We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill, 1947—Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–129 of 261. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill 1947
Enacted

No. 43 of 1947 ›

I move amendment No. 1:—

Before Section 2 to insert a new section as follows:—

2.—This Act shall continue in force until the 31st day of December, 1948, and shall then expire unless the Oireachtas otherwise determines.

I am putting down this amendment because this is an extremely long and very complicated Bill. The old system under which this House was elected was in itself sufficiently complicated. It is now still further complicated and lengthened and certain new arrangements are made. There is, for example, a new arrangement by which persons nominated by the nominating bodies will be voted upon before they can be submitted to the electorate of the Dáil and Seanad and members of the county councils. There is a proviso for giving five votes to each elector, and there is a certain doubt whether that proviso is in accordance with the Constitution.

We are upon the eve of a general election, as is generally agreed, and it is, in the nature of things, impossible for us to go through this Bill and give it proper consideration. Even if we were to meet after Christmas and devote three full days to the Committee Stage, there would still be a considerable number of points which interested Senators would desire to raise. On the other hand, it is stated, with indeed every appearance of truth, that it is necessary to have this elaborate machinery. I am not in agreement with the scheme fundamentally.

It is alleged that this Bill must become law before Christmas in order to allow adequate arrangements for the Seanad election, which will take place within 90 days after the dissolution of the Dáil. In the light of these circumstances it is not possible for us to give this Bill the attention it deserves. The other House may very well be excused for not discussing in detail a Bill for the election of the Seanad, but we ought to discuss it adequately.

If we cannot do that, it seems to me the best compromise we can possibly make is to say that this Act shall continue in force until 31st December, 1948, and shall then expire, unless the Oireachtas otherwise decides; in other words, that we should give this Bill to the Minister, allow it to be operated for one election, and provide that at the end of 12 months it shall expire. The implication of that clearly is that the first business of the Oireachtas when it assembles after the general election would be the discussion of this Bill in the light of how it had worked at the preceding election.

That proposal appears to me to be quite reasonable. We could go through this Bill and get certain points made clear, but we could refrain from the kind of amendment certain people would like. The Minister would get his Bill, the new election would take place under this complicated scheme, and, in the light of the experience gained, the Bill would have to be reconsidered—and it might be reconsidered as the first business for the new Seanad. Indeed, it might be initiated by the Seanad, a thing that both Governments have been shy of doing—that is, initiating Bills in the Seanad.

Without any regard to the merits of the Bill, upon which I made myself clear on the Second Stage, but, taking the Bill with its 67 pages of very complicated provisions, my proposal is that it should be put into operation but should not become permanent legislation, and that there should be an obligation on the new Parliament to reconsider this matter in the course of 1948. I, therefore, move this amendment, which would have the effect of expediting the passage of the Bill, while at the same time giving us the saving clause that after one experience of its working it would be again put up for discussion and amendment.

Comment on this

I am strongly in favour of this amendment. My reasons are very similar to those expressed by Senator Hayes, though in some respects I would put them a bit differently.

The reason for this Bill is generally the almost unanimous dissatisfaction with certain aspects of the present system of election. It is the interest of all sections of the House that when a change is made it should be as satisfactory as possible. To make it satisfactory you want to have the collective experience of as many people as possible who have had experience of elections.

It would be better, if the circumstances were different, that this House should take this Bill seriously, spend two or three days in Committee, and after a fortnight or so reconsider on Report the various points raised and discussed.

There are quite a number of matters that I would like to raise in Committee, but I would not know until I see how the discussion goes whether I would think it advisable or not to put down amendments for the Report Stage. It would be better if this House could do it, because we know the circumstances. We have some 40 or so members who have had experience of elections. We have no certainty that the next House will have any members who have had experience of the old system of election, but there is a reasonable possibility that some of the members now here will get back and that the next House will be able to give this measure good discussion. This is not a Party measure. It is not a matter on which there are likely to be Party differences and I would suggest that there might be agreement to accept this amendment, allow the Bill to go through all stages this week, having simply a discussion in Committee to see if any obvious errors are detected, and have it brought forward again as a new measure in March or April, preferably, as Senator Hayes has suggested, introduced in this House first and then going to the Dáil.

It is generally found that in the spring this House has very little business and unless the circumstances are very different from what they have been in the past, it would be quite easy to have a full discussion. I do not see that any possible harm could come of that. We would get the benefit of a discussion which could take place now, possibly with the loss of some of the members, and there would be, in addition, the experience which has been gained through one election. I think that is a commonsense way of dealing with this.

The other alternative seems to me to take the Committee Stage now, adjourn the Report Stage for two or three weeks, until this matter has been discussed. I do not know what effect that would have on the proposals for the general election, but I presume it would mean either that it would be postponed or that this Bill would not be passed in time for the next general election. A compromise would be to say, frankly, we have not the time and it is not possible in the circumstances to give it all that discussion; that we will pass it into law subject, possibly, to some minor amendments that may be agreed upon by consent and have it rediscussed at leisure before another general election.

Comment on this
Seán MacEntee Minister for Local Government (Mr. MacEntee) Fianna Fáil

I would ask Senator Hayes and Senator Douglas not to press this amendment. I would ask them not to press it, first of all, on the ground that it is not necessary. If it is desired that the operation of this Bill, after the next Seanad general election, should be reviewed with a view to amending it, there is nothing to prevent fresh consideration being given to the law and an amending Bill initiated, as has been suggested, in the Seanad, by those Senators who feel that the law has not operated satisfactorily. However, in regard to that, I would suggest that the test at the next general election should not be taken as a conclusive one, because some very important provisions of the present measure will not be in full operation. I refer to those which relate to the preparation of the new register for nominating bodies and, of course, for nomination committees, which will be based upon this new register. I would also suggest that, out of consideration, perhaps, for members of the other House who will have to face the electorate within a very short period, perhaps three, four or five weeks, unless it is imperative to bring them back to consider an indispensable amendment from the Seanad during the week preceding Christmas or the week preceding the New Year, the Seanad ought not to do so. I know that members of the other House and members of the Government have on occasions made demands upon the Seanad which Senators might regard, in some cases, as being scarcely reasonable, but I am putting it to members of the Seanad, whose election campaign will certainly be less strenuous than that which the members of the Dáil will have to face, that, even if only out of consideration for the latter, they should not press this amendment in view of the fact that, as I have said, the amendment is not necessary in order to secure a review of the manner in which the new method of election will have operated.

A suggestion has been made in the course of Senator Douglas's speech that if this amendment were not accepted—I hope I do not misunderstand him—a possible alternative might be either to compel the election to be carried out on the basis of the existing law or else to force the Dáil to forgo what is I think the general desire of all members of the Dáil that at the earliest possible date the present anomalous and uncertain situation should be cleared up and the verdict of the people secured as to who and what Party will have authority to act for them in the national affairs henceforward.

I would suggest that it would be very unwise for the Seanad to court a general election to this body on the basis of the old legislation. From the point of view of the public, I think, very little would be gained. It is the general belief that the present method, having been tried at four general elections, has, from a public point of view, been considered very unsatisfactory. It am not one of those who fully subscribe to that view, but, nevertheless, it is the general public impression which prevails, and I think the members of the Seanad in particular should take full cognisance of that, and should be careful not to appear to flout public opinion in regard to it. For that reason, again, as I have said, as an experiment, let us go through with the election upon the basis of the present Bill and let us give the new procedure a full trial. That, as I have said, must mean this, that we should have an election based upon a new register of nominating bodies. That is a point of view which may be contested, but, if it is contested, another opportunity will arise after the general election of persuading the House that the operation of the Act has shown that further amendments in the procedure are urgently necessary and it will be open to any member or any body of members in the Seanad who may wish to review or amend this present Bill to initiate legislation in this House to that end. There is no estoppel upon that and members have full liberty to exercise their own discretion and their own judgment in that regard. For that reason, as I have said so many times, I think this amendment is unnecessary even to secure the purpose which Senator Hayes and Senator Douglas have in mind.

Frankly, as I have indicated, I do not believe that we are saying the last word as to the method by which the Seanad must be elected but we are feeling our way—put it that way and put it no further than that—towards a better system. We can do that only by a process of trial and error but at least let us not, by imposing a rigid restriction upon the period during which an Act of this sort is to be operative, create a situation in which we might have almost chaotic confusion in this country. If by any chance the Dáil were to be dissolved suddenly, within a week or a fortnight before the time limit fixed in this amendment has run, and if the Oireachtas had not replaced the existing legislation by other legislation, I do not know what sort of position we would find ourselves in. I think it would not be prudent at any rate even to run, if you like, the slight risk that that might happen. This is a matter where we cannot afford to take risks of any sort. We must have always on the Statute Book legislative provisions which will enable us, in due form and in accordance with the law and the Constitution, to elect both Houses of the Oireachtas. If we accept this amendment, it may happen—it is not likely that it will happen—but it may happen that we should not be in a position to fulfil that essential requirement and, for that reason, I suggest we should not accept this amendment.

Comment on this

I do not understand the Minister's attitude. I think the amendment is quite reasonable. I venture to suggest to the Minister that he need not be too worried at all as to what his successor in office may say about this measure in 12 months' time. His successor may find himself in the position that he will be concerned to see the whole scheme reconsidered before the expiration of 12 months.

This is the fourth effort to try to provide machinery for the election of a Second Chamber. I think we are getting no nearer the light on that. Indeed, I think the position is getting more complicated, and I suggest that there will not be half-a-dozen candidates going forward for election under this scheme who will have the remotest idea of how they are going to be elected. There is going to be utter confusion. The proposition that this matter should be open to review in 12 months' time would make it imperative on the people who will get elected to this House to examine the whole situation. Surely the obligation on us at the moment is to pass good laws. The suggestion, or the threat, that something is going to happen in regard to the other House if this Bill is not hurried through, is, surely, no justification for our passing a measure with which we are not in agreement. We cannot honestly say at the moment that we believe this is a good scheme, because we are not in a position to examine it. The Minister knows quite well that it would be a physical impossibility for the members of this House, even if they were to give every minute of every day to an examination of the proposals before them, to pass judgment on them and to be able to say, frankly, that they had done their best and were satisfied with them. Not one of us is in a position to say that. We are being asked to commit ourselves to something in the dark.

I cannot understand why the Minister should be so concerned about having a review of this measure, of making it obligatory on the Government to look over this scheme, at the end of 12 months. The Minister has a new Local Government Bill which is going to be a part of this whole scheme. My own view is that these measures will be repealed by the next Parliament and that everything will be thrown completely into the melting pot. Certainly I am convinced that, when the people of the country come to realise what are the implications of the Local Government Bill, it definitely will be repealed. That may compel a reconsideration of this measure at once. Senators now find themselves in the position that they are being asked to accept this measure without getting time to give it adequate consideration on Second Reading, in Committee or on Report Stage. That is asking the house to do the impossible.

The Minister says that we might find ourselves peculiarly placed if we were to have another election under the old measure, but the people who wanted to get into this House by bribery or corruption, if there were such people, will find a way under this Bill, too. Maybe they will be bribing some of the members of the nominating committees who will have votes for the panels. The people who have money to spend need not spend as much on individuals. They can spread it around more. I think the Minister will find that already there are people who are ready to experiment under this Bill, and probably they will be just as effective under it as they were under the last one. I really do not think there is any need for the Minister to be worried as to what the people will say because the other scheme was not satisfactory. This is not going to be satisfactory either. Nobody is getting time to produce a satisfactory measure—neither the Minister nor the people responsible for putting the measure through. In all the circumstances, I think that the Minister, in justice to himself and as a member of the Opposition if he succeeds in getting re-elected, ought to provide this opportunity of having a piece of his own handiwork reconsidered in 12 months' time. This measure should not be put on the Statute Book without an opportunity being given to the people to have it re-examined in 12 months' time. I think it would be unfair to everyone to have it rushed through this House at the present time.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter says that he cannot understand the attitude of the Minister. I am in the position that I cannot understand Senator Baxter, nor can I understand the amendment. This is an electoral Bill. Did anybody ever see in any Parliament an electoral Bill passed with a clause in it such as that suggested by the amendment, that it would continue in force only for 12 months? An electoral Bill is a measure that goes to the very root of the Constitution of the country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

And yet it is suggested that this Bill should be brought forward at the end of the year like the Increase of Rent Act, and that we should have inserted in it a clause providing that it shall remain in force only for a specified period of time. I think that proposition is preposterous. Senator Baxter's arguments were, in my opinion, extraordinary. He suggested that it is not the voters who now will be bribed but the members of the nominating bodies if you please. I do not know of any member of a nominating body who could be hoodwinked by anybody with an offer of a bribe. I know that I would not like to see a man offer a bribe to the members of the medical profession, to the members of the Council of the Incorporated Law Society, to the members of the Technical Congress or to such people. Why, it is an insult to the country to suggest that people in such positions would be capable of considering, or of having offered to them, such a thing as a bribe. Anybody who makes such a suggestion has a very low idea indeed of the honour of the people of the country.

As the Minister has said, if this Bill does not work properly there is nothing to prevent anybody bringing forward an amending measure to have it repealed, and a new measure substituted for it. Every Bill is capable of being repealed. Therefore, to insert a clause such as the amendment suggests is just unnecessary verbiage.

Comment on this

Can the Senator tell us how many Bills have been repealed by that particular process—of the Seanad moving for their repeal?

Comment on this

It is very hard to know how many Bills have been repealed. That, I suggest, does not affect the question at all.

Comment on this

Would the Senator like to get an answer to that question?

Comment on this

Every Act can be repealed. All that is necessary is to bring in an amending Bill and put it through both Houses of the Oireachtas. The original Act is repealed as soon as the new one gets the President's signature. Why, above all in an electoral Bill, should such a clause be inserted, in a Bill providing for election to one House of the Oireachtas? Is this Bill not like the 1923 Act, and others, which provide for the election of members to the Dáil? Is it to be contended that such measures are to remain in existence for a specified period of time, such, for example, as those with which we deal annually under the Expiring Laws Continuance Act?

Comment on this

Only until it has been rediscussed.

Comment on this

There is nothing to prevent a rediscussion of it at any time after it is passed. On the first day the two Houses meet after the election they might consider a new Bill, or they might set up a new committee, if they are not satisfied with the findings of the Joint Committee which have been put into effect in this measure. It is a pure waste of time to discuss the matter at all.

Comment on this

I have often heard the Minister for Local Government when he was evasive, outrageous and insulting, but I never heard him more evasive, outrageous, or insulting than he was to-day. He evaded the whole issue in this case. This is a Bill which, according to the Minister, is very complicated, is not completed, and which we cannot amend. That is his case. We cannot amend this Bill at all —and I hope Senator O'Dea understood that—or any other Bill which is now before us. We can amend none of these Bills because we cannot bring the Dáil back to discuss amendments. In other words, we are presented with this great mass of legislation and asked to pass every single line without amendment. That is an outrageous proposal. The worst possible kind of insult is an insult to one's intelligence and the Minister is insulting the intelligence of the House by this proposal. The Minister himself had more than 40 amendments in the Dáil.

Comment on this

A lot of them verbal.

Comment on this

The Minister had more than 40 amendments in the Dáil. Is that not right? I have no doubt that the Minister's amendments would be verbal, but he had more than 40 amendments. So far as we are concerned, however, we cannot pass a single amendment. That is the Minister's case. The Minister's case is that we must pass the Bill this evening or to-morrow—we cannot put it over until January. In other words, he wants this complicated scheme passed without consideration by this House. I suggest that the House stultifies itself if it agrees to that proposition.

Senator O'Dea shocks me by the way in which he has fallen for this completely evasive, insulting and fallacious argument of the Minister. There is to be no amendment to this Bill and there is nothing to prevent its being reconsidered. Of course, there is nothing to prevent its being reconsidered, but Senator O'Dea must surely recognise the difference between a private member bringing in a Bill to amend an electoral Act and the Government bringing in such a Bill. They are quite different things. In theory, you can do it, but, in practice, it is a matter of very great difficulty indeed. If, as Senator O'Dea said, and rightly said, this electoral Bill goes to the very root of our democratic system, surely he cannot agree with the Minister that we must put it through all stages without amendment this week. Surely he cannot believe that this Bill goes to the root of our democratic system, and, at the same time, accept the Minister's view that we must put it through all stages now without amendment. That is the Minister's proposal and what I should like to know is whether that is the attitude of the majority.

Senator O'Dea tells us that this is an electoral Bill, and that, because it it an electoral Bill, it ought not to have in it a proviso terminating its life after one year; but it is an electoral Bill which is to be passed in very remarkable and very unique conditions. It is a Bill brought in at the end of a Parliament and presented to us by a Minister who tells us that it is complicated and that we cannot, in common decency to the other House, amend it. Surely the answer to that is: "Very good; we will give you your Bill. We know that it is defective and you yourself know that it is defective, but, having given you the Bill, we will provide that the Bill and its scheme must be reconsidered in the new Parliament."

Surely that is a most reasonable proposition. It will give the Minister what he wants and prevent members of the Dáil who are now engaged in electoral activities throughout the country from having to come back, because, remember this: the Minister's case is that we must not pass any amendment to any Bill, because the Dáil must not be brought back. He objects to the amendment on the ground that it would bring the Dáil back, but if the Minister were to accept the amendment, the Dáil would not object to it, and all that the Dáil would need to pass it would be a quorum of members resident in Dublin. I could guarantee, if he agrees to this amendment, to give the Minister ten members in the Dáil, that is, half a quorum, and I am sure the Minister could provide another ten members himself at any time to deal with this amendment.

There is no necessity to have members coming from the country to discuss the amendment if the Minister accepts it, because obviously, if he accepts it, it will be a non-controversial matter. If the Minister were to recommend it to the Dáil, he would not have the slightest difficulty in getting a meeting without causing any inconvenience to members of the Dáil for its acceptance. The meeting need not take more than ten minutes. The Minister must think we are all very innocent if he thinks we do not know how these things are done.

The Minister made another point against the amendment. The amendment proposes that the Act should have validity only until the end of 1948 and the Minister painted a dreadful picture of what would happen if the Dáil were to be suddenly dissolved. The Dáil is never suddenly dissolved. There are always a few days before a dissolution and there is nothing to prevent the Act being continued in force by passing a very simple one-clause Bill through both Houses. It could be passed through both Houses before the dissolution in a day or two days, considering that these 67 pages are to be passed through all stages to-night by this quiescent House which apparently is going to do the Minister's bidding without exercising its own intelligence at all, if we are to believe Senator O'Dea. Surely, if that is the case, a one-clause Bill to continue the existing scheme in operation could be passed by both Houses in a couple of days. According to what we are doing now, a one-clause Bill should be passed before it is introduced at all. It need not take any time—it should be a minus quantity.

I never before heard any case like the Minister's case this evening. He objects to the amendment on the ground that it would mean bringing the Dáil back; he objects to any amendment of this Bill or to any amendment of any of all the Bills on the Order Paper to-day; he objects to a meeting of the Seanad after Christmas—why should we meet after Christmas if we cannot amend any Bill—and he wants us to pass all this complicated scheme which, in the nature of things, cannot possibly be perfect and must be capable of amendment, and to leave it the law of the land in perpetuity, to leave it the permanent law, and he refuses to accept a proposal which would simply mean that, after the general election, the Government in office after the next election, with the machinery the Government has at its disposal and the new Parliament would have to consider this. This seems to me to be an eminently reasonable proposal and I should like very much to hear what members of the House have to say about the Minister's thesis that we must pass all these Bills and that, in common decency, we can amend none of them.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it is necessary to reply to the speech which Senator Hayes has just made, because it seemed to me to be highly repetitive, and, as is usual with many of the Senator's speeches, highly inaccurate.

Comment on this

Inadequate?

Comment on this

Highly inaccurate.

Comment on this

The Minister as an apostle of accuracy!

Comment on this

I would have thought that a former Ceann Comhairle would realise that it is very bad Parliamentary manners to interrupt continuously.

Comment on this

I was only getting clear what the Minister was saying. I cannot understand him.

Comment on this

It is not too easy at times, and sometimes he is sorry for what he says.

Comment on this

I am sorry the Senator is dull of apprehension. I was saying that, not for the first time, the Senator has been inaccurate, because I did say this Bill is long but did not suggest it was complicated. I did not use the word "complicated" in connection with this Bill at all, and I did not use it because it would have been quite inaccurate to describe it as complicated. The explanatory memorandum issued with this Bill shows how simple it is. The Bill is bulky, but it is bulky because it was thought it would be more convenient to have all the statutory provisions governing the election of the Seanad in one measure. The main purpose of the Bill is to give effect—I know that Senator Baxter will jeer at this, at the suggestion that anything could be done by any body of Parliamentarians, unless he was an active participant—to the recommendation which was made by the joint committee of both Houses of the Oireachtas which was set up to consider the present method of electing the Seanad and which made these recommendations. The committee began to sit in February, 1946, and reported in May, 1947. All of that was Parliamentary time. The House is not being asked to pass this measure in one day.

Comment on this

It is, of course. When did we get the Bill?

Comment on this

The House was asked to pass this Bill after having in its hands the report of this joint committee which reported in May, 1947, and even Senator Baxter might surely have had time to familiarise himself with those recommendations and make up his mind in advance whether they were good or bad recommendations. I am sure he would, as usual, make up his mind without having heard the views of anybody, but that is bound to be the case, since the Senator is one whom no argument can change and no experience teach.

Comment on this

And no money can bribe, as you well know.

Comment on this

I never offered the Senator a penny piece to influence him. Is he suggesting that I did?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister must be allowed to continue.

Comment on this

I think the remark is most uncalled for. The Senator has suggested in his interruption that I at some stage or other attempted to bribe him with money.

Comment on this

Does the Minister want me to explain?

Comment on this

If the Senator means that once I was asked to approach him in order to ask him to form a coalition to prevent the Public Safety Bill from being enacted, it is quite true that I did.

Comment on this

Coalitions can be good at some time.

Comment on this

Coalitions can be justified by dire circumstances, to prevent great injustice being done.

Comment on this

To prevent a thing being done which the Minister for Justice now has adopted himself.

Comment on this

Senator Baxter on that occasion did not see the light and is wandering in the outer darkness ever since, with much wailing and gnashing of teeth.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister might now deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

I was saying that this explanatory memorandum shows how simple the Bill is. It proposes things which are simple, because it proposes to give effect to recommendations which in themselves are essentially simple and not at all complicated. The Bill proposes that a new register of nominating bodies be established on a somewhat broader basis than at present and it sets out that basis very fully, in language anyone can read and understand in the Bill. It proposes that, in lieu of the appeal committee as at present constituted, to consider appeals in connection with the annual revision of the register, an appeal board should be set up consisting of the Chairman and Deputy-Chairman of each House of the Oireachtas, together with a judge of the Supreme Court. Could there be, for the purpose of considering objections or of reviewing decisions, relating to membership of the Oireachtas, a fitter board of appeal than that? Does not the commonsense of every member of the House tell us that it is a reasonable recommendation and one which should be accepted? The next recommendation——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I take it we are not discussing the merits or reasonableness of this Bill, but discussing whether, the Bill being what it is, it ought to be restricted to 12 months of life. Otherwise, we are going into a Second Reading discussion which might last for ever.

Comment on this

The speech with which Senator Hayes supported his amendment was one which would have been more properly made, I submit, on the Second Stage. He described this Bill as long and complicated. However, I am admitting that it is a long one, but I am not admitting that it is complicated; and I am adressing myself to the task of proving that it is a very simple measure, with no complications whatever.

Comment on this

You are a brave man.

Comment on this

Can we do that on the Committee Stage?

Comment on this

I am doing it in order to controvert the argument used in respect of this amendment—an amendment which, I am afraid, is designed to defeat the whole purpose of the Bill. If I am in order, I will proceed; if not, I will content myself with referring the members of the Seanad to the explantory memorandum which was circulated with the Bill, in which the extreme simplicity of the proposals is fully exhibited.

Regarding the other argument which the Senator adduced, that a considerable number of amendments were put down on the Committee Stage in the other House, it is true that there was a great number of amendments, but most of them were verbal amendments. For instance, in making its decision, the committee had suggested that there should be "nominating committees." We had already nominating bodies.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Minister need not deal with that. We will deal with the amendment now.

Comment on this

I am on the point of the number of amendments. I am merely pointing out that, in order that there should be a clear distinction between the nominating bodies— perhaps more properly described as proposing bodies—and the nominating committees, we decided to call the nominating committees "nomination committees"; and a considerable number of verbal amendments went down in the other House in order to give effect to that decision. Similarly, in order to meet the situation which was caused by reason of the fact that a general election was impending and that it would be, perhaps, unfair to impose upon a new officer, who had no previous experience of conducting a Seanad election, the obligation of giving effect to the provisions of the Bill, it was decided that the experienced officer who had conducted previous Seanad elections would be the fitter person to act as returning officer for the first Seanad election. Accordingly, transitory provisions had to be embodied to provide for that.

Again, we had the situation that the new register of nominating bodies would not be prepared in time to permit it to be utilised for the purpose of the impending general election and we had to include transitory provisions to provide that the bodies on the existing register would be deemed to be nominating bodies for the purposes of this Act. Again, we had to adjust and fit in with the existing body of the law the proposals of the joint committee for having nominating bodies and the proposals of the joint committee setting out a new procedure for selecting vocational candidates for the Seanad. In doing that, we decided that, on the whole, instead of following the usual Parliamentary practice of deleting words here and there and inserting new words in their stead, it would be better to repeal the relevant sections in toto and submit an entirely new section.

That gave the appearance of drastic amendments on the Committee Stage, but in fact there is only one amendment of any substance, and of that I gave notice on the Second Stage. The one amendment of substance was the new proposals for regulating and controlling the method of postal voting so as to make it at once indubitably consistent with the Constitution and at the same time secure from interference. I am sorry to say, notwithstanding all the attention which we devoted to that problem, we have not yet been able to satisfy Senator Baxter, although now I am glad to say that he is satisfied to this extent——

Comment on this

How do you know?

Comment on this

Is not this desperately irrelevant?

Comment on this

He can say what he likes about Senator Baxter.

Comment on this

That there is no longer any possibility that ballot papers will be interfered with.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We are not dealing with that amendment. The Minister should come to the amendment before the House.

Comment on this

I am in your hands, Sir.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister is entitled to answer points raised by other speakers.

Comment on this

Surely he should speak on this amendment and nothing else. The Minister is making a Second Reading speech. Does the Minister not know what date it is?

Comment on this

I think that Senator Baxter has great reason to be thankful to Senator Hayes.

Comment on this

What did you say?

Comment on this

All right, all right, do not mind him.

Comment on this

It was argued by Senator Baxter that there may be people already contemplating the corruption of the nominating bodies. If Senators wish me to be merciful to Senator Baxter and treat his remarks with the silence which they justify I am prepared to do that.

Comment on this

We do not want the Minister to be tiresomely irrelevant.

Comment on this

Senator Hayes has been so strictly relevant——

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

It is for the Chair to decide that.

Comment on this

——that I am endeavouring to follow his good example. I have addressed myself to the argument he used. He said that the Bill was long and complicated. I admit that it is long, but I deny that it is complicated. He said that I was evasive, but when I am trying to address myself to the arguments of Senator Hayes, on the one hand, and Senator Baxter on the other, up jumps Senator Hayes on a point of order. I am not entitled to intervene on a point of order and I have not intervened. I have listened with patience to what Senator Hayes has said, but apparently Senator Hayes's idea of proper procedure compels everyone else to be silent while his tongue is loose.

I only wish to say this: I would ask the Seanad not to accept this amendment on the grounds that it is quite unnecessary. I am going to go a little bit further: it does not perhaps matter very much whether we bring the Dáil back or not. Senator Hayes has indicated that he controls 20 members of Dáil Éireann whom he can assemble at any time.

Comment on this

Twenty members?

Comment on this

Ten members, then, to do his bidding.

Comment on this

For Heaven's sake, cannot the Minister talk some kind of sense?

Comment on this

How could he?

Comment on this

I never said that. I said that we could get a quorum to pass this amendment of people resident in Dublin.

Comment on this

I am always giving up in despair——

Comment on this

That would be the best thing that could happen.

Comment on this

I cannot understand Senator Hayes's attitude. I understood him to throw out a kind of challenge to me saying that he was prepared to gather ten just men in Dublin, members of Dáil Éireann, who would assemble at his behest in Leinster House to consider an amendment from the Senate. I am not prepared to say that I could do that. I do not know what the members would say if I were to ask them to come together in that rather summary fashion. I am going to suggest to the Seanad that this amendment is quite unnecessary to achieve the purpose which the Seanad has in view. I do not know whether the Senator is pessimistic about his chances of re-election to this House or not. I do not know that, but surely if he is optimistic that he is going to be returned, he himself can do one or two things. He can put down a motion asking for a new joint committee to be set up to reconsider the methods of electing the Seanad, or he can introduce a Bill in this House to amend whatever legislation may be then in force governing the election of the Seanad. This can be done by any member of the new House and I suggest that it would be more fittingly done by a member who has undergone the ordeal of election under the new Bill. Surely if it is to be decided that the proposals of this Bill, if it becomes law, should be further amended, the fitting body to do that would be the new Seanad, but we should not insert anything in this Bill which would willy-nilly compel them to reconsider the method of election whether they desire to do so or not.

This amendment reminds me of provisions very frequently found in wills in this country many years ago, where the dead hand endeavoured to fetter the conscience and discretion of posterity. There used to be a provision that so-and-so would inherit property unless he married a person of another faith. We are trying to compel another Seanad and another Dáil, another Oireachtas, to amend this Bill whether they feel that it is necessary to amend it or not. I suggest that this is an abuse—if one wishes to put it that way —of the powers of the Oireachtas. The Oireachtas can do it if it wishes but I do not think in the present circumstances it would be wise for the Oireachtas to do that.

Comment on this

I would like to make my own position quite clear. I am not going to follow the Minister as I have not the language equal to dealing with it. There are three courses open to us, firstly to make this a temporary measure, and to pass it through all stages at once without adequate discussion; secondly to treat it as a permanent measure, an extremely important electoral Bill as was pointed out by Senator O'Dea, and to take proper time, to take the Committee Stage to-day and to-morrow, to adjourn the House and then take the Report Stage; to treat this as a serious Bill affecting the future of the Seanad. Our third choice is to say that this is a serious Bill which should be carefully examined, but to say "we will do nothing whatever about it" and pass it. The Minister and Senator O'Dea held that the first course was a tremendous mistake. The proper course would be to ignore politics, to take the business seriously, to put our minds to it and to ignore the Minister's suggestion that it should go through at once.

I would have been prepared to agree to the other course. I should, however, like to make my position clear in that respect. I was not a member of the committee. When I received the committee's report I read it carefully and I decided that certain of the recommendations were very doubtful and that, at any rate, they should be fully discussed. I was open to conviction on all the matters concerned. I discussed them with some of my friends and found that they were not very convincing. I decided there was nothing to do until we knew whether the Government would accept the report and agree to implement it. It does not really matter now whether the Bill is simple or complicated because we will discover that when we go through the Committee Stage. I shall have a lot of questions on the various sections when we discuss the Bill on the Committee Stage. The Minister may try to convince me that the answers to my points are perfectly simple. On the other hand he may find that they are not so simple. He may be able to give me an answer at once and, for that again, he may not. I have now come to the conclusion that, in view of the Minister's attitude and particularly in view of the attitude of Senator O'Dea, it would be better to withdraw this amendment and to proceed in a leisurely fashion and to do the work properly. I think it is wrong for us to pass this measure in a day or two this week. We shall be laughed at by the public to whom we are in a certain measure responsible if we do so. Personally I would have been reluctantly prepared to agree to the making of one or two of these measures of a temporary character so that a proper discussion could take place before they became permanent. I recognise that there is a certain amount of validity in the argument that this is really meant to be permanent and that it should be treated as permanent legislation. If so it would be nothing less than a farce, in the case of a Bill which is intended to be permanent and which, the Minister points out, is to be tried at least for a few elections, to pass through all the stages to-day. I submit that that would make this House a laughing stock. If it is passed by the House in a majority I have nothing to say but to register my protest.

Comment on this

I have been listening to the speeches made by members on both sides of the House and I am unable to satisfy myself as to who wants the Bill enacted. Senator Hayes apparently is the only one desirous of getting this Bill disposed of immediately. However, he wants to adopt a life limitation of 12 months in that connection. In other words, he wants it to be made an annual Act.

Senator Douglas, apparently, thinks it is a Bill that should be examined with great deliberation and that a long time should be spent on its examination. There is plenty of time. We have this afternoon, to-morrow and Friday. We have a lot of time, if that is all we want, to examine the Bill. Let us examine this Bill section by section, paragraph by paragraph and take our time in doing so. There is no use in talking about giving the matter consideration unless we are willing to consider it. I think nobody is rushing us and I would suggest that that is the remedy for Senator Douglas.

On the other hand, the Minister seems most anxious that we should not dispose of the Bill at all. If he is in a hurry with it he should not make speeches which carry him back to the glorious coalition of 1927. It would be better for him to keep to 1947 and to the third week in December, 1947.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is the way to get the Bill. I should say that I do not approve of the amendment and that if a vote is taken I propose to vote against it. This is not an annual Act. This is not like some of these clauses in the Labourers Act of 1883 or some of these Local Government Acts which are kept in the legislation as temporary measures until some day a lot of these temporary provisions will be gathered into a conglomerate statute. This is not a Bill of that nature. There is no sense whatever in saying that this is a Bill which will have effect until the 31st December, 1948, because about the 20th December, 1948, we will get the Expiring Laws (Continuance) Bill, to the Schedule of which this Act will be attached, and that will go on for 40 years. Senator Hayes will achieve nothing and this House will achieve nothing by placing on the Bill a life limitation of 12 months.

I do not think the House should be asked to divide on that but if there is a division I do not think that very many members can conscientiously support a matter of that kind. I suggest that Senator Hayes put the amendment down not for the purpose of having it carried but for the purpose of giving him elbow room for argument. I am not finding any fault with him in this respect. He is quite entitled to do that if he thinks it is the best method of getting discussion on the points he has to make. The Minister suggests we cannot bring the Dáil back——

Comment on this

On the contrary, if the Senator will pardon me, I have not suggested that. I said the House has the power to bring the Dáil back. My suggestion was that it would not be considerate in present circumstances to exercise that power.

Comment on this

It may be argued that we might not be justified in making an amendment which would involve recalling the Dáil——

Comment on this

An amendment of this type which, as the Senator himself has so ably shown, is unnecessary.

Comment on this

I agree if that is the view. I submit that if the view prevails that none of these 12 or 14 amendments on the Order Paper can be accepted then we are wasting our time. I suggest, however, that whatever the Minister may have meant to say that his colleagues firmly believe the Bill is already law, or nearly so. I have read a circular issued by one of his colleagues inviting voters to vote for him for the next election. I did not intend to refer to it only that the Senator concerned is now in the House. It may be of some interest if we were to tell the House the nature of the circular. It is dated 13th December, 1947, and is addressed to each county councillor in the Senator's county. It reads as follows:—

"A Chara,

As you are no doubt aware, immediately after the coming general election there will be an election for the Seanad. This election will, I understand, be held under the new system of election which in effect means that every member of a county council will have the right to vote.

Under the new scheme each member will be entitled to vote on all five panels. In other words, each voter will be entitled to vote No. 1 for each of five candidates, provided that they are all on different panels and so on down to the end of the list of candidates.

I expect again to be a candidate for the Agricultural Panel and hereby solicit your support for your No. 1 vote or earliest possible preference.

Thanking you in anticipation,

Mise, le meas,

(Signed) BILL QUIRKE."

Now, I take it that the Minister has indicated to the members of his Party or, shall I say, to his friends in this House that the Bill is as good as passed.

Comment on this

I think the Senator must have recruited Senator Duffy to be part of his election team.

Comment on this

I would like to thank Senator Duffy for the publicity and the canvass he is making on my behalf.

Comment on this

I am very glad that I have been of service to the Senator. I would not have read the letter had Senator Quirke not entered the House. I raise the matter merely to indicate to the House that the Minister, whether he has said it in so many words or not, regards the Bill as having passed into law as it stands at present. My attitude towards the Bill has been made perfectly clear. I do not think it is going to do for the Seanad what the Minister said it would do or even probably what he hopes it will do. I admit it is a tremendous improvement on the practice in the past.

I think the House should give the Minister credit for his realisation of the fact that the legislation passed by his Government at an earlier stage was unwise legislation and is in need of amendment. I am anxious to have a change. I suggest to the House that we would be equally wise in defeating this amendment moved by Senator Hayes and in examining this Bill, clause by clause, to see whether there is in fact anything in it now that needs either alteration or amendment. I think we should do that as expeditiously as possible so that the Minister may get his Bill through before the end of the year.

Comment on this

When I saw this amendment I took it to mean that Senator Hayes was dissatisfied with the Bill as it stands. I thought that he believed that it was not by any means a perfect measure and that it had some obvious defects. The difficulty of recasting the Bill would be very great and Senator Hayes probably thought that by ensuring that the Bill is of a temporary nature some sort of compromise would be effected. Personally, I find myself in somewhat the same position. To my mind, there are certain defects in the Bill which call for amendment or remedy. I hope to be in a position to correct some of the defects. A good deal of latitude has been allowed to members of the House in explaining their own difficulties. Perhaps I may be permitted to show in what way I think the Bill is defective. I shall give you an example from my own personal knowledge and from my experience derived in my effort to get elected to the Cultural and Educational Panel. We have 48 vocational education committees. Now, I may be misinterpreting the Bill and, if so, I trust the Minister will correct me. These committees, in the first instance, will be allowed to nominate——

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

That matter will arise later, on a section.

Comment on this

I merely want to explain why I object to this Bill. I shall not delay the House. Having got through the first stage, and run a pretty severe gauntlet, we find there are five people nominated by that particular body and five nominated by each of the other nominating bodies. These will in turn sit in judgment upon the two nominated by the vocational education committees throughout the country and these committees may then be deprived of their right entirely through the action of bodies to whom they have no responsibility or anything else. It seems to me to be ridiculously complicated. It is both undemocratic and objectionable.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

The Senator will have an opportunity of repeating all that on the section and he might as well reserve his speech until we come to deal with the section.

Comment on this

This amendment was put down for the purpose of ensuring that there would be agreement that this particular scheme would be discussed in the new Parliament and there would be agreement in this House, as a kind of message to the new Parliament, to that effect. Quite clearly there is no agreement. The amendment, therefore, serves no good purpose and we may as well get on to the actual discussion of the Bill and to whatever attempt we can make to amend it. I ask leave to withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

As my name has been brought into this debate, I do not agree to the amendment being withdrawn.

Comment on this

I did not bring in the Senator's name to the amendment at all.

Comment on this

I did not say the Senator brought it in. I said my name was brought into the discussion on the Bill.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

We have failed to get tellers in favour of the question. I think the best procedure to adopt, therefore, is to ask if there are any two Senators assenting to nomination as tellers on the Tá side, so that the House may proceed to a division.

No Senator rose.

Comment on this

In other words, the Tá's have not the courage of their convictions.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Therefore, there cannot be a division as the House has not provided me with the machinery. The motion for withdrawal is accordingly carried. The amendment will be withdrawn accordingly.

Comment on this

You can take me as formally objecting to that decision. I intend raising the matter in a place where it can be properly dealt with.

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Might I read the relative Standing Order:—

"When the doors have been locked and the Division Lobbies cleared the Cathaoirleach shall again put the question and declare afresh the result, in his opinion, of the putting of the question. If such fresh declaration be challenged, he shall order the Seanad to divide and shall nominate two tellers for each side...."

Comment on this

He "shall nominate two tellers." I do not propose to go into the merits of the decision at the present time. This is not the place to discuss a decision of that nature; but certainly I shall raise the matter and have it properly dealt with where it can be dealt with. I wish to be taken as emphatically dissenting from it.

Comment on this

For the moment, there is no division.

SECTION 2.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:—

In page 7, line 12, after the word "Éireann" where that word secondly occurs, to insert the words "other than a member of Seanad Éireann nominated under Section 3 of Article 18 of the Constitution".

This section covers the definitions for the purposes of the Bill. It will be observed that on page 7 a special meaning for the purposes of the Bill is given to the expression "member of the Oireachtas", which, on this definition, means a member of Dáil Éireann or a member of Seanad Éireann. The purpose of the definition here is to determine, in so far as the Seanad is concerned, who is entitled to make nominations or to join in making nominations for the new Seanad. It also determines, so far as Seanad Éireann is concerned, the persons entitled to vote in an election for a new Seanad. The purpose of the amendment is to delimit that definition so that the persons appointed members of the Seanad under Section 3 of Article 18 of the Constitution will not be entitled to make nominations or to join in making nominations or to vote in an election for a subsequent Seanad.

The persons concerned in this amendment are the 11 persons who were nominated by the head of the Government to be members of Seanad Éireann. If we desire to preserve the democracy of the institution, it is obvious that we should exclude from the right to make nominations and the right to vote those members who did not enter the Seanad through any elective channel, whether from nominating bodies or from the other side of the Seanad panels. So far as I am concerned, there is no personal reflection on any individual in making this proposal. Senator Sir John Keane, who, I just now remember, is affected by the proposal, says he hopes not. I can assure him that I did not even look up the list to find out who would be affected.

Comment on this

I would not like to bet that you did not know them.

Comment on this

If the Senator does not believe me, I cannot help that. It is a matter of absolute indifference to me. There is no member of this House who, I think, is more worthy of a vote and of making nominations than Senator Sir John Keane. If I were a candidate and he had a vote, I have reason to think I would get it. That, however, does not rob my argument of its merit. The argument is that there is in the House a group of members selected by the head of the Government to be members of the Seanad. They are entitled to all the privileges of membership. I suggest, however, that it is weighting the elective machine considerably in favour of the Government of the day if the 11 persons nominated by the head of the Government can register 55 first preference votes in a Seanad election. That is the principle upon which this amendment is based.

I would ask the House to have regard to the facts and to leave out of account individuals, estimable individuals like Senator Sir John Keane for instance. Think, for instance, of the effect of a group of votes of this magnitude in some future election. That vote may be decisive. Members of the House sitting opposite probably have it pre-eminently in their minds that a certain Government will be making these nominations after the next election. Suppose it happens that there is a change of Government after the next election. I am just wondering what Senator Hearne and Senator Hawkins will be saying in six or 12 months' time from such election because here is what it means. The head of the Government will have the right to nominate 11 persons but, no matter what else happens, the 11 people who are in the House now and who were nominees of the head of the present Government will have the right to register 55 first preference votes at the next election. It may please Senator Hearne to say: "Well we can account for a fair share of these 55 votes." That is true, but if there is a change of Government within the next two or three months, and another election takes place in a year or two, the balance will be cast against Senator Hearne and he may then see the error of passing over lightly the claim of the 11 persons nominated by the head of the Government to poll 55 votes in a Seanad election.

I am putting this view to the House without any regard to Party considerations, without any regard to the individuals concerned, without any regard to what any person may feel about the proposal. I am putting it to the House as a matter which requires serious consideration. Some people have, in fact, objected to the proposal that any retiring member would have the right to make a nomination or to have a vote. That argument has been put frequently from many quarters. I have heard it made repeatedly within the last 12 months. It has been argued, for instance, that in no kind of club is an outgoing member entitled to nominate himself or to vote for himself. I am not familiar with the rules of clubs and I do not know whether that is true, but it is suggested that it is derogatory to the State that outgoing members of this Assembly should be entitled to join in nominating themselves and voting for themselves. After all, if there is some person in this House pre-eminently popular amongst all members of the House, the 60 members of the House could almost inevitably secure his election against the world. I wonder is that good? My own feeling is that it is not, but I am not taking that wide field. I am just confining myself to the very narrow aspect, the part occupied by the 11 persons who, as I have said at the outset, enter the House, not through election, not through any process of representative organisation, whether it be election by the Houses of the Oireachtas or through the machinery of the nominating bodies. I have no personal feeling in the matter but I would urge on the House to consider whether it is not desirable that an amendment of this character should not be made.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Seing that Senator Duffy has paid me the honour of introducing my name into this debate and into the argument he has put forward, I think I must make my little contribution towards defeating his amendment. We must accept it that each and every member elected or selected to this House has an equal right and an equal standing and that each and every member selected by the Taoiseach has been selected because of some service which he or she rendered to the Irish nation in the past. I hope, no matter what Party is in power or no matter what person occupies the position of Taoiseach, he or she—because it may come to that—will bear these considerations in mind when he or she is making appointments to the Seanad.

Senator Duffy suggests that only those people who have been elected directly by the electorate should have a vote or a voice in the election of members of the Seanad. Does Senator Duffy suggest for one moment, that a member of this House who has been elected in the past by his own vote— and there are such members in this House—should have some particular privilege over and above those people who are selected by the Taoiseach because of some past service they have rendered to the nation? Does the Senator suggest that people who were chosen simply because they were members of a particular county council, to exercise a vote on the part of the county council, should have a right to a vote in this House over and above the people who were put here because, as I have already stated, of some service they have rendered to the nation?

Senator Duffy has fallen into what he often falls into—a muddle of figures. He tells us that if these 11 members selected by the Taoiseach are to have the same rights as members who were elected in the ordinary way, that is if they have votes in the election of the new Seanad, they would outweigh all the rest of the electorate.

Comment on this

Oh, my goodness, no.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

I did not interrupt Senator Duffy when he was speaking.

Comment on this

Surely the Senator is not entitled to misrepresent me?

Comment on this
An Leas-Chathaoirleach

Senator Duffy, on a point of explanation.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

I shall allow him to wrap himself up as much as he likes in figures.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Senator, I merely want to put him right. I never made any such fantastic statement as he has attributed to me.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

He has made so many fantastic statements that I would hardly be capable of picking out the most fantastic. To say that if these members selected by the Taoiseach have the right to take part in the election of the new Seanad, they will out-vote and overbalance all the other members of the Seanad——

Comment on this

Would the Senator permit me to correct him? Let me tell him what I did say. I said that these 11 people would exercise 55 first preference votes. Make what you like out of that in balances.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

We will examine this. There are 11 persons and an electorate of something like 980. Each of those has five votes and the 11 persons have 55 votes between them out of a total vote of almost 5,000. If Senator Duffy can convince me that the 55 votes can out-balance the votes of the elected representatives, I shall be satisfied.

Comment on this

The expression I used was that the 55 votes might be decisive.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

I will agree with the Senator that they may be as decisive as in the case of those members whom he and his Party supported in the past and elected to this House on their own votes.

Comment on this

We were not alone in that, thanks be to God.

Comment on this

I disagree with the amendment and I think much of the argument put up by Senator Duffy could be used against allowing a coopted member of a county council to have a vote. My main objection to his line of argument—and I agree with what Senator Hawkins said—is that here we have one type of Senator, the Senator who is nominated. As a member of the Seanad he is entitled to all the privileges and all the duties that that membership entails. I disagree very violently with one Senator who has been nominated here, Senator Sir John Keane, but I would be the very last to deprive him of any of the rights he enjoys here or the duties to which he attends so admirably. I believe it would be most invidious to make distinctions. In theory the votes might be decisive, but in actual practice I wonder how decisive those votes would be; whether these people are given votes or not, whether they will have 11 number ones or whether there will be 11 number ones less in the electorate, I believe the result of the election under this system would not be materially affected.

Comment on this

It may be considered unbecoming for me, being one of the selected members, to speak in this debate, but, with all respect to Senator Duffy, I do not think that my intervention is as unbecoming as is his amendment. As Senator Hawkins and Senator Hearne said, we are either members of the Seanad or we are not. We have the right to vote here in divisions and we enjoy all the privileges of the Seanad. Why should there be any difference?

Senator Duffy also hinted—and this is really the worst part of the whole thing—that the selections of the Taoiseach are political. They are not. There is, for instance, a vast difference between the politics of Senator Sir John Keane and the politics of Senator Matt Stafford. The political views of these two men are widely different. They have a different outlook altogether, one might almost say a different nationality. I think the amendment is most ill-advised, introducing as it does a very ugly spirit into the Seanad. For my part I consider that it is a greater honour for me to be selected by our Taoiseach than it would be if I were elected by the votes of every man and woman in the 32 Counties.

Comment on this

I should like to refer to Article 14 of the Constitution, which says:—

"Seanad Éireann shall be composed of 60 members of whom 11 shall be nominated members and 49 shall be elected members."

If we accept this amendment we will do something that is absolutely contrary to that Article of the Constitution, because we will be saying that some members of the Oireachtas who, according to the Constitution, are members, are not members at all. The definition says:—

"Member of the Oireachtas means a member of Dáil Éireann or Seanad Éireann."

Surely, you cannot have a qualification put into that which contradicts the Constitution? I submit that this amendment is entirely unconstitutional.

Comment on this

I think the Senator, in deference to the arguments that have been used against this amendment, will see the unwisdom of pressing it. There would be grave doubts. I am not a lawyer but, looking at it as a layman, I cannot see how you will divide the Seanad into two parts. The Seanad is a corporate entity and all the members of that entity must share the privileges and duties that attach to this House. It would be wrong for the Seanad to accept this amendment and I think the Senator, on reconsideration, will not press it.

My general attitude is that I am here as the agent of the joint committee; that is my position in relation to this Bill and I cannot advise the House, even if I thought the amendment were a good amendment—which I do not—to accept anything which would be so contradictory to the general spirit of the committee's report as this would.

Comment on this

Every member of the House who has spoken is opposed to the amendment. I think that is decisive, but I would like to point this out. The Minister was a member of the committee that examined this problem and I think he will agree that what we are now discussing was not considered at all by the committee—there was no view one way or the other. I have merely drawn attention to what I think is one of the weaknesses of the scheme. Others will probably emerge when we see the Act operating. I am satisfied that I have done my duty, but the House, apparently, is not willing to accept my amendment and therefore I shall withdraw it.

Comment on this

May I raise one point on Section 5? I am not sure whether there is much of a point in what I will refer to, but I should like to have it cleared up. This is the section which enables the Minister to make regulations. There is no provision in the Bill to have these regulations tabled. We have made it the practice for a long time that wherever that omission is detected we draw attention to it and usually Ministers agree that the regulations should be tabled and both Houses should have an opportunity of annulling them if they thought fit.

Comment on this

This section is taken from the old Act and it is not proposed to make any amendments in the existing law other than those which the committee recommend should be made. Accordingly, the section as it appears is taken holus-bolus from the existing Seanad Electoral Act, and I do not think it is necessary to amend it. There has not been any objection to the regulations made under that Act or to the forms and, so far as I am concerned, the regulations which will be made under this Bill will conform as closely as possible to the existing regulations.

If there is any feeling on the matter, I suggest that it is a subject the new House might consider, whether these regulations should be tabled or not. I would have no objection to tabling them, but I do not think any amendment is essential and I would ask the Senator not to consider making any amendment of this Bill at this stage. I have no objection, and I am sure no successor of mine will have any objection, to accepting a provision requiring the regulations to be tabled.

Comment on this

Between ourselves, I think the whole thing about tabling regulations was overlooked by the committee. It was not in the Act. I have looked through the Bill and I have come to the conclusion that the kind of regulations which remain under Section 5, in the main, are not the kind of regulations which ought to be annulled. I do not think there is a lot in it, although an occasion might arise where the House would be entitled to examine certain kinds of regulations. The Minister's statement that he is quite willing to table regulations, has no importance whatever unless both Houses have power to annul the regulations when tabled. I will not press it any further. I do not think it is worth while to press it under this section because the regulations, in the main, will be machinery regulations with which nobody will interfere.

Question agreed to.

Business suspended at 6 p.m. and resumed at 7 p.m.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:—

In page 10, line 30, after the word "subscriptions" to insert the words "fees, or other equivalent payments by its members".

This amendment is related to paragraph (d) of sub-section (2) of Section 8. That paragraph provides that the Seanad returning officer may refuse to register any body, with certain exceptions, of course, that is to say, any nominating body, unless its average annual revenue from subscriptions during a stated period amounts to a certain sum. The only difficulty I find is with regard to the use of the expression "subscriptions". The term is not defined in the Bill and normally, in common use, the word means a voluntary payment, a payment to a charity, a payment to any organisation which is not prescribed or fixed by rules. It seems to me that the use of that expression will present difficulty in respect to a number of organisations. The first that springs to my mind is the National Teachers' Organisation. Its income is not derived from subscriptions; it is derived from fixed contributions or fees. The same applies to other organisations, for instance, the Trade Union Congress. Its income is derived from fees prescribed in its rules and payable by the affiliated organisations—30, 40 or 50 affiliated organisations. It occurs to me that the phrase is inadequate and, in fact, may be misleading. I am endeavouring to insert additional words so that the purport of the paragraph would then be expressed something like this:

"The Seanad returning officer may refuse to register any body—with the stated exceptions—unless its organisation and direction are governed by articles of association, rules or other regulations which provide certain things and its average annual revenue from subscriptions, fees, or other equivalent payments by its members amount to a certain figure."

I am not tied to this amendment at all. I submit it is as a matter of importance in drafting this Bill. If the Minister is satisfied that the expression "subscriptions" has a defined meaning, that it is an expression that will admit to the register bodies of the type I have mentioned, I am satisfied on that assurance to withdraw the amendment, but I think the matter deserves to be raised and considered.

Comment on this

I do not think that it is necessary to amend the section in order to deal with the problem which Senator Duffy has in mind. The word "subscriptions" is not defined in the Bill and therefore, I take it, would have a very general application, and that anything which might be of the same nature or the same character as subscriptions, for instance, say the affiliation fee of an ordinary body would be regarded, and properly regarded, by the Seanad returning officer as a subscription. It would, perhaps, be better, I quite readily admit, if we had embodied the words, which Senator Duffy proposes to insert, in the original draft. I have looked into this from the point of view of the Senator's amendment and I am assured that the term "subscription" is not a restricting term. It is not, as I say, defined in the Bill, but it can be given a very comprehensive interpretation and would include anything which was of the same nature or character as a subscription.

Undoubtedly, what the joint committee had in mind was the sort of subscription which a person pays as an annual membership fee. I merely put it on record now that the Seanad returning officer will have regard to what I am saying—the matter may not arise at all—but if, subsequent to the passage of this Bill, the occasion arises, this is one of the points which, I think, we could properly deal with.

Comment on this

I had intended to raise this matter in a slightly different form. I do not know exactly what the Minister is trying to achieve. Is not the object to provide that the body is of some substance? It seems to me that it should be quite sufficient if its annual revenue reaches a particular figure. I do not see why you want fee or the word "subscription", or any particular description, in a case such as that. Take the case where a trade body or a number of trades—we have a number of trade associations of various kinds—get together for the purpose of doing some work. There may be a nominal annual subscription. It may not be the same in each year. That will depend on the work that it is proposed to undertake. Sometimes it may be work of a semi-research character. On the other hand, it may be work which will involve quite heavy expenditure. There are a number of such bodies which, I believe, would be perfectly suitable bodies for the purpose of making nominations. The amount subscribed by them may, as I have said, vary. In one year it may be five guineas and in another year the figure may run from 100 to 150 guineas, according to the work they propose to undertake. I think it would be quite sufficient to leave out the word "subscription" and say "its average annual revenue".

I do not think there is any definition in the Bill of what "a charitable body" is. I am not quite clear myself as to what a charitable body is as distinct from another kind of association. Let us suppose that all the people in trade A get together and that the voluntary subscription varies from one guinea to five guineas, can that body be described as a charitable body? I take it that it is not intended to be, but if not, what is intended to be a charitable body and why? There may be excellent reasons for the distinction that we find in the sub-section as between "£1,000 and not less than £250" in the case of a charitable body. In the past Senators will remember that there was a certain amount of keen competition to get on the register of nominating bodies. In view of that, these points are going to be extremely important in the future. I think, for instance, that the meaning of the word "subscription" will have to be decided. What the Minister says about the word "subscription" will have no legal effect. If there is going to be a dispute as to whether certain bodies will get on the register or not, the point that I am raising is an important one, and there should be some means of deciding it.

The same thing applies to the expression "charitable body". I draw attention to the words which appear a line or two above the one with which the amendment deals and which refer to "the audit and certification of accounts by a public auditor or other qualified person." What is the meaning of the words "or other qualified person"? I frequently audit the accounts of charitable bodies that I am connected with, and whether I am a qualified person or not is, of course, a matter of opinion. I do not know what the expression means as it is used in this section. It seems to me that it would be quite all right if it were a sort of general rule, but if a legal decision is going to be based on the use of such words, without any definition as to whether a body is qualified or not, then I think the use of such expressions is far too vague.

Comment on this

I think that we ought to distinguish between the procedure which contemplates interpretation by the courts of an expression in a statute and interpretation by a Departmental official. I think that is important. We have had that distinction raised in other cases, let us say the Unemployment Insurance Acts, the Widows' and Orphans' Pensions Acts and statutes of that kind. In the earlier days of these Acts relating to social insurance, the determination of such issues lay with the courts. One does appreciate the fact that a court is not influenced by anything that may be said by a Minister, or said by anyone else either in this or in the other House. I am not a lawyer, but I think it is a recognised practice amongst lawyers not to refer to debates in Parliament in the interpretation of statutes. I think that is axiomatic, but it is not quite so where the decision has to be made by a Departmental officer. I think it is quite proper to argue with an officer what the House believed they were doing when they passed a certain Bill into law.

Comment on this

Before an appeal board?

Comment on this

I accept that. I put down the amendment with that in view. There is that point to be cleared up, but if we can have the assurance that the expression "subscriptions" is all-embracing and does not exclude the payment of affiliation fees, for instance, I personally am satisfied and would not wish to press the amendment further.

Comment on this

I think the Senator is justified in feeling that it is not necessary to press the amendment further because, normally, the first decision in this matter would rest with an officer of this House, who will be the Seanad returning officer, the Clerk of Seanad Éireann. He is the first person who will be called upon to interpret the provisions of this section and I think we can rely on him to interpret them, having in mind the purpose of the section, which is to ensure that the composition or constitution of this House will not be vitiated by having on the register bodies which are not worthy to be there—bodies which have been started for a temporary purpose, bodies which are not genuinely representative of the interests which they claim to be concerned with, and bodies which have been established by a group of persons for the ad hoc purpose of having their names proposed for nomination by a nominating committee to one or other of the nominating bodies sub-panels.

So far as the general interpretation of this section is concerned, we may be certain that the Seanad returning officer will endeavour to interpret the provisions of this section in a reasonable and—it is rather difficult to find the word—at the same time, strict way. Accordingly, I assume that he will give a fairly broad interpretation to the term "subscription" as it is used in this connotation. It is quite clear that it is a general term intended to cover a great many forms in which revenue can be derived by a body claiming to represent a particular industrial, cultural or commercial interest. That is the first point I should like to make.

The next point arises in reply to Senator Douglas. This is not a matter which will ultimately and finally be decided by lawyers. If the decision of the Seanad returning officer is not acceptable to all the interests concerned, if people object to it either because they think he has been too lax in his ruling or too rigid in his interpretation of the section, there is an appeal to an appeal board, and the finding of that appeal board on a question of admission to the register is to be final and conclusive. The appeal board consists of men of experience in public life, men who are aware of what the Oireachtas was trying to do when it framed the provisions of the section. It is to consist of a chairman who is to be a judge of the Supreme Court or High Court nominated by the Chief Justice, the Chairman and Deputy-Chairman of Dáil Éireann and the Chairman and Deputy-Chairman of Seanad Éireann. I suppose the judge will be there to arbitrate should any conflict of opinion arise as between the four official members, so to speak, the four ex officio members of the tribunal, and we may be fairly certain that they will interpret the provisions of the section in approximately the way in which the joint committee anticipated they would be interpreted when they made this recommendation.

So far as the precise legal definition of the term "charitable body" is concerned, I do not think there is any difficulty in that regard because it is a term which has already been defined in common law. There must be very numerous decisions hinging around the proper interpretation of that term, so that, so far as the legal aspect is concerned, I do not think there will be any difficulty in getting guidance from existing decisions of the courts, not in relation to any particular matter which may arise here, because this cannot go to the courts, but in relation to matters which have arisen in the courts where the question of the proper interpretation of the term "charitable body" has been an issue.

Comment on this

Would the Minister give the reason why there should be a distinction?

Comment on this

I am afraid the Senator will have to study the report of the committee in that regard, though I can see why there might be that distinction. A charitable body is only entitled to be registered in respect of the Administrative Panel. The question will not arise in relation to the Cultural and Educational Panel, the Industrial and Commercial Panel, the Agricultural Panel or the Labour Panel. It arises only in connection with one panel, the Administrative Panel. In Section 3, the expression, "Administrative Panel" is prescribed to mean "the panel required by the said sub-section (1) to contain the names of persons having knowledge and practical experience of the following interests and services, namely, public administration and social services, including voluntary social activities." It is only in relation to registration on that panel that this question will arise. What is being provided for here is to ensure that, if we are going to give any body of men the highly exclusive right of nominating or proposing persons for nomination at an election of the Seanad, we will be satisfied that the bodies are substantial bodies which render real voluntary social service.

Senator Douglas asked me why we insist that a nominating body should have a substantial income. The reason is to prevent people——

Comment on this