We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Electoral Amendment Bill, 2000 [ Seanad Bill amended by the Dáil ] : Report Stage.

Contributions 150–304 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Electoral (Amendment) Bill 2000
Enacted

No. 67 of 2000 ›

I defend the right of the Sunday Independent to use that language, though I do not agree with it.

Comment on this

The amendments are about opinion polls. Amendment No. 47 seeks to delete "a presidential" and substitute "an", amendment No. 48 seeks after "Dáil" to insert "or Seanad election" and amendment No. 49 seeks to delete "and, in the case of a Dáil election, includes a bye-election". Senator Quinn referred to Government legislation, but I would refer to it as Dáil legislation as the Dáil amendments were first introduced on Committee Stage on 28 June.

Comment on this

Is the Senator talking about Senator Ross's amendments?

Comment on this

The amendment was tabled by Deputy Olivia Mitchell in the name of Fine Gael and was as follows:

In page 32, before section 35, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:

"35.–No opinion poll shall be taken or published in the 7 day period prior to any election or referendum and no opinion poll whatsoever shall be published in the 7 day period prior to any election or referendum."

Those were the terms, and in the new legislation section 59 states:

(3) A person shall not carry out or cause to be carried out an opinion poll on any of the 7 days immediately preceding the polling day at an election or referendum.

(4) A person shall not publish or cause to be published on any of the 7 days mentioned in subsection (3) the results of an opinion poll, being a poll that–

(a) has been carried out on any of those days, or

(b) has been carried out before the first of those days and the results of which have not already been published before that time.

That is what Fine Gael sought and what Labour supported at the Select Committee.

I cannot understand why Senator Coghlan is raising the issue of the Attorney General now as that must have been discussed earlier. Why did they not think of it at that stage? They were the people who introduced the measure that has been passed by the Dáil. I am also surprised at the silence of their leader in this controversy. Deputy John Bruton first mentioned the issue of referring the matter to the Attorney General and he got great backing for this – including from Senator Manning, who everyone knows is a supporter of Deputy John Bruton.

Comment on this

Now please hang on.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will you stick to the amendments please?

Comment on this

I am just saying what I think. It is similar to what happened in the rail strike last year where there was an internal difference in the trade union. This is an internal difference in Fine Gael and this is why they have come—

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The amendments.

Comment on this

As far as opinion polls are concerned, I never liked them. They are a recent phenomenon and banning them will not impair freedom of speech. There is always freedom of speech in the press, but an opinion poll carried out on a sample of 300 people is not accurate and can be misleading.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Minister of State at the Department of the Environment and Local Government (Mr. D. Wallace) Fianna Fáil

I will address the amendments before us. Amendment No. 47 seeks to delete a presidential election from the provisions of the section. The amendment is not accepted as opinion polls could have a more serious effect on the outcome of a presidential election than other elections because of the nature of the election. It was claimed by the Fine Gael candidate that this occurred at the 1990 election.

Amendment No. 48 seeks to include Seanad elections in the prohibition of opinion polls. Seanad elections are excluded as they are not direct elections and it would be difficult to conduct a professional poll among such a disparate electorate—

Comment on this

I am sorry but I did not hear the last phrase clearly. Did the Minister of State say "difficult" or "different"?

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

The Seanad elections are excluded as they are not direct elections and it would be difficult to conduct a professional poll among such a disparate electorate. Also the elections are to different panels in the case of panel elections or different university establishments. An Opposition amendment was accepted on the Seanad Committee Stage debate to exclude Seanad elections from some of the Bill's provisions because of the vocational nature of the Seanad and now I am being asked to include Seanad elections.

Amendment No. 49 seeks to delete Dáil by-elections from the provisions of the section. I cannot accept these amendments and ask the Senators to withdraw them.

Comment on this

The Minister's reply was an insult to the House. The Minister read a brief and contemptuous script which replied to virtually none of the points that were made.

Comment on this

If the media are that easily insulted then what about the poor politicians?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order, please. Senator Walsh has made his contribution.

Comment on this

This is typical of the attitude of this Administration – not only to the people but also to the Parliament. None of the points, bar the bare points in the amendments, was addressed by the Minister. I would have thought that the Minister, although he is supplied with a script – and we accept that – would have taken the trouble to take the points that were made and replied to them. Some people here went to a great deal of trouble to make serious points in this debate and they have done so all day. If the Government does not take this particular Bill seriously, then that is fine if they want to rush it through but it is showing a complete contempt for the Seanad as they did for the Dáil on this particular Bill.

The attitude of the Government on this Bill is quite simple. I commend Senator Walsh at least for speaking on it – although I do not agree with him he spoke on it and did so articulately – and Senator Rory Kiely for putting a point of view with which we do not agree. At least they are defending it. There is another point of view – we are not so intolerant on this side that we do not believe there is another point of view – but for the Minister to come after God knows how many speakers have made serious points on these amendments and to read a one page script written by civil servants makes me wonder what is behind this Bill. I would have expected – and I accept that he is a Minister of State of great competence – that he would come here with the authority and respect for this House that he would actually reply to the points made here. This is inadequate and contemptible.

Let me take one or two points which the Minister made – I think he only made two, so it will not take very long. He addressed the issue of the Seanad elections. He is completely wrong about that. Obviously the Government did not think this through. It would be the simplest thing in the world – not difficult – to get a sample of Senator Quinn's constituency and take an opinion poll by telephone on it. I believe it consists of some 100,000 people now and the Minister can correct me, but is that not the size of an average constituency? We are talking about a geographical constituency for the Dáil and a non-geographical constituency for the Seanad – the numbers are roughly the same. Let me tell the Minister how difficult it would be. You get a book with 100,000 names in it, look up their telephone numbers, dial numbers which have been selected at random and ask them which way they are going to vote. That is an opinion poll. It is very simple to do and would be just as accurate as any other telephone poll that was taken and which is forbidden.

There is an extraordinary anomaly there – it just was not thought about. This is a completely cocked up Bill and there is no logic behind it whatsoever. Senator Quinn might well think of doing that at the next election because that sort of opinion poll would give very valuable information. I have done it in local elections before – if you get a reasonable sample you know where your strength is and find out what the issues are. It is just a formula and then you get people to vote for you. I did it myself in Bray. I was miles behind in the first local election then did an opinion poll, found out where the strength in every camp was, found out what the issues were and the idiots went and elected me. That is what happened and it can be done at Seanad elections. Let us not have this kind of inconsistency that is going on. It is perfectly fair to do it at Seanad elections and even on the panels. Any Senator here can correct me on this; there are about 900 or 1,000 votes on the panels, and one could easily conduct an opinion poll there that would be pretty accurate. Maybe because of the nature of the electorate they would not tell the truth in that case. There may be a difficulty there as they are notable for not telling the truth.

To talk about the vocational nature of the Seanad is nonsense. It is not the vocational nature of the electorate – it is utterly irrelevant when it comes to the electorate – but only of the nominating body. One is not going to be polling the nominating body, but the councillors, Deputies and Senators who have votes. Out of those 900, one could easily get a good sum which might give one an accurate response. There is inconsistency in what is being said.

The Minister of State did not reply to the point I made about the Presidency or anybody else. There are no issues in presidential elections. They are mindless beauty contests. There cannot be any issues because the President has to be above politics by definition. Opinion polls are probably the most accurate, interesting and relevant information one can get on presidential elections because they are solid facts. They allow one to know where the various candidates stand and they influence one's vote. There is nothing wrong with that. To know where public opinion stands is a valuable tool when exercising one's democratic right. I do not accept that these issues, minor as they may seem in the bigger political picture which has exploded in the Government's face, are being considered.

There is some validity in what Senator Walsh said about the press being somewhat partisan on this issue. I cannot see how we can blame them. One would not expect them to do anything else. If we said to the press, we will ban advertising, we would not expect them to say that is a good idea, that they will not allow stories that sell newspapers. Opinion polls happen to be an issue that sells newspapers, but they also happen to be something that the public want. That is the whole point of them. I do not know very much about selling newspapers, but I know that opinion polls sell them. I accept that, but there is nothing wrong with that. There is a great hunger for this type of information. That is why newspapers sell more if they carry an opinion poll on the front page. The population want and have a right to that information. For people to say the press are getting hysterical is like saying they should not have the right to defend what is a commercial interest to them, but it is not an evil commercial interest, it happens to be a commercial interest which the public also want. The evidence is there that newspapers sell more when they carry opinion polls. This has been presented—

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I ask the Deputy to speak to the amendments.

Comment on this

I am addressing Senator Walsh's points which I am allowed to do.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy should speak to the amendments.

Comment on this

I am.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Please do.

Comment on this

I am doing so and I will continue to do so. Public opinion polls – I am addressing them specifically for presidential elections or Seanad elections – are something in which the public and the press have an interest. If we ban them for presidential elections or Seanad elections, we will deprive the public of something they want. It is silly and paranoid for Fianna Fáil to indulge in that sort of press bashing. I do not accept what Senator Walsh said about the Sunday Independent for which I work. I know the article to which he referred. I asked the Library to get some of the latest articles—

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator is straying from the amendments.

Comment on this

I am, but these articles are relevant and I will read them into the record if the Chair wishes.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Senator may not do that when speaking to the amendments. He may do so later if he wishes.

Comment on this

These apply directly to the point I am making about presidential elections. The Minister of State, Deputy Molloy, in an article last week, referred specifically to banning opinion polling in the week before an election. That applies also to presidential elections, which are included in this amendment. Bobby Molloy wrote an article—

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Minister, Deputy Molloy, please.

Comment on this

Sorry, the Minister, Deputy Molloy. I thought the Chair was addressing me as Minister.

Comment on this

The Senator should have respect for this side of the House.

Comment on this

I see the Senator is sitting on the opposite side.

Comment on this

The Minister of State, Deputy Molloy, made a coherent and valid case for what the Government has done. That appeared in The Irish Times yesterday or the day before – I am not sure of the date. John Waters who is in a prominent position was allowed to have a go quite freely and say that he believed that banning opinion polls was perfectly all right. This is not completely and utterly one-sided. Partisan articles have been written on the other side. It is also insulting to think that in presidential elections or other elections the public will be bamboozled by articles on one side and they will not get to consider the other side. The press does not have that sort of power. Where the power lies in the media is not in the press but in television and radio. They are far more powerful than the press. They make a far stronger and far more lasting impression on people. It is absurd to be paranoid about the press.

The Minister of State did not respond to one or two other points raised by speakers to which he should have responded. Once one suppresses information of this sort, where does it stop? Who makes these decisions that one thing is bad for people to hear and another thing is good for them to hear? If this is allowed, and I am being serious about this, the next thing that will be stopped will be the presenting of ideas. Ideas are far more dangerous than information.

Comment on this

There are none on this side of the House.

Comment on this

There are no ideas but there are plenty of people. That is why we will lose. Ideas are far more dangerous and subversive than information. If the presenting of information of this sort is to be stopped in the last seven days – some people wanted it to be 14 days – before presidential or Seanad elections, the next thing they will do is stop ideas being presented in these types of elections. I can see that happening because they are deciding that information of this sort is bad for the public.

We saw censorship here before. I happen to approve of it in certain situations where violence is involved. We got rid of censorship under section 31. We are now seeing censorship of completely and utterly harmless, but extremely entertaining and important information. The next thing we will see is censorship of more information and then we will see censorship of ideas.

We are going down a very dangerous road. I do not think the Government has any evil intent in this. It has blundered into this. It played a little political trick by trapping the Opposition into taking a position which it did not really want to take. It then decided to run with it, but its heart is not in it.

Before I put the amendment to a vote, I ask the Minister of State in subsequent amendments to reply to points made by individuals. If he is going to read from his script, which he is perfectly entitled to do, he should also reply to the points made by individuals in the House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Are the amendments being pressed?

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 48:

In page 94, line 30, after "Dáil" to insert "or Seanad election".

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 49:

In page 94, lines 31 and 32, to delete "and, in the case of a Dáil election, includes a bye-election".

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 51:

In page 94, line 36, after "State" to insert "over eighteen years of age".

This is a matter of definition. I am somewhat confused by this clause. It is really a matter of drafting and perhaps the Minister could help the House in this. Section 59(1) states:

"opinion poll" means a systematic inquiry conducted by means of questioning a sample of persons considered to be representative of the population of the State or any part thereof for the purpose of ascertaining the likely opinions of the population of the State as a whole or part thereof on matters relating to an election or referendum referred to in subsection (3) including the manner in which the population of the State or part thereof may vote in such election or referendum;

I assume this excludes by definition anyone under the age of 18 years, but what if an opinion pollster or an organisation or an individual, wishes to poll people who are under the age of 18, and is that legal? I presume this will be taken and is assumed as being people over the age of 18 and therefore being of the age of majority, but it does not say that anywhere. I would like to know where and how this is defined and why we are to understand that.

Comment on this

This issue concerns a matter of some significance. Members of the House will be aware that there is a very pro-active attitude among teachers to gain the interest of students in the democratic process. It has become common in many schools to role-play an election at election time. The children are encouraged to express their views and newspapers regularly publish the results of the poll taken in local schools and compare how close the results are to the actual election results.

The Bill as published defines an opinion poll as: "a sample of persons considered to be representative of the population of the State or any part thereof". This goes way beyond the question of opinion polling for elections. These might be the views of school students who do not even have a vote. This is now part of normal school work, it is part of civics teaching in most post-primary schools. It also features at primary level and it is used as an attempt to deepen the engagement with the democratic process, to ensure that there is a greater understanding of the democratic process of elections. People are encouraged to participate in elections. The school class will debate the election, talk about the issues, look at the election material and offer points of view. A mock or quasi-election is then held and the results and conclusions are published. This is now very definitely a breach of this section.

It probably indicates some of the worries that this legislation will intrude into the most unlikely parts of the life of the citizens and society. I would have expected this to be discussed with amendment No. 67, which deals with persons engaged in polling for academic or research purposes. This is one of the daft consequences of this proposed legislation and there are some others also. I hope the Minister will accept this amendment and at least ensure the normal educational processes and the operation of civics classes and the chance to give students a greater understanding of the electoral process would not be interfered with.

I do not misunderstand the section. It is absolutely clear in its meaning. Prior to the last referendum the various Departments circulated information about Europe to schools. There was no referendum on the euro but there might have been. We are seeking to bring children and young people to a greater understanding. Effectively, that activity would be in breach of the legislation and that is another reason for not going through with this ridiculous, ludicrous, insidious and invidious Bill. I ask the Minister of State to recognise that the clean thing to do would be to withdraw the whole thing. If he cannot do that he should at least ensure that those who are not adults, who are not voters and who are part of the school system are exempt from this legislation.

Comment on this

I thank the Independent Senators for putting down this amendment. It has the effect of showing the daft nature of this proposal when it is closely examined. Of course, we are the only ones getting an opportunity to do that.

When I read the definition of "opinion poll" it occurred to me straightaway how broad it is. In a school a leaving certificate or pre-leaving certificate class of 17 year olds could be barred from holding their own opinion poll. That is daft in the context of civics classes, learning about politics and training in the political system before engaging to a full extent in it. It shows up how crazy this proposal actually is. I appeal to the Minister to accept this reasonable and simple amendment thereby avoiding a proposal the applicability of which enters into the realms of craziness.

A number of Members have said it was never the intention of the proposers of this amendment to restrict the free flow of information. The thinking behind it was to avoid undue influence by opinion polls on the voter. That was based on the thinking that the voter is influenced by opinion polls despite the fact that we have no evidence to that effect. Earlier in the day I would have said the same but as the debate has gone on I am beginning to wonder. I reiterate that we have to look again at the proposal before us here. The implications are not only daft, some of them are actually horrendous to contemplate.

Comment on this

No one would do other than encourage participation in civic classes. It gives young people an interest and an insight into what is not the most easily understood electoral system in the world – our system of proportional representation.

The word daft was used but the interpretation being put on this is not just daft, it is also mischievous. Though I am no lawyer, section 59 seems fairly straightforward. It states:

"opinion poll" means a systematic inquiry conducted by means of questioning a sample of persons considered to be representative of the population of the State or any part thereof.

Comment on this

Schoolchildren could do that.

Comment on this

Surely it is implicit in the wording that children and schools are not included.

Comment on this

It is in my eye implicit.

Comment on this

To say that is a distortion and adds to the hype we have seen from the other side of the House all day. People are talking about having meaningful debate on the issues but it does nothing for the standing of the House to be nit-picking purely for the sake of it.

Comment on this

This is a new approach to legislation.

Comment on this

Logic would tell anyone, apart from those who obviously have not read the wording—

Comment on this

Read subsection (3).

Comment on this

Logic tells us that no judge in the world would prosecute children for conducting an opinion poll at any stage, be it during an election, after an election or at any other time.

Comment on this

If it was in the law he would.

Comment on this

It is ludicrous of the Opposition to put forward such propositions.

Comment on this

In this House we try to improve legislation and one of the reasons we do so is that we want to ensure the law never becomes a laughing stock. We want to ensure that we never come to a pass such as that referred to by Senator Walsh whereby we pass a law and instruct the Garda to ignore it because if it is tested in court the judge will throw cases out because he will realise they are not covered by the intention of the law. That is such bad law. It is such bad thinking and something that should never happen in this House. If we pass a Bill it becomes law because it is to be enforced. I spoke earlier on the Waste Management (Amendment) (No. 2) Bill, 2000, about the dog muzzling law enacted many years ago and about which Senator O'Toole often talks. If we jump in without attention and pass legislation in the knowledge that it is not going to be enforced, then we are making a laughing stock of ourselves.

One of the surveys carried out regularly which makes us hold our heads up high is the democratic survey. It shows that Ireland is high up in the democratic stakes. That is judged by the examination of a number of the different freedoms we have. We are reasonably high up because of education whereby we have instilled in young people a sense of how the democratic process works. One of the ways in which it works is through those young people we have spoken about of 17 and 18 years of age. In all the schools I know transition year – at 16 years of age – is where this instillation takes place. Now there is also the leaving certificate applied whereby skills and intelligences that are not otherwise measured are measured so that the seedbed of those talents is fertilised to ensure they grow.

One of the ways that is done is to involve young people in opinion polls coming up to elections. If we are now going to provide that is against the law it is very bad. If this was taken in the cool calm of a normal debate where the Minister listening to the case being made was accepting amendments, I have no doubt that the Minister would say he understood the point. Then this would not apply to anybody under the age of 18 years. Yet I have a sense the Minister of State is not going to say that. I sense he is not going to take this very good amendment on board. I am not sure what words he will use to decry it but it is wrong if he uses words such as "well, that is not the intention of the Bill so I am sure that no judge will ever prosecute such persons".

That is not good lawmaking. Either the Minister reconsiders and takes this whole Bill back for consideration of a Stage or he accepts this amendment. There is no in between in this case. We will damage the infrastructure of our democratic process if we do not manage to make this the sort of Bill we can stand over and declare ourselves proud of as good legislation. Let us make sure this amendment is accepted or drop the whole Bill.

Comment on this

I support what has been said. Not alone are these opinion polls and samplings conducted in transition year in secondary schools, they are also done in primary schools. The definition of "opinion poll" has to be very clear. At first glance one would take it that the sample used would be taken at random from the register of electors, but that is clearly not the case. Clearly there is no such commitment set out in the definition. It can be any sample. It is possible that the sample could be one of children attending a primary school.

In many primary schools in my area this exercise is gone through during elections. In two cases of which I am aware opinion polls conducted in a certain school reflected accurately the tally of the local polling station in the election two days later. It is extraordinary that these opinion polls were correct almost to a vote. They were accurate to an extraordinary degree. One might say that it was an exercise in fun in many ways and it was a serious exercise in a sense, but nevertheless it would appear that it could be a serious offence under this legislation.

Therefore, the Minister of State, Deputy Dan Wallace, must make a clear statement here regarding the sample to be used. Either there must be a clear definition or, as was suggested, the Bill should be taken back and reworked totally in the next session in October. He should not turn the law into what Mr. Bumble called "a ass". If the interpretation to be taken from this is, as it appears, that this kind of civics exercise which is carried out in all schools nowadays cannot proceed without fear of sanction from the law, the Government will be a laughing stock.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I want to explain to the House that I did not refer to primary school pupils because of the fact that the age of criminal responsibility has been raised to 12. I felt it did not apply to them in that sense. Senator Connor is absolutely right. Opinion polls are conducted in primary schools. However, I do not think the law would apply to them in this regard.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

In relation to the matter raised in the case of schools, the poll would have to be representative of the population of the State. It must be related to an election. If students are not voters, then the poll would not be directly related to the election. Classroom polls are not normally made for publication. However, there could be some press reporting of the event.

In relation to the amendment, this amendment seeks to insert the words "over eighteen years of age", into the definition of opinion polls. If the people carrying out the poll questioned people under 18 years of age, then the case for prohibition and publication in the section would be stronger. One must, if one can, rely on the professionalism of the polling organisations in the matter. The proposed amendment is not considered necessary and in the circumstances I cannot accept it. The Senators may wish to withdraw it.

Comment on this

The Minister of State's reply convinces me more than ever that this amendment is actually necessary. I am deadly serious about it.

Comment on this

He deceived the House.

Comment on this

Yes. He said it would be representative of the population of the State but he left out the next few words, that is, "or any part thereof".

Comment on this

A classroom would not be representative.

Comment on this

It is representative of "any part" of the State. The Senator should not tell me that the class is not representative of any body at all. That is typical of the patronising element which has gone into this Bill.

The Minister of State left out those words. I do not think he did it deliberately but he was probably misguided by somebody. To say that school children are not representative of any part of the State is patently and self-evidently untrue. They represent themselves.

The more I think about it, the more ridiculous I think this now becomes. I do not know whether the Minister of State is actually saying that these polls will be banned or that they will not be banned. He is not telling us. I think he does not know.

He went on to say that they are not normally meant for publication and that may be so, but they could be published. If I get an opportunity in my professional capacity to publish the opinions of school children at the next election, I will put them in a newspaper.

Comment on this

Tony Blair announced his election campaign in a school.

Comment on this

Senator O'Toole is quite correct. Therefore, they can be published. He chose a school because it was representative of a very significant part of the state. He felt it was such a telling image that it was a good place to launch that campaign.

This is just bad drafting. It is a bad Bill. It is badly thought out. This will be a running sore and it will be an issue in the next election. There will be schools which will conduct polls and the question will be whether the teachers can be prosecuted for carrying them out. Perhaps there will be the wonderful vision where we lock up a few school teachers, which in other circumstances might not be a bad idea but in this case is not a particularly good idea. It is ridiculous that Senator O'Toole or someone else could be prosecuted because some teachers carry out an opinion poll. I beg the Minister of State to with draw the Bill and certainly this particular aspect of it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Does the Minister of State want to add anything?

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

I have nothing further to add.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister of State cannot reply now.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If he wants to add something, he can.

Comment on this

Can we respond to what he says?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

No.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

I have nothing further to add. I have outlined the position.

Comment on this

I propose an amendment to the Order of Business, that the House should suspend until 8.45 p.m.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 52:

In page 94, line 38, to delete "referred to in subsection (3)”.

This amendment relates to the section which defines an opinion poll. A number of difficulties arise from the definition of an opinion poll set out in the Bill and these difficulties are serious enough to render the Bill questionable.

The Bill defines an opinion poll as "a systematic inquiry conducted by means of questioning a sample of persons considered to be representative of the population of the State, or any part thereof, for the purpose of ascertaining the likely opinions of the population of the State as a whole, or part thereof, on matters relating to an election or referendum".

During the recent by-election I canvassed for our candidate in Tipperary South. It is my habit, when canvassing, to inquire of the person who answers the door how he or she intends to vote. I introduce myself and ask if the person has made up his mind how he will vote. That is a question. If one canvasses 50 houses it is a systematic inquiry. A canvass can take place outside an election as well, but in the context of this legislation the relevant time period is the week coming up to an election.

I do not consider a canvass that I would do in my own constituency or any other to be complete if I do not ask the person how they intend to vote. I can ascertain by their body language, their answer or their non-answer what their intention is. I may not be as experienced as some Members of this House, but as one who is fairly experienced in this process, I can come back from visiting 50, 70 or 100 houses in an afternoon and have a pretty good idea of what is going on. The definition of opinion poll here raises a question about that kind of inquiry. Like my colleagues, I have from time to time carried out this canvass accompanied by a person with an electoral register or a sheet of paper on a clipboard and a pen.

Comment on this

There will be no more of that.

Comment on this

Only for bingo.

Comment on this

Some political organisations within constituencies would argue that it is not an effective canvass unless they ascertain as closely as possible how that person intends to vote. They go back to their election office with the information and try to work out how many people will vote for Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour etc. I know people who do that. It is considered the most effective way to gather information about what is happening.

It is possible to do a relative sample either throughout the election or from one year to another. It is possible to ascertain how opinions are going and particularly to establish the mood of the electorate in the last two weeks of an election campaign. If that is not an opinion poll, I do not know what is. It would only be published to a small number of party people and it is used for party reasons. The definition of opinion poll here relates very closely to that activity and that is one of the reasons this legislation is so problematic.

It might not be the intention of the drafters of this legislation to outlaw the activity I have outlined. Senator Walsh might be able to look into his heart and know what the spirit of the legislation is, but not everybody can and Senator Walsh will not be available to everyone who asks the question. The legislation should be without ambiguity, but it is full of ambiguity and, as we saw from the previous amendments, it is full of problems. The definition of opinion poll, accurate as it may be, actually describes other very basic and central political activity, which we all as members of political parties engage in before and during an election campaign and certainly during the last week of a campaign.

If I am being told that activity is now within the confines of a ban, we have a problem. It is time to accept that we have a difficulty here, withdraw the legislation and go back to the drawing board. Of course, I am pretty sure that will not happen.

Among the comments made in the past week in favour of the general ban is the belief, particularly among those in political parties and especially the largest party in the State, that the publication of an opinion poll in the last week of an election actually influences or may influence the outcome and therefore we should not have one. We should create a space in which the electorate can reflect without the influence of an opinion poll and make its decision based on issues and other factors. What evidence do we have, except our own impression, that an opinion poll is influential?

An Cathaoirleach: Senator O'Meara is now making points which would be more relevant later in the debate when we come to the question that the Bill be received for final consideration. At this stage we are discussing her amendment No. 52 which, she stated, refers to the definition of opinion polls and not to the effects opinion polls might have.

Comment on this

I accept your ruling on that and I will save my point for later in the debate. I have made my point adequately on the definition of opinion polls. I suspect that other Members, particularly on this side of the House, will probably have other examples of where this definition can be applied not only to the taking of an opinion poll but to activities which we would consider to be normal political activity and which, in my opinion, it was never the intention of the legislation to curtail or ban.

Comment on this

I second the amendment. There is an issue here about the way we do our business and I will come back to it again. Perhaps it might be easier to come back to it knowing that people recognise that tomorrow's newspapers are written and programmes are put to bed for tonight; therefore people cannot deliberately misinterpret the reasons for opposition.

There is a way in which we do our business here. The reputation of this House is dependent on people working to a set of beliefs, principles and philosophies. These may differ from each other but are nonetheless valid and we are required to articulate them as strongly and firmly as we can.

The points made by Senator O'Meara are absolutely correct. An opinion poll is not what people might think it is, would like it to be or what it might be interpreted as in the future; it is as defined in the words from line 34 down to the end of that subsection.

This amendment is closely related to my amendment No. 60 and I would have been happy to deal with both of them together. The work of party activists, functionaries, canvassers or workers is effectively the polling of the opinion of people. I was quite astonished by an earlier response from the Minister. I know him well enough and long enough to know that he would not deliberately mislead the House, but I am sure his view in answer to an earlier question that this related to polling organisations was not meant to be an exclusive position. There is no mention anywhere of this being confined purely to polling organisations. If it were, it would take many of the problems out of the Bill.

These are problems like the one I raised earlier about schools and the problems raised now by Senator O'Meara. It is not just the publication that is wrong, but also the taking of the information. That is why this amendment is important. The proposal is that we take away the words referred to in subsection (3), which refers to an election or a referendum and they are defined earlier in the section.

During a canvass people ask questions at each of the doors they call to. One person does Auburn Drive; the next does Auburn Walk; the next does Auburn Crescent. They all come back to meet their canvass organiser at the end of the evening and they have now broken the law. I am not saying that might arise, or that anyone will take action against them. That is what brings the legislation into disrepute. As long as those words are included, and reference is made to people working in these situations, a difficulty will arise down the line.

We cannot work on the basis that people may be breaking the law, but that it is okay because it was never intended that the law would apply to them in such situations and that no action would be taken. One cannot operate on that basis as the legislation would be brought into disrepute. On that basis all we would need to do is publish legislation, say what we intend by it, and get rid of lawyers. That might have many attractions, but things do not work that way. Lawyers point to the words used and argue as to what they mean and whether what a person did was wrong.

I appeal to the Minister to consider what we are doing. We are walking into a morass and bringing the legislative process into disrepute. This is not good legislation and will not work. I ask the Minister to park it and revisit it in the autumn so we can see what needs to be done to meet the specific needs of people.

Comment on this

I support the arguments put forward by Senators O'Toole and O'Meara regarding the clarity of the legislation. Legislation must be unequivocal: there should never be a question mark about the intention behind it or about the spirit of the intention. If it is clearly defined it will be clearly understood.

Senator O'Meara spoke about polling, a process we all undertake to find out where our strengths and weaknesses lie. Recently I was in Great Britain for a personal reason and while there I noted they have a peculiar system, namely, if somebody is voting for Labour in a household, they put a small plaque in their garden indicating that, ensuring people know where they stand. I was in the greater Manchester area and the large farmers had plaques with "Conservative". If that process was introduced here, candidates who counted the plaques would be polling. That is how farcical this can become. There is a need for either clarity in description or removal of the section and a new start made.

Comment on this
Dan Wallace Mr. D. Wallace Fianna Fáil

This amendment seeks to delete the cross reference in the definition of opinion poll in subsection (3). This is a drafting matter and I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I accept it is a matter of drafting, but I have no intention of withdrawing the amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 53 is a substitute amendment for amendments Nos. 53 and 54 on the white list. Amendments Nos. 65 and 66 are related to amendment No. 53 and may be taken together by agreement. If amendment No. 53 is defeated, then amendments Nos. 55 to 66, inclusive, cannot be moved.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 53:

In page 94 to delete lines 47 to 51 and in page 95 to delete lines 1 to 39.

In light of the Cathaoirleach's remarks on the effect that a defeat of amendment No. 53 would have on the amendments up to No. 66 inclusive, I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The amendment is not seconded.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 55 is related to amendment No. 58 and they may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 55:

In page 95, line 6, to delete "preceding" and substitute "following".

The intent of this amendment is, unapologetically, to negate the purpose of the section. It seeks to delete the word "preceding" and substitute the word "following". If one were to do that, one would forbid opinion polls being taken after the event, which seems to be a perfectly sensible proposal to suggest.

Comment on this

Will the Senator explain it?

Comment on this

It would be difficult to explain it in more simple terms. The reason is obvious. The Bill states there should be no polls taken for seven days beforehand. Will the Minister of State indicate where that will leave us on polling day? I ask him to answer the question of whether newspapers or anyone else will be able to publish one minute after midnight on the night before polling day or later on polling day the results of a poll taken eight days beforehand or one taken that night. In other words, will it be possible for a scientific poll to be taken just after midnight on the night before polling and the results published in the newspapers that day? It is a sensible question. It is not beyond the practical bounds of possibility for a newspaper, the media or anyone with a good organisation to publish the result of such an exercise.

What I am envisaging is that eight days beforehand a poll could be taken on a scientific basis with the express purpose of the results being read out on the news at midnight on the night before polling day or taken one or two hours after midnight on the night before polling day and the results read on the news at 8 a.m. on polling day. That would have a bigger influence than the results of any poll taken just beforehand because it would inform the people about the state of opinion as they go to the polls. One could carry out polls throughout polling day and give a running commentary on the state of the polls, or one could carry out polls, as they do in the United State which seems to be fairly ridiculous, giving the results which are published before a large number have voted on the day.

The Minister of State can correct me if I am wrong, but I understand the references in the Bill to timing are all to do with the preceding seven days. What is to stop a polling organisation breaching this by taking a much more up-to-date poll and publishing the results of an eight day old poll? What will happen to it if it publishes a poll taken in the seven forbidden days before polling day? That is the reason I tabled this amendment and I would be interested to hear the Minister of State's answer in detail.

Comment on this

I second the amendment and appeal to my colleagues opposite to understand that this is not a game. As I said when I last spoke, the media are all gone home to bed until tomorrow morning. There is, therefore, nobody here trying to make an impact on them. There are serious points at issue. We are making idiots of ourselves with this legislation. We are putting through legislation that is inoperable, unworkable and based on a false premise. A series of amendments show specifically that under this legislation it could be determined that pupils in their civics classes could be at variance with it or that canvasses at election time, putting together opinions at the end of a night's canvassing which is practical work, could be in breach of it. This legislation is not only aimed at polling organisations, which would make some sense. There is also the point made by Senator Ross.

Those of us who have been opposed to this legislation have said that the way to approach this matter is to have a voluntary code between political parties and media outlets to ensure there would be a moratorium on this type of reportage for a period of three days, the day of the election and for two days prior to it. People would be supportive of such an approach. Instead we have this nonsense. We will have entry polls, exit polls and polls taken on the day. Every possible use will be made to subvert the legislation. We will find ourselves in a situation where the last position will be worse than the first.

We are trying to convince the people that this is bad legislation. It is badly drafted. It does not discharge the purposes or the objectives for which it was intended. It makes a laughing stock of all of us. As to the idea we have heard across the floor three or four times that this is not what the Bill is meant to do, while that may be the case, if words are written, they mean what they mean. This is not Alice in Wonderland time where we can say they do not mean this or they were not intended to do this, that or the other. It is our business to pass legislation that is accurate and not open to all sorts of varying interpretations and which can be implemented.

This is a disastrous section. In dealing with this legislation, we are not getting respect in terms of getting answers to our questions and a clear understanding of where we are at. Senator Ross asked the Minister of State to state that this legislation does not exclude opinion polling on election day. It does not forbid, criminalise or outlaw it from midnight on the day before polling day. I want that on the record to enable the people to realise that what we could finish up with would be a position where the last one could be worse than the first. Any of us here can envisage what will happen. Eight days before the election an opinion poll will be taken and the results not published. On the morning of the election another poll will be taken. The headlines on polling day will be that this is what has happened in the past week. We will finish up with the last position being worse than the first.

I am failing to make any impact on the Minister of State. Someone somewhere should talk to somebody. I want to give the Minister of State an opinion poll. In the course of this afternoon I spoke to four people who have no involvement in politics. They are ordinary people who go about their day's work. All four unsolicitedly asked me what was my position on this legislation. They were appalled that we should allow it to go through. I am not giving the Minister of State that information for any reason. It may mean nothing other than they are the type of people to whom I speak all the time.

This is poor legislation which undermines the work we do. The amendment tabled by Senator Ross highlights once again the type of nonsense into which we are moving. We are walking into a morass where our last position will be worse than our first. This legislation does not do what it sets out to do. It leaves us worse off than we were before and creates all sorts of anomalies.

It is fundamentally the reflection of a rushed piece of work and we are paying the price here. It has not been discussed, parsed and analysed in any other place except here in the course of the afternoon. I would welcome hearing the views of our Fianna Fáil colleagues on this I do not want to hear views about the reasons we are doing this. I ask them to ignore our motivations or think they are the worst, but to deal and engage with the issues we raised which are serious. I would have been out of here two hours ago if I thought there was a serious understanding of our position on the far side of the House, but I will not move from here as long as people take the negative view that they cannot see the problems with this legislation. The Minister's party workers will suffer as much as anybody else.

Comment on this

This seems to be an extremely interesting amendment. I do not imagine Senator Ross wishes to be helpful to the Government in its campaign. If the Government was serious about the principal intent of this Bill, then he has certainly unearthed something which seems to frustrate that intent. If it is serious one would anticipate that it would accept this amendment because it helps the Bill achieve what it sets out to do. If it is to accept any amendment at all, or if it is serious about anything other than a media bashing exercise, then this is obviously an item it will have to take on board. If there is a way around this, which I do not think there is, I will be very interested in hearing the Minister's suggestion.

One of the reasons I am in favour of opinion polls is that sometimes they isolate questions which are of concern to the electorate, but which political parties have decided to neglect. This is one method of concentrating the mind of even an unwilling Government or Opposition on those matters. I will find it difficult to understand if the Government reject this amendment.

The question regarding timing, such as one minute after midnight, is interesting. It is possible that opinion polls affect voter's intentions. There is the bandwagon effect, and, on the other hand, there are people wishing to jump off a sinking ship. One can see this by watching the coverage of American elections. Because of the time zones, exit polls in one time zone are announced while people are still voting in another. It has always seemed to me that this effect tended to even itself out. The people are entitled to the fullest possible information.

I support this amendment, and look forward to its being put to a vote. I remind my colleagues that voting is part of the democratic exercise. I hope we have about 16 further votes this evening, principally because I have missed attending the theatre.

Comment on this

This is better than theatre.

Comment on this

I support what has been said. I do not know if the Minister and his advisers understand that we are banning the taking and publishing of opinion polls for seven days preceding the election, but that does not include the day of the election. The date of the poll commences at one minute past midnight and there will be seven hours before polling booths open.

As has been pointed out, material for an opinion poll can be collected or put together up to seven days beforehand and can be published. It will still be early enough to make the morning newspapers. This information can be used in all the media – written, spoken and visual – on the day of the poll. The biggest news impact comes from early morning radio and the morning newspapers. That could influence people. A colleague has said that some people will want to jump on a ship that is sailing fair, while others will want to jump off a ship they think is sinking. For that reason the Minister will have to explain how he will get around this problem. It makes a joke of so many things in this Bill and particularly in relation to definitions which I was last speaking about.

I make these points to the Minister and his advisers only to be helpful. The whole idea of banning opinion polls was to ensure that they would not have an influence on voter opinion for a clear period before an election. If they are published on the day of the poll, they could have a very clear impact because they had been prohibited for the previous seven days. I am often dubious about the influence of such polls, but if they are to have influence, they will certainly have influence if this is allowed to happen.

Comment on this

The debate on this amendment has thrown up an interesting point. It is hard to see that there is not some validity in it as regards having an opinion poll published on polling day. If it is not permitted to gather the information in the seven days before the poll, it would presumably affect the validity of the poll. To be consistent, however, publication should be prohibited. In saying that I would not go as far as to suggest that the gathering of opinion on the day of an election should ever be prohibited. The exit polls which this legislation allows, but which may be overtaken by electronic voting, is a quite useful facility for people and the media. It has often turned out to be quite accurate.

The amendment before us does not deal with that issue. All the amendment does is to put forward the deletion of the word "preceding" the day of election and inserts "following" the day of the election. This negates the whole purpose of the legislation—

Comment on this

On a point of order, we are discussing amendment No. 58.

Comment on this

I am discussing No. 55 which I think I am entitled to do.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are discussing amendments Nos. 55 and 58.

Comment on this

That is on polling day.

Comment on this

I want to deal with the amendment on which I have been speaking, No. 55.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are discussing both amendments.

Comment on this

I am speaking specifically on deleting "preceding" and substituting "following", which is the substance of amendment No. 55. That negates the purpose of the Bill—

Comment on this

That is its purpose.

Comment on this

—and I accept that is the intention. Banning exit polls would be wrong and is something we should not countenance.

Comment on this

When I was a child, we went off chocolate and sweets for Lent. We were allowed to finish our pledge at midday on Easter Saturday and we hoarded our sweets waiting for that moment. We looked forward to it no end, because we had not had sweets for six weeks. We waited for the Angelus on Easter Saturday and then gorged ourselves with sweets and chocolates. This is a bit like chocolate legislation. It is a bit like saying, "Chocolate is not good for you, so it will be banned".

What will happen? Every television and radio station will advertise for their audiences to tune in at midnight on the eve of election day, only hours before voting begins, and will tell them what is happening. The country will wait for the news because it has been deprived. People are currently interested in opinion polls, but on that day they will be on the edge of their seats waiting for the findings. This is bad legislation, it says people will be informed at midnight on polling day and not one minute past it. Each newspaper will advertise that people should read it before they vote because the opinion polls it will have conducted seven days earlier will tell them what is happening. People will be on edge waiting for them. If not this way, the media will find some other way of circumventing the provision.

This is bad legislation and I do not want the House associated with it. None of us wants the Oireachtas associated with it. However, the other House will not be blamed for it because it did not have a chance to have a say in it. If there are flaws in the Bill, and it is flawed, no one can blame Members of the other House because they did not have a chance to do anything about it. We will be blamed for introducing flawed legislation.

I am saddened we are not listened to when we make points, such as those about children not being able to conduct an opinion poll in their school during a general election, and by the fact that opinion polls can be launched on the public, hours before they go to vote. If the Government believes, and other parties have a sense, that there are flaws in publishing opinion polls, perhaps we should opt for what is done in Germany where there is a voluntary code of practice in the media whereby the larger papers agree not to publish opinion polls and few of the smaller newspapers breach it. This is the type of provision which should be voluntarily rather than statutorily applied.

The Government is wrong and, as Senator Ross pointed out, it is bad legislation. I urge the Minister of State to respond to the deep concerns expressed by everyone on this side of the House. Senator Walsh also expressed deep concern about the flawed Bill. I hope the Minister of State considers withdrawing it.

Comment on this

The debate has been interesting.

Comment on this

Now it is becoming more interesting.

Comment on this

It has become more interesting as it has continued. It is possible to identify certain elements of the Bill and interpret them in what ever way one wants. I suppose that is what is involved in debating legislation.

I have certain reservations and comments to make about opinion polls. I fought an election in 1987 when Senator O'Meara's then party leader was elected by just four votes. If an opinion poll had been published the day before suggesting one candidate led another by 20%, it would have been grossly unfair because people might have thought that if one candidate was so far ahead, there was no point in voting for the other, although they wanted to. An opinion poll could have suggested one candidate was far ahead which might have made people unwilling to vote for the other candidate. The result was neck and neck. Who would have been responsible in that situation?

I have many reservations about opinion polls, although I have been involved in a number in recent months.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Senator Kiely, we are discussing amendments Nos. 55 and 58.

Comment on this

I am getting to them.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are not having a general discussion on opinion polls.

Comment on this

I do not understand the argument of the Opposition which states that an opinion poll cannot be published until one minute past midnight on polling day.

Comment on this

The legislation states that an opinion poll cannot be published in the seven days preceding polling day.

Comment on this

How can one publish an opinion poll that is seven days old?

Comment on this

TG4 did it in south Tipperary.

Comment on this

One might as well publish opinion polls taken 12 months before. If the opinion poll to be published is to be seven days old, one might as well publish one that was taken two months ago.

Comment on this

The poll in south Tipperary was ten days old.

Comment on this

It is exactly the same.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We must have an orderly debate. Senator Kiely is in possession and I ask him to confine his comments to the two amendments being discussed, namely, amendments Nos. 55 and 58.

Comment on this

Unless I read it wrongly, I am speaking to amendment No. 58 which states: ‘to delete "on any of the 7 days mentioned in subsection (3)” and substitute “on polling day“'. The Opposition has referred to the famous one minute after midnight on polling day. If any of the media print opinion polls on polling day, it will not give the public a true reflection, or is my reading of this incorrect?

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

Am I completely confused about what members of the Opposition are trying to say to me? I cannot grasp their point. If an opinion poll taken seven or 14 days earlier is published a minute after midnight on polling day, what relevance does it have? It is not an accurate poll and is unfair. It gives the opinions of seven or 14 days previously, which is unfair and unjust.

Comment on this

The Bill allows it.

Comment on this

I cannot see anyone conducting an opinion poll one minute after midnight no matter how good the modern technology. Remarks were made about exit polls in the United States but there are time differences in that country, something we do not have in Ireland – when it is midnight in Dublin, it is midnight in Kerry.

Comment on this

In fairness to the media, there has been an understanding that they do not mention or discuss an election 24 hours prior to polling day.

Comment on this

They will now.

Comment on this

This has been the understanding for a long time. I do not accept that they will deviate from the manner in which they have conducted their affairs until now. That is my opinion and I am entitled to express it in the same way other Members expressed opposing views. What is to be gained from publishing an opinion poll? Where is the spirit of democracy?

Comment on this

More sales. More newspapers will be sold.

Comment on this

The Senator has a vested interest. I do not have a vested interest in this in terms of selling papers or television or radio advertisements. As Senator Quinn will know more than anyone else because, like all advertisers, he tries to get the best value for money, 70% of the penetration in advertising is through television, and 90% of television is public broadcasting. I do not see RTÉ abusing or misusing its privilege in the national interest.

Comment on this

What about newspapers on the Internet?

Comment on this

RTE can be trusted and I will trust it. I have no difficulty doing that. Only a percentage of people have access to the Internet.

Comment on this

The number is growing.

Comment on this

Yes, but every voter does not have access to it. I would question the sincerity of the media which, in fairness, have an understanding that this does not happen 24 hours prior to elections. It would be most unfortunate, to say the least, if this were to happen. It would be shameful. I do not see this happening given the many editors and producers who have the good of the country at heart. What use is information which is eight days old? Given our experience as legislators, we know that stories which are 24 hours old are not used. If one goes to the media with a story which is 24 hours old it is considered to be "old hat".

Comment on this

If you made it into a story—

Comment on this

If one does not wish to tell the truth of the news one could make it into a story. I am not in that business, even though I was communications spokesperson for the Fianna Fáil Party for 11 years. If we are talking about people who are not interested in printing or broadcasting the truth of the news that is a different discussion which will have to be addressed.

Comment on this

Why is it not the truth?

Comment on this

I ask the Cathaoirleach for his protection because some unruly Senators are getting more unruly as the evening progresses. I gave them a break for a meal earlier which I thought would bring back a little sanity to the debate.

The Government in its wisdom proposes a ban on polls for seven days prior to elections. As Senator Ross has highlighted an issue which could cause major difficulty in regard to the legislation, perhaps we should consider the issue overnight. Perhaps we could get the considered view of the Minister of State regarding the proposal before us. We are all here in the interests of passing the best, most accurate and most workable legislation possible and Members on this side of the House wish to be part of that plan. This side of the House will have no objection if the Minister of State and his officials wish to consider overnight the proposed amendment.

Comment on this

That took a while.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Order, please. I call Senator Ormonde on amendments Nos. 55 and 58.

Comment on this

Having listened to the debate at length I am concerned that a poll could be introduced. I agree with the Leader of the House, Senator Cassidy, that should there be a doubt in this regard perhaps the matter should be considered again. Given what he has said, I believe there should be a moratorium. The media has always honoured that understanding. Regardless of the legislation, I hope that no one would comment for the last two or three days prior to an election. It would be very low-minded of the media if they produced a poll the morning of polling day.

Comment on this

It is possible.

Comment on this

It would reflect this country and the media in a very bad light if they behave in such a manner. We are all aware the influence polls can have, which has been debated here for the past hour. I welcome the fact that Senator Cassidy is prepared to review the matter if that is acceptable.

Comment on this

I am pleased the Government side has seen the light in this regard, even though there was a great deal of toing and froing, note-passing and people running in and out before a conclusion was reached. I thought the actual debate would have resulted in common sense on the issue, plus the fact that we said earlier that any Bill which goes through should be unambiguous and clear in its content. This amendment is seeking clarity on the issue because a "freeby" newspaper, for example, with a particular agenda might decide to publish something at 12 o'clock the night before an election. At long last there is some movement on the opposite side. It has been a long day and if we had this type of reception earlier I am sure the debate would be over long ago.

Comment on this

I too welcome what appears to be some light at the end of the tunnel. I suspect the Government side is anxious to come back with a way of closing a loophole which has been identified on this side of the House. Given that the Leader of the House recognises this section is full of holes, I want to point out another few holes in regard to his comments.

First, he made the case for a voluntary code of practice. He spoke about the moratorium RTE operates in the 24 hours preceding polling day. For the information of the Leader of the House, that is not just a voluntary moratorium but it is very much predicated on news values. In other words, if a story breaks in the print media, that moratorium is subject to the reporting of that story which could be related to an opinion poll.

Second, even if an opinion poll was taken seven or eight days preceding election day, the fact that it has not been published and that no one else has the material makes it not just a valid news story but a big news story, one which would be trumpeted, advertised and promoted. People would be told, "Listen to the news bulletins, we have news for you".

Third, while our native news media might engage in a voluntary code of practice, there is absolutely no reason to believe that news organisations based in Great Britain would take that view. They would look on this as an opportunity. Sky News, for instance, considers Ireland a very important part of its target audience. It has advertising which is targeted specifically at its Irish audience.

This aspect dealing with opinion polls is so flawed and so full of holes that it is simply bad legislation. I am pleased there is some dawning of the light on the opposite side, even though I suspect the overnight consideration which is being sought is simply an attempt to close the gap which has been identified.

Comment on this

Am I correct that if we adjourn now the Minister of State will respond in the morning?

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is correct.

Comment on this

That would give people a chance to consider the issue overnight.

Comment on this

I propose that we suspend further deliberations on this Bill until 2 p.m. tomorrow and that we now deal with the Second Stage of the Local Government Bill.

Comment on this

I do not agree. We should have the Minister's considered reply first so that we can consider that overnight. Let us see what the Government position is and then we can adjourn.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We have a proposal from the Leader of the House.

Comment on this

Will the Leader agree to the Minister's speaking first?

Comment on this

The Minister can speak at any time.

Comment on this

I understand that the Minister needs to consider this overnight and he will give his considered view at 2 p.m. tomorrow.

Comment on this
Brian Mullooly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

There is a proposal to the House that consideration of amendments Nos. 55 and 58 be deferred until 2 p.m. tomorrow. We are adjourning debate on all of the Bill and we will resume tomorrow at 2 p.m. on amendments Nos. 55 and 58. The Minister will give his reply and Senator Ross will then have his right of reply. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this