We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Bill 2009: Committee Stage (Resumed)

Contributions 371–549 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Bill 2009
Enacted

No. 44 of 2009 ›

I wish to speak to the amendment.

Comment on this

That would be a change.

Comment on this

I question whether this amendment deals with the issue. I am not quite clear what it is about. The amendment may have had some favour in the 1950s but it is extremely out of date and misinformed.

The notion that someone who works as a registrar on behalf of the State to provide a service would have a difficulty providing that service is strange. A registrar who, as a result of his or her conscience, is able to opt out of doing the basic job he or she is employed to do, which is to bring two people together in a partnership, should not be working as a registrar.

As Senator O'Toole pointed out, under this amendment, if a registrar had a difficulty with a particular heterosexual couple, he or she could opt out under the conscience clause. Why would someone work as a registrar if he or she would not do the job they have signed up to?

The law is the guidebook on how the registrar works. This is what a registrar is employed to do. I do not understand where this conscience clause comes into it. I made the important point yesterday that conscience certainly comes into spirituality and religion but it does not come into law. Law and conscience do not go together. We live in a civil society. We represent all the people.

Comment on this

This is not a worthy amendment and I hope it will not be approved by anyone other than its two proposers. It does not have a place in legislation. The idea that people can opt out of doing their job on the basis of conscience is not acceptable. We all carry prejudices and religious beliefs with us. Everyone who does a job has views unrelated to that job. The amendment is not related to the job of registrar. Conscience is a matter outside civil society. It is not a matter of law but of religion or spirituality. To insert conscience clauses in legislation would be regressive rather than progressive.

Comment on this

I have listened very carefully to all of the arguments made. I thank Senator Mullen for making my argument by listing the various issues that show clearly how a freedom of conscience clause in legislation would allow public servants to take an à la carte approach to legislation passed by the Oireachtas on behalf of the people. The general public deserves to know that if we pass legislation on its behalf, it will be implemented without fear or favour on an equal basis. If we were to implement a freedom of conscience clause in relation to any of the exemptions I mentioned previously in the other House and that Senator Mullen has listed on my behalf, I could foresee future Members speaking on the Order of Business in the Dáil or Seanad and objecting to the fact that public servants were not implementing legislation passed by the Oireachtas. How could one run a country and how could the public service be expected to run a country if individuals were allowed to adopt a view contrary to the stated intention of the representatives of the people? That is the essence of democracy.

We have heard much about republicanism, including self-professed republicanism. We seem to refer frequently to our neighbouring island. I have not looked to see how our neighbouring island deals with this issue, as one would not be comparing like with like. We have a Constitution and an independent Judiciary, the members of which make their own decisions. Of course, we are subject to EU laws, but the Constitution is supreme on these issues. We have passed legislation to ensure equal treatment of the general public and it has stood the test of time.

I respect the views expressed by Senator Ó Murchú. He indicated that he would find it difficult to have it on his conscience if someone was sent to prison as a result of this legislation. I believe he was a Member of this House when it passed the Civil Registration Act 2004, but he may correct me if I am wrong. Section 17(4) of that Act states clearly that a "registrar shall have and perform ... functions conferred on him or her by or under this Act". The word "shall" is used, not "may". Section 70 contains the penalties for offences under the Act and there is provision for officials to be relieved of their duties if they do not perform the functions conferred on them. It states a person guilty of an offence shall be liable on summary conviction to six months imprisonment or a fine, or on indictment up to five years imprisonment. What we are doing in this instance is adding, as we are doing in a number of other areas, the issue of civil partnership to this legislation and the Civil Registration Act 2004.

When the issue of conscientious objection was originally raised, my officials made inquiries in this regard. Everything that has come back, anecdotally and otherwise, shows that registrars have no problem with and are looking forward to the implementation of this legislation. That begs the question: where is this coming from? I cannot answer that question.

I was asked what representations the Department or I had received on the use of church property. I can say there were representations from religious representatives who made out, incorrectly, that they would be forced to use their church property. We did not receive representations from any of the people supposedly affected by a freedom of conscience clause.

As a matter of public policy, there is no reason in any democratic society, when legislation is passed, circumstances would be allowed to obtain where it could not be implemented. I suggest to any legislator who says we should do this that it would leave the State open to a potential claim for substantial compensation on the basis that people who had not received the service to which they were entitled under the legislation would have an open and shut case for compensation because the law had not been implemented without fear or favour and on an equal basis. For public policy and also practical reasons, if we pass legislation, the least we can expect is that it will be implemented.

My officials have been dealing with this legislation for the past few months. They may very well have a conscientious objection to dealing with it, as officials in the Seanad may have with this or any other legislation. However, as elected Members, we cannot allow a situation where such persons, whether they have an issue, which is fair enough, will not do their jobs because that is what they have been appointed to do, as public servants.

Others have made the arguments and I fully agree with them. To be fair to Senator Walsh, I must acknowledge that at my meeting with him and his two colleagues they at least understood the argument I was making on behalf of the Government.

Comment on this

They did better than me.

Comment on this

That is the benefit of being a member of a political party.

Comment on this

The Minister showed favouritism.

Comment on this

That is something, of which Senators Walsh, Ó Murchú and Hanafin were well aware until yesterday. It is one of the reasons they find it very difficult to do what they are doing.

Comment on this

I will sign up for a skiing trip with the Minister in order that I can have his ear sometime.

Comment on this

I listen to local radio and hear and understand what the Senator says about me.

Comment on this

Nothing was personalised.

Comment on this

The Houses are the primary location at which the debate and the argument on these issues should take place, not the peddling, which I hope did not come from the Senator——

Comment on this

We would have fun on LMFM.

Comment on this

I hope it was not Senator Mullen, whom Senator McDonald referred to as having said the Minister or somebody had been "got at".

Comment on this

That might have been me.

Comment on this

I was not got at by either side on this legislation. I do what I regard as my duty as an elected representative. I will deal primarily in this and the other House with the argumentation on issues I bring forward as a Minister. I will not apologise to anyone for not engaging on the public airwaves or otherwise.

Comment on this

The Minister is a public representative.

Comment on this

As I said, I have not met any of the groups which were lobbying on this legislation other than the Oireachtas Members of my own political party. I engaged fully with my party, as Senator Walsh has indicated on many occasions.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We need to get back to the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not accept there should be a free vote on the issue. I heard what was said about what Fine Gael had done. Of course, there may be people within a political party who hold a certain view that may not be in line with the majority view. Again, that is the democratic system that has worked very well for this country and I do not think we should change it. While I do not want to be pejorative in this regard, I wonder, when the very people who potentially would be affected by the amendment are not the ones calling for this change——

Comment on this

I will address that issue.

Comment on this

——why is it being suggested?

On the overall issue, it makes no sense in the running of a democratic state if a law is democratically passed through the Legislature for people to be allowed, in effect, to adopt an à la carte approach to its implementation. One would not be able to run a country or any of its public services, particularly given the society we now have, if that were to be the case. Twenty years ago this was a mono-ethnic, mono-cultural and virtually mono-religious society. Today, it is multicultural, multi-ethnic and multi-religious and includes those with no religion. That is why we, as legislators, cannot legislate for one concept of morality; we have to legislate for the common good as best we can. We will not always succeed because there will be people who will be adversely affected by the legislation we bring forward. However, when the vast majority of the elected Members of both Houses agree with the principles laid down in this legislation, I do not support the effort made to chip away at the principle of treating people with fairness and equality and implementing what is contained in the Constitution. It is our Constitution, not a British constitution. It does not concern what the British do in this regard; it dictates that we should treat everyone equally before the law. In this regard, it also gives special recognition to the family and marriage. It is that balance, whether we like it, that we must, as legislators, adhere to.

Comment on this

I look at this issue from the point of view of my profession. As doctors, nurses or other allied health professionals, we could not begin to have issues of conscience. There are ethical questions such as abortion which are major for health care professionals. We should be very careful, as the Minister pointed out, in how we interpret "conscience". It could make life absolutely impossible and people could take views which would have more to do with prejudice, which can be major or minor, than genuine ethical concerns about how they do their jobs.

Comment on this

By way of an opening response, I would never intentionally engage in a filibuster, as suggested earlier.

Comment on this

The Senator could have fooled us.

Comment on this

Long-winded on occasions I may be——

Comment on this

——but I do not lack respect for the procedures of the House. One of the Senators who contributed earlier mentioned to me that on a previous occasion he had spoken for two hours on an amendment, which it was generous to acknowledge. There are circumstances where people feel the need to air points.

Comment on this

Not in modern times.

Comment on this

There is much philosophy here. I apologise if I got people's backs up or if they got the impression I am trying to filibuster. I am not doing so but unlike what I take from Senator Joe O'Toole's comments, I believe there is a profound issue of genuine liberalism at stake here.

I said earlier that——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There is no need for the Senator to say again what he has said already. There is no great need to be repetitive.

Comment on this

What has this to do with the amendment?

Comment on this

I must be allowed to comment on certain remarks made about me earlier. I do not mind people seeking to ridicule, taking me on in arguments or suggesting that my amendments might have unintended consequences or might facilitate bad people in society. I am a big boy and am able to argue my case. I take issue with being accused of dressed up bigotry. In one case Senator McDonald suggested I might have issues with women but I would be happy to supply her with references from some of the exes.

Comment on this

Why are they exes so?

Comment on this

Senator Norris compared me to Uriah Heep, and Senator Regan basically suggested homophobia is behind the amendment. That hurts and is unfair. The Labour Party suggested there were hidden agendas and the Minister made half a suggestion to that effect. There is no hidden agenda and the proposed amendment is not designed to set this entire Bill at naught. I have problems with aspects of the Bill but my problems with the civil partnership model being proposed in the Bill pale into insignificance with the concern I have for the protection of conscience in our society. It is a genuine concern and I would be grateful if people would attack me on the argument and not on my bona fides.

I do not normally talk about my personal life but I subscribe to a Christian world view, which suggests we should be ready to give our lives for one other. Whether a person is homosexual, a sister, brother or distant relative does not come into it. That is the standard I try to live by. There is no hatred or fear of homosexual persons in my heart and I do not believe it is in the heart of any of the others who have tabled amendments. It would be too bad if people trying to legislate for the common good were constantly having their motivation scrutinised and being accused of some quite ugly motivation when such motivation is absent.

I ask those people in the House who brought up the suggestions — they know who they are — to reflect genuinely and dispassionately on what they have said and consider whether they might withdraw them either on the record or privately to me. I would appreciate it if people would not second-guess the motivations of others. There is no hatred, distrust or dislike of homosexual persons in my heart but there are legitimate differences of moral opinion in our society, which is what I am trying to protect.

The Minister indicated I made his argument by going through the various categories, which I will not repeat. He gave examples such as bank officials refusing to open a joint account, doctors refusing to share information with a civil partner, Revenue officials refusing to consider civil partners as a couple or funeral directors refusing to handle a burial ceremony according to the deceased. If the Minister or Senator Pearse Doherty had considered my amendment, they would see it gave no comfort to any of those persons.

The reason this amendment is necessary is precisely because Ireland is becoming a multicultural society. Once upon a time people did not need to think about their consciences because they did what the church or the law indicated. We all accept that it is now wonderful that we are getting to a society where people think for themselves and will decide for or against what they hear from churches and other bodies.

I gave the example of the abortion Act in Britain which specifically provides for a conscientious objection to participation in treatment. I am glad Senator Twomey brought that up because it at least establishes the principle that it is sometimes necessary in a just and pluralistic society to allow people who have a genuine problem in their conscience to continue to function as State officials in certain positions while being allowed to go their own way and live out their ethos and morality. It is a delicate issue calling for a balance.

My argument to the Minister, which I did not hear him address in any detail or at all, is that my amendment offers that balance. It would not in any way give comfort to a racist or other motivation. It starts from the premise that there are different points of view in our society with regard to sexuality and recognition of same-sex partnerships. It offers some comfort to those who may have a conscientious objection by saying that provided it does not impact on the State, they can be accommodated. That is different from giving carte blanche to racists or homophobes to blithely claim a conscientious objection and gum up the works. That is impossible under my amendment and I would have been grateful if instead of attacking me personally, other Seanadóirí would have teased out what my amendment proposes. By all means they can attack any unintended consequences found.

It cannot be argued, as Senator Doherty and others have tried, that if conscientious objection is allowed in one case, the floodgates will be opened. It is our job as a Legislature to set out the circumstances in which we will allow for exceptions. In that regard I want to be very clear on the subject. Considering the existing equality legislation, it is replete with exceptions and anti-discrimination provisions have exceptions included designed to achieve the common good. I will not go through all of them but, for example, treating a person who has not attained the age of 18 more or less favourably than another shall not be regarded as discrimination. There are even provisions for discrimination in the treatment of a person on gender grounds with regard to services of an aesthetic, cosmetic or similar nature.

We all know about section 30 of the Employment Equality Act, which the Supreme Court said was necessary for employment equality legislation to be constitutional. That exception allows religious-run schools or hospitals to make decisions, where necessary, to prevent the undermining of their ethos. We have admitted the principle of conscientious objection into our law. Not only that, the Constitution has stood by it and indicated it is necessary.

It makes a mockery of legislative debate if the first time someone comes up with an exception that is carefully crafted, he or she is accused of ulterior motives. That is not in the best spirit of legislative debate.

Comment on this

Will the Senator give way for a moment?

Comment on this

The Senator has instanced a number of cases where there are exceptions. There is no exception to the circumstance where a public servant, in the performance of statutory duty as laid down by legislation, is allowed to decide based on freedom of conscience. It is nowhere in existing legislation.

Comment on this

That is completely true.

Comment on this

It is true and I do not believe I said anything to gainsay that fact. In other cases, such as the British abortion Act, it has been deemed necessary to have such a provision.

Comment on this

We are talking about the Irish context.

Comment on this

There could very well be a public employee seeking to invoke such a provision. It is the first area in which British law might be relevant. The second issue was brought up by Senator Regan and is very telling. He mentioned the Islington borough council case, which as far as I know involved an evangelical Christian who did not want to be involved in the provision of civil partnership. In that case Senator Regan agrees with the eventual decision, which I understand was against that person.

It is very well for the Minister to say there has never been anyone who brought up this concern or that the trade unions have not yet expressed it. That may be true. In light of the reaction to that expression of concern by me, does the Minister think people would feel courageous enough to raise that concern? We can consider the reaction when I raised the possibility that someone might have that concern.

We must legislate prospectively because we are becoming a multicultural society. There may be a lady or gentleman who will mirror that British issue and indicate a conscience problem. I do not have any problem with the fact that our current equal status legislation, for example, prohibits discrimination on sexual orientation grounds. I have never opposed that idea. By legislating for the new model of civil partnership, new issues are being brought to light requiring us to look at the workings and implications of existing legislation and this Bill in particular.

The principle I am standing up for today is not necessarily a principle on which I would intend to rely. The fact that I worked for the church in the past is being allowed to muddy the debate because people are focusing on the idea that the exception comes from a particular quarter. The principle I am defending is the idea that a person with whom I may disagree——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is making a Second Stage speech.

Comment on this

Genuinely, I am not.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator spoke for half an hour before this and has been on his feet for another ten minutes. The Senator should stick to the amendments.

Comment on this

I shall try. I assure Senators I am not in any sense trying to filibuster. A number of profound issues arise.

Comment on this

The Senator is making a Second Stage speech.

Comment on this

Senator O'Toole respectfully suggested that the amendment is tantamount to a bottle of smoke and that there is no real mischief which it seeks to remedy. It is my view that the amendment seeks to pre-empt a possible mischief that might arise. I offer the amendment in sincerity to the House and on the basis that we are moving into a multicultural society within which we must begin to contemplate issues of conscience. It is precisely as a result of the multicultural nature of our society that in the future people will hold views or whatever that will differ from the prevailing morality. That morality will probably be very secularised in nature.

On the issue of sexual orientation and same-sex relationships, I am of the view that society does not have a settled opinion. For the foreseeable future, there will be a majority and a minority in respect of this matter. There are two roads which can be taken from the point. One can decide to impose the morality of the majority and state that anyone who dares to differ therefrom should not work in the Civil Service. On the other hand, one can try to tack with the changing circumstances that prevail to discover whether there is a means by which people of a different ethos can be accommodated. We must also ask whether we can allow people who hold a different ethos to function as respected members of society or as employees of the State without coercing them in some way and without frustrating the State's ability to get the job done.

Comment on this

On a point of order, did the Senator not make this argument already?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, he did.

Comment on this

The Senator is citing case law. As he is well aware, apart from anything else, hard cases make bad law. I am of the view that Senator Mullen is being repetitive.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is being repetitive.

Comment on this

The Chair should put the question.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask Senator Mullen to make his point to the Minister. There is no need for him to travel all over Europe to underpin his argument.

Comment on this

It is difficult for people to understand that there are some issues which are of profound importance to some members of society. Senators Ó Murchú and Walsh and I have received a great deal of correspondence in respect of this matter. Much of its was sent by people who do not understand from where we are coming and just as much came from those who are of the view that this is a civilisational issue that deserves careful attention, especially as it goes to the heart of the question whether we will allow freedom of opinion and conscience in our society.

Alexander Solzhenitsyn, who lived much of his life under a regime based on the denial of the authentic rights of conscience, once stated that those who clearly recognise the voice of their own conscience usually recognise also the voice of justice. I mention this because conscience is being denigrated in this debate as something that will allow narrow-minded people to be awkward. The history of conscience and conscientious objection is much more about people, such as Martin Luther King Jr., who stood against laws because of principles they ultimately believed to represent the common good. I sincerely believe that the common good is best served by allowing people with different values to function to the greatest extent possible, subject to the overriding need of the State to get the job done.

It is in that context that I ask Senator Regan, in particular, to at least consider that I may hold such a view without being a homophobic person. This really matters to me. To be accused of being homophobic when what one is trying to do is secure the common good for everyone in society is not acceptable. Nothing I am proposing would prevent civil partnership from working, particularly as it would be subject to the overriding ability of the civil registrar or superintendent to avoid delay.

Senator Alex White stated that my proposal emanates from a theocratic position. As I understand it, under a theocracy church leaders make the laws of the land. I am no theocrat. That is why I refer to religious and ethical concerns. We do not have a right to question from where people obtain their views and values. Nor do we have a right to assume that the only reason a person has a certain moral view is because some guy wearing a mitre has done his or her thinking for him or her. That is not the truth. The truth is that people form their own consciences according to the authorities they most respect and on the basis of the arguments they find most convincing. Let us forget notions of theocracy and say rather that there are people in our society who harbour different moral views. Let us try to facilitate these people to the greatest extent possible without frustrating our ability to get the job done. As I stated, let us try to legislate prospectively.

We should not worry about the fact that the registrars have not, for whatever reason, been lobbying the Minister. The tenor of this debate is one good reason they would not do so, particularly in the context of the reaction they would receive. I am not criticising the Minister in this regard but the general tone of the debate has not been good.

Comment on this

What the Senator has just said is both appalling and unfair.

Comment on this

I do not believe that is the case.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen should confine himself to the amendment. If he does not do so, I will put the amendment.

Comment on this

I am about to conclude.

Comment on this

It is a ten-minute conclusion.

Comment on this

Senator O'Toole raised the issue of conscience and the way in which Éamon de Valera dealt with it. In his book, The Begrudger’s Guide to Irish Politics, Breandán Ó hEithir characterised that whole incident in a chapter entitled——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

This has absolutely nothing to do with the amendment. The Senator should confine his remarks to the amendment.

Comment on this

I solemnly swear——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The amendment relates solely to registrars.

Comment on this
Fiona O'Malley Senator Fiona O’Malley Progressive Democrats

If this Chamber were a stage, Senator Mullen would be determined to remain on it.

Comment on this

The Senator is repeating what everyone has said. We already know what has been said.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen to continue, without interruption. The Senator should confine himself to the amendment.

Comment on this

We are approaching a stage where there are people in this House who will not even allow one to respond in respect of comments that have been made in respect of one.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen has had plenty of time to respond. He has been on his feet for 15 minutes and he spoke earlier for more than 30 minutes.

Comment on this

In a private conversation I had earlier with one of the officials, I indicated that people's stress levels increase when matters of this nature are dealt with in an overly heavy-handed way. Almost everything I have said in the past 15 minutes has been relevant. I remained on point but I accept that I may not have been as concise in my arguments as could have been the case. However, that is the nature of the beast. If one is determined to set one's face against detailed, reasoned argument, then one is on the road to dictatorship because one has given up one's ability to value such an argument.

Comment on this

The only dictator here is Senator Mullen.

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Senator Mullen to continue, without interruption. The Senator should confine his remarks to the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not ask colleagues to accept my arguments in an unthinking way. I merely request that they consider and reply to them without denigrating me and others.

In concluding, I ask the Minister to inform me how, in view of its tight scope, the amendment before the House could possibly offer carte blanche to the people on the list to which he referred. There is not a single item on that list which could be contemplated in the conscientious objection clause as I have drafted it. Why is it not the prerogative of the Oireachtas, as the State Legislature, to contemplate our new society and the issues which arise in respect of it? In view of the exemptions contained in the equality legislation, why should we not, in a tightly drawn way, facilitate one group in society — which may possibly be small or which may not, as yet, have manifested itself — without treating its members as bigots and while also ensuring the State can get the job done at the same time?

Comment on this

Will the Leas-Chathaoirleach confirm that the Order of Business states that all Stages must conclude at 5.30 p.m.?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Order of Business does not state that. It says that the proceedings shall be adjourned not later than 5.30 p.m. The debate is, therefore, open ended.

Comment on this

We are dealing with No. 15 of 77 amendments. I had not intended to contribute to the debate on Committee Stage. What I had feared would happen, namely, the making of circular arguments, has come to pass.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator should confine his remarks to the amendment.

Comment on this

I am speaking about the process and I will address the amendment. This is the only occasion on which I have contributed to the debate on Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am aware of that. However, we must confine ourselves to discussing the amendment.

Comment on this

Certain other Members have spoken for 30 minutes at a time.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Changing the Order of Business is a matter for the Leader.

Comment on this

As far as I and my party are concerned, if a motion is tabled to the effect that the question should be put, then that motion must be given active consideration. We cannot continue with this process for hours, days or weeks.

On amendment No. 15, the practicalities involved have been well argued by the Minister. I do not doubt the sincerity of those who moved the amendment. I am of the view that they genuinely believe in the veracity of the argument they are making. I wish to address the effect of that argument. There seems to be an implication that there are people with conscience and people without conscience. That might be too broad a generalisation but that it exists at all is offensive. Even in its narrowest sense, the implication is that there are those who possess a more developed sense or higher form of conscience and that this is better than the form of conscience possessed by others. That is offensive. The further implication is that there are people who want to apply their sense of conscience specifically to people with a certain lifestyle and sexual inclination and that this would salve their conscience, regardless of the effects on other members of the community. As the Minister said, the further implication is that public servants could address their public service roles in an à la carte manner without having to apply the law, as passed by this and the other House, directly and even-handedly. That is offensive, regardless of the sincerity with which the argument is made, how genuine those who believe in the argument are, how the argument is heard or represented. I suggest my speech will be well short of the average length of the contributions made on Committee Stage.

Comment on this

Well short.

Comment on this

The record of the House on Committee Stage will be grossly unrepresentative of the nature of the contributions made on Second Stage. I am confident, however, that we will win the eventual vote at the end of these proceedings which should finish this week. Any attempt to prolong the process or engage in the type of——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That has nothing to do with the amendment. It is a matter for the Leader of the House. We are on amendment No. 15.

Comment on this

It is directly related to the amendment.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is not.

Comment on this

I will explain how it is related. We are addressing amendment No. 15, the debate on which has taken up most of the time of the House on Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Some 77 amendments have been proposed to the Bill which has over 200 sections. I ask the Senator to confine his remarks to amendment No. 15.

Comment on this

I am addressing it particularly. I remind the Chair of the brevity of this contribution and that is the only time I will come in on the amendment. The disproportionate amount of time we have spent on it — we have spent more time on it than on any other — has eaten into the amount of time we will have to discuss the other amendments. If we were to list all of the remaining sections and amendments that have yet to be discussed, we would not reach the allocated time of 5.30 p.m. During the rest of this debate and in the light of the overwhelming willingness of the Members of this House to have the legislation passed we will need to give serious consideration to how we should make progress with this Bill.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is a matter for the Members who may wish to speak.

Comment on this

I have a great deal of sympathy for what Senator Boyle said. Perhaps we will have to approach the issue in another fashion. On the amendment, I said on Second Stage that I thought the proposal to introduce a conscience clause was a contrivance.

Comment on this

I have not spoken this morning and will not detain my colleagues for very long. Nothing I have heard in the last three hours has persuaded me that what I said on Second Stage was wrong. This proposal is a complete contrivance because it is based on the perception that classes of people may require to exercise an objection. The point made by the Minister in his intervention ten or 15 minutes ago was bang on. We should consider his clear statement that "nowhere in existing legislation" have we provided for public officials to opt out from implementing the laws passed by these Houses. The point made by him in his timely intervention on our codes and laws is absolutely the case for very persuasive and compelling legal, constitutional and democratic reasons. Of course, it is true.

I accept the genuineness of what Senator Ó Murchú said about people having their views. He may not have meant it to come across as slightly patronising when he said he was prepared to let people have their views. However, there is a corollary to the holding of that position. One cannot say, "I do not mind if people are gay, or want to live in a particular way," unless one is also prepared to include in law a means by which such persons can vindicate their right to live in such a manner; for example, with whoever they like. I heard an interview with Senator Mullen — I think it was on radio — in which he was pressed on this issue which has come up time and again in terms of motivation. He said he believed people who were homosexual absolutely had a right to their dignity.

Comment on this

I said they had their dignity.

Comment on this

He has said they have their dignity, as if that is something that requires to be conceded to them by him.

Comment on this

No. It is because people have been calling my motivation into question.

Comment on this

I will not be interrupted.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator White to continue, without interruption, on the amendment.

Comment on this

I ask Senator White not to misrepresent what I said.

Comment on this

I will not be interrupted.

Comment on this

The Senator is trying to demonise me.

Comment on this

There is no question——

Comment on this

He ought to be ashamed of himself.

Comment on this

——of being prepared to concede——

Comment on this

He is just like his colleagues.

Comment on this

——that people have their dignity——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen should allow Senator White to address the amendment.

Comment on this

——without being prepared to include in law a means and a method by which their rights can be vindicated. That is the point I would like to make genuinely to Senator Ó Murchú. It is at the heart of this debate. One cannot have one without the other. In a democracy one cannot say in all fairness and honesty that it is fine for people to be gay and to want to live with somebody of the same sex without also providing for laws that allow that to occur. Senator McDonald made the same point eloquently earlier in this debate. That contradiction is at the heart of this proposal.

Comment on this

The Senator should read the amendment.

Comment on this

I will refer to the wording of the amendment. One of the provisions in the amendment is very telling. It refers to protecting registrars who raise an objection, as long as it "is not based on any of the discriminatory grounds identified in section 3, subsection (2), paragraphs (a), (c), (e), (f), (g), (h), (i) of the Equal Status Act, 2000”. That is the section of the Act that lists the prohibited grounds, including sexual orientation. How could the objection of a mythical registrar to registering a civil partnership not offend against the law that states there should be no discrimination against people of a particular sexual orientation? What else would the objection be based on? It could not be made on any other ground. Such an objection would constitute a direct form of discrimination. If I am wrong in that regard, I suggest it would certainly constitute indirect discrimination. How could it be otherwise?

As Senator McDonald said, this proposal would be a charter for discrimination. It does not stand up in any respect. This bogus notion is supposedly being proposed to accommodate those who hold a different moral position. In a democracy one debates what the laws governing state services should be, but one cannot play out the controversy every time the State delivers that service. The controversy should take place in Parliament and public when one is deciding what the solution is. One draws up a law on that basis. That law cannot be implemented, or not implemented as the case may be, on the basis of the views of a person providing the service. That is not how democracy works. One plays out the issues in public and Parliament and then one makes one's decision. I think Senator Mullen understands this. I do not intend to stray into the area of questioning people's motivation. Senator Mullen is intelligent enough to understand precisely what I am saying. I will set out the central contradiction. Perhaps "flaw" is too marginal or benign a word. The central dishonesty——

Comment on this

——is that it can be nothing other than an attempt to attack, undermine and set aside the basic objective of the legislation. It should be opposed absolutely. I thank the Minister for being so clear in his opposition to this provision which we should reject. If it is order to do so, I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach to put the question now.

Comment on this

I want to intervene on the same basis as Senator White. Before I do so, I genuinely do not believe Senator Mullen is homophobic. I accept that completely.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

To a certain extent, this is a battle in which Senators are engaged on the issue of freedom of conscience, but there is a bigger battle to be fought on what are probably more difficult ethical issues that will come down the line in years to come.

Comment on this

That is partly true. There is a principle at stake.

Comment on this

In his last intervention the Senator clearly indicated that he had foreseen that there would be difficulties in this respect. Most people would accept there might be issues coming down the line, in respect of which freedom of conscience may very well be examined. However, we are dealing with the issue of civil partnership which we all accept is a reality. The Senator's amendment would for the first time set a precedent, whereby a public servant could discriminate on the grounds of sexual orientation. That is specifically stated in the amendment. Section 3(2)(d) of the Equal Status Act 2000 includes what is known as “the sexual orientation ground”. The Senator has gone even further, saying a refusal or objection on the grounds of sexual orientation or marital status would not be deemed to be discrimination.

Comment on this

I disagree with the Senator because clearly that would set up the possibility that a public servant could opt in or out as he or she so wished. I made the point that one could not run a country on that basis, that on issues such as this, particularly to do with sexual orientation or marital status, people would have the right to opt in or out as they so wished.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am satisfied the amendment has been debated adequately in the House.

Comment on this

An issue was raised that needs a response.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the amendment being pressed?

Comment on this

May I respond briefly?

Comment on this

It would not be to the credit of the House——

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is section 22 agreed to?

Comment on this

I am pressing the amendment.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I put the question. The Senator is too late.

Comment on this

I was raising a point of order and not whispering.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

After I have put the question, I cannot take a point of order.

Comment on this

I asked to raise a point of order before the Leas-Chathaoirleach put the question.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I put the question and it was dealt with.

Comment on this
Senators

Vótáil.

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Will the Senators claiming a division please rise?

Senators Feargal Quinn, Rónán Mullen and Shane Ross rose.

Comment on this
Pat Moylan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

As fewer than five Members have risen, I declare the question carried. The names of the Senators dissenting will be recorded in the Journal of Proceedings of the Seanad.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

This section is opposed by Senators Hanafin, Ó Murchú and Walsh. I call Senator Walsh.

Comment on this

I will be reasonably brief. I note from the explanatory memorandum that section 23 imposes a fine of €2,000 or imprisonment of up to six months on a registrar who is in breach in regard to registration. I do not know whether it goes further than applying to registrars.

There are three parts to the conscience issue. There are religious bodies, with which we will deal later as we have tabled an amendment in regard to them, registrars or the employees of the State and service providers. In regard to service providers, if I had a premises such as a hotel which provided a service and I was approached by a couple who wished to celebrate their civil partnership in it, I would have no difficulty allowing them to have their celebration there and I would gladly take their money. Balancing the anti-discrimination side with freedom of conscience is an important issue in this respect.

While I am taken with what has been said, if an employee of the State in particular does not comply with the legislation, surely there is provision under industrial relations procedures to deal with that. I have concerns about criminalising such non-compliance in cases where people could have a very genuine conscientious objection. We must try to see if we can allow for that. I could not find a way as to how we might allow for it without there being a feeling of some form of discrimination. It was for that reason we thought that not criminalising it might be a better approach.

Comment on this
John Gerard Hanafin Senator John Hanafin Fianna Fáil

I agree with what Senator Walsh said. I am very conscious of the allowance that is made in the UK for nurses who, on conscientious grounds, will not perform or be involved in the performance of an abortion. How can we have a situation where we would criminalise people for genuinely conscientiously held reasons? It appears to be excessive and very wrong. The issue goes beyond the fine or term of imprisonment of six months. It is at the core of what Senator Labhrás Ó Murchú eloquently spoke on during the Order of Business on an occasion. The section imposes penal laws on people who have genuinely held beliefs. Such actions will not promote the liberal agenda. For the remainder of the debate it would be useful if people spoke on what we believed rather than what they think we believe.

Comment on this

I made my views on this issue known before the Bill was brought before the House and I still feel the same way. There are Senators in the House who may not necessarily take the same view as we do on some issues and who may have certain reservations about the Bill which I hope can be revisited. Criminalising somebody in this way would serve no purpose. It generally has a counter effect. In this case we would be as well off not to include such a provision in the Bill.

Comment on this
Joe O'Toole Senator Joe O’Toole Independent

I am happy to take the opportunity to speak to the amendment which goes to the core of some of the arguments made, some of which have been disgraceful. It is pure scaremongering; the arguments made have no basis in fact or law. I went to the trouble of checking after I heard what Members had to say yesterday. The amendment would change the 2004 Act which deals with the issue of criminalisation. Under the Act, on summary conviction, a person is liable to a fine of up to €2,000 or a term of imprisonment of up to six months for deleting, altering or procuring the deletion or alteration of information on the register, keeping or procuring information on the register on a computer and changing it. There is a list of wrongdoings and actions specifically taken to corrupt the process of registration, in other words, there is a wilful act in breach of the law which covers all such eventualities.

The section being opposed adds a new offence and I would like the House to listen carefully. It deals with a registrar who refuses to registers a civil partnership. I would like Senator Walsh to listen to this. It reads: "A registrar who without reasonable cause either fails or refuses to give a civil partnership form shall be guilty of an offence". Somebody has to say, therefore, that there was not reasonable cause. There can be a range of responses to the offence, but if one takes it that the range will have to be reflected in the judgment of the court — this would be the least serious of a series of offences — this is not something that should worry decent people; it is not something about which we need to worry. It does not mean somebody who fails to give a civil partnership form will be criminalised and thrown into jail. A person will first have to be asked why he or she did something. Perhaps that is why Senator Walsh asked why there was no provision for a human resources approach. There is. The first question to be asked is: "Why did you do it?" Somebody will then have to decide that there was not reasonable cause. This does mean somebody will be thrown into jail or fined €2,000. One could argue the provision is excessive, an argument to which I am prepared to listen but not agree with, as I can see the point of it. However, it is wrong to give the impression that somebody who fails to act on the basis of conscience or any other will suddenly winds up in jail. That is not the case.

Comment on this

I do not want to be controversial in my remarks, but there is something inherently wrong with this debate when we compare the celebration of a same-sex union with a person's objection to carrying out an abortion. When a person who puts them on the same level says he is not homophobic, there is an inherent contradiction. Much of the debate on the Bill has skewed completely from what it seems to be about. There is a need, therefore, for the Senators who oppose the Bill to tighten their arguments on what their objections are and not use emotive language while debating the issues involved and not make such a direct link. They should make their points on the ethos of a church or religious institution but stay away from making such comparisons.

Comment on this

We support section 23 which is very straightforward. The arguments in favour of it have been made. Senator Alex White has made the same point. The sanctions are included in section 20 of the 2004 Act and section 23 simply extends them to cover civil partnership registration and the work of a registrar in that regard. It is appropriate that we do this. I do not think we will ever see anyone being prosecuted or penalised for breaching the provisions of the section which has been in place since 2004 and there was no objection to it at the time. This is a red herring, a non-issue and an attempt to destabilise and undermine the Bill. It is time we moved on because the Bill has the broad support of the overwhelming majority of Senators.

Comment on this

I agree with the Bill and will be voting in favour of it. That does not mean we have to agree with every single point, part or section of it. I disagree with virtually everything that has been said about this clause on both sides of the House. An offender under the section can go jail and be fined an enormous amount of money. I have just read it and may be open to correction. The person concerned is being put in the category of a criminal, which is completely different from the offence which he or she has supposedly committed. The other offenders under the 2004 Act all actively commit offences such as fraud which is obviously something which not only has to be discouraged but also punished. I understand in this case, based on what Senator O'Toole said, that when a person "without reasonable cause" — a very subjective judgment — fails to do something, he or she is committing an offence. It is when someone fails to do something which is part of his or her job that he or she is committing an offence. The idea that for not doing one's job for whatever reason — I do not want to discuss the issue of conscience because I do believe there is a case to be made for conscientious objection which is impossible to define — a person can be put into jail is utterly wrong. There should even be such a possibility——

Comment on this

On a point of order, it is already included in the 2004 Act.

Comment on this

I do not care about that. It was wrong then and it is wrong now. That is the point. Just because it is included does not make it right. The Senator knows this perfectly well.

Comment on this

Propose an amendment.

Comment on this

It is obvious that this is an inappropriate punishment. The appropriate punishment in this case is simple: people should be dismissed from their jobs — end of the story. I do not know if people in the private sector are put in jail when they do not do their job. It only happens when they commit an offence such as theft, show disloyalty or do something which is against the law. We are creating a new offence of not doing one's job which is utterly wrong. We hear a lot about others possibly being sent to jail, but that this will happen to people in the public service is unacceptable. To be told it is unlikely to happen is totally unconvincing. I agree it is unlikely to happen, but to suggest people should be locked up for not doing their job is extreme. On this issue only I am prepared to vote against the Government. I appeal to the Minister to consider amending this provision in a reasonable way because it is not convincing to say it is impossible for this to happen. It is possible; it is the law. Judges can make completely different decisions for different reasons. The idea that someone in the public service should go to jail because he or she has said, for whatever reason, that he or she will not do his or her job is utterly wrong. Let us fire them or leave them to be subject to the normal process of employment law. Let us not send him or her to jail.

Comment on this

By opposing section 23 I hope to achieve a similar goal to my previous amendment. Whereas I had attempted to define "reasonable cause" so as to leave the offence in place while giving a person room to avoid being deemed to have committed an offence, I oppose the section because the severe punishments it sets out are inappropriate in the context of registration of civil partnership. As far as I am aware, if an official fails to comply with the law in the North, he or she may lose his or her job but would not be liable for criminal prosecution.

Senator O'Toole argued there is no basis in fact or law for what is being claimed. I demur at the use of the word "disgraceful" to describe not only the issue but also by implication the motivation of the people who put forward the amendment. I dissent from such an approach to the argument. Senator O'Toole is incorrect to claim there is no basis in fact or law for what is being claimed by the proponents of this amendment. There is the possibility of an offence which covers a range of transgressions. Nothing in the legislation excludes a possible offence in this context from the most severe of the penalties. The Senator may have an arguable case that there is no basis in fact on the grounds that this area has not seen many prosecutions, although he appeared to be looking into the crystal ball when he suggested there never would be a basis in fact.

Comment on this
Joe O'Toole Senator Joe O’Toole Independent

No, I am not. It is not there.

Comment on this

He is certainly wrong to say there is no basis in law because the law clearly provides for this possibility. It is no argument to say "trust us", which is the essence of Senator Bacik's intervention. We are here to legislate for situations that may not have occurred in the past but which might occur in the future. We must have an eye for the changing trends in society and possible future examples of intolerance on the secular side, just as there was in the past intolerance on the religious side. This is why we have to think out the future. To paraphrase G.K. Chesterton, let us not be so open minded that we let our brains fall out. We must predict what is going to happen.

The opponents of this section do not have to meet a high threshold. They merely have to show that, for the avoidance of doubt, it would be preferable to exclude the possibility that a person would face such severe sanctions for a transgression of this nature. To my mind, they have discharged that obligation persuasively and I will support them.

Comment on this

I was about to make a point that I have discussed with Senator O'Toole but I think he is the better person to make it.

Comment on this

Senator Ross is totally wrong. This is not a simple question of someone not doing his or her job. The offence is unlawful discrimination and, worse still, it would be committed by a public servant acting in an official capacity. This is why sanctions are needed to prevent such discrimination.

Senator Mullen used the term "reasonable cause", which is contained in the Act. If I understand him correctly, he is saying sexual orientation is reasonable cause to discriminate where the registration involves a gay or lesbian couple. This brings us back to the hostility against gay and lesbian couples which, as far as I can see, is inherent in this and other amendments.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. Well said.

Comment on this

I support this section. It is appropriate that jail is the ultimate sanction in our penal code. A person who threatens to kill somebody can be imprisoned for life but he or she would more commonly receive a suspended sentence or two years in jail. That is an example of the sliding scale and the evidentiary process. When a public official makes a mistake or discriminates against another individual in the course of his or her duties, he or she will be subjected to the rigours and fair process of the disciplinary system. In a worst case scenario, where the discrimination is so blatant and terrible that it warrants jail, that would have to be considered in the final analysis. Generally speaking, however, that road has never been followed.

I do not agree with Senator Ross's assertion that people cannot go to jail for not doing their jobs. At issue here is an official who performs a public duty by marrying same-sex couples. It is not sufficient that discriminatory practices would merely result in the perpetrator losing his or her job and continuing these practices in a new position until, perhaps, the penny drops that he or she requires a conversion on the road to Damascus. If one has a problem with same-sex couples getting married, one should not be a registrar but one should not discriminate.

Comment on this

In other jurisdictions around the world where minorities have suffered, tough legislation was needed to stop discrimination. Before the Equal Status Act came into force, Travellers were refused service in many bars. Now, however, they can go into bars and they behave themselves. I appreciate there are times when everything is not okay but if the sanction was not available we would never have taken that quantum leap. We must move away from the word "tolerance" and begin to accept all minorities in society.

We are debating a phantom minority which does not exist. We say minorities need to be protected because we are navel gazing or wondering what will happen in the future. We will deal with the future when it comes but, right now, we are dealing with a minority whose rights have been trampled on for decades and who were criminals in this country 16 years ago. We need to move on with this legislation and put the section to a vote. I accept Senator Walsh's bona fides in opposing the section but it is my right to disagree with him. We need to move on to vindicate the rights of the minority we are here to protect.

Comment on this

Like Senator McDonald, I do not agree with the opposition to the section. It is just a red herring or a pretext for the wider opposition to the Bill. Public officials, by their very nature, are good people who carry out their duties to the highest standard. Those who work in the public service do not and, I hope, would not seek the freedom to ignore State policy. This Bill is going to become State policy. If they had that freedom, the machinery of the State would grind to a halt and we would become a banana republic.

Job descriptions change from time to time. We have all taken on added responsibilities or covered new areas at some point in our working lives. ICTU or another source would have sought an amendment or protocol to the Bill if there were any such concerns about persons performing their duties. I agree with Senator McDonald that a person who is not capable, on the basis of conscience or otherwise, of treating everyone equally and with dignity and respect should not be a registrar.

Comment on this

I have not spoken much on this topic. This issue has been simplified and speakers have not recognised that some people have real problems with the section. It has been argued that job descriptions change from time to time. When this occurs, people are disciplined or, as Senator McDonald stated, disciplinary procedures are pursued. If someone does not obey the outcome of a disciplinary procedure, he or she is usually sacked. Senator Ross is correct on that point. This matter is different, however, because we are creating law which will last. I am concerned about the use of terms such as "it is highly unlikely" or "generally speaking". Relying on improbabilities or generalities does not make good law.

If we do not remove the section, a person who commits an offence because of a change in his or her job description could go to jail. While I accept that such a scenario is highly unlikely, I am not in favour of making laws which rely on generalities or improbables. As Senator Ross noted, the solution is to dismiss those who do not do the job they are supposed to do.

Comment on this
John Gerard Hanafin Senator John Hanafin Fianna Fáil

I concur with Senator Quinn. If a scenario is highly unlikely or does not feature on the agenda, why is it provided for in the Bill? It seems the purpose of the section is to be penal in the sense of penal law, in other words, vindictive. The approach appears to be one that those who do not agree with our view will be made to pay for it.

It appears I am not allowed to use an example unless it is pari passu. This does not happen at times but it accentuates the point. I ask the Minister to address two points. If it is acceptable in the United Kingdom for a nurse to be allowed to decline to perform her duty as prescribed by law, why is a similar scenario — a decision taken in conscience and not necessarily provided for in the Act — not acceptable? I have requested a schedule of cost for the legislation and ask the Minister to provide such a schedule to show the cost of the Bill in the next three to five years.

Comment on this

Apart from his preamble on the motives of people who hold a contrary view to his own, Senator O'Toole hit on something for which I felt like cheering him. On examination, however, I believe he is incorrect because having discussed this point with the Minister, we left the meeting believing there was a possibility that someone would go to jail in this context. I will be pleased if it transpires that I am wrong and Senator O'Toole is able to show this is not the case because this is the only aspect of the Bill on which I have spoken, whether on the Order of Business or at other times. I continue to make the same point on this section. If, as most people argue, the scenario provided for is unlikely, it is not necessary to include it in the legislation. Senator Hanafin went further and asked why the section is included in the Bill. If it does not serve a purpose and we are not trying to send out some type of message and wish to continue to implement legislation in the right spirit, it would be better not to have a provision of this nature in the Bill.

Comment on this

I know lay people who are much more religious than I am and hold conscientious views on matters which they believe infringe on their beliefs and the teachings of their religion. I can envisage such persons being caught by this provision. I assumed — perhaps I was wrong — that the words "without reasonable cause" would not cover such persons. Perhaps the Minister will clarify this matter, on which there have been discussions among officialdom. If a person found himself or herself in the circumstances described, will it be possible to accommodate him or her to ensure he or she is not criminalised? I do not mind if a person is suspended for a week or transferred to another Department.

I do not disagree with anything Senator McDonald said about discrimination. What we are trying to do is reconcile two competing priorities, namely, the need to ensure people are not discriminated against and the need to accommodate genuine freedom of conscience. I know the latter is difficult to determine. If the Minister is able to give me any comfort on this matter, I would take a different view on opposing the section.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Mullen is indicating.

Comment on this
Joe O'Toole Senator Joe O’Toole Independent

The Senator has spoken since I last spoke. I would like to respond to his comments as he challenged my views.

We need to examine what is happening here because it is a little like the invasion of Afghanistan when the Russians stated they were invited into the country. The group of people the amendment is rushing to protect does not want our protection. The individuals in question are doing their job, are aware of the issue given that it has been widely reported in the newspapers yet not one of them has said he or she needs our protection. Some of us are determined to give it to them in any case. We are rushing to help people who do not want to know. The last thing they want to see is a group of politicians rushing at them, as it were.

We need to consider this issue in real world terms. Important issues have been raised by a number of speakers, including Senator Quinn. To assist Senator Mullen and others, I will read again what is written in the section. It will apply to a registrar "who, without reasonable cause, fails or refuses to give a civil partnership registration form to one of the parties". What happens before one reaches this point is the human relations aspect of the process to which Senator Walsh referred. If someone working in an office indicates to his or her boss that he or she is not prepared to carry out civil partnership functions or weddings, the boss then has a job to do, namely, find a local arrangement, transfer, sack or suspend the person or find another solution. We must bear in mind that a crime has not been committed and a human resources procedure is followed before one proceeds further. When someone refuses to carry out a function it must be dealt with locally. Sacking the person, as some Senators have suggested, could be much more costly than the maximum fine of €2,000 provided for in the section. The action taken will depend on the local arrangements in place. At that point, the civil registrar may simply refuse to carry out his or her function.

Why do we need the provisions of the section? It is not only a matter of scale, as a number of speakers suggested, but also one of aggravating circumstances. In many cases, a gay couple will not have a great deal of self-confidence in dealing with public matters of this nature. Not only could they be deprived of the civil partnership registration form, there could be aggravating circumstances, for instance, they could be led to believe that it is not possible for them to enter into a partnership or a form could be lost. The scale provided for is necessary to address such aggravating circumstances.

The issue is not one of a person refusing to hand over a piece of paper or sign a form but one of discrimination. I ask Senator Mullen or another opponent of the Bill to put a price on discrimination. At what point does a continuing contravention of the law by discriminating against a person fail to be important? If someone continues to hold an unlawful position, should we back off? While I do not envisage such a scenario, I am being forced to bring the hypothetical case to its conclusion. If there are aggravating circumstances, we must be able to measure them in terms of the response of the law. We are depriving a citizen of a legal right — rights we are putting in place with this legislation. Someone is being discriminated against. Someone is being deprived of his or her rights. Someone is not applying the law we are passing. Someone may not have dealt with this or agreed with any arrangement that was made previous to this in his or her office, whatever HR arrangements were there. This is all the background stuff. Things do not happen like that. As there is always a story behind a story, how would we get to it?

The other issue is moral hazard. The idea that we could put into legislation that someone can refuse to do an aspect of his or her job is inviting situations where people go forward. I am not talking about people with a conscientious objection; that may well be the case. I find it difficult to deal with that issue, but I am not talking about that. A parish priest described someone some time ago by saying "It's not that he had lost his religion; he was just too lazy to get up to go to Mass." I am talking about someone who is too lazy to do his or her job and claims to have a moral objection. That is a moral hazard. It would open issues which would make it impossible to control because someone could claim to have a conscientious objection. Someone who is lazy might not have any trouble telling lies or — I remind Senator Mullen about this — might have a mental reservation about it one way or another.

The serious point is that this is not something that happens like a bang. This is something that builds up. If someone working in an office or elsewhere, including in teaching, claims to have a difficulty about something or other, the boss needs to deal with it. If it cannot be dealt with, action needs to be taken. If action is not taken, it moves to a next step. If it is a minor thing that someone has refused to do his or her job, action should be taken about that.

Comment on this

If they do not, they can end up in prison. That is the point.

Comment on this
Joe O'Toole Senator Joe O’Toole Independent

We need to allow for aggravating circumstances. I will not hear anyone say that the refusal is simply refusing to hand out a form. I want to hear it said that this is discrimination and deprivation of a legal right we are putting in place. We need equality before the law. It is important we respond to it in that way. I do not want to and I do not believe I will ever see anyone go to jail as a result of this. However, I want people to know that we, in this House, value the rights of our citizens and will ensure they will be delivered for them. That is why it goes up that sliding scale. It is not as if someone makes a mistake and finishes up in jail. There are many steps in between.

Comment on this

Senator O'Toole has very adequately dealt with a number of points. I believe Senator Mullen indicated very honestly that this is, to a certain extent, a device for reopening the discussion that has been held already on——

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

He said something very close to it.

Comment on this

No, a million miles away. I shall explain in a minute.

Comment on this

Something very close to that was said. I shall leave it at that.

The Minister has largely dealt with these problems. Taking into account that this is a device for reopening the discussion of the subject matter of amendment No. 15 and because the wording of that amendment also includes marriage, it opens up the floodgates of Islamophobia, etc. There may well be cranks who would not give a civil partnership to people who are Muslim. That is a much greater possibility than the possibility of someone going to jail. I do not believe that anyone would go to jail. I think it is highly unlikely that this clause will ever need to be invoked in terms of the provision of service. I have just returned from the barber's shop. I have read reports in the newspapers that some people believe that hairdressers would be forced do weddings and civil partnerships. I asked in the barber's shop whether there would be any objection and everyone there fell around the floor laughing. It is so bloody absurd.

This is not a victimless crime. It is not just someone claiming he or she does not want to shuffle a piece of paper around. Senators should imagine themselves in the situation of people who want to apply for a civil partnership, which they will be perfectly entitled to do under the law of this land, hopefully, after this evening, and are bluntly told: "No. Get lost. We're not doing it." What will their feelings be? This is really poisonous.

Senator Hanafin and several others have deliberately dragged in the idea of abortion. I now call on them publicly to clarify that and to make it absolutely clear that they are not equating in the slightest sense or in any way the performing of a civil ceremony for same-sex couples with the performing of an abortion. That must be clarified. It is so easy to throw around the word "abortion", which gets many people very steamed up. I want that issue to be clarified urgently.

I hope we will not have a repetition of what happened last night when on a series of amendments with exactly the same wording we were put through the necessity to vote.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That has nothing to do with the amendment.

Comment on this

The Cathaoirleach asked the Senators who had called for the vote to stand up. Members, who had never contributed once to the debate, came into the House and stood up to have a vote.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Norris——

Comment on this

That is acceptable on one occasion but not for the same amendment endlessly.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Norris, that has nothing to do with this amendment.

Comment on this

I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach to keep moving on and get the job done.

Comment on this