Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill, 2001.
Contributions 1–183 of 534. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 60 of 2001 ›
I welcome the Minister and his officials, Tom Mulhern, Geraldine Gleeson and Tim Quirke. We want to conclude Committee Stage today so that people can receive their payments on 1 January. Some of us would not like to be seen to delay that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the increase in the consumer price index since the commencement of the Act of 2001 to the commencement of this Act, and the said report shall compare the percentage increases in payments set out in Schedules A and B to this Act with the corresponding provisions of the Act of 2001.”.
This is an extraordinary session of the committee in unique circumstances. We normally would have had a week or two to tease out some of the points the Minister made today following our contribution on the debate in the Dáil. I fully accept that we must ensure people at least get their backdated rises by the middle of February.
There should be a mechanism in the Bill whereby the impact of inflation is taken into account. I know the Minister will say this has been one of our better years. This was a fundamental issue this time last year. The Opposition argued very strongly that social welfare increases were barely covering themselves with inflation running at 7%. Inflation is still a factor. Deputies will have noticed that since the summer, particularly in the groceries and drinks sector, there has been a significant rise in inflation. The 4.6% to 4.7% measured by the CPI may not really reflect the impact of inflation on the poorest households. Although the basic £8.06 is greater than the4.6%, it is still a serious issue. I hope the Government drafts a social welfare Bill that takes account of inflation.
I know most of the attention was on benchmarking. Separate amendments on that issue have been tabled by me and my Fine Gael colleagues. The Combat Poverty Agency stated that general income rises were 10.8% in most of the past year. Almost half of that has been taken away by inflation and that is very significant. Social welfare Bills should have a mechanism to take that into account. That can be contrasted with the PPF, for example, and the negotiations leading to it. Inflation is a key element in deciding pay increases. Why should this not be provided for in social welfare legislation? This is an old argument.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. We had an opportunity to debate this issue last year, the difficulty this year is the short truncated period we have to debate the entire Bill. I do not blame the Minister for that. If the budget was in early November a lot of these problems could have been resolved. There would have been a longer run-in to discuss the legislation. That is the problem we face this week.
Deputy Broughan made a valid point about inflation. When I studied economics the most fundamental lesson I was taught about inflation was that it affected low income families more than anyone else because their incomes were much lower and, consequently, they depended on basic foodstuffs to get them through the week.
The St. Vincent de Paul Society sent us a very interesting submission, which we had the opportunity to debate with its delegation a month ago. It stated 60% of a poor person's budget was spent on food bills. I agree with the Minister's projection regarding inflation of 4.4% for the next 12 months, but the difficulty is that is not an issue for approximately 15% of the population who must live on small incomes. If one is living on a small income of which 60% is used to buy food at a time when food inflation is running at almost 10%, a mechanism must be employed to ensure social welfare increases match inflation.
The amendment is not wide of the mark. There is even a review mechanism under the PPF. The point I have always made about social welfare increases is that there is no absolutely no review mechanism built in. They are introduced annually following financial resolutions tabled by the Minister for Finance. There should be a mechanism to allow us to review the effects of increases on the poor.
One way the Minister could do so would be for himself and the Minister for Finance to make a statement to the House every three months on the effects of inflation throughout the year. That was another element of my pre-budget submission that the Minister did not mention on Second Stage. That would be a good amendment to the Social Welfare Bill. It would not cost any money and would permit the Minister and the Minister for Finance, who ultimately has power over the allocation of moneys for such measures, to explain to the House every three months the effects of inflation and the CPI on social welfare increases. If the Minister conceded to make a state of the union address every three, four or six months in the House, it would be a useful development. There are review mechanisms in other areas of policy and the PPF, but such a mechanism is not built into the Social Welfare Bill. Social Welfare recipients are not part and parcel of the PPF. The amendment has merit and while I am interested in the Minister's reply, I can guess what it will be.
Comment on this
I thank you, Chairman, and Deputies for facilitating us on Committee Stage. I accept the comments regarding the short time we all have had to prepare. Deputy Hayes said the budget should have been announced in November, but then we would be accused of not delivering on payments until much later. I was a strong proponent of the Government's view that we should reduce the timescale between announcing and delivering on increases. It is not all doom and gloom for Opposition Members because, while they may only have a short time to debate this legislation, they will have an opportunity to repeat themselves when the Social Welfare Bill comes before the House next year. There are two Bills this year which is an advantage for the Government as it can highlight the great work it has done.
Inflation is estimated at 4.9% for this year. The annual inflation rate has fallen in the past six months. The annual change up to October was 4.3%. The main rates of social welfare increased by 10.3% and 10.4%. This represents a 5.1% and a 5.2% increase in real terms this year. The projected rate of inflation for 2002 is 4.2%. The main rates of social welfare will increase by 9.4% from January 2002. This represents a real increase of 5%.
I have outlined all the reasons that it is not feasible for the Minister to come into the House now and again to make a statement, even though in recent years it might have been to the Minister's advantage to proclaim the message that in each of the budgets that the Government has been lucky enough to bring forward there have been increases in social welfare payments.
There is nothing to prevent the committee from requesting the Minister to respond regarding increases during the year. It has always been a case of swings and roundabouts when it comes to increases, but social welfare recipients have largely benefited in recent years. If it happens that the increases are lower than the rate of inflation, generally compensation is made the following year. That has always been the case, where possible. During the lifetime of the Government the CPI has risen significantly. An objective analysis would show social welfare increases have outpaced the rate of inflation and been in line with the increase in average industrial earnings and greater than it in some years.
QAAs have increased from 13.1% to 17.4% which represent real increases of 8.2% and12.3%. In addition to the general increases for QAAs, recipients of contributory, retirement, invalidity and private person's pensions aged over 66 years will be given a further increase of £6 and £7 per week bringing the overall increase to £15 per week. These combined payments represent increases of between 23% and 25% or real increases of between 17.9% and 20.5%. An increase of £10 in personal rates represents an increase of between 9.2% to 10.5%, or a real increase of between 4.8% to 6.1%. There has been a real increase of 7.3% in widow's pensions and 6.9% for lower social welfare payments over the rate of inflation. An increase of £8 equates to a real percentage increase of between 3.1% and 5%. There have been real increases in every payment.
Deputy Hayes mentioned an incorrect figure in regard to food inflation which is running at 6.8% for the past 12 months. The Government committed itself in its action programme to increasing social welfare pensions to £100 per week by 2002. Contributory pension has been increased by £16 more than we intended. Similarly, non-contributory pension has been increased by £5.53 more than intended. There have been real increases in recent years of between 4% and 5% at every level. While I cannot accept the amendment, that would not prevent the committee from requiring the Minister to respond to inflation variations.
Comment on this
Are all the figures the Minister went through officially published during the year or are they available to him only now?
Comment on this
Are the various figures given available in an official publication during the year or could the committee request that information from the Department?
Comment on this
Yes. The £10 increase given this year is 9.2% to 10.5%, which, in effect, is a real increase over the anticipated rate of inflation of 4.8% and 6.1%. That also applies to other increases. Those figures would be available to the committee on request. We have all these figures.
Comment on this
The only problem in all this is that we have to operate on the basis of the previous year. There is no point thinking in terms of what will happen in the future. For example, we do not know what will happen in earnings growth next year, given that, according to Mr. David McWilliams and others, we are definitely in a recession. In that context it is difficult to measure what will happen. The 5% inflation figure the Minister gave for 2001 is high. Workers are being compensated on average to the extent of approximately 10.8% in that regard, but the Minister has not met that target for people in receipt of social welfare benefit.
Comment on this
The difficulty about all of this is that effectively we have to operate a year in reverse and the Minister has to act on the basis of what has happened in earnings and inflation in the previous year. To some extent, it is a compensatory mechanism as we move into the next year. I accept what the Minister is saying - the Chairman is right and I agree with Deputy Hayes - this should be kept under review because after Christmas there will be a strange scenario in the sense that I presume there will be euro-wide inflation rates as well as our local position. There is a case for putting this measure into the heart of the legislation
Comment on this
Table A 19 of our annual statistics report, which we issue every year and of which members probably get a copy, gives information on the index of short-term payments, the consumer price index and the average industrial earnings over a number of years.
Comment on this
When the Minister came into office, the increases were paid for 29 weeks of the year but they are now paid for 52 weeks of the year. What is that worth to the recipients?
Comment on this
It is very simple. I am sure the Minister and his officials will answer that point. I do not want an answer from the Deputies opposite.
Comment on this
The Deputy should ask a social welfare recipient if it is accurate? Social welfare recipients would tell him that previously they had to wait for months for their increases, but they do not have to wait for them now.
Comment on this
The Deputy said that in the past increases were paid for 29 weeks of the year. If one got an increase that ran from April to April, irrespective of how one calculates it, that is not an increase for 29 weeks but for 52 weeks of the year.
Comment on this
Payment of the increases is now being brought back to January. When the Deputy's party was in office, the increases were not paid until——
Comment on this
I will answer the Deputy's question. Every time we have framed a budget, the Minister for Finance and his officials have asked how much we need in the budget year and how much we need in a full year and we operate on that basis. In the past, successive Ministers for Social Welfare would have had a pot of money, which they tried to ensure covered everything. If they had difficulty doing that, which they always had, they pushed payments out to later in the year.
Comment on this
In other words, instead of introducing an increase in, say, April, they pushed it back to September or October, as has been done over the years.
Comment on this
Social welfare recipients want their increases paid as soon as possible after they are announced. That is what we are doing. When I came into office the payments were made for only 29 weeks of that year, but henceforth, unless the position is regressively changed, all budgetary increases will be paid in the budget year, for 52 weeks of the year.
Comment on this
I know he is. I am sick of hearing balderdash being thrashed out here as if it were fact. It even stated in the Minister's script that when he came into office in 1997 the increases were paid for 29 weeks. That is not true.
Comment on this
To take the 1996 budget, the increases kicked in from a particular time. From memory, I think they were delivered in May.
Comment on this
They ran then from that June until the following June. Therefore, in 1997 if an increase was granted, it ran from the start date until the next increase the following year, which was for 52 weeks. I acknowledge what the Minister said, that they have clawed back the date increases are paid. The date of payment of increases has been clawed back by a little each year and now they will be paid on 1 January. I remember everyone on this side of the House last year and the year before asking why taxpayers were able to get their increases at a particular time but social welfare recipients were not. The date of payment of social welfare increases has been gradually clawed back to ensure parity with the date of payment of taxpayers' increases.
Comment on this
The statement by the Minister is not accurate; never in the history of this State was an increase given for 29 weeks in a year. That has never happened and it is incorrect to say it has.
Comment on this
I was never a school teacher and I might not have the same command of the English language as some Deputies, but I do not know if Deputy McGrath's argument stands up. I think it was the rainbow Government that started this process - even if it moved the payment of the increases back only by a week or two.
Comment on this
The rainbow Government started the process and it must have seen some value in it. The Minister has made huge strides and completed that process. I do not know what the argument is about.
Comment on this
Everything is a non-argument to the Deputy. Wait until he moves to this side of the House and then we will hear the arguments and——
Comment on this
Social welfare recipients will get their increases as early as possible. The Deputy is correct in saying that in 1997 the increases were delivered on 2 June. Increases will now be delivered effective from 1 January. That will be a major benefit to social welfare recipients' income. As I said on Second Stage, it is 4% to 5% of an increase, apart from the percentage increase they will get in their overall payments.
Comment on this
If the Minister were to think back to 1991, the increases were delivered on a certain date, in 1992 they were delivered on another date and in 1993 on another date. One can go back as far as one likes——
Comment on this
I studied history. My recollection is that it was an Administration led by Charles Haughey - I am not sure who were the Ministers for Finance and Social Welfare - that put social welfare increases back to the later part of the year. The Minister should check it out. Fianna Fáil pushed the date out and now it is bringing it back.
Comment on this
I will give the figures. In 1992 it was 23 weeks and it was 23 weeks until 1995. As the Chairman said——
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to be a historian, perhaps he should look at the Christmas bonus. We introduced that and every time the Deputy's party was in power it was reduced and every time we were in office it remained the same or was increased.
Comment on this
I am aware the time allocated for Second Stage was curtailed and some members did not get to contribute but this discussion must be on the amendment.
Comment on this
Would it be a useful exercise to organise a plenary debate on this every three or four months? The Minister comes before the committee at various times in the year but does he not accept that the debate needs to take place not just in this committee but between him and the Minister for Finance? Ultimately, decisions on increases or the extensions we are seeking in the benefits will involve a Department of Finance decision. In other parliaments the Minister with responsibility for public expenditure and the Minister with responsibility for social security regularly come before parliament in plenarysession, even if it is only once every six months, to address it on the effects of the changes on inflation. I accept the Minister is not prepared to commit to that practice by way of legislation but will he make a verbal commitment to it? If, in four or six months time, I seek a debate with this Minister and the Minister for Finance, will he make a commitment to have it?
Comment on this
I support Deputy Hayes. We are due to start using a new currency. We are already within that currency system but we will soon physically use it. Concerns have been expressed in the past few years by some economists that if, for example, the euro strengthens against sterling, there could be significant inflationary pressures. That could happen in the coming year and it would have an impact on the people we represent. There is due to be a general election and, hopefully, there will be a new Administration but this will be an ongoing issue as the year progresses. Some people think we should not do away with our reserves in theCentral Bank because we might still needthem.
Comment on this
I have nothing further to say on it. While I can come before the committee, I do not see the reason for the Minister for Finance and I debating inflation during the year. Neither I nor the Minister for Finance has a say in relation to inflation. However, all Ministers for Finance predict the inflation rate for the coming year and the Estimates are based on that. More often than not, inflation tends to be lower than estimated by the Department of Finance; historically, that is the case. To a certain extent, therefore, people have made gains on the basis of inflation being over estimated. If we were to go to the Dáil every three months to debate these issues, there would be cries for a budget every three months, which would be impossible. Governments must frame their Estimates and budgets from year to year.
Comment on this
Two years ago, when inflation was more serious, did the Minister not go to Cabinet seeking a revision of the rates?
Comment on this
Would it not have been helpful in that circumstance if there had been such a mechanism in the House? At that time, inflation was getting out of hand and the Minister was aware that it was impacting negatively on social welfare recipients. It was reported that the Minister went to Cabinet, although I am not sure if the Minister confirmed the reports, and asked for——
Comment on this
——some recognition of what was happening to social welfare recipients but he was turned down.
Comment on this
Would it not have been helpful for the Minister to have a mechanism in the Dáil to discuss this?
Comment on this
It was incorrect. So the Minister did not realise what was happening to people on social welfare.
Comment on this
——as I have proved with this and every other budget with which I have been involved.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzgerald is right. In fact, the Minister occupies a footnote in chapter four of Deputy McCreevy's book.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of closing the differential between the rates of periodic benefit and assistance paid to an adult dependant and the rates paid to a qualifying adult, and of removing any limitation of the amount of payment made to a couple as opposed to a corresponding payment to two adults who are not living together.".
The Minister referred briefly to this. The Minister for Finance has moved ahead with individualisation in the tax code. There was a terrible crisis among Fianna Fáil backbenchers about it a few years ago but that appears to have been resolved. Two members of a household who are working get full tax relief as individuals. Why has the same thing not been done in the social welfare code?
The Minister will make numerous statements, particularly about over 66 year olds, and claim to have gone above 85% in the increases. However, let us talk about the broad group of younger people on assistance payments or on the new basic payment, for which I commended the Minister. If the Minister had, as many people wanted, increased the adult dependant rate to 70% of the main rate this year, it would have meant an increase of at least £4, which would have resulted in the Minister increasing the amount by £12 instead of £8. In relation to individualisation, therefore, he has made a hospital pass, as it is known in rugby football, in terms of passing this issue to the next Government. It will be that bit more difficult to get the adult dependant rates up to the 70% or, indeed, to get everybody to a rate applicable as an individual, regardless of who they are.
It still remains a large task for this Minister and his successors to ensure that adults are no longer paid a derisory £62, as they will be on 1 January. In effect, the Minister should have opted for the 75% rate across the board this year. He has made it more difficult for his successor next year to reach that level and, in subsequent years, to reach the desired target of fully individualised payments.
Comment on this
Will the Minister restate his policy on individualisation? What targets would he set in this regard? Is it the intention, from a policy point of view, to move towards full individualisation? If so, is there a timeframe for it? Did he have a timeframe when he took office? What is the current position on reaching the target of individualised payments following the budget?
Comment on this
The issue of individualised payments will take a long time to resolve. Even under the PPF the most on which they could agree was administrative individualisation, which involves dividing the existing payment in two, which is not a huge leap. This was the first Government to indicate clearly that it would increase progressively qualified adult allowance on contributory old age pension to the stage where it would reach the non-contributory old age pension rate, in other words, that it would move towards some form of individualisation. However, that was a first step which we are continuing in the budget. In the case of the other payments, to a certain extent it is built into the target of reaching the figure of 70% or whatever is deemed to be the eventual target. When we took office QAA was somewhere in the region of 59% to 60%. It is now over 66%.
I do not accept what Deputy Broughan says about a hospital pass. The only hospital pass the Government will give to the next Government is the ability or otherwise to reach the all-time record achieved in the last two budgets of a £850 million increase in the social welfare budget.
Comment on this
One of the good things the Minister has done is to create, to some extent, a floor. If there is a reversal of roles and we are sitting on the other side of the table this time next year and the Minister is on this side berating us, does he agree that it is likely that the Government, irrespective of which parties are in office, will ensure it will at least match the rises given in the previous two years? That is a good development. It will be put up to future Governments to at least come up with the sum of £8.06. From that point of view, it is a step forward.
Comment on this
I told the Minister yesterday that I will have no problem with that. There are ways.
Comment on this
In recent years there have been unbelievable surpluses in the current account of £3 billion, £4 billion or £5 billion. There has been £1 billion a year in the social insurance fund. On the current account, it certainly seems there is plenty of money to do the things we need to do. One must make choices. It might come down, for example, to a choice between a super stadium and a hospital or introducing full individualisation in the social welfare system.
Comment on this
I remind the Deputy that, while he may be going out on a limb in saying one can raise corporation tax, it was a member of his party, when Minister, who devised the policy for which his party at least claims credit. It left us a hospital pass when it left office in the sense that it had brought the negotiations at EU level to a certain point. We had to finish them and subsequently implement what was an excellent corporation tax regime, which, the Deputy must admit, has been one of the key successes of the economy and is the reason so many people are at work today.
Comment on this
At the weekend a commentator was saying that the debate on the budgetary side, including taxation and social welfare, was phoney. Because of the stability pact we are constrained when it comes to borrowing. It is all academic. It is history. Because we are a member of what is a huge currency union the impact of borrowing on such a small part of it would be residual. The other point the person concerned was making was that we could not move ahead, as the Minister's party has tried to do, with the tax regime of Texas and attempt to have the social welfare regime of Sweden.
Comment on this
The Deputy should say that to taxpayers. Commenting on television Deputy Rabbitte said that it was his hope that all commentators would be clamouring at the weekend, but they were not. The best commentators of all are members of the public. The Deputy knows, as I do, that they were more than happy with the budget delivered.
Comment on this
In terms of costs, as the Minister said, moving towards individualisation is primarily a financial issue. What costings were placed before the Minister in making decisions about the choices to be made in individualising payments in the different categories?
Comment on this
I do not have the figures, but it would cost hundreds of millions, if not billions, of pounds to do it over an extended period. It would have to be something Governments would do progressively. I claim credit for the fact that this was the first Government to move significantly with some purpose. As the Deputy will appreciate, we probably picked the fairest category, that is, women who through no fault of their own had to leave the workplace to work in the home as a consequence of which they did not have the advantage of continuing their stamps. We started the move with those aged over 66 years, the qualifying adults of their spouses. Their payment has risen to 85% as a result of this and last year's budgets.
Comment on this
That was an important move which everybody present would obviously welcome. How does the Minister see the strategy of moving towards individualisation developing during the years in terms of his grand plan with its high costings? He is correct in stating it is a long-term issue and a very expensive one, but what is the macro plan in his Department?
Comment on this
Because there are now so many females working we will reach the stage in a few decades where virtually everybody will receive a payment in their own right. Individualisation will take effect.
Comment on this
The figure of 60% was set in one of the previous social partnership agreements, progressively worked up to by the previous Government and achieved in our first budget. The commitment in the following social partnership agreement was that it would reach 70%. That has been done. Progressively we will get to the stage where many will be taken care of, but resources will only permit so much to be done. The other way of doing it would be to freeze or slow down the main rate and increase QAAs.
Comment on this
It would cause quite a number of anomalies. We made changes last year to the old age pension rate of £10 and £15 - £25 for a couple - which caused quite severe difficulties for those not entitled to full payments. If we continued the £15 increase over a period, there would be some on QAA means-tested payments who would be getting much more than the main recipient.
Comment on this
Everyone agrees it is a welcome move. Not so much in the case of pensioners, but those on unemployment assistance etc., the gap was too wide. It was an incentive for couples to pretend they were not living together. The system should never encourage people to pretend they have a different status.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the provisions of the Social Welfare Acts which are not in force by reason of the fact that a commencement order has not been made, and the plans if any for bringing such provisions into effect, including in particular the FIS provisions of the Social Welfare (No. 2) Act, 1995, dealing with divorce.".
We tabled this amendment only in order to inquire about the major sections. The Minister told Deputy Hayes that section 17 of the Social Welfare Act, 1988, which provides for the actuarial review of the social insurance fund, would have been commenced and I presume it was. The major legislation the Minister promised in that area, to which we will come later, has not been introduced. Which sections, if any, are relevant? Last year this issue was very topical because the previous year the Minister had abandoned searches on the roadside. The Garda pulled out and the Minister quietly abandoned that section of the 2000 budget. What sections are outstanding?
Comment on this
The Minister stated child benefit will be covered by the Social Welfare Bill, 2002. The rationale behind this legislation was to introduce changes from 1 January and that any other changes would be dealt with in next year's Social Welfare Bill. Will the Minister consider amendments to some schemes in advance of the publication of the Social Welfare Bill, 2002 because a number of other changes, as Deputy Broughan said, under the consolidation Act have not been invoked in this legislation?
Comment on this
The scope of the Minister will always be limited in terms of what is allowed under the Social Welfare Bill because it is dictated by the budget and, therefore, there is no leeway for me to agree to anything that would cause extra expense. The reason for this legislation is to ensure payments are made quickly. Child benefit and other increases will not take effect until 1 April and, thus, can be taken under next year's Social Welfare Bill. That will provide the Oireachtas with an incentive to pass the Bill by that date in case it slips down the pecking order.
Comment on this
Yes, it would not make a difference. The payments will not be paid until 1 April and the budget dictated that.
Comment on this
This is strange legislation because we cannot table amendments which will increase expenditure. This is theatrical.
Comment on this
I know but the Minister could have made the changes in the resolutions made by the Minister for Finance. Will the passage of the Bill next March be another PR exercise?
Comment on this
We could have made regulations but it was felt primary legislation would be required.
Comment on this
We have received complaints about the social welfare budget. One complaint relates to the income disregards of a spouse on an invalidity pension. People have checked in their local social welfare or Comhairle office and have found there have been no changes to a large number of schemes. Will the Minister make changes to disregards and other areas to give those in receipt of payments a boost?
Comment on this
Deputy Broughan referred to invalidity pension. I had a case recently involving an individual whose husband was claiming the carer's allowance——
Comment on this
The upper ceiling for QAA and retention of full child dependent allowances increases from £145 to £155 per week from January 2002. It may well that the individual whom the Deputy mentioned might have been talking about the position now rather than in January. That is done by regulation and, therefore, it is not in situ.
I refer to the statutory provisions that have not commenced. All sections of the Social Welfare Act, 2001, have commenced with the exception of section 37(6), which provides for the commencement of the amendment of the provisions to the principal Act and the consolidation Act required as a consequence of the introduction of the euro currency with effect from 1 January 2001. The sole provision in the 2000 Act to be commenced is section 3, which relates to changes in the administration of the SWA that will be addressed in conjunction with additional administrative issues. All sections of the 1998 and 1999 Acts have been commenced.
There are, however, some provisions in earlier Acts for which commencement orders have not been made. The 1997 sickness allowance scheme has not been introduced. The overall purpose of the proposed scheme will be reviewed as part of an ongoing review of all income maintenance schemes. All those who would have qualified for sickness allowance are currently catered for through other payments. Nobody has lost out as a result. Section 26(1)(b) of the Social Welfare Act, 1997, contains powers to prescribe the provisions relating to benefit and privilege in the context of means assessment.
Section 10(4) of the Social Welfare (No. 2) Act, 1995, provides for regulatory powers under which a divorced person may receive a qualified adult allowance in respect of more than one person. The need for this provision is kept under review. Section 22 of the Social Welfare Act, 1995, provides for regulatory powers designed to standardise the arrangements applying to various social welfare schemes in regard to absence from the State. It is planned to introduce the relevant regulations later this year.
Section 20 of the Social Welfare Act, 1994, refers to the integration of occupational injury benefit and unemployability supplement payable under the benefit scheme of disability benefit. A number of EU directives await transposition into domestic law and they are proceeding apace.
Comment on this
When the Minister makes regulations will he examine a number of simple changes that could be made at relatively little cost? Maternity benefit is based on one's qualifying stamp year. If one makes a claim in 2001 the relevant qualifying stamp year is 1999-2000. The rate of benefit payable is 80% of one's earnings in that year. There have been substantial increases in wages during that time and it is not fair that if a woman takes maternity leave now, the level of benefit she will receive will be based on her income two years ago.
Comment on this
Will the Minister make a change given that it would only involve a small cost? There is a question of fairness to women involved in this issue.
Comment on this
I will deal with it when we reach that amendment. There are arguments on both sides in this regard.
Comment on this
An increase of £8 in the invalidity pension has been introduced. However, a case involving one family was brought to my attention last week. Following the budget the spouse who was in receipt of the invalidity pension will no longer be able to obtain the full tax credit under the home carer's allowance as the £8 increase will breach the existing income limits. There are currently two income limits, £4,000 and £5,000, with a buffer zone in between. This issue relates to the Finance Bill but this increase will lead to a family losing money throughout the year unless the income disregard is increased under that legislation.
Comment on this
I ask the Deputy to forward the details of the case to me. With regard to medical cards and so on if the social welfare rates increase, the income disregards also increase, as has happened already. There was provision in the budget in this regard even though people may criticise us in regard to medical cards. The limits have increased to take account——
Comment on this
The Minister referred to the FISC provisions for divorce under the Social Welfare (No. 2) Act, 1995. Have they been introduced?
Comment on this
The two payments under QAA relating to the Family Law (Divorce) Act, 1996, have not been introduced.
Comment on this
The provision is being kept under review on an ongoing basis. I do not know if there is a huge demand. The provision is already in place.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the social welfare situation of persons resident in Ireland who are in receipt of pensions under the social security legislation of any other jurisdiction.".
This arose on a number of occasions. I seek information in this regard. The Minister reported on a number of occasions on Question Time on the position of those who made social insurance contributions before 1953. I understand some living outside the jurisdiction or returning home would be eligible for any measures under this heading. How do they stand at present? Will the Minister also make a statement regarding means testing of people who receive a pension from another jurisdiction?
Comment on this
Deputy Broughan tabled this amendment last year. When we clarified the position, his question related to people who had British Rail pensions and whether they would qualify for the living alone allowance or the over 80 allowance. We made the point that the allowances are an integral part of the Irish pensions system and are designed to cover specific contingencies and have nothing to do with pension payments made to Irish people by other EU member states or under a bilateral agreement. None of these schemes is connected with British pension recipients in Ireland.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:
"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a system of benchmarking or indexation of all social insurance payments for the purpose of giving security of income to all recipients thereof.".
This formed part of the reason a vote was held an hour or two ago in the Chamber. Regarding the Minister's attitude to benchmarking and indexation, we belatedly received the benchmarking report six weeks ago and found it very interesting. One aspect about which I wondered was that the committee did not consider the minimum wage as a benchmark. It considered various other options and came down in favour of gross average industrial earnings.
A major criticism of the Minister's administration, which we heard last night and this morning, is that we are not clear whether he accepts the benchmarking report and the target of 27% of gross average industrial earnings with a possibility of revising that, depending on how the economy performs, up to 30%. The Labour Party gave a commitment a few months ago in Cork that we would strive in any Government in which we took part for 30% of gross average industrial earnings and would not allow people slip below that. The Minister said he would reach the 31% mark in contributory pensions in 2002. The pensions report argues for a figure of 34%. For years the trade union seniors groups had a target of 40% but they appear to have adjusted that recently to 34%.
The Minister criticised Father Healy and CORI and the fact we quoted them. Why should we not do so? He and his colleagues have in the past decade, and prior to that, issued the quickest and most thorough critique of the budget. The Combat Poverty Agency and other groups will issue their analysis in a few weeks. CORI's basic wish in 1997 was that parties would commit themselves to a basic income for all people. One of the striking features of the past five years and possibly why the CORI document is so negative about the budget and the Minister's social welfare improvements is that, instead of saying to Fr. Healy that this is not the way the Government wants to do business, that it does not believe paying every citizen a certain sum of money and taking some of it back in taxation is efficient, the Minister has waltzed around Fr. Healy and his colleagues for the past four or five years. We have not even reached the Green Paper stage, never mind a White Paper or legislation on basic income.
We must pay great tribute to our trade union colleagues, Peter Cassells of the ICTU, his successor, David Begg, Des Geraghty of SIPTU and all the colleagues in the trade union movement for the manner in which they have tried to advance this cause. I also give credit to the community and voluntary pillar, including Fr. Healy whom I have mentioned. It also includes the INOU, Treoir, the Vincentian partnerships, the St. Vincent de Paul and all the groups which have combined to form the "open your eyes to child poverty" initiative. Their fundamental achievement under the Programme for Prosperity and Fairness has been to bring forward this idea that people on social welfare assistance and benefits should not be made live in penury in a prosperous society. The critique is that, despite the Minister's improvements of the past two years, such people have fallen further behind since he came to office. Through the partnership talks, we have managed to bring forward the idea of a basic income being a serious issue for future Governments.
I commend the Minister and give him credit for the fact that he has probably created to some extent the notion that there will be a floor below which people on social welfare will not be allowed slip, that no matter what happened in previous decades, this will not happen again and that there will be a fundamental benchmark. All the Minister has to do is publish the report and state at one of his public relations events that he accepts this and is committed to it. He has not done that and that is a concern. He could have built it into this legislation. That is why Fr. Healy wanted Green and White Papers - he wanted legislation guaranteeing the payment floor for those on social welfare.
The minimum wage is disgracefully low and should be higher.
Comment on this
We advocated it down the years. The Dáil through the Committee on Enterprise and Small Business played a role in forcing the Minister, Deputy Harney, to bring it forward eventually.
Comment on this
That is true and the reality of what happened. The people who raised the issue and made it an item for discussion were, again, Peter Cassells and the ICTU group. They said, and rightly so, that they would not enter another partnership negotiation unless the Government introduced the minimum wage. The Minister will remember the campaign on behalf of the minimum wage when we marched through the streets. I understand we will not have a £5 minimum wage until October of next year.
Comment on this
Some of the Minister's predecessors were not afraid to march the streets when it was necessary.
Comment on this
This area should not just be confined to indexation and benchmarking. It should include the minimum wage, although there is a form of benchmarking in that area which does not exist in social welfare. A few weeks ago at a meeting of this committee at which the Minister was not present but which was attended by one of his officials, officials from the Departments of Enterprise, Trade and Employment and Finance strongly defended their decision to turn down this report. They said benchmarking could not be accepted because the Minister for Finance must have discretion. If he were given discretion, increases lower than inflation could be introduced.
There should be a benchmark index. The figure of 27% is a good start. The Labour Party's target is 30% and we will publicise that in the general election. We will support increases of that order.
Comment on this
The Labour Party knows it will not be in power. Following Deputy De Rossa's performance as Minister for Social Welfare, how can they ever go back to the people?
Comment on this
I saw the report we have been talking about for the past 12 months there. Nobody told me the report was due to be published or invited me to its launch. Normally, the Minister would buy a full page advertisement in the newspaper to tell everyone about such a report. We proposed these same amendments to last year's Social Welfare Bill and the Minister advised us to wait for the report. The report has now been published. I compliment the Department officials on having the courage to stick their heads above the parapet and support the majority recommendation. The three officials who were on the expert group put their names to the report and said it was the way to proceed. They deserve the same support from the Minister as they have given him in recent years. What is the Minister's position on this issue?
The Minister refused to be drawn when I asked him questions in the House last evening. When officials from the three Departments came before the select committee some weeks ago it was clear that the Department of Social, Committee and Family Affairs was in favour of the report and that the other two Departments were opposed to it.
This issue is bigger than mere party politics and I said as much to CORI, the Society of St. Vincent de Paul and the other third pillar groups which came before the committee. The implementation of this report would require a huge degree of persuasive politics throughout the country. We would have to make arguments to middle class people who know nothing about this issue and do not understand the poverty which exists in parts of our communities, rural and urban alike. If we are to make progress, we need more than political parties simply saying they are committed to implementing the report.
Combat Poverty, in its analysis of last year's and this year's budgets, pointed out that the Minister is the first Minister for social welfare to suggest that we are trying to move social welfare payments in the direction of general income levels. I give him credit for that. Why can he not make a commitment to accept, between now and 2007, this committee's recommendation? In order to achieve consensus we agreed to recommend that the lowest rate of social welfare payment should be 27% of gross average industrial earnings. The current figure is about 21%. We can achieve 27% if year on year increases of the magnitude which all sides of the House want to see are made. This is a touchstone issue and to achieve it will require more than party politicking. It could be an important legacy of the Minister's period in office.
Did the Minister have discussions with his three officials who agreed to the majority recommendation, unlike those from the Departments of Finance and Enterprise, Trade and Employment, before they signed the document or since? Will the Minister now sign up to the report to which his officials have already agreed? He owes as much to his officials who have been working on this subject during the past 12 months.
When I read the excellent report on a sunny September afternoon, I recalled our discussions of last year and was optimistic that a decision would be forthcoming. What is the Minister's position?
Comment on this
These are the Department's targets. Is this report merely a ploy? I am sure the figure could have risen to 27% this year if the increase given to child benefit had been spread differently. This statistic takes no account of the increase in child benefit. I am concerned that Ministers may become obsessed with this report and with the requirement to show progress on it every year. This could drive Ministers away from the commitment to child benefit, at which we have just arrived.
Comment on this
That point is well made and I will not repeat it. The Departments of Finance and Enterprise, Trade and Employment and IBEC are, at least, consistent in their positions. Other groups who were part of the discussions under PPF and who signed up to the majority opinion then decided they wanted more. We must be consistent in making agreements. The document was published on the website with my knowledge because it is a PPF document of public record. I was not about to suppress it. I am surprised the Deputy was not told it was available. I may even have issued a statement in relation to it but I cannot recall doing so. In any event, there was nothing to hide.
Before, during and after the discussions in relation to this matter, my officials acted completely under my authority and instruction and with my knowledge. The negotiations were hard fought. Between the Deputy's proposal to this committee and the final result of its deliberations, changes were made. I kept a close eye on that and I believe the committee was correct in the position it adopted. The report says:
The majority of the group considered that the target of 27% of gross average industrial earnings on a current year basis for the lowest social welfare payments was not an unreasonable policy objective. Given current uncertainties in relation to the short-term economic position, it was difficult to be prescriptive about the precise timeframe although it would not be unreasonable to expect that the target would be met in full by 2007.
That was framed at a time when there was quite a lot of uncertainty and there has been even more uncertainty since. An increase of 27% presupposes and implies an estimated annual average increase in relation to the lowest social welfare payments of £9.70 over the six budgets between now and 2007. I raised the lowest social welfare payments by £9.56 in this budget. Actions speak louder than words.
This issue will feed into the process of the national anti-poverty strategy review, the results of which will be available in the near future. In our budget speeches the Taoiseach and I referred to how we see us moving over a period. I ask Deputies to look again at what we said and thank them for recognising that I am the first Minister not just to speak about reaching average industrial earnings but for having achieved that goal over the last number of budgets. Many people do a lot of talking but never implement what they talk about. I would criticise some parties on the opposite side who do too much navel gazing but do not take enough action where it matters.
Comment on this
On a point of information, the Minister may recall that a colleague of ours from the Louth constituency who was in the House this morning lost the whip early in his career over a social welfare budget because he deemed it insufficient.
Comment on this
He was correct because it was not sufficient. I recall that instance. I must say the Deputy came from a Fianna Fáil background.