We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Joint Committee on Transport, Tourism and Sport

Governance and Funding of Football Association of Ireland: Discussion

Contributions 481–727 of 727. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I am aware that Senator Mark Daly has not got in yet. I want to make the point that, based on what the Minister has said, the key appointment for change will be the independent chairperson.

Comment on this

The independent directors.

Comment on this

If those independent directors do not come in, is the whole thing a house of cards?

Comment on this

We do not contemplate that happening.

Comment on this

Those independent directors have not said they will come on board yet and that is the point.

Comment on this

Is that a danger?

Comment on this

There are many dangers and we are trying to overcome them, one by one.

Comment on this

I understand that. I am just pointing out a key point.

Comment on this

I apologise because I had to go to other meetings and come back and this question may have been asked already. In the interests of openness and transparency, the business plan that the FAI presented to the Minister on Monday should be provided and made available to the public. Is the business plan credible? If we are going to start a culture of openness and transparency, we should start with the business plan and it should have been circulated to the members of the committee. The FAI seems to be good at avoiding meeting Sports Ireland, the Minister and this committee. The FAI has previously supplied documents that we have seen and which are not credible. I ask the Minister to provide to the public by this evening the business plan that was proposed. The Government is being asked to bail out the FAI and we need to know whether there is any credibility to its business plan.

I also raise the competency of Deloitte as an auditor although I know it can only deal with the figures it is given. There must have been interest payments on the loan. Did Deloitte ever question the figures that were presented? I ask the Minister and Sport Ireland how many other sporting organisations are Deloitte the auditor for. How many tickets did Deloitte get from the FAI when it was the auditor of the association? That would be insightful. Deloitte did not do its job.

Has the Minister made any efforts to find out from the FAI whether the county organisations are being run on the same basis as the FAI? The culture that exists at the top could seep into every county. We are talking about reforms and legislation, as we were the last time the Minister was before the committee, and that things have to change. During the term of this Government, there has been the Olympic Council of Ireland scandal and boxing has been an issue because the people in control at the top of those organisations have got money from the Government but the Government is unable to do what is in the best interests of the sports because the guys at the top are controlling everything. Power needs to be taken back by the Department and Government because fiefdoms have been created by people in different sporting organisations which are not being run in the best interests of those organisations but of the very few at the top. There have been issues about the greyhound industry and there are issues now with the FAI. What legislation has been brought in during his term to stop those sorts of things happening since we found out about the Olympic Council of Ireland?

Given the number of sporting organisations involved and the amount of time being wasted, is there a proposal that an audit will be done - I suggest by a company other than Deloitte - of those organisations? Instead of us having to bail out the FAI at Christmas in order to keep people who are in jeopardy of losing their jobs because of the incompetence of the bosses in their jobs, we must ensure that we will not be back here again in six months or a couple of years' time discussing another sporting organisation that is being run by individuals for their own gain and profit. Is the Government proposing that there will be a forensic review? That is the only way it will work because the auditors seem to be beyond useless. They are off bolting doors after the horse, or the greyhound in some cases, has gone down the field. What does the Government intend to do and what legislation has been introduced since we started dealing with the issues relating to the Olympic Council of Ireland?

I want to raise another issue regarding what was brought up here about pension entitlements-----

Comment on this

Did we receive correspondence on that?

Comment on this

Sport Ireland sent us correspondence on that. We got an answer to the question about the different schemes.

Comment on this

The Senator asked about the plan that was given to us. The word “confidential” was written all over it.

Comment on this

Confidential to whom.

Comment on this

I presume that those involved do not want it released.

Comment on this

The Minister should release it.

Comment on this

It would be difficult to do that. When someone gives one a confidential document-----

Comment on this

It is not a legal document.

Comment on this

Let the Minister answer the question.

Comment on this

He could ask the FAI.

Comment on this

The Deputy show allow the Minister to answer the question and then he can ask additional questions.

Comment on this

I told the members, and maybe I should not have done, that there was an €18 million figure to give them the scale of the demands they were making and to assure them that it was not a credible document. It had the word “confidential” written on it. I will not breach that but I am quite happy to tell the Senator that it was not a credible document. I can tell him, specifically, that it was a request for a bailout and it was not, therefore, something we could consider seriously.

Comment on this

Who drafted it?

Comment on this

The FAI, presumably, drafted it.

Comment on this

Were auditors or a financial body involved?

Comment on this

Grant Thornton gave them some advice on it.

Comment on this

Yet it is not a credible document.

Comment on this

It is not a credible document because the association is seeking €18 million. That is not something we are prepared to consider for a moment. That is the answer to the Senator’s question. As to whether the Government is considering looking at all those organisations in terms of audit, Mr. Treacy might answer that question.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We regularly audit all of the sporting organisations. We will be auditing 14 next year. We did eight or nine this year. We will be continuing to do that. We do use Deloitte but we use other auditors also. We just need to be careful that we do not cast aspersions on one particular firm. I understand the point the Senator made in terms of the misses around the FAI but at the same time we need to be careful. I have to say that we get audits from Deloitte and they are very good.

Comment on this

On the legislation proposed since the Olympic Council of Ireland debacle, will there be any change to the way sporting bodies will be governed? Almost every year there is a scandal about a sporting organisation. The Sports Council does not have all the powers. It cannot go into an organisation and start opening filing cabinets. We discussed previously the question of having such powers. Changing personnel is a way of saying that we will ensure the ship is run better by getting a better captain. The problem is that the super structure is always wrong. It seems to be that if there is a bad egg in a sporting organisation, they can do whatever they want. They run the show. They hire and they fire, and there is no accountability. We have seen that time and again. To come back to the question, does the Minister have the answer? He might supply it to the committee. Someone might ask Deloitte if it got tickets from the FAI, the number involved and whether it paid for them. What we are trying to establish here is the credibility of the organisation. First and foremost, these are the people who should have raised red flags. We had this previously with the banking crisis. Here we are again, with another group of auditors saying, "We have enough caveats on this that we are not responsible for anything that goes wrong but we will get paid a lot to do it".

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

If I may come in on that, we discussed our revised terms and conditions of grant aid in the context of full audits of the NGBs. We need to remember also the role and responsibilities of the boards of the organisations that are running sport in the country. I refer to all the corporate governance work we are doing with them in terms of ensuring they know what their duties. The board of the FAI, in this case, has responsibility for the organisation and how it is run. What we can do is provide the guidance and the training they need, as we do in terms of organisational development and change. All that structure has been in place for the past number of years but if, hypothetically, a rogue chief executive or someone comes in-----

Comment on this

I do not need a hypothetical-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

It is the board's responsibility to ensure the organisation is properly governed. It is as simple as that.

Comment on this

Can I ask the Minister-----

Comment on this

We heard from the directors that all information given to the auditor is all the information they have. Is that not the point?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

That is the point.

Comment on this

Mr. Treacy makes that point in his opening statement.

Comment on this

Before the Minister leaves, could I ask him to ask the FAI if it will allow him release the business plan?

Comment on this

Absolutely, yes. I am sorry but I have to go.

Comment on this

The Minister did indicate that he has to leave. He has been here-----

Comment on this

The Minister is relieved. My questions are for others. I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister will be followed by the press.

Comment on this

The order has not changed. Initially, the order was Senator O'Mahony, Deputies MacSharry, Jonathan O'Brien, Catherine Murphy and Coppinger, Senators Ó Céidigh and Feighan, Deputy O'Keeffe and Senator Mark Daly. Senator Mark Daly was not here when his turn came up so I moved on to Sinn Féin.

Comment on this

That is fine.

Comment on this

We agreed that when the Senator arrived, he would get his turn. We started the second round then with Senator O'Mahony. As the Senator was not here, we went to Sinn Féin but as he is here now, he may come in. I am not upsetting the order. I will call the Deputies then.

Comment on this

I have to leave as well.

Comment on this

I have not asked any questions yet either.

Comment on this

I have to leave at 2 p.m. as well.

Comment on this

I will be brief. I just want to make a few quick points.

Comment on this

We all have a duty to due diligence in terms of our work here. In fairness to everybody, we are all doing that. We have been here since 9 a.m.-----

Comment on this

All of us have been here since 9 a.m..

Comment on this

-----so if we need to reconvene, we will do so. There is no problem. I am sure the Minister will come back if we want him to do so.

Comment on this

This question is for Mr. Treacy. Following on from what Deputy O'Keeffe said earlier, there was a discussion about a draft KOSI report. I was not in the room. I was trying to use my time efficiently so I was watching the proceedings in my office at the time. That question was not answered. The Minister said that he did not see any draft reports and that he only saw the final report. Can Mr. Treacy confirm that there was a draft report?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

There was a draft report, yes.

Comment on this

Did Sport Ireland submit comments on that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Yes, we did.

Comment on this

Did the FAI do the same?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Yes, it did.

Comment on this

Who in the FAI saw it?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The financial people who were dealing with it and some members of the board.

Comment on this

Did all the remaining six directors see it?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I am not quite sure about that.

Comment on this

We would be interested to know that; Mr. Treacy might send us a note. There was a draft. As we are not allowed to see it, Mr. Treacy cannot tell us what comments he made on it. That is also unfortunate.

I think I know the answer but I ask this for the record. In his opening statement the Minister said the KOSI report had found that State money was spent on what it was supposed to be used for. Why would we not be not be confident - or have an element of confidence - in the new set-up?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

It would be because of other elements in the report.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Treacy share those other elements?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I cannot share it.

Comment on this

Mr. Treacy has made that clear and we have accepted that is the case.

Comment on this

It is not tolerable. Given the seriousness of the issue-----

Comment on this

The point is that because of the overall financial situation, that money could-----

Comment on this

That is what I wanted on the record.

Comment on this

That is the reason.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State; he has answered the question.

On the KOSI report, I feel the committee should ask the Government to consider introducing legislation, which can be done very quickly, to give the members of this committee rights to see that report. It was done with the banking inquiry.

Comment on this

I think-----

Comment on this

I am just suggesting it. I do not even want a response. I am just putting it out there.

As part of our research for this, everyone has been googling and looking at stuff. I read an article from about ten years ago about what was then the Irish Sports Council. With the benefit of hindsight did the Irish Sports Council miss an opportunity when matters relating to the FAI were being raised by a number of then directors?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I do not think so. We did audits of the FAI and continue to do it. We got good reports. At the time we were being accused maybe of being heavy-handed with organisations. That is one of the things we are trying to balance. We got good reports of what the FAI was doing on the ground.

Comment on this

The issue then involved two or three directors. It ended up in court and I am not getting into the detail of that. Those members of the board at the time were seeking to raise concerns about the FAI's finances ten years ago. Maybe if we had embraced that-----

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

No evidence was ever produced to us.

Comment on this

No evidence was ever produced. Okay. When it was raised at the time it was pushed back by the rest of the board in the Irish Sports Council.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

It was discussed at the board. I cannot recall what was discussed ten years ago.

Comment on this

It might be useful information. Mr. Treacy might be able to send the committee a note on that. I know that the Irish Sports Council became Sport Ireland. In my research I found an Irish Independent article which reported that a row had emerged between three directors and the rest of the board and it centred on the FAI.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

No, it did not.

Comment on this

It was the impression I got.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

No, it did not. It centred on leaks from the board of Sport Ireland.

Comment on this

I am quoting from an article.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I am telling the Deputy what it emanated from.

Comment on this

That is grand; I am just quoting from an article.

Comment on this

It is a serious point. Does Mr. Treacy want to finish his point?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

There were issues in terms of behaviour of board members. I will leave it at that.

Comment on this

Okay. That is fair enough. Between now and our next meeting, I ask Mr. Treacy to send the committee a note on that because I think it is a legitimate question. I am quoting from an article from the Irish Independent. Mr. Treacy and other people know the facts; the committee does not. There is an element of relevance, albeit that Mr. Treacy might be able to give us an answer indicating that there is nothing to see here. It is a legitimate question. While I appreciate I have just sprung it on Mr. Treacy now, I will get him the Irish Independent article that made me ask the question. It is from seven or eight years ago.

I am conscious that the Minister, Deputy Ross, has gone but no doubt the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, speaks for the Government. Up to very lately the Government position was that we needed a total clear-out of the FAI. Is the total clear-out complete or did the Government have any issues either with the current executive lead or the other five directors who joined the board since July? I ask that for two reasons. First, Fianna Fáil is interested in moving this thing forward. Second, these people are entitled to their reputations. If there is confidence in them, they are entitled to hear it from the Minister of State today. If there is not, the nation also wants to know that the clear-out is not complete, that X and Y still have to go and that the Government is still not content. Can we have some confidence today to say that we are happy with the six we have? I am still in the dark as to when the independent directors will be appointed. Who are they? Who is appointing them? When will it happen?

Comment on this

No one wants this to move forward more than the Government. We want to see the independent chairman and independent directors in place. We want to see an independent chief executive appointed as quickly as possible. We are happy to work with those people and do our best to move this forward and achieve progress. Earlier we discussed the process of appointing the independent directors, which should have started earlier. We are where we are. As the Minister, Deputy Ross, said earlier, we want to meet those people the day they are appointed and get stuck in. Unfortunately, we are not at that point yet, but we want to get there and we want to work with those people.

Comment on this

Is the clear-out complete?

Comment on this

It is not complete. We are looking for a new chairman and a new chief executive.

Comment on this

That is not a clear-out; that is an appointment. Of the existing team of directors-----

Comment on this

We met directors on Monday night. Whereas they did not get the outcome they wanted, it is important that there is dialogue and a relationship there. We know that we are far from complete in terms of the line-up we need to have.

Comment on this

Chairman, I am just trying to get the answer. There are six people there-----

Comment on this

There is one. I think the president still has to go-----

Comment on this

Does somebody still have to go?

Comment on this

-----before there is a completely new board.

Comment on this

The president is going in January; we know that.

Comment on this

He has not gone yet. He is still there.

Comment on this

Mr. Conway has indicated that he will leave in January.

Comment on this

Is there anyone else?

Comment on this

No. I think that is it for now-----

Comment on this

Are we happy then?

Comment on this

-----as far as I am aware. As we discussed earlier, if further information comes to light later, that will change the situation. We are very much dealing with hypothetical situations at present.

Comment on this

I have to move on.

Comment on this

We have been over this already today.

Comment on this

I accept that. I just want to respond to one point Deputy MacSharry raised. The KOSI audit happened because we insisted there should be a forensic audit of the organisation. Nobody wants it more than I do, because I had to ask the FAI president, Mr. Conway, three times to do it and each time he did not commit to it. However, now that audit has been done. The Minister said:

I have also consulted An Garda Síochána, which has advised me that the matters outlined in the KOSI report are central to its investigations and those of the ODCE. The Garda has further advised me that making the report public at this time could have serious implications for any criminal proceedings subsequently brought by the Director of Public Prosecutions.

That is a very clear position that we have on that. The committee has agreed. We have made sure that there is no questioning which would put that in peril. Notwithstanding the Deputy's suggestion that we should all have a copy of it, I think it is the last thing we should get before the Garda confirms it is finished with it, irrespective of what it does with it.

Comment on this

I am thinking about the ODCE audit.

Comment on this

I am just saying it should go through due process on that.

Comment on this

On the KOSI report, people have a problem that when clear wrongdoing is identified, nobody is held to account. A report has gone to the Garda and the ODCE. I certainly want to see a successful outcome to that if possible because that would restore confidence.

In the view of the Minister of State, in the absence of a guarantor, be that UEFA, FIFA or the Government, is bank re-financing an option?

Comment on this

I am not an expert on financial matters but from reading of the figures it would not be likely.

Comment on this

It is unlikely to happen in the absence of a guarantor, which shows the importance of establishing a high-level group to find a solution. Is this type of engagement happening between Sport Ireland, the Department and the Minister, Deputy Ross?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

UEFA is central to the process. That should not be forgotten. The Minister, Deputy Ross, is keen to meet with UEFA this week or early next week but-----

Comment on this

The 14th was mentioned, which is some time away.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

That engagement is central to this piece. Perhaps Mr. Spratt would like to comment.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenneth Spratt

The Minister offered to meet with UEFA this week, if needs be.

Comment on this

The week of the 14th was mentioned.

Comment on this
Mr. Kenneth Spratt

It is confirmed for the 14th but the Minister did say he would be available Monday or Tuesday next week, the latter being Christmas eve, but UEFA is not available then. The nearest date on which it is available is 14 January.

Chairman: If anything happens in the meantime, what then?

Comment on this

There is some urgency in that the Minister and UEFA are going to meet very soon. They have to be central in all of this as, I believe, does FIFA.

Comment on this

They are. In our recent engagement on the FAI, I pointed out that as a large organisation FIFA has the means to help and it is in its interests to help. The FAI is a member football association. FIFA has a role to play here.

Comment on this

In the absence of a domestic league, there would not be an international league.

Comment on this

The doomsday scenario is that if the domestic league is wound up international teams do not participate.

Comment on this

Am I correct that having a domestic league is a prerequisite to having an international team?

Comment on this

I am not certain about that.

Comment on this

That is my understanding. Perhaps the Minister of State will have it checked out and come back to me on it.

Comment on this

We are trying to avoid the doomsday scenario. These are the issue we want to discuss with UEFA.

Comment on this

My question is one that I would have expected the Minister of State, Deputy Griffin, as Minister with responsibility for sport, to be able to answer. When we speak about doomsday we need to know what doomsday looks like.

Comment on this

It is pretty clear that if the FAI does not exist, there can be no domestic league.

Comment on this

If there is no domestic league, there can be no international team.

Comment on this

I would imagine that if there is no FAI, there would be no international team. The Deputy's question is whether the FAI can exist with only an international team and so on. I will have to check that out.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister of State to come back to me on the scenarios.

Comment on this

We are all aware that all of the potential scenarios are not good. From the Government point of view, we are working to avoid any scenario that would be negative to Irish soccer. We are working to get the funding to the front line through the youth sports programme and we have restored funding to the international women's team. We are anxious to meet with UEFA.

Comment on this

I would appreciate it if the Minister of State would come back to me with that piece of information.

Comment on this

To be clear, the Deputy wants to know if the FAI-----

Comment on this

I want to know the consequences if there is no domestic league.

Comment on this

My understanding would be that if there is no domestic league, there would be no need for the FAI and, therefore, there would be no international team.

Comment on this

What happens next summer in terms of competitions and our relationship with-----

Comment on this

Obviously, without an international team we could not participate.

Comment on this

We need to flesh out that scenario because it brings into sharp focus exactly what we are talking about.

Comment on this

If the FAI folds, our international team will not be in a position to participate and so the game in Slovakia in March will not take place. Again, that is a hypothetical situation. We are trying to avoid that scenario.

Comment on this

We all want to avoid that scenario.

On the skillsets, new independent directors have been appointed and more are to follow. These are, in the main, volunteers who may also have full-time jobs. Are they have sufficiently resourced in terms of expertise to work through the current crisis or is additional expertise required?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

Mr. Aidan Horan is continuing to support the organisation in a meaningful way. There are professional staff within the organisation and they are progressing the work. The four independent directors bring a level of expertise to the board. There are also people on the board who are engaged in the current IPA course being run by Sport Ireland. Obviously, the independent directors would already have this expertise, which will enhance the board. The governance review sets out what needs to be put in place. This is set out in black and white for the organisation as well.

Comment on this

We have been told that the FAI believes that it is a going concern, although the auditors have raised a red flag in that regard. Is it a going concern on the presumption of State funding, UEFA funding, FIFA support or is any of that known?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

All of the above. It probably needs all of the support it can get in terms of where it is.

Comment on this

Is it assessed as a going concern on that basis?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

No. It is mainly around UEFA supporting the FAI and its sponsorship income. That is what it is relying on predominantly.

Comment on this

That is a major source of concern. There are people who, having worked with other organisations, have expertise in this area, including Brendan Menton and Sarah Keane, in terms of her hands-on approach to the restoration of an organisation. The committee could usefully hear from such people if we are holding another session in the new year. We should have another session because this is going to be an ongoing process.

I do not think the new directors of the FAI are helping their case in terms of their communications strategy and how they are working through the 78 recommendations. It would be far better if they gave a constant update on where they are in the process. That would be of assistance to people and sponsors who have concerns in terms of reputational damage and so on.

Comment on this

I can give the Deputy a breakdown of the 78 recommendations. Earlier, I referred to the fact that there is a KOSI implementation group between Sport Ireland and the FAI. On the governance review group and the oversight group, there were 78 recommendations, 16 of which were considered priorities. Of these 16, 11 have been implemented and five are in progress. In total, 30 of the 78 recommendations have been implemented or completed, 20 are in progress and 28 have not yet commenced. I do not have the specifics in this regard, which I accept would be useful.

Comment on this

We need the specifics in regard to each recommendation.

Comment on this

Which ones, specifically?

Comment on this

We need specifics around the ones that have been implemented, which ones are outstanding and why they are not being implemented. That type of information will be helpful.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We can share that information.

Comment on this

In regard to Deloitte, in 2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017 it was paid €88,000, €106,000, €103,000 and €135,000, respectively. The total amount for tax and audit advice over four years was €430,000, which is an awful lot of money. Some of those accounts had to be restated. There are other issues in regard to FRS102, which is about related parties. One would expect to see that in a set of accounts, where somebody who purchases jerseys or goal posts is related to a member of the board. In this regard, there was nothing recorded for 2017. There was also nothing recorded for 2014 or 2015.

Rigour was not demonstrated in those accounts. I am using this as an example for Sport Ireland. In addition to internal audit, does Sport Ireland look at what might be missing or at how routine accounts are, which may suggest they are almost copied and pasted?

Comment on this
Mr. Colm McGinty

It is part of the mid-year review process. A review of the annual financial statements presented is carried out by the director of finance every year. This does not relate only to the FAI's accounts but to those of every organisation we fund. Over the years, Sport Ireland raised several queries about the FAI's accounts. We reported to the committee on queries raised about the 2017 financial accounts and the position with regard to net current liabilities and solvency. The FAI provided a response, which has been provided to members of the committee. That is just an example. Queries were raised about the FAI's financial statements every single year, as is the case for every set of accounts presented to us.

Comment on this

I will make one point on that, which may be helpful. I have been informed by someone who looked at the accounts of the Irish Football Association in the North of Ireland, which has a turnover of €15 million, that its audit fees totalled less than €40,000. There is a huge difference between the situation here and there.

Comment on this

I do not know the breakdown between fees for tax advice and audit is but we ended up with a tax liability, which may have arisen because the auditors did not have sight of some information.

Comment on this

That is the fee. The other point made to me was that payments into people's pensions were not discovered by the auditor. I have been told that these would have been very easy to find if the question had been asked.

Comment on this
Mr. Colm McGinty

To clarify the situation in respect of the recently published financial statements and the revised 2017 statements, these are currently being reviewed by the executive of Sport Ireland. We will be going back to the FAI with a comprehensive series------

Comment on this

The audits did not show them up. That is the point.

Comment on this
Mr. Colm McGinty

It is a fair point.

Comment on this

I will make a couple of other points very quickly with regard to structures. The number of people who will elect, for example, the next president is very limited. Does Mr. McGinty have concerns about that? Has Sport Ireland been talking to the FAI in this regard? That is part of its governance arrangements and it strikes me that this number may not be representative of the totality of the organisation.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The Deputy is correct. The FAI will look at extending the range of people it can put in. They will not come from the council itself but from a wider pool. The Deputy makes a very valid point. We need to ensure that we capitalise on the expertise available, probably not through an elected body.

Comment on this

Concerns have also been raised with regard to underage structures. I refer to the under-13s and the relationship between their clubs and the league. There are serious concerns about the quality and sustainability of the underage game. Does Sport Ireland have concerns in this regard? Has it talked to the FAI about the issue, given that it falls under promotion of sport? Does Sport Ireland play such a role?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

This issue has not come across our desk. We have not heard about it. Has Mr. McGinty heard anything on it?

Comment on this
Mr. Colm McGinty

No, not specifically.

Comment on this

I can send Sport Ireland something in that regard.

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

The Deputy can send us something, if she would not mind doing so.

Comment on this

I thank everyone for their perseverance today.

Comment on this

We will finish after Deputy Rock's questions unless anybody else wants to make a contribution.

Comment on this

I will keep to questions rather than making statements. What exactly did KOSI say about how much the FAI spent on Sport Ireland-funded work? When before this committee in April, Mr. Donal Conway said that the figure was four fifths, 80%. What did KOSI say on that?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I cannot get into the details but I can say that the funding we provided to the FAI was expended on the purposes for which it was given. I have received legal advice and that is what we are saying. We were well-covered in terms of the funding we provided. We were happy enough with what we sought in these audits and previous audits. I do not want to go any further than that today.

Comment on this

Can Mr. Treacy say whether Mr. Conway's statement to the committee in April was accurate?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

If I did, I would be commenting on the KOSI report.

Comment on this

In fairness, it was decided earlier that the issues raised in the KOSI report are not germane to our debate today. I can clue the Deputy in if he wants. We have raised this with a number of people-----

Comment on this

I have been watching the proceedings.

Comment on this

I want to mention this to the Deputy. I have been very clear on this. An Garda Síochána has said that the matters outlined in the KOSI report are central to its investigation and those of the Office of the Director of Corporate Enforcement. Making the report public could have serious implications for any criminal proceedings. We have all been very conscious of that all day. In fairness to Mr. Treacy, we have to be consistent on this to protect the integrity of the report and to avoid compromising anything the Garda may do in this regard. That is the truth.

Comment on this

Of course, I am simply trying to probe matters based on our previous hearings but that is fair enough. I understand the position. I will move on. Given that the FAI is often audited and that Sport Ireland often cites such audits as a sign of the health of a sporting organisation, does Mr. Treacy feel this sort of problem could exist elsewhere? As the Chairman has outlined, this sort of forensic audit only happened as a consequence of the insistence of the Chair and the committee. It has shown up a number of shortcomings in the regular audit process. Does Mr. Treacy feel this kind of problem could exist in other organisations?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

If our funding represents more than 50% of an organisation's turnover, we do an in-depth audit of that organisation. We received the agreement of the FAI to carry out an in-depth audit in March, when this issue came up. Through the prompting of the Chair, we did a forensic audit. We have now changed our terms and conditions, as the Deputy will know. We will carry out in-depth audits of all the organisations in future. That has been agreed with the organisations. We do not need legislation to do this if we agree with the national governing bodies that it is what we are going to do, based on consent. That is what we are doing.

Comment on this

Will Sport Ireland be looking at any other organisations retrospectively in the same way as it has looked at the FAI?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

We certainly will be. As we said earlier, we are going to audit 14 sporting organisations next year. We will continue to do that. We have increased the number of audits we carry out over recent years. We will do a thorough job. We are doing a lot of training on corporate governance with the national governing bodies as well. By and large, when we carry out audits - and we have lots of experience in this - we do not find a great number of significant issues. If we find significant issues, we sit down with that organisation over the course of a year to ensure that such issues are addressed. The national governing body has to verify that with us. That process has been in place for quite some time.

Comment on this

With regard to the restated accounts of the FAI, these were restated in 2016 and 2017 and the accounts for 2018 were released at the same time. Has consideration been given to going further back into the FAI's accounts to find the genesis of this problem and to find out when these problems originated within the organisation?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

I do not know the answer to that question. The KOSI report went back a little further. The question is how far back do we go?

Comment on this

Indeed. It might be a question to which Mr. Treacy can find the answer. I do not see how it could impinge on Garda investigations in any way. I may help give us a clearer picture. With regard to the current state of health of the FAI, notwithstanding the confidential figure that was inadvertently revealed by the Minister here a short time ago, do we have a sense of the FAI's overall position for 2019 as a going concern? We are getting to the end of the year.

Presumably, its position has eroded significantly further from when the 2018 accounts were published. There is a view that it is continuing to erode as time passes, for example, as a result of losing its main sponsor. Does the Department have a view on this?

Comment on this

I do not want to reveal anything confidential. I gave a figure of €62 million earlier in the context where the debt stands. It is not good, but there are income opportunities as well that the directors are hopeful will result in an improved scenario. The reason we are meeting UEFA is to see if we can get this matter resolved, but the FAI will need serious assistance if it is to avoid a very stark situation in 2020.

Comment on this

In terms of the Government's response, there is the direct scheme the Minister outlined earlier today and there is funding for the international women's team. Is that the limit of the measures the Government is willing to undertake or will there be further direct interventions?

Comment on this

We have found a way of getting the money to the women's team. Under the youth field sports programme, we announced today that we are getting that money out to the front line. We are working with our partners and the relevant stakeholders. Again, we are talking to UEFA and will meet its representatives. The key thing to resolve this is to get the proper personnel in place in the FAI. Without the independent directors in place, it will be very difficult to resolve and it will be difficult for the Government to do what it potentially could do into the future. At present, there is no public trust in the organisation. KOSI Corporation Limited has stated quite clearly that the organisation is not in a position to receive public moneys. As long as that continues, it will be difficult for the Government to assist.

We are doing what we can and trying to resolve as much we can where that is within our power. Personally speaking, my priorities are the players at every level, the volunteers throughout the country who, in some cases, have given decades of service to soccer in Ireland, the staff in the organisation and the hundreds of thousands of passionate Irish soccer supporters of the League of Ireland, the international team or any other team. I am a passionate supporter of soccer so I want to help and try to get this resolved, but it will be very difficult. Nobody should be under the illusion that this will be easy because it will not be. It will be a massive challenge for all of us to get this fixed.

Comment on this

I have a final question. Does the FAI have the money to pay the senior team ahead of the UEFA Euro 2020 matches? I presume there would be a conflict with UEFA intervening in respect of that tranche of funding.

Comment on this

That is one of the challenges. I do not wish to reveal too much of what was presented to us as a confidential document on Monday, but it is not in a good place at all financially and significant assistance will be required to perform all of the ordinary tasks of a football association. I will not get into the business of where it would cut back or where it would or would not pay. That is a matter for the FAI and its directors, but they will need serious financial support to function.

Comment on this

I apologise for my late attendance. I have some questions for the Minister of State. One relates to funding of the League of Ireland and the prize money for clubs in the future. This is a huge concern for clubs. I have been a lifelong supporter of Sligo Rovers. Clubs are struggling to survive each year. Deputy MacSharry and I are big supporters of Sligo Rovers, and there is only one Rovers.

Comment on this

That is for sure.

Comment on this

We see the fundraising that takes place in our local community to help Sligo Rovers to survive. There are many other clubs in the country in a similar situation. As we move forward will the overall structure of, and investment in, the league be part of the Government's role in the restructuring of the FAI?

Comment on this

First, I acknowledge how important Sligo Rovers FC is to soccer in the north west. The team has a proud and strong tradition. We spoke earlier about Limerick FC and there is also Cork City FC in the case of Deputy Jonathan O'Brien. Clubs are very important to their fans and to the people who live locally. The structure of the League of Ireland and the prize money are matters for the FAI, not for the Government. We had a stakeholders forum in May and there were discussions about the league and all the things that need to happen. Ultimately, however, the FAI must have its house in order for all these matters to be resolved.

I have my own ideas on how I would like to see the league proceeding, what I think might be a better way forward for the league and so forth. It is not the role of the Minister or the Department to set preconditions or to advise on the league, however, it is a matter for the FAI to get it right. We know it is not performing next or near where it could be performing. I believe there is far greater potential for the League of Ireland, but this is something that would have to be done internally. That is why it is so important that there are proper structures in place and that the voice of the grassroots, supporters, volunteers and all the people who make soccer possible in this country would be heard and have an avenue to impact on decision making. It is clear that has not been happening and that is a big problem.

Comment on this

That is true. My next question is about outstanding payments promised by the FAI to grassroots clubs. A commitment of €50,000 was given to Ballisodare United recently. Also, there are payments to be made by the FAI in respect, for example, of developments where there has already been an announcement of sports capital funding. There is another one in place with regard to the redevelopment of the MacSharry development in Sligo town. This money was allocated under the sports capital programme along with FAI funding. Will these go ahead while audit investigations are taking place?

Comment on this

I have made inquiries in the Department about how we can do this. The FAI is trying to get a handle on what has been promised, what facilities have gone ahead based on promises and so forth. That work is under way. I am keen to find out about that. I have made contact with a number of clubs in my constituency to ask about the situation in that regard. There appear to be different models of draw-down and different models regarding who is paying back the money or where the money comes from. In one club the funding was provided to the club from a finance agency and the FAI was due to pay back the agency, with the club only paying interest. A development went ahead on the basis of that set-up.

These are matters we are trying to get on top of in order to find out exactly what has been promised and what the implications will be if clubs have factored projected income they had been promised in the future into their business plans and if that income is not available now. The reason is that I am keen to help and make life easier for the clubs and the volunteers. We will see what we can do to help them because the last thing we want is clubs and volunteers who have been audacious enough to put facilities in place for their communities to then find themselves in difficult financial situations as a result of what, effectively, would be a broken promise. It is difficult to find a pattern even in terms of how those decisions were made, but we are trying to get on top of that.

Comment on this

With regard to the club with the commitment of €50,000, it has invested €350,000 in an all-weather surface, lighting and so forth over the past 12 months.

The €50,000 is the final part of the money. It is vitally important that money would be made available because the contract has been signed and the work has been completed.

Comment on this

I ask the Deputy, to get it right, to take it up with the Minister of State afterwards. I am sure he will help the Deputy in every possible way.

Comment on this

If the Deputy forwards me the specific details, I would be happy to.

Comment on this

I do not want to complicate the big picture here. We have a lot of-----

Comment on this

I have just one more question, Chairman.

Comment on this

I welcome Deputy McLoughlin and he should not get me wrong. For the record, our staff have been here for over six hours with a 15-minute break and members are anxious to do other things as well. I am anxious to concentrate on the big picture. Notwithstanding that, the constituency picture is the biggest one of all. I would ask the Deputy to bear with me here.

Comment on this

In Drogheda, there is the Chairman's own club as well.

Comment on this

I have already raised it. It was the first thing I said.

Comment on this

I am concerned about where we are at. Certainly, a lot has been trashed out already.

Comment on this

I would ask the Deputy to be fair to us.

Comment on this

I would be concerned in my area. These are the concerns that have been expressed by people in Sligo-Leitrim.

Comment on this

Deputy McLoughlin can raise them.

Comment on this

I do not want to get into a row with Deputy McLoughlin over this-----

Comment on this

The Chairman will not get into a row with me.

Comment on this

-----because he happens to be the Government deputy Whip in the Dáil as well. I ask the Deputy to stick to the big picture. The Minister of State will answer all the Deputy's questions about the other matters.

Comment on this

The Minister of State, in fairness, is well aware of these anyway, and I have asked him. Is he happy with the existing members of the board going forward?

Comment on this

We have had this, I think, three times, already. We will go a fourth time. We have stated clearly we want to see the independent directors appointed.

Comment on this

I welcome that.

Comment on this

We can work with the newly appointed people who came in during the summer. We want to see a new chair in place and we want to see a new independent chief executive in place. Mr. Conway has indicated that he is leaving in January. All of that will help in terms of the relationship between Government and the FAI.

Comment on this

I welcome what the Minister of State said about the chairman and the three new directors. I refer to the existing people who are going back on the board. Is the Minister of State happy or has he done a trawl in relation to these people?

Comment on this

None of the eight directors was on the board previously. One who had been has resigned.

Comment on this

I understand he has resigned this week, to be helpful to the Deputy.

Comment on this

No, for the record-----

Comment on this

I have already stated this previously.

Comment on this

We have done it three times.

Comment on this

What we have always said is that we want a fresh start here. We want new people in here who do not have a previous association with the board. That is why we had difficulty previously with people who were appointed to positions who we knew were very much immersed in the FAI previously. Had our concerns been taken on board earlier, I suspect that we would be further along the road in terms of trying to reach a recovery here. They were not taken on board and we are here now at the end of the year in this almighty mess. That is something that is very frustrating.

Comment on this

I seek clarity on that point. I took it - it is our third lap on this issue - from the Minister of State's response that he is happy with the six who remain, not including the president, who is going in January and who resigned last week. I refer to the post-July six. That is what I took from earlier unless I picked the Minister of State up wrong.

Comment on this

I took the same. Those are directors. The Minister of State stated that if other issues arise, and there may be other issues that arise, they would have to be dealt with. That is fair.

Comment on this

Exactly. There may be matters that we do not know about and I do not want to be sitting here in three months. I merely wanted to clarify that we are going off what we know at present. Everyone can use hindsight at some stage in the future.

Comment on this

Here and now, in real time.

Comment on this

From what we know. Exactly. We need to work with those who are there to try to resolve the issues, but I must emphasise how important it is that the independent directors get in place quickly and that we get an independent chief executive in place without further delay. Every day that is wasted here increases the risk to the organisation.

Comment on this

Everybody has had a fair run of the questions. I have only a couple. One of them, which was in the media recently, is that Mr. Brian Kerr and Mr. Niall Quinn have proposals. Has the Minister of State met them or is he aware of their proposals? Would it be helpful to meet them?

Comment on this

The proposals, referring to Deputy McLoughlin's question earlier, are matters that a normal football association itself would organise.

Comment on this

I think it was a rescue for the FAI.

Comment on this

It is not the job of the Minister or the Government to decide on what models or structures there would be in terms of a league.

Comment on this

I think it is not a league. It is separate. It is a whole rescue. I want to make the point because I told Mr. Niall Quinn that we would be discussing these issues in the public domain today. As a Member of the Oireachtas, I have a keen interest in it. I am not asking the Minister of State to commit to anything, but has he met them? That is it, really. It seems they are trying to separate the community from the commercial aspect of the game. Would that be fair?

Comment on this
Mr. John Treacy

That is a fair summary of it. We have not met them on it, to answer the question. In terms of everything we do around having strong organisations, when one fragments an organisation it goes against the grain. Sport should be governed by the national organisation and that is why one does not fragment it. It all should fit in, one piece after another. The development leads to talent identification. Talent identification leads to high performance. Fragmenting an organisation probably is not the way forward. Obviously, as was said here, the new organisation needs to give a great deal of time to the League of Ireland and to the underage development of the game and lift the whole organisation up now.

Comment on this

It is important that there would be an avenue for such proposals and ideas, whether relating to the league, player development, grassroots or whatever, to get proper consideration.

Comment on this

Mr. Treacy has answered the question I was going to ask. The crisis management here-----

Comment on this

Will the Chairman let me just-----

Comment on this

I just want to ask my question now.

Comment on this

I am not asking a question. I want to make a point. My understanding, to helpful with the Chairman's first question, is that to split an organisation like that is against FIFA's rules. It will only recognise one federation.

Comment on this

It might well be so. All I am saying is that a Member of the Oireachtas had the courtesy of inviting me to a meeting I could not attend on Monday last and I contacted Mr. Niall Quinn stating that I would be happy to invite them in here. I spoke to the clerk to the committee about it. What I am getting at is there is a great deal of goodwill out there. I want to make this point clearly. There is a crisis in the football association and I want to make sure that everybody who wants to have an input has a vehicle for doing that. Perhaps through here might be the way.

The question on the crisis management is that while I have every confidence both in the Minister and in Sport Ireland, in reference to Deputy Catherine Murphy's point, if there are any additional skills and expertise needed, these should be made available and the Minister should find a way to get these to them.

The other point is one I made earlier. I acknowledge the wish of the Minister to meet UEFA before Christmas. The fact that the meeting will not take place until 14 January concerns me. That is not a criticism. It seems the quicker that meeting can take place, the better. The downside of all of this is coming at us like an express train. Any time that is lost in getting a solution worries me. UEFA needs to be at the table. It needs to be there now. I agree with the Minister of State that it should meet him before Christmas. This will not get better. It will get worse. The implications for the national team, the league and young people are considerable.

Comment on this

We have tried to meet it.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

There is open and ongoing communication between the FAI and UEFA on an ongoing basis. It gives some reassurance. We are keen and if they can meet us before 14 January, the offer is open to meet before then.

Comment on this

We will adjourn sine die, that is, after Christmas. We will meet as soon as possible if the FAI states it will come in. I thank everybody, particularly our staff. I thank the Minister of State, Sport Ireland and all my colleagues and friends.

Comment on this