Pensions (Amendment) Bill, 2001 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 227–458 of 458. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 45 of 2001 ›
It does not matter if one has ten products or just one. I apologise for moving around this section so extensively, but may I draw the Minister's attention to section 787G?
Comment on this
No. I have a question about a reference in subsection (2), on page 53, to "the PRSA administrator from the individual beneficially entitled to the assets in the PRSA or from the estate of the deceased individual, as the case may be." The Minister has not put a time limit on the transfer of the estate of a deceased PRSA contributor, which naturally goes to the spouse or next of kin. Is such a time limit necessary to ensure the spouse gets the money as soon as possible?
Comment on this
I come across cases in my constituency where a person dies and the matter of trying to access the funds into which they have been paying can drag on for a considerable period. Regarding PRSA, did the Minister consider putting a time limit on transferring that money where someone dies? Is there such a provision in the Bill?
Comment on this
No, there is not. There would be no benefit in doing anything from a legislative point of view because to do so would be to restrict the transfer.
Comment on this
I am talking about imposing a limit on the amount of time it can take for a transfer to occur.
Comment on this
Paragraph 787K(1)(c)(ii) provides for an annuity or other sums payable to commence, or for assets to be made available, between the ages of 60 or 75. Why is the age limit of 75 there?
Comment on this
A limit is set out because, to a certain extent, after that age what is being done is not pension planning. It is more estate planning and the provision might be misused.
Comment on this
Is the cut off age of 75 included in other legislation?
In page 62, from line 36, subsections (a), (b), (c) and (d) refer to the declaration of a PRSA administrator. One of the conditions is that the declaration must be signed by the declarer. Am I right in saying that there is no definition of “declarer” in the definitions section? Who is the declarer?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 53:
In page 63, lines 34 to 36, to delete all words from and including "the" in line 34, down to and including "commences" in line 36 and substitute the following:
"no longer than 6 months after the enactment of this Act".
This amendment relates to "establishment day", meaning the day on which section 5 of the Pensions (Amendment) Act, 2002, commences. I want to provide that commencement will take place no longer than six months after the enactment of this Bill. Is it clear what "establishment day" means?
Comment on this
We intend to set up the office of the ombudsman as quickly as possible and this proposal is not necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 63, between lines 36 and 37, to insert the following:
" 'Oireachtas Committee' means the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Family, Community and Social Affairs;".
Through this amendment I seek to involve our committee in the deliberations leading to the appointment of an ombudsman. Increasingly, parliamentary committees will scrutinise the appointment procedures for positions on State boards and many other positions of importance in the State. The absolute power to appoint an ombudsman is the Minister's and I do not object to that. What I suggest in these amendments is that our committee should be involved as it is this committee, or its appropriate successor, that will be charged with monitoring the effectiveness of this legislation as we go forward. It would be good practice for the relevant Oireachtas committee to, at least, hear the people putting themselves forward for this office. We may well issue an opinion, but ultimately the decision will be a matter for the Minister. I am not suggesting it should not be, I suggest that we should have a role in vetting those putting themselves forward as candidates for this office.
Such practices will be introduced in the case of State boards and they should be introduced regarding office holders like this. It would be a useful way of involving this committee in the important work of the pensions board and, in particular, that of the pensions ombudsman.
Comment on this
This is a very worthwhile idea, which I support. When important officers come to the notice of the membership of the Dáil, it seems sudden. I am not sure what were the recent criteria in choosing the new governor of the Central Bank, but the office was in the news in recent weeks in relation to the AIB crisis. I have no doubt that the new governor is very well qualified and will be a fine representative in that job, but for that type of position there should be an input by a committee, in that case the input of the Oireachtas Committee on Finance and the Public Service and of the Committee of Public Accounts. Given our remit as the social affairs committee, it would be useful for us to have the opportunity to have an input into choosing a candidate to fill the office of pensions ombudsman.
Part 3, along with the PRSA provisions, forms the main part of the Bill and it is a wonderful innovation. The call for the creation of a pensions ombudsman has been the ongoing refrain of groups of former employees and pensioners since our colleagues across the water went down this road. It will be a very important public office and it is right that the Oireachtas, through this committee or its successor, is involved in the appointment.
Comment on this
The Bill provides for the appointment of the pensions ombudsman by the Minister, which I consider reasonable, given the nature of his work. It is important that a suitably qualified person is appointed, following the practice in the appointment of previous ombudsmen. I have no problem with the ombudsman, when appointed, coming to the committee and there is nothing in the Bill to prevent him from being called, but the appointment itself is a ministerial matter and one for the Government of the day.
Comment on this
That has certainly been the practice to date and I am not so sure that it has worked well in all cases, though in quite a number it has. We need to move to a scenario where Parliament has a role in the appointment of an ombudsman, given that the ombudsman will mediate on much of the legislation we put through the Oireachtas. The limited amendment I seek to make to allow us some say in the appointment of an ombudsman fully recognises the ultimate power of the Minister. I would not take that away for the moment. Politicians should appoint these people and we are politicians too. Involving the newly established office with this committee would be a very useful exercise. We will be charged, presumably, with the function of assessing the annual reports the ombudsman produces when the Minister lays them before the House. I am not singling out the poor pensions ombudsman, this is the way to go in the case of all future appointments.
Comment on this
Have the beginnings of this system not already been introduced in relation to judicial appointments? As I understand it, limited reforms have been made in this area and some people feel much more fundamental reforms are required. Has a process been initiated which gives the legal profession an input into these decisions? Obviously, the measures do not go as far as in the United States where Congress has the supreme role in this regard. There, the executive makes a decision which usually goes before Congress for confirmation. This allows one to examine factors such as the candidate's career. It is right that Parliament should be involved in the appointment to what will be one of our most important offices. Given our experience as Deputies, many queries and issues will be raised with this office from it first day onwards.
Comment on this
We are not dealing with American circumstances. I question whether the Deputy's example of the legal profession's influence on the selection of judges is a good one. I do not propose to comment further on the matter except to point out that the view is that it is already difficult enough to be included in the list proposed to the Government and that, to a certain extent, people who are not in the know and the ordinary five eighths do not make it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 64, between lines 37 and 38, to insert the following:
"(2) Before the Pensions Ombudsman is appointed by the Minister, the appropriate Oireachtas Committee shall consider the suitability of persons who are making themselves available for the position of Pensions Ombudsman. The Committee may make a recommendation to the Minister before an appointment is made.".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 57 is an alternative to No. 56 and No. 59 is related. The amendments may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 64, to delete lines 38 to 44.
The amendment would remove the age limit imposed on the person to be appointed by section 128, paragraph 2 of which states: "A person shall be not more than 61 years of age upon first being appointed to the office of Pensions Ombudsman." I do not understand the reason this provision has been included. I am aware of a very celebrated case taken by a distinguished former Member of this House and current member of my party against a former Government on the basis that the age bar in the legislation in respect of, I believe, the office of the refugee commissioner was unlawful. Given that he won the case, we should not impose an age limit on the person to be appointed.
Comment on this
I support the amendments for the reasons enunciated by my colleague. It appears the European Union anti-ageism directive, which will become law in 2006, will make it illegal to impose compulsory retirement ages or compulsory ages of any kind on recruitment practices. A number of these kinds of cases have crossed my desk during my time on this committee. An interesting one related to a provision in the harbours legislation enacted in 1996 which stipulated that people of 60 years and over could not be appointed pilots in Dublin Port while existing pilots could continue to serve until they were 65 years.
This type of issue arises fairly regularly. Many people argue that if one is medically fit and has done the job very well, this practice must be discriminatory. In the case of the Harbours Act, I referred the matter to Mr. Niall Crowley of the Equality Authority. There is a grey area with regard to employment equality and equality legislation. In the long-term, I do not envisage that this practice will survive and it appears that under European Union legislation, it will not. One could also argue that a senior person - I will avoid the term senior citizen - would probably be the most dynamic and interesting in terms of pension provision. This also relates to my point with regard to the board, namely, that pensioners would feel that they best know the conditions under which they live and the way in which occupational schemes performed in the past. While I am not arguing that the ombudsman must be a pensioner, one can see the logic in appointing someone with extensive experience of life. This provision stands such logic on its head and for this reason I strongly favour deleting these provisions.
Comment on this
I will examine the matter as the figure of 61 years may be a little low given that I am also getting closer to it.
Comment on this
It would be ludicrous to have it open ended. To return to the legal profession - coming from that profession you may think I am being very hard on it today - in the past some judges sat on the bench well into their eighties, which I do not believe is a good thing. There should be an upper limit and while the figure of 61 years is perhaps a little low, it was chosen because it applies to the public service ombudsman.
Comment on this
All kinds of issues will arise from equality legislation with regard to this area. It was put to us, for example, that——
Comment on this
As we have discovered in recent times, equality legislation, while very welcome, can be taken to its absolute extremes. If we remove an upper age limit, why set a threshold at the lower end of 18 years? Why should five year olds not be allowed to apply?
Comment on this
I think it was Sir Matt Busby, a famous manager, whose prescription for his very successful Manchester United team - I speak as a supporter - was that if one is good enough, one is old, or young, enough.
Comment on this
Without mentioning the name of my party colleague involved in the case to which I referred earlier, was it not the basis of his action that the Government imposed an age limit in the legislation and was he not successful?
Comment on this
I expect it got him something else, the money without the job. The point is that imposing an age limit is precisely the problem encountered in that legislation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
In page 65, to delete lines 5 to 20.
While reading this section, it struck me that the powers to get rid of the pensions ombudsman rest solely with the Minister. It is over zealous that, at the stroke of a pen, he can decide to remove an ombudsman without recourse to the committee or other Ministers. I tabled the amendment because I am interested in fleshing out what the Minister has in mind in this respect. What would happen, for instance, if a Minister who disagreed with the findings of a pensions ombudsmen also had the power to remove him? The provision is extreme and should be recast for all future appointments, not just that of the pensions ombudsman.
Comment on this
Under legislation the Ombudsman is statutorily independent of the Minister. If this provision is deleted, nobody can remove the officeholder, even if circumstances change. This is a standard provision in legislation regarding other ombudsmen and, on balance, it is better to have it.
Comment on this
How does the Minister intend to recruit a person for the job? Will there be a general advertisement for the position?
Comment on this
We will do something along those lines. There are a number of ways of choosing a pensions ombudsman. It is a specialised area. We have not yet given much thought to the appointment.
Comment on this
He or she should be in place shortly after the Bill has been passed. We have yet to address the mechanism, but it will probably be by advertisement in the newspapers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 66, lines 17 and 18, to delete ", with the consent of the Minister for Finance,".
All of the amendments refer to the Minister for Finance. I do not know the reason he is involved. The Minister will probably tell me that this is a standard provision in legislation, but this is an issue in which the Minister for Social, Community and Family Affairs should be involved. We do not want a situation to develop where moneys cannot go directly to the office to fund it in an appropriate way because the Minister for Finance does not like the estimate of expenditure that comes to his office.
What will happen if, six or 12 months after the ombudsman has been appointed, the workload requires an additional number of staff in the office? There has to be a guarantee that funding will be available to back up requirements. Couching the legislation on the basis of the consent of the Minister for Finance is not the way to go. As Deputy Broughan said, this is a very important officeholder who will have huge responsibilities to rule on evidence put to him or her from various parties. We have to ensure the person concerned has maximum independence and flexibility, of which part will be to ensure the requisite number of staff will be in place to do the job. Too often the Department of Finance can have undue influence on legislation such as this. Money should be provided for the ombudsman to do the job. The Minister for Finance should not have any place in the legislation to deny the money required.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance must have some view in regard to this matter. In practice so far, this standard provision has not presented a problem in regard to the Pensions Board. We obtained sanction for more staff than will ultimately be necessary, partly due to subsequent changes to the Bill that have removed some of the workload from the board. It is a standard provision that it be done with the consent of the Minister for Finance, which is the case in regard to any expenditure across my or any other Department, whether I sign regulations or legislation. Obviously, I propose my own amendments.
Comment on this
It is unduly restrictive, particularly as we go forward. This is an office that will shortly be operational and do very important work. I will propose an amendment later which would extend the look-back period to a much greater time span than the Minister proposes in the Bill. It is vitally important that the person in the office has funding available to him or her. There have been cases where the Department of Finance has not provided the requisite funding for people to do their jobs and I would not like such a situation to develop.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:
In page 67, between lines 21 and 22, to insert the following:
"(b) a complaint made to him by or on behalf of an actual or potential beneficiary of an occupational pension scheme or PRSA who alleges that he has sustained financial loss occasioned by reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, other investment products, gross domestic product and property;”.
The amendment relates to the functions of the pensions ombudsman to investigate certain complaints and disputes. Section 131(1)(c) of the Bill refers to a complaint or dispute falling within a category prescribed by regulations made by the Minister. I am seeking to make it very specific, in line with amendments I proposed this morning, in order that it reads, “a complaint made to him by, or on behalf of an actual or potential beneficiary of an occupational pension scheme or PRSA who alleges that he has sustained financial loss occasioned by reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, other investment products, gross domestic product and property.”
In paragraph (a) there is reference to a person who alleges that he or she has sustained financial loss occasioned by maladministration. Could this also be taken to mean bad management of a portfolio of investments if decisions are badly made? To some extent, what is envisaged by the Bill could be construed to include the issue I am trying to raise under the amendment. There has to be some accountability and transparency that people will be held to the highest achievements of comparable products.
The legislation does not go far enough. Perhaps when the review is being made this difficult area of how PRSAs might be evaluated will be addressed to some extent. I was struck by the debate in the Seanad that someone with experience in the area should feel very strongly about the matter. I agree with the point made that the capacity for ripping people off is immense and that there does not seem to be any comeback for investors who suffer as a result of bad practice.
If in the future this is interpreted by the Supreme Court, the issue could be included within the meaning of maladministration. I would prefer, however, to insert the amendment on the basis that there should be some standard of accountability. We can only go on the experience of those who come forward, but one example raised in the public domain concerned employees of The Irish Press, some of whom were represented by me and some of my colleagues. There were deep concerns about the administration of a particular fund.
The feeling was that there was no fraud, but that there was underfunding or that the fund was placed in the wrong kinds of investment in respect of the workers concerned who believed they were short-changed when the time came to pay out benefits. By contrast, there were other funds in the Irish Press Group, to which journalists, for example, belonged, which seemed to perform better.
Perhaps we have achieved the desired effect based on the Minister using the word "maladministration". Perhaps we should make it clear that there could be a comeback or that one could be held to account if one makes a bags of it, if one has expertise as a fund manager.
Comment on this
There is no definition of "maladministration". If there was, the issue to which Deputy Broughan referred would be solved. Having read the Bill, I notice that maladministration and misinformation could be confused. It is very subjective as to what exactly they mean.
Comment on this
In my legal training a differentiation was made between malfeasance and misfeasance. We could include a definition in the Bill, but it would not be exhaustive. Ultimately, it would be left to the courts to decide what constituted maladministration. Perhaps one would be better off leaving it as it is because one man's definition of "maladministration" might be different from somebody else's. Maladministration, to my mind, means somebody doing something on purpose that has the effect of placing people at a disadvantage. Mismanagement of a fund by negligent administration or management, rather than fraudulent administration, would not be caught.
I will return to the age old example of malfeasance, as we used to know it. If a county council fixes a pothole and one falls into it, it is a case of malfeasance. If the county council does not do anything with the pothole and one falls into it and injures oneself, it is a case of misfeasance and it is liable. In this instance, it will be interpreted strictly by the courts in terms of the managing of the administration rather than the managing of the fund. That is what we are getting at. In the light of the original point I made about the first few amendments, we could not have either the Pensions Board or, in this instance, the pensions ombudsman, making judgments on whether a fund performed well. That would not be within their remit.
Comment on this
If a product was managed very badly in market terms, surely that would be a cause for concern. It is on the basis of complaints that the ombudsman can intervene. Could he or she use this provision to include management of the fund?
Comment on this
If he or she believed that it was administered in such a reckless way that it led to a very poor performance by a fund, leaving it undefined could give him or her the option of interpreting it in that way. If we start to define it, we will have to say what constitutes maladministration. It could then be said it was definitely not mismanagement of the fund and was, for example, a case of the fund manager not shoving paper around at the appropriate time.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 67, line 44, to delete "Ombudsman-" and substitute the following:
"Ombudsman. It shall be a matter for the Pensions Ombudsman to determine what complaints or references under this section shall be investigated and a determination made thereupon.".
This is one of the key issues in the Bill. I know the Minister made progress in respect of allowing a greater look-back period. I think the original period was three years. It is now six. If we are genuinely trying to put in place a completely independent ombudsman to do the job as set out in legislation, we need to give the person concerned maximum independence and flexibility.
As is currently the case in subsection (4), pages 67 and 68, we are trying to tie the hands of the ombudsman. There is no need for any of the references to the issue of complaint and the time when the complaint occurred. I propose in amendments Nos. 63 and 64 that dealing with these issues would simply be a matter for the pensions ombudsman. The amendment reads, "It shall be a matter for the Pensions Ombudsman to determine what complaints or references under this section shall be investigated and a determination made thereupon."
There are many pensioners who have questions to ask in respect of the management of their pension schemes in recent years, as the Chairman well knows. While the issue of retrospection is debated regularly, it is a difficult one to call. We have got to give, in this legislation, maximum powers to the ombudsman to allow him or her to investigate whatever he or she likes. Where an initial complaint or representation is brought to the ombudsman's office, he or she should be able to look at it very quickly, determine whether it requires additional investigation, an oral hearing or written representations. He or she could then determine the facts as he or she sees fit.
As I said in my Second Stage contribution, I am very much opposed to putting any time limit on this officeholder to do his or her job. It may well require additional resources as I said in response to other amendments. It is important that there is maximum independence and that we do not go forward with the time limits the Minister is proposing. I am aware of a general provision he is making that the ombudsman can investigate other matters, but we need to be as flexible as possible in this regard in order that those who believe they have a genuine grievance, which has not been recognised by the Pensions Board because it could not do so on the basis of the information that it had available to it, can be treated appropriately by an ombudsman with maximum control and independence. The best way to do this is by accepting my proposals in amendments Nos. 63 and 64.
Comment on this
I add my voice very strongly. In amendment No. 65 I propose to remove the look-back time limit. I have received a lot of correspondence since last summer on this issue. I have received about 30 submissions, perhaps more. A typical one is from a pensioner who writes:
I have been agitated for many years by the establishment of a Pensions Ombudsman because of three factors:
1. The ability of a large Irish company and its UK parent to resort with impunity to unbelievable subterfuges in order to cover up that, during a particular period, the Irish company had applied pension increases in a way which was (a) blatantly unfair, (b) in breach of the Pensions Act, and (c) in breach of the rules and procedures of the pension scheme.
2. The repeated unwillingness (sometimes by way of subterfuges) of the Pensions Board and the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs to address and be seen to address the substantial evidence produced by me in support of the allegations referred to above.
3. My belief that both public bodies are reluctant to address this evidence because they are party to and/or aware of the specious reasoning which accounted for the Irish company being given approval (probably from the Revenue or Pensions Board) for applying the irregular increases referred to above.
I thought that my fight for justice was finally rewarded when I learned in September last that the Pensions (Amendment) Bill 2001 would provide for the establishment of a Pensions Ombudsman. However, on reading the Bill I discovered that it included a clause in Section 131 which would preclude me from raising the above issues with the Pensions Ombudsman as the acts given rise to issues will have arisen more than 3 years before the enactment of the Bill. This exclusion does not apply to complaints after enactment.
He then goes on to say that he raised the issues with the Minister on 5 September 2001 and received no satisfaction. The Minister's reply did not address the substantive issue. That is typical of about 30 submissions I have received from different companies, some of which I mentioned in my speech on Second Stage. I referred to the Irish Press Group, the retired Tara Mines workers and the Ford Motor Company. A lot of them relate to the management of surpluses and indexation. That is a fundamental issue which runs through them all. This legislation seeks to establish a new and important public office. Pensioners welcome it because they feel that they now have someone who can fight for them. People are familiar with the insurance ombudsman, but the problem is that it stems from the industry and is not an independent national office. People had hoped that the ombudsman would come to grips with the unfair underfunding, use of the surplus or failure to keep up with inflation in indexation. I know the Minister has yielded a little on this.
We have PRSAs and other things have happened in recent years. However, the big issues brought to our attention tend to date back ten or 15 years. Maybe it would be for the best if the ombudsman was able to look at the entire area. Clearly a lot of these schemes will be brought to his or her attention fairly quickly. The person whose letter I quoted mentioned that he could apply to the court for the Pensions Board to address the evidence that substantiates the claim of his group. This legislation is a great step forward. It seems terrible that the Minister is not prepared to accept either of our amendments and give the ombudsman free rein. I am sure if it is something that affected a relatively small number of people a long time ago it could be thrashed out fairly quickly. I understand the fears that the office might be bogged down. As Deputies, we are used to getting correspondence relating to intractably difficult cases that have gone on for years. The Minister should allow an open-ended look-back because of the nature of pensions.
Comment on this
There has been no unrestricted look-back for any previous ombudsman. The scope for a look-back prior to legislation is very restricted. We have looked back six years. We have looked at this again since the Bill was in the Seanad but we cannot go back any further. There are 86,348 schemes encompassing 629,801 people. It only takes a few disgruntled people to seek a look-back and the pensions ombudsman's office would be inundated with claims and queries for schemes that may go back as long as 40 years. Some of the major schemes that are causing difficulty go back that far. Personally I have a lot of sympathy for those people. Someone evidently took his or her eye off the ball in the framing of the trustee documents. I have often spoken of one substantial scheme where I have much sympathy for the people involved. When I asked them to produce the trustee papers it did not require a legal expert to see that they were excluded from the position that was at issue. When I read it out to them they immediately accepted that, even though they will not accept it publicly. In many cases people did not perhaps have the wherewithal to question what was included in the document on their behalf. The Deputy asked what their representatives were doing at the time.
Comment on this
It is a matter of whether one can allow the office of the ombudsman to be inundated at the initial stages. Six years is quite a long time. As I said in the Seanad, the reference in the Bill to the action in section 131 allows flexibility of interpretation. This would obviously have to be determined by the ombudsman. It is similar to the amendments to the Civil Liability Act, 1961, regarding the taking of legal actions. There used to be a strict ruling that one could not take a legal action more than three years after the event. There has been a dramatic change based on a court decision. It related to when the person first became aware of the act which caused them the injury. To a certain extent that has opened the claims floodgate. That is one of the reasons we have such an amount of claims in this jurisdiction.
There is a provision in the legislation similar to that in the Civil Liability Act where reference is made to the act. It states:
The Pensions Ombudsman may investigate a complaint or dispute under this section notwithstanding that the act giving rise to the complaint was done prior to the establishment day if, and only if, the complaint or reference is made to the Pensions Ombudsman within the period of 6 years from the date of the act giving rise to the complaint or reference.
We have taken legal advice on this and it is open to interpretation when that six years starts. The ombudsman will have some discretion in this. He or she could ask when the person concerned first became aware that he or she was disadvantaged and had a source for a complaint.
Comment on this
If that is not within six years of the date of the act giving rise to the complaint, it could lock out people who have been making complaints to us. The Minister has been saying there are 86,000 plus schemes. The bulk involve people getting benefits, who are paying into the scheme and are happy with their lot. The problem for the minority - including some high profile cases - is that there is no closure for them.
The other issue is that we are not talking about companies which have gone out of business and are not paying into schemes. In many respects, they are existing large Irish companies which have not met their obligations. That is the point - it is not a question of fly-by-night companies.
Comment on this
I would hesitate before saying they have not met their obligations. In many cases one will find that they are strictly interpreting the trust documents. If, as the Deputy says, they were not complying with their obligations, it would be easy to take an action against the trustees or the scheme because the people concerned would not be getting their due entitlements. They are not taking that route because of all the advice received. I have received a myriad of complaints to my office and when one gets to the nub of it, one finds that the reason they are coming to people like us is that there is no legal justification for what they are saying.
Comment on this
Surely, that would make the argument that the intention of the amendments is to give maximum discretion. If the people concerned presented at the office and the ombudsman took a quick look at what they had to say, he or she - or his or her staff - would know that there was not a good enough case to take forward and the people concerned did not have good enough grounds for their complaint.
I still do not see the difficulty in allowing this look-back because we are giving ultimate discretion to the ombudsman. We are asking him or her to look at these complaints and make an initial judgment on them. As the Minister knows, up to now the Pensions Board has not been able to make these judgments on the basis of the facts before it. There is a need to give the office the right start. It will become obvious to the ombudsman quickly, on the basis of documents submitted to the office, whether there is a case to be answered by the trustees and the scheme concerned.
Comment on this
That is a good point. Very often what people are looking for is closure. An expert, as the ombudsman will be, is the best person to look at the matter. He or she may decide that it is not a case of gross maladministration or one for the national bureau of fraud investigation, but rather it is inherent in the rules of the scheme that trustees have accepted during the years. I imagine the big chestnuts will be dealt with relatively quickly.
Comment on this
I do not know if that is the case, but I make the point again that in the six year look-back and the interpretation by the ombudsman of when the person concerned first became aware of the act there will be substantial flexibility in what he or she can do. We must balance the fact that we are legislating for the future and I must be careful not to clog up the system. The strong advice is that the system would be clogged up and that the ombudsman would not be able to get off the ground in relation to future issues to do with pensions if he or she was dealing with issues that relate to the past. It has also been said that people, irrespective of whether their "claim" is statute barred, would make a claim or complaint to the ombudsman leading to appeals to the High Court resulting in the entire process becoming even less flexible.
Comment on this
We were going around the houses on amendment No. 63. Without summarising everything he has said, does Deputy Hayes wish to make one last comment?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In page 67, to delete lines 45 to 53, and in page 68, to delete lines 1 to 12.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 68, lines 17 to 20, to delete all words from and including "if" where it firstly occurs in line 17, down to and including "reference" in line 20.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 68, between lines 20 and 21, to insert the following:
"(6) The Pensions Ombudsman shall not investigate or determine a complaint or dispute unless the procedures referred to in section 132 have been resorted to and exhausted in accordance with their terms.".
This amendment has been inserted to clarify that the procedures for internal dispute resolution for an occupational pension scheme or PRSA, as set out in section 132, must be exhausted before the ombudsman can investigate or determine a dispute or complaint.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:
In page 69, line 1, after "Minister" to insert ", with the consent of the Minister for Finance,".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:
In page 69, lines 48 and 49, to delete "Subject to the prior approval of the Minister, the" and substitute "The".
This is another formulation of the argument I made earlier. I am seeking to remove the phrase "Subject to the prior approval of the Minister, the Pensions Ombudsman may from time to time engage such consultants". If we are serious about the independence of the office, why should the ombudsman have to go to the Minister to bring on board consultants or advisers as he or she deems necessary? I presume the Minister will make the argument about the financial implications and so on. However, it seems strange that the ombudsman cannot engage consultants or advisers when he or she believes it necessary without the prior approval of the Minister.
Comment on this
In the normal course of events the ombudsman would have a budget provided from the Department's Vote. If the provision regarding the Minister's approval did not exist and, for example, the ombudsman ran up a significant bill for consultants, it would be asked whether any check was in place. This provision is a check and a balance, but in reality there would be a certain level of agreement with regard to what can be spent on consultants. That is the same for any body under the aegis of a Department. Considerable difficulties would arise if this provision was not included in the Bill.
Comment on this
I will not labour the point. Presumably the procedure will operate on the basis that the ombudsman sends to the Department an estimate of expenditure for the next year, part of which relates to consultants or advisers if he or she deems it necessary.
Comment on this
That is correct. However, if, during the year the ombudsman decided to take on a multimillion pound contract, there would be little the Department could do to stop him or her entering discussions without some sort of hold.
Comment on this
One of the points raised by the former UK ombudsman who came here last September to speak at a conference, at which the Minister also spoke, was that one of the defects of the British legislation was that the ombudsman could not delegate responsibility to people beneath him or her. Is there such a provision in the Bill as proposed?
Comment on this
The ombudsman can delegate everything within his or her remit except the determination. The ombudsman must make that determination.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 70, line 48, to delete "any court" and substitute "the High Court".
This section deals with a stay in court proceedings where a complaint is made. By proposing "any court" does the Bill not make it easier for people to stay proceedings? Would it not make more sense to stipulate the High Court? If someone wished to place a stay on proceedings, the higher the court, the greater the cost. It is immeasurably cheaper to secure a stay if the provision refers to "any court". Would this not encourage more third parties to seek a stay?
Comment on this
Restricting the provision to the High Court would limit the ability to make a complaint.
Comment on this
If, for example, someone makes a complaint against a provider of any scheme who decides to seek a stay on proceedings for whatever reason, it is very easy for that provider to go to any court. It would be cheaper to go to the Circuit or Districts Courts. The Minister has pointed out that stipulating the High Court places the bar higher in terms of securing a stay. Does the Minister understand my point?
Comment on this
Yes, but if one exclude the Circuit Court there would be no power to stay proceedings. If the proceedings were in the Circuit Court and the Bill restricted the provision to the High Court, there would be no power to stay proceedings in the Circuit Court in the event of a complaint.
Comment on this
I would not have thought so, unless we provide for it. That is why we have used the phrase "any court".
Comment on this
When reading the Bill I thought this was an opportunity to reduce the possibility of staying proceedings. Presumably the bigger the company or the bigger the potential loss it will suffer, the more recourse it will take to the courts.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:
In page 72, between lines 37 and 38, to insert the following:
"(11) The Pensions Ombudsman may, of his own volition, refer an investigation file to the National Bureau of Fraud Investigation of An Garda Síochána and to the Director of Public Prosecutions.".
This amendment concerns an issue about which I asked earlier. If the pensions ombudsman receives a complaint he or she will investigate the matter and will make a determination. However, does the legislation make it sufficiently clear that the ombudsman has an obligation to pursue a matter with the Garda, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the National Bureau of Fraud Investigation? The Minister is a lawyer. Will the office of the ombudsman not be similar to tribunals in the sense that all its investigations would have to be reinvestigated by the National Bureau of Fraud Investigation if there is to be a successful prosecution in the case of gross maladministration amounting to fraud? Should we not include in the Bill a specific remit in this regard, given that we have had some famous cases? On Second Stage I referred to one such case which seemed to constitute an outrageous fraud.
Comment on this
I agree with the portent of the Deputy's proposal and we will consider the matter further before Report Stage. I will have to take legal advice in the meantime.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 73, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:
(4)(a) Nothing in this section shall prevent any of the parties to the investigations seeking an oral hearing from the Pensions Ombudsman.
(b) The decision to grant an oral hearing referred to in paragraph (a) shall be a matter solely for the discretion of the Ombudsman.”.
This amendment proposes that any parties to an investigation shall be able to seek an oral hearing with the pensions ombudsman. The amendment is broad in its definition in that it proposes that "The decision to grant an oral hearing referred to in paragraph (a) shall be a matter solely for the discretion of the Ombudsman.” Perhaps the Minister will tell me if this power already exists. Many of these problems could be ironed out if an oral hearing was part and parcel of the functions of the ombudsman.
Comment on this
Under the Bill the conduct of the investigation, including whether to hold an oral hearing, is a matter for the ombudsman. In this regard a person could make whatever representations he wishes to the ombudsman, so the amendment is unnecessary. We would like to give the ombudsman as much discretion as possible - I believe that is what the Deputy is trying to do - on the issue of holding an oral hearing.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 73 is in the name of Deputy Broughan. Amendment No. 74 is related so it is proposed to discuss amendments Nos. 73 and 74 together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 73, to delete lines 32 to 42.
This amendment concerns cases where the ombudsman makes a determination on a complaint and may give directions as he considers necessary but we specifically exclude any amendment of the rules of the scheme, the conditions of the PRSA contract or the substitution of the decision of the pensions ombudsman for that of the trustees. How will that work in practice? If, for example, the rules or some of the decisions made by the trustees, using their discretionary power under the scheme, had been seriously deficient, would it not be reasonable to expect the ombudsman to give a direction that changes be made to the PRSA or to the scheme that would remove any faults that existed previously which may have led to the complaint in the first place? I do not understand how that can work if we do not give that type of power to the ombudsman.
Comment on this
The determinations of the ombudsman are binding subject to an appeal to the High Court. The proposals the Deputy is making are not considered reasonable from the perspective of the pensions schemes and the employers as they could put at risk the viability of a scheme from a cost perspective. They could also lead to the closing down of schemes as employers might feel that they could not risk any case being referred to the ombudsman on any issue. The Deputy is putting a particular onus on the schemes which might cause them to fold up.
Comment on this
If the Minister made a determination under the rules which led to additional benefits being granted to the contributors in a scheme, surely he would not allow the same inappropriate rules to continue into the future. The issue of winding up a scheme may arise anyway because what would be the point of a scheme which the ombudsman has determined deprived people of benefits to which they are entitled? I do not like to hear the Minister raising the issue of cost but even in the debate we had last night we talked about giving a response to needs assessment for carers or people with a disability. If there are absolute rights to particular benefits guaranteed in legislation, the scheme in this case, by definition, would have to ensure those benefits accrued. Are we not restricting the power of the ombudsman in this case and therefore taking away from the large benefit that might flow from it? I understand that if the ombudsman criticises a particular scheme or PRSA, future providers will not make the same mistake, but how does that help people in existing schemes who believe they have been deprived of some benefits to which they are entitled?
Comment on this
The experience, particularly in the United Kingdom, has shown that we have to be careful on these issues because quite a number of schemes in the UK have closed down as a result of over-regulation. What we have put in here is a balance which will ensure that there is not a run on these schemes in the event of substantial complaints being made to the ombudsman which might end up in the High Court, with huge costs involved.
Comment on this
In relation to a standard PRSA or the way trustees might operate, does the Minister see it as part of the ombudsman's remit, say, five years from now or into the future, to have models of good practice in relation to determinations?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 74, lines 1 and 2, to delete "but shall not exceed any actual loss of benefit under the scheme or PRSA" and substitute "and shall have reference to the best known market indices which measure growth in value of equities, other investment products, property and gross domestic product".
This amendment relates to a determination in a case where the ombudsman is restricted to an actual loss of benefit. I tried to extend that to include the best possible indices of what could have been achieved under the scheme. I wondered how that would be calculated and whether there would be any actual loss of benefit. Surely the ombudsman would have to look at the market to some extent in relation to some investment products, but it is the same point I made in the debate on the first series of amendments, so I withdraw this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 75:
In page 74, line 37, to delete "Minister" and substitute "Pensions Ombudsman".
This amendment relates to the enforcement of determinations of the pensions ombudsman. There is a reference in line 37 to "the Minister". Why is the Minister making the application? Why is it not being made by the pensions ombudsman?
Comment on this
We felt it would be more appropriate for the Minister to do the enforcing, but I can have a look at that for Report Stage. The advice of the Attorney General's office was that it should be the Minister rather than the pensions ombudsman.
Comment on this
On the basis that the pensions ombudsman makes the determination and it is not being enforced.
Comment on this
If he makes a number of determinations, they will land back on the Minister's desk for enforcement.
Comment on this
Yes. That is why we are willing to look at it again. I am not sure what the precedent is for other areas but we will have to look at it.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will look at it with a view to putting a limit on it. It would be another cog in the wheel if the Minister was once again involved in enforcement. It should be a matter for the pensions ombudsman, not the Minister.
Comment on this
It would be challenged in the courts on the basis of a point of law. I do not know how else it can be determined. If a determination is made and it is not being enforced, I would have thought it would be the pensions ombudsman's job to enforce it.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 76 is in the name of Deputy Broughan. Amendment No. 77 is related so the proposal is to discuss amendments Nos. 76 and 77 together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 76, line 28, to delete "3" and substitute "2".
This is a little reminiscent of the first debate we had on Comhairle when the Minister set up a new office. I thought that in line 28, three years seems a long time in relation to the statement of strategy. Obviously the basic statement is submitted within a year and after that every three years. While pensions are a long-term investment the time could be shorter.
Comment on this
The reason three years was decided was that that is a standard period for the drafting of strategy statements for virtually all the agencies under our remit and, I think, most other Departments.
Comment on this
I wish to ask a question on section 141. Where the ombudsman makes a determination did the Minister consider telling someone to pay up, and in respect of a complaint being brought against a third party is there power to impose interest on those who do not comply in a sufficiently swift manner with the determination?
Comment on this
Under that section which allows someone to go to court, it would be open to the court to charge penalties.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 79:
In page 77, to delete lines 32 to 35.
The amendment relates to the staff of the pensions ombudsman. The provision contained in section 145(1)(b), which appears odd, reads: “The power of appointing a person to be an officer or servant of the Pensions Ombudsman shall be vested in the Minister.” I would have thought that if the ombudsman was making a proposal for an estimate of expenditure it would be up to him, not the Minister, to hire and fire people. If every additional appointment to the office has to go back to the Minister and the Department, that is over-regulation and is crazy.
Comment on this
No matter which way it is set up, that is the way it would have to be. Subsection (3) of the same section states: "The Minister may delegate to the Pensions Ombudsman the powers exercisable by him under the Civil Service Commissioners Act .. ." We are not setting up the ombudsman's office as a body corporate on its own. This is the exact same way it was done in relation to pension service ombudsmen. What we are doing is in line with the Civil Service Acts and no more. It is not to try to restrict the ombudsman in respect of staff. It is common procedure to do it this way.
Comment on this
We had a discussion earlier on Deputy Hayes's amendment, which we supported, in relation to the Oireachtas committee. In terms of the Committee of Public Accounts, would the ombudsman be the accounting officer of his own agency?
Comment on this
The Minister is setting this up in the context of the existing legislation for civil servants. Is that how it is done in the UK?
Comment on this
I am not suggesting the Minister would abuse this power but for future reference, if a Minister got into sticky water with an ombudsman for whatever reason, this power could be invoked to not appoint staff to the office. Consequently, he or she can decide at any time in the future not to appoint these additional staff. We are all aware of relationships breaking down between key officers and a Minister.
Comment on this
That is the way life is. If one wants to appoint staff one has to go through the Department of Finance. That is the reason it is set up in this way under the Civil Service Acts.
Comment on this
I wish to ask a question on section 145 which deals with disclosure of information. Does any of this come under the provisions of the Freedom of Information Act?
Comment on this
Are any of the other pension ombudsmen subject to FOI? I am not sure. We can check it.
Comment on this
I do not think they are because this is regarded as the last line. It is interesting, but to the best of my recollection the ombudsman is not subject to FOI. The idea of the ombudsman is the same as FOI.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 80:
In page 80, line 21, to delete "offence.'; and" and substitute the following:
"offence.
(b) Where a person of whom a requirement is made by the Pensions Ombudsman under subsection (1) or (2) of section 137 fails to comply with that requirement, he shall be guilty of an offence.’;
and".
This amendment arises directly on foot of an amendment on Report Stage in the Seanad. The purpose of the amendment in the Seanad was to allow pensions ombudsmen to bring proceedings for a summary offence under the Pension Acts in relation to his jurisdiction. This amendment reinserts the actual reference to the offence in the context of the ombudsman which was inadvertently omitted on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I welcome the fact that the Minister has included the rights of part-time workers in this section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 81:
In page 83, line 1, after "Minister" to insert "and the appropriate Oireachtas Committee".
We had a debate on this matter already. I am trying to get an involvement for the committee on all these matters that relate to the Act.
Comment on this
This amendment is not considered appropriate given the operation of the board in relation to its advisory role to the Minister. However, the board has appeared before committees of the Houses and will continue to do so. If an Oireachtas committee wished to ask for the board's advice on an issue it could do so directly or through the Minister, depending on the nature of the request.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 82:
In page 87, lines 1 and 2, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:
"(b) in subsection (2) by the substitution for ’paragraph 1 or 3 or both’ of ’any or all of paragraphs 2, 3 and 4’.”.
This is a technical amendment which rectifies an error in relation to quotation marks.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 83:
In page 87, to delete lines 50 and 51, and in page 88, to delete lines 1 to 23 and substitute the following:
"(i) in paragraph (b) by the substitution for ’for the purposes of this Act.’ of ’for the purposes of this Act, or’; and
(ii) by the insertion of the following paragraphs after paragraph (b):
'(c) in the making of a payment to another scheme which is not a funded scheme, which provides or is capable of providing long service benefit, of which he is a member or a prospective member and the trustees of which are willing to accept payments made under this paragraph, or
(d) where so prescribed, and in accordance with such conditions as may be prescribed, in the making of a payment to the trustees, custodians, managers or administrators of an arrangement for the provision of retirement benefits established within the State, not being an arrangement of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), (b) or (c), or
(e) where so prescribed, and in accordance with such conditions as may be prescribed, in the making of a payment to the trustees, custodians, managers or administrators of an arrangement for the provision of retirement benefits established outside the State.’;
and
(c) by the insertion in subsection (6) after ’subsection (3)(a)’ of ’or (c)’.”.
These amendments concern the issue of buy-out bonds which we debated earlier. A buy-out bond is an insurance policy designed to accept a transfer of payment from an occupational pension scheme. The intention in the Bill, as originally published, was to abolish buy-out bonds and replace them with PRSAs. However, these two amendments restore buy-out bonds in certain circumstances where they still have an important role to play. This arises from the policy decision to only allow moves from occupational pensions to PRSAs in certain defined circumstances, as set out in the tax provisions. Where a person has been a member of a pension scheme for over 15 years there cannot be a transfer of a preserved benefit to a PRSA but only to a buy-out bond.
Comment on this
I welcome that news. In the original proposal the Minister removed it. I assume there was a good deal of consultation about that.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 85 is related to amendment No. 84 and they be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 84:
In page 92, lines 43 and 44, to delete "(being such a certificate having an effective date after 1 June 2002)" and substitute "having an effective date after 1 June 2002".
These amendments are to clarify the provisions in relation to AFCs. The first amendment is to clarify that the reference is to the first AFC after 1 June 2002 and not the first AFC. The second amendment is to clarify that AFCs, actuarial funding certificates, with an effective date before June 2002 have a nine month period after 1 June 2002 when the old provisions in relation to AFCs continue to apply.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 85:
In page 93, to delete lines 16 to 26 and substitute the following:
"(a) where an actuarial funding certificate relates to an effective date not later than 1 June 2002, the specified percentage shall be 0 per cent,
(b) where an actuarial funding certificate relates to an effective date after 1 June 2002 but not later than 1 June 2012, the specified percentage shall be the certified percentage,
(c) where an actuarial funding certificate relates to an effective date after 1 June 2012 and on 1 June 2002 the scheme concerned was a funded scheme, the specified percentage shall be 100 per cent.’.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 86:
In page 95, to delete lines 22 to 26 and substitute the following:
"(b) the making of one or more payments under policies or contracts of assurance that are effected on behalf of the member with one or more undertakings (within the meaning of the Insurance Act, 1989) and that are approved by the Revenue Commissioners under Chapter 1 of Part 30 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which policies or contracts of assurance shall not be deemed to be an occupational pension scheme for the purposes of this Act, or
(c) where so prescribed, and in accordance with such conditions as may be prescribed, the making of a payment to the trustees, custodians, managers or administrators of an arrangements for the provision of retirement benefits established within the State, not being an arrangement of the kind mentioned in paragraphs (a) or (b),”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 87:
In page 98, line 26, to delete "to be equal" and substitute "that is so provided being equal".
This amendment is to ratify an inconsistency between the language used in section 56(a)(i) and 56(a)(ii)(b) which both set out the same type of guarantee that must be contained in the rules of an occupational scheme in order for a scheme to be exempt from the indexation provisions.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 88:
In page 100, to delete lines 20 to 52, and in page 101, to delete lines 1 to 8 and substitute the following:
"58A.-(1) An employer who deducts any sum from the wages or salary of an employee for remittance to the trustees of a scheme or to another person on their behalf, shall remit every such sum to the trustees or that other person on their behalf, as the case may be, within 21 days following the end of the month in which the deduction was made. An employer shall not make any deductions from the sum required to be remitted by him under this subsection.
(2) Where an employer is obliged (whether under a contract of employment, the terms of a scheme or otherwise) to pay any sum expressed as a cash amount or as a percentage or proportion of an employee's wages or salary (other than a sum deducted from the employee's wages or salary), on behalf of or in respect of that employee, to the trustees of a defined contribution scheme or to another person on their behalf, he shall, within 21 days following the end of every month, pay to the trustees of the scheme or that other person on their behalf, as the case may be, a sum equal to the appropriate cash amount or percentage or proportion of every payment of wages or salary made to that employee during that month. An employer shall not make any deduction from the sum required to be paid by him under this subsection.
(3) An employer who-
(a) deducts any sum from the wages or salary of an employee for remittance to the trustees of a scheme or to another person on their behalf, or
(b) is obliged (whether under a contract of employment, the terms of a scheme or otherwise) to pay any sum, on behalf of or in respect of an employee (other than a sum deducted from the employee’s wages or salary), to the trustees of a defined contribution scheme or to another person on their behalf,
shall give or cause to be given to the employee concerned and to the trustees or that other person on their behalf, a statement in writing not less frequently than once a month specifying-
(i) the total amount deducted from the employee's salary or wages and remitted to the trustees or that other person on their behalf, as the case may be, and
(ii) where appropriate, the total amount paid, on behalf of or in respect of the employee (other than any amount deducted from the employee's wages or salary), to the trustees or that other person on their behalf, as the case may be,".
This amendment relates to the remittance of PRSA contributions by employers and trustees. Section 41 places a statutory requirement on employers to remit employee and certain employer pension contributions within 21 days of the end of the month in which the deductions were made where employee contributions are concerned and to give monthly statements of the deductions to the employee and trustees.
These amendments arose from certain concerns raised in the Seanad debate. The first amendment arose from the use of the term "administrator" and the term "manager". It was felt that these terms were not broad enough to encompass the circumstances for which they were envisaged.
In amendment No. 89, I propose the trustees will have to invest the moneys they receive within ten days of when they should have been paid over by the employer. Overall, this would give a maximum of 31 days from the end of the month in which the payment was made by the employee to when the money was applied for his or her benefit by the trustees. This arose from the points made by Senator Ross in the debate in the Seanad.
Comment on this
That arose from points that were made by a gentleman in Galway who had been watching the proceedings on the Bill. The Minister included a stipulation of 21 days, that an employer must hand over the moneys within 21 days. Within how many days did the Minister say this provision will ensure the administrator must invest the moneys?
Comment on this
This provision will ensure that the administrator will not be able to hang on to this money.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 89:
In page 101, line 30, after "received" to insert "and that the sums referred to in subsection (1) or (2) of section 58A are invested in accordance with paragraph (b) within 10 days of the latest date on which those sums should have been remitted or paid by the employer under subsection (1) or (2), as the case may be, of section 58A”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 90:
In page 101, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:
"(c) to ensure that where an ongoing surplus exists in an occupational pension scheme, an employer shall continue to make his normal contributions and shall not take a so-called contribution holiday;”.
This is an amendment to section 59 of the Principal Act dealing with the general duties of trustees of schemes, which involve the proper investment of resources, membership and the keeping of proper records. In this amendment I seek to address the problem brought to my attention concerning a number of schemes in which there is an ongoing surplus and where, by virtue of that, employers might take advantage by stopping the payment of due contributions for a period. I am talking about the rules governing schemes. What I propose in this amendment may be covered. Many pensioners are upset about the management of surplus funds in such schemes and feel they should be passed on to them as the people who made the contributions rather than used, perhaps, to some extent, to facilitate a stronger balance sheet for the company. This amendment proposes to include in the list of the general duties of trustees of schemes reference to how surpluses should be treated, having regard to the experience of contributors to such famous pension schemes as the Ford Motor Company, Guinness and others, who were strongly of the view that surpluses had not been dealt with favourably towards contributors.
Comment on this
As we discussed on amendment No. 10, occupational pensions operate on a voluntary basis. This proposal regarding a surplus in a scheme and the employer not being allowed to take a contribution holiday would lead to the disappearance of surpluses in the schemes. As the Deputy is aware, in the defined scheme it is the employer, not the employee, who takes the risk and must make up the balance of the cost if there is a shortfall. I accept that there are issues regarding surplus and I have tried to address this in section 39 dealing with indexation of pensions and payments. There has been a good deal of debate and discussion in the UK and, to some extent, here regarding the treatment of surpluses and deficits in pension schemes from an accounting point of view. This may lead to the demise of the defined benefit schemes. The Deputy's proposal would have a similar effect and I must, therefore, oppose the amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 91:
In page 101, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:
"(c) to ensure that payments from an occupational pension fund shall be indexed to a level not less than increases in gross average industrial earnings;”.
This amendment also relates to the duties of trustees of schemes. I tabled it in response to a number of submissions I and most other Deputies received in the run-up to the taking of this Bill. The Minister referred to the provision for indexation in section 39. That would be an improvement on the current position. In this amendment I seek to ensure that the basic benefits are indexed to a level, as was sought during the debate last night. We are trying to index the benefit to the level of 27% or 30%. The NIPI report urged that 34% should be the basic index level. There was grave dissatisfaction with the position over the years. We spoke about the extent to which public sector employees will raise with the ombudsman when that office comes on stream some of these key pension issues such as parity and indexation. The last major demonstration I attended in this regard was the mass meeting of Aer Lingus and Aer Rianta pensioners who felt that the owners of these companies and the Government had not ensured that level of benefits was commensurate with the rise in income of existing employees and that they were being left behind.
We were happy to make a major commitment in that regard on behalf of the Labour Party and it is one I hope the Government wil l also take on board. Again, I am not sure if this is the most appropriate area to do so. The three issues are that the trustees should have some duties in relation to surpluses, indexation and the integration of schemes, with the famous clawback. The second amendment relates to indexation.
Comment on this
I agree that all occupational pension schemes should provide for indexation of pensions and payments and I believe we addressed this, in so far as we could, in section 39. It is probably a more appropriate and safer way to do it. The Deputy's proposal would impose a mandatory requirement in a voluntary regime and set this requirement at the level of increases and earnings which is not in keeping with the practice at present where indexation is provided. This usually relates to the lower rate of 4% and the CPI. Many public service schemes provide indexation related to earnings but these are seen as top-up provisions and would be extremely expensive to replicate in the private sector. This would have huge funding implications which would, again, lead to the demise of the fine benefit schemes.
Comment on this
In the future we will look at earnings and salaries. The National Centre for Partnership, under Peter Cassells, is starting the debate on the next programme. There were some innovations in the current programme where issues such as child benefit and so forth were addressed. What we are doing today also probably came within that remit. In that context, therefore, the real costs of business must include pension provision for employees if that is the case, it should be on the table as an issue that trustees would be responsible for this.
Comment on this
I agree but I cannot accept the amendment. I agree it is an issue that should be discussed in the new partnership agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 92:
In page 101, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:
"(c) to ensure than in any integrated payment of an occupational pension scheme with the state contributory scheme, that the employer shall only deduct the state pension from the occupational pension on a pro-rata basis in accordance with the percentage of the employer’s PRSI contribution and in a case of early retirement or redundancy, the state pension claw back shall be equal to the state pension’s value at the date of retirement or redundancy;”.
This is the third part of the extra duties that many pensioners, certainly those who made representations to the Labour Party, and trade union leaders would wish us to add to the duties of trustees under Part 6 of the Pensions Act. I am seeking to ensure integration. We have had the practice of deducting the State pension from an occupational pension. This practice of integration of the two systems is considered to be most unfair and, to some extent, to be defeating the purpose of what we are trying to do, which is to extend provision to include both the State pension and the occupational pension.
I am seeking that in any integrated payment of an occupational pension scheme with the State contributory pension the employer shall only deduct the State pension from the occupational pension on a pro rata basis in accordance with the percentage of the employer’s PRSI contribution. Pensioners have asked why they are not entitled to their segment of PRSI free of any impediment on their occupational pension. In the case of early retirement or redundancy, the State pension clawback should be equal to the State pension’s value at the date of retirement or redundancy. When an employee retires or is made redundant at 55 years of age, the State pension clawback, in fairness, should be frozen at its value then. While the company pension does not become active until the normal retirement age of 65, current policy is that the employer deducts the State pension at its value at the normal retirement age of 65 rather than its value at the actual date of retirement or redundancy, even though the person would not have paid PRSI in the intervening ten years.
An advocate for a number of famous pension schemes says that a State pension deduction should be at the value of the time of retirement or redundancy, 55 as in this example, pro rata in accordance with PRSI contribution. As an exercise, he says, one can compare State pension provision today against pension provision ten years ago. He strongly believes that State pension rates should be frozen at the age of early retirement or redundancies. His submission points up a huge issue, the integration of occupational pensions with State pensions. In so far as it is possible, we should try to reach a situation where people will have the second pillar. A number of people who were public sector workers in the semi-State sector and who retired at a relatively young age are in the fortunate position of having enough insurance to have a full State pension as well as their occupational pension, and that is good. We should encourage people to make the widest possible provision. This is an area I was anxious to highlight. Perhaps it should be addressed in the future in the context of the duties of trustees.
Comment on this
The issue of integration has received more focus because of the significant increases in social welfare pensions in recent times. In previous Social Welfare Acts I banned post-retirement integration to ensure it could not be introduced. The issue of integration at the point of retirement was discussed extensively by the commission on public service pensions which reported in 2000. While there were many areas of non-agreement in that commission, I understand its members all agreed to the principle of integration. This was because it allows an employer to top up the social welfare pension to provide an earnings related one.
There are issues regarding the operation of integration and I have asked the Pensions Board to examine them further. I do not agree with the Deputy's proposal because there could be unintended negative outcomes as a result. However, like other Members, I believe it is incongruous that people's State pension should be clawed back because of the increases.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 95 and 96 are alternatives to amendment No. 94 while amendments Nos. 96 and 97 form a related composite proposal and amendment No. 98 is also related. Amendments Nos. 94 to 98, inclusive, may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 94:
In page 108, line 44, and in page 109, lines 1 to 14, to delete paragraphs (a) and (c) and substitute the following:
"(a) the substitution in paragraph 2 of ’16’ for ’14’;
(b) the substitution for clauses (g) and (h) of paragraph 8(1) of the following:
'(g) one shall be a representative of consumer interests,
(h) one shall be a representative of pensioner interests,
(i) one shall be a representative of the Minister for Finance, and
(j) one shall be a representative of the Minister.’;
and
(c) the insertion after subparagraph (7) of paragraph 8 of the following:
'(7A) The member of the Board representing consumer interests shall be a person nominated for appointment thereto by the Minister or such organisation or organisations as the Minister considers to be representative of consumer organisations.
(7B) The member of the Board representing pensioner interests shall be a person nominated for appointment thereto by the Minister or such organisation or organisations as the Minister considers to be representative of pensioner organisations.'.".
I am providing for representatives of consumer and pensioner interests to be added to the Pensions Board. This will give a better balance to the board. I considered the various representations made to me in regard to other interested groups and I am satisfied with these proposals. I decided to bring forward a proposal, following the debate in the Seanad, in relation to including a representative of pensioners' interests. It is ludicrous that we do not have a pensioner on the board. While I am reluctant to extend the numbers on the board, we need to have somebody representing pensioners.
Comment on this
I propose to put another member on it. The Minister will have received representations from the insurance brokers. They feel aggrieved they have been omitted, given that actuaries, solicitors, accountants and insurance companies are represented. They believe they have a specific insight into the market. I have been told that about 90% of all single premium pensions are sold through insurance brokers and that 50% of all self-employed personal pensions and about 70% of individual and group pensions are sold through brokers. They make the point that there is a distinction between insurance companies and insurance brokers. They have asked that we might consider their inclusion on this board. These will be the key people in selling the product ultimately and they make the point that they have an input to make in policy that the board will be considering.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 98, which was written initially in long-hand, should read "the insurance brokering industry", instead of "banking". I welcome what the Minister is doing, particularly concerning pensioners' representatives. It would be ludicrous not to have a pensioners' representative on the board. The ICTU's pensioners' body or the Senior Citizens' Parliament could nominate a member for the board. Consumers' interests should be represented on the board as strongly as possible. On the existing Pensions Board there are some fine representatives of various areas of society, but there should be at least one pensioners' representative.
I concur with Deputy Hayes on the brokering industry. I met representatives of PIBA a few days after the Minister published the Bill and I received a good briefing from them on many issues. I dealt with the Minister's staff on those issues over the following three or four months and the Minister has now addressed most of the issues about which PIBA's representatives were upset. They were afraid because of what had happened in the United Kingdom where big companies squeezed out the small personal insurance advisers.
Most of us are dependent on having good local advice on insurance, from cars to homes. In such cases, it is important to have a good personal relationship, such as one would have with a doctor or solicitor. The insurance brokering industry fulfils a useful role in that regard. Some years ago, people were upset when one of the founders of the brokering industry disappeared without trace in what seemed to be a breach of trust. If the job is done well, however, it can play an important role. While I am conscious that we cannot incur extra cost on the Exchequer by extending the size of the board, there should be an insurance broker on the board. Given the quality of the industry representatives we have met, it would be a great asset to the Pensions Board.
Comment on this
I have some sympathy with that position but I am constantly being criticised that there are far too many pension industry interests on the board. I received an earful from certain Members of the Seanad in that respect. The Irish Association of Pension Funds is represented, as is the Irish Insurance Federation which is aware of the views of brokers. There are also pension lawyers, accountants and actuaries whose knowledge of the insurance sector is very helpful to the board. I am reluctant, therefore, to add yet another representative. I am not saying that the Irish Insurance Federation represents brokers but it has the general view of the insurance industry. I have been, and am, reluctant to extend the board in respect of the industry's interests. If I had my way I would be more inclined to make the board more representative of consumers' and pensioners' interests. At the same time I recognise that it is a specialist board and one needs specialist opinions on it.
Comment on this
The Minister would accept that many of the observations that have been made by PIBA and other organisations have been helpful to the Bill in trying to streamline the legislation and make it more effective. We are all thick-skinned about these things. The brokers are a distinct group involved in selling these products and their voice should be represented on the board. They would bring something to the board over and above what is involved in the larger insurance companies. The Minister should consider this matter between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
How does the Minister think the sale of PRSAs will develop? Does he think there will be consolidation? I note the merger that has occurred between Irish Permanent, the TSB and Irish Life which is the controlling company under Mr. David Went. Branches of the TSB are oriented towards direct sales. The company seems to be initiating a policy where sales of insurance products directly to banking or building society customers will take place. Does the Minister expect that things will happen in that way? That appears to be what happened in the United Kingdom where the brokering industry was bypassed.
Comment on this
I would not think so. I do not think we are doing anything in this Bill that would assist that. At the same time, we are trying to create an open market whereby as many providers and others selling the product will be there. There is nothing in the Bill that brokers need to fear. In putting a brokers' representative on the board I could come under pressure to put other industry interests on the board. I have been criticised, as has the board, because it is regarded as being top heavy with people. While I might say it is useful to have a pension lawyer on the board, the accusation has been made that they are there for a reason, to look after their interests. Similarly, as regards actuaries, it is said that there is a quid pro quo for their advice on the board.
I suppose everyone who goes on the board would have a particular perspective, and equally so if the brokers went on it. First and foremost, they would look after the interests of their members. I would rather see more people representing consumers and pensioners on boards such as this. Obviously, there has to be a balance. Five pension industry people out of 17 is significant when one takes into account that there are four social partner representatives, two Department representatives and three ministerial nominees. However, there will now be five ministerial nominees, two of whom will have to be consumer and pensioner representatives.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 95 and 96 are alternatives to amendment No. 94, so if amendment No. 94 is agreed to, amendments Nos. 95 and 96 cannot be moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 97:
In page 109, between lines 14 and 15, to insert the following:
"(7B) The member of the Board representing the Insurance Broking profession shall be a person nominated for appointment thereto by such organisation or organisations as the Minister considers to be representative of the insurance broking profession.'.".
I will withdraw the amendment and come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 98:
In page 109, between lines 14 and 15, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) The Minister shall take such steps as are necessary to ensure that of the members of the Board determined by the First Schedule to the Principal Act, as amended by this section, at least two shall represent consumer interests, one shall represent a national pensioner's representative body and one shall represent the insurance banking industry.".
I will withdraw the amendment for the moment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 99:
In page 117, after line 39, to insert the following new section:
"60.-(1) For the purposes of persons who obtain short-term employment contracts within the public sector, nothing shall prevent such persons from continuing to make contributions to the pension scheme or pension plan that they contributed to prior to the taking up of employment within the public sector.
(2) In this section 'short-term employment contracts' has the meaning of a contract in any part of the public sector for not more than 5 years.".
This issue has been brought to my attention. Under existing legislation, an individual can only be a member of one pension scheme at a time. The public sector requires compulsory participation in its pension scheme for all employees. Traditionally, employment in the public sector was a life-long arrangement. Even when public sector employees took secondment arrangements to other State sponsored agencies, arrangements were put in place to maintain their pension contribution at their original employment level.
In recent years, as a result of SMI and other measures to "professionalise" certain Civil Service functions traditionally carried out by general civil servants trained for certain jobs, professional candidates have been more frequently recruited externally specifically for certain jobs over a certain timeframe. Generally, these contracts are between three and five years. However, regardless of the potential recruit's previous employment and pension arrangements, as I understand it, the State requires compulsory participation in the State pension scheme.
In real terms, this means that a potential employee with ten years' experience in the private sector and a personal pension plan applying for a three year contract in a public sector agency is at a relative disadvantage. A public sector employee applying for the same job would be employed on secondment with his or her previous pension arrangements maintained by the new employer. However, the private sector employee would be required to suspend his or her personal pension plan and to compulsorily participate in the State scheme even though his or her contract arrangements make him or her an unestablished civil servant with no security of tenure longer than the duration of the contract.
Where there is movement from the public sector to the private sector, it is viewed among some at least that there is discrimination in the practice of how the pension arrangements are put in place. More flexibility in the labour market means that it is possible for people to move between private sector and public sector jobs. Employees who cross between the public sector and the private sector during their careers are in danger of ending up under-pensioned and, as a result, suspending their personal pension plan once or more often. The net point behind this amendment is that people who join the Civil Service for a period of three to five years must, as was suggested to me, automatically participate in the State pension scheme.
Comment on this
We can check it but I would have thought that would have been part of the contract under which they take up employment with the State. I would not have thought they would have been absolutely obliged to participate.
Comment on this
Would they be able to transfer their former pension plan to the Department or agency in which they are working?
Comment on this
I do not know if they can do that. I would have thought that would be suspended. We will have a look at that. If one moves from the Civil Service to the private sector, one cannot do that because one would have to resign from the Civil Service.
Comment on this
There is a new unestablished category of civil servant, that is, people who come into the service for a number of years. It was brought to my attention some months ago that a person had moved into the Civil Service and had this difficulty in terms of pension cover.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Deputy will give us the details. We will look at it now that the Deputy has raised the point.
Comment on this
No. There was a room on my corridor which used to be full of computers, faxes and so on, but we got rid of that because that was the cabal. There is only one.
Comment on this
No, not in the Minister's Department but in other Departments. He does not have consultants at the moment.
Comment on this
I would like to signal that on Report Stage, I intend to bring forward a small number of technical amendments to deal with custodian arrangements, society of actuary guidelines and the access to PRSA contributors to the ombudsman. As we are still receiving technical views on the Bill, some clarification amendments may be required. If so, I will bring these forward on Report Stage. In addition, specific issues were raised by Deputies today and I have undertaken to review these.
Comment on this
I hope so. I thank the Minister and his officials, the people from the Revenue Commissioners and the Pensions Board, Mr. Long from the Irish Insurance Federation and the members, particularly the two spokespersons, for efficiently getting through all the work.