We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE AND THE PUBLIC SERVICE

Finance Bill, 2002: Committee Stage.

Contributions 157–315 of 315. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 2002
Enacted

No. 4 of 2002 ›

The manifesto mentioned the setting up of a board.

Comment on this

It said it would be safe in the hands of the Minister. That is exactly what it said.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

At present there is a surplus in the social insurance fund. There has been a surplus for the past couple of years and it may continue for another few years. However, if events took a turn for the worse, that situation could change. The social insurance fund has been augmented in the past by general taxation in order to pay contributory pensions. However, because of what is looming in the future, we should formalise the relationship between social insurance fund surpluses and the national pension reserve fund. At present only 30% of known future costs are covered. Those of us who have been in the Oireachtas for nearly 30 years know that is a short period. These arrangements will begin in 20 years so it is, therefore, reasonable to make increased prudential provision compared to what is being done at present. I know a counter argument has been made by others. Will public servants be in a position to add to their contributions?

Comment on this

Yes. They are able to do so at present and they will be able to avail of this age-related mechanism also. If a civil servant succeeds in completing a full 40 years service in the near future, he will not be able to add to his pension. AVCs are a mechanism to help people avail of the maximum pension other than via the death grant. If a person such as a teacher joined the Civil Service at age 44, they will certainly avail of AVCs. A person aged over 50 years may contribute 30% to build up a pension.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Has any thought been given to developing that principle to allow added contributions for the purpose of an increase in widows' pensions from, for example, one quarter to one third?

Comment on this

The change being made here allows for that.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Is a maximum amount allowed?

Comment on this

Up to 100% is allowed, which would include what the deceased spouse would have received. Deputy Mitchell is very welcome to give any views on pensions. I asked a colleague in his party for his views when I was contemplating changes in the past. It is fair to say that I have done everything about pensions totally by myself in the Department of Finance over the last five years.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

All the civil servants declared their interests.

Comment on this

The Minister and I have had a difference of philosophy on this matter before. I still prefer to think of pensions and the way in which we contribute to them as insurance rather than a savings scheme. That is the fundamental difference between us. I do not wish my position regarding the pension reserve fund to be misunderstood. I have moved from being somewhat sceptical to being deeply sceptical about it. On any read of the figures, there is no demographic time bomb. The additional cost is something that could be relatively easily absorbed and it requires a constant balance between the needs of the future and current needs. I am not convinced that even making provision for 30% of the costs in the second quarter of the century would be a priority of mine. I would be grateful if the Minister could recapitulate the terms of the retirement annuity contracts.

Comment on this

When I was making changes regarding the self-employed some years ago, I came across books that listed all these rules about employees and I decided to tackle that issue. I wanted to make substantive changes regarding employees on this occasion, but the more I discussed it with my civil servants, the more bogged down we became. There was one rule in particular that I was determined to change. As an example of how it worked, let us take a self-employed carpenter in Longford-Roscommon who works very hard and makes £25,000 a year. For some amazing reason, if he puts his money into a self-employed pension scheme such as an RAC - a retirement annuity contract - and then has the good fortune of being taken on by FÁS as an instructor and joins its occupational pension scheme, he is precluded from contributing to the RAC, even though he may have paid into it for ten or 15 years. I thought this rule was very stupid and have introduced a measure to abolish it.

However, tax relief will not be available on further payments made to a self-employed scheme unless the person - the carpenter in this case - continues to declare some earnings from his or her profession. At least he will be allowed to continue to contribute to the scheme if he has already done so for 15 or 20 years. In the circumstances I have described most people paying into a group scheme may not want to continue to do so because they will not receive a tax break, but many others may want to continue because they have paid into their scheme for 20 years. Under the existing rules, one is debarred from doing so. The only change is to eliminate this rule. The reason for its introduction has been lost in the mists of time.

I am aware of one particular case many years ago of a self-employed person, a proprietary director, who for years paid into a scheme - I believe it was an occupational pension scheme - only to be told by the pension company many years later that it was obliged to return to him the money he had paid in, even though he wanted to continue in the scheme. Despite informing the company that he did not want the money, but wished to have his fund grow, the rules meant it returned the money to him.

Comment on this

Acceptance of the amendment involves the deletion of section 10 of the Bill.

Comment on this

I oppose section 10 on the grounds that a small part of it concerns pensions and all pension issues are brought together in the new section.

Section 10 deleted.

SECTION 11.

Comment on this

This section proposes to change the date, is that correct?

Comment on this

Section 11 is technical in nature. It amends section 128 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which sets out the tax treatment of gains realised by a director or employee from a right to acquire shares or other assets granted by reason of his or her office or employment. Under section 128, a company granting such rights in a tax year is required to make a return of the detail to Revenue by 13 June following the end of that year. As a consequence of the alignment of the tax and calendar years, the return date will be changed to 31 March following the end of the tax year. In addition, it is provided that, where a company is not resident in the State but operates here through a branch or agency, responsibility for making the return will rest with the company's representative in the State.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 25 is an alternative to amendment No. 24. Both may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 24:

In page 19, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:

"(11) Where any sporting body, organisation or the like, in the State, reimburses members for the cost of attending training or other preparatory events then notwithstanding any other provisions of the Income Tax Acts, such reimbursements shall, up to a maximum of €750 in any one year of assessment, not be liable to taxation in the hands of the recipient provided that the Revenue Commissioners are satisfied that a listing of all such reimbursements by a relevant sporting body or organisation is complete and accurate and was for the bona fide purpose of reimbursing members for actual cost incurred.".

Comment on this

I wish to amend our proposal. I do not have the wording of the amendment, but we will bring forward a text on Report Stage. We want to discuss the Minister's proposals on elite sportspersons, a group for which he will allocate approximately €5 million per year. It seems very strange that he wants to give back 40% of the tax paid by sportspersons who have decided to retire after a career of perhaps ten years. As they are, obviously, already highly paid, I do not know the reason they should want this money. During his Second Stage speech on the Bill, DeputyMcDowell made the point that it would not be reasonable for a young person who has been given a position with Manchester United or, better still, Leeds United, to decide to live here and commute by Ryanair every week to ensure that in ten years time he will be able to receive a clawback from the Minister's gift to sportspersons.

Tremendous commitment is given by a whole range of sportspersons in this country on a weekly basis. Tens of thousands turn out week after week to watch their county team perform in inter-county football and hurling games in which I know the Minister also takes an interest. Last Sunday, for example, an atrocious day by any standards, I went along to Cusack Park to see Westmeath hammer Cork, which was very pleasing.

Comment on this

Except for people from Cork.

Comment on this

It was very interesting to see. About 7,000 people turned up to see the match in dreadful conditions and were entertained by 38 or 39 young players. The Cork supporters and players travelled at least 150 miles to be there, which involved a lot of time and effort. The level of fitness, commitment and training on the part of the players is absolutely colossal, but they do not get paid.

After reading the suggestion in a newspaper on Monday that intercounty players should be paid €127 per week, I began to think and I looked at some figures. I suggest to the Minister that intercounty hurling and football players should get a relatively small tax credit for their services to their counties. About 60 players represent each of the 26 counties at senior level in either football and hurling each year. If each of them was to be given a tax credit of about €1,000 per annum, the total cost would only be €1.5 million. There would be no cost to county boards, many of which are crippled by trying to bear the cost of running championship and league matches.

Westmeath footballers had a particularly good run last year, playing eight championship matches for the first time. The result, however, was that the county board accrued debts of €200,000, which is a lot of money for volunteers to have to raise. The €5 million that the Minister proposes to give to elite sportspersons could be better used and I suggest that we should look at the possibility of rewarding intercounty GAA players by way of tax credits as a small gesture. The €1,000 I mentioned is the income equivalent of €5.000. It would help the players and would not be seen as making the GAA professional. It would be a reward for the tremendous entertainment we receive, not just for a couple of months in the summer, but throughout the year in league campaigns and other matches. It would serve as an acknowledgement of the GAA's contribution to Irish sport.

Comment on this

I wish to comment on the section as a whole, as I do not understand what it is meant to do. In at least one interview in recent weeks, the Minister compared this measure with the tax relief for artists introduced by the former Minister for Finance, Charles Haughey, in the 1960s. It was reasonably clear, although I was quite young at the time, that Mr. Haughey's measure was intended to encourage artists to ply their art, if that is the right phrase, by writing books and producing all forms of artistic output. As a profession, if I may call it that, art is often poorly remunerated and artists often endure periods without payment. I presume it was intended as a type of income support and I am sure it was directly or indirectly aimed at getting people to live here who might not otherwise have done so. Many Irish artists had gone to live abroad, but the introduction of this measure quelled that trend and also led to many foreign artists coming to live here.

Mr. Haughey's tax relief for artists was broadly supported and it attained its aims, generally speaking. I understood the Minister as saying in recent weeks that the measure in section 12 is intended to do something similar, but I cannot understand how that can be achieved. I do not see how it encourages people to forgo other income and to play sport for a smaller income, on the basis that they may be given a lump sum after ten years have passed. I do not understand how this proposal will encourage people to continue to live in Ireland or to return to Ireland from abroad, on the basis of a potential lump sum ten years down the line. It is not possible for sportspeople to calculate how large the lump sum will be, as those in the first years of a sports career do not know how much tax they will pay over 10 years and, therefore, do not know how much they can reasonably expect by way of tax rebate. I cannot see how this measure amounts to anything other than a "thank you" at the end of a sports career and I am not sure that is a sufficiently good reason to introduce a tax break of this kind.

I have a few specific questions before I move on to my amendment. I would love to know how the figure of €5 million was reached, or whether there is any science to it at all. I appreciate there has to be a certain level of guesstimation, but——

Comment on this

The figure that was originally envisaged was between €2 million and €3 million, but we provided for €5 million in the interests of certainty, so there is no science. The figure we came up with was between €2 million and €3 million, but someone said we should double it to be safe.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Will the Minister identify the civil servant who made that proposal?

Comment on this

We can answer that question.

Comment on this

There is no such person.

Comment on this

We knew that.

Comment on this

Neither was there such a person about pensions, SSIAs——

Comment on this

We can get back to the cost of that at some later stage.

Comment on this

——or tax credits.

Comment on this

That certainly answers my question. It is not difficult to think of a few sportsmen who, if they were ending their careers now, could claim back an amount in excess of €2 million or even €4 million. I will not put their names into the public arena, but it is not too difficult to think who they might be.

I do not fully understand how it will work for part-time sportsmen, such as League of Ireland players who may have an income from a part-time job, or a virtually full-time job, as well as their income from sport. I understand the section specifies that one can only claim on the basis of income from sport, but that is abated by 40%. Tax is calculated from total income and I am not quite sure how it will work in practice. At best, it could be worth more to one sportsman than to another, even if they are working for the same amount. I am not sure how much one receives for playing for Dundalk these days, although I am sure it is not a huge amount of money, but a person playing for Dundalk for ten years may receive more from tax relief than a similar player on the basis of their marital status or their other job.

Comment on this

It will depend on the total tax paid in a given year. I can explain this mattereasily enough; one pays tax as normal during one's playing career. If one's income for 2002 consists, for example, of €30,000 from a PAYE job in the Guinness brewery, where Deputy Jim Mitchell used to work, and €10,000 as a part-time footballer for Dundalk, one pays tax in the normal way. Depending on one's circumstances, for example if one is married or receives other tax breaks having availed of good financial advice and invested in films or BES, one may not pay any income tax. An unmarried footballer with the exact same income, who pays full tax at 42% on the extra €10,000 he receives for playing in the League of Ireland, would pay a great deal of tax. If he chooses that particular tax year when he retires, his tax will be recalculated, simply by reducing the €10,000 gross by 40%, to give him an expense allowance of €4,000. His net income for that job would be €6,000, which would be added to the €30,000 from the brewery. The tax he would have paid on that basis is then worked out, less the tax he has already paid, and if that gives him a refund he will receive it.

Comment on this

The obvious effect of that, although I am not sure it is the intended effect, is that someone on a marginal tax rate of 42% benefits to a greater extent than someone on a lower marginal tax rate.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

This would mean that people with the same income from sport could end up disproportionately benefiting from the Minister's tax relief depending on where their other income comes from and the amount of that income.

Comment on this

It is like most tax relief in that one does not benefit if one does not pay tax.

Comment on this

We have also moved towards standardising the rate of relief in recent years. However, this measure does not do so because it is available at the marginal rate.

Comment on this

We spoke about pension contributions on the previous amendment. Pension contributions are allowable at the person's marginal rate, as are medical expenses.

Comment on this

The Minister has clarified this issue and that helps. However, the basic point remains the same. I have not worked out the details, but I tabled an amendment for discursive reasons to suggest that there is an alternative approach, which amounts to a grant system more than anything else, by allowing expenses, whether imputed or paid to someone, to be claimed or set-off as an expense against tax. I have also suggested a mechanism which would guarantee some benefit to everyone by allowing a minimum amount of expenses - I suggest €2,000 per year.

The €5,000 per year maximum at the standard rate which I suggest amounts to €1,000 benefit. I suggest that a maximum of €5,000 expenses in any given year would be allowable. This would result in a benefit of €1,000 in terms of tax credit or reduced taxation. That is still only €20 per week, which is a fairly small amount of money. However, if we are talking about a gesture from the Exchequer which acknowledges the role that people have played, then it seems that is as practicable a way of doing so as any other. This would be available to amateurs and professionals.

The Minister knows that the major problem with this proposal is the signal which it has sent to amateur organisation, not least GAA players, who are unhappy that their role is not being properly recognised by the organisation for which they play. The Minister's tax relief proposal has unwittingly added to this.

Comment on this

Certain GAA players would not think that way. There might be a welcome for this debate.

Comment on this

That may be so and I do not necessarily disagree. However, as the Minister might suggest, that is a matter for the GAA.

Comment on this

The Minister said one of the reasons for this proposal was to help those in sport who have a short career. He also said that it was in the interest of sport. This is baffling. Deputy McGrath pointed out that, as far as the GAA is concerned, moves were afoot to give some financial benefit to players, but this proposal has accelerated that. If we can believe what we read in the newspapers, the Taoiseach recently met the GAA players. I do not know whether the Minister was at that meeting, but the whole situation was accelerated. Apart from the Minister's intention of improving sport and helping professional sportspeople, he has also accelerated the position with regard to GAA players who wish to become professional or semi-professional.

Comment on this

I take the Deputy's point that I brought the debate forward. Deputy Deenihan is concerned that he missed this.

Comment on this

The Minister also referred to jockeys. He is from Kildare. The bloodstock industry is tax free.

Comment on this

It is not tax free. Stallion fees are tax free.

Comment on this

Stud fees.

Comment on this

Many people, including some Deputies, refer to the fact that the bloodstock industry is tax free. That is not the case. Bloodstock farming is treated the same as farming cattle, sheep, pigs or whatever. It is only stud fees which are tax free. The ordinary breeding establishment which sells mares at Goffs or Tattersalls is treated the same as if it were selling cattle, sheep or pigs or trading in bananas. Tax is paid in the normal way whether it involves a corporation, an individual or whatever. Most people believe that a stud farm which has mares is tax free, but that is not the case. It is regarded as normal farming and is treated the same as everything else. I take this opportunity to clarify this point for the benefit of Members and those outside as there seems to be some confusion.

Comment on this

So the rumour that County Kildare is to become a tax free zone is untrue.

Comment on this

That is in the second coming of this Minister.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

On the issue of Kildare being a tax free zone, that is the point I made on Second Stage. When this novel suggestion was published on the same day as the Bill, I was urged to attack it. However, I refused to do so on the basis that every Minister for Finance is entitled to one peccadillo in every Finance Bill. Between them, the Minister and Deputy Dukes have almost made Kildare a tax free zone. Betting tax is down from 20% to 2%, stud tax is abolished and we now have this little concession for has-been jockeys.

Comment on this

Before Deputy Deenihan makes his contribution I will read the official note and then give my own views, if the notes do not encapsulate those views properly and adequately. With regard to the amendment in the name of Deputies Mitchell and McGrath, where a sporting body or organisation reimburses its members, whether players, selectors, coaches or referees, for bona fide and reasonable expenses they incur in attending training sessions, matches, etc., those payments are not assessable for income tax. There is no set limit to the amount of expenses which can be reimbursed tax free in any year as it depends on the facts in each case.

If the intention is to ensure that bona fide expenses in such circumstances are tax free, then the amendment would appear to serve no purpose. Deputy McGrath has stated that he will table a different amendment on Report Stage. However, amendment No. 24 could prove to be an unnecessarily limiting factor because of the reference to an annual cap of €750. This is the case only where the payments amount to no more than would cover the expenses incurred. In this context it is the normal practice of the Revenue Commissioners to use the Civil Service mileage and subsistence rate as a benchmark in determining whether travel, meal and overnight allowances are reasonable or not. Where the payments fall within these limits and are subject to reasonable controls there is no charge to income tax.

On the other hand, where payments go beyond reimbursement of genuine expenses and are, in reality, a form of reward or bounty for services rendered dressed up as expenses, then the question of taxation can arise. For example, where regular payments are made by a sporting organisation to a player and these payments exceed, or are not connected with, expenses incurred, a charge to income tax may arise on the profit element of those payments. It may be the case that an employer-employee relationship has been created between the club and the player because of the payment's circumstances.

There is no doubt that since the section 12 scheme of relief for retiring sportspersons was announced, there has been considerable media comment about sportspeople in amateur codes. However, in my view the question of whether players in certain amateur sporting bodies should be paid or not is an entirely separate matter from the section 12 relief. Such questions are for the organisations concerned to decide and have nothing to do with tax relief. In any event, I do not propose to accept this amendment as it appears to serve no purpose. Bona fide and reasonable expenses paid to members of sporting bodies are entirely tax free. Bona fide expenses paid to any employee are not an issue for the Revenue Commissioners. However, payments dressed up as expenses which contain an element of reimbursement are taxable. That applies throughout the income tax code.

I do not understand amendment No. 25 which proposes to give a tax deduction, presumably against a person's total income from all sources, for expenses incurred by certain sportspeople in playing or training for their sport to be specified in regulations. This appears to be regardless of whether or not that person derives any taxable income from the sport concerned. The deduction would be subject to a ceiling of €5,000 in any one year with a de minimus figure of €2,000 to be assumed to be incurred for this purpose.

In general under the tax code, expenses are allowable only to the extent that they represent costs incurred wholly and exclusively in deriving income. In the case of employees there is a further test in that the expenses must also be necessarily incurred in the conduct of their employment. Therefore, in the case of persons who earn income from their sport, any expenses incurred when playing or training will, to the extent that they are not reimbursed, normally be fully allowable for tax purposes against their sporting income. It would appear, therefore, that this amendment would not help such cases. In fact it may hinder them by imposing an annual ceiling of €5,000 on allowable expenses where there is no such ceiling at present. A person who does not earn an income from sport cannot claim a deduction for sports-related expenses against his ordinary employment or business income because the sports expenses are not for the purpose of earning his income. The net effect of Deputy McDowell's amendment would therefore be to give an annual tax reduction of up to €5,000 to amateur sportspersons to the extent that their expenses are not reimbursed.

Depending on the regulations referred to in the amendment, it may prove difficult to stop the extension of tax breaks to persons who engage in sports as a leisure activity rather than a competitive activity, for example by effecting tax relief on subscriptions to golf clubs. Such relief would be enormously costly and it is difficult to see what it would achieve. There is no doubt that the introduction of relief for targeted sportspersons in section 12 of the Bill has prompted a renewed debate on the question of amateurism versus professionalism in certain sporting codes. This debate has already been going on for a number of years. The issue of whether to pay certain categories of sportspersons should be decided by the sporting organisations concerned and has nothing to do with tax relief. There are much more fundamental issues involved in such decisions and I am not, therefore, prepared to accept the Deputy's amendment.

We must differentiate between what was always intended and what some people have now widened the debate to include. Deputies McGrath and Belton have referred to——

Comment on this

I will pick just one point from the list. Why has the Minister snookered the snooker players?

Comment on this

I did not snooker anybody. Earlier I referred to the fundamental changes I made for the self-employed and proprietary directors. One of those changes was to introduce a sliding scale allowing a person to write off 15% or 30% as a deduction in respect of retirement annuities. If a person is over 50 he is allowed to pay up to 30% of his net relevant earnings and obtain tax relief against his income. I decided at that time to allow people in professional sports to avail of this as they have short earning careers. That was put into section 19 of the Finance Act, 1999, and is now known as Schedule 23A of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997. It is a list of the sports professions included in the measure. In many other countries additional contributions for pensions are allowed for people with short earning careers in sports. The list of people who qualify, including athletes and badminton players, comes from that.

When I extended the sportsperson relief this time, I simply said that it refers to the Schedule of the Act referred to above. I did not amend it. Therefore, if amendments are to be made to include other sports, I will amend that Schedule. The Schedule was commented upon at the time as I included many sports and much of the debate about pensions at that time referred to the other major changes I was making in pensions, not to the 30% I was allowing to people in sporting careers. That is where the list came from. I did not make it up.

The debate about sportsperson relief has widened to include amateur sporting bodies and what should be changed or paid for. As I said earlier, these are matters for the different organisations. However, I am trying to give a tax break upon retirement to a person who has earned an income from their sport. I do not like to name people, and Deputy McDowell did not, but we may take the example of flat jockeys, who have a slightly easier life than national hunt jockeys. The latter is the only profession in the world, as far as I know, in which two ambulances drive behind a person in the course of his daily work to pick up the bits off the ground. I do not know of any other profession to which this applies.

Boxing has good medical rules and ambulances at the arena. I know many boxers who had short earning careers, made quite an amount of money for everyone concerned, paid a lot of taxes in the meantime and are now skint. I know hundreds of star jockeys that were washed up after a few years and are now standing on street corners in Longford or Kildare. They paid their taxes in the few short years of their careers and do not now have two bob to scrape together. I know soccer players who gave countless hours of enjoyment here while earning very small amounts of money, paid their taxes, and are now in their 30s and 40s with no career to fall back on and without a shilling. There are very few who are now in other professions and making a good living, although there are some.

The idea of this relief is to give a tax break to the people who will benefit from it. It is not designed to help the stars. This tax relief will encourage some people to be tax-resident here. It will be of no benefit to the high earners who decide to live outside the country, sometimes for tax purposes and sometimes for career reasons. If they do not pay tax here and are not resident here they will not benefit.

Comment on this

Why not a hockey player?

Comment on this

I will come to that later. A favourite phrase of mine is illustrated in the following story. There is a countyman of Deputy Belton's who is a Member of the Dáil. On one occasion we were having a Christmas event and needed somebody to play at it. The Deputy was given the job of telephoning the manager of a particular artist who is still around. The manager said that he supposed they would work on the usual basis of dividing the proceeds 60:40, upon which my friend replied that he could have 60% and 40% of nothing and still have nothing.

If people who are not currently resident decide to live here on account of the tax benefits, that will be of benefit to the Exchequer as we will receive their taxes. They will pay their taxes on a normal basis, so high earners will have to make a decision as to whether they would be better off living in Ireland on the basis of the tax breaks they would get. The Exchequer will be getting oodles of tax from those people from whom it is currently getting nothing.

Comment on this

So we are going to win.

Comment on this

Nobody will lose in that situation. It is a temptation, but people will have to make their own decisions. Why is it done in this particular way? Deputy McDowell asked in a recent parliamentary question why there should not be a break such as artists receive. They are exempt from tax on their earnings under section 2 of the Finance Act, 1969. I was a student at the time and I remember that time well. Under this exemption, taxes are not paid. However, my experience has been, as I outlined last week, that most of the people I know in these professions have earned some money for a few years in their twenties and then blown it. Most of them do. They do not have anything left when they reach the age of 28 or 29 and their careers are over. I thought it would be far better for them to pay their taxes in the normal way, as everybody else does, and when their careers are finished - by injury or otherwise - to pick ten tax years for their tax-free contribution so that they can have a few pounds.

Comment on this

I am surprised at that.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy might say that, because it goes against my general way of doing things. However, going backwards is a better approach. If the tax breaks were received as one's career went along, one would have more money but might not have the advisers to deal with it. The top professionals have advisers, but they are very few. If anyone can name two top professionals, I will name 98 that he has never heard of and for every two who have made large amounts of money over the last ten years I can name 198 who are standing on street corners with not a shilling in their pockets.

The debate has spilled over to include the question of amateur sport, particularly GAA. Many people in my constituency and many of my friends train hard and are involved in sport. I know many of my own age with nice cushy jobs who spend hours each week practising their golf, but they have still a 16 to 20 handicap. Surely nobody is suggesting that I give a tax break against general earnings to those people, who might be solicitors, barristers, accountants or civil servants, because they spend so many hours at their sport. They are totally dedicated to their sport. There is a certain gentleman on my left who spends an extraordinary number of hours playing tennis. I doubt that people expect I should give him a 40% tax against his civil service income because he spends six hours a day practising his forehand drive.

I bring this analogy to the GAA. I am as familiar with GAA activities, in my county and nationally, as any Deputy in the House and I know the effort players put into perfecting their skills. There are junior B club players all over Ireland training harder than county teams did 25 years ago. They get no recompense at all, but they play to try to win their local junior championship. People volunteer for that themselves. They want to perfect their skills and play, but they are not earning a living from it, although over the past seven years or so there have been a few full-time rugby players. Generally, it is not GAA players' full-time business but what they do with their free time.

If the GAA or any organisation wants to change their rules, so be it. There are pluses and minuses to having an amateur code. Many in the GAA say it will never happen that players and coaches will be paid. Many sportspeople put an enormous amount of time into their particular sport and feel they should be paid. Perhaps it is good that this sportspersons' relief has brought the debate to a head. There has been much misinformed comment on the issue. The sporting organisations concerned hardly expect the Exchequer to give, more or less, a grant for what people do in their free time. We give many grants to sporting organisations for equipment and to improve facilities etc, but some people seem to suggest that we should have a refundable tax credit for those who participate in sport. Deputy McGrath wants to apply it to county players.

What about the lads who were playing for Rathnew against Ballinderry last Sunday who were up to their oxters in muck? The Kildare fellows who played Cavan, or the Westmeath men who played Cork were in the same level of muck. Are they to be paid while the Rathnew players, who trained as hard, get nothing? We could hardly be asked to differentiate there. If the GAA wishes to pay its players, they will be subject to the normal tax rules and I would foresee no difficulty amending the relevant Schedule of the 1999 Act which incorporates such players.

Comment on this

The disappointment in the GAA fraternity has been fairly well documented in the newspapers. The Minister is missing the point in regard to county and club players. The amount and level of commitment and the sacrifice county players have to make to be competitive is on a par with any professional and I have seen that at first hand. Club players playing for recreation and for the love and honour of their towns and villages are different. It is a recreational matter for them. There are elite athletes with the GAA, but the Minister has failed to see that. They may not be in every county but there are many of them.

Comment on this

I do not think we will agree but I hear what is being said. The Irish Rugby Football Union had that problem. Initially when the rugby union decided to let go of the amateur status many clubs decided to have full-time professional players on pay, but most of them found they could not survive by doing that. The IRFU came up with a unique solution which had not been thought of at the time. They have a certain number of players who are club players and if they get to province level, they get a contract and if they play internationally, they get more. I am all for the lateral thinking that went on there.

Originally when the IRFU went professional everyone thought, myself included, that the clubs would have to start paying players. Clubs started doing that but discovered that they would not be able to do it without going broke unless they had rich benefactors to keep them going. The IRFU came up with a different solution. They decided to give contracts to a certain number of players and those players are full-time athletes. I am not advocating the same for the GAA, but a little lateral thinking might not go astray. It has worked effectively for the IRFU. The clubs still work well while the elite players get some reward.

Comment on this

The Minister should look at the level of spectator interest in the GAA compared to all other sports put together. Sunday after Sunday GAA players earn vast amounts of money for the association and the Exchequer. A match in Dublin is worth a lot of money. Does the Minister have figures for the spin-off from an All-Ireland final? I am sure it is worth up to £5 million or £6 million to the city. This opens the major question of how we value our Gaelic sport. There is not a full understanding of its value. To some politicians it is seen as a way of getting a headline or being seen at a match. It is much bigger than that.

Some politicians like to have it on their CVs that they are members of the GAA. Many of them never kicked a ball in their lives, but I have seen it on their CVs. It is obviously of benefit to them in their constituency. They do not, however, fully realise the difference between the nationalism surrounding the GAA and what the GAA really means to the players involved and nor do they realise the level of effort players put into the GAA or the amount of money accruing to the Exchequer and the GAA throughout the country. It accrues more than any other organisation. Rugby or soccer do not have the same number of matches with such large attendances. Sunday after Sunday we get large numbers around the country. There is a spin-off for all parts of the country from the GAA, not just for Dublin, Cork or Limerick. I am not advocating anything but when the Minister introduced this provision, which I welcome as a sportsman, it was riddled with inequities and people are sore about it.

The provision for artists and writers, which was introduced by Mr. Charles Haughey when he was Minister for Finance, was more embracing. The Minister should have looked at the Schedule. There are about 75 national sporting organisations and some of their members must become professional to be competitive at national level. It is a disincentive to people based in this country to become professional unless the Minister expands the provision to other sports. The only way we will win Olympic medals at international level is to have professional athletes representing us. Will the Minister extend the Schedule?

Comment on this

There is no problem with that. If a case is made for any particular sport, there is no problem adding it to the Schedule. I explained how the Schedule came about as a result of the 1999 Finance Act relating to pensions.

Comment on this

If one watched the Winter Olympics, one would have seen an Irish athlete who did exceptionally well. That represents a sport that is not even recognised in this country and receives no funding from the Government or from any body. The Winter Olympic Games are as big as the Olympic Games.

Deputy McGrath's proposal would be some consolation to GAA players. It would go some way towards meeting demands and easing the frustration and sense of being ignored by this provision, or of being treated as second-class citizens. That is how people feel about this. I do not want to name those in Kerry but these people feel they are professionals in every sense of the word. They regard themselves, and rightly so, as being on a par with our international soccer players. That is how Kerry people and Kerry footballers think. I remember an individual, now a distinguished journalist, who always thought he was Kenny Dalgliesh. I will not mention his name because he is on television occasionally but that is how he thought and how present Kerry footballers think. I am trying to explain to the Minister that this is the way gaelic footballers and hurlers think about this provision. Can the Minister explain whether he has a justifiable reason for excluding them, or for including the provision?

Comment on this

I can make it more specific than the relevant section. The Schedule includes footballers so that can include a gaelic footballer, a soccer footballer or whatever the case may be. There is no problem with that and the Schedule can accommodate it. However, GAA players are not paid for playing.

Comment on this

What about GAA players who are coaching, where the county takes them on as full-time coaches? They make their living out of coaching.

Comment on this

No, nor will it apply to coaches from the other sports. It is only for those actively or directly participating in a sport, whether as athletes, boxers, cyclists or otherwise.

Comment on this

But they are full-time gaelic footballers playing with their county. This will happen more and more. If they get more professional the county can pay them through coaching. In that sense, would there be any opportunity?

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Does the Minister agree that this discussion should not go on without a few pints? This is like a debate in Doheny and Nesbits. It is very enjoyable but it is not serious. The Minister is pulling a bit of a stroke for some of his constituents who are ex-jockeys or involved in other sports. We are not complaining about that but could we get on with the debate?

Comment on this

I reject what the Deputy says, and that it is for one category of sportsperson. All categories of sportsperson are included, and more than those the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

Let us be honest about it.

Comment on this

Many rugby players are now paid for play but the figure is less than 200. There are about 200 paid soccer players also. There are some tennis players, I am sure, and many athletes, jockeys, cyclists, and boxers. I do not believe that the cost will be anything like €5 million but, to be doubly sure, I put in that figure. Otherwise I would be accused of not including a realistic figure.

Regarding the points Deputy Deenihan made about county GAA, no person in this Government has tried to do more for sporting organisations in terms of realistic grants for facilities than I. In my first budget, I gave £20 million to the GAA for Croke Park and all hell broke loose. I remember saying to the Taoiseach before I did it that we could give money to anyone we liked but that, once the GAA was mentioned, official Ireland would go crazy. That is how it turned out. The Taoiseach had experience of this when he gave £5 million to the GAA and the world almost fell in. There were letters of all kinds to newspapers. I think the budget that year was of the order of £13 billion, if added up in gross, but the £20 million for Croke Park was seen as responsible for waiting lists, homelessness and everything else. Official Ireland's reason went out the window because I gave money to the GAA.

I understand the importance of the GAA in every locality. However, if GAA county players have a gripe, and I do not believe that they do, it should be with the GAA and not with the Minister for Finance. If the GAA wants to change its rules and reward its players it should do so. Most players want to play for their county. It is well known that over 16 years ago I was on a certain radio programme when a certain Mr. Byrne asked me what my greatest regret in life was. I said that it was never getting the chance to play senior intercounty football for Kildare in Croke Park. There are thousands of people like me and thousands whose greatest honour would be to get on their county team, be it Kerry, Kildare or Westmeath, and to play for their county in Cusack Park in Westmeath, Croke Park, Tullamore or wherever. They just want to don their county jersey. All the tax breaks in the world will not change their views about that and I believe that will be the situation in 2010 as it was in 1910.

The question of whether the GAA should pay its players is a separate one. Neither the GAA nor any other amateur organisation can expect me to give a tax break related to earnings where no earnings exist. I give grants from the Exchequer towards sporting facilities and equipment. There is no problem changing the Schedule if it needs to be changed to include other sportspersons. I accept that there is a spin-off from GAA activities, but if the GAA wants to change its rules, it should go forward and do so. Perhaps it will do that in a few years' time but the GAA and other organisations cannot expect me to give a tax break where no earnings exist. Individuals who speak Irish do not expect to get a tax break for speaking it.

Comment on this

In certain parts of the country they do.

Comment on this

The Minister can console himself that in my 37 years in politics, and in the 40 budgets I have seen in that time - with the extra budgets - I have never seen a scheme introduced yet that did not cause dissatisfaction among the begrudgers. The Minister has made a sound case as to why the GAA should not qualify for tax incentives when their players are not professional.

In relation to those who do qualify, if, for example, a boxer or a jockey gets killed, would his or her widow or widower get the rebate?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I suppose this debate is amusing in ways but there are important questions. The Minister has made a lot of play - that is perhaps not the best word to use - in relation to some sportspersons having very short careers and is providing that when they retire they can then reclaim their tax. Golf is a sport that people can play for a long time. Professional golfers can participate on the various circuits around the world. When they reach a certain age, they move to the seniors' circuit which is also professional and is fairly highly paid. After that, they can become club professionals. Would the ordinary club professional, who is perhaps on the circuit, retired or working at his club, qualify? If that golfer also designs courses and all of that——

Comment on this

No, club professionals are coaching and giving lessons. That will not qualify as it is not direct participation in the sport. However, the earnings a club professional gets for the competitions in which he or she plays is what will be rebated. If they keep playing into their 60s, it will be a long time before they cost the State any money because it applies only when one retires.

Comment on this

The Minister also included appearance money.

Comment on this

No, that has been taken out.

Comment on this

It is in it.

Comment on this

A professional jockey, for example, gets prize money, gets paid for riding the horse——

Comment on this

And appearance money.

Comment on this

——and also gets a percentage of the fund less deductions. It will include anything directly related to participation in the sport.

Comment on this

What about the golf professional doing clinics and circuits around the country? I do not want to name names but I know golf professionals who come to clubs and are paid a fee. That is appearance money because they are club professionals and it is associated with their sport. They give demonstrations or whatever around the country. Is that included?

Comment on this

No. In some of the bigger tournaments, some golfers get a fee for turning up on the first day whether they win or not.

Comment on this

They all get that.

Comment on this

Deputy McGrath might be interested to know, and I do not know if he plays golf——

Comment on this

Badly.

Comment on this

——that the majority of professional players from Ireland who try to make a living out of it make about one third of what Deputy McGrath and I get as Deputies. There are the high profile exceptions and I can think of only one who lives in this country, even though they are Irish.

Comment on this

I would like the Minister to help me out a little since we are talking about golf. If one lives here and earns virtually all one's prize money abroad, I assume if one is a tax resident here one would be liable for the tax. Does that happen in practice?

Comment on this

The rules are that one pays the tax where one is tax resident. If one is deemed a tax resident in Ireland, one pays the tax here.

Comment on this

One could be a tax resident here and still earn most of one's prize money abroad. Golf is the obvious case.

Comment on this

If one played golf, for example, one would definitely earn most of one's prize money abroad because the tournaments here would not be——

Comment on this

But one would pay tax in Ireland on prize money earned abroad if one was a tax resident here.

Comment on this

Yes, if one is an Irish tax resident.

Comment on this

Does that happen in practice?

Comment on this

I do not know the circumstances concerned but of all the high profile people, I think only one is a tax resident here. Having a house here is not enough.

Comment on this

I am inclined to agree with Deputy Mitchell. In order to balance it up perhaps there should be a grant scheme of some kind or other. Perhaps we need to look at other means of doing that. We will not be able to it through the tax code. The only thing that still sticks in my craw somewhat is the possibility of a relatively small number of elite sportsmen claiming an awful lot of money. To that extent, I think the Minister should cap it but beyond that, we should move on.

Comment on this

Is amendment No. 24 being pressed?

Comment on this

Will the Minister respond to the idea of a cap?

Comment on this

We do not have a cap on artists' relief. As the Deputy well knows, when I brought in other substantial changes - for example, to capital gains tax - I did not try to do it piecemeal; I did it in one fell swoop and I got a good bang for my buck. I do not like having caps if I can avoid it. I want to make this attractive and to encourage people. If people become tax resident here, we will get revenue we would not otherwise get. It will give Ireland prestige which it does not have now. I want that incentive to be there.

It may interest the Deputy to know that when I thought up the idea of this disallowance of 40% when walking the roads of Kildare, I thought of the late John Boland. Deputy Mitchell is long enough around to know that until the former Deputy, John Boland, gave us a substantial increase in 1983 or 1984, 50% of a Deputy's earnings was disallowed. When the late Deputy Boland gave us a substantial increase, the hoo-ha was so great it was eliminated and was replaced by an expense allowance which was actually a little more generous than the tax allowance. I recalled that because I was a Deputy at the time but nobody in either Revenue or the Department of Finance could remember it. It is not unusual to have such a disallowance.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister gave a discourse for about 25 minutes but I think he should put it in pamphlet form and circulate it.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 19, before section 13, to insert the following new section:

"13.-Section 128(2) of the Principal Act is amended-

(a) after ’realised’ to insert ’or at the option of the taxpayer for the year of assessment when the asset is actually sold’, and

(b) after ’her’ to insert ’actual gain or his or her’.”.

We received a great deal of correspondence on the issue of share options which the Minister has done much to promote in recent years. However, they have gone sour because of the downturn, especially in the IT sector. A number of people who got share options as part of their remuneration package have had to pay tax on the difference between the purchase price and the market value but the market value has now collapsed and they face serious losses.

The purpose of this amendment would be to allow the taxpayer to opt when they pay the tax, at the time of acquisition or the time of the sale and based on the value of either. That would meet prospective cases. I would like to know if the Minister is inclined to accept this amendment and what he has to say to those who have had their fingers burnt.

Comment on this

This amendment is concerned with section 128 of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, which governs the tax treatment or rights to acquire shares or other assets granted to directors of companies and employees. Under general tax law, an option to acquire an asset, including shares granted to a company director or any employee by reason of employment, is chargeable to income tax. Section 128 fixes the charge at the date of exercise of the option and by reference to the difference between the price paid for the asset and its market value at that date. Any subsequent increase in the value of the asset on a subsequent disposal will be chargeable to capital gains tax.

The purpose of the amendment appears to be to postpone the income tax charged when the asset is sold and then to have the charge based at the option of the taxpayer on either the actual gain or in the gain computed in accordance with existing tax treatment in accordance with section 128 if less. The amendment may be prompted by the recent decline in the stock market as a result of which some employees who exercised options to acquire shares incurred an income tax charge which may be a large part or even greater than the proceeds of the shares subsequently sold.

Share options are a form of remuneration used by some companies and section 128 accordingly fixes the income tax charge on the value when acquired. This treatment is no different from the tax treatment of cash remuneration which is taxed on the amount received. On acquisition of the shares, the employee may dispose of them to realise his or her remuneration and pay the appropriate income tax due. Alternatively, he or she may decide to retain the shares in investment in anticipation of future capital growth.

The provisions I introduced in the Finance Act, 2000, and in section 128(a) of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, allow the deferral of the payment of income tax charged when an option is exercised on or after 6 April 2000 for a period of seven years or until the shares are sold, whichever is the earlier. When an employee decides to hold the shares, he or she is making a conscious investment decision and there is no reason he or she should be treated differently from other shareholders who decide similarly. If having held them their value falls, this may give rise to difficulties for the employee but these problems arise not because of unusual or anomalous application of tax law but wholly as a result of his or her holding shares in a declining equity market.

Providing the employee with preferential tax treatment will inevitably lead to demands for similar treatment for other investors who find themselves in financial difficulties. Equity investment is a risky business as share prices may rise or fall and the Exchequer cannot be expected to underwrite the negative impact on employees' investment decisions which go wrong. Even if I was to accept the amendment, the question of its retrospective application, which would be necessary to deal with cases in which difficulties have arisen, and the income taxes still outstanding would probably have to be considered. However, this would be unfair to those who have already met their tax obligations and it would be of no help to those who have sold their shares.

The ultimate net effect of the amendment would be to allow capital gains tax losses on the disposal, that is, the difference between the value on which the income tax charge is currently based and the sale proceeds, to be offset against the income tax charge. This would be a fundamental departure from the existing situation and would represent an undesirable mixing of different tax charges which would be without precedent in most other tax jurisdictions. It would not be confined to employee share options only, but in equity would have to apply to all capital gains tax losses with large-scale potential Exchequer costs. For these reasons, while I have sympathy for any individual whose investment decisions go wrong, I am not prepared to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 28 is related to amendment No. 27 while amendment No. 29 is consequential. Amendments Nos. 27 to 29, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 19, to delete lines 17 to 26 and substitute the following:

"(b) were-

(i) securities issued to the trustees of the employee share ownership trust referred to in paragraph (a) in an exchange to which section 586 applies,

(ii) securities (in this subparagraph referred to as 'similar securities') similar to the securities referred to in subparagraph (i) and which were acquired by those trustees using dividends received in respect of the securities so referred to or in respect of similar securities so acquired,

(iii) securities issued to those trustees as a result of a reorganisation or reduction of share capital (in accordance with section 584) which occurred subsequent to the exchange referred to in subparagraph (i) and which securities represent the securities issued in that exchange and the similar securities (if any) referred to in subparagraph (ii), or

(iv) securities (in this subparagraph referred to as 'similar securities') similar to the securities first-mentioned in subparagraph (iii) and which were acquired by those trustees using dividends received in respect of the securities so mentioned in subparagraph (iii) or in respect of similar securities so acquired,".

I propose to take amendments Nos. 27 to 29, inclusive, together as all three refer to section 13.

Comment on this

If the Minister does not mind, I suggest that his speaking note be circulated. As the area is technical, it would be helpful to have it before us.

Comment on this

I will have it circulated. Section 13 introduces a series of amendments that have arisen regarding the Taxes Consolidation Act governing the employee shared ownership trust ethos and approved profit sharing schemes or APSSs. The first amendment will enable an ESOP which has acquired securities other than ordinary shares as a result of a take-over of the original company by a company with no or insufficient share capital to use the interest income it receives in those securities to buy more securities. The legislation as it currently stands does not provide for this, whereas dividends on shares can be used to buy more shares.

The second amendment amounts to a rewriting of the existing section 511A of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, to ensure that any period in which shares or securities remain in the ESOP for the benefit of those involved is taken into account in determining how long those shares and securities have to be held by those individuals under an APSS to avail of tax relief. Normally, there is a three year attention period for an APSS. This clarifies that the period the shares are held in the ESOP counts towards the three year retention period.

The third amendment will insert a provision to include the company which acquired the former Irish National Petroleum Corporation Ltd., INPC, as a relevant company for the purposes of the legislation. As with ACC Bank, which is included in section 13 as published for the same reason, the principal effect is to allow the benefits of ESOP-APSS participation for existing employees on the day the trust was established and to carry that through in the circumstances of any further company restructures. I am satisfied these changes will make the ESOP-APSS provisions more responsive to individual circumstances. I commend the amendments to the committee.

Comment on this

We have worked out how this applies to the ACC Bank and INPC, but does it have any impact on Vodaphone Eircom? I am happy to go into private session if the Minister wishes to explain that point.

Comment on this

Does the Minister wish to go into private session?

Comment on this

Yes.

The Select Committee went into private session at 5.14 p.m. and resumed in public session at5.17 p.m.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In page 19, between lines 45 and 46, to insert the following:

"(b) by substituting the following section for section 511A:

"511A.-(1) This section applies where, on or after the passing of the Finance Act, 1998-

(a) the trustees of an approved scheme make an appropriation of shares to which section 510(3) applies to a participant,

(b) the shares concerned had been transferred to the trustees of the approved scheme by the trustees of an employee share ownership trust to which section 519 applies, and

(c) the participant concerned was a beneficiary (within the meaning of paragraph 11 or 11A, as the case may be, of Schedule 12) under the employee share ownership trust concerned at all times (other than any period which forms part of the 30 day period referred to in paragraph 12A(b) of Schedule 11) during the period (in this section referred to as the “holding period”)-

(i) beginning on-

(I) the day the shares concerned were acquired by that employee share ownership trust, or

(II) if later, the day that participant last became such a beneficiary,

and

(ii) ending on the day those shares were appropriated to that participant.

(2) Where this section applies, then, notwithstanding section 511-

(a) the period of retention, in relation to the participant and the shares concerned, ends-

(i) in the case where the holding period is 2 years or more, on the day following the end of the holding period, and

(ii) in any other case, on the day following the end of a period which, when added to the holding period, forms a period of 2 years, or, if it is earlier, on the date referred to in subparagraph (i), (ii) or (iii), as the case may be, of section 511(1)(a),

and

(b) the release date, in relation to the participant and the shares concerned, means-

(i) in the case where the holding period is 3 years or more, the day following the end of the holding period, and

(ii) in any other case, the day following the end of a period which, when added to the holding period, forms a period of 3 years.',".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 22, to delete line 25 and substitute the following:

" '(c) ACC Bank plc, or

(d) a company which acquired control of the Irish National Petroleum Corporation Limited;’,

(ii) in paragraph 13(3)(a) by inserting ’or of securities to which subparagraph (ii) or (iv) of paragraph (b) of the definition of “specified securities” in section 509(1) applies’ after ’the founding company’,”.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 30:

In page 22, before section 14, to insert the following new section:

"14.-Schedule 12C of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, is amended by the deletion of subparagraphs (2) and (3) of paragraph 8.".

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

I have raised this issue a few times with the Minister by way of parliamentary questions. It involves the tax treatment of share options. A scheme was introduced where the gain from shares acquired as a result of employee share options will be chargeable to capital gains tax only. The amendment relates to the conditions applying to that scheme which was introduced approximately a year ago. A number of companies have been in touch with me about this matter. As a result of some parliamentary questions I tabled, I discovered that only eight or nine of the 70 or 80 schemes that were submitted received approval.

Comment on this

Only two.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

According to the reply to my last parliamentary question on this matter, it was nine. It is a matter of whether the conditions provided in the scheme should be, to use the Minister's word, "softened". There are problems relating to a couple of aspects, including similar terms having to apply to everybody, and the question of what treatment would be given to a key employee.

In the case of indigenous companies trying to attract high-flyer employees from abroad the question of being able to offer share options is quite important, as is the tax treatment of those options. The best method may be to delete subparagraphs (2) and (3) of paragraph 8 of the scheme which originally was an amendment to the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, as introduced by a measure last year. Tecnhically the amendment is not totally correct. There would probably also need to be an addition to paragraph 14. If one wanted to be fully correct about it that subparagraph (c) of paragraph 14, which I intended to be included in the amendments, would read as follows: "Scheme shares shall not be subject to any restrictions other than restrictions which attach to all shares of the same class." I propose that an insertion in brackets should be added as follows: "(apart from shares held by a company controlled by or on behalf of the State and shares held by a company which were purchased at market value by a venture capital company)". It is a question of whether the Minister agrees that the scheme is a good one. Because of the tight provisions there has not been any great uptake of the scheme. Perhaps uptake is the wrong word. There have been quite a number of applications - upwards of 80 - but an approval rate of 10% is very low and seems to indicate that something needs to be liberalised in the context of the schemes. I am moving this amendment in order to give the Minister an opportunity of easing the conditions.

Comment on this

I support Deputy O'Keeffe's comments. I have been contacted by employees of a large multinational in my area who are concerned that their scheme is having difficulty in obtaining approval. In answer to a parliamentary question I was informed that of 50 applications only two had been approved at that stage. There have since been more applications and more approvals. As Deputy O'Keeffe said there must be something very restrictive in these schemes if only 10% have succeeded. I ask the Minister to explain why there is a delay in approvals and to say why schemes are being rejected. I wonder why there is such a high failure rate. Has the Minister misread the intent of the scheme?

Comment on this

This amendment relates to section 12 (c) of the Tax (Consolidation) Act which sets out conditions for approval by the Revenue Commissioners of share option schemes established by companies for the benefit of their employees. The scheme was enacted in last year's Finance Act and in common with the other employee share schemes, that is, approved profit-sharing ESOPs and SAYEs, requires that approved schemes must in general be open to all the company's employees on similar terms. A scheme may contain a key employee element where options can be granted on 30% of the shares over which rights are granted in any given year without similar terms and conditions. The amendment proposed by Deputies Mitchell and McGrath would delete the requirement as to similar terms but not, I presume, the requirement that it must be open to all employees. However, without the similar terms rule, retaining the all employee element is somewhat meaningless as employees could for example be given a very small quantity of options just to satisfy it. This effectively means that the scheme would allow unlimited relief for fully discretionary schemes.

The amended tax treatment of share options which I introduced last year followed extensive and prolonged consultations with representative bodies and State agencies. The purpose of the new scheme is to help companies recruit and reward skilled and internationally mobile staff as well as facilitating participation by all employees in the fortunes of their employing company.

Notwithstanding the consultation process between my officials and those in Revenue I understand that the "all employee" and "similar terms" rules are now creating difficulties for schemes which are attempting to receive approval from Revenue. Nine schemes covering 6,800 employees have been approved to date. Representations have been made asking me to soften the "similar terms" rule to provide considerable discretion to companies in the allocation of options and also to eliminate the "all employee" rule. My officials met with representative bodies to discuss these proposals. The changed proposals are complex, giving rise as they do to significant issues of policy and practical difficulties in terms of application of many proposed amended rules. I have decided against making any fundamental change in the scheme at this time and in those circumstances I am not prepared to accept the Deputies' amendment.

I have given a lot of thought to the issue share options over the last three budgets. The debate has been continuing since I became Minister for Finance. I made some changes which were referred to earlier. The significant change was made last year. Arising from the original negotiations for the PPF, all gain sharing schemes including share options were to be considered by a group. There was an attempt to rush that before the passing of the third last Finance Act. This one is number three and the first one was the year before last. It was not possible to conclude negotiations at the time. The trade unions, understandably, do not want a situation where highly-paid employees effectively have a legitimate tax avoidance scheme. The group sat for most of a year and there was considerable lobbying by the representative organisations.

IBEC, the employers' representative, had a sub-group which produced a fine document and copies were distributed to Deputies. In the Finance Bill last year I decided to cross the Rubicon and I made a very significant change in the capital gains tax treatment of share options. Deputy McDowell met the IBEC group and wanted to move as far as possible to accommodate their interests and to encourage employees. He and other people in the trade union movement were very concerned that we were not giving tax-relieved remuneration to the higher-paid employees and that would also be my consideration. After considerable discussion and much thought, we decided to jump that hurdle. The concession was that the terms must be similar and I made a big concession by going down the key employee section - that 30% could be left aside for key employees. That would have caused considerable difficulties for the trade unions and some Deputies but I was prepared to do it. While the trade union representatives were somewhat annoyed, they did not make a big fuss about it.

It was recognised at the time that we had to have a good share option scheme comparable to those in other countries to attract and retain employees, encourage them to come here and allow some companies in the start-up phase to give smaller remuneration to employees on the basis that if they did well and helped grow the company, they would be very well rewarded. Many of these companies fail in any event, but it is one approach they take.

Share options have been a very successful way of doing business, particularly in the United States. Last year, therefore, I made a quantum leap which was welcomed wholeheartedly by the employers' side. In fact, employers more or less danced in the streets when I announced the change. I had numerous meetings and many deliberations with my colleagues in Government - with some more than others - before finally arriving at this scheme. It was a major step given that, as Minister for Finance, the leader of my party effectively closed off share options in 1992 because they were being so widely abused, in particular by financial institutions, to reward well paid employees even further.

When I introduced the change in the Finance Act, it had been discussed thoroughly with IBEC. A group comprising members in many multinational companies argued in favour of the scheme and described how best it could be implemented. I am a great believer in ensuring that all the schemes I introduce work. I do not approach tax changes half-heartedly and believe in ensuring that all significant changes must work. I do not take the titillating kind of approach to financial and tax matters.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister is not referring to sport.

Comment on this

That scheme is not titillating either. Therefore, when I returned to share options, I decided to do it properly. We used the submissions received from all the various bodies and designed it in the way the companies wanted. The Finance Bill was published after the best part of two years was spent working on this subject. Luckily, one tax adviser wrote to us to say that the provision, as it stood, would mean that most companies of which he was aware would not qualify to participate in the scheme although the same companies were represented on the group and all the members of which had stated that the proposal would work. One major firm stated the scheme would not work for it and, therefore, it was doubtful if it would work for others.

Having taken the big leap and invested so much work in it, I became very frustrated and was tempted to say "To hell with them all", but I was persuaded to make the appropriate changes on Committee Stage to accommodate all the groups which discovered that they did not qualify. They did not approach the Revenue Commissioners and perhaps they did not inform the group about how their schemes operated.

We then took a big scalpel to the Finance Act and introduced another raft of amendments on Committee Stage at the behest of the companies. We so bastardised the relevant section of the Finance Act that it would take an expert to understand what we did. Having done this, it transpired that the Dáil had made further mistakes and most of the companies still could not qualify. Deputy McGrath is correct that until about November only two schemes out of more than 40 had been accepted. The figure is now nine of 71 applicants. Having made the quantum leap, I did everything to make sure——

Comment on this

How do they qualify?

Comment on this

The problem is that it differs from company to company. Much of the difficulty relates to the fact that some multinational companies must operate a similar scheme throughout the globe, which means it must be in line with the schemes they operate elsewhere, for example, in the United States.

Comment on this

Is part of the difficulty that some of the big multinationals effectively concentrate the decision making power in relation to the awarding of share options in the hands of managers and they can, at their discretion, and up to a point——

Comment on this

Some do, while others have ringfenced the scheme through their local operations or to apply to some, but not all, employees. Some have all kinds of problems. In any event, Deputy Jim O'Keeffe will be pleased to know that, having consulted again to come up with a mishmash of amendments, it, too, did not work for most of the companies.

This brings us to this year's Finance Bill. Last year, to be fair to IBEC, it again brought together a large group of rational and level-headed people in the industry and worked on the problem fairly extensively and with a great deal of brain power. It came up with various solutions to the problem, but even they will not satisfy all IBEC members. After all this, I took the clear policy decision not to do anything about the issue in this Finance Bill. Instead, I will try to force companies to adapt their schemes to accommodate last year's changes.

I hate to bring in a scheme which does not work. That is not my style. I want it to work, which is the reason I introduced it last year. It is useless if it does not work and the camel cannot get next or near the eye of the needle, let alone through it. I do not believe in that kind of approach to tax legislation and have decided, for the time being, to make no substantive changes to this year's Finance Bill. If I made changes to accommodate everybody, I would be effectively returning to a scheme which was in place in the late 1980s. While it would be very popular with some employees, I would have the Irish Congress of Trade Unions down on my neck and rightly so. It took a very reasonable approach last year to the very significant change I made to this in principle.

When I state I made changes to accommodate everybody in this area, it transpired that they were not exactly as they or I had intended. I am not prepared to do this again in this Finance Bill. The matter can be re-examined in the future. I am sticking to the position that I did the business last year and made the quantum leap.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

Does the Minister agree that, despite his gallant efforts, he produced a scheme which does not work? A 90% failure rate on application is not an indication of a scheme that is working well. I have been told that the way in which it is currently framed does not allow companies to use share options linked to performance and contribution unless the employee fits within the key employee category. My colleague, Deputy Jim Mitchell, has given me 25 pages of supporting documentation from IBEC, which has obviously done a great deal of work on this issue. I do not intend to plough through it as my basic approach is fairly simple. There is a need for the scheme.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

The Minister made a gallant effort to produce one which would work. As it is not working, to where do we go from here? I have no simple solution but I would like a commitment from all parties, not least on this side of the House, to allow us to deal with the matter in the not too distant future. It should be recognised that the scheme is not working and that a major effort must be made to try to iron out the problems which clearly exist.

Comment on this

As an aside, although it is clearly part of the same argument, the Minister has not produced a gain sharing scheme during his tenure. I am aware he has been trying to work on one, but the absence of such a scheme is unfortunate and somewhat skews the argument. Perhaps it is important to restate my position. I believe encouraging employees to financially participate in the companies for which they work is a good thing. While it should apply to the maximum possible number of employees in a given firm, it does not necessarily have to apply to all of them. I do not believe that every employee would necessarily be interested even if he or she was, in theory, eligible to participate in the scheme.

The purpose of this scheme should be to encourage the maximum possible level of financial participation in the company's share capital. It is good for the company and it incentivises the employees. There are a variety of other reasons that are not difficult to elucidate. We should not seek to develop a scheme which is specifically intended to give a lower marginal rate of tax to people who are already highly paid. If companies seek to take the top 3% or 4% of employees, managers or owner-shareholders simply to increase their remuneration at a lower marginal rate of income tax, which is effectively what it amounts to in some cases, I certainly do not agree with it. If that is the stated purpose of the scheme, I do not want it to succeed because that is not what I want it to do. I want to encourage the maximum possible number of employees to participate, for a variety of reasons, but if we are talking about simply paying a small number of highly paid people more money at a lower marginal rate of tax, I do not want it.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

The main purpose of share options is to try to remunerate people who otherwise would not be attracted into companies because of an internationally competitive environment. We might as well be honest and admit that is what it is about in principle. If we cannot agree on that, there is no sense doing it, but it may have unintended consequences; we may not be able to get key people.

Comment on this

As colleagues will have gathered, I have become fed up with this particular issue, although not with the debate here. Having tried so valiantly to operate the scheme and to do exactly as requested, I ended up with gobbledegook that only three or four people in Revenue and the Department of Finance can understand when the changes are to be made. I am loath to revisit the matter in this Finance Bill. I would prefer to say that this is what we have and we can work on that basis, giving similar terms to key employees. I have turned my face against making a change in this year's Bill. I want the scheme to work, but I do not have a closed mind on it. I am an advocate of how one can use a share options scheme - as it has been used effectively in other countries - to get businesses going. I support that type of approach.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister on that point.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy agrees, but I want to let the matter settle for a while.

Comment on this

We should put it on record that these people are still getting their share options but they are not paying 20% tax on them. They are paying the rate of income tax.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

Therefore, they are still receiving the options.

Comment on this

It is a normal rate of tax.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

That is a fair point. Despite receiving representations from all quarters about this year's Finance Bill, I have closed the matter for this year. It will not be closed in the future, however.

Comment on this

I am astonished by the figure of 30%, which is too high. I am also astonished that they cannot accommodate the key employee factor within 30%. We should send a clear message that they should get their act together and do it.

Comment on this

Why is this section included? It appears to impose a cap on how much a passive investor can put in, but, according to everything the Minister has said so far, he is against caps. What is wrong with a passive investor investing in the repair, maintenance and restoration of certain buildings that have been approved by the Minister for Arts, Heritage, Gaeltacht and the Islands? We should encourage that sort of activity.

Comment on this

The Deputy is spoiling the reputation I have garnered in some quarters of the media and with some other people who comment regularly on my budgets outside the House. When the record of my five years as Minister for Finance is written, I will have closed off more tax avoidance mechanisms than any other Minister for Finance in the history of the State. That is particularly the case with the ones I closed off through the significant changes I made in my first Finance Bill, which effectively ended the write-offs and brought these caps into existence. There is no reason that somebody in the Law Library, earning the equivalent of £1 million a year, should pay no tax.

When I brought in these changes in my first Finance Act, nobody bet that I would succeed in bringing about the changes in the end. They thought I would have to make significant changes. There were forceful representations from around the country, which were not highlighted in the media, to make me change my mind, but I did not. It was the biggest element of equity in the tax code that I have introduced. One of them concerned the ring-fencing allowance I introduced. Most high income earners were using these provisions to write off many things. Many changes were made at that time but one of the most significant was in that area.

This section is far removed from share options. This inserts a new section 409C of the Taxes Consolidation Act, 1997, for the purpose of restricting the use by passive investors of relief under section 482 of that Act. This relief was available in respect of the repair, maintenance or restoration of certain buildings by the owner-occupier of such buildings. The buildings concerned are those that have been determined by the Minister for Arts, Heritage, Gaeltacht and the Islands to be of significant scientific, historical, architectural or aesthetic interest and determined by the Revenue Commissioners to have reasonable public access. The relief was given by treating the amount of such expenditure as an amount of loss in a trade which, under the Tax Acts, can be used to reduce a person's liability to income tax. Subject to certain transitional arrangements, an individual who, as a result of participating in a passive investment scheme, claims relief under section 482 as the owner of such a building will be limited to €31,750, which is £25,000, in the amount to which he or she can reduce his or her tax relief in any year.

Broadly, a passive investment scheme is defined as a scheme under which a person, who will make a claim under section 482 as an owner, takes an interest in the building from its then owner if at that time or in the next five years the building is determined to be an approved building for the purpose of section 482. The arrangements cover cases where the original owner has influence over how expenditure on a building is to be incurred or the original owner is entitled to participate in the tax benefits or the original owner may acquire the interest.

There are transitional arrangements in this particular section to facilitate three projects in respect of which representations have been made. In the case of the projects concerned, I consider it fair and reasonable to exclude those from the scope of the proposed section. I can name the three projects if Members wish. On budget day I announced that I was closing off an avoidance loophole. The aesthetic buildings relief has been there for some time and it allows people to improve their buildings. We were informed about the probable tax avoidance scheme that would allow funding of a certain restricted building in a location in Dublin whereby the ring fencing I introduced some years ago would not apply to section 482. That would permit high income earners to effectively reduce their tax liability to nil. I thought that was an inappropriate form of the intended purpose of section 482 and we decided to close off this loophole. It has now been closed off in this section with transitional arrangements that allow three projects through that were already under way. There was a good article about it by John McManus in The Irish Times on Monday this week.

Comment on this

The Minister appears to be suggesting that not much relief has been claimed under this section. He does not think it is being abused but he is concerned about what is possibly coming down the road.

Comment on this

No, this relates to passive investors.

Comment on this

Does the Minister know how much was claimed under this section by passive investors?

Comment on this

Originally, section 482 was designed to benefit people who owned these significant buildings.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

That was the purpose of the relief. Some great tax adviser came up with the idea that one could use section 482 effectively to create a tax avoidance scheme to allow high income earners to write off their tax liability. We became aware that such a scheme was in the offing, which was never the intention of section 482. I announced it in the budget because I am able then to apply the change from that date.

Comment on this

Was there some kind of provision last year where people were making contributions to some bodies for the purchase of certain listed properties? It seems to run counter to——

Comment on this

Relief is given at the marginal rate on donations to charities. This was the use of section 482 by passive investors effectively to write off their tax liability. A scheme was created into which they made the investment and their money would be returned in six years' time earning a tax relief of 42%.

Comment on this

They were getting some class of an interest.

Comment on this

Of course one must get an interest but that can be arranged by means of a partnership.

Comment on this

One could just have an arrangement with the owner, I suppose.

Comment on this

It would have been legally correct and it would have been a proper tax avoidance scheme but I did not think it was appropriate.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 31:

In page 24, before section 15, but in Chapter 2, to insert the following new section:

"15.-As respects the year of assessment 2002 and subsequent years of assessment, paragraph 8 of Schedule 3 to the Principal Act is amended-

(a) by substituting ’in the previous 10 years of assessment’ for ’previously’, and

(b) by substituting ’€10,000’ for ’€5,080’ in both places where it occurs.”.

This amendment is concerned with an aspect in the tax code dealing with the taxation of redundancy payments. While statutory redundancy payments are exempt from tax, other redundancy payments are taxable but qualify for some relief from tax. There is a basic exemption of €10,160 together with €765 for each complete year of service with the employer who is making the redundancy payments. In cases when an individual is not a member of an occupational pension scheme or irrevocably gives up the right to receive a lump sum from such a scheme, the basic exemption is increased by €5,080. If the individual receives or is entitled to receive a pension lump sum then the increased exemption is reduced by the amount of the pension lump sum. This increased exemption is only available once.

The case to be made that there is a need to make changes in regard to this additional exemption to (a) update the amount given that the amount has not been agreed since this relief was introduced over 20 years ago in the Finance Act, 1980; and (b) modified existing arrangements whereby a worker who has once benefited from the additional exemption cannot claim it in the future, regardless of the length of time that may have elapsed since the previous claim. This proposed amendment addresses both issues. It will allow the exemption to be claimed again once a period of ten years has elapsed since the previous claim was made. It increases the additional amount that is available on top of the basic exemption limits from the existing figure of €5,080 to €10,000. This is a significant advance on the present position and represents a very positive and meaningful response to the case made to me. In the case of an individual made redundant after ten years' service, he or she may, in addition to statutory redundancy, receive a tax free ex gratia payment of up to €27, 810, that is £21,900. I commend the amendment to the committee.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:

In page 25, before section 15, but in Chapter 3, to insert the following new section:

"15.-Section 45(3) (Donations to approved bodies, etc.) of the Finance Act, 2001, is hereby amended by the substitution of '€100' for '€250'.".

This is in relation to the comprehensive relief for donations which the Minister introduced last year in the Finance Act, 2001. The case has been made to me that the figure of €250 is too high and that many donations to schools are frequently under the €250 minimum sum and therefore do not attract the grossed up tax relief. In order for schools to be able to claim the tax relief - which at this stage is an unfortunate but well-established practice - the annual limit should be reduced from €250 to a sum in the region of €100.

Comment on this
Jim Mitchell Mr. J. Mitchell Fine Gael

I support Deputy McDowell's amendment. We had a long drawn out debate on this subject last year and the Minister was untypically intransigent on the issue. I hope his heart has mellowed and softened. In view of the concession we have made to him on his first proposal I ask him to concede on this point.

Comment on this

I also support this amendment. Quite a number of charities are saying that the typical subscription they receive is around €100 to €130. They request that the limit be reduced as it is too high for the level of subscription. I ask the Minister to give an indication of the uptake as a result of last year's Finance Bill and indicate whether many schools have benefited. I communicated with schools in my area and while there was initial enthusiasm I do not think many of them followed through and went to the trouble of gathering subscriptions. They may have been discouraged by the high minimum sum.

It could be a very valuable scheme and the returns are excellent. A sum of €290 will attract a rebate from the Revenue Commissioners of €210, making a total subscription of about €500. It is very attractive but the high figure of €290 seems to be a stumbling block. Hence, I support this amendment.

Comment on this

I received representations to reduce the limit to €100 as suggested in this amendment and indeed to phase it out altogether. I have decided against making any change for the time being for the following reasons. It is already very generous being at the taxpayer's marginal rate of tax when an individual donor can be paying as much as 42%. A reduction in the minimum donation would have the effect of increasing the numbers of donations qualifying for relief and would therefore be costly. Donations for any year can be on a cumulative basis so that a monthly donation of little more than €20 can qualify for the relief.

The new scheme of tax relief on donations has hardly been in operation for a single year yet and while I understand the desire of those concerned to have the lower limit reduced further, I am not aware that the limit of €250 has had any negative impact on the levels of donations to charities in the interim. The Irish charities tax reform group has informed my officials that it has found the new relief very useful in the obtaining of donations. I am also concerned that any reduction in the minimum donation could increase significantly the administrative burden on the Revenue Commissioners who would have to deal with a large number of small claims particularly with regard to donations made by the PAYE sector which must be reclaimed by charities at year end. The cost to the Exchequer of the donation scheme as expanded last year will not be known until after the end of the current year. Clearly any reduction in the minimum qualifying donation would increase the cost to the Exchequer. I am not prepared to accept the amendment at this time.

Last year I made a concession on the subject of charities. I had a figure of £250 and I reduced that to £200 and now the figure is €254. I am using a crystal ball to look into the future. I believe that the changes I made in taxation of charities will be of considerable benefit in the years to come, far outweighing many of the changes I made in many other areas of the tax code which have been highlighted to a greater extent. As the Deputies will be aware, I decided last year to simplify the tax code by the amalgamation 12 or 13 different reliefs throughout the tax code. This was based on the American model and I was not influenced by the Department or the Revenue Commissioners or any representations. I was in the United States at one time and I learnt that $198 billion was contributed to charities and foundations in a year and mostly triggered by tax relief. I was of the opinion years ago that we should copy that system. I gathered all the reliefs together and decided to make everything simpler. Relief would be given at the marginal rate of tax; self-employed persons would be entitled to write it off as a normal expense and PAYE persons would pay €290 and the Revenue would return €210, or the person would give €580 and the Revenue would return €420, making up €1,000. That is how the scheme is operated in the United States. I believe that when all the high-profile changes have been forgotten about, this change will be of considerable benefit to charities. It has not been fully exploited yet.

In this year's Finance Bill I have taken on board the suggestion made by Deputy McGrath last year about sports bodies. I had that idea myself some years ago. We introduced the measure for charities last year. The figure of €254 is a minimum and I am not saying it will remain that forever. I want to have it up and running because we did not have a system in place until last year. I do not want the whole system to get bogged down with, for example, a figure of €10 from one person and €15 from another.

The difficulty to which the Deputies refer may be that some schools, for example, the secondary schools in Naas, have been using the scheme provided for under covenant legislation which goes back years. One of my friends in my previous career as an accountant who was involved in the committee approached me about the matter because his company had been using the scheme for several years. It now has time to change to the new system, which is still being worked out. I would like to give it a little time to bed down. Consequently, while I cannot accept the amendment, I do not have a difficulty with the principle and perhaps I will return to the matter in my second coming.

Comment on this

As it is now 6 p.m, I am required to put the following question in accordance with an order of the Dáil of 21 February: "That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to sections 15 to 21, inclusive, and not disposed of are hereby made to the Bill and, in respect of each of the said sections undisposed of other than section 19, that the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to."

Comment on this