We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE

Finance Bill, 1998: Committee Stage (Resumed)

Contributions 163–318 of 318. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 1998
Enacted

No. 8 of 1998 ›

I will withdraw the amendment, which I might resubmit on Report Stage. Perhaps the Minister might send me these obscure regulations. There may be an argument for us to modernise them.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 125 is related to amendment No. 118 and both may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

Has amendment No. 119 been ruled out of order?

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 118:

In page 102, before section 96, but in Part 4, to insert the following new section:

96.-Any exemption from stamp duty on any instrument transferring by way of conveyance or lease an interest in a new dwelling-house or apartment shall apply to such an instrument relating to premises which were the subject of a previous conveyance or lease provided that the person acquiring the interest on the occasion in question is acquiring an interest in residential premises for the first time and is himself or herself taking up residence in the premises as his or her bona fide principal private residence, and the rates of stamp duty specified in the First Schedule to the Stamp Act, 1891, as amended by section 117 of and the Eighth Schedule to the Finance Act, 1997, shall not apply to the instrument.".

Amendment No. 118 attempts to address the difficulties arising in the housing market by looking at stamp duty. I am sorry amendment No. 119 was ruled out of order because it is an important part of the balance I am looking to strike. Amendment No. 118 seeks to eliminate the liability to stamp duty for first time buyers of secondhand houses. Amendment No. 119 proposes imposing a liability for stamp duty on those other than first-time buyers buying new houses.

The reason for these amendments is simple. For a long time we targeted State assistance at the construction industry, partly to encourage the construction of houses and partly to encourage the industry and support the employment it gives. It is clear that in so far as it relates to domestic houses, that support is no longer necessary. It has been necessary in the past and may be necessary in the future. There are reports of labour shortages in the industry. An increasing number of houses is being built and there has been a considerable increase in the number of houses coming on the market. The problem is that those houses are not going to first time buyers or people wishing to live in them, but are bought up by an increasing number of investors.

We need to retarget State assistance away from the construction industry and at those who wish to buy houses. The current difficulty is with first time buyers in particular. We all know, anecdotally and from the newspapers, that it is next to impossible for a single person to buy a house in Dublin and very difficult for young couples. My constituency is old and well-established. The starting price for houses built in Beaumont, which is a typically lower middle class area, is £135,000. No young person or newly married young couple can be reasonably expected to afford that. If they are buying houses, we are encouraging them to get into a level of indebtedness which is unacceptable.

They are priced out of the market by investors. I have no problem with people buying houses for speculative gain with a view to selling them in the future. However, we have a responsibility to tilt the balance against investors, take away some of their advantages and focus our assistance on first time buyers.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 125 proposes to allow first time buyers a refund of stamp duty on the purchase of secondhand houses. The refund is £6,000 or the duty, whichever is lower. This relates to a house costing up to £100,000. By limiting the refund to £6,000, it is targeted at those entering the middle or lower end of the market. We also suggested some provisions to combat abuses.

Home buying is an aspiration for all young people and is one the most stabilising factors in our society. The level of house buying is relatively high here when compared with other countries, but the trend appears to be moving in the opposite direction as a result of the huge inflation in house prices, fuelled by investors and speculators. They are entitled to be in the marketplace but some advantage should be given back to those we wish to assist most - the first time house buyers. This amendment proposes one way of assisting that process, although it will not be dramatic.

Comment on this

The issue of house prices is an important one. The Department of the Environment and Local Government recently set up a committee to look at this topic. It covers a wide variety of issues. I am concerned about amendments such as this one. It is a piecemeal approach to a big problem. I would prefer to wait for a report from the Department of the Environment and Local Government which will cover taxation, grants, zoning, profits, investors and first time buyers.

I agree with Deputy McDowell that we do not need State support for the construction industry. However, the logic of that argument suggests we should abolish the £3,000 grant for first time buyers. I am concerned about reducing stamp duty in certain cases. The problem is there is too much money available for buying houses. By reducing a tax on housing, the money saved will go back to those selling houses. I am not happy with a piecemeal approach to this issue. We will discuss it in a wider forum in the months ahead.

Comment on this

We have an acute dilemma and the discussion of this Bill is an opportunity to take some remedial action to relieve the pressure on young couples, for whom the purchase of a house is rapidly going out of their reach. I am not sure the modest measures proposed in these amendments will conflict with anything likely to be done in a more comprehensive fashion. Deputy Fleming is telling young people "live horse and you will get grass".

With all respect to the Minister of State with responsibility for housing and urban renewal, he has promised action for a long time. It is important we see the colour of his money soon. The problem is getting worse and all that is proposed here is that some alleviation be given in a culture where home ownership is traditionally highly valued. As we said yesterday, traffic is becoming an economic obstacle and a restraint on continued economic growth. We are continuing to push people into the Minister's constituency and counties adjoining Dublin because the purchase price of houses in the city area is beyond the reach of those on average industrial earnings.

The thrust of these amendments regarding secondhand houses will make some contribution to putting them in range of that category of purchaser. In the current climate, the Minister is obliged to make some gesture in that direction. It is most unlikely it will conflict with any measure likely to be imposed by the Minister of State with responsibility for Housing and Urban Renewal. He is on his mettle as regards this issue and it is time we saw some proposals for action. The certificate of reasonable value may not have worked well, but at the rate things are going I am not sure what will happen if we cannot address the issue with whatever proposals the Minister will make.

Comment on this

I agree with some of the sentiments expressed about first time buyers. The previous Government had an opportunity to address this problem while it was in office but I am open to correction by the Minister on this matter.

Comment on this

The last Government increased stamp duty by 65 per cent.

Comment on this

First time buyers' are discriminated against, whether they are buying a new house or buying a secondhand house where they have to pay stamp duty. New houses are rapidly going out of the reach of young couples. Some people cannot even afford to buy a modest secondhand house.

Last week I said we should look at the sale of refurbished houses and buildings in designated areas, etc. When these houses and buildings are being sold they should not have stamp duty applied to them because they are not new.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that this is a panacea to solve the housing crisis but, as Deputy Rabbitte said, it is an opportunity to do something now. Of course Deputy Fleming is correct that a more comprehensive response is necessary and we await that with interest. It is hard to see how this measure will conflict with it.

Comment on this

I am conscious of what Deputies have said on this matter. I am also conscious of the concerns expressed by various people regarding house prices. I am very aware of the escalating house prices in Dublin because I represent a constituency that has experienced the same phenomenon. In recent years all politicians representing County Kildare, including myself, have experienced the problems relating to the overflow from Dublin and the effects this has had on planning applications.

The aim of the amendments tabled by Deputies McDowell and Noonan is to make housing more affordable by granting a stamp duty relief to first time buyers of new or secondhand houses. I do not believe houses will be more affordable by implementing their measures.

Much has been said and written in the past weeks about the escalating cost of local authority housing to the State. Most commentators attribute the rising prices to the short supply of houses but the Deputies' proposals do not address this fundamental problem. In fact these proposals will ensure vendors further increase the cost of houses because they will think purchasers have more money available to them. Even if that were not the case prices will still rise due to market forces unless the supply issue is addressed.

Any proposed changes to stamp duty on property will need to take account of its possible impact on rising house prices. The Minister for the Environment and Local Government has commissioned a study on house prices, the aim of which is to analyse all available information on trends and factors influencing house prices and the implications of changing house price levels. The results of this study will be made available to the Government to enable it to further develop our housing policy. I am reluctant to pre-empt the outcome of this study.

If I were to implement the amendments the Exchequer would be at a significant loss and no real relief would have been afforded to first time buyers. In fact, vendors will benefit more from this amendment because of the way the market operates. As Deputy Coveney will be aware, interfering in a market for selected items often creates a further imbalance in it. I prefer to wait until the end of March for the results of the study on house prices and I will then make an informed proposal. Therefore, I oppose this amendment.

As a representative of Kildare I am aware that the short supply of land on which to build houses is a major factor in prices. Another consequence of spiralling housing demands is problems with planning permission in Dublin and, increasingly, in Kildare. It is only in the past few years that Kildare has had any problems with the rezoning of land. In future councillors will be reluctant to rezone any land. Councillors, even with advice from planners and experts, have refused to rezone land. Pressure groups have been formed to lobby politicians to prevent land rezoning. This is a very serious situation. Some of the proposed rezoning of lands in many parts of Dublin and Kildare would have been excessive. Dublin councillors are now reluctant to rezone land, even if they get good advice from planners, etc., that it is necessary. No matter what zoning takes place somebody will object to it and put pressure on politicians. When pressure is applied to politicians, particularly in an election year, they will make whatever decisions they like. There are local elections due in 1999. If you take this into consideration we are left with a very serious situation.

Over the years there has also been a reluctance of planners and local inhabitants to accept a greater density of housing. Some experts now believe that a higher density of housing is acceptable but it will be some time before this view is accepted by the public.

There has also been a huge increase in the number of lobby groups all over the country which will make it very difficult for any of these proposals to be implemented. We also must take into account the cost to the Exchequer of the provision of services to housing estates.

Interest rates are currently low by our standards. In the past, like many other people, I have suffered the effects of very high interest rates. I find it hard to believe, as I am sure Deputy Coveney does, that we are in an era of lower interest rates and this will benefit businesses and mortgage holders. For the foreseeable future interest rates will remain low. There will also be implications for our interest rates when we join the EMU on 1 January 1999. We must take these factors into consideration.

As regards any amendments dealing with stamp duty. I would also be loath to interfere from the tax point of view. Stamp duties give a significant yield to the Exchequer. In 1997 the total yield from all stamp duties was £424.8 million. Of these, stamp duties on property contributed £254.3 million. We do not know how many first time buyers buy secondhand houses. Based on data in the Department of the Environment's 1996 annual housing statistics bulletin, the cost of this amendment would be £46 million. If we reduce the stamp duty yield we will have less money to relieve income tax payers. One of our key taxation problems has been that too great a burden has been placed on the shoulders of the income tax payer, both PAYE and Schedule D tax payers. Stamp duty is a relatively painless form of taxation, £254 million of stamp duty comes from stamp duty on property, £75 million from shares, £22 million from cheques, £9 million from insurance policies, £13 million from general deeds, £1 million from penalties, £9.1 million from credit cards, £13.5 million from non-life savings, £2.2 million from Section 84 and £5.5 million from ATM tariffs. Income tax is a much more painful form of taxation. I am committed to reducing direct taxation over the next number of years. For those and other reasons I am not in a position to accept these amendments.

Comment on this

I acknowledge that consultants have been studying this question for a number of months. I hope that the collective thought processes of the Minister's Department and the Department of the Environmnent and Local Government have been frozen while these consultants do the job for us. Nothing in the Finance Bill is helpful to the housing market. The Government's move on CGT is particularly unhelpful.

Comment on this

I believe the opposite. The reduction of CGT will bring more houses on the market.

Comment on this

We have a genuine disagreement here. In his contribution the Minister did not express any concern about the number of new houses being purchased for investment purposes. That is a central problem. We can look at all the supply side solutions in the world but if a growing percentage of new houses are bought for speculative gain we will never satisfy first time buyers. Does the Minister see this difficulty?

Comment on this

The study will address that point. Even before the reduction in CGT was announced in the budget a considerable proportion of new houses were being purchased by people who already owned houses. That is a result of increasing prosperity.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept that this constitutes a problem?

Comment on this

It is another problem which must be put into the pot with all the other problems. Given our constitutional right to own private property it is a problem which cannot be easily addressed.

Comment on this

We already give incentives to first time buyers and I presume we can, constitutionally, continue to do so. An imposition of stamp duty on the sale of new houses to buyers other than first time buyers or owner occupiers would help first time buyers and raise revenue.

Comment on this

We cannot forbid investors to invest.

Comment on this

I do not suggest that. I simply suggest a liability for stamp duty for buyers other than first time buyers.

Comment on this

I cannot see the Minister's problem in tipping the balance of advantage in the direction of the first time house purchaser and away from the investor. This would surely be a good thing. Deputy McDowell and I know that a comprehensive response is called for but we should seize this once off opportunity to tip the balance in the way I have suggested. I do not accept that this measure would cause house prices to rise. It would equip the first time buyer with a little more money and enable him to stand the competition from investors. If more houses are bought by first time buyers, even if the price of houses rises, it would be an improvement on the present position. We wish to press this amendment.

Comment on this

Commentators and vested interested have been making the point that the action of the previous Government in raising the rate of stamp duty on houses sold for more than £150,000 is causing a logjam in the market. I see no evidence for this. Very few first time buyers buy houses in that price range. We must look with a jaundiced eye at comments made by vested interests in the property trading business rather than give them more credence than they deserve.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 119 is deemed out of order because it involves a potential charge.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 120:

In page 103, before section 97, to insert the following new section:

97.-(1) Section 59 of the Stamp Act, 1891, is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (6):

'(7) In subsection (1) "stock, or marketable securities" does not include a share warrant issued in accordance with the provisions of section 88 of the Companies Act, 1963.'.

(2) This section shall apply to contracts or agreements for the sale of share warrants entered into on or after the 4th day of March, 1998.".

This section amends section 59 of the Stamp Act, 1891. The effect of the amendment is to make contracts for the bearer shares liable to stamp duty. Normally when shares in a company are acquired stamp duty is chargeable on the consideration paid for the shares in the same way as stamp duty is chargeable on all other transfers of property. However, by creating a class of bearer share in the company to be acquired and then shifting the value of the company into those bearer shares, stamp duty on the transfer of those shares could be avoided. This is because a document is not needed to transfer bearer shares and, as you know, stamp duty is a charge on documents. My purpose in bringing forward this amendment is to limit the attractiveness of bearer shares as a mechanism for avoiding stamp duty.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 121 has been ruled out of order as it involves a potential charge.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 122, 123 and 124 are related and are to be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:

In page 104, subsection (1)(a), lines 9 and 10, to delete "interest chargeable under".

These amendments relate to section 101 of the Bill, which reduces the rate of interest chargeable on overdue and overpaid stamp duty. Amendments Nos. 122 and 123 are purely technical. Their purpose is to ensure that the only penalties being reduced are those which relate to interest chargeable at the rate of 1.25 per cent per month or 15 per cent per annum on overdue stamp duty. Many of the sections referred to in paragraph (a) of section 101 contain penalties in addition to the penalties which I have mentioned. These amendments make it clear that these further penalties are not being amended.

Amendment No. 124 reduces the rate of interest paid on refunds of stamp duty which arise under section 112 of the Finance Act, 1990. Section 112 grants a relief from stamp duty on large new houses.

Comment on this

Is this for all overdue taxes?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

What is the rationale behind this amendment?

Comment on this

This amendment relates to the interest on overpaid stamp duty and will bring this area into line with other changes to overpaid tax. The rate of interest on under collected tax used to be 1.25 per cent per month or 15 per cent per annum and I have reduced it to 1 per cent or 12 per cent per annum. I am doing the same here, bringing this area broadly into line with what the Prompt Payments Bill has imposed on State companies, where the figure is 11.75 per cent.

Comment on this

Is that Bill published?

Comment on this

I think it is law.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Richard Bruton introduced that legislation when Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Rourke was so involved with that Bill that one would not be sure which of them brought it in.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 123:

In page 105, subsection (1), lines 1 to 12, to delete paragraph (b) and substitute the following:

"(b) Where any interest to which this subsection applies is chargeable, for any period commencing on or after the date of the passing of this Act, in respect of stamp duty due to be paid whether before, on or after such date, such interest shall be chargeable at the rate of 1 per cent per month or part of a month in the case of interest which, but for this paragraph, would be chargeable at the rate of 1.25 per cent per month or part of a month, or 15 per cent per annum, as the case may be, specified in those sections and those sections shall have effect as if the rate of 1 per cent per month or part of a month were substituted for the rate so specified.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:

In page 105, between lines 17 and 18, to insert the following subsection:

"(3) As respects any month, or part of a month, commencing on or after the date of the passing of this Act, section 112 of the Finance Act, 1990, is hereby amended-

(a) in subsection (3)(b) by the substitution for 'one per cent.' of '0.5 per cent', and

(b) in subsection (6) by the substitution for 'one per cent.' of '0.5 per cent'.".

Comment on this

Is it clear that in this case the provisions concerned are obsolete?

Comment on this

As part of tidying up the stamp duty code, I am providing for the repeal of certain obsolete and superfluous provisions which are no longer required.

Part IV refers to capital acquisitions tax and I intend to table an amendment on Report Stage which will extend the stamp duty relief available for stock lending transactions contained in section 150 of the Finance Act, 1995.

Comment on this

To what does stock lending refer?

Comment on this

Securities lending or stock lending as it is also known is a mechanism whereby securities are transferred temporarily from one party to another. Legally, the transaction involves the disposal and acquisition of stock with provisions to undertake an opposite transaction at a future point. The taxation of such transactions means charges to capital gains tax, income tax or corporation tax might arise, despite the fact that the substance of the transaction is essentially lending.

This is a stamp duty amendment which is sought by the Stock Exchange to facilitate the transaction of security lending.

Comment on this

I would hate those chaps to be unduly penalised.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 125 in the name of Deputy Noonan has been discussed with amendment No. 118.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 125:

In page 105, before section 103, but in Part 4, to insert the following new section:

"103.-(1) Subject to the provisions of subsection (2) of this section any instrument giving effect to the purchase of a dwelling-house or apartment where it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that:

(a) any person to whom this section applies has not previously been the owner of or entitled to any beneficial interest in any other dwelling-house or apartment, and

(b) any person to whom this section shall apply shall reside in the said dwelling-house or apartment as their sole or principal place of residence for a period of ten years, subject to the exemption of subsection (3) of this section, and

(c) any person who ordinarily resides in the said dwelling-house or apartment for more than 90 days in any tax year within a period of five years from the date of the instrument giving effect to the purchase shall be a person who shall have a joint beneficial interest in the dwelling-house or apartment with any other person or persons who ordinarily reside therein for more than 90 days in any tax year, except where that person is a minor child of any person ordinarily residing therein, an incapacitated person or a dependent relative within the meaning of section 466 (2) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, and

(d) that any person ordinarily residing in the dwelling-house or apartment to which paragraph (c) applies is a person to whom this section would apply if that person was a party to the instrument giving effect to the purchase of the said dwelling-house or apartment,

then any stamp duty payable on any such instrument shall be reduced by a sum equal to the amount of the stamp duty payable thereon or £6,000 whichever is the lesser subject to the provisions of subsection (6) of this section.

(2) For the purpose of determining whether this section shall apply to any instrument, the Revenue Commissioners may require the delivery to them, in such form as they may specify, of a statement or statutory declaration by-

(a) any person directly or indirectly concerned with any instrument giving effect to the purchase of the dwelling-house or apartment, and

(b) any solicitor acting on behalf of any person to whom paragraph (a) or subsection (1)(c) and/or (d) applies,

of any facts which the Revenue Commissioner consider relevant in the making of any such determination. The provisions of section 5 of the Stamp Act, 1891, shall apply except that the provisions of subsection (3)(i) thereof shall be construed as if the sum of '£1,000' was deleted and the words 'a sum equal to the stamp duty payable on the instrument was inserted' therefor.

(3) The relief shall cease to be applicable to the instrument giving effect to the purchase of the dwelling-house or apartment if the said dwelling-house or apartment is sold or compulsorily acquired within a period of ten years after the date of the instrument giving effect to the purchase and is not replaced within a period of one year of the sale or compulsory acquisition by another property to which the provisions of subsection (1) would apply if the replacement property and the property sold or compulsorily acquired were deemed to be the same property.

(4) In the event of a dwelling-house or apartment or any replacement property ceasing to quality at any time during the period of 10 years any person to whom subsection (2) shall apply shall notify the Revenue Commissioners by filing a return to the Revenue Commissioners in such form as they may from time to time prescribe within 30 days of such an event occurring. The date upon which the instrument shall be liable to tax shall be the date upon which the event occurs.

(5) For the purpose of this section a principal private residence shall be a dwelling-houses or apartment to which the provisions of section 604 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997 applies.

(6) The Minister for Finance may be regulations restrict the relief in this section to such dwelling-houses or apartments by reference to floor area, location or situation as may be prescribed from time to time.".

Comment on this

The following Members are recorded as dissenting: Deputies Coveney, McDowell and Rabbitte.

SECTION 103.

Comment on this

With regard to capital acquisitions tax, charges arise when one member of a cohabiting couple dies. They are treated as strangers and a full charge of inheritance tax applies. Will the Minister consider introducing relief in this regard in the future?

Comment on this

I must declare a personal interest in the issue the Deputy raises because I have been cohabiting with another person for many years. In the event of death I will be caught by the existing capital acquisitions tax provisions.

I have not tabled amendments in this regard because it is a complex matter and finding an amendment to deal with the problem which would be in line with Irish law and the Constitution has proved difficult. There are a number of substantial problems, including difficulties with definition, which have been identified in attempting to provide a general relief or exemption from capital acquisitions tax treatment of cohabiting couples. Any extension of the married treatment for capital tax purposes would involve recognising relationships in the tax code which are not recognised in the context of general law. In general, it is not appropriate for tax law to pre-empt general law.

On account of my circumstances I have steered away from the matter in case I would be seen as engaging in special pleading. However, I recognise it is a serious problem, although I am not sure how it might be tackled in Irish law.

Comment on this

The Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs has found a way to define it.

Comment on this

When I was Minister for Social Welfare the then Minister for Finance, now the Taoiseach, was asked regularly why the tax code did not coincide with social welfare code. I do not know how the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs gets around the matter. There are difficulties in the taxation which are not as amenable to change.

Comment on this

I tabled amendment No. 27 to the personal income tax provisions which was taken from the social welfare provision. It states:

For the purpose of income tax assessment, married persons shall mean-

(a) a man and woman who are married to each other, or

(b) a man and woman who are not married to each other but are cohabiting as man and wife.

That is how the social welfare code deals with the matter. Predecessors of the Minister promised that in the wake of the divorce referendum this matter would be tidied up. It is unsatisfactory and is hard to defend a situation in which the State has one view when giving money and another when taking money.

Comment on this

That is precisely the problem. It is a matter with which officials in the Department of Finance and others have been wrestling for some time. It is a serious problem.

Comment on this

Perhaps identifying a period of cohabitation prior to death might help in the definition.

Comment on this

We will look at that matter but there are many complexities associated with it. I will consider the matter further before next year's Finance Bill, now that I have declared my interest. We must find a solution to the problem.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 126:

In page 106, before section 104, to insert the following new section:

104.-(1) Section 117 of the Finance Act, 1993, is hereby amended-

(a) in paragraph (b), by the substitution of 'one per cent.' for 'one and one-quarter per cent', and

(b) in paragraph (c), by the substitution of 'one per cent'. for 'one and one-quarter per cent'.

(2) This section shall have effect in relation to probate tax due before, on or after the date of the passing of this Act where the period in respect of which interest is to be charged, or a discount falls to be made, commences on or after that date.".

This section reduces the rate of interest charged on overdue probate tax from 1.25 per cent per month or part of a month to 1 per cent per month or part of a month.

Comment on this

Since people may not seek a grant of probate immediately they may get into serious delay innocently. In the experience of the Revenue Commissioners is there a high incidence of delay and do they use their discretion to waive the charges in cases of delay?

Comment on this

How soon do the penalties take effect?

Comment on this

Where the general requirement to pay probate tax before probate or letters of administration is granted may pose an obligation on the executor or administrator to borrow funds to pay the tax, a discount is allowed for early payment. The discount applies where the tax is paid at least one month before the commencement of the interest charge, which is nine months after the date of death, and will amount to 1 per cent of the tax due for every full month prior to this commencement date. Thus, if the tax is paid four months prior to the commencement charge, that is within five months of the date of death, a discount of four per cent will be allowed for. The discount system was introduced to compensate for the cost of interest charged on money borrowed to pay probate tax. It is a carrot and stick approach.

Comment on this

Unlike most other cases people are often unaware of the need to pay probate tax. They may not extract a grant of probate for some years and they may find themselves in paying interest. The tax is relatively new. Do the Revenue Commissioners have a general power to discount it if they wish or not to charge the interest? Is it used frequently.

Comment on this

There are hardship provisions which allow the Revenue Commissioners to do that. In the event of liquidity problems they can exercise discretion.

Comment on this

Is non-payment of probate tax not an impediment to title? Does one inherit even if one does not discharge the probate?

Comment on this

Yes, one does but the difficulty is that because one does not need to prove title unless in the case of remortgaging or selling, one may not chose to change the name on the title for some years if that is the only asset. A grant of probate may not be extracted for some years after the death.

Comment on this

I presume this situation applies to all these capital taxes. From the State's viewpoint it remains as a charge on the property. They are self-collecting.

Comment on this

I was under the impression that until the probate issued one did not inherit.

Comment on this

That could not be so, because with grants, administration and probate, they are not taken out for many years. A person would be entitled to that particular property, but if her or she wanted to effect the Title or wanted to sell the property, other inheritance tax would have to be paid.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 127:

In page 107, subsection (1), line 8, after "section 36(2)" to insert "in respect of the gift or inheritance in relation to which the decision or assessment is made".

This is a purely technical amendment. Section 105 of the Bill inserts a new section to the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act, 1976, which ensures that a person who is aggrieved by a decision or assessment of Revenue must deliver a self-assessment return and pay tax in accordance with that return before being allowed to appeal against that decision or assessment. The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that the self-assessment return which the appellant must deliver before being allowed to appeal relates to the gift or inheritance under appeal and not to any other gift or inheritance.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 128 and 129 are related and will be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment 128:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 5, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 127 of the Finance Act, 1994, is hereby amended by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (6):

'(6) To the extent that property of a company ("the first company") or a business ("the first business") are used wholly or mainly by an associated company ("the second company") or another business ("the second business"), such property shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to be owned by the second company or the second business in determining whether such property consists of a business or an interest in a business or shares in or securities of a company which will qualify under the provisions of this section.'.".

These proposals relate to the transfer of family businesses and provide for the more complex structures now in existence. The proposals are generally dealt with, as of now, by concessionery arrangements with Revenue. This amendment will give effect to what is general practice.

Comment on this

This amendment is apparently intended to ensure that business relief is not denied to a subsidiary company whose assets consist of property and/or inter-company loans which are used by other trading companies, within the same group, for the purposes of their trade. The business of such a company would not be excluded from relief under section 133 of the Finance Act, 1994, since an exception is made in that section for companies whose business consists wholly or mainly in the holding of land or buildings wholly or mainly occupied by members of the group which are trading companies. Neither would the assets of such a company be excluded from relief under the heading of "expected assets" provided they are used for the purposes of the trade carried on by the trading subsidiaries.

If I understand the amendment correctly, the situation envisaged by the Deputy would qualify for business relief as the legislation stands.

Comment on this

It is not a matter of concession?

Comment on this

No. Accordingly, I must oppose the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 130:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 5, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 19(5)(a)(ii) of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act, 1976 is hereby amended by the addition after the words 'agricultural property' of the words 'or within such other periods of time as the Revenue Commissioners shall in the particular circumstances determine to be reasonable'.".

This relates to the compulsory purchase of agricultural land. At present only one year is allowed for reinvestment. In other words, if someone's agricultural land is compulsorily acquired and if they do not reinvest in an alternative farm within a year they could have a very serious tax liability. Some people could have difficulty in meeting that deadline and this amendment seeks to give the Revenue more time where they feel that is fair and reasonable.

Comment on this

A sale of agricultural property within ten years after the taking of a gift or inheritance may result in a clawback of agricultural relief if it is not replaced by other agricultural property within one year of the date of the sale. This amendment is intended to ensure that the clawback will not arise if the reinvestment takes place after one year of the sale but within a reasonable period of the sale as determined by Revenue.

The Revenue inform me that they are not aware of any case where this one year period has caused a problem but in any event it would be very unsatisfactory to give the Revenue a discretion in this matter as it would mean that there could never be any certainty as to whether any particular sale resulted in the clawback. No case has come to the attention of Revenue where this has been a problem.

Comment on this

If somebody in good faith was seeking actively to reacquire another farm in a situation where they had a compulsory purchase order, it would seem reasonable that the Revenue would take that into account.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners have discretion in a hardship case to look at a matter such as that. I assure the Deputy that if anything comes to light between now and next year's Finance Bill I will again look at it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 131:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 5, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 19 of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act, 1976, is hereby amended in the definition of 'agricultural value' by the deletion of 90 per cent and the substitution therefor of 100 per cent.".

Amendments Nos. 131 and 134 are related and I will speak to both amendments.

The amendments relate to capital acquisitions tax. In recent years successive budgets have provided for an encouragement of the transfer of farms and businesses. In the 1997 budget 90 per cent of the value of a farm or business fell out for the purpose of establishing capital acquisitions tax. It would be consistent to increase that to 100 per cent for both farms and businesses. Because of the difficulty of transferring businesses from generation to generation, particularly farms where the age cohort is still extremely unfavourable and very high, anything we can do to encourage young farmers to persuade their parents to hand over farms without the payment of substantial sums of money is something to be desired. The same would apply to family businesses. That is the purpose of amendments Nos. 131 and 134.

Comment on this

The purpose of this amendment is to exempt from mainstream capital acquisitions tax all gifts and inheritances of agricultural property taken by farmers. Deputy Noonan has put down similar amendments in relation to business assets and probate tax.

My predecessor as Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, increased agricultural relief from 30 per cent for land and buildings on amounts over £250,000 and 25 per cent for livestock and machinery, to a flat 90 per cent over his term of office.

At this stage, although there is no significant cost involved, for broad equity reasons 100 per cent agricultural relief for mainstream capital acquisitions tax would not be appropriate. Under the existing relief a farmer can transfer a farm worth approximately £2 million to a child free of mainstream capital acquisitions tax. Accordingly, I oppose the amendment.

There is a certain logic in what Deputy Coveney says. If we have gone so far with capital acquisitions tax regarding business relief, why not go the whole way? There should be some capital acquisitions tax liable to be paid by some farmers and businesses on the transfer of assets. If Deputies Coveney and Noonan want to suggest that we do away with all these capital acquisitions taxes, I do not think for broad reasons of equity it would be appropriate to go further than 90 per cent. The reliefs that the former Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, introduced are very generous. I do not know if the Labour Party's current finance spokesman is as generous in his thoughts on this matter, but the reliefs are there now and I have no plans to change them.

Comment on this

I recall that the Minister asked last year why it was not done away with altogether rather than introduce relief rates of 90 per cent. There is logic in abolishing it. I will not press the amendment, but I would like my dissent put on the record.

Comment on this

Deputy Coveney will be recorded as dissenting.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 132 introduces a new section. Amendments Nos. 133, 135 and 136 are related and may be taken together, by agreement. Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 132:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 5, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 109 of the Finance Act, 1993 is hereby amended in the definition of 'agricultural value' by the deletion of the words 'reduced by 30 per cent of that value' and the substitution therefor of 'as determined by section 19 of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act, 1976'.".

These are similar measures in relation to probate tax on agricultural land and businesses. At the moment the market value on agricultural land and businesses is discounted by 30 per cent for probate tax purposes. We are suggesting that following the capital acquisition tax changes of last year, we should substitute 90 per cent for 30 per cent for the same reasons, to facilitate the handing on of farms and assets without having to sell in order to pay the probate tax.

Comment on this

As Deputy Coveney has said, for probate tax purposes the value of agricultural land is reduced by 30 per cent. The intention of these amendments is to increase the reduction to 90 per cent and extend it to livestock and machinery. This proposal fails to take into account the whole basis of probate tax, which is to apply a small charge to the majority of estates. It would be inconsistent in approach to except whole categories of assets from the charge. It is difficult to see the argument that the application of a charge of 2 per cent can have anything but the most minimal impact on the transfer of a farm from one generation to the next.

If there are insufficient liquid assets in the estate to meet the tax, the Revenue Commissioners are empowered to postpone payment for such a period and upon such terms as they think fit. It is also possible to insure against liability by taking out a section 60 policy, the proceeds of which will be exempt from all capital acquisitions tax, including probate tax. The cost of this proposal would be £6 million in the full year. Accordingly I am opposing the amendments.

Comment on this

I do not feel as strongly about this as I do about the amendment concerned with CAT.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 134:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 6, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 126 of the Finance Act, 1994, is hereby amended by the deletion of '90 per cent' and the substitution therefor of '100 per cent'.".

Comment on this

Deputy Coveney will be recorded as dissenting.

Comment on this

That disposes of Parts 4 and 5 of the Bill, covering sections 96 to 105. We will now consider Part 6.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 137:

In page 107, before section 106, but in Part 6, to insert the following new section:

"106.-Section 905(2)(b) of the Principal Act is hereby repealed.".

This amendment is not as innocent as it looks. I accept it is a blunt instrument, as was one of the amendments I tabled yesterday. It seeks to remove from that section of the Principal Act the exemption which banks have from the requirement to disclose information to the Revenue Commissioners if they ask for it. The Revenue Commissioners have a general power under section 905 of the Taxes Consolidation Act to require individuals, bodies, institutions and companies to provide them with information. It is a very general power but there is a specific exemption in the section as it relates to banks. The Minister will know this arises out of recent controversies where the Revenue Commissioners had some difficulty in requiring the disclosure of particular information unless they already knew account numbers or the names of account holders.

The Minister made some interesting remarks when he responded to questions on Tuesday indicating that he was considering changing the law to give a greater controlling power to the Revenue in specific circumstances. I would like to see the Revenue requiring banks to disclose information in circumstances where there was a prima facie case that a particular product or scam was being operated by a credit institution, specifically a bank. In anticipation of the Minster’s rejection of this amendment, I invite him to explain in greater detail the changes to which he referred in response to questions on Tuesday and on which he was prevented from elaborating as we ran out of time. We can use this opportunity to elaborate on what he might have said on Tuesday.

Comment on this

Section 905 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, gives to authorised officers of the Revenue Commissioners the power to visit business premises to conduct an audit or investigation. The power extends to the examination of books and records of the business on the premises, the search for them or their removal for further examination. The power does not extend to premises where banking business is carried on. In relation to the audit of a professional person there is a prohibition on access to client files. The prohibition on outdoor audit of banks is in section 905(2)(d), not (b) as suggested in the amendment.

When this power was first provided by the then Minister for Finance, Mr. Richie Ryan, in the Finance Act, 1976, he advised the House that "the exclusion of banking business was done deliberately in order to remove any possibility of a suggestion being made that there was an invasion of the confidential relationship between banker and customer".

I believe successive Governments have generally subscribed to this point of view. Nonetheless I acknowledge that, in the light of recent events, a serious review of Revenue's powers in relation to banks is required.

As I have made clear on a number of occasions, I have asked the Revenue Commissioners and my Department to review the adequacy of Revenue powers generally following the report of the McCracken tribunal. I would not rule out new provisions if they were shown to be necessary, for example, for financial institutions to report to Revenue where they become aware that financial products sold by them may facilitate tax evasion, or to notify Revenue where funds have been transferred, in certain circumstances, to or from particular offshore locations. There may also be new powers for Revenue to access bank accounts where there are reasonable grounds to believe that certain accounts are, or may be, used for tax evasion.

Under the current tax code Revenue can apply to the High Court or to the Appeal Commissioners for an order to access the bank account of a named individual. Before putting forward proposals it will be necessary to have all the relevant information from the series of inquiries under way. The Moriarty tribunal is specifically charged with making recommendations in the areas of banking supervision, the protection of the revenues of the State and offshore accounts. Any proposals put forward will need to be carefully considered to ensure that they will be effective, could not be circumvented, would not needlessly disrupt the affairs of law abiding citizens and would be proportionate in their effect on the financial sector when measured against the problem to be tackled.

Any responsible Government would need to have as much information as possible by way of answer to these issues before it acted. Indeed as part of that information gathering process officials from my Department and Revenue are visiting the tax administrations of other European countries to establish best practice on the question of the balance between bank secrecy and Revenue's right of access to bank accounts.

To accept Deputy McDowell's amendment at this juncture would be premature and irresponsible. I have no intention of being either. Therefore I reject this amendment.

Comment on this

I am interested in what the Minister said. He outlines, fairly succinctly, three different cases in which he is considering additional powers. I strongly urge him to give the Revenue Commissioners additional powers in the instances he has mentioned. I accept the Minister's point that we should await the outcome of inquiries and I take the assurances he has given the committee and which he gave the Dáil on Tuesday as being given in good faith. In view of these assurances I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 138, 140 and 141 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Amendment No. 138, in the name of the Minister for Finance, involves the insertion of a new section. The new section, section 107, repeals a credit union provision on DIRT and disclosure of dividends. The acceptance of this amendment will involve the deletion of the existing section 107. Amendment No. 140, in the name of Deputy Noonan, is an alternative to amendment No. 138. Amendment No. 140 proposes lines 7 to 14 of the existing section 107. However, by agreeing to insert the new section 107, the committee has accepted the principle of deleting the existing section 107. Amendment No. 140, therefore, cannot be moved because it refers to the existing section 107. A similar situation arises in relation to amendment No. 141 in the names of Deputies Noonan and Flanagan because it is another alternative to amendment No. 138. Amendment No. 141 proposes to insert a new sub-paragraph to the existing section 107. Again, since the committee has accepted the principle of deleting the existing section 107, amendment No. 141 cannot be moved because it relates to the existing section 107.

Comment on this

That leaves me to oppose the section after the hard work my colleagues did all night drafting the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 138:

In page 108, before section 107, to insert the following new section:

107.-(1) The Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, is hereby amended-

(a) in section 256(1), by the substitution of the following paragraph for paragraph (a) of the definition of 'appropriate tax':

'(a) in the case of a relevant deposit or relevant deposits held in a special savings account, at the rate of 20 per cent, and',

and

(b) in section 891, by the insertion of the following subsection after subsection (1):

'(1A) (a) In this subsection, "credit union" means a society registered under the Credit Union Act 1997, including a society deemed to be so registered under section 5(3) of that Act.

(b) This section shall not apply in relation to any interest paid or credited by a credit union in respect of money received or retained by it.

(2) (a) Paragraph (a) of subsection (1) shall apply as on and from the 6th day of April, 1998.

(b) Paragraph (b) of subsection (1) shall apply as respects chargeable periods (within the meaning of section 321(2) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997) beginning on or after the 1st day of October, 1997.".

Comment on this

I am not sure that your ruling is correct, Chairman. You seem to be saying that we cannot move the Opposition amendments if the Minister's amendment is accepted. The Minister's amendment has not yet been accepted.

Comment on this

The Minister has moved his amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister may have changed his mind on this matter. He may wish to go back to the status quo.

Comment on this

This amendment relates to what was certainly one of the most - if not the most - discussed items in the Finance Bill. The amendment gives effect to the agreement I entered into with the League of Credit Unions in our meeting on 16 February last, that the proposals to impose DIRT on credit union deposit interest and to require reporting of credit union dividend income above £500 would be deleted from the Bill.

In addition, as also agreed, provision is being made to remove the requirement of credit unions to report interest payments in excess of £500.

It was also agreed that a working group will be set up with the league under an independent chairperson to examine the taxation of returns on credit union savings bearing in mind the special and particular nature of the credit union movement, their contribution to society and the wider taxation issues involved. The working group will report its findings to me by 30 September 1998.

My Department is currently undertaking consultations with the Irish League of Credit Unions regarding composition of the working group and a suitable chairperson. I am satisfied that these proposals will offer a reasonable basis for addressing the issue of credit unions taxation.

Interest and dividends received by credit union members was and continues to be taxable and must be included on their returns of income.

The date on which the report is due is also my birthday. If I forget the credit unions I will be unlikely to forget my birthday. I will celebrate both accordingly.

Comment on this

We should congratulate the Minister. He has recognised the valuable role which the credit union movement plays. Now that he is recanting so fulsomely and disarmingly, he may wish to tell us what provoked him to bring in these provisions in the first place.

Comment on this

I have gone over this on many occasions. Money in credit unions may be in share accounts or deposit interest accounts. For a number of years credit union interest on deposits above £500 was required to be reported to the Revenue Commissioners. Some credit unions did not distinguish between one type of account and another and have reported both. Many were surprised to discover, during the recent controversy, that they were not obliged to report dividend income. This was true of some of the largest credit unions.

The deputation from the Irish League of Credit Unions asked me to address three matters. I received a request to meet the League in December. I replied that there was no point in meeting them because I did not intend making any change which would affect them in the Finance Bill, 1998. They, nevertheless, wanted to meet me. They put some ideas to me. They wanted the corporations profit tax exemption to continue. This was necessary because the old exemption referred to the old Credit Union Act, 1966. They wanted DIRT imposed on interest on credit union deposit accounts. People do not often come to the Department of Finance to express a desire to pay tax. It would solve many problems if they did. The imposition of DIRT made sense to the representatives of the League. Interest on credit union deposits must be declared on one's tax return and is taxed at the marginal rate. To pay DIRT at the new rate would benefit credit union members. The standard DIRT rate will be 24 per cent after 6 April and the Irish League of Credit Unions submitted that this would be of benefit to its members. When one pays DIRT, that is the end of the tax liability. That type of interest must be returned on one's account but it is not subject to marginal relief. The Irish League of Credit Unions wanted that provision.

It also wanted a revised approach to the limit on shares. In a period of ten weeks, it put forward three different proposals. After the meeting in December, it wrote to me seeking an exemption threshold on £15,000 worth of shares. If one had in excess of £15,000 worth of shares in a credit union account, the league suggested the dividend above £15,000 would be subject to a new retention tax. It subsequently changed this proposal to a different figure on the Tuesday in the week the Finance Bill was published. When it held a press conference on the Friday of that week, it changed the figure again.

I thought in my innocence that if there was a £500 reportage requirement in relation to credit union interest in any event, why impose further complicated tax measures on dividend shares. The league told me on the basis of its figures that 90 per cent of the total money invested in credit unions is in the form of shares and only 10 per cent is in the form of deposit interest accounts. The 1990 figures show that £150 million was invested in deposit accounts while £1.35 billion was invested in shares. The figures changed in 1996 to reflect a bigger amount of money but that is the approximate ratio.

Of the 90 per cent invested in credit union shares, approximately 1 per cent involves people who have in excess of £10,000 to £11,000. I thought, given that in excess of £500 was reported in relation to credit union interest in any event, the same reportage requirement should be introduced for dividends and no new tax should be imposed. On the basis of the league's figures, I thought it would only affect 1 per cent of credit union members. I considered this would be of benefit to them rather than introducing another tax - although the league wanted another tax in that area - and that was the basis of my original proposals.

It was obvious to me from the coverage on the Thursday evening, Friday and Saturday that the majority of the commentators did not understand the basis of the credit union movement. It was also my view that the majority of credit union members thought the imposition of DIRT would apply to everything. However, that was not the case. It would only have applied to deposit interest, a move which was requested by the Irish League of Credit Unions. Deputy Rabbitte had dealings with the credit union movement in another sphere and it probably did not surprise him that there was such confusion. However, it surprised me. I have a good sense of humour and I recall being in Kildare when this broke. I did not know what was happening in Dublin. My office rang me but I could not stop laughing.

Comment on this
A Deputy

I would say there was great hilarity in the Taoiseach's Office.

Comment on this

I do not think there was great hilarity in other Departments. However, I saw the funny side of it. This either proves that I am weird or other people are weird. It must be the first time in the history of the State that during a Finance Bill a Minister went out of his way to help an organisation by introducing a change, which he thought it wanted, and was pilloried from Malin Head to Caherciveen for doing so. The only matter on which I and the league disagreed was the third proposal and I considered that my approach was much simpler.

I learned many things from this experience, as I stated in reply to parliamentary questions in the House recently. The first is that one should not assume journalists and commentators know anything about what one is discussing. The second is that one should not assume that a representative organisation really speaks for its members. The third is that one should be aware of Greeks bearing gifts.

There was no intention to make this a revenue raising measure. On balance, the opposite would be the case. A sum of £2 million in DIRT payments would be paid, but if everybody returns deposit interest and some of their tax at the higher rate, the position would be neutral. The idea was not put forward by me. The former Minister, Deputy Quinn, had much going for him when he announced that he would not meet any groups before he introduced his first budget in 1995. I will bear this very much in mind in future. If I have any more dealings with the credit union movement, I intend to bring along Deputy Rabbitte. His knowledge of dealings with it will stand to us for many years.

Comment on this

I am reluctant to give advice to the Minister, but he has not acknowledged that there is a compliance problem. I suspect a significant number of people who receive dividend income from credit union shares do not return it for income tax purposes. This reality in addition to the theory must be addressed.

Comment on this

I am glad Deputy McDowell raised that point. I may have referred to it briefly in an interview which took place during those three great days. The previous week everybody had been discussing evasion, but the first time anything was done about it, all hell broke loose. There appears to be a psychological problem about that in Ireland. Deputy McDowell does not suffer from it because his comments have been fair. However, people are against tax evasion as long as it does not relate to them. When the debate moves on and writers and commentators have time to think about it, they will realise how ridiculous some of the propositions they put forward over four weeks appear. I suspect much of the commentary and hullabaloo about this matter was related to the person who introduced the measure rather than the measure itself. Insufficient critical analysis was carried out by some commentators before they went off half cocked about it.

Comment on this

The Minister should be careful about being paranoid. We must acknowledge in relation to dividend income that credit union shares are not the same as shares in anything else. Due to the peculiar structure of credit unions, if people want to join they will generally buy shares before they go beyond the £30,000 limit. Therefore, their primary income from their membership of the credit union is by way of dividend income which is chargeable at the rate of income tax. If we acknowledge the special position of credit unions, we must consider whether it is appropriate to place charges on dividend income on credit union shares in the same way as charges on dividend income are placed on all other shares. I do not consider that is appropriate.

Comment on this

That matter can be discussed by the working group. I was aware before this issue arose that there are different types of credit unions. Deputy Rabbitte is also aware of this. A large number of credit unions have assets in excess of £40 million and put forward the case that they should become banks. They are big organisations and want to progress. However, credit unions in other parts of the country deal with a totally different market. The Irish League of Credit Unions must address this point. Unfortunately, I was dragged into the mire in this regard. This thing never ceases to be funny. I had not concluded an agreement with the Irish League of Credit Unions on the Monday night after the whole hullabaloo, when I received letters from a credit unions disassociating themselves from the vitriolic campaign by the Irish League of Credit Unions and urging me to stick with my original proposals. Not only did I receive letters from individual credit union members exhorting me in that direction, but I received letters from the boards of credit unions exhorting me in that fashion. Had I spoken to my good friend, Deputy Rabbitte, I would have known that, because he must have learned that during the course of the debate on the Credit Union Act, 1997. Unfortunately, I was not so well informed. Hopefully, I will not make the same mistake again.

Comment on this

I attended a number of annual conferences of the credit union movement, including a special conference in Limerick to consider the provisions of that Act. The first thing I saw on entry to an assembly of 900 delegates was a heart ambulance parked at the door. At that stage, I felt I should pay very careful regard to whatever I had to say.

There is a minor, but important, provision in the Credit Union Act, 1997, which permits the development of community enterprise in the local area of the credit union. It is quite important to make the point that a shareholding in a credit union is different to a shareholding in Allied Irish Banks PLC, etc. We have probably paid too little attention to that area of fostering community development, which has taken off in recent years, stimulated to some extent by funds which were available through various EU schemes.

It is a good thing to encourage people who have some disposable income to invest it in shares in their credit union for the development of local enterprise, etc., and that factor ought to be taken into account when the working group is considering the question.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 139:

In page 108, before section 107, to insert the following new section:

"107.-Section 212 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion after '1978,' of 'or Part II of the Credit Union Act, 1997,'.".

Frankly, I do not know what this amendment is about.

Comment on this

I cannot accept Deputy McDowell's amendment because it is unnecessary. I appreciate his motive in wanting to ensure the correct references in the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, to credit unions, having regard to the Credit Union Act, 1997. However, I would point out that section 45 of the Bill achieves what the Deputy is seeking as well as relocating the exemption from tax for income of credit unions in the corporation tax chapter of Part 7 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which Part deals with exemption from tax.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 142:

In page 109, before section 108, to insert the following new section:

"108.-Section 823 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the substitution in subsection (2)(a)(ii) of the following for clause (I):

(I) an employment, the emoluments of which are paid out of the revenue of the State, except emoluments in respect of services provided outside the State on peace-keeping missions under the aegis of the United Nations, or'.".

As the Minister will be aware, the relief from income tax for persons who are out of the country for 90 days excludes all employees of the State. We are proposing here that it should be applied to those who are involved in peace-keeping under the aegis of the United Nations. We think that would be a recognition of their work and an encouragement to them also.

Comment on this

As Deputy Coveney stated, this is just in recognition of public servants who contribute to peace-keeping. We have always received very positive feedback from peace-keepers who have contributed greatly to the country.

This puts them on a level footing with those in the private sector who are catered for by section 823 of the Principal Act.

Comment on this

I appreciate the purpose behind the amendment. I know that Deputy Timmins speaks from personal experience, having recently been a member of the Defence Forces. I do not think this amendment is necessary.

The amendment relates to the foreign earnings deduction which provides for a deduction from income for tax purposes for time spent on the duties of an employment outside the State. To qualify an individual must be out for at least 90 days in a year made up of absences of at least 14 consecutive days at a time. The deduction is generous, based directly on the time spent abroad. Thus, an individual who is absent for six months would be entitled to a deduction of 50 per cent of his or her income.

The foreign earnings deduction does not apply to the employees in the public sector or to employees of State boards or authorities. The amendment seeks to make an exception to this exclusion for individuals who go abroad on UN peace-keeping missions.

The foreign earnings deduction is aimed at persons going overseas for significant periods, many to developing countries, for the purposes of selling Irish goods and services such as consultancy services. It is, therefore, focused entirely on the private sector, providing an incentive for firms to exploit new markets and expand Irish business and employment.

The extension of the deduction to individuals on peace-keeping duties would involve a total departure from the original objectives of the measure. Peace-keeping personnel are paid by the State and have the option to volunteer for, or refuse participation in, such missions. While abroad, these personnel are compensated through various allowances which are paid tax-free.

If the deduction were given to peace-keeping personnel as proposed, all other areas of the Civil Service and the public sector generally would have valid grounds for seeking their inclusion. Any such wider extension would be very costly, given the generous nature of the deduction. It would also totally change the character of the relief from the targeted measure which it represents at present. For these reasons I cannot accept the amendment.

The foreign earnings deductions were introduced in the Finance Act, 1994, to compensate individuals who must spend a great deal of their time abroad on trade missions or consultancy service. It was a worthwhile measure at the time, but to extend it now to other areas would completely go against the spirit of what it was introduced to achieve.

People in the public sector generally are queuing up to go on these foreign missions. There is no lack of incentive for them to take them up. They want to do it. I cannot agree to the amendment.

Comment on this

Did the Minister cost the extension of the measure if it was to be extended to those on peace-keeping duties?

To take up the Minister's last point, I am sure the Minister knows that in the case of the Defence Forces' duty in the Lebanon, for example, it is increasingly difficult to get people to go on those tours and there have actually been shortages of personnel. As the Minister will be aware, many people are doing back to back tours abroad from six to 18 months at a time. The situation is a little difficult.

For obvious reasons we need a range of confidence building initiatives for the Defence Forces at present. I would be interested in the Minister's view on this and the cost involved. Is it inevitable that the measure would be extended if it was granted to the Defence Forces? Does he see it leading to an inevitable knock on effect in other areas? Perhaps he would state the areas in which that would occur.

Comment on this

I recognise the Deputy has a great interest in this particular matter and any matter related to the Defence Forces, not least because she is the Opposition spokesperson on that matter but also due to her family background.

I have represented the Kildare constituency now for nearly 21 years. Most of the Army vote is in Kildare South so I no longer represent them. I have found the opposite during my political career - people want to go on these peacekeeping missions and there is no problem getting them to volunteer. However, if the Deputy has other information I am willing to look at the matter.

I do not think that the granting of a foreign earnings deduction allowance to the Defence Forces would increase people's desire to go on missions abroad, if that is the intention behind the measure. Defence personnel who go abroad are given generous tax free sums. I do not have the cost of that but it would be small in the context of the overall budget. As other Ministers for Finance have found, if one gives relief in one area on the basis that it will be the last time it will be sought, before the next budget someone else will look for it and it is impossible to justify not giving it, a head of steam builds up behind the relief, politicians are lobbied - which is a legitimate thing to do - election time comes around, parties promise it in their manifesto and it continues to spiral. For that reason, if for no other, I cannot agree to the amendment.

Comment on this

Members wishing to be recorded as dissenting please raise their hands.

Deputies Timmins, Fitzgerald, Coveney and McDowell raised their hands.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 143 to 146, inclusive, are related and may be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 143:

In page 109, line 14, to delete "section 10" and substitute "section 10(1)".

These amendments seek to amend section 108 which contains enabling provisions to allow the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform to make regulations requiring solicitors or barristers on free legal aid panels to hold tax clearance certificates. Amendment No. 143 is a technical amendment to correct an incorrect reference. Amendments Nos. 144 and 145 are technical amendments to include within the tax clearance procedure any statutory instrument made under the Tax Acts, the Capital Gains Tax Acts and the Value Added Tax Act, 1972. While section 108 as it stands allows for the making of a requirement to have a tax clearance certificate, it does not provide an explicit sanction against a solicitor or barrister in the event of non-compliance with that requirement. Amendment No. 146 corrects this possible lacuna by ensuring that the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform can provide for the deletion from the free legal aid panels of the name of a solicitor or barrister who fails to comply with a requirement to furnish a tax clearance. The amendment is advisable lest it be argued that the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform does not have this right.

Comment on this

I have never been on a free legal aid panel so I do not have a direct interest but Members will know I am a solicitor, although I am not practising. I have no problem with this amendment or the original provision. However, the profession would be more given to accept this with alacrity if payments of fees due under the free legal aid scheme were made remotely close to the time they were incurred. I am not sure whether the Minister has any brief in relation to that but until recently there were lengthy delays in paying solicitors and barristers who worked under the scheme.

Comment on this

Why were they excluded in the first place when this applies to everyone else working for the State sector, including the medical profession?

Comment on this

It simply was not done. The requirement of a tax clearance certificate was extended over a number of years and there may have been a reason for that. I have been advised about this - perhaps we could go into private session to allow the experts to explain it.

Comment on this

Is that agreed? Agreed.

The Select Committee went into private session at 3.45 p.m. and the public session resumed at 3.46 p.m.

Comment on this

In response to Deputy McDowell, I am aware that over the years there have been difficulties getting payments from the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform but efforts are being made to clear up that matter. I am not briefed as to the current state of play.

Comment on this

It is not solely a matter of self-interest for the individuals concerned because it is important for the proper operation of the scheme that people should be properly remunerated and in good time. It is also important that good barristers and solicitors offer to work on the scheme.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 144:

In page 109, line 29, after "Act" to insert "(and any instruments made under those Acts)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 145:

In page 109, line 49, after "Act" to insert "(and any instruments made under those Acts)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 146:

In page 110, line 3, after "Collector-General" to insert the following:

"(within the meaning aforesaid),

(f) matters consequential on, or incidental to, a requirement or condition prescribed under paragraph (d) or (e) of this subsection (which may include a provision enabling the deletion from any list kept pursuant to regulations under this subsection of the name of a solicitor or barrister who has failed to comply with a requirement prescribed under the said paragraph (d)).".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 147:

In page 110, before section 109, to insert the following new section:

"109.-(1) In this section-

'appropriate percentage' in relation to a year of assessment, means a percentage equal to the standard rate of tax for that year;

'qualifying expenses' in relation to an individual means the amount paid by an individual for specified services;

'specified services' in relation to a year of assessment, means such services as shall be specified, for the preceding year of assessment, by regulations made by the Minister for Finance.

(2) Where an individual for a year of assessment proves that in the year preceding the year of assessment-

(a) the individual, or

(b) if the individual is a married person assessed to tax in accordance with section 1017 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, the individual's spouse has made a payment for a specified service, then, the income tax to be charged on the individual if the individual made the payment, or on the individual's spouse, if the individual's spouse made the payment, for the year of assessment, other than in accordance with section 16(2), shall be reduced by an amount which is the lesser of-

(i) an amount equal to the appropriate percentage of the full amount of the payment, or

(ii) the amount not to exceed £250 in the case of an individual assessed to tax under section 1017 of the aforementioned Act or is a widow or widower and in any other case £125, and

(iii) the amount which reduces that income tax to nil.

(3) Where the income tax reduction of one of the spouses is ascertained in accordance with subsection (2) then-

(a) if there is no income tax to be charged on the spouse for the year of assessment, other than in accordance with section 16(2), in relation to which relief under subsection (2) may be given, the relief may be given in relation to income tax charged on the other spouse for that year, other than in accordance with section 16(2), and

(b) if the amount so ascertained exceeds the income tax to be charged on the spouse for the year of assessment, other than in accordance with section 16(2), the excess may be used to reduce the income tax to be charged on the other spouse for that year, other than in accordance with section 16(2).

(4) Where relief is given under this section, no relief or deduction under any other provision of the Income Tax Acts shall be given or allowed in respect of the payment or part payment, as the case may be.

(5) For the purposes of determining whether the provisions of subsection (2) shall apply an Inspector of Taxes may require the delivery to him or her in such form as may be specified or such receipts, evidence of payment or other information relating to the provision of such specified services and of any statement or statutory declaration by any person claiming an income tax deduction in accordance with this section.".

This is a small but novel proposal which would empower the Minister to provide tax relief of £250per annum for a married couple or a widowed person and £125 for all other people, which sum would be tax deductible at the standard rate to spend on household services. It would require the use of registered contractors or traders so that in addition to having a small tax benefit to householders it would also have an effect in stamping out the black economy. The idea is that after 5 April the Minister would announce the measure applicable for the previous tax year.

Comment on this

I must be around here a long time - this is so novel that it existed before, between 1979 and 1982. It is understood that the Deputy is proposing tax relief for expenditure on home improvement services by VAT registered providers of these services. The relief would be on expenditure of up to £250 per year in the case of married or widowed persons and £125 in other cases and would be given at the standard rate of tax. The measure may be designed to stimulate demand for these services, thereby creating employment in the regular rather than irregular economy. In that case it is similar to provisions which existed between 1979 and 1982 which provided relief for home improvement work done by registered contractors. That relief was more attractive than that currently being advocated by Deputy Noonan in that it was in respect of expenditure up to £900 in the case of a married couple and £450 for others and was given at the marginal rate rather than the standard rate. The experience of that relief was that contractors operated a two tier price structure depending on whether the taxpayer was claiming relief. Further, it is not known to have created any worthwhile additional employment - most of the contractors involved were already in the tax net and a considerable amount of the work done involved the installation of aluminium windows. Because the cost of administration far outweighed the benefits the relief was abolished in 1983. This latter experience is also repeated in the area of tax relief for rent paid - most of the landlords concerned are already in the tax net.

In a time of ever increasing demands for scarce resources the Government must be selective and critical in its analysis of how these resources are expended. Because of previous experience with similar expenditure reliefs the Deputy's amendment must be opposed. In any event, the idea put forward by Deputy Noonan has been around before. I remember debating it in the House and at the time it was a reasonably substantial relief. The figures are £250 for a married couple at the standard rate of tax and £125 for a single person. For the amount of administration involved, I would ask the Deputy not to pursue this.

Comment on this

Given that there is a current budget surplus of £1 billion, just how big does that surplus have to get before the Department of Finance starts giving the Minister grief and talking about scarce resources?

Comment on this

We can be quite clear about that - it can never get big enough.

Comment on this

I suspected as much.

Comment on this

Another Corkman, Pearse Wyse, introduced the previous measure.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 148:

In page 111, before section 111, to insert the following new section:

"III. The Freedom of Information Act, 1997, is hereby amended in the Third Schedule thereto by the addition to Part I at the end thereof-

(a) in column (1), of 'No. 39 of 1997',

(b) in column (2), of 'Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997', and

(c) in column (3), of 'Section 857'.".

This amendment proposes to insert new sections in the Finance Bill to amend the Freedom of Information Act, 1997. Under section 32 of that Act information will not be disclosed if such disclosure is prohibited by another enactment, unless that enactment is listed in the Third Schedule to the Act. Under section 857 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, certain Revenue personnel are obliged to make declarations of confidentiality undertaking not to disclose information in relation to the affairs of schedule D taxpayers. That section is not currently listed in the Third Schedule to the Freedom of Information Act, and its omission has been drawn attention to by the office of the Information Commissioner designate.

In order to avoid a situation whereby the omission of section 857 from the Third Schedule would prevent the disclosure of information which would otherwise fall to be disclosed under the Freedom of Information Act, the new section being inserted into the Finance Bill amends the Third Schedule of the Freedom of Information Act to insert into it a reference to section 857 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 149:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-Section 7 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the insertion in subsection (1) after 'cease' of 'continue to'.

The remaining amendments in my name were all tabled by Deputy Ferris in the course of the debate on the Taxes Consolidation Bill. I will formally move them, since that was the advice given to Deputy Ferris at the time.

Comment on this

I believe the Deputy intended to phrase this amendment such that the words "shall cease to apply" would become "shall continue to cease to apply" in section 71 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. Section 7 provides for the application of the Age of Majority Act, 1985 to tax law. The concern of the Deputy seems to be that section 24(b) of the Age of Majority Act, 1985 ceased to apply in 1986 when the underlying legislation was enacted. It cannot cease to apply again if it already no longer applies. Legislation is always current and should be read as current. Accordingly, the phrase "shall cease to apply", while having effect back in 1986 has equal effect in 1998. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendment. Even if we understood it we could not accept it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 150:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-Section 96 of the Principal Act is hereby amended by the deletion in subsection (3) of 'Where' and the substitution of 'Subject to section 645(3), where'.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 151:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in section 271 by the insertion in subsection (1) in the definition of 'industrial development agency' after 'Authority' of 'or Forfás'.

(b) in section 273 by the insertion in subsection (1) in the definition of 'industrial development agency' after 'Authority' of 'or Forfás',

(c) in section 283 by the insertion in subsection (1) in the definition of 'industrial development agency' after 'Authority' of 'or Forfás',

(d) in section 285 by the insertion in subsection (1) in the definition of 'industrial development agency' after 'Authority' of 'or Forfás', and

(e) in section 403 by the insertion in subsection (7) after 'Authority' of 'or Forfás'.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 152:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in section 487 by the deletion in subsection (1)(a)(i)(II) of 'state' and the substitution of 'territory',

(b) in section 826 by the deletion in subsection (4) of 'state' where it firstly and secondly occurs and the substitution of 'territory', and

(c) in section 828 by the deletion in subsection (2) of 'country' and the substitution of 'territory'.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 153:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in section 548 by the deletion in subsection (3)(a) of 'the United Kingdom' and the substitution of 'Great Britain and Northern Ireland',

(b) in section 832 by the deletion in subsection (1) in the definition of 'the Convention' of 'Government of the United Kingdom' and the substitution of 'British Government', and

(c) in section 832 by the deletion in subsection (4)(a) of 'the United Kingdom' and the substitution of 'Great Britain and Northern Ireland'.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 154:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in section 860 by the insertion in subsections (1) and (2) after 'oath' of 'or affirmation',

(b) in section 905 by the insertion in subsection (2)(f) after 'oath' of 'or affirmation',

(c) in section 938 by the insertion in subsection (2) after 'oath' where it firstly and secondly occurs of 'or affirmation',

(d) in section 939 by the insertion in subsections (1), (2) and (3)(b) after 'oath' of 'or affirmation',

(e) in section 939 by the insertion in subsections (2) and (3)(b) after 'sworn' of 'or affirmed',

(f) in section 1066 by the insertion after 'oath' of 'or affirmation',

(g) in section 1066 by the insertion after 'swears' of 'or affirms', and

(h) by the insertion of the following section after section 1104 of that Act:

1104A.-The Oaths Act, 1888, and also every Act for the time being in force authorising an oath to be taken in any particular manner shall apply to the oaths required by this Act to be taken.'.".

This amendment involves a substantive point in so far as it seeks to insert the word "affirmation" where the Act refers to oaths.

Comment on this

The purpose of these amendments is to remove ambiguity and inconsistencies in the Taxes Consolidation Act by making express provision for the affirmation which, in the case of conscientious objection to taking an oath, is a legal alternative to an oath. Where the Interpretation Act, 1937, already makes express provision for the term "oath" to include affirmation, and also for the term "swear" to include affirm in every Act of the Oireachtas, the provisions of the Interpretation Act, 1937, imply in the case of persons for the time being allowed by law to affirm instead of swearing.

As regards the Oaths Act, 1888, during the Report Stage of the Taxes Consolidations Bill, 1997, Deputy Ferris brought to my attention the fact that the provision which allows a person to affirm instead swearing is the Oaths Act of 1888 and that the permission given in that Act only applies for the purposes of legal proceedings. The result is that the provisions of the tax code which do not involve legal proceedings, but which provide for the swearing of an oath, are not covered by the Oaths Act, 1888. Accordingly, in such cases it is not permissible to affirm or declare and a person must swear. While there is an issue there, my officials are still considering the full implications of superimposing the Oaths Act on to the Taxes Consolidation Act. There is also the question of other taxing statutes, for example, VAT, excises and capital taxes. While these issues may not be considered in time for Report Stage, I can assure the Deputy that the matter is receiving attention. At this time, therefore, I am opposing the amendment, but I hope to have the matter resolved at least by next year's Finance Bill.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's assurances in that regard.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 155:

In page 111, before section 113, to insert the following new section:

"113.-The Principal Act is hereby amended-

(a) in section 867 by the insertion after 'make' of 'by regulations',

(b) in section 905 by the insertion in subsection (2)(c) after 'as' of 'affecting section 645(3) or'.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 165:

In page 115, line 4, to delete "Principal Act".

This is a technical drafting amendment. At the beginning of the text of Schedule 2 the words "Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997" and "Principal Act" both appear. Principal Act was left in during printing in error.

Comment on this

I may put down amendments on Report Stage, or, if necessary, recommit amendments in respect of four items: I may propose a technical amendment to amendment No. 78 concerned with relief for double taxation for repatriated profits; a technical amendment relating to the rules for leasing of assets; a technical amendment relating to section 11, which was not discussed here; and I am also looking at some changes to the new seafarer's allowance which I may propose on Report Stage. My officials are still looking at these issues and, while I am obliged to mention them at this stage, I cannot be more definitive.

Comment on this

I may wish to revisit the issue of the enterprise zones and the documents authority provisions on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister has in mind in respect of the seafarer's allowance but a case has been represented to me in respect of those who service the oil rigs.

Comment on this

That is one of the matters I am considering.

Comment on this

I would be obliged if the Minister would look at the matter because I understand the problem associated with the seafarers generally is also associated with that issue. I know that employers and unions are anxious that the Minister look at it in terms of what might be possible.

Comment on this

That is one of the matters we will look at in that area.

Comment on this

We may wish to move amendments on Report Stage in respect of the enterprise zones and Dublin docklands.

Comment on this

I thank all Deputies for their contributions and co-operation on this debate. I know from experience that Committee Stage of the Finance Bill is an onerous task, especially for Opposition Deputies. The same expertise is not available to them as it is to me. I also thank all Deputies for their deliberations. Since becoming a Member of this House I have regarded the Finance Bill as a great learning experience and one to be enjoyed. However, over the years it has become much more technical and it is a major undertaking today, especially when one is in Opposition. We tried to produce the more substantial amendments late last week, however, difficulties arose when some Deputies received them and others did not.

I also thank my officials and officials in the Revenue Commissioners for their work in this area. It is a major undertaking and many hours were spent on it. Deputies will note that, despite my objections, I have become politically correct. I thank all involved, including you, Chairman.

Comment on this

I also thank you, Sir, for your forbearance and temper. I thank the Minister and his officials for their assistance and advice. The earlier part of the debate yesterday morning was most unsatisfactory in so far as we only dealt with a tiny number of the amendments scheduled. A number of the sections were not even considered. This is something we will have to look at in future years.

Comment on this

I thank you, Sir, for your forbearance. I also thank the Minister. He always conducts his business seriously but with a sense of humour, something which is too often left out of politics nowadays.

Comment on this

I am not supposed to be humorous, according to some major newspapers.

Comment on this

I do not think the Minister will change; I hope not. I also wish to be associated with the Minister's comments on his officials and on the officials in the Revenue Commissioners. I was Minister of State at the Department of Finance and I am aware of the work undertaken to meet these very demanding days which were set at time when Finance Bills were much simpler.

Deputy McDowell's points were made in a constructive manner. Given the pressure on the Minister and his officials and the ludicrous amount of time provided to the Opposition to deal with the issues involved, much of which is very important, a small extension of the dates allocated to the Bill would probably produce better law.

Comment on this

I wish to be associated with those sentiments. It is evidence of the blind spot people have that the thrust of the comment is on the personal income tax side. However, subsequent business is arguably more important to personal income taxpayers.

Given the misallocation of resources between Government and Opposition, we find it difficult to cope with the legislation in its entirety, especially in the fashion it was structured on this occasion. Having said that, I thank you for your forbearance and the Minister for his courtesy. It was not a contentious Bill.

Ignoring the advice from wild Bill Hickock, I have sat with my back to journalists. I have not seen any journalists since the procedure commenced. That raises profound questions about the committee structure. I find it difficult to understand the argument that the annual Finance Bill, or at least major sections of it, is not worth pursuing by persons who purport to comment on it later. It raises questions for politicians. If we are to have an elaborate committee structure for the number of Members in Dáil Éireann, as compared to approximately 650 Members in the neighbouring Parliament, it imposes an impossible strain on servicing it.

Members of the media must be brought into the equation. Some who do not attend Dáil Éireann will write articles about the House not sitting during St. Patrick's week and about Minister travelling around the world when in most cases they are on national business. In view of this, we are entitled to comment that the media should get its house in order in terms of covering the affairs of Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this