We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FAMILY, COMMUNITY AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS

Social Welfare Bill, 2001: Committee Stage.

Contributions 203–409 of 409. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Social Welfare Bill 2001
Enacted

No. 5 of 2001 ›

My implication does not relate to the taxpayer. As a society Ireland has an obligation to provide more facilities other than child benefit, which is not enough. The Minister is confusing policy if his Department continually says child benefit is a payment for child care costs because it can never be. It is only a drop in the ocean given the child care costs parents face. The reason I am going back to this is that it is a confusing policy at Government level, not just at departmental level, to claim that child benefit will cover child care costs.

Comment on this

Nobody is claiming that. I have not said that. We had this discussion earlier but the Deputy was not present.

Comment on this

I heard that part of the debate but it is also relevant to this amendment.

Comment on this

The earlier discussion related to increasing the supply of child care places, which can only be done by investing in infrastructure. The Government has fast-tracked a commitment to spend £400 million this year on the provision of child care places. Only then will the cost of child care reduce for those who are paying excessive amounts currently. Is the Deputy seriously suggesting that if there is a change in Government her party will fund totally the costs of child care for people who work? That would be a false promise. The Government committed itself to taking into account those families who decide their own circumstances in terms of whether both parents work or one stays at home, and to give them a contribution towards their child rearing costs, not a contribution towards paying child care which is their responsibility. That involves a substantial investment. It will also have the added benefit of resolving many child poverty issues.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept there is a fundamental contradiction in the Government's position? At one level it is encouraging a new group of people to re-enter the workforce to take up job vacancies but, at another level, as Deputy McGrath said in terms of the number of places it has provided directly or supported, it is failing to meet that additional group's demand in terms of child care. The exchange in which the Minister is engaged with Deputy Fitzgerald exposes the contradiction between a fiscal policy which dramatically favours individualisation and a policy which does not meet his targets for the provision of child care places.

Is the Minister aware of the cost in Dublin per week to a family of placing a child in a crèche? Does the State have any responsibility in providing child care as another layer of education? The majority of funding for pre-school facilities is provided by the State with some local contribution. Is the Minister saying the State has no responsibility in providing child care through pre-school education facilities given that a significant number of other EU countries with modern social welfare and education systems already do so?

Comment on this

The State makes provision in many guises. My Department provides substantial funding to community development projects and family resource centres so that they can provide child care facilities within communities where they are most needed. Many other initiatives in this regard are funded primarily by the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform which has responsibility for this area. One must have the supply to encourage people into the workplace. It will take some time to build up that supply but the resources are available now. When one looks at everything we have done in context, we have put a huge investment into the supply side, and into the demand side, in the guise of child benefit. The Deputy mentioned individualisation and the tax code, which helps women in particular who choose to go out to work. They get the entitlement they should have been entitled to as equal partners and not as an appendage of their husbands, as was the case heretofore. A combination of those three initiatives will make a substantial start on a long road towards providing proper child care facilities and supports to parents. It will take some time and cannot be done with a magic wand. It is simplistic for the Opposition to say nothing is happening. There is a lot happening and anyone who looks at the initiatives objectively, particularly those in the area of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform, will see that there are many changes in the area and that it has received many resources in order to meet demands.

Comment on this

The Minister said we are being simplistic but he is being simplistic in saying the increases in child benefit he made give parents a choice. The reality is that they do not.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy saying should be put in place?

Comment on this

I have lots of ideas.

Comment on this

The Deputy should pin her colours to the mast because she must come down on one side or the other. Should this be done through the taxation code? If so, then she is excluding at least 30% of the population.

Comment on this

The Minister is saying——

Comment on this

The Deputy does not have any answers.

Comment on this

I do. The Minister is saying that child benefit increases give parents a choice. However, unless those increases are substantially higher they do not, in effect, give parents a choice because the cost of child care and child rearing are so substantial now that the increases in child benefit do not effectively give parents any more choice.

Comment on this

I do not accept that.

Comment on this

That is the truth. If it costs £70 to £120 per week then the increases in child benefit do not make a substantial difference to the costs. Child benefit should be higher and we should have a child care policy.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy saying that the State should, in effect, pay people to have their children fully minded in crèches so they can go out to work while other mothers who decide not to work will get no payment?

Comment on this

The Minister should not turn the argument around.

Comment on this

That is the logic of the Deputy's argument.

Comment on this

There is an obligation on the Minister, who has it in his own policies, to help parents combine work and families. I am questioning the Minister on his continual assertion that child benefit gives parents choice about child care. It does not and he is confusing——

Comment on this

No. I said it gives them the payment——

Comment on this

There are no child care facilities out there.

Comment on this

——to make their own choices.

Comment on this

It does not.

Comment on this

It does.

Comment on this

The costs are too high so they do not have a choice. Government policy has neither provided the child care places nor given sufficient increases in child benefit to help realistically.

Comment on this

Again, the Deputy has a simplistic view because she is in Opposition. As I said, it takes a substantial amount of time to build up the places required in order to bring the cost down. Child benefit, as I said, is a payment to people as a child rearing cost so that they can make their own choices. We are not forcing them to do something, as would be the position if we brought in a taxation method of paying people; we would not be giving people a choice and we would be discriminating against women in the home.

Comment on this

The Minister is not giving people a choice.

Comment on this

There would be discrimination against women in the home.

Comment on this

There is no choice at present because there are insufficient child care facilities, nor has the Minister improved child dependant allowances or child benefit.

Comment on this

More has been done since we entered Government than when the Opposition was in power.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment with a view to resubmitting it on Report Stage,

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In page 7, before section 7, to insert the following new section:

"7.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of the extension of the family income supplement to the families of persons who are self-employed and phasing out of the back-to-work scheme.".

This relates to a broader issue regarding the FIS. Many of us hoped the Minister and the Minister for Finance might have agreed to refundable tax credits and working this through the taxation system. The objective of bringing in the tax credit system seemed to be achieving refundable or positive tax credits rather than directly involving this Department at all. Obviously we have not achieved that desirable goal but the Minister replied to a parliamentary question about the back-to-work enterprise scheme during a recent Question Time. The question related to the 38,000 people who have availed of that scheme. Two years ago the Labour Party carried out a report on the back-to-work scheme from the employee and enterprise sides. The constant refrain from the latter side was the difficulties people suffered after the fourth year and that was the context for this amendment and a similar amendment last year - we are seeking to support some people.

I understand that the Minister's report commented on the enterprises some people had created. We on the north side of Dublin are familiar with the partnerships and people entering the hackney or taxi industries. Obviously questions have been raised about this scheme as an enterprise support mechanism or as a mechanism to help people out of long-term unemployment. Nevertheless, there is still a strong necessity, given my experiences of the northside partnership area over the last 14 to 15 years, for some sort of income support system for those who want to move into self-employment. Given how tough that can be in the early years, when one's long-term unemployment assistance is withdrawn, this was another method we saw as helping to sustain small businesses.

There is a range of other supports and one of our key supports in our area is to provide cheap enterprise space, which one might get for one-tenth for commercial space in the same locale. There are subsidies through the general community in that regard.

Comment on this

The Deputy's position is normally that taken by the farmers' lobby. Us urban people——

Comment on this

I know last year Deputies Crawford and McGrath put down a strong amendment regarding the general situation of the self-employed but it is a tremendous achievement for a slightly older person to go from unemployment to self-employment, running one's premises, doing the books and perhaps eventually employing someone else. It is hard enough to go from unemployment to employment but this has been a valuable scheme in many ways and going back to our pre-budget submissions, I was struck by the suggestions of Fr. Healy and CORI on refundable tax credits. We thought the Minister for Finance might surprise us with those this year but he did not.

Comment on this

The Chair made the argument against the extension of this. The argument made about FIS is that it is for employees and not the self-employed. There has been pressure from the farming sector to have it extended and there is a working group under the PPF to look at the possibility of integrating FIS with the taxation system rather than the social welfare system. As the Deputy will know, FIS is not available to self-employed people. I accept that when people come off welfare, it is as if there is a sudden death. In relation to self-employed people, it is a sum of about 25% and my Department has taken a number of initiatives to help people entering self-employment under the particular scheme. We have provided a sum of £250,000 to enable them to meet the cost of public liability insurance for their employment, something which is a big burden on them. We have provided an extra £250,000 to the First Step organisation to help it expand its programme of interest free loans to self-employed participants. The Deputy will probably know there are separate arrangements with the credit unions to guarantee loans to scheme participants.

It is an issue all right but pending the review of FIS generally, I cannot give any commitments one way or the other in relation to it. The question of extending FIS to self-employed back-to-work allowance people would obviously have implications and there would be knock on demands from other groups, such as farmers, to have it extended to them as well.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 35 is related to amendment No. 19. We will take amendment No. 19 and amendment No. 35 in the name of Deputy Hayes together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 19:

In page 7, before section 8, to insert the following new section:

"8.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of extending the social welfare free schemes to widows and widowers with dependent children and of raising the widowed parent grant to £2,000.".

This is a big issue for widows and widowers with dependent children. I also included the widowed parent grant in the amendment. Widows feel hard done by because there is still a range of anomalies in relation to their treatment which the Minister has not addressed. I know it is an old chestnut but we always come across the problem people on disability benefit have in accessing a full benefit. The Minister gives them a half rate in regard to disability benefit and that has been the situation over the years. A number of widows currently on disability benefit feel they have missed out, even though their contributions should have given them entitlement to it. I know we are moving into the territory of drawing more than one welfare benefit but, nonetheless, there is still a feeling that many widows and dependent children are suffering.

The Minister told me that the free schemes work out at an additional £9 or £10 per week on average for senior citizens. The extension of the free schemes to the over 70s is something on which I would commend the Minister. It was a very valuable development. Indeed, I got a lot of mail during the year from 72 and 73 year old men pointing out that the mortality rate among men increases as they advance into their 70s and that very few people over 75 years of age would be able to take advantage of it. However, I welcome the movement in that regard. I also welcome the extension of the schemes to the carers.

However, there seems to be an anomaly and the Labour Party and Fine Gael amendments concentrate on that. Given that this is a relatively small group of people, why can we not give them this little extra provision? Looking at the survivors' rates, widows with dependent children are a very vulnerable type family in that perhaps the major income of the family is suddenly snatched away after the trauma of the person dying. I mentioned this before in relation to Members of this House. Given the expense of and the difficult life in politics, if a Member with dependent children dies, think of the difficulties people at that level would face, not to mention somebody on a lower income. I ask the Minister to look at making provision for widows with dependent children, in particular.

Comment on this

As Deputy Broughan rightly said, his amendment No. 19 and our amendment No. 35 try to really improve the position for widows. As someone who was just elected in 1997, of all the groups one meets, this is one that stands out. Such people face a very difficult period when they have to deal at increasingly younger ages with the death of their spouse. The State has to show some leeway, particularly in these good times when we have the opportunity to deliver some kind of increase to them.

As Deputy Broughan rightly said, the extension of the free schemes to people over 70 years of age was a very worthwhile announcement. However, with a small amount of money, we could improve the position for widows and widowers.

I hope the Minister might agree even to a report between now and next October-November. This is my first Social Welfare Bill and it is unlike any other legislation in which I have had the privilege or misfortune of being involved since 1997. All these amendment seek a report, so no additional expenditure would be incurred by Ireland plc. We are simply asking for reports. Given that the period between now and next October, when the Minister will frame his next Social Welfare Bill, is relatively short, there would be much validity in introducing these reports. I ask the Minister to consider both amendments.

Comment on this

I thank the Deputies for raising this issue which is one that has been exercising my mind for the last number of years. I have looked at it in much detail because I get many representations from my parliamentary party, in particular, saying that we need to do more for widows. A review of the free schemes was carried out two years ago and it looked at this issue of extension to other groups, from old age pensioners to those on disability. It strongly suggested that there should be no change in terms of giving the free schemes to additional categories because the scheme was targeted at particular groups initially. If one was to give it to widows, there would be knock on demands from other groups, such as lone parents and other single people.

I strongly looked at the issue of extending the free schemes but over the last three budgets, I brought forward an increase in the bereavement grant from £100 to £500 and I introduced a new special grant for widows with children giving them an extra £1,000 so that a widow or widower, on the death of their spouse, would get £1,500 cash to assist them at that particular time. We also made changes in the continuance of payments after death for six weeks. We rationalised all those to make sure there were not discrepancies and anomalies, as there had been.

We looked at the free schemes but I finally came to a pre-election promise and that was to raise the widow's pension to the old age contributory pension rate. That is the reason we started along the route of giving a special increase of £12.90 to widows over 66 years. Some 68,000 widows will get the special increase of £12.90. That will be followed next year with a further special increase in order to bring them up to the level of the old age contributory pension. There is an exemption in relation to the free schemes which was made a number of years ago. It permitted widows and widowers between the ages of 60 and 65 years, whose late spouses were in receipt of free schemes, to retain their entitlements to ensure their households did not suffer a loss. The Government has also made substantial changes in the taxation code to assist widows.

This is an issue that is high on my agenda. It is not that I am against producing reports but I strongly suggest that the committee examine this issue. If it can make some recommendations, we will consider them. This issue has been at the core of discussions the Department has had at a policy level.

Comment on this

The Minister correctly pointed out that if the scheme is extended to one category of people it could have knock on effects. What are the problems with the knock on effects here? Are they purely financial?

Comment on this

Yes, they would be financial. In effect, it would mean giving the free schemes to everybody.

Comment on this

Is it not a useful way of delivering benefit to people?

Comment on this

Ultimately it would mean, particularly in relation to free travel, that everybody would have free travel.

Comment on this

There has to be a benchmark.

Comment on this

Some people have it on the DART already, late at night.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 8, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following subsection:

"(5) Noting that the tax year 2001 is of 38 weeks duration and noting that tax allowances are allowable at 74 per cent of the normal annual rate, that the Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the impact of section 8 on taxpayers who will no longer be entitled to receive the PRSI 'tax holiday' in this tax year.".

This matter was raised by my colleague, Deputy McGrath, and the Minister responded in his concluding remarks on Second Stage. This will be a shortened tax year, from 1 April to the end of December. It is a nine month period instead of a 12 month period and the number of weeks is obviously fewer than in other years.

In section 8 the Minister is increasing the PRSI ceiling for employees from £26,500 to £28,250. We welcome that; it is good policy. The situation to date for employees with incomes above those thresholds was that they got a PRSI holiday for the part of the tax year that their income exceeded the PRSI threshold. In the last tax year, almost 340,000 employees availed of this holiday, which averaged about £300 per person. Since the 2001 tax year is a shortened tax year of 38 weeks, we argue that it will have an effect on the ability of that group of taxpayers to claim their PRSI holiday at the end of the year. The personal allowances and the PAYE allowances announced in the Budget Statement and provided for in the Finance Bill are 74% of the annual amount. In a later amendment, this Minister refers to this 74% amount, given the shortened tax year.

We argue that it is not unreasonable to expect the PRSI ceiling to kick in also at 74% of the value. This is something the Government clearly forgot. Under the current proposals, this group of taxpayers will not gain a tax holiday at the end of the year because of the special circumstances this year, so the amendment seeks a report on this matter.

Comment on this

The amendment in my name to which the Deputy referred relates to voluntary contributors——

Comment on this

It is the percentage.

Comment on this

If I am referring to the same amendment, it allows them to make the requisite contributions and not have them paying more than would be required.

This amendment suggests that PRSI contributors are being disadvantaged in relation to employee annual earnings ceilings which will apply in the transition year 2001. This is incorrect and I am anxious to clear up confusion in this regard. Normally, employees who have annual earnings in excess of the ceiling have a period, referred to as a PRSI holiday, at the end of each tax year where they do not make an employee contribution. This period, in the case of a person earning £36,000 per annum, would run from mid-January to 5 April in a normal year.

In the transitional year 2001, this contributor will pay PRSI from April to December 2001 and continue paying PRSI from 1 January 2002. He/she will have a PRSI holiday in the period October to December 2002. The overall effect is a delay in the commencement of the PRSI holiday period by nine months on an ongoing basis. This contributor will not lose as a result of the alignment process. He/she will have two holiday periods, one in each of the calendar years 2001 and 2002. The only change is the period where the holiday comes into effect. Overall, all employees who pay at the main rate will gain as a result of the 0.5% reduction in the employee rate, from 4.5% to 4%.

There is no justification, in equity, for a reduction in the PRSI annual earnings ceilings in 2001. Any such reduction would only benefit higher earners, who comprise 13% of all employees. If a reduction of 26% was adopted, these contributors would pay less PRSI in the calendar year 2001, unlike all other contributors. This would represent a once off gain to a relatively small number of higher income employees.

It is also important to remember that I am making provision in the Bill so that nobody will be disadvantaged with respect to entitlement to benefits as a result of the nine month short tax year. It follows, therefore, that it is also appropriate that PRSI contributors make the same contribution as they would ordinarily make in the nine month period from April to December of any year. A similar situation will apply to income tax and this is the purpose of the 74% tax allowances. The employee PRSI ceiling is not an allowance and therefore there is no necessity to reduce it. In fact, to do so would be unfair to the vast majority of contributors.

What is at issue here is a matter of timing. Nobody is losing. People will get the PRSI holiday in the last three months of 2002 instead of in the first three months of that year. To do what the Deputy suggests would effectively mean that people would have two holidays in 2001.

Comment on this

That is the net issue. There are two calendar years but there are three tax years. Deputy McGrath's question is why, therefore, are there not three PRSI holiday opportunities for taxpayers in those three tax years? From April 2000 to April 2001 is one tax year, April 2001 to December 2001 is a second tax year and January 2002 to December 2002 is a third tax year. There are three tax years but, as the Minister points out, there are only two tax holidays, one in 2001 and one in 2002. Deputy McGrath's point is that the allowances have already been changed to take account of the three tax years in the Finance Bill. Why is there not the same application of that principle in the Social Welfare Bill?

Comment on this

It is because we have, in effect, only two benefit years. The Deputy cannot equate RSI with the tax years; it must be equated with the benefit years, that is, social welfare benefits. Nobody is losing out as a result of this. That is how it has been organised in the Bill. It is only a matter of delaying the holiday because of the nine month period. Nobody will lose out in relation to contributions made or benefits gained.

Comment on this

In other words, there will be no difference in terms of the total amount that taxpayers would not fail to gain. If Deputy McGrath's amendment was accepted, however, they would obtain a tax benefit at the end of this year and another at the end of 2002. Is the Minster stating that if the two were added together it would be the same as obtaining the full amount at the end of 2002?

Comment on this

Over the entire two year period, there will be no loss to people in relation to PRSI contributions or no gain either.

Comment on this

The point Deputy McGrath makes is that, administratively and in terms of how it will operate for taxpayers, it would be a better system if at the end of 2001 they obtained a proportion of the tax holiday to which they are normally entitled and obtained the remainder at the end of 2002. Is the Minister stating that there is no net difference between the two systems?

Comment on this

That is the point we are making, but I am not sure that Deputy McGrath is making the same point. As I understand it, the net effect of what he is proposing to do would be to give somebody two PRSI holidays in the same year and another holiday in the following year.

Comment on this

One at the end of each tax year.

Comment on this

Yes, but they would also have one at the start of the nine month period.

Comment on this

I will withdraw the amendment and allow Deputy McGrath to revisit the matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 8, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following subsection:

"(5) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, issue a statement to both Houses of the Oireachtas on the impact of abolishing the ceiling on employers PRSI as it affects competition and employment policy.".

My party's spokesperson on Finance and I referred to the matter covered in this amendment in our contributions on this Bill and the Finance Bill. The Minister is abolishing the upper ceiling limit on employers' PRSI from the previous amount of £36,600 and there is a great deal of concern among employers about this measure. I tabled the amendment, which requests that a report be placed before the Houses, in order that we can discuss this matter in detail.

The major concern expressed by employers was that this measure was introduced so suddenly and that the Government made no attempt to outline its policy in this area. Given the difficulties that are emerging in the US economy and the problems our economy is experiencing with regard to the supply of labour, many people have pointed out that this will act as another disincentive in terms of attracting skilled people to come here to take up the considerable number of jobs on offer. I repeat the point made by IBEC that this was a very sudden move and that no effort was made to indicate that it would happen.

The amount of money involved is significant. If we take a person with a salary of £50,000 - I do not fail to recognise that this is a sizeable amount - under the old regime, with the ceiling of £36,600 in place, the amount of employers' PRSI to be paid would have been approximately £4,300. Under the new scheme, however, an employer is obliged to pay over £6,500 in PRSI on a salary of £50,000. That may seem to be a small increase when viewed in conjunction with significant improvements in corporation tax and other measures that have been introduced by the Government. However, we have an obligation to assess these measures against employment and competition policy. These changes in PRSI will not just affect multinationals. Many domestic businesses which are obliged to employ people on high salaries could be exposed as a result of the abolition of the ceiling. As a result, I ask the Government and the Minister to allow us to report on the effects of this measure in respect of competition and employment policy.

Comment on this

On this occasion I cannot support my colleagues in Fine Gael. I accept that this decision was sprung on people but the broader issue the Minister for Finance raised, namely, the contribution of business to the national Exchequer, remains important. We made a decision - I believe Deputy Quinn was responsible for initiating it - to start reducing corporation tax to 12.5%, which is an amazingly low rate for business and is one of the reasons the Minister, Deputy McCreevy, got into trouble recently with is European colleagues. I recall, when I taught economics, looking at national accounts where the contribution from business on the taxation side was practically zero, the only exception being the few thousand pounds paid in corporation tax. It was only during the 1990s, with the advent of the IFSC and similar enterprises, that there was any kind of decent return in terms of the amount paid in corporation tax. I am amazed that it is still increasing in overall terms, even though the rate is decelerating to 12.5%.

The Minister for Finance stated that he was only going to claw back £150 million or £160 million through this provision, which is fair enough. We are moving towards a position when everyone will qualify for contributory pensions and when people are going to have some form of PRSA or occupation pension. Included in this could be people of foreign origin who are working here at present but who, having returned to their home country, could be entitled to claim an Irish pension. The Minister's action, therefore, is fair in terms of enabling us to recover some funding from business, which obtains such extensive help from Enterprise Ireland, IDA Ireland, etc.

Comment on this

With regard to Deputy Broughan's question, is this part of the claw back, is it thefull claw back or are there further measures to come?

Comment on this

I cannot predict the changes that might be introduced in future budgets. Deputy Hayes made the point that it will affect ordinary people. It will not do so, in a direct way, in that it is an employers' contribution, not an employee's contribution. It would not, therefore, deter people from returning to this country to work.

One of the reasons we have been so successful in encouraging large international industries to establish operations here is the 12.5% rate of corporation tax. While Deputy Broughan might try to claim some credit for his party leader, Deputy Quinn only made his announcement a number of short weeks before the last election. When we entered office we had to commence the negotiations in relation to reducing the rate of corporation tax and, thankfully, we were extremely successful in our efforts.

The total cost of the various changes in corporation tax announced in the budget will amount to £214 million in a full year, which is substantially higher than the projected yield of £150 million from this particular change. I do not accept the arguments made by other people. We have probably one of the lowest, if not the lowest, levels of PRSI in Europe. We are way ahead of Britain in respect of virtually all the rates and there has been ceiling on employers' PRSI there for many years. In my opinion, ours is a reasonable response. I agree with many of the sentiments expressed by Deputy Broughan in this regard. The social insurance fund needs to be maintained in relatively good stead because the rainy day will come soon in regard to PRSI and demographic trends.

Comment on this

It was a policy decision to abolish the PRSI ceiling. Why was the decision taken to abolish the ceiling as opposed to extending the limits significantly?

Comment on this

It is somewhat unfair that there is a ceiling. Why should people at the higher end of the scale not pay their fair share? Ceilings tend to assist the better off.

Comment on this

The Minister considered the matter closely with his colleague, the Minister for Finance, and is convinced this change will have no adverse effect on our ability to attract the brightest and best back to Ireland at a difficult time in the labour market.

Comment on this

If the brightest and best examine the social insurance contributions payable in Ireland as opposed to elsewhere, they will realise this regime and its benefits are much better than comparable systems in western Europe.

Comment on this

Is the Minister concerned about employment and competition policy?

Comment on this

I will always be concerned about employment but companies do not make strategic decisions based on relatively small money in comparison with the overall scheme of things. Given that the corporation tax return, based on the steps taken to reach a rate of 12.5%, is much higher than its yield, much of the publicity engendered by this change was unwarranted.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:

In page 10, before section 12, but in Part 3, to insert the following new section:

"12.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of making provision for the extended payment of maternity or adoptive benefit to women who take maternity or adoptive leave on or before the commencement of this section but after the making of regulations under the Maternity Protection Act, 1994, or the Adoptive Leave Act, 1995, extending the period of leave.".

The amendment refers to the welcome extension of maternity and unpaid leave by four weeks. We discussed earlier the introduction of the additional four weeks from 8 March. People who are on maternity and adoptive leave from 8 February are entitled to the extra unpaid leave but they cannot avail of the additional leave with adoptive and maternity benefit. A timeframe had to be laid down in this regard and the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform zeroed in on 8 March but many women on maternity leave felt they were hard done by because of this decision.

A more generous view could have been taken and everybody who had applied under the Maternity Leave Act, 1994, and the Adoptive Leave Act, 1995, could have been included. Both Acts provide for a requirement of four weeks leave but there is a strong demand to be generous in this regard and include all those who are currently on adoptive and maternity leave. Many people contacted me within hours of the provisions being made public. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform informed my colleague, Deputy O'Sullivan, that this was impossible because of the operation of both Acts.

Nonetheless this could have examined in a generous light. I have tabled an amendment with a similar request in regard to carer's benefit. Many people have contacted me who took carer's leave at their own expense in the past few years and feel they have also been excluded from availing of additional benefit because of the way the Carer's Leave Bill, 2000, has been drafted. When it comes into operation they will be discriminated against and they feel they should have been considered.

I appreciate the Minister would have to go back to the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform to introduce new regulations and so on under the two Acts but there is a question of equity in this regard.

Comment on this

I claim credit for the extension of this provision to adoptive leave because the original intention under the PPF was to review and improve the maternity protection legislation but it was pointed out that the same was needed in regard to adoptive leave. That is why it was extended, even though it was examined by the PPF working group.

We have been as generous as legally and practically possible. We originally intended to introduce this provision on 5 April and make the announcement on budget day but because of representations from the public and both sides of the House we decided to introduce it as quickly as possible. We were prepared to pay the extra money involved to introduce the provision earlier. The constraints of the two Acts involved restricted us and we had to propose positive motions in both Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

Could the provision have been made retrospective under the legislation?

Comment on this

No, we tried to do so but the Attorney General strongly advised us that it could not be done retrospectively once the regulations were signed. One must still provide four weeks' notice if one wishes to avail of unpaid maternity or adoptive leave. If people are availing of four extra weeks of unpaid maternity leave they are doing so at the employer's behest and not as a legal imperative. The regulations were signed on 8 February and will come into operation on 8 March.

We introduced the provision as quickly as possible and we cannot do much more. The necessity to have motion passed in both Houses of the Oireachtas was also a constraint.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 10, after line 42, to insert the following subsection:

"(5) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report detailing the implications of:

(a) extending maternity leave to 20 weeks, and

(b) introducing paid parental leave for 5 days.”.

I welcome the increase in maternity leave and I congratulate the Minister on the change in adoptive benefit because it is important. Combining work and family can prove very difficult, particularly following the birth of a baby. We have been very slow to extend maternity leave and that has not made life easy for people. I welcome the improvements because they are good and necessary. Had we not made them now, we would never have made them. The economy is strong enough to make them now, and they are undoubtedly economically driven rather than child driven. The improvements have taken a long time to be passed into law and we are still low by EU standards in the leave we give to parents. The amendment seeks to extend maternity leave to 20 weeks and to have consideration given to paid parental leave.

Does the Minister have figures for those who have taken parental leave? One of the problems is it is unpaid and those who take it lose pay and take it at their own expense. The Minister said in the Dáil recently that he was considering this issue. Has any progress been made? A new report is being published today by the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform. Will the Minister update us on that? The amendment extends the provisions the Minister brought forward in maternity and paid parental leave.

Comment on this

The extension to maternity leave was agreed at social partnership level. Obviously there were differences of opinion and a compromise was reached. As soon as the report was issued the Government agreed to provide the necessary resources in the budget to implement the measures and that was done more quickly than was thought by the social partners. Any extension of that would have to be discussed with the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, who would have direct responsibility for it, in consultation with the social partners.

As regards parental leave, there is provision under the Parental Leave Act, 1998, whereby employers are obliged to pay up to three days'force majeure leave for urgent family reasons. That is available in certain cases. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform is in consultation with the social partners. He has sought nominations from various interest groups for a working group to conduct a review on this. It is expected the group will commence deliberations shortly and that the question of paid parental leave will be raised in the context of that review.

While we would like to see improvements, conflicting interests are involved and it is a question of trying to marry them as best as possible. That is what happened with maternity leave. I thank the Deputy for her comments about adoptive leave. The improvements were relatively easy to make because a huge amount was not involved for employers in terms of finance and numbers. Paid parental leave is on the Government agenda and is one of the issues it wishes to promote. Obviously that must be done in consultation with the social partners.

Comment on this

Does the Minister have a date for that review?

Comment on this

No. The Deputy should take it up with the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform.

Comment on this

Is the review established under the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform an interdepartmental one? This is a social welfare issue as well. Will the Minister's Department be represented on it?

Comment on this

We will. We are the paymasters. We would have to have some view.

Comment on this

Amendment Nos. 24, 25 and 32 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:

In page 16, between lines 44 and 45, to insert the following subsection:

"(2) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report considering the implications of:

(a) increasing the respite care grant to £1,000 to all carers including those who are excluded by virtue of a means test,

(b) removing the disqualification, whereby carers in receipt of social welfare payments are excluded from qualifying for a carer’s allowance in special circumstances.”.

This is a touchstone issue as far as our party is concerned in terms of the provisions of the Bill. While we recognise there has been a small improvement in the respite care grant, it does not meet people's needs. This point was made repeatedly on Second Stage. There are more than 120,000 carers. The Minister in his reply to the Second Stage debate stated that 17,000 carers have been in receipt of the grant and that, as a result of the changes he has introduced, another 4,000 to 5,000 will receive it.

The amendment calls for an increase in the respite care grant to £1,000 and that it be available to all carers, including those excluded by the means test. It is the least we can do for a huge section of people who provide care for many people and who receive very little in return. This is the minimum the State can do to recognise their contribution. The amendment also proposes the removal of disqualifications whereby carers in receipt of social welfare payments are excluded from receiving a carer's allowance in special circumstances. I understand Deputy Broughan has a more specific amendment in this regard.

This was an area where there was general disappointment with the Minister's announcement of changes in the Bill. The improvements are meagre, small and insufficient. While he has made improvements in other areas, he has not made matching improvements for carers. The Minister stated that, because so many more people are working, the claim on social security and the financial resources to meet it are not as great as they once were. However, other states have a much more integrated system of providing assistance for carers. We need to follow those examples. I implore the Minister to examine these amendments because they are touchstone issues as far as our party is concerned.

Comment on this

This was the substance of a similar amendment last year. When one meets carers at conferences or through their representative bodies, it is obvious their time and health are under severe pressure when caring for an older person or a child with a disability. Many people at the carers' conference in Drumcondra last summer told me the key issue is to have some time to themselves. They want some time off in the form of a significant break during the year. After that conference I spoke to older women from my constituency who cared for men who were not that old, in their early 50s, who were suffering from Alzheimer's disease. I found it very moving and emotional as they described the enormous pressure they were under. I thought the Minister would just double this from £300 to £600, particularly if one thinks of the costs involved if one is on the carer's allowance of £80 per week. If one were trying to put together money for a reasonable holiday in the west or south-west, or indeed going abroad, £400 is a small amount to be offered. That is why I suggested £1,000 to enable people to have a week or ten days away. I ask the Minister to examine the possibility of doing this for the most vulnerable and heroic group of our fellow citizens.

There is an old rule that I referred to in discussing the position of widows regarding people being unable to get full disability benefit even though they felt they were entitled to it. Those on lone parent benefit who are also looking after seniors with a grave disability, a young woman looking after a couple of children and trying to care for a seriously disabled older person, had their claims for carer's allowance refused by the Minister. These are special cases that should be looked at again. No matter how expensive it is to look after the carers of Ireland, we in the Labour Party feel it is a fundamental issue and most people would give the Minister marks for introducing carers benefit, though it took him a year to get it to this stage although people are still not really covered. When will this Bill be introduced? It will be at least well into April, which is a year and a half after the Minister took the kudos and bows from the carers of Ireland; only then will people be covered by carer's leave legislation. I do not see why the Minister did not get onto the Tánaiste and say he wanted the legislation in the parliamentary session which ended this time last year. It should have passed before last Easter to be fair to those seeking carer's benefit.

We need a bigger respite and a comprehensive system of caring for these people. We did the basic mathematics on this matter. Last night there was a big meeting of carers in Limerick under the strong leadership of Ger South, who has been a vigorous proponent of the rights of carers over the years. Over 200 people turned out for that meeting though there were no Fianna Fáil representatives there. The Labour Party was represented by Deputy O'Sullivan and Fine Gael——

Comment on this

That is the drudgery of being in Government. The Deputy is keeping us locked in here.

Comment on this

It was Monday night. It was specially organised so that Deputy O'Dea and the other famous representatives there, who was keeping an eye on the new Leader of Fine Gael, could have turned up. Only Labour and Fine Gael were there to make the commitment to remove the means test for carers and to look at this on the basis of medical need. There is a groundswell there.

We did the mathematics on this last year and no matter how one works it out, the 120,000 carers referred to by my colleague are carrying out £2 to £2.5 billion worth of work. The Minister is prepared to give them only £120 million worth of income through the social welfare system. There are ongoing questions to answer about this. The Minster has tinkered this when it demands a full scale collective response to these very vulnerable groups - the carers and those they look after. We have to work with the Department of Health and Children on this and there is a motion down on the cost of caring allowance but the fundamental issue remains - carers are hard done by.

The Minister was not as generous this year as everyone thought with the disregards. The Taoiseach sent a message to the meeting the other night that he will increase the disregard next year to £330 per year for a family. I am not sure if that was cleared with the Department of Family, Community and Social Affairs.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sure it was not Deputy O'Dea who sent the message?

Comment on this

He could have turned up. The basic point is that the respite grant of £400 is miserable. What about the people on lone parent benefit - I came across two instances of that - and other benefits also? They may also have a caring role but the Minister will not relax this rigid rule that one can only have one benefit at a time. How long does the Minister have left?

Comment on this
Matt Brennan Mr. M. Brennan Fianna Fáil

A year and four months.

Comment on this

The Minister has 16 months left.

Comment on this

Not according to the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Minister should not make the same mistake John Major made in going for the last hour of the last day. He has 16 months left to deliver for the carers and the general feeling is he has abandoned them and has not delivered. He has tinkered with a few things but he has not delivered. These two amendments are proof of what is needed.

Comment on this

For the purposes of balance it is only fair to say the Minister did lift the disregards to the level this committee asked for in our pre-budget discussion.

Comment on this

Respite care has been very important to carers and they are very appreciative of it. The fact it exists at all shows the huge need that is there. These amendments suggesting respite care is increased should be accepted by the Minister. There is no need to repeat at length the extraordinary demands that caring places on people and the fact that it is a 24 hour job. We have all met representatives of the carers' associations and those who are carers and it is an extraordinarily demanding job that has gone largely unrecognised.

One of the major shortcomings of the social welfare system is the absence of recognition for caring as such. We have two payments but neither constitutes a recognition. One is the carer's allowance, which is means tested, as we know, but is really for low income carers. The other is a short compensation for giving up work. The contribution of family carers is simply not recognised or rewarded. Is the Department engaged in any policy development in this area? We have these allowances but has any thought been given to a cost of care payment or cost of disability payment, whatever one wants to call it? Is any work being done on this in the Department? Is it being considered? Should we not be planning for the introduction of a carer's payment which is not contingent on means or social insurance? What is the policy direction of the Government on this? Obviously, the voluntary organisations in this area would like to see such a development.

There is a lack of coherence between social welfare and tax policies. The home carer's tax credit is exactly the same, whether one is caring for a healthy 18 year old or an incapacitated child or adult. This credit is not available if the person being cared for is a spouse, yet there is a reasonably generous tax allowance if a person can afford to employ a carer to look after an incapacitated person at home. There is a lack of coherence between the taxation and social welfare approaches. Will the Minister tell the committee whether he is considering introducing a cost of caring payment as opposed to the two payments currently in place, one of which is means tested for low income carers and the other is compensation for giving up work? Will there be recognition of caring per se or will there be any other developments in that area?

Comment on this
Matt Brennan Mr. M. Brennan Fianna Fáil

The Minister should make special provision for those caring for people with Alzheimer's disease. A friend of mine who is caring for her mother who has this disease does not qualify for a carer's allowance because her income is too high. I would like to see something being done for this person. If this woman visits friends or relatives, her mother is always on edge and wishes to leave after a short time. This is a full-time job but, thankfully, the woman gets home help and respite breaks from people who look after her mother. However, there should be special arrangements for people with Alzheimer's disease.

I compliment the Minister on extending the mileage in relation to the carer's allowance, particularly in rural areas. I know of a case where a daughter lives within six or seven miles of her parents. This woman is caring for her parents as well as for her own family. After putting her children to bed, she travels to her parents' home and remains there until approximately midnight. This woman was refused carer's allowance because she lived some distance from her parents. TheMinister has increased the mileage which allows that person to qualify for the carer's allowance, which I welcome. If that woman did not care for her parents, they would probably be in St. John's Hospital, Nazareth House or some other institution in Sligo. Because of the allowance this woman is receiving, she is keeping her father and mother out of an institution. I welcome this change to the proximity rule, particularly in rural Ireland.

Comment on this

It is difficult to disagree with any of the comments made. While the Minister has made great progress, will the Department of Health and Children live up to its responsibilities?

Comment on this

The Chairman is correct when he refers to the Department of Health and Children. I am not trying to abdicate responsibility but people tend to think this is the only support available to people. There are a myriad of other supports, primarily in the Department that has primary responsibility in the area of caring for the infirm. It is somewhat disingenuous of the Opposition to say I tinkered with the system or made minimal changes. They suffer from very short memories. There have never been more changes to a scheme than in this case since I became Minister. There has been an 81% increase this year in recipients of carer's allowance since we came to office. The changes in this year's budget, which are anything but minimal, are substantial for 5,000 people. This will mean that by the end of this year there will be well an increase of over 100% in the number of people in receipt of this allowance; it will increase from 9,000, when we came into office in 1997, to 22,000 the nujmber of people in receipt of carer's allowance. These people will also receive the benefit of the free schemes, which very few of them were receiving up to now. People over 66 years of age who were receiving carer's allowance will now qualify for all the free schemes. The amount of money dedicated to the scheme was £35 million in 1997, £110 million currently, together with another £21 million; £21 million was the cost of the improvements we have made here.

I thank Deputy Fitzgerald for referring to the much needed respite care grant. People tend to forget that this Minister and Government introduced the respite care grant and increased it progressively in each budget to the current level. Obviously we will continue along these lines within the budgetary constraints that exist.

On the carer's benefit, I am particularly pleased about that scheme because, like anything relating to social welfare, when one gets a foot in the door, it is a bit like pre-1953. This has turned out to be an incredibly successful scheme. I have no doubt the carer's benefit——

Comment on this

Last year there were——

Comment on this

There were a few but the numbers are small. Like any scheme, it will take some time for numbers to build up. We estimate that somewhere in the region of 6,800 people will qualify for this allowance when it is fully up and running. I have no doubt, given the extent of the PRSI coverage, that it will increase over time.

I thank Deputy Brennan for his kind remarks and interest in this area. I made major changes in relation to the rules on close proximity. Until I became Minister, one did not receive a carer's allowance for looking after a relative who lived next door. I changed this regulation. Subsequently, particularly as a result of representations from Deputy Mattie Brennan, I was able to get sanction from the Department of Finance to do away with the close proximity rule which was causing difficulties. When this change was introduced, I gave a commitment that I would monitor its effects. That is just a flavour of some of the changes I made in this area.

In relation to overall planning, the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, and I met on a number of occasions recently to discuss the longer term view on how we should proceed. A consultancy study is considering the issue of long-term care and how we can perhaps marry the existing systems in order to have one coherent system. The Minister for Finance has already indicated that he is tabling amendments to the Finance Bill to assist people in their taxation arrangements in relation to insurance policies for long-term care. This is an issue I welcome and have promoted with the Minister for Finance to ensure people make provision for their problems which will manifest themselves in the future.

A lot of planning for the future is taking place. I would just say to Deputies that I fully accept the difficulties of carers. Each of us would have a life experience, so to speak, in this regard in our own families. In some cases, people will get assistance and in other cases they will not. The carer's allowance is a means tested payment. For a party, particularly the Labour Party, to say it will abolish the means test, will in effect mean giving the same amount of the limited resources available to the very well off as well as to those most in need. I do not agree with that policy direction.

To a certain extent the reason the Taoiseach was able to make a commitment to the meeting in Limerick was that I had already indicated on more than one occasion, publicly in the Dáil, to the carers' lobby groups and at parliamentary meetings this year, that having raised the disregard as requested by this committee, I aim to extend it to a stage where a family on average industrial earnings will be able to qualify for the maximum carer's allowance in the event of their fulfilling the other conditions. It was not rocket science. We had already promised that. In respect of Deputy Willie O'Dea, I am not altogether sure he was at the meeting, but I can assure Deputies that on Tuesday morning he lobbied me about the indications made at the meeting. If he was not there in person, his spies were. Without meaning to be in any way critical, it is important to say that the Deputies are relatively recent converts to the issue, given that all the major changes in the carer's allowance, over which I have sole operational power, have taken place during my tenure in office. Examination by any outside person will prove that to be the case.

Comment on this

The Department's estimate of the number of carers is about 50,000. Is it intended to revise that figure in the light of the finding of the pilot research in the Western Health Board area that there are 20,000 family carers in that health board area alone? If that estimate were taken to be extended over, say, ten health boards, the number of family carers could be over 200,000. Is the Minister standing over the figure of 50,000, most of whom are not getting a payment? What is the Department's estimate of the total number of carers in the country? How is the Department approaching that at present?

Comment on this

People were surprised by that survey. The Carers Association is probably the primary advocate of carers, and its estimate is probably about right. I understand it was based on projections made by the Carers Association in the UK and on the amount carers get on a pro rata basis there. I wonder why we do not carry out similar research here so that we would have a budgetary framework that would enable us to see exactly what it would cost if we were to do it on the basis of medical need. We do other things in the budget on the basis of medical need. The Scottish Labour Party, in coalition with the Liberals in the Scottish Parliament, are indicating that they will give free care to senior citizens. I am not sure it is such an unbelievably revolutionary idea. It will obviously put Mr. Blair under pressure in terms of the rest of Britain. It would mean something, ultimately an independent Scottish nation. It makes the point that perhaps it is not so revolutionary to consider a system of comprehensive care which would give resources to everybody in need. In terms of bilateral meetings with the association, conferences and so on, we are talking primarily about women because the vast bulk of carers are women. Hence it is also a gender issue. The great majority of carers are excluded from carer's allowance and probably will not qualify. Their situation will be no better. The Minister may talk, almost glibly, about whether we want to include the wealthy, but there is a large group of people we are still not reaching. That is why this is still and will continue to be such an important issue.

Comment on this

That is one of the reasons it is important to raise the disregard and bring in people who are at the lower end of the scale rather than bringing in everyone in one broad sweep. The average industrial wage is a target we would like to reach before we leave office. That commitment is very much appreciated by the care lobby groups, one of which recently went on an outing in Wales where they had their eyes opened in terms of the difference between what was available here, particularly in terms of carer's allowance, and what is available in Wales.

Comment on this

I understand that in the UK the local authority must assess the basic health needs of the carers. That does not apply here. There is no such right. That was Deputy Fitzgerald's point.

Comment on this

That is one of the reasons we set up the process of needs assessment as recommended by the review. The Deputy referred to the number of carers. Research was carried out in the context of the carer's review document which was published in 1998. I suggest that Deputies opposite should read it, if they have not already done so, to see exactly how the figure of 50,000 was arrived at. I do not know what the overall figure is. It depends on where one sets the bar. This is the whole issue in examining the proposal to have a continual care payment. It was suggested that a system of needs assessment in respect of both the carer and the person being cared for should be put in place before this is implemented. My Department does not have the capability of putting a needs assessment scheme in place right across the country. That would be the responsibility of the Department of Health and Children which would ultimately lead it and deal also with a number of other cross-departmental issues. The issue of long-term care is being looked at more broadly, and one aspect of that relates to changes made by the Minister for Finance in relation to tax relief on insurance policies.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 16, before section 15, to insert the following new section:

"15.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing the respite care grant for recipients of carer's allowance and benefit to £1,000.".

Comment on this

We now come to amendment No. 26. Amendments Nos. 27, 28 and 31 are related. We will discuss them together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 16, before section 15, to insert the following new section:

"15.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of abolishing the means test for carer's allowance.".

We have dealt in general terms with the subject matter of these four amendments which are an attempt to deal with key issues about which carers feel very strongly. We referred at length to the numbers qualifying for carer's allowance, the means test and the fact that many consider it a poor law approach to the whole area of provision for probably the most heroic people in the community. I ask the Minister to look at this matter. The case for abolition of the means test could be made. Based on the Minister's figures for the 1998 review what would be the cost and how could it be financed if we were to proceed along that road? It has been said there are other ways in which caring could be financed and some have referred to the social economy. Deputy Brennan referred to day care and to daily or weekly respite for the main carer who has a 24 hour job. Is the Minister working with the Departments of Enterprise, Trade and Employment and Health and Children on ways in which the burden of caring could be spread, where vital work could be done through the social economy and where people would be helped more extensively in their homes? That is an area that many carers say the State should look at and which would be helpful. The basic issue in this amendment is to bite the bullet and abolish the means test.

On amendment No. 27, we welcome the Taoiseach's commitment on the average industrial wage. It was stated that this was the recommendation of the committee. I recall saying during our discussion we should aim at the figures on the average industrial wage. I meet many semi-skilled 19 and 20 year olds earning £400 and I wonder about the famous average industrial wage. It is an almost esoteric type qualification now. The last figure the Minister gave me in 1999 for some of the social welfare rates was £333, but it could be £400 per week now. If the Minister cares to look at my speech, GDP per capita would be a great deal higher if the average industrial wage is £30,000 per annum. This matter should be considered. My amendment seeks to go a step further by seeking £150 for a single person and £300 for a married couple rather than £125 and £250 respectively. It is difficult to understand why the Minister did not take the extra couple of steps so that the rate would be close to the average industrial earnings target. I expect it will bring 5,000 or 6,000 new carers within the remit.

Amendment No. 28 refers to the demand I have heard among carers for a move beyond the carer's allowance to a broader based payment, with reference to medical needs and a continual care payment. Some were thinking in terms of a rate per hour. There could be more significant expenditure on recognising the role of caring rather than a basic income support for carers. We are actually saying: "You do a vital job in our community, you are on call 24 hours a day, seven days a week". This is the type of care provided for a man in his late 50s suffering from Alzheimers who has to be taken up the stairs, lifted into the bath etc. This is the type of work which many carers are providing without any real support from the State. I ask for a more comprehensive payment for carers.

In regard to amendment No. 31, Deputy Fitzgerald put forward a basic proposal before the budget. The Labour Party made a similar proposal which suggested £25 per week. If I am not mistaken, the British have such a payment. We still have not caught up with the British on child benefit. In sterling terms the rate per week for the first and second child will not be equal to British rates. Let us not forget that they have stakeholder pensions and have introduced the full "Blair-ite" agenda. While this Government has tried to be a "Blair-ite" Government——

Comment on this

Please stay with the amendment.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was being derogatory when he called me "Blare-ite". Every time I meet my counterpart Alistair Darling he asks what I am doing with the old age pension and why people there cannot get what those in the Republic of Ireland get.

Comment on this

Children might have said something different.

Comment on this

We are way ahead of the UK.

Comment on this

On the cost of caring allowance the Minister said we should also speak with the Department of Health and Children because the cost of disability, the aids and the accessories of caring should be paid either through the person with the disability or partly to the person with the disability and partly to the person who cares. There can be significant additional expense in that regard. Through the local authorities there is the disability extension where one can get lifts and various improvements of that nature. However, there is still an ongoing request for a monthly or weekly cost of caring allowance set at £25, £50 or whatever. This is an aspect of caring on which neither the Minister nor his colleague the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, have delivered.

Comment on this

In relation to the social economy the Tánaiste, in the proposals she is bringing forward, is acutely conscious of the need to assist carers. As a result of the budget changes the increase in the disregard is exactly as requested by this committee. Not only will that allow an extra 5,000 people to qualify for new carer's allowance recipients but 3,000 existing carers will receive an increased payment. The effect of all these increases will mean that a couple with two children earning a joint income in the region of £15,100 will qualify for the maximum carer's allowance while a couple in receipt of £26,000 will qualify for a minimum carer's allowance. Obviously all those people will get the free schemes and the respite grant.

There have been some major improvements in this area. This disregard is by far the most generous in the social welfare scheme. The Deputy has asked that the disregard be increased to £300 but I have indicated that over time it would be the intention to reach the average industrial earning which, in my estimation, is £360 per week. That would allow a larger number of people to enter the remit of the carer's allowance. I accept the carer's allowance as a social welfare payment is not designed to assist as well as a payment could be designed. That is the reason the issue of continual care was considered. The medical condition and medical signing required in respect of eligibility for the carer's allowance is a doctor's certificate together with some investigation by our medical people. The circumstances of beneficiaries in receipt of the carer's allowance differ. To an extent, it is not fair, if one beneficiary's circumstances are much worse than the another's.

Comment on this

Has the Minister not got experience of that from the Department?

Comment on this

That is the way the scheme is currently set up and that is why the review examined the issue of the continual care payment which will be based on a needs assessment.

Comment on this

Many benefits are contingent on medical referees. The Minister introduced a few measures to provide for those in receipt of invalidity benefit, including their being allowed to return to work. An anomaly arose last year concerning beneficiaries in receipt of invalidity benefit who got sick at work in that they were already sick. I forgot to table an amendment on that. Have we not got experience of giving benefits based on medical need? I cannot understand why we should balk at abolishing the means test for the carer's allowance.

Comment on this

We are not talking only about income.

Comment on this

Could a person in receipt of disability benefit who was quite wealthy and had enough stamps not move on to qualify for an invalidity pension. Would that person not qualify for an invalidity pension purely on the basis of his or her medical needs? That person could be allowed to return to work in certain circumstances and also, perhaps, be entitled to a living alone allowance and various other allowances. Is such circumstances not comparable to what I propose? Why is it necessary to require a means test for eligibility for the carer's allowance?

Comment on this

That situation is based on a person's contributions.

Comment on this

The carer's allowance scheme is a social assistance benefit, it is not based on contributions. Beneficiaries get only what they paid in.

Comment on this

Is it not similar to the position of pensioners in that those concerned will have a contribution record?

Comment on this

Ultimately they will and that is why many more people will qualify for carer's benefit. That is the rationale behind bringing in carer's benefit.

Comment on this

How stands the amendment?

Comment on this

I wish to press it.

Comment on this
Division

The Select Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 6
·
Níl 8
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 16, before section 15, to insert the following new section:

"15.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing the weekly income disregard for the carer's allowance to £300 in the case of a married couple and £150 in the case of a single person.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 16, before section 15, to insert the following new section:

"15.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of subsuming the carer's allowance into a new continual care payment to be paid to medically approved recipients without reference to individual or family means.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 19, before section 16, to insert the following new section:

"16.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of identifying key areas of disadvantage, both urban and rural, with proposals to give additional social insurance and social assistance supports to the population of those areas.".

I welcome the extra island allowance of £10. I am most familiar with the Beara peninsula in Deputy O'Keeffe's area, which encompasses an uninhabited island. However, in the context of the Minister's anti-poverty programme, Combat Poverty and the NAPS unit, I am occasionally dissatisfied regarding spatial disadvantage. The Minister's colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Eoin Ryan, recently announced the RAPID programme which will cover 25 areas. However, the lack of information on areas of major disadvantage is a continual problem.

Crossing to islands is dangerous and some of them are cut off. I understand there is a lack of social provision and recreation facilities on islands but, as the Minister is aware from his constituency, there are islands of massive disadvantage in urban areas. I, the Chairman and other Deputies are familiar with such areas. As I said on Second Stage, the agencies have not put enough effort into defining these areas. For example, in terms of health disadvantage in the UK, over the past number of years the British Government appears to have had available to it a matrix of statistics in relation to mortality rates, the quality of hospitals and care issues. This is only one aspect, but if one lives in the home counties in south-west London, one's quality of life is significantly better and one's chances of mortality are much lower than if one lived in Manchester. Despite the association with some famous cultural icons, statistics show that one has a much higher chance of dying younger in Manchester than in other areas. However, such statistics are not available in Ireland.

The Minister and I are aware of some areas of the city where the mortality rates are the highest in the country and among the highest in Europe. The Chairman and I were members of the healthy city project a few years ago which showed that the north side of the city in general was perhaps the most deprived area in Ireland in terms of the indices of disadvantage. The Minister has been asked to extend the national anti-poverty strategy to other areas, but other issues also need to be addressed. For example, if one was to stay tonight in certain parts of the north side and west side of the city, the chances are that there would be a serious joyriding incident in one's estate and one would have to endure amazing aggravation and irritation for many hours. Crime levels are higher and one's access to medical care is lower. One's access to educational advantage is also lower.

The Dublin 10 postal district on the west side of the city has the second lowest take up rate of third level places in the country while the area in which I live, Dublin 17, has the lowest rate. In this context, it is extraordinary that additional social welfare benefits have been presented for certain areas of the country without reference to any statistics or research. The Minister, Combat Poverty or the NAPS unit have not carried out such research. The Minister could not outline the position in clear quantitative terms. Professor P. J. Drudy worked on a report on housing for the Labour Party. His figures showed that if a part of south-east Dublin - mainly the constituency of my party leader - is excluded, one finds that the remainder of the city is an area of massive deprivation. It is an important aspect which the Government has not addressed because it does not care and, primarily, it would not be seeking votes in those areas. The reality is that the Government has written off votes in some areas of the country.

Comment on this

I am looking for them.

Comment on this

Yes, Cathaoirleach, you are looking for them, but you are the exception, and your brother is also. Perhaps the Government parties know that they can find a plurality of votes in the wealthy areas of these constituencies. When the Minister introduces legislation such as this, it is welcome in so far as it goes, but when will he do something about deprived areas? I would accept improved provisions for education and health rather than income based improvements through the social welfare system. The Minister, however, has paid virtually no attention to this area and does not care about it. Perhaps he does not live in such an area, but I do. These areas have been hopelessly neglected by the Government, and not just by the Minister himself. The NAPS scheme and the Combat Poverty Agency have not paid enough attention to this matter. It is not just an urban problem because rural areas are also affected. I have seen similar statistics for long-term unemployment in parts of the midlands. I do not think the Minister has addressed the problem in general. I also mentioned this point on Second Stage because I feel strongly about it. I do not see why the Minister is not prepared to come forward with real statistics.

On what basis did the Minister select 25 areas for the RAPID programme? While it is welcome, I do not know how much money these areas will receive, although some backbenchers from the Minister's own party were able to tell me. I received a publication from the Minister of State, Deputy Eoin Ryan, listing areas in my own constituency which were included in the RAPID programme. The backbenchers, however, told me that another parish was included in it, so I feel the Government is making this up as it goes along. It is like a famous flats complex on the southside where the media reported on the horrible state of life many people had to endure. Yet, a few days later, the Taoiseach appeared with the city manager and said he was going to demolish the place. He did a rerun of an announcement he had Gmade two years earlier, but nothing will change for those residents in the foreseeable future. The Minister should address the spatial concentrations of poverty. A major initiative is required from agencies under the aegis of the Minister as well as from the Minister himself.

Comment on this

There is much merit in what Deputy Broughan said. Without a proper map or picture of this situation, one cannot locate social disadvantage or deprivation in specific areas. This matter has to be tackled estate by estate. We have two cultures in society but people in rural areas do not understand this to the same extent as those in urban areas. People in the majority culture are doing very well and participate fully in the new, successful economy. However, there is a minority culture which is pocketed in well defined parts of Dublin city and county, as well as parts of other large cities. The Minister will know about this. In these areas we have not dealt with the problems of poverty in a concentrated way.

I wish to comment on the RAPID programme. This morning a constituent rang me from a parish in my own constituency, which is not in the west Tallaght area but in central Tallaght. That community has the same level of social deprivation and disadvantage as west Tallaght but it is excluded under the RAPID scheme. How was the classification for this scheme established? How can one estate - which has the same levels of unemployment and one parent families, few private cars and a lack of participation in third level education - be left out of another larger conglomeration of estates which seem to be part of this scheme?

There is a need for some mapping agency to precisely identify the areas we are talking about. Under the broad brush approach, west Tallaght, north Clondalkin and other parts of Dublin city become the central focus of capital funding under this RAPID programme to the exclusion of other areas. That is the wrong policy approach.

I welcome the fact that the Minister was able to make improvements concerning island communities. That is both worthwhile and sensible, but if those improvements can be made in respect of certain rural communities, why can we not have the same approach to urban areas?

When the last Government introduced the "Breaking the Cycle" education programme in parts of west Tallaght, not all schools in the area were included. When it comes to social policy in Dublin city and county we seem to identify the same areas while ignoring others which should be included in such schemes. I support Deputy Broughan's mapping amendment to identify key areas of disadvantage, urban and rural, but particularly in relation to urban areas. The vast majority understands the kind of culture that exists in some of these communities, where policing is nowhere to be seen, there are poor levels of housing, people do not have private cars and there are all kinds of health problems, including higher mortality rates. We do not have the kind of close identification and mapping we should have. The amendment is necessary.

Comment on this

The RAPID programme has probably brought this matter to the fore, but how does one approach these problems? It is done by district electoral divisions rather than by estates. All the indices are in the RAPID programme.

Comment on this

The point is that they are not. Nobody checks the mortality rates, housing conditions or crime by district.

Comment on this

Certain indices are there, but it depends on the mix. I agree with the RAPID programme. If they asked the opinion of public representatives they would probably have received more logical answers. The RAPID programme has produced some rather strange things, but it was done in a statistical way.

Comment on this

How does that happen?

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that it depends on what indices or tables have gone into it. The answers that have emerged are not ones those of us on the ground would agree with. Certainly, in my area, estates that might be worst off did not come out of the pot, perhaps because they were in the same district electoral division as a smaller 50 house estate which did a balancing act on it. Funny things have come out, but I do not know how one can achieve a perfect world other than going back to the unstructured way of asking local public representatives who often provide the right answer, although it might not be the methodical way of doing it.

Comment on this

I do not for one minute accept what Deputy Broughan said about my party. He alleges that my party gives up on certain areas in the country, but that is typical of the arrogance of the Labour Party whose members believe they have the monopoly in looking after the less well off in society.

Comment on this

We are left to pick up the pieces.

Comment on this

Time and time again we get 40% of the vote, a large proportion of which comes from areas of the country that a party properly espousing socialist ideals would normally receive. We receive that vote, however, because our party, particularly in the person of Deputy Noel Ahern, represents those members of the electorate well. In some of the very poor areas of my constituency, I beat representatives of every party, including some of those from parties which are recent converts to the democratic process. I totally reject, therefore, the Deputy's assertion in that regard.

I was not the lead Minister on the rapid programme - that responsibility fell to the Minister of State at the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy Eoin Ryan. I was present when a briefing was given to the Cabinet committee on social inclusion when the officials from that Department were absolutely adamant in respect of the methodology used in choosing these areas. Two schemes were allocated to Drogheda and Dundalk in my constituency and I would not query the result at which the Department arrived in that regard. The Deputy may recall that these areas were designated in the PPF and it was decided that 25 areas throughout the country would be chosen. The methodology by which those areas were chosen was decided upon in consultation with the social partners. It was intended that the areas chosen would not be exclusively urban. However, the 25 areas chosen were all urban in nature.

The Government has agreed that schemes will be established in provincial towns and rural areas. I do not accept what the Deputy stated. There has been rapid progress in relation to the extension of the national anti-poverty strategy. The Deputies opposite are, apparently, still holders of the dual mandate, and as the national anti-poverty strategy is extended to local authorities it will be incumbent on them and their colleagues from all parties to ensure that it is implemented at that level.

Comment on this

It has not yet arrived.

Comment on this

It is being moved out. In any event, councils should be taking the lead. We can discuss these issues in an esoteric way but, ultimately, we need to see schemes being delivered on the ground. There will be an additional £4.5 million to be invested in the rapid programme to employ co-ordinating staff who will work in conjunction with the county development boards, or their equivalent in urban areas. That will commence in the near future. The aim of this is to fast-track and front-load the money that was designated to those areas, across a range of agencies, over the lifetime of the national development plan.

There is a great deal of work going on but, ultimately, this matter boils down to deliverability, which is the responsibility of the various agencies at local level, particularly local authorities. I reject any suggestion from any member, including the Chairman, that certain areas were chosen because of political considerations.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

The areas were chosen on the basis of good and logical methodology. If Members table questions to the relevant Minister, they will obtain the answers they require.

Comment on this

I do not believe the Minister has the information I require.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong.

Comment on this

When the rainbow Government was in office, the Combat Poverty Agency was given a role in investigating the position of schools because, in the early stages, it appeared that a number of better off schools gained disadvantaged status. The Combat Poverty Agency was supposed to take the lead in indicating which schools were disadvantaged. As I understand it, according to Deputy Shortall, there is now, more or less, no qualifying criterion involved. In my opinion it should be the responsibility of the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs to discover the spatial concentrations across a range of criteria. Deputy Hayes made a valid point about this matter. In my constituency there is a famously affluent area but there is also a very deprived working class area, with major socio-economic problems, situated in the centre of the former.

What is required is a breakdown on a constituency by constituency basis. I believe that the Government and the Minister's party has done this deliberately. Up to eight or ten years ago before the partnership process started, it could be clearly seen that money was granted to areas which were not in greatest need. For example, lottery grants were given to golf clubs and sailing clubs. Indeed, I recall from meetings of the Committee of Public Accounts that one Minister procured a grant for the sailing club in Kilkenny. That was outrageous.

Comment on this

The Deputy is completely off the wall and he is wrong.

Comment on this

You have done it deliberately.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making all sorts of bald and wild statements. He should inquire about the methodology used to choose the areas designated under the rapid programme. As far as I am concerned, the specific estates designated in my constituency were the correct ones to be so designated. The Deputy should check the position regarding the areas in his constituency to which he refers instead of making bald and wild statements.

Comment on this

I am not merely talking about the rapid programme, I am referring to the general scenario. The Minister was dragged screaming and bawling through the negotiations on the PPF——

Comment on this

If the Deputy discovers any proof that the areas chosen were the wrong ones, he should communicate that fact to the Minister of State, Deputy Eoin Ryan, or me. However, he will find no such proof.

Comment on this

To return to the amendment, one could make the case for additional income supports for people living in certain areas of the country. In my opinion, disadvantaged urban and rural areas should have been considered but the Government has refused to do so. There is an outrageous lack of health, education and sporting facilities in these areas. On Friday night last, the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, made great claims for the "Bertie bowl", while international boxers and athletes are obliged to change in garden sheds etc.

Comment on this

The Deputy is being ridiculous

Comment on this

The Government has not taken this matter seriously or tried to take comprehensive action.

Comment on this

The Deputy is absolutely incorrect.

Comment on this

In relation to the rapid programme, why did not the Department work through the existing organisations, such as the partnership companies, which were established for that purpose?

Comment on this

The Deputy is absolutely incorrect.

Comment on this

What was the involvement of the Minister's Department in the selection process which obtained with regard to the rapid programme? In terms of the community aspect of its remit, the Department would, from time to time, allocate not insignificant sums of money for capital projects for family mediation centres etc. One would have thought that it would have had a role in terms of choosing the areas to be targeted under the rapid programme, given that it is the lead Department in relation to social welfare matters.

Comment on this

My Department had no role in choosing the rapid areas. They were chosen by the lead Department, namely, the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation.

Comment on this

Was that Department informed about the number of social welfare recipients living in the various areas?

Comment on this

All that information would have been made available to it. The Deputies are barking at the wrong Minister, they should table questions to the Minister of State at the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy Eoin Ryan, and they will find that the process of choosing these areas was open and above board and accepted by the social partners.

Comment on this

Much of the data used in the rapid programme came from an outside agency. Should your Department not collate these statistics independently?

Comment on this

I do not have all those statistics.

Comment on this

It is a case of what is the mix of the cake.

Comment on this

I could provide statistics in regard to the number of people in receipt of payments but might not be able to do so in regard to the number in a specific estate. That programme was run by the Department which has a role in partnerships, ADM and all the other programmes.

Comment on this

It is a problem. Perhaps the rapid programme will provide another forum to address it. What other unit is the one to go by? The DED has imperfections because it has a bad estate and a good estate.

Comment on this

The Minister has admitted there is a considerable deficiency in terms of producing the evidence on which Governments can make policy decisions.

Comment on this

I have not. The necessary parliamentary questions should be tabled or the Minister of State at the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation should be called before the committee. However, I have no doubt whichever committee he is answerable to will be able to question him in regard to the choice of areas for this programme.

Comment on this

Was the Minister approached directly in this regard?

Comment on this

My Department was involved in providing information but it did not have a lead role.

Comment on this

Were the Minister's views on Dundalk and Drogheda sought?

Comment on this

No, nor did I have any influence. I said that publicly in Drogheda.

Comment on this

The spatial location of poverty is the Minister's responsibility. My party had a major role in establishing the Combat Poverty Agency. I read an interesting 1983 report by one of the Minister's predecessors, Barry Desmond, who was so able that he administered the Departments of Health and Social Welfare.

Comment on this

He made some disastrous political decisions for which the party is still suffering in my constituency.

Comment on this

He also made some good decisions together with former Deputy Cluskey. Mr. Desmond clearly identified that the location of poverty was the key. The Minister referred to politics and who represented the poorest of the poor. I accept Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael receive their share of votes and so on. However, there is a low turn-out in the poorest areas, particularly for local elections. Many of my constituents are not prepared to vote unless there is a strong local candidate running because they feel abandoned by the political system. We should know at least statistically what is people's quality of life.

I welcome the provisions for the islands. For example, people living on islands off the south-west coast enjoy a quality of life which encompasses music, culture and so on that is light years away from that in comparable low income areas of cities. My constituents in such areas cope with major insurrections nightly which the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, the Taoiseach and some journalists do not think is their business, yet people's lives are terrible. The Minister is responsible for many of these people's incomes and it is an area which I hope we will address if we get another opportunity in Government.

Comment on this

How will the Labour Party address it?

Comment on this

By establishing the facts and outlining them to people. That is a start at least.

Comment on this

Deputy, you have raised some interesting points and given me ideas. The committee might examine the issue and invite the Minister of State at the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation and his officials to appear before us. I am not a member of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Tourism, Sport and Recreation but it does not spend a great deal of time discussing local development. The committee could take this issue up but can we leave it for another day?

Comment on this

The Minister is a member of the Cabinet sub-committee on social inclusion. The RAPID programme was brought to the attention of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Tourism, Sport and Recreation. Was it instigated by the committee?

Comment on this

There was a commitment in the PPF to nominate 25 areas of disadvantage and it was agreed a certain methodology would be used to choose these areas. That was done in consultation with the social partners and it was always under the remit of the Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation through the Minister, Deputy Ryan, and the former Minister, Deputy Flood, who had responsibility for the URBAN programme, the drugs task force and ADM programmes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:

In page 20, between lines 37 and 38, to insert the following subsection:

"(3) The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report setting out the number of persons who will lose the living alone allowance as a result of gaining from the rent-a-room scheme contained in the Finance Act, 2001.”.

The Government has tabled a good amendment to the Finance Bill, 2001, to permit people to take in additional tenants without paying tax unless their rental income exceeds £6,000. I first proposed this scheme two and a half years ago, as housing spokesperson for my party. The Minister will be aware that two or three rooms lie idle in many homes. A typical example is an old age pensioner who owns his home, and it makes sense to utilise the available space.

The Government has introduced the rent-a-room scheme, the provisions of which are generous as people are permitted to take people into their homes and provide them with accommodation. If someone is in receipt of the living alone allowance and other benefits and it is Government policy to encourage others to move into their homes to utilise the empty bedrooms, it would make sense to ensure social welfare recipients would not lose benefits. The living alone allowance is not large but elderly people may not participate in the scheme if they feel they will lose the allowance.

The amendment ensures nobody will lose the allowance as a result of availing of the provision of the Finance Bill. It is a problem which could occur from time to time.

Comment on this

I made changes in recent years to ensure people who let a room would not lose their means tested payments, particularly old age pensioners and widows. The living alone allowance is not properly understood. I accept the Deputy's argument that we are encouraging people to use vacant space. At the same time, it would go against the spirit of the payment if we were to allow people to continue to avail of it while still being able to rent out rooms in their premises. Renting rooms means they receive additional money so there would not be a loss.

Comment on this

I understand the Minister's point but this is not about money. If we try to achieve a policy objective by means of a tax measure we should do so in such a way that older people are not discouraged from availing of it because they fear they may lose out elsewhere. This could make a psychological difference. Has the Minister set his mind against this completely or am I barking up the wrong tree?

Comment on this

Deputy Broughan and I have spoken about this at local authority level under the financial contribution scheme where people sell their houses and get senior citizen flats. The free schemes, such as telephone rental and television licence, the medical card and other benefits have been problems until now but they have been dealt with. It was the case last year that if a person sold his or her house to the corporation or privately, he or she would lose his or her medical card and free schemes because he or she would have money and would be assessed on that. All those headings have now been covered, except the living alone allowance, but that is a case of losing £6 and gaining £100. Of the other road blocks, the medical card was the main one and now everyone over 70 will get one.

Comment on this

My point is that we are trying to encourage elderly people to take people into their homes to provide them with accommodation. That is a clear policy objective which we support and welcome. At the same time, it is important people do not feel they are losing out, although they may not.

Comment on this

It could not be called a living alone allowance in the case where they took in a person. The change in taxation is recent and, as the Chairman said, because of representations made at committee meetings and meetings of our parliamentary party, changes were made recently so that people would not be disadvantaged because of their means when it came to means tested payments. This would apply where they took people in or sold their premises. While we will examine it, I cannot give a commitment because it would go against the principle of the living alone allowance to make exceptions in this respect.

Comment on this

An exception has already been made by virtue of the fact that a certain amount of the money people make from rents under the rent a room scheme is exempt from tax. That is for the purposes of achieving a national objective. I do not want to see the rent a room scheme lose out because of the small technical reason that people lose out on relatively small sums of social welfare payments.

Comment on this

They could try subdividing their houses.

Comment on this

They would then have two doors and the planning department might not accept that.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 52 is consequential on amendment No. 34 and both may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:

In page 21, before section 20, but in Part 3, to insert the following new section:

"20.-The Principal Act is amended by-

(a) the substitution in section 32(1) (as amended by section 17 of the Act of 1997) for paragraph (b) of the following paragraph:

'(b)(i) that the claimant has qualifying contributions or credited contributions in respect of not less than 39 contribution weeks, of which at least 13 must be qualifying contributions, in the last complete contribution year before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the day for which the benefit is claimed, or

(ii) that the claimant has qualifying contributions in respect of not less than 26 contribution weeks in each of the last two complete contribution years before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the day for which the benefit is claimed,

and',

(b) the substitution in subparagraph (a)(i) of section 38 (inserted by section 10 of the Act of 1997) for clause (B) of the following clause:

'(B) (I) that the claimant has qualifying contributions or credited contributions in respect of not less than 39 contribution weeks in the last complete contribution year before the beginning of the benefit year in which the relevant day occurs or in a subsequent complete contribution year before the relevant day, or

(II) that the claimant has qualifying contributions in respect of not less than 26 contribution weeks in each of the last two complete contribution years before the beginning of the benefit year in which the relevant day occurs,

or',

(c) the substitution in subparagraph (a)(ii) of section 41B(1) (inserted by Article 6 of the European Communities (Social Welfare) Regulations, 1995 (S.I. No. 25 of 1995)) for clause (B) of the following clause:

'(B) (I) that the claimant has qualifying contributions or credited contributions in respect of not less than 39 contribution weeks in the last complete contribution year before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the first day for which health and safety benefit is claimed, or

(II) that the claimant has qualifying contributions in respect of not less than 26 contribution weeks in each of the last two complete contribution years before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the first day for which health and safety benefit is claimed,

and,

(d) the substitution in subparagraph (a)(i) of section 41H(1) (inserted by section 11 of the Act of 1997) for clause (B) of the following clause:

'(B) (I) that the claimant has qualifying contributions or credited contributions in respect of not less than 39 contribution weeks in the last complete contribution year before the beginning of the benefit year in which the relevant day occurs or in a subsequent complete contribution year before the relevant day, or

(II) that the claimant has qualifying contributions in respect of not less than 26 contribution weeks in each of the last two complete contribution years before the beginning of the benefit year in which the relevant day occurs,

or', and

(e) the substitution in section 43(1) (as amended by section 8 of the Social Welfare (No. 2) Act, 1993) for paragraph (b) of the following paragraph:

'(b) (i) that the claimant has qualifying contributions or credited contributions in respect of not less than 39 contribution weeks in the last complete contribution year before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the day for which the benefit is claimed, or

(ii) that the claimant has qualifying contributions in respect of not less than 26 contribution weeks in each of the last two complete contribution years before the beginning of the benefit year which includes the day for which the benefit is claimed,

and',".

Amendment No. 34 provides for changes to the existing contribution conditions for short-term social insurance benefits. The change involves the addition of an alternative contribution condition for these benefits. This is designed to make access to the benefits involved more flexible for persons who have atypical work patterns and who may fail, under current arrangements, to qualify for the relevant benefits. The proposed new arrangements will benefit about 21,000 contributors, including a wide range of atypical workers and those job sharing and work sharing.

My Department had various meetings last year with both ICTU and the Irish Banker's Federation in connection with the PRSI position of certain job sharers. I propose to introduce an alternative contribution test for short-term benefits which has been developed by my Department. This will allow people who do not meet current contribution conditions, that is, 39 PRSI contributions paid or credited in the relevant year, to claim short-term benefits if they have 26 paid contributions paid in the relevant year and 26 contributions paid in the previous year. This alternative contribution test already applies to the carer's benefit. Extending it to other benefits will be of benefit to atypical workers, for example, job sharers, who, despite a long attachment to the workforce, find that their employment pattern means they have less than 39 contributions or credits in particular years.

While it was not possible to include these new arrangements in the budget for 2001 due to other competing demands, it is proposed that the new arrangements will be implemented in 2002. This will allow adequate time to put in place the necessary computer development. It will also give advance notice of the new arrangements to those who work on an atypical basis and provide substantial flexibility in work patterns.

This measure represents another significant development of the social insurance system. Access to short-term benefits will now be more flexible thereby ensuring that many atypical workers who fail to qualify for benefits will do so in the future. This flexibility will reflect developments in the changing working environment and will be of particular value to all those who have to combine work with family responsibilities.

Amendment No. 52 is an amendment to section 28 of the Bill to provide that transitional arrangements which, in relation to all other contribution conditions, will apply similarly to these conditions.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

In page 21, before section 20, but in Part 3, to insert the following new section:

"20.-The Minister shall, having regard to the financial difficulties encountered by widows and widowers, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on-

(a) the feasibility of extending to all widowers and widows:

(i) the free travel pass,

(ii) the free electricity allowance, and

(iii) the free telephone rental allowance;

and

(b) the possibility of a special increased payment to widows and widowers who have no other source of income other than social welfare.”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:

In page 21, before section 20, but in Part 3, to insert the following new section:

"20.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passage of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the feasibility of introducing a free schools-meals scheme.".

I will not take up much time on this because the Minister and I had an opportunity to discuss the matter on Question Time on Tuesday. I note from his reply that he expects a report this summer on a new school meals scheme. I do not know if the Minister can disagree with the amendment because it asks him to bring forward a report and, given that one is in the offing and will be with us some time this year, I am interested to hear his response. There is a need to expand this scheme radically, and we are one of the few countries in Europe which does not have such a scheme. While I welcome the fact that the Minister has put more money into the area over the past two years, we need to improve it further.

Has the Minister had discussions with the Minister for Education and Science about the benefits the scheme can bring to disadvantaged communities in particular, especially in respect of the nutritional benefits it can give children? There is a huge schoolgoing population and, if we are serious about doing something for the nation's diet and encouraging children to eat the right food, this is a direct way in which we can help and also deal with child poverty and improve the nutritional benefits of children's diets. Before Christmas the Minister said this report was due around the first quarter of this year but from what he said last Tuesday it may now be issued later in the year. We need to bring this problem to an end given the resources at our disposal.

Comment on this

I warmly support the amendment. The pilot programme launched in my constituency a year and a half ago involving three parishes in north Coolock had a big impact on families in the area and particularly on children. When we introduced the school breakfast scheme it gave the schools a chance to implement training in nutrition while also encouraging children to get up and come into school early. It was very valuable and I have seen the benefit of a good school meals system. Other countries take it for granted that hot nutritious meals can be provided for even very young schoolchildren who may have long days in school. This is also linked to the need to involve school resources such as buildings in child care, and nutrition is another aspect of this approach. I warmly support the amendment.

Comment on this

It would not be necessary to put this into legislation because the expenditure review group which is looking at this will report before summer. Obviously the report will be available to the committee at that stage so I suggest this amendment is not necessary.

I was out in Baldoyle recently to visit the schools mentioned by Deputy Broughan. It is an excellent scheme and it is hoped that the standard reached by a number of schools in Drogheda, in my constituency, will be met. I visited one of the pilot projects in Drogheda and there is a hot food service there. I am particularly interested in moving this project on with a view to putting substantial funding in place in the not too distant future provided the review comes up with what we are hoping for - support for voluntary groups based around schools to develop this project.

Comment on this

Does the Minister have a figure for how much this would cost to extend nationwide?

Comment on this

That will depend on the review and would also be affected by the take-up. We would be encouraging communities to come forward so we would not have an indication. It would also have to be done at second school level as well as primary.

Comment on this

Was last year's sum £300,000?

Comment on this

It was £300,000 this year and £100,000 last September.

Comment on this

How much of that was spent?

Comment on this

I think all of it was spent.

Comment on this

There was some suggestion that even the headline figure that was set aside for the pilot programme was not all spent.

Comment on this

I can check the figure. The figure was put aside in September so it may not have been spent by the end of the year but we added to it this year and it is now £300,000. I indicated yesterday that there were quite a number of groups seeking to be included so I do not think we will have any problems spending the money this year.

Comment on this

What about the report?

Comment on this

The report will be available when it is launched. It will be publicised like any other expenditure review from my Department.

Comment on this
Matt Brennan Mr. M. Brennan Fianna Fáil

Is this scheme just for Dublin?

Comment on this

No, there is one in Drogheda. There are nine projects in the country and Drogheda is probably the best. Those schemes were at the initiative of the local communities and started by those communities.

There was an earlier question regarding the Department of Education and Science and I have had discussions with the Minister for Education and Science. There have also been discussions at official level.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned the voluntary sector. The groups in my area mentioned the logistical problems for volunteers - the amount of food that has to be stored and bought - and we may need a professional contribution also.

Comment on this

The Drogheda group got significant funding from the Forum for Peace and Reconciliation but that is probably not available to areas in Dublin, as it is Border funding. The Drogheda group got the funding to provide hot meals and their work is of a very high standard - they were trained but it is still all voluntary even though they may have a paid manager. The group receives approximately £22,000 from my Department towards the cost of the scheme, though there is also a local contribution. This has enabled the numbers served by the scheme to increase by at least 40% while reducing the cost to the children and parents by half.

Comment on this

This highlights the need for the amendment mentioned earlier by Deputy Broughan which seeks to highlight the exact areas of disadvantage in the country school by school. It seems strange from the education perspective that some schools have this service and others have not, even though the profile of the children from school to school would be the same. This highlights the need to map out nationally the areas of disadvantage.

Comment on this