Governance and Funding of Football Association of Ireland: Discussion
Contributions 238–480 of 727. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
I will take that question. Yes, it is free to sell its share in it. The FAI owns 42.5% of the Aviva stadium. The Irish Rugby Football Union, IRFU, owns 57.5% of it. They are joint owners of New Stadium DAC, which owns the asset. The FAI is free to sell its share but can only sell with the agreement of the Minister. Yes, it is free to sell it. Having said that, the Minister has first charge on the asset. There is a deed of covenant and charge on it that protects the Minister's interest, which was the significant investment that was made by the Government initially.
Comment on this
What has it been valued at?
Comment on this
It has not been valued. The stadium cost €460 million to build at the time. The Government's contribution was €191 million over seven years from 2004 to 2010, but it has not been valued in today's value.
Comment on this
Is there any consideration of additional State money being made available for soccer, leaving aside not administering funding through the FAI? Are any funds being looked at, even as a transition arrangement?
Comment on this
As I have said, straight out, we are not going to bail out the FAI.
Comment on this
No, I am not looking for that.
Comment on this
That is absolutely out of the question.
Comment on this
I am not looking for that.
Comment on this
It is always our ambition to secure more money for sport, which we have done over a period of time.
Comment on this
But is there anything specific?
Comment on this
There is no specific move being made about that at the moment but every year it is our ambition to increase the amount of money given to soccer specifically.
Comment on this
I shall now turn to oversight, Sport Ireland, and the reliance on external auditors. The same auditors were used for a long time for this entity, which in itself is a lesson. Is Sport Ireland likely to change its governance arrangements to seek rotation after a reasonable period of time as an extra safeguard?
Comment on this
The Deputy is right and that can be done. Sport Ireland has used different auditors to audit the FAI and we rotate our own auditors on a regular basis. It is good practice to do that. This is something we certainly could put in place very easily.
Comment on this
I want to clarify just one point. Reference was made to the stadium and the Minister having first lien on the FAI interest in it. If the company became insolvent or went into liquidation, would it mean that the Government or the Minister would then become the owner of that asset or would it be the creditors? Who would get that asset?
Comment on this
New Stadium is a designated activity company that is part-owned by the IRFU and part-owned by the FAI. In the event the company became insolvent, the banks could move on the asset. The Minister and the Government, however, do have first charge on the asset if it is realised.
Comment on this
So what would that mean? Would the Government then own the asset if it has a €191 million stake in it?
Comment on this
It would depend on how it played out. If, for example, the bank was happy enough to move in on the asset and hold it, then the bank would become the part shareholder instead of the FAI. If the bank held on to the asset, which it could do, the bank would simply replace the FAI as the shareholder. Whether or not they wished to sell it, that can only be sold with the permission of the Minister. The Minister cannot unreasonably withhold permission to sell it, but it could be sold, and whether or not the Government would be interested in buying it would depend on circumstances.
Comment on this
If it was sold it could mean that any private speculating company could buy in and take ownership of it. The Minister could not reasonably withhold his consent, and nobody would want that either.
Comment on this
It does have to stay in sporting use. There is an agreement from the owners that it will stay in sporting use for 30 years from 2010. It has to continue to be a sporting facility until 2040. Any prospective buyer would need to be very mindful of that fact.
Comment on this
This is all part of the Department's considerations in the model of activity it is studying.
Comment on this
It is. It only really works if it is owned by national governing bodies for sport. The stadium has a significant annual cost. It raises revenue from concerts and conferences and so on, but the gap must be filled by the two national governing bodies. This is filled through a licence for each of the national governing bodies to hold a number of fixtures each year. Based on the revenue raised from those fixtures, they are able to fill that gap. It is a not-for-profit company but it does wash its face as there is a little bit of a surplus that goes into a sinking fund. It really only works by being owned by the two national governing bodies and by being used for sport.
Comment on this
I will start with questions to Sport Ireland. When this series of committee meetings started out, in the earlier meetings we had, Sport Ireland was still funding the FAI. That stopped. Today Sport Ireland has announced a huge change in the terms for the allocation of grants. All national governing bodies must provide full details of the remuneration package of their CEOs. Why was this not done a long time ago? This is being done without any difficulty now. It did not require a change in legislation. It just required Sport Ireland to change its terms and conditions. I ask this because surely Sport Ireland and successive Ministers for sport must have seen the caviar culture that was going on at the top of the FAI.
It was at a time when birthday parties and rent were paid for. Prawn cocktail would not even make it onto the menu, by the sounds of it, yet the public was part-financing the organisation. Why did it take so long for the powers that be to react?
Comment on this
The matter came to light on the St. Patrick's Day weekend this year. In April, two weeks later, Sport Ireland suspended funding to the FAI. The terms and conditions of grant aid are reviewed in consultation with the governing bodies of sport. When we rewrite our terms and conditions, we contact the governing bodies, tell them what we are doing and secure their consent. We conducted the KOSI audit with the consent of the FAI. We did not have the power to do it-----
Comment on this
Mr. Treacy is saying the FAI would not have consented previously.
Comment on this
Yes. In respect of what we need to do about the issue, it has definitely upped the game in the round.
Comment on this
The other striking aspect of Mr. Treacy's statement was when he spoke about the auditors, and undeclared transactions of serious concern and unrecorded liabilities. What should happen with the auditors in that regard?
Comment on this
Dealing with the auditors who undertook that the case is a matter for the FAI. The Minister has also written to them.
Comment on this
I would have thought it was a matter for the State.
I turn to women's football. Mr. Treacy stated the grant of €195,000 for women's football will now be paid through a private company, BDO. I knew nothing about BDO before the meeting but researched it. Its website states that it advises a number of corporate and personal clients, Irish and multinational, on their tax planning strategies, from both a domestic and international perspective. It seems like a strange organisation to disperse sports funds on behalf of the taxpayer. How much is BDO paid for the role? Are there no women in the sport who could be asked to take on the role? Are there no civil servants who could do it? It seems like an effective further privatisation, whereas our difficulty has been in having private organisations such as the FAI answer to the public.
Comment on this
BDO is an auditing company. It has a good reputation and has undertaken to do this for us. It-----
Comment on this
How much is it paid?
Comment on this
That is a matter between BDO and the FAI. I do not know exactly what it is but it is not a substantial sum.
Comment on this
Who pays BDO the sum?
Comment on this
It seems like a further expense added to the grant of €195,000, when-----
Comment on this
We were trying to find a solution and BDO was a solution.
Comment on this
I turn to the Minister, who met the FAI the other night. He stated not a cent will be given to the FAI as yet, and I am sure everybody would agree with that. There is no way the public should funnel money into the FAI at present because it would end up going to the banks. Is the FAI sustainable as an organisation without a bailout or will it go bust? What liabilities are due, and when, that could tip the FAI into administration?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy that a bailout is out of the question, and we will not yield in that regard. Many players are involved, including UEFA, the FAI and Sport Ireland. We met the FAI at its request in order that it could outline the gravity of the circumstances. It has not in any way accepted there is some sort of Doomsday scenario. It came to us to warn us of how bad it was, give us some stark figures and determine whether any money was available from the State. My guess is it will now have to come up with a new plan, which may or may not be viable, but it will depend on the banks, which will have to decide whether they will give a further extension. UEFA is also funding it. That is where the solution will lie.
If the independent directors are appointed, I expect there will be a new atmosphere in respect of the issue. That they are not in place - I do not point the finger at anybody - means there is a blockage. The appointment of the independent directors will release a dynamic that will be quickly followed by a process to appoint an independent chief executive and an independent chair, which is what we sought.
Comment on this
The Minister made that point earlier and my time is limited. He has lately posed as something of a hero of Irish football.
Comment on this
Approximately 170,000 people participate in soccer every week, yet the funding it receives does not compare with that for other sports. It receives €2.9 million, despite almost 200,000 people playing. Greyhound racing receives €16 million, while white-water rafting will receive €22 million from the taxpayer through Dublin City Council. The allocation to soccer, however, has been low. Nobody suggests the FAI should be allowed to carry on in its practices, but people want to be assured that support will continue for grassroots football, such as the League of Ireland and people who play the sport every day. It is critical, not least for obesity levels and so on.
The Minister will meet SIPTU later. The trade union and the workers were whistleblowers in respect of what was happening at the FAI for a long time. In April, I read an article in which Mr. Conway contradicted SIPTU and stated its claims that the company was bankrupt were unfounded. At that time, therefore, the workers were aware of the state of the accounts but were publicly cut across by leading people at the FAI. Will the State guarantee job security for the workers, who took pay cuts while their bosses enjoyed themselves, and will their jobs be safeguarded in the interest of providing ongoing development of the sport?
Has the Schoolboys Football Association of Ireland, SFAI, yet accounted for the €50,000 it spent to hire a corporate box at the Aviva Stadium? Was that public money and, if so, is it the case that such an organisation can move money from one place to another before receiving it again? Hiring a corporate box for schoolboy football is the most bizarre financial transaction one could imagine.
Comment on this
I will take the funding question. The youth field sports programme is funding we give to the FAI, and similar sums are given to the Irish Rugby Football Union and the GAA. Such organisations have relatively large incomes compared with those of other national governing bodies of sport, but it is not the only funding we give them. In 2018, for example, which was the most recent round, soccer clubs throughout the country benefited from the sports capital programme to the tune of €6.5 million, while in the 2017 round, the figure was just over €7 million.
That funding is hugely beneficial to the sports in question and it is not counted in terms of the core funding that is administered through Sport Ireland. Those sports, just by virtue of their size, get a proportionately larger amount of the overall sports capital budget. Of the €57 million allocation under the most recent round, they received €6.5 million. That is considerable, amounting to roughly €1 out of every €8 that was administered. The capital grants do reflect the size of the sports more than the current allocation, the reason being that there is strong income for those sports on the current side which other national bodies do not have. In 2017, the capital allocation of €7 million to the sports in question again represented approximately one eighth of the funding that was given nationally through the sports capital programme.
Comment on this
However, all of those sports have other sources of funding as well. For example-----
Comment on this
They are eligible to apply for sports capital funding. However, because other sports are not as widespread and are not represented in every community as the three main field sports are, the field sports tend to get more funding. Another factor is the nature of the sports in terms of pitch maintenance and the requirements for-----
Comment on this
The Minister of State has one minute left to answer Deputy Coppinger's questions, after which I must call Senator Ó Céidigh.
Comment on this
Under the national sports policy, which we launched in July last year, we committed to double funding for sport between 2018 and 2027 and to treble high-performance funding. We are on track to achieve that and it will benefit all sports. There have been substantial increases in funding for sport in the past two budgets and that is reaching all sports. We have 67 national governing bodies, if I recall correctly, and we are trying to benefit everybody. As I said, there are sports which are less popular and not in every community, and we are trying to give prominence to and encourage them. These sports do not have the funding opportunities that are available to the larger sports and we must be mindful of their needs.
Comment on this
An example that comes to my mind is the Minister's cheerleading of a grant of €130,000 to a private rugby school. Not many people will benefit from that. The reality is that soccer and football are the most popular sports in the country but soccer does not get the level of State support that many other sports do.
Comment on this
As someone who plays both soccer and football, including all summer with my football club, I am a passionate supporter of both sports. I certainly feel there is full fairness in the system of allocations for sports capital and across the board. Those allocations reflect the popularity of the sports but are also responsive to the needs of communities. If we look at the most recent round of sports capital funding, it is clear to anybody who has analysed the figures that we very much try to target disadvantaged communities. Of the €57 million that was allocated recently, €19 million went to disadvantaged communities and €4.5 million was given to what are considered affluent communities, according to the Pobal deprivation index. The funding is heavily stacked towards disadvantaged communities, and that is very positive.
Comment on this
With all due respect to the Minister of State, that is absolute rubbish.
Comment on this
What part of the facts I have outlined can the Deputy correct? I have given the figures.
Comment on this
I will tell the Minister of State if he stops shouting over me.
Comment on this
The Deputy has said something is rubbish when I have given her the facts. How is it rubbish?
Comment on this
I will tell the Minister of State if he will let the sound of other voices occasionally-----
Comment on this
This is the mantra the Deputy is always spouting, but I have given the facts.
Comment on this
RTÉ did an exposé, for example-----
Comment on this
If one looks at RTÉ's exposé, it did not consider all the figures.
Comment on this
I know that because I heard the Minister of State being interviewed.
Comment on this
Yet the Deputy is quoting a flawed exposé.
Comment on this
The Minister of State likes the sound of his voice. Will he not listen to one sentence from me?
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy, through the Chair, to continue, please.
Comment on this
When I was on Fingal County Council, it was well documented that more middle class areas got more sports grants, and that continues to be the case. I am making this point without derailing the whole discussion. It would be helpful if I could get answers to the other questions asked.
Comment on this
Under the latest sports capital programme, €1 in every €3 went to disadvantaged areas, or €19 million out of €57 million. It is a long time since Deputy Coppinger was on Fingal County Council.
Comment on this
May I have an answer regarding the SFAI's hiring of a corporate box at the Aviva Stadium?
Comment on this
We will have a second round of responses. I remind colleagues that Senator Ó Céidigh is under time pressure.
Comment on this
The SFAI does not receive any Sport Ireland funding.
Comment on this
Where did it get the money from for the corporate box?
Comment on this
I thank the Chairman for letting me in before the break. He will recall that I sent him a letter concerning this meeting. I will be brief as colleagues have asked a lot of good questions. Having audited its accounts, Deloitte announced that the FAI is effectively bust. Let us call a spade a spade. Before indicating its intention to resign as auditor, Deloitte restated the 2017 accounts from approximately €2.7 million of a profit to a loss of €2.7 million, which is a shift of about €5.5 million. I have some sympathy and understanding for Sport Ireland and the challenges it faces because, it seems, it bases its review, to a large degree, on independent audited accounts. Having said that, I have the Sport Ireland Act 2015, to which several speakers referred, in front of me, and I take issue with one or two of the points Mr. Treacy made in that regard.
Section 11 of the Act, which sets out the criteria, terms and conditions of assistance, states, in subsection (3)(a), that Sport Ireland may "request any person or body applying for or receiving assistance under section 8(4)(a) to supply Sport Ireland with information in such form and at such time as it may require". This means that Sport Ireland has absolute flexibility in terms of how deep it wants to dive. I have the transcript of the meeting where I asked whether Sport Ireland had identified any red flags in this regard, in response to which Mr. Treacy did not highlight any concerns. To me, a red flag was raised when Deputy Jonathan O'Brien or Deputy MacSharry - I am not sure which of them it was - asked whether there had been a meeting with the board of the FAI. The answer given was that there was one such meeting in 2015 and there were two further occasions on which members of the board were invited in by Sport Ireland but did not show up. Did they give a reason for not showing up? Subsequent to their not showing up, Sport Ireland still gave the FAI €2.9 million in funding in January or February of this year. Will Mr. Treacy comment on that?
Comment on this
The Senator referred to the 2015 Act. In April of this year, we got legal advice regarding our powers under the legislation. Section 11 refers to information which Sport Ireland reasonably determines is necessary for the proper carrying out of its functions. Those functions include matters relating to high-performance participation, our performance and how we carry out our functions, and how the national governing bodies support us in our role. I will read out the legal advice we received.
Comment on this
It is one short paragraph, as follows:
Dealing briefly with the relevant provisions of the Act, there is no provision of the Act that would give Sport Ireland statutory authority to audit or inspect the books and records of a body in receipt of Sport Ireland funding. Section 11(3) of the Act allows Sport Ireland to request information from a body in receipt of assistance and withhold or refuse assistance if that information is not forthcoming, but this does not amount to the right to audit such a body. Accordingly, Sport Ireland will need to rely on the terms of the application grant arrangements, in particular the terms and conditions mentioned above, in respect of such audits.
The terms and conditions are drawn up in consultation with the organisations and we get them to agree to those terms.
Comment on this
Deputy Coppinger referred to Mr. Treacy's indication in his opening statement that organisations are being asked to meet some extra criteria. Surely Sport Ireland could have put that requirement in place from day one and that would have been well within the legislation? I am repeating Deputy Coppinger's question. I am not trying to hang anyone out to dry here.
Comment on this
May I just say that we would have been-----
Comment on this
Section 11 provides that Sport Ireland may demand a refund of any financial assistance provided. Has Sport Ireland done that or thought about doing it?
Comment on this
An audit certificate and a tax clearance certificate are very powerful in regard to the provision of funding by any Government agency. They are a pretty standard requirement in the vast majority of cases. I am not trying to get at Sport Ireland.
I believe that Sports Ireland have and had the power and authority to investigate this in far greater detail before now. In questions to the Minister-----
Comment on this
We do not have investigative powers within the Act. We are not a regulatory agency. We are a sports promotion agency, which works in partnership with other governing bodies. That is the ethos of Sport Ireland as to its functions. If one looks at these functions, these relate to participation, high-performance, anti-doping and codes of conduct. There was an opportunity in 2015 to make Sport Ireland a regulatory agency but that would have been the wrong thing to do. We do not want to be a regulatory agency but want to be here to work in partnership with and to support the organisations. I have made the point in here previously that we took on an audit function where, in many other areas involving grant aid, such functions have not been taken on. We took it upon ourselves that if were giving 50% of funding to an organisation, we would do a full audit. We took a view which was shared by others, that if one is not providing a huge amount of funding to an organisation - 5% was the figure used by the FAI - and we tried and wanted to push the boat out. We were rebuffed and pushed back because we did not have the power to do that.
Comment on this
We are splitting hairs in relation to regulation and non-regulation. It is standard practice in the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport, when I was involved in aviation, when one was tendering for a contract. Enterprise Ireland, Údarás na Gaeltachta, Fáilte Ireland and Bord Iascaigh Mhara do the same. One has to prepare three years of projections, to be sure of this funding or the grant-aiding authority must be comfortable that this organisation is going to be here in a year, two or three years' time. This is standard practice in the Department from my own personal experience, and rightly so. I believe there were flags there in respect of the FAI.
I have asked the Minister about this point previously in the Seanad and one of my colleagues also has mentioned it, namely, the €16.8 million allocated for greyhounds in this year's budget a month or six weeks ago. I cannot for the life of me understand why the FAI is getting €2.8 million or whatever the figure is. The Minister told me, when we discussed at the time, that this money comes out of the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine's funding. Would the Minister speak to his colleague, the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Marine, to ascertain whether this funding could come under his Department's aegis - because a significant amount of the whole greyhound sector comes under his Department - and that some form of re-balancing would take place?
Comment on this
The Senator has asked a good question there. I am not entirely sure how to answer it, which is probably the definition of a good question. I have made my personal views on the greyhound issue very plain but I am a member of the Cabinet and am obviously bound by Cabinet solidarity.
Comment on this
With the solidarity bit now, is that a Freudian slip?
Comment on this
I will deal with Deputy Coppinger in a few minutes.
I made my personal views plain on this. I do not know how much I can or should say about that here. It is well known that I have been sympathetic with the greyhound industry and I am not sympathetic with the situation that money should be given to it in the way that it is at the moment. The Cabinet has made a decision and I am bound by it as a member of the Cabinet I will support it. There may be a bit of resistance to me taking over a position there, which may involve a lot of stress. If the Senator wishes, I will ask the Minister, Deputy Creed, if I can take over his Department in-----
Comment on this
In fairness, Minister, I think there is more than greyhounds involved in his Department.
Comment on this
That is right. I could see if I can take over that part of his responsibility but I believe that would be resisted. There is a problem there as to why the industry is given quite so much when there is so much wrong with it. That is my view, which I say quite openly.
Comment on this
My two agencies have suspended funding to promote the industry.
Comment on this
I appreciate the work that the Minister, Mr. Spratt and his team have done in bypassing the FAI to provide funding to the grassroots. I have questions on that point. The funding is being looked at through the Grant Thornton accountancy firm, I believe, to look at supporting development officers. What about the rest of the staff who are not development officers? Will their salaries be supported as well or is this support be restricted to development officers, of whom there are approximately 60 around the country.
Comment on this
This is just part of programmes that are being supported by us. The Senator is asking the big question as to what is going to happen and are there going to be cuts. That is something the FAI is going to have to address very shortly.
Comment on this
I am asking specifically if the funding that the Minister is structuring in a different direction to the grassroots will only pay the salaries of the development officers or are more staff members included in that funding?
Comment on this
No, it is just for development officers.
Comment on this
It is for development officers only, who are roughly 60 or 70 in number.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. I have one last question on that point. This is how it is hitting grassroots. There is a small soccer club in north Galway, Colemanstown United FC, which was the overall national FAI club winner of the year this year. It received €5,000 in prizes, which was huge money for it. That money and more has been spent on development and the club now has bank overdrafts. Is there any way that the club can get the prize money it won or is the Minister aware of anything like that in this process?
Comment on this
I am aware of that issue. Someone from that club, a lady whose name I cannot remember just now, has been touch with me. Representations are in train. This club is due to receive the €5,000.
Comment on this
This is just one example. That is great to hear and I thank the Minister.
Comment on this
I see the problem but I do not want to spark off hundreds of clubs coming around saying that they are owed money.
Comment on this
Absolutely.
Finally, we are all around the table together on this point. What happened in the past should never have happened. The Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement, ODCE, the Garda and others are looking into that and a process is being gone through. I am asking that we all now consider looking at a transition now, while asking how we can go to the future but learning from the past. On a transition, I am asking that the Minister, Sport Ireland and the Department consider suggesting to the FAI that a transition process and an interim board be put in place. The problem with new directors coming in is that when they come in to this role, he or she could be personally responsible for the debts in this the past. Who, in fairness, will do that? If I was advising somebody, I would suggest that they be very careful in this regard because their house could be on the line. A new structure should be created for transition in order that good people are placed on the board. They can then appoint an independent CEO and get professional advice from one of the professional organisations to understand how to restructure in a professional manner. This is what is needed because there appears to be no transition, plan or structure and we are going headless into this. A suggestion like this has a good chance of working. I believe there is a great future for the FAI and out of this dust, a very good soccer structure will emerge in Ireland.
Comment on this
I will address Senator Ó Céidigh's point by saying that if the independent board members are appointed, they could consider a structure along the lines he has suggested. The key point, among a lot of others, is to get these independent board members on board first in order that they can set this structure up. Nobody else is going to do that.
Comment on this
These new members will be part of the board as well, but will be in a minority on the board.
Comment on this
All of the other board members, while none of them have been on the board before, are members of the association and have a lot of knowledge. I believe Senator Ó Céidigh, however, is referring to professional skills here-----
Comment on this
I am talking about professional skills.
Comment on this
Exactly. I am also talking about a structure that is outside of a company that is limited by guarantee.
It is only then they are going to get people who are willing to go on that board. Right now, if people go on that board, they could be personally liable for debts if the company is insolvent. I thank the Chairman for allowing me in.
Comment on this
Again, I would like to emphasise, as someone who has come from a small club myself, that I know how important even relatively small figures are in terms of funding. That is why I want to emphasise to the committee that it has been incorrectly reported in various media that we are not continuing grants to soccer. We are continuing sports capital grants to individual clubs around the country. We have allocated a huge amount in the most recent round. We will be opening it up again in a couple of months and all of those clubs will be eligible to apply again. We are not going to see a situation where the small clubs, the volunteers and the players at grassroots level are being negatively impacted upon. What we are doing is that we are not providing the sports capital that has been allocated to the FAI itself. We are not making that available for drawdown, but it is only a relatively small amount overall. All of those clubs throughout the country are eligible to come back in again for sports capital, and those that have been allocated funding are eligible to draw down that funding as normal.
Comment on this
That is great. I thank the Minister of State for clarifying that. It is very important.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses for coming in. It is hard to believe that, since last March, we would have arrived at this situation. I have a long involvement in junior soccer. I was treasurer of the Roscommon district league back in the 1980s, I was secretary of my local soccer club, I ran a double-decker bus to Germany in 1988 and I was at a celebration of junior football in Sligo County Council last Monday. I know from members and playing members on the ground that they are absolutely disgusted at what has happened, and I can only reflect that back. We are trying to get to the end of this but it is hard to imagine we could have ended up where we are.
I am disappointed at the FAI's absence. Its representatives should have come in here today to answer questions and I hope we will have them here in the future.
I wish to ask a few questions. There was a joke many years ago. If one asked a doctor what two plus two was, the doctor would have said four. If one asked a dentist what three plus three was, the dentist would have said six. If one asked an accountant what four plus four was, the accountant would ask, "What do you want it to be?" It seems that Deloitte has many questions to answer as well. It is difficult to believe that it signed off on the books. Mr. Treacy is right, in that we rely on professional auditors to do the right job. I do not know whether it is in order, but can the committee invite the accountants?
Comment on this
We discussed that at our last meeting. The advice we have received through our clerk is that we have no role in respect of the auditors or accountants. I appreciate that the Senator might not have been present at the time, but I raised the matter at the meeting. I contacted the Irish Auditing and Accounting Supervisory Authority, IAASA, and made a written submission to it asking it to examine all aspects of the Deloitte audit. I received an acknowledgement, which I circulated to members. I wrote to the authority as a Deputy, but it replied to me as Chairman of the committee. Everyone has a copy of it, and it might be helpful for the Senator.
Comment on this
The Minister stated: "While I have been advised that it would be unlawful to share the full details of the KOSI auditors’ findings, [which we understand] I can confirm that their opinion is that the FAI is not fit to handle public funds." He cannot say more, but that is probably the most damning statement made today. My heart goes out to the 200 staff and their families who are caught up in this bad situation, which is not of their making. I hope that what the Minister is doing will help to protect them and others in the FAI who are innocent of any wrong-doing.
We speak about an all-Ireland soccer team. Since the time I grew up, we have been asking why the lads in the Irish Football Association, IFA, do not fold up their tent and join an all-Ireland soccer team, but what would the IFA have to do with the FAI now? This situation has put back an all-Ireland soccer team years. If we want to be honest, we have to resolve what is happening in the FAI.
The FAI is a toxic brand. As many brands have done, is it time for a name change? That is a matter for the FAI, but if the State is giving it funding, perhaps it needs to start afresh and change its name to, for example, "Soccer Ireland". Given what has happened over the past two years, it needs to reflect on a name change. We need to start from scratch.
At our first meeting on this matter approximately six months ago, I stated that the FAI was like "Goodfellas". Look at UEFA. It is the governing body and Mr. John Delaney had a powerful executive role there. UEFA has questions to answer as well. What is it doing and what has it done? Can the committee ask representatives of UEFA to attend a meeting? The Minister, the Minister of State, their officials and Sport Ireland have done excellent work trying to uncover facts and be helpful, but the FAI's governing body is UEFA and it should come clean about what is happening. It should appear before us to explain what it will do.
Comment on this
On the comments relating to UEFA, we are due to meet it shortly and the Senator has raised many of the questions that we will be asking.
The image of the FAI and Irish soccer is damaged, although I hope not irreparably. I am conscious of the fact that Irish soccer's image must improve if it is to get out of this situation, given the issue of acquiring sponsorships and other necessary elements. For example, the Olympic Federation of Ireland rebranded, having formerly been the Olympic Council of Ireland. That may be a template.
I agree with the Senator that the issues are grave. For a long time, he has been supportive of the concept of an all-island body. That is a matter for both governing bodies, though, and is not for the Government to comment on.
Comment on this
I will reiterate that remark. Senator Feighan's contribution was useful in several ways. The accountants have questions to answer. I do not know whether this is the right forum for that, but it seems somewhat absurd for Sport Ireland and, by extension, the State to depend on the accounts only for it to turn out that they have to be restated. That makes much of the accountants' work redundant. They have questions to answer, but whether they appear before the committee is up to themselves rather than the committee. It would be welcome if they appeared to explain what happened.
I am ad idem with the Senator on an all-island soccer team. I would love to see that. It has probably been set back as a result of this situation. As the Senator will be aware, it was meeting other obstacles, but I suspect the IFA would be less inclined to get involved with an organisation that the Senator described as having a toxic brand. It will give those who do not want an all-island soccer team for other reasons, which I do not accept, an excuse for not getting involved, which is a great pity. It is another setback.
UEFA is a key player in this matter, and as the Minister of State alluded to, we will meet it on 14 January. I believe that is the date set at the moment. We will look to talk to UEFA in as constructive a way as possible about what can be done to save Irish football.
Comment on this
Regarding the Senator's comments, I hope that we do not compromise our national anthem. It would be like athletes from Russia going to Tokyo next year with no flag flying over them.
I am seen as someone who puts up his hand for being offside. I do not have to use the VAR system.
Comment on this
Floodlight failure, match postponed.
Comment on this
We have come a long way in the past few months. When I saw the accounts, I went to a professional accountant to be sure. So much has gone off track with the financial stability of what is a large national association. That said, I would not be in favour of dismantling the association. As happened with the Olympic Council of Ireland, perhaps a name change might be a move in the right direction.
I am delighted that the Minister met some representatives of the FAI last week, but I wish to ask him about people producing and seeing reports. In fairness to Sport Ireland, the KOSI report shows that it acted fine in its distribution of money, in that the money was accounted for and it went where it was supposed to go. That was good to hear. The governance review group was chaired by Mr. Aidan Horan and produced a document. Did the Minister see that document before it was signed off on and put into the public domain?
Comment on this
Yes, the document produced by Aidan Horan.
Comment on this
Did the Minister see the document with 78 recommendations?
Comment on this
Did the Minister see the document before it was put in the public domain?
Comment on this
There was a recommendation that a minimum of one or two previous board members should be retained. Why did the Minister not pull out that time?
Comment on this
My official will answer the question.
Comment on this
We did have sight of the IPA report. We were asked for our observations on it and one of the observations that the Minister did put back to the chair was his concern about the two staying on. That recommendation around up to two staying on was noted by the Minister and was remarked upon. His observation back to them was that that should not be the case.
Comment on this
Why was the Minister so slow to come out of the traps?
Comment on this
We got the report as well and made our observations. We made the same suggestion back that all of the board should go. We know the rationale for keeping two on was for continuity-----
Comment on this
---- but we suggested that all of the board would go.
Comment on this
Yes. I cannot remember the exact sequence of what happened here. At no stage did we make any bones about the fact that we wanted the entire board to go and they made a recommendation that was not in accordance with that.
Comment on this
While the Minister did later on, he did not condemn the recommendation within days of the report being published. It was more or less when nominations came through for the FAI AGM that he spoke his mind. He did not put it on public record when the report was published that he was unhappy with the recommendation.
Comment on this
I am not sure that the Deputy is right about the sequence of events.
Comment on this
The Minister waited until the nominations came out for the FAI.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy is correct about this. I made it absolutely clear at every stage when I was asked that I thought every single member of the board should go. The IPA made a recommendation, which was not in accordance with my wishes, but that is up to them and makes them independent. I do not know whether it was before or afterwards but I made it quite clear that I felt that the entire board should go. That was unambiguous all along.
Comment on this
The document was done in joint partnership with Sport Ireland. Is it correct that Sport Ireland sponsored the document?
Comment on this
Yes. Before the document was finalised, our observation was that the entire board should go. We inputted that back into the group. The IPA and the group that formulated the report did a very good job. They got that from us but they are independent and they made their own suggestions, as is their right to do.
Comment on this
It is very important that the group was independent of us and of Sport Ireland. They made a recommendation against very strong feelings that were expressed to them. I regret the recommendation as it was wrong but at least they were an independent group and they said, "Look, keep them on". That is fine and proves their independence.
Comment on this
Aidan Horan was independent and professional. He knows his job.
Comment on this
Part of the problem was that the FAI might not have co-operated with the process if one did not do that.
Comment on this
Did Sport Ireland or the Department see draft copies of the KOSI report before the finalised document was published?
Comment on this
So the document that is with the Garda was the only document issued by KOSI and there were no drafts prior to that.
Comment on this
I wrote to Mr. Treacy that I required a copy of the report under the relevant Act.
Comment on this
A draft copy or the signed-off copy?
Comment on this
That was the first sight I had of it.
Comment on this
So no draft copies were given beforehand.
Comment on this
The Minister has acknowledged, and as acknowledged by the KOSI report, the distribution of the State funds. One of the reasons we have a big interest in the affairs of the FAI is because there are State aid or grants involved. It has been acknowledged that as bad as the figures were, the FAI distributed the money where it was supposed to go, as in what Sport Ireland and the Department signed off on. Now, the Minister is on about bringing in other means of distribution, which will add an astronomical cost because firms such as BDO do not come cheap. When the firm gets money to allocate, will it get the money plus a fee or will the fee be taken out of the grant money? It will cost at least a couple of €100,000 to distribute the money.
Comment on this
Where did the Deputy get that figure?
Comment on this
I ask the Minister for a figure. What quotes has he for the distribution of these moneys from the independent agencies?
Comment on this
I am sorry. I will go back to the record.
Comment on this
I said earlier, in response to Deputy O'Brien, that we must be protective of public moneys. There is a high risk that if we were to give money directly to the FAI, given that KOSI has stated that the moneys were pretty much well accounted for and given the precarious financial situation that the association is in at the moment, we could not guarantee that it would not disappear into a black hole. That is one of the big challenges. I mean when one has so many overdrawn accounts and different issues going on we want to ensure that the money gets to the front line and to the people who need it. By going through the FAI, obviously there is a cost. I understand that it is a very low cost to take the alternative route but at least we are guaranteeing that the money reaches where intended. We would have no guarantee channelling the money through the FAI. That would be completely out of the question and the KOSI clearly states that the FAI is not fit to receive public moneys.
Comment on this
To be helpful, I suggest that Deputy O'Keeffe tables a parliamentary question on the issue so that when the Dáil resumes he may have the answers for what this costs, who submitted tenders, etc.
Comment on this
Only a few years ago, the Olympic Council of Ireland, OCI, was in trouble and we suspended funding for a period. We started funding the OCI before the final conclusions were reached and the matters were resolved. Can we assume going forward that if the new FAI board is in place, we can surely put a guarantor in the administration to ensure the money would continue to be distributed? We must give the current FAI credit and move on.
Comment on this
We have made it quite clear that the FAI will not be given funding until its corporate governance is fully compliant and satisfactory and its finances are in order, and not before that. There is nothing more than we want to do than to fund Irish football one way or the other. As my ministerial colleague said, we cannot give the FAI money when we have been advised that it is not fit to receive money. That would be folly.
Comment on this
There is a delay in appointing independent directors. Why are they slow to take up their positions? Have they been privy to the KOSI report?
Comment on this
I am not sure but I think they have. Mr. Treacy might comment on whether that is correct.
Comment on this
No. They have been going through the recent financial statements of the FAI and they have been briefed by Grant Thornton on those. That is where it is at.
Comment on this
No. They have not seen the KOSI report and they will not.
Comment on this
As another member pointed out, the directors cannot place themselves in jeopardy without having full and proper professional advice in every respect. It is the reassurance they need because if they do not have that they cannot take up those jobs. Is that not it?
Comment on this
I apologise as my phone is ringing. There is a sports meeting on in Bandon. I hope it is good news. Is the Minister happy to deal with the FAI on a professional and official level when the incumbent chairman vacates his position? Is the Minister waiting for more heads to roll?
Comment on this
We have already met its representatives.
Comment on this
That was without the incoming chairman.
Comment on this
Was that in an official capacity?
Comment on this
It was an official meeting and it was without the president. The meeting was at their request and we agreed to meet those representatives. I would absolutely jump at the chance to meet the independent directors when appointed, along with the new chairman.
Comment on this
When the current president steps down officially and the independent directors are put in place, the Minister will be ready to meet the FAI in an official capacity.
Comment on this
I am ready to meet the independent directors the day they are appointed. I am ready to meet the other directors and the new president on their appointment. It will be straight away.
Comment on this
We are talking about the current directors, apart from the president, who is stepping down. Will the Minister meet the independent directors and the new chairman as a group?
Comment on this
I will meet the independent directors, the new directors appointed last June and the new president on their appointment.
Comment on this
Who is the Minister leaving out?
Comment on this
The Minister is not looking for any more heads.
Comment on this
We are looking for appointments. We are looking for new people committed to reform and who are independent.
Comment on this
The next speaker was supposed to be Senator Paul Daly, who I appreciate was here earlier. Should he return, I will take his questions as soon as he comes in. That will be fair to him. The order is the same as it was in the first round so we will have Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin and so on.
Comment on this
I will be brief. Mr. Treacy mentioned that Sport Ireland invited the FAI in twice in 2018 and it turned down the invitation both times. Will he give us some more information on that? For example, what were the dates in 2018 and what reason was given for not coming in? What was the response of Sport Ireland and did it not raise a red flag in itself? There was continuous speculation that the association was in difficulty even at that time. Is there more detail on that? I also have a question for the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin.
Comment on this
I can clarify the point. The first invitation was issued towards the end of 2018. It may have been the November board meeting. The former chief executive officer was not available as it clashed with Ireland's away game in the UEFA Nations League in Denmark. The second invitation was for the next meeting, which may have been the December meeting. The former chief executive was not available as he was out of the country attending to business in his role with UEFA. There was an executive meeting in UEFA and it was essentially a clash of dates. We were working on other dates and there was a date in the diary for the first quarter of this year that seemed to suit all parties. However, The Sunday Times article was published on St. Patrick's Day and events quickly overtook us. The very next meeting of the board of Sport Ireland was the time when the decision was taken to suspend and withhold funding to the FAI.
Comment on this
The first invitation was in November 2018. Was Sport Ireland comfortable in that four months before The Sunday Times article was published? I am sure the former chief executive was not travelling all the time.
Comment on this
The board meets on a monthly basis. We meet in November and December before we meet again in February. At that stage there was not a great urgency and we were trying to fit in with everybody's schedules. We invite in the governing bodies during the course of the year but we can really only take one at a meeting. We deal with 65 governing bodies of sport. Usually when the governing bodies come in, it amounts to an hour. If it is done properly, it takes an hour to exchange views.
Comment on this
What would have been on the agenda for the meeting?
Comment on this
Essentially, a body like the FAI would give an update on the programmes it ran. We would also hear if there were concerns or worries. It was that type of meeting.
Comment on this
The fact that the meeting did not happen did not raise any red flags.
Comment on this
We would have liked to have seen them when we issued the first invitation, as we would with the second invitation. We were told they were not available. We cannot put a gun to someone's head.
Comment on this
The invitation was issued on foot of previous attendance by the chief executive of the Irish Rugby Football Union, IRFU, in September last year. The October meeting would have been attended by the Ard-Stiúrththóir of the Gaelic Athletic Association, GAA. It was part of the series of meetings with the IRFU, the GAA and the FAI. The chief executives of the bodies have very busy diaries and it is not always possible to align dates.
Comment on this
Did other governing bodies have similar clashes in dates? Was the FAI the only governing body with such a clash?
Comment on this
As secretary to the board, I cannot recall a specific example but it is fair to say, when arranging meetings with governing bodies, that it is always a challenge to align diaries between the chief executives of very busy organisations and the high-profile roles. It is for various reasons, and people can be out of the country at international competitions, etc.
Comment on this
I thank the witnesses. The Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, mentioned earlier all the governing bodies that have signed up to the code of governance. Is the information on who has signed up to the code or who is yet to sign up in the public domain? I know the numbers but I am talking about names.
Comment on this
Sport Ireland has the information. Is it available publicly?
Comment on this
Deputy Quinlivan can start as I have a couple of questions.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister, Deputy Ross, and the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, as well as their officials for attending today. The Minister, in response to a question, indicated that if the FAI goes, the League of Ireland goes too. That has sent a shock across the State and people have been in touch with me since the Minister made that statement. Will he commit that whatever happens, the League of Ireland will be protected?
I have a number of specific questions on Limerick FC. I mentioned them briefly to the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, earlier. Is the Minister aware that the Limerick FC club is being wound up? Was he aware of the difficulties facing Limerick FC prior to last week's announcement? Had he any discussions on the problems at Limerick FC? As sports Minister, does he have any intention of stepping in to try to save the club, which has existed since 1937? As things stand, next season's Airtricity League first division will have nine clubs if Limerick FC is not there. The clubs left will face weeks with no games to play because Limerick FC will not be there. It is an historical team and people are employed there. I want to ensure the current position of Limerick FC is not lost in the absolute shambles of the FAI we are discussing today. The club has existed for 80 years.
It is a core part of Limerick's sporting tradition and it is vital that it gets the support it needs.
Comment on this
I will answer the question about the League of Ireland. I have deep concerns about it. It is principally a matter for the FAI as to what happens to it in a doomsday situation. We are trying to avoid that. That is our ambition. I am particularly concerned about the League of Ireland and I say this absolutely sincerely because I have felt for some time, as the Deputy does, that it had been neglected to an extent under the old regime. There is room for improvement and I have made this perfectly clear. When the independent directors come in, I intend to let them know that one of the great concerns we have relates to the League of Ireland. It is one of the forgotten stakeholders and it should be given greater consideration and respect for what it is doing. I will raise the issue of the League of Ireland specifically - I thank Deputies Quinlivan and O'Brien raising it - with UEFA on 14 January. I am not sure whether UEFA is aware of the vulnerability of the League of Ireland. I will certainly do this because the league needs protection. Obviously, it is subject to the consequences of what has happened. Our ambition is very definitely to save football and to save the League of Ireland and see that it continues to flourish. I do not want to make any commitments, financial or otherwise, and I am not going to do so. I would not do that. I assure the Deputies that the representations they make are not falling on deaf ears. I will ask Minister of State to answer the question on Limerick.
Comment on this
I was very sorry to hear about Limerick FC last week. There is a long and proud tradition of soccer in Limerick. There was so much hope in recent years and the club had been performing well until relatively recently, which compounds it. It is a huge pity. The licence is a matter for the FAI in terms of league participation. I acknowledge the fact that an uneven number in the first division present all sorts of difficulties in terms of the team that will have a by every week and the lack of gate takings for those clubs. Logistically, nine is a very small number to have in a league. Since the club has gone into receivership, a prospective buyer will be dealing with the banks. The Department would certainly be open to talking to any prospective buyer on how we could help and how other partners might help, for example, Limerick City and County Council. I know for a while the club had been playing in Thomond Park. There was a partnership with Munster Rugby. At the same time, we cannot really intervene in the day-to-day running of the club or operational matters for the FAI in the context of the league. The state of the overall league and its future security will be on the agenda for discussion with UEFA. I will be very keen to explore it and see what, if anything, can be done to safeguard the league.
Comment on this
Prior to the meeting with UEFA, we are prepared to meet a representative specifically of the League of Ireland, if the Deputy is of the view that this would be helpful, in order that we can take that message with us.
Comment on this
As stated, there is major concern about the Minister's statement that if the FAI goes, the League of Ireland will go. The Minister needs to address the issue more strongly than he has to date. I appreciate his response, which was quite good, but we need a commitment that whatever happens the League of Ireland will be protected in some form.
Comment on this
Let us meet the representatives. We can set it up, or the Deputy can do so if he likes. Let us meet them. I am very happy to do so and take their message further. The Deputy is making a fair point. The League of Ireland teams are sometimes forgotten and it is not reasonable that this should be the case. Certainly, we will set up a meeting-----
Comment on this
Going back to Limerick, one reason it was probably forgotten is because the League of Ireland was forgotten by the FAI.
Comment on this
I would love to give a commitment of the type the Deputy is seeking but we are back to the fundamental question of whether we bail out the FAI. That is the other side of it. Again, there is so much collateral damage and it is very serious. That is one of the risks. It is hypothetical at present and that is why we will meet UEFA and why we will explore all options to see what can be done.
Comment on this
I have a number of quick questions. The Minister stated earlier that the FAI is a going concern in his opinion. That is not the opinion of the auditors. I want to put this on the record. The auditors have indicated that they do not know whether the FAI can meet its liabilities and that, therefore, they cannot support the assumption that it is a going concern. On what basis is the Minister making the assumption the FAI is a going concern? That is my first question. If the Minister wants to answer it, I will come back in afterwards.
Comment on this
The association is trading as a going concern. Its future is in some sort of peril, as we can see, but it is currently as a going concern.
Comment on this
It is the FAI's view that it is a going concern.
Comment on this
I would not put much weight on the FAI's view in fairness. That is just my own opinion given everything that has happened.
Comment on this
Speaking not as a League of Ireland fan but as a football fan, we have had situations for years where League of Ireland supporters and clubs had been trying to explain exactly how the FAI operates. It has ridiculed us and laughed at us. It threw some of us out of football grounds for trying to expose the incompetence in the organisation. We had a situation where the FAI described the League of Ireland as the problem child. We were not the problem child. The FAI was the absentee father. Forgive my language because I am angry about this. The FAI was the absentee father. It did not give an absolute bollocks about the League of Ireland and continues to not care about the League of Ireland. Somebody needs to say this because it has not been said vocally enough. I apologise for my language.
Comment on this
I do not apologise for the sentiments behind it because there are a lot of League of Ireland supporters and football supporters out there who are really angry about what is happening. I am not going to get into reports or finger-pointing because I will respect what the Chairman asked me not to say at the start of the meeting, but we have a situation where Irish football is on the brink in terms of its future. We are reliant on an organisation that has proved it cannot operate with due diligence to be the guardian and saviour of Irish football.
I do not want to see a situation where the FAI is liquidated. I do not think anyone in the room wants to see it. The consequences are too great to comprehend at present. I am starting to come to the belief that if we are serious about protecting the future of Irish football we may end up with a scenario whereby the FAI goes into examination. While it is in examinership an alternative structure could be put in place to take it back out examination. If that were to happen, it would require financing and possibly State financing. That the only way we will protect the national teams and the leagues as well as grassroots football. It is the only way it can be done. If it is liquidated under the articles of UEFA, the domestic leagues and the national teams will be gone. They will all be gone.
Whatever our opinion of the FAI and its management structure, we cannot allow a situation where the FAI is liquidated because the consequences are unbearable to think about. If it goes into examinership, somebody has to step in and we must be preparing for that eventuality now. It might never happen but I do not want to wake up and find that the FAI has gone into examinership and we are not prepared to take it back out and protect Irish football. That is the responsibility of the Minister, all of us and football fans throughout this country. We need to start preparing for that.
I welcome the announcement of the 60 regional development officers that will be put in place. There might be a misunderstanding about how this operates. Those officers provide the coaching, they do not answer the phones or organise schools to compete in programmes. Who is going to do all of that if we are not funding it? We can provide the funding for development officers who will provide the coaching but if there is no one organising soccer schools and kits to be delivered, how does it work?
Comment on this
I am ad idem with almost everything the Deputy has said. We hope that the FAI will co-operate but there is no sign of full co-operation yet. We want a completely new chapter. We will reduce the risk of things like examinership and liquidation and it is right that the Deputy has raised those issues. We will reduce the risk of that immediately through independent directors coming in and that will mean more confidence in the FAI from the stakeholders including UEFA, the banks, the FAI itself and ourselves. We might be considering changing the name of the organisation but whatever it will be called, we are looking for the moment that door is unlocked. We might have a real opportunity to do the sorts of things the Deputy is talking about, specifically with the League of Ireland. This could be a chance for something radical and some real reform could come out of this. We are staring into a chasm but there are opportunities to correct something that has been going wrong for many years and respond to the things the Deputy is talking about, particularly with regard to the League of Ireland. We will have an entirely new group of people involved who are not captured by the prejudices and loyalties of the past. I hope we will have an opportunity in the coming days and weeks to get a strong chief executive in place because that is vital. We need a strong group of independents who will turn their backs on the past. We need a strong new chairman and we can set the example from the top. That is not the solution but it is part thereof, as everyone here recognises.
The principal problem has been diabolical corporate governance and if we can sort that out, we will soon sort out the confidence issue. We will be able to move on to the details thereafter, some of which are not our business, although the Deputy has addressed them, and many of which are symptoms of the things that are going wrong. Our ambition and determination is to get those particular parts in place shortly and we can then address the issues about which Deputy is talking.
There are sensitivities about us getting too involved which we will not breach. Government policy and confidence are important factors. We will have confidence if we see steps to reform that are radical enough to satisfy the requirements of corporate governance and begin to set in train an improvement in the finances.
I agree with everything the Deputy said. We are meeting SIPTU this evening as a matter of urgency in order to hear more of the sorts of things the Deputy is saying because they are important to us. We recognise the suffering that has been inflicted on people but we also recognise their importance as stakeholders and the contributions they will make to the FAI, or whatever the organisation might be called, in the future.
Comment on this
What about the administrative staff that are needed?