We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE

Finance Bill, 2002: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–156 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 2002
Enacted

No. 4 of 2002 ›

Amendment No. 4 is an alternative to No. 3. Amendments Nos. 1 to 5, inclusive, are related and all may be discussed together, by agreement.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I do not think the Chair's ruling is correct. Amendments Nos. 3 and 4 are separate, but Nos. 1, 2 and 5 are connected.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Mitchell. Amendments Nos. 1, 3 and 5 deal with the issue of individualisation, while the other two deal with the middle rate notion.

Comment on this

I was advised that they are related.

Comment on this

I presume the committee may reconsider the order if it wishes.

Comment on this

If the committee is agreeable, we will take them separately. Is it agreed to take amendments Nos. 1, 2 and 5 together? Agreed.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 11, between lines 30 and 31, to insert the following:

"

The next €15,000 | 30 per cent | the middle rate

".

The purpose of these amendments is to provide for a third tax band of 30% to interpose between the 20% band and the 42% band. Those on middle incomes are still paying a much higher proportion of their incomes in taxes than those on both lower and higher incomes. Until fairly recently, at least, they were still paying more income tax here than in the United Kingdom. These are the very people who are having difficulties in buying their own homes. It is well known that, for the first time in our history, couples on middle incomes are experiencing such difficulties. I am speaking of those who want to set up home and start a family. This is something we have proposed for the last several years. We are proposing that €15,000 of the income of a single person should be taxed at 30%, that is, 12% less than the current figure. He or she would end up paying €1,800 less tax per year. For a couple, the benefit would be twice that amount.

If we are to keep this country competitive - this must be the first consideration in anything we do - and if we are to be successful in drawing in people with required expertise, we must have attractive tax rates. The gross cost of this proposal would be in the order of €400 million per full year. The net cost would be less than €300 million.

Comment on this

This would mean, in effect, a cut of 12 percentage points for higher rate taxpayers at a time when the Government is endeavouring to assist those on lower incomes by removing as many of them as possible from the tax net. The proposed new 30% rate of tax would cost €750 million in a full year, more than the entire income tax package for the 2002 budget. As I explained when we last debated the proposal for a third, intermediate rate, the approach to tax reform comes down to one's judgment. I have often said I would be happy to be judged on the combined effect of the five budgets for which I have been responsible. Each of my budgets must be taken as part of a sequence. The tax strategy I have pursued is bearing fruit in terms of higher take home pay and increased incentive to work. I am confident that the considered judgment of the electorate on this record will be favourable when the general election comes around.

In my five budgets since 1997 I have made radical reforms to the whole tax system which is now inherently fairer as a result of the introduction of tax credits. Tax rates have been cut to improve the incentive to work and contribute to the development of the economy. Furthermore, as a result of the 2002 budget, 57,000 income earners have been removed from the top rate of tax. The Deputies may also be interested to know that according to the most recent data available from the OECD, relating to the year 2000, for a single person on the average production or industrial wage or APW Ireland has the lowest tax rates in the European Union. The EU average tax wedge is 45% while the figure for Ireland is 28.8%. The provisional data from the European Union relating to the same year shows that the EU average tax wedge for a single, low paid person on 50% of the APW is 35%, while Ireland's tax wedge for that income is 14.8%. For married couples on 50% of the APW, the tax wedge in Ireland is 3.8% while the EU average is 32.2%. Under the circumstances, I have no alternative but to reject these amendments.

If we compare Ireland with the United Kingdom, married persons in Ireland are better off up to a wage level of €50,000 while single persons are better off in Ireland up to €30,000. These figures are from the OECD and the European Union. Before the second last budget Deputy Mitchell submitted a parliamentary question to me regarding these powers in the United Kingdom. That gave me an opportunity to compare take home pay in Ireland and the United Kingdom taking account of social insurance in the United Kingdom, PRSI here, tax and debt rather than produce graphs. The Deputy was not finance spokesperson at the time, but I used that question——

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I nudged it in the right direction.

Comment on this

——to beat my officials over the head. Even the current president of SIPTU had to acknowledge Irish workers had been lower paid. I made the point in this and last year's budget that whereas in recent years the changes made have benefited the lower paid I accept that when we move to higher levels of income we have not caught up with the United Kingdom. It is not possible to do everything at the one time. My main critics during the years used to blame me for not doing anything about the lower paid, but I have done more for them than for anyone else. I accept that when we look at the figures mentioned, €50,000 for a married person and €30,000 for a single person, the graph goes in the other direction between Ireland and the United Kingdom. Over a period of time, when I prepare my next five budgets, I will be able to address this.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is conceding the point. Will he circulate a comparative table up to £200,000 showing how taxpayers here compare to those in the United Kingdom?

Comment on this

We have a graph table that goes up to €110,000. My official tells me that up to €110,000 nobody is more than 2.2% worse off - it goes from 0.3% to 2.2%.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Are there some worse off?

Comment on this

Yes, but the figure is very low. For a single person it is different. It ranges from 1.9% to 5.3%.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is the point I am highlighting. Why should this particular group, which normally has higher costs because its members are at the period in life when they are setting up home and having a family etc., pay comparatively more tax than those in the United Kingdom? Many of those in the United Kingdom are the type of people we need to attract home. For instance, some of my children's friends who are well educated and earning money in London in big jobs would love to come home, but cannot do so because taxes are higher and they cannot afford to buy a house. That is the group we want to assist.

Comment on this

I will not anticipate the view of the electorate which I believe is favourably disposed towards the present Administration, but if it was not so favourably disposed and returned the Opposition, I would look forward to an interesting discussion between Deputies Mitchell and McDowell on this point. They will not agree.

Comment on this

The Minister has had the advantage of being able to talk about this matter in public for the past five years and we know his views. He also has a fair idea of mine on most of these issues. I do not agree with the idea of a middle rate. It is not a priority or something I would envisage doing, but I make one exception. We have a strange anomaly in our system which arises through the interaction of PRSI, social insurance and tax. The Minister did not mention this, but he knows that the major reason Irish take-home pay comes in around the same or more than that in the United Kingdom is that social insurance rates in the United Kingdom are significantly higher than they are here. I would have no difficulty with this. If we were to reduce income tax and increase social insurance in order that we had an increased dedicated fund available for social insurance purposes, that is something for which I would have time. I have no difficulty in devising lots of useful ways in which money in the social insurance fund could be productively spent to good social benefit. Much could be done in terms of the balance between tax and social insurance.

There is a difficulty for those paying the higher rate of tax and social insurance up to the social insurance ceiling. When the Minister introduced his budget last year I expected him to address this issue. Inevitably, anybody who examines the social insurance system will conclude it is a total mess with its threshold, exemptions, ceiling and all the rest. With its various contribution levels it makes no sense. There is an anomaly for some of the people Deputy Mitchell is looking to address in his amendment who are paying at the higher rate of tax and PRSI for the part of their income in the higher rate. This makes no sense.

Comment on this

I had intended to make very significant changes this year to the PRSI system which had become a nightmare with its various thresholds and cut-off points. In the previous budget I set myself up for the radical move of abolishing employer's PRSI. It would have been quite simple and something the Deputy himself advocated some years ago. However, due to changing financial circumstances, a lot of extra work had not been done. It would have been my intention to ensure nobody was worse off. Even in the sub-classes of PRSI there are a number of taxpayers. My general thinking was that we should make everybody even, to have an effective, straightforward system that would not disadvantage anybody in terms of benefits or contribution rate etc.

To make matters more complicated there are two rates to do with employers also. Before my latest budget the employer's rate was about 12%, but for certain employers it was 8.5%. At least, I got employers over the upper thresholds of the previous budget. There are also different classes and sub-classes of benefits which I intended to streamline. If the financial circumstances had been better, it would have been possible to do this. Because it was not possible, I only managed to reduce the employer's general rate by 1.25% from 12% to 10.75%.

PRSI interaction, or PRSI for employees, the health levy and tax do cause a net minus in some income bands when a person receives an increase. What I was trying to achieve, therefore, was a simple system. I had written out the general principles and expanded upon them over a year ago. My officials and I had done some work on them, but the change in our finances meant it was not possible to introduce them. I hope to address this matter in the second coming.

Comment on this

The major problem, which Deputy Mitchell's amendment seeks to address, is that there is a tranche of income, between about €28,000 and €38,000, where taxpayers are paying a higher rate of tax plus PRSI than they would if they had a higher income. This does not make sense.

Comment on this

In the Minister's few words he covered a variety of matters. Perhaps under the Freedom of Information Act we might be able to find out what the rumblings were.

Comment on this

There was nothing about that. I gave the exact rate to start with and went through with my officials what we intended to do in the previous budget. I discussed my thoughts. I would have written out what I intended to do and read from it. That was the general basis of where we were headed, but we had to call off that onward march from about September last year. There was no point entering into detailed discussions about it then because I was not going to be in a position to follow through.

Comment on this

Obviously, the Minister is not going to write them up for the coming year either. There are many things left behind that he did not sort out. Some mentioned last year were simple. I expected from his reaction that he would try to address them. For example, a Dáil question on the self-employed, PAYE in terms of FIS, a sister Department——

Comment on this

Is this about being ripped off——

Comment on this

No, this is to do with taxation. It is to do with the Department of Finance and Revenue. What is happening is——

Comment on this

It is not related to the amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking about health contributions, PRSI and anomalies in the system. As he raised the matter, I am entitled to talk about it.

Comment on this

I will allow it on this occasion.

Comment on this

Thank you. On the question of FIS, let us suppose we have two families living next door to each other with exactly the same income as certified by the Revenue Commissioners. Each has a declared income of £10,000 and the commissioners accept both incomes as genuine. Each has three children. The family in the PAYE sector can get a top-up of social welfare in terms of FIS, but the other family does not qualify for that payment. In other words, the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs is saying to that family that it does not accept the figure given as the family's real income, that the Revenue Commissioners are not doing a good job and are not looking at the family's income properly, that the family is earning much more than the figure claimed and that the Department will not accept it. That is unfair. We are talking about people on relatively low incomes, such as small shopkeepers in rural areas and postmasters and postmistresses, as the Minister is aware. There are many people in that category and, because they happen to be self-employed, they do not qualify. Farmers also come into that category. That is a serious anomaly and should be addressed. An all-party committee looked at the matter before and recommended that it should be changed.

We must also look at what happens in the Department of Education and Science. Again, it is something the Minister noted last year, but nothing was done about it. I will take two families living next door to each other as an example. One family includes a PAYE worker, perhaps in Bord na Móna, with an income of £20,000 per annum. The children of that family will qualify for education grants. However, next door to them is perhaps a taxi driver, a farmer or somebody in a self-employed category who has recently leased a car or machinery, etc. When that person submits a figure of £20,000 to the Revenue Commissioners, the Department of Education and Science insists on adding the money paid for leasing. The £20,000 income that is acceptable to the Revenue Commissioners as that family's income is not acceptable to the Department of Education and Science which deems that the family has a notional income of perhaps £25,000. The effect is that the family does not qualify for higher education grants.

Comment on this

I do not understand how that impacts on amendments Nos. 1 to 3, inclusive, or amendment No. 5. Will the Deputy stick more closely to taxation than education?

Comment on this

This is to do with taxation and recognition by the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

It is not. It is to do with the Department of Education and Science and not the Department of Finance.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

The Deputy should stick to the amendment.

Comment on this

The third point relates to non-recognition of figures produced by the Revenue Commissioners in terms of social welfare payments for self-employed farmers. A farmer with a recognised income——

Comment on this

Tell me how that relates to the amendments.

Comment on this

It is to do with taxation and how the system works. The Minister is talking about——

Comment on this

The Deputy may speak about these matters under the section but not in relation to the amendments.

Comment on this

Let me finish this point as it is the last I will make on this particular issue. In relation to social welfare assessments of farmers for social welfare payments, even if the farmers have returned income to the Revenue Commissioners, have paid an accountant to put in their income and get certified figures to say that their income is a certain amount, when they go to the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs and produce that information, it is not accepted. The Department says that it does not work that system. It counts how many sheep farmers have and what payments and subsidies they have received. It reaches its own figure in that way.

Does that not make a laugh of the idea of a unified Government operating to any extent? There should be, across all Government systems, a unified approach to the recognition of income and tax liability. As things stand, that is not the case. The examples I gave are fair, but the Chairman is pressing me not to talk about this issue. I will move on.

Comment on this

I said the Deputy could address these matters while speaking about the section but not while discussing these amendments.

Comment on this

The amendment proposes the creation of a middle band. The Minister produced figures to show that there was a difference in taxation levels close to the €30,000 cut-off point. It is exactly that group which we hope to address with the additional middle band and the €15,000 figure. The Minister's cut-off point is €28,000. Above that figure, a person moves into a higher bracket of taxation at the 42% rate. That is an extremely low level at which to hit the higher rate of taxation. As Deputy McDowell said, there are anomalies in relation to PRSI payments and various levies that arise. A strong case can be made to balance the tax take between Ireland and the UK, but also to give back additional funds to those on modest incomes.

What is envisaged has a cost to the Exchequer, which is estimated at €400 million. That is a substantial amount of money, but it is a question of one's priorities. The middle income group we are discussing pays for everything. People in that group are trying to buy houses and, if they are married and have double incomes, they are trying to put their children through college. That group is caught for everything and never gets the benefits other groups might get. Such people do not qualify for council housing and must buy their own houses. On that kind of income, they are very restricted in what they can do. The Minister suggested on the basis of his figures that, if he had had the opportunity, he would have done something to widen the band or to reduce the level of taxation on people in that category.

Perhaps the Minister might rethink this and introduce a third rate. It is within a strictly defined level of taxation. It pushes out the limit from €28,000, which is the cut-off point for the 20% rate. The amendment intends to have the next €15,000 taxed at 30% and income thereafter taxed at 42%. It creates a reasonable amount of income before people come into the top rate of tax. It is a reasonable amendment.

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath referred to the fact that the middle income taxpayer is caught for everything. I have much sympathy for his political perspective on this matter. It has not been politically correct in recent years to refer to this category of taxpayer. These taxpayers feel that they do not share the benefits at the lower end and they do not get tax breaks. In my budgets I have alleviated the burden on that class of taxpayer.

In the early days of the Government, on Committee Stage of my first Finance Bill, much time was taken up debating who and who was not wealthy. I cut the top rate of tax in my first budget by two points, as promised to the electorate a few months earlier. It was outlandish that a Government could fulfil its promise to the electorate in that way. The amount of funding for health and education has quadrupled and Deputy McDowell cannot deny that fact. I considered the debate about wealth nonsensical. Those earning close to £13,000 were deemed to be wealthy and were paying tax at 48%. A figure such as £260 or £280 per week was deemed to make a person wealthy. That was nonsensical. That class of single income taxpayer was caught, as was the married taxpayer in that bracket. Over the period of the last five budgets, I have alleviated the burden on that class of taxpayer by pushing him or her out further before he or she hits the top rate of tax.

Comment on this

The Minister's point is not completely fair because he says that people hit the top rate of tax at £13,000 of taxable income. At that stage he had already taken off——

Comment on this

No, I had not——

Comment on this

Yes, the Minister had. This was prior to the introduction of the tax credit system.

Comment on this

No, in my first——

Comment on this

One took off personal allowances before one hit the rate of taxation.

Comment on this

In 1997-98 a single income taxpayer hit the top rate of tax at a very low level if he or she had no mortgage interest relief or other allowances. It would have been very simple to fulfil the electoral promises by just cutting the rates, not widening the tax bands or going down the road of tax credits. It probably would not have cost as much. There would have been a lower rate of tax, but taxpayers would still have hit it at a very low level. I have increased the bands considerably; they have been moved out very much further than in 1997-98. This has allowed all income taxpayers to benefit, of which the proof is that the number paying tax at the top rate is smaller than it was when I became Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

It went up for the first three years. The Minister cannot deny that. The percentage paying the higher rate of tax increased during his first three years in office and dropped back only in the last two.

Comment on this

The better way to look at the figures is to look at the total number of earners on the files of Revenue. I have benefited all taxpayers in the changes I have made during the years, but those who have benefited most are those at the lower end and those then in the middle income bracket. One of the advantages of having a single band and widening the standard rate band, as I have been doing now for three budgets, is that one compensates the taxpayers to whom Deputy McGrath referred such as dual income households where both members get up very early in the morning, travel some distance to work, have their children looked after and incur other costs and problems associated with going to work. They are getting some reward.

Whatever criticisms people might have of the Government, very few of those who are working - I do not expect everybody to agree with this point - would criticise our taxation policy because they have seen the dramatic benefits. Previous budgets made only small changes to taxation and nobody noticed. The effect of what we have done over five budgets has been so dramatic that everybody has noticed. It would be the equivalent of walking around for a year with ten stone on one's back. If one took it off, one would notice the difference. It has been like that in regard to taxation. I am not saying we cannot be criticised in other areas, but taxpayers have appreciated the changes we have made to taxation.

Deputy McGrath referred to other areas, including assessments for higher education grants, social welfare payments and family income supplement, and said the same basis is not used. If I was being really politically astute, I would not mention this period, but when I was Minister for Social Welfare I had prepared a Bill providing for a single means of assessment. My theory was - it has not yet been progressed - that when dealing with the State, whether the local authority for housing or for a higher education grant or social welfare payments, there should be a single means of assessment. Even across the social welfare code there was a myriad of assessments. As a forerunner to a one-stop-shop, I was going to have a single means test which would have necessitated another Social Welfare Bill, but the Government fell in November 1992 and the Bill never came to fruition. It had been produced in the earlier part of that year, but there were all kinds of problems with it and certain aspects about which people were worried. My intention was to deal with the situation to which Deputy McGrath alluded. Since I left the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs that idea has not been progressed much. The theory was to have a single means of assessment whereby one would be able to deal with people in the same way in their dealings with the State.

Part of the argument was that it would have led to greater use of what was then known as a universal identifier, or PRSI number, now known as the PPS number, but we ran into some difficulties. In part of my time in the Department I tried to make use of this under data protection legislation, but there were some difficulties in this respect also. It is not a case of Big Brother. I have always considered that the most liberal society as far as personal freedoms are concerned is the United States which allows citizens the right to free speech. Freedom of expression is enshrined in the American constitution. However, under American law, one must use one's social security number when dealing with all arms of the state, from bank accounts to social welfare. People do not say this is anti-democratic and very oppressive even though the United States has a very liberal ethic in these matters. I have always felt that in a society such as ours with only 3.8 million people, with one's number one should be assessed in the same way, regardless of whether one is looking for local authority housing or a higher education grant. Some progress has been made because there are now social welfare cards, etc. Some were delighted that I was not left as Minister for Social Welfare, but I had moved down this road and made considerable progress. I mention to Deputy McGrath in the dying days ofthis Administration that it was going to come about.

Comment on this

We are now ten years on. The Minister has been a senior figure in government for most of that time, but has done nothing about it.

Comment on this

As Minister for Finance, I have been able to achieve many of the things I intended to achieve as Minister for Social Welfare because have come at them from another direction.

In 1997 a single person would have hit the top rate of tax at a gross income of £13,600. He or she would have had a personal allowance of £2,500 and a PAYE allowance of £800. The tax band at that stage was £9,900. He or she would have hit the 48% tax rate at £13,600. The tax band is now €28,000, or £22,052. One does not hit the top rate of tax now until one reaches £22,052. There is now a different system in place. It is, in fact, higher because of tax credits.

Comment on this

Those on middle incomes know they have benefited hugely in the last five years. As a middle income earner, I have noticed the net increase in my take home pay. It may not be the same proportion as those on lower incomes - no one is decrying the fact they were entitled to it - but those on middle incomes have benefited hugely from the tax concessions in the last five budgets. That needs to be said.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 4 is an alternative to amendment No. 3. Both will be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 12, column (1), line 11, to delete "€37,000" and substitute "€42,000".

This amendment refers to individualisation, which the Minister introduced. The gap continues to widen. People with the same responsibilities living next door to each other will pay different levels of taxation depending on whether they have one or two incomes. Fine Gael is committed to reversing this situation and moving back to that which pertained previously where one and double income families would be treated equally. It is ridiculous to think that if one partner in a working couple stops working, it can mean that the person who remains working suddenly pays tax at a higher rate. At present, a working couple can share allowances but if those are lost when one person stops working, the other partner cannot be expected to pay additional tax. It is grossly unfair and does not recognise adequately the work that has been done by a partner, male or female, rearing a family in the home. I hope the Minister will do an about-turn on this amendment, but I will not hold my breath.

Comment on this

I tabled the amendment as a symbolic indication of our continuing opposition to the individualisation process. I realise the Minister has taken the process some distance and that there is now a significant gap of €19,000 between the standard rate band of a single income married couple and that of a double income married couple. We have rehearsed these arguments so many times before that they hardly bear repeating. However, I have always been of the view that the State should effectively be neutral and, in so far as it was not neutral, it should encourage people to exercise a choice which suited their family circumstances.

The Minister changed the status quo two years ago. One of the justifications offered at the time was that it would increase the participation of women in the workforce. I would be interested to hear if the Minister has any figures to show whether their participation has increased in the interim. If not, then at least part of the reason behind the move falls.

Comment on this

As I have indicated on many occasions, the Government is committed in its Action Programme for the Millennium to work towards having 80% of income earners taxed at the standard rate. With allowances converted to tax credits, the only way to get the number in the top tax rate down is to widen the standard rate tax band. The most effective way to widen the tax band is to put it on an individual basis and tax a person on what they earn as individuals, whether single or married. The first step in this direction was taken two years ago. It was continued in last year's Finance Act and we are continuing along this road in this year's Bill. Considerable progress has been made and, as a result of the band widening, which is provided for in the Bill, the percentage of income earners on the higher rate will fall to 26.7%. This compares, for example, to 32% paying at the top rate in 1999-2000.

I take it that the purpose of the amendments tabled by Deputies Mitchell, McGrath and McDowell, in so far as they relate to the standard rate band for one income married couples, is to partially reverse the process towards an individual rate band structure for taxpayers. However, the amendments do not achieve that purpose; they merely maintain the same difference of a higher income level at a significantly increased cost. This is because the increased standard rate band of €19,000 for the two income married couple would remain in place, thus providing, perhaps unwittingly, for a standard rate band structure of €28,000 for a single person, the same as the budget proposal. That is €42,000 for a married one income couple and €61,000 for a married two income couple under the proposals of Deputy Mitchell and Deputy McGrath or €40,000 and €59,000 under Deputy McDowell's proposed amendment compared to €37,000 and €56,000 under the Bill as published. This would also mean that a married two income couple would have more than twice the standard rate band of a single person, which I do not favour.

The amendment regarding the standard rate band proposed by Deputy Mitchell and Deputy McGrath would cost €270.5 million in a full year. Deputy McDowell's amendment would cost €170 million. As the Deputies said, this matter has been the subject of considerable debate since I began the process three budgets ago. In this budget, the matter was also addressed by Mr.Callanan of the ESRI in his analysis of the distributional impact of budget 2002. He said:

What about the impact of the budget on families of different types? Did it, as some have argued, favour two earner families without children over single earner couples with children? Our findings indicate that this is not the case. Relative to the neutral benchmark, two earner couples without children gain half a percentage point in income after the budget, but one and two earner couples with children gain about 1.5%. The largest gains were for those depending on welfare. Pensioners and unemployed persons without children gained from 2% to 4%, while unemployed couples with children gained an average of about 7%.

Comment on this

That was as a result of child benefit, not the tax change.

Comment on this

Exactly.

Comment on this

Deputies switch when they want. If Deputies want to criticise me, they pull out one particular aspect. When they say I did not do something else, they say I should do something for child benefit. When I do something for child benefit, because it is the greatest thing one can do to assist families, they say they do not want to discuss child benefit, that it has nothing to do with it.

Comment on this

That is because they reckon that child benefit was someone else's idea.

Comment on this

Nobody anticipated two budgets ago that I would go about raising child benefit over a three year programme. People might have dreamt about it, but no one thought the Minister for Finance would do it. However, we did it over three years. We introduced the first tranche in the last budget and the second one now. Hopefully, I will be in a position next year to fulfil that particular proposal. There is a separate debate starting now about child benefit, but we decided two budgets ago that this was the most appropriate way of dealing with the problem. It was an existing mechanism. We decided the Government would head down that road and it did so.

Regarding the issue of widening the standard rate band as it is now known, I readily confess that when I did it two budgets ago I used the term "individualisation" of the standard rate band. That had connotations of individualisation of the taxation code, which is not the case. That is atotally separate debate. Widening the standard rate band, as it has become known and referred to by the social partners, is probably the most appropriate phrase. Having listened to all sides of the argument over the past two and a half years, whatever about Deputy McGrath's philosophical and political viewpoint, it astounds me that Deputy McDowell has objected strenuously to these proposals.

For as long as I have been in politics, and before I came near Dáil Éireann when I was a student in the 1960s, people of his political persuasion would have argued strongly for fairness and equality between these areas in the taxation code. Most trade union members I know do so, including the equality officer of SIPTU who is not known as a supporter of mine. I congratulated her on it. In the midst of my difficulties in the first budget, when all hell broke loose——

Comment on this

Including the Minister's backbenchers.

Comment on this

More so my own backbenchers than anyone else, may I say.

Comment on this

He had the home carers as well.

Comment on this

Which was a fiasco too.

Comment on this

Many other politicians around the world have said it, but the late Deputy Oliver Flanagan advised politicians: "Keep your enemies close, but keep your friends even closer." It was an example of that.

On behalf of ICTU, she issued a strong statement at the time that I was in line with its equality principles down through the years. That particular individual had many difficulties with me concerning other matters, including taxation. While I do not know the person well, she gained a high mark in my mind forever more because she said that in the midst of everything and when it would have been much easier for her not to say anything. She is definitely not of my political persuasion and I was in much difficulty. I do not know her personally, but I hold her in very high esteem.

Basically, it is the fairest thing to do. That was the situation up to the 1980-81 tax year. There were many rates, up to 77% on one occasion, and people used to hit the top rate in a flash. On another occasion, for two years we had 10% on top of the rates as a form of surcharge so that the 35% rate became 38.5%, the 45% rate became 49.5%, and the 70% rate became 77%.

Since the introduction of taxation there had not been a doubling of the bands between married couples and single persons. It was first introduced in that year. Many people confused this with the Murphy judgment, but that judgment did not require the bands to be doubled. Most people regard the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s as the dark ages as far as equality is concerned. The debate that ensued after my first budget was more like a debate that might have been conducted during those times. It concerned whether a woman's place was in the home and questioned whether women should be in the workplace, pursuing their own careers. In my view, that was a debate for that time. There was no debate during the 1960s and 1970s that this should be changed——

Comment on this

A very important fact is that within the public service in particular, different rates of pay pertained depending on whether a person was single or married. That would also have to be factored into that discussion.

Comment on this

There were all kinds of rules at that time. Up to 1972 or 1973, women were forced to resign from the Civil Service on marriage.

Comment on this

The rates of pay are also a factor in what the Minister is saying.

Comment on this

I was a Member of the Dáil at that time. I was not aware of any debate at that time either in the Dáil or outside which questioned the fairness of this and suggested that there should be a change to a double band. It was not an issue at the time. From 1980 onwards, more and more women were participating in the workplace and one would have thought, when I made the changes two budgets ago, that my efforts would have been welcomed as a fair and just measure which encouraged equality. As it turned out, and with due respect to my colleagues who paraded on the plinth, the people of Ireland who were at home and did not ring the radio stations very much welcomed the proposal. A survey taken in January showed a high appreciation of the budget proposals. The people doing the most shouting on the radio and television were not reflecting the views of the people who stayed quiet.

Comment on this

I was never on the plinth in my life.

Comment on this

That was a fact. I appreciate Deputy McGrath's viewpoint on this matter, but I have always been amazed by Deputy McDowell's approach to it. It also amazed me at that time. I also fast forwarded the introduction of the home carers' allowance at the same time as I widened the bands.

Comment on this

Had the Minister been planning to do that?

Comment on this

That was in the Fianna Fáil manifesto. We planned to have a £3,000 home carers' allowance at the standard rate. When the Chairman, Deputy Michael Ahern, was chairman of the Fianna Fáil finance group when we were in Opposition, we discussed this matter during the preparation of the election manifesto and he and others raised the question of the person at home. As a result of those deliberations, the £3,000 allowance at the standard rate was included in the Fianna Fáil manifesto. A married couple with one partner earning now has a home carers' allowance——

Comment on this

Only if they have child dependants.

Comment on this

If there is no one to care for at home, they do not receive the allowance.

Comment on this

The married couple with one partner earning has a double personal credit. There is now a double credit in place of the double tax-free allowance. I also fast forwarded the home carers' allowance. This is very familiar to the Chairman. I have always been amazed by this debate, but I note that is not as strong now as it was then.

Comment on this

At least 120,000 families are affected.

Comment on this

I am just making the political point.

Comment on this

I have never accepted that this was an equality measure within the terms described by the Minister. It changed the treatment of families and, in particular, the treatment of married couples with children. As regards changing the balance between men and women, I never accepted that it was intended to do that or that it did it. It was always open to married couples to allocate the double allowance as they wished and they could, if they chose, divide it equally and individualise it. That was always an option available to them. What the Minister did was to ensure that they will now be individualised up to a point at least. The logical conclusion of the process the Minister started is to individualise it completely.

It provided a particular disincentive to people such as working women who were married, had children and decided at a certain point in their lives to take a break of five, seven or ten years from the workplace. I know of many such people. Previously they were able to do so without too great a financial loss because their husbands took the double standard rate band in those circumstances. The Minister could justify individualisation if it was designed to increase the participation of women in the workforce and if he specifically wanted to keep women working. In fairness to the Minister, he never said that explicitly. I have always been aware that the primary driving force behind the change was to reduce the number of people paying tax at the higher rate. From my perspective, it would have been a more justifiable aim to seek to increase the participation of women in the workforce. I do not believe it would ever achieve that aim and I would be interested in the figures.

We made general comments about taxation earlier. During my contribution on Second Stage of the Finance Bill, I stated that if the Minister had chosen not to pursue his individualisation process further this year at a cost of something in excess of €300 million, it would have been possible for him to meet one of the other taxation aims stated in the programme - taking people on the minimum wage out of the tax net completely. It would have cost roughly the same to pay for that remaining tranche instead of pursuing the individualisation process that bit further.

Comment on this

In the interests of historical accuracy, it is not in the Fianna Fáil election manifesto that everyone on the minimum wage would be taken out of the tax net. We committed ourselves to the minimum wage in the PPF.

Comment on this

That is what I meant by the programme. In terms of choosing how to target the tax reductions, which is what the Minister was forced to do this year, it would have been possible to take people on the minimum wage out of the tax net entirely if he had foregone the extra bit of individualisation which he chose to introduce.

Comment on this

The commitment in the PPF was to move people on the minimum wage out of the tax net over time. When the process of widening the standard rate band is completed, people will wonder what all the fuss was about when it started. When the change over to the tax credit system is completed, it will be much simpler for Ministers for Finance to make all kinds of adjustments to the tax code. The biggest change has been the move to tax credits and the widening of the standard rate band. It will be a much simpler process and it will enable a linkage to the social welfare system.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

This is my final Finance Bill in this term. When I became Minister for Finance, I deliberately decided not to take the piecemeal approach to reform of the tax code. Many of my ministerial predecessors and their policymakers would have liked to have been in a position to do what I have done. The difficulty was always that a little was done everywhere, but nothing radical was achieved. I am sure the advice to my two predecessors was that to do what I have done would have been too expensive and created an ongoing problem. It is necessary to make the big jump and widen the standard rate band. I did not anticipate the hue and cry that occurred. While I expected some debate, I thought we had moved on considerably between 1960 and 1998.

That said, I decided to take the approach of taking very big steps. When the process is complete it will be simple enough for the Minister for Finance to do certain things. The same will apply when the third tranche of child benefit is completed in the next budget. It will have been brought up to a certain base level, from which it will be easier to move forward. To reach that level costs an awful lot of money - roughly £1,000 million over three years. Therefore, it cost £325 million to £330 million in the first year and the same last year. However, once the new threshold is reached, one will be able to move forward at whatever pace one wishes.

It is the same with the tax code. I am endeavouring to create a taxation system which is simple, easy to administer, understandable, leads to less evasion and incentivises. I have served for the best part of 25 years during which I have been able to achieve most of this. There are several little things I would like to do in future budgets to finish the bigger process, after which, as I used to say at press conferences, it will be harder to make a mess of budgets in the future because sound foundations have been created, but perhaps that is wishful thinking.

I assume the figures on women in the workforce come from the CSO. In 1998 the figure was 44.7%. For the first three quarters of 2001 it was 48.4%.

Comment on this

The far more interesting figure is the age cohort of women in the workforce.

Comment on this

There was a study undertaken about a year ago by one of the brokers or agencies which provided a breakdown and compared the position here with that in other countries. As far as I remember, the highest rates of women in the workforce are in Denmark. There are significant differences, however, when the figures are broken down by age group. While we are fairly well established at the lower end of the spectrum, we track back downwards when one consider the group, 44 to 49 years, and above.

Comment on this

The interesting feature of women in the workforce is that many of those who took the option of looking after their families at home were badly hit by individualisation, will continue to be badly hit by it and feel hard done by as a result.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy travels around County Westmeath more often than I travel around County Kildare - this is because of a lack of time, particularly in recent months. I return to the point I made about increasing the number back at work and general participation in the workforce. On account of the significant budget increases in child benefit last year and this year, I have heard many women question whether they should keep their jobs. At least my action on child benefit gives people the choice.

I do not accept Deputy McDowell's comment that I am trying to force people to make distinctions. I hope this is not the case at any rate. The child benefit increases have given people good reason - alongside other good reasons - for deciding to stay at home for five, six, seven, eight or nine years. As I have said in debates on the Finance Bill, I have been in two relationships in which different approaches were taken to this matter. I accept the benefits of both. I cannot see that what I did in the Finance Acts, in widening the standard rate band, forced people to do anything because not a single change in my budgets has led to anyone paying more taxes.

Comment on this

The point is, however, that the Minister made it more difficult, particularly for women with children, to give up work for a period or permanently to look after children than was previously the case. It is clear the previous system encouraged marriage, if one likes, or, to put it in very positive terms, underpinned the family in so far as it allowed couples to exercise the choice of one partner working with the extended standard rate band and the other looking after the children, whereas now the clear prejudice of the State is in favour of double income married couples.

Comment on this

Dr. FitzGerald has argued that point in his column, but I do not agree with him.

Comment on this

We have travelled this one about as far as we can.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 7 to 17, inclusive, are related to amendment No. 6 and amendment No. 15 is an alternative to amendment No. 14. Amendments Nos. 6 to 17, inclusive, may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 12, column (3), line 32, to delete "€3,040" and substitute "€3,710".

Chairman, there is probably a more sensible way of grouping these amendments, but we will do it this way if you want. I wish to address amendment No. 6, in particular, which relates to the personal tax credit which it seeks to increase for married couples from €3,040 to €3,710. Its point is to remove the minimum wage from the tax net altogether. If my maths are correct, as matters stand, the minimum wage, is €236 per week. The basic principle, which I have enunciated on many occasions, not just at this committee, but elsewhere also, is that it is unreasonable and illogical to insist, on the one hand, that people should not be paid less than the minimum wage while taking part of it on the other. The minimum wage should not be taxed. This would be the purpose of increasing the personal tax credit.

I did not comment earlier during the more general discussion about taxation and will not speak on the matter at great length now. The Minister will know that it has always been my preferred option in terms of reducing tax to increase personal tax allowances or personal tax credit as it is now known. During the years he has approached this matter on several different fronts at the same time. He has reduced the upper rate of tax which is only of benefit to those on the upper tax rate, increased the standard rate band which also benefits only those on the upper tax rate and means part of their income is now paid at the lower rate, reduced the standard rate of tax which benefits everybody who pays tax, and increased the personal tax credit which also benefits everybody who pays tax. Therefore, some of his measures have benefited everybody, including those who also benefited from the measures exclusively geared towards upper rate taxpayers. One can blind everybody with statistics, but the Minister's claim, which he has made on a number of occasions, that only a relatively small percentage of his tax reductions were geared towards upper rate taxpayers is misleading because they have also benefited from the other measures to reduce tax.

I have argued since before the last general election and have always believed that the way to proceed is by way of allowances, now the tax credit, an even fairer system than its predecessor. The purpose of the amendment is to use the personal tax credit to remove the minimum wage from the tax net.

Comment on this

This proposal makes a great deal of sense. When one considers the personal rates of credit available it is a shame that those on the minimum wage are not removed from the tax net. I accept that the amount of tax they will pay, which I am sure the Minister will quote, is relatively small. Nonetheless, the principle of those on the minimum wage having to pay tax is at stake. The Minister told us earlier about what he has given to the less well-off. I acknowledge Deputy McDowell's comment that widening the band will have a knock-on effect, but an additional £100 per week, approximately, has been given to a single person earning £50,000 during the Minister, Deputy McCreevy's tenure. There is an enormous cumulative cost over five years for all those earning over £50,000. In crude terms, the Minister decided that he wanted to give a tax break to people in that tax bracket rather than to those at the lower end of the scale. The knock-on effect of targeting high earners in this manner has been that they pay far less tax than was the case.

There have been cumulative gains for high earners and few benefits for the low-paid. We must bear in mind that there are many people in the latter category; about 32% of all employees earn less than £10,000 and about 62% earn less than £25,000, which is frightening. When these figures appeared in a parliamentary question, I was contacted by a journalist who wanted to know what was causing so many people to earn below the minimum wage. Many part-time workers, who earn relatively low incomes, are included in the figures. The money that has been given back to top earners could easily have been used to take those on the minimum wage out of the tax net. The Minister may regret, when he moves on, that he did not achieve the removal of those on the minimum wage from the tax net.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 6 to 17, inclusive, propose increases in personal tax credits over and above those already provided for in the Bill. Deputy McDowell seeks an increase in the basic personal tax credit, the age tax credit and the incapacitated child tax credit. Deputy Jim Mitchell and Deputy McGrath seek increases in the widowed parent, incapacitated child, dependent relative and home carer tax credits.

Comment on this

I apologise for interrupting the Minister, but I wonder if it is possible to take them individually, which would make more sense from everyone's point of view. I addressed only the personal tax credits, but I could have addressed other ones. I am not sure if the Minister's notes are written on the basis of the grouping.

Comment on this

The increase in the basic personal tax credit proposed by Deputy McDowell would cost €545 million in a full year. The proposed increases in the married person's tax credit from €3,040 to €3,710 and in the single person's tax credit from €1,520 to €1,855 would cost €545 million in a full year. If I agreed to Deputy McGrath's proposed intermediate tax credit, people at the higher end of the wage scale would pay much less as an intermediate rate of 30% would be even more skewed in their direction. The percentage of low-paid people in the tax net has decreased as a result of the five budgets I have introduced. This year's budget means that about 692,000 people will be outside the tax net altogether. I wish to clarify for an individual outside the House that people outside the tax net will not be affected by measures in next year's budget. The best I can do for those not paying tax is to keep them outside the tax net.

This matter is a constant theme of a well-known commentator outside this House who has never found anything to praise in my budgets, at least not to my recollection. I would like to point out to him that one cannot benefit from changes in taxation if one is already outside the tax net. It is a separate matter, but there is a certain logic to what I have done over the years as regards the tax system. Who is to say what will or will not be done in future years following the merging of the tax and social welfare systems? The figure of 692,000 people outside the tax net is a multiple of the number some years ago and the best I can do for them is to keep them outside the taxation system.

Comment on this

Does the Minister have any idea how many of these people are part-time workers?

Comment on this

I am not sure as we received the figures from the Revenue Commissioners. Perhaps the figure the Deputy seeks may be found by combining statistics from Revenue and labour force surveys, but I do not think anybody has made such a——

Comment on this

I do not wish to be argumentative, but it would be useful for the committee to be told how many people on the minimum wage or a similar wage are

full-time workers and whether they are in the tax net. Perhaps the figure is relatively small, but I do not know.

Comment on this

I know from making tax returns and filling out various PAYE forms that tax offices do not keep a record of the hours worked by employees. Perhaps some body will do a survey, but it is beyond the——

Comment on this

Does the labour force survey or the household budget survey——

Comment on this

The labour force survey indicates the hours worked by part-time workers, but I do not think there has ever been an attempt to combine the statistics with income tax records. If one earns more money, one will pay more tax, so any change to the income tax system will benefit the high-paid. My changes have benefited everybody. A particular problem when I became Minister for Finance was that taxpayers reached the top rate of tax on a very low income; a single person reached the top rate on a salary of £13,600, as I pointed out earlier. This means that in 1997, a single person on 89% of the average industrial wage was liable for tax at the higher rate, which was ridiculous. By widening bands and reducing rates, one does not pay the high rate of tax until one earns more than the average industrial wage, which has increased in the interim.

The situation in 1997 was nonsensical and the changes I have made have benefited everybody. All surveys and calculations, whether by the ESRI or independent analysts, show that those who have benefited more, proportionately, are the low-paid. I do not think Deputies advocate that those earning £30,000 or £40,000 should not have benefited from changes in taxation policy. Everybody has done well; people are paying less tax and have more disposable income. It is fair to say that it was generally felt by working people that their tax burden prior to the advent of the Government was too onerous. As Deputy Briscoe said, people appreciate the difference in disposable income as a result of the cumulative effect of my five budgets.

Comment on this

We can talk this one around the Houses ad infinitum, but the basic point surely has to be that increasing personal tax credits benefits everybody by a cash amount by reducing the tax burden by that amount. People on higher incomes should benefit to the same extent in monetary amounts rather than in percentage terms. The Minister has moved on several different fronts, but if I had the same opportunity, I would have done it the other way around by increasing the personal tax credits and perhaps, if money was available, by doing some of the things the Minister has done at the higher levels. In terms of priorities, the Minister has got it wrong.

Comment on this

Are there any other contributions?

Comment on this

As amendments Nos. 6 to 17, inclusive, are being discussed together perhaps I should outline my proposals in relation to some of the other tax credits before Deputy McGrath and Deputy Mitchell address the amendments they put down. Amendment No. 13 in my name proposes a modest increase in the age allowance from €410 to €550. The Minister will know from experience of previous debates on Committee Stage of Finance Bills that I feel we should do what we can to remove from the tax net relatively small personal or private pensions that people may have as well as social welfare pensions. I appreciate the argument that people get tax benefits when they contribute towards private pensions, but people resent having to pay tax to the State on contributions for a frequently small pension on top of the social welfare contributory pension. We should move towards increasing the age allowance to try to provide some assistance to people in such circumstances.

The second amendment in my name concerns incapacitated children. There is a similar amendment in the name of Fine Gael Deputies. This allowance or credit has remained more or less the same for a number of years. There are other measures in place which seek to deal with this issue, but in so far as this is an attempt to recognise that people with an incapacitated child have particular calls on their income and responsibilities, the credit should have been increased significantly over the period in which we had the opportunity to do so. That is the reason I tabled the amendment for discussion.

We discussed this issue last year when the Minister moved on a related issue in so far as he considerably increased the allowance for those who pay for a carer. However, we should also have increased the credit for incapacitated children.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be aware that I have similar sympathy for the aged, but prefer to deal with this by way of exemptions rather than increased tax credits as it targets available resources at those most in need. Accordingly, I have again substantially increased the age exemption this year. The limit has been virtually doubled since 1997. I had similar arguments with my predecessor in that I wished to increase the age exemption, but that was not acceded to. I doubled the age exemption which has removed the bulk of aged persons from the tax net. The figure is now €26,000 for a married person and €13,000 for a single person. The figure has effectively doubled since 1997-98.

I did not increase the age credit by much as that approach benefits pensioners with large incomes. It is better to address this issue by way of exemptions as that removes the majority of pensioners from the tax net. That is the basis on which I proceeded, rather than increasing the age credit.

In the Bill I have substantially increased the incapacitated child credit by over 22%. As regards the more minor items referred to, such as the dependent relative tax credit and others, rather than the single or married person's tax credit, in time I would like to make the tax free allowance certificate so simple that it would effectively contain nothing more than the personal or married tax credit and the tax band. I would like to move in that direction to make the administration of the system easier and better for everyone. This depends on the general election and other matters, but that is the approach I would like to take. I understand the Deputy's objectives in terms of the age credit, but I approached this issue from another direction by doubling the limit.

Comment on this

The Minister and I probably agree that the difficulty with the manner in which he has approached this is that it does, or can, create a marginal problem.

Comment on this

To stand logic on its head, I have not increased the threshold for ordinary income tax exemptions so as to get away from that terrible problem which we had. I no longer have that problem as less than 1,000 taxpayers are caught in this situation as opposed 30,000 or 40,000 when I became Minister.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister take one approach with ordinary taxpayers and a second with the aged?

Comment on this

This is a work issue in terms of ordinary exemption limits, but that is not the case with the aged.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, it can be a small, or relatively small, pension issue.

Comment on this

My approach has removed the majority of pensioners from the tax net. In 1997-98 the limit was £9,200 for a married person and £4,600 for a single person. The new limits will be €26,000 and €13,000. I have more than doubled the limits.

Comment on this

We are approaching the same problem in slightly different ways. I argued for the other approach for the reasons the Minister just elucidated as far as ordinary, non-aged people are concerned.

Comment on this

That is a smaller number.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 8 to 12, inclusive, seek to address the issue of the widow's tax allowance. We wish to give widows the same tax allowance as married couples. In other words, on the death of a spouse, a widow or widower would retain the married allowance. This issue is complicated by court rulings and so on, but we should seek to overcome them. If a spouse dies, a widow has a house which requires the same amount of heat and light, she still has to feed and clothe children and so on. It is almost certain that she will already have lost a significant amount of income. A working spouse who retires typically receives half their previous income and their spouse receives 25%. This means that their income reduces dramatically. In addition, their tax free allowance is reduced.

Widows are one of the forgotten tribes in everything the Minister has done, and he has done much in the past five years. In this budget there was a special increase for widows, which was long overdue. Widows are still £20 below old age pensioners, and have no free travel, electricity or telephone allowance, etc. Some widows are living in real poverty and if they are unfortunate to live on their own, they have no living alone allowance. I am aware of many widows in their fifties who cannot wait until they are 66 years. That is an awful way to be. They cannot afford to get their hair done or socialise. Widows comprise one of the most forgotten groups. They are now the poorest of the poor with those who live on sickness benefit, are over 50 years and living alone. These are the two groups who live in the greatest poverty.

The Minister is similar to me in that his father died young and his mother was widowed at a young age. I have no doubt that his heart is in the right place, but what is the problem with giving widows the married person's tax allowance? Why not let them keep their allowance? Why not say to them, "You may lose your spouse, but you are not going to lose your tax allowance?" Amendments Nos. 14, 16 and 17 seek to double the tax allowance for people with a disabled child.

Comment on this

I support the amendments. Widows and widowers are the forgotten people. We must examine the manner in which we treat them. Deputy Mitchell outlined the level of payments which such people receive and the fact that many of them live in poverty. Losing one's spouse is a great blow, but a further significant blow is to then try to survive on a low income.

I am aware of people who lost a spouse who was, perhaps, employed by the local authority, the Defence Forces or the health board, and who had opted out of a pension scheme. I know of a number of widows who had a spouse for companionship and so on, income from social welfare because they were retired and a work pension. Suddenly they are no longer in receipt of a work pension because their spouse opted out of the widow's and orphan's scheme without their knowledge. Such people are left in poverty. I know of one lady who had been assured by her husband that she would be well looked after when he died. She cannot manage on a widow's pension and is in absolute poverty. She is trying to survive and manage even as she copes with the blow of losing her spouse. In that case, the taxation measures will not help.

The Minister spoke earlier of how he had delivered on the social welfare front. How can it be that widow's pensions are so far below old age pensions? Why can they not be increased to facilitate widows? I came across a case of a garda with small children whose wife had died suddenly. The benefit from the State - and it has changed slightly since - was that he was obliged to pay £50 per week in additional taxes.

The widowed person tax credit is a step in the right direction, but why is it phased out after five years? Why should it not remain in place while there are dependent children? That would be more reasonable and the additional income would be some consolation for those people.

In discussing the issue of home caring spouses, the Minister may consider my own case. I am in a one-income family. As Deputy Briscoe said, we are of middle income; we are doing all right. We will qualify for the home caring spouse allowance until my seventeen-year-old turns eighteen. If she goes to college it will probably cost me more, yet I will pay more tax. Why should the allowance be tied to the existence of a child under 18? It should extend at least to their college years and I do not know whether it should be taken away at all.

Comment on this

As the Deputies are aware, I have spoken for many years of my sympathy for widows. This is because of my personal background. It was I who substantially increased the widowed parent allowance in 1998. However, under the rates proposed in the Bill the widowed parent, in the first year after the bereavement, will have a tax credit of €5,640 consisting of a single credit of €1,520 plus a one-parent family credit of €1,520 plus the proposed widowed parent tax credit of €2,600. This compares very favourably with the married tax credit of €3,040 and I do not see the need to go as far as the Deputies' proposal recommends. Also, under the Deputies' proposed amendment there would be a huge step-down effect after year five as the widowed parent's credit drops from €6,080 to €3,040. I prefer a more tapered approach which would see the credit gradually diminish, as proposed in the Bill. Overall, I am satisfied that my proposed increase represents a significant movement in the right direction, given the resources at my disposal.

I brought in this substantial, tapering allowance, the widowed parent bereavement allowance, over five years. Widows with children also effectively have the married allowance plus the married tax band. There is a difficulty when it comes to the treatment of widows. Going back to my time as Minister for Social Welfare, I wanted to increase substantially the amount of money given to widows and I am sure that my successors would have liked to do the same. However, we were hamstrung by the fact that it was referred to as the lone parent's allowance and there would have to be some differentiation between widows and other lone parents. The ensuing difficulties may be imagined. I can see Mr. McDowell's constituency colleagues berating any Minister who makes that distinction. This is to be eliminated over the years. The unmarried mother's allowance, as it was originally called, was removed, followed by the deserted wife's allowance. All that has been removed. Rightly, we now have the same description for all these categories. It is more appropriate and for once I agree with this politically correct definition.

However, problems also arise with this. In my first year as Minister for Social Welfare I wanted to so something substantial for widows in the Social Welfare Bill. The budget had been announced but I wanted to do something more. I have always intended to do something for widows if I ever got the opportunity - and I am lucky enough to have been able to do many of them. I feel that my background has been forgotten. However, at the time I ran into the difficulty I explained above. All my successors have also encountered that difficulty. The same thing also applies to the taxation code. If we differentiate between widows and everybody else in tax terms we will have to do the same for lone parents. The categories are now all the same because society has moved that way. I do not have any personal difficulty with the way we deal with things.

I have brought in a special allowance for widows which tapers off over five years and that is as far as I can go. When the single standard rate band is introduced everybody will be in the same situation. At the moment the standard rate band cut-off is at €28,000 for single people, €32,000 for lone parents and €37,000 for married couples with one income. When the process is finished everybody will be at the same standard rate and the problem with the band will not exist. At the moment a widowed parent will always have the equivalent of a married taxpayer's credit, consisting of the single credit and the one-parent allowance credit. Widows with children will always have the equivalent of a married tax credit, but when the child goes beyond a certain age the widowed parent is in the same situation as everybody else. Deputy McGrath made the case for continuing the allowance. Widows still have an advantage over a lone parent but if the gap was too large we would have all kinds of difficulties.

Regarding pensions, Deputy McGrath will have noticed that before the last two budgets the gap between the contributory widow's pension and the contributory old age pension was considerable. I have narrowed that gap. I had hoped to close it but instead I have narrowed it so that the gap is very small.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

What was the gap?

Comment on this

A widow aged over 66 on a contributory pension had a smaller pension than that of a contributory old age pensioner of the same age.

Comment on this

The Minister is back in the Department of Social Welfare.

Comment on this

Until my last two budgets that gap was considerable. In this year's budget there will be a special increase of €2.58 per week in the widow's contributory pension. The increase last year was also substantial. Some lobbying on this issue by widows has taken place, although it was not widely heard, over the last number of years. It has now finally come about. There is still a small gap but next year's budget will complete the process.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There is a very clear difference between a widow with dependent children and one without dependent children. A widow solely living on £96 per week is clearly in the worst-off category. Single parents with no dependent children are no longer single parents, although it also extends to the deserted wife. We cannot find a way to give relief to widows on low income because of they are in the category of single parents. There must be some way of doing this. For instance, should there be a living alone allowance? They have no free travel, free electricity or free telephone allowance, which allowances are worth £30 to £40 per week, plus the £20 difference. We are talking about a difference of approximately £50 per week compared to an old age pensioner of the same age. Where there is a will, there is a way. We should find a way to address the issue for this category, especially the widow living alone.

Comment on this

We are dealing with taxation changes. What the Deputy is raising relates to the whole State code, including social welfare pensions. If a person was on the basic contributory widow's pension, they would not be in the tax net.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

That is true.

Comment on this

While I appreciate the point the Deputy makes regarding widows, I have gone as far as I can go in the tax code. There are other issues which can be addressed through policy and other areas.

Comment on this

As it is now 2 p.m., I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 21 February: "That sections 3 to 8, which are undisposed of, are hereby agreed to."

Comment on this

We resume on section 9, amendment No. 22, in the name of the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 22:

In page 16, line 12, to delete "(iii)".

This is a purely technical amendment to correct a printing error.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 23:

In page 16, before section 10, to insert the following new section:

10.-(1) Part 30 of the Principal Act is amended:

(a) in Chapter I-

(i) in subsection (3) of section 772-

(I) by substituting the following for paragraph (b):

'(b) that any pension for any widow, widower, children or dependants of an employee who dies before retirement shall be a pension or pensions payable on the employee’s death of an amount that does not or, as the case may be, do not in aggregate exceed any pension or pensions which, consonant with the condition in paragraph (a), could have been provided for the employee on retirement on attaining the specified age, if the employee had continued to serve until the employee attained that age at an annual rate of remuneration equal to the employee’s final remuneration;’,

(II) by substituting the following for paragraph (d):

'(d) that any benefit for any widow, widower, children or dependants of an employee payable on the employee’s death after retirement is a pension or pensions such that the aggregate amount of such pension or, as the case may be, pensions so payable does not exceed any pension or pensions payable to the employee;’,

and

(III) by deleting paragraph (e),

(ii) in subsection (7) of section 774, by substituting the following for paragraph (c):

'(c) The aggregate amount of annual contributions (whether ordinary annual contributions or contributions treated as ordinary annual contributions) allowed to be deducted in any year shall not exceed-

(i) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 30 years or over but had not attained the age of 40 years, 20 per cent,

(ii) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 40 years or over but had not attained the age of 50 years, 25 per cent,

(iii) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 50 years or over, 30 per cent, and

(iv) in any other case, 15 per cent,

of the remuneration for that year of the office or employment in respect of which the contributions are paid.',

(iii) in subsection (2) of section 776, by substituting the following for paragraph (c):

'(c) The aggregate amount of annual contributions (whether ordinary annual contributions or contributions treated as ordinary annual contributions) allowed to be deducted in any year shall not exceed-

(i) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 30 years or over but had not attained the age of 40 years, 20 per cent,

(ii) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 40 years or over but had not attained the age of 50 years, 25 per cent,

(iii) in the case of an individual who at any time during the year of assessment was of the age of 50 years or over, 30 per cent, and

(iv) in any other case, 15 per cent,

of the remuneration for that year of the office or employment in respect of which the contributions are paid.',

and

(iv) in section 780(5), by substituting 'the standard rate in force at the time of payment' for '25 per cent',

and

(b) in Chapter 2, by substituting the following for subsection (1) of section 784:

'(1) (a) Where an individual, being an individual referred to in paragraph (b), pays a premium or other consideration under an annuity contract for the time being approved by the Revenue Commissioners as being a contract by which the main benefit secured is, or would, but for the exercise of an option by the individual under subsection (2A), be a life annuity for the individual in his or her old age or under a contract for the time being approved under section 785 (in this Chapter referred to as a “qualifying premium”), relief from income tax may be given in respect of the qualifying premium under section 787.

(b) An individual referred to in this paragraph is an individual who is or was (or but for an insufficiency of profits or gains would be or would have been) for any year of assessment chargeable to tax in respect of relevant earnings from any trade, profession, office or employment carried on or held by him or her and who paid a qualifying premium in that year.’.

(2) (a) Paragraph (a)(i) of subsection (1) applies from the passing of this Act.

(b) Paragraph (a)(iv) of subsection (1) applies to any repayment of contributions referred to in section 780 of the Principal Act which is made on or after 5 December 2001.

(c) Subsection (1)(other than paragraphs (a)(i) and (a)(iv)) applies as respects the year of assessment 2002 and subsequent years of assessment.”.

This amendment proposes, before section 10, to make a change in relation to pensions which I announced on the publication of the Bill and is designed to encourage employees to increase their level of pension cover. Under existing rules, the maximum an employee who is a member of an approved occupational pension scheme can put aside in a tax efficient manner for his or her pension is 15% of his or her annual remuneration. This limit applies for the aggregate of normal scheme contributions and additional voluntary contributions, known as AVCs.

AVCs are a procedure available to employees to increase their pension entitlements where the entitlements under the employer's scheme are less than the approved limits, principally a pension of two thirds of final salary. On the other hand, the self-employed and employees not in occupational pension schemes can get tax relief on contributions up to 30% of relevant earnings on an age related basis. To mirror the treatment for employees in occupational pension schemes, I am, therefore, now providing that they will in future be entitled to aggregate annual contributions as follows: up to 30 years of age,15% of remuneration; 30 to 40 years of age, 20% of remuneration; 40 to 50 years of age, 25% of remuneration; and over 50 years of age, 30% of remuneration.

Second, I am liberalising the rules in relation to retirement annuity contracts for the self-employed. Under the existing rules, a self-employed individual who becomes an employee and joins an occupational pension scheme must terminate the RAC he or she holds, unless he or she continues to have a source of self-employment income. I am now providing that this will no longer be the case. He or she may in future continue with the RAC or own a further RAC, but without tax relief. The contribution to the RAC will be carried forward indefinitely until such time, if any, that the employee acquires a source of self-employment income.

Third, the rules of an occupational pension scheme cannot provide a pension for a spouse of a widow or widower of a deceased member which is more than two thirds of the member's entitlement. In the case of children and other dependants, the fraction is one half of what may be provided for a spouse. This, in effect, allows the equivalent of the employee's full pension to be divided between, for example, a spouse and a child; that is, two thirds and one third, respectively. While the aggregate of all pensions to the employee's survivors remains at the level of the employee's entitlement, I am removing the upper restrictions on the individual pensions in order that, for example, a full pension can be provided for a spouse or, alternatively, a child.

The revised section 10 contains the existing provision which reduces the tax charge on repayments of pension contributions from 25% to the standard rate of income tax, currently 20%. This charge is designed to recoup some measure of tax relief at the employee's marginal rate, given when the contributions were made. The level of the charge has now been aligned with the standard rate of income tax.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I have no difficulty with the Minister's proposal, but want to take advantage of this amendment to raise a couple of issues in relation to pensions. We had a discussion on an earlier amendment in relation to the plight of widows. However, the reality of most occupational pensions, especially most public service pensions, is that the widow ends up on one quarter of her spouse's income, which is an enormous drop. To do anything about it would be very expensive because of the numbers involved, but is it any longer tolerable that widows of public servants who served the country well should be left living on one quarter of their spouses' incomes? Is there anything that we should contemplate doing about it?

The other anomaly that I want to raise is a separate one about private pension schemes. In the past ten years the State has given significant increases in pensions over and above the rate of inflation, yet many private pension schemes are clawing back the difference. The State is effectively paying money into private pension funds with no benefit to it. When Deputy De Rossa was Minster for Social, Community and Family Affairs this issue was raised by us. It is still being raised by many groups. Why should there be a clawback? The intention of the State is to improve the lot of pensioners whereas the effect in these cases is only to improve the lot of the pension fund.

I realise that my comments are not directly related to the amendment, but I want to make the point while we are on the issue ofpensions.

Comment on this

I welcome the amendment proposed by the Minister. Last year, in talking about the Finance Bill, I raised the issue of public servants, particularly teachers, who had worked abroad for a number of years and may well have been members of religious orders. Having changed their status, they returned home or left the religious orders and are now working as teachers. The result is that they will not have the required number of years for pension purposes. I know of a particular case where a man wanted to buy, by way of AVCs, additional pension cover. The cap put on it at that time was 15%. He was already paying 6% by way of pension contribution. The extra amount he could pay was very limited. If one is 51 or 52 years of age, or 54 as in our case, I think, and one wanted to buy additional pension in the short period left, 6% or 7% is not a lot of good, yet somebody who is self-employed could use up to 30% of their income to make contributions.

Will this amendment deal with that? The Minister did not mention it in the briefing note and that is why I ask. Will a range of people in the public service be able to avail of this additional facility? If that is the case - the Minister's officials are nodding in agreement - would it be possible to circulate the briefing note relating to that?

The other point, to which Deputy Mitchell alluded, relates to the capping of private pension schemes. An example I have come across is Guinness. Guinness employees are caught in that if additional moneys are paid in social welfare, there is a clawback. Although the fund is enormously in profit and has colossal sums of money as reserves, they are clawing back on the social welfare increases that might be given by Government.

The same applies to the farm retirement scheme, although it is not a private scheme. There is a terrible anomaly in that scheme. A person from the Minister's constituency of Kildare spoke to me about it recently. I do not know how they came across me - maybe it was because of something in the newspaper. If a farmer avails of the farm retirement scheme and the maximum payment is £10,000, for the sake of argument, they must apply for social welfare when they reach 66 years of age. If they do so and are awarded a contributory or non-contributory social welfare pension of £150 per week totalling an annual payment of £7,500, the pension from the farm retirement scheme is reduced by the amount of the social welfare payment - in other words, it is reduced by the £7,500 so they are left with £2,500 from the farm retirement scheme and £7,500 from social welfare. If the Minister, in his goodness, comes forward with a £20 increase in the social welfare pension, income from social welfare goes from £7,500 to £8,500. There is a further clawback then from the farm retirement pension and the additional £1,000 is taken back. That couple is left with £8,500 from social welfare and £1,500 from the farm retirement scheme - in other words, there is a category of people whose income is capped by virtue of the arrangements in place.

Is there anything the Minister can do in that regard? It relates to Deputy Mitchell's point. How can the Minister's Department ensure that increases given to groups such as that mentioned are passed on and not absorbed elsewhere? It is not fair to expect those pensioners to survive on a flat income. In numerical terms, a fair number is affected. I think about 20,000 farmers have availed of the farm retirement scheme and their income has been capped. I would appreciate any words of wisdom the Minister may have on that.

Comment on this

I have a more fundamental difficulty with the provision in the first place. When the Minister introduced his gradated level of contributions, or contributions that would attract tax relief for people over 55 years of age, I was happy enough to go along with that on the basis that I understood the argument behind it. I think I said at the time that we nonetheless needed to avoid a situation where we were effectively encouraging a measure of tax avoidance or, at the very least, a deferral of tax. I think we have gone one step closer in the provisions the Minister has made today towards deferral of tax and towards encouraging tax avoidance.

This comes down to a basic philosophical question as to what we are looking to do here in the first place. The basic provision by the State is through the social insurance system and the contributory pension that is provided on foot of that. All of us now accept that individuals up to a point are entitled to and should even be encouraged to supplement their post retirement income through private provision. I am one of those who has always believed that some measure of compulsion may be required to make that system work. The introduction of PRSAs and portability of pensions through the Pensions Bill that is currently being introduced is moving in that direction in that clearly we are encouraging and obliging employers at least to have in place a system which will allow for portability of pensions and so on.

We will move inevitably, within ten to 15 years, to a system where there will be, effectively, for people over or of a certain income compulsory provision of private pensions to supplement the State income. Up to a point, it is the business of the State to encourage and incentivise people through the tax system to do that. I do not, however, say that without limit because the responsibility of the State stops somewhere and people should not be given tax relief to provide as much pension as they want. Our responsibility only goes so far. The Minister is moving inexorably and probably in accordance with his own beliefs towards making it possible for people in effect to defer tax and reduce their tax to a degree with which I am uncomfortable. I would not go so far as to say I am opposed to it but I am not sure I like the drift.

Comment on this

Over the past number of years I have made considerable changes to the pension-tax regulations. Some years ago, I made a quite fundamental change to pensions in regard to the self-employed and proprietary directors in that I dealt with the age related limits. Up to then, it was 15% of reckonable earnings. In the previous budget, for the first time in I do not know how long, I think it was 20% of reckonable earnings if one was over 55 years. I decided to change the age related percentages as they related to the self-employed and proprietary directors. More fundamentally, I changed the whole basis of how this was done before - and not just the tax relief - in that I brought in these approved retirement funds and approved minimum retirement funds. I gave discretion to people on the amount of funds they could contribute themselves. We had much debate on that at the time. It would be fair to say that was a fundamental change in the pensions area which had not been thought of before and had not been looked at from that angle.

I did not do anything at that time in relation to employees because the case was put to me that the Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs was responsible for the Pensions Act and any amendments thereto. I just concentrated on what related to the self-employed and proprietary directors. It led to an upsurge in the sale of pensions.

I expressed views over the years on how I thought things were going. I said at the time that perhaps in years to come I would make changes which would extend to the employee. What I am doing in this Bill is a relatively small step. I would have liked to make further progress in regard to the tax limits and the Revenue rules relating to employees but the more I looked at it, the more complicated it became. I left it to these changes which, effectively, do the three things I mentioned. They extend the age related mechanism to employees as far as they contribute to AVCs. That is the main thing it does. It covers the people to whom Deputy McGrath referred last year or the previous year. The teacher from aboard of a certain age can avail of the new limits of disregard regarding AVCs.

Deputy McDowell and I might come at this from a slightly different angle but the overall idea might be the same. I fundamentally believe, and have done for a long time, that in ten years' time or maybe less the State may not be in a position to fund the increases in pensions out of the public purse given the way things are going. That was the main reason I set up the National Pension Reserve Fund, that is, to put money aside so that when the demographics moved in another direction and we were hit with that big bill, it would help.

Second, it is more important for parts of the State sector, as the Deputy will have noticed in the years since I made these changes. I have made my views known over the past five years. Most schemes are now based on defined contributions rather than defined benefits, apart from the State, which has civil servants, gardaí and teachers who have half pay after 40 years' service and a 1.5% lump sum. All other companies have had to depart from that.

Within the past fortnight, there has been a major debate in the United Kingdom about a certain pension fund belonging to some very large companies which are changing the accounting rules. New rules are to be introduced as a result of a report that has been produced, and that is happening all over the world. Inevitably, as sure as night follows day, defined benefit schemes will be faced with that dilemma as well.

It has been my experience, coming from a self-employed background outside the public service, that people in the public service do not generally appreciate the value of their pension schemes. People in the private sector could not possibly fund schemes for themselves that the public sector has, such as index-linked pensions, half pay after so many years and a lump sum coming out of the public purse. They do not really appreciate those benefits. Over the years, big employers, such as the one Deputy Jim Mitchell may be familiar with, were able to have defined benefit schemes as good as those of the State, and sometimes better. However, in recent years all those big companies have had to depart from that. My raison d’être has been that we should put up a buffer to help the State provide some reserves from the good times against the time when the demographics go against us.

I am using the tax system to encourage people to provide for their own pensions. In every country, but certainly here in Ireland, people have shown that if they get a tax break they are inclined to avail of it. Private pensions provided a good tax break even before I started to make them more attractive through the fundamental changes I made in the control of the funds people had. However, very few self-employed people paid anything up to the level allowed for tax purposes. Most self-employed people probably were not paying anything like the proper level of contributions for which they would receive a tax break.

We have to go down this road and, therefore, I have tried to make tax breaks more attractive to encourage people to start providing for their own pensions. This applies even to people who are in occupational schemes because I believe, although this advice did not come from the Department of Finance or anywhere else, that inevitably this will happen. Having made big changes regarding the self-employed, which were enacted in a previous Finance Bill, I am making some changes here in the AVC area.

There are many employee pension tax rules, some of which are archaic and thus beyond their sell-buy dates. People may not even be able to remember whether or not the rules exist. I can see no reason why people should not be encouraged to avail of this, so I have introduced age-related limits for pensioned employees as well.

Deputy Mitchell asked a wider question regarding abated pensions, but that matter is really for the trustees of the pension funds. From my knowledge of that area, pension funds are based on their expectation of so many people falling out and others having State pensions. The actuary calculates the benefits on that basis. Under the Pensions Act, 1990, introduced by my colleague, the former Minister for Social Welfare, the Pensions Board has the right to examine all these pension funds. They have set an actuarial level and must comply with the law as provided for by the Pensions Act, 1990, by having sufficient funds. All those matters are accounted for in that legislation. It is not just a question of pension fund trustee legislation not taking into account what a social welfare pension would be; that must already have been built into the calculations. There will be nothing to prevent any pension fund from bringing in its own rules, but I would safely say it would definitely mean higher contributions from the employee in order to build up the reserves in those pension funds. Pension funds are contracts between the employee and the trustees of the pension fund, and the rules are regulated internally. The prudentiary rules are regulated by the Pensions Board under the Pensions Act, 1990.

It is correct to say that many pension schemes, and most that I know of, have those abatement rules. They take into account that if a person is in receipt of a State pension the overall pension is abated. That would have been brought into the calculations in setting up a particular fund, but that is solely a matter of contract between the trustees and those in the fund. It is their pension fund and that is the way things are. I am encouraging people to go outside the normal basis of their occupational pension, encouraging them to have more AVCs in order to top up their pensions, and to have a better standard of living in retirement. The dramatic fall in income for pensioners is considerable.

Comment on this

It is not clear from the text, but does it just apply to the AVCs?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Does it allow one to increase the amount of the normal contribution to the occupational pension fund?

Comment on this

It only refers to the AVCs which allow a person to subscribe money so as to be able to receive the maximum pension by adding years. The overall ceiling still remains the same. What I am doing is pretty attractive but it is not as fundamental as the change I made some years ago. In future, I may make more changes in this area. Additional voluntary contributions allow people to get the maximum benefit.

As regards widows' pensions, Deputy Mitchell is right in saying that in the State sector, if pensioners have served their maximum time they can receive two thirds of their income, although the new ones represent only half pay. If the pensioner dies the widow then receives half of that half, which is a quarter. There is, therefore, a considerable drop in income. In time to come, I am sure it will be a matter for those negotiating public sector agreements whether or not changes will be made in that regard. There would be some additional cost. This was brought to my attention on many occasions when Deputies were negotiating with me about changes in pensions and pay. Most Deputies were not so much concerned about the pension they were going to get themselves, but with what would happen when they passed on and, thus, what their widow would have as a result. As I pointed out, it would not be possible to change it for Members of the Oireachtas without have regard to the broader scope of all the public service pensions being brought into play. It is a matter that will probably be negotiated and discussed with unions representing public sector employees in the overall context of negotiating pay and pensions in future. I do not have a fixed mind about it. The changes I am introducing here will allow all those people to get a tax break if they want to contribute more to their pension scheme, thereby lessening the downward hit when they retire.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will come back to that point but I wish to deal with the clawback from pension funds. I should declare an interest in that I am a member of the Guinness pension fund, so I might benefit indirectly from this contribution.

Comment on this

They have a very good pension scheme, or they had anyway.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

There are many such pension funds where there is a clawback.

Comment on this

Nearly all of them have. In fact, they all have.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

It is fair enough for them to take a clawback of what was then the normal increase in pensions, but it is wrong that they should also claw back the bonus the State has given because of improved circumstances. The intention of the larger increase given by the State in the last number of years was to improve the lot of people.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Instead of those people benefiting, however, it is the pension fund which does so. We should legislate so that private pension funds may claw back the normal indexation, but they may not claw back any bonus the State has given.

Comment on this

I am advised that the Pensions Board is currently examining this matter and will bring forward a report in due course. If a favourable report is received, it would implicitly mean that there would have to be higher contributions to the scheme. Otherwise, the solvency of the fund would not be sufficient.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Several of the funds I know of are flush with money. It is not a question of the solvency of the funds.

Comment on this

The pension fund to which the Deputy is referring is definitely flush with money.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am not speaking about just one pension fund. I have met pensions groups over many years and several pension funds are in this position. The Minister said that the Pensions Board is looking at it, but this has been the stock answer for many years, including many years before the Minister, Deputy McCreevy, took office, but I will not labour the point.

Comment on this

There was an article in the Financial Times a few weeks ago which said that most large companies currently changing their final salary schemes are closing them to new members. Recently, Iceland and Ernst & Young froze schemes for existing members. They took the somewhat unusual step of reducing them for existing members and that caused some controversy.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I realise that. The 1% set aside allowed is the minimum that should be done and I made that clear. We should look at ways and means of increasing the set aside so that we are covered for future pension costs. Any spare Central Bank reserves or anything to spare from the capital redemption fund or the social insurance fund should go into the national pension reserve to provide prudential cover for the future. I favour some linkage of social insurance fund surpluses with the national pension reserve fund so that none of the Minister's successors will be able to resort to the methods the Minister used this year.

Comment on this

I will take this opportunity to give a better reply than would be possible in the Dáil. In 1999 I announced the establishment of the national pension reserve fund. I held a press conference about it and I issued a press release. I announced that I intended to set up two pension funds on a two to one basis - one for what I call State contributory pensions for ordinary people and one as the pension fund for Civil Service pensioners. The intention was to set up two funds on that basis. It was also intended that every year we would transfer an element of the social insurance fund. Since 1995, any new entrant to the Civil Service pays full PRSI. If I remember correctly, £170 million was the amount two years ago.

We tried to work out a basis each year to put money in from the social welfare fund and PRSI money from the social insurance fund. It became so complicated that I abandoned the idea and decided to have one fund which would receive 1% of GNP and the privatisation receipts. We avoided the very complicated format and the background documentation will show the procedure followed. The transfer mechanism for taking money out of the social insurance fund was originally envisaged when I was setting up the national pension reserve fund.

Comment on this

It was not in the manifesto. The manifesto stated that it would not be touched.

Comment on this

The manifesto did not refer to setting up a national pension reserve fund.

Comment on this

The Minister said he would not raid the social welfare fund. It is in the party's manifesto.

Comment on this