Electoral Amendment Bill, 2000 [ Seanad Bill amended by the Dáil ] : Report Stage.
Contributions 1–149 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 67 of 2000 ›
The Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 2000, has three motions for recommittal, which I propose to deal with first. If a Senator moves, under Standing Order 111, that a Bill be recommitted either wholly or in respect of certain sections or amendments, where the motion is opposed under Standing Order 112, the procedure is that the Chair allows the proposer to make an explanatory statement of the reasons for the proposed recommittal and allows a statement from the Senator who opposes the motion before putting the question. I will now deal with the motions individually in the sequence in which they appear on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
I move: "That the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 2000, be recommitted in accordance with Standing Order 111."
Comment on this
Under Standing Order 112, Senator Manning is entitled to make an explanatory statement to the House.
Comment on this
I want to have the Bill recommitted for a number of reasons. When the Seanad was being instituted in 1937, one of the reasons given by Mr. Éamon de Valera for doing so was that it would prevent hasty or ill-considered legislation passing through Parliament and that it would provide a second opinion on legislation and an opportunity to examine legislation that might not have been treated fully in the other House.
These are precisely the circumstances we find ourselves in today. The Bill we are considering was not properly debated in the other House. My main concern is the new section in the Bill dealing with the ban on opinion polling. When the Electoral (Amendment) Bill was in this House, there was a lengthy debate, but there was no reference or proposal of any ban on opinion polling. It was not discussed in principle in this House, nor was it discussed in detail on Committee or Report Stage. The Bill then went to the Dáil where the full Second Stage debate took place without any proposal to ban opinion polls. It then proceeded to Committee Stage in that House. At this stage a proposal was made by my party to ban opinion polling. I do not regard this as a party political issue, but as a matter of public policy. The Government put down its own amendment, the nature of which I will come to in a moment, but the matter was not debated and the Bill was guillotined in the Dáil without consideration being given to the section dealing with opinion polling.
We have now arrived at the position of having a Bill pass in both Houses without discussing a major departure in public policy or how it will operate in practice. We have here, in the shape of the main Government amendment, effectively a new Bill. It contains definitions and is short, although we have dealt with shorter Bills, but it is a new Bill which makes a very substantial change in public policy that has not been debated in either House. Not only is that bad practice, it is indefensible.
This House exists precisely to ensure that this sort of thing does not happen. My request today exactly reflects the spirit of what Mr. Éamon de Valera intended when he founded this House over 60 years ago. I am sure those on the opposite side who share the spirit of the founder of their party will see he would have been shocked by that practice and would have wished them to use this House, of which we are all very proud to be Members, in that spirit.
Is this new undebated proposal on opinion polling a matter of national urgency? The answer is no. Nothing will be lost by recommitting part or all of this Bill to a committee for consideration over the summer. There is no urgent clamour for the imposition of a ban on opinion polling. It can wait to be dealt with properly, so why rush this Bill? I will not accuse the Leader of the House of rushing Bills through as he has been very good in allocating full time to them, but this Bill is being rushed.
It is not only the Attorney General but also the person whose advice he sought, as well as lawyers with whom I have consulted, who believe that this Bill may be constitutionally flawed and may not stand up to scrutiny in the Supreme Court or the High Court. While I cannot read the mind of the President, it is likely that this Bill will be referred to the Supreme Court for adjudication before it is finally signed into law. There are serious constitutional doubts, some of which the Attorney General shares. I would like his advice to be published to help the public debate.
There has been no denial from Dr. Gerard Hogan of Trinity College, a very eminent constitutional lawyer, that his advice also placed a great question mark over the constitutionality of the Bill. All the lawyers I asked for advice have said there is a case to answer because the Bill may well be unconstitutional. It would be foolish, wrong and reckless of us to rush through legislation having been told by several lawyers – I hesitate to use the term eminent lawyers—
Comment on this
—as all lawyers, by definition, regard themselves as eminent – that it may be struck down at the first obstacle. Why not debate the matter in the calm way legislation requires?
Many fears have been raised on the subject and much of the debate has been hysterical. I took great exception to the comments made by some media commentators describing this legislation as Hitler and Goebbels-like legislation or repressive or Third World legislation. Many other such epithets rained down on politicians. As I have said before on debates on media reform, if people in the media want a reasoned debated, they should be careful to ensure the language they use is not out of touch with reality, hysterical or offensive. These are issues with which we can all engage and on which there are at least two points of view. Let us have the debate, but let us get rid of the hysterical language.
There are fears on the part of the media. Most media people do not trust politicians, fearing an attempt to clamp down on the messengers, the bearers of bad news. They are concerned this is the beginning of a war through repressive legislation. Their fears are baseless. This proposal is not a direct attack on the media. However, the penalties in the Bill are draconian and out of all proportion to any offences which might be committed. There is a further case to answer.
To journalists who have been shouting so loudly on this question I say we too have our fears and suspicions. We trust the media no more than they trust us. There must always be an air of tension between the two estates. We are not in their pockets, they are not in ours, they ask questions of us just as we ask questions of Government. There are fears, for example, concerning the over-concentration of media ownership in one group. If that group happened to have a particular agenda, there is the possibility that it could distort opinion coming up to an election.
Politicians also fear an absence of standards. The established opinion polling organisations behave honourably and honestly and conduct their business properly but, in the absence of a ban, what is to stop cowboy operators springing up before an election and introducing information intended to distort public debate? There is no point in the people involved apologising once the damage has been done.
There are, therefore, legitimate questions to be asked on both sides. These fears will only be met head on if the two sides sit down to talk and put reasoned cases. We could then see what the media are afraid of and, at the same time, forcefully express our fears about the way in which they operate. In that way, much of the mistrust could disappear.
One thing that has been absent in this debate so far is evidence. No evidence as to the exact impact of banning opinion polls in other countries has been brought into this debate. Plenty of such evidence exists and there are also many experts in our universities, including Dr. Richard Sinnott and Dr. Michael Marsh, and among the opinion pollsters themselves. There are plenty of people who could provide objective, sober, dispassionate analysis of the impact of opinion polling on electoral behaviour. It may well transpire that it has had no effect at all. People make up their minds for a variety of reasons such as local, party and inherited issues, or because they hate or love somebody. Opinion polls probably have only a very small effect. They appear to have an effect in Britain where, in the last general election, the polls induced many people not to bother voting because it was clear Tony Blair only had to get up on the morning of the election and drive into Downing Street that evening and he would get elected, so great was the gap in the polls.
However, the British have a different electoral system. No one would take an election here for granted. Given that we have proportional representation, multi-seat constituencies and so forth, there would be very few people saying at the beginning of an election it is all over because the polls say it is. Opinion polls are not a factor in discouraging people from voting here.
I would be happy if only the section on opinion polling did not proceed now and was referred back to committee. We will be doing a bad job if we do not do that. The other House has not behaved well. There is no justification for guillotining legislation at any stage. It is disgraceful that large rafts of legislation find their way onto the Statute Book without having been discussed in the lower House. We do our best in this House but because of the way this Bill has come to us we are not being given the opportunity to examine it in detail.
I appeal to the Members opposite in the spirit of the House to which we are all proud to belong. We should pass good laws rather than laws which will not have the acquiescence of a large section of the population, as this one will not if last night's opinion poll is to be believed. This proposal has raised doubts. In the spirit of this House and of good law making, I appeal to my colleagues and friends on the opposite side to accept the proposal in the good faith in which it is proferred and refer the Bill back to committee. The committee could return early after the recess and the Bill could be on the Statute Book by early October. We will do a good day's work for this House and for democracy if we follow that advice.
Comment on this
The opposer of the motion is also entitled to make an explanatory statement to the House.
Comment on this
This morning when Senators Coogan, O'Toole, Norris, Costello and others made arguments similar to that put forward by Senator Manning, I replied that all these points could be made during the debate on Report and Final Stages. There will be no guillotine. Members may speak for as long as they wish and all views may be expressed. There has never been a guillotine in this House under my leadership and there will not be one today.
In the newspapers during last weekend and on radio this morning I have read and heard various views regarding this proposed legislation. Anyone who thinks the media will give politicians a fair break is not living in the real world.
This proposal came from Deputy Olivia Mitchell. She proposed that no public opinion poll shall be taken or published in the seven days prior to any election or referendum and no opinion poll whatsoever shall be published in the seven days prior to any election or referendum. That proposal was supported by Deputy Gilmore. Both Deputies were asked by the Minister of State at the Department of the Environment and Local Government, Deputy Molloy, if they were speak ing on behalf of their parties. The Minister of State was assured this was the case. In fact, Deputy Gilmore said:
In the last critical week of an election the opinion pollsters should stay out of the ring and leave it to the contestants and the electorate. I support the proposal made by Deputy Olivia Mitchell.
The Minister of State went on to say, "I assume they are speaking for their parties, Fine Gael and Labour". When Deputy Molloy, as a matter of clarification, asked Deputy Mitchell if it was true that 14 days was what she had submitted originally, Deputy Mitchell said:
I changed it several times. On reflection, I realised that 14 days was too long. I have the final copy here and I can read it if the Minister wants.
The Minister of State said, "I have it here." Deputy Molloy, in conclusion, said, "I accept the principle behind the proposal and I will be willing to bring forward an amendment on Report Stage." That is what happened in the other House. We must deal with the proposal before us. The Bill was initiated in this House.
There has been no guillotine in this House on any legislation during the past four years. I accept the sincerity of the proposal from Senator Manning, former Leader of the House and Leader of Fine Gael in the House. I respect his views. He has been an eminent Senator and has enhanced the proceedings in this House in the long time I have been here. However, with regard to the points he has made and particularly the point regarding the recent British election, we cannot make an analogy with the British system. The number of Independent Members in the other House is in double figures and we also differ from the United Kingdom in having proportional representation. In the last general election, 624 votes decided five Dáil seats, and these 624 votes were fifth, sixth and seventh preferences.
Opinion polls are of the utmost importance. Is it fair that someone who has worked hard for an entire Dáil or Seanad term, served his constituents loyally, faithfully and well can be damaged by a particular interest group which controls the media, not nationally but locally, and which for reasons best known to itself does not want him to be re-elected? Such a group could announce to its readers, two or three days before polling day that a certain person had 40% support and would top the poll and that someone else was in trouble. That is not fair. The media have, for four years and ten months, an opportunity to make their case. For the week before polling day, the ordinary men and women of Ireland and the ordinary candidates who are men and women of Ireland should be given their opportunity.
We are not discussing the principle behind this proposal. I believe all political parties are in favour of having an agreed time when there would be no polls. I would like to see the House debating this issue rather than to-ing and fro-ing with votes, as we have done today. We will stay for as long as this matter takes and if it takes until next week I do not mind. There will be no guillotine or stifling of debate. We are here to listen and to debate and pass legislation.
Comment on this
The next motion is in the name of Senator O'Meara and is in respect of amendments Nos. 1 to 46, inclusive.
Comment on this
I move: "That, in accordance with Standing Order 111, the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 2000, be recommitted in respect of amendments Nos. 1 to 46, inclusive."
Comment on this
Under Standing Order 112 Senator O'Meara is entitled to make an explanatory statement to the House.
Comment on this
In moving the motion we wish to state we are doing so because of the seriousness and urgency of the situation. As has been pointed out on more than one occasion, it is not good practice to rush legislation and those of us on this side of the House have objected to the speed with which the Government side has attempted to move legislation through the House. Our specific role is to give due and detailed consideration to legislation. The speed at which the Government has moved this Bill through the Lower House is one reason for such adverse public reaction. A suspicion has been generated that in some way the Government is moving fast as they are trying to hide something from the public. There has been a negative reaction to this approach. It also looked like a bitter and petty reaction to the vote received by the Government candidate in the Tipperary South by-election. To some extent it is interpreted as a scapegoating of the media and specifically those companies which carry out opinion polls.
What we need is a debate on the use of opinion polls and their potential effect during elections and the role of the media not only during elections but in general. I specifically ask Members to separate from the issue the growing negativity and personalised reaction to media commentary about us and our actions as parliamentarians. As a former journalist I specifically ask Members to stand back and look objectively at the commentary about us and how we conduct our business, and to ask if some of it at least is fair. I know there are Members who have an increasingly negative and bitter feeling towards how the media comment on us as public representatives, but I put it to colleagues that free speech and free expression of opinion, especially when we do not like it, are fundamental to our democracy. A situation in which the media can adversely comment on us is a mark of our democracy and I ask Members to consider what would happen if the opposite were true.
The provision inserted in the Bill has been interpreted as an attempt to stifle democracy and free speech. Personally I do not think that was ever the intention but I am not in the least surprised it has been interpreted in that way, and we must take that point of view into account. We must also take public reaction into account. As Senator Manning and others pointed out, we have a duty and this week an opportunity to consider and take into account public reaction to this measure. That is our role and we must take it on board, and it is in this context that I move the motion.
Amendments Nos. 1 to 46 relate to the Bill, but not as amended by the Dáil and therefore have been ruled out of order. However, we tabled them as we believe the entire Bill must again be considered by the House for the specific reason that it has been significantly altered by the Lower House and returns to us as effectively new legislation, and we should consider it as such.
The amendments are technical in nature, and many of them are drafting amendments. Our legal advisers, whom we are very lucky to have, have spotted mistakes in the Bill which have not previously been spotted. In a constructive and positive way, as we have done on numerous occasions in the past, we have put forward the amendments for consideration by the House in an attempt to be helpful. However, because the legislation is being rushed through it will not be possible to correct technical errors in the Bill. Therefore the Bill will have 46 technical errors when it forms part of the Statute Book. Many of the errors are minor, but it is not good practice to put legislation on the Statute Book which we know for a fact to be flawed, even if some of those flaws are minor.
Issues of public importance and constitutional law have been raised in relation to the amendment passed by the Dáil without debate. Knowing constitutional issues have been raised, should we simply pass the legislation and turn a blind eye to the problems we know are evident in the Bill? We constantly and increasingly worry about our standing with the electorate and the public. We do nothing for our public reputation, or for the reputation of the House, to knowingly pass legislation without consideration in particular of constitutional matters raised by those in the wider public whom we know to have greater knowledge than us about these matters, and by those charged by the Government, the State and the Constitution to comment on these issues. How can we ignore the reports of issues raised by the Attorney General and the concerns raised previously by a former Attorney General? It is negligent to do so and undermines our constitutional position and reputation. If it is so commented upon in the public domain we have no one to blame but ourselves.
There are major issues to be debated. The Leader of the House said in response to a previous motion that there is no guillotine in this House – that is true and there never should be one. One cannot have a proper debate on Fifth Stage. It is not possible, as we have just seen in regard to the Waste Management (Amendment) (No 2) Bill, 2001, where significant amendments have come before us.
This is a matter of major importance that has grown in the public mind in the last week. A week is a long time in politics and it is a long time in opinion polling during an election. Let us not scapegoat the messengers and let us not be seen to put a rein on free speech, whether it be on ourselves or on issues in the public domain. Let us do a good day's work in this House, not a bad one.
Comment on this
All the points I made previously were in response to Senator Manning's motion regarding the rushing through of legislation. If an allegation is made in the House it should be fair-minded and have substance. Last week our Whips had to meet countless times to re-arrange business when the time we had allocated was not taken up. I ask people to be reasonable and honourable – they may talk for as many days as they like as there will not be any rushing through of legislation in this House.
As the Cathaoirleach said this morning, what happens in the other House is the business of that House. This House has not been rushing legislation through, apart from some exceptional circumstances. With regard to the legislation before us today, all the time that is necessary will be afforded to it. I do not want Senators making the allegation that legislation is being rushed through – it is neither fair nor true.
Deputy Olivia Mitchellproposed this amendment in the Dáil and Fine Gael won the Tipperary South by-election. The Labour Party had a very fine candidate in Mr. Denis Landy, and two or three days before the poll his vote was put at 3 or 4% above what he actually got in the election. It may or may not be the case that this candidate was affected by the poll.
Seven days is a reasonable time to allow people to make up their minds on who is to govern the country. Unlike ourselves who are privileged to be Members of Parliament and have decent salaries and standards of living, there are many people who do not have this and could be heavily influenced by the media. They should not be put in that position. All parties have contributed to the success of the country since 1987 and as legislators we have to act responsibly. So what if a few less newspapers are sold or ratings and advertising goes down? It is only for seven days out of five years and that is not unreasonable. We are not, and should not be, dictated to. Seven days is the bare minimum and we should discuss the pros and cons of the Bill with the Minister and his officials present. We will be here for as long as is necessary to discuss it.
Comment on this
I move: "That sections 50 and 59 of the Electoral (Amendment) Bill, 2000, as passed by Dáil Éireann be recommitted in accordance with Standing Order 111."
Comment on this
Under Standing Order 112 Senator O'Toole has the right to make an explanatory statement to the House.
Comment on this
I was appalled with the view of the Leader in responding to Senator Manning earlier when he made the point that the media never give politicians an even break.
Comment on this
The true agenda is emerging. What we are attempting to do here is to muzzle the press and silence the media. That is the clear agenda.
Comment on this
My note of what the Leader said to Senator Manning was that the media do not give politicians a fair share and they have four years and eight or ten months to do it. Maybe I am wrong, but that is what I heard. I am not sure what relevance that has to the debate in hand, unless what we are really doing here is having a go at the media. I am sure the Leader will have time to respond to that.
It seems that we are trying to turn the electorate into three wise monkeys. We do not want them to say or hear anything and we certainly not want them to do anything. That is the basis on which we are building a failed piece legislation. Time will prove that. This legislation is both reactive and regressive and of the worst type. It is something that politicians do towards the end of their regime, and that is something I will come back to. It proposes unnecessary actions and is driven by unfounded argument. It is a poor way for us to conduct our business. As a thoughtful House of the Oireachtas, with a legislative function and responsibility, it is not and should not be the way in which we conduct our business.
It is also based on the faulty and failed premise that the people are really dumb and do not understand how to deal with the media, that the public cannot deal with the facts presented by an opinion poll and that the aggregated views of the electorate would be so much a danger to the health of Irish political life that we must strike it down. That is what this seems to be saying. There is no basis on which to move forward and do our business. We have debated many times the lack of involvement of the electorate with the work of politics. Time and again we have said that nobody takes any notice of the great work we do or the great things we have to say andthat nobody is making any judgment of how well we do our jobs. Yet the first time we see any measurement or yardstick being applied to us, we run a mile from it. It sends out an incorrect signal, and is one we should not support.
We should encourage the articulation of the views of the electorate. We should be looking forward to creating circumstances where people can offer their views on us, our legislation, policies and views. That should be something we would welcome. Only a Legislature, Government or political body which chooses to listen can be successful. If we do not want to hear, and we refuse to allow people to speak in aggregate, then we are certainly not ready to listen. We are afraid that if people hear how others are voting, thinking or what their intentions are, it will in some way create a flow away from us and we will lose them. If we are going to lose them that easily we do not deserve to be here in the first place.
Comment on this
That is what it comes down to. If we are afraid of the people we seek to represent, if we cannot handle, challenge and deal with their views, then we are in the wrong business. This is the business of engagement, interaction, challenge, leadership, direction and coping with the response we get from the electorate. That is what we need to do.
We should be facilitating and encouraging political debate. We should encourage anything that allows us a clearer insight into the attitudes and views of our electorate. It is only when we can see things from the perspective of those we seek to represent that we can change their attitudes, lead them in another direction or manage their expectations. We certainly will not do that by saying we do not want them to speak or listen to what they say and then making sure that what they have to say has no influence on their neighbours or the people around them. This is in no way supportive. It is the very opposite of participation and engagement.
It is also something which I believe, without a shadow of a doubt, to be unconstitutional on two grounds. I want it to be recommitted so that we can tease out these issues in more detail and have an exchange of views with the Minister. We could listen and learn from each other and move things forward. We propose to do this on Committee Stage where we would go through the details, offer a viewpoint, hear a response, make a reply, take a modified point of view and attempt to get the Minister to go forward. That is what we are about in this House, but we are not doing that here. That is a mistake.
The right to free speech, enshrined in Article 40 of the Constitution, is being seriously threatened here. This point was cogently made by at least two Attorneys General and by another constitutional lawyer. Not all of those were made to this Government, one of the Attorneys General gave his advice to a previous Government. The Constitution is very clear on the role of the Attorney General. Since I joined this House 15 years ago, on almost every Bill that I have challenged, I have been told that the reason my proposal could or might not be accepted was on the basis of advice from the Attorney General's office. That is something which we, and Governments, have to accept.
I believe there is an Article in the Constitution which requires us to deal with this and gives probably the strongest reason for the recommital. I will go into more detail than I did earlier today and I ask the Leader to dwell on this. I accept the point he made this morning about the House being able to deal with and do its own business under Article 15 of the Constitution. The House is also subject to the Constitution. Its Standing Orders must be put together on the basis of the Constitution and be amenable to it.
The important point I wish the Leader to consider is that the Constitution makes a distinction between Bills initiated in the Seanad from those initiated in the Dáil. The latter, if amended by the Seanad, return to the Dáil where the amendments made are considered. A Bill initiated in the Dáil and amended in the Seanad is sent back to the Dáil which is obliged by the Constitution to consider only the amendments made by the Seanad and not the whole Bill. That is contained in Article 20.1 which states:
Every Bill initiated in and passed by Dáil Éireann shall be sent to Seanad Éireann and may...be amended in Seanad Éireann and Dáil Éireann shall consider any such amendment.
That is the point about legislation initiated in the Dáil. In terms of legislation initiated in the Seanad:
A Bill initiated in Seanad Éireann if amended in Dáil Éireann shall be considered as a Bill initiated in Dáil Éireann.
It begins again and returns to us as if it had been initiated in the Dáil. Therefore, it should go through all Stages and that is the reason this Bill should be treated in this manner. That is what is written in the Constitution.
The Leader argued this morning that Article 15, which allows the House to establish its own Standing Orders, takes precedence over that. I do not accept that point and I am certain that the Constitution, in making a clear distinction between the way we deal with Bills referred back from the Dáil depending on whether they were initiated in the Dáil or Seanad, does so for a reason. Our Standing Orders should reflect that difference and they do not. Standing Order 103 deals in the same way with all Bills referred back to the Seanad, even though the Constitution deals with them differently.
The Long Title of the Bill does not refer to section 59 which deals with polling. Neither was it mentioned in the financial and explanatory memorandum circulated initially. This means section 59 was not discussed in the House. We have not had the opportunity to deal with it on Second Stage or to amend it on Committee Stage, and we will now have one shot at it on Report Stage. That was never the way it was intended we would do our business. There has been a lack of discussion and it is wrong we should conduct our business in this manner. I appeal to my colleagues on the Government side to recognise that. I accept they are subject to the Whip and cannot do anything about it and we recognise we will be defeated on this. However, there is a deeper issue.
This reminds me of a long discussion we had on the rod licence Bill in the last week of a session just before Christmas. It was dealt with in exactly the same way. It was rushed through the other House and, when it was discussed in this House, we tried to point out some of the problems which were clear to us, but it was pushed through to cause interminable grief for politicians for years after.
The legislation we discuss is reactive. Every Government has introduced reactive legislation. We should keep a list and circulate it every time we discuss new legislation. Do Members remember the Bill to introduce dog muzzling or to deal with wandering horses? Every time a child is savaged by a dog or someone falls off a horse, or is kicked by a wandering horse, we introduce legislation. This Bill is similar. Someone had a good idea following the by-election in south Tipperary and legislation was introduced.
There is much more important and urgent legislation than this which needs to be dealt with. The Bill does not bring any honour on politicians and is of no use to the job we do. It does not protect us and leaves us open to ridicule. It shows we are afraid of the people and cannot cope. It sends out all the wrong signals. It undermines the role of the Seanad which is supposed to be a thoughtful legislative Chamber where we conduct our business by due consideration of the issues through a broad discussion, focused Committee Stage and general Report Stage.
The role of the Seanad to modify legislation has also been undermined. This legislation should have been returned to us as a matter of principle for us to debate the issues because they have not been discussed. Can anyone accept or agree that it is a proper way to conduct business by enacting legislation which is not discussed fully in either House? The Cathaoirleach said it is not our business to comment on how the other House conducts its business but, as Members of the Oireachtas, we must take the broad view of legislation which we are required to discuss.
Every Member of the House should write to the President asking her to consider two issues – how we have conducted our business and the business we have conducted. She should consider how we have conducted our business on the basis that our process under Standing Orders of the Seanad is out of kilter with, not amenable to and in contravention of what was contemplated and envisioned in Article 20 of the Constitution. She should consider the content of the legislation because it undermines the right to free speech as articulated in Article 40. I ask her to consider referring the Bill under Article 26 to the Supreme Court for a ruling. If the Supreme Court finds the Bill is unconstitutional or has been compiled unconstitutionally, that reflects the failure of the political system. We effectively have our wrists slapped.
Introducing legislation on the basis that we cannot trust the people with information is the basis of fascism, censorship and a totalitarian state and is the basis on which all dictatorships have been run since the beginning of history. It is the mushroom policy of keeping the people in the dark. We cannot have any hand, act or part in this type of development. I do not know how we as Members of a responsible House of the Oireachtas can take a decision which ignores the views put forward by the Attorney General. That cannot be right and we should examine it.
Most importantly, since this was mooted a week ago, every public view articulated on talk shows and phone-ins has opposed the measure. We are acting the bully by putting it up to the people and coming out with our fists high saying we will not be changed, moved or shifted by the views of the mere people whose support we seek at elections. We are effectively saying that we know better, we will teach them to know better, that they should understand better and that they will not have their way on this because we are doing it our way.
Our way should be the people's way. It is not that we should run in front of them but that, if there is a difference of opinion, we should try to manage their expectations and views and change their attitudes to the political process. We should not use a sledgehammer to crack a nut, which is what we are about here, or try to ensure the people do not have their say or have their voice heard.
Neither should we have a cut at the media. We do not need to do this. We can take them on on our own terms whenever we need to do so. They are not all-powerful. If they set themselves up as the moral authority, we can also expose them and it is our role to do so if we see them doing that. We should not be slavishly for or against them. We need to have a clear view.
I recognise I have spoken at some length on this issue but, in terms of what we are dealing with and the basic principles involved, namely, the right to free speech, the way we conduct our business, respect for the people's views, a free press, the manner in which we have political engagement, the participation of the community, engagement of those we seek to represent and for the solid constitutional, legal and other views put forward by eminent lawyers in recent days, it would be the height of foolishness for us to rush through this legislation.
As a fall-back position, will the Leader recommit section 59 and accept this is put forward with the best possible intentions and objectives in the interests of transparency? It would send a positive signal from the Upper House of the Oireachtas that Members care about the people's point of view and will represent them without shutting them up.
Comment on this
I will be brief because I made known my views earlier. No one is being muzzled. Everyone knows this is the biggest U-turn in recent years by the Fine Gael and Labour parties. We are here today to do the right thing at the right time. If the media are of such importance as Senator O'Toole said – he spoke for and against—
Comment on this
The commission should seriously consider including the Senator because he can make a good case for and a good case against. Like a former Member and MEP, he reminded me of God speaking to God.
Comment on this
Article 15 of the Constitution states that each House shall make its own rules. Standing Order 103 provides that a Seanad Bill amended by the Dáil shall be placed on the Order Paper for Report Stage. Prior to these motions, we did exactly that when we dealt with the Waste Management (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 2001. That Bill has far-reaching implications and I would contend it is just as important as the Bill now before us. As that is the norm, I do not understand the hullabaloo.
Comment on this
The hullabaloo is about capturing the imagination of the media. I wish to inform the House that there is no general election imminent and the worst thing any politician could do would be to overdo it at the wrong time. Senator O'Toole got his elevation last week, on which I congratulate him because he richly deserved it. He has been a wonderful Senator and has made magnificent contributions. However, his last one would not be in my top ten. I have always respected his views and I listened carefully and attentively to what he had to say.
This aspect has been debated in a very relaxed fashion and I hope that for the remainder of the evening, week and month there will be no muzzling of anyone. Senators should not allow themselves to be rushed because that is not the intention of this side of the House. There will be no rushing on this side and we do not want the opposite side to be caught in the jam going out the door for the summer holidays. Please do not allow that to happen.
Senator O'Toole is incorrect. A poll was taken since Deputy Olivia Mitchell tabled her amendment. The result was 53 in favour of a seven day poll ban and 47 against. Therefore, the Government is doing something right by supporting the Fine Gael-Labour amendment. There is all-party agreement on the issue. If the Independents have a difficulty perhaps that is why they are Independents. They were all born into the family. Most of them were in Fianna Fáil. Perhaps it is because there was no room in the inn that they had to get in somewhere else. However, it is wonderful to have them here because they make a great contribution. All I ask is that they allow the legislation to be debated and stop filibustering.
Comment on this
Before we recommence I remind the House that a Senator may speak only once on Report Stage, excepting the proposer of an amendment who may reply to the discussion on the amendment. On Report Stage each amendment must be seconded. I suggest to the House that we hear the Minister of State on the amendments made by the Dáil before proceeding to consideration of the amendments submitted by Senators. If the House is agreeable we will allow the Minister of State to make—
Comment on this
On a point of information, if the Minister of State is to speak on the amendments that have come to us from the Dáil, do we then speak on those amendments before moving on to our own amendments?
Comment on this
I am now totally confused. If your answer to Senator O'Meara is correct, we are taking the Bill and what has come from the Dáil before we take any amendments. My understanding was exactly the opposite.
Comment on this
If the House is agreeable we will let the Minister make his contribution. We will then consider the amendments submitted by Senators. Any Senator may speak to those amendments.
Comment on this
I do not understand the reasons for that prima facie. I do not want to be disagreeable but I find it very confusing and wrong. We are going to have the Minister of State opening the debate and all the amendments taken and then our reply to the Minister. Why do we not take things in the order in which they come?
Comment on this
The normal practice is that the Minister informs the House of the amendments that have been made in the Dáil to a Seanad Bill. The reason I suggest this procedure is that we would be following the procedure which is normally followed in the House. After the Minister has made his contribution we will go straight to the amendments. As each amendment is dealt with, each Senator will have the opportunity to speak once on that amendment, excepting the proposer of the amendment who will have the right of reply.
Comment on this
That means that we cannot then respond to the Minister's contribution on the amendments coming to us from the Dáil. We will only speak to the amendments tabled by Senators. I put it to you that we are entitled, as Members of the House, to respond to what the Minister says in the context of the amendments coming to us from the Dáil, before we move on to our own amendments.
Comment on this
I take your point and I am very much in the hands of the Members of the House. If it is preferred that we go straight to the amendments, as they are here, then we will proceed that way.
Comment on this
By this tactic we are foreclosing an element of the debate. Not only that, we are underlining the similarities with the introduction of a completely new Bill in allowing the Minister of State to speak first in this way.
Comment on this
If the House is not happy with that arrangement we will go straight to the amendments.
Comment on this
This matter was discussed last week when the group leaders met the Leader of the House. It was agreed that there would be one hour in which the Minister would make a presentation of the amendments and this would be separate from the other stage. The leaders of each of the groups were to have the opportunity to respond separately to the Minister's contribution.
Comment on this
That arrangement is not in place today. Amendments Nos. 1 to 46, inclusive, are out of order as they do not arise from amendments made by the Dáil. Amendments Nos. 47 to 49, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 94, line 30, to delete "a presidential" and insert "an".
This amendment is put down so that we can air the issue of which polls are subject to this ban and which are not. I cannot understand certain ingredients in this Bill. Why have certain polls been chosen while others have been omitted? Whatever the benefits of banning opinion polls from Dáil elections, to ban them from presidential elections is absolutely absurd. It is extraordinary.
Supposedly, in Dáil elections issues arise which are of some importance to the public and the media. In presidential elections there are no political issues involved. That is one of the big problems. There are no issues at all because they are not allowed to discuss politics. Banning opinion polls removes one of the key influences on that particular election. It is an influence and there is nothing wrong with publishing the influential information. Presidential elections are non-contests in terms of issues. Information on presidential elections is pretty scarce to begin with and the sort of information provided by polls is invaluable.
I contend that opinion poll information influences people in a small way. There is nothing wrong with that because it tells people what other people are thinking. It tells people how many think this, how many think that and how many think the other. Why should people not be entitled to that information? It is material. Someone may say, "This candidate is very close to winning and that will bring me to the polls. I was not going to vote otherwise." That is material and a very good reason for voting. As Senator Manning said in his speech a little while ago, someone else may well decide not to get out of bed because the result is a foregone conclusion according to the polls. That is legitimate and no one is obliged to vote. The information is useful in letting people know there is no point in casting that vote. It is also useful in letting them know that there is every point in casting that vote.
The idea of banning opinion polls when political promises are allowed to go unchecked and unchallenged is ridiculous. The one thing we know about opinion polls is that they are fact. They are information, they are solid and they are accurate. Promises from all political parties and indeed from Independents are inaccurate, dishonest, not kept, exaggerated and totally untrue. They are honoured more in the breach than in the observance, and yet they are allowed to go unchecked. The media will be able to have a field day in publishing promises which mean nothing and will be forbidden from publishing accurate figures. Where are we going?
Someone asked me if I should declare an interest in this. I really do not know whether I should or not, to be honest. I am quite sincere. I have no interest in this, but I am an employee of Independent Newspapers, who probably have an interest, and if that means I have an interest, so be it. I disagree with Independent Newspapers on so many other issues, however, that I do not see why I should declare an interest on an issue in which I do agree with them because it makes no difference to me, as an employee, whether or not opinion polls are banned. I must say, however, that I am an employee in case anybody does not know. It is in my declaration of interests.
There is another area which I do not understand and I have touched on it in this amendment. Why are opinion polls allowed in Seanad elections? The Minister will state that Senators are not democratically elected by a popular vote and, therefore, it does not arise. That is the sort of contorted logic which one would expect from a Government which can put forward this sort of proposal. Senator Norris and I have an electorate of about 40,000. We, or somebody else on our behalf, could easily carry out a telephone poll during a Seanad election. Our electorate is almost as large as that of a Dáil constituency.
Secondly, and more importantly, Senators O'Toole, Quinn and Ryan have an electorate of over 100,000, which is as big as that in any constituency in the country. It may not be a popular election in the sense that there is a geographical area which one can pin it to, but it would be easier still to have an opinion poll carried out among those people. A random accurate sampling of those people could be carried out by telephone and the results could be published.
For some extraordinary reason one cannot have opinion polls in a Dáil election but we can have them in a Seanad election. This is the sort of nonsense which we must put up with in this Bill because it was hastily thought out. In fact, it was not thought out at all.
Opinion polls can be held during by-elections for local authorities. Before anybody says to me that they are not elected democratically, let me say that many by-elections in local authorities are dealt with by nominating substitutes. Senator Coogan will confirm this.
Comment on this
I can see no reason political parties should not carry out opinion polls for sensible reasons before making those nominations to find out who is popular and who is not. Under this Bill they can do that and such polls can be published. If a political party is putting somebody forward in a by-election to fill a vacancy, the most sensible course of action is to carry out an opinion poll to find out who is most likely to be elected at the next election and then put them forward as a substitute. I do not see anything wrong with that. It is a sensible course of action. However, I do not understand why such opinion polls should be allowed and published while other opinion polls are not. I ask the Minister of State, Deputy Dan Wallace, to address that problem.
The reason the amendment was proposed in the Dáil was the by-election. That amendment in the Bill is due to one of the biggest electoral cock-ups of all time. It is a knee-jerk reaction to a by-election result which has come as a result of two parties thinking that it is in their interests to have no opinion polls because of one opinion poll which was published. Fine Gael thought that opinion polls should be banned because they thought there would be complacency as a result of the opinion poll which was taken and their man might lose, and Fianna Fáil thought that the opinion poll did them damage because they had some sort of momentum going and it stopped their candidate in his tracks. I do not know whether they were right or wrong, but one of them was certainly completely wrong.
I commend Senators Manning and Coogan and the rest of the Fine Gael Party for changing their stance on this so quickly.
Comment on this
What about Deputy Noonan? Is he changing his stance? Is the Fine Gael Party doing so?
Comment on this
It is commendable that a political party can take one stand in the Dáil and an opposite stand in the Seanad.
Comment on this
That is what democracy is about. I am quite serious. I think what happened here is quite interesting. It is interesting in terms of the difference between the Dáil and the Seanad and of the difference or schism in the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
I suppose that Senator Manning, quite rightly, is not bound by front bench decisions any longer. He decided to persuade his colleagues that this was a mistake and he is lead ing them now on the path of righteousness. That is what we want to see in a political party and it is a tremendous achievement to persuade a partner in one's own party in such a short time that he or she has made such a terrible mistake. It was a pretty hasty decision in the first place. I gather it went through the front bench quickly and was not given lengthy consideration, that it was introduced on Committee Stage without a great deal of thought and that on reflection they decided that this issue, which they had raised and which the Government had run with, was one which they should not have run with at all. Therefore, they have come into the Seanad and said that they want a proper debate, and they are right. That is commendable.
What they have done, of course, is left the poor unfortunate Government holding the baby. The Government did not really want this in the first place anyway. We now have the Government, who did not really want it, supporting it and Fine Gael, who raised it in the first place, opposing it.
Comment on this
I congratulate Senator Coogan for being on both sides and for coming down on the right side in the end.
Comment on this
This is good stuff. The House will be glad to hear that I must leave for a few minutes but I will be back, but I want to make a serious point before I finish. Opinion polls are not just informative; they are also entertainment. People should not lose sight of that. They are solid entertainment. Opinion polls coming up to general elections are one of the most enjoyable parts of those elections for the general public. People talk non-stop about opinion polls. There is nothing wrong with that sort of entertainment. What is happening here is the politicians are taking two decisions: they are stopping entertainment at their own expense – they would not stop entertainment at anybody else's expense – and they are stopping information about themselves which they do not want people to have. This is utterly inexcusable. I would like to see this proposal to ban opinion polls of any form excluded but in order to have a Committee Stage style debate on this, I am prepared to introduce only these amendments regarding opinion polls at Seanad and presidential elections.
Comment on this
I second the amendment, even though I feel I may be placing myself in some jeopardy in that I may be threatened by the congratulations of Senator Ross. I had noted the heavy irony with which he delivered bouquets of congratulations liberally around the House.
Indeed, there is a glorious inconsistency in the amendments themselves. This is all part of our harassing intent in regard to this Bill. We intend to try to make a dent in it or at least make a mark of some kind on it. When I say it is inconsistent, I mean that it is rather like that old tune, a line of which ran, "I stepped out and I stepped in again", because in these amendments we are deleting the word presidential and inserting a reference to Seanad elections. This creates a nice kind of balance. There is a certain inconsistency in doing so but it is probably a deliberate and glorious inconsistency.
Of course there are all kinds of odd features contained in this legislation. Senator Ross is correct when he says that it has opened up certain risks and chasms. In fact, a Member on the Government side said to me in a moment of exasperation during one of the divisions – I was given permission to quote the Member by name but I will not do so –"This was an amendment of the Labour Party and Fine Gael, was it not? We did not want it." They certainly ran with it when they got it. Within the Opposition parties in the Dáil, I noted with some amusement that Deputy Gilmore stated he was fully in favour of it. Then Deputy Quinn attacked it and said the party would be objecting to it. Deputy Gilmore said he would bow to party discipline and authority. There were masses of inconsistent responses.
In terms of how the Bill can fall short, one newspaper pointed out that there is absolutely nothing in the legislation to prevent, for example, a broadcast or print media source in Northern Ireland commissioning a telephone poll from there and printing it in newspapers available down here. Therefore it will not work, unless the Government, in an act of benevolence towards Northern industry, wishes to boost the sales of Northern newspapers.
I notice another feature not included in the Bill. Because there is a certain definition of a opinion poll, constituents have been in contact with me wondering, perhaps humorously, if it will be illegal for betting shops to take odds on election candidates. That is a kind of opinion poll or survey of the betting public. After all, political commentators frequently refer to voters as "your average punter" before elections. It is quite likely that if somebody hired a van and went around the polling stations, keeping a distance of 100 yards or whatever is specified, he could offer odds to the people going in and out. These examples are absurd perhaps, but the very idea of the Bill seems absurd.
The very absurdity of the Bill should not conceal the fact that it is a matter of very serious concern. I have already referred to a constituent who contacted me by telephone this morning. I also received an e-mail from a graduate of both university systems, an elector in both the constituency represented by Senator Ross and myself and that represented by Senators O'Toole and Quinn. This constituent states:
I write in a totally personal capacity as a member of both university constituencies. I am appalled almost beyond words at the passage in the Dáil of the Electoral Bill, in particular the proposal, almost ludicrous if it were not in earnest, that free expression of opinion be banned. This issue is at the core of the democracy here. Whatever the political difficulties that may be caused by the publishing of these polls in the days prior to an election or referendum, the benefits of free speech vastly outweigh them. I believe that the Constitution has something to say on this also.
Senator O'Toole said that he would attempt to have this referred. He is asking all the Members of the House to write to the President. The Irish National Newspapers Organisation sent me a fax saying they have petitioned the President to refer the Bill.
The correspondence of my constituent, who voted "Yes" in the Nice treaty referendum, continues thus:
What is almost as important is that this plan rushed through in peak of anger after the Government, as Governments do, lost a bye-election, reflects contempt for the electorate. In the first instance, we were too stupid to make up our minds and need to be swayed by the publication of the views of others; in the second, akin to the reaction of the political establishment to results of the Nice referendum, a negative to the establishment is seen as a reflection of the fickleness, perfidy, stupidity and churlishness of the electorate rather than a reaction to the isolation and aloofness of the political establishment. Finally, I hope the university Senators will defend the rights to free speech and free expression.
By opposing this Bill vigorously, we are defending the rights to free speech and expression.
It is important that Senator Ross has tabled these amendments. The inconsistencies are in the manner of a parliamentary tactic. They are rather curious when they include the Dáil. Perhaps the Minister of State will address this. When the Dáil is included, why is the Seanad ignored?
On the Order of Business this morning, I referred to the fact that Fintan O'Toole, a distinguished journalist, in discussing this matter on "Questions and Answers" last night, categorically stated that the Bill had passed. He said, "There has been no debate on this law in the Oireachtas, which has now been passed." Apparently, a highly distinguished correspondent for The Irish Times believes we are a unicameral State. Is it the Government's position as well? Is this the reason the Seanad was removed from the Bill?
Senator Ross is quite correct to include the Seanad. Every time there is legislation of this nature, where the Dáil is mentioned the Seanad should also be mentioned as a matter of course. I am happy to support this amendment and I have little doubt that it will be put to a vote.
Comment on this
The bouquets scattered around by Senator Ross, if picked up, would be found to be very thorny and full of nettles as well. Doubtless, the Senator was being heavily ironic. If he had listened carefully to what was said in the debate on the Order of Business, by both Senator Manning and myself, he would know nobody said anything about the value or lack of value of opinion polls, whether they are of benefit or if they influence people. The issue we raised was not about the benefits of polling seven days before an election or anything of that kind, but concerned the Government's decision that the processing of legislation would be cut off at the knees. The Government made a decision to guillotine a serious aspect of a very serious Bill. We feel very strongly that the opportunity to debate should be given to one of the Houses. I call upon the Minister of State to allow this discussion to be a Second Stage debate to examine all the issues concerned.
Previous speakers made interesting points about the value of retaining polling up to seven days before and election or not at all. Such comments make one reflect on whether one should vote against it. The more I listen to speakers who are against the concept of banning polling, the more I begin to question the issue myself. I have not been fully convinced and I want to hear more debate. That is the purpose of the Houses of the Oireachtas. However, the Lower House decided that the issue would be decided by the Government without consultation. That is not the way to pass legislation. In a true democracy, opportunities are given to everybody to examine every aspect of a Bill. Therefore, we rose to our feet this morning, not as Senator Ross said, with the intention of doing an about turn, but with the intention of having the issue examined and debated fully prior to a decision being made – a decision based on well considered concepts about the value of polling.
Comment on this
In my years in this House, I have not heard such outrage from the public as I have heard about the way this item has been handled, particularly in the other House. I know we do not debate in the Seanad what has happened in the other House – we are debating amendments Nos. 47, 48 and 49. I have great difficulty in understanding why the Government is pushing this legislation through in spite of the total absence of debate in the other House and our not being allowed to have a Second Stage debate on the matter. There will be an inquiry into the constitutionality of the issue.
Words such as dictatorship and fascism were used earlier. These are the words that come to mind when a government begins to act like the present Government. It is incredible that it thinks it can stifle information. This Government is the one that supports a Freedom of Information Act, admired throughout the world. Before freedom of information legislation was introduced, we looked at similar legislation in other countries and created the best legislation there is. I gather that other countries are now looking at our freedom of information legislation. Then the Government comes along with a proposal to stifle information, because it does not want the public to know how other people feel.
One aspect of the proposal is worthy of consideration in relation to the Nice referendum. It seems when the public opinion polls showed a huge majority would vote "Yes", large numbers of people decided not to bother going out to vote and we ended up with a very low poll. I can understand the need for action on that and perhaps that is the objective. However, it is only one of several objectives and, as Senator O'Toole said, it is like taking a sledgehammer to crack a nut. There is no need for this insistance on getting it through this week without debate and with such unseemly haste.
I telephoned a young politician in France last night to ask about the position there, because I understood France had a similar law in place. He told me France had introduced a similar law 15 years ago, but that a Bill is currently before the French Parliament which will overturn the law which cancelled polls one week before elections. I have not heard that mentioned here today or in the other House where no debate whatsoever took place. Here we are jumping into something the French did 15 years ago yet decided to change because they realised they had made a mistake.
Does the Minister of State realise the embarrassment this will cause for a country like ours which has been held in such high regard elsewhere in Europe? We will become a laughing stock. They will ask what the Irish are doing introducing a Bill similar to one the French enacted 15 years ago, perhaps for very worthy reasons, which they have now introduced legislation to cancel.
Ireland used to be the butt of jokes ten or 15 years ago. Irish jokes were always being told on British television. One does not hear those any more. Talking about this last night, we were told that one of the reasons was that the image of the Irish person 15 years ago was of someone who was not very clever or sensible, was on low income and was forced to emigrate because he or she could find work at home. Now the image of the Irish is of young, bright, articulate, intelligent, hi-tech, successful people who are among the wealthiest in Europe. We are very proud of that image. Then we are seen to do this, introduce a Bill and disallow debate on it only to discover that the French have changed their minds about similar legislation they introduced 15 years ago. That is sufficient reason to slow down and think twice about it.
Comment on this
We are dealing with three specific amendments here, not Second Stage, which we had here some weeks ago.
Comment on this
The Senator is raising more general issues. I ask Senators to address the three amendments.
Comment on this
Let me address the amendment on the presidential elections. Again I refer to France. During the last presidential election in France, a newspaper based in Geneva in Switzerland published a poll three days before the election and invited the French people to check out on its Internet site how they intended to vote. What will happen if UTV decides to conduct a telephone poll of 1,000 or 10,000 people south of the Border during the next presidential election and then decides to publish it as it is entitled to do? Can we say the law is achieving what it set out to do? Of course not, because we would be unable to do anything about it. I have taken UTV as an example because it is on this island and could make local weekend calls so the exercise would not cost much. It would be unfair competition for newspapers although I am not greatly concerned about that.
I hate to think that, as an independent, highly regarded State, we are passing laws that make a mockery of what we are trying to achieve. The Government will pass the law only to find it does not work, having been told by us that it could not work. We are debating all three amendments so this applies to presidential and Seanad elections. We have to think this out. We need to hear from the Minister what steps will be taken if the Irish News, the Newsletter or the Belfast Telegraph decides to conduct and publish a poll here. Will we ban it on this side of the Border? It is censorship not to allow newspapers into the country because they are breaking our law. I do not believe either we would do that, or that we would or should be able to do it.
What happens during a presidential election if a medium outside the State publishes an opinion poll taken inside the State? Will we ignore it or ban it? If those questions are answered, we can allow the next step to proceed. I also ask the Minister how he would handle the scenario that has arisen in France, where a law was introduced 15 years ago to outlaw the publication of opinion polls eight days before elections and which has now introduced a law to cancel it? I urge the Minister to think this through and provide a response that will put to rest the minds of the people. I will support the amendments unless I hear something new to persuade me to the contrary.
Comment on this
The most important aspect of this matter is having available to us the advice given by the Attorney General. Already we know there are conflicting views regarding the advice. In fairness to him and the House, we deserve to know precisely what his advice is. The matter is too important for us to rush ahead and skip over that advice. Mr. Padraig Flynn, who was Minister for the Environment and Local Government in 1991—
Comment on this
Again I interrupt to inform the Senator we are dealing specifically with amendments Nos. 47, 48 and 49 and I ask the Senator to address these.
Comment on this
The amendments deal with opinion polls. I assure the Acting Chairman that I will respect his ruling if he decides to rule me out of order. However, I will contribute only once on this matter and beg him to bear with me.
As I said, as the Minister for the Environment and Local Government in 1991 when the idea of banning opinion polls was first mooted, Mr. Padraig Flynn has confirmed that the Attorney General of the day, Mr. John Murray SC, now a Supreme Court judge, sounded a note of caution as to the constitutionality of the proposal. Mr. Justice Murray said that it could be vulnerable to challenge on the grounds that it might interfere with the rights of the public, opinion poll organisations or, indeed, the right of candidates and political parties to impart and receive information. That was then, this is now and we should not move beyond this point at this juncture without having available to us the best legal advice we can obtain.
That advice must come to us from the Attorney General. We deserve to know from the Attorney General that the relevant constitutional provision protecting the right of citizens to express freely their convictions and opinions is not being infringed by anything we do as legislators. That would be a bad day for democracy. If the Government is determined to persist in not making available to the House the views of the Attorney General I hope the President will convene a meeting of the Council of State and subsequently exercise her right to refer the Bill to the Supreme Court for a test of its constitutionality.
Opinion polls can have four possible effects. Their effect can be absolutely neutral. Some people might not pay attention to them and not even read about them in newspapers. They can also increase or induce apathy. This is very dangerous. If an opinion poll indicates a clear-cut outcome some people might not bother voting because they feel their vote would make no difference. Public apathy and cynicism about politics is already on the increase and this, perhaps, represents the biggest single threat to democracy. The falling turn-out at elections and an increased reluctance by people to become involved in politics represents a problem which strikes at the core of the democratic process. In every general election since 1981 the turn-out has fallen and the situation is even worse for referendums.
The third possible effect is that a voter who is very interested in politics might decide to make the maximum use of the PR system and give his number one preference to the candidate who had scored lowest in the opinion poll and work through an order of preference to whomever he wants to favour most. The final possible effect, which has received much comment, is the band wagon effect. People reading opinion polls might wish to support the winner. I heard a prominent political commentator say on television that she reserved the right to join a bandwagon and wished to know where it was going.
Comment on this
Absolutely. I cleared it with your immediate predecessor in the chair, whom I assured that I would make only one contribution on the Bill. You will have done with me soon.
RTE also did a vox pop of which many Senators will have heard. It showed clearly that opinion polls could and do influence people and could also increase apathy. None of us wishes to jeopardise freedom of expression. The nub of this matter is the advice of the Attorney General. I would like to hear this advice before we proceed. Perhaps the Minister of State will impart that advice to the House. I look forward to hearing what he has to say.
Comment on this
It is worth reminding ourselves that we are discussing three amendments, in the names of Senators O'Toole and others. The first proposes that presidential elections should not be included in any ban on opinion polls. The second, in the names of Senators O'Toole and Ross, proposes that Seanad elections should be covered by a ban on opinion polls for seven days before the election date and the third amendment proposes that by-elections to the Dáil should be covered by the ban on opinion polls.
The question of opinion polls has been hyped in the past week and the manner of this hype is regrettable. An article in one of last Sunday's newspapers carried the headline "Just like pigs at the trough, arrogance and greed are the hallmarks of the current Dáil." The article continued at some length on the issue. For the many people in both Houses of the Oireachtas and in local government who have given unstinting and selfless service over many years, that was gratuitously offensive and was unworthy of the person who expressed the opinion. If such intemperate language was used about a minority there would be an outcry and it would be described as racist, sexist or homophobic. It is regrettable that the debate has descended to that level.
What influence do opinion polls have on presidential, Seanad and by-elections, to make my point relevant?
Comment on this
I thank the Senator. In my four years in the Seanad I have never seen the power of the media more strongly in evidence than it has been today. If the hype of the past week had not materialised there would not have been any controversy regarding this legislation. The ordi nary man in the street will not be influenced by the decision we make on this issue.
Comment on this
The people who have tabled these amendments have been strongly influenced by the media. The media have an entitlement to express their point of view. However, the Irish electorate, which is politically sophisticated, has an interest in the outcome of opinion polls and in politics generally. It would have been better if it had been acknowledged that opinion polls are extremely good copy. They are commercially valuable for newspapers and I see nothing wrong with newspapers protecting their own commercial interests. However, it is disingenuous to raise this issue under the guise of protecting freedom of speech.
Comment on this
I am glad that, on mature reflection, Senator O'Toole has come on-side on this issue. His loquacious contribution earlier and his feigned indignation were obviously for the benefit of "Oireachtas Report".
Comment on this
There is actually no edition of "Oireachtas Report" tonight. The Senator's contribution will be lost.
Comment on this
All that is being banned is the systematic taking and publication of polls within the last seven days of an election campaign. I know of no scientific evidence on this matter but there may be anecdotal evidence.
Amendment No. 49 refers to by-elections. On the evening of the count in the Tipperary South by-election, after watching the second half of the Munster final on television, I listened on my way home to a radio discussion of the outcome of the by-election. A number of political commentators were participating and one of the issues raised was whether the TG4 opinion poll had in some way influenced the outcome of the election. The general view from the participants, who were all representative of the media, was that that it had not, with one exception. That exception was that they felt the Labour candidate who was at the bottom of the TG4 poll with about 16% may have suffered by people transferring votes elsewhere because of the opinion poll. In my view that type of anecdotal evidence is important and needs to be factored into the debate on this issue.
Our political system, based on proportional representation, has a large sensitivity to a small number of votes. Many seats are won by only a handful of votes and therefore anything, other than the merits of the candidates and political parties, that unduly influences the election should be looked at seriously. Those seats can decide the Government and there is a considerable amount at stake politically and nationally.
After the last referendum, a number of people said to me in almost apologetic terms that they had not voted and regretted it. Because of the opinion polls leading up to the vote, they had assumed that it would be passed. That can occur either way. We want to encourage as many people as possible to participate at elections. A worrying aspect of the democratic system in the western world – not just in Ireland – is the number of people not exercising their franchise. I would not suggest that having opinion polls is the primary reason, but if they are influencing even a small proportion of people not to exercise their franchise, then there is merit in doing it.
Opinion polls can be carried out and published at any time other than that one week.
Comment on this
On a point of order, are we still dealing with amendments Nos. 47 to 49, inclusive, or has the Government very graciously yielded to allow us to make Second Stage speeches? We would respond with great alacrity if that were the case.
Comment on this
I have already pulled up Senator Coghlan on this and I would appreciate if Senators would stick to the amendments before us. There are other options for speaking on the Report Stage of the Bill.
Comment on this
If Senator Norris had been here, he would have seen how I related my contribution to the amendments.
Comment on this
For Senator Norris's benefit, I am saying that if he had been here, he would have heard that.
Comment on this
This is an important issue and it is appropriate that we are having a debate on it. I appreciate the latitude the Chair has given and it will obviously not follow through to other amendments.
I have heard nobody give any argument either in the media or here today against the banning of opinion polls within the last seven days before an election. I have heard people making all sorts of comments.
Comment on this
Goebbels is alive and well in the media and, listening to the contributions earlier today, he has many disciples.
Comment on this
That is not in order. On the Report Stage amendments, Senator Ross is the only person allowed to reply after the Minister. If anybody else wishes to speak, they must do so before the Minister replies.
Comment on this
I understand that Senator Ross is the only person who can speak twice, but surely it is in order to request to hear the Minister's view on all this so that we can make this mean something.
Comment on this
This is not Committee Stage; it is Report Stage. Only the proposer of the amendment can reply after the Minister.
Comment on this
On a point of information, at the very outset the Minister offered to come in first. It was put to the House and the House—
Comment on this
That is not a point of information. In reply to Senator O'Toole, only the proposer of the amendment can speak after the Minister. Any Senator who wishes to speak before the Minister may now do so.
Comment on this
I have no complaint about the Minister – that was not the point. It would be far more appropriate if the Minister spoke in the midst of the debate so that there could be a response to the views he had articulated. The Minister is as much confined, constricted and constrained by the rules of the House as we are so it is no reflection on him.
Having listened to the points made by Senator Walsh, it is extraordinary that it has come down to press bashing. We are being told that the electorate will not be influenced by the press or opinion polls, but it defies—
Comment on this
Having listened to Senator Walsh explain to the House my reasons for speaking when he described my contribution as feigned indignation, I will certainly take every opportunity to attribute to him, as I see it, the points he made.
Comment on this
I heard him being unable to cope with any negative press publicity. I heard him say that we were all doing this for the honour and glory on a television programme tonight, which will not be broadcast at all. If this is as factual as the rest of what he had to say, I do not know where we are. He makes the point that this is in the guise—
Comment on this
I would appreciate it if the Senator would stick to the amendments.
Comment on this
In the interests of the way we do our business, I was amazed and appalled that you allowed the previous speaker the latitude you did. However, having done so, I promise I will not stray one iota beyond the points that you tolerated from him. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.
According to the previous speaker, this is being dealt with under the guise of freedom of speech. If we stop people from articulating their point of view, that is a freedom of speech issue regardless of whether I or other people like it. People may take the view that this is not kosher or correct, but if we stop the media, academics and polling companies from pooling together the views of the electorate, that is a curtailment and a restriction on free speech.
Comment on this
That is why I am utterly opposed to what we are doing here. In deference to the Chair, I would not go beyond these amendments, but I felt that there was need to make a point. I accept that your ruling is correct and I appreciate your tolerance on it. I will now come back to the issue and the amendments we are dealing with. We felt it was necessary to put down these amendments, not because we wanted these particular proposals to be applied to elections, but simply to point out how ludicrous the legislation is, how rushed it has been and how it has been cobbled together.
The definition of an election to this House does not even include the issues we mentioned. For the sake of posterity we would like to put our hands up and say we are here too. We must also provide for presidential elections – we should look at all elections and treat them equally. We cannot accept the definition of an election which does not include elections to this House. Maybe we are just trying to make ourselves seen and heard, or being assertive. Maybe we want to protect the presidency in the same way. Even this negative legislation should include all elections in its definition.
Can we speak on the section as well as the amendment?
Comment on this
No, the Senator must speak to the amendment. The Senator is well aware that—
Comment on this
—he cannot speak to the section. The Senator must address the amendment.
Comment on this
Therefore the only issues we can deal with are the amendments to the amendment. The Bill was passed by Seanad Éireann on 21 June and has returned with two pages of changes concerning section 59 in particular. Is the Chair ruling that we cannot speak on the major amendment to the Bill?
Comment on this
The Senator can speak to the amendments before the House.
Comment on this
There is a significant point here. There are two pages of amendments made by the Dáil, which we have previously not seen. I am not trying to be awkward, but I want to make a point. I am not seeking to create a difficulty or embarrass the Chair. However, I want to point out that two pages of changes were made in the other House, introducing new sections to the Bill. Is the Chair saying that this House cannot discuss the new section?
Comment on this
This will become important when I challenge the process later. I am not challenging the ruling of the Chair, I just want the ruling of the Chair to be on the record.
Comment on this
When we have disposed of the amendments, the question, "That the Bill be received for final consideration", will be proposed and the Senator can then make his contribution, as I have already said.
Comment on this
When can we speak on the issues raised by the amendments made in the Dáil? We are faced with a situation where we cannot discuss them until we have changed them.
Comment on this
I wish to clarify matters for the Senator. When we have disposed of all the amendments now being considered, the Minister will address the House on the amendments made by the Dáil. At that stage each Member will have an opportunity to speak about the amendments. Therefore, the Senator will have an opportunity to speak on them.
Comment on this
Therefore, we cannot deal with the amendments until we decide how we change them. Is that correct?
Comment on this
We cannot deal with them now until we have disposed of these amendments. At that stage the Minister will be called on to outline to the House the amendments made in the Dáil, that is, to give a report of the Dáil amendments to this House. Then every Member will have an opportunity to contribute if they so wish.
Comment on this
I did not intend speaking on these amendments, but I have been encouraged to do so by some of the comments made. I commend colleagues on this side of the House for tabling these amendments and for the effect they are having, as outlined by Senator O'Toole. They clearly show the rushed and ill thought-out manner in which this Bill has been changed, despite what has been said. Clearly there are extraordinary internal inconsistencies in the amendments made in the Dáil – one does not have to spend too much time reading them to figure that out.
I wish to speak about how the media have reacted to this issue since it was first raised last week, and I beg the indulgence of the Chair in this regard as he has allowed other people to speak on the matter. I have listened to comments made, particularly on the other side of the House, on how the media report proceedings in the House, how they comment on our business and on politics in general. To a certain extent I can relate to the sensitivity of Members or politicians who, in the words of Members on the Government side, are hard-working, decent and fair public servants—
Comment on this
—as most of us are. I have read the commentary in the media since last week. Undoubtedly some of it is over the top.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to return to the amendments. We can discuss the matter raised by the Senator later if she so wishes.
Comment on this
These amendments show up the inconsistencies in the legislation. Sensitivity to commentary in the media has gone way over the top in the House. We should remember that the media are entitled to describe us—
Comment on this
They are. The commentary of the Senator bordered on paranoia. Can we please stand back and remember that we are talking about democratic debate? So what if we are referred to as arrogant?
Comment on this
Senator Walsh has made his contribution. He should allow Senator O'Meara to contribute.