Health Information Bill 2024: Committee Stage
Committee Stage focused on aligning the Bill with the EU Health Data Space by changing “Digital Health Record” to “Electronic Health Record” and advancing a step-by-step move from fragmented systems to shared care records and, ultimately, a national EHR. Deputies pressed the Minister on timelines, costs, integration with maternity, paediatric, GP, private and voluntary services, and whether records would follow patients across the system. The Minister said the shared care record pilot should begin by year-end, with Waterford as an early deployment area, while a full national system will take significant time and capital. Amendments on PPSN use were also advanced to improve patient matching and safety, while preserving access to care for anyone without a PPSN.
Contributions 133–267 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 61 of 2024 ›
The reason I am asking these questions is that there is an opt-out. People can opt out. There is a series of amendments which we will come to later. We do not want to see people opting out. We want to see people opting in. To opt in, there needs to be that level of transparency. When people see their PPSN is being linked to an IHI, they will want to better understand it. I have made the point.
Comment on this
If the app is a way putting all of that together, that would be useful.
Comment on this
I just want to be clear that the PPSN replaces the IHI at the front end for people. Is that right?
Comment on this
If somebody arrives at the health service who does not have a PPSN, perhaps somebody on holidays, what happens in those cases?
Comment on this
They will still get healthcare. It is not a barrier to it.
Comment on this
As Mr. Tierney said, the IHI legislation had a number of keys, namely, forename, surname, date of birth, gender and PPSN. If people do not know their PPSN and do not have an issue with it being looked up, their surname, date of birth and a few other bits of information can be used to identify them and proceed on that basis.
Comment on this
Would it be the same for newborn babies, who are not assigned a PPSN until the birth is registered?
Comment on this
Yes, exactly. There are edge cases where we do not expect somebody to have a PPSN. It takes four to five weeks to generate a PPSN for a newborn baby. The IHI has been developed to be available almost at the point of birth. There would be one lined up in the maternity ward for babies.
Comment on this
Exactly. Tourists would not have an Irish PPSN. They would be assigned a new IHI so those records could be connected. There are commitments down the line where we would be passing the information in respect of a tourist back to his or her country.
Comment on this
It is great this has been solved after so many years and that there is a unique personal identifier with a link to a recognisable PPSN. The PPSN was developed a long time ago but technically this could not be done. Deputy Cullinane made a very good point about having the IHI on the app. Eventually the two numbers will sit on the app.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 9, lines 8 and 9, to delete “Minister for Public Expenditure, National Development Plan Delivery and Reform” and substitute “the Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 9, between lines 19 and 20, to insert the following:
“Progress report
7. The Executive shall, after 18 months and within 24 months of the passing of this Act, submit a report to the Houses of the Oireachtas outlining:
(a) progress towards system-wide Digital Health Records;
(b) progress on integrated financial management systems and outstanding requirements;(c) progress on digitisation of primary and community care services, including the delivery of technology-assisted care at home;
(d) progress on digitisation of acute health services;
(e) engagement with general practitioners, community pharmacists, and other community practicing health and social care professionals on their information
technology needs as it relates to system-wide integration or interoperability and the modernisation of service provision;
(f) engagement with acute hospitals, including voluntary hospitals, on their information technology needs as it relates to system-wide integration or interoperability and the modernisation of service provision;
(g) resource requirements for the implementation, development and maintenance of major information technology projects;
(h) the extent of data collected for the purposes of population-based planning and any blockages or inhibitors identified during the period requiring policy change or additional funding to resolve;
(i) the level of funding made available for digital innovation;
(j) security risks and the steps taken to mitigate such risks.”
As other members have said, all of this is very exciting. There are a lot of benefits to what is being done here. The framework published last year was a very good and an important piece of work for the health service. I fully support it and I want to see its implementation. The committee has discussed this issue a number of times over a number of years. We had what I would describe as a tense or difficult session with the Secretary General of the Department and his officials. There had been pushback from the Department of public expenditure against rolling any of this out. The Minister might recall some of that. It was controversial at that time. We want to park all of that and move forward. We have the new strategy and a new plan. There are lots of moving parts to this. It would be useful to impose an obligation on the health system to come back in a number of years with a progress report setting out where we are. Some progress has been made since we met in 2023. We got that information today and it is all very worthwhile and commendable.
It is important for us, as a health committee, to keep track of it, particularly given the advantages we have discussed to patients, the healthcare system and so on. Will consideration be given to that? I know these amendments are routinely put down for Bills and are very often not accepted for all sorts of reasons, but given that we have a strategy and there is a lot in this legislation that we all want to see progress and of which we are all supportive, it would be useful to have a report and then a meeting of the health committee to look at what progress has been made. That is the purpose for which the amendment is intended.
Comment on this
I totally understand the intent of the amendment. I have drafted amendments along this line for the same reasons in various contexts. Section 6 contains a provision that "The Minister shall review or cause to be reviewed ... no later than 5 years", but that is not what the Deputy is suggesting at all. I understand what he is trying to achieve and the need for it. This should not require a statutory basis. I should do this review anyway, in co-operation with the committee and proactively, and then offer it to the committee, rather than being required to do it by statute. There is a shared interest in making sure this happens.
I note that the Department of public expenditure and reform is now the Department of Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation. I am quite sure, therefore, that officials in that Department share the sense of urgency I have about the need to ensure that electronic health records progress efficiently and in a well-funded way. Members might take the view that they wish to interview officials from the Department of public expenditure, and potentially the Minister, should they find it necessary. I am making the best business case I can in the national development plan review for doing this in a staged and managed way that achieves this outcome in the coming years. I will have no difficulty coming before the committee at any time with a report. I am not sure we need a statutory basis for that and, on that basis, I will not accept the amendment. We just need to do it anyway.
Comment on this
I accept that. It would be useful if the officials and the Minister appeared before the committee on a yearly basis or every second year. It would be useful to get that update.
Comment on this
That is perfectly fair.
Comment on this
I certainly agree that we need to put pressure on the Department of public expenditure and reform, whether it is the Minister or the officials, because there has been pushback. I submitted freedom of information requests on this subject. I have read some of the responses. Other officials in previous hearings would be aware of some of the concerns. I understand those concerns because there has been a number of scandals with digital systems. PPARS, for example, seemed to have paralysed the health service. Never again will we go anywhere near it. We have to move away from that.
When we are spending money on very costly systems, we have to get it right, which is why discussions like this are important in order that people can fully understand what we are doing, what we are getting, what the benefits are and how much it will cost, although cost is somewhat sensitive if procurement processes are in place. There is work to be done with regard to the Department of public expenditure and reform. It and the Department of Health are not fully aligned. If we, as a committee, can help in any way to push the former Department on, we should play a role.
Comment on this
I welcome the Deputy's support. I despise having to correct the Deputy, but that Department has responsibility for public expenditure, reform, infrastructure and digitalisation, so I think the Department's enthusiasm for this project is overwhelming. The Minister, Deputy Jack Chambers, has been a really strong advocate for electronic health records. Not to tell tales about the programme for Government discussions, but the Minister is very committed to health digitalisation. Why would he not be, being a qualified doctor and having worked in that system? He is very committed to it and enthusiastic about it, as are the Taoiseach and Tánaiste. Recognising the importance of this project to the State, through long-term cost savings, management of public expenditure, the impact on the current budget, being able to track expenditure through the IFMS and the integration of all these different things, it is an imperative for the Department of public expenditure, reform, infrastructure and digitalisation. I am sure the Department will be as enthusiastic and co-operative with this committee as I am.
Comment on this
I will add one final point to that. We also had very lengthy discussions in this committee on health spending. Through FOI requests and leaked information, we learned about meetings between officials from the Department of public expenditure, reform, digitalisation and officials from the Department of Health regarding the deficits that were in place for a number of years. The Minister might recall that. There were very sharp differences between that Department and the Department of Health. Later amendments will deal with the tracking of health spending. We routinely submit parliamentary questions on issues and are told that the HSE does not collect data or does not have the data. The more we digitise the health service, the more data we will get and the better we will be able to help everybody. A data-rich health service is one of the best ways to get productivity in the healthcare service.
Comment on this
That is something we need to push and impress on that Department as well. I do not want to overstate the Department's views, but it is important.
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. There are a couple of pieces to that. The IFMS system is essential in us tracking spending in HSE hospitals and, crucially, voluntary hospitals. Some of the deficit issues exist on the voluntary side. It is therefore even more important that they are enthusiastic about bringing this in and enabling us to track the consistency of spending, including the cost of a hip transplant in St. James's Hospital versus somewhere else. That is really important. Where we have managed to achieve some progress on that is the productivity dashboard. That shows the value of transparency in hospitals. It perhaps removes some of the myths about one hospital or another and looks at the actual productivity in different specialisms and gives us a real way of analysing that over time. Of course, it requires time to analyse that on a hospital-by-hospital or specialism basis, but at least we have the capacity to do so now. It should be the same with the financial management system.
I wish to make a clarification that I should have done earlier. Mr. Tierney has very helpfully checked and there is a way for people to get their IHI at the moment. People can email hids.info@hse.ie. They can do it that way if they wish but I still think it would be preferable to have it on the app.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister's commitment to review because this will take considerable expenditure and up-front investment for efficiencies down the line. We have to be careful we do not beat ourselves over the head. We look to the NHS but it cannot be set up as a model. The NHS had a £10 billion issue with its national IT programme between 2010 and 2013. It started in 2003. The NHS was already computerised before that. This is a fraught exercise. There is risk in it, but we have no choice but to push forward. Case studies have been done on the NHS issue over the years. One of the lessons from it is that it is about working from the bottom up, taking small steps, not using a top-down approach and carrying out regular reviews of what is happening. It appears people got into silos. They got defensive about the particular pieces of work they were doing on the system, but approximately £10.1 billion, which is maybe £13 billion, was spent and the NHS still does not have full buy-in from all its trusts. I take Deputy Cullinane's point about the Six Counties, but at the end of the day, this is a difficult, complex exercise. I understand and welcome the work on it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 11, line 5, to delete “every patient a digital health record” and substitute “every patient a national electronic health record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 11, line 6, to delete “a “Digital Health Record” ” and substitute “an “Electronic Health Record” ”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 11, line 9, to delete “Digital Health Records” and substitute “Electronic Health Records”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 11, line 11, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 11, line 14, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 11, lines 24 and 25, to delete “ within the meaning of section 262 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 12, line 25, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 12, between lines 32 and 33, to insert the following:
“Use of personal public service number
12.(1) Subject to subsection (3), a health services provider shall record the personal public service number of each of his or her patients and shall associate the personal public service number of the patient with any record that the health services provider makes in relation to the provision of a health service to that patient.
(2) For the purpose of subsection (1), a health services provider may request a patient to provide his or her personal public service number to the health services provider.
(3) A health services provider shall not refuse to provide a health service to a patient to which the patient would be otherwise entitled to solely because he or she—
(a) has not been allocated and issued with a personal public service number, or
(b) is not in a position to provide the health services provider with his or her personal public service number.
(4) For the purposes of performing its functions under this Act the Executive may, where appropriate, use a personal public service number to identify a patient in order to identify and link the patient’s health information to his or her Electronic Health Record.
(5) A relevant person shall, for the purpose of providing health information to the Executive under this Act, provide the personal public service number of a patient to whom the health information relates where the number is requested by the Executive, and the relevant person has the personal public service number in his or her possession.”.
This amendment is about the use of the PPSN, which we have discussed in part with amendment No. 3.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 12, line 35, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 12, line 36, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 13, line 9, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 13, line 16, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 13, line 18, to delete “health services provider” and substitute “health practitioner”.
Amendments Nos. 18 and 30 are technical amendments replacing the term “health services provider” with “health practitioner”. Upon review of the published Bill, it appeared there were a couple of instances where the term “health practitioner” might be more appropriate than “health service provider” as it is more precise and better aligns with the use of the term “health professional” under the EHDS regulation.
Amendment No. 41 is a technical amendment deleting the term “health services provider” and substituting “the executive” instead. That seeks to correct an error in the published Bill as it is the HSE that is required to retain a record in respect of when a health services provider accesses restricted information including the reasons for so doing.
Comment on this
A lot of questions arise from this. It is more about getting clarity. We spoke earlier of the need for buy-in and trust. It is important that we tease out in which circumstances a person would not get access to data. These sections relate to withholding data for people in certain circumstances where it “has reasonable grounds for believing that such access would be likely to cause serious harm to the physical or mental health of the patient concerned.” We will get to that first. However, in relation to practitioners, it refers to “where there are factual indications that disclosure would endanger the vital interests or rights of the health practitioner”. I will wait for the Minister’s response, but we have had a lot of issues recently relating to CHI where patients had to go to the courts and on the steps of the courts were provided with information and data they needed. Clinical reviews are ongoing into the practice of some clinicians in that hospital. That happens at times, unfortunately. We do not want to be withholding information that would protect the interests of the practitioner. What I am trying to understand here is how tightly the sections of this Bill could be applied. What is meant by “vital interests” of the healthcare practitioners? Can we have examples of why access would be denied on what are called “reasonable grounds for believing that such access would be likely to cause serious harm”? What scenarios are we talking about here?
Comment on this
I will ask Mr. O’Connor to come in, please.
Comment on this
I will start and I might bring Ms Doyle in too. The legislation is very determined to ensure that the citizen has full comprehensive rights to access their own information. We are just creating a bit of latitude in the Bill. For instance, if a diagnostic test or a scan for a cancer came through, the health practitioner might wish, for very good reasons, to have a direct personal conversation with their patient in advance of the information being immediately uploaded to their record. That is an instance where it would be appropriate to personalise the information and engage appropriately with the patient. Those are the circumstances. They would be very limited circumstances in which -----
Comment on this
Does it prescribe those kinds of instances? Mr. O’Connor says a bit of latitude, but sometimes a bit of latitude means you can drive a horse and carriage through it. In circumstances like the ones Mr. O’Connor just explained, there may be a rationale, but the concern is that a medical practitioner would not provide the information because in their view it was protecting their vital interests as opposed to protecting the interests of the patient. We talked about guardrails earlier. What are the guardrails here to make sure no unintended consequences might flow from that section?
Comment on this
I will ask Ms Doyle to speak to it and I will come in with an idea.
Comment on this
We are probably looking at two different scenarios here around restrictions. One is around a health service provider or heath practitioner restricting access to part of the electronic health record for a period of time. Mr. O’Connor gave the example of where there might be test results that have come back but where the conversation on the impact and implications of those test results has not been had. The provision there is very much about restricting as briefly as possible and only what is necessary and proportionate. Without wanting to pre-empt other amendments in this session, another amendment draws from data protection regulations, re-emphasising the point that that restriction should only be in respect of that particular part of the electronic health record. It should not be interpreted as a blanket restriction across the electronic health record.
Comment on this
Ms O’Connor might put herself in the shoes of a patient for a second. If a patient is looking for the information and, in the scenario Ms O'Connor has painted, the medical practitioner believes they need to have a conversation with that patient first, is that then communicated to the patient immediately to say the reason they cannot be given this is that the medical practitioner wants to see the patient? How does it work in practice?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. As he says, it is a really important reflection. He can see what we are trying to achieve here but we may not quite have struck the balance. I might bring in a slight tweak on Report Stage that makes it time limited or time bound because the purpose is not to restrict access to personal information but to ensure that information is given appropriately, sensitively and not in a damaging way rather than restricting access. If the Deputy will let me reflect on it, I will come back on Report Stage, perhaps with a time-bound period, to make sure we are achieving what we intend.
Comment on this
We need to be careful because if there is a wait time, for example, there might be results from a scan and it might be information that cannot be imparted over the phone and needs a face-to-face consultation.
Comment on this
We need to be careful about time restriction because the next review appointment might be 28 days or seven days later, depending on the seriousness of the condition. I would be careful. It should be robust if it is time limited and there should be a very good reason for holding back the information pending the outcome of an appointment, maybe.
Comment on this
Let me reflect on it and we will find an appropriate time. The Deputies might have particular suggestions. What we are trying to achieve here is to make sure information is delivered in a face-to-face way and not restricted from a patient in perpetuity.
Comment on this
If Deputies want to think about whether that is, say, three months or what the appropriate period is, I am happy to take suggestions and we will reflect on it as well so that we collectively achieve what we are trying to do here.
Comment on this
I will press it with the proviso that I will bring a clarification on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 13, line 20, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 13, between lines 26 and 27, to insert the following:
“(6) Nothing in this section shall operate to prevent a health services provider from granting access to a patient to so much of the information sought in relation to his or her Electronic Health Record as may be granted without causing serious harm to the physical or mental health of the patient concerned.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 13, line 28, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 13, line 29, to delete “Digital Health Records” and substitute “Electronic Health Records”
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 13, line 33, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 14, line 16, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 14, line 20, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 14, line 22, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 27 and 40 are related. Amendment No. 40 is consequential to No. 27. They may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
In page 14, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
“(b) The Executive shall retain, for a prescribed period, a record that the patient or appropriate person acknowledged that he or she had been informed of the matters referred to in paragraph (a) prior to the restriction of access to all or part of his or her Electronic Health Record in accordance with subsection (1).”
This section provides for a patient’s right to restrict access to their electronic health record by health services providers but in advance of any restriction being applied, the HSE is obliged to inform the patient that such a restriction could impact on the quality of care they receive. The amendment allows for a record to be retained of any such conversation so as to show that it did take place and perhaps to help with any misunderstandings at a later date.
Amendment No. 40 is consequential to that and provides for an additional provision to be inserted to allow for regulations in respect of the form, manner and length of time that that record should be retained. I am to consult with the Data Protection Commissioner and other stakeholders in that regard. It is important to note that a health service provider may override the restriction and access restricted information contained within the electronic health record in order to protect the vital interests of the patient. If that does happen, the patient concerned can be advised by the HSE as to the reason.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 14, lines 26 and 27, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 15, lines 4 and 5, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 30:
In page 15, lines 7 and 8, to delete “health services provider” and substitute “health practitioner”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 31 and 42 are related and may be discussed together. Amendment No. 42 is consequential to amendment No. 31.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 15, line 9, to delete “section 15” and substitute “section 15(3)(j)”.
Section 14(1) provides for a patient's right to obtain access to their electronic health record, including details on the information that has been accessed, by whom and when. However, that right can be restricted by the HSE in exceptional circumstances where there are factual indications that any such disclosure could threaten the vital interests of the health services provider or the patient. These amendments seek to correct an omission from the published Bill and provide for an explicit power to make regulations to allow the HSE to restrict the application of section 14(1), and this again is subject to consultation with the Data Protection Commission.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 15, line 13, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
In page 15, lines 18 and 19, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 34:
In page 15, lines 37 and 38, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 35:
In page 16, line 2, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 36:
In page 16, line 4, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 37:
In page 16, line 8, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 38:
In page 16, line 10, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 16, lines 12 and 13, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 16, between lines 14 and 15, to insert the following:
“(h) the form and manner in relation to which, and period during which, a record under section 13(3)(b) shall be retained by the Executive;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 16, line 16, to delete “a health services provider” and substitute “the Executive”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 42:
In page 16, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
“(j) measures to permit the Executive to restrict the application of section 14(1);”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 43:
In page 16, line 30, to delete “A Digital Health Record” and substitute “An Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44:
In page 16, to delete lines 34 to 36 and substitute the following:
“(b) subject to suitable transparency arrangements being in place, be used by the Executive where it considers that its use is necessary for—
(i) a public interest purpose in the area of public and occupational health, including activities for the protection against serious cross-border threats to health and public health surveillance or activities ensuring high levels of quality and safety of health services, including patient safety, and of medicinal products or medical devices,
(ii) the development of policy and regulatory activities in order to improve, promote and protect the health and welfare of the public, including service planning and performance management in the area of health, or
(iii) the purpose of statistics, including national, multi-national and EU level official statistics, within the meaning of Regulation (EC) No. 223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 2009, related to health or care sectors.”.
This section provides that electronic health records may be used by health service providers for the purposes of care and treatment and also be used by the HSE for specified public interest purposes. This provision aligns with the EHDS regulation in providing for the data contained in electronic health records to be used not only for direct care and treatment but also for secondary purposes. As in the published Bill, these specified public interest purposes mirror those contained in Part 4 of the Bill. Clearly setting them out here, however, seeks to clarify that this provision applies across all sectors, public, private and voluntary, regardless of the arrangement entered into within the HSE. We discussed some of this context a little earlier.
Comment on this
We would all accept the logic of that and of using what is personal health data for policy development, preparing regulations and the collection of data and statistics and so on. The question then is whether that data will be used in an anonymised or pseudoanonymised fashion only or whether a person's personal information can be made available in the context of doing what I referred to. In other words, is the data only used in the form of anonymised or pseudoanonymised versions?
Comment on this
For secondary purposes, the default would be anonymised data, just to generate the-----
Comment on this
That is the default, but is it clear in the legislation that this data can only be used in an anonymised or pseudoanonymised form?
Comment on this
We will be legislating later for the detail of the secondary purposes. The GDPR will continue to exist alongside this provision, so identifiable information for research purposes would continue to require the consent of the individuals engaged in that research.
Comment on this
The kind of general audit performance assessment can absolutely be done effectively with anonymised data.
Comment on this
If the person's information was being used for any kind of research, they would have to give their consent.
Comment on this
Yes, they would have to give their consent.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 17, line 4, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 17, line 6, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 47:
In page 17, lines 9 and 10, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 17, line 14, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 17, line 16, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 50, 51, 55, 56, 58, 65 and 67 are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In page 17, line 29, after “time” where it secondly occurs to insert “, whenever it considers it appropriate,”.
Section 18 sets out the manner in which the HSE is to request the provision of personal health data for the purposes of electronic health records. A request shall be in writing and shall specify the reason for the request, as well as the period within which the request shall be complied with, including where information is to be updated the period within which updates are to be made. All health service providers are within scope and must comply with these requests. If a health services provider does not comply with such a request, it is open to the HSE to go to the Circuit Court mandating compliance. Amendment No. 50 seeks to remove any ambiguity around the timing and regularity of any requests and to emphasise that a decision as to when to request data and how often rests with the HSE.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 18, line 34, to delete “patients and”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:
In page 19, line 8, to delete “Digital Health Records” and substitute “Electronic Health Records”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 53:
In page 19, line 10, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 19, line 13, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 19, line 25, to delete “only”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In page 20, line 7, after “made,” to insert “and”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 57 and 59 to 62, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 20, to delete lines 8 to 14.
This Bill complements and builds on data protection legislation, including the GDPR. Section 21 of Part 4 provides for a number of procedural and processing safeguards in respect of the HSE's use of its power to mandate the provision of health information. These safeguards must include proportionality, data minimisation, purpose limitation and transparency measures. Amendment No. 57 seeks to serve a number of purposes, including reducing any confusion in respect of the definition of "relevant person", as well as better alignment with the EHDS regulation, which does not make a distinction between public and private healthcare or in terms of its definition of a "health data holder". This amendment also seeks to avoid duplication in respect of the necessary safeguards for requests under Part 4 to be necessary and to be proportionate. The Bill also provides that a request under Part 4 must be relevant, necessary and proportionate for the purpose in relation to which the request was made. Additionally, amendments Nos. 57, 59, 60 and 62 seek to provide clarity on the purpose behind Part 4.
In practical terms, the understanding of the definition of and requirements for "pseudonymisation" vary significantly across the sector. The Bill's text as drafted could be confusing and its interpretation could frustrate the intended benefits of data sharing, so we need some clarification. According to GDPR definitions, "anonymised data" is not personal data and cannot be associated with an individual, while "pseudonymised data" is personal data and allows for data linkage to using identifiable data if and where needed. Amendment No. 61 provides that the HSE shall adopt suitable and specific measures to safeguard the rights of data subjects when processing personal data and this may include limitations on access to the data undergoing processing to prevent unauthorised collection, consultation, alteration, disclosure or erasure of the data, strict time limits for the erasure of the data and mechanisms to ensure such time limits are observed, specific targeted training for those involved in processing operations and technical and organisational measures to ensure respect for the principle of data minimisation. These suitable and specific safeguards are not intended to be exhaustive. My Department has engaged with the Data Protection Commission on these amendments and the HSE is required to consult with the Data Protection Commission on suitable and specific measures it proposes to adopt.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
In page 20, line 15, after “request” to insert “such”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 20, lines 16 and 17, to delete “to data to be furnished in a pseudonymised form,” and substitute “to personal data,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 20, line 19, to delete “by anonymised data” and substitute “by anonymised or other data (not being personal data)”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:
In page 20, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following:
“(5) (a) Where a request under subsection (1) relates, in whole or in part, to special categories of personal data, the Executive shall adopt suitable and specific measures to protect the data, which may include:
(i) limitations on access to the data undergoing processing within the Executive in order to prevent unauthorised consultation, alteration, disclosure or erasure of the data;
(ii) strict time limits for the erasure of the data and mechanisms to ensure that such time limits are observed;
(iii) specific targeted training for those involved in processing operations;
(iv) technical and organisational measures to ensure respect for the principle of data minimisation, including pseudonymisation provided that the purposes of the data processing can be fulfilled in that manner.
(b) The Executive shall consult the Data Protection Commission on the suitable and specific measures it proposes to adopt under paragraph (a).”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 20, lines 30 and 31, to delete “, including whether or not the information is to be provided in anonymised or pseudonymised form”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 63 and 64 are related and may be discussed together. Amendment No. 64 is consequential to No. 63.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 20, line 36, to delete “Subject to subsection (7), a relevant person” and substitute “A relevant person”.
These amendments seek to negate the potential of the effectiveness of Part 4 being undermined in circumstances where data holders may seek to rely on the GDPR or other statutory provisions to refuse to comply with a request under Part 4. As mentioned previously, this Bill complements and builds on data protection legislation and suitable and specific safeguards have been incorporated in this regard. The amendment also better aligns with the European health data space, EHDS, regulation, which defines electronic health data and health data holders very broadly.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In page 21, to delete lines 1 to 3.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 22, to delete line 6 and substitute the following:
“(a) on the basis of, and in accordance with, the purposes specified in the request, and”.
Comment on this
At this stage, may I flag an amendment I wish to introduce on Report Stage? Is that appropriate?
Comment on this
I will table a technical amendment on Report Stage to allow a final outstanding section of the recent Patient Safety Notifiable Incidents and Open Disclosure Act 2023 to be commenced. The relevant section of the patient safety Act includes provision for the extension of HIQA's power to carry out an independent review of a defined type of serious patient safety incident where some or all of the care of the patient was carried out in a nursing home. My Department was advised by the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel that a minor technical amendment is required to ensure that public nursing homes are covered by this provision as well as private nursing homes. The amendment is currently with the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel for drafting and I am signalling my intention to introduce it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 5, line 5, to delete “An Act to provide for” and substitute the following:
“An Act to give further effect to Regulation (EU) 2025/327 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 February 2025 on the European Health Data Space and amending Directive 2011/24/EU and Regulation (EU) 2024/2847 and for those and other purposes to provide for”.
This amendment incorporates a reference to the EHDS regulation in the Long Title, emphasising that this is the first of a suite of legislative measures to give full effect to the regulation. The EHDS regulation came into force, as Deputies know, in each member state at the end of March 2025.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:
In page 5, line 7, to delete “creation and assignment” and substitute “creation and assignment by the Health Service Executive”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 68:
In page 5, line 8, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 5, line 9, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 70:
In page 5, line 9, after “Record;” to insert the following:
“to provide that a health services provider shall record the personal public service number of each of his or her patients; to provide that the Health Service Executive may, where appropriate, use a personal public service number to identify a patient;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 71:
In page 5, lines 9 and 10, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 72:
In page 5, line 12, to delete “Digital Health Record” and substitute “Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 73:
In page 5, line 14, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 74:
In page 5, line 16, to delete “a Digital Health Record” and substitute “an Electronic Health Record”.