Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Bill 2009: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 187–370 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 44 of 2009 ›
Conscience is about standing up for what one believes in. The Chair will be glad to hear that I will conclude shortly, but before I do I will mention why it is so necessary for us to discuss this issue in detail. The reason is that there have been problems in other jurisdictions. I will not mention New Jersey, but in the United Kingdom, for example, Catholic adoption agencies have been forced to close because they would not accept same-sex couples as prospective adoptive parents. The diocese of San Francisco was forced to alter its pension scheme to recognise the partners of employees.
There is another problem in that the Minister has sought to claim there would be many undesirable and unintended consequences if one were to make the slightest provision for the conscience of a State official. I have been critical of him because he has not been willing to meet critics of the Bill outside this forum. We could have ironed out this problem by showing just how possible it was to write narrow amendments that would not give comfort to bigots, wife-beaters and so on. For example, the Minister stated a court clerk might refuse to issue divorce orders because of a religious belief. He said a fundamentalist Christian garda might refuse to arrest a person who had breached a safety order on the basis that a husband was entitled to chastise his wife. He said a judge might refuse to register a power of attorney in favour of a person's civil partner. In his most Islamophobic moment he said a Muslim — or a Mormon — accident and emergency doctor might refuse to treat a person for alcohol poisoning. He said a social welfare official might refuse to pay carer's allowance to a person's civil partner and that a probate officer might refuse to issue a grant of administration to a deceased person's civil partner. Of course, these are the lines people wrote for the Minister, the convenient rhetorical points which take no account of legal possibilities to arrive at something much more nuanced.
Comment on this
Senator Mullen, in accordance with Standing Order 48, your contribution has concluded. I call the next speaker, Senator Doherty.
Comment on this
I am sorry. Will the Chair please quote the relevant Standing Order to me?
Comment on this
Standing Order 48 states a Senator who persists in irrelevance or repetition in a debate, or who, in the opinion of the Cathaoirleach, is speaking for the purpose of obstructing business, may be directed by the Cathaoirleach to discontinue his speech after the attention of the Seanad and-or the committee has been called to his conduct.
Comment on this
Excuse me. On a point of order, is the Chair ruling that what I have just said is somehow irrelevant?
Comment on this
No. What I am bringing to your attention is the fact that you have spoken for in excess of 32 minutes, during which I repeatedly asked you to stop repeating yourself and moving away from the point of the amendment to irrelevancies.
Comment on this
Now that I am on a relevant point——
Comment on this
On a further point of order, will the Chair allow me to speak further on the amendment?
Comment on this
On that basis, I will resume my seat.
Comment on this
I have no problem with Senator Mullen speaking on the amendment for the rest of the day, regardless of how difficult it is to listen to the words coming from his mouth. The amendment goes to the heart of the legislation. The Senator acted the same way yesterday and will continue in the same way today, with support from others, nitpicking and turning the legislation on its head.
Yesterday I stated my party and I supported the Bill because of our commitment to equality. The Bill does not go far enough, but if this amendment were to be accepted, the incremental advances we have achieved in the legislation would be rolled back. We are being asked to carve out an exception for those civil registrars who do not believe in the principle of non-discrimination so far as gays and lesbians are concerned. This would defeat the entire purpose of anti-discrimination laws. The amendment is worded in such a way as to avoid a precedent being set. It would not allow those who have not come to terms with the increasing diversity of Irish society to refuse to serve mixed race couples. Clearly, this is being done for the sake of expediency because there is no logic to the argument that one form of conscientious objection is wrong and another is not, nor is it the case, as Senator Mullen has argued, that there is universal agreement on the issue. Let us not forget that only last year a judge in the state of Louisiana refused to marry an inter-racial couple. No doubt there are still those who believe that Protestants and Catholics should not marry. There are many in the Six Counties who particularly hold that view.
Comment on this
With respect to Senator Mullen, I said I would have no problem listening to him speak on this amendment for the rest of day and I did not interrupt him. It is a reality that people still hold a strong view based on the religious beliefs that Protestants and Catholics should not marry. Many of those who hold that view are in the Six Counties. I ask Members to imagine the reaction of Senator Ó Murchú or Senator Walsh if registrars in the Six Counties were given the right to refuse to carry out ceremonies in such cases. We would lambaste that type of discrimination and it is right that we would do so, but that type of discrimination and what is being proposed here are two sides of the same coin.
The amendment's proposers have evoked the Constitution's guarantees of freedoms — freedom of conscience and free exercise of religion, but the Bill as proposed would do nothing to limit those freedoms. They are, a letter in today's edition of The Irish Times notes, freedoms granted to the citizen. A civil registrar acting in the course of his or her duties is acting on behalf of the State. Registrars remain free to discriminate, if they must, in their personal lives but nothing in the Constitution entitles them to subject a person who comes to them, seeking a service of this State, to differential treatment based on their own personal morality. As the amendment would undermine the limited degree of equality provided by this Bill, my party and I will oppose it.
Senator Mullen mentioned a list of issues which the Minister gave as examples if we were to apply the conscientious clause across the board. I agree with the Minister in this regard. I will examine how this would apply if we were to expand it to members of the gardaí without talking account of workers in the health service, Muslims or mixed race marriages. I will give the example of a member of the gardaí who was to investigate abuse in a gay relationship and who refused to investigate it because of his or her principled stance on this issue.
Comment on this
It is ridiculous that members of the gardaí who are employed by the State can discriminate in this way. The proposed amendment is disgusting——
Comment on this
——and it should be rejected outright by this House.
Comment on this
Senator Doherty has put the matter extremely well. He has gone right to the heart of the matter. A registrar acts on behalf of the State, on behalf of the people, and he or she must implement the law. Once the law is passed, that must happen.
Senator Mullen made me feel young again. I thought I was in a kindergarten being instructed laboriously by an inexperienced teacher. I found his analysis of Shakespeare wrong-headed but intriguing. I would have referred rather to Dickens. Uriah Heep comes to my mind immediately.
Comment on this
The Senator is not very humble, that is for sure.
Comment on this
Moving on to the principal points I wish to make, I endorse 100% what Senator Doherty said with great dignity and, unlike myself, never having interrupted, although he was churlishly interrupted.
As I understand it, no single registrar in this State has made any formal objection to this legislation. Therefore, Senator Mullen, having colonised my feelings and having interpreted Shakespeare's mind, now represents the registrars as well. There seems to be a slight touch of megalomania.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the amendment. I am talking about the fact that no registrar and no trade union has raised this matter. Therefore, it seems to be unrealistic.
I agree with the Senator on one point. It would not be at all appropriate for a registrar in these circumstances to go to jail. There are a large number of matters on which it is inappropriate for people to go to jail. I deplore the building of extra jails and I believe the number of them should be reduced. I submitted a proposal to the effect that it is idiotic to put women — or anyone for that matter, but I was thinking of the case of a person who did not pay a television licence — in jail and the taxpayer then had to pay——
Comment on this
I want to make this point, and I am coming to it, but I accept the Acting Chairman's ruling, of course.
Comment on this
I do not mind if it is not relevant. I am enjoying the Senator.
Comment on this
It would be wrong to penalise the taxpayer by having to pay for the jailing of a registrar, if this were true, who did not abide by this legislation. If a registrar refuses to do this by his or her stated intention of refusing to implement the law, he or she has automatically ruled himself or herself out.
Another point is that the Senator used a nasty way to make a smear, and I did not like it. I do not at all find it appropriate that the celebration of either a marriage or a civil union should be compared, as Senator Mullen has done, to an abortion. I respectfully ask him to withdraw that phrase immediately from the record of the House.
The tests that he gave were sincerity of belief. I have no idea how Senator Mullen or anyone charged with operating these tests would know whether someone's belief is sincerely held. It seems to be an absurd and hypothetical matter.
Senator Mullen and his colleague, and they include, sadly, another Member of the Independent benches who poses as having great concern for the——
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to speak to the amendment. He does not need to comment on what people are doing.
Comment on this
No, I am making a very clear point and then I will sit down.
Comment on this
The very same people insisted on the inclusion in equality legislation of an exemption for the churches so that teachers could potentially be fired. There is no difficulty with the firing of teachers simply because they are gay, but, on the other hand, we cannot ensure a registrar fulfils the job for which he or she was paid.
Can the Acting Chairman tell me how many minutes I spoke and how many minutes Senator Mullen spoke?
Comment on this
Thank you. There is a time limit for this debate. Every time we exceed our time allocation, we take time from other Members.
Comment on this
The debate is to conclude by 5.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I can assure the Acting Chairman that I will be taking fewer than five minutes.
Comment on this
I will. I do not mean to get on the right side of the Acting Chairman——
Comment on this
I compliment the Acting Chairman on the wonderful way she is chairing the debate. She has been very fair and very firm-handed, on which I compliment her.
Comment on this
I would like, as Senator Norris has done, to highlight the importance of the fact that no trade union has sought an opt-out clause. If trade unions are not seeking an opt-out clause and they represent the majority of public sector workers, we should not be even talking about an opt-out clause. The Acting Chairman was not in the Chair at the time but I got confused as to what amendment I was speaking to a few minutes ago and I thought I was speaking to this amendment when I explained I am a nominee of the labour panel, as is Senator Hanafin. We are well aware of the workings of the trade unions——
Comment on this
The Senator seems to be in danger of being repetitive. I have no objection.
Comment on this
——and the respect trade unions attach to the area of equality. I will go further and say I am well aware because I have been contacted by members of trade unions who have asked me to speak on this amendment and to say that if they wanted an opt-out clause, they would have gone through the proper channels and lobbied the Minister for appropriate amendments. They have not done do. I repeat they represent the majority of public sector workers in this country.
The opt-out clause is not emanating from workers, rather it is emanating from a small minority of Independent Senators in this Chamber. I heard Independent Senator Mullen on "Today with Pat Kenny" a number of mornings ago. When Pat Kenny put it to him that he could do nothing to bring down the Bill he agreed, but he threw in a lovely remark with a laugh in his tone when he said, "But we can delay it". I am sad to be part——
Comment on this
On a point of order, Senator Feeney is completely misrepresenting what I said on that programme. I was explaining the position of the Seanad which is that the most we can do is delay legislation.
Comment on this
That is not a point of order. Senator Feeney, resume your contribution. Senator Mullen, sit down.
Comment on this
I meant a point of clarification. I got my terminology wrong.
Comment on this
We had such wonderful Second Stage speeches here yesterday and everybody got an opportunity to say what they said. Not one person supporting this Bill did not recognise the hard work and craftsmanship which went into bringing the Bill to its current form. Everybody said what an important Bill it was. It saddens me that we are now being almost preached and dictated to by people who feel——
Comment on this
——-that they have a higher moral ground than anybody else. The majority of Senators support the Bill. As we saw from the votes yesterday there were 46 or 48 votes to five.
Comment on this
It is hard not to conclude that this amendment, tabled by Senator Mullen and other Independent Senators, is being used as pretext——
Comment on this
There are Government Senators, not Independent Senators.
Comment on this
——for opposition to the entire Bill.
Comment on this
They are mainly Independent Senators.
Comment on this
They are mainly Fianna Fáil Senators.
Comment on this
They are Independent. They are no longer under the Fianna Fáil Whip.
Comment on this
The current equality legislation, which we have spoken about often enough in this House, I am glad to say has stood the test of time. There is no evidence to say that a pub, bar or hotel has been disadvantaged in any way by treating all its customers with the same level of respect and dignity. I ask the Senators who have opposing views to the majority of Senators to bear that respect in mind and exercise a little of it.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Doherty. It is helpful that Senator Mullen spoke at length to this amendment because I found the more he spoke and grasped different arguments and straws to support his argument it so obviously became threadbare. It is hard to know what is the purpose of the exercise. I am trying to examine the basis of why he and other Senators tabled this amendment. It boils down to a hostility towards gay people.
Comment on this
That is outrageous. On a point of order, I ask the Senator to withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
I ask the Acting Chairman to take advice from——
Comment on this
Senator, I am tired of shouting over you. When I am speaking I ask you to allow me to be heard. That is not a point of order.
Comment on this
I do not think you did because I am sick of being interrupted by you. A point of order relates to procedure. The Senator in possession has merely offered an opinion. I ask the Senator to please be seated. I ask the Senator in possession to resume his contribution.
Comment on this
May I ask for a clarification on whether it is appropriate for one of my colleagues to accuse another Member of hostility towards a group in our society?
Comment on this
I said that because I want to know what is so distasteful about a civil partnership registration that it can give rise to a crisis of conscience. It is one thing for our conscience to guide our behaviour but it is another matter when we seek to impose our extreme views on others. That is what is at the heart of this.
Senator Mullen is a lawyer and I will quote the law to him. There is a case in the United Kingdom, Islington Borough Council v. Ladele:
The claimant, a registrar of births, marriages and deaths, was required by the respondent council to conduct civil partnerships between persons of the same sex in accordance with the Civil Partnership Act 2004. She refused on the ground that such unions were contrary to her Christian beliefs, and she was subjected to a disciplinary hearing on the ground that her refusal was contrary to the council's equality and diversity policy. She made a claim to an employment tribunal that she had been discriminated against, directly and indirectly, on the ground of her religion.
The position of the court and the logic adopted there is instructive in this matter. She lost her case. The Employment Appeals Tribunal held:
[T]hat the view that the requirement that all registrars perform civil partnership functions was a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim and that the council was entitled to adopt as a legitimate objective an unambiguous commitment to the non-discriminatory provisions of services by all staff and it followed that they were entitled to require all registrars to perform the full range of services. The tribunal held that the claimant could not pick and choose what duties she would perform depending on whether they accorded with her religious views. At least where her personal stance involved discrimination on the grounds of sexual orientation which was inconsistent with the council's non-discriminatory objectives, accordingly the council's refusal to accommodate the claimant's religious belief did not involve indirect discrimination. The tribunal held that the freedom to manifest religious beliefs under Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, as scheduled to the Human Rights Act, did not apply where it involved discriminating on groups Parliament had provided were unlawful, such as the right of same sex partners to have their partnerships recognised by law.
That is jurisprudence which is equally applicable in Ireland.
Senator Mullen has undermined his own case. He said what is at issue is that there is a right to pass legalisation which is necessary "To get the job done".
Comment on this
Parliament is deciding that it is appropriate to have legislation to acknowledge, recognise and have a system of registration of civil partnership. It is a legitimate objective. The question is whether the means to achieve that objective are reasonable and proportionate. That is the decision we are making and in the debate to date we have considered it is legitimate and proportionate to have the means to achieve the objective that people who are in the public employ are obliged to register civil partnership unions. That is the objective and the means to achieve it. It is appropriate that the Bill makes provisions to ensure that it is done. On principle and law the Senator is wrong and I urge that the House reject the amendment.
Comment on this
My party and I have a fundamental objection to this amendment and Senator Alex White put our objections very forcefully yesterday in his Second Stage speech. We believe the so-called freedom of conscience clause amounts to a rather obvious attempt to undermine the purpose of the Bill. Senator McDonald correctly described it as dressed up bigotry. It is a fig leaf to cover what would otherwise be blatant prejudice. Other speakers have made the point that it would be a mandate to discriminate under the guise of so-called genuinely held religious or ethical beliefs. Senator Doherty outlined some of the scenarios that might arise if we allowed this precedent to come into effect. Another example that springs to mind is of State officials refusing to register children born to cohabiting couples. The sort of law contemplated in the amendment would be appropriate in a theocracy but not in a republic which holds the separation of church and state to be a fundamental principle. I am glad that the Minister is setting his face against the amendment. Most of use agree that we should leave our views of religion at the door when we legislate.
The registrars have not requested this amendment. Their ears must be burning when they hear others purporting to speak for them. I am reminded of the apocryphal story that de Valera looked into his heart to know what others were thinking. It is all very well to look into one's heart to know what registrars may be thinking but it also belittles and demeans them. Registrars are impeccable public servants——
Comment on this
——and there has been no indication that they are seeking this sort of opt-out clause. As Senator Regan has pointed out, there is no issue.
In regard to the technical import of the amendment and what it purports to amend, Part 7 of the Civil Registration Act 2004, which deals with marriage, allows registered solemnisers from different churches to solemnise marriages. The Bill before us sets out a different means of registering civil partnerships through a new Part 7A to be inserted by section 16 and new sections 59A to 59I. These rules are rather different from those pertaining to the registration of marriage in that only a registrar may register a civil partnership. There is no question of persons other than public registrars employed by the HSE being involved. Under section 59E, the venue would have to be agreed by the registrar if it is other than his or her office.
A number of Senators have spoken about criminalisation of registrars but section 22 simply adds a provision to section 69 of the 2004 Act, which is the general section providing for offences. The 2004 Act already provides that it is an offence for a registrar to delete or alter information contained in a register or index contrary to the Act or to refuse or fail to register a birth, still birth, marriage or death without reasonable cause. The Bill simply expands this category of offences to include omissions or failures to register civil partnerships. It is entirely appropriate that we would see these sorts of offence and penalties, which are standard for minor offences, set out in section 70 in respect of public officials who are privy to all sorts of sensitive information on individuals who seek to register births, marriages and civil partnerships. No one objected to those offences being included in the 2004 Act and there can be no valid objection to the extension of these offences and penalties to include civil partnerships.
Section 37 of the Employment Equality Act 1998 already provides opt-outs for religious run schools and hospitals. Many of us strenuously object to these opt-outs because they provide a mandate to discriminate against persons who offend an institution's ethos. This principle is wrong and we certainly should not extend it in any way. Catholic run, State funded schools already impose an obligation on teachers to teach Catholic religious doctrine. This should no longer prevail in a secular republic but it is an argument for another day.
This amendment is an attempt to undermine and destabilise the legislation dressed up in the language of freedom of conscience. We should look forward to celebrating the first civil partnership ceremonies conducted by professional registrars in the employment of the State. These red herrings should not be discussed because they simply are not an issue.
Comment on this
I completely agree with Senator Bacik. The amendment raises a number of questions, one of which is the motivation behind it. Having listened at length to certain Senators over the past 24 hours, it is clear from the explanation for this amendment that a different agenda is being pursued.
I commend the Minister on the strength of his argument in regard to public servants. This is not an issue for church or canon law. These are public servants who are employed by the State. They are required to uphold and implement the law and they can have no excuse for not doing so. I am in complete agreement with the Minister and he needs to face down the critics.
The proposed amendment states: "The registrar's refusal or failure to act is based on a conscientious objection to the registration of the marriage or civil partnership grounded in a sincerely held religious or ethical belief". I ask how one can prove that an ethical belief is sincerely held. I have come across many people who claimed to hold sincere held beliefs against homosexuality of same-sex couples. They may regard their beliefs as sincerely held but others would simply regard them as homophobia. While I do not think any registrar is of that ilk, this amendment would put into law the potential to discriminate.
I note Senator Mullen's argument that the legislation perpetuates new forms of injustice and discrimination. I have not received a single submission from the more than 100 registrars employed in this country. The Minister has stated that he has not received correspondence. I am not sure whether any Member has received correspondence from a registrar on this issue.
Clearly, some Senators are looking into their own hearts and seeing things that are not there. I cannot accept that the amendment is being put forward for any purpose other than to wreck this Bill or to diminish the rights it would afford to same-sex couples.
Comment on this
We certainly will not be supporting it.
Comment on this
I totally object to this amendment. It is badly worded, stating: "A registrar who, without reasonable cause, fails or refuses to give a civil partnership registration form to one of the parties to an intended civil partnership ... commits an offence", whereas "A registrar who, with reasonable cause, fails or refuses to register a marriage or civil partnership or to give a marriage or civil partnership registration form shall not be taken to discriminate against a person for the purposes of the Equal Status Act 2000." It attempts to make an exemption under the 2000 Act in respect of civil partnership ceremonies but, as I stated yesterday, that is nothing but dressed up bigotry.
I also stated yesterday that we would create a moral hazard were we to allow officials to pick and choose what they want to do. We would run into chaos. Many people in this country have heartfelt views on Travellers, ageism or even women. They are entitled to these views but they should keep them in their own minds. The process of acting on such thoughts is called discrimination. The State and its Legislature do not allow that.
Senators spoke about Hamlet.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the amendment. I am responding to Senator Mullen's description of my comments on tolerance as lacking refined thinking. I believe Hamlet also said Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned.
Comment on this
While they were not the words of Hamlet, they are certainly true.
Comment on this
On the subject of Hamlet, he was not a great family man and appeared to be confused in respect of family principles. As I stated, the proposal is not acceptable in a democracy such as this and we cannot support it.
Comment on this
I will refrain from engaging in soliloquies and such like. This is a most important issue which goes to the heart of the republic we want to create, namely, one that is inclusive, non-discriminatory and tolerant. As a result of some of the comments made today, the debate today does not reflect the quality of debate yesterday.
Comment on this
If I am seeking tolerance in a republic, I must practise restraint. For this reason, I will not respond to the pejorative remarks made by other speakers.
Comment on this
I received advice from GLEN that pejorative words such as "bigoted" and "homophobic" would be levelled at us, but we should have the courage to speak our minds on these matters. May I contrast the debate on this issue——
Comment on this
If the Acting Chairman allows me to continue, it will become clear that this matter is closely related to the amendment. I will contrast the debate in the Houses of Parliament in Britain which was held within the past six months with the debate in this House. During the debate in the Britain the former head of the judiciary in England and Wales, Lord Mackay, stated equality laws should not force people to provide goods and services in a way that conflicted with their conscience. Tabling an amendment to the Equality Bill which he subsequently withdrew before a vote could be taken, he argued that current laws should be more flexible to accommodate differing points of view. He cited the example of printers, both from the point of view of same-sex printers being forced to print matter alien to their views and——
Comment on this
What is a same-sex printer? I am confused.
Comment on this
He also noted that the British Government's argument on the law did not provide sufficient flexibility for conscience. The contrast between the debate in the Britain and the views expressed by Senators who disagree with the proposal before us is clear because those arguing against Lord Mackay's amendment agreed that greater flexibility was needed to accommodate conscience.
I direct the following remarks to the Minister. The Minister sponsoring the UK legislation, Baroness Thornton, suggested employers could take practical measures to respect the private views of their staff. She cited specifically the example of a registrar — this is pertinent to this debate — stating that "if an individual registrar does not want to conduct civil partnership ceremonies because of their religious beliefs, a local authority could arrange for a different registrar to conduct the ceremony if there is one available." Senator Regan referred to the Ladelle case which was also referred to in the debate in the House of Lords when a Lord stated the relevant local authority was not prepared to work in the manner described by Baroness Thornton. This matter should be addressed in the context of labour relations.
While we have been challenged on this matter, we have had the benefit of a meeting with the Minister and his officials, at which we examined this issue. We can see both sides of the argument and do not want people who have prejudiced views to be in a position to use the veil of conscience to engage in discriminatory actions against people who are gay or, for that matter, any minorities. We will discuss later an amendment we have tabled proposing a conscience clause in relation to religious ethos and on which we take a different view from the view we hold in this case. We were reinforced in our belief by the unreasonable attitude taken by a group of people outside the Houses last week who were criticised from all sides. Its intolerant approach, whether directed at Members of the House or minorities, was unacceptable and I have no truck with it.
Comment on this
I propose briefly to discuss one further interesting example.
Comment on this
It is very relevant. Senator Regan referred to developing jurisprudence on the neighbouring island in respect of the Ladelle case and its Employment Appeals Tribunal. A very interesting case arose in which a person who had strong beliefs on climate change took serious issue with the chief executive of his company and lost his job as a consequence. When the Employment Appeals Tribunal found against him, he took an appeal to the courts which ruled that, as a result of his genuine beliefs on climate change, the plaintiff should be afforded the same protection as that afforded to religious belief in British law. Christian groups have objected to the ruling and I do not make a case for it. I am merely highlighting the developing views on this matter which needs to be examined.
To clarify our position, we believe there are conflicting priorities between freedom of conscience and the absolute entitlement not to be discriminated against. As a consequence, we did not table the amendment and while we will not support it, we will not oppose it because the issue needs to be addressed in a manner that gives reassurance and protection to people of conscience, regardless of whether they provide individual services or work for the State. We will oppose the criminalisation of such persons through the sanctions included in the Bill.
Comment on this
On a point of clarification, virtually the entire executive and founding members of GLEN are in the Visitors Gallery and they have no notion or knowledge of the statement——
Comment on this
I promise to be brief and confine my remarks to the amendment. I concur with Senator Walsh that the amendment goes to the heart of the republic we want to create. If we were to pass it, we would create a homophobic, intolerant and discriminatory state. The fundamental question the amendment raises is what do the proposers have against gay people.
Comment on this
Senator Walsh described a previous amendment as addressing the crux of the matter. The Senators have a right to hold a view on this matter, although I disagree with them. Are they seriously arguing that we row back on the advances achieved in recent years on the issue of equality? I did not hear any voices of conscience when funding for the Equality Authority was substantially reduced.
Comment on this
Senator Norris spoke out from a different perspective. Every Member of the House has a conscience. I act in conscience every day and did so throughout the years I taught in a classroom. Was I to stop teaching a student who had failed to secure an A grade in an examination?
Comment on this
I am discussing the issue of discrimination. The subtext of the amendment appears to be a lack of respect. I am a practising Catholic. While the God in whom I believe does not discriminate, the church of which I am a member does. If we allow freedom of conscience on this issue, will we allow publicans to ignore equality legislation and bar all Travellers from their premises or will we extend it to encompass marriages between black people, Asians and Caucasians? Senator Doherty was right. If this happened in Belfast or Derry there would a revolution down here and we would be almost unanimous in giving out. Republicanism is about equality. I support the Minister in what he is doing and I heard what he said earlier. How many civil registrars have objected to divorce and then performed marriages involving divorcees? As with Senator Hannigan, I have not heard one complaint from a registrar. The opposite is the case. This amendment questions the public servant who does a very good job. It is about creating exemptions and is about discrimination. I hope we stand firm and do not allow it. The final paragraph of the amendment states: "(9C) A registrar who, with reasonable cause, fails or refuses to register a marriage or civil partnership or to give a marriage or civil partnership registration form shall not be taken to discriminate". What is it if not discrimination?
Comment on this
Debates such as this allow people to pick and choose and make their arguments one after another. Lord Mackay may sound like a very innocent Member of the British House of Lords, a doddery old man etc. I just checked his voting record there. He has been violently and completely anti-gay rights all the time in the British House of Lords. Let us not speak from the point of view of being in favour of gay rights and then use examples of people who are bitterly opposed to gay rights, which is where Lord Mackay of Clashfern is coming from.
Senator Mullen raised the issue of the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights. It is important to consider some of the other articles, including Article 16, which states:
Men and women of full age, without any limitation due to race, nationality or religion, have the right to marry and to found a family. They are entitled to equal rights as to marriage, during marriage and at its dissolution.
I know Senator Mullen, as a lawyer, will say it mentions men and women and that it is implied that it is men marrying women, but that is not what the article states.
Comment on this
We had an interesting discussion the other day.
Comment on this
If we are getting our ducks in a row, let us put all the things down there together. I do not want to undermine the force of the Senator's argument, but I thought it lacked some passion and that he was just going through the procedures.
I wish to confirm for the House the position of the trade union movement on the matter. I sat in Government Buildings during many negotiations on national partnership agreements when this issue was put forward and governments were urged by the trade union movement, employers and other groups to move towards having civil partnership. It subsequently became part of the programme for Government. There has been no objection from trade union members about this issue in any way cutting across them. The view of the trade union movement is completely supportive. It might feel the Bill might have gone further, but it supports the Minister in what he is doing.
I believe my colleagues sat down to ascertain how they could undermine the legislation and this is one of the devices they used.
Comment on this
I know, but I am entitled to my view as to how I see it. You may not speak for your other six people either. People have different views.
Comment on this
People regularly vote against proposals for all sorts of reasons. They might be bitterly opposed to each other. My interpretation is that people were opposed to the idea of civil partnership and found this particular one. The proposed amendment allows registrars to have a conscientious objection not just to civil partnerships, but also to marriage. In that regard alone it undermines the entire case put by previous speakers in its favour. It means we could go back now and say they may not take that particular point of view.
We have a long history of conscientious objection in this country. I have dealt with the issue myself. I made passing reference last night to the teaching of religion in schools. Very often during the appointments procedure a prospective teacher will be asked if he or she objects to teaching religion in order that he or she is sewn into that particular commitment. Alternatively they might not be asked, but it is part of the school programme although not part of the national programme. People might genuinely lapse or evolve, whichever one prefers, to atheism or agnosticism and find themselves in a position with which they are uncomfortable and might have a conscientious objection to the teaching of religion. In these cases people tend to take a practical view that it is part of what happens in the school and needs to be taught.
I was a primary school principal and whereas I would not have subscribed to the religious knowledge, I would have insisted as school principal that as we were there in loco parentis all children went through the programme and knew their stuff as well as anybody would expect them to do. I did not find that in any way cynical or ironic. It is part of a job. One gets in, does it, gets on with it and moves on. It is no big deal. We should recognise that every day hundreds of teachers teach a religious education programme to which they would be fundamentally opposed, to which they do not subscribe or in which they do not participate. However, they do it because the parents and school management would like it to be done. The teachers take the view that they are paid to do a job and should get on and do it. It is mathematics now and religious education next; get on and do it, if that is the way it is. People might not like that and people like to think it comes from the heart in all cases; it does not. It does in some cases and it does not in others.
In Irish history we have dealt with this before. I will make a particular reference to the Fianna Fáil Party and its founder. I want to make particular reference to the Catholic Church. At one stage Senator Mullen worked with an eminent cardinal and Archbishop of Dublin, who found himself in difficulty at times. His way of dealing with it, as he described to the entire world, was by establishing a mental reservation. He could do what he wanted without committing himself to what he was doing. It was a mental reservation. This has been done by the Catholic Church; it does not seem to cause a problem. I found it problematic. I say to my friends coming from the Catholic background that they might advise any registrars they know to have a difficulty that they can use that little device. It works and exists, I understand. Theology and Canon Law support it. The Pope in Rome does not have a difficulty with it. Who am I to give out about it?
Comment on this
The Senator has class; I will give him that.
Comment on this
Let us explain to them how we should do it and perhaps Senator Mullen might explain in more detail how it works when he gets to reply later.
I recommend that good friends on the other side should look at the situation of their party's eminent founder, Eamon de Valera, who found himself in a somewhat awkward position in 1927.
Comment on this
There are a few exceptions to that. Eamon de Valera was not my man.
Comment on this
In 1927 he found himself faced with taking an oath of allegiance to the Crown which caused him some concerns. However, he knew if he did not take it he could not get in the door to establish the privilege our friends mentioned earlier. I am explaining this to my Fianna Fáil colleagues as a device they could also use. They could say:
I asked myself what my duty was and anything that was not wrong I was prepared to do. I would not have felt justified in committing perjury or doing anything equivalent to perjury. The party opposite, the Cosgrave-ites, told the people that this was not an oath at all. I believe that the words "I swear" mean an oath. But the Deputies opposite thought differently. They said it was a formality and that anyone could take it. I asked myself whether in a crisis like that I would be justified in staying outside when this was a mere formality.
Eamon de Valera listened to Fine Gael who convinced him that this was a mere formality and he moved on. He then said: "When I came to take the so-called oath I presented to the officer in charge [an English chap I think]." He presented a document to the officer in charge which contained the republican declaration that they did not regard the oath of allegiance as a binding oath. He told him that was their attitude and that they were not prepared to take the oath. He produced a written document in pencil as Gaeilge which contained the statement made to the officer who was supposed to administer the oath and said he was not prepared to take the oath. He just took it. He put down the words, signed up to it and went on to describe it as an empty formula.
I am proposing to my Fianna Fáil colleagues that they see these words as an empty formula. They should not get carried away with it. They should just get down and make it happen. It is an empty formula and is a process well established throughout the history of the Senators' own party. I will actually support them in getting——
Comment on this
I just want to make sure that the record is absolutely correct. These are three members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are not taking the Fianna Fáil Whip at the moment.
Comment on this
Would the Senator call them independent Fianna Fáil?
Comment on this
They fully understand the processes, procedures and history of their own party and there is a device within that to suit their occasion.
Those of my colleagues who come from a Catholic background and who are worried about that have the mental reservation device. Those from the Fianna Fáil background should listen to the Cosgraveites on this side and get on with it. They should not be upset. They should do what their founder did and simply say that this is an empty formula. Why can they not dothat?
The reality is that this amendment is a bottle of smoke. It does not meet any particular needs of any group of which I am aware. It is rare for us to find an issue of pressing concern to a group of people being articulated by their public representatives but which has never been articulated by the group itself. Who are we talking about? Public servants are there to do a job. They sign up, they take the shilling and they follow the flag. They do their job as it is set out for them. In most work places, if people find they have a difficulty in doing some aspects of their job, they find ways around that. People work together and tend not to steamroll each other into doing what they will not do. If somebody has a difficulty then they might be sick on the day they are supposed to do it. They can take a day's holiday or a day's pay cut or whatever. We deal with that all the time. We had to meet this morning trying to find a man.
Comment on this
There is no difficulty in dealing with the perceived problem. I do not believe it is a real problem. The registrars have never articulated a problem. I can give much more evidence as we go along of the other ways in which we have dealt with this kind of thing before. This is not new. I do not want Members to think this is a major issue of importance. It is a huge argument about nothing. It is an issue that does not concern anybody outside the few Members in here who raised it. They raised it for their own reasons. I have given one of my views. I am happy to be contradicted on it, but I still hold my view.
As parliamentarians, we must recognise where this legislation is going. Were this amendment to be accepted, it would undermine the spirit and the operation of the legislation. It would also create moral hazard because it would allow, encourage and reward people for not doing their jobs. It would force extra work on other people who would have to pick up the slack from those who claim to have a conscientious objection. If this lead to a situation where somebody was jailed for these acts, then that would be ridiculous. There are certainly better ways of dealing with it, but that is not to be for or against anything. It is a kind of a scare tactic that was raised to add a bit of credence to an argument that was pretty threadbare. It was long and interesting, but it added little to the overall argument. I have not found a scintilla of argument or evidence put forward in the last two or three hours that would change my view on this amendment. We should just dispose of it and vote on it shortly. I do not think I am entitled to put the question under Standing Orders, but somebody can.
Comment on this
On the Order of Business this morning, the Leader complimented the Seanad on the standard of debate which we had in the House yesterday. Several Senators spoke exactly along the same lines. While I did not speak, I certainly agreed. The Minister made exactly the same point. He said that in his 26 or 27 years here, the discussion he had on Second Stage, which he may have slightly corrected on Committee Stage——
Comment on this
I appreciated what he said and I have huge admiration for the man. I am not saying that in a patronising way. I genuinely have great admiration for him, especially due to his accessibility to us when we wanted to meet him and his officials.
Comment on this
I have listened to a lecture from Senator O'Toole as to what we should do, having been put out of Fianna Fáil. I did not hear any interjection, and I congratulate the Senator on what he said. I may discuss the formula with him. I notice that when those of us who hold a certain view get up, we are told it is not relevant. In fact, it will show itself to be relevant when I am finished. I just wonder why the interjection comes so quickly when it has not come when other Senators were speaking.
Comment on this
I have taken over the Chair from somebody else, so I do not know what interruptions occurred until now.
Comment on this
If you wish, I will not make the contribution. If that is what you want, I will sit down because I just get the feeling——
Comment on this
It is all right. I will not make the point that I was prepared to make.
Comment on this
I am not trying to stop anybody from speaking, but they must speak to the amendment.
Comment on this
It would be nice if we got exactly the same innings as everybody else. If you feel that we do not deserve that, I will sit down.
Comment on this
When Senator O'Toole was moving away from the point, I asked him to speak to the amendment. You started complimenting the Minister, but we want to talk about the amendment. The discussion has been going on for quite some time.
Comment on this
I understand that, but I have sat here for the last two hours and I have listened. The clock has nothing to do with my views.
Comment on this
No, but if you want to speak to the amendment, there is no problem with that. However, you are not speaking to the amendment.
Comment on this
I had not even started to make my views.
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the House is not prepared to listen to reasoned views from Members, but prepared to allow pejorative views that are personal, then I suggest you close down the debate and you move to pass the Bill.
Comment on this
If that is the attitude of the House, then I suggest you do that.
Comment on this
Is Senator Walsh proposing a vote on the amendment? I support his position on this.
Comment on this
Senator Norris, you have not been called. Senator Ó Murchú, you were asked to speak to this particular amendment. All I have heard is a commentary about the Minister. If you can speak to the amendment, there is no problem. When other people did not speak to the amendment, I pulled them up. I am not that long in the Chair and I cannot say what happened before that, so I am not casting aspersions on anybody.
Comment on this
I have heard so many comments in the last few hours which had absolutely nothing to do with the amendment but dealt with us as individuals who had a separate view. Are you saying to us that we cannot go back on those views and explain our opposition to the amendment?
Comment on this
Exactly. I would like to continue and if you feel that you are not able to abide what I am doing, I will sit down. It would be for the good of this House to have fair comment across the board.
What the Minister said was correct. There has been an exceptionally good debate in this House. Several other Senators made exactly the same point. My name is not to this amendment, but I fully uphold the right of Senator Mullen and Senator Quinn to put down that amendment. I also uphold the right of every Senator to oppose that amendment. My view on it has been informed by the debate that I have heard here. This has been one of the most learned debates ever in this House. I compliment all those who have brought professional expertise with them to the House and who have made it known to us. That is precisely what we are doing.
For those outside the House looking in, those we represent, the Seanad has been done a service today by the opposing views being put in such a generous and open-minded way. That all relates to the amendment because it is important I put it into context.
Like Senator O'Toole, I have been a lifelong trade unionist but I do not accept it is vital that the trade union movement must make a comment or interact with us, as legislators, to have a view. Whether one is Independent or a member of a party, one is still entitled to have a view. That is in response to a comment made.
Whether it is 46 votes to five or 46 votes to one, the numerical strength of the vote has nothing to do with democracy because if we follow that concept, someone may presume that on the basis that only a minority is putting forward a point of view, it should not put it forward at all. If we follow that concept, it is a negation of democracy itself.
We have some new converts to brevity today, and so be it. I wish to make a point, on which Senator Norris touched. My hearing is not as acute as it should be and I did not have the earphone on my ear.
Comment on this
I do not believe I referred to anything the Senator has with hearing.
Comment on this
I did not say that. I was coming to Senator O'Toole. I did not know whether to include him in the following point. The only point I have made on this issue on all Stages was in regard to the imprisonment of a registrar for six months. I made a contribution on the Order of Business on this issue and I have been misquoted. I have made this point three times. I said I do not want to find myself in a situation of having to stand up in the Seanad in defence of a prisoner of conscience under this particular section in legislation, of which I will have been seen to be part. I was anxious to pre-empt what might be said subsequently and deal only with that focused issue.
I make that same point again. I do not believe imprisonment is necessary as a deterrent in this case. We are using a sledgehammer in the wrong way and it is undermining much of the goodwill and debate which has taken place heretofore.
I refer to edges of the debate when it gets iffy or flippant. That is in order and I am not raising questions about that. We should not all stand on a butter box on issues such as that because I am sure we have all fallen into that trap at times. However, in the course of that iffy part of the debate, I always feel disappointed that when we are discussing a specific issue, a blanket is thrown over us all as if, in this case, we are opposed to gays and lesbians.
I ask Members to read the record of the House. When we were allowed to make statements, I made very definitive, strong and supportive statements. I will not use words because, at times, Senator Norris feels people are being patronising even when we repeat perhaps some of what he has said. When I made points in a ten-minute statement, I laid out precisely my view on gays and lesbians. That is what this amendment is about.
Comment on this
For someone, in the course of the debate on the amendment, to in some way throw a blanket over us all as if we were homophobic or whatever is wrong because that does not help the debate.
Comment on this
However, we are entitled, when considering the rights of same-sex couples, to discuss the impact of those rights on the rights of other people. We will discuss this in the context of other amendments.
For the rest of the debate, we should leave aside that blanket cover as if, in some way, we were anti-gay and anti-lesbian. I am not, never have been and never will be. I am supportive of them having their rights. Why should they not have rights? I have made this point before. This should not be used as an obstacle to developing the debate in order that we can find out precisely what is inherent in the legislation.
I genuinely learned much from Senator Mullen and I listened to him with great interest. I heard him refer to different sources but I did not hear any repetition in what he put forward. I accept that perhaps it was somewhat long in the context of the time but unless there is an order to indicate the time allowed, then we will have a difficulty in the future.
For years I have sat in this House when we were discussing Bills and I listened to what I did not think was, in any way, what we might consider rational debate. People used other words and terms. I listened to those debates but not once in my 13 years in the House did I make any reference to personalise that or, in some way, demonise the point being put forward. How often have we heard that being put forward in the debate on this amendment? For the remainder of the debate on the amendments, I genuinely hope we can all feel free to put forward our views on each amendment without personalising or demonising anyone else in doing so.
Comment on this
I find it an unusual concept for someone to say to me that if one feels something in one's heart, one should leave it there. I find that strange. I do not believe anyone in this House would subscribe to that concept. It strikes me as not setting the right tone for this debate.