Social Welfare Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–202 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 2001 ›
I welcome the Minister and his officials, Tom Mulhern, Tim Quirke and Geraldine Gleeson. It is proposed to sit until 8 p.m. and to take a break at 5.30 p.m. Amendments Nos. 2, 33 and 49 have been disallowed because they involve a potential charge on the Revenue. A list has been circulated of proposed groupings of amendments.
SECTION 1.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 5, subsection (2), line 13, after "one" to insert "and may be cited together as the Social Welfare Acts, 1993 to 2001".
I thank the Minister and his officials for their briefing on the Bill. It was conducted at short notice in my case because I was debating the Carer's Leave Bill, 2000. The amendment is an old chestnut which we feel should be made. There are many references to the Social Welfare (Consolidation) Act, 1993. I have attended Committee Stage of the Social Welfare Bill for the past three years and this is my second attempt to have this amendment made. There is a widespread feeling that we are proceeding on an ad hoc basis in regard to social welfare legislation as evidenced by our receipt of an amendment by the Minister his morning.
The Minister will say the amendment is covered by section 3(8) of the 1993 Act but there remains a necessity to examine social welfare provision under more generic legislation. Everybody in opposition experiences difficulty when debating a Social Welfare Bill and preparing amendments. There is a feeling that the legislation is being rushed through, similar to the Finance Bill, at great speed. We are trying to facilitate its passage but the Opposition is not given much time. In other countries the civil service assists Opposition members in drafting technical amendments based on previous Acts. Unfortunately, this has not happened yet in our democracy. The two largest Bills each year are rushed through the Houses. This legislation is more important to the 900,000 social welfare recipients but it is being rushed through at breakneck speed because there will be a second Social Welfare Bill later in the year. The amendment is a reference to the necessity for further consolidation in this area, despite what the Minister might say about the 1993 Act.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister and his officials and look forward to working with them. This is the first time I have attended the committee. I thank you, Chairman, for allowing me to contribute to the debate, even though I have not taken up membership of the committee yet.
I support Deputy Broughan's amendment, which he also tabled last year. The various Social Welfare Acts since 1993 have been very complex and there is a need for consolidated legislation. The Minister made a commitment on this matter last year. A social welfare regime is needed whereby changes that are made every year can be easily understood.
While many of the headline changes were announced in the budget we are only getting to debate them in late February and early March. That is unsatisfactory from a parliamentary point of view. The process in which we are engaged requires a guillotine on the passage of the legislation at the end of March so that the new changes can be implemented in the first week of April, which I welcome. However, because there is a guillotine it is very difficult to have an effective input to the major policy changes in this legislation.
There is a need for greater consolidation. There will be a great deal of confusion this year and next year given the changes that will occur in social welfare provision such as the short tax year in 2001, an additional Social Welfare Bill in the autumn and the euro changeover. Consolidation is needed and Deputy Broughan's amendment would be a useful instrument in achieving that.
Comment on this
As I said last year, my advice is there is no need for this collective citation. It is already contained in section 3(8) of the 1993 Act. Work has begun on consolidation and we do not expect it to be finished until next year. However, the work on consolidation is ongoing.
Comment on this
Could the benchmarking process be used for a more consolidated approach? I understand an interim report will be published. The point Deputy Hayes and I make in regard to the variety of schemes administered by the Minister is valid. Last year on Committee Stage we discussed 44 or 45 major payments. For example, all backbenchers received the same information regarding the mobility allowance and we were all trying to track down the Minister responsible. Certain aspects of the social welfare system are upsetting at times, particularly payments to health boards and who ultimately carries the can for them.
Last night, for example, a delegation of health sector workers came to the House to see me regarding pension provision. They feel they are being short-changed as a result of amendments made in this area by the Minister. There is a necessity for a cleaner, simpler regime through legislation.
Comment on this
Consolidation merely brings together provisions of legislation into one Act - it neither adds nor subtracts in terms of provisions. Regarding benchmarking, it has specific terms of reference in relation to indexation of social welfare payments and I cannot see how it could be used as a vehicle to promote consolidation. In the planning section of the Department work is ongoing on bringing forward a consolidation Bill, but it is at a relatively early stage as there are quite a number of other issues on our agenda, with much planned legislation, as I indicated, which will take precedence.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 5, between lines 13 and 14, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the rationale for the differing commencement dates of social welfare payment increases.".
While I recognise there has been substantial progress this year in moving forward the dates of payment for many of the increases announced in the budget and included in the Social Welfare Bill, there is still a need to clear up the dates of operation for some of these changes. I refer specifically to child benefit, the increases in which will be effective from 1 June. We need one date upon which all increases are introduced. It would be churlish of me not to accept that there have been improvements this year, but the longer the period between the announcement and the increase, the more difficult it is. The Minister should bring child benefit in line with other increases in unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit. There are also tidying up difficulties regarding 4, 5 and 6 April, which should be considered by the Minister. I am particularly interested in child benefit and do not see why the increase cannot be brought forward to April.
Comment on this
I will repeat what has been said in the hope the Minister might at least take note of what we are saying. There are a number of dates for increases coming on stream, and it is very confusing for ordinary people. Last year there was a difficulty in terms of some of the free schemes coming into force in October. The amendment concerns providing a fixed date when all new schemes and increases can be brought on stream. Of course, the Minister will tell us what he has done, that he has brought certain dates forward, and no doubt we will get a history lesson in that regard outlining the marvellous job he has done. Nonetheless, a valid point can be made for all benefits and other changes, such as changes in income tax, to kick in at the same time. Last night, for example, the Minister announced a change in relation to stamp duty on the purchase of houses which came into effect from 14 February. Why can all changes not come on stream at the same time? From next year all welfare benefits will kick in from 1 January, and I hope this will include child benefit. In his speech on Second Stage the Minister was very good in setting out what child benefit would be payable in 2003 but he did not say when it would kick in. In Britain, increases in social welfare payments kick in from the week following their announcement. Their system is equally as complex as ours.
Comment on this
I do not care about the amount, it does not matter. They can announce and implement a change without having to wait months, and that could be done here if the will existed. Perhaps today the Minister will tell us they will all come on stream at the one time.
Comment on this
I support my colleagues in Fine Gael. It was deplorable that in Charles Haughey's time benefits and increases were delayed almost to the end of the year. The Minister has been recovering ground lost by predecessors from his party. The move to 1 January is very welcome. Unfortunately, the Minister has missed his key target of 1 January in relation to increases and is accepting that increases will not be paid as promised on that date. Therefore, a key election promise of Fianna Fáil has been broken by the Minister. It is regrettable that he has not kept to the timetable announced by the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, two years ago. When will child benefit increases be made next year? It seems the Minister will have to back-date all payments at this stage.
Comment on this
Minister, is Deputy Broughan's history lesson correct? Was it not the 1973-77 Government which should have been referred to?
Comment on this
It was not a Fianna Fáil Government which brought forward the budget from early February to early December in recent times, which in effect lengthened the period between the announcement of increases and receipt of them. It is wrong that social welfare recipients should have to wait so long for increases and we have endeavoured to set the dates as close to budget day as is humanly possible. When I came to office increases in payments were made in late June and early July, the dates adhered to by the previous Government. Benefit increases will now be paid on 5 April and next year they will be effective from 1 January. There are logistical problems because of the cycle of book payments etc.
Regarding the UK experience, I and my officials are not aware of what Deputy McGrath mentioned about the kicking in of benefits. Our understanding of their system is that they have a longer lead-in time. It may be that their announcement is more designed for PR than reality - perhaps the decisions and announcements were made previously and reannounced.
Regarding child benefit, in recent memory it has always been paid in September. This is the first Government to undertake to bring that progressively forward and in this year the changes will be effective from June. We hope that over following years we will progressively bring this date forward.
Deputy Broughan referred to an election promise. We did not make an election promise in relation to bringing payments forward, rather a decision was made during the lifetime of the Government to align the tax and social welfare years. We have gone even further than anyone anticipated by coming to 1 January. It is exactly the same regarding this amendment. Irrespective of what happens with the delivery of the increase, people will obviously continue to get their primary payment. They will also get their increases effective from 1 January irrespective of when they actually get them. That goes to the core of the amendment, to a certain extent.
Comment on this
It depends. If people go on electronic fund transfer, and quite a number of people are, they would get their payment on the due date. Obviously if people wish to get their payments on the due date they will be informed that this is the way to go. Anyone on a post office book, as Members will know from yesterday's Question Time, will need a six month period in which to implement the changes in those books. This is not an easy system and cannot be changed overnight. What we are trying to do, as Deputy Hayes has encouraged us to do, is to reduce the time between announcement and delivery.
Regarding the amendment, different commencement dates reflect the fact that some payments are made in advance, such as disability benefit and pensions, while others are made in arrears, such as unemployment benefit. Neither our system nor the post office would not be able to cope with everyone getting paid on the same day. Also, events such as unemployment and maternity take place on different dates for individual cases, so it would not be possible to deliver increases and payments on one date. While increases for this year are scheduled for different dates they are paid as and from the same week, 1 April 2001.
Comment on this
Why does this process take six months? Can the Minister do anything about resources so that it will not take that long to change? What is the problem? To clarify, when will child benefit be paid from next year?
Comment on this
Child benefit for this year will be paid from June. We have not made any decisions as those are obviously budgetary decisions which will be made at budget time. We have indicated already a substantial investment in child benefit. Not only did we increase it hugely to £25 and £30, we brought it back three months, which costs a substantial amount of money. If we did so progressively the cost would come out of the £330 million earmarked for next year and each following year.
Regarding the six month period, I am sure I offered committee members the chance to visit the printing works where all these books are produced by a commercial company. That company has had the contract for some time. When Deputy Woods was Minister he took us down to see how the system operated and the committee did not take up my request, to my surprise. It was a learning experience for me that time to see how the system works.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct that this year, given our good decision to bring the payments back to 1 January, there will be a delay in paying people and obviously resources will have to be put into ensuring that is lessened or eradicated in following years. The Government has agreed that that would be the case. The situation with a private company such as the one which has this contract is that it will not invest in more machines that would be lying idle for long periods, so obviously that is something we will have to negotiate with that company in the coming year.
Comment on this
Yesterday the Minister put quite an emphasis on the importance of child benefit when I raised the issue of child poverty. Given that child benefit is the main mechanism the Minister is using to tackle child poverty, would it not have made sense to bring the payments forward to an earlier date given the well documented level of both relative and consistent child poverty in Ireland relative to our EU neighbours? If that is the Minister's policy——
Comment on this
That is why we brought them forward. With the amount of money available we could have brought them forward a couple of months more but that would have reduced the overall amount we were giving people - the £25 and £30 - out of what was available. I have made the point in relation to other social welfare payments that one is better off giving people a higher increase over a 12 month period than reducing it. I accept what the Deputy says. She should accept that this costs £85 million for three months - from September to June - but it could go up because the amount will rise by over £300 million. That was the rationale, to bring this back progressively and Members should accept our bona fides on that.
Comment on this
The Minister has clarified that it costs approximately £85 million to implement the change we have outlined in this year's funds, so it is a money argument as against a bureaucratic or book argument. It is not really about books. If the issue is about money, it is about money and it would be fairer of the Minister to flag that to the committee as against saying it is about books. If we cannot design a system of payment which can get around this problem it says a lot about our commitment to IT and other changes in the workforce. If this is about money it makes the argument that much easier as I suggest to the Minister that it is then unfair that he should therefore, from April to June, not allow the changes he has already announced, in respect of child benefit, minimal as they are, to kick in. It is important to clarify the issue and I am glad the Minister did so but this is not really about book payments. One could possibly introduce a situation where in the first week of June the backdated amount of money adults and parents have lost as a result of the failure to implement the increase could not be brought about. This is easily done if the commitment is there, so this amendment has clarified for this side of the House the precise reason we cannot have commencement dates for these increases occurring at the same time.
Comment on this
Since I have arrived the Minister invited us on a junket to the printers. Even if we see the perspiration on the foreheads of people dropping with exhaustion to get these books out, what will that do to rectify the delay in getting the books out?
Comment on this
As I said earlier, it is to allow the committee members to understand the complexity of the situation involved.
Comment on this
By going there the Deputy will see and better understand exactly what is involved in this. Deputy Hayes referred to minimal changes. The minimal changes we have made to child benefit, if one can call them minimal, are far more excessive than the ones he and his party called for no less than six months ago. We have gone further——
Comment on this
It is not history; it is fact. We have gone further in relation to child benefit than any of the Opposition parties even sought. The facts speak for themselves.
With regard to post office books, they are the preferred option of the vast majority of social welfare recipients. There has been reluctance to opt for any other payment method. We deliver our payments in many different ways but the preferred one, by far, is the book. Much of that is to do with that fact that old age pensioners and widows, in particular, like to get out, go to the post office and enjoy the social interaction. They would not have that with EFT.
We must work with the system that exists. If we are to continue on the strategic route of bringing forward the payments as near to the date of decision, that is, budget day, as possible, we will have to ensure that the wherewithal is available to do it. However, we will also have to encourage whoever has the contract and give them the resources to deliver the books more quickly. Ultimately, there is no point trying to pull back the payment dates as near to budget day as possible unless there is the wherewithal to deliver the payments at that time.
Comment on this
This boils down to pounds and pennies. If the will was there, the Minister could do it by a number of methods. First, the Minister could pay them retrospectively. The money could kick in immediately and, as soon as the cheques and books are ready, the money would be paid for the period for which it is owed. Second, is it not beyond the ingenuity of officials in the post office, having been briefed on the increase, to pay the additional payments from the first day without the books being changed? It is easy to do that. As far as I know, that is what happens in Britain. People are paid as soon as the increase has been made.
Third, while the Minister says the preferred option of many people is the book, does the smart card system not operate in post offices? The customer's smart card goes through the post office machine, just like a credit card, and the assistant pays him or her the amount indicated on the screen. Why not extend that system? Eventually, the Minister could get rid of all books and operate on smart cards. The Department has far more control in that case and will be able to implement, almost instantly, the changes that occur. Might that not be a better way to invest the Department's money? In the longer term, it would eliminate the need for books.
Comment on this
There are plans to move towards the type of system suggested. The payments made by using the smart card are generally short-term payments, such as unemployment payments. There are plans to move towards an easier system and that is one of the reasons the company that has the contract for delivery of the books is not prepared to move too far down the line, particularly because there is also a general trend to move towards becoming a cashless society. Undoubtedly, EFT will become far more popular as the years pass.
We are caught between having a system that is preferred by the people - everybody wants to get "the book" - and the inevitable move toward the use of better technology. The preferred choice of my Department would obviously be electronic fund transfer which means that everybody would get his or her payment on the day. It would also cost a good deal less, as we discovered previously during debates on the issue of rural post offices. However, we must hasten slowly in this regard because there are implications down the line. There will be encouragement for people, in the changes we have made for 1 January, to opt for EFT if they want their payments on the due date.
Comment on this
In relation to commencement dates for maternity benefit and maternity leave, approximately 8,500 women missed out because the Minister did not opt for an earlier commencement date. He had the opportunity to do so, given that he was introducing the improvements to ensure women would benefit immediately. The issue of commencement dates is extraordinarily important. Many women are disappointed that they have lost out on these.
Comment on this
The Government made those welcome changes. It was not the fault of the Department that the changes could not be introduced earlier. The original decision by the Government was to introduce the changes - as would have been the case with any decisions made by the Fine Gael Party when it was in Government - on a date in the future. However, we decided to bring the date forward as quickly as possible. We were caught with the change of regulations in the maternity leave area. The regulations had to be changed before we could introduce the benefit, so there was a time constraint. While some people were disappointed when the announcement was made, it was made clear that it would date from 5 April and many more people qualified, who would not otherwise have done, when we brought the date forward from 5 April to 8 March.
Comment on this
I am not convinced by the Minister's arguments. If I were a cynic, I would suggest that the variety of dates, which stretch from April to June, could provide this Government with many opportunities to go to the polls either within that period or shortly afterwards. If the money is available to pay these increases, they should be paid now.
The Minister's argument on Second Stage was clear. He said increasing child benefit was a direct way to help families deal with the problem of child poverty. If that is the argument, the increases should be effective from 1 April. If the Minister gives a commitment that he can pay those families the difference between April and June, I will withdraw the amendment. It is hard to believe the suggestion that a private contractor is determining the methodology of payments because they have failed to come up with a means of providing books for people who receive their payments in that way. It is right and proper that people who will require additional resources from child benefit should receive those payments in April. This is a most important matter. I am not putting a frivolous or technical argument to the Minister. Payment is required now. If these changes cannot be made today, given the amount of money in the economy, when can they be made? This is an important point of principle so the amendment should be pressed.
Comment on this
I have two questions for the Minister. First, what is the total cost of printing the various books and so forth that are produced by the Department each year? The Minister probably does not have the figure - I knew I would catch the officials out somehow today.
Comment on this
Chairman, this is relevant. What is the cost and does it go to tender? I received an e-mail about maternity leave. The order was made on 8 February but it does not take effect until 8 March. Why was there a four week lead in period? Could the order not have been expedited from the day it was made? Was it necessary to have a four week lead in period? If so, why?
Comment on this
We may be wandering from the amendment. I think the order is made by the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform. Let us not wander too far from the amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister rightly congratulated staff regarding the recovery of a few hundred million pounds which were fraudulently acquired. Some commentators stated that the Department might owe arrears. I think it was Fintan O'Toole who commented on the difference in the manner in which we chase people who owe the State taxes and those who received social welfare payments to which they were not entitled.
The Minister has admitted on several occasions that he is going to miss his 1 January deadline. Will he be able to make this up in terms of interest payments to those on social welfare benefits who will receive increases on 1 January due to the introduction of the euro? These people will suffer for a number of weeks before the Minister pays them the arrears. Does he intend to make up the additional interest on the arrears to which these people might be entitled? He will miss the date for a range of book related payments and people might be entitled to certain money over weeks or months. How is the Minister going to make this up to them? He is not prepared to give the date next year on which child benefit will increase.
Comment on this
We must keep to the amendment. We are touching on later amendments. This amendment refers to dates.
Comment on this
It is obvious that Deputy Hayes does not recall 1997, which is not too long ago, when his party did nothing about bringing child benefit back from September and gave paltry £1 and £5 increases. These were unbelievably low increases at a time when money was available. The increase was £1 as opposed to £25. This year's increase is amazing.
Deputy Hayes may or may not be aware that there is only so much one can do in one year with a budget package of £850 million. He stated that the country is awash with money. However, there are constraints on the public finances and one has to cut the cloth to one's measure. Over a three year period we have undertaken to pay a substantial amount of money - £1 billion - in child benefit. The aim will be to bring the increases forward progressively as much as we can.
It would be wrong to be critical of the company which produces the books. It is not just a simple matter of printing a few books. This is a high security, high risk business. By and large, it has not gone wrong over the past number of years and credit is due to the company involved. Only two companies in Ireland have the wherewithal to deliver these books and this company is a past master at it. The printing contract is worth about £1.8 million.
I cannot say when I will introduce increases in child benefit. I am not going to give a date as this is a budgetary matter.
Comment on this
The Minister stated that there are constraints on public expenditure and that we all have to be responsible in respect of the amount of money spent in the economy. The Minister hates to be reminded of the fact that he went to his Cabinet colleagues late last year to try to obtain an additional envelope of money for people in this category and was dramatically turned down due to the effects of inflation. He understood, recognised and proposed the kind of dramatic increase in expenditure to deal with the crisis we had and continue to have. I am using the arguments the Minister used to his colleagues before he was so dramatically chucked out of the Cabinet room. It was one of the most humiliating blows suffered by the Minister.
This is an important amendment. We have the money and the resources. With a little additional IT comprehension we should be able to put in place the kind of regime which would allow people on relatively modest incomes to receive the increases back dated to April.
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy not to believe everything he reads in the papers. I will give him another history lesson. I have been more successful than any of my predecessors in getting progressive percentage increases in the social welfare budget. Last week the Deputy said he might have been in short trousers. I assure him he was not in short trousers three and a half years ago when his party's budgetary package was £215 million.
Comment on this
This budget amounts to £850 million - more than four times as large. Money is being dedicated to a pension fund for the future. That is where much of the money is going. We are putting money away for a rainy day. I hope the Deputy agrees with this decision and, unlike the Labour Party, does not want to raid that money. That is prudent government.
Comment on this
If the economy had not been managed successfully between 1994 and 1997 the Minister would not be in the position he is in today.
Comment on this
The Deputy's party did not deliver an iota to ordinary people. It gave £1.80 to old age pensioners. Shame on it. It also gave a £1 increase in child benefit. That was just three and a half years ago.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 5, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the increase in the consumer price index since the commencement of the Act of 2000, and the said report shall compare the percentage increases in payments set out in Schedules A and B to this Act with the corresponding provisions of the Act of 2000.”.
We discussed elements of this amendment in the previous debate. Before Christmas, the ESRI made an interesting report to the Labour Party which showed conclusively that last year, by the skin of his teeth, the Minister gave a very modest rise indeed. I do not want to go through history lessons but the effective inflation rate for most of last year was almost 7%, yet the Minister gave a very basic increase of £4. Even impartial State economists agree, however, that either there was no rise in basic rates last year or as regards some benefits and assistance payments, perhaps there was a tiny rise of literally 50p or £1, when one factors in the significant inflation.
As the Minister knows, inflation had a profound impact on public life last year. My colleagues in the trade union movement, particularly in SIPTU and IMPACT, were deeply upset at the way in which rampant inflation threatened to totally unhinge the PPF. The whole programme seemed to be under threat last September, as the Chairman will remember, and that was why I raised the matter at this committee. Workers had the trade union edifice to stand up for them and make the point, as Mr. Cassells, Mr. Geraghty, Mr. McAloone and others did very eloquently in September and October. They called on the Taoiseach to immediately instigate the review mechanism, whereby the PPF was effectively renegotiated. That happened because of a mechanism in the PPF which the trade unions had inserted so that workers' representatives would have an opportunity to re-examine the programme if inflation went ballistic, as it did, due to pressure from the falling euro. Social welfare recipients, however, have nobody except us to make the point for them.
Deputy Hayes is right in saying that towards the end of the year the Minister's friends in the media pushed out the story that he had asked the Cabinet for £74 million. He knew that despite all the bravado at this committee last year and during Dáil questions he had short-changed social welfare recipients who had lost out drastically due to inflation. The ESRI says that was the case. The Minister came in with his request for £74 million but he was told to get lost, perhaps by the Progressive Democrats wing of the Cabinet, led by the Ministers, Deputies McCreevy and Harney. They said they would not give any significant package such as was sought by this committee in January to make up the short-fall to social welfare recipients as we did for workers covered by the PPF. There is no such mechanism for social welfare recipients. I am walking in the footsteps of a former Minister, Deputy De Rossa, in asking the current Minister if it is possible to insert in the Bill some mechanism that would track inflation from now on.
Our entry into the euro zone has been a roller-coaster experience; we have been up and down, but mostly down. It is a helter-skelter ride and we really do not know where we are heading after the negotiations at Nice. I remember the major debate on the Nice treaty between the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Cowen, and Deputy John Bruton. We are not quite sure where it will lead. If the euro strengthens against sterling before a, hopefully, re-elected Labour Government can bring Britain into the euro zone, we could be faced with a difficult prospect later this year or next year.
Everybody appreciates that the £8 basic rate was not what most of the groups we met before Christmas wanted. Nearly everybody wanted a basic £14 increase, including the Combat Poverty Agency. The Minister granted an £8 rise but the Irish National Organisation for the Unemployed said that the minimum rise should have been £10 to allow for inflation last year. The Minister should have given £5 to make up for what was not granted last year and another £5 to cover this year. That would have amounted to £10 but the Minister did not do so and, therefore, he is running the same risk this year. We can no longer believe the Department of Finance's inflation projections. The Minister's Department is much more reliable in this regard.
While we have discussed this issue in a previous debate, we need some mechanism in the legislation which may be binding on the Minister and his successors. The Minister has given us a load of history lessons, but I do not want to go into the history of the issue again when the Minister responds.
One of the extraordinary aspects of the Minister's administration of his Department, which we will be drawing attention to in the forthcoming general election campaign, is the percentage of money spent on social protection as a ratio of the national income. It is officially the lowest in Europe. We used to be the second lowest after Luxembourg, but we have now gone to the bottom of the social protection league. I know these figures do not refer only to the social welfare budget, but Denmark spends up to 30% on social protection, while the United Kingdom and Finland spend 27%. Spain is the second lowest, spending only 21%. The Minister mentioned pension increases but the UK still spends a much higher proportion of national income on social protection programmes.
I studied economics and I know it depends on how one looks at the figures. Some of the Minister's officials have told me that this year social welfare spending is down to less than 7% of GDP. We need a mechanism whereby social welfare spending will keep pace with inflation. When I first became a member of this committee a couple of years ago I heard Deputy De Rossa eloquently arguing for such a mechanism because of the onset of the euro. The fact remains valid and the Minister should consider such a measure this year. Workers have eloquent and determined trade union leaders from SIPTU, IMPACT and other unions to stand up for them, but social welfare recipients have nobody but Deputies, including the Minister.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. My amendment No. 2, which is similar, was ruled out of order for reasons that I now understand. This is an important matter, particularly as the PPF had a rough ride before it was accepted. I learned from my first economics lesson that inflation affects people with small incomes more than any other group in society. We should insert in the Bill a legislative provision to allow us and the Minister to report, at regular intervals between now and December, to the Dáil or this committee on the effects of inflation on the Minister's proposals. This is important for all the reasons Deputy Broughan has outlined.
The Minister may claim that he is meeting the targets which he set and which were set for him in the PPF. Another commitment was made in the PPF, however, that as economic growth continued to increase we would re-examine the increases that were given by way of the annual Social Welfare Bill. The increases of between £8 and £10 are insignificant this year given that people on low incomes had to catch up last year because of inflation. It is, therefore, absolutely essential that it is provided in legislation that the Minister should report to the House or this committee on the effects of inflation on people in this category. It is important that this provision is made for future Ministers. I commend the amendment to the committee.
Comment on this
I support Deputy Broughan's proposal. Those in receipt of UA or UB are paid £77.50 per week which will rise to approximately £85 per week when the legislation is enacted. How can anyone survive on that income? Much of the increase given to these recipients last year was eaten up by inflation. Many of us do not fully realise that a crisis can arise for them every day with some unforeseen expense, such a child needing money for school or a bigger than anticipated ESB bill and so on. It is important that their payments should be maintained at a level at which they can survive. A provision could be made to automatically compensate them when inflation rises. The Minister was aware of the inflation problem last year and tried hard to bring forward payments. He appreciated the problem. If he accepted the amendment, perhaps it could strengthen his hand if a similar scenario arose and he had to return to Cabinet. He could say to his colleagues that increased payments are provided for under social welfare legislation. It could help him if the issue arose again and he would able to deliver increases. Perhaps he will accept the amendment in that light.
Comment on this
I correct Deputy Broughan's statement that the average inflation rate last year was 7% as it was 5.6% according to the consumer price index.
Comment on this
The average rate was 5.6% and it has always been the case in regard to inflation, no matter which Government has been in office, that if there was a problem in any given year it would be examined the following year. Towards the end of 2000 the Government examined all these issues and made a good decision to provide a 100% Christmas bonus to social welfare recipients rather than a 70% bonus at a substantial additional cost. Money was put in the people's pockets at a crucial time.
Comment on this
Whenever my party has been in Government, the Christmas bonus has remained the same or been increased as was the case last year whereas when Fine Gael and the Labour Party have been in Government the bonus has remained the same or been decreased. When Garret the Good was in Government the Christmas bonus was reduced.
The Government also made a decision when increasing the Christmas bonus to examine inflation in the context of the budget. Social welfare increases in the budget ranged from 10% to 18% depending on the scheme, which is well ahead of the anticipated rate of inflation for 2001 at 4.5%. One does not need to be a rocket scientist to figure out that substantial compensation is built in for those who did not benefit as anticipated because of the increase in inflation. The same applies to old age pensioners, although the effect was not as acute in their case.
During the Government's tenure in office there has been a substantial improvement in real terms in the position of social welfare recipients. The figures are stark. The old age contributory pension has increased by 40%, a real increase of 19% as opposed to 4% during the tenure of the Rainbow Coalition, albeit over three budgets as opposed to four.
Comment on this
Widowers and those in receipt of unemployment and disability benefits have received real increases of 11%. Non-contributory old age pensions have increased by 41.5%, a real increase of 24% as opposed to only 4.7% when Fine Gael and the Labour Party were in Government. Similarly, short-term unemployment assistance has increased by 28%, a real increase of 12.5%. I do not accept the comments regarding inflation. Old age pensions have increased by between 36% and 41.5% since the Government took office, a real increase of between 19% and 24%.
I do not accept Deputy Hayes's remarks about the commitments under the PPF. They have been delivered. Over the lifetime of the PPF, which covers three budgets, we promised to deliver £1.3 billion extra in social welfare benefits. In the first of the three budgets we have delivered £850 million; therefore, we are ahead in that regard. The previous Government committed £525 million to Partnership 2000 over three budgets. The outturn ultimately reached more than £1 billion under this Government. Our record stands on its own.
I do not accept Deputy Broughan's comment that this committee is the only body which looks after the interests of social welfare recipients. The Government has made a huge commitment which has been proven by the resources we have committed in this area. Equally, in the partnership process the community and voluntary sector is a strong advocate of this position.
Comment on this
In my view CORI misunderstood the commitments in relation to the PPF, a view shared by others who are part of the partnership negotiations. Over the lifetime of the Government we have provided real increases, which contrast starkly with the policy decision, made by a Government of which Fine Gael and the Labour Party were a part, to link social welfare with the rate of inflation. Fianna Fáil in Government has never done that nor will we. Fine Gael committed itself to giving increases at the rate of inflation, not surpassing it or going below it.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to eventually learn that he must compare like with like. We have heard this story and the same old tune has been played on the fiddle every day on Question Time, etc. The Minister is very lucky the land is flowing with milk and honey, with budget surpluses which were never heard of. How can the Minister treat us as morons by presenting figures that do not stand up? He repeats the same thing every time he speaks. If a pensioner has £96 and the rate of inflation is 5.6%, the increase is £4. However, the Minister says he provided an increase of £10, and asks what Garret FitzGerald did. If the Minister wants to use history, then what did the 1977 Government plan under Jack Lynch do? It nearly buried the country. The great leader, Charles Haughey, did not do much better. If the Minister wants we can go back to Brian Boru. He is not comparing like with like, he is making no effort to be intelligent and is treating us like morons by making comparisons which cannot stand up. The Minister has a good grasp of his brief and I ask him to enter reality and stop wasting our time by giving us gibberish. He does the same on Question Time over and over again. It is not right that the Minister is wasting our time by giving us nonsense.
Comment on this
I have listened to the debate, including to Deputy Hayes, who is a young Deputy and has a lot to learn. I have been in different countries, including the UK and America, and there is no culture as generous to old age pensioners as Ireland. I say this without fear of contradiction. The health service——
Comment on this
I am, but I did not interrupt the Deputy when he was speaking. The health service in the US is terrible and it is also terrible for pensioners. Far more money is being provided here than in the UK. The Minister, since his appointment, has increased payments in every budget in line with the commitment he gave when he became Minister. I have been a Member of the House for over 19 years and schemes and increases were mostly introduced by a Fianna Fáil Government. I was on the Opposition benches a few times when Fine Gael and the Labour Party were in Government and I saw no worthwhile increases being introduced.
Comment on this
A couple aged over 66 years on a contributory pension will receive an increase this year of £25 per week, bringing it up to £185 for a couple. A single widow will get an increase of £26 per week bringing the pension of a widow with three children up to £191 per week, a very good increase without question and I am very happy with it. Inflation is not as high as has been suggested. Charles Haughey introduced more free schemes than any other Minister.
Comment on this
I wish the Deputy would withdraw that comment. He brought in schemes, and was recognised for doing so——
Comment on this
Ask the people who realise what Charles Haughey did for the elderly. He introduced free schemes, including free travel. Fine Gael was in Government for quite some time over the past 19 years and brought in almost nothing. It should be ashamed of itself rather than criticising what the Minister is doing.
Comment on this
I wish to set the record straight. Deputy Brennan said a widow with three children would now receive £191 per week. I think this is slightly exaggerated.
Comment on this
The briefing note the Deputy got from the Department must have put him astray. He said a widow and three children would get £191, but the figure will be £158.
Comment on this
Declan Bree, a former Deputy, whom I would like to see returned to the House, contacted me——
Comment on this
I hope he returns. He contacted me about the miserable £5 fuel allowance which has not been increased for 12 years. We are getting much history, but for 12 of the past 14 years Fianna Fáil has been in power. It is like the long era of Fianna Fáil power up to 1973. The party has had every opportunity to do something more dramatic in relation to social welfare, but it has done nothing.
We are not too sure about the euro while Britain, by far our biggest trading partner, is not part of the euro zone and may never be part of it, which may result in economic uncertainty. Economists working for State agencies, such as the ESRI, have said there was next to no rise last year in social welfare benefits. It is deplorable that people are on assistance rates of £85.50, and even worse is the provision of £54 for adult dependants which will be introduced in April. I accept what the Minister said in relation to inflation and that it should not be a guide. The measure should be the income of the country and by that measure the Minister has not done well as we have had growth rates of 8% and 10% over the time of the Government.
I asked the Minister three years ago to give the 100% in relation to the Christmas bonus even though I was not the social welfare spokesperson at the time but three times the Minister said no. Last year, because he knew it was something I would ask around October, the Minister jumped the gun and issued a statement saying he would do so, though he had four chances to do so previously. The public relations section of his Department is fairly famous since Deputy Woods' time, when we got statements from him every day of the week.
Can we not have some mechanism dealing with this? The voluntary pillar is very disappointed and feels it has failed regarding PPF. That is why this committee is important. Surely there is some way we could monitor this through either the Christmas bonus or another budget. There may be a general election, in which case those of us on this side of the House can implement that.
Comment on this
Irrespective of the banter and history lessons, this is an important amendment which does not involve an additional penny of public expenditure. It provides a mechanism whereby the Minister can report regularly to us about the effects of inflation. That is all. What does the Minister feel is the main objective of social welfare payments? Is it just to keep people going on small sums of money or is it a way to get people out of poverty? Between 1997 and 2001, when this Government has been in office, for every £1 increase in the lowest rates of social welfare, someone on the average industrial wage got £4.10 while someone on £60,000 got £6.80 and someone on £100,000 got £9.40; those figures relate purely to tax cuts and do not include wage increases.
Whatever the history lessons from this or the other side, it is clear that the gap between the rich and poor is growing. The mechanisms and changes suggested by the Minister are insufficient to reduce that gap and to give those on low pay a decent rise so they can contribute to society like everyone else. I ask the Minister to reconsider this amendment and to answer my question as to the objective of social welfare payments.
Comment on this
The Deputy raised a number of issues. Regarding his questions, the Government has been singularly successful in reducing consistent poverty in Ireland. Our philosophy goes back to a point Deputy Broughan was trying to make, though he was not giving the full facts regarding the proportionate spend of our society on social welfare as opposed to other societies. If one looks at the spend in Italy on pensions compared to Ireland one would think they are spending much more than us on old age pensions but the reality is they are spending a lot less. They have a much greater cohort of old age pensioners than us. We have the lowest spend on pensions in Europe in overall figures but in reality we have the most generous old age pension regime in the world, as Deputy Brennan said.
This relates to what we were saying about poverty. Since the Government took office 120,000 people have come off the live register. That is not only a saving for the Exchequer and the taxpayer as those people are in a productive mode and that affects the overall social welfare spend. The sickness schemes have also shown a fairly dramatic fall in participants because again there are people taking jobs and not relying on social welfare.
It is the Government's job to ensure that those on social welfare who through no fault of their own are unable to fend for themselves, like old age pensioners, lone parents or those on disability benefit, are given reasonable increases. Our record in this regard, as Deputy Brennan said, is second to none. If one looks at the percentage increases for any of the schemes they are dramatically ahead of anything given previously.
Comment on this
In comparison to what was given previously. To what else can we compare it? We can compare it to the UK where social welfare pensions went up by 75p at the same time that they rose by £7 in Ireland.
Comment on this
One cannot compare people in jobs. The reality is that people in jobs will also get a higher increase than those on social welfare.
Comment on this
That is an inevitable consequence of economics. I do not have to give an economics lesson; that will always be the case.
Comment on this
No, it is always the case. When one looks at the last few years, it is undoubtedly the case that with the supports available to people who are unemployed or on disability benefit, there are so many supports built into the system that it pays people to go out and work. Those who work see the benefits and that is one of the reasons, as we discussed yesterday, the numbers on FIS have fallen. It is because of the economic situation. One cannot look at this in isolation. The situation since the Government took office is that instead of paying people to do nothing, we have tried to get them into employment which is now available while more than looking after those in the social welfare system.
I return to the commitments of the PPF. Any objective reading of that and any yardstick in relation to real increases, which is the phrase used in the commitments, such as the commitment to reach £100 in general increases, will show that we have more than fulfilled our commitments and will do so in the remaining lifetime of the agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 5, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of closing the differential between the rates of periodic benefit and assistance paid to an adult dependant and the rates paid to a qualifying adult, and of removing any limitation of the amount of payment made to a couple as opposed to a corresponding payment to two adults who are not living together.".
This amendment relates to the ongoing disastrous situation of dependent adults due to the social welfare regime over the years. The Government obviously set a target through PPF of moving to the 70% rate over three years, which includes the remaining lifetime of the Government. The increases in relation to the dependants on contributory pensions to bring people up to the non-contributory rate is welcome and a good step forward and I commend the Minister. However, we are still left with the situation, across a range of social insurance and social assistance payments, where adult dependants are on low rates. I referred earlier to the £54, which will be introduced in the next few weeks, where the Minister gave £7 to the dependants of people on long-term unemployment. I am aware the Minister held a forum and that my colleagues in Fine Gael also had a forum. We, too, held a forum for the main representative bodies of people who depend on social welfare income and there was a unanimous desire to move to the 70% rate this year. This would have meant an amount of £56 in the context of long-term unemployment assistance of £85.
I am aware this is related to the situation of older women in the economy and people who dropped out many years ago for home duties who did not have sufficient stamps. There are other amendments in that regard and I do not wish to stray into that territory but it is related to the fact that seniors will not be eligible for full payments in their own right. I call again on the Minister to look at the possibility of moving towards a better rate of payment. I believe the current rate is insulting, as I have pointed out every year in the House. It is now a miserly £54 for an adult dependant and this amendment seeks to highlight this issue again.
Comment on this
I support this timely amendment. It is particularly timely that Deputy Broughan should talk about the individualisation of social welfare payments when the Minister for Finance is going a long way towards completing the individualisation of taxation. The issue of individualisation would not sting nearly as much if it were applied across the board. However, it is not applied in social welfare.
This payment of £54 often goes to the woman who is at home. She sees that payment as the total regard the State has for her. Her husband is worth almost twice as much by virtue of the fact that he is the recipient of the payment while she is the adult dependant. It is a very small amount. Where would one go with £54? The Minister and I could not manage on anything like that amount for a week. I hope the Minister will move towards full individualisation as quickly as possible.
It would also overcome the terrible problems, which we have discussed previously, created by the disincentives to people to get married. If two people are on full rates of social welfare and they are living together - the Department probably does not catch them - there is no incentive for them to get married. If they do, their payments will be reduced to the main payment and the adult dependant payment. They will lose between £30 and £40 per week when it is already difficult to survive. It is a disincentive to getting married. The chairman has spoken about this issue before. The sooner we reach full individualisation of social welfare payments, the better.
Comment on this
This is one of the anomalies in the system which dates to the bad old days when there was not enough money and people on small rates of income were dependent on the State for everything. I accept the Minister's argument that the situation has changed and that we must change with it. For the information of the committee, however, will he outline the general cost that would be borne by the Exchequer as a result of this change? It is a change that is necessary, right and proper given our current circumstances.
Comment on this
Does it date to the bad old days, Minister, or is it due to the commission on social welfare?
Comment on this
The relationship of the QAA to the personal rate was considered in the report of the working group which examined the treatment of married, cohabiting and one parent families under the tax and social welfare codes, which was published in August last year. The working group proposed, on foot of research on equivalent scales undertaken by the ESRI for the group, that the QAA should be increased to 70% of the personal rate. The Government intends to reach this recommended level over a period of three budgets. This was the second budget.
Following 2001, the relationship between the QAA and the relevant personal rates ranged between 63.2% and 67.7% for those under 66 years and between 68.9% and 75% for those over 66 years of age. The percentage increases range from 13.3.% to 25.9%, averaging around 15% for those under 66 years. The Government gave a commitment to increase the QAA for people over 66 years to the full old age pension non-contributory rate. As a result, we gave a special increase of £15 for qualified adults over the age of 66 years. As Deputy Brennan indicated, old age pensioners will get between £20 and £25 per week in April for a couple, which is a dramatic increase in one's weekly income. I believe it will be much appreciated. The sentiments expressed by Deputy Brennan would be fully understood by all those in receipt of the increases, even non-Fianna Fáil supporters.
In principle, the QAA rate is set at less than 100% of the personal rate on the basis that there are economies of scale where two people live together in the same household and that account should be taken of those economies when the second person does not have a direct entitlement to the payment in his or her own right. However, the group recommended that the existing arrangements for making separate payments should be made available on a more general basis. This issue was considered under the PPF and it was agreed to develop proposals to progress the individualisation of social welfare payments in the context of the continuation of joint assessment of means.
A number of working groups will be established to produce proposals to progress the implementation of the administrative individualisation within the social welfare system - that basically means dividing the existing payment - and to provide proposals to develop a fully inclusive social insurance model which would facilitate combining work and family responsibilities in the context of changing work and social patterns. The group dealing with administrative individualisation has been established and is at present examining the issues associated with this proposal.
We have gone further in this budget than was the commitment in the PPF by proposing the increase in the QAA for people over 66 years of age. However, I share the views of Opposition Members and given the more widespread PRSI cover in the system, there will be a situation - although it probably will not be in the lifetime of this Dáil - where people will get a payment in their own right on the basis of the contributions they made. That is as it should be. However, the QAA currently caters for a situation where people historically opted out of the workforce and, in some cases, were forced out of it and were unable to continue their contribution record. I am on record as endeavouring to change the system, as far as possible, to alleviate some of those difficulties. However, we will not be able to go the full way in that respect.
Comment on this
The Minister told us yesterday that approximately 87% of the 900,000 get payments in their own name. What number of QAAs are involved?
Comment on this
I am not sure off hand. The figure is decreasing but I could not give the number off hand. We might be able to give the number to the Deputy on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 5, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the provisions of the Social Welfare Acts which are not in force by reason of the fact that a commencement order has not been made, and the plans, if any, for bringing such provisions into effect.".
It is traditional for the Labour Party to table an amendment such as this. The amendment concerns the fact that a number of significant provisions in Social Welfare Acts from the 1990s have not been brought into force. Last year the Minister read out about six important provisions on which no commencement order has been made. This highlights our initial discussion on the need for consolidation and simplification of the social welfare code so that legislation is implemented.
Two years ago we discussed the section regarding road blocks manned by Garda, Army and social welfare officials. This provision was being implemented and Deputy Joe Higgins was interested in that section. However, this section has fallen into disuse.
Comment on this
We discussed that section for days but it does not seem to be operating. Allegedly senior gardaí refused to take part in those kinds of patrols which is understandable given the range of important work they have to do. Is this area still giving rise to concern as suggested by our legal advisers?
Comment on this
All sections of the Social Welfare Act, 2000, with the exception of section 31, have been commenced. Section 31 provides for changes in the administration of the SWA scheme which will be addressed in conjunction with other administrative issues.
All sections of the Social Welfare Act, 1999, have been commenced. However, there are some provisions of earlier Acts in respect of which commencement orders have not been made. These include section 17 of the Social Welfare Act, 1998, which provides for actuarial reviews of the social insurance fund to be undertaken on a five yearly basis which will be commenced later this year.
Part 4 of the Social Welfare Act, 1997, provides for the introduction of a new sickness allowance scheme. The overall purpose of the scheme will be reviewed this year as part of the review of income maintenance schemes for people with illnesses and disabilities. All those who would have qualified for sickness allowance are being catered for through other payments such as SWA.
Section 26(1)(b) of the Social Welfare Act, 1997, contains regulatory powers to prescribe the provisions relating to benefit and privilege in the context of means assessment. The relevant regulations will be introduced this year. Section 10(4) of the Social Welfare (No. 2) Act, 1995, provides regulatory powers under which a divorced person may receive a qualified adult allowance in respect of more than one person. The need for this provision is kept under review on an ongoing basis.
Section 22 of the Social Welfare Act, 1995, provides regulatory powers designed to standardise the arrangements applying to various social welfare schemes concerning absence from the State. It is planned to introduce the relevant regulations later this year.
Section 20 of the Social Welfare Act, 1994, provides for the integration of occupational injury benefit and unemployability supplement, payable under the benefits scheme, with disability benefit. The overall role of occupational injuries benefit payments will be included in the review of the sickness/disability schemes taking place this year. Decisions on the implementation of this section will be taken in light of the findings of this review.
Comment on this
When I was spokesperson on Enterprise, Trade and Employment we had not implemented many EU directives. Is there a similar situation with regard to social welfare? We did not have information on this side of the House last week as it was becoming a major issue. However, with respect to the new European anti-poverty programme, the Minister will have to submit a revised programme with more significant targets than the existing NAPS or some of the discussions we held last October on the revised NAPS target. Is this also the case regarding European legislation?
Comment on this
We are fully compliant with European social security directives. The only outstanding area involves pensions which will be included in the forthcoming pensions Bill. As regards NAPS we have to bring forward action plans in June and we will be doing so fairly soon. That process is ongoing.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 5, line 27, after "amended" to insert "to the extent that the instrument concerned is consistent with that provision as so amended".
This is similar to the previous amendment in that it involves a small additional provision which we feel would be a safeguard concerning the continuance of instruments provisions in this section. The amendment stipulates that any additional instruments are consistent with the provision as so amended. It is a small technical amendment which is desirable.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputy for tabling this amendment which I accept on the advice of the Chief Parliamentary Counsel.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 6, before section 4, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the social welfare situation of persons resident in Ireland who are in receipt of pensions under the social security legislation of any other jurisdiction.".
I raised this issue on Committee Stage of last year's Bill. I was contacted by a number of people from the west Cork and Kerry areas who were retired on British pensions but who did not receive a number of allowances payable in this jurisdiction, particularly the living alone and over 80 allowances. This issue should be re-examined as it is a concern for Irish people who have returned to the State to live in west Cork, Kerry and other areas. These people feel that some of the provisions regarding senior citizens do not apply to them. There is a grey area as to the extent to which such people can access the benefits we have introduced for pensioners which were so eloquently spoken of by Deputy Brennan.
Comment on this
I support this amendment. A large number of people are returning from Britain to live in Ireland, some are living in my area.
Comment on this
No. More often than not they are returning home having had to leave this country in the 1950s and 1960s. Having worked abroad they are coming home and are back with their families. Some of them find it hard to settle back into life here and to get used to our ways because the Ireland they knew was different from what it is now. I know some of them have difficulty understanding why they do not qualify for various allowances. They are assessed on everything they have, although their pension might be low. Social welfare officials are currently examining British pensions and because sterling is strong, they are increasing their value which means the pension they might get from here will be low. Deputy Broughan and I raised this issue a couple of years ago when sterling was weak against the pound. We asked for it to be examined, but we were told that could not be done. It is mean to reassess it just because sterling is strong.
We should also bear in mind that the British Government, for all its faults, pays the Exchequer a huge sum of money. The last time I checked it had paid approximately £65 million to the Government to look after its pensioners who are here and to give them health benefits, etc. That is a substantial amount of money to pay not to the relevant health boards or social welfare offices but to the Exchequer. We should bear in mind that many of these people, who were forced out of Ireland, are now coming back and reinvesting their foreign currency here. The type of report suggested by Deputy Broughan would be worthwhile as it would give us a fair indication of what is happening and how we can best support these people.
Comment on this
Deputy Broughan raised this issue last year and he clarified on Committee Stage that his question related to people who had British pensions and whether they would qualify for the living alone or over 80 allowance. This allowance is an integral part of the Irish pension system and is designed to cover specific contingencies. As such, it does not have applicability vis-à-vis pension payments made under different social security regimes of other EU member states or countries with which we have bilateral agreements. This is fully in accordance with the EU regulations which allow member states to decide which benefits are granted and under what conditions. The free schemes are different and they are available to people resident in thecountry, subject to fulfilling the minimum conditions.
As regards the pension payments to this country by the British Exchequer, I suggest to the Deputy that the Exchequer makes a substantial payment to Britain for Irish pensioners living there. As I said before in relation to pre-1953 contributions, which the Chairman successfully exhorted me at my parliamentary party to introduce, we estimated that 3,000 people would qualify. However, that figure is now 12,300 and it is rising. A large proportion of those people are UK residents who are becoming aware of this change in the contributions and who are now qualifying for the special 50% pension.
As regards people who are being assessed on their additional income from a British pension, there is an ongoing examination of all means tested payments. The recent changes made to the amount of capital people on means tested payments can have are substantial and beneficial. Many people will benefit from those changes which are being made to allow them to retain some money and also their social welfare payments.
Comment on this
I understand there is an ongoing review of the entitlement to payments under the social welfare code based on contributions made. However, an anomaly has arisen, particularly in relation to people coming back from abroad. I know of two men with families, who live beside each other, and one of them worked for a short time here before he retired. He is now getting a full contributory pension. While he worked in Ireland before he went away, it was in the black economy. His next door neighbour, who is a little younger, worked for Leitrim County Council as an under-age worker, although the age limit may have been manipulated slightly for his benefit. He is recorded as having paid two years' stamps with the county council before he went to England where he worked for 30 years. He has now returned home and is working here again. He will have accumulated eight or ten years' work here when he reaches pension age, but because of the averaging system and the fact he had stamps previously he will miss out badly on the contributory pension. He will get a greatly reduced rate, although his contributions will be greater than those of his neighbour who was here for a short time. This is because the averaging system counts back to the first day one started work and got the first stamp. That is a disadvantage. Is this issue part of the ongoing review? It mainly affects people who have been resident abroad for a while. I ask the Minister to accept the amendment in the context of the review of contributory pensions.
Comment on this
I do not know of the specific case but there is an examination of the contribution system. We are moving towards the view that we should move away from the averaging system and consider giving people credit for total contributions. There is an examination currently under way in that respect. I hope it will come to some conclusion and that recommendations will be made to me in the near future. I, like any other public representative, am acutely aware of the anomalies which can be thrown up as a result of the averaging system.
Comment on this
I am not sure. The Deputy should table a parliamentary question to me on that issue. We launched one phase some time ago where we made some changes and we said there would be a second phase some time this year, perhaps before the summer.
Comment on this
An indication was given by some of the Minister's colleagues when we were talking about pensions that it would be before Easter.
Comment on this
That may have been the case. It is a fairly difficult and complex issue. It may be Easter, but I was being careful when I said before the summer. I would like to think it would be on my desk with some recommendations before the next budget to see if we can do anything. One issue is to back date the homemakers scheme to try to give women extra credit for the stamps they have. It is an extremely complex issue. We must be fair to those people who have made contributions over their lifetime. When we start reducing the level of contributions required, we must be careful not to discriminate against those people who have made full contributions over their lifetime.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 6, before section 4, but in Part 2, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a system of benchmarking or indexation of all social welfare payments for the purpose of giving security of income to all recipients thereof.".
This amendment relates to part of the discussion on amendments Nos. 3 and 4. The Minister has belatedly, towards the latter part of his administration, appointed the benchmarking committee under the chairmanship of Professor Kennedy. I understand we will receive an interim report in a few months and a full report towards the end of the year. Most of those interested in the area of social welfare income see the necessity for benchmarking. The banter in which we have engaged today, however, illustrates the fact that it is hard to get a handle on the income supports the State should provide. To revert to Deputy Hayes's earlier question, what is social welfare for? That is the fundamental question we must ask. Even independent economists would say that the gap between higher income earners and the lowest 30% has widened significantly under the Government.
In our discussions before Christmas, the Senior Citizens Parliament and the trade union representative group for pensioners asked us to aim at providing non-contributory pensions based on 34% of the average industrial wage. By my reckoning, this would provide a basic non-contributory pension of £113 per week, not £106, based on average industrial wage figures for 1999. People have spoken about median and per capita income, but it is necessary to move away from this type of Poor Law approach to the social welfare net and pension provision. We should look at social welfare income as part of the general income structure, but the Government has failed to do so. The State has also failed to do so for most of its history.
Labour Party Deputies in the 1920s, 1930s, 1940s and 1950s should have taken a more robust attitude to the two main parties, particularly as regards the poorer sections of the community. In previous decades the levels of welfare provision, particularly in Dublin city and county, were so appalling that people were driven to emigrate in their tens of thousands. Some are now returning to live here.
We must put in place a system, such as the one pensioner representatives are rightly seeking, which will form part of another partnership programme after the PPF, if there is to be one. Many voices in the trade union movement and my own party are of the view that we should not take that route for the simple reason that low-paid workers and those on social welfare have not gained sufficiently from the partnership agreements. The amendment refers to something very basic.
The Minister misled the committee in an earlier contribution on pensions. He mentioned Italy as an example, but the reason social protection provision is so high as part of national income in other European countries is that they have far better welfare regimes. The German Government, which is Labour led, is debating whether to cut final income for pensioners from 70% of a person's final income to 65%. The equivalent Irish figure could be 30% if one is talking about non-contributory pension with little occupational income. This country is not even at the races compared to Germany or Italy.
In recent years we have been lambasted by the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, over his decision to salt away so much money for pensions provision in 30 years time. We did not get a chance to discuss the matter. When the Dáil was not sitting one summer the Minister just came along and said, "I'm going to do this whether you like it or not". The Minister refers to us as wanting to raid that provision, but should we not be doing something about pensioners living in poverty, despite the Minister's much vaunted increases?
This time last year an survey of pensioners by Kitty Holland in The Irish Times found that many pensioners on the north side of Dublin were still living in poverty. They were living basic lives and had very little to spend on a night out and not enough for energy supplies. When the man or woman of the house was working, they had a reasonable income, but it collapsed as they moved into the contributory pension area.
Much will depend on what is considered the benchmark. It is a fundamental issue. Social welfare should be benchmarked against average national income. That is the recommendation I expect Professor Kennedy to make at the end of the process. It should be a significant figure. Senior citizens are correct to seek rates of 34% and 40%. I commend the Minister for appointing the commission. We will receive its report later, but the step was taken belatedly given the seriousness of the issue. Throughout the history of the State we have expected people to live on rotten, low incomes.
Comment on this
In an earlier contribution the Minister referred to the £100 target in the PPF. He outlined that he and the Government are making progress in fully meeting it before the end of the third year of the PPF. To repeat to what I said, there is another part of that commitment which clearly states that we should review the £100 target as growth in the economy increases. Even from the period when it was first negotiated and accepted by all concerned the target was seen to be dated. Given the inflationary problem encountered last year and the general rise in prices, those on small incomes are suffering. We will have to renegotiate the £100 target because it is part of a commitment for another year. That is the reason the amendment in respect of benchmarking is so important.
Deputy Broughan asked the Minister about the percentage of social spending on many schemes. I understand we prop up the bottom of the European league table for social spending as a percentage of GDP. While the average is about 28%, we are at 16%. Many of the Scandinavian countries are at figures well above the average. The Minister said that one of the reasons spending in this area has gone down is that many people have returned to work and are no longer relying on the social welfare system. That does not provide much comfort or credibility, however, for the sections of the community in need of supports such as child benefit and carer's allowance. We can take no comfort from the fact that spending as a percentage of GDP in this area has fallen over the lifetime of the Government. There are much more sophisticated models in other EU countries for supporting people both in and out of work. We have not even begun to understand the full range of entitlements which people should be drawing down.
I welcome the Minister's establishment of a benchmarking commission. Is there a commitment in the group's terms of reference to report by a specific date? This is an urgent matter as we approach the mid-point of the PPF. Finality is needed in respect of the Government's policy on benchmarking. It is important that an amendment such as Deputy Broughan's should be provided in the legislation. Will there be a decision in this regard before the next Social Welfare Bill? If we knew the answer to that question, it would beeasier to judge whether the amendment is necessary.
Comment on this
Will more power be taken out of the political process through the benchmarking process?
Comment on this
Deputy Broughan referred to old age pensioners living in poverty. I will not give the Deputy a history lesson but any objective examination will show that over the lifetime of the Government the contributory pension increased from £78 to £106 per week. It increased from 27% of income to more than 31% and is approaching the 34% of income level proposed in the NPPI. The interpretation by certain individuals of the PPF commitments in my view and that of many independentcommentators is not correct. Our commitments on minimum payments are stark. Weare well on the way to achieving them during the lifetime of the PPF. There is also acommitment to increase all rates of social welfare to a level above the rate of inflation. That will be achieved during the lifetime of the agreement.
The benchmarking and indexation group set up under the PPF had its first meeting in December 2000. The Chairman may be correct that, similar to all issues relating to social partnership, benchmarking to an extent will take power from the Oireachtas. That is a good price which we must pay to ensure stability in our society over the past decade continues. The group has had a number of meetings and is due to make an interim report in April. Its terms of reference do not provide that it must report by a specific date but the final report will be published before the end of the year.
Comment on this
I am not sure what is the group's view in that regard and, therefore, I cannot give a commitment. I have no doubt given that it is a PPF group the interim report will be made available but I will not second guess its position on that. The final conclusions of the group will be made public and the Department will consider its recommendations.
It is not an easy issue. NESC has already examined it and there were detailed talks during the PPF negotiations in this regard. Neither group could reach a definitive agreement. The chairman of the benchmarking group is extremely capable and was a good choice. It is hoped the group will bring forward recommendations on which we can act over time.
Comment on this
No, these terms of reference were agreed during the PPF negotiations. They require the group "to examine the issues involved in developing a benchmark for adequacy of adult and child social welfare payments, including the implications of adopting a specific approach on the ongoing up-rating or indexation of payments having regard to long-term economic, budgetary, PRSI contribution, distributive and incentive implications in light of trends in economic, demographic and labour market patterns and to examine issues of relative income poverty".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 11 is related to amendment No. 10 and both may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 6, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the increases granted to unemployment benefit recipients, having regard to the impact of such increases on:
(a) the local authority differential rent scheme, and
(b) the rental subsidy scheme for private accommodation.”.
Deputy McGrath and I have tabled two amendments to provide for a report on UA and UB. The basic 8% increase and the 10% increase at the top of the scale are unacceptable for both categories of payments. The lowest social welfare rate will be £84 per week. The 1998 living in Ireland survey puts the poverty line in terms of the basic 50% payment at £93 per week and if that is indexed to 2001 the payment would be £102 per week. The lowest rate of payment at £84 per week is unacceptable.
When the increase kicks in, as my colleague Deputy McGrath has stated on other occasions at this committee, it will have a negative impact for many people living in local authority accommodation. Depending on the scheme put in place by most local authorities, under the differential rent scheme, people's rent will be increased. The increase under the legislation will be eaten up by the differential rent scheme and increases in other parts of the economy. Both amendments are essential if the Government is serious about this significant group of people having a decent quality of life under the UA and UB schemes.
What percentage of the total social welfare spend is made up of UA and UB? The Minister continually points out that one of the reasons expenditure is reducing is that more people are returning to work.
Comment on this
I concur with Deputy Hayes's comments. The amendments relate to UA and UB because they had to relate to the legislation but they could relate to all social welfare payments. The Minister is aware of the problem. He said in the House on one occasion that when increases kick in the local authority differential rent system does also and the community welfare officer then reviews household incomes. A constituent contacted me recently. He was one of two people in rented accommodation. Their rent had increased by £3.50 each per week while their social welfare payments had increased by £8 per week each. They felt badly that so much was being clawed back instantly by the local authority under the differential rent scheme. I do not know how to resolve this because the scheme is generally good but there is a problem with the claw back.
The bigger difficulty is in the private rented sector where social welfare recipients are entitled to a rent allowance. Because of changes in social welfare payments the base rate for calculating rent allowances changes. Therefore, the amount of money people have to pay out of their own pocket increases. This claws back any increase they are getting in social welfare payments. People affected feel very bad about this. They see the Minister and others announcing an increase of £8 or £10 per week while they receive much less than this when the claw backs are taken into consideration. Such people feel they are getting a raw deal while others are doing particularly well. What can the Minister do to protect the increases given to social welfare recipients so they are real rather than having part of them clawed back? I have not mentioned the claw back which results from inflation. These taken together will almost negative some increases. I ask the Minister to prepare a report and bring forward some real examples of how this works, what happens and what can be done about it.
Comment on this
I support both amendments as they raise important issues. Our local authority amended the differential rent scheme about five years ago and we inserted a clause that only 15% of an increase in social welfare benefit can be passed on, a reasonable system. This is a problem across the board and weekly we try to cope with homeless people and people in private rented accommodation. In the Dublin area there have been unbelievable increases in rents, up to £1,000 per month per house, which highlights the impact on desperate young couples and young women who have tears in their eyes trying to cope with demands for increased rents and who know the rent supplement will not match the increases.
This morning the Taoiseach raised this issue of housing and how it impacts on people, especially those on social welfare income, in private rented accommodation. This will be one of the significant issues in the coming general election and the amendments try to address it. There is no point handing out something with one hand and taking it back through the local authority differential rent scheme or the rent supplement administered by the health boards.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputies for raising this issue. I do not have responsibility for the differential rent scheme and I would not be able to produce a report on it - I do not have the wherewithal within the Department. It is a matter for the Department of Environment and Local Government. The Deputies who are members of local authorities have some say on the differential rent scheme, though I know much of the scheme is dictated by the Department.
Regarding increases over the years, particularly the stark increases in recent years, it is important people do not lose out or end up in a situation whereby the entire increase is clawed back under the differential scheme.
I have responsibility in relation to SWA and I have made some changes in that regard which are of benefit to people. Pensioners on SWA rent or mortgage interest supplement did not get the benefit of the additional increases as it was automatically clawed back through a reduction in other SWA schemes. However, in the budget this year I announced that the first £5 of additional increases in social welfare payments would be disregarded for rent and mortgage interest supplement purposes. In other words, instead of a reduction of £10 per week in rent or mortgage supplement, couples on pensions will get a net gain of £5 as a result of the changes. People on one parent family payments and unemployment benefit are not affected by clawbacks of budget increases in terms of the rate of rent and mortgage interest supplement. In this case, weekly payment rates are increasing by £8 for a single person and £15 for a couple.
The operation of the claw back will be examined in the fundamental review of the SWA currently under way. The differential rent scheme is the responsibility of each local authority and the issue of excluding social welfare payments is a matter for those on local authorities, subject to the overall guidelines laid down by the Department of the Environment and Local Government.
Comment on this
The Minister seems to be neutral on whether this could be included in the Bill. The amendment only asks the Minister to produce a report from his perspective. There have been many such examples in the past, most notably the interdepartmental committee which produced work on the rental scheme for private accommodation, which the Minister has been trying to implement for some years in terms of moving responsibility from the Department to local authorities. Did that committee discuss this issue, as I suspect it did? The current problems relate to IR difficulties in terms of implementation. It would be useful to include the amendment as it would at least highlight for the Department of the Environment and Local Government and local authorities which have not complied with the compassionate understanding of the differential rent scheme in the way in which Dublin Corporation has, the concern of the Minister and the Department in respect of ensuring the increases are not clawed back through dramatic increases in rent. I put it to the Minister that both amendments would help the case of the Department in highlighting the need for such provision.
Comment on this
I have nothing further to add. Deputy Broughan is correct in saying those on SWA rents are in substantially more difficult circumstances than those on differential rents. Differential rents are designed to assist people, and as their income increases the rent increases, which is implicit in the system - it is the quid pro quo for what is in effect a very beneficial system of housing.
Comment on this
That is not an issue. Generally there are broad guidelines which are adhered to by local authorities and they cannot simply stray from them. The issue of uniformity in the system must be raised with the Department of the Environment and Local Government. Our role concerns income adequacy and people have to meet whatever demands are on them from that income. It has been a bone of contention with members on all sides. It has been previously raised with me but, as I have said, this is primarily a matter for the Department of the Environment and Local Government.
Comment on this
On Second Stage I raised the situation of a widow over 66 who was on the top-up injury benefit and whose husband got killed at work. Is that widow getting the full £12.90 increase this year? The last couple of years she did not.
Comment on this
She gets a £10 increase. The widow's pension paid under the occupational injury scheme is paid at a higher rate than other social welfare payments. Nevertheless, in this year's budget I provided that a £10 increase would apply to widows over 66 in receipt of this payment. Those receiving the general widow's pension who are over 66 receive an additional £2.90, which brings their payment to £102 as a first step in bringing the payment into line with the OACP rate. No special increase was necessary for those OIB widows over 66 whose rate is now £109.40. It is because they are on a higher rate.
Comment on this
That confuses me every year. Is there a policy decision within the Department to do away with that top-up? For the last couple of years the widow over 66 did not get the over-66 increase. That is the fourth year in a row and now she is losing £2.90 this year. Is there a long-term aim to abolish that top-up for occupational injuries?
Comment on this
No, I do not think so but the view was taken by the Department, regarding one or two of those pension rates at a higher rate than normal, that a huge number of people are not involved and because they are on the higher rate, the increase they would get would not be as much as those on the general rate. I will look at this again as I would not like the perception to be that these people are losing out.
Comment on this
I put down a parliamentary question on this and I thought I got an assurance that it would not happen again. I do not understand it. If there is a policy decision to abolish this we should be told.
Comment on this
The particular case I raised - there are only 50 or 60 people involved - involves a widow whose husband was killed at work. This will be the fourth year in a row she perceives that she is not getting the full pension increase her widowed neighbour is receiving. She always had a top-up but that seems to be reduced year by year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 6, before section 6, to insert the following new section:
"6.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a personal childcare payment of £20 per child per week.".
One of the best parts in the budget and the Social Welfare Bill was the significant increase in child benefit to the rate set out here, £67.50 and £86. Many constituents would probably ask why it is not the same rate for all children, in other words, why does the £86 not apply across the board and why does everyone not get the £30 rate? Nonetheless, it is significant progress to bring the rate for the first child up to approximately £16 per week. There are still many parents who feel there is confusion between the necessity for increasing basic income for children and providing resources through the social welfare system for child care. In other words, the provision of child care is an entirely different task. This amendment contains a spelling error and should read: "parental childcare payment" of an additional £20 per child per week.
Labour and Fine Gael discussed an amendment to this effect last year but I abandoned the distinction of between zero and five because I agree with the Minister. Children are expensive all the way through, or become increasingly more expensive, so the distinction should probably not be drawn. Last year Deputy O'Keeffe put forward a target payment per child of £25 per week and we should be aiming for that for every child. Studies have shown a basic living standard for a child costs £40 to £45 per week and we are a fair distance from that target.
Friday is family at work day and I know the Tánaiste said on radio this morning she wanted a massive expansion of child care facilities. She admits the Government has failed to provide that, despite the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform's war chest. We have not had the resources coming through. Pat Kenny raised the issue of using schools during holidays and after 3 p.m. with the Tánaiste this morning but we have failed to get the necessary resources. I know that goes beyond the remit of this amendment but we could have adopted the Childcare 2000 proposal to have a major parental child care payment. Our trade union colleagues would suggest working through the taxation system and they have sent all of us tough letters on that matter, pointing out that the Minister for Finance did nothing to provide resources through the taxation system when speaking on the Finance Bill. This will be a major area of discussion in the forthcoming election and the record will show that despite the Minister's increases this year, he has signally failed to provide a basic income for children and he has absolutely failed to provide a network of child care support systems for parents. We are as far away as ever from that. The Tánaiste has also failed in that regard; she has made no demands of business regarding this matter. I have been trying to get the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform to provide resources for major child care projects which are ready to go but it is very difficult.
Comment on this
I do not accept what the Deputy says. It is true we are starting from a low base. We did not have the resources up to a few years ago but we now have the necessary resources. Our national development plan contains a commitment to spending a significant amount of money in this area and the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform have front loaded this year's provision from £45 million to £104 million in relation to the increase in supply of child care places. The purpose is to try to achieve an increase in the supply. Like the housing issue, which will not be solved unless there is an increase in supply, the child care problem will not be solved unless there is an acceleration in the number of places. That can only be achieved by front loading expenditure. To judge by the money expended in recent months the take up in terms of applications by private operators has been very successful. I accept there are planning difficulties with child care facilities. In some residential areas residents are objecting through the planning process to the provision of crèche facilities in their area.
I reject the Deputy's comment on my involvement in assisting child poverty. This is the largest investment in the children of this country in the history of the State.
Comment on this
In any year. The Government's commitment to invest £1 billion over three years is more than the Opposition has ever done and more than many lobby groups, even in their wildest dreams, expected. The Combat Poverty Agency would normally be critical of Government decisions, but it was highly complimentary of our action in this area. It believes it is the right way to tackle child poverty. None of the many lobby groups, where there are as many opinions on this issue as there are Deputies, could agree on the way to deal with the provision of child care payments. I met some of the groups, following which they were more divided among themselves as the best way of providing assistance.
Comment on this
We took the most equitable option. The comrades in the trade unions, most of whom support Fianna Fáil while making subscriptions to the Labour Party, wish to do it through the taxation system, but that fails to take account of the 29% of the population who do not pay tax or those who are on the lower end of the pay scale.
Comment on this
We selected the best option, which will put money into the pockets, not of the husbands but the mothers to enable them look after the children. All research has shown that is the best way to deliver money to those people who primarily have the care of children. Ultimately, it is a question of giving people assistance towards their child rearing costs so that they and they alone make their own decisions on rearing their children. The Government will stand on its record on the issue of child related payments.
Comment on this
I do not need to repeat the amount spent on this area by the previous Government. People have very short memories, but I do not.
Comment on this
Despite what the Minister has said he must admit the Government has failed on the question of child care, and not because of the failure to allocate money. In the budget of 1999, the Minister announced an allocation of £46 million to child care. Of this, £20 million was to be allocated to capital projects, but by the end of last October only £58,000 had been drawn down. The Government allocated a further £25 million to capital projects knowing the money would not be spent, although it provided media headlines. The total allocated by the end of last October was £3 million.
This is similar to the health services where there is substantial funding available but where the management of the provision of the services is causing problems. If the Government is serious about child care it must be proactive in managing the provision of facilities. A measure that might help is to provide that estates of more than 75 houses should have a designated house for the provision of child care. Our local authority is implementing this. It means that when people are buying houses they will know where the child care facilities will be provided.
Deputy Broughan's suggestion about how to become more proactive on the issue is a start. When Government Deputies knock on the doors they will be told they have failed in this area. Chairman, I will be unable to rejoin the committee because I am meeting a delegation from Finland.
Comment on this
I ask members to ensure that debate is relevant to the amendment and not to introduce other issues, such as planning or moneys from the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform.
Comment on this
The Minister has said he favours taking radical action to increase payments to all children through child benefits. Like St. Paul on the road to Damascus, he has only recently been converted to this approach. He has had to spend three years in Government to understand the policy implications of the views he has expressed to the committee. The difficulty is that in the period since 1997 much has been lost in terms of the payments that could have been made from the substantial budget surpluses.
If the country is serious about dealing with child care it is necessary to ensure that a tier of the education system is devoted to a State child care system. While many initiatives at local level are very good in terms of the subvention they receive, there must a national commitment to a national system of child care, as there is in Denmark, Sweden and other north European countries. That is the only long-term way in which options will be provided to families. The Government's policy fails to address that.
Comment on this
I do not accept the criticisms of the Opposition. I thank Deputy Broughan for, at least, accepting my arguments on child care, child care payments and aid related payments. I have made them since I became Minister and was alone in arguing against the latter. Deputy Broughan asked about the application of two different rates. The Combat Poverty Agency or the ESRI investigated carefully the option of one or two payments. It strongly recommended that because there is a higher risk of poverty in large families the payment should be greater for them. That is the reason they are graduated for the first two children, then third and subsequent children.
Fine Gael has been all over the place on this issue. There was a huge difference in approach by the former leader, Deputy John Bruton, and the current leader, then finance spokesperson, Deputy Noonan. At one point one said that £20 per week would be given in respect of children under the age of five year while the other had promised £25.
Comment on this
When it was indicated to them that the rearing of children after the age of five years does not become less costly and that large families would be subjected to a huge loss in terms of income adequacy, they decided to invent another payment between the ages of five and 12 years.
Comment on this
Fine Gael policy is all over the place. The Government has gone further than anything proposed by Fine Gael. The direction we have taken is the correct one. It puts money in the pockets of mothers. I am surprised that Deputy Fitzgerald is opposed to it. This money will allow mothers to make choices about the rearing of their children. At the end of the Government's term of office, especially following the next budget and another increase in child benefit, I will be prepared to go before the people who will give their answer to the Government's commitment to children.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 17 is related to amendment No. 13. Amendments Nos. 13 and 17 may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 6, before section 6, to insert the following new section:
"6.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of bringing the child benefit for twins into line with the provision for multiple births of 3 or more children.".
All members will have received campaign documentation from Parents of Twins Ireland. The agency is most concerned that twins be treated the same, in terms of child benefit, as other multiple births. Triplets, for example, receive six child benefit payments per month, that is, £282 in total, while quadruplets receive eight child benefit payments per month, that is, £394 in total, whereas two children born together are treated as one and a half and receive three child benefit payments, that is, a total of £127.50. The amendment deals with the question of whether significantly more should be paid for twins, the most common form of multiple birth.
In a household that I visit now and again there are two children with their grandparents. The little boy and girl are within three months of each other in age. I can imagine, therefore, the additional extra care cost which falls on a couple who have two babies of the same age. The two children I mentioned are aged about one year and 14 months, respectively. It is a similar situation to twins, although these children belong to two different families and the grandparents are providing the child care. I am aware that Miss Hilliard, the leader of the organisation mentioned, has been in contact with the Minister to ask if he has spotted the anomaly. Obviously, he has not or he would have changed the rates.
Comment on this
Having read the reports of Committee Stages of the Social Welfare Bill in previous years, I am aware that this issue regularly arises. It is an anomaly. I cannot understand the reason various Ministers have refused to recognise it and respond appropriately. There seems to be a suggestion of economies of scale and that twins are somewhat different from other multiple births. It is a discrimination in the social welfare code.
Whatever about existing rates of child benefit, the gap will widen from 1 June. I implore the Minister to look sympathetically at both amendments given the reporting mechanism in place. The Minister will present another Social Welfare Bill later this year and perhaps he will consider this issue before then. I would be interested to know the amount of money about which we are talking in terms of ending this discrimination. We need to address this issue which is a bone of contention for the parents of twins.
Comment on this
Prior to the introduction of the Social Welfare Act, 1998, child benefit was payable at double the normal rate for each child where three or more children were born together. The rate was double for triplets. In the case of twins, child benefit was paid at the normal rate. However, a grant of £500 was payable on the birth of twins and further grants of £500 were payable when the twins reached the ages of four and 12 years.
In fulfilment of our pre-election commitments I introduced two key additional measures in the Social Welfare Act ,1998. First, the rate of child benefit payable in respect of twins was increased to 150% of the normal child benefit rate and, second, the £500 grants, which were previously confined to families with twins, were extended to include all families with multiple births of three or more children. Both these measures took effect from September 1998 at a full year cost of £4.8 million.
The enhanced child benefit rates payable in the case of twins and other multiple births give an appropriate level of recognition within the child benefit scheme to the special nature of such births and their additional associated costs, and fully implement the commitment made in this regard.
As we have provided for significant gains for all families with children, the child benefit rates will kick in from June 2001, three months earlier than usual. The cost of providing for double child benefit payments for twins is estimated at £10.2 million in a full year, based on the improved rates recently announced in the budget. That figure would be higher in the context of next year's increase being similar to that granted this year. However, I have stated that I will keep an eye on the issue. I have other pre-election commitments with which we have complied. I have stated that I would prefer to fulfil all the commitments and then return to the issue of twins. I will examine the issue in the context of the next budget, but I cannot give any guarantees.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 15 and 40 are related to amendment No. 14 and these amendments may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 6, before section 6, to insert the following new section:
"6.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of providing for a uniform rate of child dependant allowance by increasing the different rates to the maximum rate and of increasing the child dependant allowance for widows and widowers to £20 per child per week.".
I was struck by the unanimity of the social welfare submissions I received before Christmas. I think it was the Society of St. Vincent De Paul which made the point that the general increases in child benefit were welcome. During the partnership Government, my colleague, Joan Burton, then Minister of State at the Department of Social Welfare and who, I hope, will return to the House after the next general election, was very keen on extending child benefit.
Things have changed a little, however, in the past seven years. That was the reason the Society of St. Vincent De Paul was of the view that we should try to better target resources at the children of those on social welfare incomes. This is particularly the case given the points made on earlier amendments on the manner in which social welfare incomes have fallen behind general incomes. I received particularly strong representations from the Widows Association and individual widows with young children stating that the £17 rate was disgraceful. Widows with children face difficulties. This would be a way of targeting resources at them.
An additional child benefit payment could be made to those on social welfare, but why would one do so when there are child dependant allowances? Schedule B concerns rates of assistance. The rate for a qualified child, where payable, is £13.20. The one-parent family rate is £15.20. Some of the rates in Schedule A, such as disability and unemployment benefit and old age contributory and retirement pensions, are £13.20. Widow's and widower's pension is the only rate which is slightly higher. The representations I received were to the effect that we should re-examine child dependant allowances.
We have heard all the arguments and I understand the general points the Minister makes about increases in child benefit. The Combat Poverty Agency highlighted the fact that a particular problem arises concerning the 12% of children who still live in consistent, never mind relative, poverty. That is a huge percentage of children. The Minister has an instrument at his disposal to address the issue, but it is obvious that he is not going to move on it today. However, he should examine the issue again or establish one of his famous departmental committees. My amendment calls for £20 per week per child, but one could argue for £25 per week for children in these circumstances.
This is a way of topping up the whole family's income. I was struck by the fact that so many groups, including the INOU, were of the view that we should look at this issue again. What would the £13.20 payment be if we had indexed it up to 2001? I urge the Minister to reconsider the implications of upgrading child dependant allowances.
Comment on this
Child dependant allowances are paid at different rates ranging from £13.20 to £17. Standardising these rates is an outstanding recommendation of the Commission on Social Welfare. What are the Minister's plans concerning these allowances? It seems the intention is to allow them to wither away. They have not been increased for seven years. The Government is working through child benefit, but it has never formulated a policy on child support. Will the Minister elaborate on the Government's policy in this area? Does it intend to abolish child dependant allowances? Is this what is happening? What is the long-term plan on basic income for children whose needs cannot be met by families?
The Minister talks a lot about child benefit which he confuses with a subsidy for child care. Child benefit will never be a subsidy for child care as the cost of the latter is enormous. Child care is not available. Will the Minister clarify the Government's policy on child dependant allowances? Are there plans to standardise them? Perhaps the Minister views this allowance as irrelevant although all the submissions we have received highlight its importance for families and advocate its standardisation. The argument advanced is that the standardisation of the allowances would not create a poverty trap and would not act as a disincentive in terms of people taking up employment. What direction is the Government taking in regard to child income support and how does this allowance fit into its plans given that nothing has happened in this regard for seven years?
Comment on this
The CDAs have been considerably rationalised over the years in line with the recommendations of the Commission on Social Welfare. Some 36 rates applied at one time compared with the current three. Deputies will be aware that the loss of CDA by social welfare recipients on taking up employment can act as a disincentive. In the case of widows, it can also act as a disincentive to remarriage. On taking office, I examined the policy direction to freeze CDAs which commenced under former Minister, Deputy De Rossa, in his first year in office. I concurred with the rationale behind that decision and the strong recommendation made by officials to me and the former Minister that available money would be better spent on the universal child benefit payment rather than the CDA as its loss on taking up employment or on remarriage acts as a disincentive.
The policy of non-indexation of the CDAs and increasing child benefit above the rate of inflation has been in place since 1994. It is important to recognise that over that period, the combined child benefit and CDA payment has increased by more than double the rate of inflation. In 1994, child benefit payments represented 29% of the total child benefit-CDA payment for a family with four children but currently represent 47% and will further increase to 57% from June onwards. The cost of child dependant allowances in a full year currently amounts to £257 million and the introduction of a standard rate would prove extremely costly. The cost of paying all CDAs at the higher rate of £17 is estimated to be in the region of £49 million per annum while the estimated cost of paying a standard rate of £20 per week per child is £102 million. That would run counter to the thrust of existing policy in this area. Child benefit has been hugely increased in recent budgets at a cost of £330 million this year alone. Last year, the figure was £106 million, a substantial increase on the previous year when the increase totalled £40 million. I do not accept the Deputies' criticism that the Government does not have a policy in this regard. Most people would accept that the policy direction we have taken in regard to child poverty and child benefit is the correct one.
Comment on this
Childcare 2000, in its famous campaign prior to the budget before last, argued that parental child care payments should be taxed although that would raise all manner of questions. I spoke earlier about the various sectors in our society and, if one were to take the top 20%, it would be possible to raise questions about the fairness of across the board increases. However, if the Government were to decide not to go down that road because funds go to the primary carer in any event, it should be possible to re-examine CDAs. I was struck by the coherent arguments advanced by some organisations, particularly by widows, that child dependant allowances offered one means of targeting resources at the poorest 12% or 15% in society, the majority of whom are social welfare recipients.
Comment on this
I will undertake to re-examine the matter but I cannot guarantee any changes in this area. The labour market has changed since 1994 and has changed even further since 1997. However, the Government has already made a policy decision to invest heavily in child benefit; that will require significant resources and will not leave much scope to do anything else in this area. I will consider the matter further in light of the representations made.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's willingness to reconsider this matter. Many people expressed concern that increased allowances would act as a disincentive and would put families into the poverty trap on taking up employment. Given the change in the employment market, that argument is not as strong as it would previously have been. If one considers the issue of child poverty and the provision of resources to the most vulnerable families which still depend on social welfare, the child dependant allowance would directly benefit those families and could significantly reduce levels of child poverty. I look forward to the Minister coming back to us on this issue. Perhaps he will outline his views in the Dáil if further parliamentary questions are tabled on the matter. Many organisations such as the INOU and the St. Vincent de Paul Society strongly advocated the standardisation of these allowances which they felt could have a positive effect on child poverty levels. I am sure they made their views clear in the pre-budget forum.
Comment on this
People also feel that child benefit should be increased but that the Government should adopt a two-pronged approach.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 7, between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the extent of child poverty and the feasibility in the context of the existing surplus funds within the Exchequer, of increasing child benefit to £100 per month per child.".
We have been over this ground already on the question of child benefit and have been treated to a series of propagandist messages from the Minister since budget day. There is a widespread feeling on this side and among members of the public that since this Government took office, we have not witnessed the level of improvements in child benefit which our economic surplus would warrant.
While we welcome this year's improvements, Fine Gael vehemently opposes their introduction three months down the line rather than in the first week of April. I urge the Minister to re-examine child benefit rates even if they only apply for a nine month period until 31 December. We hope to see significant improvements in this area in the next Social Welfare Bill. As Deputy Fitzgerald correctly pointed out, the Government does not have a coherent policy on children and the supports which should be put in place to look after them. In spite of the Minister's propaganda, the rates which have been set are very disappointing in view of the resources which exist within the economy.
Comment on this
I will not go over the same ground. I do not accept the Deputy's comments. At the end of the period during which the Government indicated it would spend £1 billion on child benefit, families with two children will receive £117.50 per month and those with a third or more children will receive £146 per month. That represents a substantial investment in children. The most recent independent survey carried out by the ESRI showed that the level of consistent poverty among children had reduced to 12%, a decrease of almost 30% in 12 months between 1997 and 1998. This accelerates the downward trend in child poverty figures with consistent poverty among children halved from 24.8% in 1987 to 12% in 1998. The Government is committed to further reducing poverty in society. We are examining new targets to be set under the national anti-poverty strategy. Child poverty will be one of the issues.
Comment on this
Yes, we had this discussion earlier. It is a payment to families towards child rearing costs to allow them to make their own decisions on how they organise their lives in terms of whether both parents work or one remains at home. If we did anything other than provide child benefit, we would discriminate against a large section of the community. It is the fairest, most equitable way of putting money in people's pockets to assist them with child rearing. Child benefit will never pay people to care for their children, which is ultimately their responsibility alone.
Comment on this
Child care costs for many people range between £70 and £120 per week. Through child benefit, one can never hope to give the families a choice. Child benefit does not provide parents with the ability to pay such costs. Is it not confusing to think child benefit can pay for child care? One only has to examine the figures quoted by the Minister. There is no doubt child benefit is increasing and heading in the right direction. It is not true that it is a payment for child care given the costs. Perhaps it is a contribution but it is good to give people a choice. If the Government expects that child benefit will pay for child care or even be a subsidy towards it, it is not realistic given the costs of child care. Is it not necessary to adopt another policy through the social welfare or taxation systems, as promised in the programme for Government? Is it not confused thinking that child benefit will pay for child care given the costs?
Comment on this
The inference in the Deputy's suggestion is that the taxpayer should fund parents totally for looking after children. Child benefit or the taxpayer could never totally fund the cost of child care places for parents who work. We are making a contribution through child benefit towards child rearing costs. Ultimately, it is their responsibility to look after their children and to decide whether they wish to work or stay at home. It would be discriminatory to do otherwise.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying the Government does not have a responsibility to develop a child care infrastructure which is accessible by parents?