Finance Bill, 1998: Committee Stage.
Contributions 143–279 of 391. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 8 of 1998 ›
I have a minor concern about this - that is the reason I highlighted the back to work scheme - which is that people are concerned about what they will get into their pockets. Long-term unemployed people seem to have a vested interest in taking up the BTWA whereas clearly the greater benefit of this proposal will go to employers. I accept we must give incentives to employers to take on long-term unemployed people but I am concerned that pressure might be put on employees or potential employees by employers to opt for a scheme which is less beneficial for them. That is the only caveat I am entering at this stage. I accept the Minister's good faith on the matter and I wish him well with the scheme. I hope it is successful.
Comment on this
I am glad the visits to Limerick of Deputy Rabbitte and Deputy Dennehy have convinced them of the merits of this scheme. I would have thought they were familiar with the problems of the long-term unemployed nearer home and that they would not need an excursion to Limerick to make them aware of those. The point being made by the Irish National Organisation of the Unemployed in respect of the low take-up is that if the Minister can dedicate £5 million to this scheme in a full year, why not use it in back to work allowances? If only 200 or 300 people take up the scheme, there will be £5 million in the budgetary figures for a full year in 1999 which will not go to the benefit of the long-term unemployed. It is an issue of allocating resources and using them to the best effect. I will not press this because obviously there are merits on both sides. I hope it works.
Comment on this
I confess I have not read the section so I am not clear as to how the schools will be designated. Will that be done under the previous disadvantaged schemes because there are problems with that sort of designation, as I am sure the Minister is aware?
Comment on this
That is my concern because I understand the Department of Education and Science discontinued designating schools as disadvantaged about three years ago and anomalies remain in the system. I am aware of cases where feeder schools to a particular secondary school are designated disadvantaged but the secondary school is not, even though the schools are in the same area and deal with the same pupils. I am also aware of a case in a particular parish where the girls' primary school is designated as disadvantaged but the boys' school is not. I do not object in principle to what the Minister is proposing but in terms of the designation there are wrinkles in the system which have to be ironed out.
Comment on this
The designation of schools is a matter for the Minister for Education and Science. I will raise with him the difficulties to which the Deputy referred.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 30, line 33, to delete "United States".
This is a technical amendment to delete a superfluous reference to the United States.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 30, before section 15, to insert the following new section:
15.-Section 268 of the Principal Act is hereby amended in subsection (5)(a)(iii) by the substitution of '30th day of September, 1998' for '31st day of December, 1997'.".
Capital allowances for hotels and other industrial buildings were restricted to hotels and buildings located in the State in the Finance Act, 1996. This measure was brought in to counter exploitation by certain investors who bought and then leased hotels in another country for the purposes of availing of the capital allowances against their Irish income. Transitional provisions were put in place at the time in response to representations received in respect of a number of new or refurbished hotels in Northern Ireland which were adversely affected by the change. The transitional provisions required an agreement in writing to acquire the site prior to 23 April 1996, a construction contract to be concluded before 1 July 1996 and the construction to have commenced before 1 July 1996 and to be completed by 31 December 1997.
It has now been established that one of the projects originally provided for in the transitional arrangements will not meet the 31 December 1997 deadline for completion of building. The project was delayed due to the reticence of bankers to back the project after the collapse of the ceasefire in February 1996. The promoters have invested significant resources to date in the project and the project is near completion. The deadline for completion of construction is being extended to 30 September 1998 to accommodate this project.
Comment on this
The Dáil has passed the Air Navigation Transport Bill which is with the Seanad now. It effectively constitutes the Aer Rianta and the individual airports as independent semi-State companies. I assume the intention is to allow them to attract private finance. I have no problem in principle with this but it appears it is pointing in a particular direction - and this was raised with the Minister's colleague, the Minister for Public Enterprise - to sell off one or other of the individual airports. I would like to know if that is the case. We have constituted them separately and we are now allowing them to attract private finance but it appears that it is going in one direction only. If that is the Minister's intention, will he give us some indication now?
Comment on this
This is like living with one's reputation on the hurling or football field. This has nothing to do with the Deputy's allegation as to what may be down the road. This is a very simple section. Aer Rianta will have to pay corporation tax on its profits in the future as a result of recent legislation. Therefore it should be allowed claim capital allowances on its buildings and other structures the same as any other company. This section will allow it to claim capital allowances against its profits. It has nothing to do with——
Comment on this
I do not wish to delay the meeting. I am simply putting down a marker in relation to this.
Comment on this
The Deputy's interest in protecting the State-owned companies is highly commendable, particularly in view of the forthcoming by-election the Dublin North.
Comment on this
On this occasion the Deputy is going in the wrong direction. This is what Aer Rianta wants because it allows it to set off capital allowances on its industrial buildings against its profits in the same way as any ordinary company. There was no need to have this provision previously because the Aer Rianta profits would not have been taxable.
Comment on this
Given the Minister's assurances I take he has no intention of selling off the existing State-owned airports?
Comment on this
Yes, but in the Aer Rianta case it has no relevance because its capital allowances will be written off against profits in the normal fashion. There are 25,000 businesses which can claim normal capital allowances.
Comment on this
No, this has nothing to do with that matter. In order that I will not be hunted down in the next six months or even in the next six days——
Comment on this
If the focus was shifted from Dublin Airport to Baldonnel, what would the Minister say?
Comment on this
Baldonnel is close to my own area and that of Deputy Rabbitte. I would like to hear the Deputy's view on that matter given the forthcoming by-election in Dublin North.
Comment on this
So have I. Section 15 provides for the granting of an industrial buildings allowance in respect of capital expenditure on buildings or structures used for the management or operation of an airport. Since l992, runways and aprons qualify for this allowance and now other buildings, for example, terminal buildings, emergency service buildings and structures, will benefit. These measures will be significant for both Aer Rianta, which manages Cork, Dublin and Shannon Airports, and for other airport operators. Aer Rianta will benefit as regards qualifying expenditure incurred on or after the vesting day, that is the day on which ownership of the assets of those three main airports is transferred to it under the provisions of the Air Navigation and Transport (Amendment) Bill, l997. Other airport operators will qualify in respect of expenditure incurred on or after the date of the passing of the Finance Act, l998. In addition capital allowance will be available in respect of existing airport buildings or structures with effect from those dates. The allowance will be calculated on a net figure based on the costs originally incurred on the assets, less the capital allowances that would have been granted had those buildings etc. qualified before now.
Comment on this
I am not 100 per cent clear. If somebody wants to build a new terminal, a new airport, in Baldonnel, are they entitled to use capital allowances in this way?
Comment on this
Yes. The capital allowance for airport buildings will be 4 per cent per annum but not the accelerated allowances. In other words they are written off over 25 years. That is normal for industrial buildings owned by private operators, airports or otherwise.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 36, paragraph (a), lines 13, after "Act" to insert "or primary health care services centres".
Section 17 provides for capital allowances to nursing homes. It should be amended so that capital allowances would apply also to primary health care service centres. We should encourage group practices and move away from residential care to day care. We should encourage a move towards the services of GPs rather than hospital accident and emergency services. The availability of capital allowances for group practices, frequently of a multi-disciplinary nature, would encourage this throughout the country. Deputy Rabbitte will be pleased to hear it was correspondence from somebody on behalf of a group of people who are developing a primary health care service centre in Tallaght which inspired this particular amendment.
Comment on this
This is another of my initiatives to bring private nursing homes into the capital allowances incentivisation area. In the next ten, 15 or 20 years the biggest problem facing——
Comment on this
I think the Minister is venturing into the area I want to touch on. Each Opposition spokesperson has received a submission from the Irish Nursing Homes Association or whatever it is. I was approached by a number of nursing home owners in Limerick and it seems Deputy Noonan and I might have to consider swapping constituencies. The point is the same. They claim that this will be the end of civilisation as we know it, that the caring ethos at the heart of nursing home care will go out the window if we allow nursing homes to operate on the basis of tax considerations. That is their argument and the Minister should address it.
He should also address section 274(1)(b) of the Taxes Consolidation Act which deals with the balancing of allowances and balancing charges on industrial buildings. The provision for balancing allowances ceases if the nursing home ceases to qualify as a nursing home after ten years. The point was made that you cannot have it both ways. If conversion to a nursing home or the construction of a new nursing home is allowed, it should be required to function as a nursing home for more than ten years. On the demographic point about the needs of the community over the next 25 years, if the nursing home is converted back after ten years, what is the merit in it in the first place?
I would ask the Minister to address the point made by the chairman of the Irish Registered Nursing Homes Association in seeking to ringÍfence the capital allowances facility, by which he means to set it against the profits generated by the nursing home.
Comment on this
On foot of the correspondence received from the Irish Registered Nursing Homes Association, all of us welcome in principle the provisions in section 17. We are aware, through constituency work, of the enormous difficulties that exist for elderly people in getting access to public beds and the role private nursing homes play, and have played successfully since the introduction of the Nursing Homes (Registration) Bill, 1992. Does the Minister envisage in the implementation of this section a specific role for health boards in approving proposed investments in new nursing homes?
It would be unfair to nursing homes already in existence, approved by health boards and providing a satisfactory level of care, to have to compete with persons who receive assistance from the State to establish nursing homes. Will the Minister enshrine in this section a provision to link the availability of capital allowances with the quality of care that nursing homes are obliged to provide under the nursing homes legislation of 1992? Where a nursing home fails to meet that level of care, will the allowances be withdrawn or withheld? Nursing homes provide a service that is not comparable with any other commodity that is consumed by the customer and in that sense there is need to police capital allowances in an effective way.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Creed was in the Dáil on budget day when I made the announcement about private nursing homes. I said that nursing homes would have to be approved by a health board - the relevant section, section 17, refers to that point. I was anxious that the capital allowance would be available only to nursing homes approved under the relevant Act. This matter is covered under the Health (Nursing Homes) Act, 1990.
Comment on this
Will the establishment of the nursing home have to be approved, given that there may not be a void in the market and that other nursing homes may take up the slack in a particular area?
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte referred to this matter in another amendment which was ruled out of order and I will deal with it now. In the next ten to 15 years this matter will cause an increasing problem for the Exchequer. Despite the Celtic tiger, the Exchequer will not be in a position to meet all the demands and to bear the costs as demands are made. It is my intention to give the capital allowance, the tax incentive which has worked well in other areas, to people to allow them to set up nursing homes. That is the raison d’être behind the initiative.
Deputies should not be drawn into the argument about competition. Deputy Creed's last point relates to competition, to whether a person operating a nursing home will be adversely affected by a nursing home in the next town or village. Experience in my county and surrounding areas is that it is very difficult to get into one of those homes and it is also very expensive. Even with State subvention, which is a substantial cost to the State, many people find it difficult to make up the shortfall. Lobbying organisations, be they trade unions or employers' organisations, protect their own interests, and rightly so. I consider matters more broadly. If a nursing home is approved under the Nursing Homes Act, competition regarding prices should be the order of the day. It would be a mistake for the Houses of the Oireachtas to get into that argument and enshrine such matters in legislation.
I am not in a position to accept the amendment put forward by Deputy Noonan. It proposes to extend the scheme of capital allowances for private nursing homes, envisaged in section 17, to cover primary health care services centres. It is important to outline the rationale behind section 17, which is to encourage the provision of extra nursing home places in private nursing homes registered with health boards.
The effect of the amendment would be to provide capital allowances on the same basis as proposed for nursing homes to the centres referred to. The major difficulty with this amendment is that a wide range of facilities would be covered by it. For example, the term "primary health care services centre" could involve a large number of diverse services such as a health centre providing a range of primary care services. These could include services of a general practitioner, public health nursing, dental services, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, counselling and so on. It could also cover general practice surgeries where general practitioners provide primary medical care, with perhaps some of the services already mentioned.
There are already significant financial incentives in place under the general medical services scheme for capital grants and the indicative drug target scheme to support general practitioners in providing new or improved practice premises for themselves. Given the purpose of the nursing home incentive offered under section 17, I cannot accept the amendment as it is geared towards a completely different objective.
Comment on this
In making the case for this amendment I would draw on exactly the same material as the Minister used to make a case for capital allowances for nursing homes. There is a major difficulty facing the Exchequer. We are aware of the projections for the proportion of the population which will be a particular age at a particular time in the next millennium. First, there will be a problem with pensions. I put down an amendment, which I will refile on Report Stage, and we will deal with that matter at that stage. There will be a problem funding private, public service and social welfare pensions.
The issue that arises with nursing homes is like a seamless garment, whether people are put in residential beds or kept in the community. If there were proper primary care facilities fewer people would be institutionalised. Primary health care centres would not only have GPs, but nurses, occupational therapists, physiotherapists and dentists. If facilities to which elderly people had easy access were available around the country elderly people would spend a longer time in their homes and communities before going to nursing homes.
I could make a good financial argument citing Denmark for dedicating more money to clearing waiting lists in orthopaedic hospitals. One of its initiatives for care of the aged is to ensure they are kept mobile. It ensures it does not have a waiting list for orthopaedic purposes, especially for those who require hip replacements, or for removing cataracts from the eyes. The two medical conditions that demobilise the elderly more than any other are the inability to move around because of orthopaedic difficulties, especially in the case of those who require hip replacements, and having cataracts on the eyes.
I would like the Minister to examine the problem he has identified and bring a wider focus to it, to start from the concept that primary care facilities in the community and residential care facilities in nursing homes, hospitals or geriatric hospitals are two sides of the same coin. The better the primary care facilities, the less demand there will be on nursing homes. I know the Minister cannot accept this amendment today, but I ask him to consider it between now and Report Stage. The impact of it will not drift all over the economy. It is pretty well ringfenced. We are talking about fairly reasonable centres of population where, first, a number of GPs are compatible and are prepared to share practices and, second, where they are prepared to bring in occupational therapists, nurses and people who carry out primary testing and so on. It will not be the thin end of the wedge for allowance seekers. If there are problems with definitions, I have no doubt the officials in the Department of Health and Children will help the Minister with the definition section. Will he consider this matter, because it addresses a real need? I could use most of the material the Minister put before us in support of what he has said to equally support what I am saying. It is the same issue.
Comment on this
I am impressed by the strength of the argument put forward by the Deputy. My original section 17 relates to providing private nursing homes. The Deputy is right in saying he could use the same argument I put forward in support of that to support primary health care centres. I will consider the matter before Report Stage and discuss it further with the Department of Health and Children. I bow to the expertise the Deputy gained when he was Minister for Health in the previous Administration. If I am not in a position to accept this on Report Stage, it is something I will certainly consider for the next Finance Bill. I give the Deputy that undertaking now. I will consider all those suggestions even if they involve a great deal of cost.
Comment on this
Like the Minister, I bow to Deputy Noonan's superior knowledge of the health services since he spent some time in the Department of Health. He will know better than me there is a certain amount of patient resistance to the notion of group practices or that of primary health centres.
Comment on this
It is changing slowly but surely, but it is probably still fair to say most patients, particularly older people, who tend to get ill more often, like to have an individual relationship with the primary health care practitioner, who in many cases is a GP with his own practice and not attached to a health centre. One can construct a very persuasive argument that there should be health centres or group practices in particular areas, but that needs to be done in an organised way, probably with the participation of health boards. They need to consider areas in cities or villages and decide to encourage a group practice or more than one group practice in that area. Deputy Noonan is right in saying there are types of facilities which can be effectively provided outside of hospitals, for example, the taking of X-rays. That is quite a skill, but it could be done outside hospitals and there is no need to clog hospitals up with that service. The equipment is quite expensive and there would be some sort of capital allowance write-off system for doing that. In acknowledging there is a certain amount of resistance to group practices we need to bear in mind that the individual general practitioners must also be given some support. While we should encourage group practices, we should do so in an organised way by considering the needs of areas in conjunction health boards.
Comment on this
I accept what Deputy McDowell said and we can take this up again on Report Stage. I will respond to the point made about the question of capital allowance and balancing charges. The capital allowance for nursing homes, as in section 17, will be subject to the £25,000 limit per annum on the amount of allowances which an individual passive investor can claim against non rental income. In other words, the limit of £25,000 per annum, I am importing throughout the Bill for passive individual investors, applies in this case, but it does not apply to people who build and operate nursing homes.
Amendment No. 44 in Deputy Rabbitte's name, which proposed substituting 15 years for ten years, was ruled out of order. There is also provision for a clawback of the allowances when a building ceases to be a nursing home within ten years. Ten years is sufficient rather than extending it to 15 years. The purpose of the Deputy's amendment is to make sure people do not convert nursing homes into houses after a period of ten years.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
43. In page 36, paragraph (a) (i), between lines 13 and 14, to insert the following:
"(III) by the insertion after paragraph (g) of the following paragraph:
'(h) a building or structure, which is an industrial building or structure by virtue of paragraph (d), shall be deemed to continue to be an industrial building or structure, notwithstanding that on a cessation of its use for the purposes of the trade of hotel keeping, the building or structure is converted to use for the purposes contained in paragraph (g), and all of the provisions of this Part shall apply accordingly.'.".
Capital allowances are available for hotels. The Minister introduced section 17 which makes capital allowances available for nursing homes. That is prompted by a number of cases where hotels have been converted into nursing homes. It is to have a seamless transfer of allowances when there is a change from the use of a premises as a hotel to a nursing home. It has merit and I would like the Minister to examine it, if he has not already, between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
I am willing to accede to the Deputy's request. His amendment deals with a hotel which is converted into a nursing home before the end of its tax life for capital allowance purposes. As the law currently stands, such a hotel would lose its entitlement to any further capital allowances once it ceased to be used as a hotel. The expenditure and conversion of the building into a nursing home would, however, qualify for capital allowance under section 17. The amendment proposes that any residual capital allowance on a hotel should not be lost on its conversion to a nursing home. That is only fair. The Deputy brought an instance to the attention of my officials and it would be very unfair not to allow that individual to transfer over to a nursing home. The Deputy's amendment might have to be changed, but its spirit will be retained. I will consider it between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 39, before section 19, to insert the following new section:
19.-Chapter 3 of Part 10 of the Principal Act is hereby amended-
(a) (i) in section 339(1), by the substitution in paragraph (b) of the definition of 'qualifying period' of '31st day of December, 1999' for '30th day of June, 2000',
and
(ii) in section 339(2)-
(I) in paragraph (a), by the substitution of the following for the words from the 'reference in paragraph (a)' to the end of the paragraph:
'the reference in paragraph (a) of the definition of "qualifying period" in subsection (1) to the period ending on the 31st day of July, 1997, shall be construed as a reference to the period ending on the 31st day of July, 1998.', and
(II) by the insertion of the following paragraph after paragraph (b):
'(c) Where in relation to the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of a building or structure to which paragraph (a) relates-
(i) the relevant local authority has given to the person constructing, converting or refurbishing, as the case may be, that building or structure, a certificate in writing to which that paragraph refers certifying that not less than 15 per cent of the total cost of the building or structure had been incurred before the 31st day of July, 1997, and
(ii) an application for planning permission for the work represented by the expenditure incurred or to be incurred on the building or structure had (in so far as such permission is required) been received by a planning authority not later than the 1st day of March, 1998, and
(iii) where the expenditure to be incurred on a building or structure has not been fully incurred by the 31st day of July, 1998, the relevant local authority gives a certificate in writing to the person referred to in subparagraph (i) stating that in its opinion-
(I) that person had, on the 31st day of July, 1997, a reasonable expectation that the expenditure to be incurred on the building or structure would have been incurred in full on or before the 31st day of July, 1998, and
(II) the failure to incur that expenditure in full on or before the 31st day of July, 1998, was, on the basis of reasons of a bona fide character stated to it, due, to a significant extent, to a delay outside the direct control of that person, including an unanticipated delay in obtaining the grant of planning permission or a fire certificate, an unanticipated delay due to legal proceedings or unanticipated difficulties in completing the acquisition of a site or involving the failure of a building contractor to fulfil his or her obligations or the need to respect any archaeological site or remains,
then, the reference in paragraph (a) of the definition of "qualifying period" to the period ending on the 31st day of July, 1997, shall be construed as a reference to the period ending on the 31st day of December, 1998.',
(b) in section 340(2), by the substitution in paragraph (ii) of '31st day of December, 1999' for '30th day of June, 2000',
(c) in section 343-
(i) in subsection (1), in the definition of 'qualifying company', by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph (a):
'(a) which has been approved for financial assistance under a scheme administered by Forfás, Forbairt, the Industrial Development Agency (Ireland) or Údarás na Gaeltachta, and',
and
(ii) in subsection (2), by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph (a):
'(a) on the recommendation of Forfás (in conjunction with Forbairt, the Industrial Development Agency (Ireland) or Údarás na Gaeltachta, as may be appro-priate), in accordance with guidelines laid down by the Minister, and',
(d) in section 345, by the substitution, in subsection (1), of the following for the definition of 'qualifying lease':
'"qualifying lease" means, subject to subsection (8), a lease in respect of a qualifying premises granted in the qualifying period, or within the period of one year from the day next after the end of the qualifying period, on bona fide commercial terms by a lessor to a lessee not connected with the lessor, or with any other person entitled to a rent in respect of the qualifying premises, whether under that lease or any other lease;',
and
(e) by the insertion of the following section after section 350:
350A.-Where relief is given by virtue of any provision of this Chapter in relation to capital expenditure or other expenditure incurred on, or rent payable in respect of, any building or structure, premises or multi-storey car park, relief shall not be given in respect of that expenditure or that rent under any other provision of the Tax Acts.'.".
The existing section 19 changes from 30 June 2000 to 31 December 1999, the termination date for tax reliefs for the enterprise areas of Cherry Orchard/Gallanstown, Finglas and Rosslare Harbour as well as any such areas immediately adjacent to the regional airports to be designated by order. EU Commission approval of these areas was conditional on the shorter qualifying period. The existing section also amends the definition of a qualifying company to include reference to companies approved by Údarás Na Gaeltachta for financial assistance. These provisions are reintroduced in the new section now being substituted. They appear at paragraphs (a), (i), (b) and (c) respectively.
The new section 19 makes a number of additional changes. Clause (I) of paragraph (a)(ii) corrects the defective text in section 339(2)(a) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. This provision provided for a one year extension of the 1994 urban renewal scheme deadline to 31 July 1998. A number of words were omitted when the provision enacted in the 1997 Finance Act was incorporated in the Taxes Consolidation Act.
Clause (II) of paragraph (a)(ii) provides for a further extension of the 1994 urban renewal scheme deadline to 31 December 1998, subject to conditions. These include a requirement that 15 per cent of expenditure should have been incurred by 31 July 1997, which was a condition for the previous one year extension. An application for planning permission must be received by a planning authority by 1 March 1998. The planning authority must certify that the failure to meet the July 1998 deadline was due, in its opinion, to a significant extent to unanticipated delays relating to obtaining planning permission or a fire certificate, legal proceedings or a number of other factors.
Paragraph (d) amends the definition of "qualifying lease" to ensure such leases will benefit from the deadline extension. Following the amendment, a qualifying lease can be granted for a period of up to one year after the qualifying period.
Paragraph (e) inserts a new section at the end of the 1994 urban renewal scheme provisions. Because of the extension of the qualifying period to 31 December 1998, this scheme will overlap with the new urban renewal scheme beginning on 1 August 1998. The purpose of the new section is to ensure relief cannot be claimed twice for expenditure incurred in the overlapping periods.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 39, before section 19, to insert the following new section:
19.-(1) Chapter 1 of Part 10 of the Principal Act is hereby amended-
(a) in section 322-
(i) in subsection (1), by the substitution in the definition of 'the specified period' of '31st day of December, 1999' for '24th day of January, 1999', and
(ii) in subsection (2)(b), by the substitution of '31st day of December, 1999' for '24th day of January, 1999',
and
(b) in section 323, by the deletion of subsection (3)(b).
(2) This section shall come into operation on such day as the Minister for Finance may, by order, appoint.".
The availability of accelerated capital allowances in the Custom House Docks area expires on 24 January 1999. To allow for the completion of some current projects in the area, in particular the area between Commons Street and Guild Street, it is proposed to extend the termination date to 31 December 1999. Approval is required from the European Commission under state aid rules. This has been sought but not yet received. The amendment provides for the provision of the Bill to be brought into effect by order once EU approval is secured.
The amendment also removes the restriction on the level of allowances claimable in respect of expenditure incurred in the last year of the qualifying period of the scheme. While accelerated allowances of up to 100 per cent are generally available for projects in the Custom House Docks area, these are restricted to 54 per cent in the final year of the scheme. This restriction is being removed to encourage completion of outstanding projects.
Comment on this
I do not have a problem with the substantial amendment which gives us an opportunity to mention the Custom House docklands area scheme. It is my understanding that many of the incentives available were set out in last year's Finance Act and that the Minister can expect a communication in the near future from the docklands authority on the application of particular incentives to particular areas.
The price of residential accommodation being built in the docklands area associated with the IFSC has increased enormously in the past year. I am aware of cases where the price of apartments has more than doubled. It is self-evident that for much of the docklands area we do not need to give the kind of incentives on offer for the construction of residential apartments and houses, except perhaps for social housing. If and when the Minister receives an application relating to apartments or houses I hope he will look critically at this.
Comment on this
I will bear what the Deputy said in mind. To illustrate how bright politicians cum accountants can be, one and a half years ago I advised a client, given their financial circumstances, not to purchase an apartment in the area in question, that it was not the thing to do. This goes to show that one should not take advice from accountants. I was totally wrong. The Deputy's point about tax incentives driving up the price of residential and non-residential property in the docklands area is taken by me. That is the downside of the package of incentives. I will bear the Deputy's point in mind if a proposal is submitted to me.
Comment on this
On a related matter, in 1986 a package of tax incentives was introduced for Shannon Airport to establish a financial services industry. A similar package was subsequently put in place for the financial services industry in Dublin, principally on the Custom House Docks site. There is a case to be made for promoting Shannon once more. I am not looking for any changes in the package of incentives in place but, because of the interest of the Taoiseach of the day and the resources of the State in the Revenue Commissioners, the Department of Finance and the IDA were mobilised to actively promote it. The financial services industry in Dublin was a great success and Shannon got little of the action. Given the rate of asset inflation in the docklands area in Dublin and the difficulties being encountered in attracting skilled graduates to work in the financial services industry, the argument that the Minister should look at what he can do to promote Shannon on an equal basis has merit. I do not want to take anything from Dublin but it appears the wider international financial services community is not aware that there is another financial services industry located here. I ask the Minister to become involved in promoting it.
Comment on this
The Deputy may be aware that a request for EU approval for another financial services centre would not be greeted with glee by the European Commission. Shannon has an inbuilt advantage over Dublin in one respect. The 10 per cent tax incentive rate applies to all services in the Shannon area. In Dublin it applies only to financial services in the IFSC. That is the main difference between the two locations. The package of tax incentives approved in writing in 1986 by the European Commission for Shannon and Dublin will come to an end in 2005. As the Deputy will readily appreciate, it is not difficult to predict that we would not receive EU approval to establish another financial services centre here.
Comment on this
I am not asking the Minister to do that. The package of tax incentives in place at Shannon Airport is being inadequately promoted. As the financial services industry in Dublin was promoted strongly initially, it is a success. Given the rate of asset inflation and the pressure on the labour market, will the Minister look again, with the IDA officials involved and the committee responsible for promoting the industry in Dublin, at the manner in which the Shannon initiative is promoted since it has not been as successful?
Comment on this
I may have taken the Deputy up incorrectly. I will discuss with the relevant bodies the question of how Shannon could be marketed more successfully. The Deputy is correct in saying that to give the financial services industry in Dublin a kick start, much effort was put into marketing it. There is everything to be gained in promoting Shannon. I will not hesitate to draw the attention of the relevant interdepartmental committees and agencies to this matter.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 39, before section 20, to insert the following new section:
"20.-Section 286 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (2):
'(3) In respect of any bus used for the carriage of members of the public there shall be available free depreciation for the purposes of determining what capital allowances are available to a person for any chargeable period.'.".
There is general agreement that traffic congestion is one of the major problems affecting the country, particularly Dublin. It is almost impossible to make a political speech without referring to it. Short-term solutions are limited. This is similar to the housing problem. I will table another amendment on Report Stage dealing with stamp duty on secondhand homes for first time buyers because the one I tabled on Committee Stage was rolled over in the first vote this morning.
The only viable solution to traffic congestion in the short, medium or long term is to encourage people to move from private to public transport. This amendment provides for "free depreciation for the purposes of determining what capital allowances are available to a person for any chargeable period". This would mean banks and other financial institutions would be prepared to lease buses to CIE and private bus carriers. There will be major demands on the Minister to upgrade Dublin Bus and Bus Éireann's fleet as soon as possible. People will move from the comfort of private transport to public transport, only if buses are comfortable and upgraded. The Minister faces a bill of several hundred million pounds for upgrading buses, which will come out of his capital allocation for subsidies to CIÉ. The measure I propose is an alternative way to solve the problem and would trigger negotiations between CIÉ and certain financial institutions, particularly the main lending banks, who were previously involved in leasing arrangements with the manufacturing industry.
The same could apply in the case of private bus companies and there would be no loss to the Exchequer. Revenue is foregone when one introduces tax efficient leasing arrangements. In the case of CIÉ, our choice is direct funding or this proposal, which is worth considering.
Comment on this
Section 20 merely extends the qualifying date. I despair of this provision and wonder why we bothered doing this. The Minister will probably tell me the former Minister, Deputy Quinn, introduced this measure and I suspect he did. However, I wonder at the wisdom of encouraging people to take their cars into the centre of Dublin. This inevitably results from the provision of multi-storey car parks.
We have free car parking at Leinster House. I live in Killester, but I do not always use the DART even though I know I should. If I did not have a car parking space here, I would not drive to work. We are encourage people to take their cars to work by providing car parking spaces in the city centre. In that context, I fail to understand why this measure was proposed. I appreciate it merely extends the qualifying date, but I hope this will be the last of it.
Comment on this
Deputy McDowell referred to the substance of the section whereas Deputy Noonan's amendment relates specifically to the traffic problem. I could have an interesting debate on what I would do, if I had dictatorial powers, about traffic congestion in Dublin. I profess to being Kildare's expert on Dublin's traffic problems because since October 1967 I have travelled from Kildare to Dublin several times a week. I accept that something radical must be done. From a survey I carried out in the past year and a half I discovered that there is only one person in 18 out of every 20 cars coming into Dublin each morning.
I do not believe the problem is getting worse. Tax breaks and skilled personnel are not the only attractions Dublin offers to business people. Quality of life in the city is a major factor. If that is damaged by severe traffic congestion we will lose business. Therefore, the matter should be addressed. The section merely extends the qualifying date by a short period. The traffic problem can be debated in another forum because, from my 31 years of experience of travelling to and from Dublin, I have personal views on the matter. I used many different forms of transport during that time.
While I accept the import of Deputy Noonan's amendment, accelerating capital allowances or free depreciation is not the way to resolve the problem. Buses have never been entitled to free depreciation. Some years ago the taxation code included free depreciation allowances, but successive Ministers for Finance have introduced a more realistic and streamlined way to deal with capital allowances. Buses are written off over five years at 20 per cent per annum. As Deputy Noonan correctly pointed out, bus companies would not benefit from free depreciation because they do not pay tax. Banks and other financial institutions would use this provision to get tax breaks and we would lose their tax revenue. On its own, this measure would not resolve the traffic problems. However, it could be put in the melting pot with all the other suggestions on how to deal with the problem. I have no objection to the proposal, but I cannot accept it in this format.
Comment on this
During the debate on the budget I outlined clearly what traffic congestion in Dublin will do to the economy. I am not advocating this as a complete solution, a package of initiatives will have to be put in place to deal with the problem. However, in so far as it has been identified as a primary problem, particularly in Dublin, it should be addressed under any relevant legislation. I cannot propose building ring roads around Dublin, the early commencement of the Luas project or placing cameras on bridges to ensure there is more than one person in cars driving into the city. The Finance Bill is not an appropriate vehicle to introduce radical solutions, but there is merit in what I have suggested. One of the principal reasons people do not travel on buses is that they are not nice vehicles; some of them are in an appalling state. The condition of the buses in my city deters people from using them. People travel on the DART because it is convenient and attractive and journey times are fairly fast.
If the Minister is refusing to accept the amendment he has an obligation to say if he will directly fund the CIÉ fleet so that there are modern buses in all areas, particularly Dublin. Dublin Bus vehicles should attract, not repel, passengers. We must introduce measures which will encourage the use of public transport by couples who live in the suburbs and use their cars to travel to work and drop their children at school. One measure could be a benefit in kind for people who use public transport. I could draft an amendment along those lines. We could also give a limited tax allowance to people who buy monthly or six monthly tickets, while people who buy a season ticket could be given a tax write-off.
Every Friday evening private buses take young civil servants to the four corners of the country. The Minister must provide funding for CIÉ so that it can provide this service. Otherwise the pressure will mount and when the portfolio proposals are put forward the Minister will have to pay a direct subsidy to CIÉ and a grant-in-aid to private carriers. A better way of doing this is through the tax code and the application of accelerated capital allowances to bus fleets. This will enable the financial institutions to become involved in leasing arrangements. The banks are looking for outlets for their money and if they were given the opportunity they would invest in the upgrading of public and private fleets very quickly. This would ensure that the vehicles are in place when the larger package to solve the traffic problems is introduced.
Comment on this
There is a certain logic in the Deputy's point but an individual measure like this will not solve the traffic problems. As this is a Finance Bill the proposed initiatives relate to taxation. On tax based incentives, the Deputy said that the Exchequer would have to subsidise the cost of replacing the bus fleet. It is important to remember that tax based leasing incentives also have a cost to the Exchequer even though it is not as evident. I am not prepared to amend the Bill in the way proposed by the Deputy but I will give some thought to what he said. I accept some of the arguments but I cannot accommodate the amendment in the Bill.
Comment on this
This provision will extend the period to 30 June 1999. I will have to examine the matter in the context of next year's Bill. I am very taken with some of the arguments made by the Deputy regarding multi-storey car parks in the inner-city and I will give consideration to them.
Comment on this
It depends on whether one wants to apply it on a stick or carrot basis. If there are no more incentives to build multi-storey car parks in the inner city, where will people park their cars? If there are no car parks people will have to use public transport to travel to work. However, the Government is refusing to go ahead with Luas and has done nothing to improve public transport. There is a danger that the city will grind to a halt.
Comment on this
I predict that the city will grind to a halt some day, and that is the only way the traffic problems in Dublin will be solved. The Deputy referred to the dilapidated buses on which he has travelled. Between 1967 and 1975 I travelled on a CIÉ bus every day. I was a Garret FitzGerald type expert on all the buses which left Busáras for Cork, Limerick, Mountmellick, Birr etc. I knew the time they left and the stops they made. I know all about travelling on dilapidated buses.
Comment on this
It reminds me of the film "The Italian Job" where the job was successful because the city of Milan ground to a halt and mini cars had to be used. Something similar will happen in Dublin city in the next two or three years: there will be gridlock for about five days and action will have to be taken to deal with it. I speak as an expert in this area having travelled in and out to Dublin city for 31 years.
Comment on this
One is not supposed to refer to the obvious but this is what will happen. It is only then that we will do something about it.
Comment on this
I propose to table a Report Stage amendment to create a link between the provisions of the 1997 Finance Act dealing with urban renewal in the Dublin docklands area and the functions of the Dublin Docklands Authority in recommending areas for designation.
Comment on this
Does the Authority recommend applications for relief for certain parts of the docklands?
Comment on this
As it is now 4.30 p.m., I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 26 February: "That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to Chapter 3 of Part 1 of the Bill and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill; and, in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said Chapter, other than section 38, that the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to.".
Comment on this
The Select Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
We now move on to Chapters 4 and 5 of Part I covering sections 43 to 49, also including new sections 60 and 61.
NEW SECTIONS.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 65, before section 43, but in Chapter 3, to insert the following new section:
43. The Principal Act is hereby amended, in sections 723(1), 737(1) and 838(1), by the substitution, in the definition of 'specified qualifying shares', of '£200,000,000' for '£100,000,000'.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 65, before section 43, but in Chapter 3, to insert the following new section:
44. Chapter 1 of Part 7 of the Principal Act is hereby amended in section 198-
(a) by renumbering the existing provision as subsection (1) of that section, and
(b) by the addition of the following:
'(2) In relation to interest paid in respect of a relevant security (within the meaning of section 246), subsection (1) shall apply-
(a) as if there were deleted from subsection (2) of section 445 , "and any certificate so given shall, unless it is revoked under subsection (4), (5) or (6), remain in force until the 31st day of December, 2005", and
(b) as if there were deleted from subsection (2) of section 446, "and any certificate so given shall, unless it is revoked under subsection (4), (5) or (6), remain in force until the 31st day of December, 2005".'.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 76:
In page 66, before section 45, to insert the following new section:
45. (1) Section 713(3) of the Principal Act is hereby amended-
(a) by the substitution of 'specified in section 21(1)' for 'specified in section 21(1)(b)', and
(b) by the substitution of 'in respect of the part specified in subsection (6) of the unrelieved profits' for 'in respect of the part specified in subsection (5) of the unrelieved profits'.
(2) This section shall apply as on and from the 6th day of April, 1997.".
This is a drafting amendment. Section 43 of the Finance Bill, 1998, amended section 21(1) of the Tax Consolidation Act, 1997, to avoid a new 32 per cent rate of corporation tax. The amendment introduced a new paragraph (c) into section 21(1). The existing reference in section 713(3) to section 21(1)(b) is no longer accurate and has been changed in paragraph (a) of this amendment to read section 21(1).
Section 713 deals with the taxation regime of life insurance funds. Paragraph (b) of the amendment corrects a consolidation error in section 713(3) where the current reference to subsection (5) should be the reference of subsection (6).
Comment on this
I am confused because of the way the numbering system has changed. I gather we have already agreed section 43 which actually changes the rates of corporation tax. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Given that I was not awake at the time I am going to use section 44 to address that issue. I do not want to delay because we have brought out this point in public a number of times but I want clarification on one point. It strikes me that there are two ways in which corporation tax could be reduced, accepting the broad principle that we want to reduce it to 12.5 per cent over a period, that is, by lowering the lower rate and raising the threshold at which it applies or by reducing both rates. I have argued previously that we should have taken the former route, that we should benefit in the first instance the 93 per cent of companies that pay at the lower rate of corporation tax rather than give a windfall profit to the largely financial services-based companies which pay the higher rate. Has that point been negotiated with the European Commission and, if so, is it insisting that we reduce both rates or retain the discretion to go the route I have suggested, namely, raising the threshold for the lower rate?
Comment on this
In the budget I reduced the general corporation tax rate from 36 per cent to 32 per cent and the relief for small companies with profits of less than £50,000 from 28 per cent to 25 per cent. Approximately 94 per cent of all companies have profits - subject to previous figures - of less than £50,000. To be absolutely precise, approximately, 18,500 taxpaying companies had profits of less than £50,000, of whom 2,000 had very small payments.
The Deputy has raised the question of corporation tax rates previously and I understand where he is coming from. Both this Administration and the previous Administration concluded that the special 10 per cent corporation tax rate available to manufacturing industry and companies in the IFSC and to Shannon has been a major determinant factor in contributing to Ireland's economic growth in recent times and over the past 20 years. Export sales relief operated from 1956 until we changed the rules and introduced the 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate.
A feature of Irish industrial policy since the mid-1950s has been lower taxation to attract foreign companies in particular. Until we introduced the 10 per cent manufacturing tax, export sales relief was successful in attracting companies here. It was also attractive to Irish companies. All Administrations have accepted that this has been a major contributory factor to economic prosperity and it must be continued as an incentive to keep business here.
In the 1980s when we decided to set up the Irish Financial Services Centre, the Government concluded an agreement with the European Commission that the 10 per cent rate for the IFSC and Shannon would continue to the year 2005. Neither at that time nor at any previous time was our special 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate regarded by the European Commission as a general aid to business. In 1996 things started to change from the European Commission's perspective. Whereas the general corporation tax rate had been at 50 per cent and 40 per cent for many and we had started to reduce it 38 per cent and later to 36 per cent, the outgoing Administration recognised that the situation had changed within the European Commission. Consequently after some thought had been given to the matter the outgoing Administration concluded that the only way out of this problem was to reduce it to a new single rate It is within the competence of every member state to decide its own level of taxation. We had a difficulty given our high rate of taxation - 36 per cent when this started but reduced to 32 per cent - and a special low rate because it was going to be construed by the Commission as a special aid. The last Administration concluded that the only way out of this was to adopt a single low rate for everybody except companies with passive income. That announcement was made in May 1997 by the previous Administration and the Commission was informed. In the intervening period we have been in negotiation with the Commission on how to get from our general rate to the new rate and the outgoing Administration put forward 12.5 per cent.
At no stage in the negotiations with the Commission has the quantum of the rate been an issue. The Commission has no interest in whether the rate is 12.5 per cent or 2 per cent so long as it applies equally to all companies. There may be those within the broader Europe who would like to go down the road of having a single effective rate but that is not within the remit of member states. During the debate last year on the code of conduct Ireland was not the only country holding out. Germany and France do not want that either. If a single harmonised rate is ever to be achieved throughout Europe, it may not happen in our lifetime.
I announced in the budget that the Government was aiming for a single new rate of 12.5 per cent. We are negotiating with the Commission as to how that will be introduced. Some commentators and many politicians referred to the rate of 12.5 per cent. The rate of 12.5 per cent has never been raised with Commissioner Van Miert, Commissioner Monti or anybody else. It is not within the remit of the Commission to dictate to a state what its general level of taxation should be. That is within the competence of a member state. The reason I give that background is to clear up some of the confusion in that regard.
We hope to conclude this year with the Commission the position of transitional companies. There is a written agreement, reached in 1986 and renegotiated in 1994, that the 10 per cent rate will apply to Shannon and IFSC companies until the year 2005. The question then arises as to what will be the position for companies paying the 10 per cent manufacturing rate. For example, will the general rate, which has been reduced from 32 to 28 per cent, apply to a company coming to Ireland in the next couple of years, or will the 10 per cent rate apply? That, together with the period of time in which the transitional arrangements will be put into effect, is being finalised with the Commission at present. It was necessary to explain this matter in some detail to clarify some of the issues raised in the recent past not only by Deputies but by commentators who do not understand the full picture.
Comment on this
The reason I asked the question was to determine whether we retained discretion in the way in which we move to the single rate. Everybody here accepts we will move to a single rate, and from what the Minister said I assume it will be 12.5 per cent rather than 10 per cent.
Comment on this
In the next few years we should encourage small companies, which are the engine of the economy, particularly in the services sector, by first giving them the benefit of the reduction at the lower rate and over time gradually increasing the threshold, which is now £50,000. That is different from what the Minister has done, which is to reduce both rates.
Comment on this
The Deputy is correct about the low rate for companies. It is within the competence of the Minister for Finance to decide that matter prior to the budget. There were a number of options on the table, for example, to reduce the rate from 28 to 25 per cent or retain the 28 per cent and increase the threshold to £100,000. All those options are open to me, but that is only a small part of the picture. I am influenced by the cost, and that is a matter which I will consider in next year's budget, but one cannot lose sight of the bigger picture.
For existing manufacturing companies, the 10 per cent rate will apply until the year 2010. For IFSC and Shannon companies, under an existing agreement the current rate will apply until the beginning of year 2006. The Government, and the previous Administration, concluded that the best way forward is to set a single low rate, and a rate 12.5 per cent was decided for companies in general. The question is how to go from the current rate of 32 per cent to 12.5 per cent in a given period, and the Deputy can work out how that will be done. For companies on the existing rate until the year 2005, we are in negotiation with the Commission as to what will be their position.
Comment on this
It was not necessary in moving to the single rate to give a significant windfall profit to banks, insurance companies and some multiple supermarkets.
Comment on this
Perhaps I have not explained the matter very well. As a country, we have no choice in this matter. I must reduce the rate, which before the budget was 36 per cent, to 12.5 per cent within a certain period of years. In deciding what I will do for smaller companies, I will have discretion in next year's budget to reduce the rate, increase the threshold or whatever; but I will still have to go from point A, which is 32 per cent, to point B, which is 12.5 per cent, in a relatively short period.
Comment on this
If the Minister increases the threshold, for example, to £100,000, £500,000 and, in time, £2 million, he would not give the windfall benefit to the biggest companies until the last minute. We should defer doing that for as long as possible.
Comment on this
They are the companies to which I am referring - banks, insurance companies and big supermarkets. We are giving them a huge windfall profit, as can be seen from the asset value of their shares. That was a gift which we did not need to give to those companies.
Comment on this
Some commentators criticised other matters in the budget, but significant measures were introduced which were not highlighted, one of which is the effective abolition of tax credits. The saving to the State from that measure is in the order of £60 million. I reduced tax credits this year from 21 over 79 to 11 over 89, and they will be abolished on 6 April 1999. That is a serious matter for big shareholders. By passing the Financial Resolution on 3 December companies which were about to distribute shares were caught in the net. Representations were made, which I did not accept, and in fairness to the institutions involved they did not follow up the matter. I have discretion in regard to smaller companies, but I still must get from point A to point B in a fairly short timespan.
Comment on this
The Minister is obviously right in saying that his challenge is to get from A to B, and I think we all agree on the single lower rate, but he is surely not right in saying that the Commission does not mind whether the rate is 12.5 per cent or 2.5 per cent. The Commission would regard 2.5 per cent as the equivalent of tax dumping and a State aid to industry, notwithstanding that tax harmonisation is not around the corner. The point of the exercise is to get a balance. The previous Government's view was that a 12.5 per cent rate is the correct balance. If the rate was set as high as 15 per cent, that would mean a 50 per cent increase for many companies located here. At the same time we were faced with the argument about State aid to industry. I am convinced the effective tax rate was always a great deal less than the corporation tax rate because of reasons with which the Minister's profession will be more familiar than I am. It is important that is clarified. The Commission is concerned about the rate that is set for the reasons I have given, and the Minister should clarify that.
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Rabbitte has raised this point, which was also raised by other Deputies in the Dáil. The general tax rate of a member state is a matter for the member state. The Commission has raised no objection to the rate of 12.5 per cent. In discussions with one of the Commissioners directly concerned, he said that he did not mind what the rate is. There has been confusion in this regard. It is up to each member state to regulate its tax affairs and set whatever tax rate it wishes. The Commission is interested in having one general corporation tax rate, say 36 per cent, and a special rate of 10 per cent. Members will note the legitimate case for that. The Commission considers this a State aid and an incentive to dislocate industry or business throughout the Community and the Minister for Finance concluded on behalf of the Government that this is a smart way out of that. We can reduce our general corporation tax rate, which is within our competence to do. Everybody will pay the same rate and there will be no complaint. I emphasised on numerous occasions that that point of view was not raised in the negotiations with the Commission. Under the Treaty provisions a member state is entitled to make its taxation laws and set rates, but is not entitled to set special rates. In my budget speech I said I must seek EU Commission approval in respect of other areas of taxation, such as hotel reliefs, airport designations, enterprise zones and rural renewal etc., because they involve a special tax rate incentive which might fall foul of the EU Commission on State aid rules.
Many people, not only Deputy Rabbitte, have been confused about this point. The Deputy may be confusing the Commission's debate on the 10 per cent corporation tax rate with a more general debate which was part of the Monti group proposals on the code of conduct for business taxation which we concluded before Christmas. That is a political agreement between member states on a code of conduct. Those two debates ran at the same time, but at least one is out of the way. The Government used to deal with Commissioner Monti and his officials about a code of conduct. Many ideas were put forward by the Commission in the discussions on that agreement about a single effective rate throughout the Community. We cannot confuse that debate with the debate on the 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate. Former Ministers and a number of commentators may have been confused about that but they are not the same thing. That was not part of the debate on the 10 per cent corporation tax rate and the single low rate of corporation tax.
Even in Commissioner Monti's proposals, the beginning of the text is about whether one sector should get a rate which is different from the general rate in the country concerned. That is in the code of conduct which was finalised last December. Even in the debate on the Monti group it was never contended by anybody that it was not within a member state's general competence to have its own rate of taxation.
I attended many ECOFIN Council meetings last June and much of our time was taken up with the Monti group discussion. This point about having a similar rate throughout the Community was raised by many member states and the majority, including those who were pressing the Commission to press Ireland about our 10 per cent rate, made the point that they were not pushing for a single low effective rate throughout the Community. Perhaps that is the backdrop to some of the confusion. The rate of corporation tax has never been an issue between the Commission and us.
Comment on this
Thank you for that lengthy expose. Given what the Minister has just said and that he was very critical of the 12.5 per cent, it seems that-
Comment on this
Deputy Coveney is a very reasonable person. In the Fianna Fáil election manifesto a single rate of 10 per cent corporation tax was put forward.
Comment on this
Why did the Minister not do that when he claims now he could have? That is what he promised the corporate sector?
Comment on this
Moving from 10 per cent to 12.5 per cent involves an annual cost of approximately £200 million.
Comment on this
As Sean Lemass would have said, I was in Opposition then. Deputy Rabbitte made the point about the rate being reduced to even 2.5 per cent. If there was an excessively low general corporation tax rate, the Commission might investigate it. I assure Deputy Rabbitte that when we decided the 12.5 per cent rate the Commission wanted to know how we would move from A to B in regard to new companies. Our EU partners might object if we had an excessively low rate.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned the 2 per cent rate. That is more the speak of the Minister, Deputy O'Rourke - if it gets out, it would not be a runner.
Comment on this
If we opted for an excessively low rate, we would fall into difficulty with the Commission. The Irish corporate tax rate is the most transparent in the EU. There has been tremendous focus on Ireland in recent times by the Commission and our EU partners on a wide variety of areas. Phrases such as "Celtic tiger" have been of no benefit, particularly to the Ministers travelling to Brussels trying to negotiate Structural Funds or whatever. I note Deputy Coveney agrees with me. That title has been great for attracting companies to invest here. There has been focus on many matters in Ireland, particularly taxation rates, by other EU partners. Many other countries do not have a transparent rate, like Ireland, but they have an effective rate of taxation for their corporates, lower than the Irish 10 per cent manufacturing tax rate. One of the reasons we could never have a single effective rate throughout the Community is that there are different computational rules and ways of assessing how things are communicated. That is what other countries are doing. I know that if a company proposes to set up in a number of countries it can effectively negotiate a rate much lower than 10 per cent. The 10 per cent rate can be worked out very easily. Effectively, other countries in the Community have a lower rate. Their general rate might be 32 per cent, 33 per cent, 36 per cent or 40 per cent but foreign industries can negotiate their own rate. As Deputy Coveney may well be aware, those countries are able to offer companies a far lower rate and they are not under scrutiny because of the different computational basis and the way of doing business. Ireland has been under scrutiny in this regard. I object to this because other countries have effectively as low a rate and do not come under the same scrutiny.
Comment on this
It appears the Minister wants to have it both ways. When we were discussing personal taxation, rates and bands, the Minister zealously defended the democratic obligation that was on the Government and Fianna Fáil to go the route they did on reforming personal taxation because he said they had received a democratic mandate to do so. The Minister is now seeking to evade the democratic mandate his party received in the same election on the issue of corporation tax. The Government campaigned during that election on the 10 per cent rate. The outgoing Government was criticised because of the 12.5 per cent and we are now led to believe there is no obligation on the Minister, from outside the State, to opt for a 12.5 per cent rate. He is reneging on the commitment he made during the election and the mandate he received. There is no obligation on the Minister to accept a 12.5 per cent rate. He is reneging on the commitment given during the general election. I cannot understand the logic behind his approach.
Comment on this
The general election was held on 8 June 1997. The Deputy should look forward to the next one. My party was preaching for two and a half years prior to the general election about the personal taxation measures introduced in the budget. I justify them on those grounds.
I have not adjudicated on whether the figure should be 10 per cent or 12.5 per cent. When the previous Administration announced in May that the rate would be 12.5 per cent, multinational companies here did not raise any objections. Given the sum involved, £200 million plus, I thought it would be a prudent Minister for Finance who would accept such a rate.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 77:
In page 66, before section 45, to insert the following new section:
"45.-Section 343(1) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, (previously section 41A of the Finance Act, 1994) is hereby amended by the insertion of the following:
'(c) the rendering of-
(i) services to embarking or disembarking aircraft passengers, including hotel, catering, money-changing or transport (other than air transport) services,
(ii) services in connection with the landing, departure, loading or unloading of aircraft, or
(iii) services in the course of furtherance of a business of freight forwarding or the provision of logistical services in relation
(d) the operation of a scheduled air transport service;
(e) selling by retail, otherwise than by mail order or other distance selling, in relation to which the Minister is of the opinion, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, that they contribute to the use or development of the airport;
(f) the sale of consumable commodities for the fuelling of aircraft or for shipment as aircraft stores.'.".
Section 343 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, provides for a special regime of capital allowances to apply to enterprise zones. In the 1997 Finance Act the airports, apart from Dublin and Shannon were granted enterprise zone status. However, the trading operations which qualify to avail of the enterprise zone reliefs do not include removal services beside the normal airport related services. The amendment seeks to do this by extending the definition of "qualifying services" to include air transport, freight forwarding and logistics, and various services related to passenger traffic.
The regional airports have the potential to become hubs of economic activity. It is appropriate that we should complete the work started last year by ensuring the core activities of the airports concerned are covered by the available incentives. It is our hope that the initiative taken in last year's budget will lead to increased economic activity around the airports. That is the purpose of the amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister will have received a copy of a letter to the Tánaiste from the Mayo County Manager who is chairman of the North Mayo Enterprise Initiative. He was asked to serve in that capacity by the Tánaiste following the demise of Asahi Chemicals outside Killala. He is also a member of the board of Knock Airport. He wrote a detailed letter to the Tánaiste in respect of the situation at that airport which derives its income from two sources - landing charges and duty free sales. On landing charges, it is dependent on Ryanair flights while it appears duty free sales will be abolished before too long.
The Tánaiste was asked to consider amending the definition of qualifying trading operations as defined in section 343(1) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, previously section 41A of the Finance Act, 1994, by the insertion of the following: the rendering of services to embarking or disembarking aircraft passengers, including hotel, catering, money-changing or transport, other than air transport, services; services in connection with the landing, departure, loading or unloading of aircraft, or services in the course of furtherance of a business of freight forwarding or the provision of logistical services in relation to such business; the operation of a scheduled air transport service and a number of related matters.
I will give some background information, of which the Minister is probably well aware. In 1992 the chairman of the committee, Deputy Ahern, met Alliance International, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Perot Group, the chairman of which is Ross Perot Junior and the representative of which in Ireland is Mr. Harry McKillop. When I was appointed Minister for Trade and Tourism I had a number of meetings with the board of Knock Airport, its chairman and administrator, Monsignor Greally. One of those meetings resulted in an invitation to travel to Dallas and Fort Worth in Texas to view at first hand the Alliance International operation in the company of the chairman of Knock Airport, the Monsignor and a number of other personnel. It is a phenomenal operation.
It was indicated in discussions arising from the analysis of Knock Airport in the context of western regional development that designation would be required. I explained, as I understood the Finance Bill amendments, that its report would not have been available to the Cabinet prior to the introduction of the 1997 Finance Bill. I suggested to the Cabinet prior to the conclusion of the Finance Bill that an enterprise zone should be provided for on lands adjacent to Knock Airport. It decided not alone to provide for an enterprise zone on lands adjacent to Knock Airport but to extend the provision to the other regional airports, including Cork.
Following the announcement, the European Commission was in a state of confusion about the specification of the enterprise zones. It is my understanding that it expressed its concern. Following discussions with the Minister, it was agreed that projects would be grant aided by the IDA and receive clearance from Brussels. I have no difficulty with this.
Unlike a previous leader of Fianna Fáil, the Minister has travelled to many places throughout the country. He declared a professional interest in the locality. During the debate on last year's Finance Bill he said:
An excellent case could be made for designating the area at Knock Airport. I know the area well as my company has a practice not far from there. Long before I became a Member I proposed that the west should be a designation area for special tax status for 25 years. Had that been done it would have been interesting to see how it would have worked. There is a need for certain parts of the country to be designated for tax purposes. So far as the area around Knock Airport is concerned, there is not much industry or business but the airport is doing very well. I was one of those who had grave doubts about Knock International Airport which I expressed both inside and outside the House and went against the wishes of my party at the time but have been proved wrong. It has worked well and has brought much business to the area.
The Government has proposals in respect of urban and rural designation. The Shannon corridor is one element. As a practical politician with long experience, the Minister will understand that of all the regional airports Knock stands the best chance of deriving benefit from the amendment. I am not interested in some aspects of the amendment but I am particularly interested in paragraph (c)(iii) which reads: "services in the course of furtherance of a business of freight forwarding or the provision of logistical services in relation to such business". This aspect of the amendment should be approved by the Minister and if it needs to be done on a pilot or individual basis, so be it.
What the airport board has in mind is breaking up large cargo and forwarding it to other points in Europe in smaller aircraft. The logistics and administration of this measure should be included under the designation programme. I am sure the Minister will not accept the other parts of the amendment because they do not apply to all airports, and I accept some measure must apply across the board.
I assume from statements made by the Minister, in Opposition and in Government, that he is interested in the development of that region. Pressure groups have been calling for the resignation of Deputies and Ministers if matters are not delivered by the end of September. Knock Airport is central to the development of the north west. If this provision is approved, it has the capacity to attract a large amount of business. A 10,000 square foot unit, which forms part of a six part factory development, is currently being constructed at the airport. I have a copy of the final draft of a report compiled by the senior advisers to Alliance International which deals with the development of Knock Airport. In referring to public-private partnership, it states:
The vision of the airport as a gateway extends well beyond the airport itself. It is a vision for the entire Western region. This regional vision will integrate new businesses into the fabric of existing communities. Therefore, the county and its political representatives must be sold on the airport's vision. They will have to become willing partners to help deliver it. This public-private partnership will be critical in order to extend the control issue well beyond this.
The vision needs to be sold across the region. Attracting companies to the airport and to the region requires continuous co-operation and communication in order to deliver economic development to the community in the form of jobs, increased future tax base and economic diversification. Beyond this the community will also derive substantial secondary benefits from increased commerce which can raise property values and the overall standard of living. Therefore, public sector issues, such as planning approvals, rebate on infrastructure, tax designations and other incentive tools are crucial for the airport's private sector success to become a success for the entire region.
The public sector, and by extension the voters, must be convinced that they are making an investment in a project that is both long term and worthwhile. [The next sentence is crucial.] Having and delivering a vision are two different things. All projects like Knock are partnerships and the strength of each of the parties must be highlighted and the roles must be clear. At the end of the day it is the community's success as a whole.
Will the Minister accept the crucial aspect of the amendment which deals with logistic services, freight forwarding and the inherent back-up administration. This is feasible in the context of the Government's proposals. Some people may claim this is impossible because the Commission was not notified and we do not have the authority to do it. The Minister negotiates as a very senior Minister in a sovereign Government. We have the right to provide equal treatment for our people and regions. Regardless of the conditions the Commission may wish to lay down, the Minister is entitled to put forward such a proposal.
Because of the length of its runway, Knock could benefit from freight forwarding. Large aircraft could land with cargo which could then be broken up and forwarded to other points of Europe by smaller aircraft. While I accept the Minister cannot accept other aspects of my amendment, I appeal to him to accept this crucial provision.
Comment on this
Deputy Kenny and Coveney outlined the position very well. The Minister could agree to this proposal.
When one excludes Galway, 20 per cent of the population live in Connaught-Ulster. Approximately 1,000 jobs per week were announced last year, but only 17 per cent of them went to Connaught-Ulster. We did not get our fair share of Structural or Cohesion funds, we did not get our fair share from the National Roads Authority or from Government. Deputy Kenny made a very valid case. As chairman of the task force, the county manager wrote to the Minister for Finance and to the Tánaiste about this matter. There have been major job losses in Asahi. We have gained nothing from the Celtic tiger. The people of my county are outraged with all Governments, including the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael parties who, when in Opposition have all the answers, but when they go into Government they do nothing for the west. This is an opportunity for the Government to show it is serious about the west. There are more people leaving the west than are leaving the priesthood.
Knock is the jewel in the crown. When certain companies locating at Galway Airport pressed the Minister for funding - the cry did not come from the politicians - the conditions were changed. Knock Airport had to come up with 50 per cent in matching funds while Galway had to come up with only 25 per cent. That is unfair.
We want the Government to accept this proposal. A political decision is necessary. The Minister should not heed his officials because they are not serious about the west, they were probably never in that part of the country. This is the Minister's opportunity to prove he is serious about creating jobs in the west. The west needs a break.
Comment on this
The 1997 designation programme for airports meant little to Kerry County Airport. It did not create economic vibrancy in the area. Further incentives are necessary. Although this amendment is directed at Knock Airport, it could include Kerry airport. With the abolition of duty free sales, that airport will lose approximately £200,000, the equivalent of 15 jobs. I understand that Manx Airlines pulled out of Kerry County Airport last week, further threatening its viability. I would be quite concerned about the future viability of Kerry County Airport unless it gets further support and can avail of incentives such as those included in this amendment. I appeal to the Minister when considering this amendment to consider the broader application of it. It would be very difficult for him to apply this amendment to only one airport because it would have wide scale application to the other regional airports, particularly Kerry County Airport. While I do not want to be seen to be disagreeing with my learned friend, Deputy Kenny, Kerry County Airport has a longer runway than Knock Airport.
The designation of 1997 despite its positive intention, etc., is not working and it is certainly not working in Kerry County Airport. The incentives included in this amendment would certainly help to act as a catalyst to get the airport moving. I am worried about the future of the airport unless it gets some kind of a kick start. Therefore, I appeal to the Minister to look at this amendment in a positive light and not dismiss it as just another amendment in the range of amendments.
Comment on this
I will put the Cork case to level the pitch. In the context of regional development we cannot overstate the importance of airports. They are critical. Knock Airport was described as an airport built on the side of a mountain. It was an act of faith by Fianna Fáil to support the building of an airport in Knock. People said the runway would sink and the airport would be a white elephant. People knocked the idea but I supported it because I believe in regional development in general. It is critical that we support this proposal but as Deputy Deenihan says on the basis of its application across the board. It was unfair in the regional context that the SFADCo marketing budget for Shannon was £2.5 million higher than for places like Cork which was one of the principal airports in the region at the time. We need to encourage the regional airports. I suspect because we would need to apply equality across the board, there may be difficulties for the Minister in this particular instance. Every possible advantage should be given to the regional airports. I would not just select two or three because the capital will have an obvious advantage and it can be taken out of the equation. I suspect there could be difficulties with the EU about this but one could not select only one airport and give it preferential treatment. That happened for 15 to 20 years in the case of one airport, and was a cause of hassle but it has been evened out across the board.
My party has given its support and commitment to Knock Airport for quite a long time and I am glad others are being converted to that idea.
Comment on this
The amendment relates to the whole change in the 1997 Act creating enterprise zones around regional airports. The amendment is of a general nature, but many of the specifics relate to Knock Airport. There is certainly no other area in the country to which I would be more disposed than part of County Mayo. I have affection for County Mayo, it put bread on my table for a long time, apart from anything else, and for that part of County Mayo I feel more than affection. I will do everything I can to assist in that regard.
There is a major problem with this matter and I will put it in context. Over my political lifetime I have featured on the front pages of many newspapers - I recently featured on page one of The Western People, a newspaper I purchased quite frequently when the late Mr. John Healy used write a column for it after he gave up writing for a national newspaper. I still have an affection for the paper. I understand from the good offices of Deputy Michael Ring that I featured on the front page recently.
The amendment seeks to amend the definition of qualified trading operations which may be carried on in enterprise areas. At present such operations are confined to manufacturing activities qualifying for the 10 per cent manufacturing scheme of corporation tax and internationally traded services designated under the Industrial Development Act, 1986. Capital expenditure incurred in the provision of industrial and commercial buildings in which the qualifying trading operations are carried on are entitled to 100 per cent write off with up to 50 per cent in year one for all their operators and 25 per cent for lessors. Traders leasing such buildings are entitled to a double rent allowance for a ten year period.
The 1997 Finance Act provided for the designation by ministerial order of the areas immediately adjacent to seven regional airports as enterprise areas. The legislation provides the designation may only be made following receipt of a proposal from or on behalf of a company intending to carry on qualifying trading operations. The airports in question are Cork, Donegal, Galway, Kerry, Knock, Sligo and Waterford. No area adjacent to an airport has so far been designated as no qualifying project has been put forward.
In May 1997 in the context of State aids the competition directive of the EU Commission sought detailed information on new tax reliefs for regional airports and new enterprise areas provided for in the Finance Act, 1997. This was on foot of an article in The Irish Times publicising the new schemes. The Commission then initiated a full investigation into all the enterprise areas, including those six enterprise areas designated under the Finance Act, 1994.
Last December the Commission decided to approve the tax reliefs for the enterprise areas in the context of State aids but the decision did not cover the regional airports enterprise area scheme. However, when projects for the airports enterprise areas are approved by the Irish authorities and areas are then designated they will then be submitted to the EU Commission for approval. The Commission approval was in respect of the following qualifying trading operations: (a) manufacturing companies which qualify under the finance Acts for 10 per cent corporation tax; and (b) internationally traded service activities excluding financial services within the meaning of the Industrial Development Act, 1986. Companies must also have been approved for financial assistance by the State industrial development agencies, Forbairt or IDA Ireland - the approval of qualifying companies given through a certification process involving inter alia Forfas and the Ministers for Enterprise, Trade and Employment and Finance.
The amendment proposes that the routine activities carried on as an airport including retail sales, the sale of fuel, the provision of catering and hotel accommodation and money changing services to passengers would constitute qualifying trading operations. The measure would mean that all the airport buildings and structures would come within the scope of the accelerated capital allowance regime provided for enterprise areas.
In any event if additional qualifying activities were to be made eligible for tax relief under the enterprise areas scheme it would be necessary to go back to the Commission for approval. Special rules and frameworks of the Community law apply to certain sectors of industrial activity including the transport sector. In the context of the Commission's approval of the enterprise areas scheme the Commission noted that this specific sector inter alia was excluded from the scheme. It has been indicated to us recently by the Commission that it is most unlikely that a cargo handling operation for instance, involving road haulage, would be approved by them as a qualifying activity under the enterprise area scheme. We are currently seeking EU approval for, among others, incentives for hotel developments in several western and north western counties and a new pilot renewal scheme in the upper Shannon area. We do not wish to jeopardise the case for EU approval of these schemes by requesting the Commission to change its present approval for enterprise areas, which was only obtained after a long delay and with considerable difficulty, for the sake of a proposal for transportation activities which may be rejected by it in any event. For those reasons I cannot accept the amendment.
Before the 1997 general election, six enterprise areas were designated for special taxation incentive reliefs under the 1994 Act, some of which are well known to the people here. One of the most successful is the Eastpoint Business Park here in Dublin. In 1997, a newspaper article appeared stating that a particular Deputy would get approval from the Government to have Knock Airport specially designated as a type of Shannon relief scheme. That was the impression given in the newspapers at the time and the information was picked up by the EU Commission.
When the Finance Act came into effect, the then Government decided, perhaps for political reasons, to designate all the regional airports and the only remaining available incentive was enterprise zones. As I pointed out in an earlier debate, to go down the road of having a new Shannon would bring down the wrath of the European Commission on us, so the only available option was an enterprise zone.
The Commission was not happy to discover that Ireland had enterprise zones. It was unaware that we had tax incentive areas even though they had existed since 1994. With the backdrop of the debate in the Commission and in Europe about the Irish tax incentives, the Commission quickly contacted the Minister to ask about these enterprise zones. It was concerned that we intended to extend Shannon to another airport.
Arising from that, we then had to seek approval for the enterprise zones which had been in existence since 1994. Since 1994, a considerable number of operations were set up, particularly the Eastpoint one in Dublin. Members might remember I was not long in office when I issued a press release, perhaps in July, to the effect that we were in negotiation with Europe about the enterprise zones. My reason for doing so was not to make political capital out of the issue but to put on notice possible investors in those areas that there was no approval and that it might not be forthcoming. That was done to protect the State's interests against possible legal costs in the future because the zones already in existence were now under question. The reason for the press release was to safeguard the State's position.
This problem was not brought upon us by officials or civil servants in the Department of Finance. They battled successfully from then until the middle of December. We thought we would receive approval for the enterprise zones before the budget but that did not happen until the middle of December. I have stated what the Commission is prepared to do. It gave permission for the enterprise zones in existence since 1994 but in regard to those created around the regional airports it stated specifically that approval will be given subject to examination on a project by project basis.
Notwithstanding my good will I am not in a position to extend the qualifying trading operations to address the problem concerning Knock. I assure Deputies I am not approaching this from a financial perspective or in respect of loss to the Exchequer in terms of tax. Regardless of the merits of designating enterprise zones around some of the regional airports - I would have questioned that at the time if I had been in Cabinet - Knock deserved such classification. I do not want to criticise one area more than another but some did not deserve the classification of enterprise zone. That does not make any difference now, however, because it was done for the other regional airports. I cannot say whether it would have improved our case if Knock had been left as an enterprise zone to the exclusion of all others, and it is too late to find out at this stage. That is the dilemma I faced.
There is no by-election pending in the constituency of Mayo but I have explained the difficulty I faced as best I can. If I go back to Europe seeking to extend the definition of qualifying trading operations, I will be in danger of unravelling the agreement I reached regarding enterprise zones in many areas. It must be remembered that I have to seek EU Commission approval in regard to hotels, rural renewal, etc. That was not done before. When I mentioned these in my budget speech I said they were subject to EU Commission approval. The Commission has taken a grave view of the way we treated this matter and the fact that it was not notified. I hope I have explained the position fully.
Comment on this
We received a letter this morning asking members of this committee to resign if they cannot deliver on this and other items. We might have five by-elections in Mayo in October.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his response to the case that has been made. I note his comment about the Commission's dissatisfaction. I recall one of the members who sits on the Commission and who has responsibility for European affairs doing a radio broadcast from about 10,000 feet as he flew into Knock Airport. At that stage his vision had been realised and there were buildings everywhere. When I met him subsequently as Minister for Tourism and Trade I asked him how he was, he replied that for two Castlebar fellows, we were not doing too badly and suggested that the Commission would follow his lead on anything.
I do not have any problem understanding the Minister's difficulties with the rural designation and the Shannon corridor. I accept the negotiations the civil servants carried out in respect of the project by project analysis. That has to be done when an industry or a manufacturing service comes into an airport and receives IDA approval. However, the issue of the logistics and the ability to handle large cargo aircraft is critical to the type of development envisaged for an airport with Knock's runway capacity.
If the Minister dispenses with the other parts of the amendment and deals with that issue, his desire to do something for Knock will be more focused. The Commission will not turn down this proposal and we have an obligation to make that case because the lifeblood of this region is draining away on a daily basis. The logistics and the back-up administration is only a small element but it is critical for the future routing of that airport. The Minister should go back to the Commission and make a case for approval, even if only for a pilot project, because I believe approval would be forthcoming. If this is a pilot project in respect of logistics, it would probably get approval. There is a willingness from Commissioner Mario Monti, Commissioner Wulf-Mathies, Commissioner Papoutsis and others to support this region of the west of Ireland.
Comment on this
I do not want to prolong this discussion unnecessarily. Is the Minister or his officials in contact with any groups or individual businessmen located in, or intending to locate in, or adjacent to any of the regional airports which were designated and does he expects to be in a position to put any projects to the Commission in the foreseeable future?
Comment on this
That is a good question. We have had an indication from only one individual concerning a project relating to Cork Airport. He was in contact with the Department of Finance recently but the project has not been submitted, even though the section will not take effect for a year.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Dennehy for his support. I think there is a good prospect that the Cork proposal will be the most successful of those designated. I had a small part to play in it, I am pleased about that myself and I think it will happen. It takes longer than people imagine to put these things together, but the particular proposal in Cork includes ICC as a partner so it is well funded. I believe that with or without these amendments the Cork proposal would work. If the Minister were to take on board what Deputy Kenny and Deputy Ring say, relating to paragraph (c)(iii) and specifically, Knock, is it possible to accept an amendment subject to the approval of the European Commission?
Comment on this
I take the points made by Deputies Coveney, Kenny and Ring. This may bring back memories to Deputy Coveney and possibly Deputy Kenny. Commissioner Van Miert has responsibility in this area. We must negotiate with him not only on this issue but on the transitional arrangements regarding the corporation tax regime and the whole question of regional and State aids. I am in the dilemma here and, while not wishing to jeopardise other matters, I want to be as helpful as possible to the Knock situation. Between now and Report Stage I will seek, through telephone contact, to ascertain if paragraph (c)(iii) of the amendment, relating to Knock, can be accepted without upsetting the applecart. That is as far as I can go.
Comment on this
It is the old dog for the road. Under the operational programme for tourism, in my time as Minister a number of German airlines were grant-aided to fly into that region. I fully support the Minister's concept of rural designation in the Shannon corridor zone. One of the critical elements for people from Europe was to be able to get into the region quickly and efficiently and the airport was a central part of that. The evidence is clear from the reports. Due to those chartered flights, which were brought in specially, people were able to get to the region a day earlier and leave a day later. As a central focus for its development that is good. I accept the Minister's word on this and he will get every assistance from our side and whatever contacts we have in Europe.
Comment on this
A Commission official came to Ireland in connection with this whole debate about the enterprise zone, etc. and visited Knock. It did not change her mind about the whole matter of enterprise zones or regional airports, but at least the Commission will be aware of it and has first hand knowledge. Whatever about Deputy Ring's area of west Mayo, I spent many days during my youth travelling around to the hostelries and the carnival halls in east Mayo and I know it quite well,
Comment on this
On a few occasions he was. The population structure of that part of Mayo has changed a great deal since then and I am willing to do whatever I can to assist the area. This is a straightforward problem. Normally the Minister for Finance would oppose an amendment like this on the basis that it would impose a charge on the Exchequer. This is not the reason for opposing it on this occasion. The matter is much more complicated.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 78:
In page 67, before section 47, to insert the following new section:
47.-The Principal Act is hereby amended as respects accounting periods ending on or after the 1st day of April, 1998, in Schedule 24-
(a) by the substitution for-
'Relief from Income Tax and Corporation Tax by Means of Credit in Respect of Foreign Tax
Interpretation
1.(1) In this Schedule, except where the context otherwise requires-
of
'Relief from Income Tax and Corporation Tax by Means of Credit in Respect of Foreign Tax
PART 1
Interpretation
1.(1) In this Schedule, except where the context otherwise requires-',
(b) in paragraph 1(1), by the substitution for the definition of foreign tax of the following definition:
'"foreign tax" means-
(a) in the case of any territory in relation to which arrangements have the force of law, any tax chargeable under the laws of that territory for which credit may be allowed under the arrangements, and
(b) in any other case, any tax chargeable in respect of which credit may be allowed by virtue of subparagraph (3) of paragraph 9A'.,
(c) by the insertion, after paragraph 9, of the following paragraphs:
'PART 2
Unilateral Relief
9A.(1) To the extent appearing from the following provisions of this paragraph, relief (in this paragraph referred to as "unilateral relief") from corporation tax in respect of profits represented by dividends shall be given in respect of tax payable under the law of any territory other than the State by allowing that tax as a credit against corporation tax, notwithstanding that there are not for the time being in force any arrangements providing for such relief.
(2) Unilateral relief shall be such relief as would fall to be given under this Schedule if arrangements with the government of the territory in question containing the provisions in subparagraphs (3) to (5) were in force, and a reference in this Schedule to credit under arrangements shall be construed as a reference to unilateral relief.
(3) Subject to Part 1 and to subparagraph (5), credit for tax paid under the law of a territory other than the State in relation to a relevant dividend paid by a company resident in the territory to a company resident in the State shall be allowed against corporation tax attributable to the profits represented by the dividend.
(4) For the purposes of subparagraph (3)-
(a) "tax paid under the law of a territory other than the State in relation to a relevant dividend paid by a company" means-
(i) tax which is directly charged on the dividend, whether by charge to tax, deduction of tax at source or otherwise, and the whole of which tax neither the company nor the recipient would have borne if the dividend had not been paid, and
(ii) tax paid in respect of its profits under the law of the territory by the company paying the dividend in so far as that tax is properly attributable to the proportion of the profits represented by the dividend,
(b) "relevant dividend" means a dividend paid by a company resident in a territory other than the State to a company resident in the State which either directly or indirectly owns, or is a subsidiary of a company which directly or indirectly owns, not less than 25 per cent of the share capital of the company paying the dividend; for the purposes of this subparagraph one company is a subsidiary of another company if the other company owns, directly or indirectly, not less than 50 per cent of the share capital of the first company.
(5) Credit shall not be allowed by virtue of subparagraph (3)
(a) for tax paid under the law of a territory where there are arrangements with the government of the territory,
(b) for any tax which is relevant foreign tax within the meaning of section 449, or
(c) for any tax in respect of which credit may be allowed under section 831.
(6) Where-
(a) unilateral relief may be given in respect of a dividend, and
(b) it appears that the assessment to corporation tax made in respect of the dividends is not made in respect of the full amount thereof, or is incorrect having regard to the credit, if any, which falls to be given by way of unilateral relief,
any such assessment may be made or amended as is necessary to ensure that the total amount of the dividend is assessed, and the proper credit, if any, is given in respect thereof.
(7) In this Schedule in its application to unilateral relief, references to tax payable or paid under the law of a territory outside the State include only references to taxes which are charged on income or chargeable gains and which correspond to corporation tax and capital gains tax.
Dividends Paid Between Related Companies: Relief for Irish and Third Country Taxes
9B.(1) Where a company resident outside the State (in this paragraph referred to as "the foreign company") pays a dividend to a company resident in the State (in this paragraph referred to as "the Irish company") and the foreign company is related to the Irish company, then for the purpose of allowing credit under any arrangements against corporation tax in respect of the dividend, there shall, subject to Part 1, be taken into account as if it were tax payable under the law of the territory in which the foreign company is resident-
(a) any income tax or corporation tax payable in the State by the foreign company in respect of its profits, and
(b) any tax which, under the law of any other territory, is payable by the foreign company in respect of its profits.
(2) Where the foreign company has received a dividend from a third company and the third company is related to the foreign company and to the company resident in the State, then, subject to subparagraph (4), there shall be treated for the purposes of subparagraph (1) as tax paid by the foreign company in respect of its profits any underlying tax payable by the third company, to the extent that it would be taken into account under this Schedule if the dividend had been paid by a company resident outside the State to a company resident in the State and arrangements had provided for underlying tax to be taken into account.
(3) Where the third company has received a dividend from a fourth company and the fourth company is related to the third company and to the company resident in the State, then, subject to subparagraph (4), tax payable by the fourth company shall similarly be treated for the purposes of subparagraph (2) as tax paid by the third company, and so on for successive companies each of which is related to the one before and to the company resident in the State.
(4) Subparagraphs (2) and (3) are subject to the following limitations-
(a) no tax shall be taken into account in respect of a dividend paid by a company resident in the State except corporation tax payable in the State and any tax for which that company is entitled to credit under this Schedule, and
(b) no tax shall be taken into account in respect of a dividend paid by a company resident outside the State to another such company unless it could have been taken into account under this Schedule had the other company been resident in the State.
(5) (a) In this paragraph "underlying tax" in relation to a dividend means foreign tax borne by the company paying the dividend on the relevant profits (within the meaning of paragraph (8)) in so far as it is properly attributable to the proportion of the relevant profits represented by the dividend.
(b) For the purposes of this paragraph-
(i) a company is related to another company if that other company-
(I) owns directly or indirectly, or
(II) is a subsidiary of a company which owns directly or indirectly,
not less than 25 per cent of the share capital of the first-mentioned
(ii) one company is a subsidiary of another company if the other company owns, directly or indirectly, not less than 50 per cent of the share capital of the first company.',
and
(d) in paragraph 10, by the substitution for-
'Miscellaneous
10. Credit shall not be allowed'."
of
'PART 3
Miscellaneous
10. Credit shall not be allowed'.".
This amendment inserts a new section into the Bill. The new section inserts two new paragraphs into Schedule 24 of the Principal Act. The two new paragraphs provide a considerable level of double taxation relief to companies resident in the State which have overseas subsidiaries and it should help to prevent double taxation on dividends received by Irish multinationals from their overseas subsidiaries.
Under existing law when an Irish resident company receives a dividend from its overseas subsidiary, the dividend will be taxed here notwithstanding that the profits of the subsidiary were taxed in the country in which it is located. The result is double taxation. If the country concerned has a tax treaty with Ireland, the foreign tax will be credited against the Irish tax and the dividend in order to eliminate the double taxation. However, if there is not a tax treaty, the only relief for the foreign tax would be a deduction in calculating the Irish taxable income.
The first change which is contained in a new paragraph 9A addresses this issue and ensures that Irish resident companies which have subsidiaries in countries with which Ireland does not have a tax treaty may offset foreign tax, whether in the form of withholding tax or corporation tax on its profits, against Irish corporation tax on its dividends. The second change addresses a problem encountered by groups of companies which have tiers of foreign subsidiaries - for example, where an Irish company has a subsidiary resident in France, which in turn has a subsidiary resident in Denmark and so on. Under existing law an Irish parent company will only get credit against Irish tax for tax paid by the subsidiary in France. No credit will be given against Irish tax for tax paid by the company in Denmark. This issue is addressed by the new paragraph 9B which allows tax paid by subsidiaries in other countries to be brought up to tiers of companies in the group to be offset against Irish corporation tax and dividends received by the Irish parent. I am confident that this will be of significant assistance to our Irish multinationals and it will help them to grow. The unilateral credit relief brings Ireland into line with most of its EU partners.