursuit authorisation approved and 20% do not. The important piece is that it is clear that there be good governance and accountability so that, in the event that somebody stands down a pursuit and something happens, it is recorded. If someone does not and something happens, that is recorded. That is also a protection to the control room members, approximately 94% or 97% of whom are trained. I may be wrong on that percentage, but almost all of them are trained in pursuit management. Those supervisors, who are at sergeant and inspector levels, are then responsible for deciding.

I reinforce the point I made earlier. Pursuit driving is high risk. It is a significant risk. In the policy and procedure, the two pieces that need to be considered immediately are the use of the stopping devices known as stingers, which are the quickest way to bring a pursuit to an end as opposed to a chase, and the air support unit. I am sorry to go on. There is a significant-----

Comment on this

We will go back to air support in a moment. The consultation process on the pursuit policy was done in 2025. We just heard from the AGSI and the GRA that they felt their input was disregarded and omitted from the current policy.

These are the guys who are front line and have to deal with this daily, and they feel their input was omitted and disregarded. Does Mr. Ferry accept that?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not have the specifics of their submission, and I will certainly look at that.

Comment on this

It is in their opening statement, so he can have a look.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

With any consultation you take on board what is being-----

Comment on this

If the input of front-line gardaí was disregarded and omitted, then whose input was put into this policy? They said the first line of the pursuit policy is to give direction to gardaí, but they say they are getting no direction.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not agree with that. As I have said, the policy sets out the way to manage and conduct pursuits. That is clear within the policy. The only element of that policy we are talking about is further training of our members in pursuit. We want to reinforce the point made earlier. The most important thing, and it is in the policy, is to try to prevent and stop any element of a pursuit as quickly as possible. Unfortunately, we have seen in some of those most recent incidents that these things can go wrong very quickly.

One thing the associations have highlighted, which the Commissioner is on record about and has put into the submission, is that they are looking for protections and supports in terms of that higher standard. That has been submitted to the Department and will hopefully be considered as soon as possible.

Comment on this

I agree that prevention is better than cure, but the way things are you do not know. As Mr. Ferry said, if somebody goes off in a car they do not know if that is a really serious crime or just somebody who has not got tax and insurance or stuff like that. At that stage, they feel they are abandoned when they phone in to the headquarters and either get a yes or no. They also feel the controllers who make that decision on the radio when they call in are also open to feeling abandoned.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I think it gives them a level of protection because a level of assessment is being done by the supervisor based on the information, the conditions, the number of people on the road, the time, the weather and all of those factors. You have to recognise that, for the member, when those things happen it is spontaneous and instant. Sometimes it is that clarity the control room can bring to tell them to stand down. I go back and say that 80% of pursuits are authorised by the control room and the member is told it is okay to pursue, but that is under constant review based on the risk, and that is really important. I think that is a protection for the member as well.

Comment on this

The assistant commissioner mentioned at the start that the legislation has been sent by the Commissioner to the Department of justice. Will he tell us what is in that legislation?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The key element in that submission is highlighting the relevant section 87 of the Road Traffic Act 2010. That talks about the exemptions given to drivers of emergency services. That is not just the Garda. That is the fire service and the ambulance service, etc. It highlights how that is where there are issues and challenges. It is also making recommendations based on the UK and how they do it. As part of this we are hoping to further engage with the Department to give clarity about what the key requirements are. We have looked internationally at other police forces and what they do. In simple terms it is about acknowledging that if people are trained to a higher standard and follow procedure, control room instructions, guidance and so on, and they drive at the level of training expected of them, then there will be a higher threshold to be considered. At the moment, it unfortunately might be felt that is not the case. They are being considered as ordinary road users as opposed to people who are in this case highly trained. I know the figures may change, but there are between approximately 4,000 and 4,500 members trained on what we call the standard driving course. That is a significant number of members when you take the front line of a force that is just under 15,000 at the moment.

Comment on this

I am not sure if it was the AGSI or the GRA, but we heard about individual gardaí being prosecuted. Does Mr. Ferry think it is reasonable for a member of An Garda Síochána to be prosecuted when they are going about their lawful duty in a reasonable manner?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No Deputy, of course not. I am a police officer, the exact same as them. I was there. I was in the same position as a lot of them. What is important is that, at the moment, there are nine members. That is nine too many. Of all of the pursuits and incidents that have happened, unfortunately or regrettably, there are nine members. That is not something we have control over. If there is an incident where someone is injured, we have to report that to Fiosrú. It is then for Fiosrú to carry out its assessment and investigation. Obviously, the decision to prosecute is with the DPP.

Comment on this

We were told earlier that gardaí were being discriminated against by the employment by the DPP's office of junior counsel to prosecute them in prosecutions. It would be entirely different if any of my colleagues here on the committee or I were prosecuted, in that it would be done by a garda or sergeant. To have a qualified and experienced lawyer prosecuting a garda-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Just be cautious of the separation of powers there in terms of legal processes.

Comment on this

There is no transgression on that, Chair. There seems to be a discrimination between what a member of the public would face in terms of being prosecuted by a member of An Garda Síochána and what a garda with a similar charge would face, namely, prosecution by junior counsel. It seems to be disproportionate and unfair. What is the assistant commissioner's view on that?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not have on because I am not familiar with that. I may have missed that comment. I did not see all of what the associations meant. That matter is for the courts to decide. I hope everyone is treated-----

Comment on this

The courts do not decide to appoint junior counsel. That is a decision made somewhere else. The court will only deal with whatever case is before it.

A number of years ago, we in my constituency were promised that we would have gardaí on mountain bikes patrolling the area. There was an issue about gardaí being trained to cycle bikes. At the time, I thought it was utterly ridiculous and that most gardaí would be able to throw their leg over a bike and pedal them away without training. When one drilled down into it, though, it was more about health and safety and stuff like that. There is a pursuit policy but there are no pursuits taking place, according to what we have heard today. I know anecdotally from my own constituency and talking to gardaí on the front line that there is huge frustration that no pursuits are taking place. It is affecting morale. Does Mr. Ferry think that it comes from a health and safety point of view or from an employer-employee liability point of view, or is it something else?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is very important that members be trained to the highest standard. We always have to assess a member's capability, even from a driving perspective. We all know people who have passed the test and can drive a car but from a policing perspective, that is why the CBD 1 assessment is in place. It is to assess people's capability of driving because they are now going to be driving a police car as part of their job. Whatever requirement we have, there is a responsibility on the organisation to make sure that people are trained to a certain level. What you then try to do is build on that training and build their capability to drive or perform other skills, and that only comes from training. That is something the organisation has been committed to in most cases.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. Ferry.

Comment on this

I thank Assistant Commissioner Ferry and Chief Superintendent Sugrue for attending. One of the biggest challenges at a macro level for An Garda Síochána at the moment, as would be widely acknowledged, is in trying to get numbers into the force to an excess of 15,000 and, hopefully in the not-too-distant future, approaching 20,000. Obviously, there are pay and conditions elements of that. As alluded to by the GRA and the AGSI, there is a moral sense of responsibility in service of the community before somebody decides to become a member of An Garda Síochána.

I feel that this is being eroded by poor communication internally and particularly in the area we are discussing at the moment. Ultimately, it is our job as legislators and the job of An Garda Síochána management to protect those who are entrusted to go out and protect our communities. If they feel that they are being adequately supported and empowered to do their job then they will do that job an awful lot better. Mention was made about the statistics around pursuits and that 80% of pursuits are sanctioned and authorised, and therefore that 20% are not. The lack of certainty when it comes to decision-making on the part of members of An Garda Síochána is something that has to be addressed. We heard earlier from the GRA that this issue was highlighted as far back as July and August of 2008. In the 18 years plus that have passed since then, it is still an issue whereby members of An Garda Síochána are fearful that if they commence a pursuit they will be subject to the courts in the event of that going wrong. Equally, members would be fearful of not commencing a pursuit because of the possible consequences of that. Clarity is absolutely needed there. Will the assistant commissioner give us a little bit of background on progress being made towards this anomaly being overcome?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The revised policy came in from December of 2024 on pursuits. The four control rooms that exist across the country are fully staffed 24-7, and the procedure is there, which I think gives a lot of clarity. First, the control room members are trained. As I said earlier, almost 94% are trained and that is a continued piece around making sure that they are there to give that consistency of application for decisions around authorisations of pursuits. The members obviously have that level of governance but also that level of support around the decision to authorise a pursuit. In this case we are saying about 80% are authorised. It is unusual for them not to be authorised. What then happens, as the pursuit continues, is that the priority has to be to prevent-----

Comment on this

Would Mr. Ferry accept that there is a big flaw there at the moment because of that contradiction continuing to exist?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Maybe I misunderstood the Deputy. The key piece here is that before we had a policy of this nature, and before we had the dedicated control rooms, a member could be making that decision in isolation, whereas now there are control rooms that are getting the information, assisting with that decision-making, seeing what the conditions are, seeing what the volume of traffic is and seeing the number of people around in the area. We must keep remembering, however, the risk if a pursuit takes up. For the members, the protection the member has is that all of this is recorded and all of that is there for their benefit-----

Comment on this

I am going to have to cut across Mr. Ferry very briefly because I am just trying to get one other question in. In his opening statement, the assistant commissioner made reference to the engagement with social media platforms. I think this is vital given that social media platforms are being used to glorify reckless driving and to glorify contraflow driving on our public roads. What progress is being made in that engagement with the social media companies?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We have had very positive engagement and we have met with one of the companies so far. We have engaged with the other companies as well to meet them. Again, it was very beneficial for us to understand the level of work they do around looking at content and moderating content. What we are trying to do is make sure that if there are any improvements then we can make contact with them to make them aware, and likewise where they can assist-----

Comment on this

Are we getting any closer, with the indulgence of the Cathaoirleach, towards a stage where the uploading of such videos will be prohibited? Are we close to progress in that regard?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

From the engagement I had with most recent meeting, they are very positive about being proactive in trying to remove content.

The challenge is obviously the assessment of what is content, because lots of people take pictures and videos of their cars. If there is a criminal element to it, I suppose that is the piece. What I certainly felt from the meeting, and we are to follow up again later this month with them, had to do with making sure that we had those processes.

Comment on this

What about the point specifically on the glorification of reckless driving?

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Senator Kelleher. I am sorry.

Comment on this

Is there any timeline on when that element is likely to be achieved?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What I would say is that content was removed by the companies and it continues to be removed. That is one of the things on which we will be engaging with them and making sure there is a process for how that content is flagged. If they do not catch it from their side and we become aware of where there is an incident or criminal activity, we can then make contact and they can be proactive and remove it.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank Mr. Ferry. I call Deputy Gannon, followed by Deputy Callaghan.

Comment on this

I thank the assistant commissioner for coming in to us. I want to very briefly follow on from the last contributor. Are the social media companies breaking the law in enabling the content to be platformed on their platforms?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That is not something I could make a comment on.

Comment on this

Senior gardaí-----

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What I said a few minutes ago was that we had had very positive engagement with them.

Comment on this

I am wondering why the Garda is having engagement with them. Is the Garda doing the Government's job in the absence of it doing it? My expectation of senior gardaí is that they would just go in and enforce the law. If somebody is breaking it, they arrest them and they will be held accountable before the courts. Otherwise, there is just a lobbying activity going on that I would not expect to be under the Garda's remit. Are they breaking the law or otherwise? We can come back to that question because I have other ones.

Mr. Ferry mentioned that 4,000 members were trained in the standard driving course. Is that the CBD 1 basic driving?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No, that is CBD 2. CBD 1 is an assessment of general driving.

Comment on this

Does that allow appropriately qualified gardaí to respond under emergency conditions but does not allow pursuits?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It does. Mr. Sugrue might respond to that point.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

They are not trained to undergo pursuits, but they can be authorised by a regional controller.

Comment on this

To what standard is the divisional controller trained?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The regional controllers are trained as serious incident dispatchers and supervisors. Both have training-----

Comment on this

Do they have pursuit training?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Yes, pursuit training.

Comment on this

Who provides that training?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

It is in conjunction with the Garda College and the policy owner. They work closely with the college to develop the training.

Comment on this

This is where I find the difference. I agree that there is very little difference between the GRA, the AGSI and Garda management and they all have the best intentions in mind. The two representative bodies say that not a single garda in this country is trained in pursuits, but when I stand in front of senior management and the Minister, I will be told that that is not the case. It is very difficult to fill that gap. Either we have 4,000 gardaí trained to pursue-----

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

If I could clarify, approximately 4,500 members have been trained in CBD 2. That is response driving. It is roadcraft and response - blue lights and sirens - to make progress quickly to calls.

Comment on this

That is response driving.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

It is not pursuit driving. Those members can be authorised to engage in pursuit by the control room staff. It is pursuit management but not driving.

Comment on this

That is really helpful and it does give great clarity. Effectively, we do have a pursuits policy, but we do not have gardaí training in pursuit.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Right at this moment, we do not.

Comment on this

Is there any other orifice of the State, organisation or private company where we have an expectation of a worker doing a job for which they were not trained, especially in such serious conditions? I do not blame the witnesses for this. I am just wondering how we got to this point and how we get out of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What we have done here is we have updated the policy to reflect the challenges that are involved in terms of responding to incidents when a response to an incident turns into a pursuit. It is important that we have additional training, so the people who have done their CBD 2 will now be trained on in-pursuit driving, which I understand is a five-day training course. That will be delivered. That will give them a better understanding of how to manage.

Comment on this

Is that the new pursuit training?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is the new pursuit training.

Comment on this

I would love to get there.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

That is a five-day training course. I keep coming back to what is the most important point for us, which is the control around this and trying to prevent the pursuit. The aim is to try as early as possible to terminate that. The safest way to do that is through the use of the stopping devices known as stingers.

Comment on this

That is fantastic. Where possible, they should be used but we know that is not always going to be the case, which is where the frustration lies for members across the board, including the witnesses.

In July, the Commissioner came before the committee and told me that there would not be pursuit training before the end of the year. He referred to the fact that we would have the EU Presidency. That is fine. We disagree about that, but he was very clear in that message. Some 33 days later, that seems to have changed.

There was an announcement by the Minister for justice the day after the M9 crash, where he said that pursuit training would begin before the end of the year. Could Mr. Ferry tell me how many gardaí he believes will start their training on the five-day pursuit course before the end of this year?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Realistically, it is likely that we will only have time to run a single or maybe two courses by the end of the year. We will not have our instructors trained up as mission phase pursuit instructors until the middle or end of November and then we will have to schedule a course after that, so realistically the capacity for 2026 is negligible. It is almost a pilot.

Comment on this

I can understand that. Do we have ten instructors at the moment?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No, we have capacity for 50 instructors, but it is 45.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Today, we have 45 instructors.

Comment on this

Are they all in Devon and Cornwall at the moment learning pursuit training?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No, that is the number of driving instructors we have between the Garda College in Templemore and here in Dublin.

Comment on this

How many instructors are at present learning the pursuit training in Devon and Cornwall?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Colleagues from Devon and Cornwall are travelling to Ireland in November to finalise the process. There are three modules to become an instructor in initial phase pursuit. By the end of November we will have four instructors fully trained and 11 more will have a number of modules completed. We will have internal capacity then to continue training our own staff.

Comment on this

Am I right that the train-the-trainer course does not begin until November?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The third module will be completed in November for a number of members, as well as the second module for some. There are different rolling modules occurring at the same time.

Comment on this

How many gardaí will be trained to deliver the programme?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The aim is to get up to 40 members trained. We are engaging through the assistant commissioner with UK colleagues to seek further support so we can roll this training out at scale. The more instructors we have trained, the more training we can introduce.

Comment on this

Does Mr. Sugrue anticipate that it will be in 2027 or 2028 that a mass number of gardaí will have that training?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Yes, the aim is that we will roll it out at scale in 2027 and continue into 2028.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses.

Comment on this

I thank the witnesses for being here today. I will follow on with the same point. We are speaking about pursuit training and ensuring that we have the instructors. It was mentioned that six drivers may be trained in pursuit training by the end of 2026, all going well. I am curious about what difference that will make for the garda who is out on the beat, who is in the car, when they are told they have been trained in pursuit so off they go. I say that considering the challenges and the fear, and to quote the opening statement from the AGSI, the "belief among members of An Garda Síochána that in the absence of the appropriate legal protections they will be thrown to the wolves by the Garda organisation for conducting their duty". They are saying that they feel that way due to the lack of legal protection should something go wrong in a chase. What difference will it mean for members of An Garda Síochána once they have completed the course in pursuit training?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

What that will obviously do is give greater training to the members. It will be the start of the greater roll-out for dealing with pursuits. The most important thing is to emphasise again that this is more than just the training of members for driving in pursuit because this is high risk. It is very dangerous.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Our aim is that the more people that get trained, the greater the understanding they will have of the dangers and risks. It will better inform the control rooms.

Comment on this

I understand that piece. I understand the practicalities of getting out and being in the car and driving. That is not the piece that I am concerned about, nor does it seem to be the piece that members of An Garda Síochána seem to have raised. I acknowledge the witnesses are members of An Garda Síochána also. They feel there is a risk of being prosecuted for doing their duty. In the absence of the updated legislation, which might come at the end of December, does Mr. Ferry foresee that there will be a huge uptick in the number of members of An Garda Síochána putting themselves forward to do pursuit training considering that there will be no material difference to how they will be treated legally should something go wrong in a pursuit?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The most important thing is that the Commissioner is very supportive of those protections that have been sought. We will be pursuing that and I hope that will be considered as early as possible. We want to reassure the public that, although the associations rightly point to the concerns and risks, in every situation, members will do what they need to do as members of the Garda Síochána.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I have no doubt that they will turn up, attend and try to prevent crime and protect people.

Comment on this

It should be clear that the other members from the Garda Representative Association today said the exact same thing. From that perspective, Mr. Ferry is on the same page.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We are also on the same page in that the Commissioner and everyone else is supportive of the members. When incidents happen, there is never a situation where someone is thrown to the wolves. We have to follow our procedure. If someone is injured as part of that, at the event or very close to the event, then we have to report that to Fiosrú. I reassure the public and our members who may be aware of this that the supports are present locally to make sure that they feel that they have done what they are trained to do and done their job. Supports are there from a welfare perspective. I hope we are very strong in that regard.

Comment on this

The challenge seems to be the length of time for which people can be suspended from duty. Let us talk about well-being. The extended period for which they can be off-duty or suspended from duty pending an inquiry can be a challenge for many members of An Garda Síochána. We need to see the same level of urgency when it comes to that and the timeline that is set out for everybody getting their pursuit training. In tandem, we need a sense of urgency to get the legislation passed so that there is a material difference. Once people have done their pursuit training, they can do that without fear. There seems to be a sense of fear, as expressed by the Garda representative organisations. They are giving a voice to their memberships. We need to take that seriously. I am not suggesting for a second that the witnesses are not, but saying from my own perspective that it needs to be taken seriously.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I confirm that is being taken seriously. That is why we made that submission. I also want to be clear that, to my recollection, no member who has been involved in an incident of this type in relation to pursuit is suspended or has been suspended.

Comment on this

Okay. That is not a protracted period-----

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is maybe not within our control. I think the Commissioner said that we would like to see these things considered quickly and early and a decision made not to prosecute. We all know that that does not sit with us. I am 90% sure - I will check my notes before we leave in case I am wrong - that no member who has been involved in an incident involving a pursuit has been suspended.

Comment on this

Regarding the Garda College, what steps are happening to ensure that training in An Garda Síochána stays ahead of emerging risk? I am acutely aware that as we sat here on 14 July, we were speaking about scramblers, e-bikes and e-scooters, and we did not even mention the contra-driving on motorways. It was only when the catastrophic event happened on the M9, which directly impacted constituents of mine-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am sorry, but we are way over time.

Comment on this

I know, but it is an important question.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

It is, but the Deputy should have asked it first.

Comment on this

Everybody has important questions.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Exactly.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. There are members of An Garda Síochána who are battling emerging risks that have not risen to public attention yet. Is the Garda College aware of that?

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will be accused of favouritism towards Fine Gael at this rate.

Comment on this

I am going to clip that.

Comment on this

You would never be accused of that, Chair.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

In the training course, the initial phase pursuit and subsequent courses, decision-making is a key aspect, as well as communication. The policy makes it very clear that the risk of driving contraflow on motorways is particularly high, so that will be factored into training.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I will try to be brief. I have a number of questions. To be clear, the initial phase pursuit training that will be carried out is about instructing the instructors. How many are currently undertaking that training?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

We have 15 undergoing training as it stands in various modules. There are three separate modules.

There are 15 members at various stages.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

None have completed it yet.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

None have completed it. Some will have completed the training in entirety by mid-November and then will have the ability to continue training internally. We will have capacity to train members ourselves at that stage.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

When will they begin to be able to train others?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Towards the end of November.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Mr. Sugrue is saying that there will only be one class of six.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

Yes. It is not at scale. That is why we are engaging with UK colleagues in an effort to train further instructors so we can develop scale.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is it important that members of the Garda receive this training?

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

I believe it is, yes.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Why is it only happening now? That is the crux of the question that everybody is asking today.

Comment on this
Mr. Brian Sugrue

The policy was introduced at the end of December 2024. We engaged with-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We did not need this policy to tell us it was important that people were trained in this type of pursuit.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The policy was updated to reflect the changes that we are seeing with activities involving pursuit, and the importance of having governance and accountability around that. The delay is regrettable, but it does take time to put in place the training material, to make it specific to An Garda Síochána. We hope to have further engagement outside of-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I think it is important that we acknowledge that we were far too slow. The Garda, the Government, and everybody was far too slow about ensuring that this type of pursuit training was in place. Is that not just a statement of fact?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The Deputy is entitled to make the statement. The one thing that I want to be sure is reinforced is that pursuit driving and pursuits are high risk.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I know, and nobody is disputing that. The fact is that there are 40% fewer gardaí connected to dedicated roads policing units today. That is excused. That is explained away and we are told that is actually not an issue. That is a consequence of reality, is it not? A previous Government had a target of 21,000 gardaí. We are far away from that at the moment. The truth is, if we were anywhere closer to that, there would be more members of road policing units today. Is that not fair to say?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

On the number there, I am not 100% certain, but I am fairly clear that the 21,000 was the overall strength of the organisation, and that was bringing the Garda sworn members from 13,000 to 15,000, the number of Garda support staff from 2,000 to 4,000, and the reserves from 1,000 to 2,000. That is what the 21,000 was. So the target is 15,000 for sworn Garda members.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

We are at about 14,700.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Exactly.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Is Mr. Ferry satisfied? Does he think 15,000 is a sufficient strength for an Garda Síochána with the current population and population projections?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Getting to 15,000, with 4,000 on the staff side, and more in the Garda Reserve, will give us greater availability and capacity for the daily needs.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

For sure, but does Mr. Ferry think it is enough?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

I do not think there is any certainty. If the population increases, you might logically say you should increase the force but we also need to point to the level of technology use that is now available, the mobility device, and the use of cameras. All of these things can make roads policing better.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I am sorry for cutting across Mr. Ferry. Time is short. I would argue that there is not a law-abiding individual in this State who would contend that there are enough gardaí involved in roads policing, including, as we have heard in evidence today, members of the Garda themselves. It is quite evident. People will tell you from their own personal experiences that the chances of meeting a road checkpoint now are a fraction of the chance from a generation ago. When we all know that, the truth is that criminals know that. Those people who want to cause havoc on our roads know that the chances of them being caught are reduced because we do not have enough gardaí dedicated to policing our roads. Is that not, again, a fair statement?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

It is important that all of our members have a responsibility for roads policing. It is not just the people assigned to roads policing.

That is why, as I said earlier, we now have superintendents and inspectors dedicated to the roads policing unit. That was part of the recommendations that came from the Crowe report.

As assistant commissioner, I am now tasking, co-ordinating and having meetings around the divisions right across the country to ensure we get that consistency of application. One of the things the Commissioner has been very strong on from the start is high-visibility policing and looking at the benefits of the approach that we have taken to date. As assistant commissioner for roads policing, I am conscious we need to keep looking at what we have done and ask whether it is effective.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Okay.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

When you see the number of detections and incidents-----

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

No, I get all of that. Briefly, because we have been talking about pursuits, are there technological resources that the assistant commissioner feels would be useful and beneficial, that the Garda does not currently have, particularly when we are talking about dangerous situations such as driving the wrong way on the motorway? Is there anything that the gardaí currently do not have that Garda management feels would be beneficial?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

The devices for stopping vehicles, the stingers, are a key to what we talk about in pursuits. We have those. We also need to look at where they are being utilised. There are approximately 2,000 people trained and there are training instructors right across the country. We are looking to see have we got the required numbers trained to get greater use of those. In terms of fleet, it is keeping a view of the type of vehicles that we need to get the best use out of our roads policing and our members out there on the networks.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

Thank you. Before we conclude, I will let Deputy Murphy in briefly.

Comment on this

I welcome the assistant commissioner and, indeed, the chief superintendent here this morning. I chair the transport committee and they will be before it in a couple of weeks. I want to, first of all, express my support to the men and women of the roads policing unit. More often than not, they are the first on the scene after a collision. That cannot be easy. The assistant commissioner's perspective and the perspective of his members really matters.

Could I have a "Yes" or "No" answer to this question? Having regard to the number of fatalities last year, the RSA provisional review of those fatalities and the statistics to date, and I am conscious that behind every one of those statistics is a family and a community absolutely devastated, would the assistant commissioner describe road safety in this country as being in crisis?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

No, I do not believe it is in crisis. It is regrettable that we are seeing an increase on last year. There is always more that can be done and we have one part of that. As I said in my opening statement, we also need to look to the personal responsibility of people out there driving. We all do it and we recognise members of our families do it, but there is a personal responsibility that people have to think about.

Comment on this

I agree there is a personal responsibility. If I reflect on the six months of focused hearings we had at the transport committee, the first of the two big issues we are still grappling with - we are working on our report at present - is that key question of who is in charge in the whole system. It is an issue that intersects with so many Departments and agencies, including An Garda Síochána, but it is designed in such a way that there is nobody in charge and accountable. I will park that for a second.

The second big issue is enforcement. Driver behaviour really matters and ultimately what shapes driver behaviour is enforcement. We have so many people on Irish roads for whom the rules of the road are optional. I can quote statistic after statistic and the assistant commissioner will agree with me on that.

Then Commissioner, Mr. Drew Harris, was before the transport committee in May 2024 and he committed to increasing numbers in the roads policing unit by 150. Assistant Commissioner Ferry's predecessor, Assistant Commissioner Gunne, in October of last year confirmed that only 75 of those posts were filled. What is the status regarding the remaining 75 posts that the former Commissioner, Mr. Harris, committed to?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

Commissioner Kelly has said that it is the largest specialist unit within the organisation. The changes that we have made as part of the recommendations around the superintendents and the inspectors being dedicated in each division is-----

Comment on this

What really matters is visibility on the ground, with great respect. I appreciate the important role of inspectors and superintendents, but it is visibility on our roads. For example, there is one member of the roads policing unit at the national level for every 150 km of road. I am in a constituency that falls within the Clare-Tipperary division.

We have one member of the roads policing unit for every 250 km of road. I know what Mr. Ferry is saying, and the Commissioner has said it as well, which is that it is the responsibility of every member of An Garda Síochána, but I do not see evidence of that on the ground. My appeal to Mr. Ferry is to strengthen our roads policing unit.

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

As assistant commissioner for roads policing, I have a certain bias. I will obviously try to do everything I can to maximise the resources we have. It is also about making sure that we look at all the members. We need to be sure that everyone out there is not only responsible for preventing crime and ensuring safety but also for roads policing.

Comment on this

What is the single biggest intervention we can make to reduce the number of road fatalities?

Comment on this
Mr. Denis Ferry

We need to continue to look at speed on our roads and whether we can reduce that. Even during my short period in this role, when one sees the impact of reduced speeds and speed levels, suddenly one sees an impact on the number of incidents or collisions. Obviously, enforcement is a big part of that. What I am trying to do is to target the areas that do not have cameras or GoSafe allocations and make sure we are dynamic about moving those. Some of them could have been static for a while, and we need to look at that. That is an important part. It also involves maximising the use of our members who are there and targeting it so it has an impact.

Comment on this
Matt Carthy An Cathaoirleach Sinn Féin

I thank all Deputies and Senators for their engagement. I propose that we publish the opening statement on the committee's website. Is that agreed? Agreed. On behalf of the committee, I thank Mr. Ferry and Mr. Sugrue not only for attending but also for their frank exchanges with members on an extremely important matter. I propose that the committee go into private session to consider a couple of housekeeping matters. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this