We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE

Finance Bill, 1998: Committee Stage.

Contributions 280–391 of 391. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 1998
Enacted

No. 8 of 1998 ›

I move amendment No. 79:

In page 71, subsection (1), to delete lines 10 to 20 and substitute the following:

""qualifying energy project" means a renewable energy project in respect of which the Minister has given a certificate under subsection (2) which has not been revoked under that subsection;".

Amendments Nos. 79, 80, 83, 84, 85 and 86 are technical amendments necessary to correct a drafting error in the Bill as published.

When the definition of "qualifying energy project" and "relevant investment" are read together the effect is to deny relief altogether where the limits on the allowable investment are exceeded. The intention was to deny relief only to the excess of the investment above the limits. The main element in this current series of amendments is the insertion of a new subsection (5) which denies relief to the excess only. The other amendments are consequential.

Amendment No. 81 amends the section to ensure that projects approved by the Minister for Public Enterprise under the recent alternative energy requirement competition, AER III-1997, can avail of the relief. These projects were always intended to be included but a specific reference to them is being inserted so as to remove any doubt on this point. I commend these amendments to the committee.

Comment on this

My amendment No. 82 is self-explanatory and adds solar power to the definition of renewable energy. This is becoming more common and we should encourage it. I wish to extend the application of the section to include solar power.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 80:

In page 71, subsection (1), line 36, after "means" to insert ", subject to subsections (4) and (5),".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 81:

In page 72, subsection (1), line 15, after "project" to insert ", (including a project successful in the Third Alternative Energy Requirement Competition (AER III - 1997) initiated by the Minister)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 82:

In page 72, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:

"(a) solar power,".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 83:

In page 72, subsection (1), to delete lines 24 to 32 and substitute the following:

"relation to a renewable energy project to be undertaken by the company, that the renewable energy project is a qualifying energy project for the purposes of this section.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 84:

In page 73, subsection (1), line 5, after "condition" to insert "so".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 85:

In page 74, subsection (1), between lines 13 and 14, to insert the following:

"(5) Relief under this section shall not be given in respect of a relevant investment which is made at any time in a qualifying company if, at that time, the aggregate of the amounts of that relevant investment and all other relevant investments made in the qualifying company at or before that time exceeds an amount equal to-

(a) 50 per cent of the relevant cost of the project, or

(b) £7,500,000,

whichever is the lesser.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 86:

In page 75, subsection (1), to delete lines 25 and 26 and substitute the following:

"shall not be issued-

(a) without the authority of the authorised officer, or

(b) in relation to a relevant investment in respect of which relief may not be given by virtue of subsection (5).".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 87:

In page 77, before section 49, but in Chapter 4, to insert the following new section:

49. Section 88 of the Principal Act is hereby amended in subsection (3)(b)-

(a) by the deletion of subparagraph (ii), and

(b) by the substitution of '£3,000,000' for '£1,500,000' in subparagraph (iii).".

The new section makes two changes to section 88 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which provides for a tax deduction for company donations to Enterprise Trust Ltd. The Enterprise Trust is a charitable organisation established under the Programme for Economic and Social Progress to channel the support of industry towards local development initiatives in areas of high unemployment. It has an important role in generating private sector funding for local enterprise development and its contribution to it is acknowledged in the Partnership 2000 programme.

First, it is proposed to remove altogether the current limit on the relief for donations by a single donor company in an accounting period. Currently, the limit stands at £100,000. Second, it is proposed to double the donation limit to £3 million, which Enterprise Trust Ltd. may receive in a year and which qualifies for tax relief. I am satisfied these proposed changes will be beneficial for Enterprise Trust Ltd. and will encourage further donations from the corporate sector.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 88:

In page 77, before section 49, but in Chapter 4, to insert the following new section:

49.- (1) Section 715 of the Principal Act is hereby amended in subsection (2) by the substitution for paragraph (a) of the following paragraph:

(a) (i) subject to subparagraphs (ii), (iii) and (iv), subsection (1) of section 710 shall apply with the necessary modifications and in particular shall apply as if there were deleted from that subsection all references to policyholders other than holders of policies referable to pension business,

(ii) where apart from this subparagraph any profits would be excluded in making the computation solely by virtue of that part being reserved for holders of policies referable to pension business, that part shall not be so excluded,

(iii) in relation to investments of any fund representing the amount of the liabilities of the company to policyholders in respect of its pension business or general annuity business, as the case may be,

(I) any increase in value of those investments (whether realised or unrealised) shall be taken into account as a receipt, and

(II) any decrease in value of those investments (whether realised or unrealised) shall be taken into account as an expense,

to the extent that the increase or decrease, as the case may be, is included in the value of those liabilities as valued by the actuary to the company, and

(iv) where the profits of an assurance company for an accounting period (in this subparagraph referred to as 'the first accounting period') are computed in accordance with subparagraph (iii) and the profits of the most recent preceding accounting period are not so computed, the increase or decrease in the value of investments referred to in subparagraph (iii) shall as respects the first accounting period be computed by reference to the cost of the investments at the time they were acquired by the company and such increase or decrease shall be treated as a receipt or as an expense, as the case may be.'.

(2) This section shall apply as respects an accounting period of a company ending on or after the 4th day of March, 1998.".

The amendment inserts a new section in the Bill to address the taxation of profits of life assurance companies in respect of their pension and annuity business in two areas. Whereas the income and gains of the pension funds are tax exempt, profits made by the company on behalf of its shareholders are not. In computing the shareholders' profits for tax purposes, the existing provisions of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, permit the directors of the company to deduct an amount which, while not allocated to pension policy holders, is reserved for them. The reserves can be written back to profits at a later date whenever the directors decide to do so. The need for this ability to deduct from profits these reserved amounts is no longer considered necessary and is removed by the amendment.

A second issue with regard to the computation of the shareholders' profits for tax purposes is that the existing tax code can be read to effectively permit a double deduction for unrealised gains on investments held by or for policy holders. This double deduction is an anomaly and is prohibited by the amendment.

Comment on this

The section deals with the reduction in the rate of capital gains tax with which I most emphatically do not agree. It is probably the single most inequitable measure introduced by a Minister for Finance. I am at a complete loss to understand where this comes from. When the Minister replied on Second Stage, he listed four bodies which had made representations to him since he taken up office. None of the bodies in question made representations which came remotely close to halving capital gains tax, which is what he did. The Minister must understand in those circumstances that people will explicitly question what was his motivation.

The introduction of this section by resolution on 3 December 1997, has enriched a small number of already rich people, examples of which have been published in the press; but it was entirely predictable that certain individuals would gain a great deal from this measure, one for which there was no demand. We know as a matter of record - the Minister and I had an exchange about this before - that representatives of the Dunnes trust made representations to officials of the Department several years ago looking for changes in capital taxation which would reduce considerably, in certain circumstances, the liability to tax of the trust. We are also aware other rich individuals stand to make, or perhaps already have made, considerable gains by changing their family or company arrangements.

If this it to be done, the measure needs to be spelt out. It sends all the wrong signals to ordinary, decent taxpayers if a once off significant windfall benefit is given to people who are already super rich. The measure lacks completely in terms of equity and it is interesting that the Minister is his attempts to defend it has not once referred to equity. He said he does not expect to lose money because of the measure but to gain a little. Whether one gains or loses income as a result of this was not a factor considered by the Minister. Perhaps that can be dismissed as being one of his motivations.

It does not appear to concern him that unearned income, which this effectively is, is now taxable at a rate of 20 per cent whereas earned income from the sweat of one's brow is taxable at a rate of either 24 per cent of 46 per cent. Yet, if I buy a house or other property and sell it in two years gaining £30,000 or £40,000, my gain, for which I have done little except borrow money, will be taxed at 20 per cent whereas if I work day in day out over the same period I will be taxed at a marginal rate of 46 per cent. It greatly understates the case to say this is inequitable, and the Minister must address this issue because it sends all the wrong signals.

One negative, tangible effect of this measure affects the housing market, which is overheated, particularly in the bigger urban centres. A significant percentage of houses are being traded and have become speculative items. Houses were once pursued by young couples or people looking for somewhere to live, but people now engage in the housing market for speculative purposes. It is an open market and one is entitled to do so, but a consequence of that is that young people are priced out of it and a considerable incentive is given to people who want to get involved for investment purposes. We should look at the housing market and the aids given to the construction industry with the aim of helping, in particular, first time buyers. There is no doubt this measure is causing serious difficulties by giving an incentive to people to engage in property investment.

I asked the Minister a number of questions in the House yesterday about CAT to test his resolution on the primary reason he has given it, which is to free up assets. I asked, for example, whether he agreed assets which could be transferred by way of gift or inheritance should be taxed at a lower level and he said they should not. Obviously, with regard to death, he does not have much discretion but he does for gifts. If the intention is to free up assets, he should be looking to encourage the transfer of assets by way of gift between members of the same family, etc. I tabled the question with a view to determining whether there is a consistency in his argument and I did not detect much.

Comment on this

I will deal with some of the more outlandish arguments put forward by Deputy McDowell as I do not agree with any of the cases he put forward. A number of organisations presented a case for the lowering of capital gains tax - Forfás, the Irish Stock Exchange, the Institute of Taxation and IBEC - apart from many individual representations. Forfás proposed a widening of the 26 per cent rate which was then the standard rate. The Irish Stock Exchange proposed a reduction to 26 per cent which was the standard rate. The Institute of Taxation proposed a standard rate of capital gains tax, excluding speculative gains on developed land, of 26 per cent. IBEC also proposed a standard capital gains tax rate of 26 per cent. In the budget I changed the standard rate of tax to 24 per cent because I reduced the CGT. In future I hope to bring it down as low as 20 per cent.

Comment on this

Effectively CGT is considerably lower than the standard rate.

Comment on this

I will deal with that matter later. The Deputy also mentioned the Dunnes trust. As I pointed out in reply to a recent Parliamentary Question, the representatives of the trust made a case to the Department of Finance while my predecessor, Mr. Quinn, was in office. There have been no representations from trusts made to me or my officials since October 1996 about a reduction in CGT.

Comment on this

What about individual taxpayers or companies?

Comment on this

No individual made representations to me prior to the budget about reducing CGT. Representations were made to the Department of Finance. I only met representatives from the Institute of Taxation, IBEC, the Stock Exchange etc. and discussed a variety of taxation issues with them.

The general whinge of people on the left of Irish politics, for as long as I have been a student and probably longer, has been to keep taxes high so nobody will take any chances, the Exchequer will not get any money and the Government will not be able to redistribute that money to anybody else.

I recently received figures about the changes on the Stock Exchange. I am not saying that my reduction of the CGT has inspired the Stock Exchange to new heights solely but it may have had some benefit. I consistently reiterated my view that the 40 per cent of CGT was a disincentive to enterprise and encouraged the long-term holding of shares for no other reason than the potential exposure to high taxes. The evidence from the Stock Exchange proves that I am correct in holding this view. For some time the average daily turnover on the Exchange had been rising with the rising stock market values. The figures suggest that a reduction in the CGT rate has had a significant impetus on this turnover. In 1997 the average daily turnover in October was £125 million and in November it was £150 million. In 1998 the average daily turnover in January was £210 million and in February was £276 million. Indications are there has been a significant unlocking of long standing share portfolios. It is precisely this kind of economic activity that I foresaw and I believe needs to be encouraged. There is encouragement for people to enter the market. Ordinary citizens can invest in it and people with business ideas are encouraged to implement them.

I see no reason why the unlocking of long-standing share portfolios will not be matched by the sale of property portfolios. I made this point during a recent Dáil debate. Members of the Opposition, Deputies Rabbitte and McDowell, inquired who was asking for changes in the CGT rate. They thought that only an expert group could provide ideas, particularly in relation to taxation issues, and that the Minister for Finance is not supposed to use his own initiative. He is supposed to be act like a hoover by absorbing all the ideas from all over the place. He then can implement whatever he perceives to be the lowest common denominator of the experts' views. I do not subscribe to that view of a Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

The Minister wants individuals and groups out of the way so he can make all the decisions.

Comment on this

Deputies Rabbitte and McDowell made that suggestion in the Dáil.

Comment on this

No, I did not.

Comment on this

The Deputy wants the Minister for Finance to act as a receptacle for other people's ideas and not initiate anything.

Comment on this

I never said that. I said there was an onus on the Minister for Finance to-

Comment on this

The Deputies have consistently stated that the lower rate of CGT was not sought by anyone. They and other people from outside Leinster House have implied this is the only way any Minister for Finance should bring forward ideas; unless he has sifted through other people's ideas, he should not initiate anything himself.

Comment on this

The Minister is filibustering.

Comment on this

Many of the ideas in the Finance Bill and the budget are mine and have been around for some time. Nobody would have been surprised by my attitude towards CGT if they had read my speeches.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister.

Comment on this

The changes in CGT will inspire economic activity and prosperity. I know that not all Fine Gael Members agree with their party's line on CGT. The changes will benefit the Exchequer and fund a wide range of social services and other desirable activities. In the future I will be judged on my decision to change the CGT from 40 per cent down to 20 per cent.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil Deputies in Cork held various views on the CGT.

Comment on this

I am a great admirer of the Minister's style and his ability to contradict himself never ceases to amaze me. On the one hand he says he is not responding to anybody out there and on the other hand he says he consulted with Forfás, IBEC, the Stock Exchange, etc. I did not challenge the Minister's right to function as one.

Comment on this

The Deputy implied that in the Dáil.

Comment on this

No, I said there was no public demand for this measure. I never suggested the Minister should just function as his very eminent, expert and learned officials advise him. I have a high regard for the Minister's advisers. The Minister reminds me of a story about Peadar O'Donnell and Eamon de Valera. When Peadar O'Donnell complained to Eamon de Valera about the rate of emigration in the 1930s, 1940s, etc., de Valera said if Mr. O'Donnell was in his position they would still be emigrating. Peadar O'Donnell said they might but it would be different people who would be emigrating. Similarly, if I was in the Minister's position I would hope that I would do my own thing but it would have a different impact on different people. What does the Minister expect the Stock Exchange to say to him? They are in this business.

In terms of the Stock Exchange lobby to seriously suggest that their first concern is the generation of wealth and productive employment in the economy would be attributing just a little bit too much altruism to them. If we were in a depression I could perhaps see some argument for this drastic decision and the releasing of resources into the economy. Has any other major tax in the history of taxation been slashed in half? Forfás - added to the IBEC Stock Exchange lobby - did not advocate the halving of the tax. It is quite an extraordinary decision. It is having implications which I do not think the Minister foresaw.

I gave the example of a tenant purchase house in my constituency where the person wanted to return to rural Ireland -presumably to avail of the introduction of the new rural scheme - and the sale was stopped because the local authority invoked a particular section of the tenant purchase scheme and refused sanction. The reason they refused sanction was that the purchaser had already bought 11 or 12 houses in the area. That means the ordinary couple are in direct competition with investors in purchasing property. The Minister's purpose seems to be to divert housing policy into rented accommodation. Perhaps he is aware of what he is doing, but I am not sure that is the culture of the people. Many people aspire to owning their own house. The Minister's decision to halve capital gains tax is putting that possibility out of their reach.

I enjoy the Minister's homespun philosophy and lectures about the left wing while he was at UCD - the Minister has told us a number of times today that is a long time ago. Anybody who argues for the punitive tax rates that the Minister is ascribing to the left does not understand as I do that nobody in the super-earning bracket is paying tax at the super levels that applied in the past. There are all kinds of shelters, capital allowances etc.. One would need to be stupid to believe that and these people are not. The best of tax avoidance brains is available to these people to aid them in constructing another scheme when the Minister shuts off this one. We cannot fight this on the level of swapping philosophies. The Minister has made a decision on capital gains tax at a particular juncture of a booming economy. The example was given of four directors in national insurance who saved £1.1 million as a result of the decision. This is not a wise decision to make when our economy is booming and one is not short of resources to release into the economy. It is an inequitable decision. It is worsening the situation in the housing market in terms of access for the ordinary couple. I do not think the Minster has justified his decision.

Comment on this

Deputy Rabbitte referred to a person in his constituency who when selling his house discovered the same person had bought 11 or 12 other houses in the area. That may be anecdotal evidence. I should point out to the Deputy that if a person is doing that he is deemed to be a trader in property. A cursory knowledge of the Income Tax Acts will tell a person that you may have a once-off dip into the market and sell your house, but if you do it on more than a couple of occasions Revenue will consider you a dealer in property and you will be taxed as if you were trading in sweets or cigarettes. If the Deputy's information is correct, then when he meets up with the individual concerned again he can break him the good news that he will be deemed to be a trader in property if he is so investing.

Comment on this

He is a landlord. There is no secret about it.

Comment on this

If he is a trader in property the question of capital gains tax does not arise.

Comment on this

He is purchasing houses and renting them to people whom the Minister is subsidising through the Eastern Health Board rent subsidy scheme.

Comment on this

The Deputy is making the case that this problem arose as a result of the halving of capital gains tax. I am pointing out that this man's dealings on the property market have nothing to do with capital gains tax.

Comment on this

The Minister is fuelling the availability of investment resources to enable someone to do this.

Comment on this

I am trying to explain to the Deputy that that individual will be deemed to be a trader in property. The halving of the capital gains tax rates has nothing to do with the property market.

Comment on this

The individual is a businessman in a number of areas. I am saying that kind of aggregation is taking place and the average young couple are in competition with a person like that. The halving of the capital gains tax is a factor in fuelling house prices which are out of reach to the ordinary people in Dublin.

Comment on this

We are discussing capital gains tax.

Comment on this

That decision is releasing funds to purchase houses in this fashion.

Comment on this

I am trying to explain to the Deputy, perhaps badly, that capital gains tax, whether at 40 per cent or 20 per cent, bears no relevance to that person because he is a trader in property and will be deemed so by the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that if I make £1.1 million on the Stock Exchange, as in the instance I gave, that does not enable me to buy houses in his constituency or mine?

Comment on this

The Deputy outlined a case in the Dáil and here today of a person who was going to buy property——

Comment on this

The Minister knows the county manager. I can get him to write a note to the Minister.

Comment on this

——and was not allowed to do so because he had purchased 11 or 12 houses in that area. If that person is making decisions on the basis of the lowering of capital gains tax he or she is mistaken because he will not qualify for the 20 per cent or 40 per cent rate. That person is regarded as a trader in property in the business of buying and selling and will have to do his accounts on that basis.

Comment on this

That is not the point I am making.

Comment on this

The Deputy can explain to the person concerned that he or she is making a mistake. I am the first Minister for Finance to limit, quite severely, the capital allowances and other tax breaks available to high income earners. I signalled in the budget on 3 December that as a result of a Revenue survey - I referred to it in my Budget Statement - I was limiting these tax shelters which Deputy Rabbitte quite rightly points out have been used successfully by high income earners to illegally limit their exposure to tax. I am the first Minister for Finance to make these very significant changes. Conscious of the debate we had this morning about personal tax rates, might I say to the Deputy that the widening of bands or allowances is of absolutely no relevance to the person earning £300,000 and £400,000 per year because they are using tax shelters. I have put very severe limitations into the Finance Bill in relation to these matters. I have done this in an effort to do away with the illegal mechanisms which high income earners are using to reduce tax liabilities.

Comment on this

I agree with the reduction in capital gains tax from 40 per cent to 20 per cent in that it will encourage people to part with assets which will contribute to growth and development. It is good to unlock assets. What amazes me, and has done so since this decision was announced in the budget, is that the Minister is being accused of fuelling the crisis in the housing market. That is a phoney argument. It is one that could have been made against the previous Administration, who eliminated residential property tax. That was a flawed decision. I am listening to the people who participated in and brought about that decision criticising this Minister for this decision. Residential property tax brought in about £4 million in the last financial year of 1995/1996. We are all aware of the increases in the property market over the past number of years. I am quite sure if residential property tax had remained it would yield about £20 million in a full year. I ask those people who are complaining about this decision to think about what they did in relation to residential property tax. That has also had an impact in fuelling the housing market crisis. I call on people to maintain a balance on this matter. The Minister has already referred to the freeing up of assets over recent months. If that continues, it will cost the Exchequer very little in the years to come and will allow for increased growth and development.

Comment on this

I refer to my earlier discourse with Deputy McDowell. Under existing taxation law, the death of a person does not give rise to a capital gains charge. Therefore, rather than people taking the opportunity to get rid of their assets during their lifetimes, they will often hold on to them until they die. Capital acquisition tax rules are then invoked and there is a higher exemption threshold. It is better, and I suspect many Members think similarly and not just those in Fianna Fáil, to have people doing business and trading with the State getting its take, which can then be distributed via the Exchequer to other worthwhile causes. I subscribe to that philosophy and it is one to which Fine Gael used to subscribe; perhaps, since its two and a half years in Government with other parties, it no longer does.

Comment on this

First, I wish to dispose of the Hoover argument. I never suggested the Minister should act as a Hoover and simply echo comments made to him by his officials. I am happy to have the Minister take initiatives. When the Minister takes an initiative to implement a change which is manifestly unfair there is an onus on him to back it up and he has not does so. He makes an argument about activity on the Stock Exchange. I wonder about the value to the economy of boosting the asset value price of the shares of a relatively small number of public companies. If they were more companies entering the market looking for funds and exchanging shares it would benefit the economy but I am not convinced boosting the asset value of shares irrespective of their income earning is ultimately of much benefit to the economy or the Stock Exchange. It may be of benefit to those dealing in the shares but not to the exchange itself.

The Minister commented on the way those on the Left discourage people from taking chances. Perhaps this was true once but not anymore. We want to encourage a level playing field but it must extend between different types of income. The Minister has steadfastly refused to confront the issue of equity - the differential between the 20 per cent tax on unearned income and the potential 46 per cent marginal tax on earned income. The issue of equity, which is critically important in terms of the messages being sent out by the taxation system, has not been addressed.

Comment on this

I do not like the bona fides in this regard. I understand the Deputy's view but I do not agree with his philosophy. I do not believe in high nominal tax rates as they are a disincentive, be they in the capital gains or income tax areas. It may suit many people to say the Minister's stance was not credible. but anyone who has known me for a long time should be in no doubt about it. I do not fly any false colours in this regard.

The Deputy raised the issue of funds on the Stock Exchange building up the value of a few companies. More private companies will apply to the Stock Exchange as a result of this relief because they will be in a position to unlock their investments and make a mark in capitalisation. If they go to the exchange they will only have to pay 20 per cent on capital gains whereas until now it would have been 40 per cent and many companies would not take a chance. I believe in that philosophy and have no problems with Deputies or others who do not subscribe it. I have not recently being converted to it and do not mind people criticising what I am doing but it must be understood I come from a totally different philosophy than that being articulated by people inside and outside the House. I do not want there to be any doubt about my ideas in this regard.

Comment on this

We almost have a consensus. I accept the Minister's bona fides but he can hardly complain when Members of the Opposition say that by reducing a rich man's tax, he is benefiting rich men and is giving disproportionate benefit to the better off in society.

Comment on this

I do not agree with that.

Comment on this

Deputy Fleming was probably right about the residential property tax but I will make two points. First, we attempted through the use of stamp duty on houses above a certain threshold to try to stop the phenomenon about which he complains. Second, even though he was not a Member, he was close enough to the action to know it was a headline policy objective of his party. Perhaps that is not a good advertisement for adversarial politics.

The Minister told us on 3 December 1997 he expected this decision would cost £19 million; six weeks later in a parliamentary reply he told us the estimate was £40 million and, judging by the booming economy, that figure is likely to continue to rise. Why did the Minister not slash capital gains tax to the level of corporation tax? Is there any precedent for halving a tax? How is it fair that an individual who makes a capital gain through a paper transaction is taxed at the 20 per cent rate while another individual working in an area of the economy creating wealth is taxed at 28, 30, 35 per cent depending on the category he or she is in? I do not know how the Minister can explain that.

The Minister referred to eminent bodies which gave him this advice.

Comment on this

No, they sought this relief.

Comment on this

That is a better way of putting it. Did the Department advise him to do this?

Comment on this

Deputy Rabbitte asked why I did not reduce the rate of capital gains tax from 40 per cent to 32 per cent. If it was reduced to that rate, one would not achieve a decisive move in the market or get people to release their assets. It would not work if it was carried out in a piecemeal fashion.

The Deputy raised the question of cost. On budget day, I said it cost would £19 million net and my reply to the parliamentary question also stated this . On a static basis it was calculated that for every 1 per cent reduction in capital gains, it would cost the Exchequer £2 million, which totals £40 million. It was estimated that due to increased activity as a result of the reduction, £20 million would be brought in and £1 million would be saved by reducing personal allowances on capital gains tax by £1,000 for a single person and £2,000 for a married people. Reducing this to £500 would save another £1 million. That is where the £19 million was deduced at the time. During the budget speech I said that "as a prudent accountant" I was making this provision even though I believed it would have an enormous effect. That is how the figures were calculated. That is the figure I gave to Deputy McManus. Obviously she did not read the reply which stated that the gross cost was £40 million but the net cost was £19 million. I do not have the briefing notes I had during the budget debate but I can remember clearly how it was calculated. The figures are the same.

I provided £19 million to be prudent, even though I believe that the effect of the capital gains tax change will be to give a significant boost to the Exchequer. The CGT change only came in on 3 December so the effects will be felt in future years more than in 1998. The figure is not at variance with the figure I gave in the budget. Deputy McManus would have understood that from even a cursory reading of the reply.

It is not the practice for the Minister for Finance or the Government to comment on advice given by the Department of Finance. Officials in the Department of Finance know this about me, as do those in the Departments of Tourism and Trade and Social, Community and Family Affairs: I believe in the principle that advisers advise, Ministers decide.

Comment on this

Members wishing to be recorded as dissenting please raise their hands. Deputies Rabbitte and McDowell raised their hands.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 91:

In page 78, before section 50, to insert the following new section:

"50.-Section 29 of the Principal Act is hereby amended:

(a) by the deletion in subsection (4) of 'the United Kingdom' and the substitution of 'Great Britain and Northern Ireland', and

(b) by the deletion in subsection (4)(c) of 'the United Kingdom' and the substitution of 'Great Britain and Northern Ireland'.".

The Minister will identify amendment Nos. 91, 96 and 97 as the work of my learned colleague Deputy Ferris who proposed them during the Taxes Consolidation Bill. On that occasion the Minister suggested that they were more appropriate to the Finance Bill. I move them on the basis that they are drafting amendments.

Comment on this

I propose to deal with amendments Nos. 91 and 153 together. These amendments were raised by Deputy Ferris during the Taxes Consolidation Bill. They are intended to achieve uniformity of expression in the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, by substituting the term "Great Britain and Northern Ireland" for the "United Kingdom". Amendment No. 91 is seeking to amend section 29 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. This provision modifies the charge to capital gains tax in the case of gains arising to resident or ordinary resident individuals who are not domiciled in the State from the disposal of assets situated outside the State and the United Kingdom.

Amendment No. 153 proposes to amend, respectively, sections 548 and 832 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. Section 548 is concerned with the valuation of assets for capital gains tax purposes. Section 832 contains provisions relating to the UK Double Taxation Convention. While I might agree with the aim of these amendments, that we should strive for as much consistency as possible in the consolidation Act, the fact remains that there may have been good reasons the Oireachtas used slightly different versions to describe what might seem the same thing at first sight. Therefore, we need to be careful when making changes in case we inadvertently make a substantial change to the law.

For example, the parliamentary draftsman's office advises that replacing the expression "the United Kingdom" with "Great Britain and Northern Ireland" could, in certain circumstances, result in an alteration to the meaning of the underlying legislation.

The question was posed as to what would be the status of the United Kingdom's areas of the continental shelf or even the territorial seas of the United Kingdom. In this connection I refer the House to section 276 of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act, 1992, which is the UK equivalent of our Capital Gains Tax Act, 1975, where the territorial sea of the UK is deemed for all purposes of the taxation of charitable gains to be part of the UK. In light of this provision it is arguable that the use of this expression "Great Britain and Northern Ireland" in Irish legislation, instead of "the United Kingdom" may in some instances have the effect of excluding such areas from the scope of the legislation. In these circumstances and in the absence of any obvious or pressing need for change I am not prepared to accept the amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 92:

In page 78, to delete lines 36 to 38 and substitute the following:

"(3) Subsections (2) to (7) of section 741 shall apply for the purposes of this section as if references in those subsections to a non-qualifying offshore fund were references to an offshore fund.".

This is a technical drafting amendment.

Comment on this

To be consistent I oppose this section. There is a special rate of 26 per cent capital gains tax which applies in the case of certain shares and companies. If we are to be consistent in opposing the earlier motion we should also oppose this. However, if the Minister has had his way with 20 per cent, then it should be 20 per cent here too.

Comment on this

Members wishing to be recorded as dissenting please raise their hands. Deputies McDowell and Rabbitte raised their hands.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 93:

In page 80, subsection (1), to delete lines 34 to 36 and substitute the following:

"55.-(1) Section 597 of the Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in subsection (2), by the substitution for paragraphs (f) and (g) of the following paragraphs:

'(f) such of the activities of a body of persons established for the sole purpose of promoting athletic or amateur games or sports as are directed to that purpose,

(g) farming, and

(h) the letting or property where the individual or individuals are charged under section 75 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997.',

and

(b) in subsection (3), by the substitution for paragraph (c) of the following paragraphs:".

This amendment seeks to extend rollover relief to a number of sectors which do not currently enjoy this relief. In particular, it seeks to extend rollover relief to people providing private rented accommodation. We are all aware of the crisis in house prices with new homes becoming inaccessible to many first time buyers in particular and this has forced many people to continue renting. However, if we are to ensure a sufficient supply of good quality private rented accommodation at affordable rents, steps must be taken to assist that process.

If property owners do not have rollover relief the costs of disposing of older, often more run down properties, and replacing them with better quality buildings, becomes significant. Inevitably, these costs are reflected in increased rents. This step should be taken for reasons of equity but especially to promote an increasing supply of affordable private rented accommodation.

Comment on this

I am opposing this amendment. The Deputy is seeking to grant rollover relief on the disposal of rental property. This would mean that a landlord could sell a rented property and invest the proceeds in a new investment rental property without incurring a capital gains tax liability. That capital gains tax liability would not arise until the new property was disposed of where the proceeds were not invested in a further new property. This amendment was put forward by the Irish Property Owners Association. I met its representative and stated that I would not accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Members wishing to be recorded as dissenting please raise their hand. Deputies Coveney and Creed raised their hands.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 94 and 95 are to be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 94:

In page 81, subsection (1), to delete lines 42 and 43 and substitute the following:

"57.-(1) Section 652 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsections after subsection (3)".

Section 57 of the Bill amends section 652 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, by the insertion of a new subsection (3)(a) which provides capital gains tax rollover relief for the disposal of lands by a greyhound racetrack. This amendment adds a further subsection to section 652. The use of subsection (3)(b) is to ensure the sales of development land by statutory bodies to the Dublin Docklands Authority will be entitled to "roll-over relief" within the capital gains tax code. This will mean that these statutory bodies can use the full proceeds from the sale of land in acquiring new assets. Capital gains tax will not apply at the time of such disposals. Under section 28 of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority Act, 1997, the Minister for the Environment and Local Government may transfer, by order, land from a statutory body in the Dublin Docklands Development Authority for full consideration. Providing rollover relief for the disposal of lands by the statutory bodies avoids a circular flow of State moneys. I commend this amendment to the committee.

Comment on this

Are we talking about CIE or the Docklands Authority?

Comment on this

Of the 1,300 acres within the Dublin docklands area, in excess of 400 acres are owned by State bodies. While much of this land is currently, and will continue to be, required by those bodies for their own purposes, almost 125 acres are surplus to their requirements or will become surplus in the near future. These lands represent over one half of the available acreage available for redevelopment. The bodies concerned are CIE, An Bord Gáis, Dublin Corporation, the ESB, An Post and Dublin Port.

The rollover relief is for these statutory bodies who will be selling land to the Authority. If they paid capital gains tax the money would have to be sent back to them another way, so this avoids the circular flow of money.

Comment on this

How do greyhound tracks relate to this?

Comment on this

This section amends section 652 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which gave rollover relief to disposal of lands for a greyhound track.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 95:

In page 82, subsection (1), to delete line 30 and substitute the following:

"(ii) subsection (11)(b) had not been enacted.

(3B) Subsection (1) shall not apply to consideration obtained for a relevant disposal effected by an order made under section 28(1) of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority Act, 1997.'.".

Comment on this

Amendments No. 96 and 97 are to be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 96

"59.-In page 82, before section 59, to insert the following new section:

"59.-Section 1030 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (4):

'(5) In this section "spouse" has the meaning assigned by section 2(2)(c) of the Family Law Act, 1995.',".

These amendments were proposed during the Taxes Consolidation Bill, and in essence they seek to bring the definition of "spouse" in line with the Family Law Act, 1995, and the Family Law (Divorce) Act, 1996.

Comment on this

The intention behind this amendment was included in section 1030 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, where the proposed definition of "spouse" appears in subsection (1) of that section as a result of suggestion from Deputy Ferris at the time. The amendment is therefore unnecessary.

Comment on this

What is the basis for not making the distinction in this area? Why is it not in the personal income tax code? Why are cohabiting couples treated differently?

Comment on this

This is not about cohabiting couples. Deputy McDowell's amendment relates to a section proposed by Deputy Ferris during the debate on the Taxes Consolidation Act to ensure consistency in the definition of "spouse".

Comment on this

I oppose this section. Prior to this a married couple had a £2,000 limit; now there is a £1,000 limit but they cannot transfer it between them. In reducing capital gains tax from 40 to 20 per cent, it is inappropriate to hit that group. I presume this is part of the Minister's clawback scheme, but many of these people are not in the capital gains tax bracket. They have found they can use the £2,000 between them but the Minister's proposal means that the husband can use his but cannot avail of the difference between his allowance and his wife's. It seems unfair.

Comment on this

To prove my bona fides and to ensure the Minister understands that it is not that I am completely opposed to transactions of this kind, but I do not understand the Minister's position. He has changed his mind since the budget in so far as he has restored the individual allowance to married couples although they cannot transfer it between themselves.

We should be trying to encourage people to dabble in the stock market or to create small gains. A small gains allowance is a useful way of doing this, and this is precisely the part of the capital gains tax code where one could introduce it. However, the Minister has chosen to attack this section as a way of clawing back the gift he has given to those who are better off.

Comment on this

How much is involved here?

Comment on this

We are reducing this from £2,000 to £500. That is what I announced in the budget.

Comment on this

A typical example of people dabbling is in employee shareholding schemes. People buy a certain number of shares in the company they work for and dispose of them usually within the year. That would normally be free of capital gains tax because of the BIK element and because it would be under the £2,000 limit. In many cases such people will now be caught by reducing the limit.

Comment on this

There is a slight inconsistency in the Deputy's argument because I reduced capital gains tax from 40 per cent to 20 per cent. When doing so, I was going to have no exemption threshold but then decided on a minimalist £500 exemption. Otherwise it would have been more trouble than it was worth for people making their tax returns.

Subsequent to the budget arguments similar to the Deputy's were made for small gains and I showed my good heart in increasing it from £500 to £1,000, which is generous. The yield from the non-transfer of £1,000 is £500,000. The old relief was £1,000 for a single person and £2,000 for a married couple. Couples can transfer assets from one partner to another without capital gains tax charge or stamp duty arising. I should not be giving tax advice. Those at the smaller end of the market should be encouraged to make gains.

Comment on this

Why not continue those small gains to individuals? Why change this?

Comment on this

Reducing the capital gains tax rate from 40 per cent to 20 per cent was a major change in the tax code. I felt there was no need to make further changes. I have come from zero and am now at £2,000.

Comment on this

The Minister is giving a huge benefit to those greatly engaged in the market and clawing back small benefits where people dabble in it.

Comment on this

The following Members will be recorded as dissenting: Deputies L. Belton, D. Carey, H. Coveney, M. Creed, D. McDowell and P. Rabbitte.

NEW SECTIONS.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:

In page 82, before section 60, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

"60.-Part 10 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion after Chapter 6 of the following:

CHAPTER 7

Qualifying areas

372A.-(1) In this Chapter-

lease", lessee", lessor", premium" and rent" have the same meanings respectively as in Chapter 8 of Part 4;

"market value", in relation to a building, structure or house, means the price which the unencumbered fee simple of the building, structure or house would fetch if sold in the open market in such manner and subject to such conditions as might reasonably be calculated to obtain for the vendor the best price for the building, structure or house, less the part of that price which would be attributable to the acquisition of, or of rights in or over, the land on which the building, structure or house is constructed;

"multi-storey car park" means a building or structure consisting of 2 or more storeys wholly or mainly in use for the purpose of providing, for members of the public generally without preference for any particular class of person, on payment of an appropriate charge, parking space for mechanically propelled vehicles;

"qualifying area" means an area or areas specified as a qualifying area under section 372B;

"qualifying period" means, subject to section 372B, the period commencing on the 1st day of August, 1998, and ending on the 31st day of July, 2001;

"refurbishment", in relation to a building or structure and other than for the purposes of sections 372H and 372I, means any work of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, including the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities, carried out in the course of the repair or restoration, or maintenance in the nature of repair or restoration, of the building or structure.

(2) This Chapter shall apply if the Oireachtas passes an Act which refers to this Chapter and provides for the renewal of certain urban areas and the submission of plans (to be known as "Integrated Area Plans") to the Minister for the Environment and Local Government which have been drawn up by local authorities or companies established by local authorities (being local authorities as referred to in such Act) in respect of an area or areas identified by such an authority or company on the basis of criteria prepared by that Minister, including physical and socio-economic renewal of such an area or areas.

372B.-(1) The Minister for Finance may, on the recommendation of the Minister for the Environment and Local Government (which recommendation shall take into consideration an Integrated Area Plan submitted by a local authority or a company established by a local authority to that Minister in respect of an area identified by it), by order direct that-

(a) the area or areas described (being wholly located within the boundaries of the area to which the Integrated Area Plan relates) in the order shall be a qualifying area for the purposes of one or more sections of this Chapter,

(b) where such an area or areas is or are to be a qualifying area for the purposes of section 372D, one or more of the categories of building or structure mentioned in subsection (2) shall or shall not be a qualifying premises within the meaning of that section, and

(c) as respects any such area so described in the order, the definition of "qualifying period" in section 372A shall be construed as a reference to such period as shall be specified in the order in relation to that area; but no such period specified in the order shall commence before the 1st day of August, 1998, or end after-

(i) in the case of sections 372C, 372D and 372E, the 31st day of December, 1999, and

(ii) in any other case, the 31st day of July, 2001.

(2) The categories of building or structure referred to in subsection (1)(b) shall be-

(a) buildings or structures which consist of office accommodation,

(b) multi-storey car parks, and

(c) any other buildings or structures and in respect of which not more than 10 per cent of the capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on their construction or refurbishment relates to the construction or refurbishment of office accommodation.

(3) Every order made by the Minister for Finance under subsection (1) shall be laid before Dáil Éireann as soon as may be after it is made and, if a resolution annulling the order is passed by Dáil Éireann within the next 21 days on which Dáil Éireann has sat after the order is laid before it, the order shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.

(4) Notwithstanding an order under subsection (1), the granting of relief by virtue of any provision of this Chapter shall be subject to such other requirements as may be specified in or under the Act referred to in section 372A(2).

372C.-(1) This section shall apply to a building or structure the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area and which is to be an industrial building or structure by reason of its use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a).

(2) Subject to subsection (4), section 271 shall apply in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies as if-

(a) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted,

(b) in subsection (2)(a)(i) of that section "to which subsection (3) applies" were deleted,

(c) subsection (3) of that section were deleted,

(d) the following subsection were substituted for subsection (4) of that section:

"(4) An industrial building allowance shall be of an amount equal to 25 per cent of the capital expenditure mentioned in subsection (2).",

and

(e) in subsection (5) of that section "to which subsection (3)(c) applies" were deleted.

(3) Subject to subsection (4), section 273 shall apply in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies as if-

(a) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted,

(b) the following paragraph were substituted for paragraph (b) of subsection (2) of that section:

"(b) As respects any qualifying expenditure, any allowance made under section 272 and increased under paragraph (a) in respect of that expenditure, whether claimed for one chargeable period or more than one such period, shall not in the aggregate exceed 50 per cent of the amount of that qualifying expenditure.",

(c) subsections (3) to (7) of that section were deleted.

(4) In the case where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies, subsections (2) and (3) shall apply only if the total amount of the capital expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the building or structure immediately before that expenditure was incurred.

(5) Notwithstanding section 274(1), no balancing charge shall be made in relation to a building or structure to which this section applies by reason of any of the events specified in that section which occurs-

(a) more than 13 years after the building or structure was first used, or

(b) in a case where section 276 applies, more than 13 years after the capital expenditure on refurbishment of the building or structure was incurred.

(6) For the purposes only of determining, in relation to a claim for an allowance under section 271 or 273 as applied by this section, whether and to what extent capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of an industrial building or structure is incurred or not incurred in the qualifying period, only such an amount of that capital expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction or, as the case may be, the refurbishment of the building or structure actually carried out during the qualifying period shall (notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts as to the time when any capital expenditure is or is to be treated as incurred) be treated as having been incurred in that period.

372D.-(1) In this section, "qualifying premises" means a building or structure the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area, and which-

(a) apart from this section is not an industrial building or structure within the meaning of section 268, and

(b) (i) is in use for the purposes of a trade or profession, or

(ii) whether or not it is so used, is let on bona fide commercial terms for such consideration as might be expected to be paid in a letting of the building or structure negotiated on an arm's length basis,

but does not include any part of a building or structure in use as or as part of a dwelling house.

(2) (a) Subject to paragraph (b) and subsections (3) to (6), the provisions of the Tax Acts (other than section 372C) relating to the making of allowances or charges in respect of capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of an industrial building or structure shall, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in those provisions, apply-

(i) as if a qualifying premises were, at all times at which it is a qualifying premises, a building or structure in respect of which an allowance is to be made for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under Chapter 1 of Part 9 by reason of its use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a), and

(ii) where any activity carried on in the qualifying premises is not a trade, as if it were a trade.

(b) An allowance shall be given by virtue of this subsection in respect of any capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises only in so far as that expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period.

(3) In the case where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a qualifying premises, subsection (2) shall apply only if the total amount of the capital expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the qualifying premises immediately before that expenditure was incurred.

(4) For the purposes of the application, by subsection (2), of sections 271 and 273 in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises-

(a) section 271 shall apply as if-

(i) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted,

(ii) in subsection (2)(a)(i) of that section "to which subsection (3) applies" were deleted,

(iii) subsection (3) of that section were deleted,

(iv) the following subsection were substituted for subsection (4) of that section:

"(4) An industrial building allowance shall be of an amount equal to 50 per cent of the capital expenditure mentioned in subsection (2).",

and

(v) in subsection (5) of that section "to which subsection (3)(c) applies" were deleted,

and

(b) section 273 shall apply as if-

(i) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted, and

(ii) subsections (2)(b) and (3) to (7) of that section were deleted.

(5) Notwithstanding section 274(1), no balancing charge shall be made in relation to a qualifying premises by reason of any of the events specified in that section which occur-

(a) more than 13 years after the qualifying premises was first used, or

(b) in a case where section 276 applies, more than 13 years after the capital expenditure on refurbishment of the qualifying premises was incurred.

(6) (a) Notwithstanding subsections (2) to (4), any allowance or charge which apart from this subsection would be made by virtue of subsection (2) in respect of capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises shall be reduced to one-half of the amount which apart from this subsection would be the amount of that allowance or charge.

(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the amount of an allowance or charge to be reduced to one-half shall be computed as if-

(i) this subsection had not been enacted, and

(ii) effect had been given to all allowances taken into account in so computing that amount.

(c) Nothing in this subsection shall affect the operation of section 274(8).

(7) For the purposes only of determining, in relation to a claim for an allowance by virtue of subsection (2), whether and to what extent capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises is incurred or not incurred in the qualifying period, only such an amount of that capital expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction or refurbishment of the premises actually carried out during the qualifying period shall (notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts as to the time when any capital expenditure is or is to be treated as incurred) be treated as having been incurred in that period.

372E.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying lease" means, subject to subsection (8), a lease in respect of a qualifying premises granted in the qualifying period on bona fide commercial terms by a lessor to a lessee not connected with the lessor, or with any other person entitled to a rent in respect of the qualifying premises, whether under that lease or any other lease;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsection (5)(a), a building or structure-

(a) (i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area and which is a building or structure in use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a), and in respect of which capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period for which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under section 271 or 273, as applied by section 372C,

(ii) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area and in respect of which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under Chapter 1 of Part 9 by virtue of section 372D, or

(iii) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area and which is a building or structure in use for the purposes specified in section 268(1)(d), and in respect of the construction or refurbishment of which capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period for which an allowance would but for subsection (6) be made for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under Chapter 1 of Part 9,

and

(b) which is let on bona fide commercial terms for such consideration as might be expected to be paid in a letting of the building or structure negotiated on an arm's length basis, but, where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a building or structure in respect of which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, or in respect of which an allowance would but for subsection (6) be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under any of the provisions referred to in paragraph (a), the building or structure shall not be regarded as a qualifying premises unless the total amount of the expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the building or structure immediately before that expenditure is incurred.

(2) For the purposes of this section, so much of a period, being a period when rent is payable by a person in relation to a qualifying premises under a qualifying lease, shall be a relevant rental period as does not exceed-

(a) 10 years, or

(b) the period by which 10 years exceeds-

(i) any preceding period, or

(ii) if there is more than one preceding period, the aggregate of those periods,

for which rent was payable by that person or any other person in relation to that premises under a qualifying lease.

(3) Subject to subsection (4), where in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of a trade or profession a person is apart from this section entitled to any deduction (in this subsection referred to as "the first-mentioned deduction") on account of rent in respect of a qualifying premises occupied by such person for the purposes of that trade or profession which is payable by such person for a relevant rental period in relation to that qualifying premises under a qualifying lease, such person shall be entitled in that computation to a further deduction (in this subsection referred to as "the second-mentioned deduction") equal to the amount of the first-mentioned deduction but where the first-mentioned deduction is on account of rent payable by such person to a connected person, such person shall not be entitled in that computation to the second-mentioned deduction.

(4) Where a person holds an interest in a qualifying premises out of which interest a qualifying lease is created directly or indirectly in respect of the qualifying premises and in respect of rent payable under the qualifying lease a claim for a further deduction under this section is made, and either such person or another person connected with such person-

(a) takes under a qualifying lease a qualifying premises (in this subsection referred to as "the second-mentioned premises") occupied by such person or such other person, as the case may be, for the purposes of a trade or profession, and

(b) is apart from this section entitled, in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of that trade or profession, to a deduction on account of rent in respect of the second-mentioned premises,

then, unless such person or such other person, as the case may be, shows that the taking on lease of the second-mentioned premises was not undertaken for the sole or main benefit of obtaining a further deduction on account of rent under this section, such person or such other person, as the case may be, shall not be entitled in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of that trade or profession to any further deduction on account of rent in respect of the second-mentioned premises.

(5) (a) A building or structure in use for the purposes specified in section 268(1)(d) shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of this section unless the person to whom an allowance under Chapter 1 of Part 9 would but for subsection (6) be made for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, in respect of the capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of the building or structure elects by notice in writing to the appropriate inspector (within the meaning of section 950) to disclaim all allowances under that Chapter in respect of that capital expenditure.

(b) An election under paragraph (a) shall be included in the return required to be made by the person concerned under section 951 for the first year of assessment or the first accounting period, as the case may be, for which an allowance would but for subsection (6) have been made to that person under Chapter 1 of Part 9 in respect of that capital expenditure.

(c) An election under paragraph (a) shall be irrevocable.

(d) A person who has made an election under paragraph (a) shall furnish a copy of that election to any person (in this paragraph referred to as "the second-mentioned person") to whom the person grants a qualifying lease in respect of the qualifying premises, and the second-mentioned person shall include the copy in the return required to be made by the second-mentioned person under section 951 for the year of assessment or accounting period, as the case may be, in which rent is first payable by the second-mentioned person under the qualifying lease in respect of the qualifying premises.

(6) Where a person who has incurred capital expenditure in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure in use for the purposes specified in section 268(1)(d) makes an election under subsection (5)(a), then, notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts-

(a) no allowance under Chapter 1 of Part 9 shall be made to the person in respect of that capital expenditure,

(b) on the occurrence, in relation to the building or structure, of any of the events referred to in section 274(1), the residue of expenditure (within the meaning of section 277) in relation to that capital expenditure shall be deemed to be nil, and

(c) section 279 shall not apply in the case of any person who buys the relevant interest (within the meaning of section 269) in the building or structure.

(7) For the purposes of determining, in relation to paragraph (a)(iii) of the definition of "qualifying premises" and subsections (5) and (6), whether and to what extent capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure is incurred or not incurred in the qualifying period, only such an amount of that capital expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction or refurbishment of the building or structure actually carried out in the qualifying period shall (notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts as to the time when any capital expenditure is or is to be treated as incurred) be treated as having been incurred in that period.

(8) (a) In this subsection-

"current value", in relation to minimum lease payments, means the value of those payments discounted to their present value at a rate which, when applied at the inception of the lease to-

(i) those payments, including any initial payment but excluding any payment or part of any payment for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee, and

(ii) any unguaranteed residual value of the qualifying premises, excluding any part of such value for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee,

produces discounted present values the aggregate amount of which equals the amount of the fair value of the qualifying premises;

"fair value", in relation to a qualifying premises, means an amount equal to such consideration as might be expected to be paid for the premises on a sale negotiated on an arm's length basis less any grants receivable towards the purchase of the qualifying premises;

"inception of the lease" means the earlier of the time the qualifying premises is brought into use or the date from which rentals under the lease first accrue;

"minimum lease payments" means the minimum payments over the remaining part of the term of the lease to be paid to the lessor, and includes any residual amount to be paid to the lessor at the end of the term of the lease and guaranteed by the lessee or by a person connected with the lessee;

"unguaranteed residual value", in relation to a qualifying premises, means that part of the residual value of that premises at the end of a term of a lease, as estimated at the inception of the lease, the realisation of which by the lessor is not assured or is guaranteed solely by a person connected with the lessor.

(b) A finance lease, that is-

(i) a lease in respect of a qualifying premises where, at the inception of the lease, the aggregate of the current value of the minimum lease payments (including any initial payment but excluding any payment or part of any payment for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee) payable by the lessee in relation to the lease amounts to 90 per cent or more of the fair value of the qualifying premises, or

(ii) a lease which in all the circumstances is considered to provide in substance for the lessee the risks and benefits associated with ownership of the qualifying premises other than legal title to that premises,

shall not be a qualifying lease for the purposes of this section.

372F.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372J(2), a lease of the house the consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium which does not exceed 10 per cent of the relevant cost of the house;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(a), (4)(c) and (5) of section 372J, a house

(a) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area,

(b) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(c) the total floor area of which

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(d) in respect of which, if it is not a new house (for the purposes of section 4 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979) provided for sale, there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost, the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of construction of the house is not less than the expenditure actually incurred on such construction, and

(e) which without having been used is first let in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"relevant cost", in relation to a house, means, subject to subsection (3), an amount equal to the aggregate of-

(a) the expenditure incurred on the acquisition of, or of rights in or over, any land on which the house is constructed, and

(b) the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the house;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred expenditure on the construction of a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of that expenditure as is to be treated under section 372J(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(3) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period on the construction of the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (2) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the expenditure incurred on that construction.

(4) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary-

(a) of the expenditure incurred on the construction of that building or those buildings, and

(b) of the amount which would be the relevant cost in relation to that building or those buildings if the building or buildings, as the case may be, were a single qualifying premises,

for the purposes of determining the expenditure incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises and the relevant cost in relation to the qualifying premises.

(5) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs-

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (2) in respect of expenditure incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(6) (a) Where the event mentioned in subsection (5)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the amount which under section 372J(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (3)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period on the construction of the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed the relevant price paid by such person on the purchase.

(b) For the purposes of this subsection and subsection (7), the relevant price paid by a person on the purchase of a house shall be the amount which bears to the net price paid by such person on that purchase the same proportion as the amount of the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the house which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the relevant cost in relation to that house.

(7) (a) Subject to paragraph (b), where expenditure is incurred on the construction of a house and before the house is used it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(ii) the relevant price paid by such person on the purchase;

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(b) Where expenditure is incurred on the construction of a house by a person carrying on a trade or part of a trade which consists, as to the whole or any part of the trade, of the construction of buildings with a view to their sale and the house, before it is used, is sold in the course of that trade or, as the case may be, that part of that trade

(i) the person (in this paragraph referred to as "the purchaser") who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the relevant price paid by the purchaser on the purchase (in this paragraph referred to as "the first purchase"), and

(ii) in relation to any subsequent sale or sales of the house before the house is used, paragraph (a) shall apply as if the reference to the amount of expenditure which is to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period were a reference to the relevant price paid on the first purchase.

(8) Section 372J shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372G.-(1) In this section-

"conversion expenditure" means, subject to subsection (2), expenditure incurred on-

(a) the conversion into a house of a building

(i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area, and

(ii) which has not been previously in use as a dwelling,

and

(b) the conversion into 2 or more houses of a building

(i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area, and

(ii) which before the conversion had not been in use as a dwelling or had been in use as a single dwelling,

and references in this section and in section 372J to "conversion", "conversion into a house" and "expenditure incurred on conversion" shall be construed accordingly;

"qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372J(2), a lease of the house the consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium which does not exceed 10 per cent of the market value of the house at the time the conversion is completed and, in the case of a house which is a part of a building and is not saleable apart from the building of which it is a part, the market value of the house at the time the conversion is completed shall for the purposes of this paragraph be taken to be an amount which bears to the market value of the building at that time the same proportion as the total floor area of the house bears to the total floor area of the building;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(b), (4)(c) and (5) of section 372J, a house-

(a) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(b) the total floor area of which-

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(c) in respect of which there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of conversion in relation to the house is not less than the expenditure actually incurred on such conversion, and

(d) which without having been used subsequent to the incurring of the expenditure on the conversion is first let in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(2) For the purposes of this section, expenditure incurred on the conversion of a building shall be deemed to include expenditure incurred in the course of the conversion on either or both of the following-

(a) the carrying out of any works of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, and

(b) the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities, "in relation to the building or any out office appurtenant to or usually enjoyed with the building, but shall not be deemed to include-

(i) any expenditure in respect of which any person is entitled to a deduction, relief or allowance under any other provision of the Tax Acts, or

(ii) any expenditure attributable to any part (in this section referred to as a "non-residential unit") of the building which on completion of the conversion is not a house.

(3) For the purposes of subsection (2)(ii), where expenditure is attributable to a building in general and not directly to any particular house or non-residential unit comprised in the building on completion of the conversion, such an amount of that expenditure shall be deemed to be attributable to a non-residential unit as bears to the whole of that expenditure the same proportion as the total floor area of the non-residential unit bears to the total floor area of the building.

(4) Subject to subsection (5), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred conversion expenditure in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of the expenditure as is to be treated under section 372J(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(5) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the conversion expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (4) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the conversion expenditure actually incurred in relation to the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(6) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary of the expenditure incurred on the conversion of that building or those buildings for the purposes of determining the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(7) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs-

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (4) in respect of conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(8) Where the event mentioned in subsection (7)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of conversion expenditure in relation to the house equal to the amount of the conversion expenditure which under section 372J(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (5)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed-

(a) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(b) in case only a part of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house.

(9) Where conversion expenditure is incurred in relation to a house and before the house is used subsequent to the incurring of that expenditure it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period conversion expenditure in relation to the house equal to the lesser of-

(a) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(b) (i) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(ii) in case only a part of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house;

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used subsequent to the incurring of the conversion expenditure in relation to the house, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(10) This section shall not apply in the case of a conversion unless planning permission in respect of the conversion has been granted under the Local Government (Planning and Development) Acts, 1963 to 1993.

(11) Section 372J shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372H.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372J(2), a lease of the house the consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium-

(i) which is payable on or subsequent to the date of the completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or which, if payable before that date, is so payable by reason of or otherwise in connection with the carrying out of the refurbishment, and

(ii) which does not exceed 10 per cent of the market value of the house on the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates and, in the case of a house which is a part of a building and is not saleable apart from the building of which it is a part, the market value of the house on that date shall for the purposes of this subparagraph be taken to be an amount which bears to the market value of the building on that date the same proportion as the total floor area of the house bears to the total floor area of the building;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(b), (4)(c) and (5) of section 372J, a house-

(a) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(b) the total floor area of which

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(c) in respect of which there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of refurbishment in relation to the house is not less than the relevant expenditure actually incurred on such refurbishment, and

(d) which on the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates is let (or, if not let on that date, is, without having been used after that date, first let) in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"refurbishment", in relation to a building, means either or both of the following-

(a) the carrying out of any works of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, and

(b) the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities,

where the carrying out of such works or the provision of such facilities is certified by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, in any certificate of reasonable cost granted by that Minister in relation to any house contained in the building, to have been necessary for the purposes of ensuring the suitability as a dwelling of any house in the building and whether or not the number of houses in the building, or the shape or size of any such house, is altered in the course of such refurbishment;

"relevant expenditure" means expenditure incurred on the refurbishment of a specified building, other than expenditure attributable to any part (in this section referred to as a "non-residential unit") of the building which on completion of the refurbishment is not a house, and for the purposes of this definition where expenditure is attributable to the specified building in general (and not directly to any particular house or non-residential unit comprised in the building on completion of the refurbishment), such an amount of that expenditure shall be deemed to be attributable to a non-residential unit as bears to the whole of that expenditure the same proportion as the total floor area of the non-residential unit bears to the total floor area of the building;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or, if the premises was not let under a qualifying lease on that date, the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first such letting after the date of such completion;

"specified building" means a building-

(a) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area,

(b) in which before the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates there are 2 or more houses, and

(c) which on completion of that refurbishment contains (whether in addition to any non-residential unit or not) 2 or more houses.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred relevant expenditure in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of the expenditure as is to be treated under section 372J(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(3) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which-

(i) is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor, and

(ii) is payable on or subsequent to the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or, if payable before that date, is so payable by reason of or otherwise in connection with the carrying out of the refurbishment.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the relevant expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (2) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the relevant expenditure actually incurred in relation to the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(4) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary of the relevant expenditure incurred on that building or those buildings for the purposes of determining the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(5) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (2) in respect of relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(6) Where the event mentioned in subsection (5)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of relevant expenditure in relation to the house equal to the amount of the relevant expenditure which under section 372J(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (3)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed-

(a) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(b) in case only a part of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house.

(7) Where relevant expenditure is incurred in relation to a house and before the house is used subsequent to the incurring of that expenditure it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period relevant expenditure in relation to the house equal to the lesser of-

(a) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(b) (i) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(ii) in case only a part of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house;

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used subsequent to the incurring of the relevant expenditure in relation to the house, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(8) This section shall not apply in the case of any refurbishment unless planning permission, in so far as it is required, in respect of the work carried out in the course of the refurbishment has been granted under the Local Government (Planning and Development) Acts, 1963 to 1993.

(9) Expenditure in respect of which a person is entitled to relief under this section shall not include any expenditure in respect of which any person is entitled to a deduction, relief or allowance under any other provision of the Tax Acts.

(10) Section 372J shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372I.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying expenditure", in relation to an individual, means an amount equal to the amount of the expenditure incurred by the individual on the construction or, as the case may be, refurbishment of a qualifying premises which is a qualifying owner-occupied dwelling in relation to the individual after deducting from that amount of expenditure any sum in respect of or by reference to-

(a) that expenditure,

(b) the qualifying premises, or

(c) the construction or, as the case may be, refurbishment work in respect of which that expenditure was incurred,

which the individual has received or is entitled to receive, directly or indirectly, from the State, any board established by statute or any public or local authority;

"qualifying owner-occupied dwelling", in relation to an individual, means a qualifying premises which is first used, after the qualifying expenditure has been incurred, by the individual as his or her only or main residence;

"qualifying premises", in relation to the incurring of qualifying expenditure, means, subject to subsections (4) and (5) of section 372J, a house-

(a) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area,

(b) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(c) in respect of which, if it is not a new house (for the purposes of section 4 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979) provided for sale, there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of construction or, as the case may be, refurbishment of the house is not less than the expenditure actually incurred on such construction or refurbishment, as the case may be, and

(d) the total floor area of which

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres, in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres;

"refurbishment" has the same meaning as in section 372H.

(2) (a) Where an individual, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred qualifying expenditure in a year of assessment, the individual shall be entitled, for that year of assessment and for any of the 9 subsequent years of assessment in which the qualifying premises in respect of which the individual incurred the qualifying expenditure is the only or main residence of the individual, to have a deduction made from his or her total income of an amount equal to-

(i) in the case where the qualifying expenditure has been incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises, 5 per cent of the amount of that expenditure, or

(ii) in the case where the qualifying expenditure has been incurred on the refurbishment of the qualifying premises, 10 per cent of the amount of that expenditure.

(b) A deduction shall be given under this section in respect of qualifying expenditure only in so far as that expenditure is to be treated under section 372J(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period.

(3) Where qualifying expenditure in relation to a qualifying premises is incurred by 2 or more persons, each of those persons shall be treated as having incurred the expenditure in the proportions in which they actually bore the expenditure, and the expenditure shall be apportioned accordingly.

(4) Section 372J shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372J.-(1) In sections 372F to 372I-

"certificate of reasonable cost" means a certificate granted by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government for the purposes of section 372F, 372G, 372H or 372I, as the case may be, stating that the amount specified in the certificate in relation to the cost of construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, the house to which the certificate relates appears to that Minister at the time of the granting of the certificate and on the basis of the information available to that Minister at that time to be reasonable, and section 18 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, shall, with any necessary modifications, apply to a certificate of reasonable cost as if it were a certificate of reasonable value within the meaning of that section;

"house" includes any building or part of a building used or suitable for use as a dwelling and any outoffice, yard, garden or other land appurtenant to or usually enjoyed with that building or part of a building;

"total floor area" means the total floor area of a house measured in the manner referred to in section 4(2)(b) of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979.

(2) A lease shall not be a qualifying lease for the purposes of section 372F, 372G or 372H if the terms of the lease contain any provision enabling the lessee or any other person, directly or indirectly, at any time to acquire any interest in the house to which the lease relates for a consideration less than that which might be expected to be given at that time for the acquisition of the interest if the negotiations for that acquisition were conducted in the open market at arm's length.

(3) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372F, 372G or 372H if-

(a) it is occupied as a dwelling by any person connected with the person entitled, in relation to the expenditure incurred on the construction of, conversion into, or, as the case may be, refurbishment of, the house, to a deduction under section 372F(2), 372G(4) or 372H(2), as the case may be, and

(b) the terms of the qualifying lease in relation to the house are not such as might have been expected to be included in the lease if the negotiations for the lease had been at arm's length.

(4) (a) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372F or, in so far as it applies to expenditure other than expenditure on refurbishment, section 372I unless it complies with such conditions, if any, as may be determined by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government from time to time for the purposes of section 4 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, in relation to standards of construction of houses and the provision of water, sewerage and other services in houses.

(b) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372G or 372H or, in so far as it applies to expenditure on refurbishment, section 372I unless it complies with such conditions, if any, as may be determined by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government from time to time for the purposes of section 5 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, in relation to standards for improvements of houses and the provision of water, sewerage and other services in houses.

(c) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372F, 372G, 372H or 372I unless the house or, in a case where the house is one of a number of houses in a single development, the development of which it is a part complies with such guidelines as may from time to time be issued by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, for the purposes of furthering the objectives of urban renewal without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, such guidelines may include provisions in relation to all or any one or more of the following-

(i) the design and the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, houses,

(ii) the total floor area and dimensions of rooms within houses, measured in such manner as may be determined by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government,

(iii) the provision of ancillary facilities and amenities in relation to houses, and

(iv) the balance to be achieved between houses of different types and sizes within a single development of 2 or more houses or within such a development and its general vicinity having regard to the housing existing or proposed in that vicinity.

(5) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372F, 372G, 372H or 372I unless persons authorised in writing by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government for the purposes of those sections are permitted to inspect the house at all reasonable times on production, if so requested by a person affected, of their authorisations.

(6) For the purposes of sections 372F to 372I, references in those sections to the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, any premises shall be construed as including references to the development of the land on which the premises is situated or which is used in the provision of gardens, grounds, access or amenities in relation to the premises and, without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, as including in particular-

(a) demolition or dismantling of any building on the land,

(b) site clearance, earth moving, excavation, tunnelling and boring, laying of foundations, erection of scaffolding, site restoration, landscaping and the provision of roadways and other access works,

(c) walls, power supply, drainage, sanitation and water supply, and

(d) the construction of any outhouses or other buildings or structures for use by the occupants of the premises or for use in the provision of amenities for the occupants.

(7) (a) For the purposes of determining, in relation to any claim under section 372F(2), 372G(4), 372H(2) or 372I(2), as the case may be, whether and to what extent expenditure incurred on the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, a qualifying premises is incurred or not incurred during the qualifying period, only such an amount of that expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, the premises actually carried out during the qualifying period shall be treated as having been incurred during that period.

(b) Where by virtue of subsection (6) expenditure on the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, a qualifying premises includes expenditure on the development of any land, paragraph (a) shall apply with any necessary modifications as if the references in that paragraph to the construction of, conversion into, refurbishment of, or, as the case may be, construction or refurbishment of, the qualifying premises were references to the development of such land.

(8) (a) For the purposes of sections 372F and 372G other than the purposes mentioned in subsection (7)(a), expenditure incurred on the construction of, or, as the case may be, conversion into, a qualifying premises shall be deemed to have been incurred on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(b) For the purposes of section 372H other than the purposes mentioned in subsection (7)(a), relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the refurbishment of a qualifying premises shall be deemed to have been incurred on the date of the commencement of the relevant period, in relation to the premises, determined as respects the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates.

(c) For the purposes of section 372I other than the purposes mentioned in subsection (7)(a), expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises shall be deemed to have been incurred on the earliest date after the expenditure was actually incurred on which the premises is in use as a dwelling.

(9) For the purposes of sections 372F to 372H, expenditure shall not be regarded as incurred by a person in so far as it has been or is to be met, directly or indirectly, by the State, by any board established by statute or by any public or local authority.

(10) Section 555 shall apply as if a deduction under section 372F(2), 372G(4) or 372H(2), as the case may be, were a capital allowance and as if any rent deemed to have been received by a person under section 372F(5), 372G(7) or 372H(5), as the case may be, were a balancing charge.

(11) An appeal to the Appeal Commissioners shall lie on any question arising under this section or under section 372F, 372G, 372H or 372I (other than a question on which an appeal lies under section 18 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979) in the like manner as an appeal would lie against an assessment to income tax or corporation tax, and the provisions of the Tax Acts relating to appeals shall apply accordingly.

372K.-Where relief is given by virtue of any provision of this Chapter in relation to capital expenditure or other expenditure incurred on, or rent payable in respect of, any building, structure or premises, relief shall not be given in respect of that expenditure or that rent under any other provision of the Tax Acts.'.".

This amendment proposes the introduction of a new scheme of tax reliefs to foster urban renewal. The existing scheme, operating since 1994, was due to expire at the end of July 1998 but has now been extended for a further five months. This brings it up to end December 1998 for certain projects.

It is proposed the new urban renewal scheme will be operated as follows: There will be a new process of designation based on integrated area plans proposed and produced by local authorities to address the physical and socio-economic renewal of areas. Those authorities will recommend areas of designation to a Department of the Environment and Local Government advisory panel which will, in turn, make recommendations to the Minister of that Department.

The Minister for Finance will make orders applying one or more of the tax incentives now being provided to areas designated by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. Unlike the urban renewal tax legislation to date, there will be no blanket entitlement on the reliefs for any particular qualifying area. These are said perhaps to vary for different areas. A similar range of tax reliefs will be available under the new scheme as were available under the 1994 urban renewal scheme. There will, however, be provisions to discriminate between specific types of commercial development for tax incentive purposes.

In general, the scheme will have a three year life span to operate from 1 August 1998 to 31 July 2001. Due to considerations relating to the State aids provision of the EU Treaty it is necessary to distinguish between the business incentives and residential reliefs. Accordingly, the business incentives were initially from 1 August 1998 until 31 December 1999 while the residential reliefs will apply from 1 August 1998 to 31 July 2001. Business incentives will be reviewed when the position on the post 1999 EU regional aids is finalised.

A new chapter is being inserted in the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, to provide tax incentives under the new urban renewal scheme which comprises 11 sections; 372A. is the interpretation section for the Chapter and links the reliefs through urban renewal legislation to be passed by the Oireachtas. It envisages the concept of integrated area plans as a basic component of that legislation. Section 372B. empowers the Minister for Finance, on the recommendation of the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, to designate certain areas to qualify for one or more reliefs being provided for in the Chapter and to discriminate between different types of commercial development such as offices only, multi-storey car parks only, other commercial buildings only or a combination of one or more of these in regard to the lease in question.

Comment on this

I think we are all probably more interested in rural development but we will agree with the Minister on this amendment.

Comment on this

I thought that.

Comment on this

Providing there is nothing confidential in the Minister's notes will he provide us with a copy?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

That would enable us to have further consideration on it before Report Stage.

Comment on this

I will be tabling a minor technical amendment on Report Stage to correct an error in the general urban renewal legislation. I will also be tabling an amendment on Report Stage to increase the minimum floor area from 30 square metres to 38 square metres to conform with recent guidelines issued by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government. I am obliged to make it legal for report Stage.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 99 is in the name of the Minister, Amendments Nos. 1 to 6, inclusive, in the names of Deputies Noonan, Creed, Timmins, McGinley and Carey are related and will be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 99:

In page 82, before section 60, but in Part 1, to insert the following new section:

61.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in Part 10, by the insertion after Chapter 7 (inserted by this Act) of the following:

CHAPTER 8

Qualifying rural areas

372L. -In this Chapter-

"lease", lessee", lessor", premium" and rent" have the same meanings respectively as in Chapter 8 of Part 4;

"market value", in relation to a building, structure or house, means the price which the unencumbered fee simple of the building, structure or house would fetch if sold in the open market in such manner and subject to such conditions as might reasonably be calculated to obtain for the vendor the best price for the building, structure or house, less the part of that price which would be attributable to the acquisition of, or of rights in or over, the land on which the building, structure or house is constructed;

"qualifying period" means the period commencing on such day as the Minister for Finance may by order appoint and ending on the 31st day of December, 2001;

"qualifying rural area" means any area described in Schedule 8A;

"refurbishment", in relation to a building or structure and other than for the purposes of section 372R, means any work of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, including the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities, carried out in the course of the repair or restoration, or maintenance in the nature of repair or restoration, of the building or structure.

372M.-(1) This section shall apply to a building or structure the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area and which is to be an industrial building or structure by reason of its use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a).

(2) Subject to subsection (4), section 271 shall apply in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies as if-

(a) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted,

(b) in subsection (2)(a)(i) of that section to which subsection (3) applies" were deleted,

(c) subsection (3) of that section were deleted,

(d) the following subsection were substituted for subsection (4) of that section:

"(4) An industrial building allowance shall be of an amount equal to 25 per cent of the capital expenditure mentioned in subsection (2).",

and

(e) in subsection (5) of that section "to which subsection (3)(c) applies" were deleted.

(3) Subject to subsection (4), section 273 shall apply in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies as if-

(a) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of industrial development agency" were deleted,

(b) the following paragraph were substituted for paragraph (i) of subsection (2) of that section:

"(b) As respects any qualifying expenditure, any allowance made under section 272 and increased under paragraph (a) in respect of that expenditure, whether claimed for one chargeable period or more than one such period, shall not in the aggregate exceed 50 per cent of the amount of that qualifying expenditure.",

and

(c) subsections (3) to (7) of that section were deleted.

(4) In the case where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a building or structure to which this section applies, subsections (2) and (3) shall apply only if the total amount of the capital expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the building or structure immediately before that expenditure was incurred.

(5) Notwithstanding section 274(1), no balancing charge shall be made in relation to a building or structure to which this section applies by reason of any of the events specified in that section which occurs-

(a) more than 13 years after the building or structure was first used, or

(b) in a case where section 276 applies, more than 13 years after the capital expenditure on refurbishment of the building or structure was incurred.

(6) For the purposes only of determining, in relation to a claim for an allowance under section 271 or 273 as applied by this section, whether and to what extent capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of an industrial building or structure is incurred or not incurred in the qualifying period, only such an amount of that capital expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction or, as the case may be, the refurbishment of the building or structure actually carried out during the qualifying period shall (notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts as to the time when any capital expenditure is or is to be treated as incurred) be treated as having been incurred in that period.

372N.-(1) In this section-

"approved scheme" means a scheme undertaken with the approval of a local authority which has as its object, or amongst its objects, the provision of sewerage facilities, water supplies or roads for public purposes;

"qualifying premises" means a building or structure the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area, and which-

(a) apart from this section is not an industrial building or structure within the meaning of section 268, and

(b) (i) is in use for the purposes of a trade or profession or for the purposes

of an approved scheme, or

(ii) whether or not it is so used, is let on bona fide commercial terms for such consideration as might be expected to be paid in a letting of the building or structure negotiated on an arm's length basis,

but does not include any part of a building or structure in use as or as part of a dwelling house.

(2) (a) Subject to paragraph (b) and subsections (3) to (6), the provisions of the Tax Acts (other than section 372M) relating to the making of allowances or charges in respect of capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of an industrial building or structure shall, notwithstanding anything to the contrary in those provisions, apply-

(i) as if a qualifying premises were, at all times at which it is a qualifying premises, a building or structure in respect of which an allowance is to be made for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under Chapter 1 of Part 9 by reason of its use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a), and

(ii) where any activity carried on in the qualifying premises is not a trade, as if it were a trade.

(b) An allowance shall be given by virtue of this subsection in respect of any capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises only in so far as that expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period.

(3) In the case where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a qualifying premises, subsection (2) shall apply only if the total amount of the capital expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the qualifying premises immediately before that expenditure was incurred.

(4) For the purposes of the application, by subsection (2), of sections 271 and 273 in relation to capital expenditure incurred in the qualifying period on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises-

(a) section 271 shall apply as if-

(i) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted,

(ii) in subsection (2)(a)(i) of that section "to which subsection (3) applies" were deleted,

(iii) subsection (3) of that section were deleted,

(iv) the following subsection were substituted for subsection (4) of that section:

"(4) An industrial building allowance shall be of an amount equal to 50 per cent of the capital expenditure mentioned in subsection (2).",

and

(v) in subsection (5) of that section "to which subsection (3)(c) applies" were deleted,

and

(b) section 273 shall apply as if-

(i) in subsection (1) of that section the definition of "industrial development agency" were deleted, and

(ii) subsections (2)(b) and (3) to (7) of that section were deleted.

(5) Notwithstanding section 274(1), no balancing charge shall be made in relation to a qualifying premises by reason of any of the events specified in that section which occurs-

(a) more than 13 years after the qualifying premises was first used, or

(b) in a case where section 276 applies, more than 13 years after the capital expenditure on refurbishment of the qualifying premises was incurred.

(6) (a) Notwithstanding subsections (2) to (4), any allowance or charge which apart from this subsection would be made by virtue of subsection (2) in respect of capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises shall be reduced to one-half of the amount which apart from this subsection would be the amount of that allowance or charge.

(b) For the purposes of paragraph (a), the amount of an allowance or charge to be reduced to one-half shall be computed as if

(i) this subsection had not been enacted, and

(ii) effect had been given to all allowances taken into account in so computing that amount.

(c) Nothing in this subsection shall affect the operation of section 274(8).

(7) For the purposes only of determining, in relation to a claim for an allowance by virtue of subsection (2), whether and to what extent capital expenditure incurred on the construction or refurbishment of a qualifying premises is incurred or not incurred in the qualifying period, only such an amount of that capital expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction or refurbishment of the premises actually carried out during the qualifying period shall (notwithstanding any other provision of the Tax Acts as to the time when any capital expenditure is or is to be treated as incurred) be treated as having been incurred in that period.

372O.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying lease" means, subject to subsection (5), a lease in respect of a qualifying premises granted in the qualifying period on bona fide commercial terms by a lessor to a lessee not connected with the lessor, or with any other person entitled to a rent in respect of the qualifying premises, whether under that lease or any other lease;

"qualifying premises" means a building or structure-

(a) (i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area and which is a building or structure in use for a purpose specified in section 268(1)(a), and in respect of which capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period for which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under section 271 or 273, as applied by section 372M, or

(ii) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying area and in respect of which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under Chapter 1 of Part 9 by virtue of section 372N,

and

(b) which is let on bona fide commercial terms for such consideration as might be expected to be paid in a letting of the building or structure negotiated on an arm's length basis,

but, where capital expenditure is incurred in the qualifying period on the refurbishment of a building or structure in respect of which an allowance is to be made, or will by virtue of section 279 be made, for the purposes of income tax or corporation tax, as the case may be, under any of the provisions referred to in paragraph (a), the building or structure shall not be regarded as a qualifying premises unless the total amount of the expenditure so incurred is not less than an amount equal to 10 per cent of the market value of the building or structure immediately before that expenditure is incurred.

(2) For the purposes of this section, so much of a period, being a period when rent is payable by a person in relation to a qualifying premises under a qualifying lease, shall be a relevant rental period as does not exceed-

(a) 10 years, or

(b) the period by which 10 years exceeds

(i) any preceding period, or

(ii) if there is more than one preceding period, the aggregate of those periods,

for which rent was payable by that person or any other person in relation to that premises under a qualifying lease.

(3) Subject to subsection (4), where in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of a trade or profession a person is apart from this section entitled to any deduction (in this subsection referred to as "the first-mentioned deduction") on account of rent in respect of a qualifying premises occupied by such person for the purposes of that trade or profession which is payable by such person for a relevant rental period in relation to that qualifying premises under a qualifying lease, such person shall be entitled in that computation to a further deduction (in this subsection referred to as "the second-mentioned deduction") equal to the amount of the first-mentioned deduction but where the first-mentioned deduction is on account of rent payable by such person to a connected person, such person shall not be entitled in that computation to the second-mentioned deduction.

(4) Where a person holds an interest in a qualifying premises out of which interest a qualifying lease is created directly or indirectly in respect of the qualifying premises and in respect of rent payable under the qualifying lease a claim for a further deduction under this section is made, and either such person or another person connected with such person

(a) takes under a qualifying lease a qualifying premises (in this subsection referred to as "the second-mentioned premises") occupied by such person or such other person, as the case may be, for the purposes of a trade or profession, and

(b) is apart from this section entitled, in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of that trade or profession, to a deduction on account of rent in respect of the second-mentioned premises,

then, unless such person or such other person, as the case may be, shows that the taking on lease of the second-mentioned premises was not undertaken for the sole or main benefit of obtaining a further deduction on account of rent under this section, such person or such other person, as the case may be, shall not be entitled in the computation of the amount of the profits or gains of that trade or profession to any further deduction on account of rent in respect of the second-mentioned premises.

(5) (a) In this subsection-

"current value", in relation to minimum lease payments, means the value of those payments discounted to their present value at a rate which, when applied at the inception of the lease to-

(i) those payments, including any initial payment but excluding any payment or part of any payment for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee, and

(ii) any unguaranteed residual value of the qualifying premises, excluding any part of such value for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee,

produces discounted present values the aggregate amount of which equals the amount of the fair value of the qualifying premises;

"fair value", in relation to a qualifying premises, means an amount equal to such consideration as might be expected to be paid for the premises on a sale negotiated on an arm's length basis less any grants receivable towards the purchase of the qualifying premises;

"inception of the lease" means the earlier of the time the qualifying premises is brought into use or the date from which rentals under the lease first accrue;

"minimum lease payments" means the minimum payments over the remaining part of the term of the lease to be paid to the lessor, and includes any residual amount to be paid to the lessor at the end of the term of the lease and guaranteed by the lessee or by a person connected with the lessee;

"unguaranteed residual value", in relation to a qualifying premises, means that part of the residual value of that premises at the end of a term of a lease, as estimated at the inception of the lease, the realisation of which by the lessor is not assured or is guaranteed solely by a person connected with the lessor.

(b) A finance lease, that is

(i) a lease in respect of a qualifying premises where, at the inception of the lease, the aggregate of the current value of the minimum lease payments (including any initial payment but excluding any payment or part of any payment for which the lessor will be accountable to the lessee) payable by the lessee in relation to the lease amounts to 90 per cent or more of the fair value of the qualifying premises, or

(ii) a lease which in all the circumstances is considered to provide in substance for the lessee the risks and benefits associated with ownership of the qualifying premises other than legal title to that premises, shall not be a qualifying lease for the purposes of this section.

372P.-(1) In this section-

"qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372S(2), a lease of the house the duration of which is not less than 12 months and the consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium which does not exceed 10 per cent of the relevant cost of the house;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(a) and (5) of section 372S, a house-

(a) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area,

(b) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(c) the total floor area of which-

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(d) in respect of which, if it is not a new house (for the purposes of section 4 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979) provided for sale, there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost, the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of construction of the house is not less than the expenditure actually incurred on such construction, and

(e) which without having been used is first let in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"relevant cost", in relation to a house, means, subject to subsection (3), an amount equal to the aggregate of-

(a) the expenditure incurred on the acquisition of, or of rights in or over, any land on which the house is constructed, and

(b) the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the house;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred expenditure on the construction of a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of that expenditure as is to be treated under section 372S(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(3) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period on the construction of the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (2) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the expenditure incurred on that construction.

(4) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary-

(a) of the expenditure incurred on the construction of that building or those buildings, and

(b) of the amount which would be the relevant cost in relation to that building or those buildings if the building or buildings, as the case may be, were a single qualifying premises,

for the purposes of determining the expenditure incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises and the relevant cost in relation to the qualifying premises.

(5) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs-

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (2) in respect of expenditure incurred on the construction of the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(6) (a) Where the event mentioned in subsection (5)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the amount which under section 372S(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (3)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period on the construction of the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed the relevant price paid by such person on the purchase.

(b) For the purposes of this subsection and subsection (7), the relevant price paid by a person on the purchase of a house shall be the amount which bears to the net price paid by such person on that purchase the same proportion as the amount of the expenditure actually incurred on the construction of the house which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the relevant cost in relation to that house.

(7) (a) Subject to paragraph (b), where expenditure is incurred on the construction of a house and before the house is used it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(ii) the relevant price paid by such person on the purchase,

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(b) Where expenditure is incurred on the construction of a house by a person carrying on a trade or part of a trade which consists, as to the whole or any part of the trade, of the construction of buildings with a view to their sale and the house, before it is used, is sold in the course of that trade or, as the case may be, that part of that trade-

(i) the person (in this paragraph referred to as "the purchaser") who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period expenditure on the construction of the house equal to the relevant price paid by the purchaser on the purchase (in this paragraph referred to as the first purchase"), and

(ii) in relation to any subsequent sale or sales of the house before the house is used, paragraph (a) shall apply as if the reference to the amount of expenditure which is to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period were a reference to the relevant price paid on the first purchase.

(8) Section 372S shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372Q.-(1) In this section-

"conversion expenditure" means, subject to subsection (2), expenditure incurred on

(a) the conversion into a house of a building-

(i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area, and

(ii) which has not been previously in use as a dwelling,

and

(b) the conversion into 2 or more houses of a building-

(i) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area, and

(ii) which before the conversion had not been in use as a dwelling or had been in use as a single dwelling,

and references in this section and in section 372S to "conversion", "conversion into a house" and "expenditure incurred on conversion" shall be construed accordingly;

"qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372S(2), a lease of the house the duration of which is not less than 12 months and consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium which does not exceed 10 per cent of the market value of the house at the time the conversion is completed and, in the case of a house which is a part of a building and is not saleable apart from the building of which it is a part, the market value of the house at the time the conversion is completed shall for the purposes of this paragraph be taken to be an amount which bears to the market value of the building at that time the same proportion as the total floor area of the house bears to the total floor area of the building;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(b) and (5) of section 372S, a house-

(a) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(b) the total floor area of which

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(c) in respect of which there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of conversion in relation to the house is not less than the expenditure actually incurred on such conversion, and

(d) which without having been used subsequent to the incurring of the expenditure on the conversion is first let in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(2) For the purposes of this section, expenditure incurred on the conversion of a building shall be deemed to include expenditure incurred in the course of the conversion on either or both of the following-

(a) the carrying out of any works of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, and

(b) the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities, in relation to the building or any outoffice appurtenant to or usually enjoyed with the building, but shall not be deemed to include

(i) any expenditure in respect of which any person is entitled to a deduction, relief or allowance under any other provision of the Tax Acts, or

(ii) any expenditure attributable to any part (in this section referred to as a "non-residential unit") of the building which on completion of the conversion is not a house.

(3) For the purposes of subsection (2)(ii), where expenditure is attributable to a building in general and not directly to any particular house or non-residential unit comprised in the building on completion of the conversion, such an amount of that expenditure shall be deemed to be attributable to a non-residential unit as bears to the whole of that expenditure the same proportion as the total floor area of the non-residential unit bears to the total floor area of the building.

(4) Subject to subsection (5), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred conversion expenditure in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of the expenditure as is to be treated under section 372S(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(5) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the conversion expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (4) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the conversion expenditure actually incurred in relation to the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(6) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary of the expenditure incurred on the conversion of that building or those buildings for the purposes of determining the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(7) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs-

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (4) in respect of conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(8) Where the event mentioned in subsection (7)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of conversion expenditure in relation to the house equal to the amount of the conversion expenditure which under section 372S(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (5)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed-

(a) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(b) in case only a part of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house.

(9) Where conversion expenditure is incurred in relation to a house and before the house is used subsequent to the incurring of that expenditure it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period conversion expenditure in relation to the house equal to the lesser of-

(a) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(b) (i) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(ii) in case only a part of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the conversion expenditure incurred in relation to the house;

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used subsequent to the incurring of the conversion expenditure in relation to the house, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(10) This section shall not apply in the case of a conversion unless planning permission in respect of the conversion has been granted under the Local Government (Planning and Development) Acts, 1963 to 1993.

(11) Section 372S shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372R.-(1) In this section "qualifying lease", in relation to a house, means, subject to section 372S(2), a lease of the house the duration of which is not less than 12 months and the consideration for the grant of which consists-

(a) solely of periodic payments all of which are or are to be treated as rent for the purposes of Chapter 8 of Part 4, or

(b) of payments of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a), together with a payment by means of a premium-

(i) which is payable on or subsequent to the date of the completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or which, if payable before that date, is so payable by reason of or otherwise in connection with the carrying out of the refurbishment, and

(ii) which does not exceed 10 per cent of the market value of the house on the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates and, in the case of a house which is a part of a building and is not saleable apart from the building of which it is a part, the market value of the house on that date shall for the purposes of this subparagraph be taken to be an amount which bears to the market value of the building on that date the same proportion as the total floor area of the house bears to the total floor area of the building;

"qualifying premises" means, subject to subsections (3), (4)(b) and (5) of section 372S, a house-

(a) which is used solely as a dwelling,

(b) the total floor area of which-

(i) is not less than 30 square metres and not more than 125 square metres in the case where the house is a separate self-contained flat or maisonette in a building of 2 or more storeys, or

(ii) in any other case, is not less than 35 square metres and not more than 125 square metres,

(c) in respect of which there is in force a certificate of reasonable cost the amount specified in which in respect of the cost of refurbishment in relation to the house is not less than the relevant expenditure actually incurred on such refurbishment, and

(d) which on the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates is let (or, if not let on that date, is, without having been used after that date, first let) in its entirety under a qualifying lease and thereafter throughout the remainder of the relevant period (except for reasonable periods of temporary disuse between the ending of one qualifying lease and the commencement of another such lease) continues to be let under such a lease;

"refurbishment", in relation to a building, means either or both of the following-

(a) the carrying out of any works of construction, reconstruction, repair or renewal, and

(b) the provision or improvement of water, sewerage or heating facilities,

where the carrying out of such works or the provision of such facilities is certified by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, in any certificate of reasonable cost granted by that Minister in relation to any house contained in the building, to have been necessary for the purposes of ensuring the suitability as a dwelling of any house in the building and whether or not the number of houses in the building, or the shape or size of any such house, is altered in the course of such refurbishment;

"relevant expenditure" means expenditure incurred on the refurbishment of a specified building, other than expenditure attributable to any part (in this section referred to as a non-residential unit) of the building which on completion of the refurbishment is not a house, and for the purposes of this definition where expenditure is attributable to the specified building in general (and not directly to any particular house or non-residential unit comprised in the building on completion of the refurbishment), such an amount of that expenditure shall be deemed to be attributable to a non-residential unit as bears to the whole of that expenditure the same proportion as the total floor area of the non-residential unit bears to the total floor area of the building;

"relevant period", in relation to a qualifying premises, means the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or, if the premises was not let under a qualifying lease on that date, the period of 10 years beginning on the date of the first such letting after the date of such completion;

"specified building" means a building-

(a) the site of which is wholly within a qualifying rural area,

(b) in which before the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates there is one or more than one house, and

(c) which on completion of that refurbishment contains (whether in addition to any non-residential unit or not) one or more than one house.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), where a person, having made a claim in that behalf, proves to have incurred relevant expenditure in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises-

(a) such person shall be entitled, in computing for the purposes of section 97(1) the amount of a surplus or deficiency in respect of the rent from the qualifying premises, to a deduction of so much (if any) of the expenditure as is to be treated under section 372S(7) or under this section as having been incurred by such person in the qualifying period, and

(b) Chapter 8 of Part 4 shall apply as if that deduction were a deduction authorised by section 97(2).

(3) (a) This subsection shall apply to any premium or other sum which

(i) is payable, directly or indirectly, under a qualifying lease or otherwise under the terms subject to which the lease is granted, to or for the benefit of the lessor or to or for the benefit of any person connected with the lessor, and

(ii) is payable on or subsequent to the date of completion of the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates or, if payable before that date, is so payable by reason of or otherwise in connection with the carrying out of the refurbishment.

(b) Where any premium or other sum to which this subsection applies, or any part of such premium or such other sum, is not or is not treated as rent for the purposes of section 97, the relevant expenditure to be treated as having been incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the qualifying premises to which the qualifying lease relates shall be deemed for the purposes of subsection (2) to be reduced by the lesser of-

(i) the amount of such premium or such other sum or, as the case may be, that part of such premium or such other sum, and

(ii) the amount which bears to the amount mentioned in subparagraph (i) the same proportion as the amount of the relevant expenditure actually incurred in relation to the qualifying premises which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(4) Where a qualifying premises forms a part of a building or is one of a number of buildings in a single development, or forms a part of a building which is itself one of a number of buildings in a single development, there shall be made such apportionment as is necessary of the relevant expenditure incurred on that building or those buildings for the purposes of determining the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises.

(5) Where a house is a qualifying premises and at any time during the relevant period in relation to the premises either of the following events occurs-

(a) the house ceases to be a qualifying premises, or

(b) the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes to any other person but the house does not cease to be a qualifying premises,

then, the person who before the occurrence of the event received or was entitled to receive a deduction under subsection (2) in respect of relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the qualifying premises shall be deemed to have received on the day before the day of the occurrence of the event an amount as rent from the qualifying premises equal to the amount of the deduction.

(6) Where the event mentioned in subsection (5)(b) occurs in the relevant period in relation to a house which is a qualifying premises, the person to whom the ownership of the lessor's interest in the house passes shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period an amount of relevant expenditure in relation to the house equal to the amount of the relevant expenditure which under section 372S(7) or under this section (apart from subsection (3)(b)) the lessor was treated as having incurred in the qualifying period in relation to the house; but, in the case of a person who purchases such a house, the amount so treated as having been incurred by such person shall not exceed-

(a) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(b) in case only a part of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house.

(7) Where relevant expenditure is incurred in relation to a house and before the house is used subsequent to the incurring of that expenditure it is sold, the person who purchases the house shall be treated for the purposes of this section as having incurred in the qualifying period relevant expenditure in relation to the house equal to the lesser of-

(a) the amount of such expenditure which is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, and

(b) (i) the net price paid by such person on the purchase, or

(ii) in case only a part of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house is to be treated under section 372S(7) as having been incurred in the qualifying period, the amount which bears to that net price the same proportion as that part bears to the whole of the relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the house;

but, where the house is sold more than once before it is used subsequent to the incurring of the relevant expenditure in relation to the house, this subsection shall apply only in relation to the last of those sales.

(8) This section shall not apply in the case of any refurbishment unless planning permission, in so far as it is required, in respect of the work carried out in the course of the refurbishment has been granted under the Local Government (Planning and Development) Acts, 1963 to 1993.

(9) Expenditure in respect of which a person is entitled to relief under this section shall not include any expenditure in respect of which any person is entitled to a deduction, relief or allowance under any other provision of the Tax Acts.

(10) Section 372S shall apply for the purposes of supplementing this section.

372S.-(1) In sections 372P to 372R-

"certificate of reasonable cost" means a certificate granted by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government for the purposes of section 372P, 372Q or 372R, as the case may be, stating that the amount specified in the certificate in relation to the cost of construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, the house to which the certificate relates appears to that Minister at the time of the granting of the certificate and on the basis of the information available to that Minister at that time to be reasonable, and section 18 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, shall, with any necessary modifications, apply to a certificate of reasonable cost as if it were a certificate of reasonable value within the meaning of that section;

"house" includes any building or part of a building used or suitable for use as a dwelling and any outoffice, yard, garden or other land appurtenant to or usually enjoyed with that building or part of a building;

"total floor area" means the total floor area of a house measured in the manner referred to in section 4(2)(b) of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979.

(2) A lease shall not be a qualifying lease for the purposes of section 372P, 372Q or 372R if the terms of the lease contain any provision enabling the lessee or any other person, directly or indirectly, at any time to acquire any interest in the house to which the lease relates for a consideration less than that which might be expected to be given at that time for the acquisition of the interest if the negotiations for that acquisition were conducted in the open market at arm's length.

(3) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372P, 372Q or 372R if-

(a) it is occupied as a dwelling by any person connected with the person entitled, in relation to the expenditure incurred on the construction of, conversion into, or, as the case may be, refurbishment of, the house, to a deduction under section 372P(2), 372Q(4) or 372R(2), as the case may be, and

(b) the terms of the qualifying lease in relation to the house are not such as might have been expected to be included in the lease if the negotiations for the lease had been at arm's length.

(4) (a) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372P unless it complies with such conditions, if any, as may be determined by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government from time to time for the purposes of section 4 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, in relation to standards of construction of houses and the provision of water, sewerage and other services in houses.

(b) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372Q or 372R unless it complies with such conditions, if any, as may be determined by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government from time to time for the purposes of section 5 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979, in relation to standards for improvements of houses and the provision of water, sewerage and other services in houses.

(5) A house shall not be a qualifying premises for the purposes of section 372P, 372Q or 372R unless-

(a) persons authorised in writing by the Minister for the Environment and Local Government for the purposes of those sections are permitted to inspect the house at all reasonable times on production, if so requested by a person affected, of their authorisations, and

(b) throughout the period of any qualifying lease related to that premises, the house is used as the sole or main residence of the lessee in relation to that qualifying lease.

(6) For the purposes of sections 372P to 372R, references in those sections to the construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, any premises shall be construed as including references to the development of the land on which the premises is situated or which is used in the provision of gardens, grounds, access or amenities in relation to the premises and, without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, as including in particular-

(a) demolition or dismantling of any building on the land,

(b) site clearance, earth moving, excavation, tunnelling and boring, laying of foundations, erection of scaffolding, site restoration, landscaping and the provision of roadways and other access works,

(c) walls, power supply, drainage, sanitation and water supply, and

(d) the construction of any outhouses or other buildings or structures for use by the occupants of the premises or for use in the provision of amenities for the occupants.

(7) (a) For the purposes of determining, in relation to any claim under section 372P(2), 372Q(4) or 372R(2), as the case may be, whether and to what extent expenditure incurred on the construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, a qualifying premises is incurred or not incurred during the qualifying period, only such an amount of that expenditure as is properly attributable to work on the construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, the premises actually carried out during the qualifying period shall be treated as having been incurred during that period.

(b) Where by virtue of subsection (6) expenditure on the construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, a qualifying premises includes expenditure on the development of any land, paragraph (a) shall apply with any necessary modifications as if the references in that paragraph to the construction of, conversion into, or refurbishment of, the qualifying premises were references to the development of such land.

(8) (a) For the purposes of sections 372P and 372Q other than the purposes mentioned in subsection (7)(a), expenditure incurred on the construction of, or, as the case may be, conversion into, a qualifying premises shall be deemed to have been incurred on the date of the first letting of the premises under a qualifying lease.

(b) For the purposes of section 372R other than the purposes mentioned in subsection (7)(a), relevant expenditure incurred in relation to the refurbishment of a qualifying premises shall be deemed to have been incurred on the date of the commencement of the relevant period, in relation to the premises, determined as respects the refurbishment to which the relevant expenditure relates.

(9) For the purposes of sections 372P to 372R, expenditure shall not be regarded as incurred by a person in so far as it has been or is to be met, directly or indirectly, by the State, by any board established by statute or by any public or local authority.

(10) Section 555 shall apply as if a deduction under section 372P(2), 372Q(4) or 372R(2), as the case may be, were a capital allowance and as if any rent deemed to have been received by a person under section 372P(5), 372Q(7) or 372R(5), as the case may be, were a balancing charge.

(11) An appeal to the Appeal Commissioners shall lie on any question arising under this section or under section 372P, 372Q or 372R (other than a question on which an appeal lies under section 18 of the Housing (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 1979) in the like manner as an appeal would lie against an assessment to income tax or corporation tax, and the provisions of the Tax Acts relating to appeals shall apply accordingly.

372T.-(1) Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this Chapter, sections 372M, 372N and 372O shall not apply in relation to any building or structure in use for the purposes of a trade, or any activity treated as a trade, where the number of individuals employed or engaged in the carrying on of the trade or activity amounts to or exceeds 250.

(2) Where relief is given by virtue of any provision of this Chapter in relation to capital expenditure or other expenditure incurred on, or rent payable in respect of, any building, structure or premises, relief shall not be given in respect of that expenditure or that rent under any other provision of the Tax Acts.',

and

(b) by the insertion after Schedule 8 of the following:

SCHEDULE 8A

DESCRIPTION OF QUALIFYING RURAL AREAS

PART 1

Description of qualifying rural areas of Cavan

The District Electoral Divisions of Arvagh, Springfield, Killashandra, Milltown, Carrafin, Grilly, Kilconny, Belturbet Urban, Ardue, Carn, Bilberry, Diamond, Doogary, Lissanover, Ballymagauran, Ballyconnell, Bawnboy, Templeport, Benbrack, Pedara Vohers, Tircahan, Swanlinbar, Kinawley, Derrynananta, Dunmakeever, Dowra, Derrylahan, Tuam, Killinagh, Eskey, Teebane, Scrabby, Loughdawan, Bruce Hall, Drumcarban, Corr, Crossdoney and Killykeen.

PART 2

Description of qualifying rural areas of Leitrim

The administrative county of Leitrim.

PART 3

Description of qualifying rural areas of Longford

The administrative county of Longford.

PART 4

Description of qualifying rural areas of Roscommon

The District Electoral Divisions of Ballintober, Castleteheen, Carrowduff, Kilbride North, Lissonuffy, Killavackan, Termonbarry, Roosky, Kilglass North, Kilglass South, Bumlin, Cloonfinlough, Killukin (in Roscommon Rural District), Strokestown, Annaghmore, Tulsk, Coolougher, Ballinlough, Kiltullagh, Cloonfower, Artagh South, Artagh North, Ballaghaderreen, Edmondstown, Loughglinn, Buckill, Fairymount, Castlereagh, Frenchpark, Bellangare, Castleplunket, Baslick, Breedoge, Altagowlan, Lough Allen, Ballyfarnan, Keadue, Aghafin, Ballyformoyle, Crossna, Kilbryan, Boyle Rural, Boyle Urban, Tivannagh, Rushfield, Tumna North, Tumna South, Killukin (in Boyle No. 1 Rural District), Oakport, Rockingham, Danesfort, Cloonteem, Kilmore, Elia, Ballygarden, Aughrim East, Aughrim West, Creeve (in Boyle No. 1 Rural District), Creeve (in Roscommon Rural District), Elphin, Rossmore, Cloonyquinn, Ogulla, Mantua, Lisgarve, Kilmacumsy, Kilcolagh, Estersnow, Croghan, Killummod, Cregga, Cloonygormican, Kilbride South, Kilgefin, Cloontuskert, Drumdaff and Kilteevan.

PART 5

Description of qualifying rural areas of Sligo

The District Electoral Divisions of Ballintogher East, Ballynakill, Lisconny, Drumfin, Ballymote, Cloonoghill, Leitrim, Tobercurry, Kilturra, Cuilmore, Kilfree, Coolavin, Killaraght, Templevanny, Aghanagh, Kilmactranny, Ballynashee, Shancough, Drumcolumb, Riverstown, Lakeview, Bricklieve, Drumrat, Toomour, Kilshalvy, Killadoon, Streamstown, Cartron, Coolaney, Owenmore, Temple, Annagh, Carrickbannagher, Collooney, and Ballintogher West.'.".

Comment on this

We have tabled amendments to Schedule 8A increasing the area covered by the rural renewal scheme. Limerick, Clare, North Cork, Donegal, Wicklow and Mayo have been included. The pace of decline in the rural economy is such that many other areas of the country could convincingly argue for incentives of this kind. Our problem with the Minister's proposal is that its application does not appear to be well thought through. No one argues that the so called upper Shannon area does not require economic stimuli - indeed it does. However, many other parts of the country are equally suffering from rural decline, depopulation and the erosion of the traditional agri-economy. For example, the undeveloped areas of Galway, Kerry and other parts of the country spring to mind.

The tax measures proposed appear to be well drafted. However, they lack focus for the following reasons: Various agencies throughout the country are spending both State and EU funding trying to address rural decline. The introduction of these reliefs provides the Minister with an opportunity to have Leader groups, county enterprise boards, local authorities and area partnerships combined to target incentives in a much more co-ordinated and planned way. The scatter approach of simply naming a county and offering reliefs without any proper local co-ordination is a mistake. It is a start and, in principle, we are in favour of it. However, it is not getting the best value for money due to failures in co-ordination and planning with the local development agencies.

Finally, we wish to give notice, that due to insufficient time available for consideration of this section we will be bringing forward further amendments on Report Stage.

Comment on this

As somebody who lives on the banks of the Royal Canal and close to the river Enny which is one of the major contributories of the river Shannon I was shocked that Westmeath did not get a mention in relation to this. Whoever advised the Minister is not sure of his-her geographical locations and I say that with some reservation. There are 1,000 miles of tributary waters of the river Shannon and 38,000 come from the estuaries. It drains one fifth of the area. I am delighted to see - and my colleague Deputy Belton is here - that Longford is included. Deputy Belton comes from the banks of the River Inny and I am only a kick of a football from there. I can understand why Cavan is included because the Shannon emerges there and flows through beautiful countryside to the River Inny, which is a major tributary of the Shannon. North County Westmeath is one of the most depopulated areas of the country. Areas such as Multyfarnham, Coole, Rathowen, Street, Ballynacarrigy, Lismacaffry and Lisryan sustained large populations in the past. I originated this idea many years ago and it was taken over by the farming organisations. Large rural hinterlands are suffering from great depopulation and decline. This impacts on everything from putting out a local football team to keeping Garda stations and schools open.

I agreed privately with the Minister that there should be a pilot scheme. The area to which I refer in the River Inny basin in north Westmeath was submitted for the rural integrated programme in the late 1980s for the same reasons, although it did not take off. There is a programme in place there and the Minister's former colleague, Mr. Henry Abbott, was involved at the time. I am surprised the area is not included. I did not think it would be necessary to table an amendment on Report Stage but I will do so.

On 15 December 1997 Westmeath County Council, on which the Minister's party has a majority, agreed unanimously to a motion that the area of north Westmeath should be included. Only 12 per cent of farmers are under 35 years of age which indicates the demographic imbalance in the rural areas. I salute the Minister for taking on board the suggestion and I am delighted for the areas which are included. However, the inclusion of north Westmeath should be considered for the Report Stage.

Comment on this

I welcome the introduction of the concept of rural renewal because urban renewal has been successful. However, I am disappointed it is being introduced in a pilot form. That has the hallmark of doing something simply to get out of a difficult situation. It begs the question of the long-term commitment to the scheme. The Minister should take the suggested amendents on board. I am particularly interested in the inclusion of the north Cork region and I have been in correspondence with the Minister with regard to the study carried out by Cork County Council in the Duhallow/Sliabh Luchra area. The problems in that area are comparable with the worst scenario of rural decline anywhere.

Also in favour of the north Cork amendment is the local authority's involvement. Local authorities have a function in recommending areas for the urban renewal scheme. The local authority in Cork has suggested that the north Cork area, expecially the Duhallow/Sliabh Luchra area, should be included. We have done a baseline study against which the success of a rural renewal programme can be measured. I do not understand how the Minister decided on the areas to be included but I wish them luck. However, it is important that such a programme can be measured against important economic indicators - for example, participation in the workforce and unemployment levels. In the study Cork County Council commissioned with UCD on the Duhallow/Sliabh Luchra area the important economic indicators have been measured and we are capable of measuring the success or failure of a pilot programme. This is a strong argument for the inclusion of that area.

The areas seeking inclusion are crying out for industrial employment in particular. The number of people directly employed in agriculture has declined over the past few years. The lifeblood of many rural regions is being sucked into the large urban centres because the people cannot get employment in their own areas. The proposed scheme has much merit in terms of the capital allowances for industrial and commercial investment——

Comment on this

As the time is running short I must call the Minister to reply.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about the other Deputies offerring?

Comment on this

Many Deputies have waited to speak on this issue.

Comment on this

I will conclude by asking the Minister to consider the amendments favourably.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

In the previous Government I dealt with rural renewal and I am glad the concept has taken root, so to speak, in the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

I would correct the Deputy by pointing out that this took root in the brain of the Minister for Finance. It would be wrong to associate it with the Department of Finance.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I was going to compliment the Minister on his persuasiveness because I was not able to achieve it. I do not know how many schemes I had overruled.

Comment on this

Ministers decide, advisers advise.

Comment on this
Donal Carey Mr. D. Carey Fine Gael

I am happy the scheme is being introduced. I know Deputies would like a widespread application of it. There are areas in many counties where there is very serious population decline. The recent report from the NESC on settlement patterns gave such an indication but no conclusions. When we raised the issue of settlement patterns in the Dáil the debate was inconclusive. The Minister for Finance should ask the NESC to further examine its report and make definite proposals. They are urgently needed in the rural areas.

With regard to the west, I do not understand why there has been a delay since the change of Government in setting up and financing the Western Commission, particularly with the venture capital proposed. The Minister is proposing a pilot scheme for certain areas which are deserving, but no venture capital is available for proposals that might come from those areas. The Western Commission was a vehicle to provide such money for specially constructed long-term ventures. However, the Bill has been delayed - I do not know whether the Department of Finance is responsible. I urge the Minister to raise the delay of legislation with the Department.

Comment on this

As it is now 8 o'clock, I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 26 February:

That the amendments, set down by the Minister for Finance to Chapters IV and V and Part I of the Bill not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill, and in respect of each of the sections undisposed of in the said Chapter that the section or, as appropriate, that the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to.

Comment on this
Division

The Select Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 8
·
Níl 7
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I note that this question disposes of all amendments up to, and including, amendment No. 99 on the printed list of amendments. That concludes the Business of the Select Committee for today. I thank the Minister and his officials for attending.

Comment on this