We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).

Contributions 1–148 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Government Bill 1924
Withdrawn

No. 18 of 1924 ›

I beg to move Amendment No. 26, which reads:

Before sub-section (1) to insert a new sub-section as follows:

"(1) (a) a common lodging house shall for the purpose of the Public Health Acts and all other Acts, applicable thereto be defined to mean a lodging house, the valuation of which shall not exceed the sum of £15 if situated in the City of Dublin, £12 if situated in any of the cities of Cork, Limerick or Waterford, and £10 if situated elsewhere;

(b) a boarding house shall be defined to mean all other houses, excluding hotels, as hereinafter defined which carry on the business of letting a furnished room or rooms in apartments whether with or without board or service;

(c) hotels shall mean any premises with ten bedrooms and upwards, including boarding houses as hereinbefore defined, which shall be set apart exclusively for the accommodation of guests;

(d) no common lodging house shall after the passing of this Act let rooms or beds or permit or suffer the same to be let unless the lodging house shall have been registered as defined by the Public Health Acts;

(c) no boarding house shall within one month after the passing of this Act carry on the business of boarding house or shall let to any person or persons any room or rooms, beds, or apartments in any boarding house unless the same shall have been inspected, certified and registered in manner hereinafter appearing."

Perhaps it would save time if I speak now on this and the amendment following it on the Order Paper?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Just state the substance of the amendments.

Comment on this

My first amendment is simply to define what apparently has never been defined, either in the laws of this country or in the laws of Great Britain; that is, what a common lodging house really is. Under the Act of 41 and 42 Vie., Chap. 52, a common lodging house is defined as meaning "houses in which, or in part of which, persons are harboured or lodged for hire for one night or for less than a week at a time." That, I submit, is exceedingly vague and might include under its scope first-class hotels. The amendment I put down is defining a common lodging house in the words stated in the amendment. The definitions that are set forth in my amendment are, I think, sufficiently clear, and they call for the serious attention of the Seanad and the Government. I was glad to hear the Minister making observations yesterday, or the day before, to the effect that no subject had made greater advances in the recent past than the science that treats of the prevention of diseases.

It is a matter of great and far-reaching importance to this country, to our friends across the Channel, and even our friends at the other side of the Atlantic, that boarding houses, lodging houses, etc., should be under suitable inspection and registered. It is largely, as far as boarding houses are concerned, voluntary action at the present time. The matter has claimed very close attention in some districts, and has led to a considerable outlay on the part of localities. Amongst the other things that have brought the importance of these matters to the minds of the people in my district has been the action of the United States of America. The United States of America for some years past have had their attention very seriously drawn to the need of inspection and registration of houses, not only in the neighbourhood of the great port of Cobh, but in other parts of Ireland. Two years ago they sent over to Cobh a representative, paid for by the American Treasury. They have instituted a place there, and they have gone to considerable trouble in the erection and fitting of buildings there, through which people emigrating to the United States have to pass to be inspected. The different American lines of steamers have also appointed a medical representative to look on and confirm the action taken by the American medical representative. This is entirely voluntary and at no cost to the State. What is called for now is some official appointment.

Notwithstanding what I have just mentioned, emigrants have gone on board and have been taken as far as New York, and when they reach that destination it is well known that in some cases they are found infected with lice, etc., which my friend, Senator O'Sullivan, President of the Irish Medical Association, sitting behind me, will, I am sure, confirm, are the carriers of the dreadful disease of typhus and also of other diseases promoted through incubation. The Government of the United States feel that there is a tremendous risk from people going into their country. Perhaps, after a fortnight walking about the streets of Boston or New York, typhus might break out amongst them. It might lead to the closing of the port of Cobh, so far as shipping for the South of Ireland is concerned, if epidemics of the kind could be attributed to Ireland.

Moreover, over-crowding in some of the houses in which people going abroad have to lodge before sailing, is extremely dangerous. I do not now speak of the South of Ireland only. I refer as well to Limerick and the West of Ireland, the districts of Connaught and elsewhere. In these places there is considerable over-crowding. Incidents have been told to me where several people have been put into the one bed, and then perhaps the moment they leave it another train comes in and more people are put into the same bed. In some cases I believe as many as three people have been known to be put into one bed. I do not suggest that there is any such thing as immorality, but the thing is an evil all the same. All these things call for legislation of a very important character. I beg to move the amendment.

Comment on this
Séamus Aloysius Bourke MINISTER for LOCAL GOVERNMENT and PUBLIC HEALTH (Mr. Burke) Cumann na nGaedheal

I think the Seanad generally are unanimous in agreeing with Senator Haughton that our sanitary laws require some, little lubrication or some stimulus so as to put them into more effective operation at the present time. I am afraid, however, that Senator Haughton's amendment is not going exactly the right way about it. The difficulty with the present sanitary code is that it has not been put into effective operation. Legislation is there. We have very ample powers for insisting on the registration of lodging-houses and for seeing that those lodging-houses are inspected with a view to preventing overcrowding and uncleanliness, and a generally unsatisfactory condition as regards sanitation. We have all those powers. We have ample powers for dealing with nuisances and for permitting us to inspect those houses whenever it is felt necessary to do so.

Senator Haughton starts off with a definition of common lodging and boarding houses. I am afraid if we insert such a definition into a Bill like this, it will seriously conflict with the legislation that has gone before. The present public health code is extended over numerous Orders and Statutes that have been going on for the last 50 years or more, and common lodging and boarding houses have had their particular meaning under those various Orders and Statutes. If we now introduce a different meaning at this stage, it will bring about endless confusion and difficulty in the carrying out of the laws. Senator Haughton restricts the definition of a lodging or boarding house to a house of less than £15 valuation. That would classify all our large tenements in Dublin more or less as hotels. It is really in connection with those houses that the greatest need appears for sanitary inspection. If we were to go very fully into the definition, we would probably find several anomalies of that kind.

We have ample power to deal with the problem, but we are not able to make use of that power because the machinery is defective. When we have a medical officer of health in each county, and when we have sanitary machinery properly operating, we will get much more satisfactory results. If we fail to get satisfactory results, that will be the time for the introduction of new legislation to make up for any deficiency that may arise in our sanitary laws. I think it is very inadvisable to touch our sanitary code before it has got an opportunity of proving whether or not it is efficient.

Amendment put and negatived.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I take it, Senator Haughton, that disposes of the remaining amendments, standing in your name, to Section 18? They are all more or less consequential upon the amendment that has been negatived?

Comment on this

I am sorry to say that that is so.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Section 19, sub-section (1). Line 26. To delete the word "shall" and to substitute therefor the word "may."

The object of this amendment is to make it a voluntary matter for the county council to appoint a medical officer of health. In the Bill the word "shall" is used, and I want to substitute therefor the word "may." In certain counties, I believe, councils will object to the appointment of this whole-time officer. Probably some of them will consider that the £400 or £500 paid to the medical officer of health could be much better spent in other directions. The opinion prevails in many places that they cannot afford, until times improve, to make any new appointments. If this officer is appointed, of course he will be whole-time and possibly he will be a sort of local Czar. The county council will have very little control over him. He may make any rules or regulations he desires under the Act. I presume notices will then be served and solicitors will take the matter in hands. I am aware that in one small town in County Monaghan a house was condemned by the medical officer 20 years ago as unfit for human habitation; people are living in that house still.

Comment on this

You should get the Commissioners to attend to that.

Comment on this

That house was unfit for human habitation 20 years ago, and to-day, even though it is very insanitary, it is occupied. What can the council do? What alternative accommodation can be given to the occupier? Unless they put the people into the county home there is no alternative accommodation. There are no houses being built in any of the smaller towns. Under this Bill I presume the medical officer of health will have power to order the closing of an insanitary dwelling such as I have referred to. That would be considerably in advance of public opinion, I submit, and people will not stand for throwing those unfortunate occupants out on the road, until some other accommodation is provided elsewhere.

We should not ask county councils to make those appointments until they feel that the county finances would justify such action. Such a section as this is a considerable number of years before its time. Such a provision as is embodied in this section might be suitable for some places, but it would be very unsuitable for such places as Cavan, Monaghan and other counties.

It is very proper and we all agree that the sanitary laws should be enforced, but the people against whom they will be enforced are all very poor persons who are not able to rebuild their houses or put them into proper sanitary condition. I suppose the gentleman working under the county council will seek a definite order that every insanitary house will be rebuilt. But where will the money come from? It is out of the question to ask poor people to put their houses into proper sanitary order in a short time. If each county council had a discretion, probably after a number of years they would appoint these whole-time officers, but I think a discretion of that sort should be left to them.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You stated that the medical officer seemed to have absolute power. You may be quite right, but I cannot find anything in the section that enables him to override the views of the council. I cannot find he has any greater powers than the present medical officers of health, as the section apparently provides that he is given power to do such things as the council may, with the consent of the Minister, approve of. I cannot find that he has got these arbitrary powers that you stated, unless they are contained in another part of the Bill.

Comment on this

I do not say that they are in any other part of the Bill. But this county medical officer will be a whole-time officer. The present men, who are part-time officers, are the dispensary doctors, and know the whole extent of their district. This man will be a stranger. He will get an order from the board of health and his business will be to put into effect that closing order. The county board of health or the county council, as the case may be, composed of seven or eight men, will not sit down to analyse all his recommendations and orders will be issued to close up these premises.

Comment on this

I suppose I might as well say on this amendment what I was going to say in regard to the section generally, that is to ask the Minister to explain how he will stand in this matter, in a practical way. Up to now, as I understand it, the dispensary officers have been doing this work. The plan they work on is that they get a red ticket to go to some poor house where people are sick, perhaps with fever. When they go to the house they see that it is in a very unsanitary state, and perhaps the bed-clothes, where the man has fever, have to be destroyed. The medical officer then reports this to the relieving officers, and the thing is carried out at once. The bed-clothing and any other clothing, according to the doctor's orders, is destroyed, and the whole thing is done automatically, practically immediately, whereas now one medical officer is appointed for a whole county, or perhaps two for a county. I do not know how he will be able to inspect all those houses, unless he goes all over the county, putting his nose into every house that he has suspicion of. It seems to me that it will be a very difficult job, whereas it was hitherto done without any expense, because the medical officer visited these houses on other business. Now it will be a whole-time, separate job, and it will be a very expensive one. Very likely the Minister will explain how it is going to be done, but I do not see how it is going to be done, except at great cost. Of course I may not be very well informed.

Comment on this

I rise to oppose this amendment. I consider the appointment of a whole-time medical officer is the most important part of the Bill. Sanitary matters, as they were carried on during my time, and I have an experience of over 25 years, did not at all receive proper attention. Senator Colonel Moore is evidently confusing the dispensary medical officer with the medical officer of health. He may be the same individual, but the duties are entirely different. The duty of the sanitary sub-officer, who is at present the relieving officer, when he discovers places that are in an insanitary condition, is to report to the medical officer of health, who then' reports to the council. Frequently no action is taken. I welcome this Bill, if for nothing else than the appointment of a whole-time medical officer. I think it is absolutely necessary to have such an officer, and I think it would be futile and absurd without it. I speak as a medical officer with an experience of well over a quarter of a century.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I rise to support this amendment. I think this appointment should be permissive. I hope no one suggests that in supporting an amendment of this kind one is not solicitous for the health of the people. But the position is this: how in many cases can these very desirable measures of reform be made effective?

We know all these things. They are well known and they do not require a whole-time medical officer to deal with them. They are frequently reported, but, as Senator O'Rourke points out, if you do enforce the powers you possess, you turn the people out on the streets and perhaps into the workhouse. There is no other accommodation available. and this is bound up in the whole finance of housing. Until you can build alternative houses, it is futile to try to put these very desirable powers into effect. When you close these insanitary houses you may make an order on the owner to put them into repair. When owners, especially owners of small house property, are faced with the question of rebuilding or repairing, they will abandon the houses. My experience is that it is far more economical. It is quite impossible for an owner to expend money remuneratively on improvements, however desirable, so what is the alternative? He leaves the house empty. You cannot force him to spend money on it. The rents at present are very small and a large portion of these are taken up in the very inadequate repairs that are now done. I admit the repairs are inadequate in small towns in the country, and very often the houses are left derelict. Under the Rent Restriction Act the rates are payable by the owner. Well, the owner is not going to do that. His only alternative is to pull the house down sooner than pay the rates. That is the position you are faced with, and that is the position I believe you will be driven to. You may say it is very desirable that these houses should be pulled down, but if they are the situation would seem to be worse than before. You are going to drive these people you eject into the county homes or on to the streets, or create worse overcrowding elsewhere. Therefore, I feel, as Senator O'Rourke says, that this is in advance of the times. What is wanted is quite well known at present without the appointment of a whole-time medical officer, and it should be left to the county councils to act as they like in this matter.

Comment on this

I hope that the Seanad will reject this amendment. I think the objections to this proposal have been taken on rather a strange issue. The allegation seems to be that this medical officer of health will have some extraordinary power with the county council which the existing officers have not got. You, Sir, have pointed out that he would have no power over the county council at all in respect of the shutting up and pulling down of houses. He must act on their instructions and all he can do is to report and recommend; if the county council in its wisdom thinks that certain houses should remain as they are because of the circumstances of the time, there is nothing to prevent it from deciding accordingly. But surely to goodness he has duties to perform other than recommending that certain houses must be shut up. All over the country there must be a number of ways in which the enforcement of the sanitary laws, the prevention of disease and so forth, can be carried out other than by the shutting up of houses, and it would be deplorable, simply because the county council thought this man might be too well informed for them and might really brush up public health matters, that he should not be appointed.

I cannot understand Senator Sir John Keane and Senator O'Rourke saying that this is in advance of the times. When may we expect to have reached a period when the laws of sanitation shall be applied to the best of the ability of the people who are charged with public administration? In the twentieth century one would imagine that we had at least reached that elementary stage. There are certain situations in which compulsion must be used in the case of a reactionary county council. One has to use powers of compulsion to abate a public nuisance; you cannot allow a man next door to you in a city to keep pigs and generally to pollute the atmosphere; you cannot say: "Let us wait until that man's intellectual development has reached such a stage that he will see that it is undesirable in the interests of public health and common decency to do these things." Many county councils hereafter may be just as reactionary as their predecessors and may say that what Was good enough for their great-grandfathers is good enough for themselves and their families. I do not think we should allow this very important provision to be deleted simply because there may be here and there a county council, such as the County Council of Monaghan, who think they are quite good enough as they are, and that there is no need for improvement. The charge on a county will, I presume, be a farthing or a halfpenny in the £ at the very most, and the additional expense involved will be negligible compared with the benefits to be derived, without taking away from the prestige or the power of the councils, as was mentioned by Senator O'Rourke.

Comment on this

I do not think it is necessary to say very much after Senator O'Farrell's statement; I think he has dealt very fully with the whole position. This county medical officer is not to be a Sultan or a Czar over the heads of the county council. He will have to act according to their instructions in the ordinary course of events, and in any case it is to be assumed that he will be a man of ordinary common sense, and a man worthy of holding such a responsible position. An officer in a position of that kind will not insist on such a high standard of hygiene and sanitation in some backward portion of Connemara as, for instance, in one of the townships in South Dublin. He will use his discretion all along the line, and I do not anticipate that in very many cases an officer of this kind will find it necessary to condemn a house and insist on the inhabitants being turned out and the house pulled down. But in a great many cases while it will not be necessary for him to go that far, it might be necessary for him to insist on the house being whitewashed, or insist on some of the four-footed animals leaving, and preventing in that way the spread of typhus. That is one of the principal reasons for the recurrence of these typhus outbreaks in the West of Ireland, the fact that in many of these smaller cottages four-footed animals are allowed to stay.

This officer will not interfere with the functions of the ordinary medical practitioner that Senator Colonel Moore has referred to, nor with those of the sanitary sub-officer. He will co-ordinate their work, and he will be the driving force in the county who will see to it that work that heretofore was very badly carried out will be performed efficiently. I do not think there is any reason to anticipate any objection on the grounds of expense. The salary of such an officer spread over the whole county would amount to very little; as Senator O'Farrell says, probably about a farthing in the pound. I see that Senator Douglas has an amendment down which I hope the Seanad will be willing to accept, to allow the county medical officer to act for two counties if there are not sufficient duties for him in one. So that every possible safeguard is provided to see that the carrying out of these duties will not cost too much.

Comment on this

I should like to take the view of the Seanad on this. I think that these new councils to be elected shortly should have a little discretion. The appointment of a new whole-time officer at £400 or £500 a year will not be a very popular thing for them to do after facing the electors. In districts where the rates are largely paid by farmers the ratepayers are in a very bad position. A halfpenny in the £ is very small, but it is all halfpennies; if you take two or three dozen halfpennies it becomes a big thing. I do not think it is a very healthy thing to ask the new county councils as their first act to appoint a medical officer at £400 or £500 a year and to pension fourteen or fifteen other comparatively young men.

Comment on this

Well, they are the existing medical officers of health and their offices will be removed. I believe they will have to be pensioned, but that is a small matter. I think this provision is not fair to the new county councils.

Comment on this

I would like to ask a question, arising out of the remarks that have been made. Is the whole-time medical officer not to be appointed where there are already existing medical officers? To my mind the value of this Bill is the fact that he will be a whole-time medical officer. It will make him independent. Anyone practising in a district knows that there are times when he will be placed in the position in which I once found myself. I had a case of diphtheria in a dairy, and the father of the child was the proprietor of the dairy. If I closed the dairy where was my remuneration to come from? These questions will arise, and the value of the Bill is the independence of the medical officer. I hope that those that are already acting will be pensioned, because the expense is not at all a thing that can be measured with the value of the improvement in public health that should arise from this. We will never get to the period when the time will catch up with us if we wait in that way.

Comment on this

I move:—Line 28, after the words "as such" to insert the words "and possessing a diploma in public health from a recognised university or college for at least ten years prior to the date of the appointment."

This officer will occupy a very important position, and it is advisable that every safeguard should be taken to see that his qualifications will be of the highest. I advocate the principle that we adopted some time ago in selecting district justices and judges— that is, that they should be qualified for a certain period before they were appointed. I think the period which I have mentioned is a very moderate one, and in addition to the other qualifications that may be prescribed by the Minister it is desirable that we should insist that any person appointed should have a diploma of public health from a recognised university or college.

Comment on this

I have to oppose this amendment. All medical men know very well that the diploma of public health, say of ten years ago, was more ornamental than useful. The examination has of late got more strict, and it is becoming progressively more difficult to get a diploma now. A medical officer of one year's standing, with the D.P.H., would be better than a man of ten years' standing. You might select a man of ten years' standing with a D.P.H. who was in private practice and who knows nothing about public health matters. I would agree with Senator Linehan if during the ten years he did nothing but public health matters. I am afraid that if we adopt this amendment we may get men who are more or less antique in public health matters.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

What you object to is the provision about the ten years. You want that left out.

Comment on this

I think, as the thing stands in the Bill, it is all right.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

I support that amendment. Surely in this matter it is not a question as to the technique necessary. It is far more a question of experience of the world to deal with those problems of psychology and of human relations which the latest graduate from some college is quite unfitted to handle. If you insist on qualification in judicial matters and on experience, why should you not insist on experience in a case like this? To a layman, it is hard to conceive that the value of the whole-time medical officer will turn on his academic qualifications. Really, is it necessary for his duties that he should possess the very highest scholastic qualifications? Is it not more necessary that he should have experience of the world, of dealing with people, and a certain personality and presence, which largely comes from experience, by which he can meet and deal with the councils which he will serve? Above all, how can you expect a young man who has just left his teens and who is fresh from some college, to be able to fill a position of that kind in a proper manner?

Comment on this

It seems to me that if you read the Bill closely you will find that the qualifications are left more or less at the discretion of the Minister. I am not very keen on the question of a diploma, because I have frequently found people predominating in college who do not so predominate in the community outside, and it does not take an extremely technical or involved diploma to estimate the sanitary condition of any house. One's nose is nearly qualified to do that. We need not have a mature diploma of 10 years' standing or any diploma at all. It is impossible to go through a medical curriculum, which now takes seven years, without being able to estimate whether a house is fit for human habitation or not.

Comment on this

I rise to support the amendment. People living in the provinces, especially poor people, are entirely dependant for their medical attendance when sick on the local dispensary doctor. We who have county council and public body experience know how strings are pulled in an election of medical officer. Merit, qualification, experience and personality are of no consideration at all, with the deplorable result that nearly all the poor dispensary clientele are sometimes neglected. A very admirable course has recently been taken by the Ministry by the setting up of a Selection Board in making appointments of a serious character of that nature. This Board is composed of qualified medical men, representing medical schools and bodies in the city, each coming from his own affiliated society or association, all men of the highest qualifications. I was appointed as chairman of such a body. I had simply to sit there and listen, and I was delighted to find the spirit in which these men approached the analysis of the qualifications of those candidates who presented themselves. They did not want to know their names. They made that a first condition. They gave them numbers, went through their papers, and they said the public are entitled to the very best man—a man of experience, personality and character— who applied for the position. The result is that every satisfaction has been given. It is a new departure, and it has given admirable results. Applying that principle here, I say some such course should be followed. I say the inevitable result, which comes from personal canvassing, of getting the worst man, should be avoided as far as possible. Under any rule made here the result should be that the very best man must secure the position.

Comment on this

I am in rather a difficult position. I am in favour of the necessity for a diploma of public health, but I agree with Senator O'Sullivan that the ten years' period is rather long. I think it is quite possible for a competent local authority under the section to elect an officer to the position who would not have a diploma. That, to my mind, would be a disaster. The section is rather vague, and I think it would do no harm to put in an amendment requiring the possession of the diploma of public health. I move in section 19, sub-section (1), line 28, after the words "as such" to insert the words "and possessing a diploma in public health from a recognised university or college."

Comment on this

I wonder would it be possible to provide a panel, to be arranged by some expert board, from which these medical officers might be selected. The selection of county medical officers and dispensary doctors seems to be a very big responsibility to place on a body of laymen. After all, I suppose the medical profession is the most important profession in existence, as it attends to the well-being of the human frame. It is a desperate responsibility to leave the selection of members of that profession for public positions to a body of laymen who have no knowledge of medical science. In addition, elected bodies are open to considerable influence, particularly in country districts. The present system, we know, has become a public scandal, and the results have been deplorable. I have been told of a case of a medical officer of a county infirmary. He was able to carry out fairly serious operations, and the people of the county could go to the infirmary for treatment. The position became vacant, and it is alleged that, through extraneous influence, a man was appointed to the position who was utterly incapable of dealing with the same class of cases, with the result that everybody who can afford it now has to come to Dublin, and those who cannot afford to do so have to go without treatment, with serious consequences in some cases. The county council may have made that appointment with the very best intentions, and still have made a mistake. I was wondering if it would be possible to have a large panel of competent medical men, whose names would be before county councillors and members of boards of health, and from whom it would be possible to select a man, and to say that he is qualified, whatever else might be said against him. I do not know whether that is practicable or not, or whether abuse might not creep in. But I think it would be a better way of making a selection than leaving it to people who have absolutely no knowledge of medical science.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The amendment proposes to insert the words set out on the Order Paper. Since then an amendment to that amendment has been proposed by Senator Bennett to omit the words "at least ten years prior to the date of the appointment."

Comment on this

I submit that until my amendment be disposed of no other amendment is in order.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is not quite right. If your amendment was ruled out, then Senator Bennett would be deprived of an opportunity of moving his amendment. If your amendment is carried, it would be open to Senator Bennett to move that it be amended by omitting the concluding words. However, we had better hear what the Minister has to say before putting the question.

Comment on this

I assume that we are dealing with Senator Linehan's original amendment. Senator Dr. O'Sullivan has pointed out that the D.P.H. of, say, 10 years ago, is rather an obsolete qualification to-day, and I consider that it would not be a qualification which would entitle a man to hold a position of this kind. It is a qualification that is becoming more difficult to obtain every year, and a man who qualified a year or two ago would be much more capable, from the standpoint of sanitary science, than a man who qualified ten years ago. For that reason it would be inadvisable to entertain this amendment. I think we should rather regard this officer as being an executive and an administrative officer, than a man highly qualified technically. He will be a man who will require driving force. He will have to be somewhat of a leader of men—a man who can have his way in the county, and who will be able to influence the various people he will come in contact with, and I feel that it will be a very difficult thing to get men of that stamp. He will be much more than a highly qualified medical officer; he will be a first-class executive officer. I anticipate that we will have great difficulty in getting men of that calibre.

Senator O'Farrell has mentioned that it would be a good thing to have some body other than the county councils to determine who shall get those appointments. It has been the practice recently to nominate selection boards in connection with the appointment of officers for all these positions, and I hope to adhere to that practice in the appointment of these officers, and to see that no man will be appointed who has not been approved by a selection board, composed of competent medical men in a position to appraise his qualifications. In practice, I do not believe that you will have anybody appointed who has not the D.P.H. That is, judging things from the present standard, but I do not know how things may vary in the future. It is just possible that you might have a man with high qualifications in other respects who did not happen to possess the D.P.H., and it might be inadvisable to rule him out. I have been in touch with the Rockefeller Foundation, who are dealing with public health all over the world. They have agreed to allow three fellowships to Irish medical practitioners, on condition that they get appointments. I consider that a fellowship of this kind would be of great value. The holders would be entitled to receive a course extending from six months to eight months, and these men would be very highly qualified. I think that a man who had gone through a course of that kind would probably be better qualified to take up a position of this class than a man possessing the ordinary D.P.H. That is one of the reasons that make it inadvisable to lay down hard and fast rules, and I think it would be better not to insist upon this qualification.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I will now put the original amendment, as it appears on the Order Paper.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 4
·
Níl 30
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Do you wish me to put your amendment now, Senator Bennett?

Comment on this

I think it would be well to have some such insertion, as I suggest, in the Bill. In fact, I think it would be essential. I am moved, too, by what the Minister said about such things. After all, people will know that these appointments are coming on, and I am sure it will be felt by every young medical practitioner that he should try to get this diploma.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

With regard to the selection board appointed to select the names of medical officers to be put before the county council, may I ask the Minister who is to compose that selection board?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not see that there is any provision made for a selection board. The appointment is to be made by the county council itself and not by a selection committee of that body. Of course, by consent or arrangement, I suppose the county council could set up a committee of their own and call it a selection board, but, as far as I can see, there is no obligation on them to do that. Of course I may be wrong.

Comment on this

We have got the power to sanction, and we can refuse to sanction the appointment of an officer if he fails to pass the selection board. This selection board is more or less in the experimental stage at the present time, but as time goes on we intend to stereotype it. The last selection board we had gave very great satisfaction indeed. It acted on several occasions, and was composed of representatives of the three teaching bodies of the medical profession—Trinity College, the College of Surgeons and the National University, with Senator Kenny as the representative of the General Council of County Councils. Dr. Dixon represented Trinity, Sir Arthur Chance the College of Surgeons, and Dr. McLoughlin the National University.

Comment on this

Is it compulsory on doctors appointed to positions as county medical officers of health to pass this selection board? I am anxious to know that, because the Bill does not say that it is.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No. I understand the way it works out is this. There is nothing in this Bill, or any other Act that I know of, requiring the county council to take first the opinion of the selection board. The Local Government Department apparently think they have the power—they are probably right, and I do not question it for a moment—to say to a county council: "We will not sanction any appointment made by you unless he has been recommended by the selection board." In that way the thing can be worked out, I presume, legally, but I pronounce no opinion on it.

Comment on this

On the other hand, that will lead, as it has led in the past, to a conflict between the Local Government Department and the appointing authority.

Comment on this

Arising out of the remarks of Senator O'Farrell and Senator Kenny, might I suggest a further addition to Senator Bennett's amendment? The addition I suggest is to vest the appointment in the hands of the Minister and of the selection board. I am afraid I have made myself somewhat prominent in calling attention to various scandals—they are nothing short of scandals—which have taken place in many parts of the country. I think there is a great deal in what Senator Colonel Moore has said. If the Minister waits until the county council have appointed someone—he may be a very improper person-and then refuses his sanction to the appointment, it will lead to a conflict between the Minister and the county council. If the appointment, in the first instance, were vested in the Minister and in the selection board, it would meet the points raised by some Senators. It would be very desirable, I think, to do that. It would help, too, to minimise the amount of corruption that goes on in many places in connection with some of these public appointments. If the Minister sees no objection, I will propose the addition I have suggested to the amendment moved by Senator Bennett.

Comment on this

I rise to support the amendment moved by Senator Bennett. In addition to the qualification of D.P.H., I think the Senator should include in his amendment the diploma of sanitary science conferred by some of the Universities. That is a very high qualification, and if it were omitted it would mean that graduates possessing it would be excluded from appointments to be made under this Bill. As a matter of fact, I think it is a much better qualification than the D.P.H., and I urge its inclusion in the amendment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Do you see any objection to the addition of that to your amendment, Senator Bennett?

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

I think it is very desirable that we should have this diploma in sanitary science recognised under the Bill.

Comment on this

As there are a great many subjects turning on this amendment, and as the Minister, I think, is sympathetic towards some alteration or change, he might, on Report Stage, bring up an amendment that would cover the whole ground that has been touched on to-day.

Comment on this

I was going to suggest to the Minister that between this and the Report Stage he should consider very carefully whether he has power to make it a condition of the appointment of medical officers that such persons should be chosen by a panel of this selective committee.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I have my doubts.

Comment on this

The only way it can come in is under sub-section (1) of section 19:—"The council of every county shall appoint, with the approval of the Minister for every county health district in such county, a medical practitioner duly qualified as such, and with such other qualifications as may be prescribed." Being selected from, or on a panel of this kind is not strictly a qualification, and I doubt if he would have power under this sub-section to prescribe that as one of the qualifications. I think he should consider that carefully.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it would be wise for the Minister to consider the suggestion made, I think, by Senator Barrington, whether he would not put in a provision that the person to be appointed should be one of the panel appointed by the Minister, but on the advice of the Council of the College of Surgeons and Physicians, or something of that sort.

Comment on this

Following Senator the Earl of Mayo's question, if we had a motion suggesting that the Minister should supply himself with a selection committee, would not the selection of that committee give the Minister power to appoint?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If you put it into the Bill that there was to be a selection committee it would, but there is very serious doubt whether in the absence of a special provision in the Bill the Minister, as such, would have inherent powers to say, "You must have a committee of selection."

Comment on this

If it were a committee of selection empanelled from medical practitioners it would give people an assurance that those who knew the job were more or less able to select candidates, and at the same time it would take away any question of doubt, such as Senator Brown sees may arise with regard to the Minister's powers.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Possibly the Minister might think it well to let the matter stand over and think upon it between this and the Report Stage. He would be well advised, I think, in the meantime to consult Senators O'Sullivan and Gogarty on the matter. They have very great experience.

Comment on this

There are several propositions put forward on this amendment. One, by Senator Bennett, makes a panel of selection and leaves it in the hands of the Minister.

Comment on this

No, no; I never said anything of that kind.

Comment on this

No, but I think some other Senator did, and it is in regard to this selection power that I wish to take issue. If you have a panel of selection and submit that to the county council which has charge of the doctor, they are going to appoint, I think it is right to pick from that panel one from the two or three that may be sent up. But I think, if you allow the Minister to interfere with the power of selection of the one on the panel, it will only lead to friction in the elected bodies.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I had in mind only the panel of recommendation.

Comment on this

Let there be a panel made by the county council and let the Minister be satisfied with knowing that the candidate selected has the necessary qualification, but if the Minister is to have the sole appointment then goodbye to local administration.

Comment on this

I think we are all fairly well agreed upon the general principle that we are seeking in this matter. I had hoped some Senator would move an amendment which would put this whole matter of selecting candidates for appointment on a proper basis, but when we started hammering out the terms of the amendment we found it ran practically into a new Bill, and I think it will take up a great deal of time.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If you let it stand over till the Report Stage possibly I might be able to put it in a few lines. It is not a matter that should be rushed at all. You should have plenty of time to consider it, and it would not be reasonable to suggest that you should finally decide now. I think the most convenient plan would be to have it brought up on the Report Stage and if the Committee agree to that we will let it stand over until then.

Comment on this

I beg to move in Section 19, sub-section (5), line 56, to delete the word "expert." I think the word "expert" is unnecessary.

Comment on this

I think the word "expert" is necessary, but that the word "medical" is unnecessary. Expert advice relates to public health and not to the treatment, say, of disease.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would it be better to leave out both the words "expert" and "medical," and say "where advice is required"?

Comment on this

The advice is as to public health and not advice as to surgical or other treatment.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The present proposal is to leave out the word "expert."

Comment on this

I will fall in with any suggestion made by the President of the Irish Medical Association.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then, with the leave of the House, you substitute for your amendment the omission of the word "medical."

Comment on this

Expert advice really relates to public health.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think that these words are necessary, because the gentleman in question is an expert in public health. He is the public health officer and, of course, his advice would only be asked on matters relating to public health.

Comment on this

That is not so. I know public boards very well. They might ask for advice as to treatment— whether such a patient might be sent to a certain hospital. I want to put that outside the pale.

Comment on this

You would also put sanitary matters outside it.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Sanitary matters would, of course, be included in public health.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then it would read "where expert advice is required on matters affecting public health."

Comment on this

I would prefer to leave it as it stands in the Bill, or to accept Senator Haughton's amendment as it was. I think Senator O'Sullivan rather complicates the issue. The county medical officer would be responsible for the curative as well as the preventative side of disease. His duties are not allocated yet, and it may be possible that this would cut out portion of the duties put upon him in some counties. I prefer to be left some little discretion.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The main objection which the Minister sees to this is that the medical officer might say: "I am only appointed to advise you on matters affecting public health, and I refuse to advise on other matters." As the Minister says, there might be a variety of questions on which his advice might be desirable.

Comment on this

A medical officer of health is not responsible for the curative side of disease.

Comment on this

He might have duties in regard to tuberculosis, and he might differentiate between them.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

There is objection to your amendment, Senator O'Sullivan, in so far as it would indicate that his advice would be limited.

Comment on this

I want to limit his advice to matters relating to public health. He must not have anything to do with the treatment of disease, as he would then step in on the domain of other men.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Could it not be put in such a form of words as, for instance, "excluding advice on individual cases." His abstract opinion as to whether treatment is good in regard to tuberculosis might be desirable, but it might be undesirable for him to say that it should be treated in a particular way.

Comment on this

There is the tuberculosis officer to advise on tuberculosis in most counties.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Would the situation be met if these words were adopted: "on any matter affecting the health of the county or district"?

Comment on this

I agree with that.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Then the section would read: "where expert advice is required on matters affecting the health of the county or district."

Comment on this

I move:

In Section 19, sub-section (6), line 62, to delete the words "performance of his duties" and to substitute therefor the words "service of one or more local authorities."

The sub-section as it stands would confine the county medical officer of health to the performance of his duties in one county health district. A county health district under the Bill excludes every urban district in the county, and it would further prevent the county officer of health from also being the officer to advise and take care of the public health in urban districts. That system seems to me to be very wasteful, because there should be nothing to prevent a county officer of health from attending to matters of public health in one or two urban districts. In a county like Kildare or Carlow it may be possible that one county officer of health could very easily do the two counties, and that would be a practical and economical provision.

Comment on this

I support the amendment. I think it should be mandatory on urban councils to contribute towards the services of a medical officer of health, but as the clause stands it is not mandatory. They could apply and get his services if they wish. The part of the county that requires a medical officer of health, especially, is an urban district, as the housing conditions in the lanes and back streets of most towns are appalling. The conditions under which people live are desperate, and are the cause of a good deal of the disaffection in the country, as well as a good deal of disease. I think it ought to be mandatory on urban district councils to employ a medical officer of health.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I am not disputing that, but the amendment will not have that effect, as it only makes it permissive but not mandatory on them.

Comment on this

I am only throwing out a hint that it ought to be mandatory.

Comment on this

To a layman it is difficult to see how the amendment alters the position in the Bill. The sub-section reads: "A county medical officer of health shall not engage in private duties and shall devote his whole time to the performance of his duties." He might work under three councils and still confine himself to the performance of his duties. The amendment says that he shall devote the whole of his time to one or more local authorities, but he would still be confining himself to the performance of his duties. There may be some legal subtlety in this.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think there is, as I found the same difficulty as you.

Comment on this

The term "local authority" is defined in Section 1 of the Bill as:—

"A county council, county or other borough council, urban district council, rural district council, board of guardians, or the commissioners of any town."

If you insert the words suggested, "service of one or more local authorities" in lieu of "performance of his duties," it will be one of these five local authorities which are the local authorities that can exist in a county.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

The point that Senator O'Farrell made will remain, that if a gentleman is acting for forty counties he is still performing his duties. If you said that no matter who or what he is, he is to spend his whole time in the performance of his duties, that will cover his duties whether they include an urban district or a county.

Comment on this

As the sub-section stands he can only perform his duties in the one county health district. That would exclude him from performing any duty in an urban district or in another district of the same county.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think as the section stands, and so long as the officer is acting for a county, he has to spend his time performing his duty, and if he is acting for two counties he equally performs his duties if he attends to both.

Comment on this

The county health officer must be appointed to one county health district. That is stated under a previous section.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

You do not alter that by this side wind.

Comment on this

You cannot appoint him to another county, and an urban district could not appoint him to be a medical officer of their district.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

What is the effect of the addition of these words and how can the amendment accomplish that?

Comment on this

It permits him to be appointed to any urban district or by any other local authority as defined in the Bill.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I am afraid it does not confer any such jurisdiction. If you want to do that it should be done in express language. You cannot possibly say in this way that the same gentleman appointed under Section 19 as health officer of a county is given power also by the amendment to accept the position of medical officer of an urban district. You could not do it in that indirect way and the words in the amendment would not have that effect. If there is another section which says that a county health officer may be also health officer of an urban district, then the amendment would work. Senator Brown has considered it, I have not.

Comment on this

The alternative suggestion would include not only an urban district but every local authority in a county.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Certainly.

Comment on this

I will undertake to have a section to that effect drafted and brought up on the Report Stage.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it is essential, as I am quite sure a court would say that these words of yours could not per se confer jurisdiction to appoint this gentleman to other local bodies in the county.

Comment on this

I follow that, but as was stated, this would prevent them.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I do not think the other alters the position at all. All it says is, that he is to perform his duties. If his duties under this Bill include serving local authorities, then the duties under sub-section (6) include the duties of the local authority.

Comment on this

It would if there was an additional section.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It will require an additional section.

Comment on this

In dealing with an earlier section in connection with the same matter it was stated that two counties could combine to engage the services of one medical officer. If the words suggested now were adopted it would prevent counties combining.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If there is a provision that two counties could combine that is only a provision for conferring dual jurisdiction on the medical officer of health. Any proposal now brought in would require amendment of that section.

Comment on this

Surely the whole object of this section is that the county medical officer will not engage in private practice.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is so. Whether he is an officer of one or ten districts, he is to give his whole time. The amendment would certainly not confer power under the Bill to extend the services of this gentleman from the county to the local authority. That would require legislation.

Comment on this

I understood there was a suggestion that if a man was appointed medical officer of health for a county he could say: "I am in the county and I am not going to serve the urban district." Senator O'Sullivan said that it is in the urban districts the medical officer's services are most necessary.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That is not the point. I understand that under the Bill as framed the county medical officer of health is not necessarily medical officer of the urban district.

Comment on this

He cannot be.

Comment on this

We want him to be.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Exactly. You cannot do that by this amendment. If you want him to be medical officer of the urban district you must take power in the Bill to appoint him to the dual position.

Comment on this

That is very important. Can it not be put into the Bill now?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think it ought to be.

Comment on this

Why should not the medical officer of health for a county be free to act in the urban district if they come to an agreement?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

That would depend on the amendment that is to be introduced.

Comment on this

I think that should be done, as some urban districts could not afford to pay a whole-time medical officer.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It would require an amendment to the effect that every person appointed medical officer of health for a county or an urban district under this Bill shall, if so required by the Minister, also serve as medical officer for other districts, as the case may be.

Comment on this

Does not sub-section (2) of Section 19 deal with that?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

No, that is only where a district covers two counties. Some urban districts have part of their territory in one county and part in another. I think Athlone is such a case. This would require a special section, I think.

Comment on this

I think we had better leave this matter over for the introduction of an amending section making it mandatory on every urban district council to have a medical officer of health. We could consider it with the Minister between now and the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I think we had better leave the matter over until the Report Stage. So far as urban councils are concerned I think they are included in sub-section (2). If that is read in conjunction with sub-section (1) it will be quite clear. Perhaps this amendment will not give the power we require with regard to appointing a medical officer of health for two or more counties.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

I think not.

Comment on this

I think, perhaps, it would be well to leave it over till the Report Stage.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

Will the Minister also consider this aspect, that some contribution should be made by the urban district towards the expenses of this whole-time officer. It is only right that the urban districts should make a contribution towards the salary.

Comment on this

Sub-section (3) deals with that. A demand can be made on an urban council for that contribution.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

It is not quite clear, because it says the salary is to be paid by the county council. The obligation is thrown on them.

Comment on this

"And shall be charged on the area for which he acts." The county council may strike the rate in part for the rural districts and in part for the urban districts.

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

If the officer is acting for both there is a little ambiguity which might lead to trouble and conflict. However, this can also be looked after when the amending section is being brought in. At present the position is not clear in the case of a gentleman who would be acting for two county councils or for one county council and perhaps all the urban boroughs.

Comment on this

Perhaps it would be better if the sub-section were allowed to stand as it is at present. I, therefore, withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Before we pass from this section, I would like to know if anything can be done for the provision of district nurses under this Bill?

Comment on this
AN CATHAOIRLEACH

Of course there is no objection to the Minister replying to that question.

Comment on this

In the congested districts, in the West of Ireland particularly, the provision of district nurses is a matter of the utmost importance. As it is, there is something of a struggle even to keep one district nurse by voluntary contributions and under Lady Dudley's nursing scheme. The difficulties are great, and it is of the utmost importance that some provision in this respect should be made.

Comment on this

I believe we are subsidising those nurses under schemes for maternity and child welfare, and we are giving them every encouragement we can at present. I do not think it is necessary to put anything in that respect into the Bill we are now considering.

Comment on this

Is the subsidy sufficient to pay the nurses? That is a matter that to my mind is really more important in some districts in the West than even the question of doctors.

Comment on this

I beg to move:—

Immediately before Section 20 to insert a new section as follows:

"20.—(1) Every sanitary authority shall appoint, with the approval of the Minister, for their sanitary district one or more persons registered under the Veterinary Surgeons Act, 1881, to be veterinary inspectors for such district.

(2) Every such veterinary inspector shall be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878.

(3) This section shall not come into effect until the appointed day."

I am asking the Seanad to include under the terms of this Bill some little recognition for the veterinary profession. So far, veterinary surgeons have not been referred to in any part of the Bill. In the past, under most of the rural district councils, veterinary surgeons were appointed to carry out duties pertaining to public health in addition to duties relating to live stock. In some of the poorer districts in the West of Ireland, persons other than veterinary surgeons were appointed by the rural district councils to carry out those duties. I would ask the Minister to include this provision in the Bill to make arrangements, when appointments are being made in connection with the inspection of live stock, meat, and milk, to have those duties carried out by veterinary surgeons.

There is a further reason why I am anxious the Seanad would help the veterinary profession. Since the advent of motor cars, and since the departure of many rich people from Ireland— people who heretofore were the patrons of the veterinary surgeons—it is very difficult, indeed, for the country veterinary surgeon to get a living. If the little local jobs that were given to the veterinary surgeons by various sanitary authorities are taken from them, there would be little or no inducement for a local veterinary surgeon to remain in a county, and the poor people who have stock that may become affected with some disease will be obliged to fall back on quacks or local chemists if they want to have their animals treated.

At various times the Minister for Lands and Agriculture told us of the value of live stock to Ireland. We are frequently informed that it is the main source of Irish wealth, and it is the main hope of Ireland in the future. We can congratulate ourselves in Ireland on having escaped the scourge of foot and mouth disease which is raging in every country in Europe. We ought to be grateful to the veterinary profession, the members of which have watched carefully in order to avoid Irish herds becoming affected. For those reasons I ask the Seanad to adopt this new section. I am sure the members of the veterinary profession will be very grateful to the Seanad for this recognition.

Comment on this

I desire to support this new section. There is nothing more important in the matter of public health than the inspection of meat and milk, and the methods of production of meat and milk. To do this adequately, I think it must be admitted that the veterinary surgeon is the only person competent. Under this Bill it is quite possible that a veterinary surgeon will be so appointed; but if this new section were adopted, it would make it more certain that duties of that type would be carried out by veterinary surgeons. Under the Inspection of Dairies Order, a veterinary surgeon is appointed for each county.

If this new section were passed and a veterinary surgeon were appointed for the duties referred to, possibly the same man might combine the two offices, and such an arrangement could be made between the Local Government Department and the Department of Agriculture. That could be made a workable arrangement. Apropos of this matter, in view of what has been revealed as to the way in which certain veterinary surgeons, who were appointed veterinary tuberculosis officers did, or rather did not, carry out their duties, I would like to throw out a word of warning to authorities to the effect that if they instituted some system of supervision which would be a little more drastic, probably these things would not occur.

Comment on this
John Keane Sir JOHN KEANE Independent

In this matter we have to watch very carefully the interests of the ratepayers. For the life of me, I cannot see why a whole-time medical officer could not examine milk or meat. I really doubt very much if it is a veterinary officer's job at all; that is a doubtful point. I feel that a whole-time medical officer is quite competent to pronounce a decision in regard to the quality of meat and milk. If this question of a whole-time veterinary officer is going to be considered, it must be considered, I suggest, in all its aspects; otherwise we would be faced with the position of having one veterinary officer not a whole-time officer, and another veterinary officer specially appointed ad hoc for those sanitary duties. We would be having one veterinary officer appointed under this provision for sanitary duties, and another veterinary officer appointed under the Diseases of Animals Act. In such circumstances we will have really a multiplicity of officials thrust upon the already hard-pressed ratepayers.

The matter cannot, in such a fashion, be decently dealt with. If it is to be handled at all it must be handled in its entirety and from the point of view of having one expert doing all the work and not simply doing portions of the work in one area, irrespective of under what Acts the duties are imposed. I would ask that we should look more at the matter from the ratepayers' point of view. That is the point of view that sooner or later will have to be faced by the Government and by everybody who seeks the franchise of the people.

Whether reasonably or unreasonably, the fact remains that the people generally are getting very anxious about this tendency towards the creation of appointments. They are not able to discern the niceties of those appointments, or how much money is spent in connection with them; their main consideration is the tendency to multiply officials. We should be careful not to encourage anything in that direction. We should see that officials are appointed with full regard to all the duties they have to perform. There should be no appointments piecemeal, and no appointments of large numbers of officials, all of whom might not be fully employed.

Comment on this
Earl of Mayo The EARL of MAYO Independent

I should like to support the amendment, because I think, with the mover of it and Senator MacLysaght, that it is very necessary that provision should be made in the Bill for the appointment of veterinary surgeons. The amendment states: "Every sanitary authority shall appoint, with the approval of the Minister." That is, of course, a saving clause. The Minister need not approve unless he likes.

Comment on this