We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Select Committee on Health

Health Information Bill 2024: Committee Stage

Summary

Committee Stage focused on aligning the Bill with the EU Health Data Space by changing “Digital Health Record” to “Electronic Health Record” and advancing a step-by-step move from fragmented systems to shared care records and, ultimately, a national EHR. Deputies pressed the Minister on timelines, costs, integration with maternity, paediatric, GP, private and voluntary services, and whether records would follow patients across the system. The Minister said the shared care record pilot should begin by year-end, with Waterford as an early deployment area, while a full national system will take significant time and capital. Amendments on PPSN use were also advanced to improve patient matching and safety, while preserving access to care for anyone without a PPSN.

Contributions 1–132 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Health Information Bill 2024
Enacted

No. 61 of 2024 ›

The purpose of this meeting is to consider Committee Stage of the Health Information Bill 2024. The aim behind the Bill is to improve the use of health information, ensure that the right information is available in the right place and at the right time and ensure the best care of and treatment for patients. The Bill provides for a duty to share held information for patients' care and treatment, the establishment of digital health records for all patients in Ireland, greater access for patients to their health information, greater protections around health information for primary use and better health information for the HSE for patient-interest purposes. It also underpins Ireland's EU obligations. I welcome the Minister for Health, Deputy Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, who is accompanied by officials from her Department this morning.

Members are reminded of the long-standing parliamentary practice that they should not criticise or make charges against any person or entity by name or in such a way as to make him, her or it identifiable, or otherwise engage in speech that may be regarded as damaging to the good name of the person or entity. Therefore, if members' statements are potentially defamatory in relation to an identifiable person or entity, they will be directed to discontinue their remarks and it is imperative that they comply with any such direction.

A total of 74 amendments have been tabled, and the grouping list has been provided to members. We will consider each amendment in turn.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 6, line 16, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.

There are quite a number of amendments in this group. They are: amendments Nos. 1, 6 to 10, inclusive, 12, 14 to 17, inclusive, 19, 21 to 26, inclusive, 28, 29, 32 to 39, inclusive, 43, 45 to 49, inclusive, 52 to 54, inclusive, 68, 69 and 71 to 74, inclusive. They are deal with the same thing, namely the deletion of the term "Digital Health Record" and its replacement with the term "Electronic Health Record". The purpose of this is to ensure that the terminology in the Bill is aligned with the language used in the European Health Data Space, EHDS, regulation, which came into force in each member state at the end of March. The aim behind the regulation is to establish a common framework for the use and exchange of electronic health data across the EU. The regulation will empower each of us to access, control and share electronic health information, both within Ireland and across borders, in the context of direct care.

The purpose of the amendments is simply to make that naming change across the various provisions of the Bill. I can continue if Deputies wish but that is the purpose of this series of amendments.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. As she noted, this amendment is grouped with many others.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 1 is grouped with 14 or 15 other amendments. I can see what the amendments do. What is the purpose of replacing the term “Digital Health Record” with “Electronic Health Record”?

Comment on this

It is to simply align the terminology in the Bill with the language used in the EHDS regulation. We are trying to establish a European-wide ability to share data in a consistent way. This simple terminological change will enable us to do that and to avoid purposely create legislation that is linguistically at odds with the rest of Europe.

Comment on this

The last time we had a debate on this issue, it was in respect of the heads of Bill. Some of the same officials are involved again today. We had very lengthy discussions on the lack of progress in this area. Two years have passed. The question is, what progress has been made since? There was a lengthy discussion at that time on the different types of records involved. I refer to summary records, shared care records and then electronic health records. My understanding is that we are still at the point of working towards summary care records. Is that the case, and how far have we progressed in that regard?

Comment on this

I will ask Mr. Tierney, who has been working throughout the period in question, to address that.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Since we met last, we have mobilised what it known locally as a national shared care record programme, which is about developing shared care records across care settings. For example, if a person was to seek assistance in an accident and emergency department, a shared care record would provide the staff involved with access to GP records and, where they exist, pharmacy and hospital records. This would mean that for at least the person's first intervention, those providing care could see a minimal level of information to help with diagnosis or intervention. The next phase-----

Comment on this

Have we moved beyond summary care records to shared care records for everybody?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Yes. In practical terms, they are one and the same thing. That shared care record programme is now mobilised. We have appointed a vendor. Work is under way. By the end of this year, our ambition is to deploy that. Our first deployment in the Deputy's area in Waterford and the surrounding community will involve launching a shared care record pilot phase deployment. This will then be widened on a national basis in 2026 and 2027. We have made great progress.

Comment on this

I want to tease out a few issues, and other members will want to come in as well. Obviously, that is good if we want to get to that space, but we are still a couple of years away from getting to the shared care record space. What is the key difference between that and a full electronic health record?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

If we think about a shared care record, the main differentiator is that it is a longitudinal record that starts to connect fragmented records across the system in order to provide a unified view to those who are receiving care and those who are providing it. What we call an enterprise electronic health record, in the first instance, is to provide that level of functionality. Second, at a much deeper level, it is effectively about automating the patient journey in order that from the time a person receives his or her first intervention, the care plan is being automated and planned for at the next level or stage. Let us say that on the basis that we have a full enterprise electronic health record in situ when a person arrives at a GP or even into an accident and emergency department, his or her next steps are already being preplanned. His or her labs are being ordered-----

Comment on this

We are told that the children's hospital will have full electronic health records.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Wall-to-wall digital care.

Comment on this

What is the difference between what will go live in the children's hospital and the summary care records that will be used across the remainder of the health service? Will that involve integration with GPs and community care facilities or will it just be an EQ system?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

The shared care record definitely involves integration across all care settings where a person's health information exists. In other words, information relating to GPs, pharmacies and hospitals. There is little data being collected in the community because it is predominantly a paper-based system. We have a plan to create some capability in community care. If we think about it, the electronic health record system in the children's hospital is a full digital record from the time a child is admitted for care for paediatric services until he or she is discharged, whatever his or her condition or need is. It is very deep, and it automates his or her plan. That is the difference. If I was talking about our ambition to implement an electronic health record at national level, I would ask the Deputy to think about the children's hospital but on a national level.

Comment on this

I have a final question. In the North, two of the health trusts - the western and southern trusts - went live with electronic health systems in May. Has Mr. Tierney engaged with colleagues in the North? Has he had a look at their systems? I think it is the Epic system that is in use there.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

It is. We are very fortunate because if we think about it from the perspective of the children's hospital, we must think about that ease of integration between what we are deploying there and paediatric services in the North. Then, we start opening up the possibilities of all-island paediatric care. That will be the game-changer. That is the opportunity.

Comment on this

With regard to records that are already in place, some, although not all, of the maternity units have computerised records. The first four involved began doing this five years ago. Can the electronic record relating to a baby born in a maternity units be passed on if that child is subsequently brought to the children's hospital 12 months later? Will such records be capable of being passed on in computerised form rather than by means of a paper file?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

At a minimum, a shared care record will allow minimum access to health information wherever it is in the system. If the question is about whether we can we pick up a baby's electronic record and ingest it into the system within the children's hospital, in theory, yes, we can. However, we have to work through matters in terms of interoperability. Going back the first part of the Deputy's question, the committee will be aware that Limerick maternity unit went live on the maternity HR system just three weeks ago. That is a major milestone because it sets us on a path to get 70% of all births on a maternity HR system. That is great news.

Comment on this

There are 19 maternity units. How many operating electronic systems?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

By the end of the year, all the larger sites will be in our maternity hospital deployment. This means that 70% of all births will be captured on an electronic health record system by that time. We will then have to figure out how we pick up the satellite units in terms of how we feed in information from them. We are working through that.

Comment on this

Electronic records very much relate to mothers. I am asking whether electronic records is kept in respect of babies following birth.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Mother and child.

Comment on this

Therefore-----

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

It is a care model that is digitised for the care of the mother and the child, following birth.

Comment on this

The other issue I want to ask about is with regard to the number of systems. Denmark was down to 25 systems about four years ago. It is now working towards having five systems. My understanding is that between all the hospitals, GPs and pharmacies, we had something like 1,700 different systems. What is the number now?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

I will tell the Deputy where we would like to get to. We would like to get down to one system nationally, which is that relating to our enterprise electronic health record. We have developed a business case. We are engaging with our colleagues in the Department of public expenditure and reform for support for investment to start the programme in that regard. The matter is under active consideration.

We have thousands of discrete independent systems throughout the health service. The challenge is to connect them. The way to do that is to start replacing them over time with a shared care record that is longitudinal and that takes information out of those hundreds of systems to provide a unified view and, in time, replace this with an enterprise electronic health record. The goal is to get down to one system. In fairness to the authorities in Denmark, they have been at this for 30 years. We have only really started.

Comment on this

If we go back to the maternity services, on the basis that when a child is born and an electronic record is being kept from the start, the question is about the priority of getting every maternity unit to operate an electronic system. Mr. Tierney referred to a figure of 70%, but it is about moving forward from there. The issue is the timescale we were talking about whereby if we have 70% that are electronic and 30% that are not, this will cause its own problems even if they are transferred.

There is another issue I want to raise. I was speaking to a general doctor recently in one of the largest hospitals in Dublin. He informed me that he spends 50% of his day chasing down X-rays or scans for patients and trying to get them on to their files. It is about getting all those records on to a patient's file once the scan or X-ray has been performed. How far along are we in trying to achieve that goal?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

The national shared care record will link into what we call the national integrated medical imaging system, NIMIS, which is our national imaging database. GPs will have immediate access to a person's images and diagnostics once we deploy our national shared care record.

Going back to the Deputy's previous question about how long it takes to roll out an electronic health record, as Deputy Cullinane pointed out, the North has been successful in this regard, but that was on the basis of an eight-year programme. These things take time, particularly as we have to standardise work practices and workflows and then digitise the information using an electronic technology platform. We are under no illusion; this takes time and effort and commensurate funding That is where we are at the moment.

Comment on this

Deputy Daly is next. We will then move to Deputy Sherlock.

Comment on this

What is the name of the system that will be used in the new children's hospital?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

It is an electronic health record which is wall to wall-----

Comment on this

Is there a name for this system, the operating system?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

I think they called it Project Ogham. We know who the vendor is and I am not sure if I want to start naming vendors in the committee. That would be unfair. We are in procurement for a wider-----

Comment on this

The Department is in procurement and cannot say who the vendor is. Will the record of somebody who reaches 16 or 18 years of age and needs to go to St. James's Hospital be compatible with its system?

Comment on this

That is the ultimate goal and what we are trying to get to. This is going to be a staged process over time. As we said, we started with the maternity hospitals, the children's hospital and the national rehabilitation hospital have this measure. This is about making this the complete system for all healthcare interactions. The whole purpose is to get to the point where a person’s care is available to whichever provider he or she turns up to, whether in a scheduled way such as transitioning from paediatric to adult services or in a more organic way, such as when a person has had a trauma or an accident and turns up at a different hospital. The same record is individualised or personalised to that person and should be available. That is going to take us some time, not only to integrate the different systems between acute, paediatric, adult and community, but on a regional basis and in terms of how we stage that securely, effectively and reasonably throughout not only the different elements of the healthcare system, but the regions of it, along how we stage this. What the Deputy is describing is our goal.

Comment on this

This is no reflection on the Minister, but about ten years ago I sat in the Department of Health and we talked about all of this and very little has moved. If someone is in the children's hospital and reaches the age where he or she has to go to the adult hospital, are those systems integrated? That is my first question.

I understand there are sensitivities around procurement but there are only one or two big systems around that we are talking about. My second question is again on IT. We mentioned general practitioners. GPs have been 95% computerised for the past 25 years, since the year 2000. We know that from the chronic disease management programme. In order to participate in that programme, one had to be computerised. There is a 95% uptake of GPs. In fact, we were talking to 40 GPs who operating an old system. There is a great dependence on one or two companies. One company dominates the GP space. There is great concern that if that company for any reason - I am not suggesting it will - became vulnerable financially or otherwise, or was sold out of the State, this whole network of the only part of the health service that is fully computerised and paperless would collapse. This is a question not an opinion but would it not be a worthwhile project to look into the HSE and Department taking over the national GP, and integrating it with the rest of the health service?

Comment on this

I will start and ask Mr. Tierney to come in. It is very important, not only as we go through this procurement process but the many procurement processes I hope we will be in together over the next number of years, that we manage those processes from the perspective of maximising the advantage of the State, which is all of our shared interest. We will need to be careful on that. I ask Mr. Tierney to give more information on some of the Deputy’s other questions.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

I take the Deputy’s first question. The scenario he is presenting is a child or patient in CHI receiving care, and after reaching the age of 18, he or she needs to receive acute care in St. James's Hospital, for example. I will answer that in two ways. The purpose of this Bill is to ensure that the patient's data is accessible and follows him or her on his or her care journey. We are here today to make sure we at least establish a legal underpinning, obligation and duty to share, to allow us live through that duty of care. At a practical, technical level what I would say is that the national shared care record in the first instance allows both the patient and the caregiver in St. James's to have access to a minimum level of information from the CHI system to understand what the patient need is and what care has been received to date.

Comment on this

There will not be an integrated record.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

As the Minister said, in time-----

Comment on this

That is the answer

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

-----we want to get to a national EHR. I will deal with the GP question. It is a very interesting scenario the Deputy presents and is one on my mind as we go into procurement for an enterprise EHR. The Deputy is right that there are four systems in the GP community but one vendor has dominance. That is in my mind and is something we are considering in future options but we are in a live procurement and I do not want to go any further.

Comment on this

I understand. At least it is on the radar.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Absolutely. The liability is-----

Comment on this

There is critical exposure there.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Correct. There is.

Comment on this

It is great we are having this committee meeting today. I very much welcome the Bill. I wish to pick up on some of those questions about the integration with primary care and, in particular, GP records. Is there a view it will be just GMS patients who will be captured by this system, or will it be all GP patients? By extension, I am thinking of dental services and the integration of public health records and records held by private hospitals. What is the shareability? If I turn up at a private hospital or dental practice in the morning, will that accessibility be there whenever the system is fully operational?

Comment on this

The intention is that it will be for all patients and GPs and not just GMS. The information we have is that it will be richer for GMS patients in the first instance. I ask Mr. O'Connor to comment on the legal piece and Mr. Tierney on the technical.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

The whole Bill is about supporting integrated care and the transitions from community to acute and to GPs. Part 3 of the Bill sets out the categories of information we commit to providing for each citizen. The digitalisation is a huge detail of the enterprise system and will take many years. The Bill facilitates the interoperability of data from different systems to consolidate information into summary care records for all citizens. We believe that will deliver value in a much nearer term. The overall digitalisation is a vital investment in the medium to longer term.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

To add to that, the Bill does not distinguish between public or private. A patient is a patient and a healthcare provider as a healthcare provider. At a technical level, when I look at our shared care record, all information is up for grabs. If there is information a GP system needed for a person's care, we do not distinguish between private or public. We are giving effect to the Bill and how we get access to data, whether it is a publicly or privately provided service. I expect the private sector will be knocking on my door looking for publicly held information, particularly diagnostics and images, so it will cut both ways.

Comment on this

Ultimately, the software provider of these systems will be a private company, not something developed within the HSE or the Department of Health itself.

Comment on this

That is not the intention. The scale of what is necessary from a data management, cyber security or integrated perspective we are looking at data providers. It would not be appropriate for the Department of Health or HSE, which are not IT companies but health service and policy delivery vehicles. That is not their function. I ask Mr. Tierney to elaborate on it.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

There will The Deputy is right. We will not be developing code from scratch. If the Deputy looks at our national shared care record, we have procured a joint venture - effectively a company that delivered OneLondon. It is a joint venture between a technology provider and an integrator and there will be a configuration around what we need in terms of what information or records we want to get access to. We are not coding from scratch, from first principles. We are buying in a proven, reliable technology stack that is delivered in another jurisdiction and proven its effect.

Comment on this

Our witnesses might explain what Community Connect is. We have had some correspondence alleging that this project has not gone to tender and the HSE is developing its own in-house framework. Could the witnesses explain what it is and clarify it for us? Whatever we have heard, the witnesses have been alerted to those concerns as well.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

If I take it back to where we currently are, we have systems and data that are fragmented and isolated. Where we have systems, it is great but in our community setting, we are predominantly a paper-based system. Our records are paper and are manually derived.

Comment on this

When Mr. Tierney says community now, he is talking about CDNTs, primary care-----

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Correct. I would say the wider primary care settings. It is predominantly paper based and we do not have any maturity around digital systems, digital technology or data collection systems in our community settings. Therefore, there is a gap. While our longer term plan is to roll out a national electronic health record, we recognise there is a need to deliver some capability to the community in the interim. This is what community connect is. It is a solution to bridge a gap in time until we get to the final state, which is an enterprise national electronic health system. We have now commenced a programme where we are using an existing framework to start to deploy an existing solution into the community, into mental health in the first instance, widening to palliative care and then widening it again to wider community services. The vendor is currently delivering a solution for us. I would say it is a mid-tier vendor and we are exploiting that framework to roll that out into the community, to bridge a gap and fill a need they have.

We do not have the luxury to be able to pick and choose. We are not fully funded to make decisions for everything. We have to standardise our approach and we have to exploit existing frameworks and technology where we can. Part of our job is to understand what we have, whether it delivers capability and how we can use that within the system.

Comment on this

Does the Department of Health have any concerns about the procurement process or lack thereof?

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

My job is to push us away from paper and enable us with digital capability. That is where we have to go. None of us has the luxury to pick and choose.

Comment on this

I am just clarifying that the Department of Health does not have any procurement concerns as regards community connect or projects such as that.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

That is correct.

Comment on this

Deputy Cullinane indicated he wanted to come back in. I am conscious that we are still on amendment No. 1 of 74. I want to get through the others and we have two hours left. I ask him to be brief.

Comment on this

We have loads of time. I have three quick questions. When we look at the scale of what needs to be done even to get to the shared care records, we have multiple service providers across acute, primary and community. I do not underestimate the challenge. We have multiple systems. Am I right in saying that initially at least we are looking at interoperability of multiple systems? Following on from that, has the Department met any challenges or resistance in getting to that space?

Comment on this

I will ask Mr. Tierney to begin and I might come in after that.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

I will try to set out what the shared care record is from a technology perspective. If we think about it, it is a black box and all it is doing is connecting into those existing systems the Deputy talked about. It is not about forcing systems to talk to each other. It is dropping down into each of those systems, pulling out the relevant information and connecting it so that patients and healthcare providers are seeing that combined unified record as it exists within the system in separate parts.

Comment on this

The reason I asked the question is that when we look at other European countries and indeed the North - we just talked about that - they have single system of electronic records with full bells and whistles. That is a single system, but we are not talking about that. If our objective is to move to full electronic health records, would that require a single system?

Comment on this

It would. That is what we are ultimately getting to, but this has to be a transition. There is no other practical way of doing it. I very much hope we will be having this conversation in a number of years from now and that we are talking about a single system as other countries in Europe have. While not all have managed to do it, those that have managed to do it have begun this journey a little earlier than us and we want to end up in that space. To transition from what we currently have-----

Comment on this

I appreciate that and the scale of it. I fully understand that. Mr. Tierney and I have talked previously in private discussions about the cost of all of this. I know the system in the North cost over €1 billion and other European countries have spent a lot of money. What is the budget over the coming years even to get us to a point of having a shared care record? What would be required to get to a point where we would have the full electronic system across the entire health service? How much money are we talking about?

Comment on this

I will ask Mr. Tierney to take that. However, we need to be aware we are in a live procurement process.

Comment on this

Am I right in saying it is very expensive and would require very significant capital expenditure?

Comment on this

It would require very significant capital expenditure. We are in a live procurement process. We do, of course, have a budget at present of about €190 million which is keeping things going at the moment, maintaining our cyber security, and Mr. Tierney can provide more detail on that. We are in a live procurement process and we are talking about very significant capital investment.

Comment on this

Is that for the shared care record?

Comment on this

It is for the whole thing, including the planning of it. To get to the ultimate electronic health record, the unified system, we are talking about very significant capital expenditure.

Comment on this

However, current procurement is not for a single system, is it? It is for the-----

Comment on this

Nevertheless we are in a procurement process now. We are making a business case at present and we are also in NDP discussions. This is a public session, of course. I am very aware that vendors might have an interest in it. We need to manage our conversation on finances carefully in the interest of the State.

Comment on this

I have one final question and then perhaps Mr. Tierney can come back on both. Was there any resistance from any of the voluntary hospitals? That was something that came up previously. Obviously, they have their own boards and have their own systems. Are we getting buy-in from across the entire health service?

Comment on this

I would like Mr. Tierney to come in on the Deputy's earlier questions but I would also like Mr. O'Connor to give his perspective on the co-operation of the voluntary hospitals with, for example, the productivity dashboard. The purpose of Bill is to make sure there is no ambiguity regarding the sharing of information about the patient. That applies to all things. It is necessary that the voluntary hospitals implement this. For example, the integrated financial management system, IFMS, is already an essential part in making non-pay savings. I expect to see the voluntary hospitals do that enthusiastically where that has not yet been done. I would expect them to co-operate with this as well because they are being paid for by the State.

Comment on this

The question is: are they doing it?

Comment on this

I might ask Mr. O'Connor to speak about the productivity dashboard, which might be helpful.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

Part of the fragmentation in our health information landscape has arisen from the public, private, voluntary nature of the Irish system. There was not always an enthusiastic willingness to share data between voluntary and public, and between private and public. There were instances where voluntary hospitals entered into data sharing agreements with the NTPF which required them not to share that data with the Department of Health. We have ironed out those issues. I can detect and see very considerable progress through a data access group.

The section 38 hospitals, as a group, have engaged with the complete refreshment of data sharing arrangements with the HSE. They recognise the importance of connected health. They recognise the European move to centre it on citizens' rights to have their health information connected, irrespective of where they get the data. Although not yet enacted, the Bill is having a very positive influence on the commitment to share. It is vital that we operate as a coherent system. The sharing of care records from different sources, as we have spoken about, is now supported in legislation. There is a clear legal basis for the sharing.

There are much stronger powers for the HSE to require data, to specify the categories of information it wants and crucially - I think the Deputy was picking up on this - the standards to support interoperability. The beauty of it is that the interoperability we seek will not just unify health information in a connectable way here in Ireland, but will have it connected across the wider 27 member states of the EU and associated countries that plug in. Therefore, we can really transform this quickly from what I would regard as very poor behaviours at times around data sharing. I am confident that we are really getting places now. The productivity dashboard that the Minister spoke about took about 18 months of work, trying to renegotiate data sharing and trying to secure the reporting in sensible formats to bring that visibility to the productivity and performance in health and social care so we have a unified system.

We are engaging with the private hospitals. They have not all been co-operative but we are working with them to ensure we get a citizen-centred approach, which while rather agnostic to the site in which the healthcare is delivered, captures the data arising.

Comment on this

I call Deputy Roche, who has not spoken yet, followed briefly by Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

I wish the Minister and her officials a good morning. I am excited about the prospect of this. It is a move in the right direction. We are in the digital age now and whether we like it or not, it is fair to suggest or for me to think it is worth bringing all the systems together and channelling or filtering that information about one's file such that wherever an accident or emergency might occur, at least that information can be tapped into. Easy access means early intervention and that primarily should be where we are trying to get to.

I had a number of questions and have been saved the task of asking them because previous speakers have posed them so I am not going to go back over that. I anticipate resistance, maybe, by some to engaging in this process. Sometimes people are afraid the information might be used for the wrong reason or that outside parties might have access to that very confidential and private information. Does the Minister anticipate resistance in that regard due to fear of the information getting shared or will it be managed such that only those who have a need to access it can get hold of it?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy mean resistance or reluctance on the part of individuals or hospitals?

Comment on this

"Reluctance" is probably a better word. It could be from hospitals or individuals. Of course, if individuals resist, the chances are they are cutting off their nose to spite their face.

Comment on this

We are very respectful of the personal rights of individuals and how their data is held and managed. There is a need to hold data electronically for the purposes of providing care, but there are certain guardrails put around who may access that data and on what basis. At the next level when we are looking at how we share and consider data on a more collective level, for health research for example, clearly all that is anonymised and is at a completely different level. In the same way everyone benefits from the changes made to organ donation on the basis it might be the Deputy or it might be me but we all benefit collectively, we all benefit from sharing information not just in Ireland but with Europe in a completely anonymised way for health research purposes and for innovation purposes.

From the perspective of hospitals, I am afraid resistance really is not an option. Resistance is futile, in the words of the Borg. To be clear, the State pays for hospital care and it does not matter whether it is a HSE hospital or a section 38 one. The State is the entity paying and all of us are the people who are responsible for that. It is like being slow on integrated financial management systems. It is really not acceptable. This is what we are doing. We are providing a legal basis for how that may be done. There should be no ambiguity about this. This is what is happening.

Comment on this

Excellent. What about timelines? The Minister mentioned how long it took Denmark. When does she anticipate this will be live or will be enacted?

Comment on this

I might ask Mr. Tierney and Mr. O'Connor to come in on that.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

My deadline for the Minister is to have the shared care record deployed in a first pilot by the end of this year. That is a very aggressive timeline.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

We had to negotiate hard with the vendor to get there, but that is the commitment. We want to deploy it in an integrated setting between Waterford general hospital and the wider community, get it to work there as a proof of delivery and then widen it on a regional and national basis. In parallel, to go back to Deputy Cullinane's question, we have developed a business case for the longer term system of an enterprise electronic health record. We are engaging with the Department of public expenditure and reform in the context of the NDP and funding levels and we have commenced a procurement engagement with the market. That is where we are. I am very focused on doing this.

Comment on this

All I will say in conclusion is well done and the best of luck with it. I am excited about the prospect, I must admit.

Comment on this

I might ask Mr. O'Connor to answer the earlier question.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

On the assurances patients have, the Bill provides a clear assurance for them to access their information to ensure that for the purpose of direct care, only health professionals with a direct and legitimate interest in their care can access it. Echoing the kind of commitments coming from Europe, patients will be able to obtain information on any others accessing their information. In time you will be able to see your information in a summary care record, but you will also have a log of others who have access and you will see it is your GP, your GP nurse and so on. Patients will also be able to raise concerns or anything like that. There is a huge amount built around the assurance and the trust, which is vital in this space because health information is very personal information, but it is vital it be available to health and social care professionals in different settings. There is a great amount of assurance and a really solid, clear legal basis. We will work to maintain the trust and confidence of the population.

Comment on this

To be clear, the guardrails are set out in section 12 of the Bill. It is important to say we are very respectful and concerned about individuals and their privacy. There are a couple of elements to that. One is that we need them to be in the electronic health system so they can get the quickest possible and the best, most integrated care. If you turn up to a hospital with a major trauma and have a complex medical background, you need the people who are caring for you to be able to access your complete information. Nevertheless, you are also entitled to the protection of your data, how that is managed, how it is shared and who can access it.

Part of our responsibility is the security side of this. We are quite aware of the scale of the cybersecurity attack on the health system that happened. That it happened during Covid, I always felt, somewhat masked the seriousness of it because there was so much disruption in the health system as a consequence of Covid. When the cybersecurity attack then happened at the same time, very significant disruption occurred as a consequence. I often felt people did not really attribute the disruption to the scale of the attack that happened here. We are very conscious of that in how we approach this. This is a live concern, not just for the Irish system, the current system or the future system but right across the EU. We hear of increasing concerns, especially in the eastern part of Europe, about how health systems are managed. We are very aware of that and we are taking every possible step we can on that side of things. There is a balance here. The individual is protected and respected in every possible way. We have set out the guardrails and the way in which that can be done, in section 12 in particular. Then there is a very different perspective in respect of hospitals more generally. They are funded by the State, they participate and that is it.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister. The introduction of a new modern IT system with all patients' records available across the health service will be a game-changer. There is no doubt about that. It is something I have called for. I am aware it will be expensive and will take time to introduce. Is there an approximate timeframe for the introduction of this system?

On CAMHS and with reference to the scandal in the services in both north and south Kerry, can I take it the records of all these children and young adults will introduced to this new system?

Comment on this

Yes. Over time, all those records will be integrated into the system. It will take some time, and I will ask Mr. Tierney to speak to the specific timeline we hope to achieve and envisage achieving. Of course, it is subject to all the elements going well and having the funding to do this in the reasonable way we hope. The goal is that all records will ultimately be in this electronic health system. Mr. Tierney might speak to the detail of it.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

We have asked where we would like to get to ultimately and how we can get there in a stepped way. Earlier this year we launched a HSE patient app, which was about putting information we can currently get access to into the patient's hands so we can start empowering them to take responsibility for themselves and take an interest in their health and well-being.

The second step is to, as I said earlier, mobilise a shared care record, which is about looking to what we have, how we can dip into it, pull it up and connect it in a unified way so that we have a minimum level of information to be able to give back to a patient through the app or through their healthcare-giver, wherever they are in the system. Longer term, we would like to get to an enterprise electronic health record, which would cater for the need of every person on the island and of every healthcare provider who has a stake in providing care for the patient. As I mentioned in response to Deputy Sherlock earlier, one of the intermediate steps, particularly around CAMHS, is how we can exploit existing technology and roll it into primary care community so that we can, for instance, start understanding how we digitise CAMHS, palliative care and other wider primary care services. It is to bring all of that jigsaw together ultimately.

Comment on this

I will just add that the app is really important. While the Internet signal is historically terrible in committee rooms in the basement in LH 2000, it is an app you can download. You need a MyGovID to sign in. Obviously, I expect everybody in the room has downloaded it and is part of the group of 80,000 people who have committed to registering their personal health information. The functionality of it would be easier to see were the signal slightly better in the committee room, but I have talked to people who have downloaded it and they can see, for example, all of their medications on it. Sometimes taking complex medication can be difficult. It can be hard to manage, especially when you turn up to a new healthcare provider, to describe what your medication is and what that happens to be. If you log in with your MyGovID, which is secure, you will be able to see locally, wherever you are, where the emergency care centres are and what the primary care options are. You can also see your vaccination record, from both a flu perspective and a Covid perspective. I was embarrassed to realise that there was a bit of gap between my vaccinations and I will not let that happen again this year. You can see your records. It started out being piloted on the maternity side and people could book appointments. We are rolling out increased functionality all of the time. We will get to the point where you can book appointments - where you will need to book appointments - through the app. I would encourage everybody to get it, because this is stage one of this electronic health record, to the extent that Members can put it in their newsletters or email updates to their constituents. If we are going to get to an electronic health record, certainly everyone in the Oireachtas needs to download the app but we also need to start encouraging people to do that. I hope they will see the increased functionality over time and that they will begin to see some of the benefit of it. That is stage one so please go for it.

Comment on this

Deputy Cullinane raised the issue about cost and there is an important question about controlling costs in the development of this. However, we also need to look at savings that will be achieved by having the system there. I referred to Denmark earlier. Back in 2004, Denmark worked out that they were saving about €1.5 billion per annum because of their computerised system. I would imagine that if we have a fully computerised system, it will be a huge saving.

If someone is admitted to hospital, say, as a result of a car accident, and they are not able to give instructions, will staff be able to access their records?

Comment on this

That would be the objective-----

Comment on this

Without consent? Say, for argument's sake, the person is not able to give consent.

Comment on this

That would be the objective because in the current instance that person would have to treated in any event. The objective would be that they would be able to access their records as quickly as possible with whatever identifier was available. The Deputy is right to identify the savings and I will ask Mr. Tierney to speak more to that. I visited the National Rehabilitation Hospital recently. Everything is computerised. There are little trolleys where staff input at the bedside the details that need to be there for the whole system. There is a saving in that it will free up staff's time and facilitate staff in being able to recall records. I have also visited archive rooms in hospitals right across the country. These are rooms that are down around the back of the hospital, in some room far away, and unfortunately we are now requiring hospital staff to find physical files and bring them back. That all takes time, particularly when someone presents in the accident and emergency department. There is a huge time saving that is a cost saving. I will ask Mr. Tierney to speak more to this. However, it is essential that we do this and this is-----

Comment on this

The reason I am raising it is that I was dealing with an incident where someone who had come in from Germany had a psychiatric problem and was admitted to hospital. The person would not give their consent. He was on medication but the German authorities would not release his records. The doctors could not work out even what medication he was on, to such an extent that he had to be transported back to Germany, accompanied by two healthcare officials, because they could not manage him here. The big issue was that they were not allowed under the German system to access his records.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

Let me answer that. There are a few questions rolled up in this so I will try to unpick it if I can. The purpose of the Bill is to ensure a minimum level of health data is captured for the patient's benefit so that when he or she needs intervention, the healthcare provider has a minimum level of information from which to work. At the moment, if I arrive at an accident and emergency department in which I have never been treated before, those who are providing me with first intervention do not know who I am, what my need is or what medication I am on. They do not even know what my history is. Think about the time they spend just to get a basic diagnosis of what is being presented in front of them. If we think about digitising health records, the primary benefits are increasing safety and quality of care to deliver better outcome. On the time-saving piece, I am sure Deputy Daly would agree healthcare professionals would rather spend more time providing face-to-face care than documenting the care they are giving. It is about being equipped with a capability to free up precious, valuable time in the context of giving care rather than administrating paperwork on that level of care. As the Minister says, one of the secondary benefits is the time saved and realised in the overall system. Time costs money and, therefore, there is a productivity saving and a cash release gain, ultimately. Any way we have looked at an enterprise EHR, the benefit-to-cost ratio makes absolute sense here. There is no argument about it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.2:

In page 6, to delete line 29 and substitute the following:

“(e) data in relation to care (within the meaning of Regulation (EU) 2025/327 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2025 on the European Health Data Space and amending Directive 2011/24/EU and Regulation (EU) 2024/2847);”.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 7, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:

“ “personal public service number” has the same meaning as it has in section 262 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005;”.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 3, 11, 13 and 70 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I ask Deputies to support the amendments in this grouping to ensure all health service providers as defined under the Bill are empowered to collect and record patients' PPSNs. Our health system needs a robust and proven identifier so that health information can effectively and reliably be associated with the correct individual. That is essential for care and treatment and patient safety. As part of this, the Bill aims to enhance patient safety through stronger identified patient processes including best practice use of the PPSN and eircode to uniquely identify patients. In that context, the individual health identifier, IHI, was provided for in the Health Identifiers Act 2014 as a unique identifier for health services. The IHI was designed and developed to enable the unique identification of a patient across healthcare services. Since the enactment of that legislation, the HSE has been embedding the IHI in health information programmes and locations across health services. However, in order to enable the full benefits that IHIs can bring in terms of quality, safety and efficiency, the IHI match rate needs to be as close to 100% as possible. Evaluation of those match rates shows that those health systems that are already collecting and recording the PPSN have significantly higher match rates than those systems that do not. It is also important to recognise that the health systems are part of the wider public service ecosystem, including the national digital strategy. For example, the national data infrastructure, which has been developed as part of the Civil Service renewal plan and the public service ICT strategy, includes the PPSN. It is one of the three trusted unique identifiers, along with eircodes and unique business identifiers, to facilitate the sharing and aggregation of data on a public service-wide basis to support digital services.

Amendment No. 11 amends the reference to the PPSN under the patient summary.

Amendment No. 13 provides for the insertion of a new section mandating a health service provider to record the PPSN of his or her patients and associate the PPSN with any record of the health service provider they make in the provision of health service to that patient. It also empowers a health service provider to request a patient provide his or her PPSN, empowers the HSE to use a PPSN to identify a patient in order to identify and link the patient's health information to his or her electronic health record, and mandates a relevant person to provide the PPSN of a patient where the number is requested by the HSE and they have that PPSN in their possession.

The patient cannot be refused a health service solely because they have not been allocated or issued with a PPSN or because they are not in a position to provide it. That is really important.

Comment on this

We had lengthy discussions on this subject in the past and I came away from them with a somewhat clearer understanding of it. Is it correct that individual health identifiers were essentially put in place during the Covid-19 pandemic? Was that the starting point or when the process accelerated?

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

The IHIs have been seeded into hospital systems. The HSE is working with the GP systems mentioned earlier to ensure they can take IHIs and PPSNs. The PPSN is basically the front of house. It is one of a few numbers most people know in respect of themselves. It is a very useful-----

Comment on this

I am trying to tease out if this is more of a practical thing. It is not that the PPSN will replace the IHI. It is matching it.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

The IHI is the back-end, long-string number. The PPSN is the interface with the customer.

Comment on this

The IHI is essentially the spine, if you like.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

The IHI is the unique-to-health identifier and the PPSN is one that extends across the broader public services. In the near future, when people check in at a health facility they will be asked for their PPSN and that will generate automatically.

Comment on this

Most people will know their PPSN. How does someone find out what their IHI is?

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

It will begin to appear on some medical-----

Comment on this

Rather than beginning to appear, if I wanted to find out mine right now, how would I go about it?

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

I am not sure there is a way to get one's IHI right now. There is a master index on which we have worked with the Department of Social Protection and the HSE. Every PPSN in the country has an IHI which corresponds with it. Our sense is that we do not want to confuse people with two different numbers. The front-of-house number, the interface with patients, will emphasise PPSN.

Comment on this

If somebody wanted to avoid confusion and wanted to know what his or her IHI is, is Mr. O'Connor saying there is no way of finding out?

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

As part of the roll-out we can-----

Comment on this

I am talking about now.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

There is not a phone line that offers that access to service, but the information is there. We can engage with the HSE as to how that facility could be made available.

Comment on this

What about this new app we have heard a lot about.

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

That would be an excellent way, actually. That is a good idea.

Comment on this

It could be. I downloaded the app. I do not know if my IHI is visible on that, or is it?

Comment on this
Mr. Muiris O'Connor

We could build it into the accumulation of extra services in the app. That is a good idea.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

If we go back to the start of my conversation, thinking about the current landscape, we have data on Deputy Cullinane, depending on what care he has been given in different parts of the system. It is not joined up. In parts of the system, what is thought about is what care is being given to Deputy Cullinane in that locality. He could be accessing care at the other end of the country and there may be a number of different identifiers associated with him. What the PPSN is try to do is bring it all together to say-----

Comment on this

I understand that. We talked about safeguards earlier. I have questions about how we can protect people's data. People are particularly precious about giving out their PPSN. We have had data breaches in the past. In the HSE, we had a cyberattack. Even online, there are lots of scams designed as emails that people get asking to send on a PPSN because it is valuable to scammers. It is important those protections are in place. My fundamental point is that transparency is really important as we roll this out. Trust is really important. We have had a very poor culture of giving health information in the past. It is something we have to change. We have to change the public's attitude as well as systems within the HSE. We all have to be leaders in that space. We have had such resistance in the past, sometimes rationally and sometimes irrationally. If I am told there is an individual health identifier that is obviously important but that I cannot access or where there is no way of me finding out what it is, that could raise concerns or suspicions. If it can be integrated into the app or there were some mechanism to allow people could find it, that would be important.

Comment on this

That is completely reasonable. We will look at it. I wish I could log into the app right now. If the IHI is not there in the background, there is no reason it could not or should not be there. We will find a way of doing that.

Comment on this
Mr. Derek Tierney

The IHI is built up of different constituents, such as a surname, first name, date of birth, eircode and contact number. We now want to put the PPSN in to strengthen the match rate so when someone accesses the app and logs in by a verified means, they will have trust and confidence that it refers to them, it is their information and it is what the health service is seeing around that person.

Comment on this