Finance Bill, 1998: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 1–162 of 318. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1998 ›
I welcome the Minister and his officials to the Select Committee. We resume the debate on the Finance Bill, 1998, Chapters 1 and 2, Part 2, sections 60 to 84.
I wish to bring to the attention of Members the following typographical errors in the list of amendments to the Finance Bill, 1998:
Amendment No. 107 should substitute the word "deduced" and not the word "deduce".
Amendments Nos. 133-136 are addressed to Part 6 of the Bill. As these refer to capital acquisition tax they are properly related to Part 5 of the Bill. Accordingly, these amendments will be taken during consideration of Part 5.
Comment on this
My predecessor extended the car scrappage scheme to December 21 1997. I confirmed my intention to end the scheme in October 1997. Subsequently, the Society of the Irish Motor Industry put it to me that, having abolished the scrappage scheme, I might reduce VRT somewhat. The reduction is small but it is a gesture to the motor trade to offset the abolition of the scrappage scheme. The society wanted the rate reduced to 20 per cent. This section reduces the rate of VRT in category A vehicles from 29.25 per cent to 28 per cent in respect of vehicles with an engine of a cylinder capacity exceeding 2,500cc and from 23.2 per cent to 22.5 per cent in respect of vehicles with engines of a capacity up to and including 2,500cc. Both rate reductions came into effect provisionally on January 1 1998 by way of the financial resolution of December 3, and are now being given permanent effect.
Comment on this
I ask the question because it appears that the rate of VRT is not dissuading people from buying cars.
Comment on this
It may be too early to make long-term judgments on this matter but more than 130,000 new cars were purchased in 1997. This was way above our best estimate at the start of the year and even the best estimate of SIMI throughout the year. It was extraordinary. The projection for 1998 was that there would be a slow down in car sales but that is not the indication from the first two months. I doubt there will be the same upsurge in car sales in the last quarter of this year as there was at the end of 1997. As confirmation of the end of scrappage deal inspired many people to buy new cars. However, the sales in the first two months of this year are up on the first two months of 1997.
Comment on this
It would be interesting if the Minister outlined his judgment on the scrappage scheme. Did it take a significant number of old cars off the road?
Comment on this
Yes. I do not have full details to hand, but I gave information on this matter in reply to a recent parliamentary question. The VRT refund scrappage scheme was introduced with effect from 1 July 1995 and was originally due to end on 31 December 1996. However, the scheme was extended for a further year by my predecessor until 31 December 1997 to enable car owners to clear the decks in advance of the proposed introduction of mandatory car testing in 1998. By the end of 1997 close to 61,000 vehicles had been scrapped since the introduction of the scheme with approximately 36,000 vehicles scrapped in 1997 alone. The take up of the scheme surpassed original expectations and is considered to have been very successful in removing from the roads a large number of older and less efficient vehicles and, in the process contributing to increased new car sales.
With regard to yesterday's debate about traffic in Dublin, during discussions with my officials about VRT and the scrappage scheme in the lead up to the budget, I was under the impression that there was a high rate of car ownership in Ireland. However, I was amazed to discover that there is a low rate of car ownership in comparison to our near neighbour, the UK, and that it is less than the European average by a considerable amount. This is good news for the Exchequer in terms of extra revenue in the buoyant economy, but it is bad news in terms of traffic congestion in major centres. Ireland has approximately 27 cars per hundred population while Germany has approximately 50 cars per hundred of population. The rate in the United Kingdom is approximately 40 cars per hundred population so Ireland is well below the European average. This was news to me.
Comment on this
Is it possible to state whether the huge increase in the purchase of new cars is broadening the base of car ownership or is it a case of people who already have cars buying new ones? Are figures available on this aspect?
Comment on this
We do not have figures on that but it would be an interesting study for an organisation or perhaps the motor industry. The Department has no details on that aspect and my knowledge of it is anecdotal. I am sure somebody will produce a study on it shortly.
Comment on this
Prior to the budget I spoke with SIMI at a presentation in my constituency. I raised that issue with it and senior personnel in SIMI said its long-term target is to increase the level of car ownership to 36 cars per hundred population. The UK rate is 42 cars per hundred population and it is much higher in Europe. One of the reasons for this is that Ireland has a younger population in terms of car ownership. As a result, even with the current buoyancy in the economy, it will be many years before the rate is increased to 36 cars per hundred population, which is the target SIMI wants to achieve. If members are interested, the SIMI has carried out research on this topic.
Comment on this
Will the Minister give the committee the benefit of his wisdom on the purpose of this section? It relates to the valuation requirement for on-licence wine premises.
Comment on this
This section amends sections 8 and 13 of the Refreshment Houses (Ireland) Act, 1860, which dealt with the issue of wine on-licences. The purpose of the section is to update and simplify the application procedure for the issue of wine on-licences by the deletion of the current minimum rate of valuation requirements for the issue of such licences. Section 8 of the 1860 Act specifies the minimum rate of valuation levels required before a wine on-licence can be issued in respect of a particular premises. Where the population of an area is less than 10,000, as recorded in the most recent census, the minimum rate of valuation requirement is £8. Where the population is 10,000 or more, the required minimum rate of valuation is £15. Paragraph (a) amends section 8 of the 1860 Act to remove completely these rate of valuation requirements. Paragraph (b) makes a consequential technical amendment to section 30 of the 1860 Act. The section has effect from the date of the passing of the Act.
It was put to me during the formulation of the Finance Bill that this provision will overcome a problem on the islands. The issue arose when an applicant for a wine retailers on-licence was refused in the case of a resident of one of the western islands as the rate of valuation was below the minimum valuation required under section 8 of the Refreshment Houses (Ireland) Act, 1860. Representations were made concerning the matter and it was the subject of a parliamentary question on 8 October 1997. When the case was examined it was found that the problem related to the valuation of the premises rather than the legislation. Nevertheless, when the wider issue of rate of valuation was considered in conjunction with the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform, and the Revenue solicitor, the conclusion reached was that the valuation requirement was an anachronism from the last century and had little relevance today in the case of wine on-licences. Some wonderful information comes to the Minister for Finance during the preparation of the Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I am tempted to use the section as a Trojan horse to debate the issue of the regulation of licences.
Comment on this
I am interested that it appears as a provision in the Finance Bill. Deputy Rabbitte and I have tried to get the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform to consider the issue of liquor on-licences and off-licences. We have not succeeded to date so perhaps we should direct our attention to the Minister for Finance and try to have it included in next year's Finance Bill.
Comment on this
Given my experience with the vintners' association recently, I do not intend to pursue the matter. I suggest the Deputy direct his representations to the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform.
Comment on this
Following my experience of not consulting Deputy Rabbitte on credit unions - he also had some dealings with the vintners - I suggest Members consult him as his voice is not taken lightly on these matters.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 101, 102 and 103 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 101:
In page 85, line 20, after "amended" to insert "as on and from the 1st day of April, 1999,".
The purpose of amendment No. 101 is to delay the coming into effect of the changes being made by section 67 as initiated. Deputies will recall that section 67 amended section 21 of the Betting Act, 1931, which deals with the hours of business of registered bookmakers premises. The proposal was that, with effect from the date of the passing of the Act, bookmakers premises would be allowed to remain open from 7 a.m. until 10 p.m. from April to August inclusive and from 7 a.m. until 6.30 p.m. from September to March inclusive. These opening hours would also apply to Sundays. However, the current restrictions on opening on Christmas Day, Good Friday and Easter Sunday were to continue.
A number of Members on both sides of the House expressed concern about the ramifications of this proposal. In particular, Deputies Noonan, Power, Lenihan, Carey, Ring and others expressed their concerns about the need for consultation with staff who must cover the extra hours. I also received representations directly from staff employed in betting shops as well as from other members of the public. In addition, I have met representatives of the various bookmakers' representative bodies, some of which, in welcoming this proposal, have requested that its implementation be deferred until April 1999. In response to these concerns and to the concerns expressed by Deputies, this amendment proposes to defer the implementation of the extended opening hours until 1 April 1999.
I appreciate an extension of opening hours will not appeal to all sides, no more than any extension of trading hours in any other Irish service sector. Nevertheless, having met with the various representative bodies and having considered all the implications, I am satisfied that a substantial demand now exists for the change. After all, Deputies will appreciate that there has been no change in the statutory opening hours of betting shops for 67 years and it is recognised by all that major changes have taken place in the industry during this period. For example, there is now Sunday racing and many evening meetings during the summer.
Our legislation cannot be seen as curbing the ability of the trade to expand and develop. It must keep in line with ongoing developments in the trade as failure to do so could drive business underground with consequential loss of tax revenues, both directly and indirectly. In proposing this change, I am conscious of the fact that the law as it stood did not cater for what is currently happening in the trade, and my discussions with the various parties have reinforced this view.
The amendment should give the necessary time to facilitate preparations for the implementation of the measure by those businesses which intend to extend their opening hours. Deputies should remember that this is an enabling provision giving bookmakers the opportunity to regulate their opening hours according to demand. Not all bookmakers will choose to avail of the extended hours, whether at all or even on a regular basis. It is worth noting, for example, that in the UK, where similar opening hours apply, bookmakers' shops often open beyond "normal" working hours only when the demand arises, namely, where a quality horse race or some other significant sporting event takes place.
All parties recognise the developing environment in which betting takes place. However, not all parties agree about the changes necessary to keep up with these developments. On the one hand, the Allied Betting Shops Association, in welcoming the proposal, has pointed out that up to 700 new part-time jobs will be created in the industry by the extended opening hours. On the other hand, the Irish Independent Betting Offices Association has opposed the proposal, possibly because of the inconvenience they feel the new opening hours may cause them or, perhaps, because they feel threatened that any extension of opening hours may put them at a relative commercial disadvantage. Either way, it is not possible to arrive at a consensus view within the industry of what will benefit all its members. Accordingly, while conscious of the concerns that have been expressed by some within the industry, I feel on balance that the demand for the trading conditions of betting shops to be put on a modern footing cannot be resisted. It is on that basis that I move amendment No. 101.
Amendments Nos. 102 and 103 are amendments to delay the coming into effect of the changes being made by section 68 of the Bill as initiated. Section 68 amended section 18 of the Finance Act, 1931, to provide for an increase in the excise duty on the registration of a bookmaker's premises from the current rate of £200 per annum to £300 per annum. The increase in this duty was linked to, and broadly in line with, the increased opening hours for bookmakers' premises provided for in section 67 as initiated.
As a consequence of the delay I have made until 1 April 1999 in the implementation of the extended opening hours for bookmakers' premises, I now propose to also defer the coming into effect of the increase in bookmaker premises registration duty until 1999.
For technical reasons due to the fact that bookmakers' premises licences fall to be renewed after 30 November each year, I propose that the excise duty increase be deferred until 1 December 1999.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 102:
In page 85, line 40, to delete "1998" and substitute "1999".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 103:
In page 85, line 45, to delete "1998" and substitute "1999".
Comment on this
This section amends section 43 of the Finance Act, 1975, which deals with licence duty on gaming machines. The purpose of the amendment is to add Fridays to the Saturday, Sunday and public holiday period validity for the reduced gaming machine licence.
The proposed change is in response to representations from the trade who have pointed out that the current "weekend" licence, which enables holders to open on Saturdays, Sundays and public holidays, does not allow them to pick up any business from, for example, persons who arrive at resorts on Fridays for their weekend break. As traders require a full, seven day, gaming machine licence to do business on Fridays at present, this amendment will enable them to avail of additional trade at no extra cost.
The new arrangements will apply with effect from 1 May 1998.
Comment on this
Does this refer to the licence held by somebody who is operating a premises with gaming machines?
Comment on this
The reason I asked the Minister to elaborate is that I am wondering whether the Minister is satisfied that the current requirements of the law are attired to in full. Due to the input of local authorities we are all aware that these machines are maintained illegally. Certainly, that is the case in this city. In that case, I presume that they do not either apply or pay for the licence. In terms of general compliance, is the Minister satisfied that the law is being complied with at present?
Comment on this
Is that agreed? Agreed.
The Select Committee went into private session at 10.55 a.m. and the public session resumed at 10.58 a.m.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 104:
In page 86, lines 38 to 43, to delete subsection (3).
The reason I am disoriented is that yesterday, in the confusion about the new numbering, we indicated we wished to reserve our position in respect of re-entering certain matters on Report Stage. As regards section 18, dealing with capital allowances for fishing vessels, I wish to try to construct an amendment for Report Stage.
The purpose of my amendment to section 71 is to remove the increase on unleaded petrol so as to draw a distinction between leaded and unleaded petrol in the hydrocarbons area. The simple deletion I have proposed may not meet that requirement but an incentive to use unleaded petrol should be built in.
Comment on this
I did not increase the cost of unleaded petrol in the budget and the effect of Deputy Rabbitte's amendment would be the opposite of what he intends. The Budget Statement and Financial Resolutions of 3 December made no change to unleaded petrol.
Comment on this
The difficulty arises because the Minister imposed an increase on super unleaded petrol. I do not know what problem there is with super unleaded but I gather there are environmental and health aspects.
Comment on this
The purpose of section 71 is to confirm the selective budget increases of four pence per litre in excise duty on leaded and super unleaded petrol. These increases were contained in Financial Resolution No. 2, which was voted on and passed by the Dáil on budget day, 3 December 1997. The rate of excise duty on the more environmentally friendly unleaded petrol was not increased on that occasion. The increases to leaded and super unleaded petrol are for well known environmental reasons. The primary purpose of the rate changes are to further encourage the substitution of unleaded petrol for both leaded and super unleaded petrol.
Section 71(3) provides that the rate of excise duty on ordinary unleaded petrol does not increase in line with leaded and super unleaded petrol. In order to maintain the current rate of excise duty on ordinary unleaded petrol at the levels set in 1997 - that is, £294.44 per 1,000 litres - the rate of rebate is increased from £33.87 to £66.92 per 1,000 litres. If this subsection were to be deleted, as is proposed in the amendment, it would mean the rate of rebate set in 1997 would remain the same with a resulting increase of four pence per litre, including VAT, in the rate of excise duty on ordinary unleaded petrol. For these reasons I cannot accept the amendment.
Comment on this
If Mr. Roger Garland is watching I apologise to him. If I may return to my disorientation this morning, I gather I have missed amendment No. 100 and I give notice that I wish to re-enter it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Is there a breakdown of the percentage sales of super unleaded petrol? People believe that by buying super unleaded petrol they are helping the environment but in fact they are doing the opposite. We should stress this point because many are not aware of it.
Comment on this
Super unleaded petrol accounted for approximately 4.2 per cent of total petrol consumption in 1997, which is very small. It is anticipated this will fall further to 3.8 per cent in 1998. The tax on super unleaded petrol is 48.2 pence per litre, of which 35.7 pence is excise duty. This is 8.3 pence per litre more than the tax on unleaded petrol. The excise yield is expected to be £23.3 million in 1998, including an additional yield of £2.5 million due to the duty increase.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 105:
In page 87, before section 72, to insert the following new section:
"72.(1) Section 21 of the Finance Act, 1935, is hereby amended-
(a) in subsection (15)-
(i) in the definition of 'motor vehicle' (as amended by section 84(6) of the Finance Act, 1994) by the insertion after 'on roads,' of 'including any vehicle which is designed, constructed or modified to be suitable for traction on a road by a mechanically propelled vehicle,', and
(ii) by the insertion after the interpretation of 'mobile well drilling equipment' (inserted by the said section 84(6)) of the following definition:
'the expression "fuel tank" means any tank in or on a motor vehicle which is used or is capable of being used to supply fuel for combustion in the engine of the motor vehicle for the purposes of propulsion or of another motor vehicle which can provide traction for such purposes;',
and
(b) by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (15):
'(16) For the purposes of the definition of fuel tank in subsection (15) of this section, it shall be presumed, until the contrary is shown, that a tank is capable of being used to supply fuel for combustion in the engine of a motor vehicle for the purposes of propulsion if there are any outlets from the tank other than-
(a) those which are permanently and solely connected to and for the sole supply of fuel for refrigeration, oxygenation, thermal insulation or other specialised systems in or on the motor vehicle, or
(b) those which are solely for the purpose of discharging fuel from an oil road tanker to a vessel or tank separate from such oil tanker.'.
(2) This section shall come into operation on such day as the Minister for Finance may appoint by order.".
The purpose of this section is to expand the excise definition of a motor vehicle to include a trailer and also to provide a definition of a fuel tank in order to combat a new source of duty evasion. The amendment is necessary due to the illegal use by certain hauliers of rebated diesel or marked gas oil in so-called "belly" tanks on motor vehicles. Marked gas oil is subject to a lower rate of excise duty. Belly tanks are large tanks with extra fuel lines which are fitted to trailer refrigeration units in addition to the manufacturers standard fuel tank. Refrigeration units on trailers have normally been fuelled from special tanks of rebated oil. Recent developments have involved the installation of large belly tanks with two way switching devices in the cabs of trucks, which enable drivers to draw rebated diesel from such tanks to power the cab units, by-passing road diesel tanks. The use of marked gas oil in this way is almost impossible to detect, due to the driver's ability to switch from the belly tank to the normal fuel tank while the vehicle is in motion.
The purpose of the proposed amendment is to make it an offence to have rebated diesel in a fuel tank on a trailer except when the tank is solely connected for the purposes of refrigeration, oxygenation, thermal insulation, etc. The amendment may be implemented at a later date by ministerial order. This will give hauliers time to adjust tanks so that they only supplied refrigeration or other specialised units.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 106 is a drafting amendment, amendment No. 107 is cognate, amendments Nos. 108 and 109 are related and all may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106:
In page 94, subsection (12)(c)(iii), line 41, to delete "deducted" and substitute "deduced".
These amendments rectify errors in the Bill at the printing stage. I understand that at the start of the meeting the Chairman changed the word "reduced" to "deduced".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 107:
In page 95, subsection (15)(b), line 8, to delete "deducted" and substitute "deduce".
Comment on this
The purpose of this section is to allow that samples of goods taken by Revenue officers with a view to possible Customs and Excise proceedings may be given to a third party such as a courier to an agency such as the State chemist for analysis. In order to protect the integrity of the samples as evidence in any court proceedings, procedures are stipulated for every stage of the process from sampling to analysis. This measure allows for a more cost-effective method of transmitting Revenue samples for analysis. It was brought to my attention that there is a stage by stage process in prosecution and barristers and solicitors were able to have court cases dismissed if procedures were not exactly followed. This provision will make it easier for the State to win cases.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 108:
In page 95, subsection (1), line 12, to delete "section 82" and substitute "section 82.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 109:
In page 95, subsection (2), line 17, to delete "to cause it to" and substitute "or cause it to".
Comment on this
I am now required to put the following questions in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 26 February:
"That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to Chapters 1 and 2 of Part II of the Bill, and not disposed of, are hereby made to the Bill.
In respect of the sections undisposed of in the said chapters, that the section, or as appropriate the section as amended, is hereby agreed to."
Comment on this
This question disposed of all amendments up to and including amendment No. 109 on the printed list of amendments. We now move to Part III covering sections 85 to 95.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 110:
In page 96, before section 87, to insert the following new section:
87.-Section 4 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsections after subsection (8) (inserted by the Act of 1997):
(9) Where a disposal of an interest in immovable goods is chargeable to tax and where those goods have not been developed since the date of the disposal of that interest (hereafter referred to in this subsection as "the taxable interest") any disposal of an interest in those goods after that date by a person other than the person who acquired the taxable interest shall, for the purposes of this Act, be deemed to be a supply of immovable goods to which subsection (6) applies.
(10)(a) Where a disposal of an interest in immovable goods is chargeable to tax and the person who acquires that interest is obliged to pay rent to another person (hereafter referred to in this subsection as "the landlord") under the terms and conditions laid down in respect of that interest, the landlord-
(i) shall, notwithstanding the provisions of section 8, be deemed not to be a taxable person in respect of transactions in relation to those immovable goods other than-
(I) supplies of those immovable goods on which tax is chargeable in accordance with the provisions of this section, or
(II) supplies of other goods or services effected for consideration by the landlord, or
(III) post-letting expenses in respect of that interest,
(ii) shall not be entitled to deduct tax in respect of transactions in relation to those immovable goods other than-
(I) supplies of those immovable goods on which tax is chargeable in accordance with the provisions of this section other than subsection (4), or
(II) supplies of other goods or services effected for consideration by the landlord, or
(III) post-letting expenses in respect of that interest,
(iii) shall be deemed, where that landlord is not the person who made the disposal of the interest, to be a taxable person in respect of post-letting expenses in relation to that interest and shall in relation to those post-letting expenses be entitled to deduct tax, in accordance with section 12, as if those post-letting expenses were for the purposes of the landlord's taxable supplies.
(b) For the purposes of this subsection post-letting expenses in relation to an interest in immovable goods are expenses which the landlord incurs-
(i) in carrying out services which the landlord is obliged to carry out under the terms and conditions of the written contract entered into on the disposal of the interest which was chargeable to tax but does not include transactions the obligation to perform which is not reflected in the consideration on which tax was charged on the disposal of that interest, or
(ii) which directly relate to the collection of rent arising under the contract referred to in subparagraph (i), or
(iii) which directly relate to a review of rent where the terms and conditions of the contract referred to in subparagraph (i) provide for such a review, or
(iv) which directly relate to the exercise of an option to extend the interest or to exercise a break-clause in relation to that interest where the terms and conditions of the contract referred to in subparagraph (i) provide for such an option or such a break-clause, but do not include any expenses relating to goods or services of the type specified in section 12(3).'.'.
This amendment deals with VAT on long leases of commercial properties. It takes account of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Erin Executor and Trustee Company Ltd. The amendment inserts two new subsections into section 4 of the VAT Act. The first provides that any supply of an interest in property after a taxable supply is exempt from VAT. This confirms the general position that the supplier of a property is only subject to VAT once, unless it is redeveloped. While the Supreme Court judgment did not deal directly with this issue, concern has been expressed that one of the implications of the judgment could be to make all supplies of property taxable.
The second new subsection gives effect to the Supreme Court judgment and clarifies the circumstances in which post-letting expenses are deductible for VAT purposes. The amendment has effect from the date of passing.
Comment on this
I will read the note for the Deputy in this regard. However, I can say from personal experience that the most complicated area of VAT law relates to property. It is a nightmare. Some years ago the Revenue Commissioners published a worthwhile booklet to try to explain it to people, but even then it was still complicated. The entire area is a very complicated one.
This amendment concerns VAT and property matters. As a result of the recent Erin Executor case, which I have already mentioned, we feel we have to bring in this particular change in the law. Up until December 1997 the Revenue Commissioners did not allow deduction of VAT on post-letting expenses incurred by a landlord. This meant that VAT incurred by landlords on expenses such as legal, architectural or debt collection services could not be deducted and were a charge on the landlord's business. In December 1997 the Supreme Court found that VAT on post-letting expenses incurred by a landlord in the course of a taxable lease should be deductible. However, post-letting expenses were not defined and the judgment did not fully deal with the circumstances under which VAT deduction should be allowed. This amendment sets out to legislate for the judgment by making post-letting expenses VAT deductible while clarifying the type of expenses concerned and the circumstances in which deductibility will apply. Deductibility will be allowed on (a) expenses the landlord is obliged to incur under the terms of the lease and which are reflected in the taxable value of the lease; (b) rent review and rent collection expenses; and (c) expenses to do with the exercise of a break clause or option to extend the lease.
This section has effect from the date of passing of the Act.
Comment on this
We may be speaking at cross purposes because I am referring to the existing section 87, while obviously the Minister is referring to a new section. Is this section 88 or does it replace it?
Comment on this
No, it will be inserted ahead of the existing section 87 in the Bill as a new section. I was speaking about the new section. I will deal with the initiated section 87 in the next note.
The amendments always refer to the Bill as initiated. The next time you see the Bill all the sections will be different and a new explanatory memorandum will be issued. It took me an entire year working with the Finance and General Affairs Committee before I was able to figure it out for myself. I do not blame the Deputy for being confused because I was totally confused about it myself the first time I sat through the Finance Bill on Committee. At the end of 22 years I think I have figured it out.
Comment on this
This section amends section 5 of the VAT Act which deals with the supply of services. Due to gaps in the existing legislation certain telecommunication services and financial services consumed within this country by visitors from outside the EU could escape VAT. This section contravenes the basic assumption behind VAT, which is that the place of taxation is the place where goods or services are consumed. Accordingly, the relevant law has been amended to achieve this. For the same reasons the amendments will allow refunds of VAT to suppliers of telephone cards sold here for later use outside the EU. The changes in relation to telecom services are necessary to fully implement the relevant EU rules in Irish VAT law.
The change in relation to financial services closes off an anomaly under which, for example, a bureau de change could claim VAT input credits for that part of its business involving services to visitors from outside the EU.
This section will come into effect from 1 May 1998. I am assured by my advisers that it is essentially a tidying up exercise.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 111:
In page 98, paragraph (a), to delete lines 34 to 40 and substitute the following:
"(ii) by the substitution in subparagraph (iii) (inserted by the Act of 1997) of 'services specified in subparagraph (i) and either or both of goods of the type specified in subparagraph (ia) and goods of the type specified in subparagraph (ii) supplied in the circumstances set out in that subparagraph' for 'services and goods specified in subparagraph (i) and (ii)',
(iii) by the insertion of "or" at the end of subparagraph (iii), and
(iv) by the insertion of the following after subparagraph (iii):
'(iv) goods of the type specified in subparagraph (ia) and goods of the type specified in subparagraph (ii) supplied in the circumstances set out in that subparagraph, the total consideration has not exceeded and is not likely to exceed £40,000,'.".
Section 88 amends section 8 of the VAT Act, which deals with taxable persons. These are minor technical amendments to the provisions of the Bill as published, and relate to AI and livestock semen. They provide that (1) where a farmer makes supplies of certain agricultural services and either or both of livestock semen and nursery garden stock, he or she will be obliged to register an account for VAT where turnover from such supplies exceeds £20,000; and (2) where a farmer's actual turnover from the supply of both livestock semen and nursery stock exceeds or is likely to exceed £40,000 he or she will be obliged to register an account of VAT on such supplies.
Comment on this
I have been contacted by numerous Deputies regarding a technical difficulty relating to the provisions of the Bill on AI and bovine semen. Essentially, the question relates to the situation where an AI station would opt to split its business into a farming entity, providing AI services, and a non-farming entity supplying semen only. The intention is that the farming entity will be able to retain its flat rate farmers' status and therefore will not charge VAT on the AI services it supplies. The non-farming entity will be required to register for the tax if annual turnover exceeds a goods registration threshold of £40,000.
However, the question is whether supplies of semen produced on farm by the farming entity to the registered non-farming entities would count for the purpose of the VAT registration threshold. That is not the intention. If the AI station wishes to continue to supply AI as flat rate farmers, rather than as VAT registered traders, they will be able to do so, even in those circumstances. I have been advised that an amendment on Report Stage to clarify the position on AI stations which opt to split their businesses will be necessary.
Comment on this
If people are involved in the same product would one not one be uncompetitive against the other?
Comment on this
Yes. Under current VAT law, AI stations qualify as flat rate farmers and accordingly do not charge VAT on their supplies of insemination services in bovine semen. This treatment stems from the time when licensed AI stations, whose main purpose was seen as protecting the quality of the national stock of cattle, were engaged primarily in insemination services using bovine semen from their own herd. However, direct sales of bovine semen can constitute a relatively minor part of their overall business. The stations were allowed to retain their flat rate status even where the goods registration threshold was exceeded.
However, in recent years direct sales of bovine semen have increased significantly. Most of these direct sales are of semen which has been purchased from abroad. Such sales are primarily to farmers who now trade in AI and can provide services their own herds. The AI stations are now in direct competition with independent traders who also supply semen to farmers and are registered for VAT.
There is a significant competitive advantage for AI stations if they are allowed to remain unregistered. Unlike their competitors, the stations do not have to charge VAT on their supplies of bovine semen. Farmers would prefer to purchase from a source which does not charge VAT because, in general, farmers are not registered for VAT and consequently are not in a position to reclaim any VAT incurred on the purchase of the bovine semen.
The independent operators must register on account for VAT at the current rate of 21 per cent if their annual turnover exceeds £40,000. This VAT treatment places them at a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis the AI stations. There is no doubt that the independent operators were disadvantaged and that a remedy was needed.
The effect of the amendment is that all suppliers of livestock semen would have to register and account for VAT where their turnover on supplies exceeds £40,000. AI stations whose turnover exceeds that limit would have to register an account for VAT on all their supplies of insemination services of bovine semen. However, it is open to them to separate these activities into two separate entities and incur a liability only on their sales of bovine semen. In this way they can retain their flat rate status for the provision of insemination services. They may not, however, separate their bovine semen sales in the smaller units to avoid registration. As a VAT registered entity, the AI station can recover VAT incurred on all purchases of goods connected with its tax income and supplies.
As part of the overall package for this sector, the VAT rate on livestock semen is being reduced from 21 per cent to 12.5 per cent. Insemination services also qualify for this rate of tax. This reduction is permissible under the EU sixth directive. The cost of the measure to the Exchequer will be minimal and will be confined to cash flow. All the VAT charged on AI and bovine semen would be either deductible in the case of registered farmers or be taken into account in the calculation of the level of the flat rate addition on non-registered farmers. I take it there is no problem with this in Tallaght.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 112:
In page 99, before section 91, to insert the following new section:
"91.-Section 12 of the Principal Act is hereby amended-
(a) by the insertion in subsection (1)(b)(iii) after 'outside the State' of ', other than services consisting of the hiring out of motor vehicles (as defined in subsection (3)(b)) for utilisation in the State,', and
(b) by the substitution in subsection (2) of 'sections 20(1A) and 20(5)' for section 20(1A)'.".
This amends section 12 of the VAT Act which deals with deductibility. The amendment at paragraph (a) is one of a package of two amendments which I am proposing in response to a recent decision by the European Court of Justice in the ARO case.
The European Court of Justice ruled that the place of supply and service of leasing means of transport is the place where the lessor is established, not the place where the means of transport was used. The effect of the judgment is that a leasing company in another member state can lease vehicles to Irish customers and not charge Irish VAT. Instead, the leasing company will charge VAT at the rate applicable in the other member state and the customer will be able to reclaim it if the rules of the member state allow it. In Ireland, we do not allow business customers to reclaim VAT on the purchase or lease of their business cars, therefore, if we do not take measures to respond to the court judgment, the Irish car leasing business would be disadvantaged compared with its EU competitors operating in member states with either lower VAT rates or wider deductibility rules.
The judgment has caused a significant amount of disquiet in most member states as it overturns one of the fundamental principles that VAT is charged where the taxable goods or services are consumed. It is understood that the EU Commission intends to bring forward proposals to make legislative changes to the directive in question so as to address the balance in these cases. In the meantime, I have decided to take these measures to clarify and strengthen the existing rules, pending a change at EU level. This will prevent our deductibility regime from being examined and undermined and will ensure that the Irish car leasing industry is not subject to a tax based distortion of competition.
The amendment to section 12 at paragraph (a) is a technical amendment which maintains the status quo in respect of lessors established in other member states and operating in the Irish market at present. We have traditionally prevented foreign lessors from getting deductibility on their purchase of vehicles for leasing out to Irish customers. This was a mechanism for encouraging them to register here and thereby qualify for deductibility of their purchases, in the same way as Irish established lessors. The amendment takes account of the fact that since the ARO judgment, the legal basis applying to such services is no longer the State. The amendment establishes a cross reference in section 12(2) to the new rules concurring unjust enrichment which were introduced when the Bill was published.
Comment on this
Is it the case that if these changes were not made, people would be able to lease these vehicles in another jurisdiction at a lower rate of VAT and reclaim the VAT in some way?
Comment on this
Yes. The European Court of Justice gave its verdict in the ARO case July 1997. The judgment dealt with the place of taxation of cross border leasing from one EU country to another and it has potentially serious consequences for the Exchequer. We do not allow deduction of VAT on car leasing, even for business purposes. The ARO case opens the way for Irish businesses to source their leased cars from leasing companies in other EU countries at more favourable VAT deductibility rules than ours. Under the normal EU rules, the Irish customer could claim back the VAT on the leasing charges from the other country's tax authorities. This is an unacceptable outcome as it would undermine our temporary legal curb on car deductibilities and in so doing cost the Exchequer some £75 million to £100 million per year and undermine the competitive position of the entire Irish car leasing sector.
With other member states, we raised this issue at European level. In the meantime the amendments I propose to sections 12 and 13 of the VAT Act will strengthen existing safeguards in the law to maintain the status quo regarding car leasing. The effect will be that Irish companies could, for example, lease from the Netherlands where lower VAT rates apply. They would be entitled to bring the vehicle to this country and deduct the VAT on the lease. At present under Irish law nobody is allowed to deduct the VAT on leased cars, even for those in the business of car hire. This would totally undermine our existing position at a cost of between £75 million to £100 million. The EU is considering this and there is likely to be a directive, but this will take some time. We are, therefore, taking this opportunity to strengthen our existing VAT law to cover this point.
Comment on this
The other side of the coin is that Irish industry must be competitive with its European counterparts - and it has difficulties in that regard even now. If our competitors can avail of this facility to reclaim VAT on a truck bought in the Netherlands, for example, and we ring fence our position - for reasons which I understand - will we make our transport costs, which are so vital for exports, uncompetitive? I am not speaking about private cars.
Comment on this
It is a good point. It is our understanding that most countries are taking the Irish position in this regard and will resist the ARO judgment because it has serious implications for their exchequer positions also. In the case concerning the leasing of cars from the Netherlands to Belgium, the court found that the Dutch VAT rate should be charged on the lease payments. The consequence of that is that if an Irish business decides to lease cars from the Netherlands, Dutch rather than Irish VAT will be chargeable.
Comment on this
Worse still, from an Exchequer viewpoint, VAT chargeable in one member state to a business in another country may be claimed back by the customer. The basic rule governing these so-called eighth directive refunds is that, in this example, the customer is entitled to deduct the VAT charged. It is governed by the deductibility rule in the supplier's country. Our curbs on deductibility could be circumvented, with resultant distortion in trade, loss of business to Irish car lessors and loss of revenue to the Exchequer.
In regard to the point made by Deputy Coveney, this case only affects the deductibility on car leasing.
Comment on this
From my previous experience in another sphere, I know that businesses are allowed deduct the VAT charged on the leasing of a truck.
Comment on this
If I remember correctly, it does not have to be a truck leasing business. Nobody is allowed to claim back the VAT charged on the leasing or sale of cars.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that a tourist who leases a car at Dublin Airport and goes to Northern Ireland pays VAT at Irish rates at the airport which cannot be deducted or refunded, whereas if the car could be sourced in another jurisdiction VAT would be chargeable at the rate applicable in that jurisdiction and could be reclaimed?
Comment on this
This does not apply to tourists but the Deputy's summations are otherwise correct. In the case in question people in Belgium leased cars from the Netherlands. The deductibility rule under the eighth directive is that the VAT charged on a foreign import is allowed. Most countries, including Ireland, do not allow the VAT charged on car leasing to be reclaimed. However, the European Court of Justice decision allowed that.
If that were to be extended it would mean that Irish companies, rather than leasing cars in Ireland, would lease them from the Netherlands, for example, where deductibility is allowed. Apart from causing a loss of business to Irish car leasing companies, there would also be a loss to the Exchequer because the company would be entitled to claim back the VAT against sales under the ARO judgment. Therefore, there would be a double loss. In addition, we would also have to pay £75 million or £80 million in VAT because under the eighth directive the business person would be allowed to reclaim the VAT on those sales against his VAT.
Comment on this
Yes. We hope the EU will issue a directive on the matter because we are not the only country affected by it. However, it just applies to cars. To make matters worse, a Dutch leasing company could source cars here and then——
Comment on this
Yes, the domicile of the leasing company. The kernel of the judgment was that the matter was determined by the tax residence of the leasing company. One could think of all kinds of beautiful avoidance measures in that regard.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 113:
In page 99, before section 92, to insert the following new section:
"92.-Section 13 of the Principal Act is hereby amended in subsection (3) (c) by the substitution of 'or in respect of motor vehicles (as defined in section 12(3)(b)' for 'or in respect of means of support'.".
This amendment amends section 13 of the VAT Act which deals with remission of tax. This is the second amendment in the package of amendments to cater for the ARO judgment of the ECJ.
The rules in section 13(3) provide for VAT refunds to be given to traders established outside Ireland who pay Irish VAT to suppliers of goods or services here but who are not themselves performing taxable activities in the State.
Up to now, we have prohibited the refunding of VAT to leasing companies who purchase any vehicles - that is, either commercial vehicles or passenger cars - for hiring out or leasing to Irish customers. This was part of our approach to encourage such lessors to register for that business here. We regarded the place of taxation of those lessors as being the place where the vehicles were used. Lessors who are established here and who purchase vehicles for leasing here are granted deductibility in relation to the VAT incurred.
Since the ARO judgment, we must regard the place of taxation of leasing services to be the place where the lessor is established. In the circumstances, it is necessary to make sure we do not disadvantage the Irish customer of a lessor established in another member state when leasing a commercial vehicle. This is because the customer, if fully taxable, is entitled to input credit of all the VAT on the leasing charges. It is necessary to ensure that, if the Irish customer leases from a lessor established in another member state, there will be no trapped VAT. Under the amendment, those lessors will be able to get a VAT refund on commercial vehicles purchased for the purpose of leasing out to customers here.
The same case cannot be made for the customer who leases a passenger car. Such customers are not entitled to deductibility here except for stock-in-trade and cars for driving schools. Therefore, the amendment maintains the status quo in respect of purchases of passenger cars by lessors established outside Ireland. It follows on from the previous amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister used the term "trapped VAT" which I have never heard before. What does it mean?
Comment on this
It is VAT which cannot be deducted. For example, one cannot claim back the VAT paid on the purchase of a motor car or petrol.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 114:
In page 101, line 26, to delete "period--" and substitute "period.".
This amendment clears up a punctuation error in the Bill as initiated. No change of substance has been made to the section as a result of this amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 115:
In page 101, between lines 41 and 42, to insert the following:
"(b) by the insertion of the following paragraph after paragraph (vc):
'(vd) the supply of the following bakery terms:
fresh scones:- brown, white, fruit; rock buns; donuts:- cream, jam, chocolate; eclairs; fresh cream cakes; yeast bun goods; pancakes; potato cakes; yeast soda; fresh fruit bracks; danish pastries; hot plate goods; fresh apple and all fresh baked tarts.'.".
This may seem a minor matter but a number of Deputies have received strong representations on it. I believe they are from the same constituency as Deputy Rabbitte, so he will know of this as well.
Comment on this
These goods have no shelf life. They are sold as fresh and cease to be so within 24 hours. I gather the profit margins on them are exceptionally low. They are generally produced by small companies or groups of people and they are competing with partially fresh products with a long shelf life. The industry is relatively employment intensive and, in many cases, the supermarkets which give shelf space to the products do so on the basis that, if they are not sold, they must be taken back. This small sector of the economy is under pressure. Many people involved in the area have been unemployed and have set up little businesses for themselves. For those reasons, there is a case for giving them a zero VAT rate and that is the purpose of the amendment. I ask the Minister to give it serious consideration.
Comment on this
I also met these people when I was the Opposition spokesperson on Finance. I accept the points made by both Deputy Coveney and others but I regret I must oppose the amendment. The purpose of the amendment is to extend the zero rate of VAT to the items listed which are currently taxed at the reduced rate of VAT of 12.5 per cent, except perhaps for yeast buns, yeast soda and hot plate goods which could be at the standard rate of 21 per cent depending on precisely what they are. Most food in Ireland is zero rated. However, flour based confectionery, biscuits other than chocolate biscuits, food supplied in restaurants and heated foods are taxable at the reduced rate of 12.5 per cent. Chocolate and chocolate biscuits, ice cream, sweets and snack foods are at the standard rate of 21 per cent. Positive VAT rating has always been applied to these items on the basis that they are discretionary items of expenditure.
I am sympathetic to the baking industry and have been in correspondence with it on this matter. Officials in my Department met with these representatives to give them an opportunity for their case to be heard. In addition, the difficulties in making any changes in the current VAT rating structure because of the constraints in EU VAT law were explained to them in detail. Under EU VAT law, member states may retain the zero rates they had in operation on 1 January 1991 but the introduction of new zero rates by member states is forbidden. As the items in question were not zero rated at the time, unlike the situation in the United Kingdom, it is not now open to the Government to apply such a rate. Any attempt to apply new zero rates or even expand the scope of existing zero rates would be open to challenge in the European Court of Justice. There have been restrictions on the introduction of new zero rates for many years.
I have also considered the application of a 5 per cent rate to flour confectionery which would be legally possible under EU VAT law. However, I must rule out such a move due to the adverse budgetary implications. It is estimated that a reduction in the rate on flour confectionery to 5 per cent would cost the Exchequer approximately £15 million per annum. Of even greater significance are the consequences such a move could have for the current rating structure. Introducing a new rate of 5 per cent for bakery produce would inevitably lead to pressure from other sectors which avail of the 12.5 per cent rate to also be put at 5 per cent. To concede to a 5 per cent rate for all categories at 12.5 per cent would cost of the order of £400 million per annum.
Following the meeting with the officials of my Department, the Flour Confectioners and Bakers Association indicated it would meet with the VAT administration branch of the Revenue Commissioners to see if anything could be done under existing zero rate provisions. I understand a meeting has been arranged and Revenue is prepared to examine the matter as sympathetically as possible, especially in regard to any borderline cases.
Comment on this
I did not fully understand the last part of the Minister's reply about the meeting with Revenue and the reference to the zero rate of VAT. It seems to be the opposite of what he said to begin with, that nothing could be done. Could he explain it again?
Comment on this
The idea of the meeting is to see if it is possible for the law to be interpreted in a different and sympathetic way. I am precluded from applying a zero rate to anything which did not have a zero rating prior to 1991. The purpose of the meeting is to see what can be done for the people involved.
The second part of my argument is that I could offer to reduce the VAT rate for flour based confectionery from 12.5 per cent to 5 per cent but if I were to do that, apart from the immediate cost to the Exchequer of £15 million per annum, I would be inundated with requests to reduce the VAT rate from 12.5 per cent to 5 per cent for a range of other products. That would cost approximately £400 million. I do not want to open the floodgates. The meeting between the Revenue Commissioners and the Flour Confectioners and Bakers Association will examine if anything can be done under existing zero rating provisions to solve specific problems. Breads are specifically defined in VAT legislation as being zero rated.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying he is sympathetic and will go as far as possible with the Revenue Commissioners in interpreting the matter as favourably as possible and that there is some light at the end of the tunnel?
Comment on this
We shall have to wait and see. I know Marks and Spencer in Cork is importing fresh products daily from the UK. I must admit for my sins that I have eaten them. There are small people trying to compete against such companies.
Comment on this
My expertise in this regard is well known. I made a bakery shop in County Kildare famous in my political lifetime. The people concerned are well known business people in Naas. I regret that they decided to close the shop in the past year. It will shortly become a fast food outlet, one of a chain of such outlets owned by a group. The place I made famous and about which I wrote in some books will no longer have its sign at the lights in Naas. Deputy Coveney is correct. I am aware of this problem and of the problems Irish industry faces in this regard. I would like to resolve it but I cannot as my hands are tied under VAT law. Perhaps the meeting between the Revenue Commissioners and the association might be able to resolve some difficulties. It might be possible to interpret some of the existing provisions in a different light. That would surmount some of the problems about which the Deputy has spoken.
Comment on this
I do not fully accept the floodgate theory about the 5 per cent option, unless the Minister's successors will be very weak people. It is a matter for any Minister to stand up to. Is the Minister saying the reduction to a 5 per cent rate on these products alone would cost £15 million?
Comment on this
Given the Minister's personal sympathy in the matter, perhaps he could go that far if the meeting with Revenue leads to nothing.
Comment on this
I cannot do so for the reasons I have outlined. I am regularly put under pressure from all types of organisations to reduce the rate from 12.5 per cent to 5 per cent. Consistently Ministers for Finance have refused to do so. The Minister for Finance and the Government come under pressure at various stages and I do not wish to create a precedent in this regard. Despite my sympathy for these people, I cannot countenance a change.
Comment on this
I would not be enthusiastic about a proliferation of rates - this is something we have tried to move away from. We can await the result of the meetings with Revenue which will have the Minister's sympathetic consideration.
Comment on this
Regarding section 94 (b), was there a case before the appeals commissioners in respect of filofaxes?
Comment on this
Is the rate not being maintained here? I am not necessarily advocating the cause of the filofax brigade, but in terms of being up to date why is the law not being changed?
Comment on this
We are discussing section 94. Deputy Coveney's amendment would create a new section. Deputy Rabbitte is referring to the actual section.
Comment on this
Perhaps we can deal with Deputy Coveney's amendment before dealing with the issue raised by Deputy Rabbitte.
Comment on this
Section 94 (b) confirms that the zero rate still applies to books, booklets and atlases. However, the amendment excludes certain items from the zero rate. Diaries and organisers, which are liable at the 21 per cent rate, are specifically mentioned in order to clarify the law following an appeals case. The other excluded items are listed in order to ensure the scope of the zero rate is crystal clear for the benefit of the printing trade in particular.
Comment on this
Therefore, the decision of the commissioners was wrong in our view and we are re-imposing a VAT rate of 21 per cent.
Comment on this
Newspapers have had a VAT rate of 12.5 per cent for some time. The rate was previously higher.
Comment on this
Following changes in the Finance Bill, all periodicals will now have a VAT rate of 12.5 per cent. Previously, some had a VAT rate of 12.5 per cent while most had a rate of 21 per cent. There were some unusual classifications of items at the different rates. For example, the RTÉ Guide was classified as a paper and had a VAT rate of 12.5 per cent.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 116:
In page 102, paragraph (b), to delete lines 23 to 31 and substitute the following:
(e) printed music other than in book or booklet form; but excluding:
(i) other printed matter wholly or substantially devoted to advertising,
(ii) the goods specified in subparagraphs (b) to (e) of paragraph (xva) of the Second Schedule, and
(iii) any other printed matter;'.".
Section 95 amends the Sixth Schedule to the Principal Act which deals with goods and services chargeable a VAT rate of 12.5 per cent. This amendment clears up an alignment error in the Bill as initiated. It clarifies that printed matter as specified in subparagraphs (a) to (e) inclusive of paragraph (12) of the Sixth Schedule excludes items listed in subparagraphs (i), (ii) and (iii).
Comment on this
On the point raised by Deputy Fleming regarding magazines and reduced VAT, does the Minister wish to direct any comment towards magazine vendors who have always claimed VAT to be the apparent reason for the particularly high prices vis-à-vis appreciation against sterling? Is there an argument for having the competition aspect examined now that VAT has been reduced?
Comment on this
As a result of reducing VAT we have written to the Director of Consumer Affairs about these issues. The Deputy rightly points out that the VAT rate of 21 per cent has long been put forward by people in the business as the reason for the very high prices. I have now given them a concession which will cost the Exchequer approximately £1 million in a full year. One would reasonably believe that prices will come down and I hope this will happen. Deputy Rabbitte took some interest in this matter both in Government and Opposition.
Comment on this
It was not one of my spectacular successes. The consumer is annoyed by the fact that it is very difficult to justify the cover price of British and American magazines. The Director of Consumer Affairs, if he has adequate staffing, ought to be asked to monitor whether the reduced VAT rate is being passed on. In their defence for not passing on the value of an appreciating punt it was pointed out by those in the business that magazines are zero rated in Britain while the VAT rate here is 21 per cent. My conviction is that VAT rates alone did not justify the differential.
Comment on this
My officials have written to the Director of Consumer Affairs and will follow with interest what happens to the price of magazines. The differential was put forward by those in the business as a justification for the cover price. We have now reduced the VAT rate to 12.5 per cent and would like to see this benefit being passed on to the consumer.
Comment on this
The VAT rate on some high gloss magazines, considered luxury items, is being reduced from 21 per cent to 12.5 per cent at the cost of £1 million.
Comment on this
The last time such a move was made it was in the context of newspapers. At that time the cost of newspapers went down but increased again very quickly.
Comment on this
The consumer is more watchful now and the office of the Director of Consumer Affairs is better staffed. Consumers are more alert and it is proper that the signal should go out to distributors, who have been suspected in the past of collusive activity, that the situation is being monitored. The report of the consumer authority published some years ago was dubious about the extent to which real competition applied. The consumer ought to expect to get the benefit of the VAT reduction, not just on glossy magazines but on the whole array of magazines which have a big market in Ireland.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. The trade said it would reduce the price and the consumer should be looking out for a reduction. I agree the consumer is much more aware in the 1990s than 20 years ago. I look forward to seeing how the situation, which we will monitor, develops.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 117:
In page 102, before section 96, but in Part 4, to insert the following new section:
"96.-Stamp duty shall not be payable on buildings or lands acquired by non-profit making voluntary, sporting or community organisations or bodies, where the purchase of such buildings or lands is to provide sporting, leisure or recreational activities.".
The purpose of the amendment is to deal with the phenomenon of sporting clubs and non-profit making organisations in the community who acquire lands or buildings for sporting purposes. Perhaps such phenomenon can best be illustrated by an example recently brought to my attention. The sporting club concerned spent approximately £250,000 acquiring new grounds upon which to build new clubhouses etc. For that expenditure - much of it borrowed and raised by the local community - they received a letter to the effect that they would get an award of £10,000 from the national lottery. However, a further letter stated that because the work had been done on a voluntary basis by members of the club they were not eligible for the £10,000 award because they could not produce receipts. Simultaneously they received a letter stating they owed £13,000 in stamp duty. There are a proliferation of non-profit making, voluntary, community sporting organisations who have demonstrated tremendous community spirit in acquiring facilities throughout the country. These facilities, because of the phenomenon already discussed and rising house prices, are becoming more and more expensive. It seems especially severe that when members of such clubs come together and do the work themselves they hit for punitive stamp duty.
The purpose of my amendment is to seek the agreement of the Minister to exempt non-profit making community sporting organisations from stamp duty where the purpose is to use these facilities for sporting and leisure activities. I am not talking about circumstances where such clubs would be used for the sale of alcohol or revenue yield. We ought to acknowledge the work done by community organisations. It would make their burden more bearable and their objectives more achievable.
Comment on this
The Deputy is proposing to exempt transfers of land to sporting community organisations where the land is being required for sporting and recreational purposes. I am not sure whether exemption for grant purposes would achieve a major reduction in the overall cost to a sporting body of acquiring land. It is possible the vendor would increase the price when the intending purchaser is a sporting organisation. That means the proposal would result in a loss to the Exchequer with no significant benefit to the sporting organisation. For that reason, I oppose the amendment.
I suggest to the Deputy that what the sporting organisation should do in this regard is seek charitable status. Organisations that achieve charitable status from the Revenue Commissioners receive a CHY number and are exempt from stamp duty.
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with the decision we made yesterday in respect of registered charities. Is the Minister saying that any sporting club has the right to apply for charitable status?
Comment on this
No, there are rules with which organisations must comply before they can get tax exemptions by virtue of their charitable status. There are many thousands of charities with a CHY number in existence.
Comment on this
One of the conditions for achieving charitable status is that the organisation must be for the public good and if Articles of Association apply they are changed. Some sporting organisations have successfully applied for charitable status. I am not sure that the particular organisation referred to by the Deputy could do so. I am sympathetic to the Deputy's amendment and the purpose for which it was intended. The situation involves a circular transfer of funds: the State paid a grant out of one pocket and took money in the other. There are many examples of the circular transfer of moneys within the State. I do not think an exemption in this regard would necessarily decrease the cost of land acquisition by sporting organisations. I believe that the seller of any property takes account of the purchaser's potential. I do not think it is possible to achieve what the Deputy is trying to do.
Comment on this
If the Minister takes the example I have given whereby the organisation have acquired the land and have to build a clubhouse. Money has been spent on acquiring the land and the only way they can build the clubhouse is by members of the club collecting bricks etc., from builders, getting donations from corporate sponsors and physically building the clubhouse as a result of which they have disqualified themselves from the lottery award. They cannot seek a receipt from the builder who gave them the 200 blocks. They are then faced with a bill for £13,500 in stamp duty. It is not exactly encouraging community endeavour.
Comment on this
This creates a problem in relation to the black economy. I take Deputy Rabbitte's point that this was voluntary but the State must also guard against the danger that in giving grants it is not funding the black economy.
The Minister mentioned the possibility of such groups achieving charitable status. If they were successful in that regard it would have the same effect on the price of land because whether they get it by charitable status or as outlined in the amendment the effect would remain the same. One might well say there is not much point in achieving charitable status because land prices will rise if they do not have to pay stamp duty.
Comment on this
Those of us involved in community projects are sympathetic to and understand the points raised by Deputy Rabbitte. I am not totally au fait with the payment of grants but I think a change was introduced recently whereby one-third of the required sum had to be raised locally. Under EU regulations efforts made by the group concerned will be taken as their contribution. Raising money was proving to be a major problem for small clubs in particular.
Achieving charitable status is the method we have found works best for scouting and other organisations. With the best will in the world, many end up having a bar and the drug problems which go with that. Deputy Rabbitte identified that problem. There is much to be said for looking at ways to contribute more to groups trying purchase facilities although I see difficulties. Charitable status has been used in a number of operations and to date, it has been successful.
Comment on this
I know clubs which did not employ contractors, did not have invoices for material and did not qualify for grants. Some of the materials came from people who chose to subscribe in that way. The initial thinking behind the provision of grants for sporting clubs is lost along the way. If sporting clubs were highly organised and employed contractors who could complete a job within a certain period, they probably would not need any help from the national lottery, so this self defeating. Will the Minister tell us what qualifies as charitable status? As far as I am concerned, every sporting club should have charitable status. What does the Minister mean when he says some sporting clubs have charitable status and some do not?
Comment on this
There is a general law on how an organisation qualifies for charitable status and for a CHY number. I will arrange for the guidelines and the rules to be forwarded to the Deputy.
Comment on this
A number of small clubs are struggling and receive £5,000 or £10,000 from the national lottery. The Minister is not catering for people who are making an input into their clubs by giving a few hours of their time each weekend and by buying materials. It is all right for national sporting organisations which may employ big contractors and sign contracts.
Comment on this
This is a matter for the Minister Tourism, Sport and Recreation. The question of lottery grants has been debated for some time. Even the last Administration set up a study group which reported on this matter before the general election. We will never be able to put in place a system which will meet with universal approval. I accept the amount of voluntary work done throughout the country by sporting organisation and have no hesitation agreeing with Deputy Belton in this regard. However, Deputy Rabbitte's amendment raises a specific point about exempting from stamp duty the cost of the acquisition of lands. I do not favour as a general rule bringing in exemptions.
As regards the celebrated case in the budget, I have used in my defence the fact that PAYE and VAT coming back to the State from a particular building operation will be considerably greater than the amount of money given in grants. The two issues should not be confused. I understand the intention behind Deputy Rabbitte's amendment. It seems unfair the Exchequer is taking stamp duty from sporting organisations but it is handing back Exchequer money by way of subvention by means of a grant. We must look at the two issues separately.
If the Minister for Finance or the Government were to apply that type of thinking to everything, there would be no taxation in certain areas because the people would be paying back what we have given them in terms of benefits. It is not a principle we should adopt. Consequently, I cannot accept the Deputy's amendment.
Comment on this
Will the Minister let me in on the secret of what constitutes a club getting charitable status? Deputy Dennehy offered me the helpful advice that we have done this on a few occasions and I will talk to him privately afterwards. Why would a club in my constituency or the Minister's get charitable status, while another club would not? That is what people outside the House will ask. Does it help that the secretary of the club is a good Fianna Fáil member?
Comment on this
I will ensure my Department and the Revenue Commissioners send details to the Deputy of how an organisation qualifies for charitable status. I do not have the rules with me but an organisation may qualify under a number of heads, including religion, education, relief of poverty or other purposes which benefit the community. The Acts relating to this matter are very old.
Comment on this
Over the years I was often amazed at how some organisations qualified for charitable status, while others did not. There are about 8,000 or 9,000 organisations with CHY numbers and 4,000 are active. There are rules under which an organisation must qualify and I have been amazed at how some qualify.
Comment on this
The Revenue Commissioners lay down rules and there is a section within Revenue dealing with this matter.
Comment on this
The need does not arise for most people. Funding in urban areas is directed towards community associations and community councils. I mentioned scouting because I am involved in it and the national organisation advises people. If an organisation does not have charitable status, it is usually because of a lack of knowledge or need. Most organisations would qualify under the rules if they applied. This is similar to the original applications for lottery grants in that some groups availed of expertise when applying but others did not know how to do so. It is hassle for the secretary of an organisation to have to deal with Revenue.