Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Bill 2009: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 1–186 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 44 of 2009 ›
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 23, line 39, after "specify." to insert the following:
"Any recognised religious denomination such as the Unitarian Church which celebrates the marriage of same sex couples may if the incumbent of such of their church buildings is agreeable have it regarded automatically as a proper and appropriate place for the registration of the civil partnership.".
I welcome the Minister back to the House after a late sitting last night. I am sure I speak for all of us when I say we greatly appreciate that he is taking this serious matter himself and is not delegating it to a junior Minister in his Department because that signifies the importance of the debate.
I will not spend a long time pushing amendments because we have discussed most of the substantive issues. This issue relates to freedom of religion, freedom of conscience and respect for religious identity. In the United kingdom, the Unitarian Church, in particular, has had its position recognised. The reason I tabled this amendment is that I have been lobbied by prominent members of the Unitarian Church, including Chris Hudson, who was the leading light of the peace train which ran between Dublin and Northern Ireland. He is now the pastor of the Unitarian Church in Belfast, although a Dubliner and a very prominent trade unionist. He believes, and I agree with him, that it would be appropriate for a church, such as the Unitarian Church, which performs religious marriages of same sex-couples, to conduct these marriages. The only such ceremony I attended was the marriage of a very old friend of mine to his partner in that church on St. Stephen's Green. It would seem extraordinary not to recognise the right of a church to conduct these marriages and to be regarded as an appropriate place to do so.
I say this although I believe completely in the separation of church and state. It would be far better if we had the French system where those, like myself, of a religious disposition could receive the blessing of the church in what is regarded as a sacrament but that the church kept its hands clean of officiating at what is, in fact, very largely a distribution of property and assets and the legal arrangements surrounding that.
It is inappropriate for the church to be involved in the registration process but if it happens in one church or in a series of churches, it should happen in all churches and in all circumstances where these institutions are recognised. I look forward with great interest to the Minister's response.
Comment on this
We support this amendment. We had a substantial debate last night on some of the very significant issues in the Bill and on some of the omissions from it, which we believe are important. We do not intend to duplicate any of that debate today. This amendment could be read along with amendment No. 18 which seeks to include the Humanist Association of Ireland in the Civil Registration Act.
Comment on this
Senator Norris was correct in what he said about the French system. There is much to be said for it. I have always understood the separation of church and state as being about protecting the zones of the state and the church to carry on their business and not to be interfered with. There is much to be said for the French system where there are separate ceremonies for church and state. However, I disagree with Senator Norris's characterisation of the state marriage as being largely about property and such arrangements. The state has an interest in marriage as an institution and it is very much linked with children, encouraging people to bond in lifelong unions and to found families. That is not just about property and so on. It would be wrong to think the only people interested in the common good in that sense are religious and church bodies. The state has a particular view. As an entity, it acts on behalf of the community and represents its shared vision of the importance of marriage. If there was no such thing as church marriage, although marriage originated as a church ceremony before the State put rules around it, there would be a need for the State to have a vision of marriage as being for the good of society.
On the amendment, I am inclined to think it would be better to avoid any possible misunderstanding that there is a furthering of an undue interconnection between church and State in this zone.
It is not inappropriate to refer to a particular church. We did this in the Charities Bill with regard to mass cards, when we provided that those selling them could only do so in conjunction with a recognised religious authority which was identified as a Catholic religious authority. To avoid prosecution, the onus was placed on retailers to show that they had such a connection. Such a reference can be legitimate, although during that debate I received correspondence from people who felt there were dangers for churches in bringing in the State as a regulator of what churches might or might not do. Of course, in the context of the sale of mass cards, the regulation was introduced to avoid a practice that was being abused and facilitating a fraud upon members of the public who thought they were getting a certain thing when, in fact, they were getting something very different. The common good was served by legislation intervening at that point.
I am not sure if the singling out of the Unitarian Church is best practice, from a drafting point of view. I also have concerns about the use of the word "incumbent". Who is an incumbent in this instance? Is it the person who holds tenure or has immediate responsibility for a church building or parish? If this were to be included in the legislation, could some renegade priest within the Catholic Church or the Church of Ireland claim to be the incumbent of a parish and allow the use of his or her church building for same-sex civil partnerships? Might the church then seek to exercise its prerogative to restore the status quo ante and the so-called renegade invoke this legislation in support of what he or she was doing?
While the amendment appeals to certain liberal instincts because it recognises the right of people to provide, according to their ideas and values, for the recognition of same-sex partnerships or otherwise, it is, possibly, problematic, for the reasons I have given.
Comment on this
Section 16 inserts a detailed provision relating to the registration of civil partnership in the Civil Registration Act 2004. The inserted section 59E makes provision for places and times for civil partnership registration. Subsection (1) specifies that if the place is not the office of the registrar, it must, save in limited circumstances of an exception on the grounds of ill health, be approved by the HSE by reference to matters which the Minister for Social Protection may specify.
The effect of the amendment would be to give automatic recognition as a place where civil partnership registration may take place to the churches of certain denominations which celebrate the marriages of same-sex couples. Any organisation may, if it so wishes, apply under the inserted section 59E(1) for the approval by the HSE of its venues as places for the registration of civil partnerships.
With respect to the analogous provisions for civil marriage, the Minister for Health and Children published guidelines in 2007 relating to civil marriage. These expressly provide that "the venue must have no recent or continuing connection with any religion, religious practice or religious persuasion which would be incompatible with the use of the venue for the solemnisation of civil marriages". I expect similar guidelines to be made with respect to civil partnership registration venues in order that any venue with a recent or continuing connection with a religion or denomination would be unlikely to be approved.
There is also a major difficulty with the amendment's reference to marriages of same-sex couples. Since same-sex marriage is not legally recognised in Ireland, this renders the amendment unworkable.
I would also like to add a clarification. Approval of a place, whether automatically or by the HSE, is separate and distinct from allowing a celebrant of the given denomination to carry out civil partnership registration. The Bill provides that only a registrar may register a civil partnership.
Comment on this
The Minister's response is, as usual, enlightening in its way. He says the use of the word "marriage" invalidates the entire amendment. I had a discussion earlier today with my colleague, Senator O'Toole, who pointed out to me that in amendment No. 15 the word "marriage" was used. I assume that will render that amendment invalid, if the Minister's argument is to be sustained.
With regard to renegade clergy, I am not sure if such loaded language is appropriate, but I leave it to the House to decide. I have been contacted by a bishop of the Roman Catholic Church, perhaps not one who meets with the entire approval of the established church, but let us put that to one side. He experienced extreme difficulty in having correspondence even acknowledged by the registrar at the time. As a public representative, I had to make an appointment to see the registrar and, more or less, smuggle the bishop into the meeting.
The Unitarian Church is referred to specifically in the amendment because I was so lobbied. We could parse and analyse the amendment to death. I do not expect it to be accepted and anticipated that this would be the Minister's response.
I am interested in hearing the views of those who express themselves as strong devotées of freedom of conscience, free voting and all the rest. It seems there is a conflict. It might cause difficulties if these so-called renegade priests, bishops, incumbents, rectors, vicars or pastors decided to celebrate marriages for people normally pushed firmly outside the fold. If they wished to use their premises, I would have thought that was a classic example of people voting freely, having a conscience and acting on it. Perhaps I take a more expansive view of freedom of conscience and free voting than some of my colleagues.
Comment on this
The problem is with the use of the word — the possessive adjective — "their". Is it their premises? If it was, one would have to take the view that they were entitled to act accordingly. The State, of course, would still have its view on whether it was causing more problems than it was solving. When we come to discuss freedom of conscience in the context of the provision of services, it will be clear that it is the rights of people who have ownership of and responsibility for certain premises which are at stake.
Comment on this
I think I can solve the Senator's grammatical problem. It is governed by the major clause at the beginning of the sentence; therefore, it is the property of the church.
Comment on this
I knew I would receive an informed response.
Comment on this
There would not be an issue for the church in any shape or form. Same-sex couples who are going out to celebrate a very special day would not go to a venue that is hostile to how they want to live their life. I feel we are having a debate around an issue that is never likely to arise. I could not envisage people in a same-sex union ever seeking to use a church or go to Ely Place or wherever else it is held as a sacrament to a certain person. I could not see that happen in my wildest dreams.
Comment on this
Unless the church itself, like the Unitarians, wanted it.
Comment on this
Absolutely, although that is very different. I am amused and amazed at what Senator Mullen is calling a conscience clause. I am elected to Seanad Éireann as a nominee on the Labour Panel.
Comment on this
We are. The point I want to make is that ICTU, which represents the majority of public workers in this country, is totally supportive of the Bill in its entirety.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the amendment. I will come in again on a further amendment Senator Mullen has put forward. However, we are wasting time. The people I know who want to celebrate a special day as same-sex couples would never in their wildest dreams be going to a church hall or anywhere like it.
Comment on this
The amendment is a specific one which endeavours to give an automatic recognition to a place of a particular religion. I made the point in regard to marriages and same-sex couples. As I said previously, section 59E makes clear that this is a positive request from a church to be recognised as such. I made the point earlier that if the guidelines in regard to marriage venues as per the Civil Registration Act 2004 and the regulations made thereunder by the Minister for Health and Children, and now the Minister for Social Protection, are to be replicated and the same terms as relate to marriages are to be replicated in regard to civil partnerships, then the venue must have no recent or continuing connection with any religion, religious practice or religious persuasion which would be incompatible with the use of the venue for the solemnisation of civil marriages. If they are to extend the logic and practice as per those guidelines, it would be unlikely that these churches would be approved as a venue unless it came under the very limited circumstances.
Generally in this regard, there has been some misunderstanding about churches being forced to use their property against their wishes. Section 59 clearly indicates that the only property that can be used other than the registrar's office, if an application is made to the HSE——
Comment on this
Will the Minister direct us to that section of the Bill?
Comment on this
Yes, it is at page 23. Section 59E states: "A civil partnership may be registered only at a place and time chosen by the parties to the civil partnership with the agreement of the registrar and, if the place chosen is not the office of a registrar [the other place] shall be determined by the Executive by reference to the matters that the Minister may specify." I have excluded one of the limited exceptions in reading out that section. In other words, this has to happen on application by the organisation, whether it is a church or otherwise, to have its premises used. Therefore, there is no forcing of any church to have its property used against its wishes.
Comment on this
Similarly, there have been suggestions that celebrants of marriages under religion would be forced to be part of the civil registration process.
Comment on this
No celebrant empowered to conduct a marriage ceremony existing under the Civil Registration Act may register a civil partnership unless he or she is a registrar in the employment of the HSE. There is absolutely no possibility that any celebrant who is not a registrar could be required against his or her wishes to register a civil partnership. I can put it no clearer than that.
Comment on this
I want to make a final comment. I believe the Minister is slightly over-simplifying certain matters but I will leave that aside. Why would it be incompatible and what would the nature of the incompatibility be? If the congregation, the officiating priest and the parties to the marriage were all in agreement, in what sense could it be incompatible? Is there something about the nature of a church, the Unitarian Church in particular or the fact this man was willing in conscience to celebrate the union that makes it incompatible? I see no incompatibility whatever — I just do not understand it.
As I understand it and although I think it regrettable, in a religious service of marriage the partners, having been married, usually retire to the vestry to sign the register, and that is part of the legal confirmation of the existence of the marriage. Therefore, it does exist in that sense and the church, as the building, is held to be perfectly compatible. I do not see any reason that, for example, a Unitarian minister in the St. Stephen's Green church should not apply to be regarded as a registrar for this purpose. The Minister is indicating this would not be granted. I believe that if this did happen, the Unitarian Church would probably take the matter to court. I would certainly support it in this and I believe many people of right mind, as I would say, would also support it, including some quite surprising people.
Comment on this
What Senator Feeney had to say was very interesting. It is an argument I have heard before. It is probably an argument——
Comment on this
We are not discussing what Senator Feeney said. We are dealing with amendment No. 14.
Comment on this
We are not discussing the next amendment. The Senator should speak on amendment No. 14.
Comment on this
I seek clarification from the Minister. He has just said, and also said yesterday, that there would be no circumstances in which a church premises would be required by law to conduct a civil partnership ceremony, nor would any religious official. As one who has been thinking closely about this issue and has tabled certain amendments, I would never have made that claim or expressed that concern. Strangely, I do not know of anyone else who has. It would be very useful if the Minister could indicate the sources of the particular claim that the legislation might act in this way. I am sure there are such sources and it would be no harm if they were put on the record. Who exactly has been claiming that for the purposes of a civil partnership registration ceremony, in particular, sacred spaces, so to speak, might be required to be used? I would be interested to know who has been making that claim; it was certainly not myself.
Comment on this
The Senator could read the newspapers or the debates of the House.
Comment on this
We have had written representations from various people in this regard.
Comment on this
Will the Minister put some of those on record? I do not believe they represent any official bodies. Would that be fair to say?
Comment on this
They are letters to the Department, as they always would be. If anyone wants to receive them, they can get them under the FOI Act.
With regard to Senator Norris's point, the change in regard to the venues for registration of civil marriages was done a number of years ago and it was opened up to allow other premises to be used. Those regulations were framed in such a way that there would be a certain aura around the ceremony of civil marriage so that it would not be in the centre circle of a football stadium, for example. It would be on reasonably honourable premises fit for the celebration of a marriage.
If we pass this legislation, civil partnership registrations will become part of this process and the legislation states it must be in the office of the registrar, unless it is under the suggested exception of a place approved by the HSE. It is then up to the HSE to determine what is a suitable venue. It is not my area of responsibility and I will not have to make a decision on it. I expect the executive to replicate the guidelines for civil marriages in the case of civil partnerships, where it is indicated there should be no recent or continuing connection with any religion or religious practice. There may be a different view on the issue. I expect anybody who queries the matter will have the right to appeal the decision to a higher authority.
Comment on this
To answer a question I see forming on the lips of the Leas-Chathaoirleach, I will not be pressing the amendment. I will comment on the idea of the sacred aura surrounding these various places. One always respects the choices of individuals and I may have been misled by newspaper reports but I clearly recall reading that civil marriages have been performed in public houses and fields.
Comment on this
They have been performed on top of Croagh Patrick.
Comment on this
Yes. On one occasion a ceremony took place in a fairy fort in the south of the country. The interpretation is pretty wide and it would be rather a pity if it did not include a willing church that wished to be included. I expect that they will apply. I note the Minister's urbane response to the matter and I will not push the amendment because it is silly to push these amendments to a vote when I already know what will be the outcome.
Comment on this
Senator Norris has opened up an interesting point, although it may be peripheral to the amendment. If same-sex partners want a religious ceremony, I do not see why they should not have it. We have indicated it is a matter for each church. I agree with Senator Norris in making the point on the registration of a ceremony that if it were possible to include somebody in a church who wanted to be part of a ceremony, it could be registered on the day. We should have had more debate on this, although it may be peripheral to the amendment. There is a bigger and broader issue to be considered.
It is wrong to assume people who are entering a gay partnership would not want to go to a church hall. The only issue involved is that it should be a matter for the owners of the hall. I am certain there are some churches and religious bodies who would want to accommodate that particular type of ceremony. It would be wrong to assume that once the legislation is enacted, some people would not want to go down that road. It is a big assumption on our part.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 29, lines 6 to 12, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:
"(b) by inserting the following subsections after subsection (9):
"(9A) A registrar who, without reasonable cause, fails or refuses to give a civil partnership registration form to one of the parties to an intended civil partnership in respect of which he or she has received a notification under section 59B(1)(a), or a copy of an exemption order under section 59B(2), commits an offence.
(9B) For the purpose of subsections (4), (9), (9A) and (9C) of this section, a registrar shall be deemed to have reasonable cause where—
(a) The registrar’s refusal or failure to act is based on a conscientious objection to the registration of the marriage or civil partnership grounded in a sincerely held religious or ethical belief, and
(b) The objection is not based on any of the discriminatory grounds identified in section 3, subsection (2), paragraphs (a), (c), (e), (f), (g), (h), (i) of the Equal Status Act, 2000, and
(c) The registrar has given notice in writing to his or her Superintendent Registrar of the said objection and its grounds within one week of appointment as registrar or at least 1 month prior to any refusal or failure to act in reliance on the said objection;
Unless the Superintendent Registrar, having taken all reasonable steps in the management, control and administration of the Civil Registration Service to ensure that the registrar's objection is respected and accommodated, concludes that it is necessary in all the circumstances of a given case for the registrar to register a marriage or civil partnership or give a marriage or civil partnership registration form to one of the parties to an intended marriage or civil partnership in order to avoid undue delay in the provision of the said registration services.
(9C) A registrar who, with reasonable cause, fails or refuses to register a marriage or civil partnership or to give a marriage or civil partnership registration form shall not be taken to discriminate against a person for the purposes of the Equal Status Act 2000.".".
We come to an issue that is of major concern to many people of goodwill. This is one of three amendments which I have proposed, the purpose of which is to protect freedom of conscience in various issues. This amendment concerns the role of a civil registrar. The law currently provides that a registrar who, without reasonable cause, fails or refuses to provide a marriage registration form or conduct a civil marriage commits an offence. We are aware that in Northern Ireland a person who would commit such an offence might lose their job but in this jurisdiction, under the law as it stands, people are subject to the full rigours of the law and prosecution.
Following on from that logic, this legislation seeks to amend the Civil Registration Act 2004 by providing for similar outcomes for a registrar who, without reasonable cause, fails or refuses to give a civil partnership registration form to one of the parties to an intended civil partnership in respect of which he or she has received a notification under section 59B(1)(a) or a copy of an exemption order under section 59B(2). In such cases, that person commits an offence.
I am starting from the perspective that there is a balance of rights to be struck in this case. The State has the right to implement a model of civil partnership if that is the will of the majority in the Oireachtas, and at the behest of the Government such a model of civil partnership is created and goes through the Oireachtas. I disagree with substantial parts of this legislation, which perpetuates new forms of injustice and discrimination. Even if I am wrong in that, as a democrat I am quite happy to accept the decision of the Oireachtas as to what our laws on marriage, family and same-sex partnership will be, subject to the Constitution.
A completely separate issue arises because in accepting the majority decision on this — at least the majority of the Oireachtas — a separate question arises for people who in good conscience and not just for religious reasons have difficulties with civil partnership for same-sex couples. There are people who have a profound religious objection to public State recognition of same-sex partnerships, and this does not make them homophobic, as has been claimed in some quarters. In many cases they are people with no problem with people's right to a private life and who would have supported the decriminalisation of homosexual acts between men in 1993.
Such people may subscribe to a different moral view and would not like to be implicated in any way in the facilitation of a contrary moral position repugnant to their own. The question is whether the State has a duty or right to impose this view. I will confine my comments to the position of a State official as separate arguments will be made on the discrete amendments proposed regarding religious or community institutions with a different ethos, or individuals involved in the provision of services. Does the State have the right to oblige such an official to do his or her job in all circumstances, regardless of how repugnant to his or her conscience carrying out his or her job might prove to be? If this matter was the subject of an opinion poll — the trouble with such polls is that the outcome always depends on how one frames the question — most people would agree that there were circumstances in which provision should be made for individual conscience, even in the case of those employed by the State. In the context of the fraught issue of abortion, it would be interesting to examine the laws that obtain in other countries in order to consider whether and how people in the employ of the State might be facilitated in some way in circumstances where they were asked to do something that ran contrary to their own deep personal sense of right and wrong, justice, what constituted good conduct, etc. It is important to bear this in mind.
Much of the debate in the past 24 to 36 hours has tended to denigrate the expression of conscience. I was particularly disappointed by the comments made by Senator Harris who seems to be of the opinion that conscientious objection emanates from some form of twisted religious tradition, according to which people do not think for themselves, hold no moral views of their own, are infantilised by a greater religious authority that tells them what to think and do and are not, in their own right, moral agents who possess a well thought out approach to life.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to confine his comments to the amendment. We have a long list of speakers and many other amendments with which we must deal. I ask all Members to be brief and concise in their contributions in order that we might have a to and fro debate during which we can deal with the substance of the matter. I ask the Senator for his co-operation.
Comment on this
I will return to the issue of the balance that must be struck. The reason I asked the Minister about who had been claiming that religious officials or premises might be required under this legislation for the carrying out of civil partnership ceremonies was that I had not heard that argument being made by any creditable or reputable sources. As far as I am aware, none of the official church bodies which have commented on this matter raised this issue, although I am open to correction in that regard. However, if they did raise it, the comments gained little traction in the public debate. Just as last evening the Minister asked me to clarify my intentions, I have been asking him to clarify for the avoidance of doubt that he is not choosing to answer questions he has not been asked to avoid replying to those questions which have been posed.
Comment on this
As stated, the issue that arises relates to the balance which must be struck between the State's right to get the job done in the context of implementing a model of civil partnership and the need to recognise that people may sometimes have a conscientious objection in respect of the matter under discussion. The manner in which I have approached this has been to take the existing legislation which makes provision for registrars who, without reasonable cause, fail in certain ways. It is this failure which provides the circumstances in which a registrar may commit an offence. In amendment No. 15 I provide a definition of what constitutes reasonable cause.
In reply to any possible objections from the Minister or others to the effect that there is already in place legislation which caters for the civil registration of marriages and provides that it is an offence for a civil registrar to fail to comply, I am defining reasonable cause in such a way that it may apply not only to a person who has a conscientious objection in the context of a civil partnership but also to those who may harbour such objections in general as a result of their particular beliefs about marriage and its importance to society. The reason I have framed the amendment in this way is it is important to stress that it is not just for religious reasons, per se, that many have strong feelings about the importance of marriage to society and, therefore, concerns about facilitating marriages, in the context of divorce, or relationships, in the context of civil partnership.
It is in the context of a person's intellectually arrived at sense of the common good in many cases that he or she might harbour a conscientious objection. I am reserving my position on whether I would harbour such an objection in that situation. It does not necessarily follow that because a person might be a practising Catholic, Muslim or member of the Church of Ireland he or she would have a problem, per se, with the provisions of the legislation. It is the job of the House to legislate prospectively. Senator Feeney stated gay couples would not want to visit Ely Place and the Minister has stated no representations have been made to him to date by any of the bodies representing public officials.
Comment on this
The building in Ely Place to which Senator Feeney referred is a very fine house. It belonged to my great grandfather's cousin.
Comment on this
I hope Senator Norris is not obliged to pay an admission fee when he visits it. The least those who are responsible for it could do is recognise the Senator's noble antecedents.
Comment on this
Our job is to legislate prospectively for what might happen in the future. It is also our job to legislate for the tiny minority who might not dare to express their views to either their trade unions or representative bodies or who might have a difficulty in expressing these views in the light of the overwhelming media consensus on this issue.
What is interesting about liberalism and facilitating freedom of conscience is that, in some ways, the smaller the group involved the greater the care that we must take not to trample on individuals who might possess an alternative point of view.
Comment on this
As exemplified, perhaps, by the Iona Institute.
Comment on this
I would answer that heckle if there was any quality to it.
Comment on this
The Senator should not seek to answer it. We are engaging in a debate on the amendment.
Comment on this
However, as there was no quality to it, I will not be distracted.
Comment on this
The Senator has made the point about a person's objections not necessarily being based on religious grounds on two occasions.
Comment on this
I am glad the Acting Chairman has been listening to my contribution.
Comment on this
I have indulged the Senator who is entitled to make his comments, but he is trying my patience to a degree.
Comment on this
However, in the best tradition of the barrister before the court, I will not be diverted from setting out, fully and properly, the background to and context of the amendment——
Comment on this
——even if it takes a good while longer for me to do so. The Acting Chairman has been warned. There is important material with which we must deal.
Comment on this
Brevity is a recipe for legislation that is not well thought out.
Comment on this
It is sometimes necessary to go into the detail.
Comment on this
I cannot argue against the need to be concise.
The issue relates to the balance which needs to be struck. The amendment proposes to strike that balance by defining what should constitute reasonable cause. The first requirement is that the refusal or failure to act should be based on a conscientious objection to the registration of the marriage or civil partnership and that such an objection must be grounded in a sincerely held religious or ethical belief. That is the first test they must satisfy.
The second test a registrar must satisfy is that his or her objection cannot be based on any of a range of discriminatory grounds provided for in the Equal Status Act. These grounds include discriminating on grounds of race or membership of the Traveller community. A registrar can harbour a conscientious objection based on grounds relating to marital status or sexual orientation because there are legitimate and fundamental differences between people's viewpoints on these issues. If ours is to be a genuinely pluralist society, we must take account of this fact. The third hurdle the conscientious objector will have to meet is that he or she will have to give "notice in writing to his or her Superintendent Registrar of the said objection and its grounds within one week of [his or her] appointment as registrar or at least 1 month prior to any refusal or failure to act in reliance on the said objection". In addition, such a person cannot avail of the conscientious objection "Unless the Superintendent Registrar, having taken all reasonable steps ... to ensure that the registrar's objection is respected and accommodated, concludes" it is not necessary "in all the circumstances of a given case for the registrar" to carry out the job anyway. In other words, the objector will not be facilitated if that would lead to "undue delay in the provision of the said registration services".
The last part of amendment No. 15 ensures not only that an objector will not be reached by the criminal law under the 2004 Act but also that a person in such circumstances, having been facilitated by the superintendent registrar, will not be reached by the provisions of the Equal Status Act 2000 either. This part of the amendment has been included for the sake of completeness.
This amendment proposes to put in place a set of hurdles. This provision will be confined to circumstances in which the person can be facilitated without causing undue delay, in which the person has flagged his or her objection in due time, in which the objection is based on "a sincerely held religious or ethical belief", and in which that position is not based on any of a range of prohibited grounds of discrimination.
It is important that we make this change. Yesterday, Senator Dan Boyle pooh-poohed the concept of conscience. At the core of this proposal is an understanding of the value to any civilised society of respect for conscience. Senator Boyle quoted from "Hamlet" the line "Thus conscience does make cowards of us all." It has been a long time since I heard in this House a quote so taken out of context. It is taken from Hamlet's soliloquy in which he contemplates taking his own life.
Comment on this
Really. One would never have guessed.
Comment on this
It is the same soliloquy in which Hamlet says: "To sleep, perchance to dream."
Comment on this
It continues:
Ay, there's the rub,
For in that sleep of death what dreams may come,
When we have shuffled off this mortal coil.
Comment on this
It continues:
And makes us rather bear those ills we have
Than fly to others that we know not of.
Comment on this
I would love to give the Chair some reassurance on that point. It is in the context of that soliloquy that Hamlet says, "Conscience does make cowards of us all." Shakespeare is suggesting that our awareness of the consequences of what we do is what makes "cowards of us all". We become cowards when we realise what the possible outcomes of what we do may be. That is why Senator Boyle's quotation is highly relevant, albeit unintentionally. If we, as a Legislature, fail to make proper provision for people of conscience, who may no longer have the majority view in our society——
Comment on this
On a point of order, it is a convention of the House that Members speak through the Chair.
Comment on this
My back muscles were temporarily out of kilter.
Comment on this
It is for people who have a different moral position to assess, in their own hearts and minds, where their truth is. That is why Senator Boyle's quotation was a most unhelpful one. It was also unhelpful of Senator McDonald to say yesterday that a conscience opt-out would be a form of "bigotry".
Comment on this
I said it would be "dressed up bigotry".
Comment on this
It is not an amendment; it is a clarification.
Comment on this
I have said I will accept her amendment.
Comment on this
It does not improve the situation one iota.
Comment on this
I am not amending what I said; I am reminding the Senator that the term I used was "dressed up bigotry".
Comment on this
I accept the Senator's correction.
Comment on this
It stuck in my mind in the context of this debate.
Comment on this
It does not improve her position one iota.
Comment on this
I assure Senator O'Toole I am happy with my position.
Comment on this
Senator Mullen has laid out his amendment. Perhaps it is time to open out the debate.
Comment on this
Senator McDonald said that such a provision would be a form of "dressed up bigotry". At the same time she claimed, without any sense of irony or contradiction that "tolerance is about [allowing others] to make choices" with which one might not agree. There has been a lack of refined thinking in this forum about the meaning of conscience and its precise limitations. The Chair will be delighted to hear I am withholding my response to Senator Harris's regrettable comments until the debate on a later amendment. Instead, I will put on the record the contents of a letter I received from two people who——
Comment on this
The Senator has been speaking for 20 minutes. No one else has been able to make a contribution.
Comment on this
I assure the Chair that this is relevant.
Comment on this
The letter in question, which was written by Mr. Patrick Ryan and Mr. David Nelson, states: "We respectfully request that before passing this bill you consider a number of possibly unintended consequences, and accept amendments being proposed to rectify them".
Comment on this
On a point of order, it is a tradition in this House — it may be one of the rules of the House — that people outside the House should not be named because they are not in a position to defend themselves. The Senator has done this most unscrupulously. I would like to know whether he has permission to name these people and to quote from their letter. Even if he has such permission, it is outside the tradition of this House and the rulings of the Chair for people to be named in this fashion.
Comment on this
It is as if butter would not melt in the Senator's mouth. Has he ever broken that rule?
Comment on this
Only with the greatest of refinement.
Comment on this
I would be grateful if their names were removed from the record. However, I propose to put on the record the contents of their letter, in which their concerns are expressed. That is what I am paid to do as a legislator. The letter continues:
The right of conscientious objection is a matter for each individual in a matter which he considers serious enough to exercise his conscience. An example is a conscientious objection to the killing of animals in blood sports but not to their killing in abattoirs, without any inconsistency to his general moral position. The Minister's contention that a registrar might use such a conscientious objection clause to discriminate on the basis of colour, fat or thin, young or old is insulting to a registrar's sense of moral proportion. This attitude would trivialise same sex unions and regard them as matters of little moral concern.
Comment on this
I am going to ask the Senator to pause there. This letter is not relevant. He can quote letters from five other people who have corresponded with him
Comment on this
Excuse me, a Chathaoirligh Ghníomhach. It is relevant.
Comment on this
The Chair should listen to the next paragraph of the letter.
Comment on this
It states:
With regard to the punishment proposed to registrars [How is that not relevant?] for refusing in conscience to carry out same sex unions we consider this to be totally against the right of conscience particularly as same sex unions involve not trivial considerations of conscience but a very serious one.
I think that is relevant. The letter continues:
A specific provision could be included in the bill supporting the right of conscience objection on the part of registrars specifically and only in respect of same sex unions. We would also like to protect the rights of religious organisations.
I will hold off on that because it is not relevant. I have read the relevant part of the letter. I would like to mention something else that is relevant. The Preamble to the UN Declaration of Human Rights states:
Whereas disregard and contempt for human rights have resulted in barbarous acts which have outraged the conscience of mankind, and the advent of a world in which human beings shall enjoy freedom of speech and belief and freedom from fear and want has been proclaimed as the highest aspiration of the common people.
Article 1 of the declaration states:
All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.
Article 18 states:
Everyone has the right——
Comment on this
On a point of order, how is this relevant to amendment No. 15? The Senator has quoted extensively——
Comment on this
It is making a mockery of the House.
Comment on this
Many other Members wish to speak concisely on this amendment.
Comment on this
Many of us on both sides of the House feel strongly about this amendment.
Comment on this
If we are to be fair, we should give others a chance to speak on it. Senator Mullen is filibustering now.
Comment on this
Just a moment, please. The Chair is speaking. Senator Mullen has spoken for in excess of 23 minutes. This is a debating forum. I have consistently asked him to try to be concise in his contributions. He rightly said that as there is no time limit on Committee Stage, I cannot curtail his speaking time. I am asking him to have consideration for the other Members of this House, who are equally important as legislators as he is.
Comment on this
——to show consideration to people who might be put in prison as a result of this iniquitous provision.
Comment on this
The Senator should respect the Chair.
Comment on this
It is not necessarily in order for the Senator to quote from four or five letters from ten or 20 people. That gives those people direct access to the debate in this Chamber.
Comment on this
There are people elected to this Chamber who have higher authority to be here. I ask the Senator to have consideration.
Comment on this
That is a very dangerous and elitist position to adopt, on which I ask the Acting Chairman to reflect. It does not reflect the spirit of this institution that Members in this Chamber somehow have higher privilege than those they represent.
Comment on this
If Senator Mullen does not understand that, he should resign and give back——
Comment on this
People elected to this Chamber have a right of audience.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I would like the Acting Chairman to help us in this regard because it is evident the debate will continue for some hours and the issue she mentions will impact on the remainder of the debate. As I understand it, Senator Mullen's main point relates to conscience. Everything I have heard from him so far is related; in fairness, he is doing the House a service by providing us with the information.
Comment on this
If I am wrong about this, the Acting Chairman might tell me because it will impact on the remainder of the debate.
Comment on this
One could speak all day on the issue of conscience. Senator Mullen may talk and, as Senator Bacik said, he may filibuster, if he so chooses——
Comment on this
What is more, I resent the fact that the Acting Chairman is taking the side of Senator Bacik by going to the heart of my motivation——
Comment on this
——and accusing me of filibustering. In my honest——
Comment on this
Senator Mullen has no respect for the Chair.
Comment on this
I have every respect for the Chair. I just wish it was——
Comment on this
This is a debating chamber. Senator Mullen, you finally went through the amendment, which is what a Member is asked to do. I now ask you to desist, out of consideration for other Members. This is not the only opportunity you will have to speak on the amendment. It is in the interests of everybody that the opinions of others are heard also. Our responsibility is to allow debate, which means we should hear more than one voice. I ask you to wrap up and give the next speaker, Senator Doherty, an opportunity to make his contribution.
Comment on this
I am sorry. What the Acting Chairman said would make sense if there was a time limit. I am prepared to hear in full everybody's opinion. What is at issue is the willingness of the Acting Chairman and certain other Members to hear in full my opinions. This is a serious issue. We are talking about people going to jail. Let us not be so mindless as to pretend that we can dispose of these issues neatly——
Comment on this
We need to bring everything else into the debate. We can speak on the subject concisely.
Comment on this
——to allow politicians to return home to their constituencies by 5 p.m.
Comment on this
However, that is not my concern. Senators can take a coffee break if they wish and read the blacks later, but I will state what is important and I am not——
Comment on this
I find this extraordinarily patronising and insulting. It is not appropriate to the House.
Comment on this
Senator Mullen, you are being a bully in this Chamber.
Comment on this
This is all about a majority oppressing a minority. How appropriate.
Comment on this
You said on RTE that you would delay proceedings and that is exactly what you are doing.
Comment on this
Parties which would not even allow their members a free vote are now seeking to gang up on one Member
Comment on this
——who has a mandate to go to the heart of the issue.
Comment on this
What my party does with its members is of no relevance to you, a non-party Member.
Comment on this
Whether Senator Feeney likes it, I am sticking by Standing Orders. As I said, Article 18 correctly provides that everybody has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion. This includes freedom to change religion and belief, either alone or in community with others, and, in public and private, to manifest his or her religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance. In other words, a person does not only exercise conscience in the buildings of whatever religious organisation he or she happens to be a member; he or she may wish to exercise it without being a member of any religious tradition. Conscience is——