Pensions (Amendment) Bill, 2001 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–226 of 458. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 45 of 2001 ›
I welcome the Minister and his officials. Shall we agree the programme for the day or leave it for the moment?
Comment on this
On an issue of procedure, will the proceedings of Committee Stage be published on the website or will they be available tomorrow and, if so, at what time? If the Bill is going into Report Stage next week, which we hope it will, there must be an opportunity for Members to see the transcript of Committee Stage before drafting further amendments.
Comment on this
That is important. People who live a couple of hundred miles from here find it difficult to be here at certain times.
Comment on this
We are not talking about having another meeting tomorrow but about today's proceedings being up on the website tomorrow. The Deputy is safe.
Comment on this
I am sorry. It is usually the Dublin TDs who only live out the road who dictate what happens.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 1 is in the name of Deputy Broughan. Amendments Nos. 9, 12, 13, 22, 27, 28, 30, 31 and 93 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 13, to delete lines 38 to 40.
The common thread in all these amendments is to make a requirement on PRSA providers, with regard to contributors, that there would be a duty on them in terms of the performance of investment product which would be based on equities. That was a consistent criticism of the Bill in the debates both in the Seanad and the Dáil. We had a minimal amount of time to debate the legislation in the Dáil - I am not sure if the Chairman got an opportunity to speak on it - and, with perhaps five or six days left in the lifetime of this Dáil, it is irritating that such a significant Bill is being taken in committee effectively under a guillotine. That is not to discredit the staff in the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs who have done a fine job in bringing forward the legislation and amending it at different stages in response to contributions and submissions received.
Regardless of who among us survives to the next Dáil, we must have a basic determination to ensure that significant issues are dealt with as early as possible by the next Government to give Deputies, and the people we represent, sufficient time to discuss matters. I was still receiving suggested amendments to this legislation up to yesterday, which was too late, so I merely want to repeat that point which I also made at the start of Second Stage. I realise the debate on Second Stage more or less collapsed, but that was because it was lunch time on a Friday and Deputy Wade and other Deputies from around the country did not have an opportunity to make a contribution on the Bill. If the debate had been held in the Dáil over a number of weeks, there would have been tremendous interest in it.
Arising from the debate in the Seanad, my own contribution and some submissions I received was the view that there should be a requirement on PRSA providers to give the fullest information about the location and distribution of equities and their performance and that there would be some sort of accountability in regard to long-term savings investment for pensions. We discussed that in relation to the new stakeholder pension scheme in the United Kingdom, which commenced about six months ago, in that while the availability of this new product is meritorious and hopefully we will make a move towards ensuring that a much more significant proportion of the population has an occupational pension, particularly in the private sector where it has been an ongoing problem, we need to provide for some sort of accountability which is lacking in the Bill. Perhaps the Minister and our civil servants are of the view that giving any kind of financial accountability in terms of these investment products is going too far but we are setting out on a whole new path and we cannot be sure that when the performance of personal retirement savings accounts is being reviewed in five or ten years' time, we will not regret the fact that the particular product did not perform in line with people's expectations.
I note the Chairman has grouped all these amendments together so I presume the Minister does not intend to accept them. My amendment seeks to delete the words that ". . . neither the Board nor the Revenue Commissioners shall . . . have any duty to any contributor regarding the investment performance of a PRSA product". I disagree with that and Senator Ross, in the debate on the Bill in the Seanad, argued for some requirement of accountability and said that in relation to investment performance, that accountability should lie with the Pensions Board.
Amendment No. 9 deals with the reporting obligation of PRSA providers. Paragraph (b) of section 99(1) of the principal Act states:
a return relating to the contributors to its PRSA products which shall include such personal information in relation to each such contributor as the Board may require for the purpose of meeting its obligations under the section 117(1) relating to recording and maintaining statistics of contributors.
I have sought to add on "(c) a detailed report evaluating the performance of all investment portfolios held as part of a PRSA product, including the identification of equities held in respect of each period.”.
Given the volatile performance of stock markets in relation to products linked to equities, the general belief is that there is not sufficient accountability on the part of fund managers. When any of us receives a report on savings which are linked to the stock market, we generally get a blasé account of the performance of the particular product but we do not often know, until it is too late, that the investment was in a particular company over which there were serious question marks and that the share price eventually collapsed with the value of the holding becoming very small. I am sure Deputies have had the experience, as I have had, of a constituent presenting them with an annual or six monthly report on an endowment type policy, perhaps a life policy, and complaining that the promises made to them by the provider of the policy or the broker have not been honoured. We would inform them about the bid price and the other basic details of the linkage on the policy and they realise that they have been involved for a number of years with a stock market that initially performed successfully but which, in the past year or year and a half, has had a rocky ride in terms of such investments.
My amendment No. 9 seeks a detailed report on the performance of all investment portfolios. Amendment No. 12 relates to the Minister's regulations on investment of PRSAs. Section 103(2) of the principal Act provides that the Minister may specify requirements to be complied with in relation to the investment of PRSA assets and such regulations which have a number of conditions. It states that such a strategy will adopt an investment profile consistent with fulfilling the reasonable expectations of a typical contributor respecting the said PRSA product for the purposes of making savings for retirement. Amendment No. 12 provides for the insertion of subsection (b) after section 103(2)(a) of the principal Act, as follows “subject to the provision referred to in paragraph (c), a requirement that such a strategy adopt an investment profile consistent with equalling the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, property and other investment products”.
This amendment, as do others in the grouping, seeks to insert a benchmarking system whereby contributors to PRSAs could measure the likely returns on their pension investments by reference to the best known market indices, the FTSE, the ISEQ and the NASDAQ, and also take account of changes in relation to property and other investment products. We have talked about the Minister's desire to develop the concept of the three legged stool of pensions - which I first read about in some of the World Bank reports - including contributory and non-contributory State pensions systems, the occupational system under the PRSAs, and personal pension plans and personal investments, which would yield a good pension income. A benchmarking system should be in place to measure the market performance of PRSAs by reference to the best known market indices.
This concept also runs through the other amendments in my name in this grouping. Amendment No. 13, proposes the insertion of paragraph (g) after paragraph (f) of section 103(3) of the principal Act which states “unit or share prices that are determined with regard for equity between different generations of unitholders or shareholders.” Amendment No. 13 proposes the insertion of paragraph (g) which states “a requirement that investments consistently equal the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities.”.” I have pursued a similar approach in the other amendments I tabled to Part 2 which deals with the introductions of PRSAs.
Amendment No. 22 relates to section 111 of the principal Act which deals with the preliminary disclosure certificate. Section 111(2) of the principal Act states that a preliminary disclosure certificate shall specify the benefits and the level of them which the person referred to in subsection (1) could reasonably - that is, the PRSA contributor - expect to receive from the PRSA concerned on the expiration of a period specified in the regulations made by the Minister for the purposes of this section and calculated in accordance with those regulations on the basis of projected contributions to be made during the same period and otherwise on the basis of assumptions specified in the regulations. Amendment No. 22 proposes in page 29, line 9, after the word "regulations" to insert the words "and shall include a reference to measurement of growth in value of investments based on the best known market indices".
The same theme runs through amendment No. 27 which relates to section 114 of the principal Act which deals with general disclosure obligations. The amendment proposes in page 31, line 35, after the word "invested" to insert the words "and the report shall make reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, property and other investment products". This amendment also seeks to put in place a benchmarking system.
Amendment No. 28 relates to section 116 of the principal Act which deals with the statement of reasonable projection. The amendment states "In page 32, between lines 26 and 27, to insert the following: "(2) A Statement of Reasonable Projection shall measure the current and future value of PRSA products by reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in the value of equities, property and other investment products."." In this amendment I seek to include a benchmarking guideline.
Amendment No. 30 relates to Section 117 of the principal Act which deals with the functions of the board in relation to PRSAs. The amendment states "In page 33, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following: "(3) The Board shall, from time to time, conduct and publish reviews of the performance of investment fund managers for PRSA products by reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in the value of equities and other investment products.". This amendment requires the board to examine the best performing fund managers and make that information available to possible contributors to PRSAs. Given the experience of some investment products in the past, that would seem to be a reasonable requirement. It requests the board to review the performance of investment fund managers. The point was made on Second Stage that those management teams are often among the best paid professionals in the financial services sector. It is remarkable that we would embark on the introduction of PRSAs without some benchmark in place on how their performance might be measured in relation to PRSA products. When replying to this and my other amendments to section 3, the Minister might say that in addition to the Pensions Board a financial services regulator will be in office at some stage which would also have an impact on this area, but there is still a need to have in place a measurement methodology in regard to this area.
Amendment No. 93 relates to section 42, which amends section 59 of the principal Act which deals with the general duties of trustees of existing occupational schemes. It is part of the amendments to Part VI of the principal Act. There are a number of valuable general duties laid down. Amendment No. 93 inserts paragraph (iii) after the provision that the trustees shall determine in accordance with the rules how those resources are to be invested in cases where the members give no direction. It states:
(iii) determine in accordance with the rules how those resources are invested with reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, other investment products, property and gross domestic product;".
That formula should probably have been included in the other amendments as well. The group of amendments seeks to introduce a further level of accountability for the providers of PRSAs and the investments made by trustees of existing schemes.
In relation to existing schemes, we received many submissions in the few weeks before Second Stage about the past poor performance of investments under existing occupational schemes. I am taking the opportunity in this Bill to insert into the PRSAs a series of benchmarks whereby contributors can have a reasonable idea of what value their PRSA might have after 20, 30 or more years.
Comment on this
I have a question about section 1 which provides that the Act will come into operation on the date the Minister may appoint by order. The Minister will accept that a considerable number of regulations will have to be published once this Bill is passed. What length of time will it take to publish the regulations involved?
I have received representations from people in the industry about how long it will take to get the new PRSA regime up and running. Once the legislation is passed by the Oireachtas and the regulations are published, they will go to the society of actuaries for its guidance notes. It is estimated, after the introduction of administrative and IT changes, that the PRSA provider companies will take an amount of time to read through these regulations to see how they work before they dip their toes into the market, as it were. Has the Minister any views on how long it will take to produce the regulations of which there are a considerable number?
Comment on this
The Department and the Pensions Board are already working on the regulations that flow from this legislation. It is anticipated that the Pensions Board will, in effect, be open for business in September to take applications for PRSAs.
Comment on this
There will be a lead-in time so providers can examine the regulations being proposed. Amendment No. 31 assigns a new function to the board. The new functions of the board, which are consequent on the introduction of these new products, are clearly outlined but I believe it would be useful to add another function. The board is an expert body which has proved its mettle and worth since it was established some years ago. The function I propose to add is that it acts as an assessor of PRSA products.
At present, if somebody is selling a product of any description, be it life insurance, savings bonds, etc., the company is the agent and it outlines its own performance. It would be useful if the board had the function of issuing a statement of opinion as to which providers are doing well by comparison with others. Obviously, this would take a number of years to implement because the legislation is only now being introduced and it will take time to assess who is and is not doing well. However, I agree with Deputy Broughan that some form of independent assessment of the performance of products is needed. It is not good enough to leave it to the companies or their agents to sell the product.
We regularly see providers, who are trying to sell their products, compare their performance with four or five other competitors in the sector. Frequently, however, those comparisons are unreal. There is a need for independent assessment of performance and this would be a useful function to add to the new functions the Minister proposes to assign to the Pensions Board. In this day and age we should not rely entirely on evidence from the industry. There should be an independent assessment and the Pensions Board is the right independent assessor to carry out that task. Amendment No. 31 and the other amendments put down by Deputy Broughan are useful in respect of providing a benchmark as to how products are performing in the market.
Comment on this
I thank the Deputies for their forbearance in bringing this legislation forward. I appreciate the Bill is being rushed but time is short. The Bill has been in gestation for some time. It is probably the most complex Bill to have come before the Oireachtas and, indeed, any Department in recent years. I am not making excuses but, in the context of the priority given to legislation going through both the parliamentary draftsman's office and the Oireachtas, other Bills have taken precedence, such as Bills in relation to emergency powers vis-à-vis Northern Ireland and following 11 September. They interfered with the timetable for this legislation which, unfortunately, means we are dealing with a complex Bill in a relatively short time.
On the other hand, there are a number of net issues in the Bill which can be encapsulated into five or six topics. That was the case in the Seanad and, as a result, a clearer Bill was brought before the Dáil. This is an agreed Bill and the vast majority of the people involved in this area, from one perspective or another, are supportive of its being passed quickly. It is the result of a partnership process under the national pensions policy initiative. Due to the fact that we were having difficulty getting the Bill published because of a huge workload in the office of the parliamentary draftsman, we published parts of the Bill. I made it clear to the interested parties that we were more than willing to accept amendments and suggestions. There was a sizeable number of submissions and we took many of them on board. That is another reason the flow of the Bill through the Oireachtas was somewhat less than satisfactory. I thank the Members of both Houses for their forbearance.
Under the PRSA framework set out in the Bill, issues in relation to the investment of the PRSA assets are a matter for the PRSA provider. The provider will be required to have a default investment strategy for each of the PRSA products which will be linked to good practice for investment for retirement. The provider will be required to be certified by a PRSA actuary as regards compliance with statutory requirements in relation to the PRSA products. The purpose of the default investment strategy is to take account of the fact that many people, whom we hope will take up PRSAs, will know little or nothing about investments and do not wish to. They want to be happy that they have a relatively harm free investment that they can take out in an off the shelf manner.
There are, however, no guarantees with investments. That is a well-trodden path. This is the purpose of the various disclosure requirements whereby the PRSA provider has to give the contributor regular updates of his or her pension investment mainly through the statements of reasonable projection and the actual value of the investment at a particular time. The PRSA framework clearly puts the duty of care in this regard on the PRSA, provider which is the correct approach. It would be neither possible nor appropriate for the Pensions Board or the Revenue Commissioners to underwrite or guarantee the PRSA investment in some way. That is made clear in section 92(2)(b) which Deputy Broughan wishes to delete. There is a theme running through this group of amendments that the Pensions Board should become more active in the area of monitoring investment performance in PRSAs. There is also a reference later to pension schemes generally. I agree this is an area that merits further detailed examination and it is an issue that is on the policy agenda of the Pensions Board for this year. The board is looking at this aspect. This is also an issue that is being examined at EU level in the context of the draft directive on the activities of institutions for occupational retirement pensions. In fact, there is a meeting today of the working group examining this directive, at which my officials and the officials of the Pensions Board are attending. Future policy will be very much influenced by developments on this directive which we must await.
If it transpires that it is not possible to make progress at EU level we will have to look at the issue nationally. I will undertake to have this matter discussed by my Department with the board in due course. It will be important that future arrangements build on the fact that the pension fund investment is the responsibility of the trustees in the case of occupational pension schemes and of the PRSA provider in the context of PRSAs, and that this principle is not undermined.
Going forward, I would like to see more transparency in this area through, for example, the introduction of investment principles related, for instance, to the level of risk, portfolio diversification and charging structures. This could be formalised through investment mandates or contracts between the trustees and the pension managers. In this way all involved would be clearer about the position.
I consider that the Deputies have raised valid issues but I have outlined the more appropriate way to address them. Therefore, I must oppose the amendments.
Comment on this
While the Minister has made some good points, with regard to the last few, why could we not have that kind of formula somewhere in Part 2? Could we not have inserted a section laying down principles of investment and proposing a general outline of an investment mandate, and how the contract might be managed? I know the Minister is anxious to get the product up and running and it is good to see that after such a long gestation they will be available in early autumn. However, the fundamental point still remains; the experience Deputies have had over the years with constituents and others concerning the management of certain occupational pension schemes indicates that there is still grave disquiet in this area. People need some sort of mechanism whereby the development of their investment product could be measured over the years. Going back to my first amendment, and before we set out on this interesting new path of occupational pensions, clear rules of accountability for investment should be required of the board under this Bill. Given the history of this matter and the fact that there is widespread disquiet about how some schemes have been managed in the past, there is a possibility that some PRSA providers will develop products that, over time, will not deliver what contributors need.
Comment on this
While the office will be up and running in early autumn and the Pensions Board will accept applications then, it will presumably take a considerably longer period before applications are received. Employers will have to make quite an amount of administrative and IT changes to payrolls in order for the system to PRSA providers to be operational. Therefore, while applications will be received in early autumn there is no guarantee that the product will be available by the end of this year.
The Minister is right in saying that it is not the function of the Pensions Board to give a guarantee about any investment portfolio. I fully accept that but that power should be there if the Pensions Board requests an opinion. We will not review this legislation again for some years. The legislation aimed at introducing the Pensions Board was enacted in 1990. This is the first time we have examined the original Act, apart from one amendment in 1996. It would be useful to give this power to the Pensions Board, although whether it chooses to enforce it is a matter for the board. If an opinion is to be issued some time in the future, who better to do so than the Pensions Board? While I accept that my amendment gives a direct legal force in saying it "shall", it would be useful to have the provision in place if the board chooses to enforce it. I accept the Minister's statement that there cannot be any guarantees in this regard but given the new regulatory role of the Pensions Board in vetting applications, it would make sense to grant it this new power because we are unlikely to review the legislation for at least four or five years.
Comment on this
I thank Deputies for their comments. The Bill is just about PRSAs, and investment is a much broader issue. The Pensions Board is examining this matter generally at a policy level in conjunction with my Department as a result of what has been said during the debate on this Bill. That process will be accelerated by the fact that both Senators and Deputies have now raised this matter. It would be premature, however, to insert anything specifically about PRSAs. We should await developments in that respect but, as I indicated in my original reply, I am not averse to this matter being examined. We are of the view that this area should be looked at once the deliberations of the Pensions Board and the EU have been assimilated. I accept what the Deputies have said. They are not saying the Pensions Board should give a guarantee but, in effect, the Pensions Board would have some liability and a finger may be pointed at it, particularly given Deputy Hayes's amendment that the board should publish an annual report on the investment performance of each PRSA. The board would be inundated with annual reports if it were to do that. It might end up having to do hundreds of annual reports for each PRSA product. Apart from that, the very fact that it would give a report would, in effect, tell people what its view on the performance of an investment is, whether good or bad. I would have thought that is not really the board's remit. It is an open market and not something the board should be asked to do in that it could revert back to the board if the performance did not match up to what was being suggested by the board in the annual report.
Comment on this
As the product develops, will it be the case that PRSA providers will make claims about their products?
Comment on this
One already sees that in some investment products where people will say, informally, that their fund manager is better than another or is the best manager and that, therefore, they have got the best returns and are ahead of the ball game in regard to equities and so on. Could this be formalised a little to give people a guarantee that they would have all the information? We are looking for information.
Comment on this
I do not think the board would be adverse to having, in effect, a register of complaints in relation to people claiming something. However, this is an open market. We cannot regulate it. It is like people in shops making claims. At the end of the day the buyer dictates whether the product is a good one. That is what will happen in relation to these as well.
Comment on this
If one looks at the money sections of newspapers, the media is increasingly trying to advise their readers on different types of investment or pension products. To some extent, there is already an informal system of assessment of products. Could we go a step further and place requirements on the board?
Comment on this
It could well happen in the future, if the single financial regulator is established, that this would be a function specifically for the regulator as against the Pensions Board. The Minister referred to the fact discussions are going on at EU level on this. Surely, if we are moving towards one regulator for the entire financial services industry, this function would be given to that regulator, that is, to state opinions on the performance of various products in the market.
Comment on this
I do not envisage that would be the position in relation to pensions. It is a bit like selling houses. Some of the statements made by auctioneers in their efforts to sell houses are somewhat over the top but I do not envisage that people will be fooled in that respect. The people will get the statement of reasonable protection. It cannot be the function of the board to give a view as to whether one product is better than another.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment for the moment. They are all very similar and I may put one of them later on.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 15, between line 31 and 32, to insert the following:
"(7) The Board shall prepare, amend from time to time as it considers appropriate and publish widely a Charter of Pension Consumers Rights to include all PRSA products.".
It is a simple amendment which seeks to extend the rights of contributors or potential contributors to PRSA products. I wish to extend the section which deals with the grant of approval, the duties of the board and the duties of the Revenue Commissioners by stating that it should be a requirement of the board to prepare and amend from time to time a code of conduct in respect of the production, marketing and selling of PRSA products by PRSA providers. The idea is that a code of conduct would be extended by having a widely published charter of pension consumer rights which would include all PRSA products.
We are familiar with this as a result of our experience in other areas. Recently in local government, in which many of us are involved, we drew up a charter of consumer rights. In Dublin City Council, we also drew up a code of conduct on how consumers deal with our officials. This amendment seeks to extend the rights of pension contributors by having a published charter. In the principal Act and in the amended Act of 1996, there is such a provision. In regard to PRSAs, I did not notice a clearly laid out charter of rights for pension contributors. This is a useful amendment and I urge the Minister to accept it.
Comment on this
The Pensions Board already has a wide information and awareness role in the pensions area which it undertakes to a very high standard and I compliment it in that regard. The information role includes the provision of information booklets on all aspects of pensions and following the passing of the Bill, it will begin work on a PRSA booklet. In addition, the board attends a large number of seminars and conferences where pensions may be discussed.
That said, I am not convinced that a charter of pension consumer rights to include PRSAs would be an appropriate task for the board, especially given that I said earlier it is the responsibility of PRSA providers and scheme trustees. However, as the Deputy is aware, I am adding a representative of consumer interests to the board. I will obviously ask the board to review the spirit of this proposal in due course.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 15, between lines 31 and 32, to insert the following:
"(7) The Board may consider the previous investment performance of the PRSA applicant before deciding upon the application to be approved or refused.".
When I read the Bill, as passed by the Seanad, it did not strike me that the board, in deciding on an application on behalf of a PRSA provider, could take into consideration the previous investment record of the provider in any other guise. This is similar to the previous group of amendments we discussed.
The other issue is compliance. In all issues of financial regulation, we have to be concerned about compliance. If a provider puts forward a product for approval by the board and if the provider in another guise has a very poor compliance record or a very poor investment record, that should be grounds for the board to either accept or reject that application. When I read section 94(1) to (6) on the granting of approval of a PRSA product and the code of conduct, I did not see that included. If the Minister says the board can explicitly consider the issues of previous investment record and of compliance, that is, whether the provider had a poor record of compliance in a former life, before it grants or refuses an application, I will withdraw the amendments.
It is important to make the point that the board will have a key regulatory role in deciding on the applications which come before it and we have to give it maximum powers. It is important in this era of additional financial compliance that one of the conditions would be that the board would consider previous records in relation to compliance.
Comment on this
The intent of this amendment is already covered by the code of conduct that will be drawn up by the Pensions Board in respect of the grant of approval of a PRSA product. These areas will be examined by the board and are already covered in the framework. On the specific issue of the previous performance of the PRSA applicant or provider, obviously there will be no previous performance record where they are starting de novo. All the providers of a PRSA product would already have been approved by the Central Bank and/or the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, so they would have a reasonable track record. When the board deliberates on an applicant’s application it will have to take account of the views of the Central Bank and the Department. What the Deputy seeks will be part of the process. I do not consider that the amendment is necessary in that respect.
Comment on this
With regard to the PRSAs, I understand there are dual applications. An application is made to the Pensions Board while a similar one is made to the Central Bank at the same time. Is that the position?
Comment on this
The Revenue submits an opinion to the Pensions Board based on the information it has. Is that the position?
Comment on this
The Revenue is concerned with the taxation position. The Pensions Board has the full say in the approval or licensing of the PRSA provider.
Comment on this
When the provider applies he does so to the Revenue and the Pensions Board. Is that the position?
Comment on this
An application is made to Revenue to obtain a tax clearance certificate or whatever.
Comment on this
We were well briefed by Ms Vaughan and her colleagues on this matter. Is the Minister concerned that the overall approval of an investment company or manager by the Central Bank, the Revenue and the Pensions Board, involving a multi-faceted form of control, could form the basis for future problems? Would it not be better to assign all regulation on pension products, including the complete regulation of the companies, solely to the Pensions Board?
Comment on this
Different views were expressed on this. Following the publication of the Bill we have decided that the Pensions Board should take care of the licensing aspect. That marries with similar legislation, such as the Investment Intermediaries Act and the role of the Central Bank and the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment. We will have to see how things progress but we are satisfied that the procedure under which PRSA products are approved by the Pensions Board is the correct way to proceed.
Comment on this
On page 15, section 95 states: "Any person who, in purporting compliance with section 94(1), makes a statement knowing it to be false or misleading in a material particular shall be guilty of an offence." What is the penalty?
Comment on this
I attempted to have the penalty increased but my legal advisers said it is adequate.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 16, line 40, after "prescribed." to insert "The additional cost to the Board in administering the provision of PRSAs should be met from the fees as described in this section.".
Will the application procedure be self financing to the board? There is a considerable fee attaching to the application. The amendment provides that the additional cost to the board in administering the provision of PRSAs should be met from the fees as described in the section. The board will incur a considerable overall cost at the outset in administering all the applications it will receive. However, will future administration of applications create a revenue stream for the board?
Comment on this
The amendment is unnecessary. The purpose of the fees that will be paid by PRSA providers to the Pensions Board is to meet the cost of the PRSA product approval. The Pensions Board gets a small Exchequer subvention relating to policy issues but the cost of running its day to day business is met by the pension providers who apply to it.
Comment on this
Yes. It may also provide the board with a revenue stream, but that is well regulated for in the legislation.
Comment on this
Is the Minister happy that the board will have sufficient funding to enable it effectively operate from the outset?
Comment on this
The Department of Finance sanctioned additional personnel in view of the increased work undertaken by the board.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 16, line 55, to delete "provider," and substitute "provider' ".
This amendment will replace a coma after the word "provider" with an inverted coma.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 18, between lines 32 and 33, to insert the following:
"(2) Whenever the Board suspends or withdraws approval of a PRSA product under subsection (1) (other than in pursuance of a request by the relevant PRSA provider to do so), it shall notify contributors to the relevant PRSA provider in writing that the product has been suspended or withdrawn.".
Comment on this
The Deputy may wish to note the penalty provision. On summary conviction it is a fine of up to the euro equivalent of £1,500 and/or imprisonment for up to one year and on indictment, it is a fine of up to the euro equivalent of £10,000 and, or, imprisonment for up to two years.
Comment on this
Let the word go out. Amendment No. 7 deals with the issue of the suspension or withdrawal of a PRSA product. The Minister is aware that the board will have a new power under the Bill to suspend or withdraw a product for a number of reasons. Where the board takes that decision a mechanism should be in place to inform contributors. I am aware that on page 19, subsection (10) provides that the board shall publish the information in Iris Oifigiúil.
Comment on this
Page 18, subsection (4) states: "Whenever approval is suspended or withdrawn by virtue of subsection (1) the relevant PRSA provider shall immediately inform in writing any contributor who may be affected by such suspension or withdrawal of that suspension or withdrawal."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 20, line 34, after "the" where it firstly occurs, to insert "PRSA".
Comment on this
I am happy to accept this amendment. We were going to introduce a similar one. Perhaps the Deputy may wish to put his views on it on the record.
Comment on this
This is to insert "PRSA" before the word "business", and it did not relate specifically to the PRSA product aspect of it.
Comment on this
The Deputy may want to state his views on it so that people know what we are talking about.
Comment on this
This has to do with the reporting obligations of PRSA providers. Section 99(1)(a) of the Bill, as published and as passed by the Seanad, refers to “a report in relation to the business of the provider”. Of course the provider may have a number of businesses but by inserting “PRSA”, it relates the report to the product only. That is the intention.
Comment on this
I have one question about section 97(1)(d) on page 18. This is about the suspension and withdrawal issue. Section 97 states: “The Board, after, where appropriate, consultation with the Revenue Commissioners, may at any time suspend or withdraw the approval under section 94 of a PRSA product” if the provider “has failed, to a serious extent, to comply with its obligations under this Part or regulations thereunder;”. What is the monitoring requirement? Who would do this monitoring?
Comment on this
Presumably that will mean there will be a Department charged with this specific responsibility. Who will pay for this? We are giving it a monitoring role.
Comment on this
Yes. There is substantial acceptance that the Pensions Board must take on extra staff and it has already done so because of all this extra work.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 10 in the name of Deputy Brian Hayes. Amendment No. 20 is related. We will discuss amendments Nos. 10 and 20 together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 22, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following:
"(d) in section 26(1), by the insertion after subparagraph (vii) of the following:
'(viii) PRSA providers who in the meaning of Part X of the Pensions Act, 1990.'.".
This was brought to my attention by industry sources. I welcome the fact that section 26 of the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995, was amendment on Report Stage in the Seanad to allow restricted intermediaries to sell PRSAs. That was something which was brought to the Minister's attention. Insurance brokers, in particular, can now sell these. They could not do so under the Minister's original proposals.
These insurance brokers in the main can only deal with the defined list of product producers as set out in section 26. Currently the list overlaps with the definition of PRSA providers but if the list of the PRSA providers was amended in the future, it may well imply that brokers would not be able to deal with the expanded list. If, for instance, credit unions were licensed by the Minister in the future, would insurance brokers be able to deal directly with credit unions as intermediaries? It was brought to my attention that they may not be able to do so, given that the Minister has not amended to a sufficient degree the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995. I understand some industry sources would prefer if the PRSA providers were specifically listed in section 26.
Comment on this
When the Deputy tabled these amendments, we were not sure of the point he was making. That would be covered by the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995.
Comment on this
We understood that sections 101(5) and (6) already cover the points made but if there is an additional point——
Comment on this
No. They cover them at present but the difficulty, as I understand it, is that if in the future the Minister changes other organisations who can produce these products, will these insurance brokers specifically be able to act as an intermediary there?
Comment on this
That is a matter for the Central Bank under the Investment Intermediaries Act, 1995. They have a responsibility for implementing that. I would not see that there would be any difficulty but we can have a look at that matter between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 22, line 38, after "provider" to insert "and subject to the condition that the PRSA provider shall provide to the contributor, such functions regarding the PRSA product as he or she requests".
This relates to the idea of measuring the performance of the PRSA product. Originally I tabled this amendment to ensure that the contributor, and the Pensions Board, would have the fullest possible information on a product.
Comment on this
I am not clear on the point Deputy Broughan is making. The amendment states "the PRSA provider shall provide to the contributor, such functions regarding the PRSA product as he or she requests". Perhaps it should read "such information" instead.
Comment on this
In my original draft, I stated that it would give the fullest information to the contributor and the Pensions Board.
Comment on this
We could not understand, looking at the Deputy's amendment, what he was getting at when he included the words "such functions". My advice is that if it were "such information", that is already covered. We will look at that between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 23, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:
"(b) subject to the provision referred to in paragraph (c), a requirement that such a strategy adopt an investment profile consistent with equalling the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, property and other investment products;”.
Comment on this
The Select Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 25, line 13, to delete "5" and substitute "3".
This amendment relates to charges on PRSA products. I tabled it in order that the Minister could explain the rationale used to arrive at the two key charges listed in section 5, namely, that the amount of any particular charge made under a standard PRSA shall not exceed 5% of the amount of a contribution and that the total amount of all charges made to the PRSA assets of a standard PRSA shall not exceed a rate of 1%. That is a significant charge in the context of savings and taxable income. Is there a case to revise it downwards to 3%, thereby cutting the rate on assets to 1%? The Minister pointed out during briefings on the Bill that these charges were set by reference to the best information available on pension products and that it would be fair and equitable if rates of 1% and 5% on assets stood. However, I tabled the amendments to tease out how he arrived at these figures and ascertain whether they could not be a little keener. The tax position would still be positive, but the greatest encouragement should be given to contributors.
Comment on this
The figures were arrived at on the basis of what the market could bear having taken into consideration the views of the Pensions Board, the Department and others. These are maximum charges and we hope competition will ensure they will be much lower. If there is evidence of charges being maintained at 1% or 5% as we move forward, we will have to examine them. The maximum charge on the UK stakeholder pension is 1%. However, it must be borne in mind that there is a greater volume of pensions in the United Kingdom and ongoing debate about the sustainability of companies which receive a 1% charge.
Comment on this
Of assets. At the end of the day we are all of the view that the consumer should pay as little as possible, but we must bear in mind the charge that can be borne in a relatively small market. I guarantee it is an area that will be kept under review.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 25, line 43, to delete "timely" and substitute "two months".
I ask the Minister to withdraw the word "timely". Section 104(11) of the principal Act states, "A PRSA provider shall give timely advance notification to a contributor of any changes to charges proposed." This is open to wide interpretation. What does "timely advance notification" mean? The amendment specifies a maximum period of two months for the information to be submitted. There is no definition of "timely advance notification".
Comment on this
There is not a significant difference between us. "Timely" could be interpreted to mean less than two months. I undertake to examine the matter again between now and Report Stage. The view of the Department is that the word "timely" is better than the term "two months".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 26, to delete lines 18 and 19 and substitute the following:
"(3) An employer shall pay, at his own expense, contributions into the employee's PRSA which at least equal the employee's contributions.".
This is a key amendment, which relates to contributions. The Bill states, "An employer may pay at his own expense into an employee's PRSA." The Minister said on Second Stage this could be kept under review. It should be mandatory that an employer makes contributions. Given that under section 787J(2) of the principal Act contributions are tax exempt, there is no reason, therefore, not to place a mandatory requirement on employers in this regard.
It is an achievement that the legislation has been introduced at long last, but the Minister's remit is to encourage people, particularly those in the private sector, to take out an occupational pension. A basic encouragement in this regard would be to clearly set out requirements for employers. Highly salaried staff often enjoy compensation packages, to use Anthony J. O'Reilly's favourite term, which include major contributions by their employers to pension plans. I do not understand the reason the Minister does not grapple with this issue to make it mandatory on employers to make contributions.
This issue could become a significant aspect of wage negotiations in future. My trade union colleagues would have a direct interest in how pension contributions might be framed as a significant part of the overall benefits that a job would confer on an employee. The Minister has an opportunity under this section to take a leap and make the PRSA an attractive element of remuneration for an employee by making it mandatory on employers to contribute also, particularly given that such contributions can be written off for tax purposes.
Comment on this
This is an important issue, to which we referred on Second Stage. I have tabled an amendment, with which we will deal later, where I have tried to formulate a new section to review the contributions after a number of years if a level of cover has not been attained. The Minister said on Second Stage that he expects cover to dip below the 50% level, calculated years ago, when figures for private pensions are published later this year. A specific review mechanism must be inserted in the legislation which would allow us to return to this issue. PRSAs will not work unless there are significant contributions from employers in the long run which may well be part of a future national wage agreement and social partnership. The Pensions Board report in 1998 highlighted a consensus between employers and trade unions on this issue, which was significant. There has to be a specific review mechanism included in the Bill whereby, if a certain level of coverage is not reached within a certain number of years, the issue of contributions will be automatically reviewed. Without a form of employer contributions, we will not obtain the type of coverage we should.
Comment on this
This amendment would introduce a further compulsory element into the PRSA framework in that employers would have to match their employee PRSA contributions. While we would like to see that, I cannot agree to compulsion at this stage. The PRSA framework is an agreed partnership approach to increasing pension coverage. The voluntary approach to employer contributions must be given a chance to succeed. However, if this strategy does not work, and we will know this through the survey work, the position will have to be reviewed. I have tabled amendment No. 37 to achieve this which will allow us to review it. That is as a result of the comments made by Members on Second Stage.
The issue of "mandatory" and "voluntary" was one of the key issues in the NIPI report. All the social partners and participants in the report were unanimous that employer contributions to PRSAs should be voluntary in the initial stages. I have said in many speeches since the report was published that it may well be that, sooner rather than later, we will have to go the mandatory route. The strong view of the participants in the NIPI report was that it should be on a voluntary basis in the initial stages. I am told there are downsides to the mandatory approach in that schemes could reduce their provision to the lowest required, as apparently happened in Australia. That is the reason we want to move slowly on this to see how it transpires. I anticipate that whoever succeeds me will examine this when the review is carried out. If we do not get what is required, we will have to ensure it is mandatory.
Comment on this
I welcome the fact that the Minister is prepared to include amendment No. 37 to provide for a review. The idea of the PRSA is to act as an encouragement to people to make provision while being able to move between employments. Given the tax advantages which would ensue, surely it would be beneficial to employers as well to make as good as possible an environment for workers if there was this requirement of employers.
In the initial discussions on the Bill, what type of response on this did the Minister receive from organisations such as IBEC and other employer bodies? Were people bitterly opposed to it or was it something they saw over the long-term as being part of a normal salary arrangement?
Comment on this
I do not have anything further to say other than what I have said before on the issue of "voluntary" as against "mandatory". It is something which will evolve. Whether it will be necessary for it to be mandatory will depend on the type of survey and review we have indicated in amendment No. 37.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 19 is an alternative to amendment No. 18 and both may be taken together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 26, lines 47 to 53, to delete all words from and including "in" in line 47, down to and including "payment" in line 53.
This relates to the minimum contribution which can be made to PRSAs. The amendment proposes to delete a number of lines from the Bill which make a differentiation made between €10 and €50? Why is this differentiation made? The argument is that it is in place for electronic transfer. That said, if we are trying to make this as flexible and simple as possible for people, we should just have one amount and not include this higher amount. The minimum amount per year is €300, which would not give much of a return after ten years. The two minimum payment levels of €10 and €50 are unnecessary. Will the Minister examine this?
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Hayes's approach. I was trying in my amendment to make it as simple as possible for people to contribute, and I hope I achieved that. We had hoped with the special savings incentive accounts, that the Minister for Finance would have brought forward a new scheme with even lower thresholds or different conditions which would have encouraged people with very low incomes to make some savings provision. I was thinking along similar lines in this case. It should be made as easy as possible, especially given that during a person's career there could be times when he or she could contribute very little and other times when he or she could contribute more. I presume one would be advised by one's provider on this. That was the thinking behind amendment No. 19. I hope it has the effect I intended.
Comment on this
The reason there is a difference is that we have to find a balance between the consumer's perspective and that of the provider. Dealing with cash is more costly to the provider. The payment of €10 is allowed where it is done electronically and I am told the vast majority of transfers will be done electronically, given that they are from wages. That is why it is targeted at a much lower level. If contributions are in cash, they cause more difficulties. I envisage that very few transactions would be in cash, but we cannot exclude those. That is why there is a differentiation. It is not anything sinister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 28, to delete lines 33 to 35.
I propose to delete section 110(2) as inserted by section 3 which relates to the marketing and sale of PRSAs. I have received representations from industry sources on this issue. The subsection states that: "No document relating to the marketing or sale of a Standard PRSA may solicit the purchase of, or otherwise advertise any other product". There is a concern among insurance brokers who have made representations to me about this issue. The Bill makes it unlawful to market other products alongside PRSAs. The argument is that this counters good practice in the life and pension policy area, which is to intensify and prioritise protection needs from life cover and income protection. Consumers are adequately protected by the insertion of section 110(1) which states that it cannot be made a condition to take out another product. This makes subsection (2) unnecessary. It may mean that standard PRSAs are marketed at the expense of life cover to the detriment of families of PRSA contributors who may die young. If one sells a PRSA to a younger person who dies young six or seven years later, does he or she have the right to insurance cover which may not be a part of the PRSA? Is it good practice that this is debarred? That is the effect of subsection (2). I ask the Minister to examine this issue.
Comment on this
I can see the point being made by Deputy Hayes. While I recall receiving submissions on this issue by the PIBA and have some concerns regarding it, I would be inclined to go with the existing section. In a previous role as spokesperson on enterprise, trade and employment the relevant committee, of which Deputy Callely was Chairman, I examined the issue of insurance. One of the issues which arose three or four years ago was that of churning where it seemed that people were given much information about additional, renewed or changed life cover which may have been unnecessary. This was also an issue for the enterprise committee in the previous Dáil. There were concerns that older people, in particular, who were near retirement and who may have been vulnerable would be urged by the media to increase their cover and payments. I would be concerned that the standard PRSA should stand alone and be clearly marketed on its own. The enterprise committee compiled a report on the churning phenomenon on which it received some disturbing information.
Comment on this
This section provides for the protection of the consumer by ensuring that, in the case of the sale of a standard PRSA, the contract cannot in any way be dependent on, for example, the sale of life insurance. The contract for a standard PRSA is stand alone, as is its marketing documentation. That is not to say, however, that a person cannot take out a standard PRSA and a life assurance policy in one transaction. This is allowed, but no aspect of the contract or policy can be connected in any way. This is to ensure transparency of charges.
I agree with Deputy Broughan. While certain interests might make representations, one has to see from where they are coming. We are trying to ensure PRSAs are stand alone and not used as a marketing tool for other products. I urge the Deputy not to press the amendment.
Comment on this
There is an issue regarding protection whether as a retirement income or insurance. If we are excluding the marketing of other products regarding PRSAs, as in this paragraph, it could lead to difficulties. People are not adequately covered at the level of occupational pension cover, bonding or insurance. We should not debar this process, as is provided for in the Bill. The arguments made by some industry sources are worth considering. We do not need to over-regulate to the detriment of insurance cover. I hear what the Minister is saying and withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 29, line 11, to delete "15" and substitute "28".
This amendment deals with the preliminary disclosure certificate and the conditions imposed on a PRSA provider. Given the operation of normal business and the fundamental nature of a PRSA contract, perhaps a longer period of time would be reasonable. A period of 15 days is reasonably standard in other consumer legislation, but this is such a fundamental commitment that it is not unreasonable to ask for a 28 day period before the contract becomes binding.
Comment on this
Fifteen days is the standard cooling off period for insurance products. It would be preferable to retain it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 29, line 35, to delete "annually" and substitute "at six-monthly intervals".
This amendment deals with the statement of reasonable projection and is linked to other amendments which are important regarding the performance of PRSA investment products. I proceed on the basis of the experience of constituents and those who talk to me about different kinds of investment products. This is particularly the case where people have been disappointed. In the past I referred issues to the Insurance Ombudsman or the Consumers' Association where there was a perception that an annual projection regarding investments and equities may have been too infrequent. A week is a long time regarding stock market products and vehicles. There should be a requirement to produce a printed statement of reasonable projection more often than annually. Perhaps every six months is a reasonable period to allow people to review the performance of their PRSAs.
In this case it involves the statement of reasonable projection. However, investments, particularly equity investments, can change value at incredible speed. Through the financial media we have seen how people can be upset and matters are let slip, such as the IT downturn in the United States which had a devastating effect on some private investments and linked products. It may be fair to ask that a statement be issued more frequently than on an annual basis.
Comment on this
We are trying to be reasonable to everyone. The annual provision is strict. However, there is provision under subsection (1)(b) whereby, subject to subsection (3), the provider has to give a statement of reasonable projection at any time on being requested by a contributor to do so, subject to being given reasonable notice. In effect, there is a strict onus on the provider. It is reasonably standard to provide for an annual statement. The amendment would place a greater financial burden on the providers who might look for increased charges. I would err on the side of caution when changing this.
Comment on this
That may be the case because they had to report fairly regularly. Obviously people would phone up the company and ask what the policy is currently worth. One of the reasons these types of amendments are important is that, for example, endowment policies which were linked to mortgages seemed to be a total disaster. Public representatives had many complaints about that whole area whereby commitments were made that a 25 year mortgage would be paid off after ten or 15 years. This is how the policy was sold and people were really upset that it would barely make it after 25 years when they believed they had unnecessarily paid an additional amount of money in order to provide the life cover or whatever. Performance and monitoring of performance is absolutely crucial. I know people will phone in and ask for these things, therefore, receiving a report on a fairly regular basis would keep people on their guard. The annual reports people receive in relation to taxation and so on may not simply be good enough. Perhaps we should come back to this issue.
Comment on this
Perhaps we will look at it between now and Report Stage. I am not unsympathetic to the point raised by the Deputy but I must check it out.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 30, to delete lines 36 to 47.
Why is there disclosure before transfer from a scheme to PRSA. It is an interesting area which was discussed and on which we received submissions in regard to how it might operate. It will be interesting to see how trustees act following September or October when PRSAs are up and running. I wonder why we need to include restrictions in section 3 in regard to a transfer where someone might have a small amount of service and less than €4,000 paid into the scheme. Section 113 can stand up just as well without that subsection.
Comment on this
This subsection allows for some flexibility in the area of transfers for occupational pension arrangements to PRSAs to cover small levels of pension benefits of less than €4,000 or where there is less than two years' service and no preserved benefit. To apply the fairly heavy disclosure regime to these smaller pension benefits is considered unnecessary and would reduce further the value of the benefit to people. It is to try to protect people so that the disclosure requirements do not eat into the small benefits people receive.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 31, line 33, to delete "annually" and substitute "at six-monthly intervals".
This refers to general disclosure obligations on the PRSA provider. I note the statement of account which has a six month duration.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 32, between lines 36 and 37, to insert the following:
"(4) A Statement of Reasonable Projection shall advise a potential or actual contributor to a PRSA of developments in relation to the state pensions and of the general performance of existing occupational schemes over the past decade.".
This occurred to me in regard to performance. Subsection (3) states that "a Statement of Reasonable Projection shall advise a potential or actual contributor to a PRSA of the importance of making adequate financial provision for retirement and of obtaining appropriate financial advice in that regard."
The Minister has the power to make regulations in regard to information. He can prescribe the form and contents of the Statement of Reasonable Projection and the various types of information included. What I wish to add is a bit similar to the general drift of an earlier amendment in the names of Deputy Hayes and myself that the potential or actual contributor would be aware of developments in relation to what might be happening to State pensions. The Taoiseach told the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis——
Comment on this
——that he would raise this issue again and again.
Obviously we are talking about the three pension tiers and encouraging people to have occupational pensions. We referred to countries such as Sweden as well as Ireland. I read the literature on the pensions reserve fund on the Internet and elsewhere during the lead-in to the Second Stage of the Bill. This seemed to indicate we are among the good guys of Europe, together with Sweden, because we seem to be able to give an absolute guarantee to State pensions and we may be in a position at some stage to similarly guarantee occupational pensions. Therefore, I wonder why we cannot include here that people should be aware of the value of occupational pensions and the general performance of existing schemes. One of the problems with existing occupational schemes is that it is very difficult for ordinary citizens to get a comparison in order to see how areas are performing. It would be interesting to have this information in regard to, for example, Cadburys vis-à-vis the Guinness fund and major private sector employers such as Intel. Perhaps there could be some information in this whole area whereby one could say one company is not doing as well as another. It might be important to include a little bit of extra information on existing occupational pension schemes and also on what is likely to happen on the State front. By simply setting aside that fund, and assuming the Minister’s fears will not be realised and it will not be raided by future Ministers, perhaps the 1% will remain. Our Fine Gael colleagues are talking about throwing an extra 0.5% into it.
Comment on this
I consider it desirable to include a reference to the social welfare and old age contributory pension in the Statement of Reasonable Projection. I will undertake to come back to the issue on Report Stage. This could be a statement giving the value of the social welfare pension as a percentage of average industrial earnings at the date of projection. I will look at it in relation to the issue of general performance. As I said previously, I cannot take hostages to fortune in that respect. I cannot give an undertaking that we will put an onus on the Pensions Board or the Statement of Reasonable Projection flowing from the actuarial involvement in that as to the general performance of the funds over the previous period.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 34, line 42, to delete "section 94(6)" and substitute "section 94(1)(b)”.
This was brought to my attention and I am happy to accept this technical amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 37, between lines 6 and 7, to insert the following:
"(8) (a) Contributions shall be treated in the same manner for the purpose of relief from income tax, where the payment of the contribution is made by the contributor or is made on his behalf to the PRSA provider.
(b) Contributions shall be treated in the same manner for the purpose of relief from pay related social insurance and health levy, where the payment of the contribution is made by the contributor or is made on his behalf to the PRSA provider.
(c) Such relief from pay related social insurance and health levy as applies to PRSA contributions shall apply to contributions in respect of existing personal pensions.”.
This is an important issue. It relates to the issue of tax advantage on payroll deductions. Section 121(7) states that the employer has no duty of care to employees regarding the investment performance of standard PRSA schemes that he or she puts in place for employees. The schemes where deductions are from salary will currently have an advantage over schemes in which the employee has become involved privately because the net pay system will apply. Tax and PRSI will apply on salary, less contributions to the employer designated schemes so that the employee gets tax and PRSI levies relief through the works scheme but only tax relief when the scheme is taken up privately. Since the employer decides the scheme and has no duty to the employees regarding the performance, there is a view that there is a danger that larger schemes developing where no one is checking the investment performance could prove a risk to employees. PRSA schemes run privately by contractors should be able to attract equal benefit to counter this and to ensure that there is competition and choice for employee pension funds.
The objective of the amendment is to provide a level playing pitch in respect of tax deductibility. This concern is particularly relevant to larger, so-called monolithic schemes where very little investment assessing takes place. This is an important amendment and I ask the Minister to consider it.
Comment on this
The amendment is mainly concerned with the tax relief that applied to PRSA contributions and would more properly belong in section 4 of the Bill. It seeks to have contributions made on behalf of an employee treated in the same manner as contributions made by an employee both for tax purposes and for PRSI and health contribution purposes. Under the tax provisions as contained in section 4, PRSA contributions by an employer are treated as a benefit in kind in the hands of the employee. Such contributions are treated for tax relief purposes as having been made by the employee so that effectively a benefit in kind charge will only arise where the aggregate contributions made in a year exceed the relevant limits. Relief for PRSI and health levies will also be given in respect of such contributions.
Measures to this effect were contained in this year's Social Welfare Bill, which is being amended to allow relief for PRSI and health levies in respect of RAC and PRSA contributions where the contributor is an employee or director.
Accordingly I reject the amendment on the basis that the matter contained in the amendments is already in this Bill as drafted and also in the Social Welfare Bill.
Comment on this
The Minister is saying there is no difference, therefore, on the tax advantage for both schemes. Is that the case?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
In page 38, to delete lines 1 to 18.
I have a question with regard to page 36, section 121(4), the obligation on the employer to provide access and to pay and remit contributions. The employer has to commit funds within 21 days. For a large employer making these deductions, are there safeguards to ensure that large employers do not use these funds even for the three week period? A very large employer with 200 to 300 staff, over three weeks, could manage to use the funds for some purpose. Over 12 months or ten years, presumably if the total interest was added up, that would be an advantage to the employer. Are there any safeguards that the Minister thinks are in place to ensure that this does not happen?
I am particularly talking about large employers who would take the money at payroll source. They would have three weeks in total to commit the money to the administrator of the fund. There is nothing in my reading of it that would prevent them using this fund for other purposes for that three week period.
Comment on this
Originally a 15 day period was proposed in the Bill when it was published and we received fairly strong representations mostly from employers saying that it was a very tight timeframe. That is why the 21-day period was agreed in the Seanad. Employers would have the benefit of this money but equally they would have the benefit of money they would get from employees in relation to PRSI and PAYE. There are obligations on them to transmit the money as quickly as possible subject to the legislation in that respect in relation to income tax. We felt that 21 days was a reasonable time. There is nothing we can put in to say that they should pay interest on the money because in effect they are unpaid collectors both for the tax man and for the purposes of this legislation. Here, we are setting up another layer of bureaucracy and employers often give out about the fact that they are in effect tax collectors and deductors for employees.
Comment on this
Is there anything in the Bill which outlaws the practice of using this money for the three weeks?
Comment on this
The fact that there is an onus on them in the Bill to transmit the money within 21 days is enough. There is not really any other way because this in effect would be a rolling situation whereby they would be paying out money on a fairly constant basis. I am not saying we are not charging interest on this money because there is a quid pro quo in that they are in effect providing a service to people to deduct money and pass it on. However, we must accept that it does employ people. The amount of paperwork and bureaucracy that employers must go through is significant and this is yet another layer for which they are not getting paid. Provided they pass on the money within the relatively short space of time, which is a new obligation that was not there before in relation to other pension situations, it is a fairly strict onus on people.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 34 proposes to amend lines 1 to 18 on page 38. It proposes to take out of the legislation the replacement of buy-out bonds and there is a view that eliminating buy-out bonds does not in itself serve any useful purpose and that if they are not available, schemes for members of 15 years service and over will have no vehicle in the event of a wind-up. I am aware that there has been the suggestion that this section will not be invoked until or unless section 772(3)(d) of the Tax Act is eliminated. However, this would require further legislation which seems unlikely. This has been brought to my attention. The Minister is aware there was some publicity concerning this when the Bill was on Second Sage. Eliminating this buy-out provides fewer options for people. There has been a good deal of concern about the 15 year stipulation proposed in the Bill.
Comment on this
We are bringing forward amendments regarding this later in the Bill. This section will only come into effect when it specifically commences. Therefore, there is no need to delete it. It could be useful to have it in place in the future. Perhaps we can deal with the issue of the replacement of buy-out bonds when we deal with amendments Nos. 83 and 86.
Comment on this
No, I am saying that the section should be left in and that we can discuss the issue of buy-out bonds later.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 38, lines 42 and 43, to delete "or a defined contribution scheme".
This relates to transfers of PRSA assets to the defined benefit and contribution schemes. I am using the reference to the two types of scheme to highlight that employees are increasingly worried and upset at the drift to defined contribution schemes rather than defined benefit schemes where, like those in the public service, the risk is borne by the employer regarding the 50% or 66% pension that will accrue at the end of a time period. In defined contribution schemes the risk, effectively, is transferred to the employee. A defined contribution scheme can do well or badly depending on the performance of the investment underlying the fund. This has become a significant issue in the United Kingdom and the United States. I know from communication with the ICTU that it is one that will be raised in the next round of national pay discussions.
This is an area that we need to address. I am not sure if this is the way to do it, but the amendment gives me the opportunity to raise this issue of concern. Internationally, it is linked to the new accountancy rules whereby pension liabilities have to be disclosed on the balance sheet. In some German companies it emerged that future pension liabilities, at 65% or 70% of salaries, were enormous, perhaps even reaching the level of the other assets of the company. This is a profound issue and seems to be a bad development in countries such as Ireland that have made some attempt to promote occupational pensions. I am seeking to encourage the debate by removing the reference to a defined contribution scheme.
Comment on this
I understand what the Deputy is saying. The sentiments he expresses are related to a much broader issue not dealt with in the section. While people may have concerns, the Deputy's amendment would not assist them in any way. As it might be restrictive in the delivery of PRSAs, I, therefore, oppose it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 39, line 9, to delete "2" and substitute "6".
This relates to the retirement annuity contract and defined contribution schemes where a scheme has been terminated and the assets transferred to one or more PRSAs. It refers to the notice of at least two months that members would get. A longer time period should be imposed to allow employees and members examine what is happening and know what future plans might be. I propose to extend it to six months.
Comment on this
We consider that the shorter timeframe of two months is better as the information could be dated and changed in some way over the longer period.
Comment on this
As amendment No. 38 is an alternative to amendment No. 37, we can discuss them together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 39, between lines 11 and 12, to insert the following:
"126.-The Minister shall cause-
(a) a report in relation to the extent of the application of occupational and other pensions (other than pensions under the Social Welfare Acts), in respect of such matters as the Minister considers to be relevant, to the population to be prepared by such persons as the Minister may determine not later than 3 years after the commencement of section 3 of the Pensions (Amendment) Act, 2002, in its entirety and a copy of that report to be furnished to the Minister, and
(b) a copy of that report to be laid before each House of the Oireachtas within 6 months after its preparation.’.”.
This amendment builds a review period into the Bill to ensure the policy objective in relation to the second pillar pension coverage of the working population is being achieved over time. The Pensions Board target for second pillar pension coverage is 70% of the workforce aged over 30 years. The Government is firmly committed to facilitating the objective of increasing supplementary pension coverage among employees. Achieving the objective will, of necessity, take commitment and effort on the part of all employers, trade unions and, not least, the pension industry. All are agreed that if the proposed PRSA arrangements on a voluntary basis do not succeed, the position regarding mandatory provision will have to be reviewed. I have already said that such a review would be undertaken sooner rather than later and the amendment reflects my concerns. It makes a commitment to undertake a review within three years of the enactment of the legislation.
Comment on this
I welcome the amendment. The Minister has responded to comments made on Second Stage. It is important it is included in the Bill. If we do not reach the kind of coverage for which we are looking within a reasonable period of time, we should broach the compulsion issue again. Amendment No. 38 would probably be more prescriptive in terms of percentages to be reached by a certain period of time.
As the Minister said on Second Stage, it now looks as if the percentage in respect of coverage throughout the workforce will be less than 50%. The issue of coverage will have to be addressed sooner rather than later. The issue of compulsion will have to be addressed unless we reach the percentage increases that we all expect and wish.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 40, between lines 45 and 46, to insert the following:
"(ii) by the substitution in section 772(3A) and (3B) of 'proprietary director' for 'employee';".
This amendment relates to approved retirement funds. I am led to believe that ordinary employees cannot avail of the option to select an approved retirement fund instead of a fixed pension at retirement. Approved retirement funds allow an individual to manage his or her own funds in retirement and draw benefits in a flexible manner. Currently directors and those contributing to personal pension plans can avail of these options first introduced in the 1999 budget. PRSA holders will also be able to avail of approved retirement fund options, excluding employees in occupational pension schemes.
Amendments made to the Bill restrict transfers from occupational pension schemes to PRSAs if an employee has more than 15 years service. This was designed to stop the wholesale conversion of long established schemes into PRSAs. An adverse consequence is that long service employees will not be able to access approved retirement funds options by converting their schemes into PRSAs shortly before retirement. As some schemes transfer to aggregate years service between pension schemes, a person may have to think twice before moving a fund to a new scheme on changing jobs. It would be more likely if the 15 year rule applied to the total pension fund. A way around it would be to allow all employees avail of retirement fund based options. That is the intent of the amendment in order to create a level playing pitch for all in respect of drawing down approved retirement funds.
Comment on this
I support the amendment. I am attempting to do something similar in amendment No. 48 which states that "any employee may opt to contribute to an approved retirement fund in preference to a PRSA and may enjoy the same tax relief as self-employed contributors. . . " In the 1999 budget the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, developed ARFs and gave self-employed proprietors the freedom to manage their own retirement funds. Formerly they received tax relief on savings and then purchased an annuity, but by increasing the tax free limits or tax benefits of approved retirement funds the Minister for Finance gave the self-employed a freedom which employees do not enjoy.
The point is well taken that employees should have similar freedom, especially at the end of the life of the PRSA product. Every citizen should have the right to manage freely his or her pension fund. Since coming into the House I have found Finance Bills frustrating because they are mainly concerned with tax concessions for businesses and the self-employed while employees are dealt with in a few summary pages and receive little encouragement compared to those making a business investment. This must be balanced out. A start could be made by giving employees more freedom in this area. Therefore, I support the amendment.
Comment on this
It has been the hallmark of the Minister for Finance in the changes that he has made in tax rebates and pensions to give employees, whether self-employed or otherwise, more freedom to look after their own money. The amendment is concerned with allowing all members of an occupational pension scheme to exercise an ARF option, which would not generally be suitable for those on low incomes or with low pension cover. At present, this option is confined to proprietary directors and employees generally regarding contributions made by way of AVCs. The amendment is not related to PRSAs and would more properly be dealt with under the Finance Bill, which amends the Taxes Consolidation Act only in regard to PRSAs and related tax provisions. I must, therefore, reject it.
Comment on this
It is not entirely true to say that the Bill just deals with PRSAs as there are other miscellaneous provisions on pensions such as the appointment of a pensions ombudsman. This is an opportunity to raise the issue because there is discrimination between directors, those who have the option to purchase PSRAs, and employees who do not. The Minister stated it would not be advisable for those on modest or low incomes to do this, but that would be a matter for them. Are we saying employees cannot manage their own money?
Comment on this
The objective of PSRAs is flexibility. Why can there not be the same flexibility in this instance?
Comment on this
It goes back to the 15 year issue. We do not want a wholesale transfer from existing good schemes to PRSAs as we want to protect what is good and people's positions.
Comment on this
We are trying to balance the various conflicting interests. If a person is in a good scheme, we do not want him or her transferring everything to another product that might be of less value than the original one.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think that it is just an income related issue? Is he saying that, as directors and the self-employed have larger incomes, they can take the risk? If someone has paid into a scheme, it is his or her money and he or she has the right to decide what to do with it. At present, employees are subject to two different tax regimes. It is not up to Government or politicians to tell people what is in their interests, which is, in effect, what the provisions of the 1999 budget do.
Comment on this
I saw a photograph of the Minister for Finance in a bowler hat, or whatever it was, at the races at Cheltenham last week and admire him because he is an implacable advocate of his class, that is, those with significant assets.
Comment on this
Yes. He is an advocate of the wealthier deciles. He was the Minister's predecessor and demonstrated then the same relentless attitude towards social welfare provision. As Minister for Finance, he maintains the same attitude. I am not making a personal observation but I am talking——
Comment on this
This is a fundamental issue which relates to whether the PAYE system is constitutional, and employees' freedom compared to the self-employed and business owners. I agree with Deputy Hayes that nobody should be constrained in this way. Budgets and the tax code discriminate against employees, as does the pensions system.
Comment on this
I do not accept that. In the last budget, for example, the Minister for Finance made substantial changes to employees' pension provisions, giving them——
Comment on this
The 1999 changes were beneficial to directors and those with considerable sums of money to play with in terms of the amount of tax they had to pay. This is widely accepted. The same cannot be said of ordinary employees. The 15 year limit rule was not contained in the Bill as published but was introduced on Report Stage in the Seanad.
Comment on this
In reviewing existing pension provisions, we are asked here to do our best to provide maximum flexibility for employees and create a level playing pitch for everyone. The Department of Finance has a substantial hand in this Bill. Many of the amendments tabled on Report Stage in the Seanad were understandably from the Department of Finance. As the person responsible for trying to encourage people to put greater amounts of money into savings in the context of PRSAs, the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs should try to create a level playing pitch in this area. Clearly the existing law does not do that and it discriminates heavily in favour of people on substantial incomes. I know the advice is coming from the Department of Finance——
Comment on this
It is not only the Department of Finance. The national pension policy initiative also pointed to the need to be very careful about the transfer of funds from good schemes into the PRSA system.
Comment on this
Therefore, that defeats the argument of the Finance Act, 1999, where the Government did precisely that in respect of company directors.
Comment on this
There is a distinction between that and the rights of employees. Company directors on PRSAs are on the same footing in respect of ARFs. However, people who have paid into occupational schemes for 15 years or more will not be able to avail of this tax concession.
Comment on this
I can push it no further because I am not in a position to give any different tax treatment other than the ones approved by the Department of Finance in relation to these. I cannot make changes except in relation to PRSAs.
Comment on this
This is more than just a PRSA Bill. This Bill attempts to clean up part of the legislative code for pensions. This is an area the Opposition has highlighted.
Comment on this
That is true, but the only opportunity we get is when it is being reviewed every five years.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 41 is an alternative to amendment No. 40 and both amendments may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 41, to delete lines 1 to 18 and substitute the following:
" '(3D) A retirement benefits scheme shall not cease to be an approved scheme because of any provision in the rules of the scheme whereby, either or both-
(a) a member’s entitlements under the scheme, other than an amount referred to in paragraph (b), may, either on the member’s changing employment or on the scheme being wound up, be transferred to one or more than one PRSA to which that member is the contributor if the following conditions are satisfied, that is to say-
(i) benefits have not become payable to the member under the scheme, and
(ii) the period or the aggregate of the periods for which the individual has been a member of the scheme or of any other scheme related to that individual's employment with, or with any person connected with, the employer immediately before the said transfer is 15 years or less,
(b) an amount equal to the accumulated value of a member’s contributions to the scheme, which consist of additional voluntary contributions made by the member, may be transferred to one or more than one PRSA to which that member is the contributor.’,”.
This amendment provides that the accrued rights under an AVC scheme may be transferred to a PRSA, subject to the rules of the AVC scheme being amended to cater for this. It is to provide some flexibility in that they will not be subject to the 15 year rule.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42
In page 41, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
"(iii) by the insertion in section 772 of the following after subsection (4)(b)(iv):
'(v) allows an employee who is retiring after attaining 50 years of age a maximum pension from all sources of two thirds of twice the national average salary with the appropriate commutation of this amount as a lump sum provided the employee has made not less than five years pay relates social insurance contributions.'.".
Comment on this
This amendment relates to the issue of maximum benefits and the proposal is to amend section 772 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. The current rules for occupational pension schemes relate maximum benefits to years of service with an employer and salary when leaving or retiring. The usual basis is one sixtieth of salary per year of service for pension purposes and a tax-free lump sum of three eightieths. The basic levels are enhanced for late starters from ten years to twenty years service for those who retire early - before 65 in most scenarios - and maximum benefits are restricted by the proportion of actual to potential years service. Calculating maximum benefits in circumstances where one changes employment or retires early can become very complex. My proposed amendment would streamline matters and make the system much simpler than it now is, so that an employee retiring after age 50 can avail of fixed maximum benefits from all sources relating to, say, twice the national average salary, regardless of years service and salary at retirement, provided he or she has a minimum working history or PRSI record of approximately five years. This would streamline maximum benefits for low to middle income earners and would favour late starters, who would otherwise be penalised by having very short service with their last employer, particularly if retiring before 65. This would provide an easier system and, in my estimation, would give a benefit to middle income earners.
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to allow the Revenue Commissioners to approve an occupational pension scheme which provides, subject to conditions, a pension equal to two thirds of twice the national average salary - that is one and one-third times salary - to a person over 50 who is retiring. At present, the maximum pension that may be provided in accordance with the revenue code for occupational pension schemes is linked to the employee's final salary and to the number of years service in that employment. Of course, an employee may have pension benefits from earlier employment and these may be taken into account. The revenue code has been devised over a long period and is largely based on achieving parity of treatment between private sector employees and public sector employees. The code allows an employee with ten or more years service to receive a maximum pension of two-thirds of final remuneration. There is a sliding scale between one and ten years service. In practice, very few employees would receive benefits equal to the maximum approved limits. Such pensions would tend to be confined to high earners in whose case the amendment would have no effect. Also, the amendment is not related to the introduction of PRSAs and is more properly a matter for the Finance Bill. The present Bill deals with the Taxes Consolidation Acts only as regards the tax provisions of PRSAs Accordingly, I must reject the amendment.
Comment on this
One of the issues which we discussed prior to lunch and which runs throughout this Bill is the tax treatment given to top income earners. If we are really serious about doing something significant on pensions, we should provide incentives through the taxation system to encourage people on small incomes to put money aside. There are loopholes in the current system. I referred earlier to the issue of transfer, as it relates to the 1998 budget and Finance Act. We need to look at how the taxation code is used to encourage people to save. The treatment of those on low incomes, by comparison with those at the top end of the income scale, is not the same. While this is not a matter directly for the Minister, it falls under the Finance Act and there is a necessity to bring about a fairer regime on taxation as it applies to pensions policy.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 43 is ruled out of order as it involves a potential charge on the Revenue.
Comment on this
Why is that? The maximum at the moment is €254,000 and the amendment aims to change that figure to €126,000. This will limit the amount of tax and reduce the potential of the State to hand out tax relief for these purposes. How would that incur costs? If anything, it would keep more money in the coffers by limiting the income threshold on which people can take out these PRSAs.
Comment on this
Tax relief under the Bill as it stands would be available at up to 30% of the higher amount. The amendment would cause it to be available only up to 30% of the proposed lower amount.
Comment on this
In so far as it proposes that higher earners should not be able to avail of higher amounts of relief, the ceiling beneath which relief is available is effectively reduced and there is also a charge on the people.
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy the note that I have on amendment No. 43. Can we talk on the amendment?
Comment on this
No, it is out of order. We can talk about the section but it would be best if we came back to it later.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 53, line 15, to delete "distribution" and substitute "payment or amount treated as a payment".
This is technical amendment which removes the incorrect reference to distribution.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 55, between lines 39 and 40, to insert the following:
"(2) Any employee may opt to contribute to an approved retirement fund in preference to a PRSA fund and may enjoy the same tax relief as self-employed contributors to an approved retirement fund.".
We had a discussion this morning on this matter and it gave me the opportunity to raise the issue of the approved retirement fund option and section 787H on tax legislation. The Bill states that the assets of a PRSA may be made available to a beneficiary, that an individual may opt to have those assets transferred to an approved retirement fund and that the PRSA administrator shall make the transfer. I was trying to ensure that the full benefit of somebody being transferred to an ARF would accrue to an employee as it would to a self-employed person.
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to give an employee the option to contribute to an approved retirement fund as an alternative to contributing to a PRSA. An ARF is a fund into which the proceeds of a retirement annuity contract or the value of certain occupational pensions may be transferred on retirement. Pension contributions may be made to an ARF. Employees who are not in pensionable employment may currently take out an RAC and transfer the proceeds of the RAC to an ARF when benefits become payable. Benefits that derive from the AVC in occupational pension schemes by employees may also be transferred to an ARF on retirement.
Directors who own more than 5% of the company providing the retirement benefit may also transfer their pension entitlement to an ARF. All transfers to an ARF are subject to an individual having to transfer €63,5000 to an approved minimum retirement fund unless the individual has an income for life of at least €12,700. The PRSA tax provisions as drafted allow PRSA assets to be transferred to an ARF including the case of a PRSA to which an employee is a contributor. Alternatively, as a PRSA is a fund of assets and therefore resembles an ARF, there is an option to leave the money in the PRSA and subject to the ARF requirement to withdraw the assets from the PRSA. This option is provided to avoid unnecessary costs that might be involved in making a transfer from a PRSA to an ARF. In so far as the Deputy refers to employees being entitled to the same relief as the self-employed, the Finance Bill recently passed by the Dáil provides accordingly. Therefore, the amendment is not necessary and I must oppose it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 57, line 56, after "State" to insert "or in other jurisdictions".
The amendment is in relation to Revenue approval of the PRSA products and I want to clarify whether the arrangements in respect of that product may be entered into by an individual with a person lawfully carrying on the business of PRSA provider in other jurisdictions. Am I correct that a PRSA provider can, in effect, come from another jurisdiction?
Comment on this
However, a French company could enter the Irish market, get the approval of the product by the Revenue Commissioners and there would be no need for the amendment. The point I make in relation to the amendment is whether it is necessary to add the phrase "or in other jurisdictions".
Comment on this
I can give the Deputy my notes if he needs them. The amendment seeks to allow the Revenue Commissioners to approve a PRSA product entered into by an individual with a person carrying on a business as a PRSA provider, either in the State - as in the Bill passed by Seanad Éireann - or in any other jurisdiction. Since the PRSAs will be sold in the State to Irish residents, by and large, it is considered that the PRSA provider must be carrying on the business of PRSA provider lawfully in the State. The provider regulated abroad may well carry on the business of PRSA provider abroad. However, by definition he or she must carry on such a business here and must do so lawfully.
Persons who may be PRSA providers are defined in section 91 of the Pensions Act, 1990, as follows: (a) an investment firm authorised under Council directives; (b) an insurance undertaking authorised to transact business under Council directives; and (c) a credit institution under Article 1 of Directive 2000/12/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 March 2000.
Comment on this
Would the opposite apply? Could an Irish PRSA provider go to another market or could there be a situation where we had a stakeholder?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In page 59, to delete lines 18 to 22 and substitute the following:
"by way of transfer of the PRSA assets to the estate of the PRSA contributor,".
This amendment is to remove the reference to premiums which is more apt to describe contributions to a policy issued by an insurance company.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 60, line 12, after "50" to insert "or over".
This amendment ensures that the early retirement option will be available to those at 50 or over rather than being confined to those at age 50.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:
In page 62, to delete lines 30 to 33 and substitute the following:
"(e) in part 42, by the substitution, in subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (g) (inserted by the Finance Act, 2001), of section 986(1) of ’Chapter 1 or Chapter 2 or Chapter 2A of Part 30’, and”.
This is similar to the point I made about providing the same relief for personal pensions as company pensions, or PRSAs. As employees who contribute to their personal pension funds by salary deductions cannot avail of net pay arrangements, they may have to transfer from personal pensions to PRSAs to achieve this. This simple amendment would give greater personal protection to the chapter and the relevant paragraph and allow employees to enjoy income tax and PRSI relief at source for retirement annuity contributions, as is the case with PRSA contributions. I repeat the question asked: why should we discriminate between employees?
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to apply the net pay arrangement, which applies to an employee's contributions to an occupational pension scheme, to RAC contributions. An employee's pay for the purposes of applying PAYE and PRSI is the net amount after pension contributions. A similar treatment has been provided for for PRSA contributions deducted by an employer on behalf of an employee. There is an obligation on the employer to make such deductions which the amendment seeks to extend to RAC contributions deducted by an employer. RACs are largely aimed at self-employed persons. Those not in pensionable employment may also get tax relief for RAC contributions, but, in general, employers are not concerned with or interested in deducting such contributions from an employee's salary or wages and the application of the net pay arrangements does not arise.
The Taxes Consolidation Act is being amended only in relation to its tax provisions for PRSAs, to which the issue under discussion is not directly relevant. Questions of a general nature regarding tax relief for pension contributions would be more properly a matter for the Finance Bill. I am quite sure that the net pay arrangements apply, but I will check before Report Stage.
Comment on this
Returning to the maximum income limit, the Minister has provided for a figure of €254,000, which is considerably more than the stakeholder pension in the United Kingdom. Will those with pension cover take out a PRSA for their children or other relatives when the PRSA scheme is up and running, as a tax efficient method of putting money aside? I question the total capping income, as I do not know how the Minister arrived at the figure of €254,000 as an income threshold. The problem is that we are trying to introduce a tax measure focused on those who are not saving at present, but it is not sending out the right signal to have an upper income limit and allow virtually anyone to apply, even if they have existing cover. I question how directly this will apply to those who are not saving at present. I understand one needs a specific taxation system for the introduction of a product, but question the fact that it does not discriminate on the basis of income.
Comment on this
The Deputy seeks to reduce the earnings cap to €126,000. The limit of €254,000 proposed in the Bill is the same as that which applies to RACs. While no earnings cap applies in the case of occupational pension schemes, a funding restriction confines the maximum pension which can be provided to two thirds of the final salary. The NIPI report recommended that the tax regime for PRSAs should not favour new products at the expense of existing ones or vice versa. Accordingly, the RAC earnings cap has been retained while additional voluntary PRSA contributions linked to an occupational pensions scheme are controlled by the scheme's funding limit. While the earnings cap of €254,000, which has been in place since 1999, is relatively large, it should be viewed in light of the fact that many people not in occupational pension schemes begin to save for pensions relatively late in life. The effect of the earnings cap is that persons between the ages of 40 and 60 years are allowed to contribute up to €76,200 per annum towards a PRSA. It favours those who start saving later in life.
Comment on this
If one takes the general point raised in submissions on the Bill, that all pensions provision is a charge on the economy at a particular time, could it be inferred that high earners are once more benefiting from a bias as a result of tax expenditure foregone vis-à-vis the first tier of contributory pensions? If we make it attractive for high earners to put away the maximum amount of income and thereby receive the maximum amount of tax relief, can a case not be made in global terms that we are again discriminating against those on low incomes? Despite what I said this morning about the Taoiseach, that he would increase contributory and non-contributory pensions time and again, the scope for this is more limited when one has foregone an increased amount of tax revenue.
Comment on this
I do not think so. We want to encourage as many people as possible to benefit from PRSAs. If a cohort of late savers see PRSAs as an opportunity, they should be encouraged, irrespective of their income. I thought the other side of the House may have tried to increase the cap rather than reduce it. It is purposely generous, in order to try to get as many people as possible to invest in PRSAs.
Comment on this
There is a reference on page 50 of the Bill to "one or more PRSA products". Therefore, one can buy more than one product.