We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FAMILY, COMMUNITY AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS

Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill, 2001.

Contributions 184–356 of 534. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill 2001
Enacted

No. 60 of 2001 ›

He saw the light.

Comment on this

He knew there was no future for him. I was not around then - that was the time of Pádraig Faulkner.

Comment on this

Deputies should stick to the amendment.

Comment on this

As I said previously we are on target. We have already reached the old age pension payment of 30% and it is a sensible policy to raise other payments as and when resources permit. It would be our objective into the future to pursue a strategy of increasing other payments as resources permit so there are broadly similar levels in relation to average industrial standards in our community. I can say no more than that. It will feature in the national anti-poverty strategy review.

Comment on this

Gross average industrial earnings are a useful barometer. However, it is a narrow barometer if one considers all those who work in the public sector.

Comment on this

That is the point the chairman made.

Comment on this

That is why I thought the group might have explored the linkage to a minimum wage. They did not do so because when one begins to talk in terms of a minimum wage one immediately talks about costs and competitiveness in the economy. For example, if one said we will hit 50% of an average minimum wage of, say, £7 or \12 an hour, then one would be building it into the centre of the economy. I know you chose what you chose and you still have not accepted it, which is the basic point. You may say actions speak louder than words but sometimes one must say exactly where one stands. There have been huge resources for the last five years but they were only deployed fairly in the last two years, therefore, the fundamental question remains.

I was reading the Vincentian report, the presentation of which Deputy Hayes and I attended. There is a lot of that type of stuff coming forward. There were interesting articles last year by Kitty Holland in The Irish Times. Deputy Hayes referred to a study in DCU. Given that we are getting quite a lot of information, including the benchmark approach, is there merit in setting budget standards as referred to in the Vincentian report? Perhaps we should decide what is necessary for a family of one, two or three people to lead a reasonably good life with dignity. The bottom line in the report was that last year a lone parent with two children was approximately £40 short for reasonable food, clothing and control of bills. However, such a person was not desperately juggling or getting into arrears with the local authority, the gas company and so on. Such a citizen would need an extra £40 per week at his or her disposal to have a reasonable income. The Minister has gone some way towards achieving that target when everything is taken into account, including child benefit, but overall a lot more needs to be done.

I believe the amendments should be accepted. If the Minister was brave enough to stand up to the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy - which he is not - he would accept the report.

Comment on this

What is the percentage now?

Comment on this

There is also the question of the average industrial wage.

Comment on this

It is more than 25% but I will check that figure.

The question of budget packages is interesting. We should call a spade a spade. In 1996 the social welfare package amounted to £161 million, 24% less than in the previous year. This is important because it is all relative. That was a relative sum of money in those days when one chose to give a total social welfare package which was 24% less than in the previous year. The income tax package in 1995-6 was more or less the same. More given in tax changes in 1996 rather than spreading it somewhat. The following year the social welfare package increased exponentially by 33% from a figure of minus 24% the previous year. It increased by 40% in 1999, 27% in 2000 and 110% in 2001. Obviously it was the same this year.

Many of the discussions relate to the relative issue. Groups such as the Vincentians and CORI should know well from their religious education - a bit like the miracle of the loaves and fishes - that one gets a sum of money and one must do the best one can, no matter how large or small the sum. I am proud to have been Minister for the last five years when all these advances took place. More could have been done but in my view we have reached social welfare levels that none of us anticipated five years ago. I accept it is not excellent for one to have to live on social welfare payments. However, I must go back to what has been done in regard to employment. People in my constituency who thought they would never work are all working now. When these people are working they are not claiming social welfare, which is a saving to the State. They contribute tax, albeit a much lower rate of tax. I do not agree with the Deputy's philosophy on taxation. There used to be an attitude that it did not pay to work. Exponentially social welfare payments have increased but it pays people to work. Because of the progressive changes over the years, particularly in the last five years, people know it is better to work.

Benchmarking is a good idea but it cannot operate on its own and there are other aspects. That is one of the reasons we want this proposal dealt with in the context of the national anti-poverty strategy review.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Putting off the national anti-poverty strategy review is putting off the day when decisions are made.

Comment on this

I am not putting off anything. I have given commitments.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I do not think that is the way to approach the issue. To go back to the point I made, the Minister is correct. If we as a society wish to move from the lowest rate of social welfare it will require more than just a party or group of parties talking about it. It will require the same kind of consensus we had, up to a point, in the 1980s in respect of getting the economy right and encouraging competitiveness. There are sections of the modern Celtic tiger economy that do not recognise the abject poverty in our midst, or that relative income poverty has grown substantially in the past ten years, both during the terms of this Government and the previous one. The problem of relative income poverty has not been addressed and the Minister admitted as much yesterday when answering Deputy Broughan's question on the household budget survey.

I represent a constituency where 25% of households, or approximately 8,500 houses, are local authority dwellings. I accept there has been a dramatic shift as regards people who are coming off unemployment benefit and into work. That change has made a dramatic difference, particularly to our poorest communities. I know that for a fact because I represent a constituency with a substantial number of local authority estates which house people who never thought they would be working yet are doing so today. That has made a dramatic difference to them and to their families' lives.

The difficulty, however, is that many of the jobs that were hard won in recent years will be the first to go in the economic downturn I am already witnessing in my constituency. It is unfair to tell people who have been encouraged back to work, realising that it is worth their while to work rather than stay on the dole, and then go through a period of unemployment, even if it is only for a short time, that they will not get the kind of benefits they have paid for through the PRSI system. That is the problem.

I accept there have been dramatic changes over the past four and a half years, and during the three year term of the previous Administration. The fact is, however, that we still do not have the kind of supports we should have for those on the lowest rates of unemployment benefit and assistance. Putting off the day when a decision has to be taken on this report will ensure that we will never reach the kind of rates that should be attained in the short-term.

Comment on this

The Deputy said he studied economics and it is a fact that in times of economic boom what he calls relative income poverty, or relative income disparity, between lower and higher levels increases. That is an economic fact.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It does not have to happen.

Comment on this

The converse applies when there is an economic downturn. One cannot measure things purely on relativity because many other factors must be taken into account. All researchers say that, so it is somewhat nonsensical for people to continuously refer to relative poverty on its own. If the average income in a midlands village is £10,000 per annum and somebody there wins the lotto, there will be a huge increase in relative income differential. That does not mean, however, that people earning £10,000 are any poorer the next day. That is a basic illustration of how the relativity argument is not that relevant to ordinary people. What is relevant is that their basic incomes have increased substantially over the past five years, as regards even the lowest social welfare payments.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's point concerning statistics that show 20% of people pay 70% of income tax, but as society improves everybody's needs change. People, rightly, want to participate in the good life in which they see a significant minority indulging. From that point of view, relative poverty is an issue that must be faced up to.

Comment on this

That is not relative poverty, it is relativity.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Income poverty.

Comment on this

No, it is not. It is relativity. There was a time in this country when we had no millionaires, yet we now have millionaires all over the place.

Comment on this

There was never such a time, Minister.

Comment on this

There was.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

They just did not admit it.

Comment on this

We had very few millionaires.

Comment on this

They did not pay tax.

Comment on this

We have many millionaires but that does not mean the rest of us are poor.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

There is not a system one can put in place to ensure that when times are good, and the resources are there, substantial allocations can go to lower income groups in society.

Comment on this

The ESRI figures prove that is happening.

Comment on this

The other benchmark that people can look at in future——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

"Benchmark" is a real buzz word.

Comment on this

——is the actual growth in the economy. There are other ways in which one can look at the situation to ensure everybody is included. The Labour Party exists because it believes in equality for everyone, not only equality of opportunity. We believe that a decent proportion of whatever extra resources are available in the good times should be given to the less well off.

I agree with Deputy Hayes' point that we require political consensus to move that idea forward. To some extent, that is what has happened over the past 18 months. The Minister has continually referred to the national pensions fund which was given a kick start by those unfortunate Eircom shareholders the Minister will meet in the coming months when he is campaigning on the doorsteps.

Comment on this

The Deputy should stick to the point. That was never even mentioned.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy recall who was on the board and presided over all that, and who did not buy any shares apart from taking a big whack of money as a director?

Comment on this

When the pension fund was established we got a couple of lines in the press stating that the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, was considering it. We should have had a major public debate about this matter. For example, the Minister could have done all kinds of things, including reducing the national debt by £8 billion, thus lowering it to £20 billion. Yet, he decided to opt for the pension fund about which there was very little debate.

Comment on this

Next to Luxembourg, we have the lowest debt to GDP ratio in Europe.

Comment on this

When the Bill was going through the House, there was no attempt to involve people. Many of the people we represent will not benefit from that pension fund as they will be dead long before their time because of the conditions in which the Government has left them.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 7
·
Níl 8
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of the majority recommendation of the Social Welfare Benchmarking and Indexation Group in respect of reaching a target of 27 per cent of gross average industrial earnings by 2007 for the lowest social welfare payment.".

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 7:

In page 3, before section 2, to insert the following new section:

"2.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of paying interest to social welfare recipients where his Department is unable to deliver within a reasonable period of time either planned increases or benefits to recipients who have applied for the first time to his Department.".

This amendment asks the Minister to look at the length of time it takes to pay some departmental schemes. I am critical of the fact the Department failed to ensure that people will receive their benefits on 1 January. I know the arguments but am not convinced, given that the Minister knew for a year and a half. However, setting that matter to one side, in recent months we have seen a dearth of schemes organised by the Minister's Department whereby people are not getting paid on time. Child benefit and carer's allowance are examples. People contact my office with complaints about the length of time between an application and receipt of payment.

It may be backdated but the idea of a penalty imposed by the Department on itself for failing to deliver these payments within a reasonable period should be addressed in a report. If one owes money to Revenue, one must pay a penalty and interest. From a customer service viewpoint, it would be good for the Minister to consider a regime that would penalise his Department for this failure.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. Under the appeals system also, people receive retrospective payments. There is a view that there should be an independent appeals system because the Department adjudicates on its own decision which is against a fundamental principle of law.

Comment on this

At any given time there are tens of million of pounds outstanding to the Department in overpayments or claims that have to be paid back in small sums of perhaps £2 or £5 per week. No interest is charged on those. Likewise, the Deputies fail to see the point about these payments. I will not repeat the arguments. We have been criticised for the delay but are trying to concertina the period between announcement and delivery, which all Deputies will welcome.

The time lag between application and decision varies from scheme to scheme, depending on the scheme's complexity and requirements. Delays are kept to a minimum and many are outside the Department's control, because necessary information may not forthcoming from the claimant, for example. I cannot accede to the request, if that is what the amendment is getting at - that is not the matter on which the Deputies spoke.

We want to shorten the time between the budget and delivery of increases. This is being examined and will include closer work with the payment suppliers and the security printers. The focus will be on delivering more payments by electronic means. I can list all the schemes which will be paid on time and those which will be paid in February, although I think Deputies are aware of them. A major information campaign on this will be launched.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister said he does not charge interest on the payments of those who defraud the system.

Comment on this

It is not necessarily that they defraud the system. It might be that someone claims for what he or she is not entitled to.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Last year, he gave a figure of about £270 million that he managed to claw back in such cases.

Comment on this

I do not know the figure offhand, but there are savings of that kind every year. There is an EU wide measure for calculating them. We do not pick figures out of our head.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Does the £270 million go straight back into the social insurance fund on the current account?

Comment on this

It is taken into account in the estimation by the Department of Finance of what money is required from year to year.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

So it exists within the social insurance fund.

Comment on this

Not necessarily in the social insurance fund. It depends on where the money comes from.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It is, then, a nominal amount of money that the Department of Finance factors into the Minister's departmental estimation.

Comment on this

Yes. It is nominal in effect because it is a reduced estimate.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

As a member of the Strategic Management Committee, I see many departments using technology to get applications quickly to and from people, particularly through the Internet For what schemes in the Minister's Department can applicants use the Internet? In Revenue, one can transmit accounts and annual returns that way.

Comment on this

Claimants can download application forms from the Internet. Soon, they will be able to make applications through it. It is part of the reach process, which we expect will be on stream early next year.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 8 and 40 are related and may discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment no. 8:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of making provision for a parental leave benefit to be funded from the social insurance fund.".

This issue was highlighted by our colleague, David Begg, general secretary of ICTU, as we both pointed out. The trades union movement strongly believes that we have had the resources in recent years to extend benefits and to use the surplus to provide new and innovative ones. A glaring anomaly for many years in equality legislation, which followed EU directives, is that people can obtain unpaid parental leave but there is no parental benefit particularly in the early weeks after the birth of a child or at other key points in the child's life. There should be some possibility of establishing, through the social insurance fund, resources to provide this benefit. My party is committed to that and we had an interesting discussion on it at our conference.

A serious aspect of this is that the £1.8 billion surplus we had in the social insurance fund will now be £635 million less and the opportunity to introduce this kind of benefit has been reduced. That is the fundamental reason we think the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs, Deputy D. Ahern, should have resisted the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, and asked him to balance the budget in some other way. The issue of borrowing was, I feel, only a red herring. Why would the country borrow when it has a current budget surplus of £5 billion?

This fund should have been left alone. It could be argued that it is a hypothecated tax to which we are making a significant change today in relation to the employers' contribution - a change we decided not to oppose. The amendment offers the Minister the opportunity to introduce a major new development for parents which would have given parents of young children the chance of an easier life combining home duties with work. We spoke about family friendly work practices when discussing the family support agency a few weeks ago and the Minister has the opportunity to support them here. Perhaps parental benefit is in his manifesto but he could have introduced it over the last three years when he had the opportunity. He should have done it and our trade union colleagues believe it is time he did. He has the opportunity in this Bill and so I am pressing the amendment.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The argument has been made that people, particularly women, should take up work or return to work but unless we put in place a modern social security system to match a working parents' lifestyle we do a huge disservice to the labour market itself. We have seen a radical change over the past five years in the number of people returning to work, especially women. Parental leave and benefit is also a gender issue. It is right and proper that men should be entitled to take a few weeks paid leave when their child is born. This is not a radical departure but happens in most EU countries. Ourselves, Britain and one or two other EU countries do not have this provision. Deputy Broughan is right. Putting in place a modern social security system, based on the idea that people who pay insurance get something back from it, would be a key device to help create a flexible, modern workforce.

We all know the pressures parents are under and those pressures increase on the birth of another child. We do not have within our labour law or social security system the kind of flexibility that will ensure those under pressure can take a break. There is a high level of discrimination against men on this issue. They are frequently told on the birth of a child that they must get back to work within 24 hours. That does not make for good parenting and it does not get men involved in the process of the birth and the critical few weeks following it. People may ask how our forefathers managed. I am sure the Minister will agree that if we want to put in place flexible arrangements for parents we need to implement this kind of measure.

I agree with Deputy Broughan. We had the opportunity to introduce this measure this year. The money was there and it would not have cost too much if the Minister decided to do this instead of allowing a raid on the social insurance fund. I am interested in hearing what he has to say on the matter.

Comment on this

It is the luxury of the Opposition to be generous. Of course going into the next election every party will claim to be in favour of paid parental leave and we will do likewise. We have to work within the partnership process. That process is examining this issue and there is common assent on the principle of paid paternal leave. If it was to be done through the social welfare system the cost would depend on the level of payment, the duration or payment and the level of take-up. It has not been specifically agreed that it should be a social welfare payment. If it was paid at the rate of disability benefit lasting four weeks it would cost £28 million while a payment equivalent to the maternity benefit rate would be in the region of £66 million. The cost would depend on how it would be taken, on whether time was taken as reduced hours or days or weeks off. It would be difficult to administer in the form of a State payment. Part of the examining process is considering how it could be paid and looking at the approach taken by other countries.

The Programme for Prosperity and Fairness contained a commitment that the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform would look at the operation of the Parental Leave Act in consultation with the social partners. In line with that commitment a working group was established. The working group is chaired by the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform and comprises representatives from ICTU, IBEC, ICOS representing the farmers' pillar, the National Women's Council of Ireland representing the voluntary and community pillar, the Department of Finance, the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs and the Equality Authority. The deliberations of the group are nearing completion and the current position is that no agreement could be reached in relation to the question of paid paternal leave. Some members are not in favour and while others agree in principle with the merit of paid paternal leave they feel the implications and the full range of options for paid leave were not properly explored by the group.

It is not a simple matter of saying that we favour paid paternal leave because there is not total agreement in regard to it. My Department's views in relation to how it could be paid as a social welfare payment is that it would be difficult to administer as a payment given the different circumstances that would be involved.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Did the Minister say it would cost £68 million annually if its basis was similar to maternity benefit?

Comment on this

That is the estimate.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 10 and 24 may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the increases granted under the Social Welfare Acts having regard to the impact of such increases on-

(a) the local authority differential rent scheme, and

(b) the rental subsidy scheme for private accommodation.”.

Last year the Minister told us that the local authority differential system was not his responsibility but the responsibility of the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. We asked for a system of joined-up Government where, if a social welfare increase came in immediately, the system demanded that 15% of that would be paid. One of the questions last year was the inconsistency between different counties and the types of systems they used.

The problem of rents identified last year has been exacerbated over the past year. In my constituency rents continue to be extremely high. I am not sure if the changes brought about in the budget by the Minister's colleague will necessarily see a large drop in those rents. There seems to be inconsistency in the manner in which rent supplement is applied.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I do not wish to labour the point. Relatively small increases have been given but when the differential rent scheme is applied, much of that increase will be taken up by increased rents. A person in private rented accommodation will see a deteriorating situation. I have a question for the Minister arising from the amendments. What is the position on the proposal to integrate the rental subsidy scheme with the local authority housing departments? This was proposed almost four years ago. The money comes from the Minister's Department but the people are employed by the health board. The people we met throughout the year feel their views have not been fully aired and articulated. As the Minister is aware, a long-standing recommendation, supported by all parties, is that there would be integration of the rent subsidy scheme with the local authorities so that if rent payments have to be made, they will be given by the local authorities. There has been no progress to date on this proposal. I would be interested in hearing any information the Minister can give the committee. Both of these amendments deal with the real problem where these increases will be taken up for about 10% of the population who depend on the social housing sector for accommodation.

Comment on this

The transfer of the rent supplement to local authorities was a Government decision of a number of years ago. It has proved difficult to implement in practice. It is outside my Department - it is a matter for the Department of the Environment and Local Government. There are significant industrial relations issues because of the different structures between local authority and health board employees. They are the subject of discussions and negotiations. Perhaps the Deputy could put down a question to the Minister for the Environment and Local Government.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Will the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs provide the money?

Comment on this

The principle agreed was that we would fund somebody for 12 months but thereafter they would transfer. That was a compromise reached by the working group that looked at the issue. It would allow people some flexibility.

I cannot dictate to local authorities but we take certain things into account when we are making changes. Last year I introduced a special disregard of £5 in the assessment of rental supplement for people aged 65 and over in receipt of a social welfare pension. Instead of a reduction of £2 per week in the rent or mortgage supplement, a single person received an increase of £3 per week. Overall they gained £13 last year. This year pensioners again received increases which are higher than the increase in the standard rate of supplementary allowance. In order to ensure pensioners benefit from the additional increases, the budget also raised the amount of the disregard in the assessment of rent supplement to \10 or £7.88. As a result of changes that were made in the budget in relation to the £9.56 for the lower social welfare payments, people who are on standard rates of one parent family payment, long-term UA, UB, disability benefit and other schemes are not affected by the clawback of budget increases. They will benefit from a small increase in the amount of rent supplement payable.

On the broader issue of differential rent, this was raised with me previously and I have raised it over the last while with the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. I understand that a circular will issue shortly from the Minister for the Environment and Local Government giving guidance to local authorities on limiting the amount they take on foot of social welfare increases. That will have the effect of unifying the approach of local authorities around the country.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing increases in child benefit with effect from the first payment date on or following the 1st day of January.".

The rationale of moving to January is to bring the tax and welfare year into line with the financial and calendar year. We have succeeded in doing so except in the case of child income. If the next budget was to bring it back to January, what costs would that entail?

Comment on this

If my memory serves me correctly, somewhere in the region of £80 million. It cost about £75 million to £80 million to bring it back from June to April. It is a very significant costing and it could be more because next year's figure is so much more. The overall budget for child benefit is £82 million. The overall total is much more than when we came into office. Bringing in earlier payments will be very costly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of bringing the child benefit for twins into line with the provision for multiple births of 3 or more children.".

The organisation that campaigns on this issue still feels that the Minister is not giving a fair deal to twins and parents of twins. All multiple births should be treated the same. The organisation says that the Minister did not fulfil the 1997 promise despite the 150% target.

Comment on this

I maintain that we fulfilled our commitments in relation to this issue. We said we would increase it by 150%. I would have liked to have done that but this year I was not able to do the 100% for multiple births. People who have multiple births have received the benefit of the extremely significant child benefit increases over the last three years. We tend to forget that over the past three years the Government increased child benefit by £8 and £10, by £25 and £30 and then another £25 and £30. Cumulatively over the last three years child benefit has increased fairly dramatically for everyone, including parents of multiple births.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

In his opening remarks on the night of the budget, the Minister referred to some of the welcoming comments made by the Combat Poverty Agency in relation to the budget. However, does he also accept its criticism in respect of dealing with third and fourth children? While there were increases in child benefit in the budget, the Minister did not do anything significant for third and fourth children. This point was made clearly by the Combat Poverty Agency in the submission it sent us directly after the budget. Bigger families on low incomes have to carry the excessive cost for children. Given that the Minister accepted its compliments, does he accept its criticism as well?

Comment on this

It is not often that the Combat Poverty Agency says complimentary things about any budget. When Fine Gael and Labour were in Government, it criticised their budgets also.

Comment on this

We established the agency.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Broughan have the right people on the board?

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister appointed the board, so he is all right.

Comment on this

I do not accept the criticism of the Combat Poverty Agency because we have given child benefit increases, which even it had not expected in the last budget. Its critique of our last budget was very complimentary in comparison with what it might have been previously.

Comment on this

The previous three budgets.

Comment on this

Again this year it has been very complimentary. When the Government gives something substantial, people take it as a given and want to push it more. The day they are not satisfied is the day they are redundant. All pressure groups have to keep pushing the bar as high as they can.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister sounds like the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, and his poverty industry.

Comment on this

I have some views on that.

Comment on this

Let us hear them.

Comment on this

I will not go into them in this debate. It is not valid for me to be lectured by people who never have to put up with the representations and the personal interaction that public representatives have to make. I would never accept criticism from groups who do not do as much as we do in this area.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 13, 14, 26 and 27 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 13:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"Child dependant allowance.

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of providing for a uniform rate of child dependant allowance by increasing the different rates to the maximum rate and of increasing the child dependant allowance for widows and widowers to \25 per child per week.".

The Minister referred to the child dependant allowance earlier. Along with the fuel allowance, this is one of the few allowances he has never increased during his period in office. The social partners deserve much credit for the provisions on child benefit in the three-year programme. After this programme, I assume we will have to look again at children's income in general. There is a strong case for targeting available resources at poorer children, given that our child poverty rate is 3% above the EU average based on recent figures.

The Minister mentioned the Combat Poverty Agency. When Mr. Walsh briefed us a few months ago on all these issues, he specifically asked that the Minister address this matter this year. He wanted the Minister to bring everybody up to £15.20 over a two-year period.

Over the years, I have had strong representations from widows and widowers with relatively young children, including one person who calls to me every three or four weeks to ask me to look after widows. I have to put that to the Minister. Despite the increases last year and this year, she feels £17 is derisory in that regard. Once next year's target for increases in child benefit are reached, we must look at this.

A long-term unemployed person will get about £38 to £40 per week for the first and second child in child dependant allowance and child benefit. I hope my colleague, Ms Joan Burton, will be back in this House as a Deputy within a few months. She was a very good Minister of State at the Department of Social Welfare and initiated the real expansion of child benefit. Deputy Wade may not want to believe that, but it is true.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Proinsias De Rossa got the credit for that.

Comment on this

There were dramatic increases in 1993-94. We had this debate in our own councils involving the then Minister of State, Eithne Fitzgerald.

Comment on this

Was that the year they gave nothing to the old age pensioners?

Comment on this

At the time the decision was made to leave the child dependant allowance and extensively improve child benefit. Obviously, this has been accelerated very significantly in recent years. We utterly reject the notion of taxation of benefit, as suggested by some people, and I cannot envisage any political party doing so. It is often lower middle-income people who get caught in these traps. They would end up paying tax on their child benefit. The other model would be to revert to child dependant allowances. The Combat Poverty Agency, the Vincentian Partnership and some other groups made a strong case for that in recent years. This should be on our agenda and my amendment reflects this. Once we have achieved a basic level of child income, we should target poorer children. This should be fundamental in the next four or five years.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I agree with Deputy Broughan that there must be a way to target the poorest of the poor families because of the way child benefit goes to all families. There is no other mechanism whereby we can help lift those families out of poverty at the other end of the spectrum. It is wrong that the Minister has tabled no amendments on child dependant allowance. It must be unconstitutional to have three rates for different children. The son or daughter of a widow gets £17.50. The son or daughter of an unemployed person gets £13.50. Last year the Minister rightly pointed out that at one time there were 30 different rates, which was ridiculous. We should have made progress this year. It has been the source of criticism by many groups and I hope we can make some progress on it shortly.

There was one specific commitment given by the Government and it is the subject of amendment No. 27 in my name. It relates to the extension of the child dependant allowance to children up to 22 years of age who are in full time education. The Minister has made a very small improvement in the scheme this year, whereby students will get the allowance up to the end of the year they start in a course or at school even if they are over 18. That was a cast iron commitment in the PPF and the figures made available to me by the Department of Finance do not constitute a huge sum of money. Why did the Minister not go with the PPF commitment this year?

Now that we are moving towards substantial child benefit payment, does the Minister accept that parents have the right to obtain that money on a weekly or twice monthly basis? The Minister failed to address my submissions on that matter in the House over the past week or so. Has his Department examined this? It would be sensible to give people the money weekly or twice monthly, according to their choice.

Comment on this

Targeting money generally leads to disincentives because cut-off points are introduced. I take Deputy Broughan's point, which relates to the last one made by Deputy Brian Hayes, that there may well come a time when more can be done in the area of child benefit with regard to CDAs. Due to past three budgets, the child benefit payment is now a substantial amount of money. The amount set aside for it was £400 million when we came to office and it will be £1.5 billion next year, which is an amazing increase. The 1994 policy froze the CDAs, thereby reducing the possibility of disincentives. The rationale behind the policy is that I want to give money to people irrespective of their employment or marital circumstances. It is a disincentive to lone parents to marry or to take a partner as there is a potential that they would lose the CDA whereas child benefit is universal and goes to people irrespective of a change in employment or marital status. The policy adopted in 1994 with which I agreed when I took office in 1997 was entirely logical.

I made changes in the budget to provide for the extension of CDA payments until the end of the academic year in which the young person reaches 18 years of age. This measure comes into effect in April and is the first step in increasing the age limit to 22, as promised in the PPF which has some time left to run. The policies of indexation of CDA and of increasing child benefit by more than the rate of inflation have been in place since 1994 and it is important to recognise that over that period the combined CB and CDA payment has increased by more than double the rate of inflation. In 1994, child benefit represented 29% of the total CB-CBA payment for a four child family. Today, it represents 57% and from April next that representation will rise to 65%, which is a very substantial increase.

Comment on this

Child benefit creates a basic income for children, which is something we should always have had. Does the Minister envisage CSA and child benefit ever being means-based?

Comment on this

I could see that happening. There was a suggestion some time ago that we might merge the two into one payment.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Can the payment be made on a weekly or twice monthly basis?

Comment on this

That issue will arise when we get closer to a substantial payment. The child benefit delivery system is, with due respect to the Department, quite antiquated and it would take a totally new computer system to do that. I accept that the more the payment is increased, the greater will be the need for a different delivery system. Changes are being made under the new service delivery model and we will be looking at making payments in the way the Deputy has outlined.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

What will be the cost of the extension to 22 years of age for children in full-time education?

Comment on this

I can get that figure for the Deputy later.

Comment on this

The Minister should take his time about making the payment a weekly one. Many parents like to get it monthly.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 15:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of the extension of the family income supplement to the families of persons who are self-employed and phasing out of the back-to-work scheme.".

This amendment is resubmitted due to shortness of time. This is still an issue.

Comment on this

This amendment involves the extension of the family income supplement to the families of persons who are self-employed and phasing out of the back-to-work scheme.

Comment on this

Has your thinking developed since last year?

Comment on this

I doubt it very much.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 16:

In page 4, before section 3, to insert the following new section:

"3.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of extending the social welfare free schemes to widows and widowers with dependent children.".

I refer here to the general problems the Minister mentioned in relation to developments in contributory and non-contributory pensions for survivors. Families headed by a widow can be very vulnerable, particularly those with young children. I noticed yesterday that the Minister did not provide for further extensions of the free schemes, though in gas, electricity and household benefit some of the amounts have been increased. Of all the groups to be considered, this one should be looked at. Last year the Minister said that distinguishing between lone parents and widows and widowers would be unfair, but the argument remains to be made that the matter of widows should certainly be kept under review.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I support that. The difference between lone parents and widows is that this is an insurance based system, as people contribute through PRSI. If a husband or wife dies and they were formerly working and paying into the social insurance fund, then the argument can be made to extend the free schemes to them. The analogy to lone parents, which was the argument made last year, is not correct. This is a once-off circumstance in which people have paid substantial sums of money over their lifetimes and when they die young there is a need for the survivors to draw from that insurance. The Minister did not refer to the fact that I proposed this in my pre-budget submission. It would have been good to extend this to all widows, irrespective of age. The argument to be made to the Department of Finance is that these people paid contributions and if someone dies at age 45 the State should provide an additional benefit. This amendment is a very effective way to help people.

Comment on this

Not all deceased people have made contributions and the cost of extending this to all widows would be in the region of £30 million.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

It has increased since I last checked.

Comment on this

The problem is not the Department of Finance, it is the potential for the Department to be sued by a lone parent to determine whether or not they were being discriminated against vis-à-vis widows.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Why is it the same principle for CDA? The difference on CDA is widows can see the £17.50.

Comment on this

Nobody has taken that point. There are issues and the strong advice is that we cannot do it for widowers.

Comment on this

Are the free schemes now paid out of the social insurance fund?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Could the case be made that a widow, even of a contributor, would have a right to it?

Comment on this

That would not take in all widows. It could be extended but there would be other people who are making payments and are under 66 years with a contribution record, but who are not getting the free schemes. In the review of the free schemes, that was one of the reasons for the strong view regarding not making it applicable to people under 66 years, except in some exceptional circumstances such as those covered between the ages of 60 and 66. I received representations from all sides of the House and looked at this in some detail. The best we could come up with for widows under 66 years was to increase the normal payments and to give a substantial bereavement grant. In effect, a widow under 66 years who has children will receive £2,500 on the death of a spouse from a combination of the increased widow-parent grant and the bereavement grant. We have given a commitment to increase the payment for widows over 66 years. We are very close to fulfilling that and we will do it next year for the contributory old age pension rate.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 19, 23, 32 and 33 are related to amendment No. 18 and all may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 18:

In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of abolishing the means test for carer's allowance and introducing a carer's payment.".

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I tabled amendments Nos. 32 and 33, which relate to increasing the income disregard for carer's allowance. The much publicised pre-budget submission I produced on behalf of my party some weeks ago proposed an increase of up to £370 for a married couple and £175 for a single person under the allowance. There were some improvements in this year's Social Welfare Act which I welcome, but I encourage the Minister to go further. The reason I arrived at an increase of £370 for a married couple was to ensure that would be twice the rate given under the national minimum wage. That would be a fair assessment because even under the Minister's proposals there is still a significant group of people outside the ambit of carer's allowance who should be in receipt of support under the scheme.

I asked the Minister yesterday what is the maximum rate payable under the scheme and how many of the 22,000 recipients of the allowance are on that rate. He might refer to these questions in his reply. The group of people most perturbed by the financial resolution that was put before the House and by this legislation is carers. According to the Minister's figures there are approximately 53,000 carers while the Carers Association and other representative groups claim there are in excess of 100,000 carers. We must move rapidly to at least recognise that people who are full-time carers have the right to obtain a carer's allowance and to receive other social welfare payments, which is currently prohibited under the social welfare code.

Amendment No. 33 relates to a proposal outlined in our pre-budget submission which would provide half rate carer's allowance for persons already in receipt of other social welfare payments. If it is accepted that the allowance is a form of payment in respect of work done in caring for a loved one or friend, it should also be accepted that a reasonable payment should be provided. People who foster children receive £200 per week from their health board and virtually the same care, if not more substantial care, is provided by those who should come within the carer's allowance scheme. Why is the rate of carer's allowance less than half that for foster care?

We must move in the direction proposed in the amendments. Carers are perturbed by the budget and by this Bill. They are not happy in any shape or form with the very small budgetary increases.

Comment on this

As Deputy Hayes said, carers were the most disappointed group in terms of the budget. I note from my colleague in Limerick that the Minister of State, Deputy O'Dea, has been telling people that abolishing the means test would cost £600 million. I would be interested to know how he worked out that figure and the basis for it.

The Minister likes to look back on the past. During the term of the rainbow Government, the number in receipt of carer's allowance doubled. That number has more than doubled in the Government's term of office, given the extra resources that have been available. When the 3,200 carers receive their enhanced allowance, it should be borne in mind that half the number of carers the Minister quoted from CSO figures will not qualify for that allowance. The point that carers and key carer groups, including the Carers Association, Care Alliance Ireland and NAMHI, have continually put to us is that we need to fully recognise the work of carers. While the Government has made improvements, which I do not think anyone would dispute, we have not given carers full recognition for the work they do. That may involve establishing their work on a legislative basis.

The disability commissioner Bill, formulated by the disability groups, was introduced by Deputy Fitzgerald. The disability commissioner and needs assessment legislation in place in the United Kingdom would commit the Government to significant extra spending on people with disabilities and their carers. The carer's Act in England does precisely that. Giving full recognition to the work of carers is a challenge that remains to be met. Prior the introduction of the carer's allowance by the then Minister, Deputy Woods, the prescribed relatives allowance was in place. While the carer's allowance has been in place for ten or 11 years, a large number of carers are not adequately catered for.

The Minister disputed research in this area from the Western Health Board. Last autumn a report by the South-Eastern Health Board prepared in conjunction with the University of Ulster, Coleraine, found that the main problem expressed by many carers was that they do not get any recognition for the work they do. The most fundamental form of recognition is a payment. Abolishing the means test would effectively ensure a payment for the many carers who do not currently qualify for the carer's allowance. I ask the Minister to reconsider doing that.

In relation to the income disregard for the carer's allowance, Mr. Ger South and other able advocates for carers from Limerick, who carried out a survey, attended a meeting of this committee. They were given a message by the Taoiseach around seven or eight months ago that he would raise the income disregard for carer's allowance for a married couple. Although the Minister for Finance increased the income disregard to \158.72 for a single person and to \317.43 for a married couple, he could have gone further and increased it to \225 for a single person and to \450 for a married couple, as set out in my amendment. Compared to what the Minister did last year, his movement in this area is very limited this year. That was the reason for the initial annoyance of the Carers Association and other such bodies. They thought the Minister would move forward more fundamentally but he did not.

Amendment No. 23 deals with an issue raised with me every few months, particularly by widows and lone parents who look after a disabled relative on a full-time basis. The Minister has refused to allow them access to any part of the carer's allowance. Our colleagues in the United Kingdom, where a Labour government is in office, have——

Comment on this

It has given only a £2 increase to the old age pensioner.

Comment on this

Ireland is a wealthier country now. It has moved forward in certain areas. The Scottish Labour government, which is effectively what it is, has given free long-term care in every respect to all its seniors. It has made some amazing developments in that regard. The idea of holding some part of the carer's allowance, or whatever it will be called in the future, with another payment seems a reasonable proposition. For example, Mel Cousins's study, which is a little dated as it was carried out five years ago, indicated, as did a review, that a significant proportion of carers would have access to another allowance and, therefore, the net cost of what my amendment proposes may not be as great as might have been anticipated.

The Minister could have gone further and effectively abolished the means test or considered the possibility, as demanded by Mr. South, Mr. Eddie Collins and other representatives of carers, of giving full recognition to the work of carers once and for all and accepting the consequence of that, whatever it would mean in terms of the ultimate size of the social welfare budget. That is the most fundamental point I want to make.

I welcome the £100 increase in the respite care grant. I requested that the grant be increased to \1,270. The Labour Party has requested this for the past number of years. The Minister should consider developing a respite system rather than having an extended system of respite and community care. The Minister does not seem to have moved very far in those areas. Fine Gael suggested providing a particular amount of respite care during the year and we would be mindful to provide for something similar in addition to the respite care grant. While improvements have been made and it would be unfair to say they have not, on my findings the carers' advocates is the group most disappointed with the budget. They feel the Minister has let them down.

Comment on this

On the carer's allowance, I welcome and compliment the Minister on the improvements that have been made in recent years. The increase in the respite care grant is to be welcomed, although we have a long way to go before carers will be satisfied. Was the Deputy referring to his colleagues in the Labour Party or the Workers Party in Limerick or to the carers when he said the carers felt they had missed out?

Comment on this

I was referring to the carers.

Comment on this

The Labour Party has a few wings in Limerick. The carers came out openly on local radio——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

They made a presentation to the committee.

Comment on this

Deputy Wade was present on that occasion.

Comment on this

I invited them. The Deputy might not remember that. I do not talk as much as the rest of the members. A member of a political party, which has now merged with the Labour Party, is causing it great problems. He made matters very political in the run up to the last election. It was Seán Ryan, a councillor who has now pulled out of the race to be elected to Dáil Éireann in my constituency. He made the carer's allowance situation highly political and nearly toppled the late Jim Kemmy, whom Members cried about——

Comment on this

Was he a member of Democratic Left?

Comment on this

No, he had his own party. He was not a member of the Labour Party for long, only for a couple of years.

Comment on this

Almost everybody in the Labour Party was at some stage a leader of their own party. That is our tradition.

Comment on this

I had to deal with five leaders in east Limerick at one stage. There was Deputy Noonan, a leader in the background, Nora Bennis, Desmond O'Malley and Jim Kemmy who were party leaders while my colleague, Deputy O'Dea, wanted to be leader of the party down there. It was tough to survive it all.

Comment on this

Deputy Hayes mentioned people on social welfare getting 50% of the carer's allowance. Is there any development on that in the Department? That is the big issue among the carers we meet at local level. The people on social welfare getting——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Getting half the carer's allowance plus other social welfare benefits.

Comment on this

Listening to the Carers Association, one would never think that this was a big issue. I do not think the Carers Association represents the carers I meet or the bulk of carers. The issue has moved from the carer's allowance to the social welfare recipients. Has there been any development in that regard?

Comment on this

My officials say that if only 2,300 are benefiting from the increased payment, this would presuppose that all the others in the overall figure are in receipt of the maximum payment. Otherwise, they would have increased as a result of the budget change. We will double check those figures but it is probably logical that if 2,300, as per the figure given——

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Added on?

Comment on this

No, getting increases. If the existing carers get increases as a result of the change in the budget, the balance of the figure must be in receipt of the full payment. However, we will double check it. We do not have the figures to hand. I thank the Deputies, particularly Deputy Broughan, for at least acknowledging that there have been changes.

I am not trying to be political but if one looks at the changes since 1990, when the carer's allowance was introduced, the most dramatic took place in the past two or three years. We did not do a huge amount in my first year in office because we were waiting for the report. Following its publication, we did a massive amount in the following year and incrementally built upon that in successive years. People must accept that there is only so much the Department can do in this area. The issue of carers is primarily a matter for the Department of Health and Children in that it can provide many more supports. We only deal with income adequacy. The social welfare system was designed to pay a basic payment to people on low incomes; it was not designed to pay people for providing care.

This brings me to the point made by Deputy Hayes in relation to the difference between foster care and carer's allowance. Foster care is completely different. Most of the people cared for by people in receipt of carer's allowance would be known to the carer or there would be a relationship of some type whereas in foster care there would be no such relationship. To a certain extent, the children would come from dysfunctional families and there would be many other difficulties which would not apply to caring. The Deputy is not comparing like with like.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The work is not different. In many respect, the carers do more.

Comment on this

It would be different but it was never designed as a payment to repay people. It was always only a payment that would basically be a low income supplement. We have progressively extended it and, to a certain extent, we have done that because of pressure. I have given a commitment that over time we will increase it to average industrial earnings, which is, relatively, a sizeable income. I believe it will be the wish of every political party to reach that level.

The numbers involved have increased dramatically from 9,000 to 22,000. The cost of paying carer's allowance concurrently with another social welfare payment is not available due to data limitations but, based on the number of claims awarded or refused where the applicant received another social welfare payment, it is estimated that it would cost in the region of £36 million annually to pay it to this group alone. However, the full cost would be much higher.

I stand on my record. This Government has delivered substantial increases in the carer's allowance and there are substantial benefits accruing to the allowance. I am particularly proud of the respite grant which was initiated three years ago at an initial amount of £200. It is now £500. The carers are also in receipt of the free schemes. Something that was not publicised properly was the issue of people in receipt of domiciliary care being able to receive carer's allowance as well. There have been dramatic improvements.

While I accept a lobby group such as the Carers Association being unhappy, I received, particularly in the period immediately prior to the budget, numerous letters from ordinary people who took the time to write to me to thank me for the changes in the carer's allowance area and in the social welfare area generally. They are now seeing real benefits. They can take holidays and have a reasonable source of income. I agree with the chairman that many people appreciate what has been done.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Similarly, we regularly receive letters from people who are concerned and upset that they cannot get this payment even though they are carers. That is also a fact and I am sure the Minister receives letters in that regard too. The Minister said it was never designed as a payment to pay people. The Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children, Deputy Moffatt, has direct responsibility for carers.

Comment on this

For the elderly.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Yes, but this issue comes under his remit in respect of developing policy——

Comment on this

On the needs assessment issue.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

He takes a different view. He sees it as a first step towards payment for the work being done. On the basis of the Minister's argument about income adequacy, is it his view that this issue should not be his Department's responsibility but the responsibility of the Department of Health and Children?

Comment on this

It is interesting that the Comptroller and Auditor General drew attention to carer's allowance in his report this year. To what extent is the Minister constrained by his budget? His Department's budget is the largest, being practically 35% of the national budget. I used to be a member of the Committee of Public Accounts. If one reads between the lines, the Comptroller and Auditor General seems to be saying this is a payment which he wants watched carefully. The two issues he raises are full-time caring and medical needs. Is the Minister constrained in looking at fundamental reforms in this area because the allocation has grown? The allocation has grown impressively over the past decade. As a result the Comptroller and Auditor General wants it kept under careful review. For instance, he asked to what extent the medical report was reviewed and how is it full-time caring. He asked fundamental questions. If it were to evolve into a carer's payment, would the Minister agree that it would probably be logical to have it administered by the Department of Health and Children?

Comment on this

I have made my view clear. Deputy Broughan is somewhat correct in what he says about the issue of control of spending in this respect. To a large extent my Department would not have the capability of examining the minutiae of each individual case. The carer's allowance is more or less approved on the strength of the medical information provided. There is a referee system and reviews by medical referees, but by and large we do not have the wherewithal which, for example, the Department of Health and Children through the health boards would have, in terms of assessing the general situation of a carer and the person being cared for. There are issues in that regard. Given the fact that the payment has increased from zero to £132 million in just 12 years and there have been substantial increases, no doubt there are issues which must be looked at as we move forward. Obviously the accounting officer in the Department, that is, the Secretary General, will have to be aware of that in the context of what the Comptroller and Auditor General stated in his report.

On the broader issue of policy, my view is there is only so much a Department like mine can do. There is pressure from people such as the Deputies opposite and others on all sides of the House and outside the House who say it is not possible to live on the payment following the budget changes and that there are carers who are bereft of other income and who are in difficulty. I have expressed this view previously.

We have initiated discussions with the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, about all aspects of the carer's allowance, nursing home subvention and even home help. We want to see if there is a better model which can be provided to assist people to look after elderly people, particularly in the home, while at the same time recognising there comes a time when people cannot continue to care for somebody at home as they may need constant care and attention on, in effect, a hospitalised basis.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister state last night that he would not create a database? In contrast in the area of unemployment there is a basis for the estimate because we can state there are 154,000 signing on. We also know how many people are availing of the lone parent's allowance. Although this is straying into the health area, why is not possible for the local health board to become involved? If the health strategy evolves, the primary care area, which is one element of it, is one where it is well past time that we started moving towards multi-discipline local GP practices. If we had such practices, which would be different from local health centres, would it not be possible to know the numbers being cared for on a full-time basis, for example, in Howth? I cannot see why that information is not available. The NAMHI reports are brilliant in that we know exactly how many young people and adults have an intellectual disability. Once somebody is categorised, we know exactly what happens. It took a long time to get that information and it has been available for only a few years, but why is such information not available in this area? If we did know, at least we could be making policy.

The most irritating aspect of discussing this is the way some people - obviously the Minister of State, Deputy O'Dea, is one of them - state that there are 200,000 carers, the Carers Association state there are 100,000 and the Minister states there are 50,000 and we will be reaching 25,000 at the end of next year. It seems to me we should be able to establish the figure once and for all.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that we do need those figures. That is one of the reasons we pushed the CSO to try and verify the figures in order that my Department, the other Departments, outside groups and Members of the Oireachtas would at least have some understanding of the numbers involved. Whether a person is a full-time carer or not is an extremely subjective issue. A party may be caring for an elderly person, not necessarily giving a huge level of care but doing so on a full-time basis. That is one of the reasons for the carer's allowance review, which was really only an expenditure review. It was not a review which looked at all aspects, including other supports which are probably nearly as important, if not more important, to not only the carer but the person being cared for. The review, however, came up with the view that so much could be done in the area of carer's allowance but that we needed to look at the whole issue of needs assessment. Following a system for needs assessment being put in place, the issue of cost of continual care on a non-means tested basis could be put in place. In my view that is the direction in which we should be going.

This comes back to the point the Deputy made about the Comptroller and Auditor General, who is raising issues. When you start giving non-means tested payments based on extreme situations you need greater control mechanisms to be sure the money is going to the right people.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 20 involves the insertion of a new section. Amendments Nos. 22 and 34 are related and all three amendments may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 20:

In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of subsuming the carer's allowance into a new continual care payment to be paid to medically approved recipients without reference to individual or family means.".

We referred to these amendments earlier. The Minister mentioned the 1998 report which was very good. Members could follow up on the systems employed in other countries, particularly Germany, where the German Government has tried to get society to face up the reality that 40% of the population will require care when they are older and that arrangements should be made in this regard. The amendment seeks the extension of the carer's allowance to a continual care payment on the basis of a needs assessment provided for in legislation.

One of the ambitions of the various carers associations is to have caring inserted in the Constitution but when the Constitution review group examined this proposal, it framed its response to include parents of dependent children as well as family carers. The cost of the carer's allowance is the other element in the cost of disability allowance which we have sought continuously over the past number of years. Extra costs are incurred to cater for people with disabilities and these should be met by introducing a cost of caring allowance.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I tabled amendment No. 34. We also proposed in our pre-budget submission that a cost of care allowance should be introduced. I questioned the Minister about this yesterday and it is clear he supports such an allowance on a non-means tested basis. The issue is when it will be introduced. I acknowledge what the Minister said in regard to the reservations expressed by the Comptroller and Auditor General but progress is needed because those who do not receive any support under the carer's allowance scheme must be recognised. Massive costs are borne by those who care for a relative or friend.

We examined the care needs of the individual when drafting our proposal. There could be different payments depending on the needs of the individual concerned and, therefore, we proposed sums of £750, £1,000 and £2,000. These are considerable sums, particularly for non-means tested payments. Such a payment has been sought by many of the associations concerned and it is a logical extension to improve the carer's allowance and the introduction of carer's benefit. We need to make rapid progress on this issue and I encourage the Minister to examine it further.

Comment on this

As I have said previously, the recently published health strategy commits the Government to reforming the current arrangements, including the carer's allowance in order to introduce an integrated subvention scheme which maximises support for home care. The issue of the continual care payment will be examined in that context. The Department of Health and Children has already begun work on this with my Department, which will continue in the new year, and we hope to develop proposals in this area. The Minister for Health and Children and I have discussed this issue on numerous occasions, particularly in the recent past, to ascertain how it can be progressed. I accept the Deputies' points regarding a cost of continual care payment and such a payment needs to be brought forward.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 21:

In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passing of this Act prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of identifying key areas of disadvantage both urban and rural with proposals to give additional social insurance and social assistance supports to the population of those areas.".

I feel strongly about this issue which I also raised last year. A spatial dimension was introduced to welfare benefits when the island allowance was introduced. It was in that context that I sought to introduce a similar amendment last year. I referred to ex-offenders on Second Stage. A significant percentage of the prison population comes from certain deprived areas. The governor of Mountjoy Prison recently outlined the characteristics of the prison population and pointed out that 85% of prisoners never had a proper job.

Despite the establishment of partnership companies and the efforts of many local development groups, we still have not made an intensive enough effort to address disadvantaged areas over the past five years. I also want to explore through the amendment the possibility of providing support through the social welfare system to people who live in these areas. Spatial health and security statistics are not available and that is why the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform established the National Crime Council. One has a greater chance of dying at an early age in certain areas and an individual's life expectancy can vary by up to a decade depending on where he or she lives.

A Vincentian Partnership delegation appeared before the committee to discuss the problem and it highlighted the fact that people in disadvantaged areas may not vote regularly and may not bring their full weight to bear on the Oireachtas. My party and other parties of the left would win more seats if more people in these areas voted. I have always been unhappy with the performance of the Combat Poverty Agency and the national anti-poverty strategy in this regard. There has not been a spatial dimension to the strategy. One can live in a certain area of Dublin and one's quality of life will be poor but if one were to live a few streets away, one might as well be living on a different planet.

It is often said that the measure of the integration of a society is the extent of spatial inequality. Other capital cities such as Stockholm are safer by night and that is related to greater social integration. Ireland is a stratified society and successive Governments have failed to regenerate disadvantaged areas in which the Department has more customers. The Minister has not introduced a dynamic approach to the poverty agenda to remove such divisions in our society.

Comment on this

Rural poverty and urban disadvantage have always been key components of the NAPS and will continue to be so under the review. I do not accept the Deputy's statement that the Government has not made an effort in regard to examining poverty from a spatial perspective. We introduced the RAPID programme and quickly followed up with the CLÁR programme, even though we were not obliged to do so under the PPF. The Minister for the Environment and Local Government will soon bring forward proposals regarding provincial towns which will be included in a similar programme to RAPID. County and city development boards also have a strong social inclusion focus. Nine local authorities are about to pilot social inclusion units. A considerable amount is being done. We were criticised by some parties for dividing the country in two for the purposes of Objective One and Objective One in transition status. I thought that was the right way to proceed to maximise our advantage from an EU point of view.

Work is ongoing on a national basis and on targeting geographic areas. In addition, work has been done on the issues referred to during Question Time yesterday relating to the reintegration of former prisoners and efforts to allow them re-enter education or engage in training or work while retaining their social welfare benefits so that they are not disadvantaged as a result of having gone to prison.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

"4.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of relaxing the rule that a recipient of carer's allowance cannot claim another social welfare payment at the same time.".

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

"4.- he Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of introducing a new infancy payment to cover the considerable capital and other costs associated with the birth of a child.".

The Chairman advised me at the beginning of the meeting that, if one puts forward novel ideasin a particular year, the Minister frequently implements and claims credit for them the following year. I put forward this suggestion in the hope it might be put in place at the beginning of next year.

This is a proposal we made in our pre-budget submission whereby young couples with their first child would be paid what is known as an infancy payment or whatever one wants to call it to cover the considerable capital and other costs associated with the birth of a child. Research has shown it takes a considerable amount of money to bring a child into the world. These are not medical costs but the considerable costs involved in the early years, especially the first few months especially of a child's life. As a way of encouraging people to have children and ensuring an adequate source of funding for young parents, we should examine the introduction of an infancy payment, particularly for the first child. Recent research shows that somewhere between £2,000 and £4,000 is put aside by parents in the first year to deal with the costs associated with having a child. I speak with a degree of experience of this in recent months.

Comment on this

The Deputy should declare an interest.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I should declare an interest. If one reads the recent comments of the former Taoiseach, Dr. Garret FitzGerald, and one sees his projections relating to the number of children who will be born in future, we need to incentivise child birth and child rearing. One way to do that would be to provide funding for the first child, which would go directly towards the costs associated with that very difficult stage of the first few months after the child is born. I make the proposal on the basis that we will see it in next year's Social Welfare Bill.

Comment on this

I support this amendment. Due to demographic concerns, France introduced a direct payment for the first two children born in a family. The proposal has merit in the context of the costs associated with future generations of senior citizens. It is important to maintain the birth rate.

Comment on this

I have news for Deputy Hayes. I have already examined this matter. Two or three years ago we examined the possibility of introducing this payment. However, I decided to increase child benefit rather than going this route because, if a grant of £1,000, for example, is introduced for each birth and there are 52,000 births in a year——

Comment on this

The Deputy referred only to the first one.

Comment on this

There are 52,000 births a year.

Comment on this

Not all of them would be first time births.

Comment on this

I do not know what the proportion would be.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

The Minister is correct. If it were given to everyone, it would be very expensive.

Comment on this

I misunderstood what the Deputy said about the first child. The costs would be substantial and even £1,000 might not be sufficient to meet them. That is the reason we plumped for increasing child benefit massively because it gives a good stream of income to mothers especially.

It is an issue we keep under review and we examined it in the context of what other countries have done. Other European countries have introduced similar types of payments in this respect. There is an element of a birth grant in the system already in terms of multiple births, but obviously that only applies to a very small proportion of overall births.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

I would not see this as an income adequacy issue, rather as directly helping people who have decided to have their first child. The associated astonishing capital costs are growing and inflation in terms of the cost of child rearing is colossal.

Comment on this

The Deputy should have thought about it before he did anything.

Comment on this

It is all the pressure.

Comment on this
Brian Hayes Mr. B. Hayes Fine Gael

Perhaps I should have listened more closely in my biology lessons. As the Minister knows, this area is very difficult, especially where a woman returns to work some months after giving birth. This issue obviously will still be on the burner. Perhaps the Minister will examine it in the context of the first child. That would cut down costs considerably. If a grant were given for each of the 52,000 children born each year, the cost would be considerable. However, giving it for the first child would be a good way of incentivising couples.

Comment on this

The committee has discussed this on a number of occasions and believes the first child should receive the highest rate of child benefit and that people should receive less for other children.

Comment on this

The Combat Poverty Agency has said the opposite.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It is not the only agency which has said so.

Comment on this

A person who telephoned me the other day said he had five children and wanted to know why his two remaining dependent children are not regarded as the fourth and fifth children, which they are legally, rather than the first and second.

Comment on this

Is that the way it works?

Comment on this

Yes. It is the first child who qualifies.

Comment on this