SEANAD IN COMMITTEE. - LOCAL GOVERNMENT BILL, 1924.—THIRD STAGE (RESUMED).
Contributions 149–290 of 290. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 18 of 1924 ›
I am not quite sure of that, Senator. I think that only refers to the approval of the person selected. I think the section is mandatory as it stands and I think that the approval of the Minister only means that the person to be appointed under this section, as it stands, is to be a person approved of by him.
Comment on this
Very well, sir; let it be so then. I should like to point out, as Senator MacLysaght says, and as I know, that it is very important that a veterinary surgeon should be at the disposal of the poorer people who cannot afford to pay very large fees for doctoring their cattle and their horses. There are diseases in horses which require most careful looking after by competent veterinary surgeons. Sub-section 2 of the amendment says: "Every such veterinary inspector shall be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878." I have got the Act here. I have read the sections very carefully and I am afraid that cannot possibly be incorporated in the amendment, because I think it will run counter to the Bill. Leaving that out, I should like to support the amendment and to vote for the appointment of veterinary surgeons under this Bill.
With regard to what Senator Sir John Keane said, he always looks after our financial interests in a most careful way and I admire him for it. I listened most carefully the other day to his speech on finance. After all, these veterinary surgeons in a great many districts would be able, with the aid of motor cars, to cover very long distances. I notice that there is nothing in the amendment against engaging in private practice. With his private practice and the small salary he would have from the public authority, a veterinary surgeon would give most useful service to the public and would give great help in the carrying out of the provisions of the Bill, if the amendment was accepted. I beg to support it.
Comment on this
Whereas at present we have several sanitary authorities in the one county, under the Bill these sanitary authorities—the rural district councils—will be wiped out and we will have but one sanitary authority for the whole county, except in a few instances where large counties are to be divided.
I think it is very necessary to retain, at least for a time, the services of the various veterinary surgeons who are now distributed throughout the whole area. From a ratepayer's point of view there may be some economy in appointing one officer to cover the whole area, but what do you risk by that? At present you have these part-time officers serving the small sanitary areas —namely, the rural districts. You have them established in these areas. They know every cow and horse in the areas, as their ordinary private practice keeps them circling around there. If such an insidious disease as foot and mouth disease, or that other very terrible disease—I think it was called epizootic lymphangitis—or a disease like glanders broke out, it might result in the whole of the Free State being cut off. Formerly, when we were part of the British Isles, if an outbreak of disease occurred in, say, Tipperary, the Government under which we then existed would segregate the county of Tipperary; they would draw a line around it, and would prevent, for a time, cattle being removed from it. Now the Free State is a separate unit; we are a foreign territory, and I think that if foot and mouth disease makes its appearance in any part of Tipperary, Cork, or any other county, we will run the risk of having the whole Free State cut off. I am speaking in the interests of the ratepayers. I think the greatest precaution should be taken. That risk is there, and as it appears to me it would spell ruin for most of the farmers if a barrier were kept up for any length of time. That risk being there, I think it is absolutely imperative on us to do everything possible to detect diseases of this insidious character at the outset, and stamp them out before they get too far. These diseases in a very short time become rather widespread, and it is necessary to have every square yard of our territory under very close observation by men who are eminently qualified to detect the presence of any of these diseases as they occur. Until I considered very carefully the whole situation I took the view that one man, with the aid of a motor car might possible cover the whole area, but when I considered large counties like Cork and Waterford, I changed that view. The infection of one beast may be enough to affect cattle, horses or sheep throughout the whole country, and cut us off from the only market we have. Then I say it would be a very wise expenditure to try by every means to keep these veterinary surgeons in the areas where they are established, who formerly did veterinary work for the rural district councils under the Diseases of Animals Act. They also did duties of Inspectors under the Dairies and Cowsheds Order. These little appointments, together with such private practice as they could secure, enabled them to exist in their areas. Some of them now are at a very low ebb financially because of the times that we have passed through, and if their services are not retained under this Bill it will be imperative on them to leave their districts and go somewhere else in order to make a living.
Comment on this
I think Senator Kenny must have misunderstood me. My remarks were directed against unifying these two duties which arise under different Acts. In some districts the work of the Dairies and Cowsheds Order is done by a layman. That, undoubtedly, is perhaps undesirable, but it is equally undesirable that you should appoint a separate veterinary officer to do that work apart from the veterinary officer functioning under the Diseases of Animals Act. One man ought to do the two. I do not see how that can be effected by the amendment. The whole purpose of my remarks was to urge that the problem should be treated in its entirety and that the two Acts under which the duties arise should be considered, at the same time, in the creation of any veterinary officer functioning in any area.
Comment on this
I also feel that we should move very warily in this matter. There is no doubt that in some counties we have under the Dairies and Cowsheds Order a veterinary officer who is supposed to inspect dairies and cattle. I speak with a very intimate knowledge, because we were compelled in the sanitary district in which I was one of the people concerned, to elect a veterinary officer because the Local Government Board insisted on it. The Local Government Board proceeded against us and took us before Chief Baron Palles. We won our case, but we were defeated on appeal, though we might have gone further. We did not go to the House of Lords, where we would probably have won. You have a number of inspectors under the Dairies and Cowsheds Order receiving sums of money for doing nothing. If on the top of that you are going to appoint new officers, with new duties, leaving the existing officers with nothing to do, it would certainly not make for —I will not say economy—reasonable administration. Therefore I think the whole question of the appointment of veterinary surgeons should be delayed. We are asked that every central authority should appoint a veterinary inspector. The Bill on this point is slightly ambiguous as to whether you will have one or more sanitary authorities in each district. Certain boards will be set up to work under the county health board; whether there should be only one sanitary authority or whether we will have a number of sanitary authorities in a county does not appear clear. This point may arise, and it will want to be watched. While I think the amendment is very necessary, I do not think it should be passed as it stands.
Comment on this
We must realise that this Bill concerns the public health, not horses and cows. A veterinary surgeon is not required to tell us whether a piece of meat is tubercular or otherwise. The medical officer that it is proposed to appoint will have an intimate knowledge of that sort of work. He is trained very carefully in it. A veterinary surgeon is not necessary for it. Neither is he necessary to tell us whether milk is tubercular or unfit for consumption. The medical officer will be quite capable and efficient to do that. And as well as the medical officer of health, we have the public analyst, who can discover if there are any other matters in the milk that should not be in it. We should confine ourselves to the health of the people at present, and not mind the health of the cows. I do admit veterinary surgeons are necessary in the country; they can do a great deal of good work, but I do not see how under this Bill we can create posts for these gentlemen.
Comment on this
I wonder if Senator Parkinson has read sub-section (2) of his amendment. It states:—"Every such veterinary inspector shall be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, 1878." That would cover Senator O'Sullivan's objections to this veterinary surgeon interfering with the question of cattle with tubercular disease. I am sure that what Senator Parkinson wants is to have a veterinary surgeon to do the duty of a veterinary surgeon, and not the duty of a sanitary officer. After all we know what a veterinary surgeon's duties are. Anybody engaged in stock-rearing has to call in a veterinary surgeon very often to attend to his cows, his horses, or pigs.
Comment on this
I am afraid if that is the object of the amendment it would be outside the scope of the Bill. This Bill has nothing to do with the curing of cows and horses, and if the object is to call in a gentleman to look after cows and horses, and not to deal with them from a sanitary point of view, I would have to rule it out of order.
Comment on this
May I say, with all due deference to your ruling, that what Senator Kenny says is perfectly true. I well recall, and it may be in the memory of some people who remember the Boer War, that there was a most awful disease introduced into the South of Ireland called epizootic lymphangitis. It was a terrible disease, and that part of the country was shut up and no horses could be exported from it. Then we had Pink Eye from the same source. How would you like, if you were people who breed horses, to have your district shut up, which is exactly what happened? I had the pleasure of bringing forward the matter in the Imperial Parliament, and we had a tremendous debate about it. As a result these horses were slaughtered; it was a most horrible thing.
If a veterinary surgeon is appointed —you do not agree with me, sir, on that question—he could report at once that this disease was in existence, and then these animals could be segregated, shut up or else destroyed. They had to be destroyed before. There is no reason to suppose that this sort of insidious disease may not creep into the country again. That is the reason I support this amendment.
Comment on this
I am afraid I have wasted a good deal of my time listening to the debate on the Local Government Bill, according to what Senator O'Sullivan says. I was under the foolish impression that this Bill was brought in for the prevention of disease. I thought all these sanitary officers, and all the medical officers of health, all this cleanliness in houses, and Senator Haughton's overseeing of lodging houses, were for the purpose of preventing disease. I find it is not that, but that what the medical officer and all those higher officials have to do is to wait until a thing appears and then find what it is. The main duty, I thought, of veterinary surgeons was not to find the tubercular microbe in milk, not to find the glands in a diseased carcase, and say that a cow or bullock had tuberculosis: I thought his main duty would be to put these animals in such sanitary conditions that they would not develop tuberculosis and that people who used the meat or the milk could do so without the imprimatur of the analyst or the medical officer of health. That is why I move the amendment, so that we shall not be deprived of the services of half the veterinary profession who will have to give up this country if something like that is not provided for them.
Comment on this
My idea, Senator, was the same as yours, but it was on the ground that I thought it was rather out of place in this Bill, and that its proper place would be a Livestock Bill, or some Bill of that kind. This has nothing to do with the preservation of animals or the prevention of disease amongst animals; it is for the purpose of public health, preventing disease amongst human beings. Of course you might argue that it is possible that diseases peculiar to animals might spread to human beings. That might be so; I do not know, but I think the primary purpose of this Bill is to deal with the health of human beings and not of cattle.
Comment on this
The primary object, I take it, of Senator Parkinson is that he has the interests of human beings at heart. This amendment does not approach the question from the point of view of the animal but from the point of view of the human being. At present we have numerous sanitary officers who have really been appointed to do the work of veterinary surgeons, the inspection of meat, and duties under the Dairies and Cowsheds Order. I disagree with Senator O'Sullivan when he says that those duties could be better carried out by medical men. I think if he discussed the matter with members of the veterinary profession they would tell him that this is a highly technical matter, and is not only the inspection of diseased carcases. In some cases if a pig is condemned for tuberculosis it is necessary to condemn the whole carcase; in another case it is only necessary to condemn the head. The inspection of dairies and cowsheds is really the work of a veterinary surgeon. We insist, wherever possible, that the man to carry out these duties shall be a veterinary surgeon. He is the only man who can do this work efficiently. But in many cases this is not compulsory, and unqualified persons have been appointed to do this work. The result is that the work is not properly carried out. It has been put up from a great many sources that it would be advisable to insist that these duties should be carried out by qualified men. That is all this amendment proposes to do. It would not increase the present duties in any way, or the fees or salaries of veterinary surgeons. All it insists on is that whoever does carry out these duties must be a qualified man. For that reason I think it well to accept the amendment.
Comment on this
But is that quite right? Are there not veterinary inspectors now? This does not provide for the appointment of sanitary officers, but it provides that they are to be veterinary officers.
Comment on this
We have a veterinary inspector in Kilkenny urban district, and his duty is to inspect meat in the stalls, and to report if it shows signs of tuberculosis. He has also to help the sanitary officers in their inspections of the dairies and cowsheds.
Comment on this
I think that under the Public Health Act the local authorities have power, if they think it is desirable and necessary, to appoint a veterinary inspector. In a large centre one veterinary inspector would not be sufficient. In Dublin there are four, but then the duties of inspection of slaughter-houses and things of that kind are usually carried out by what are known as sub-sanitary officers. The veterinary inspectors do not go round to see that the slaughter houses are properly cleaned. I think that, under the Public Health Act, the local authority has power, if it thinks it necessary, to appoint a veterinary inspector, and to appoint a sub-sanitary officer for carrying out the duties under his supervision.
Comment on this
If that were so the only difference would be that this amendment would make it mandatory, whereas at present it is permissive, is it not?
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister what Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act actually is. He proposes to accept the amendment if the Seanad agrees. Any number of veterinary inspectors may be appointed according to sub-section (1) of the amendment—"Every sanitary authority shall appoint one or more." You will at least have one, and you may have a hundred. Each one of these is to be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health Act. I would like that section to be read for us before we rush into this.
Comment on this
That is exactly what I said. I do not think that Section 11 of the Public Health Act would work at all.
Comment on this
I would like to know exactly where we are before the Minister accepts the amendment. What is Section 11 of that Act? Can the Minister tell us?
Comment on this
I think it would not work very well in rural districts. We have one veterinary inspector under the Cattle Diseases Act and another under the Dairies and Cowsheds Order, and this man would be a third. The county councils will not stand this if it means five or seven new officials. We have now two, which is quite enough. There is no necessity for a third man in a district like mine.
Comment on this
Would Senator Parkinson's object be gained if he did not make it mandatory—"the sanitary authority may"? As it stands every sanitary authority, whether they wished it or not, would have to appoint this officer.
Comment on this
The whole reason for saying "shall" is that rural district councils have appointed people to do veterinary surgeons' work who are not veterinary surgeons.
Comment on this
Section 11 of the Public Health (Ireland) Act, is rather long. I do not know if I should read it.
Comment on this
Does it make provision for a sanitary officer as a veterinary surgeon as distinct from a sanitary officer as a doctor, because this makes provision that every veterinary inspector appointed shall be a sanitary officer within the meaning of Section 11 of the Public Health Act? I would like to know if that provision is specifically for a veterinary officer.
Comment on this
There is so much doubt about the existing law as to the appointment of these veterinary officers that I think it would be wise to allow this to stand over until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
The effect of Section 11 of the Act referred to is to provide that every medical officer of a dispensary district shall be the sanitary officer for such district. He is to get such additional salary as the sanitary authority may determine. Then it goes on to say: "and every sanitary authority, whether urban or rural, shall appoint such other sanitary officers, including a medical superintendent officer of health, as the Local Government Board shall in each case direct." That is all there is in the section.
Comment on this
Apparently it deals with the medical branch of sanitary officers.
Comment on this
We are asked to do a new thing altogether. We must have a medical officer under the Act, and we are now asked to appoint veterinary officers. We have no power to do it at all. Then the Minister is prepared to accept the amendment. What are we to do?
Comment on this
I had better call your attention to this, that a subsequent Act dealing with the subject of the prevention of tuberculosis was passed in 1908, and Section 17 says: "The expression ‘sanitary officer of the sanitary authority' in the Act of 1878 shall include any duly qualified veterinary surgeon approved by the sanitary authority for the purposes of that section." That is to say, any veterinary officer appointed under the Tuberculosis (Ireland) Act of 1908 is to be deemed to be a sanitary officer in the same sense as the section that I have now read in the Act of 1878, but I do not think that that assists us very much.
Comment on this
The effect of this amendment would be to compel every sanitary authority in the country to elect a veterinary surgeon as one of their officers. All the urban districts of the county will be sanitary authorities, and if this amendment is carried, each of them will have to appoint a veterinary surgeon as one of their officers. The object of the amendment has been stated to provide jobs for a certain number of officials, who are not able to live as well as they think they ought. There are many other people in the country who find it hard to make ends meet at present, and there is no opportunity of providing for them out of public funds. At present several sanitary officers are in the employment of rural sanitary authorities and, if I remember rightly the regulations, it is in the power of the Minister to refuse to sanction any sanitary officer who has not the required qualifications. It is open to him to prescribe that certain officials of the sanitary authority shall be veterinary surgeons if the work is such as should be done by those officials. I object to the compulsory provision in this amendment.
Comment on this
The concluding words of Section 11 of the Act of 1878 are important, because they define the duties of those sanitary officers of whom the veterinary surgeons would become a branch if this amendment passes. These are what their duties comprise:—The discovery, inspection or removal of nuisances; the supply of pure water, making and repairing of sewers and drains and generally aiding the administration of the sanitary laws within the district.
Comment on this
The only object in putting in that section was to give power to pay a salary. One of the provisions is that the sanitary officer shall be paid a salary.
Comment on this
Is not that a rather roundabout way of putting it?
Comment on this
Could they not have provided for a salary without making the veterinary surgeon a sanitary officer under the Act?
Comment on this
There are certain existing enactments under which veterinary officers may or must be appointed—I do not know which. It is quite possible that there ought to be a medical officer appointed to discharge duties other than those. I do not know. We ought to see, before we adopt an amendment like this, that the duties of those veterinary officers will not overlap. I move that the matter be postponed until the Report Stage, when the present clause may be looked into and an appropriate section drafted to carry out the idea of Senator Parkinson, if it is thought proper.
Comment on this
As Senator Brown said, the old provision was introduced to pay a salary, and this amendment would lead to the same thing. It would permit the council to pay a salary and create a new position. In our county we have four of those gentlemen. It is impossible to find any of them for dipping purposes or anything else when wanted. I cannot understand the Minister accepting this amendment. If it were brought up last week under the Live Stock Bill, it might be in the proper place but I consider it is out of place here.
Comment on this
In the list of duties for the medical officer, as far as I can recollect, inspection of meat or of milk was not specified and I suggest, as another Senator said, that a veterinary surgeon is more suitable for such inspection than a medical officer—with every respect to the great profession represented by Senator O'Sullivan. There is also great force in what Senator the Earl of Mayo reminded us of an epidemic which happened here some years ago when different counties were held up. In those days, with the rapid advance of science, I think we should take appointments of this kind into consideration.
Comment on this
I do not wish to rush the Seanad into a thing which some Senators do not seem to understand, and if giving them time will enlighten them a little, I am satisfied to postpone the amendment until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
He is not asking leave to withdraw. It has often happened here that after an amendment has been discussed, the Minister or a Senator would say: "We have not had time to consider this. We do not know how far it is going to carry us. It may be that you could satisfy us whether we ought to support it." The Minister might say: "I am not against the principle but I would like to look into it." I do not think we ought to refuse to Senator Parkinson what we have granted to others.
Comment on this
We never before had anything like this position in which the amendment was accepted by the Minister. I think we understand it.
Comment on this
Although Senator Parkinson and myself have been at variance with respect to the duties of our respective professions, I think the courtesy of allowing him to withdraw the amendment ought to be extended to him.
Comment on this
It is not a great courtesy, because if the Senator's motion were defeated now he could, with leave, bring it up on Report. I think it would be far better to leave the matter stand over until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
Senator Parkinson's point has been that we do not understand it. I want to emphasise that we do.
Comment on this
It is best that this matter should remain over until the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move:—
In Section 21, sub-section (1). Line 16. To delete the word "from" and to substitute therefor the word "on."
Comment on this
I move:—
Section 21, sub-section (1). Line 16. To delete the words "appointed day" and to substitute therefor the words and figures "1st day of April, 1925."
This is not quite a formal amendment, because the appointed day would there mean the 1st October next. It is quite right to postpone operation of part 1 of the Act until the 1st October, but the third part of the Act, of which section 21 is the first section, is in a totally different position. There is no reason why it should be postponed until the 1st October, because road administration is already in the hands of the county council. Between the passing of the Act and the 1st October, the duties of the rural district councils will be transferred to other bodies. Therefore this part of the Act should be in force on the 1st April and not on the 1st October.
Comment on this
I move the following amendment:—
"In Section 21, immediately after sub-section 2, to add a new sub-section (3) as follows:—The council of any county may declare any road a public road provided it is not less than 11 feet wide at any point and connecting two public roads."
Under the law at present, county councils cannot repair roads that are under 16 feet wide, except they have been repaired by the Grand Jury. The result is that in districts in which a few Grand Jury men resided in the old days they had the local roads repaired and the county council maintain those roads, but in districts where there were no Grand Jurors residing there are a n amber of small roads which are in disrepair. The county council is not empowered to repair those roads. It is to remove that grievance that I propose this amendment.
I have fixed 11 feet as the minimum width of a road which the county council will be empowered to repair. I am aware that in some counties the rule I have referred to has not been brought into operation. Neither the county surveyor nor the county secretary raise any question with regard to it, but in several counties and in my own county —Co. Monaghan—this has been a burning question. After the Local Government Act of 1898 was brought into operation, the officials of the Grand Jury came before the auditor, objected, and got the cost of repairing those roads surcharged. The result is that the county surveyor has refused to pass any payment for what he does not regard as a "legal" road. This amendment would enable a county council to repair many small roads leading from one county road to another. Those roads are what I might call "poor men's roads." A small amount of money would repair them. The men served by them have been paying rates for years. They live half a mile or so off the county road and they get no benefit from the rates which they contribute.
Comment on this
Would the Senator accept some amendment which would provide that there should be room for two vehicles to pass on those roads? If the roads are only 11 feet wide, I do not see how two vehicles can pass.
Comment on this
If you make those roads 16 feet wide, it will cost an enormous amount of money. Those narrow roads serve the people very well. They are 11 feet at the narrowest point, but there might be places where they would be 16 feet or 18 feet, and where carts could pass. If you change the width to 16 feet, it would make my amendment useless.
Comment on this
As the amendment stands, it would be a serious encroachment on the rights of private property. At the present time, for a private road to become a public road, it has to be dedicated to the public either explicitly or implicitly by the owner. If you allow the public to acquire a road in this way, it is very hard to say where it is going to end.
Moreover, I think the tendency of this amendment is in the wrong direction. Ireland is at the present time a very much over-roaded country. There are far too many boreens, and that is one of the reasons why the upkeep of roads is so very expensive. There are a great many of those roads, and the tendency in the past was for persons of influence to try to get them maintained at the public expense. By giving this power to local authorities, the tendency will be to increase that trouble rather than prevent it. On the whole, I think the tendency of the amendment is in the wrong direction.
Comment on this
I will take the views of the Seanad on my amendment. I think it is important that county councils should be given power to maintain those roads. In counties where you have small farmers, you will find fifteen or sixteen of them living along those roads. In most cases, these farmers would take out the contracts for the repair of these roads, and they would do a great deal of work to them. They have been paying rates since the Grand Jury system was established, and they have had no repairs done to those roads. They have a grievance, undoubtedly, and where a county council is willing to spend a small amount of money on these roads they should have a discretion in the matter.
Comment on this
I would like to support this amendment, subject to protecting the rights which the Minister seems to think are endangered. I think that could easily be done. There are very few individuals who wish to maintain the roads they have. And when there are roads of that character they are generally well kept. I do not think the county councils would wish to encroach on these roads. But there are many houses which are only reached by long boreens, which it is nobody's business to keep in repair. It is extremely difficult to make the journey up to these houses in winter time. Sometimes these small roads are one and a-half or two miles long, and it is a great hardship on the people who live along them to travel such roads in wet weather. These people are paying rates for the upkeep of the public roads, and I think they should have some consideration. It should be within the discretion of the county council to repair these roads which serve their ratepayers. It is news to me that Ireland is over-roaded. If it is, its roads must be in the wrong places. There are many districts which require a road, and in which there is nothing but a bridle-path. The question of encroachment on private property could be set right by a small amendment if the Minister would consider the matter on the Report Stage.
Comment on this
I think the Minister's statement is founded on some antiquated historical views, rather than on realities. I am speaking of the congested districts of the West and such places. The reason these boreens and small roads exist here, while they do not exist in France, is because in France the people live in villages, and there are large tracts of land not occupied by anybody. In the West of Ireland that is not the case. The people live in isolated cottages, which are approached by these boreens. Many of these districts are boggy or mountainous, and, as Senator O'Farrell has said, the approaches to these cottages are practically impassable.
These boreens and laneways are impassable at night. Doctors and priests going to attend patients who live in these places experience the greatest possible difficulty in trying to reach the houses. There may be a bog on the one side of the laneway and a precipice on the other. Even though Senators smile at the mention of a precipice, it is a fact, as I know myself, that in many places you have along these old roadways what constitutes a precipice at both sides. The bog at either side is often cut away to a depth of ten or fifteen feet below the level of the road. That, of course, leaves the road in an extremely dangerous condition. I know myself a doctor who fell into one of these bog holes. I agree with Senator O'Farrell that the poor people who live along these boreens ought to be provided with a safe roadway so that priests and doctors and others going to attend them at night may not have their lives endangered.
Comment on this
I desire to support the amendment. The people who live along these roads pay the usual standard rates in the county. Hence I think they are entitled to get the same facilities as other ratepayers, and it is most unfair that they should continue to be subjected to the hardships they now undergo in the matter of bad roads which give access to their homes. I think it is only right that we should give permission to the county council to keep these private roads in some sort of order. As Senator O'Rourke pointed out, their maintenance seems to be no one's concern, and the result is that they are allowed to get into a frightful state of disrepair: in fact, many of them are so bad that one's life is in danger when travelling over them. We all know that in many places the people who live on these roads will not unite to carry out any sort of repair to them. Therefore, I think it is the duty of the county council to take them over and see that they are put in fairly good order.
Comment on this
I have more experience of boreens than, I suppose, any Senator in this House. I have travelled over them night and day for over a quarter of a century, and I say it is a disgrace that considerable numbers of people in this country should be left with only such means of access, as these boreens afford, to their homes. It must be remembered that these people pay large sums of money in rates. Since they do pay rates for the upkeep of the roads in the county in which they reside, I think the least they can expect is to be provided with fairly decent roads. I know several places where a person would have to walk a mile, or perhaps two miles, to reach a house on one of those boreens. The idea of bringing any sort of a car along them would never enter the head of any man. They are not roads at all. They are merely passages and bridle paths full of pot holes and deep trenches. I think that as the people who live on them pay rates they are entitled to be provided with a proper roadway. On many of these boreens you have fifteen and sixteen families residing. In my opinion they, as ratepayers, are as much entitled to a good road as the people who live in lovely houses with grand entrances to them.
Comment on this
I also desire to support the amendment. In parts of the country that I know of, there are twenty and thirty houses situate on some of these boreens. In the winter months it is almost impossible to reach these houses. I know that in one place, after the month of November, the only way in which you can reach the houses on one of these boreens is by a boat. The county council of that county started at one time to make a decent road to these houses. They went a certain distance with the work, when they were told that they had not power to carry out such an undertaking. The work was then stopped and no further progress was made with the road. All these people are ratepayers, and, in my opinion, they have the same claim to have a good road giving access to their homes as the people who live along the trunk roads.
Comment on this
This amendment opens up rather an appalling prospect. If you are going to give a road for a motor car or for a lightly constructed vehicle such as a medical officer would use, by making every boreen practically in the country suitable for that kind of traffic, you are going to place a stupendous burden on the ratepayers. I endorse fully what the Minister said, that we are a very much over-roaded country. That is the opinion of county surveyors and of all experts who have studied this question. I would like to know the meaning of the words "and connected to public roads."
Comment on this
The amendment should read "connecting two public roads."
Comment on this
That was the point that I was going to raise. In that case, of course, there is a very considerable safeguard, because county councils will not be able to declare as public roads, roads such as boreens which merely lead to a group of houses in very many cases. These boreens do not connect two public roads, and there is a distinct safeguard there. On the whole question the fact remains that the county councils are responsible autonomous authorities, and if the evil influences are such that they cannot protect themselves against them, then I do not think there is much good in our trying to protect them.
Comment on this
As a city dweller I desire to say a few words on this question. I have had some experience in travelling through the country, and on many occasions was astounded when I saw the means of access provided for large numbers of people who live along these boreens. It is really a shame that these people should only be provided with such antiquated means of access to their homes. I have seen them going along these laneways with their carts, in some cases a distance of half a mile, and it was a marvel to me how they were able to keep the cars from turning over. During many debates in this House we were told that the tenant farmers were the backbone of the country. If they are, then we ought to provide them with better means of access to their homes than many of them enjoy at present. All that this amendment means is that the county council may take over these little roads and keep them in a proper state of repair. Surely that is the least that these people, who are ratepayers, should expect. They are paying rates to maintain the roads of the county for other people, and they are left themselves without a decent means of access to their own homes. That is a state of things that should not be allowed to continue. I hope the Seanad will not be influenced by Senator Sir John Keane's argument as to the burden that this would place on the rates.
Comment on this
On a point of personal explanation, I desire to say that my remarks were made in ignorance of the misprint of the amendment on the Order Paper. If I had known that that precaution was provided for, that the roads must connect two public roads, I would not have objected.
Comment on this
There is the other point that has not been covered by this amendment. These roads may be private property and I think there ought to be some provision put in to the following effect, "with the consent of the owners of the lands adjoining on either side."
Comment on this
A county council never undertakes to make a road except they have the consent of the adjoining-landholders.
Comment on this
This section enables them to do it without consent.
Comment on this
If consent is necessary, they will get it. The people aggrieved will come to the county council and ask to get the road put into repair. The county council will tell them to go to a solicitor and get a form of consent signed by the adjoining landholders. When that is brought back, the county council will declare the road a public road.
Comment on this
What does the Senator mean by a road less than 11 feet? Does that include the water table?
Comment on this
Under the existing law a 16-foot road is practically only 11 foot of road when you take the water table out. If an 11-foot read is to be measured in the same way, that is, from fence to fence, you will only have about a seven foot roadway on which no two cars, no matter how small, even if they were donkey carts, could pass. I think we had better be quite clear about this. There is another aspect. I do not know how the amendment here is going to safeguard the county councils from the consequences of accidents by night. Repairs to the surface of the road will not do anything in that direction. Will it entail liability upon the county council for accidents that happen and for not keeping the roads, at all times, in sufficiently good order? If cars, whether motor cars or other cars, meet with accidents, it might be contended that the road was not kept in proper order and was not maintained as it ought to be by the county council. We know and have instances in every county where glorified boreens have in time through development of one or the other, formed a link-road.
Occasionally a labourer's cottage was built there; then perhaps another labourer's cottage was built, and then some private individual came to live there, and in time the road began to assume a form of importance, whereas it might be only a boreen or short way or a connecting path between one main road and another. We have had applications in the Co. Waterford of this kind, but we do not agree to put increased cost upon the already heavy charges for the roads in that county. We have now 48,000 miles of roadway in the Free State. We are very much over-roaded compared with England and Scotland, and that entails an upkeep for those roads of £30 per mile, or one and a-half million pounds, out of the ratepayers' pockets. I do not know what extra mileage this reduction of width from 16 feet to 11 feet would mean. The Senator does not give us any idea of that, but it would mean a multiple of £30 for each mile, and that would be a considerably increased burden. These aspects of the question should be considered by the Seanad before it comes to a decision.
Comment on this
It seems perfectly evident that the rates are no longer adequate to maintain the roads of the country. This might be availed of as an opportunity to ask the Ministry to put the burden of the roads, that is the main roads, upon some other plan. Roads connecting small hamlets with the main road might be kept up by arrangement with those people served by such roads, and they might be maintained in fairly good order by them, irrespective of their rateable value. From the little I know about roads in the congested districts, the rateable value of the districts served is inadequate to keep the roads in anything like decent repair, and the result is a tremendous hardship on families that have to pull their cars through peaty and rocky surfaces. From what Senator Kenny says it is apparent that if we pay £30 per mile for the maintenance of our roads it is a perpetual recurring charge, and it can only be met by a change in the character of the roads themselves. It would require capital to provide an alternative form—namely, ferro-concrete.
I was amazed at the cheap estimate made recently that a ferro-concrete road would only cost £7,000 per mile. That would save a tremendous amount of recurrent expenses, and, certainly, a country that was able to deal with such important matters as the overlapping system of the railways should be able to deal with the question of roads on some other basis than that of the rateable value of the houses hard by, particularly as Senator Kenny has shown that the development of roads in a district has the same effect as the laws of supply and demand, and that easy access creates population. I urge upon the Ministry to get out of the narrow definition of a road by its breadth, and to try to come to some other method of rating for upkeep. The breadth of the road varies with the season of the year and the encroachment of the grass upon the border.
Comment on this
I think you are quite right, A Chathaorligh, with regard to this amendment. The council in a county may declare any road to be a public road. Private interest, of course must be considered as well as public interest, and when you, sir, said there might be actions for trespass and that sort of thing I think you are perfectly right. I think this is a particularly dangerous amendment with the words "any road" in it. "Any road" means any road in the county. I should be inclined to vote for the amendment if it means that the county council in any county may declare a certain road to be a road, but if the word "road" covers any pathway that any vehicle or car could come along it would be a different matter.
Comment on this
If this amendment is passed who will pay for the upkeep of the roads? I am very anxious to know is it the ratepayers of the county or the ratepayers at large.
Comment on this
The whole charge will fall upon the particular county, and it will be open to them to agree or not.
Comment on this
It seems to me that there are two points involved in this amendment; one is the treatment of private roads, and that could be met by the suggestion made by An Cathaoirleach himself. The other is the width of the road. I served a very long apprenticeship on a county council, and I know that these applications for new roads constantly came before us. It is a matter of intrigue and all sorts of underhand things to try and get the boreens made into public roads. Public roads, I believe, have a limited width of 16 feet. Now you are asked to still further widen the powers of the county councils to include what has been described here as bridle paths, which must give an enormous opening for intrigue and at the same time cause an enormous outlay on roads. It was always taken into account as long as I was a county, councillor that where there was a large number of families living on a road it would be worth while to put the road in contract up to this hamlet or cluster of houses. An amendment to the effect that any road exceeding 11 feet should be made a public road would be very dangerous, and I will therefore oppose the amendment.
Comment on this
I would like to ask the Minister to enlighten us on two points. First, how is the width of a road measured? There must be some statutory method of measure.
Comment on this
Then the next point is, what obligation rests on the council when a road becomes a public road? I know several roads which, owing to their width, are public roads. They serve a very restricted number of houses, and the county council gives a grant of something like £30 to be expended on them over a number of years for the purpose of doing a little surface work. Such roads are not put out to regular contract. In that case would the county council be liable if there was an accident owing to an inadequate or defective surface? The county council might, I think, quite reasonably continue or, in some cases, extend that method of grant, which costs very little. It is a different question to a grant of £30 a mile. I think the council should be protected against capricious actions for damages.
Comment on this
This matter is only permissive on the county council. If the county council does not wish to do it, or thinks it is too expensive, or only wants to do one bit at a time, it is at liberty to do so. Senator Everard has told us that there are constant applications to the county council and that they have been refused except in particular cases. Why not allow the county council to decide this matter for itself? Senators who object to this amendment do not, I think, quite understand the position, especially as regards mountain and bog roads in the West of Ireland, as they mostly live in County Meath where there are good roads. People in congested areas in the West live in inaccessible places where the roads are bad. All the developments in this country have been effected in the east, whereas the west has never been developed.
Comment on this
Many of the roads mentioned by Senator O'Rourke are used almost solely by people who, although they live in isolated districts, are large ratepayers, and although they pay a considerable amount in rates, practically no money is spent on their roads.
Comment on this
I should explain that there is no idea of spending £30 a mile on small boreens. The roads to which I refer have never been repaired, and there is not much traffic on them. People who use them have been paying a large amount in rates for several years. In my county there are many roads under ten feet wide and they have been maintained because years ago members of the Grand Jury took an interest in them. In poor districts the roads are not, however, repaired as the county council has no authority to repair them. This amendment will, however, if passed, give power to the county council to repair them, and I think that that is only a matter of justice.
Comment on this
I think we should be quite clear as to what roads are included in the amendment. Senator Sir Nugent Everard said that a road is measured from water-table to water-table, and if that is so there is no need for the amendment, because these roads are sixteen feet wide, whereas those which Senator O'Rourke has in view have eleven feet between the fences. His idea is that it will not cost anything like £30 a mile to keep them in order. I know a lot of small roads maintained at a shilling a perch, or £8 a mile.
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In Section 22, line 1, to delete the word "from" and to substitute therefor the word "on."
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In Section 22, line 1, to delete the words "appointed day" and to substitute therefor the words "first day of April, 1925."
Comment on this
I beg to move:—
In Section 23, line 28, to delete the word "from" and to substitute therefor the word "on."
Comment on this
I move:—
In Section 23, line 28, to delete the words "appointed day" and to substitute therefor the words and figures "1st day of April, 1925."
Comment on this
I move the following amendment to Section 23, sub-section (1):—
Before paragraph (a) to insert a new paragraph (a) as follows:
"(a) the expenses of maintaining and constructing main roads shall be raised and defrayed seventy-five per cent. out of the Road Fund and twenty-five per cent. out of the poor rate."
I am not tied to the exact proportion as set out in the amendment to be borne by these respective funds, but I move the amendment in order to try and persuade this House and the Government to mete out more justice to the rural ratepayers in respect to the maintenance of these main roads. The Minister may say that the system that is in force in this country for the maintenance of main roads is legally not different to that in England. The duty of maintenance is thrown on the local authorities which bear the expense, being recouped in certain measure from other central funds. That is true, but the point is what is the measure of recoupment? In order to form a true and fair opinion on this matter you have to examine that. In England a very large percentage—I am not able to say how much—of the expense of the maintenance of main roads is refunded from whatever the fund may be that is used for that purpose. It is a fund financed largely out of the duties on motor vehicles. In addition to that, it is very important to remember that the rural ratepayers in England have in recent years received a considerable grant in aid of relief of rates from central funds. I think I am right in saying that half the increase in rates since 1893 has been taken off their shoulders. I am not absolutely certain of the figure, but it is very considerable, so much so that in districts of which I have personal knowledge the rural rate on agricultural land is only 2/- in the £. Of course, if these roads had only to serve local requirements they would be of a totally different character to what they are now. Farmers' carts do not want wide, steam-rolled, highly macadamised roads which the motorists want. As a rule, motors are not part of the equipment of even substantial farmers. Horse dealers, cattle dealers, veterinary surgeons and other professional men have motor cars, but the average farmer has not. Furthermore, these roads are a detriment to the farmer in many cases, because they are very often dangerous to horse traffic. so that the farmer has an additional burden of having unsuitable roads owing to their slippery surface.
It is most inequitable to regard this matter in terms of counties. Take a county like Kildare. The traffic there is, in a very large measure, through traffic, radiating to further centres in the South. Only three-fourths—there are no exact figures available—or three-eighths of the cost of keeping main roads is contributed from other funds, so that five-eights is borne by the local rates. I need hardly emphasise that on the Minister, as he is conversant with the rural districts, and knows what a heavy burden that is on local rates and on local industry. Farmers admit that good roads are necessary to deal with motor locomotion. You cannot stop the advent of motors, but the burden should be equitably placed. Some fund other than the local rates should be used to finance the upkeep of these main roads. If merely rural interests were to be served, one-fourth of the present expense would be sufficient. The remaining three-fourths is necessitated by motor traffic, and should be taken off it.
I hope the Minister is going to give us some satisfactory assurance—something better than he gave in the Dáil— that he has power to take off local rates such roads as he may declare should be taken off. I think the Minister has inserted an amendment in the Bill which will give him power, if he wishes, to relieve certain roads that he may prescribe altogether from local upkeep, and put the charge entirely on central funds. That is not sufficient. We want an assurance from him that he is going to deal with this matter in an equitable spirit, and place this burden where it should be placed. I know that it is a difficult matter, and involves amongst other things the question as to what is the best form of motor taxation. Wherever the funds are to come from, the fact remains that it is not fair to place the burden on the agricultural dwellers. The object of the amendment is to secure that justice shall be done.
Comment on this
I am not quite sure if Senator Sir John Keane includes in the term "main roads" what have been described as trunk roads.
Comment on this
We have not got any definition of what main roads are. The Minister takes power to classify certain roads as main roads. By main roads I mean roads that serve other than purely county needs, and that should be so financed.
Comment on this
Trunk roads are classified by the Road Board as national roads. They are the main arteries of the country. Main roads are roads classified as roads connecting large centres of population. District roads are roads linking up the main roads, and spreading themselves throughout the whole district. If the amendment embraces trunk roads in its ambit, it will deal with a mileage of 8,000 miles, of which the Road Board classified 4,000 miles as trunk roads and 4,000 miles as main roads. The ratepayers are at present paying 2/7 in the £ for the maintenance of these roads. That figure has been worked out by the Road Board, so that the present cost of a main road is double the cost of an ordinary or district road. The aggregate paid by the ratepayers is one and a half millions, and when that is divided by the total mileage of the Free State it works out at £30 for some roads and £60 for main roads. According to the amendment 75 per cent. of the cost on the Road Fund would mean £360,000 taken off the ratepayers. The Road Fund is made up from motor taxation, which amounts to £700,000. What was the Road Fund devised to meet, and what work was it supposed to accomplish? Its primary object was for the purpose of reconstructing roads and it has nothing at all to do with their maintenance. A reconstructed road is expected by motorists to be a road capable of carrying up to 15 tons at a speed of anything from 12 to 15 miles an hour. The speed is often more than that. With all the resources of the Road Fund, apart from the other assistance mentioned by Senator Sir John Keane, the road authorities are not able to keep pace with the destruction of the roads without touching at all their reconstruction, or building them up to meet the needs of modern traffic.
Ferro-concrete is the only road that can stand up to modern traffic. But if you contemplate laying down a ferro-concrete road, you have to be prepared to pay an appalling figure. The cost will be so great that the finances of the country could not stand it. Eight thousand miles of road at £7,000 a mile would mean an appalling outlay. What we are making an effort to do is to get some form of road, short of the ferro-concrete kind, that will give a life of from 8 to 10 years under moderate modern traffic. That would not involve any encroachment at all on the funds now at the disposal of the Road Board. This road that I suggest would last 8 or 10 years if the modern traffic were regulated. That is to say, we will have to curb the speed and also limit the weight of the traffic. If we do not do that we cannot keep pace with the destruction of the roads. Our finances would not stand it.
A sub-committee has been sitting on this business for the past two months, and this sub-committee has given some days each week to its consideration. On that sub-committee you have a representative of every section of road users, and all are at their wits' end where to find the money to overtake the destruction. When these roads were laid down they were never intended to bear the traffic of to-day. Their foundations were never intended to cope with such traffic. Now you have to begin with strengthening the foundation and then finishing up with the modern surface. That is the position with which you are faced to-day.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Kenny in what he has said about the roads, but if we have to wait for relief with regard to local taxation until some period when the Road Board will be in a position to make the roads in Ireland able to cope with the traffic on them, it will probably be Tibb's Eve. That is very poor satisfaction for people intimately concerned with keeping the roads of the country within the reasonable limits which the ratepayers can bear, whilst at the same time satisfying, in a sort of transitory way, the needs of motorists.
In my part of the country they tried very hard within the last two years to bring up the main roads to a high standard. The main road from Charleville to Limerick was brought up to a high level. What is happening now? You had within the last year or so a tremendous flow of traffic, and that is still increasing. You have lorries weighing from three to seven or eight tons coming from the borders of the County Cork and passing over these roads. It was by a tremendous effort on the part of the local authorities that these roads were improved, but now they are full of pot-holes. At the time, the rates for the county went up as high as 16/- in the £, a figure utterly unbearable. The roads themselves cost as much as 8/- in the £ to maintain. That is a figure quite impossible for the ratepayers to bear.
I think that some arrangement should be made whereby the Central Fund, which I suppose should be called the Road Board Fund, and which is now, I take it, a growing fund, might be used for this work. I think the suggestions made by Senator Sir John Keane might be considered. Now, the use of lorries on the roads is becoming very common, and it is evident that the Minister will have to devise some system of taxation. Some of us are in favour of the taxation of motor spirit, and some of us believe that would relieve us of taxation for road maintenance.
Unless some suggestion such as that outlined by Senator Keane is accepted, you will have local authorities, no matter what explanation is made, rising up against the growing cost of the roads and saying: "We cannot maintain them." That will come before long. Nobody desires it. Every man in the country is anxious to see people come along and enjoy themselves along the road in their motor cars; but when the dweller in the country has got to pay enormous sums for the upkeep of the roads, you can hardly blame him asking: "Where is the money to come from to meet this?" For that reason, I think it would be well that some amendment on the lines of Senator Keane's should be accepted.
Comment on this
I am inclined to agree with what Senator Sir John Keane has said, and even to go further. I believe it is a good principle in finance to cut down current expenditure. If the Ministry of Local Government can give a grant from the Central Fund, I think it would go some way to ease the position. I have some figures here dealing with the laying down of a permanent road to Cork, a distance of 165 miles. Before quoting the figures, I must get rid of the unnecessary idea that there should be any opposition between the farmer and the owners of motor cars. The man who owns the motor car helps to enhance the value of the farmer's land. It brings it nearer, so to speak, to the city.
The owner of the motor car or lorry is not the enemy of the farmer. As far as I can see, there is scarcely a farmer in the country who has not got a motor car. That expensive and luxurious machine called the Buick is also called the farmer's car. If you take a sum of £7,000 per mile for a ferro-concrete road, you would get a road to Cork made for £1,155,000. That would improve the road from Dublin to Cork and also to Cobh, and it would take in all the intervening counties. I once made a mistake on this road subject. When I thought I had a good idea on the subject, I ventilated my ideas on the matter in the papers. The people who read my remarks put me down, I suppose, in that pigeon-hole in their minds where generally they place the people who usually write to newspapers. I deserved that. Without repeating what I said then, I will reiterate the opinion I held.
If we were to set down a road from Cork to Dublin for motorists it would have the effect of bringing the country tighter together. No country can be over-roaded. Amongst other things, roads make for better social conditions. In modern times no country can get on without motor transport. If you lay down a motorists' road from Dublin to Cork, it could be maintained by a system of tolls, which could be collected at toll-gates. You could also deal with the problem by giving strips of the road to Americans who might endow it and call the portion of the road after their own name, and pay the cost of laying down that particular section. You might have a Henry Ford stretch, a Rockefeller stretch, or you might have some stretches named after the Cinema people. There are probably many important Irish-Americans who are anxious to endow this country, and who have endowed it, men who have given lavishly of their money. When this thing, which is a business-like proposition, would be put before them, they might increase their endowment so as to establish a permanent highway like that which stretches across the west coast of America from Los Angeles to San Francisco.
Now, that would get rid of this expense of £30 a mile annually, or even £10 a mile, which is being spent without any hopes of permanency. The taxation of motorists is, I think, ill-distributed and therefore unjust. If anyone has had the experience of being towed by a lorry, he will understand how the road is worn by the lorry. The road is injured not so much by the speed as by the weight of the lorry. I would certainly, in all fairness, try to make an initial charge on the owners of motor lorries. That would not injure their business.
Any man who has a lorry should pay £30 or £40 for the privilege of using it on the road. All that leads up to the idea that some sort of contribution will have to be given by the Ministry of Local Government to enable them to make the roads as they ought to be.
Ferro-concrete is not I might mention, an unwearable surface at all, but it will stand for many years and save the annual outlay.
Comment on this
Senator Gogarty is wrong when he says every farmer has a motor car, but he is right when he tells us of the injury that is done to roads, and how they are ruined by motor lorries. Senator Sir John Keane in his amendment uses the words "main roads." I think it would meet the case better if he used the words "trunk roads," which we have already heard. I understand, however, that the word is not in the Bill and, therefore, it has not much force. What he has said would reduce the mileage from 8,000 to 4,000, and would deal only with the central arteries, which are the ones most required by motorists.
Comment on this
I would be inclined to agree with Senator Sir John Keane if his amendment were worded in a slightly different manner. It is not possible to give effect to this amendment for the reason that the road tax on motor-cars, which is at present the main source of building up the Road Board Fund, was imposed some years ago on the understanding that the money would be devoted to the improvement and construction of roads, and not to the cost of ordinary maintenance. Some sort of calculation was made a few years ago as to what the maintenance of main roads costs. But we have arrived at the stage now when it is very difficult, almost impossible, to say where maintenance ends and reconstruction or improvement begins. I believe that the percentages laid down here would be equitable, if you take the cost of the upkeep of the roads in future into account.
Traffic on the roads has changed to a great extent. It has increased so much that from this onwards it will take, possibly, four, five, or ten times the amount formerly necessary, to keep them in a reasonable state of repair and keep them at the standard that will be required. It would be only fair and reasonable to ask the Road Board, in other words the motorists, to provide a fair percentage of the cost. The word "maintenance" in this amendment is the difficulty. Under the guarantee given to the Motorists' Association, you cannot devote any of their money to road maintenance. The tax upon them was imposed on the strict understanding that it was for road improvement.
The question of maintenance may be omitted from this onwards. In reality what is required is road reconstruction. It is an absolute necessity that all the main and trunk roads should be reconstructed. Different material will have to be used than that to which we were accustomed. No macadamised road with the ordinary surface would now be equal to the strain of modern motor traffic. While, perhaps, a solution of the difficulty might be found in prohibiting the use of motor traffic on the roads, I do not believe the farming community would be prepared to agree with that. As Senator Gogarty states, the farmers' interests have, through the medium of the motor, been brought nearer to the towns.
We all know the agricultural industry is well served by motor transport. Motor lorries go through the rural districts collecting fowl, eggs, butter and milk and other commodities. In various ways motor traffic is a great aid to agricultural industry. It would not be to the interests of the farming community to prohibit commercial lorries and other motor traffic using the roads. That being so, the only other course left is to provide a reasonable percentage of the cost of reconstructing those roads in an up-to-date fashion. The question of receiving assistance from the Road Board will require a great amount of consideration. The cost of the road upkeep will, as Senator Kenny has said, amount to an enormous sum of money. Some way will have to be found by the nation as a whole of providing that enormous amount.
I do not feel at liberty to say much about how that money is to be got at the moment, as at present an inquiry is being held with a view to seeking a solution to this question. I would ask Senator Keane to change the wording of the amendment, and I am sure he will then have the full support of the Seanad.
Comment on this
The improvement and the construction of main roads is the difficulty. I would suggest that these main roads be taken over by some central authority and the county councils be asked to subscribe, in lieu of the money they are spending now in maintaining roads. They might, perhaps, provide an amount equivalent to 25 per cent. of what would be necessary to reconstruct those roads.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am not quite sure whether under the Constitution we have any right to deal with the finances of the country. It is suggested that 75 per cent. of the cost of the maintenance and construction of roads should be paid out of the Road Fund. I am not sure that the Seanad can do what is recommended, or that we can alter the Bill in that way.
Comment on this
I am sorry that at this stage of our proceedings the Senator should have raised this point, because we had disposed of this over twelve months ago, and disposed of it as a result of a very anxious and important deliberation that took place in the Seanad following upon a report of a Special Committee to whom the matter was delegated, and who gave a very exhaustive report on the position of the Seanad in this very matter. It was then decided consistent with, and in agreement with, the advice I had given to the Seanad, and also in agreement with the unanimous opinion of the committee appointed to go into it specially, that our rights in this matter are to be found in the Constitution, and if they are, then we have no power to interfere with money grants in a Certified Money Bill, but in any Bill not a Certified Money Bill admittedly our power of making amendments is unlimited. That is what the Constitution lays down. If the Senator is curious for the reference I can tell him that the date of the report is the 19th March, 1924, and he can obtain a copy of it.
Comment on this
I, naturally, have considerable sympathy with the idea at the back of Senator Sir John Keane's mind in moving this amendment, being one primarily interested in keeping down the rates and protecting the ratepayers as much as possible. I think it will be quite clear that I am not in a position to put this amendment into effect, if agreed to here, without the consent of the Executive Council or the Minister for Finance, without a Financial Resolution. I have only the rates to administer, and I have to depend upon the goodwill of the Minister for Finance as to what other funds I can get to assist me in carrying out my duties. Under the Bill I have taken very wide powers. I have taken power to declare what shall be a main road. Heretofore that rested with the county councils. I have also taken power to maintain or construct any road I like, and to divert money from the Road Fund for that purpose, but I am limited to the amount of money in the Road Fund, and that would not be a fleabite in the amount required for repairing and maintaining the main roads at the present time.
The fund only amounts to £360,000 and that sum would be altogether inadequate. I would like if our financial position would justify it to have a considerable addition to that fund from the Central Fund, but I am not in a position to command that. and in the circumstances I think that no useful purpose would be served by insisting on this amendment. I am doing everything I can to get grants for the maintenance of these trunk roads. Last year we got a grant amounting to over a million pounds, to supplement the ordinary Road Fund, and I hope as time goes on we will be able to increase that Fund Of course, as appears from this debate, this whole question of roads and revenue from motor taxation and the weight of lorries, is all bound up together. and there are different ways that we might arrive at the solution of this very serious problem of maintaining our roads. There is no doubt if we could exclude all the heavy lorries, that would be one way to maintain our roads. If the expenditure of last year were maintained for three or four years it would be sufficient to put them in a perfect state of repair, if they had only to bear the pre-war traffic, but when you have motor lorries of six or seven tons weight pounding along the roads it is really impossible to keep a surface that will stand up to them for any length of time.
Senator Gogarty referred to the fact that concrete roads are an ideal solution. In America they have been proved to be such, and I have travelled over thousands of miles of such roads and found them satisfactory. I have been informed by the engineers that the concrete road has not proved completely satisfactory here owing to the dampness of the climate. Concrete is a very porous substance, and when it does not get an opportunity to dry properly the surface is very friable.
In any case, it is not a regular panacea, and we have not got the money to construct these concrete roads at the present time. I am doing all I can to co-ordinate the repair and maintenance of roads and making every possible effort to get grants from the central Fund to supplement the ordinary rates, but I think it would be a very serious matter to lay down any hard and fast principle, particularly as we have the Roads Advisory Committee, of which two Senators are members, going into this whole matter of motor taxation, the proper system of maintaining roads, and the proper system of allocating and distributing the costs of these roads on the local and central funds. At the present time, in order to put this provision into operation, we would have to get a Financial Resolution passed, and I do not think it would be fair, even if we had no difficulty in doing that, to ask assistance from the Minister for Finance when we are all anxious to bring down taxation and to balance the Budget, and when particularly opinion is rather inclined for a decrease rather than an increase in income tax. I see no other way out if we pass this proposal. There is no way of putting it into effect without increasing income tax, and for that reason I would ask Senators to consider seriously the matter before passing this amendment.
Comment on this
I think this debate has served one useful purpose. It has shown the House that the Government have not, or at least have not announced any clearly thought-out policy, with regard to this crying evil, and it is a crying evil, as I hope a few remarks I will make, will show. Senator Kenny is able to distinguish between maintenance, improvements and capital expenditure, but Senator O'Duffy, who also with Senator Kenny is a member of the body inquiring into this matter, has postulated that it has in practice become impossible to show the distinction, and I think anybody who uses common sense must see that they must be bound up together. Any question of the increased quantity of metal might be put in either category, improvement or maintenance, but you have to look at the problem as a whole, and it is very disquieting to be now told for the first time that the rural rates are receiving no contribution whatever towards making these roads. That is the effect of Senator Kenny's statement, that the whole of the Road Fund is going in what I might call capital expenditure, and that the rates are bearing not three-eighths of the cost of maintenance, but the whole cost of maintenance. Whether the Road Fund money is expended in the best manner is naturally somewhat a technical consideration, but it does occur to some people, rightly or wrongly, that a good deal of the damage that is taking place on the roads is due to the neglect of waterproofing the surface, and that a larger proportion of the Road Fund expenditure might be devoted to that purpose. However, that is a technical consideration which I do not wish to press, because I have not got adequate knowledge. Here we have £760,000, approximately, being spent on what are generally called main roads, and we have got the roads in the present condition.
This is a most appalling and serious matter, and Senator Bennett has really pointed out the vista of what is likely to happen. What is likely to happen is that you will get a strike of the local councils against the maintenance of these roads, even in a condition which would be suitable for lighter motor traffic. There was a case in Mallow, where the roads were steam-rolled twice over last year, and they are almost as bad as ever. I have not verified that, but I have been told it is so. What will the local authorities do? They will not go on. They will say, "Very well, we will abandon the whole thing." That is going to happen. The Government have not shown that they have any policy to face this and to say that they are going to come down by coercion and make the local authority go on steam-rolling and resurfacing these roads every year, or twice a vear is absurd. It is simply letting the whole matter drift. Another very important consideration is involved; it arises under another section of the Bill and must be dealt with now. The Minister takes further powers to impose conditions of maintenance. Poor as the maintenance is now, and although no relief whatever for it is given, the Minister is taking power to weight the burden further by imposing conditions as to the nature and quality of the materials that shall be used on the maintenance of the roads, making the position even worse than we thought it was. We have had from the Chairman the fact that the amendment is perfectly constitutional. I would ask the House, even if they feel that this amendment could not ultimately, owing to the financial conditions, be carried out, that we should make our protest now by passing it and calling attention to the very serious state of affairs that is involved in the policy of the Government, which has put up no policy to deal with that state of affairs.
Comment on this
I wish to make it quite plain that I have assumed in the answer I gave to Senator Sir Nugent Everard that the usual Message came from the Governor-General approving of the appropriation towards the purposes of this Bill of money to be voted by the Oireachtas. That is the form it takes, and that is in compliance with the Constitution, which says that this money can only be applied by law. Another section says that no law can be passed except by both Houses. It is on that assumption that I ruled that the amendment was in order: Perhaps I might, for the information of Senator Sir Nugent Everard, read the concluding paragraph of the report to which I referred: "Article 38 of the Constitution provides that every Bill introduced and passed by the Dáil may, unless it be a Money Bill, be amended in the Seanad, and the Dáil are bound to consider any such amendment. The sole and only restriction to be found in the Constitution upon this unlimited right on the part of the Seanad to amend any Bill other than a Money Bill is in the case of an amendment which involves the appropriation of any part of the revenue of the Free State, and no such amendment can be made unless and until the purpose of such appropriation has been recommended by a Message from the Governor-General under Article 37, a condition precedent which is equally binding upon both Houses of the Oireachtas. As this condition was admittedly fulfilled by the Message in the particular case, we have no hesitation in answering in the affirmative." Therefore, I am assuming, and I believe I am right, that for the purposes of this Bill there was a Message under Article 37 of the Constitution approving of the appropriation of moneys to be voted by the Oireachtas towards the purposes of this Bill. On that assumption I have held that this amendment is in order, but of course I am not to be taken by that as in any way recommending it or saying that it is one that the Seanad should adopt. That is entirely a matter for them.
Comment on this
I think that appropriation was only voted in respect of Section 17. I do not know whether that would bring everything in the Bill under it or not.
Comment on this
I have not seen the Message, but would there not have been a Message authorising the appropriation by the Oireachtas of money for the various purposes of this Bill? Take, for example, the various officers and their salaries and pensions.
Comment on this
They all have to do with local authorities. I do not think that there was any appropriation except for the consultative councils.
Comment on this
I have not seen the Message. If the Message authorised no appropriation of Free State finances for the purposes of this particular portion of the Bill, in my opinion this amendment would not be in order, but as I have not seen the Message and do not know its form or contents, I cannot say whether this is in order or not.
Comment on this
In the absence of a Message, how could sub-section (2) of Section 17 have been passed?
Comment on this
That is my difficulty. We have passed a number of clauses which, I think, involve outlay.
Comment on this
That Message came down specially with reference to Section 17. It is the only section in respect of which a Money Resolution was required. It is printed in italics in the Bill.
Comment on this
Can you inform me, Mr. Burke, whether the Message in form expressly confined itself to the appropriation of money for the purposes of Section 17?
Comment on this
If it did, of course, the position would be quite different.
Comment on this
I think that that money has been lodged to the Central Fund.
Comment on this
That is a different matter. That does not affect the question of its appropriation now.
Comment on this
What we are now on is the amendment moved by Senator Sir John Keane, in which he seeks to appropriate the portion of the Central Fund which consists of the Road Fund, but which at present is in the Central Fund, or what in England is called the Consolidated Fund. This Road Fund now forms part of the Central Fund, and no part of that Central Fund can, in my opinion, be appropriated by an amendment in this House, or in the other House, unless there has been a previous Message from the Governor-General authorising the appropriation of that Fund for that particular purpose, and it is on the assumption that there has been such a Message that I gave my ruling.
Comment on this
This Road Fund is earmarked for road purposes, and I think the money can be spent for these purposes without any Message from the Governor-General authorising its expenditure. The money can only be spent for one purpose, and this amendment only lays down the proportions in which it may be spent. I think it is hardly the same as voting a fresh sum out of the Central Fund.
Comment on this
Before putting that amendment, would it not be better to clear up the question as to whether the amendment is in order?
Comment on this
I ruled it in order, but I did so on the assumption that the Message from the Governor-General authorised the appropriation of money to be voted by both Houses of Parliament for this particular purpose.
Comment on this
I have sent for the Message. I have a recollection of it, and my recollection agrees with what the Minister said. If we are going to adjourn now until to-morrow we could take up the matter to-morrow.
Comment on this
The suggestion I was about to make was that as a Committee has this matter under consideration, it should be left over until the Minister would decide which of the recommendations of the Committee, if any, he would adopt. That will not take a long time, and the matter could be postponed until then.
Comment on this
That is an argument on the merits. What we are concerned with at the moment is whether the matter is in order or not.
Comment on this
If this amendment be carried now, it may alter the deliberations of the Committee. It might, indeed, dissolve the Committee.
Comment on this
I do not think I could do that. Certainly if you ask me to do so, I will wait until the terms of the Message have been ascertained.
Comment on this
I do not want this House to put itself in a false position. We have asserted a certain position which I think is right and which, so far as I know, was not then challenged and has not since been challenged. Do not let us deprive ourselves of the strength of that position by making a mistake in its application. We would be making a mistake in its application if we inserted a provision in the Bill which the Message of the Governor-General does not authorise.