Governance and Funding of Football Association of Ireland: Discussion
Contributions 1–237 of 727. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I remind members and people in the Public Gallery to switch off their mobile telephones as they interfere with the recording equipment. Before commencing the main business of today's proceedings, I will turn to some housekeeping matters. I welcome the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Ross. I apologise to him and all our guests for the delay in the meeting starting. We had to deal with internal issues. I also welcome the Minister of State at the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Griffin, Mr. Ken Spratt, assistant secretary, and Mr. Peter Hogan of the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport, and Mr. John Treacy, chief executive officer, Mr. Kieran Mulvey, chairperson, and Mr. Colm McGinty of Sport Ireland.
In accordance with procedures, I am required to point out that by virtue of section 17(2)(l) of the Defamation Act 2009, witnesses are protected by absolute privilege in respect of their evidence to the committee. However, if they are directed by the committee to cease giving evidence on a particular matter and they continue to so do, they are entitled thereafter only to a qualified privilege in respect of their evidence. They are directed that only evidence connected with the subject matter of these proceedings is to be given and they are asked to respect the parliamentary practice to the effect that, where possible, they should not criticise or make charges against any person, persons or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable. Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice to the effect that they should not comment on, criticise or make charges against a person outside the House or an official either by name or in such a way as to make him or her identifiable.
The committee invited, and expected, representatives of the Football Association of Ireland, FAI, to attend this meeting, particularly when they said last Sunday week that they were prepared to do so. They are not coming and I have a letter which I will read into the public record. It is addressed to the clerk of the committee and is from Rea Walshe, company secretary. It states:
Further to my email of Friday I confirm that we had an open and honest meeting at Leinster House yesterday with Ministers Ross and Griffin.
As stressed after that meeting the immediate focus of the Board must be on the financial restructuring necessary to safeguard jobs, the FAI's financial future and the appointment of an Independent Chairperson and three Independent Directors.
At this moment in time, this requires the undivided attention of the Board of the Association and key management, it is for this reason that the Association is regretfully not in a position to appear before the Joint Committee, tomorrow Wednesday, December 18th.
As soon as the measures outlined above are complete, the Board will welcome the opportunity to appear before the Committee at a time that suits your members. The Board of the FAI thanks the Committee for its patience and understanding at this critical juncture for Irish football.
The committee is happy to issue the invitation again to the FAI and to meet its representatives at any time and, if needs be, as early as possible in the new year.
Comment on this
It is important that the committee states that we do not have patience and understanding. That is assumed on our behalf in the last line. If we are inviting them back before the committee, it should be before the tenure of Mr. Conway ends.
Comment on this
This is something the committee believes is vital because he was there when many of the events took place. He is due to be replaced at the end of January so it must be before that.
Comment on this
I agree. In fact, Deputy Catherine Murphy proposed at the last meeting that we meet at the earliest time in January to facilitate such a meeting.
Comment on this
On the one hand, we all would like to see everybody from the board of the FAI attend the meeting. On the other, however, the Minister says he will not deal with anybody from the old guard. How will we speed up the process? If the old guard does not go, the Minister will not engage with the board of the FAI.
We are looking to keep the members of the old guard in place in order that we can meet them first. How do we handle that situation?
Comment on this
I think we have to handle the situation as we find it. That is why the Minister, the Minister of State and Mr. Treacy are going to address the committee. Everybody here will have an opportunity to ask whatever questions he or she wants. It will be a question-and-answer session. We do not want speeches. We will be looking for direct replies after the three opening speakers have made their initial statements. The transparency and accountability of the Oireachtas and the work of this committee, in particular, have been very effective in dealing with this issue. We insisted on the forensic audit, which turned out to be the KOSI audit. We have nothing to be ashamed of here as a committee. We work as a committee. We are not political in that context. We want to see a future for football that involves funding being restored for young people and women who play the game. I understand that the assets of the FAI include club grounds around the country, such as United Park in Drogheda. We want to ensure that regardless of whatever happens, these assets remain in sport ownership, if at all possible. I do not know what will happen, but I know that everybody up and down the country wants us to get a new committee in place, to get the new directors in place and to move to the future. We want to ensure the mothers and fathers who are out with their children every week in good and bad weather have confidence in football as a sport. As a committee, we are working with the Minister and with Sport Ireland to restore confidence.
Comment on this
I think we should park the reply from the FAI, have our meeting here and come back afterwards to draw up our strategy for dealing with the various segments of this matter, including what happened in the past and what will happen in the future. We should leave enough time at the end of this meeting to deal with that. A process should result from this meeting.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. I invite the Minister, Deputy Ross, to make his opening statement. I thank him for circulating it, albeit at a very late stage.
Comment on this
I am joined by the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, who will also give an opening statement. I am also joined by two officials: Mr. Ken Spratt, who is an assistant secretary in the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport, and Mr. Peter Hogan, who is a principal officer in the sports division of the Department. I would like to respond to what the Chairman said about my opening statement being provided late by apologising for the fact that it was not possible to share a copy of the statement with the committee earlier than this morning. I was receiving responses to queries from UEFA, the Attorney General and Sport Ireland yesterday afternoon. Therefore, this statement was not finalised until last night. In fact, one or two changes were later this morning after the script was provided to the committee.
It is deeply disappointing to be before this committee once more to discuss the need for major reform of the FAI. It was on St. Patrick's Day that we first read in The Sunday Times about a most irregular financial transaction, namely, the 2017 loan of €100,000 by the former chief executive. This was prompted by a financial crisis in the FAI. The association was looking at a situation in which it could not settle its creditors. The national governing body for football in Ireland, which is one of the largest sporting bodies in the State, found itself without funds to pay for its day-to-day operations. In such circumstances, the board of Sport Ireland had no choice but to suspend funding to the FAI for this breach of funding conditions. The Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, and I confirmed that no funding from the Department’s sports capital programme would be provided until the corporate governance and financial control issues had been resolved to our satisfaction. I regret that this position remains unchanged today, notwithstanding the good efforts of Sport Ireland, the Institute of Public Administration and the professional firms that have been advising the FAI throughout this process.
The initial story in The Sunday Times was followed by a distressing drip feed of stories in the national media outlining years of poor corporate governance, poor financial management and a complete lack of proper oversight or key controls. This culminated in a disastrous appearance of representatives of the FAI before this committee in April. The former chief executive appeared before the committee but chose not to respond to the important questions tabled by members. The members of the FAI board who attended that meeting did nothing to restore confidence. It was clear after the meeting that there was a need for a robust independent review of all financial matters and of the governance structure of the FAI. Like the members of the committee, I am dismayed that the FAI has decided not to appear here today. I made it clear some months ago that there was a need for a total clear-out of the FAI board as part of a complete break from the past. In respect of the appointment of an interim chief executive, I stated explicitly that it was not in the FAI's interests to appoint anyone associated with the old regime. I was rebuffed in both cases, as was the FAI's right, firstly by the appointment of Mr. Noel Mooney as the interim chief executive and then by the decision of the President of the FAI, Mr. Donal Conway, and Mr. John Earley to stand for re-election to the board in July. I understand that both of them have finally decided to step down, and that Mr. Earley has already resigned.
The governance review group carried out a serious review of the weaknesses in the FAI's governance which have led directly to this crisis. The group made many recommendations, all of which were accepted by the FAI. As the committee will be aware, one of the most important recommendations involved the appointment of an independent chair and three other independent directors. As we have seen, recommendation is one thing and implementation is apparently completely different. It is a source of great and ongoing frustration that, five months later, these independent directors have incredibly not yet been appointed. I have not received a satisfactory explanation of the reason for the non-completion of this process. This should have been one of the first things the FAI did to start the process of restoring trust in the association. Instead, as we approach the end of the year, we find ourselves still waiting for these vital appointments. I have been advised that the appointments will take place in the very near future. I reiterate that filling the posts of the independent chair and the independent directors must be and is the first priority for the FAI. Thereafter, it should move without delay to launch a robust and competitive process to recruit a new independent chief executive.
The final report of the KOSI audit was received by Sport Ireland at the end of last month. I am restricted in what I can say about the KOSI report, which is with An Garda Síochána and the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, ODCE. Transparency is always crucial when it comes to tackling difficulties like those of the FAI. On foot of requests from this committee for the report in full, or even a redacted version, I have taken legal advice from my Department's legal adviser and the Attorney General. They have insisted that it would be unlawful for me to furnish the committee with a copy of the report. I have also consulted An Garda Síochána, which has advised me that the matters outlined in the KOSI report are central to its investigations and those of the ODCE. The Garda has further advised me that making the report public at this time could have serious implications for any criminal proceedings subsequently brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions.
While I would very much like to share the KOSI report, and my instinct is to do so, it is clear from the advice I have been given by the Garda that even a heavily redacted copy could undermine its work. Consequently, I am not in a position to share the report with the committee today. I hope I will be able to furnish it at some point in the future when the investigations that are under way have been concluded. I am somewhat relieved to confirm to the committee that the KOSI auditors found that the State funding given to the FAI was expended for the purposes for which it was provided. This was one of the key questions we wanted the auditors to answer. The committee was clear in its desire that the audit would be forensic in nature. I am pleased to assure members that the KOSI audit team pursued a forensic approach in its assessment of the FAI's compliance with the terms and conditions for Sport Ireland grant funding.
The second key question for KOSI was an assessment of whether the association could demonstrate its fitness to handle public funds. The committee will be aware that after the board of Sport Ireland considered the KOSI audit on 27 November last, it decided against restoring funding to the FAI.
While I have been advised that it would be unlawful to share the full details of the KOSI auditors’ findings, I can confirm that their opinion is that the FAI is not fit to handle public funds. They acknowledge that some steps have been taken to address shortcomings, but there is a steep mountain to climb before we can reinstate funding to the FAI.
In the interim, we have been looking at all options to continue our support for those who really matter, namely, the clubs, players and coaches at the heart of Irish grassroots soccer. We have developed a scheme through Sport Ireland to support the players on the women’s national team. Sport Ireland has engaged BDO Ireland to deliver funding and other support to the players, with the assurance that no public funds will be disbursed directly or indirectly to the FAI. This arrangement will enable us to continue to support the players as they seek to clinch qualification for the women’s EURO 2020, while assuring taxpayers that funding will be safeguarded. I am pleased to be able to reveal to the committee that Sport Ireland has put together a similar scheme to deliver support for the youth field sports programme which has been the primary vehicle for public funding for the development of soccer. This funding will ensure continued support for 60 development officers and the programmes they deliver throughout the country. This scheme will begin next month, and if necessary will deliver funding of €2.3 million to the development officers throughout 2020. Notwithstanding the suspension of Sport Ireland funding, there has been no break in these programmes and there will be no break. Mr. Treacy will be able to provide the committee with more detail about this funding scheme. Not one euro of this funding will go to the FAI. It will not receive a single cent, directly or indirectly, until we are fully satisfied that all weaknesses in governance and financial control have been fully addressed. The funding will be channelled through a payroll processing company which will make payments directly to the development officers themselves. That company will also ensure the payment of deducted taxes, PRSI and expenses as appropriate. Development officers play a vital role in supporting clubs throughout the country, and the last thing we want to do is disrupt their important work. Grassroots football must not suffer because of the mistakes of those at the top of the greasy pole.
As members of the committee will be aware, the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, and I met with members of the FAI board on Monday evening. The delegation was led by the vice president and executive lead, Mr. Paul Cooke, along with the FAI's financial advisers from Grant Thornton. It was a sobering experience. As I have stated, the FAI delegation accepted the need for a full changeover of the board, and for the urgent appointment of an independent chair, directors, and chief executive without undue delay. The FAI delegation presented the stark reality of the association’s financial crisis and outlined their proposed business plan to overcome these very considerable challenges. They came seeking a bailout. Deputy Griffin and I made it clear to the FAI that we cannot and will not provide it with taxpayers’ money. The KOSI report makes it clear that the association is not in a fit state to receive public funds and we must respect that. However, we did tell the delegation that we would meet with UEFA to discuss the FAI’s challenges. Officials in my Department are in contact with UEFA with a view to arranging a meeting as early as possible, which we expect to be held in early January.
Before concluding, Deputy Griffin and I pay tribute to the forgotten stakeholders - the FAI staff who are facing an uncertain future. The staff at the FAI have endured pay freezes and more over the past ten years, and have been shocked to learn about the previously undisclosed pay agreements with the former chief executive. They are not the ones who caused this problem and they deserve recognition, not victimhood, for their service to Irish football. Deputy Griffin and I will be meeting with SIPTU and the employees’ representatives later this evening to hear their concerns. I assure them that we will continue to engage with them over the challenging days to come. I will now hand over to my colleague, the Minister of State with responsibility for tourism and sport, Deputy Brendan Griffin.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the opportunity to speak to the committee today, though it gives me no joy that we are once again discussing the difficult situation of soccer in Ireland. This should be a time for optimism, given the recent positive performances from our men’s and women’s national teams and the exciting prospect of hosting EURO 2020 matches at the Aviva Stadium next year. However, the FAI has not been able to move on from the crisis which began last March. I am sorry to say that we are now seeing the real impact of failures in financial management and corporate governance at the top tier of the football pyramid on those at the bottom, namely, the grassroots clubs, coaches, volunteers, players and supporters. One of the most common criticisms we heard of the FAI is that the decisions were made by a small group at the top and the wider membership never got the opportunity to have their say. Last May, the Minister and I hosted a very successful Irish football stakeholders forum in the Mansion House, which was also attended by several members of this committee. That forum brought together stakeholders from across the Irish football community to discuss the future direction of football in Ireland. There were some hysterical warnings that this would be a bad-tempered event which would not deliver anything meaningful. However, the engagement by those who attended was respectful, considered, and serious about the well-being of the sport. There was an openness to new ideas and a willingness to listen to the views of other sectors of the game. The broader football community made it clear that they are committed to growing their sport and that they want to move past the current crisis. We in Government are committed to growing football in Ireland as well. We know the positive role it plays in Irish life in clubs throughout the country. In spite of the challenges, we have been doing all we can to support the game of soccer in Ireland.
Regarding Government assistance for capital projects, we can be very proud of the huge improvements in sports facilities in recent years. More than 10,000 projects have benefitted from sports capital funding since 1998, bringing total allocations in that time to more than €1 billion. Soccer clubs have also benefitted significantly in this regard. More than €156 million has been granted to soccer clubs, leagues and organisations. The final grants under the 2018 round of the sports capital programme were announced last month and under this round alone, more than 300 grants valued at €6.5 million were allocated to soccer clubs throughout the country. The Department is now undertaking a full review of all aspects of the 2018 sports capital programme. This review will include consideration of the timing and scale of the next round of the programme. I expect that the programme will be open for applications again in the coming months and I look forward to seeing many more excellent soccer projects from clubs in every county applying and being assisted.
This committee had a very interesting discussion with Hockey Ireland last week, which underscored the importance of State support for our amateur athletes representing Ireland in international competitions. The Minister and I are absolutely committed to supporting the players in the women’s national team who make such a huge contribution as the leading exponents of women’s football in Ireland. I am delighted that we have been able to develop an effective intermediary arrangement for the payment of grant funding for the women’s national team. The team achieved record attendance for international home games this year and delivered some impressive performances to boot. I am confident that under the guidance of team manager Vera Pauw the team can achieve its ambition of qualifying for its first major tournament, the women's EURO 2021. As the Minister said, Sport Ireland has developed a similar arrangement for the provision of funding for development officers. I welcome this pragmatic solution and I am confident that with Sport Ireland support, development officers will be able to continue their important work with grassroots soccer.
Sport Ireland is continuing to explore every option to continue our support for soccer in Ireland. With the best will in the world, it may not be possible to find a mechanism for every programme. This is why it is so important that those at the top of the FAI commit to restoring public trust. The board must show leadership and act decisively to implement serious reform in the association’s corporate governance.
At the meeting earlier this week, the board members acknowledged to the Minister and myself the serious failures that occurred under the previous regime. They indicated that they accept the urgent need for reform. I trust that they will redouble their efforts to make good on their commitment to overhaul their association.
Unfortunately, when governance failures occur within individual organisations, they tend to damage the reputation of the entire sports system. It would be unfair to tar all of those involved in Irish sport with the same brush. I frequently meet the chairs, directors and chief executives of the various national governing bodies, as do the committee members, and I have great confidence in their commitment to strive always for the benefit of their members and to the values of sport such as honesty, integrity and fair play. I understand, however, that a crisis such as this one lays bare structural weaknesses which, if not addressed, can lead to difficulties in the future. The development of stronger governance is therefore very important, at both an organisation and a system level. The need for measures aimed at better governance in national governing bodies was recognised a number of years ago and in 2017, Sport Ireland introduced the mandatory adoption by NGBs of the governance code for sport, formerly the governance code for the community, voluntary and charity sector. The governance code for sport is a principles-based code consisting of best practice for boards.
The Government’s National Sports Policy 2018-2027, which the Minister, Deputy Ross, and I published in 2018, requires that all national governing bodies, NGBs, and local sports partnerships are signed up to the governance code by the end of 2021. I am pleased to say that there has been good progress with 31 NGBs and sporting bodies already fully signed up to the code, with a further 50 working towards adoption of the code. The FAI is one of those NGBs which has committed to achieving compliance with the governance code. I urge the board and the new CEO, when that person is appointed, to ensure that they continue this important work.
As the committee knows, Sport Ireland already has robust auditing arrangements in place in respect of the funding it allocates to the main field sport NGBs – the FAI, the GAA and the IRFU. Following discussions at this committee earlier this year, Sport Ireland has now strengthened the terms and conditions of its funding schemes, which will apply to grants from 2020. The changes confer full audit rights on Sport Ireland and require NGBs to disclose the remuneration packages of their CEOs to Sport Ireland. I acknowledge the good work that Sport Ireland has done in revising the terms of conditions of funding.
The most immediate tasks for the FAI are to appoint the independent chair, the other independent directors and an independent, full-time chief executive. These appointments are vital for the association to rebuild public trust and to enable the Government to once again provide funding for the FAI’s programmes and capital projects. The FAI board members confirmed to the Minister and myself that they are absolutely committed to these appointments. I hope that we will see progress in the near future. I welcome the announcement by Donal Conway that he will step down at an extraordinary general meeting, EGM, in January and the recent resignation of John Earley from the board. I regret that they did not step down at the EGM last summer but I welcome the fact that they are now stepping down to make way for new leadership in the FAI.
As members will know, the FAI, at its annual general meeting, AGM, in June, agreed overwhelmingly to accept the recommendations of the governance review group and to completely overhaul the association’s rule book and structures. This was a positive step and I know that progress has been made since then. That progress must be maintained if the FAI is to restore public trust.
I reiterate that no public funding will be provided to the FAI by my Department or Sport Ireland until we see evidence of real reform and a clean break with the previous regime at board and executive levels. The FAI is well aware of the steps it needs to take to bring about a situation where public funding can be reinstated. I urge it to do so without any further delays.
Comment on this
I ask John Treacy to give his address. For the benefit of those who were not here when we started the meeting, each member will have ten minutes each to ask questions, and they may share time. In terms of rotation, it will be Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin, Deputy Catherine Murphy, Deputy Coppinger and Senator Ó Céidigh. In the second round, it will be Fine Gael, Senator O'Keeffe and Senator Mark Daly.
Comment on this
I am joined by my colleagues, Kieran Mulvey, chairman of Sport Ireland, and Colm McGinty, director of strategic programmes, who is sitting behind me.
This is Sport Ireland’s fourth time meeting with the committee this year to discuss matters pertaining to the FAI. At each meeting, we detailed in-depth the remit of Sport Ireland, its funding relationship with the FAI and actions taken to support the FAI through its ongoing situation.
As the committee will be aware, KOSI Corporation Limited recently completed its forensic audit of the FAI, which was commissioned by Sport Ireland under the terms and conditions of grant approval. The committee will be aware that the audit report was referred by the board of Sport Ireland to An Garda Síochána. Today, I will outline to the committee that the independent forensic KOSI audit verified that taxpayer funding to the FAI, through Sport Ireland, was spent in line with the approved submissions and for the purposes it was given by Sport Ireland during the period 2015-2018. I will give an overview of Sport Ireland’s role and remit under the Sport Ireland Act 2015, with a particular focus on the extent of Sport Ireland’s powers with regard to the oversight of public funding invested in our national sporting organisations. I will also inform the committee of recent developments with regard to governance training in national governing bodies of Sport and the revision of Sport Ireland’s terms and conditions of grant approval to enhance, on a consent basis, Sport Ireland’s right to conduct audits beyond the scope of funding provided to sporting organisations.
KOSI’s independent forensic audit of the FAI, which was commissioned by Sport Ireland under the terms and conditions of grant approval agreed with the FAI, has been completed. Sport Ireland received KOSI’s audit report on the FAI on the evening of Tuesday, 26 November, and provided a copy of the report to the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport in compliance with his request and powers under the Sport Ireland Act 2015. The KOSI report was considered by the audit and risk committee and the board of Sport Ireland early on Wednesday, 27 November. The independent forensic audit completed by KOSI confirmed that the FAI spent all taxpayer funding allocated through Sport Ireland in line with approved submissions and for the purposes it was given by Sport Ireland during the period 2015 to 2018. KOSI found that the consumption of Sport Ireland grants had been safely covered by FAI expenditure in the programme areas supported. It is worth noting that KOSI’s overall conclusion was similar to previous internal audits of the FAI completed on Sport Ireland’s behalf in 2010, 2014 and 2016, which also found that Sport Ireland funding to the FAI was fully accounted for and expended for the purposes in which it was intended. The board of Sport Ireland subsequently referred the audit report to An Garda Síochána, following consideration of legal advice, which included senior counsel input. As such, for legal reasons, Sport Ireland is not in a position to publish the audit report or provide any further information on it at this time. Our legal advice is that Sport Ireland cannot discuss the report or its contents in public, including with the Joint Committee on Transport, Tourism and Sport.
Following consideration of the KOSI report, the board of Sport Ireland agreed that the suspension and withholding of funding to the FAI remains in place. However, the board approved the establishment of a process, with the consent of the FAI, to meet with the FAI on an ongoing basis to discuss governance and financial issues and to support the FAI on its reform agenda. This is an essential requirement to fulfil as part of the pathway towards restoration of Sport Ireland funding to the FAI. Sport Ireland has written to the FAI in this regard. The status of funding to the FAI continues to be reviewed by the board of Sport Ireland on an ongoing basis. The committee will be aware that in November, the board of Sport Ireland approved a payment of 2019 grant funding for the women's senior national football team programme.
The grant of €195,000 will be paid by Sport Ireland to accountancy firm BDO, which will oversee the disbursement of the funding in line with terms and conditions.
The Sport Ireland Act 2015 confers considerable authority in Sport Ireland as the statutory body for the development of sport in Ireland. The functions of Sport Ireland are prescribed in section 8 of the Sport Ireland Act and include powers to develop participation in sport and high performance sport, eliminate doping in sport as the national anti-doping agency, develop coaching, develop guidelines on the protection of children in sport, and the development of the Sport Ireland campus. Sport Ireland must adhere to the Sport Ireland Act 2015 and cannot act beyond its legal powers or authority as prescribed by the Act. As a statutory development agency, Sport Ireland seeks to develop strong sports organisations and recognises the considerable public interest in a successful Irish sports sector. Sport Ireland is responsible for the investment of public money in sport and the subsequent oversight and accountability of this investment.
From previous meetings, the committee is aware that Sport Ireland is not a regulatory body and Sport Ireland has no regulatory, investigatory or enforcement powers relating to corporate governance in sporting organisations. This was discussed at length with this committee during meetings earlier this year. The committee is also aware that there is no provision in the Sport Ireland Act that gives Sport Ireland statutory authority to audit or inspect the books and records of a body in receipt of Sport Ireland funding. This has been confirmed by our legal advisers. The committee is aware that funded organisations sign up to Sport Ireland’s terms and conditions of grant approval, which permits audit on a consent basis.
It is important to note that Sport Ireland’s terms and conditions of grant approval clearly stipulate that all funded bodies must have in place a valid tax clearance certificate before any funding is paid. Sport Ireland can confirm it received all necessary tax clearance documentation from the FAI each year, including in 2019. Furthermore, Sport Ireland’s terms and conditions of grant approval require all sporting bodies to submit to Sport Ireland a copy of its annual financial statements, fully audited by a registered auditor in accordance with Irish generally accepted accounting principles, GAAP, accounting standards. Sport Ireland places fundamental reliance on the statutory auditor's signed audit opinion.
The terms and conditions explicitly state that the accounts furnished to Sport Ireland must "include all financial transactions of the organisation during the course of the accounting year in question". It is important to remind the committee that primary responsibility for preparation of any company's financial statements rests with that company’s management and board of directors. The FAI board is responsible for risk management within the association and for ensuring that the FAI keeps adequate accounting records. Corporate governance practice and company law require that the directors of a company must not approve accounts unless they are satisfied they give a "true and fair view" of the financial position. Sport Ireland relies on the objective, independent and professional judgment of the statutory auditors whose work was carried out in accordance with international standards on auditing. Each year the FAI's financial statements were given a clean, unqualified opinion by the external auditor Deloitte. The audit opinion stated that the auditors had not identified any material misstatements and that the financial statements, in the auditor's opinion, gave a "true and fair view" of the financial position of the FAI.
It is clear from the filing of the H4 notice in April and the restated and revised FAI financial statements that this was not the case. Undeclared transactions of serious concern and unrecorded liabilities for a number of years only came to full public attention on the recent publication of the FAI's 2018 financial statements approximately 12 days ago. Oversight of compliance with company law is a matter for the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, ODCE. Sport Ireland notes that the ODCE has extensive investigative and enforcement powers and we are aware that its investigation of the FAI, which we understand is serious, is ongoing.
Sport Ireland places a high premium on good governance and encourages high standards in governance from all funded bodies. As a development agency, it is our aim to provide leadership in this area, empowering sport organisations to take responsibility for their own governance and meet the challenges they face. We have previously outlined to the committee the range of governance training, seminars and supports provided by Sport Ireland for those in key leadership and governance roles in sporting organisations. Although Sport Ireland promotes good governance in sporting organisations, we cannot enforce good governance, and it is up to governing bodies themselves to do that. In accordance with a key corporate governance principle, the board of any national governing body is collectively responsible for leading and directing the organisation’s activities and for ensuring that effective systems of internal control are in place.
The committee is aware from Sport Ireland's attendance here in July this year that the board of Sport Ireland has approved revised terms and conditions of grant approval for all Sport Ireland-funded organisations to come into effect for 2020. To recap for the committee members, the amendments to the terms and conditions include strengthening the audit clause to explicitly confer full audit, inspection and investigative rights on Sport Ireland for every funded body, and the right to audit, inspection or investigation may also extend to any matter of concern to Sport Ireland that arises in respect of the organisation and not just relating to the use made by the organisation of the Sport Ireland grant funding. The amendments also include making it an explicit condition of funding that Sport Ireland-appointed auditors are entitled to request and receive all the information and explanations they require for the proper performance of their job and making it a condition of funding for all national governing bodies of sport and local sports partnerships to provide details of the full remuneration packages for their chief executives or equivalent positions to Sport Ireland. Additionally, Sport Ireland will need to be provided with independent verification that each organisation is fully compliant with the code of practice for good governance of community, voluntary and charitable organisations in Ireland by the end of 2021. Failure to co-operate fully with any audit, inspection or investigation on a timely basis will entitle Sport Ireland to suspend or withhold grant funding or claim repayment of any grants previously advanced by Sport Ireland. The board of Sport Ireland is satisfied that these measures are appropriate and necessary in light of the recent learnings from the FAI case. We are confident that the additions will further strengthen Sport Ireland’s authority in respect of overseeing public funds.
The Government’s national sports policy, published in July 2018, tasks Sport Ireland with overseeing a process whereby all national governing bodies of sport and local sports partnerships adopt the governance code by the end of 2021. As reported at the meeting in July, Sport Ireland has taken over the governance code for community, voluntary and charitable organisations as a governance code for sport. This follows the decision of the governance code working group to retire the code. To date, 31 Sport Ireland-funded bodies have fully adopted the code and another 50 are on the adoption journey.
Following recent developments at the FAI, Sport Ireland considered new ways to build and sustain governance capacity and capability within the national governing bodies and local sports partnerships. Sport Ireland invited applications from senior executives and board members within national governing bodies of sport and local sports partnerships to undertake a level 9 professional certificate in governance. This certificate is delivered by the Institute of Public Administration and accredited by the National University of Ireland. There were 60 applications received from national governing bodies and local sports partnerships and, following a shortlisting process, 51 applicants were selected for participation in the programme from a total of 35 sporting bodies. It is a one-year part-time programme that addresses a key area of concern to executives, boards and committees across the sport sector.
This accredited programme examines governance as a set of structures, arrangements, processes and procedures. It focuses on the principles and culture that ensure organisations are properly directed and controlled. The course covers the roles and responsibilities of governing bodies and boards, the performance and accountability of directors and executives, assurance arrangements, fiduciary responsibilities, distinction of executive and non-executive functions and reserved functions of boards, strategy, finance and leadership. On completion of the course, graduates will have authoritative knowledge of the principles and practices associated with proper direction, decision-making and control in organisations. The programme commenced on 15 November this year.
The committee will recall from previous meetings that the FAI established an implementation oversight group tasked with overseeing implementation of the 78 recommendation of the governance review group report conducted by the IPA. The effective ongoing operation of the implementation oversight group as set out in the governance review group’s report is of vital importance on the journey to reforming FAI governance, and restoring public trust and confidence in the FAI. The association recently provided an update on the work of the implementation oversight group. It reported that 40% of the recommendations have been implemented, including 11 priority actions.
I will summarise the information given in this statement. The KOSI audit independently confirms that the FAI spent all Sport Ireland funding in line with approved submissions and for the purposes it was given by Sport Ireland during the period 2015 to 2018. Sport Ireland is the statutory development agency for sport. Under the Sport Ireland Act 2015, Sport Ireland is not a regulatory body, and it has no regulatory, investigatory or enforcement powers in respect of corporate governance in sporting bodies. No provision of the Act that gives Sport Ireland statutory authority to audit or inspect the books and records of a body in receipt of its funding. This has been confirmed by our legal advisers. The board of Sport Ireland has approved revised terms and conditions of grant approval for all Sport Ireland-funded organisations to come into effect for 2020 funding. This includes the strengthening of the audit clause to explicitly confer full audit, inspection and investigative rights on Sport Ireland for every funded body.
Comment on this
I thank Mr. Treacy. We move to the members of the committee. As agreed, everyone will have ten minutes. If members wish to share their time, they should let me know. I remind everyone that the KOSI report is with An Garda Síochána and the Director of Corporate Enforcement. I ask every member to be cognisant of that in order that we do not prejudice anything that might arise by our comments today, notwithstanding anything already in the public domain. I ask everyone to ask a question and get an answer, if possible.
Comment on this
I thank the Ministers and Sport Ireland for their opening remarks. I will begin by addressing the Minister. Based on his presentation to the committee, does he agree that the only thing that has changed since the FAI was before the committee last March is the revelations of the mismanagement of the organisation over the years, their audits and so on? I take from his presentation that the implementation of reform in the FAI is painstakingly slow. I get the impression it is being brought kicking and screaming to implement reform. The Minister stated: "I have not received a satisfactory explanation as to why this has not yet been completed". The independent directors have not been appointed. If he has not had a satisfactory explanation, what explanation did he get as to why they were not appointed before now?
Comment on this
I agree with most, probably all, of what the Senator said. The slow progress - and there has been some progress but very little - on the important issues is unbelievably frustrating. What should have been done with great urgency first after the resignation of some directors last March, which we welcome, was the process of appointing independent directors.
Comment on this
I am sorry but I am time constrained. What explanation did they give?
Comment on this
The reason for the delay was that they were waiting for various staging points, such as AGMs and EGMs. The most recent excuse given was that they wanted to wait for the KOSI report and that any independent directors might want to see that. The excuse being given now is that they are examining the KOSI report and those who have been chosen are apparently deciding whether they will accept the position if offered as the situation reveals itself. I do not believe this is a good reason for not making the appointment of a new chief executive or starting the process or retaining the current chairman. The key to change and the FAI coming into a new corporate governance regime and the FAI's credibility is that those independent directors must be appointed. It is now six months later and they have not been. The reasons given vary but the delay is unacceptable. We believe the independent directors are the key to unlocking progress and reform, which is not happening.
Comment on this
The Minister has outlined how the funding is to be restored to grassroots soccer. Is there a vehicle to distribute all the funding, which, I think, amounts to €2.9 million, to the grassroots? That is going a different route, but has any other funding been withheld? I am thinking of Euro 2020. It looks as though this may run into the sand. Will there be funding for the four games in Ireland at the Aviva stadium? Is some of that funding under threat?
Comment on this
I have no indication that it is. The presentation the FAI made to us last Monday night listed the possible dangers of a disaster situation which included Euro 2020. We have no indication that the funding has been withheld from that or that there is any delay. We are absolutely adamant on the €2.9 million to which the Senator referred. That will be channelled through various independent bodies and there will be absolutely no gap in funding whatever. They will not lose out.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his brevity. Finally, how much did the FAI seek from the Minister on Monday as a bailout?
Comment on this
It looked for various scenarios. It looked for €18 million.
Comment on this
That is €18 million for now. It could be €80 million.
Comment on this
It could. One never knows what it is going to be. The FAI looked for €18 million or alternatively a guarantee of that. It presented various scenarios. That was the figure it named and it was shocking.
Comment on this
On Euro 2020, our level of preparedness is among the best of all host cities. The Department has assigned a principal officer who is dedicated to working on it. On everything in our control, we are well on top of hosting those four games and we are confident that those games will not be at risk. It would be a massive blow to the country, from the Exchequer point of view and otherwise.
Comment on this
Briefly, as I know that it is not possible to go into much detail, can Mr. Treacy and Mr. Mulvey say on what basis the KOSI report was referred to An Garda Síochána? Was it on legal advice or was it when they saw the report?
Comment on this
When we got the report, we read it and immediately gave it to our legal advisers.
We got senior counsel advice with regard to it. That is the legal advice that came back to the board. The board then referred it to the Garda the next day.
Comment on this
Mr. Treacy explained how Sport Ireland is not a regulatory body in a sense. I find it strange that the 2017 figures from the auditors were cleared without a problem or a health warning. There is a health warning on the corrected figures released a few weeks ago, however. That is difficult for the general public.
Comment on this
I agree with the Senator. It is a strange one. We can only accept what the auditors tell us. It is a serious issue.
Comment on this
Would Mr. Treacy like to see the procedures changed. This is the second time this has occurred. A couple of years ago we had the Olympic Council. We have all quoted that. I agree with Mr. Treacy’s assessment that the Olympic Federation of Ireland has been a role model of what can be done to correct such issues. Could this happen again, however, with other governing bodies?
Comment on this
I could never guarantee it would not happen again. We are dealing with 65 organisations. With the revised terms and conditions, we can do a deeper dive with our own auditors having a good look at corporate governance functions. We do it with the smaller organisations which we fund over 50%. We have done this for some time. However, for bodies that we give 5% or 10% of their funding, we were pushed back on that.
Comment on this
If Sport Ireland requested the Minister to give it stronger powers to avoid what we have seen over the past several years with two sporting governing bodies, would he give them?
Comment on this
If Sport Ireland came to us with a case that it thought it should have greater powers in this regard, we would, of course, consider it.
Comment on this
I suggest that it is added because it protects Sport Ireland.
I call Deputy MacSharry. Do you wish to share time?
Comment on this
I welcome everybody.
I am going to be quick. Where a “Yes” or “No” answer applies, will the witnesses opt for it as opposed to talking down the clock?
For all of us it is unacceptable what happened. All the witnesses have read the KOSI report. We have not. We are questioning in a vacuum as a result. The witnesses’ legal advice is exclusive to them, meaning we do not get to say whether they are right or wrong. The Minister, the Department and Sport Ireland regularly refer to KOSI. This is a difficult position for us to be in and it is not acceptable.
When was the last time the board of Sport Ireland met the FAI?
Comment on this
No, that is not the question.
When was the last time the board of Sport Ireland met the FAI? Was it, for example, as far back as 2011?
Comment on this
A delegation for the board, including Kieran Mulvey, met the FAI in March or April.
Comment on this
Is it correct that the full board does not meet the organisation?
Comment on this
When was the last full board meeting with the FAI?
Comment on this
We are talking years ago.
I will be guided by the Chairman if he feels the next question should not proceed.
Comment on this
My jersey is outside the door. I am a member of the committee.
Comment on this
There have been some press reports and it has been alleged to me that following the publication of The Sunday Times article back in March, the FAI had an impromptu board meeting in Gibraltar at which the then CEO tendered his resignation and left the meeting. It is further alleged to me that he called Mr. Mulvey and following that returned to the meeting and resumed the position as CEO. Is that true?
Comment on this
No, that is not true the way the Deputy has described it. John Delaney rang me to inform me as a courtesy.
Comment on this
Sorry, I just want to be clear. I have no issue with Mr. Mulvey answering the question.
Comment on this
I am conscious of an ongoing criminal investigation. We are advised to not name names.
Comment on this
No, I am only trying to make sure we do things properly. I am not stopping anyone. That is just a caution I have been asked to give on legal advice.
Comment on this
Mr. Delaney rang me to inform me he was taking up this vice president post. He was leaving his position as CEO. He was informing me as a courtesy. I do not know whether he did or not but he was saying that he had either rung or was ringing the Minister to inform him of the same.
Comment on this
He did. He rang me sometime around that evening. I had a short conversation with him. It was about 90 seconds long.
Comment on this
I would love to have KOSI.
We welcome the commitment to return funding through the company, BDO. Does the Sport Ireland Act permit that?
Comment on this
Some of that funding for development officers and the programmes would come from local authorities, some from the FAI directly and the balance from the State. Where is the rest of the money coming from? Is Sport Ireland funding it all?
Comment on this
No, we are not funding it all. We will provide 38% to 40% of it.
Comment on this
Are the local authorities divvying up their 50%?
Comment on this
Yes, there is some money from the local authorities.
Comment on this
They are all on board with this new proposal.
Comment on this
Yes, this was negotiated with the FAI last week.
Comment on this
What about the local authorities?
Comment on this
This is between the FAI and ourselves at the moment. It is up to the FAI to take the local authorities with them but it will.
Comment on this
Who will be the employers of the development officers?
Comment on this
The FAI is the employer of the development officers. We are not the employers.
Comment on this
Are there any superannuation implications to the set-up? I understand PRSI and so forth will be paid by BDO.
Comment on this
The FAI will pay BDO. The local authorities will pay the FAI which will in turn pay BDO.
Comment on this
That can be done by a payroll processing company.
Comment on this
Is the Minister content to let the FAI go into liquidation or examinership?
Comment on this
I certainly do not want to see that happening. The implications of that could be serious. I would far rather see a settlement whereby it rises from the ashes. That is what we would aim to see in the interests of Irish football.
Comment on this
Have the Department or Sport Ireland taken the initiative to contact the IRFU to see if it is interested in taking over the €29 million debt relevant to the stadium and the FAI’s stake in it?
Comment on this
Would the Minister take the initiative?
Comment on this
I presume that will be looked at. Up to €29 million of debt disappearing plus the associated servicing costs would presumably improve the FAI’s position.
Comment on this
We will see what the IRFU has to say tomorrow.
Comment on this
If the IRFU is not interested and third parties, such as UEFA or FIFA, cannot be identified to take it on, would the State look at taking the stake in the stadium?
Comment on this
No proposal has been made to the State about that at this stage.
Comment on this
It is actually a home-grown proposal that comes directly from me. I am asking the question.
Comment on this
I would discuss anything with Deputy MacSharry but at this stage we have not even considered anything like that.
Comment on this
If it gets to it, is it something we are prepared to consider?
Comment on this
I have no wish to lead Deputy MacSharry up the garden path about anything or to support any particular proposals. I have said that in this situation - the FAI came to us the other day with proposals - if there are reasonable proposals of any sort on the table, we are not going to reject them. However, we have not considered anything along that line at this stage.
Comment on this
Nothing is agreed until everything is agreed, presumably, so it could be on the list.
Comment on this
I am not going to give Deputy MacSharry that sort of comfort.
Comment on this
I am conscious that something needs to be done. I believe we are heading towards Bank of Ireland putting up a "For Sale" sign on the Aviva stadium. Obviously, no one wants to see that because we are all here to secure Irish football if we can. While I appreciate that the Minister will not answer, I respectfully suggest that he add that option to the list of considerations because it may well be where we end up. As much as it is unpalatable for the State and for all of us, it is potentially a realistic option. It may not be our preference, but we may need to consider it if the IRFU or others do not step up.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy MacSharry for being constructive. Reasonable suggestions have to be considered. This is a crisis and they have to be looked at.
Comment on this
Dead or dry cash, for example, providing €18 million on the never-never, is something we would all be against. I would hate to see that but if it gets to the stage where nothing else can be done, the stadium is a tangible asset that the people would be happy to own.
I am a little confused. A previous speaker referred to the independent directors. We all do our own research and we try to pick up information from the press corps, people we know in the FAI, Department officials and so on. There seems to be total confusion with regard to the independent directors. There are people in the FAI who claim not to know the names of the independent directors and that they were shown only profiles of independent directors rather than names. They say they are screaming for the independent directors to be appointed and are not delaying these appointments. I am told that the independent directors have been selected and are engaging with Grant Thornton and getting financial briefings before taking up their positions. None of us knows the independent directors but the clear public perception is that the FAI is blocking the appointment of independent directors. The Minister's words today very much suggest that is the case. I have access to Department officials, FAI staff and colleagues in the press but I still do not know who is blocking or delaying the appointment of the independent directors.
Comment on this
I will respond to the question on what I understand about the independent directors.
Comment on this
Does Mr. Treacy know their names?
Comment on this
Do any of the witnesses know their names?
Comment on this
I know some of the names that are being mentioned.
Comment on this
If I could answer the question, that might be the way to approach this. Amrop has gone through an exhaustive process. It has identified a host of candidates who put their hands up for this. It has identified a number of people who would be suitable for the board and for committees within the FAI. That process is near completion. I was hoping that a nominations committee might be put together this week. That is a critical aspect. They are, therefore, very close. The independent members wanted to see the finances of the organisation. If someone is going on a board-----
Comment on this
I have a final question, which I want to tease it out.
Comment on this
Someone going on a board needs to know what he or she is taking on. That is a critical question. Getting the accounts across the line is critical to that. Briefings from Grant Thornton have taken place with independent members in the past week or so.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say no one is delaying it?
Comment on this
Will the Minister explain why it has been said that people are delaying it?
Comment on this
The process should have started last July.
Comment on this
Is it fair to say that the existing six directors, including the executive lead of the FAI, are not delaying the appointment?
Comment on this
I do not know what is actually happening at this stage. I am not hands-on in that regard. What I am saying is this should have happened far earlier. There is no hurry to it.
Comment on this
Due process is taking place and there is no delay. That is what Mr. Treacy seems to be suggesting. He does not know the names of the independent directors. The Minister is unsure and says this should have happened months ago - and so say all of us.
Comment on this
It is still not clear who is delaying the process. The Minister is telling the public that it is being delayed. The position is still not clear.
Comment on this
It is one final question. Mr. Treacy needed time to answer.
Comment on this
I promise I will not come back in.
Comment on this
I asked Senator O'Mahony to conclude after nine minutes. For how long has the Deputy been speaking now? He has been speaking for 13 minutes. I want to be fair to everyone.
Comment on this
At what time does the Minister have to leave?
Comment on this
I will stay for as long as members wish.
Comment on this
We have plenty of time but I want to make sure everyone gets a fair innings.
I want to make one point to Mr. Treacy. I received correspondence, which I presume all members received, stating that the independent directors had been identified, the chairperson was looking at all the financial information and the other members were looking at how this would impact on their role if they took up these roles. Is that fair?
Comment on this
There is another point. The Minister is right that this process should have started a long time ago. If anything is holding it up now, I suppose it is due process, albeit a late due process.
Comment on this
Someone is going to take over the role of chairperson, which is an onerous task. The individual in question has to be sure that he or she is able to perform the role and must also have all the facts. We do not have all the facts. That is the problem.
Deputy O'Brien is next. I will call time after nine minutes.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify one point in the statement made by the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, because I had not heard about it before. I heard that the previous board had to step down before public funding was to be restored. The Minister of State referred to "the previous regime at board and executive levels". Are we now saying there are individuals at executive level with connections to the old regime who have to stand down too before public funding is restored? Have I misread what the Minister of State said?
Comment on this
I do not quite get where the Deputy is coming from.
Comment on this
The Minister of State stated: "I reiterate that no public funding will be provided to the FAI by my Department or Sport Ireland until we see evidence of real reform and a clean break with the previous regime at board and executive levels."
Comment on this
We are looking for a new chief executive without connections to the past.
Comment on this
We are not talking about people at other levels.
Comment on this
I was referring to the chief executive in particular.
Comment on this
We want a new, fresh chief executive who does not have past ties to the organisation.
Comment on this
We are not talking about employees.
Comment on this
No. The great tragedy in this is that there are some excellent employees in the FAI.
Comment on this
I wanted to clarify that because it was unclear.
Comment on this
That is why I referred to not tarring everyone with the one brush. There are people whose jobs are at risk now. They are facing into terrible uncertainty going into Christmas. It is important to state that some excellent people are working in the organisation as well.
Comment on this
For funding to be restored, it is only board members who have no connection to the previous-----
Comment on this
We need a fresh chief executive without connections to the past regime and a clean board that is able to come in an help us. However, there are also many other things that need to happen to get restored.
Comment on this
In terms of personnel, it stops at board level. Is that right?
Comment on this
That is certainly where it needs to start. There may be others but that is certainly-----
Comment on this
If there needs to be others, can the Minister of State specify at what level we are talking about?
Comment on this
It is the chief executive officer in particular for now.
Comment on this
If a new board is put in place with no connections to the old regime, funding will be restored.
Comment on this
No, we cannot say that because there are other things that need to happen. We need to be fully confident, if we are directing money directly to the FAI, that that money will not disappear into a black hole of debt, for example, or it will not go into overdrafts. We need to ensure that public moneys are protected and that is why we have looked for the alternative media to channel the funding to the front line, as we discussed earlier.
Comment on this
I am labouring the point but it is important. We are saying there may be other individuals within the organisation, who are not at board level, who may have connections to the previous regime, who may have to go in order for funding to be restored.
Comment on this
That is a possibility. We are dealing with a hypothetical situation here. At the moment, from what we know now, what we are saying is that we need a new chief executive.
Comment on this
In regard to the Minister, Deputy Ross, and grassroots football, I welcome the announcement today and the clarification by Mr. Treacy that the FAI will remain the employer and there will be no break in employment contracts, which is important. The other aspect is that, obviously, we can do something but we cannot do something for everyone. We have managed to do something for the women's team and we have managed to do something for the development officers. I come at it from a different perspective, as a League of Ireland fan. If the FAI goes into examinership in the morning, or in April, May or June, it is my understanding that the league ceases - it is gone, and there is no League of Ireland. The clubs will remain but they will not have a league to play in and there will not be any European qualification places available because they are given to the governing body and not directly to the clubs.
Have we done any work on possible scenarios? In the eventuality that the FAI had to go into examinership, is it possible to continue the league? If it does not go into examinership and just goes under, does the league automatically collapse? What happens to those qualification places? What happens to any money that may be outstanding to League of Ireland clubs? If it does go into examinership, are penalties imposed on the FAI in terms of qualification places for European competitions which will be passed on to League of Ireland clubs? Have we done any analysis on what the impact on the League of Ireland will be? While I agree grassroots football is critical and we should be doing everything to protect it, there are many jobs within League of Ireland clubs which could potentially be at risk if the FAI went under.
Comment on this
We have not done any detailed analysis on that whatsoever. When we met the FAI on Monday night, Grant Thornton was there as well and it had done some work on the consequences of examinership. I do not know how far it had gone but I asked Grant Thornton to share it with us, and it said it will share it with us in the next week or so. I would be happy to let the Deputy know the result of that. My guess is that if the FAI goes, the League of Ireland goes the same way. I think that is absolutely inevitable but it is something which we would have on the agenda for our meeting with UEFA as well because it would have implications for it too. We are going to, obviously, do some serious analysis of the consequences of examinership and liquidation, but that is what we want to avoid at all costs, of course. We do not want to see, above all, grassroots football and League of Ireland football suffering as a result of what happened.
Comment on this
I agree we all want to avoid that but we also have to prepare for that eventuality being a possibility as well.
Comment on this
Yes. Those preparations will take place and are taking place, and Grant Thornton said it would be looking at the prospect of examinership for the FAI, which it says it will share with us. I will share it with the Deputy when we get it.
Comment on this
In terms of the Minister's discussions with the FAI and its request for an €18 million bailout, did it offer anything in exchange for that?
Comment on this
There was vague talk about its assets but we did not go into any detail. To be honest, once its representatives mentioned the figure, we made it absolutely clear to them they were not going to get a bailout, they were not going to get funding and that KOSI had said they were not going to get funding, and that was it. Going further with that discussion would have been pointless.
Comment on this
Was there any discussion around where they are in terms of their efforts to restructure their finances?
Comment on this
I am trying to recall. Not in any great detail. We realised they are very heavily indebted to the banks at this stage. When someone comes looking for a bailout, that is the only card they really have to play. The bottom line was they told us the situation was pretty dire and there is no point in going into detail at that stage if that is the starting point.
Comment on this
Without that €18 million, are they viable?
Comment on this
I cannot make a judgment on that. I think they are currently a going concern but their situation is precarious.
Comment on this
Do do we know from the Minister's discussions whether they have eaten into any future revenue? I am seeing reports that UEFA was financing them and giving them a hand here, there and everywhere, and some reports suggest they have got advances on television money and future revenues. Do we know if that is true or are there any discussions around that? Obviously, we know what the accounts were because they have published them but are there any discussions on future revenue?
Comment on this
That is part of their negotiations with UEFA. We know that some revenues from the future have been forwarded to the FAI in 2019, so that has happened.
Comment on this
Do we know how much or to what extent? Obviously, that impacts on its ability to trade.
Comment on this
The figure is around €6 million, if my memory is right. While I could be wrong, I think it is in that vicinity.
Comment on this
Did Mr. Treacy say the full board of Sport Ireland has not met with the FAI since 2015?
Comment on this
Let me put it this way. The board meets ten times a year. We bring in NGBs maybe five or six times a year and it rotates around. The last time the FAI came in was 2015 and it made a presentation to the full board.
Comment on this
I think it was 2015. I am not absolutely sure but it is around that period. Our process and procedure is to invite presentations from governing bodies, so we would have had in the FAI, the IRFU, the GAA, Cricket Ireland, Athletics Ireland, Rowing Ireland and so on. It is a rotation thing to allow them to make a presentation to the board and then, on separate occasions, a special grant may be required where we would require the board to meet.
Comment on this
I would add one piece to that. Last year, 2018, we invited them in twice but they were not able to come.
Comment on this
I would find it extraordinary that the board of Sport Ireland did not meet the board of the FAI, given everything that had happened.
Comment on this
That is an important clarification
Comment on this
Not only are they refusing to appear before Oireachtas committees, they even refused on two occasions to meet with the board of Sport Ireland last year.
Comment on this
We would all agree that what was really unfortunate, when the board changed, was that some members remained.
That has caused confusion and postponed the recovery that should have happened through a transitional arrangement. In his opening statement the Minister said that the FAI is not fit to handle public funds. That was the finding of the KOSI audit. It acknowledged that some steps had been taken to address the shortcomings but there was a steep mountain to climb before funding could be reinstated to the FAI. I accept that we cannot see the KOSI report and I am not looking for it, but for the recovery to happen we need to know what the shortcomings are. Surely it will be possible to get that. Otherwise we will not be able to map out a route to recovery for the FAI. Perhaps Sport Ireland and the Minister will address that. That finding is a big statement. We are trying to work in the dark here. Is it possible to get that?
Comment on this
It was certainly my intention that it should be released and published in full. That was my objective. When trying to find a way of doing that, and that is still my intention, I met a brick wall from the Garda, the Attorney General and others. The Deputy understands the reasons, and I will not waste the committee's time by going into it. If I say anything about the reasons, I could tread into very dangerous territory. There could be some way of looking at publishing some sort of redacted summary of what is going on here. That is only a possibility. I do not under any circumstances want to give any hope. That is as far as I can go.
Comment on this
This is important. I will not promise that but it is an avenue which I will pursue. It is important that as much information as possible can come out without prejudicing legal proceedings. The Deputy is right about that. I cannot allow those proceedings to be prejudiced. There are probably two reasons KOSI said the FAI is unfit for purpose. The first pertains to corporate governance and the second to the financials. The Deputy will have to accept my bona fides on this. KOSI stated that the FAI should not be getting public funds.
Comment on this
We know that the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement and the Garda are involved. We accept that. They have to do their jobs and that is fine. However, we need a football association. Given the solvency issues and so on, whether it should be the FAI is another matter. We need a resolution so that we have a football association in place. We need to know what we need to do to achieve that.
Comment on this
I have a bunch of questions to put.
Comment on this
I may be able to clarify. The KOSI audit is very detailed. The Institute of Public Administration, IPA, put the governance reform agenda into effect. The implementation of those recommendations will address a lot of the structural issues covered in the KOSI report.
Comment on this
I have heard this point made throughout this process. We thought we could release this report but our advice said otherwise due to its nature and content. So much so that when we called a special meeting of the board of Sport Ireland, members had an hour to read the report and then had to hand it back. I do not have a copy of the report. I wish to clarify that. We did not want information to get out inadvertently and prejudice an investigation.
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy is not suffering from any time penalty here. Are structural changes other than the 76 recommendations to be made? We have been told that the IPA report does not contain all the recommendations. I think Deputy Murphy is asking how the process can be moved forward, forgetting the names of individuals.
Comment on this
There is more in the KOSI report. An implementation group has been set up between Sport Ireland and the FAI and is pursuing the KOSI recommendations.
Comment on this
Can anything be made public?
Comment on this
No. I am in a similar position to Mr. Mulvey in that I got a full briefing on the report. I do not have a copy either and I did not take one. That is how serious this matter is.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is making it very clear, but whatever-----
Comment on this
I know it is frustrating for everybody. We want the public to know all the relevant details, but for obvious reasons it is in the overall public interest that we tread very carefully when talking about any of the contents of the report. We all want as much information as possible to be public. The committee must understand that this is particularly difficult and it is dangerous even to talk about specific issues.
Comment on this
What is in public view is what has gone on and was an open secret for years. It is very unsatisfactory, to put it mildly. We understand that. We know there is a transition period, but there is also a requirement for a solution. Most of us want to contribute to that solution. It is very frustrating that we cannot see a pathway. We cannot wait until the ODCE and the Garda complete their work because the FAI has huge monthly outlays. Will it be able to meet them? Was there any indication that that would be an issue? Are there issues in relation to the staff, beyond the staff involved in promoting football through the local authorities?
Comment on this
As I said in my opening statement, we are meeting the staff this evening specifically to hear their concerns.
Comment on this
We know what their concerns are. Their concerns are whether they will be paid and whether they will still have jobs. It is not very obvious where the income for that will come from every month. That is part of this transition too. Either the organisation is solvent or it is not. Other than meeting the unions, is a clear pathway available to the Department? Can the Minister see anything in the business case to indicate that the organisation's normal expenses can be paid?
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, the indications are that the situation is very grave. We are getting shocks from the FAI on a weekly basis, particularly with regard to its financials. That is why we are meeting all stakeholders who want to meet us. We will continue to do that. That is why we are also meeting UEFA. Every single stakeholder will be met. Every point of view will be taken into account. We are in a very fast-moving crisis and we are doing everything we can to meet those who are concerned, particularly the staff who at this point are very concerned about their futures.
Comment on this
Has the Minister considered meeting FIFA? That organisation has put normalisation committees in place in other jurisdictions. UEFA clearly has an issue with political interference. Both organisations do. Are there restrictions on what resolutions are available?
Comment on this
I would have no hesitation at all in meeting FIFA. We are meeting UEFA first but would be perfectly happy to meet FIFA. I believe that FIFA also wants to meet us. I have had no recent indications of worries about us infringing the independence or anything like that. It is anxious to meet us because of the gravity of the situation.
Comment on this
On the total debt, when FIFA representatives spoke with the Department about the restructuring requirements, were they using the 2018 accounts or a higher figure than that? There is an expectation that it will be closer to €75 million or €80 million. What is the extent of FIFA's requirements with regard to restructuring? Did it give a figure?
Comment on this
The €55 million liabilities figure is in the public domain but on top of that there is also funding owed to UEFA through loans. The total figure is closer to €70 million when the UEFA funding that was lent to the FAI is factored in.
Comment on this
Right. I imagine that the new directors and the new CEO will want to come in and have a full stop at the end of 2019. We should see the totality of the debts that require to be restructured. It is important that we have a full stop there so the new board can proceed. It is essential that they take ownership of the resolution also.
Comment on this
That is why it is critically important to get the new independent directors in place as soon as possible, along with a new independent CEO. The situation is very grave and the figures are pretty stark.
Comment on this
Can I ask about the stadium-----
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy has one minute remaining. We will take Deputy Coppinger next, with members' agreement, and I propose to suspend for ten minutes after that. Is that reasonable? I cannot see us finishing before 2 p.m.
Comment on this
I just want to clarify that the figure is €62 million.
Comment on this
Okay. Is the stake in the stadium an asset that is the FAI's to sell? Are covenants in place or has that been explored? If not, will the Department explore that?