We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill, 1947—Committee Stage.

Contributions 130–261 of 261. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Seanad Electoral (Panel Members) Bill 1947
Enacted

No. 43 of 1947 ›

I did not ask that. At least, I did not mean to ask it.

Comment on this

The Senator asked why we did not say that over the average of five years the nominating bodies, the trade organisations and others who might be nominating bodies, should have an annual average income of £250 or some such substantial sum.

Comment on this

All I meant to convey was that it was sufficient to say "revenue" without the word "subscriptions." I was not objecting to the amount.

Comment on this

There is a little more to it than that. Perhaps the use of the word "subscriptions" here may be misleading. What I think the committee really intended was that the income of the nominating body should be made up of genuine subscriptions or membership fees paid by a substantial body of persons. We did not want to have a situation arising in which a rich man might set up a trade organisation, defray all its expenses as an act of grace and not an act of duty—and even as an act of duty—and by reason of his having formed this ad hoc body, might get himself and his friends proposed for nomination by the nominating committee. It was to avoid that that the committee decided that we should have some sort of provision which would exclude what would be regarded by everybody as an undesirable practice.

Comment on this

I have listened carefully to the Minister and I honestly think that, if there is to be any amendment at all, there should be amendment there as regards subscriptions. I am not suggesting that Senator Duffy should press it at this stage, but if it is found that some amendments must be made, this should be considered. I do not think the word "subscription" makes it as plain as the Minister thinks, and I do not think there is anything in his last point at all. As this is worded, the revenue from subscriptions of £250 could be £240 from one person and £1 from each of ten persons and, under the section as it stands, he is completely under a delusion if he thinks the words would prevent what he has outlined. I am not worried about it, as I do not think it is a serious danger. The words do not say that each subscription must be of the same amount—and could not say so. If the Minister thinks they do, he is quite wrong.

Comment on this

The sub-section says that "the Seanad returning officer may refuse" to register a body unless these conditions are complied with. It is not mandatory on him. In the case of the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, there may be some doubt as to whether the fees would be deemed to be subscriptions, but even if they were not so deemed, the Seanad returning officer would still have power to admit them. Senator Douglas quoted some bodies who might be very worthy nominating bodies. If they comply first of all with the conditions embodied in Section 3, then even if their subscriptions do not come to the figures mentioned here the Seanad returning officer will still have power to admit them, as it is not essential that this requirement be complied with.

There was a good deal of discussion in the joint committee about this and the figures were amended many times. The wording that the Seanad returning officer "may refuse" to register was agreed on in the end, to admit of the case none of us could think of at the moment but which might actually arise, when these conditions would not be complied with, and then the returning officer would still have discretion to admit them, if he held they should be a nominating body.

Comment on this

I am very glad to hear Senator Hearne's explanation, as I did not read it in that way and I do not think in practice it would work out in that way. The Seanad returning officer will in future be an official of this House and it seems to me that, as between the various applicants, he will have to devise a set of rules which he will apply scrupulously and fairly. The appeal committee will have to do the same. It would be quite impossible for the returning officer to admit A.B., who has only £100, saying: "I think you are suitable," and say to another: "I am refusing you because I do not think I can admit you under this Bill." Technically, Senator Hearne is correct that he has the discretion, but I do not think he could exercise his sole discretion. The fact that there is an appeal board rather suggests that the appeal will have to be heard on pretty fair lines as between all the different bodies and in a very short time the board will have, not rules but standards which it will try to apply impartially. If it has not, the whole system will break down.

If it is not possible to have a pretty fair practice, understood by all, as to the kind of body which can get on this register, this plan will not be successful. It must be remembered that the position was quite different in the past, where the total was limited and where, as between two bodies, the officer could say he preferred one but would let both in if he could. It will be unlimited here and there will have to be some sort of standard. I take it from reading the report and the section that the section was put in because, the number being unlimited, there had to be set out some kind of lines on which the returning officer would be able to refuse. I think we must assume that these are to be standards which he will expect from everybody and if he did not do that there would be trouble.

Comment on this

The amendment deals with this one word "subscriptions" and this discussion on the income of voluntary societies is entirely beside the issue. All I want to get decided at this point is whether we can have a firm assurance from the Minister that the expression "subscriptions" used in this section is adequate to cover the kind of income which is derived by certain types of organisations from their numbers or from bodies affiliated with them. The Trade Union Congress, for instance, has been a nominating body in the past and there seems to be no reason why it would not be so in the future, unless this expression "subscriptions" might be held to exclude the Trade Union Congress on the grounds that they did not have an income of £250 a year from "subscriptions" and that their total income was derived from affiliation fees paid to them on a capitation basis by the affiliated bodies.

In the case of the Trade Union Congress, this section can be set at nought, as their income will be £2,000 or £3,000 a year for affiliation fees. It is quite easy for them, if they want to qualify for the purpose of this section, to tell one organisation liable to pay a fee of £250 not to pay that fee but to send a subscription of £250 instead, to bring them within the Bill. Therefore, I am not pleading their case, as this limitation means nothing to them. It may, however, have a meaning somewhere else and I am trying to get that cleared up.

I would like to remind Senator Hearne that the committee was very definite that these figures should go in for a definite purpose. The definite purpose was (1) that organisations which claimed to be entitled to be nominating bodies should have something of stability; they should be some kind of organisation with continuity. They should have an income, they should have an office and they should have their accounts examined by an auditor. All that was intended for the purpose of making it clear to the Seanad returning officer that he was not to admit bodies specially created overnight for the purpose of being nominating bodies.

The same is true of charitable organisations. The committee discussed this thing for a long time and one of our colleagues was very anxious as to how the money side was to be settled on the grounds that the organisation in which he was interested, a powerful organisation which dominated and cowed the Minister——

Comment on this

"Cowed" is good.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Let the Senator proceed.

Comment on this

——An organisation of great influence had a very small income, although the Minister jocosely suggested that one of its members could lose £250 in a poker game between Dublin and Mullingar.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Why Mullingar?

Comment on this

Let us say Mallow, then. I recall this incident——

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Why Mullingar?

Comment on this

The Senator wants to write a catechism on this Bill, but I want to point out the significance of these references to certain sums of money. In building up the records of this House we ought not say that we would tell the Seanad returning officer that he may ignore the reference to £250 or £1,000. If you look at the report you will find that it was clearly intended that these should be minimum sums and that they were there for a purpose. A body that claimed to be a charitable organisation could not make a claim until it had an income of £1,000. In the same way, with trade bodies, whether workers' organisations, manufacturers' organisations or anything else, it was clearly intended that they should be bodies with certain rules, bodies with an office, with office equipment and an income from contributions. I think the word "subscriptions" has slipped in here in relation to the voluntary bodies rather than the trade bodies. All the time, we had in mind the expression "contributions". Again I want to say that if the Minister shows the House that the word "subscriptions" in this section is not a limiting one and will cover payment such as fees or contributions paid by, let us say, members of the teachers' organisation, I am satisfied that the amendment serves its purpose.

Comment on this

Senator Duffy is quite right. The Minister and any member of the joint committee will recollect that this question was very much debated. I raised the question on behalf of my own organisation. I said that there were 12 organisations affiliated to the national executive. The national executive as such had no income of its own, but still the national executive had a considerable amount of money at its disposal. Every member of the committee, including the Minister, assured me that such an organisation would not be objected to, or even if it were, an appeal would make it right. There could not, by any stretch of the imagination, be an objection and the same would apply to Senator Duffy's trade union congress. I am satisfied, as far as the organisation which I represent is concerned, that it should be passed as qualified to nominate candidates.

Comment on this

That is most important.

Comment on this

I think that undue consideration has been given to this particular paragraph (d) of sub-section (2), which is merely a sort of guide set up for the returning officer in case he might happen to be in doubt, while no attention has been devoted to the more positive provisions in sub-section (2) of the section. Sub-section (2) provides that a body shall not be eligible to be registered on the register in respect of any particular panel unless——

Comment on this

The Minister can raise a whole lot of points when we come to the section. At present we are only discussing the amendment.

Comment on this

Senators raised points on the amendment which involved a discussion of the section.

Comment on this

I thought it might save time.

Comment on this
Seán Goulding An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

It might be better if we left these points to the discussion on the section.

Comment on this

May I make one slight correction? I want to apologise if I misled anybody in regard to the decision of the committee. I have the report here and the actual word set out is "subscriptions." We have misled the draftsman as well as misleading ourselves.

Comment on this

Would Senator Duffy agree that supposing the Trade Union Congress had not a bob in subscriptions in any year, that it was the intention of the committee that that body should be a nominating body?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

Or the Congress of Irish Trade Unions. But I do not want to interfere in family quarrels.

Comment on this

That was the only point I made. It is not essential to have an income, be it a shilling, a pound or £10,000, in order to have a body admitted as a nominating body. Even if there was validity in the argument that the word "subscriptions" did not cover the fees that might be paid by members, it would not be essential, as that body could still be admitted as a nominating body. Practice will show that appeals to the appeal board will be against the decision of the Seanad returning officer in exercising the discretion given to him under this section.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to accept Deputy Hearne's interpretation of the report.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:—

In page 10, lines 43 and 44, to delete the words "or of persons who are in the employment of local authorities".

This raises another issue which was not covered by the committee. It relates to the type of organisation that is, by statute, prevented from being a nominating body. This section with which we are now dealing lays down principles to guide the Seanad returning officer when he has applications before him from nominating bodies for admission to the register which he will compile under this Bill. Senator Hearne a few minutes ago spoke of the discretion which the Seanad returning officer is entitled to use in forming a decision on an application from a prospective nominating body. In this instance he is deprived of that discretion. He is definitely warned that he may not register as a nominating body any body of persons who are in the employment of local authorities. There is a number of such bodies. I know of three or four and I assume that there are others.

For instance, there is a body in Dublin known as the Irish Municipal Employees' Trade Union. It is a local body or almost exclusively a local body, if it is not entirely so. Its membership consists almost entirely, but not exclusively, of employees of the Dublin Corporation, the Dublin County Council and the other local authorities in Dublin city and county. It has also members outside Dublin. For instance, it has members, I think, in Limerick and in some other centres. The members of that organisation are persons in the employment of local authorities. Consequently, their organisation is definitely excluded from the list of bodies that may become, for Seanad election purposes, nominating bodies. We have another organisation such as the Local Government Employees' Organisation which, I think, covers the whole of the Twenty-Six Counties and embraces probably 90 per cent. of the clerical and technical staffs employed by local authorities, by corporations, by urban councils, by county councils and the like. Then we have a body such as the Vocational Officers' Organisation which, I think, has circularised members of this House in relation to its position. I am not concerned entirely and, in fact, not concerned mainly, with the Vocational Officers' Organisation. I am concerned with the principle expressed in this Bill that a body of persons employed by the local authorities in this country, having formed themselves into an organisation exclusively confined to their own employment, should be precluded from being nominated. I think that is wrong. I wonder even if it is constitutional to exclude from the right to become a nominating body a particular section of our citizens. Here is an anomaly. The Irish Municipal Employees' Trade Union is affiliated to the Irish Trade Union Congress and, as such, participates in the activities of that body in relation to Seanad elections.

In other words, it has influence on the decisions of the Trade Union Congress concerning the activities of that organisation as a nominating body. A body like the local government officials may not be, and I think in fact is not, affiliated to any national body. They, therefore, are deprived of any right to participate as an organised body in the work of creating a Seanad. I do not think there is any justification for that. I do not think the employees of a local authority, whether they are clerical, technical or manual, should be excluded specifically from the provisions of this Bill merely because, and only because, they are the employees of a local authority. If a body of employees such as, let us say, Córas Iompair Éireann desire to form an organisation they may do so and they may make application to the Seanad returning officer to become a nominating body. The Seanad returning officer will be free to form a judgment on their application. He may admit or refuse to admit them according to the circumstances of the particular case presented to him. At any rate, they are free to make the application and the Seanad returning officer is free to consider it. In the case of the employees of the Dublin Corporation that freedom is taken away under this Bill. I do not know on what principle this decision has been taken except that in drafting this Bill the Minister followed the provisions of the Act of 1927. The same provision exists in that Act. The employees of local authorities are precluded from forming themselves into a body capable of being a nominating body for Seanad purposes. The Minister may say: "Well, ten years ago both Houses approved of that principle." That is probably true. I have not looked up the debates. I do not know if there was any protest. It may have been unanimous. That, I hope, will not be interpreted as precluding me from making a case now that they should be admitted. I want the House to consider that case on its merits and not in relation to any decision which was taken positively or by misadvertence ten years ago.

Comment on this

I would like to support the amendment proposed by Senator Duffy. In doing so I wish to call attention to the fact that there are two branches of teachers, primary teachers and secondary teachers, and each is on the list of nominating bodies. The vocational teachers feel that there is unfair differentiation. There does not appear to be any logical reason for such differentiation. Largely because of that I support this amendment. I would, in fairness to the Minister, mention that the body which is frequently confused with the teachers' body—the Vocational and Educational Organisation—is a nominating body. At first sight it might seem that that body meets the cases of the teachers.

It has to be borne in mind that no teacher is a member of that body. The ordinary rank and file of the teaching body are not members of it at all. Chief executive officers are the only people who are admitted to that body. To some extent the teachers have a grievance because they maintain that their particular interests are not catered for. The primary teachers' salaries are paid from some source. Their salaries do not fall like manna from Heaven. Clearly the State pays them. That particular body is admitted to the register of nominating bodies, yet this other body, the salaries of which are partly paid by the State and partly by the local authorities, is excluded. Secondary teachers are in more or less the same position. The salaries of these teachers are largely borne by the State. It is difficult to justify this somewhat invidious discrimination.

I think each member of this House has been furnished with a copy of a circular issued by the Vocational Officers' Organisation concerned in this matter. The case for admission is very ably explained in the circular. The following quotation is given:—

"It is on the general principle that it is inadvisable that public servants such as these referred to here should have political affiliations with a political Party that this amendment is introduced. I think it will be generally conceded that it is not advisable there should be any close relation between public servants and political parties, because public servants are supposed to do their work in the public interest, irrespective of what particular Party or Government is in office."

Anyone who knows the position knows that teachers differ among themselves in regard to politics. No two of them belong to the same Party. Almost every Party has some representation amongst the teachers. Labour is represented, Fianna Fáil is represented, Fine Gael is represented, and so on. I am sure that the new embryonic Party is also represented. There is no justification, therefore, for the suggestion that teachers as a whole must necessarily belong to any one political Party. I have to deal with six teachers on my own staff and I know that I would find it impossible to say what their political affiliations are; but I do know that every Party is represented—every Party without exception—in that body. The political argument, therefore, cuts no ice at all. I would suggest that the Minister should delete the words suggested by Senator Duffy. If that is done the field will be an open one and this particular body can be admitted to the register of nominating bodies. There is no justification for its exclusion.

Comment on this

The only comment I would like to make is to remind this House that this Bill merely implements the recommendations of the committee. The point raised by Senator Duffy opens up a very, very wide field as to whether employees of local authorities should take a more active interest in affairs of State than they do at present. In view of the importance of the point raised and its all-embracing character I would submit that we should remember that we here are merely dealing with this Bill as one which implements the recommendations of the committee. This point was not considered by the committee and it is too important a point to be discussed here and to be decided here and now on a Committee Stage like this.

While I have a good deal of sympathy with what Senator Duffy has said, I can see that there are grave implications involved. Supposing the amendment were adopted, there is an organisation known as the county managers' organisation; I have very grave doubts as to whether that organisation would comply with all the conditions. They are employees of local authorities; I have very grave doubts as to whether they would be a proper body to be a nominating body. There is a county surveyors' organisation; again, I have very grave doubts as to whether they would be a proper body to be a nominating body. I think this is a matter upon which there would be a large volume of differences of opinion. So important is the point and so wide is it in its implications that it has not been considered by the committee. We here are merely implementing the recommendations of the committee. I would remind the House that some of us spent the best part of 18 months at these committee meetings. If there is any point in Senator Duffy's amendment, then he slipped up badly in not having the matter discussed at the committee.

Comment on this

I left it to the Senator as the chairman of a local authority.

Comment on this

I think that Senator Hearne's speech is the most remarkable one that has been made on this Bill so far. Are we discussing a possible permanent or a temporary measure? We are discussing a Bill that will be as permanent as any other piece of legislation that has gone through the Oireachtas. Senator O'Dea pointed that out earlier in the debate. Senator Hearne now introduces the extraordinary note at this stage of the discussion that, because this has not come from the committee as a recommendation, it must not be seriously considered by this House.

Comment on this

I said that we should be very careful. I did not say it should not be considered.

Comment on this

Let us be very careful. If the sort of care that we are exercising means that we are passing a faulty piece of legislation, which is going to react inequitably against certain classes of the community, then we are not exercising a proper degree of care. I have no very positive view one way or the other with regard to the question of groups of local employees who decide to organise themselves vocationally being included within the scope of the Bill and being regarded as suitable for registration as a nominating body. I quite see Senator O'Reilly's point with regard to the Vocational Teachers' Organisation. They have protested against their exclusion. The Taoiseach says it is no use pretending they are not politicians. Of course, they are politicians. Some of them are very vigorous politicians attached to the Minister's own Party.

Comment on this

It would all depend on what you define as a politician.

Comment on this

Otherwise bigoted.

Comment on this

I did not say they were bigoted at all. I said they were exercising their rights.

Comment on this

I do not know whether I am getting deaf or whether the acoustics in this place are faulty.

Comment on this

Senator O'Reilly has made his point. I do not see why, if certain groups are admitted, certain others should be excluded. What is Senator Hearne's reason for urging consideration of this point? What is his real reason? If we were passing some measure that was only going to operate upon one isolated occasion and then terminate, there might be some reason for not considering this matter now. But this is permanent legislation. In one of the early sections of this Bill there is a very serious flaw which raises a fundamental question. Senator Hearne does not wish to have it examined. Could there be any greater condemnation of the policy of urging us to put this Bill through the House with all possible haste than this effort to rule out all possibility of discussing and examining the matter with a view to amendment? That is the attitude taken up here now.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Senator Baxter in his closing remarks suggests that we are putting this Bill through in haste. I can assure Senator Baxter from this side of the House that we are prepared to meet next week; we are prepared to meet the week after and the week following that and, if necessary, the week following that in order to give every consideration to this Bill and to have the very able and eloquent criticisms as to how it might be improved. We had here some few months ago a suggestion that a committee should be set up. We agreed to that. We agreed that we in this House would unite with the other House in setting up a committee to consider and recommend to us, what would be as near as human effort could go, an ideal Seanad. I think I would be safe in saying that that committee met on many occasions.

One very significant fact was that there were no representatives there on behalf of the Party which Senator Baxter represents at present, that they, we might say, boycotted that committee, that they did not come forward at that time when they could be so useful and could offer us their guidance as to what the composition of this Seanad might be. But the leader of that Party suggests now that, while this might be a very commendable Bill and might be a very good Bill to operate at the next Seanad election, the best thing we could do, while we might operate the Bill for 12 months, to give him and his colleagues another 12 or 15 months to consider what they might contribute towards it.

Comment on this

What has this to do with the amendment?

Comment on this
Seán Goulding An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I think the Senator is dealing with the amendment.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

I propose to deal with the amendment now. Senator Duffy has tabled an amendment to this Bill. He proposes that all employees of local authorities should have a say in the formation of the new Seanad. I think that is a very bad proposal coming from Senator Duffy. Senator Duffy purports to come into this House as the leader and the spokesman of the Irish Labour Party. I am not going to dispute that. I am not going to dispute his right to speak on their behalf. I can only say that his proposal is one which I cannot understand, which he has not explained to us and which I would like him to explain more definitely.

Comment on this

Perhaps I might be permitted to state the point of view which I hold as the representative of the joint committee as a whole. As I pointed out when I introduced it, this Bill embodies the recommendations of the joint committee and it does not do anything else. When the Bill was being considered in Dáil Éireann, I pointed out that we had an agreed report from the committee and that this Bill represented that agreement. I think it would be an undesirable breach of that agreement if we were to amend the Bill to include provisions which did not embody the recommendations of the committee or which did not arise immediately out of these recommendations. There are many members of Dáil Éireann who would have views upon this matter. They would probably be conflicting views. There are many members of the Seanad who would have views on this matter and, again, they would be conflicting views. It was felt in the other House that it would be improper, although naturally they would have the right to amend the Bill in any way they liked, to reject the recommendations of the committee. It was felt, having regard to the history of the committee, to the fact that the report was an agreed one, that it would in fact be little better than a breach of faith to amend the existing law governing the election of the Seanad in any vital or significant way. That, I think, was the frame of mind in which this Bill was considered in the other House. While it is undeniable that the Seanad can make any amendment it likes in this Bill, if it does, then I will say that the Seanad will be breaking faith, because, after all, this House did put its representatives on that committee——

Comment on this

As plenipotentiaries?

Comment on this

Well, as representatives who could speak for the House as a whole, because they were chosen from all Parties. They got, if you like, a mandate to act and to speak on behalf of the House in the same way as members of Dáil Éireann got a mandate to speak and discuss the matter on behalf of Dáil Éireann. While it is true that they did not come there as plenipotentiaries, nevertheless there is always an honourable understanding that, when you appoint a man to consider a problem and to discuss it on your behalf, you will accept the decision to which he comes, particularly, when it is a matter of agreement between a number of conflicting views. That is the position in relation to this Bill. I suggest, therefore, to Senator Duffy not to press this amendment, because I would have to ask the Seanad to reject it and I certainly would have to ask Dáil Éireann—I have definite views about it —not to reject it on its merits, if the Senator believes it has merits, as many Senators do, but to reject it on the ground that we were estopped by reason of the fact that we were participating in the deliberations of this committee through our representatives and that, therefore, we ought to abide by the agreement to which they came.

Comment on this

I entirely agree with the Minister that the committee consisted of representatives of both Houses impartially chosen by the committee of selection. There is no question about that and we ought not to quibble about it. The committee was chosen to do a particular job set out in the terms of reference. With all respect to Senator Hawkins, I think that committee did its job pretty well. There is no use in finding fault and saying that certain people did not turn up, that certain people did not take an interest in it. That is probably true. But there were always present a considerable number of people who reflected different points of view. So far as I can remember, all the decisions of the committee were unanimous. I do not remember any point being settled in the committee by a majority vote. Let us get it clear, at any rate, that there is nothing being put across us. In fairness, I think the House ought to say about the members of the committee that they did attend a number of meetings. They were not all present at all the meetings. It was not necessary for them to be present at a meeting which was held in bad weather, for instance, if they had to travel very long distances.

There was an all-round good attendance and all-round keen attention given to the matter under review. A number of members submitted amendments to drafts just as they did here. I must plead guilty to submitting a fair number of them, as Senator Hawkins would probably agree. He almost accused me of maliciously submitting amendments. I have some recollection that on one or two occasions the Minister, in fact, seconded an amendment of mine. You can imagine how far we were able to travel when we had the Minister for Local Government seconding an amendment which I moved. We have reached the stage now when we have the Bill before us and the only difficulty I am in in regard to this is that if the Minister and Senator Hawkins make the case that we have an agreement which precludes acceptance of an amendment of this kind I must join issue on that. I must join issue with the suggestion that we are obliged by our adherence to the terms of the committee's report to reject an amendment like this.

Comment on this

I thought I had made it clear to Senators that they can make any amendment they wish to the section but I am saying that it would certainly be contrary to the spirit of the discussions, and the spirit in which the report was conceived and adopted, to make any proposal to amend in a significant way the existing law otherwise than as is recommended by the committee.

Comment on this

I accept the view that this is a significant amendment to the existing law. I accept the statement of Senator Hearne that the matter was not adverted to at the committee. I do not know whose fault it was. Probably some of us who feel that the existing law is not easily justified should have adverted to it but, in fact, it was not adverted to. I have a suspicion, however, that members of the committee like Senator Hearne who are closely associated with the administration of local authorities might have some responsibility in this matter——

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

——and should have raised it. As we are in agreement I do not propose to press the amendment further.

Comment on this

I have a perfectly open mind on some aspects of the amendment—for instance, on the case made for the vocational teachers. There is a good deal of weight in that but there are other organisations of local employees who, I think, would not be suitable as nominating bodies.

Comment on this

I am prepared to accept that. I had three organisations in my mind—the Vocational Teachers' Organisation, the Local Government Officials' Union and the Irish Municipal Employees' Trade Union.

Comment on this

The first body that came into my mind when I read the amendment was the County Managers' Association.

Comment on this

In view of what I heard from the Minister, I do not think there is much point in raising a matter which I have in mind. We spent a lot of time discussing the hardships inflicted on some organisation because they had not the right to nominate. I am going to call the Minister's attention to some instances where the right to nominate is duplicated. Take the case of the Cattle Traders' Association and a number of employers' organisations. These people have the right to make nominations in their own right and, through their associations or affiliations, they have the right to influence nominations to other panels. In the case of the Cattle Traders' Association, they have the right to make nominations to the Agricultural Panel and through their affiliations with the chambers of commerce, they can exercise their influence in nominations to other panels. The same thing applies to the Irish Manufacturers' Association and other bodies. The Employers' Association has the right within itself of making nominations and through their amalgamations or associations with other federations, they have the right to make nominations to other panels.

Comment on this

That is not so. That is a statement too serious to let pass unchallenged. If Senator Foran is referring to the Federation of Irish Manufacturers, the only right they have is to nominate members of their own. They have no affiliation or contact other than friendly contacts with any other organisation at all. Surely he is not making the case that a body of such importance should not have the right to nominate?

Comment on this

I am making the case that they are affiliated with chambers of commerce.

Comment on this

They are nothing of the kind and that statement should not be made. The federation has nothing to do with the chambers of commerce any more than the Trade Union Congress has.

Comment on this

It has not.

Comment on this

There is no organisation of employers affiliated to chambers of commerce?

Comment on this

To the best of my belief, no.

Comment on this

Senator Counihan admits that the Cattle Traders' Association is affiliated with chambers of commerce.

Comment on this

I made no such admission. I said that members of our association may be members of a chamber of commerce.

Comment on this

Of course, there is no point in pressing the thing but I think there is a case there that should be looked into.

Comment on this

Even the Dublin Chamber of Commerce is not a nominating body. It only gets whatever nomination it can through the fact that it is a member of the Associated Chambers of Commerce. It is the Associated Chambers of Commerce of Ireland which has the right to nominate on behalf of all the chambers of commerce. That is a distinct body and the Federation of Irish Manufacturers is as distinct from the chamber of commerce as any trade union congress, by whatever colour we describe it.

Comment on this

I did not say the Dublin Chamber of Commerce had the right to nominate but these organisations have a certain influence in determining nomination to other panels. It is certainly a matter that should be looked into. If an organisation has a right of its own to make a nomination, it should be asked to declare that it would not enter into other panels or use its influence to secure nominations to other panels. That is all I want to call the Minister's attention to.

Comment on this

There are one or two points in connection with this section that require consideration. I think there is possibly more in the point raised by Senator Foran than appears on the surface. I am opposed to any consideration of the scheme which provides for an unlimited number on the panel. This particular section is a very good illustration of one of the reasons why I doubt it will work. I think it is impracticable to define in any section— and I do not think it is satisfactorily defined in this section—what is to be the qualification. I think it is possible to set out a line of desirable ideas and then say that 15, 12, ten or whatever the number is which best conform to these, shall be chosen, but to make the number unlimited will lead to very considerable difficulty. Whereas Senator Summerfield's statement may be correct as regards the old Act, I do not think it is necessarily correct as regards the new Bill. I think it is quite likely that all the chambers of commerce would be qualified but it is not for me to say now whether they will get on the register. That question will arise when the proper time comes. Of course, it is quite true that I am a member of the Federation of Irish Manufacturers. I am also a member of a chamber of commerce. It is equally true that certain trade unions are said to be going into trade and it is quite likely that some of their members will qualify under the labour section and also under the commercial section, and there will be a certain amount of overlapping.

Comment on this

It will be time enough to raise that when they enter.

Comment on this

The Senator is quite right, and it will be equally time enough for him to raise it when this comes into operation. The Minister, with all his ingenuity and all his staff, could not work out a section which would provide that you could have nominating bodies which will guarantee that no one of their members belongs to another nominating body. This is one of the things you will have to put up under a scheme like this; unless you can produce another system, there will be overlapping, and Senator Foran to that extent is right.

I am bothered very much about paragraph (d). It says:—

"the Seanad returning officer may refuse to register any body (not being an excepted body) in the register unless——"

That seems to me that he cannot refuse to register them, except on the grounds that they are excepted bodies, if they have all these other qualifications. If it does not mean that, I do not know what it means. When you come to the particular qualifications, they are badly drafted. I think they are absurd. One of the provisions here is:—

"——its organisation and direction are governed by articles of association, rules or other regulations which——"

Now, the articles of association, rules or other regulations, are to do certain things. One of the things they are to do is to provide that the agenda must include the minutes of the preceding meeting. No rules ever provide that. That has been taken for granted for a long time. Articles of association do not show that the agenda must have included among its items the minutes of the preceding meeting. Articles of association, rules or other regulations do not say that that must be on the agenda and do not provide for all the other things that are there.

Again, I do not know of any body which has in its rules that there must be an audit and a certification of accounts by a public auditor or other qualified person. It is not said that the accounts must be duly audited and submitted to the annual meeting. You may take it that there probably is not a single body on the register at the moment which will have in its rules or regulations or articles of association what is set out in paragraph (d).

If this Bill were considered properly, this would be brought up again on Report after careful consideration in order to see whether it could not be simplified. I was not on the committee and I do not know whether they chose those words, but I imagine that they were anxious to provide that it would be an association with proper rules providing for an annual meeting, that there would be a proper executive and that the accounts would be audited. I doubt if the committee insisted that the accounts must be audited by a public auditor.

Comment on this

It does say that.

Comment on this

I think they hardly meant it; they were concerned to see that there would be an audit. I am not attacking the Minister. I suggest that if the committee had gone through the rules and regulations and articles of association of a dozen of the nominating bodies, that would have to be worded differently.

Comment on this

This matter did arise specifically in committee and I took the opportunity of pointing out there some of the difficulties that would arise in relation to organisations about which I know something. I have in mind in particular the Irish Trade Union Congress. I am not speaking here for the Irish Trade Union Congress and I want Senator Hawkins to get that out of his mind.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

Why do you pick on Senator Hawkins?

Comment on this

In view of a few misdirected remarks of the Senator a moment ago, I came to the conclusion that he was of the opinion that I came here to represent the Irish Trade Union Congress or the Labour movement. I would remind the Senator that he is a member of the Labour Panel. I am a member of the Commercial and Industrial Panel. That may be all wrong but it is true. I think we ought to be strictly fair, irrespective of the panel to which we belong or the interests with which we are associated outside. I want to be fair to a body like the Irish Trade Union Congress or the Irish National Teachers' Organisation.

When I come to read the paragraph to which Senator Douglas referred I find myself at once in a difficulty. I would like to draw attention to this, that the Seanad returning officer may refuse—I take it in certain circumstances he would be coerced to refuse —to register any body, with certain exceptions, unless its organisation and direction are governed by articles of association, rules or other regulations which, amongst other things, provide for an annual general meeting to which all the members are invited by notice. I understand that there are, or were, 12,000 members in the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, of whom about 2,500 reside outside the jurisdiction of this State. If this paragraph means what it appears to me to mean, the Irish National Teachers' Organisation, in order to qualify for inclusion in the register of nominating bodies, must invite all its members, including perhaps the members in the Six Counties. I do not press that, but excluding them, they would be required to invite 10,500 people to an annual meeting, I assume in the Phoenix Park, for the purpose of considering the agenda, the balance sheet and the other items set out here.

I do not want to put my view against the views of people more competent to judge what the section means, but I urge that this point must be cleared up to the satisfaction of the House before we put ourselves on record as passing a statute designed to create nominating bodies for the purpose of electing a Seanad with the full knowledge in our minds that a number of the bodies who, we assumed in the past, and who, we still assume, are entitled to nominate bodies will be precluded from doing so by virtue of this paragraph.

Comment on this

May I also draw the Minister's attention to paragraph (c)? I omitted doing so when I spoke first on the section. I believe this presents considerable difficulty. The paragraph says: " a body which is formed or carried on wholly or substantially for profit," etcetera, is not eligible. There is quite a number of trade organisations—I think the Federation of Irish Manufacturers is one —which, while not in one sense a profit-making body, in that it does not distribute any profits, is for the purpose of income-tax a profit-making body: it pays income-tax on its profits.

Comment on this

It is not carried on wholly for profit.

Comment on this

It says wholly or partly.

Comment on this

It is not carried on wholly or substantially for profit.

Comment on this

I want to make a point that care is necessary. I am not pressing it any further than this, that for the purpose of income-tax it is regarded as a profit-making body. That applies to quite a number of other bodies and that is done by arrangement with the Revenue Commissioners so that subscriptions will be allowed as part of their expenses to those who pay them. That will affect quite a few nominating bodies and it is important that it should be quite clear that the expression "carried on for profit" will not have the same meaning as it would have for income-tax purposes. I am not trying to argue. I am merely raising a point that requires some consideration.

Comment on this

I do not know whether members are familiar with the existing law in relation to this matter or not. This sub-section is taken almost bodily from the existing Act and there has been no difficulty ever raised about the Federation of Irish Industries or any other organisation, which for income-tax purposes might be regarded as making a profit.

Comment on this

I do not think they were at the time they were put on the register.

Comment on this

They have gone on the register every year. The Dental Board is in the same position.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it was ever raised.

Comment on this

The point of the matter is that even if everything that Senator Douglas says is true, even if we did compel the National Teachers' Organisation to circularise its 12,000 members, what harm? Do we realise that we are giving these nominating bodies a very special privilege? They are not entitled to make proposals for nomination to the Seanad as of natural right. It is something which we are conferring on them by law to the exclusion of a great number of other people and, surely, if they want to be nominating bodies the first thing they have to do is to comply with the provisions of the law. It is not what the nominating bodies desire. It is what precautions this House and the Oireachtas think should be embodied in legislation to prevent undesirable or insubstantial groups of persons, self-seeking persons if you like, getting the right to propose for nomination candidates for the Seanad. That is the reason we have these provisions.

My criticism of this section is quite contrary to Senator Douglas's or Senator Duffy's. I do not think it is stringent enough but that view did not prevail in the committee and, in deference to the views of a number of other members of the committee, I did not press it. I would not have allowed any body to become a nominating body that had not been properly incorporated. I should have gone a lot further than the provision of this section.

Comment on this

So would I.

Comment on this

Yes. But, as I have said, we were there as a joint committee representing both Houses and all Parties. We deferred to each other's point of view and we tried to get, and did succeed in getting, agreement. That is why I would regard it as a breach of faith if any significant amendment were to be made in this Bill outside of those which were not included in the recommendations of the committee because I would have felt that I had been fairly dealt with and I know there were other members of that committee who had taken the same point of view. I know there were many members of Dáil Eireann who would have liked to put in amendments to the Bill as it was then to give effect to their point of view but they simply accepted the position that this was an agreed Bill, that it is largely experimental, as we may be certain that, perhaps, some of the Bills which will amend it will be.

We are, as I said, feeling our way. But at any rate we have to give to the returning officer here certain standards or certain directives to guide him. The principal directive is that bodies are not to be eligible to be registered unless their objects primarily relate to or are connected with the interests and services mentioned in the Constitution and that their activities are mainly concerned with such interests and services, or their members are representative of persons who have knowledge and practical experience of such interests and services. We want the body to have a representative character. We want it to be a substantial body, a body with a real existence, that does real work.

We have told the returning officer that if he is in doubt as to whether a body is representative, if he is in doubt as to whether it is substantial in character, as to whether it is in fact a body which is proper to be given the privilege of proposing for nomination, then he has these other things to which he may turn. He can look at the body and say, "this is a body that has not met for the last three years; this is a body that does not keep minutes; there is no record made of what transpires at its meetings or what decisions it comes to; this is a body with no revenue; this is a body with no offices; this is a body with no proper membership roll so that it cannot communicate with its members." He can say all these things and apply each of these tests to any organisation or any body of persons in regard to which he is doubtful as to whether it is representative or whether it is composed mainly of persons who are concerned with the interests and services which the Constitution has declared ought to be represented in this House.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.5:—

In page 11, line 23, to delete the word "that" where it first occurs and substitute the word "such".

I shall not make any speech in regard to this amendment. It is simply a verbal amendment which I think ought to be made but I will not lose any sleep over it.

Comment on this

I will say this to the Senator: I would have thought "such" just as good a word as "that" and if I were writing that sentence I would probably use it but the draftsman thinks otherwise and when a question of legal drafting arises I am not going to try to override his judgement because he might not draft a Bill for me again.

Comment on this

The draftsman's trade union should be represented here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:—

On page 11, line 54, after the word "date" to insert the words "which shall not be earlier than twenty-eight days after the day on which such notice is first published".

There is, I think, a good deal of substance in this amendment because you are dealing here with the construction of the first register of nominating bodies and the provision is that as soon as practicable after the passing of this Act, the Seanad returning officer shall publish in certain papers a notice giving public notice that the register of nominating bodies is being prepared. He is also required to give in that notice such information, including the latest date for receipt of applications for registration, as the Minister thinks proper. You will observe in Section 16, when we come to the annual revision of the register, that actually an interval is prescribed, the interval between the 15th January and the 15th February, during which similar notice must be published. It seemed to me rather illogical that when we are preparing the first register of nominating bodies, the Bill does not fix any period during which notice must be given to the public of the intention of the officer concerned to prepare the register while, in the case of the annual revision, in the case of a register already in existence, a month's notice is given. It appeared to me that we ought to be at least as particular about giving ample notice and should prescribe that notice in the case of the first register, as we are in respect of the revision of the register in subsequent years.

Comment on this

I think it may be taken that, in giving effect to the provisions of Section 10, the Minister and the Seanad returning officer will have regard to the provisions of Section 16. In fact, the Seanad returning officer is bound to send out the notices as soon as practicable and he will do that. Now, in relation to Section 10 as it stands, I do not think it is as important as it was when it was included in the Bill by reason of this fact, that all the nominating bodies on the existing register will be notified as soon as the Bill passes of their rights under the Bill. We can assume from that, that there will be a considerable amount of ferment amongst trade organisations and trade bodies generally. They will know that the register of nominating bodies is to be prepared and they will all be alert and active in looking for the official notices governing the compilation of the register, and so I think the matter is not sufficiently important to warrant any amendment of the Bill at this stage. It does not affect the procedure at the impending election because the register of nominating bodies is already in existence. It would relate to the compilation of the new register of nominating bodies to be made for next year, and in that connection all these dates will be observed.

Comment on this

I would like to get the point further clarified for my own sake. Am I to take it that the present nominating bodies will go on the new register automatically without reapplication?

Comment on this

They will. The position is this: that for the purposes of the next Seanad general election—the general election which will ensue upon the dissolution of the present Dáil—the existing register of nominating bodies will be the register of nominating bodies for the purposes of this Act. Subsequently, a new register of nominating bodies will be prepared in accordance with Sections 10 and 16 and the other procedure set out in the Bill.

Comment on this

I was confused about the matter due to what was said during the debate. I thought that all these nominating bodies would have to re-apply to get on the new register. Now I understand they will automatically become nominating bodies.

Comment on this

Not only automatically but in accordance with Section 85 under which the register is already published. It has been in force since the 25th March, 1947, and is already available.

Comment on this

Does not all this strengthen my suggestion that there should be in Section 10 the same kind of provision regarding notices that there is in Section 16?

Comment on this

That may be so, but it is not of such importance now as it would be if it were not for the provisions in Section 85.

Comment on this

All that Section 85 does is to continue the present registration. Every year subsequent to 1948 these bodies will continue registration in the ordinary way. There will be revision just as there would be a revision in 1948. The statute provides that notice of that provision shall be published 28 days before it takes place. Section 10 makes no such stipulation. It makes provision with regard to due notice, but that may be held to be ten days' notice or five days' notice as against the 28 days' notice prescribed in Section 16.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 13, line 12, to delete the word "the" and substitute the word "this".

It seems to me that the Bill was drafted in a great hurry and that there was not time to read the proofs. Sub-section (5) says that "subject to the express provisions of the Act, the appeal board shall regulate its own procedure". What is meant by "the Act"? I take it that it, obviously, means "this" Act. I think that, in fairness to ourselves, we ought to insert the word "this" instead of the word "the".

Comment on this

Is it necessary to bring the Dáil back to do that?

Comment on this

I think I am correct in stating that under our Standing Orders power is conferred on the officers of the House to make a verbal change of this kind.

Comment on this

Provided it does not involve re-summoning the Dáil, the word "the" in the sub-section should be "this".

Comment on this

On the Section, I again draw attention to what appears to me to be an oversight. It is provided under sub-section (2) that if an appeal is duly made the appeal board shall communicate to the Seanad returning officer their decision, if any. Later, reference is made to what is going to happen when all the appeals have been decided—that is, decisions, if any, thereon have been communicated and so forth. Surely there is clearly a misunderstanding there. If there is an appeal to the appeal board there must be a decision.

Comment on this

No. Could not appeals be withdrawn as amendments in this House have been withdrawn?

Comment on this

I think we will have to divide the House on this.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:—

In page 15, lines 55 to 58, to delete the words "and any body which applied at the annual revision for registration in that register, whether the application was allowed or disallowed".

Sub-section (2) of this section seems somewhat difficult to understand. It sets out:—

"Any of the following persons may appeal to the appeal board against such of the decisions of the Seanad returning officer at an annual revision as are hereinafter specified, that is to say:—

(a) in the case of a disallowance of an application, the body by which the application was made,

(b) in the case of an allowance of an application for registration, any nominating body registered in the register of nominating bodies, and any body which applied at the annual revision for registration in that register, whether the application was allowed or disallowed,

. . . . . . "

It is difficult to understand why a body which applied for registration, a body which may have no substance, no qualifications and no bona fide claim to registration and whose application was disallowed should have the right to appeal and it seems to me that we are carrying the power of appeal too far in permitting a body of that kind to appeal against the registration of some other body. The procedure in Section 13 regarding appeals to the appeal board in connection with the preparation of the register of nominating bodies is somewhat different from what is proposed here. Section 13 (2) says:—

"(2) Any applicant for registration in the register of nominating bodies on the preparation thereof in respect of any particular panel (whether its application for registration has been allowed or has been disallowed by the Seanad returning officer) may appeal in accordance with this section to the appeal board against the allowance by the Seanad returning officer of the application of any other applicant for such registration."

In that case you are dealing with people whose applications are pending, while, in sub-section (3) of Section 17, you are dealing with people whose applications have been granted and people whose applications have been disallowed, and it seems to me that we ought not to give the right of appeal to a body which probably has no real existence at all but which merely makes application, and, because it makes application, gets the right to appeal against the registration of some other body of substance.

Comment on this

Is it correct that, if there are 45 applications and one is turned down because the subscription is only a £10 note, that one body can appeal against every one of the other 44, if they are all put on? That would be the height of absurdity.

Comment on this

It must be realised that, even in the case of an ordinary citizen looking for a Parliamentary vote, any person has a right to appeal against the vote being allowed to him. The position here is that we do not wish to put any barrier in the way of any organisation which feels it has been unjustly treated by reason of the fact that its application for registration has been turned down and the application of some other organisation for registration granted. It is to preserve the widest right of appeal to any party which may be interested and we have to remember that, just as the registration law was built up on a series of decisions, so, too, the aim here will be to build up and develop a code which will govern the admission of nominating bodies to the register. You cannot do that unless you allow objections to be taken from every reasonable point of view, because a body may feel aggrieved by reason of the fact that it has not been allowed on the register, whereas another organisation having very similar characteristics and differing, according to its own view, very little from it is allowed to be registered. Surely the body which feels aggrieved ought to be allowed to go from the returning officer against whom it feels a sense of grievance to the appeal board and have the matter finally decided there.

Comment on this

There is no use doing anything about it now, but I completely disagree with the Minister. A body which intended to appeal but did not appeal, on the same principle as he has put forward, should have the right, and, in fact, any corporate body connected with the register should have the right of appeal. The Minister's argument was perfectly valid under the old system. If there were only 15 on the register, any of the bodies turned down should have the right to appeal against the others because they might get on, but in this case where there is an unlimited number and where it could make no difference——

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

With great respect, I do not think it does. The point is that, as there is no limit to the number, an appeal by AB who has applied and been rejected against CD will not put him on or give him any better chance of getting on. It is quite right that AB should appeal against his own rejection—we do not dispute that—but that he should have the right to object to all the others is something for which I can see no case. It is a provision which is going to cause trouble.

Comment on this

Surely it may feel that its case for a reversal of the returning officer's decision will be strengthened if it brings out on appeal the characteristics or particulars relating to other bodies whose applications for registration have been allowed. It will at least enable a body whose application has been disallowed to inform the appeal board of the position of other bodies. A good deal of the criticism arises from overlooking the fact that we are doing more than giving the nominating bodies the right to propose. We are giving also the right to participate in the ultimate selection of the candidates who are going to be nominated. I think the Senator is wrong when he says it does not matter, in view of the fact that we have removed the limitation, but it must be remembered that admission to the register also includes participation in the nomination committee—the right to send five persons there to vote for the selection of a candidate. Even if a nominating body does not make proposals itself, or propose persons who have already been proposed by other nominating bodies, it has the right, notwithstanding the fact that it makes no proposals on its own initiative, to send five representatives to the nominating committee, and therefore it does make a difference.

Comment on this

Surely this is an excellent example of unnecessary complications about a right which is, to a very great degree, completely illusory.

Comment on this

It is not illusory.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

We have heard a lot about rights, but this right is also exercised in relation to the ordinary Parliamentary vote. Every citizen has the right to object to his fellow-citizen being recorded as a voter on the register of voters and it is only proper that we should continue that procedure in the Seanad elections.

Comment on this

And give everybody the right. There is something to be said for that, but it is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

I take it that a person nominated as a candidate may nevertheless be one of the five and may vote himself. As to whether that is a good thing or not, I have an open mind. Under this section, a nominating body can nominate five to the special nomination committee. At the present moment they only nominate three for the purpose of by-elections. Under the transitory provisions, the register will remain the same. What would happen if a body on the register, by virtue of the transitory provisions which has nominated three, failed within the time to increase its number to five?

Comment on this

I think the position would be that the three persons would cease to be members of the committee. In fact, a notice will go out to the nominating bodies indicating that they should meet to select their five members for the committee. I do not want to commit myself to this, as it is a point that has not been raised. There is nothing to compel the five members to attend the meeting of the nominating committee. I think they would have to reappoint the members of the nominating committee and I think they would have to appoint five.

Comment on this

I am only trying to clarify it. I take it that once this Bill is law the appointments that have been made are void?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

So that if, between the time this becomes law and the date fixed by Order by the Minister, one of the bodies on the register fails to nominate five, they lose all their rights so far as that committee is concerned?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I do not agree with this section at all. It is a grotesque procedure and will prove inequitable. It is highly probable that the most representative organisation or nominating body in the group may find itself in a position that it will not have a nominee of its own on the panel at all. Under this method, the nomination committee gets together to do the voting and a certain number are to be eliminated. How is it to be done? Is there not going to be a great deal of bargaining and jockeying for position? That will happen and as a result you may get a group with a very unpleasant twist.

I know that some Senators, on the Second Reading debate, urged that if there is to be a nominating body at all it would be more satisfactory to reduce the number of nominations for a particular panel but let the nominating body be certain that it has a nominee of its own going forward on the panel. There is a good deal of humbug about a body with the right to make a nomination which could find the operation of the Bill so unsatisfactory that, however responsible and powerful it may be—responsible in the State and in the particular field of activity in which it is operating—it may not, in fact, be a nominating body at all. I would like to hear from the Minister his appreciation of how these committees will function when they get together, how they are to make their selections, and how it is to be arranged. Is the idea behind it to be that you can do a bit of engineering and manoeuvring and in a particular way you get a particular colour on your panel? If that be the fact, let that be stated.

As I see it, the idea is that this is a way which enables you to arrive at a very fair and equitable decision on the merits of the people put forward, or on the merits of a particular nominating body who will send two nominees forward; I do not agree with it. From the point of view of the confidence of the nominating bodies, it would be much more satisfactory that they should have the right to nominate but let them be responsible for making their own selection, rather than have the responsibility thrust on somebody else and the viewpoint and the decision of the particular nominating body rejected.

Comment on this

I spoke on this matter the last day. It is seldom that I agree with what Senator Baxter says, but I do agree with most of what he has said now. Since this was mooted and since the committee reported, I saw difficulties in it and I still see difficulties, though from a different point of view from that of Senator Baxter. A professional body would not be a bit keen on constituting itself as a section of the first electorate. The five members from the nominating body, constituting the nominating committee, will not be a bit keen on reducing the number of names on the panel from, say, 30 to six. It is difficult to do it and necessarily there must be a certain amount of canvassing and bargaining—"You vote for me and I will vote for you."

Comment on this

That is quite unknown at the moment?

Comment on this

Why perpetuate it?

Comment on this

No one will be elected otherwise, as each nominating body will send forward five members to the nominating committee and if they all vote for one of their own representatives each nominee will get five votes. I have not studied the mathematics of it, but I think there would be a state of equal votes for them all and you would not get any further.

If each of a certain number got five equal first preference votes, then by a complicated system you would have to check the number of second preferences which each of the candidates got. I suppose it happens often in the ordinary elections. If you mean to have these five representatives, no matter what the nominating bodies are, you will be faced with the difficulty of selecting the people whom you want to select. On the Second Reading I suggested that the number nominated —on some panels at any rate—should be reduced to one and go on the ballot paper without this system of first degree reduction by nominating bodies. The points I want to make are: the five representatives will find it very difficult to do it conscientiously and correctly from their point of view. I think that it would be better if they had not that imposed on them at all, but instead of these bodies nominating two or more, that they could nominate four. I wish to explain my argument on that. When two or more are nominated—as may occur now—these candidates will automatically have to canvass against one another in order to get the support of the nominating bodies. If two are nominated, the five members who were constituted a nominating committee must decide how they will support both. If they only can support one, they must decide which they will support and give all five votes for the one nominee. The five members will either have to support one nominee or run the risk of not having either nominee getting over the first turn. I see immense difficulties here and I have voiced them ever since the report was published. Apparently the Minister and the House will not take that view, but there are great difficulties for those who try to carry out the requirements of the section and of the subsequent section and I think that it will cause great trouble and difficulty.

Comment on this

I would like to join with Senator Baxter and Senator O'Donovan in their remarks about this particular section. I think that the body which I represent is perhaps the best example of the objections that can be raised to this proposal. We have 38 vocational education committees throughout the country which are definitely very, very representative in character, being composed of members of county councils and urban councils and of different types of vocational interests—farmers, industrialists and many educated and cultured people. What is going to happen is as certain as anything can be to my mind. It is that the new nominating committee, when they get together, will simply out-vote the comparatively provincial committee representing this association, and there will certainly be a very great sense of grievance throughout the country. These bodies are asked to go to the trouble of meeting and nominating candidates but when they are sent here to Dublin they find that as the result of the activities of 25 or 30 people the persons they have nominated will not have the chance of going before the electorate at all. I suggest that having to get over the first of the three fences in this particular case is very difficult. It means that you must get a vote of 26 counties before you can be nominated at all and after going to all this trouble you have to face the nominating committee and this mysterious body may eliminate you.

What Senator O'Donovan said is quite true. If there are two people, the five representatives will be in great doubt as to which they will support and ill-feeling will be created. It is a very objectionable section, and even if it meant calling back the Dáil for one more meeting the Minister ought to do so in order to consider revising this.

I do not know whether I am within the lines or not in suggesting this. Could there not be some group arrangement of interests in the case of, for example, secondary and primary teachers who have the right to nominate its particular members? While individual interests could not get representation, representation could be given to a group. The various aspects of medicine could be grouped together and by nominating one person only instead of three, they could get a reasonable chance of all their interests being represented eventually.

I wish certainly to protest strongly against this section and I would be inclined, for the purpose of the record, to ask for a division and vote against this particular section.

Comment on this

Would you be a teller?

Comment on this

Definitely. I think that is about all I want to say, but I certainly wish to protest in the strongest possible manner against this because I know what will happen in the interests which I am representing and the conflict which is likely to ensue. If I were the Minister facing an election I would not like to have to face the consequences, but that is a matter for himself and he is a skilful politician but I belive that there will be very, very serious friction.

Comment on this
Mr. Hawkins

As we have just a few moments before the motion on the Adjournment I should like to put this point of view to the House. Senator O'Reilly has entertained us for five or ten or 15 minutes expounding what he would like to have enshrined in the Bill, but if he took the trouble to read and study the Bill and to find out what the Bill really is, he would find that what he was trying to achieve during a five or ten minutes speech is in the Bill already. What surprised me most in the whole discussion was Senator Baxter's contribution.

Comment on this