Social Welfare (No. 2) Bill, 2001.
Contributions 357–534 of 534. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 60 of 2001 ›
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of rationalising the existing different rates of child dependent allowance as a means of assisting low income families.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 4, before section 4, to insert the following new section:
"4.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of extending the child dependent allowance to children up to 22 years of age who are in full-time education.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing fuel allowance to \13 and \20 respectively and extending the fuel allowance season for pensioners to 52 weeks.".
The Minister deserves some credit at long last for increasing the fuel allowance for the first time since the former Minister, Barry Desmond, was in office. Given the statistics for fuel poverty we discussed on Question Time the occasion before last, a strong case could be made for extending the fuel allowance season to the whole year for pensioners and having as a basic target an increase in the allowances to \13 and \20. The Minister said previously that it is also an issue for the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. We must move to a clean air situation as soon as possible but all senior citizens must have access to adequate heat. I commend the Minister for this measure.
In recent weeks, representatives of Bord na Móna have expressed their concern at the move by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government to force people to abandon traditional solid fuels and the negative impact this may have on the coal industry, which is now largely controlled by Bord na Móna. There is also concern about the impact of this move on the levels of heat enjoyed by people in non-clean air areas. This matter must be kept under close review, given that the allowance is so tiny.
Comment on this
I welcome the changes that have been made. The issue of fuel poverty is important. The Minister with responsibility at the Department of the Environment and Local Government, Deputy Dan Wallace, recently admitted that more than 50,000 local authority homes do not have central heating or, according to the Department, an inadequate source of heating. Dublin Corporation is at the top of the list on this issue. This may be because the Taoiseach is in the constituency.
Comment on this
He lives in the area. Income poverty is not the only sort of poverty. An elderly person can have a sufficient income but an appalling heating system. More than 50,000 homes do not have central heating and a considerable number of homes are not properly insulated. I welcome the small increases in the fuel allowance but we need to go further.
Comment on this
I thank Deputies for their remarks in relation to the increase. In the Dáil today I understand a Deputy asked who influenced me in this regard. Last year I came under considerable pressure from the Taoiseach to increase the fuel allowance and I finally decided to spend £25 million - the sum needed - to increase the old age pension by an extra £1 instead. I make no apology for deciding to give all old age pensioners an extra £1 for 52 weeks in the year as opposed to giving some an extra fuel allowance for only 29 weeks. There are issues in relation to the cut-off point and how money is allocated. The £7 allowance is not necessarily all spent on fuel.
We should extend the fuel allowance progressively to 52 weeks of the year so that it is eventually dovetailed into the main payment. I went as far as I could this year, within the budget available to me.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of doubling the back to school allowance.".
The Minister has made a small improvement in this allowance but there is still a significant issue. Every summer, my colleague, Deputy Shortall, calculates the cost of sending a teenage child back to school. This year she estimated the cost at between £600 and £700. The allowance, even with the welcome addition, is minuscule.
Comment on this
The change in relation to the disregard will benefit almost 8,000 children in almost 5,000 households. In addition to easing the means test, I have increased the payment rate. This will benefit 72,000 children in approximately 50,000 households.
A working group has been set up to review the back to school clothing and footwear allowance scheme. I hope that working group will report shortly. This will allow other proposals to be looked at in order to bring forward improvements in the scheme.
Comment on this
Is it possible to extend the application date? There is a three month timeframe for applications for the grant. Has the Minister examined the possibility of having a rolling application date for applications? Difficulty is often caused when applications are made late.
Comment on this
This issue was raised before. The allowance is paid through the health boards and there are time difficulties with the boards. There were difficulties in the earlier part of my Ministry and we tried to have the allowance paid earlier.
Comment on this
There are difficulties in that respect and I take the Deputy's point. I will look at the matter.
Comment on this
Many people are just missing the cut-off point for the allowance. The more attractive the allowance, the more people will——
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
"5.-The Minister shall, as soon as may be after the passing of this Act, prepare and lay before both Houses of the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing the earnings disregard for one-parent family payments.".
This is another aspect which the Minister has not increased during his time in Government. Last year he told me there were only a few hundred lone parents who would lose their benefit completely in such a situation. The limit of £12,500 is quite low. My amendment asks that an increase be considered.
Some studies this year showed that having employment is an important step for a person rearing a family on his or her own. The point was made very strongly in the One Long Struggle report. The cut in CE schemes had a very detrimental impact on lone parents. There appeared to be no logical explanation for much of what was being done by the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment but changes had a big impact on customers of the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs. Did the Minister not even consider raising the level in line with inflation?
Comment on this
My amendment is almost the same as Deputy Broughan's. The route out of poverty is through employment but we seem to have a different view of that argument when it is applied to lone parents. The weekly income limit has not been changed for some years. We should at least increase the limit in line with inflation. There are substantial poverty traps for lone parents who do not see an incentive to work even though they want to work and improve their skills. If we see employability as the way out of poverty, we should be able to extend it to all lone parents.
Comment on this
Between 300 and 400 lone parents per year exceed the limit and as one gets closer to the upper limit of £12,000, the figures are very small indeed. I looked at the issue but a number of changes will be made and proposals will be implemented in regard to payments to lone parents. There will be much more pro-active interaction with lone parents on a one-to-one basis to try to get them back to work. Reports in this area have shown that lone parents wish to get back into work and are doing so. Approximately 70% of lone parents in receipt of the one parent family payment are actually declaring income apart from the payment. There is a definite move to work on the part of lone parents. This is something we will keep under review.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 5, before section 5, to insert the following new section:
5.-A person whose income is below \400 per week shall not be liable to make contributions under the Health Contributions Act, 1979.".
Due to the short length of time available, I repeated an amendment from last year. As this could be an issue I would like the Minister's view on it.
Comment on this
The health contribution is paid in general by people earning more than £280 per week. People with medical cards do not have to pay. The contribution yield is £658 million per year and the money goes directly towards funding the health services. The amendment proposes an increase in the threshold of approximately £35 per week which would cost £29 million. This reduction would directly impact on the funds available to the health services. I find it difficult to believe that so soon after the publication of the health strategy and the criticisms from the other side of the House about the level of funds being provided that they are suggesting we should take almost £30 million directly out of health funding. As maintaining the health contribution at its current level is part of the overall budgetary arithmetic, it will not be possible to change it without resorting to compensating measures elsewhere. What are the compensating measures being suggested? Are we supposed to go back to borrowing, additional taxation or cuts in other expenditure?
The threshold ensures people on the lowest incomes do not have to pay contributions. Since coming to office, the Government has increased the threshold by 42%, from £197 to £280. This is ahead of the growth in earnings over the same period. The health contribution creates a problem with the step effect. Once a person goes over the threshold of £280 their weekly contribution goes from zero to £5.62. Increasing the threshold worsens the step effect. At the proposed threshold of £315, the drop in income would be £6.30. Ireland's aggregate income tax social contributions, including health contributions, are the lowest in the EU. Specifically for a single person on the average industrial wage the tax wage in Ireland is 28.8% compared to an EU average of 45%.
Comment on this
The point is that we are talking about low paid workers. There is some disappointment that in the overall budgetary context people on the minimum wage will still be caught for tax despite all the fine promises made by various Ministers. When people receive wage increases under the PPF they immediately jump into this relatively low threshold and suddenly find themselves paying health contributions. I know it is something the Minister did not look at last year, and it is unlikely he will do so. However, I want to put the case again and perhaps it could be considered in the negotiations for the next agreement.
Comment on this
The ESRI report shows pretty conclusively that the distributive impact of the budget for the lowest income sectors is way ahead of the richest.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 5, before section 6, to insert the following new section:
"6.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing the weekly income disregard for carer's allowance to £370 for a married couple and £185 for a single person.".
Comment on this
The subject of our motion last night which was voted down today was that the fundamental course of action of the Minister and his colleague, the Minister for Finance, in removing \635 million from the fund and putting it into the general Exchequer is unwarranted. Obviously it can be made legal. What are the implications of this action for the 1952 and 1998 legislation? It is easy to say the fund has been subsidised for years to the tune of £11 billion and that the Government is now entitled to take £500 million out of it. However, if one looks at it in relation to the benefits to which we referred and the fact that the fund has a specific purpose, this seems to be a course of action which the Government should not have embarked upon. It sets a very bad precedent for the future because others may feel they can easily raid the fund. It is unfortunate that a phoney debate was set up by the Minister for Finance between borrowing and not borrowing given the resources still available to him this year. I do not think the borrowing aspect should have come into the argument.
The Minister referred on a number of occasions last night to the comparison between the two funds. The 1% fund is a different type of fund in that it is taken straight out of the national revenue. We are talking about getting wide views from the parties in regard to supporting carers and having a national consensus on how we should move forward. It is unfortunate in regard to the other fund that there was no real debate. The issue came up during the summer and Deputy McDowell had a very short time to discuss it. Suddenly it became law. We could have a debate on paying the debt. It is a very important national decision to build up a savings fund of that nature.
Comment on this
We had a vote but it should have been a wider debate. As it now turns out it was kick started by robbing the poor Eircom shareholders who did not sell their shares within the first 24 hours of the flotation. It does not seem right to remove money from that fund. As Deputy McDowell said, a future Government may decide to put 0.75% into the fund. It is not of the same order as interfering with the social insurance fund because this is something which affects people individually. They paid the money individually. It is not just being taken from a sum of revenue and being put into another account This is a fund for the future.
I commend the Minister for Finance in general terms on thinking about the future and putting down a marker. As a nation we were like a household that had no savings of any kind. Down through the years this committee was trying to support some of the households. It was good to have a surplus in the account and to have national savings. However, the two funds are different. I believe we will be discussing the pensions fund after Christmas. The studies I have read seem to indicate that ourselves, the UK and the Netherlands get all the plaudits for pension provision because, in addition to the first tier, we have the most outstanding second tier in occupational pensions - only 30% of the private sector PRSAs get into action. Given that fact, perhaps the 1% was less urgent in this country than in a number of other countries such as Germany. The Minister talks about demographic projections but we are talking about a lengthy future, decades from now. It is good that we have some national savings but I regret the fact that the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, did not allow a few days' debate on the 1% fund at the time it was announced, because it was such a major decision.
Comment on this
I know we had a debate on the Bill, yes. Given the fact that we have a creaky and backward health system, and many bad schools - all the issues that people have been raising in the past couple of weeks - things remain to be done before we put aside so much money for posterity. It is a pity that we did not have such a debate, but this account is different. People talk about hypothetical taxes and one could argue that is exactly what this is. When the Attorney General was a Member of the House, both he and his party, the Progressive Democrats, were gung-ho to abolish the social insurance fund. I recall, one day, agreeing with the Minister, Deputy Woods, who strongly defended the fund. It is regrettable that the Minister, Deputy Dermot Ahern, has allowed the Minister for Finance to take this step. When he is resting in his chateau in north Kildare——
Comment on this
——Deputy McCreevy wants to be able to look back on his five years in office and say, "I delivered. I didn't borrow and I kept to my own straight-talking economic financial sense. I got through the period and that's it". He will probably say, "Look at the woeful Minister for Finance we have today", but he could have made different choices. I am not sure that we need a 12.5% corporation tax, for example, given that citizens pay 20%.
Comment on this
Thank you, a Chathaoirligh. I would make hard choices about some of these issues. Although it sometimes feels like I have been in the House for only a short time, this is the tenth budget I have debated. Essentially, the Finance Bill is about tax breaks for business and how to keep track of them. There are only a couple of pages on the bulk of the honchos, and the rest is for self-employed people and business. I did not accept it 20 years ago when Mr. Vincent Browne and various other journalists in that era, including Mr. Tansey, were wailing and moaning about the national debt and the country going to wrack and ruin. In 1987, small people bore the brunt of the costs associated with fixing up the country when they had not caused the trouble in the first place. The trouble was caused by people who would not pay their fair share of taxes. I have strong views on this matter. The Minister, Deputy McCreevy, was one of those voices who was ranting and raving in the early 1980s about balancing books, retrenchment and cutbacks. Yet, ordinary people suffered drastically in the 1987-90 period because they bore the brunt of the actions taken.
I do not accept that this workers' fund should be paying to eulogise or establish the reputation of the outgoing Minister for Finance. The Minister should have approached the matter in a different way; he did not need to do this.
Comment on this
This is the Achilles' heel of the Bill. The Minister has been hoisted by his own petard, primarily because specific commitments relating to this fund were given to the people by Fianna Fáil during the last election in regard to which the party has done a complete U-turn. The Minister may laugh all he likes, but he has been caught out on this issue. His party's manifesto contained exacting pledges and commitments to the people which the Minister, together with his colleague, the Minister for Finance, has chosen to ignore and ditch.
Yesterday, the Minister made some childish remarks about me. He was quite ageist in suggesting that young people have no role in politics, even though I do not feel all that young at the moment. The committee should recall the specific and exacting commitments that were given by Fianna Fáil in advance of the last general election. Only six points were made under the heading of reorganising and refocusing the social welfare system. This was not an exhaustive list of commitments, it was very specific. The first commitment made by Fianna Fáil in 1997 was to create a new board to supervise the financing and operation of the social insurance fund. Where stands that commitment? The second commitment stated: "This fund is the workers' guarantee that their benefits will be there for them when needed, without interference of means testing". It is quite clear that if one starts raiding £500 million from the fund, one is interfering and undermining the principle behind the "workers' guarantee", to use the Minister's own words. That is quite clearly the case.
The trade unions are up in arms about the third commitment which stated: "Board members will include representatives of employers, employees, self-employed people, retired people and other interested groups". What progress has been made on that commitment? The fourth commitment was a very sensible one: "An actuarial assessment of the fund and its future needs will be placed before Dáil Éireann, at least every three years". We are now slightly more than four and a half years into the life of this Dáil, so where is that particular commitment?
Those are four clear and specific commitments in the 1997 Fianna Fáil manifesto which have not been honoured. They have been completely ditched in the Bill now before us. Despite all his palaver, including the kind of personalised remarks he makes, the Minister has not dealt with the substantive point I made in the House last night.
I now wish to discuss the legislation itself. I agree wholeheartedly with Deputy Broughan's comments that section 7 is defective. If the Minister had told us exactly what he was using the money for, we could have argued about it, but we have had no such explanation. Instead, there has been a straightforward raid of half a billion pounds. Over the weekend, I read through the Official Report of the debate on the 1952 legislation, including the comments of the former Minister, Dr. Ryan - a relation of a distinguished Member of this House. It is clear from the record that this was a workers' fund, amalgamated in 1952 with the intention of paying out clear liabilities. I am aware of the fundamental distinction concerning the fund which, incidentally, makes up about 46% of the total expenditure of the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs. There is a current account and an investment account. The Minister is in charge of the current account and his colleague, the Minister for Finance, is in charge of the investment account. It is not a normal current account, however. I would argue that it is a liabilities account in that it is there for specific purposes. This is clear if one reads one of the amending pieces of legislation in the 1993 Act. Section 7(5) dealing with the social insurance fund, states
Moneys standing to the credit of the current account of the fund and not required to meet current expenditure, shall be transferred to the investment fund [controlled by the Minister for Finance].
So moneys standing at the end of the day in the current account can be given over for investment by the Minister for Finance. Therefore, it is not a typical current account where one simply decides one is going to take £10,000, £20,000 or £30,000 out and use it for another purpose. It is there for a specific purpose.
The Minister should read the 1952 legislation which provides a clear role for the Comptroller and Auditor General. Subsection (7) of the original Act, which was passed in 1952, clearly states that the accounts of the funds can be prepared in such a form, in such a manner and at such time as the Minister for Finance and the Comptroller and Auditor General may direct. Has the Minister sought approval from the Comptroller and Auditor General? What is the view of the Comptroller and Auditor General? We had a debate earlier in the context of other amendments where the Minister cited the reasons he could not extend payment. He said that in the view of the Comptroller and Auditor General we could not do it. In this episode of "Raiders of the Lost Ark", has the Minister sought the views of the Comptroller and Auditor General? The 1952 legislation sets out the role of the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Last year the Minister lectured the Labour Party about its proposals to take money from the pensioners' fund which is part of Government revenue.
Comment on this
His hypocrisy about the social insurance fund is unbelievable. He thinks he will get away with it, but the public will not buy it. The Minister might be right in that this is a "cute hoor" Fianna Fáil stunt which the public will not recognise. Fianna Fáil will say it has done the business and provided the money. However, it has serious implications for the future. We would not be doing our job as legislators if we did not highlight the gross abnormality in the legislative process. If one reads the 1952 legislation, the changes made in 1993 and the amendments made in 2000, there is a cast iron guarantee that the moneys in the fund must be used for specific purposes and not at the whim of the Minister for Finance at any given time. I want the Minister to address that issue. Why did he not explain why the section is included? There is an argument that he is showing us how the PRSI fund will be utilised. However, section 7 does not refer to that. This is a straightforward raid of the fund and that is why it is difficult for Opposition parties to concede on this issue.
Deputy Broughan said we do not know what the situation will be in the next 12 months. The Minister in his financial statement projected a surplus next year of £1.4 billion. No one knows the draw down on the fund in the next 12 months. The Minister mentioned the recent increases in unemployment assistance and unemployment benefit payments, as set out in the November unemployment statistics. He knows the difficulty we could face in six months if unemployment continues to rise. We have the problem that we cannot extend other benefits to workers who paid into the fund because the Minister for Finance has pulled a fast one on the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs and taken £0.5 billion out of it. There are serious implications for the Minister, his colleague and the Government. The public does not buy it. Last night the Minister asked me where we would get the £0.5 billion.
Comment on this
It could have been borrowed. The Governor of the Central Bank appeared recently before a committee of the House and he was questioned about a substantial reserve in the Central Bank which was used to prop up the Irish currency. The reserve fund will still exist after the currency changes in January. There is an argument that a partial sum, which was used to prop up the punt, will now be used to prop up the euro. When the pension reserve fund was established, my party's spokesperson at the time, Deputy Noonan, proposed flexibility on the issue of taking money out of the Exchequer in any given year if there was an economic downturn. We proposed that approximately 1.5% could be taken in good times which could be reduced to three quarters of 1% in bad times.
Comment on this
The Minister asked me a question yesterday evening and I am responding. We proposed an amendment which was voted down by the Minister for Finance. An achievement of the Government was the establishment of the national pension reserve fund. The House and the Government should take credit for it. It is a sensible policy to put money aside, particularly in bad times, to ensure we have funds to meet pension demands in the future. However, there should have been flexibility in the legislation to allow such a percentage reduction in difficult times. I have given the Minister two answers in response to his question yesterday.
What can we do? We are taking Committee Stage this evening and Report Stage on Friday. The Minister has negotiated a bad deal. When the Minister for Finance knocked on his door, he threw up his hands and told him he could take £0.5 billion from the fund. However, it is not the Minister's money. It is part of the contributions made by workers and their employers. It is bad legislation. People will look back on this as one of the most irresponsible acts of the Government and they will blame the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs because he has responsibility for the current account. I know the Minister's responsibilities because I read the legislation carefully. The Minister should go back to the Minister for Finance and ask him to come up with another mechanism.
Comment on this
I will not do so. I am proud of the fact that, as a result of the Government's management of the economy over the past five years, we have not only given large amounts of tax back to the people, but we have broken all records in that regard. We have allowed people to have a reasonable net income. Any taxpayer will tell the Deputy that for once in their lives they see a good benefit in their pay packets. People can see increased amounts of money in their pay cheques which they did not see before. We used to be one of the highest taxed countries in Europe. However, we are now the lowest and most of that change has happened in the past five years. Similarly, we have been able to preside over the best social welfare packages in the history of the State. I have been proud on five occasions to be able to say that I have been in receipt of the highest increases in the social welfare budget in the history of the State.
When I came into the House in 1987 the big issue for all sides of the House was the fact that the International Monetary Fund was going to close the country down from a financial point of view. We had a GDP ratio of approximately £133 million at that time. We had all types of figures about how much the national debt meant to every man, woman and child. We were close to bankruptcy during those years, mainly due to the economic management of my party led Government——
Comment on this
The national debt rose from £12 billion to £24 billion during the four years in the 1980s that the Deputy's party was in government.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy when he spoke. Not only have we given huge tax and social welfare packages, we have reduced the national debt from a GDP ratio of 133% to about 33% as a result of the budget. Today, in terms of the debt-GDP ratio in Europe, we are second only to Luxembourg, which has no debt. We are, in effect, the best. Apart from this, we have put £5.5 billion aside into a national pension reserve fund onto which we are adding another 1% or £800 million. Next year there will be £6.3 billion in the bank for pensions for the workers to whom the Deputy keeps referring. Also, 1997 was the first year in recent memory that the social insurance fund went into surplus. Even when we take out £500 million, there will be a £1 billion surplus next year which, all things being equal and continuing as we have been, will accumulate to about £2.5 billion in 2003 and £3.3 billion in 2004. The indications are that, as the demographics for the next ten to 15 years indicate, we will still have a high proportion of workers in the economy.
Comment on this
Unemployment may go up or down slightly, but we will have roughly the same cohort of workers.
I do not accept the Deputies' argument. No household would borrow money or use the flexible friend to which Deputy Hayes refers. Unless there was a strict regime for the pension reserve fund, no Government would put money aside. I have been in the House for over 15 years, in good times and bad, and every Government, regardless of circumstances, is under pressure to use whatever resources are available. In fact, the pressure is worse when times are good. I reject Deputy Hayes's flexible friend financial policy. He obviously had to ask Deputy Noonan what he should say about my specific challenges on how Fine Gael would pay for its proposals.
Comment on this
I reject that. There were no challenges. The Minister would not answer my questions last night.
Comment on this
The Deputy selectively quoted from our document. If any promise in it remains unfulfilled——
Comment on this
——I would not mind if it relates to the social insurance board. I guarantee that not one person in my constituency would raise that with me.
Comment on this
People will ask if we committed ourselves to reach a figure of over £100 in old age pensions and I will be able to say that we have gone further.
Comment on this
We have gone further by giving £116. I am able to defend my promises in the manifesto. As I said last night, I would love to have had a discussion with the Deputy on "Morning Ireland" about these issues where I could publicly challenge——
Comment on this
——the piffle from Deputies on the other side of the House. Can the two Deputies guarantee that no future Government in which they may serve - if they ever get the chance - will not take money out of the social insurance fund?
Comment on this
What was the exact mechanism whereby this happened? Is there any communication between the Department of Finance and the Minister's Department about it? Did the Minister or his staff, when they received the request of the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, think it was a joke? Did the Minister request that the Minister for Finance look elsewhere or that he leave the betting tax as it was? It is not just the social insurance fund, but also the Central Bank, which has a board with one or two distinguished members from our side of the city. However, it is expected to approve. At least, when the money from the capital redemption fund was nicked, the Minister concerned stated specifically what he would do with it.
I want to know what was the actual mechanism by which it happened. Did the Minister consult his senior staff who look after the fund? We had one good presentation from the Department, but are still expecting legislation and other developments promised by the Minister. Nothing has changed in five years. Did the Minister for Finance insist? Did the matter then go before the Cabinet where the Minister was coerced into granting the money?
This is a bad precedent for the national pension fund also as it makes it easier for a future Government to take money from it since the present Government did it in the case of the social insurance fund. In the past personal taxation was too high, such as when we paid 58p in the pound in tax and PRSI, which was an incredible amount to inflict on taxpayers, especially those in the PAYE system. However, we should look at the social insurance fund in a positive way rather than depressing it in the first few years it is in surplus. There are opportunities to spend the money as part of the social welfare budget as many of those on assistance were workers. How did it all happen and was there a showdown between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs?
Comment on this
I cannot understand how the Labour Party can begrudge the elderly and the less well off in society what they gain from the social insurance fund. If it was Fine Gael I might understand because it once took a penny off old age pensioners, but the Labour Party should be ashamed of itself. It thinks itself a socialist party.
Comment on this
It is the people's money and the Labour Party is afraid to see it go back to the people.
Comment on this
That is the point. We do not know where it went. What is it going towards? Will it go to Government jets for gallivanting around Europe?
Comment on this
Does the Labour Party begrudge it to the people who lost sweat and blood to build this country?
Comment on this
Can we get back to the issue? I asked the Minister a number of questions. Actually, he said he had not spoken to Deputy Noonan all day but that he had the answer for him the previous night but would not give it to him because he refused to answer the Minister on the benchmarking question. I thought the Minister's assessment of economic policy was interesting - all things being equal and going as they are. That is some template for the next 12 months. I have never heard a more incompetent assessment of where the economy is headed. The Minister has got this wrong and he has not answered my questions yet.
Has there been any discussion with the Comptroller and Auditor General? If the Minister for Finance was in charge of everything - current spending and investment - it might be all right. This is the responsibility of the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs. The current side of the social insurance fund is his responsibility. Has the Minister sought advice from the Comptroller and Auditor General given that in subsection (11) of the 1952 Act there are specific responsibilities for the Comptroller and Auditor General?
Comment on this
Section 7(11) is quite clear. It states "accounts of the fund shall be prepared in such form, in such a manner and at such times as a Minister for Finance may direct and the Comptroller and Auditor General shall examine."
Comment on this
It is not necessary to get advice or assistance from the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that but am asking a question which I want answered, given that the C&AG is mentioned in the original Act and again in the 1993 Act. Has the Minister sought his view on this issue?
Comment on this
Given this radical change in policy does the Minister not accept there is a role for the Comptroller and Auditor General?
Comment on this
That is astonishing given that the Minister has consistently argued that the Comptroller and Auditor General has responsibilities on other Votes within the remit of this committee. When will we see a new board to supervise this? This is central: it is not like, for example, Deputy Brady issuing a statement to The Meath Chronicle making a commitment on behalf of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
That is already in situ, as I said on Second Stage this morning. I remind Deputies that in the Social Welfare Act, 1998 I introduced a provision whereby actuarial reviews would be carried out every five years because the advice from the Department was that three years was too soon. The first review was due to be completed by the end of 2002. However, I brought this forward to this year and my Department has further engaged external consultants to conduct an actuarial review of the social insurance fund for the period 2001-06. This work is under way and will be completed shortly. That has indicated——
Comment on this
I would like to welcome Deputy M. Brennan to the House. He should come out of retirement because his party will lose his seat.
Comment on this
I have been here before and have listened to the Deputy and have watched him on the television. He has been waffling all evening.
Comment on this
That has indicated a year on year increase in the social insurance fund will be somewhere in the order of £3.3 billion. When I used the phrase "all things being equal" it was plain language for a no policy change proposal which is exactly how this is framed.
Comment on this
That is going forward by the seat of one's pants. How can the Minister make that kind of commitment?
Comment on this
I am not making a commitment but saying that they are the figures coming from the actuarial review.
Comment on this
I must also point out that Fianna Fáil slagged the Rainbow Government in 1997 but public spending now has been let go out of control. Under this Government spending leapt by one fifth, more than three times the rate of inflation. The Government has recklessly failed to meet even its own undemanding targets on containing expenditure, overshooting by £600 million of taxpayers' money. The projected deficit of close to \3 billion at the end of next year is breathtaking. The hypocrisy of Fianna Fáil on this issue is something to behold.
Comment on this
Does the Deputy recall that in those years the national debt was very high and the taxation burden on the unfortunate taxpayer was much higher than it is today? We have achieved a lot on those issues and have substantially reduced taxation over the last five years. We have given the highest social welfare budget increases in the history of the State, reduced the national debt by massive amounts, invested massive amounts into the pension piggy bank and still——
Comment on this
——even after taking £500 million, we have £1 billion remaining. What we are doing is——
Comment on this
On a point of information, in absolute terms the national debt was at its highest under the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy. It is because growth has been so massive that it has changed percentage wise.
Comment on this
That is like the argument and claptrap from some Deputies in the House. No later than this afternoon some Deputies were saying it is a disgrace that we have the lowest spend on social protection in the EU. They see the figure but do not take into account the fact that we have the youngest population in the EU, the most workers and the least number unemployed. All we are getting is claptrap from reports that have not taken those factors into account. Now the Deputy is doing the same. I am sick listening to Deputy Broughan going on with ideological catchphrases in relation to workers' this and that. Deputy Hayes said he thought it was my money or the Government's. It is not our money and we have said that bluntly. We are giving this money back to the people. In a way what we are doing is redistributive.
Comment on this
We are giving money back to the less well off. Shame on those who do not agree with that.
Comment on this
The Minister did not answer my question. What communications were there between the two Departments in order to arrive at a decision?
Comment on this
There was absolutely no disagreement between the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, and me. I admit, however, that during the years there would have been disagreements in relation to the level of social welfare payments. In relation to the budgetary negotiations, this year was the easiest because we were ad idem. I am a strong supporter of the idea that one does not go off and borrow if there is money in the bank. We do not do what parties opposite did - provide for minuscule social welfare payments when there is money in the bank. We do not go off and raid pensioners’ money when there is money in the bank. There was zilch correspondence, although the Minister for Finance and I are on the best of terms.
Comment on this
The Opposition asked how the figure of \635 million will be spent. Perhaps the Minister will answer that question. What will be the total social welfare package or spend this year?
Comment on this
How much of that money will come out of the social insurance fund and how much of it will come from the Exchequer?
Comment on this
The general increases will account for a proportion of 45% or less of the social insurance fund and 55%——
Comment on this
It will be going into the Exchequer, but equally one could say that the money will be going into the national pension reserve fund. There is a considerable amount of money coming this way.
Comment on this
I am very afraid that if there was a change of Government and the Opposition started to borrow money, it would double the national debt as happened some years ago. When Deputy Dick Spring was Tánaiste and former Deputy Garret FitzGerald was Taoiseach the national debt was doubled. I would not like to see the Opposition getting back into power and borrowing like that again.
Deputy Broughan referred to the Government jet. Every Government needs a jet. When Deputy John Bruton and Deputy Dick Spring were last in government there were two Government jets.
Comment on this
I did not get an answer to the question as to whether the Opposition parties would take money out of the social insurance fund. I thought they were going to give me a commitment that they would not.
Comment on this
The Select Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 5, before section 8, to insert the following new section:
"8.-Sections 20(6) and 224(7) of the Principal Act are hereby repealed.".
These provisions in the principal Act refer to allowing the giving of proof of various matters in court by the mere production of certificates. Proof should come from witnesses who can be cross-examined. While it is not directly related to the business we are conducting today, we could be leaving unconstitutional elements in the Bill as happened with the Employment Equality Act.
Comment on this
In any proceedings instituted under the Social Welfare Acts, where the collector general and an officer duly appointed by the Minister sign a certificate stating that an amount is due and payable in respect of employment or self-employment contributions by a defendant, these sections provide that the certificate shall be evidence that the amount is due unless the contrary is proved. These provisions have been in place in relation to employment contributions since the introduction of PRSI in 1979 and since 1988 with regard to self-employment contributions. Amendments were made last year to provide that such certificates can now be signed on behalf of the collector general by an officer of the Revenue Commissioners. This was requested by the Revenue Commissioners in order to be consistent with changes being made in the Finance Bill to allow an officer of the Revenue Commissioners certify the assessment and debt due in income tax.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report considering the implications of extending the range of benefits under the free travel scheme by:
(a) removing the peak hour ban for those attending hospital,
(b) promoting community access and travel initiatives,
(c) relaxing the accompanying rules for the elderly,
(d) promoting agreement between other EU states to allow free travel concessions overseas (Europass),
(e) preserve rights to free travel with private operators on franchised public routes, and
(f) utilise the taxi sector for elderly people living in rural areas.”.
I am looking for a report on extending the benefits under the free travel scheme, a matter we touched on yesterday at Question Time. Since 1997, 581 licences have been granted to private bus operators who cover very important routes throughout the country. However, only 40 have applied to the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs to be included in the free travel scheme with which the process of licensing private bus operators should be integrated. The buses belonging to an operator granted a licence should be made available to old age pensioners who may want to use the service.
There are other parts to the amendment, including the removal of the peak hour ban for those attending hospital. The Minister made some concessions in his Second Stage speech. He said he supports promoting community access and travel initiatives which he is trying to improve under the national development plan. I am, therefore, calling on him to relax the accompanying rules for the elderly to ensure somebody going to hospital can be accompanied free of charge. I also want him to extend the Europass, about which my colleague, Deputy Jim O'Keeffe, spoke when spokesperson on social welfare. We need to further our agreements with other European countries. In addition to my proposal on private bus operators, we should look at extending a voucher scheme to ensure elderly persons have access to taxis.
These are some of my ideas on extending the free travel scheme and I am interested in hearing the Minister's response.
Comment on this
As we debated this matter yesterday, I will not go over it again. Apart from Bus Átha Cliath, Bus Éireann and Iarnród Éireann, there are 80 private transport companies offering a service. There have been restrictions on free travel since its inception. These apply at peak times on city bus services in Dublin, Cork and Limerick. They do not apply to the mentally handicapped, to those attending long-term rehabilitation courses, to certain work experience programmes or to certain disabled or blind people. These people are issued with free travel pass which enables them travel during restricted hours. There are no peak-time travel restrictions on the DART, suburban railways or on services provided by private transport operators outside Dublin.
I spoke to the Deputy yesterday and before then about areas that are not covered by public transport. My Department cannot provide public transport, which comes under the remit of the Department of Public Enterprise, and I cannot force private operators to apply to the free scheme. It is entirely a matter for themselves. The difficulty in rural areas led the Government to establish an interdepartmental committee on rural transport led by the Department of Public Enterprise and it will report in the new year. The Minister for Public Enterprise, Deputy O'Rourke, introduced the rural transport initiative last July, for which £3.5 million is available, and 20 pilot projects are up and running or are about to come on stream. In the budget I have extended the companion travel pass to invalidity pensioners. Approximately 10% of people in receipt of invalidity pension are over the age of 65 so significant concessions have already been made in this area in recent years and the possibility of making further improvements will be kept under review.
Comment on this
I welcome the companion travel pass, which is a credit to the Minister. It is excellent that one can have such a pass. Deputy Brian Hayes raised the matter of taxis in rural areas. Many people in rural areas need to hire taxis to go to towns to collect pensions, go to mass on a Sunday, see the doctor and do their shopping. Some small provision of £5 or £10 per week for people in particularly rural areas would help them a lot.
Comment on this
The Minister said thatprivate operators cannot be compelled to participate in the scheme. If there is a tender for urban routes will a condition of winning be participation in the free travel scheme? There are two or tree private operators in our area and people who took out their travel passes on one were asked for £4, which did not make them very happy.
Comment on this
That is an issue for the Minister for Public Enterprise, Deputy O'Rourke. I would like to extend the free travel scheme to all operators.
Comment on this
Is it true that CIE is paid whether people with free travel passes use the service or not?
Comment on this
Where there is no public service available it would be wonderful if that money could be diverted to people for taxis. The north Meath community development association has established a bus service for remote areas, but it is very limited. It would be marvellous if it could be extended.
Comment on this
The rate of the CIE subvention is agreed in negotiations between it and the Minister's Department. How is this determined in the case of private bus operators? Is it based on vouchers or the number of passengers they put through their books?
Comment on this
There is a private operator in my constituency and from that I know that surveys and spot checks of such operators are conducted from which a figure is arrived at. The figure is subject to negotiation and there were some intense discussions in my constituency. Further information can be given to the Deputy later.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report considering the implications of progressively increasing the non-contributory old age pension so as to reduce the existing differential between it and the contributory pension.".
Fine Gael was happy with the increases in pensions this year, as set out in our pre-budget submission. I welcomed the increases when I spoke about the contributory pension. We made a specific commitment to reduce the gap between the contributory and non-contributory pensions and this amendment is a way for the Minister to commission a report to examine how that can be done. That would ensure that non-contributory pensioners are given a fairer pension. In the years ahead there will be fewer and fewer non-contributory pensioners because of the number of people who have been paying into the scheme. I suspect that the number now is small enough. I am interested in hearing the Minister's reply.
Comment on this
If I were not in the chair, I would declare myself against that. Is it not contrary to the fund you were talking about a few minutes ago?
Comment on this
I am not suggesting that the pensions should be equal. I am trying to understand why there is a £10 difference at the moment.
Comment on this
It is generally felt appropriate that there should be a differential between contributory and non-contributory pensions. That was confirmed by the commission on social welfare and by the national pensions policy initiative. If there was no differential there would be no point in paying contributions. People would qualify for the same money irrespective of their circumstances. A differential applies in almost all other social welfare payments and it has been suggested that it should be 10%.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report reviewing the application procedure for the social monitoring scheme.".
This is a straightforward amendment. This year someone suggested to me that we look at a longer application period for the alarm systems that are put in place. It is operated through the Minister's Department, it is a good scheme and we on this side of the House welcome it. It was mentioned to me throughout the year that the application time presents difficulties for some. If they do not apply before a certain time they lose out in the following year. I want the Minister to review the application procedure and the length of time allowed. It has been brought to his attention.
Comment on this
I am not aware of any difficulties and we are reasonably flexible in relation to applications. There is no cut-off date, though there might be an understanding that the application must be made by a certain month. If difficulties are being experienced by the Deputy they may relate to the paperwork involved. This is a scheme whereby substantial portions of taxpayers' money is paid out to various groups around the country and the issue of control is quite important. My officials have to be absolutely rigorous in our procedures. What is involved is not particularly onerous but it has worked well and every effort is made to get the money to the groups as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
Some of the smaller ones operate like that. If one makes an application to them they may say it will be next year before it can be dealt with.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of increasing maternity benefit for mothers on the basis of current yearly income as against the assessment of income two years prior to the birth of a child.".
This amendment relates to maternity benefit. I understand the payment of maternity benefit is made on the basis of the woman's salary from two years previous. I think that should be addressed. If one is a civil servant payments are made on the basis of current income but it does not apply in all cases. People make PRSI contributions in the current year so why is this distinction made when it comes to maternity benefit? People are paying the into the fund and expect something back from the year in question. I ask the Minister to look at this in terms of updating the income requirements for the year that the woman is actually going on maternity benefit.
Comment on this
The level of maternity benefit is set at 70% of the woman's earning in the relevant income tax year, subject to minimum and maximum weekly payments. For claims made during 2001 the relevant income tax year is April 1999-April 2000. The 2001 tax year will apply in respect of claims made in 2002. Unlike social welfare payments, maternity benefit is not taxable. In addition, if the employer does not pay any wages for the maternity leave period then the woman would generally be entitled to an income tax refund for that period. When these factors are taken together, the rate of maternity benefit in many instances equates to approximately 100% of the woman's net earnings, subject to an upper ceiling. Where the woman is entitled to be paid by her employer during maternity leave then the combination of maternity benefit and reduced wages will generally bring her weekly income to the level of her pre-maternity leave net earnings.
If social insurance payments were to be made fully earnings related it would involve a substantial increase in expenditure. This, in turn, would require a significant increase in the current levels of PRSI. The level of social insurance contributions paid in EU countries where the benefits provided are earnings related - France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands - range from 10% to 43% in the case of employees and 20% to 45% in the case of employers. The equivalent social insurance contribution in this country is 4% for employees and 10.75% for employers. The current system uses the most recent earnings which have been verified by the Revenue Commissioners. For instance, while the tax year has in the past ended on 5 April, employers had until the end of May to submit their P35s, that is details of the earnings, tax and PRSI paid by, or on behalf of, employees in the income tax year. Following completion of the necessary checks on this data, the PRSI and relevant earning details are transferred to my Department with the bulk of it being received by October. These details are then checked further and are used for the beginning of the calendar year in January. While the beginning of the income tax year will change from 6 April to 1 January at the beginning of 2002, the relevant income tax year for maternity benefit claims will remain unaffected by this change.
The alternative to this arrangement is to take current earnings into account. A number of difficulties would arise in this case. Which reference period should be used? For instance, claims for maternity benefit must be submitted at least six weeks before leave commences. A woman's earnings in the period immediately before the commencement of maternity leave may either under or over represent her normal earnings. A significant number of women are in receipt of disability benefit in the period immediately before taking maternity leave and may have no earnings from employment in this period. Under the current system, the rate of maternity benefit payable is calculated automatically. If recent earnings were to be used then they would have to be entered in the case of some 30,000 claims annually. This would lead to delays in processing claims. If current earnings were used, the employer would have to certify the earnings detail in all cases. Investigations would have to take place where discrepancies occurred between the earnings detail supplied by employers and those held by the Department. That would lead to further delays in processing claims. Incomplete or incorrect earnings details supplied by the employer could lead to over payments and under payments.
In the circumstances, the operation of the current system is considered to be more appropriate.
Comment on this
Reading between the lines the Minister is saying there could be cases where women would lose out under what I am proposing. That is because six weeks before they take maternity leave they might not be earning an income. There are potential downsides to it. Why can they not have a choice? They could choose to work with the current system or under what I am proposing. A number of women have raised this with me and feel it is unfair that their maternity benefit being determined on the basis of a previous year's PRSI contributions.
Comment on this
We can examine it. Perhaps it is an issue that can be teased out by the committee. I can see the arguments that are being made for it. Quite apart from the issue of disability benefit, it is an administrative nightmare and one which would cause long delays.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report on the implications of having an hourly rate of pay for the Students Summer Job Scheme commensurate to the rate of pay for the national minimum wage.".
This is an old chestnut. The Minister did make some improvements to the students summer job scheme this year. Yet, as he told Deputy Broughan yesterday, it is quite ridiculous that four months after the end of the scheme some people are only getting paid now. If the Department was told there would be a financial penalty if they did not make these payments more quickly, then I think they would make them more quickly.
I ask the Minister to consider this amendment in advance of putting next year's student summer job scheme in place. At the very least there would be a simple rate, namely, the national minimum wage. It is wrong that the current hourly rate under the scheme should be less than the national minimum wage. We have asked all employers to implement the minimum wage, yet this scheme operated by the Department, which is very good, does not abide by the legislation we passed. This is a glaring anomaly. The Minister argues that it is not employment under the terms of the legislation. For the small amount of money given to the students involved, I think the national minimum wage should be the benchmark.
Comment on this
My opinion on this scheme has not changed. It is not covered by the legislation and we have legal advice supporting that. There was a time when work would not have been available for students during the summer, but there is now work available for many students. If there was no differential students would not take up those jobs. Employers are screaming out for summer staff and often cannot get them. The scheme has had its day. I accept it is still useful for communities, especially in the west, for community work throughout the summer. However, the scheme was established at a different time when there were difficulties in the labour market. That is not the case now and we must make decisions on schemes based on changing circumstances. They have changed in respect of this scheme.
Comment on this
It is bad practice to have a scheme which pays people an hourly rate less than the national minimum wage. Does the Minister have figures for the uptake this year? Someone told me it had increased, which would disprove the point made by the Minister. If more people have applied for the scheme this year, it means more community groups are using students during the summer.
Comment on this
I am told the figures for last year were 6,000 and there is an estimate of 4,500 for this year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 5, before section 9, to insert the following new section:
"9.-The Minister shall as soon as may be after the passage of this Act prepare and lay before the Oireachtas a report reviewing the social welfare provisions available to those who are seeking asylum and the need to increase direct provision for this group of people to £20 per week for adults and £10 per week for children.".
I was disappointed by the Minister's response to the financial statement in that he did not move to increase the provisions given to asylum seekers. My amendment seeks £20 per week and £10 per week for adults and children respectively. I know a group within his Department has examined this. Repeated questions from me and others have elicited the response that it will come to a conclusion soon. It is time we made a decision. We should bite the bullet on this issue and increase this very small payment to asylum seekers. The Minister is aware these people are in a difficult position. I am aware they receive child benefit and are entitled to supplementary assistance. That said, we need to increase the provision given to these people. I know this is not an election winner, but in the context of what took place last weekend in the Wexford and Waterford areas and our overall treatment of refugees, we need to increase the payment under this scheme.
Comment on this
I support the amendment in general terms. The Irish Refugee Council, one of the groups which made pre-budget submissions, sought a direct provision of £35 per week. The asylum and immigration system is a mess, and I heard this morning that the work permits Bill has not been brought forward. Obviously the Minister, Deputy O'Donoghue, knows the system is a mess because he is mostly responsible for it being so.
I would like to see asylum seekers working while they wait for the final determination of their applications. I know such determinations can sometimes be difficult to make. However, a country such as Nigeria is not far away in communications terms and it should be possible to expedite the process and give people encouragement. One factor in stirring up racism is where indigenous people who are struggling perceive others as receiving a great deal while not contributing anything to the community. We need a policy in this regard and the Government has not come forward with one. For us the right to work is a key point. People should be able to work.
On the other side of this development in the economy in recent years, civil servants told members of the Committee on Enterprise and Small Business that the number of agencies which brought people into the country to work had mushroomed from a handful to 500 or 600. It is extraordinary the Government has not implemented legislation in this regard. This also relates to the discussion on the previous amendment in that it was suggested that up to 35% of jobs in the tourism industry are filled by immigrants.
We need a coherent policy for those who wish to come here to work, and allowing asylum seekers work may be the key reform which is necessary. Determination of their status should not take months or years but, in the meantime, there should be a facility for them to earn a living. This would be an important right to give people.
Comment on this
I will not go into details but I do not accept there is no policy. The Government has a definite policy. We granted an amnesty to certain people who had sought asylum by granting them leave to work after a certain period. That is the one and only time we did so and we were correct in doing so. There is a fine balance in this and it can be seen in the speed with which a worldwide economic slowdown has occurred, as evidenced by the unemployment figures in this country. If we were to allow an open door policy and let all asylum seekers work while a decision was being made on their applications, in effect, the decision would be irrelevant because by the time it would be made the applicants would be integrated into society, even though they would not necessarily have rightly qualified for asylum.
From that point of view, the policy the Government has implemented has proved to be correct in that it is balanced. On the one hand, it lives up to our obligations under EU conventions, which cost the taxpayer a substantial amount of money - an estimated £100 million a year. I could have done with that money in my Department and so could other Ministers in their Departments. On the other hand, the policy tries to remains in tune with a Europe-wide policy. We cannot break with the policy of other European countries, which is to have a system of vetting asylum applications and allowing applicants stay if they are genuine.
There is a working group on the issue the amendment raises and it is due to finalise its work soon. Obviously we will have to examine the issue then.