Finance Bill, 1998: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–142 of 391. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 8 of 1998 ›
As there is a quorum present the meeting can commence. I welcome the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, and the officials from his Department and those from the Office of the Revenue Commissioners.
The Select Committee will now consider the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, 1998. I remind Members that under an allocation of time motion agreed by the Dáil last week we are obliged to conclude proceedings on specific sections of the Bill not later than the time set out in the motion already circulated. Today's proceedings will conclude not later than 8 p.m., taking us up to and including sections 43 to 49.
It is proposed to group the following amendments for the purposes of debate: Nos. 1, 2 and 3; Nos. 5 to 10, inclusive; Nos. 11, 26 and 28; Nos. 12 to 25, inclusive, and Nos. 156 to 164, inclusive; Nos. 37 and 73; Nos. 38 and 39; Nos. 51, 52 and 53; Nos. 56 and 57; Nos. 60, 61 and 63; Nos. 65 - amendments Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive, to amendment No. 65 - 66, 67 and 68; Nos. 79 to 86, inclusive, Nos. 94 and 95 and Nos. 96 and 97. All other amendments not listed above and in order will be discussed individually.
There will be a sos from 12.45 p.m. to 2.30 p.m. Is that agreed? Agreed. Tomorrow the Select Committee's deliberations will commence at 10.30 a.m. and there will be a sos from 12.45 p.m. to 2.30 p.m. Is that agreed? Agreed. Under the allocation of time motion the proceedings tomorrow will conclude at 4.30 p.m. It is also proposed that there will be a sos from 6 p.m. to 6.30 p.m. this evening. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 1, 2 and 3 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 11, paragraph (a), line 23, to delete '"8,200' and '£4,000'" and substitute "'£9,000' and '£4,500'".
A number of amendments, some of which are extensive, arrived late. On a volume basis the book of amendments, which contains a number of Opposition amendments, is almost as large as the Finance Bill. While we can make political arguments in respect of the amendments, this gives us very little time to scrutinise them from a technical point of view. The committee should closely scrutinise amendments put forward by the Minister for Finance but we have been unable to do so because of their late arrival. When I arrived at Leinster House at 9 a.m. I sought the draft amendments from the Bills Office but they were not available until 9.40 a.m. We received advance copies from the Minister for Finance but this set of amendments was not available to Members until 20 minutes before the meeting commenced. We cannot do the job vested in us by the Houses of the Oireachtas when documentation is late arriving.
I am not trying to start an argument. However, any agreement I give to amendments tabled in the name of the Minster for Finance is conditional on my retaining the right to re-enter amendments on Report Stage. I am aware there are technical problems about tabling amendments on Report Stage. However, I reserve the right to re-enter amendments on Report Stage in respect of ministerial amendments. I am using that as a safety clause and I do not want to have to repeat it as each ministerial amendment is moved.
Amendments Nos. 1, 2 and 3 are consistent with other amendments tabled in my name in respect of the income tax sections of the Bill. They apply narrowly to exemption limits but they are consistent with the philosophy I advocate in respect of the budget and the Finance Bill and they are at variance with the Minister's approach. The Minister should have given significant increases in exemption limits and used his resources to increase personal allowances and widen the bands. That is the approach of all amendments tabled in my name in connection with bands, allowances and exemption limits.
In reply to Question No. 22 in the Dáil yesterday, the Minister agreed once more that the budget will oblige an additional percentage of taxpayers to pay tax at the higher rate. He made a commitment in the programme for Government to progressing to a point where only 20 per cent of taxpayers will pay tax at the higher rate. At present, in excess of 38 per cent of taxpayers will pay tax at this rate. The Minister has moved in the opposite direction to the commitment he gave in the programme for Government. The amendments tabled in my name to the income tax sections of the Bill are an attempt to reverse the position. However, they also serve the purpose of illustrating what would have happened if the Minister had adopted a different approach.
For reasons of equity, ensuring that people who are less well off are removed from the tax net completely and ensuring that those on lower levels of income are rewarded adequately when they return to work, the exemption limits should be raised by much more than the Minister has advocated. The Government proposes to increase the married exemption limits by £200 whereas Fine Gael proposes an increase of £1,000. The Government proposes to increase the single exemption by £100 and Fine Gael proposes to increase it by £200. The same philosophy applies to the other amendments. Our approach would increase personal allowances. If personal allowances were indexed for inflation this year a single person's allowance would have to be increased by £116. The Government proposes to increase it by £250 - about twice the level of inflation. We believe that the personal allowances should be increased by £1,000.
With regard to the bands, indexing for inflation would require an increase of £198 for a single person but the Government only proposes to increase the standard band for a single person by £100. In the year when the Minister had the greatest resources ever available to a Minister for Finance he proposes to increase the bands by only half of what would be required to index for inflation. The same applies pro rata to married persons. Indexing the exemption limits for inflation would have required £80 for a single person and the Government proposes £100, barely above the rate of inflation increase.
If the desire is for equity and an impact at the lower end of the labour market to return people to work in which they will be rewarded, the Minister's approach is wrong. With regard to paying at the higher rate of tax the Fine Gael proposals would give a person another £1,500 of income taxed at the standard rate. According to the Minister's proposal a person would only have £350 extra at the standard rate. Indexing for inflation would require an increase of £314. These figures are based on married persons.
Our proposals on the bands, rates and exemption limits are more equitable. People on modest and middle incomes would gain substantially more. The proposals would have a greater effect on the labour force enabling people to stay in low paid work yet have a reasonable take-home pay. They would also achieve the Minister's stated objective for the reform of income tax in a faster and more efficient way, that is, that substantially more people would pay tax at the standard rate. Our figures are not made up. We have reallocated the resources the Minister proposes to apply to reducing the rates of income tax to personal bands, allowances and exemption limits. It is a much better package.
We advocate a different approach. The main problem with the tax code is not that the higher rate is 46 or 48 per cent, but that people on modest incomes pay at the higher rate. The issue is the jump from paying at the standard rate to paying at the higher rate, from 25 to 48 per cent as is was last year, at a gross income of about £14,000. This is the issue that affects the labour market. It is inequitable and discourages emigrants from returning to take up jobs in high tech industries.
Not only has the Minister failed to address the issue, he has increased the standard rate band for the single person by £100 which is significantly less that would be required to index for inflation or £198 which is twice what the Minister proposes. When the Minister is asked what progress has been made to ensure he fulfils his objectives of having only 20 per cent of taxpayers paying at the higher rate, is it any wonder he is embarrassed when the movement is in the other direction? According to the Minister's figures there will 15,000 more taxpayers paying at the higher rate than in the 1997-8 tax year.
The Minister might consider us dishonest in proposing concessions to the taxpayer on the basis of the resources the Minister has allocated while not proposing amendments to reduce the rates. However, the Minister knows that if we propose amendments to reduce the rates they will be ruled out of order because they will be taken as an increased imposition on taxpayers rather than a reduction. According to the rules of debate we are not in a position to propose such amendments. I do not intend to clutter up the debate with amendments which will be ruled out of order. That would only be a pretence.
The Minister should get the Progressive Democrats monkey off his back and take the action he wants to take himself. He should follow the Fine Gael position as advocated during the last election, a position with which the Minister's party agreed until a week before polling when it reversed engines and allowed itself to be dominated by a minor party which is heading for redundancy.
Comment on this
With regard to the exemption limits, I agree with the points made by Deputy Noonan. The main difficulty between the Minister and the Opposition is the reason we have embarked on income tax reduction. There is a variety of reasons income tax should be reduced but the relevant reason in the context of the amendments on exemption limits is the interaction of the social welfare system and income tax.
The Minister will be aware of the inelegantly named 'TWIG' report of several years ago which recommended that the gap between personal allowances and exemption limits should be closed incrementally. It should be closed primarily because there is a difficulty with the number of people on marginal relief - at the time of that report the figure was about 16 or 17 per cent but I am sure it has reduced since. Is the Minister committed to implementing the TWIG report in relation to closing the gap between personal allowances and exemption limits. No progress in that regard seems to have been made in the budget and the Finance Bill. Does he intend to do so in future years?
Comment on this
In the grouping of the amendments I see no reference to my amendment No. 27 which relates to cohabiting couples and the attempt to bring the tax code into line with the social welfare code which regards a man and woman who are married or a man and woman who are not married but who cohabit as man and wife in the same manner. They are treated one way for social welfare and another for tax purposes. We were told for many years to wait for the divorce referendum before the anomaly could be dealt with.
Comment on this
The advice I have is that the amendment proposes a new section and it will be dealt with as such.
Comment on this
There is merit in trying to address the totality of personal income tax amendments at this stage, but we are discussing Deputy Noonan's amendments in respect of the exemption threshold. It is difficult to address personal income tax without looking at the architecture of such tax as a whole. The architecture I propose is slightly different in the sense that it concentrates on personal tax allowances and widening bands rather than on the exemption limit. The net effect is the same and the thrust is to concentrate the money that was available to the Minister on lower to middle income earners rather than on high earners, which is what he did.
The Minister inherited an unprecedentedly propitious financial situation. He had more money at his disposal than any Minister for Finance in the history of the State and chose to give the benefit of this to high and super earners. He had the opportunity to concentrate on hard pressed middle income earners and to take people on low incomes out of the tax net. We already know from a reply to a parliamentary question that he has increased the number of people paying tax at the marginal rate. It has increased from 37 per cent last year to 38.2 per cent for the coming fiscal year. The Minister may say people are paying 46 per cent tax instead of 48 per cent but the point is are they paying 26 per cent or 24 per cent? As a result of the Minister's actions 1.2 per cent more taxpayers will pay tax at the higher rate than before the budget.
There are a number of aspects we wish to deal with in terms of the detail of the different areas of exemption thresholds, tax bands and personal allowances but the thrust of the argument from the three parties present and, indeed, from the pre-budget consensus of the social partners and various community organisations, such as the Combat Poverty Agency, was that fiscal returns ought to benefit low and middle income earners, but the Minister did the opposite.
Comment on this
On Committee Stage of the previous three Finance Bills, various technical amendments were discussed in private session by the committee and experts debated those points.
I refer to the question of amendments raised by Deputy Noonan and by Deputy Rabbitte in the House earlier. Substantive amendments regarding urban renewal, cross border workers and other matters were distributed last Thursday to the Opposition. I know Deputy Noonan and others received them, but I do not know whether Deputy Rabbitte did.
Comment on this
I checked at 7.50 p.m. last Friday and had not received them. I received them yesterday, but there may have been a reason for that.
Comment on this
All Deputies received them on Thursday. A number of Deputies were interviewed on local radio about certain aspects of the amendments.
Comment on this
I am talking about the two largest amendments, the 66 page ones. I received the other amendments.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte also issued a press release yesterday which referred to 84 page amendments. The major amendments related to urban and rural renewal. His colleague in the previous Government, Deputy McManus, had responsibility for urban renewal and in these amendments tax concessions for urban renewal are repeated. The rural renewal initiative necessitates a large amount of legislation but the principles involved are simple. I remind the Deputy when the Credit Union Bill, 1996, was introduced, he tabled more than 100 amendments.
Comment on this
That is how I stayed out of trouble with them in a way in which the Minister failed to do.
Comment on this
As the Deputy said, having stayed out of trouble with them "I just gave in". Is that correct? The Deputy may answer if he likes.
Deputy Noonan missed Question Time yesterday during which I replied to some of the matters raised. I am sure he had important matters to take care of in Limerick East. For future Ministers for Finance, I will have a sign over the Department which will read "Beware of credit unions" similar to signs outside houses which read "Beware of mad dogs."
Comment on this
The Minister should correct the record or it will get him into difficulty again. He would be much better off not to describe the credit unions as mad dogs. He cannot be advised.
Comment on this
Some Opposition amendments arrived to the Department as late as 10 p.m. yesterday. There should be balance to the argument.
Comment on this
We do not have the Revenue Commissioners and the Department of Finance. We still only have one secretary.
Comment on this
Many Deputies are interested in the rural renewal sections. Where are they to be inserted in the Bill?
Comment on this
It seems it will be inserted around section 60. Will it be discussed this evening or tomorrow? It is crucial to a number of colleagues.
Comment on this
Then it is likely there will be little time to debate it. Effectively, it is a new section which will be the last one discussed this evening. Will it become section 59a or a new section 60?
Comment on this
In Part 1 there will be new sections 60 and 61. The amount of time available to debate them will depend on the progress of business. From previous experience, business tends to speed up and we do not always reach the end of scheduled business before concluding deliberations. There may be adequate time for debate.
Comment on this
I want the Chairman to give us good information on this before lunch. We agreed already to cover sections 1 to 59. Now we find something of major political interest to Deputies across the political divide will be inserted as new sections 60 and 61. We agreed we would move on from old section 60 tomorrow. It is not enough to reach a guillotine at 8 o'clock this evening. This matter must be debated.
Comment on this
Deputy Noonan's amendment seeks to increase the income tax exemption limit to £4,500 for a single person and £9,000 for a married couple. The cost of this amendment would be £11.2 million in 1998 and £22.3 million in a full year. In my budget I have allotted over £500 million in personal tax cuts and have taken the first significant step to meet the commitments set out in the Government's action programme. This Government recognises the need to reduce the burden of personal taxation to reward effort and to give people the incentive to take up work. All taxpayers will benefit from this year's tax package and it will remove around 15,000 taxpayers from the tax net. This package represents the Government's commitment to reduce the tax burden on the low paid. We genuinely wish to achieve greater equity in the tax system and to ensure that all taxpayers pay a fair amount of tax based on their level of income. In line with the commitments in the Government's action programme, this process will continue as a priority over the coming years. In these circumstances I cannot accept the amendment.
The debate about bands and allowances versus income tax cuts has gone on during and subsequent to the last general election and subsequent to the budget on 3 December last. I outlined on a number of occasions my views on this matter and outlined them again as late as Question Time yesterday in answer to Opposition questions. Of the £517 million in personal tax cuts which I announced in the budget, £104 million, or 20 per cent of the total package, went towards reducing the top tax rate from 48 per cent to 46 per cent.
There has been an amazing debate on bands versus cuts. Some people are trying to reverse the result of the last general election, which was fought on pretty clear grounds as regards taxation. Politicians do not usually like losing an election but they must accept it. Well before the election campaign I, as spokesperson for Fianna Fáil, announced our package. We said we would reduce the top rate of taxation over the lifetime of the Government from 48 per cent to 42 per cent and reduce the standard rate from 26 per cent to 20 per cent. That was put fairly before the Irish people. The Progressive Democrats had somewhat similar objectives in its tax plan. The then Rainbow Government, through its individual parties, announced a different plan. As Deputy Noonan rightly pointed out, the debate in the election revolved around bands and allowances.
Apart from the election result, which gave Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats a mandate to go into Government, if one studies the polls during the campaign on the four issues consistently put to the people - Northern Ireland, crime, taxation and employment - on all but one of them the difference between the Government and the Opposition narrowed. I cannot remember who was in front at the end of the campaign on some of those issues but on three of them the gap was insignificant - we were ahead on some, the then Government was ahead on others. Taxation was the exception. Despite a hostile media reception for the Fianna Fáil plan and adverse remarks from commentators who supported the Rainbow Government line - although there were a few who supported our proposals - Fianna Fáil was ahead on the taxation issue from the beginning of the campaign to the end.
That is somewhat irrelevant, but then we had the general election which decided the matter. If democracy is to mean anything, we must acknowledge the election is over and that we won it on this package. In my budget I have set about implementing what we said we would do during the election. I do not mind politicians giving out about this and have no objection to Deputy Noonan making an issue of it because that is his job. What I find extraordinary is that some outside commentators on Irish politics seem to object to abiding by democracy. This is a new, à la carte approach to democracy by some commentators who did not like these proposals during the campaign, did not like the result and now object to the Government implementing what was decided by the people.
Deputy Noonan and others have made interesting points about this budget favouring the rich. In a speech last week I made a comment - to which Vincent Browne gives adequate space this morning - about what the Conference of Religious Superiors said about the Rainbow Government's budgets, in particular the 1997 budget, which I will have no hesitation in reading into the record if people wish me to do so.
Comment on this
Is the Minister reading Vincent Browne's article into the record? I hear enough of him every evening without that.
Comment on this
I am not reading him into the record at the moment. I am talking about what the Conference of Religious Superiors said about the 1995, 1996 and 1997 budgets of the Rainbow Government, presented by Deputy Quinn, which is remarkably similar to what it said about my budget of 3 December.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte should know more about that than most because he repeats phrases often enough. On the Second Stage of this Bill he read into the record what CORI said about my budget and when I replied last week in the Dáil, I read into the record what it said about Deputy Quinn's last budget in 1997. In this morning's paper Mr. Browne repeats not only what CORI said about the 1997 budget but also its remarks on the 1995 and 1996 budgets. That is all good political play and we will leave it at that. I hope we are all people of common sense but some people outside with to reverse the result of the election.
Comment on this
It is a genuine point of order because I am in some difficulty in that I attempted to address the individual amendments and talked about exemption limits, which the Minister has so far not addressed. I did not address the broader issue but I wish to. I want to ensure I have the opportunity to do so without being penalised.
Comment on this
Deputy Noonan started me on this topic because he went off on a tangent. I note that Deputy McDowell did not get involved in that but he is entitled to come back.
Some of the debate has revolved around the rich versus the poor. As I pointed out in reply to a question yesterday and in my Second Stage reply to this Bill, this debate vis à vis my budget seems to be argued on the basis that a single person earning £15,000 is rich whereas a single person earning £13,000 is poor, or that a married person earning £27,000 is rich That is the level of nonsense debate to which we have sunk. Let me make this clear in case anyone is in doubt about my views on taxation, which I hope no one is. I do not subscribe to the view expounded over the last few years that there is only one way to lower taxation, which is by increasing personal allowances and widening bands - I make that clear for the 58,000th time. I believe it is important to have lower levels of nominal taxation.
The real logic of what some people have espoused since the budget is that we should never reduce the top rate of tax. Before I came into the House in 1977, the top rate of tax under the previous Government was 77 per cent at one stage - the top rate was 70 per cent and a surcharge of 10 per cent was put on all the rates, so that the 35 per cent rate became 38.5 per cent, etc. Fine Gael and Labour were in Government at that time. From 1982-87, the top rate was in excess of 60 per cent. The last budget of that period lowered it to 58 per cent. Are people trying to argue that we should keep the rates at those levels and that there is something sacrosanct about the 48 per cent rate? When you add the 48 per cent rate to the employee's PRSI, it results in 55 per cent being removed from personal income. People react when there is an economic benefit to them but if the State takes more than half of incremental income it is a clear disincentive to work. That has been my position consistently over the years. The Fianna Fáil position as early as its entry into opposition in 1994 was to reduce the top rate of tax and PRSI to a rate not exceeding 50 per cent. That is what we intend to do. Our position has been known for some time, we announced it during the election campaign and then delivered upon it. That is what seems to be upsetting people, that we delivered on these promises.
It is our intention to go further down this route. That is what we put to the people and that is what we will deliver. Deputy Noonan made the point about attracting people to come back to Ireland to work, but they are put off by our high taxation levels. The Deputy argues that they are really put off by the personal allowance bands being insufficient. I can tell Deputy Noonan from my own experience that he is right. It is difficult to attract people back to take jobs in high tech industries due to the high levels of taxation. It is not, however, for the reasons he claims. When it is mentioned that the top rate of tax in Ireland is 48 per cent they say they will not come back. The non-narrated taxation does affect the attraction of Ireland for these people who would otherwise come back and take up jobs.
Others made the point about the slight increase in the number of people paying tax at the higher rates. There is a small increase in that number but there has been a cut of 2 per cent in both the top and bottom rates. For a single person the gains range from 2.5 per cent to 4 per cent and for married couples from 2.5 to 3.5 per cent and up to 5.5 per cent in some cases. If you add in the growth in incomes under Partnership 2000, there is a considerable increase in take home pay. In the case of a single person on £14,000 income, the average tax take has been reduced from 28.2 per cent in 1996-97 to 22.4 per cent in 1998-99. In the case of a married couple on the same level of income the average tax take has decreased from 21.3 per cent to 16.9 per cent. Taxpayers will see this after 6 April.
I have had public and private debates with Deputy Noonan on this fundamental point. He has shifted his position. He does not believe in normal tax cuts anymore, he believes in the leftist doctrine of bands and allowances. The influence of the Labour Party and Democratic Left in Government has changed his mind over the years. Deputies from Limerick East have changed their positions over a period of 25 years. It is not unusual——
Comment on this
The Minister could get a writ served on him for comments about Deputies from Limerick East.
Comment on this
——for Deputies to change their views on matters such as contraception. Deputies from Limerick East have a habit of changing of changing their philosophies. The everyday influence of Democratic Left and Labour in Government with Deputy Noonan has changed his views but there must have been a slip of the pen just before the election as the Fine Gael election document did suggest cutting the top rate of income tax from 48 per cent to 45 per cent over the lifetime of the Government if they had been elected. I will not embarrass Deputy Noonan by going back to previous elections and what they said about taxation cuts. Deputy Rabbitte should take heart that his influence in Government had an outstanding effect as I now accept that Deputy Noonan genuinely believes this new leftist doctrine which in the past he did not believe. I am glad to see the influence of the left has changed him in this regard.
Comment on this
The Minister was replying to amendment Nos. 1, 2 and 3 which were to do with exemption levels. He did not mention exemption levels once. This is pure poetry in its emphasis, it should be taken down for posterity. Could the Minister address the issues?
Comment on this
I am being penalised for having stuck to the text of the amendments being proposed. As we are getting into the broader philosophical stuff I had better get in my tuppence worth at this stage.
If Deputy Noonan has changed, I would like to think he has been persuaded by the cogency of the argument. It is not an argument which was put across exclusively by the Labour Party and Democratic Left, it is an argument which has been accepted by all of the social partners including the representatives of the employers. The fundamental question is this——
Comment on this
The Minister took the programme put together after the election and then went back to bands and allowances.
Comment on this
We must ask ourselves why we are reducing tax in the first place. You may reduce tax to gain votes or because you want to give a bonanza to people who are better off. The figures in the Minister's budget documentation are clear on that. There is a significant disproportionate additional benefit to those who are better off. You may choose to do that and there may be reasons for that. George Bush and Thatcher tried to argue the case for the trickle down effect, that if you give benefits to the better off, it trickles down to the less well off. If the Minister wants to make that argument, let him make it. I do not think either of the two politicians I mentioned managed to make it work. If the Minister believes that, then let him make that argument and we will deal with it. He has not made that argument, which leads people to look at what his motivation must be. He has given a clear indication this morning. There is no doubt that cutting the rates had an appeal to people during the course of the election campaign, but some of the argument behind it was nothing short of a con job. He has repeated one of the central arguments and I ask him to think about this for a moment. He is suggesting that we are saying people earning £15,000 are rich and should not benefit from a cut in the upper rate. The truth is that people earning £15,000, and there are many of them, do not benefit in any significant way from reducing the upper rate. Some £1,500 of their taxable income is taxed at the upper rate and the Minister is reducing that by 2 per cent. They benefit by £20 or £30 a year. This is the con, the suggestion that reducing the upper rate benefits people on that income level. It does not benefit them to any significant degree.
If we had accepted the arguments made by my party that we should extend the standard rate band, those very people the Minister mentioned would not be paying tax at the marginal rate. They would be paying at 24 or 26 per cent, not at 46 per cent. Far from cutting their tax rate by 20 per cent, which is what should have been done, the Minister has cut it by 2 per cent. The Minister knows that significant benefit can only be derived from a reduction in the upper rate if one is earning a significant amount of money, not an average income - £25,000 or £30,000 for a single person and double that for a married couple. If the Minister had accepted the suggestion of the social partners and all the other parties in the House, most taxpayers - probably between 85 and 90 per cent - would have benefited to a greater degree. If the Minister believes that benefiting the better off is the way to go - and he dismissed the political orthodoxy of bands and allowances - we should be given the alternative argument. The Minister should not resile from saying he got a mandate for this. He got a mandate for tax reduction, but part of the argument used to get that does not stand up. There is an imperative to make that argument stand up.
Comment on this
I wish to make some points about the rich and poor and hi-tech companies. When the Minister takes the point raised by Deputy Noonan about hi-tech companies and labour returning here, the implication is that they are somehow innumerate and do not understand what is taxable income as distinct from reduction of the nominal rates. These people understand it extremely well. If one looks at the rich and poor argument advanced by the Minister, after £13,950, the single worker pays the higher rate of tax on £10,000, £3,150 personal allowances and £800 PAYE. That is the effect on a tangible example of what the Minister has done. The Minister said someone earning £13,000 is not highly paid, on which we all agree, although he or she pays the higher rate of tax after earning £13,950.
The alternative architecture suggested to the Minister means that no one on an average industrial wage would pay tax at the highest rate. The amendments I proposed would permit the first £10,300 part of taxable income at the standard rate and a personal tax allowance of £3,500 and PAYE at £800, which totals £14,600 - last year's figure for average industrial earnings. This means the single worker earning up to £14,600 would not come into the tax net at the highest rate. That is what it boils down to, despite what happened in the general election.
The Minister was tweaked by the Progressive Democrats. I note he did not implement any other Progressive Democrats policies for which he could equally argue he received a mandate in the election - shedding 25,000 jobs in the public service, dealing with lone parents and unmarried mothers and a number of other issues. The Minister was wise enough not to go down that road, but for some reason he has responded to the higher earners. This is regrettable regarding the trend from welfare to work, making it worth people's while to take a relatively low-paid job. Many of the jobs included in ISME surveys are very low-paid. It is only worth people's while to take a low-paid job if they are not in the tax net. Rather than fostering a dependency culture, this would encourage people to make the transition from welfare to work in the first phase and in the second phase, those on middle incomes would not come into the highest level of tax until they had at least a middle income.
Comment on this
I wish to conclude on the exemption limits covered in my amendments Nos. 1, 2 and 3. I propose an increase in the exemption limits to facilitate the movement from welfare to work. This applies particularly to those in part-time work, especially spouses who are disinclined to work a full week when tax is too high. The Minister is aware of the difficulties in the labour market, especially in the tourism industry, the catering business and bar trade. If part-timers could be encouraged to work longer hours through the use of exemption limits, there would be a good return.
Eighty pounds of the Minister's increase of £100 in exemption limits for single people is taken up by inflation. The real increase in the exemption limit for a single person is £20 in a year. The Minister might as well not have given the increase.
Comment on this
I accept the bona fides of people who put forward their views on bands and allowances. However, I object to those who say there is only one way.
Comment on this
I am not talking about Deputy McDowell, who is an Opposition politician with a job to do. There are people who say there is only one way. It has to be a combination of allowances, bands and rates. Some lobbyists imply there is only one way, a view to which I do not subscribe. I do not doubt the bona fides of the Opposition who want to achieve what we all do. There has been an emphasis on narrowing this debate to one particular philosophy, to which I do not subscribe. I am sorry I do not but it is unlikely as I approach my 50th year that I will change my mind.
Exemption limits were debated extensively by the last Finance committee, of which Deputy McDowell and the Chairman were Members. Everyone knows what the exemption limit was designed to achieve. There is such a big jump from that to a 40 per cent rate, it is non-productive. It is my intention in the next few budgets to increase personal allowances to a level where the exemption limit will no longer apply. This is a marked disincentive.
The increase I made in personal allowances this year is the same as Deputy Quinn made in his 1997 budget. His budget was £397 million, while mine was £570 million, which is £120 million more. It is not a significant increase. Of the £120 million more, I gave £104 million to the top rate. Only 20 per cent went to the top rate, which Deputy Rabbitte fails to recognise.
The 2 per cent reduction in both income tax rates will reduce the marginal tax rate paid by one million taxpayers. The gains in take-home pay achieved over 1997-98 by single workers range from 9.5 to 11 per cent while the gains for most married couples range from 9 to 11 per cent. That takes the increase in Partnership 2000 into account. Workers are seeing a genuine increase in their take-home pay. People recognised this during the election campaign and voted for it. I just implemented it.
In reply to Deputy Rabbitte, my proposals on taxation and tax cuts were on the table long before the Progressive Democrats put theirs on the table in advance of the 1997 election. I have outlined the Fianna Fáil position on taxation on numerous occasions. In January 1995, the Taoiseach outlined Fianna Fáil's position that no one would pay tax or PRSI at a rate greater than 50 per cent; our policy in this area is no secret.
Comment on this
As it is now 12 noon, I am required to put the following question in accordance with an Order of the Dáil of 26 February:
"That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to Chapters 1 and 2 of Part I of the Bill and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill and, in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said Chapters that the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to."
Comment on this
On a point of order, I am trying to be optimistic that the Minister might be disposed towards accepting the occasional amendment in the coming days. How do we deal with that? If the Minister accepts an amendment, is it incorporated into the Bill?
Comment on this
Yes. The Dáil Order states that". . . in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said Chapters that the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to".
Comment on this
Quite a number of amendments were not dealt with. Are we to assume the Minister will oppose all amendments which are not dealt with or do such amendments automatically fall?
Comment on this
The Select Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
This question disposed of all amendments up to and including amendmentNo. 36.
CHAPTER 3.
Comment on this
I would like to clarify something. The note for the information of Members on how today's business is arranged, which was circulated by your staff, indicates we will go as far as amendment No. 36, but I understood we would stop at amendment No. 28.
Comment on this
That motion was moved in the Dáil last week, but since then, new amendments and sections have been inserted. They fall within chapters 1 and 2, referred to.
Comment on this
This is appalling. As I understand it, the new section 12 deals with cross-Border workers. We are now being told that, without even realising it, we have disposed of this because of a rearrangement in the way the sections are numbered.
Comment on this
We are complying with an order of the Dáil. We will take note of the points you have made for future reference.
Comment on this
In fairness, there is a point here. Because the numbers of sections have changed, you will have to accept that we legitimately did not realise that the new section 12 was being discussed.
Comment on this
I am powerless over this matter as I am complying with an order of the Dáil, but we will take note of what you have said.
Comment on this
I appeal to the Minister to give us the benefit of some information, at least, in order to deal with the new section 12 on cross Border workers, in the course of the next session. This is really appalling.
Comment on this
While you are reflecting on that point, Chairman, I would ask you to clarify what we are now doing. We are starting on chapter 3, which deals with corporation tax and so on, in section 12. Is that right? Section 12 of the Finance Bill, which I have in front of me, concerns relief for the long-term unemployed. We agreed with the Whips on the allocation of time motion that we would start chapter 3 of Part I, covering sections 12 to 42 at 12 noon and continue to4.30 p.m. Is that not right?
Comment on this
The Minister has changed the numbers because the new section 12 deals with cross-Border workers, so I presume everything else moves back a section.
Comment on this
With respect, our Whips did not agree numbers. They agreed to debating certain sections, topics and themes within certain time allocations. If the Minister changes the numbers it does not change the rules of the game.
Comment on this
I have taken note of what Deputies have said. I must operate under the order that is before me, however, and I propose we proceed as per chapter 3 of Part I. Between now and 2.30 p.m. I will discuss the matter with the Whips and with the Minister. We will revert back to it at 2.30 p.m.
Comment on this
I have no objection to debating any section at all. If Deputies want to discuss that, it does not bother me.
Comment on this
That is easy to say when we have no time to do it anyway. The order which obliges you, Chairman, to take certain sections in particular time slots refers to the old numbers in the Finance Bill which was provided to us. It does not refer to the new numbers on the Minister's alterations.
Comment on this
I have taken note of what you have said. I intend to discuss the matter with the officials and the Whips. At 2.30 p.m. when we resume, I will take what advice I receive. I have to operate under the order of the Dáil which says that chapter 3 of Part I is to commence after 12 noon.
Comment on this
I think you are seriously in error, Chairman, because we agreed we would dispose of certain sections as numbered in the Finance Bill as originally published. We now find that, unwittingly, this Committee has passed sections on Committee Stage that we did not intend passing. That is because your officials have provided us with the wrong information. We cannot proceed on that basis.
Comment on this
I have taken note of what you have said, but I have to get clarification from the officials. I will revert to you when I get that.
Comment on this
The vote has been taken so, as the Deputy said, if he wishes to make an amendment on Report Stage he can do so. However, we cannot discuss it again here.
Comment on this
I put everyone on notice that there is no agreement on any time schedule on Report Stage. This is the worst I have ever seen on any occasion at a Committee meeting. Material has been run through by numbers being changed by the officials with the consent of the Minister, but without consulting anyone here. We have been put in a position where we are passing sections that we have not had an opportunity of discussing. We do not even know what is going on.
Comment on this
We had no involvement in this at all. This is a matter between the Committee and the Opposition Whips.
Comment on this
If the Committee wishes to discuss any of these sections again now, and the Chair allows me to do so, I will debate it. This matter, which is not my wish at all, was worked out between the Whips and the officials of the Committee. I have no objection to dealing with those sections and will deal with them now, if it can be done.
Comment on this
If Deputies wish to discuss the cross-Border workers issue between now and 12.45 p.m. I will accept it, by agreement.
Comment on this
What is the point in discussing it when we have already passed it on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
So, you agree with my original proposal that we proceed as per chapter 3 and when I have had a discussion with the officials we will discuss it?
Comment on this
We should have an adjournment to discuss this. The matter is ridiculous. If we discuss it now our discussion will have absolutely no status and we will not be discussing it in Committee. Even if we convince the Minister that he should make changes, there is nothing he can do because the Committee has already passed the matter on Committee Stage. As I understand the procedures of the House, the only option is to go back into Committee on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I have the time allocation motion here whereby we were scheduled at 12 noon, by agreement of the Whips, to discuss corporation tax and capital gains tax. From then until 12 noon to 12.45 p.m., when we are due to rise, is a very short time. They were the themes which we were to discuss. How can we possibly discuss the new section 12 when the motion which you, Chairman, have just taken has actually incorporated it in the Bill which will be published before Report Stage? There is no point in us discussing it. However, we must all enter the caveat now that, irrespective of when the discussions take place, we are permitted to re-submit issues which have not been reached here for an untrammelled Report Stage.
Comment on this
That is automatic; it has been agreed already. The Deputy knows from previous experience that one can resubmit amendments on Report Stage.
The Order of the Dáil states that Chapter 3 will be discussed from after the vote at 12 o'clock until 4.30 p.m. We will now proceed with the discussion of Chapter 3.
NEW SECTION.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 37 involves the insertion of a new section and it is in the name of Deputy Rabbitte. Amendment No. 73 is related. Therefore, amendments Nos. 37 and 73 may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 17, before section 12, but in Chapter 3, to insert the following new section:
12.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-
(a) in Chapter 2 of Part 38 by the insertion in section 882, subsection (3):
(i) after 'within 30 days of-' of '(aa) the date of registration,',
(ii) after '(i) the name of the company,' of '(ia) the name and address of the Irish registering agent,',
(iii) after '(iv) the name and address of the secretary of the company' of '(iva) the name and address of the auditor of the company,', and
(b) in Chapter 2 of Part 47 by the insertion in section 1073 of:
'(c) the Irish registering agent shall be liable to a separate penalty of £500 and, if the failure continues after judgment has been given by the court before which proceedings for the penalty have been commenced, to a further penalty of £100 for each day on which the penalty continues.'.".
Amendment No. 37 is an attempt to deal with the phenomenon of Irish registered non-national companies and it refers to section 58 of the Finance Act, 1995. The interesting thing about section 58 of that Act when one studies it in detail is, as I have been advised over the past three or four days, that it is an exceptionally good effort at confronting quite a complex issue. It is quite remarkable that the Minister for Finance and other Ministers have said that this section was not as successful as they had hoped. Each Minister who came into the House has repeated that phrase. Whereas other things have been different, they have repeated that phrase precisely. It is impossible to get to the bottom of why it has not been as successful as was hoped.
Within three months of the enactment of that section, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, in a letter to me dated 15 September 1995, stated that it was recognised at the time that this measure would not be fully effective in tackling the problem. It is very unusual to have a Minister, who tabled a quite detailed amendment a few months earlier, signalling before it was given a chance to work that it would not be effective and that other measures would be required. I am persuaded at this stage that the section was never really applied. There is a horse of a difference between saying that it is not a successful as we hoped it would be and the fact that it has not been applied.
A letter to me this morning from the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioners, on whom lies the major onus for application of the section, states that the Revenue has implemented the section as far as practicable. He then goes on to draw a distinction between companies resident in the State which would have a taxable income here, and companies not resident which would not have a source of income here. Essentially, he is stating - let me clarify that I am saying it, to be fair to Mr. Mac Domhnaill - that because they are non-resident and do not have taxable income here, it is none of the Revenue Commissioners' business. They are not policemen; their job is to collect taxes from companies which have a tax liability, and in the case of companies which do not have a tax liability it is not their job.
Let me be clear on this. I agree with the Minister. This is not a simple issue. An editorial in The Sunday Business Post ascribed to me the view that it is simple whereas a child following the argument would know that I have been making the opposite argument. I do not want to criticise The Sunday Business Post because it is a good paper and its editorials have saved me much embarrassment down through the years - rather than going to the GPO to get copies of An Phoblacht, it was easier to read the editorials in The Sunday Business Post.
I want to hear what the Minister can tell the House about the non-application of that section. Why is it ineffective? Section 58 is a very substantial imposition in terms of the reporting of these companies.
I do not want to take up the very valuable time of the committee by going through the detail of the imposition which is on these companies to report to the Revenue, etc., and why it was found to be ineffective. In his letter the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioners identifies this loophole, that it is not effective until such time as they commence trading. The point is they are not trading here. My amendment seeks to have them report from the date of registration and, more importantly, makes the Irish registering agent liable to a penalty of £500. If the failure continues after judgment has been given by the court before which proceedings for the penalty have been commenced, the agent shall be liable to a further penalty of £100 for each day on which the penalty continues. Although there is a penalty in the 1995 Act and there is a connection between section 58 and that penalty, it would appear that the penalty is ineffective. If one puts the imposition on the registering agent - never mind the fly by nighters who are coming in here to use this jurisdiction to evade taxes in their country of origin or for whatever purpose - to comply in a certain fashion and if the agent is open to being penalised to the tune of £500 a time and a further £100 each day thereafter on which he or she refuses to comply, then one would see much of this coming to heel.
I do not know the Minister for Finance's present view on the matter, but to obliterate the IRNR structure is not a simple matter. If one does so, one will inevitably impact on international companies who are here legitimately to do business in this jurisdiction and who avail of that mechanism. We must strip out the fly by nighters who are here to do no business and for the very purpose of not doing any business. How does one strip them out? I am saying put the imposition on the registering agent to report in the fashion I described in the amendment. I am asking the Minister to give serious consideration in the interim, while he is contemplating more serious measures if he still thinks that must be done, to make section 58 of the 1995 Act effective by the addition of my amendment and to require that it be policed.
It is not the job of the Minister for Finance or his predecessor, Deputy Quinn, to go around policing legislation enacted by the Oireachtas. If the Oireachtas enacted the legislation, it is the task of the respective State agencies to see it is enforced. It is quite clear it has not been enforced.
I would like to hear someone state truthfully why it was considered, within three months of its being enacted, that it was never likely to be enforced. Did someone say to the Department of Finance after the section was enacted that the Department had not foreseen the difficulties and that if it went ahead it would have adverse implications and should be changed? As a result, it has been left dormant.
I cannot see why, given the additional investment in the Companies Registration Office and the latest information technology, the Department and the Revenue Commissioners cannot exchange information in the fashion envisaged in section 58 and my amendment, which would separate the fly-by-nights and those who are here for illegal or other nefarious purposes from the companies availing of that structure for legitimate business purposes in this jurisdiction. I have tried to be as non political about this as I can but I ask the Minister to respond to that point.
Comment on this
My amendment No. 73 attempts to address the same issue. I readily accept, in anticipation of the Minister's response, that it is a fairly blunt instrument. It is intended primarily to give rise to debate so that we can move the matter on, as Deputy Rabbitte said, in a non party political way.
My party accessed some of the information about these registering agents on the Internet last week. They make a very big issue of confidentiality and the fact that the information given to them will not be revealed to anyone and is not even kept on a database. If section 58 and the amendment tabled by Deputy Rabbitte go some distance towards undermining the use of that structure for illegal or improper purposes, that is obviously good.
Deputy Rabbitte says it is not a simple issue, which is true. However, the argument has been made for the past few days, during which time the issue has received a great deal of public attention, that legitimate use is made of IRNRs by multinational corporations. I have attempted over the past few days, through several different methods, to try to determine exactly what is this legitimate use. Perhaps I should define "legitimate". I do not believe multinational corporations are using IRNRs for illegal purposes. Their use of them to avoid tax in other jurisdictions, usually the US, is quite legal. While I am not imputing illegal motives to multinational corporations, I am at a complete loss to understand the benefit to the Irish economy of the use of this mechanism by multinational corporations. My understanding is that 20 or 25 multinationals with branches in Ireland are using this tax mechanism. I do not understand why we need to encourage and provide this mechanism.
In the midst of all the party political wrangling last week I asked the Tánaiste some questions in this regard. She gave me answers which I am satisfied, having studied them, do not stand up. She talked about double taxation and the dividends of multinational corporations. My advice is that this is not the purpose for which they are used.
What is the legitimate use of IRNRs? Do we need to encourage it? The most important point, which was made by Deputy Rabbitte, is whether their use is essential to maintaining foreign direct investment into Ireland. My advice is that it is not essential but is, in a sense, the icing on the cake for multinational corporations. They locate here for a variety of reasons, including the workforce and tax concessions we offer. Their use of this mechanism to defer tax, often on income earned outside of Ireland and which should be returned for income tax purposes outside Ireland, is the icing on the cake and they could happily reorganise themselves if given a year or two to so do. If we satisfy ourselves on that point, I see no reason we cannot take decisive, clear action which would clear up the matter once and for all.
What Deputy Rabbitte has proposed and what section 58 tried to do would go some distance towards that. However, if we can take the further step decisively, without interfering with FDI in Ireland - which I think we can - we should do so.
It was not commented on sufficiently in the party political manoeuvring last week that what the Tánaiste said, and what the Minister for Finance has said since, is at variance with what was in the back-up information given to the Tánaiste. She was advised, and the individual who wrote the note clearly believed, we should move to close down IRNRs completely. What has been said since by the Minister and the Tánaiste does not comply with that.
Comment on this
This matter was discussed thoroughly by us last week and by the print and broadcast media over the ensuing week. As Deputy Rabbitte has recognised now, this is a complex area. If it was simple I am sure that Deputy Rabbitte and Deputy Quinn, the then Minister, would have solved it in 1995.
In my reply to the Dáil last week I did not seek any party political advantage in this matter but said I readily recognised that the outgoing Administration could not find a solution because it was a complex and complicated area. I have said in reply to questions in this regard that I believe the matter can only be solved by a combination of changes in three areas of law - company law, taxation law and possibly in the area of criminal justice.
I will answer some of the specific questions now and we can debate the other matters later. Deputy McDowell raised the issue of the use of this structure by multinational companies and how, while we want to get rid of the companies which are carrying on illegitimate activities, we do not want to harm the others which are carrying on quite legitimate activities. Some of the biggest multinationals in the country use this structure.
In the past few days we received a communication from the IDA setting out some of the detail in this regard. As the Deputy will know from the back-up note which was released with the Tánaiste's reply and which began this debate last week, there has been an ongoing divergence of opinion between different Government agencies and Departments on how to immediately close down companies carrying on illegitimate activities. In order to give a flavour of what the IDA has said in regard to why US companies use these structures, which is what Deputy McDowell specifically asked, I will quote from a letter from the IDA to the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment, dated 18 December 1997. It states in regard to why US companies use IRNRs:
Profits are repatriated when a dividend is paid. Profits are deemed repatriated under US tax law when a company falls foul of US anti-deferral rules e.g. sub-part F, passive foreign investment company rules.
This principle of not paying US tax until there is an actual repatriation or deemed repatriation to the US is known as US tax deferral. For companies that have an Irish operation taxable at 10 per cent and defer US taxes, they derive two benefits from an Irish low-tax operation:
- Cash Flow Benefit:
The company only pays 10 per cent tax in Ireland as opposed to 36 per cent in the US.
- Earnings Per Share (EPS) Benefit:
Under US accounting rules, when preparing US financial statements, the US parent will only charge a tax rate of 10 per cent on profits derived from Ireland if there is an intention to permanently reinvest the funds outside of the US. By only charging 10 per cent (as opposed to 36 per cent), the company has higher after tax earnings i.e. higher EPS. Earnings per share is a key measure of financial performance for US publicly quoted companies.
My Department has been in touch with the IDA on many occasions in relation to this matter. In anticipation of this debate we reactivated our contacts with them within the past few days. I will quote from a reply faxed to me yesterday which gives a brief synopsis of an overview covering US multi-nationals and which states:
"US multi-nationals can use this structure - that is IRNRs - to ensure that further US tax on profits of the Irish operation is deferred until such time as the profits are repatriated or, indeed, to be repatriated via the United States thereby preserving the benefit of the 10 per cent corporation tax rate on manufacturing products in Ireland. As you know the multi-nationals pay corporation tax in full on profits generated here and the amounts of tax paid are significant. Surplus cash can be held in the IRNR until it is repatriated. In some cases the profits may not be brought back but may be used to fund further expansion of the multi-nationals business outside of the United States".
International tax law is a very technical and specialised area. Multi-national companies, particularly some of the major ones here, use this structure. I hope my quote will answer your questions on how this type of tax law is used because most people, including myself, would not have been involved in this taxation process and would not be au fait with it. I assure the Deputy that from the IDA’s viewpoint this company structure is used. My predecessors, Deputies Rabbitte and Quinn, were faced with this dilemma in 1995 but the matter is still ongoing.
In reply to Deputy Rabbitte's question of why the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, brought in the amendment in April and then a few months later wrote to Deputy Rabbitte, who was then the Minister of State at the Department, inquiring what he was going to do about the matter, I will quote from a background note that was given to Deputy Quinn when he agreed to put forward this amendment on Committee Stage. It is quite clear from the note that Deputy Quinn received and initialled that this section was meant to dissuade IRNRs from coming here. The note stated:
"It is important to realise that the purpose of strengthening section 141 to increase the inheritance Act and to dissuade such companies from looking to here in the first place. . . . . In addition, company formation agencies will no longer be able to sell the Irish rights to a non-registered company regime on the basis of there being no requirement to disclose the activities of the beneficial owners to the authorities here".
It is quite clear from these detailed notes that, in agreeing to put forward this amendment, it was recognised then that it would act as a deterrent to stop multi-nationals setting up here. Up until then there were no requirements relating to multi-nationals. Ireland was being sold as a base for them because there were no requirements for them to meet. Section 58 of the Finance Act, 1995, was intended to act as a deterrent. The then Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, did not put forward this amendment. I cannot remember if we had an opportunity to debate this amendment on Committee Stage. Perhaps we never had a chance to discuss it. This would explain why Deputy Quinn as Minister wrote to Deputy Rabbitte subsequently to make that point. Deputy Quinn knew when he put forward the amendment that it was not a catch all section necessary to do everything required but was intended to act as a deterrent to multi-nationals setting up here. It would suit me to make a political point about this but that is the background to this matter. Deputy Quinn did not put forward the amendment as the best solution to this problem but it was only a deterrent mechanism. If you read the Official Report of the Dáil from last week, where I quoted the explanatory note to the memorandum, you would have detected that from it. I hope that explains to Deputy Rabbitte what should have been said to him in September 1995.
Comment on this
I appreciate what the Minister has just said but if you go back to section 58, it states: "every company incorporated in the State that is not resident. . . . . shall within 30 days do a number of things. The date on which it commences to carry on a trade, profession or business will be notified. . . . ..". My point is that those we are objecting to never carried on a trade, profession or business. My amendment would require them to do this within 30 days of registration, irrespective of whether they are carrying on business, and it would follow that up by putting the imposition on the formation agent to do certain things or else take the penalty. I hope just because the amendment is coming from this side of the House and the Minister can now ask me why I did not do this when I had a chance to do it, that this matter will not be glossed over. Criticise the amendment by all means. It may be imperfect in terms of technical construction. I have taken advice on this matter and the Chairman of the Revenue Commissioner identified this loophole. He says on the one hand he is implementing it as far as practicable, but there is a loophole for them because they are not conducting a trade, profession or business here. The Minister's own profession, the accountants, have to be the ones setting them up - there are plates all over the place. The Minister must require the agent to make the Companies Office and the Revenue Commissioners aware of the existence of this type of non-resident company.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte's proposal can be considered and we can debate it later. Deputy McDowell pointed out his amendment No. 73 is a totally blunt instrument in terms of Irish tax laws. The amendment which states that any company registered in the State is tax resident would stand tax law on its head. It would be terrible if his amendment was enacted into Irish law, considering our desire to have multi-national companies here. The Deputy might already know this and probably inserted this amendment merely to have a debate. In that context I cannot accept his amendment.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister might circulate his detailed notes, if there is nothing confidential in them, so we can read them over lunch. If he did that it would save time later on.
Comment on this
We should take seriously what the IDA said on this matter. Clearly there is a problem, but in moving to solve it we should confine the amendment to the area of the problem rather than extend it too widely. I recall, either when I was in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment or shortly afterwards, there was a huge lobby when the Inland Revenue in the United States decided to change the manner in which offshore American investment, particularly in manufacturing industry, was taxed. The original proposal was that they would not distinguish between the location of American manufacturing plants, that whether they were in Ireland, the United States or Australia they would all be liable for tax in the United States and that returns would have to be made to the Revenue in the United States.
Much lobbying took place at that stage. There was panic that the Irish industrial package, in so far as it rested on a 10 per cent tax regime, would no longer be effective since the liability would occur at home and there would be no net bottom line benefit to the company. After lobbying here and in the United States, the deferment policy was introduced. If I recall correctly, part of the solution to the problem was that liability would arise only when profits were repatriated. That was done for two reasons. First, American companies abroad would have the benefit of cashflow and if they proposed further expansion, either in the company which they had located abroad or in a third country, they could use the money and it would not be liable for American taxation.
Plants frequently come here and promise to employ 400 or 500 workers, but if it is successful there is a huge expansion. An example is Dell in Limerick. Mr. Michael Dell set up his first European plant in Limerick and it has been successful. I do not know what arrangements he has in terms of his tax affairs, but there was a recent announcement that the company intended to create 3,000 extra jobs in Limerick. Much of that employment will be funded from the profits of European activities which are sourced in Limerick.
As well as the cashflow benefit there is the possibility of investing profits abroad to expand a company. There is no liability because the profits are not repatriated to the United States. That is not confined to the country of the plant which generates the profits. An American multinational with a plant in Ireland which makes profits could assign the profits for expansion in the United Kingdom and it would not be liable under American tax. There was lobbying on that matter to the level of the Ambassador in Washington. The Taoiseach of the day took up the matter with the President of the United States at a St. Patrick's Day meeting and many submissions were made on it.
A subset of that was that American companies made arrangements to hold profits in situ,as it were, and not repatriate them until they needed them. If there were profits in addition to cashflow needs they could place them in a company here. I do not know whether non-residential companies are essential to that mechanism. I cannot see why profits could not be held in a local account for the local plant. I do not see where the structural advantage is in that.
There is a serious industrial relations issue surrounding this matter. A change which would be too broadly based could have an adverse effect on the attractiveness of Ireland for American investment in particular because of the way their company tax code is structured. That is not to say there is not a difficulty. At the time I was in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment and subsequently as an Opposition Deputy, I was not aware - I would be surprised if the former Ministers, Deputies Rabbitte and Richard Bruton, were briefed to this effect - those accounts were used for money laundering purposes or other illegal activity. Most shocking about the briefing note attached to the Tánaiste's written reply to a parliamentary question was that for the first time those of us who were recently in Government were apprised that those accounts may have been used for illegal activity. Somebody should explain why the Minister of the day or the Minister of State were not briefed if this information was available within the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment.
The Minister said he is adopting a three-way approach to this matter, that there would have to be changes in company law, tax law and criminal law. That is acceptable, but this is a vehicle for making changes in tax law and a start should be made here. Deputy Rabbitte has identified one loophole which needs to be closed. I find it extraordinary that, while there is a clearly countable and definable number of American companies investing here, media reports suggest there is an enormous number - 40,000 - of non-residential accounts. We need to be told the number of those accounts that are reputed to be in situ and the number of legitimate users of accounts. Is it the case, as happens in some solicitors’ offices, that there are many shelf companies in place and if a person wishes to set up a company to repair bicycles one of them is used? Are many companies registered but inactive? Is there any explanation for reports of vast numbers of these accounts? There seems to be no reality between some of the information that is being put out and anything real that is happening in the economy. Given the Minister’s profession, he might be able to give us further information on that. He should give a commitment to accept Deputy Rabbitte’s amendment on condition that whatever tidying up is necessary can be done between now and Report Stage. There is a good deal of merit in what he said and it would be a start.
Comment on this
In his speaking note the Minister acknowledges amendment No. 37 has merit. Given the best will in the world, it will take a long time to do some of the things we have been told the Government will do, or else matters have changed greatly since I was briefed on this. My amendment would impose these obligations within 30 days after incorporation. The Minister said the amendment has merit and that "it would ease the administrative burden for Revenue". He went on to say that notices requiring the information had been issued to the companies, but we know that is ineffectual. One could send out notices like confetti to the companies we are trying to weed out. It is naive to think they would have complied especially at a time when the Companies Registration Office was not up to speed for reasons of lack of investment and so on. If there is merit in this amendment, why, if we acknowledge section 58 is ineffectual, do we not at least do this much?
My amendment seeks to make a person in this jurisdiction accountable for non-compliance and the Minister also accepts that point. The problem is there is no person in this jurisdiction accountable for non-compliance at present. In his note the Minister said he is not sure he agrees with that, but he is not sure if the company formation agent is the correct mark. Maybe he is right, but who is the correct mark if not the person who is helping those people incorporate these companies in this jurisdiction? If the numbers are anything like those stated by Deputy Noonan, and the original Siobhan Creighton story has not been challenged, then somebody in Dublin 2 has a huge number of those companies on his or her books. Why not put the obligation on those company formation agents to comply with the requirements in this amendment and penalise them if they do not? Therein lies the distinction. If those people were fined for each day of non-compliance, we would soon weed them out.
Deputy Noonan mentioned the briefing I would have received. I cannot speak for Deputy Richard Bruton but I would be very surprised if his briefing was different from mine. Until the inadvertent secret document, there was no question of my being briefed to the effect that these companies were operating here in an illegal and nefarious fashion. The Minister accepted the thrust of making a person in this jurisdiction accountable, but went on to say that if a foreign agent is used pursuit of the penalties would also arise. That may be a defect in my amendment, but surely it ought to be possible to alter it to provide for an agent outside this jurisdiction incorporating companies here.
I appreciate the Minister's officials have been burning the midnight oil working on a number of other areas. Now that we know the extent of the problem and the nature of the conduct of some of those companies, why can we not send out a signal between now and Report Stage that it is our intention to ringfence the area Deputy Noonan concentrated on in terms of legitimate FDI here? Why can we not seek to deal with the loopholes that have been established? Much of the Cathal MacDomhnaill letter is repeated in the Minister's answer. I yield to nobody in my respect for the ability of senior civil servants in Ireland to draft eminently plausible, but often impenetrable, explanations for things that are quite simple. Let us not beat around the bush, this measure has not been implemented and it is not capable of being implemented because these are not the type of people who will comply with requirements imposed voluntarily. They will comply only if there is a big stick. If amendment No. 37 is less than perfect and needs to be tidied up, I ask the Minister to consider doing that between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
Colleagues better able to use the Internet than I printed information about one of the companies seeking to advertise this facility in Ireland. That company makes much of the fact that "the Republic of Ireland is the only full member of the EU offering these facilities". The standard service includes incorporation, provision of registered office, a company secretary, annual returns, filing fees etc., nominee directors, opening of bank account and execution of power of attorney. It is clear what this envisages - a shelf company with nominee directors, and a registered office in this country where business is not carried on. Confidentiality is an extremely important part of the business and not all businesses attracted by those facilities will be of the desirable kind.
Like others, I read the Minister's note over lunch and it is very interesting and instructive. One aspect of it that struck me was that opting for non-residence status seems to be separated from the process of incorporation. Surely if we bring those two processes together it must be possible to get the kind of information we require and to give real effect to section 58? Surely pre-incorporation it should be possible to require a company to indicate whether it will be resident in this country? Perhaps from the point of view of company law, that is a way we could approach this matter. As the Minister rightly divined, I tabled my amendment to obtain from him an indication of the tax based measures his Department is considering for dealing with this issue. He might give us some indication of that in his reply to this debate.
Comment on this
Will the Minister take us through a case study of one of the companies that is used, to put it delicately, to make black money white? Many people are talking in generalities about this. Has the Department of Finance or the Revenue Commissioners got their fingers on the mechanism? Will he explain how that mechanism works because then we might be able to address a solution to this matter?
Comment on this
As I indicated to the Chairman this morning, I am not a member of this committee, but I would like to table some amendments on Report Stage and I understand I can do that only with the permission of the committee. Is that in order?
Comment on this
Yes, the Deputy can indicate to the committee he intends to table amendments on Report Stage, but he cannot move them on Committee Stage.
Comment on this
Deputy Noonan said there has not been a case study. In reply to a parliamentary question tabled yesterday by Deputy McManus I said:
I am informed that concerns about the operation of Irish registered non-resident companies have been raised with the Revenue Commissioners by certain countries such as the Baltic States in the context of double taxation treaty negotiations and also formally at the OECD and certain other international fora.
More people now understand what is involved. The accountancy profession is, in some instances, justifiably blamed but not all company formation agents are accountants. Many companies such as my old firm use such agents in the city. One does not have to be an accountant to act as a company formation agent. When I was an apprentice accountant, accountants performed this function but gave up when others began to do it much more cheaply.
On their formation in Dublin by an Irish formation agent with an Irish registered office, the companies in question are registered in the Companies Office. While their responsibilities are determined here under the Companies Acts, on taxation, it all depends on where they are managed and controlled from. The problem is no one knows anything about the uses to which they may subsequently be put outside the State. The Revenue Commissioners have no responsibility in the matter as the companies in question are not carrying on any of their activities here. If a company is engaged in illegal activity in another country where it operates a bank account, we will not hear about this until it comes to the notice of the media here or it is brought to our attention. The same applies to companies operating here which are registered in the Balkans, Liechtenstein or some other part of the globe. The Revenue Commissioners are not in a position to pursue these companies. It is not, therefore, simply a taxation matter. That brings us back to the company law area.
Deputy Noonan said we do not want to interfere with the legitimate companies operating here which use Irish registered non-resident companies. He is correct that in the past decade we have encountered serious difficulties at various stages in trying to ensure the US Inland Revenue does not upset our foreign direct investment programme. On at least three occasions in the past decade various Taoisigh and Ministers for Industry and Commerce and our Ambassador had to engage in serious lobbying at the highest levels of the US Administration to ensure US multinational companies operating here were not discommoded by taxation proposals on the table in the United States legislature. These proposals covered the matters of tax deferral, passive foreign investment companies and super royalties. When Minister for Tourism and Trade, I had to engage in lobbying in the United States to ensure proposed changes would not affect Irish companies. We have to proceed with care. In the period 1989-90 there was a special working group comprising Irish and US officials which looked at all these issues.
It has been asked how these legitimate US-based multinational companies operate this system. To ensure they are not caught for taxation in the United States, surplus funds generated in Ireland are transferred offshore and used to make investments in countries such as the United Kingdom.
The question has also been asked what are we going to do about this phenomenon. The answer to Deputy Noonan's question is that there has not been a case study. Between May 1995 and March 1997 the Revenue Commissioners wrote to approximately 27,000 companies asking them to indicate if they were resident or carrying on trade in the State. A total of 2,622 indicated they were neither resident nor carrying on trade in the State. The Revenue Commissioners did not receive a reply to all 27,000 circulars issued. Those companies legitimately carrying on trade were not required to do so.
This is a difficult question to solve. The amendment tabled by Deputy Rabbitte has merit but, as I indicated previously, the Government is committed to doing something about the problem this year. This may involve changes in company law, which needs to be tightened, taxation law and criminal law. I am not prepared to accept a piecemeal amendment at this time as we have to bring all the strands together. Interdepartmental working groups have been examining this matter for some time but the time comes when one has to make decisions one way or the other. That time has come. The Government will do so this year.
Deputies Noonan and Rabbitte asked if it was known in 1995 what these companies were doing. The background note prepared for my predecessor prior to the introduction of section 58 of the 1995 Finance Act clearly indicated the uses to which non-resident companies were being put. It stated: "It is the use, however, of Irish registered non-resident companies for objectionable purposes such as criminal activities or tax evasion which is the issue of most concern to us and which is damaging to our international reputation". As I indicated last week, the explanatory memorandum made the same point. It stated: "The measure is being introduced because certain Irish incorporated non-resident companies have been used for undesirable activities and have brought Irish incorporated companies into disrepute". I am not saying that Deputy Rabbitte was lax. It was probably never brought to his attention.
Comment on this
The Irish Times article alleged that up to 40,000 companies were involved but we do not know the extent of the problem. We have seen no evidence that anyone does. I cannot tell the Deputy if the number is 40,000, 400 or40.
Comment on this
That is relevant. I do not know what information the Department of Finance had - the Minister is correct, it was not brought to my attention - but I was not made aware of the illegal conduct to which reference was made in the background note. I had no reason to believe it was anything like on the scale alleged. Section 58, as it stands, makes it a requirement to deliver certain particulars to the Revenue CommisÍsioners. How many companies have delivered the particulars sought under that section?
Comment on this
Some 9,000 have delivered the requirements in respect of section 58, 2,622 of which have indicated they are not resident or trading in the State. However, that should not be any great consolation to us because the companies we are after will not have bothered to reply. We are not concerned about the 9,000 companies which replied. We are more concerned about the ones we do not know about.
Comment on this
The Minister should acknowledge that the amendment would deal with at least one loophole. If it would mean placing an additional imposition on incorporation and on the formation agent, or apply penalties for non-delivery, he should take the spirit of it on board. If he is not happy with my crafting he could table another amendment on Report Stage. Otherwise, I will have to press the matter to a vote because the signal we send out is important. It was indicated on the Minister's behalf, if not by the Minister, that he would deal with this matter in the Finance Bill. I have the press coverage to that effect. He may have had good reason for reflecting on the matter. However, if this is seen to put pressure on the people who are proliferating those companies here, we should be seen to attempt to address it, notwithstanding anything that might be introduced before the end of the year.
Comment on this
I know the article to which the Deputy is referring, which stated the matter would be dealt with in the Finance Bill. Neither I nor anybody on my behalf gave that signal to a newspaper.
Comment on this
During my brief time in Government, I discovered that nobody from the Department of Finance ever leaks information. I accept that is the case, but somebody from somewhere leaked this information.
Comment on this
The article did not give any indication this derived from the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
I have never given any indication to anybody in the Department of Finance that the matter would be dealt with in the Finance Bill. Whenever the matter was raised I stated quite clearly that I would not deal with it in this Finance Bill because it was too complex. Irrespective of how it reached the media, I give my personal word of honour that neither I nor anyone on my behalf gave out this.
Deputies may be interested to know that the 40,000 companies referred to in the recent article in The Irish Times emanated from an article in a British tax journal in 1995 and not from an official source. I suspect that journal was used to damage Ireland’s reputation. The figure of 40,000 was first mentioned in a British tax journal in 1995.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary that issues can be brought out in a controversial environment, but we cannot get any kind of commentary on them in normal times. There is a culture of obsessive secrecy that says we dare not discuss certain subjects in public because it would do harm, but I am convinced it does a great deal more harm not to discuss them.
Comment on this
This is also news to me. My officials discovered that the figure of 40,000 was first mentioned in a British tax journal in 1995. Perhaps that is the source of the recent article in a particular Irish newspaper, which did not give the source of its information. I cannot tell you whether it is right or wrong, I simply do not know.
Comment on this
As Deputy Rabbitte is aware, under paragraph 2 of the time allocation motion, no Member may claim a division on the proceedings of the Finance Bill, 1998, except on a question put, as provided for in paragraph 1, provided however that whenever the Chairman has declared a result in his opinion on the putting of any question any Member may have his or her dissent from such declaration recorded in the official proceedings of the Select Committee by raising his or her hand when called upon to do so by the Chairman.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to be recorded as dissenting, he should raise his hand. There is a composite vote at the end of Chapter 3 at 4.30 p.m. However, a Member's dissent on any section may be recorded.
SECTION 12.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 38, in the name of the Minister, is a drafting amendment. Amendments Nos. 38 and 39 are related and may, by agreement, be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 18, paragraph (b)(i), line 37, to delete "section", and substitute "of."
Comment on this
Consideration of Chapter 3 of Part I, on which a question will be put at 4.30 p.m., covers sections 12 to 42, up to and including amendment No. 75.
Comment on this
These are purely technical amendments to correct drafting errors. My official has pointed out that what is printed in the amendments is incorrect. The relevant amendment should read, "In page 18, line 38, after "to that section" to delete "and substitute of". These are purely technical amendments. All the amendments relate to the Bill as initiated. The amendments thereto are to section 12 which deals with relief for the long-term unemployed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 25, lines 16 and 17, to delete "subparagraphs" and substitute "subsections".
Comment on this
I do not propose to press this to a vote but I am concerned about the provisions in this section. I wish the Minister well with this worthwhile initiative. He will be aware, however, of the concerns expressed about how this interacts with the back-to-work allowance scheme, in particular. From individual case studies it appears the unemployed people concerned would be better off on the back-to-work allowance rather than participating in the new scheme outlined by the Minister, whereas employers will benefit.
I do not want to delay the meeting unnecessarily on this matter, but how does the Minister perceive those two labour market interventions interacting?
Comment on this
I congratulate the Minister on this section which concentrates on a major problem not alleviated by the Celtic tiger, long term endemic unemployment. If it helps to put some of these people back to work it will be worthwhile.
Deputy McDowell referred to the back to work allowance scheme. It is time we carried out a survey of the plethora of schemes to seek how they interact and the anomalies they create between one category of long term unemployed and another. Problems arise because the scheme is interpreted in various ways by different State agencies. For example, difficulties arise in regard to who may retain secondary benefits. While it is expressly stated that people on a certain scheme can retain their secondary benefits, a local authority or housing authority may reassess the position in terms of rental liability and the health board may reassess entitlement to a medical card etc. While this has got very complicated, it does not take from the merit of what is proposed in this section.
Comment on this
I agree there is a need to look at these schemes to see how they interact. There does not seem to be much interaction between schemes and there is much confusion. It may be possible to address this problem.
As I stated in my Budget Statement, on Second Stage and in various interviews, this initiative attempts to address the problem on long-term unemployment and is complementary to the existing schemes. I cannot say if it will be a success but it is a focused attempt to deal with the problem. When I looked at the problem in Opposition I saw that some of the schemes aimed at addressing long term unemployment were so tied up in red tape that employers did not want to have anything to do with them. It was, therefore, difficult to assess their real effect. We must give a clear incentive to the long term unemployed over other people and encourage employers to employ them.
If this scheme is taken up to any extent it will give rise to distortions in the labour force as two people may end up doing the same job in the same location but one will be better off. I readily recognise this and make no apologies for it. This section attempts to put the spotlight on the long term unemployed and to encourage employers to employ them.
As Deputies said, the Celtic tiger has not made any difference to the long term unemployed. Even though we achieved some success last year in reducing the number of long term unemployed on the live register, they still account for the majority of people on it. Regardless of what is done, we do not seem to be able to fully address the problem. I hope this scheme works and that people will say it was the greatest initiative ever introduced. This was one of the solutions put forward by us in Opposition and hopefully it will work and complement the existing schemes.
Comment on this
I oppose this section as it gives no reliefs to unemployed people who return to work. It proposes a personal allowance of £3,000 plus £1,000 per child in year one, an allowance of £2,000 plus £666 per child in year two and an allowance of £1,000 plus £334 per child in year three. The employer is being given a double deduction for payroll costs so there is a significant benefit to him.
When the Minister announced the scheme on budget day I though it was a novel idea and was prepared to give it a go. I did not know for sure if the package of incentives would be sufficient to encourage the long term unemployed to return to work or to make it attractive for employers to employ them. The Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed sent documentation to me and the Minister in which it claims that this proposal is not consistent with other labour market initiatives and that the take-up will be low. The Minister's officials also seem to agree with this view because the 1998 cost of the measure is only £1 million, while the full year cost is £5 million.
The documentation included a tabular statement in which this scheme is compared with the back to work allowance scheme in terms of impact on income. I have no way of authenticating these figures but I presume one of the Minister's officials checked them with the Department of Health and Children. The INOU claims that under the back to work allowance scheme a married couple on a gross wage of £8,000 with two children will gain £55.23 and a married couple with an income of £9,000 and two children will gain £65, while they will get nothing under the Minister's scheme. The Minister's scheme seemed attractive initially but it falls down when compared with the resources provided under the back to work allowance scheme. The strong case made by the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed should be answered by the Minister. Maybe there is something wrong with its figures which I have not seen.
Comment on this
The schemes are not the same and were designed at different stages. My initiative seeks to tackle the problem from another angle. I do not know if it will be taken up by one person or 10,000 people. However, if it is taken up only by two people then there will be two fewer long term unemployed persons on the live register. I did not trumpet it as the greatest initiative ever but I know from experience that it has a fair chance of success if it is marketed in the right areas. I intend to ensure that sufficient publicity is given to the scheme. Employers in certain areas are not able to get people to fill jobs and this scheme will encourage them to focus more on the long term unemployed.
The aim of the initiative is to get the long term unemployed back into employment. It also seeks to encourage employers to employ a long term unemployed person. I am aware that the INOU is not too excited about it but I am not worried about this. If the scheme is taken up by only five people it will mean five fewer people on the live register. This is the rationale behind this proposal.
Comment on this
I am not sure that the INOU is right about this. Its submission shows an admirable preoccupation with symmetry, tables and so on. I do not know how many Members have been in certain areas of Limerick over the past number of weeks, but the reality is that in some of these areas the people caught in that situation have no prospect of becoming employed largely because they do not have the skills. In so far as there is employment for that type of person, it is limited. I would be interested to see the experience as a result of the implementation of this scheme. Provided it is not abused by employers, and I do not know what measures in the guidelines can avoid that, somebody will get the prospect of going from welfare into work for three years on concessions that are tapered. The fact that that person is back in work for three years gives him or her a better prospect of becoming employed thereafter. I have said there is a necessity to examine the interaction with other schemes and the question of ensuring it is not abused by employers, but I cannot see what harm it can do notwithstanding the symmetry of it.
The problem with all the tables we are supplied with is that whoever is making the argument obviously chooses the case best likely to win the argument. In the law of mathematics someone can always find a case that shows they are worse off than when they started, but there are other cases where that does not apply. There are huge areas of concentrated unemployment that have been exacerbated by other instruments over the years like housing policy, and if we do not get some of those people back to gainful employment we will have a social phenomenon of enormous gravity. That is not widely appreciated. I am in favour of taking the risk with it.
Comment on this
As one of those who have knocked on a number of doors in Limerick over the past month I agree with Deputy Rabbitte's comments. I have always favoured bringing forward a policy specifically aimed at these unfortunate people. People have raised possible difficulties and the comparison with somebody already in similar employment, but my argument is that throughout the various policies introduced by the State there has been positive discrimination. It is unbelievable that the main opposition to this proposal is that there might be a low take-up of the scheme. The Minister made the point that if only two people availed of the scheme it would represent a gain, but I do not believe the take-up will be as low as that. This proposal is viewed as a positive step in the areas I represent. I strongly support it and I am glad other speakers support it also.